In Episode 588, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about improving home improvement and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Gavin and Acey: We are confused about which sitcom this is referencing, but not how well Gavin Williams pitches to close out the White Sox 2. Something Brewin': The 2026 Milwaukee Brewers can be whatever you want them to be, but they are definitely up 2-0 on the Dodgers. 3. FRAUD WATCH: Well one fraud is down 1-0, but that means one is up 1-0 as well. 4. The Gang Tries to Find a New Manager: It's always a little bit funny in Philadelphia. 5. How well do we remember 2020? Five and Dive is listener-supported, you can join our Patreon at patreon.com/fiveanddive. If you want to get in contact with the show, the e-mail address is fiveanddive@baseballprospectus.com. Our theme tune is by Andy Matthews, who you can follow on Bluesky @andymatthewsmusic. You can listen to him on Spotify and Apple Music. It was produced by Barrie Maguire and Tim Ferguson. Posted Just now
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Thank you.
Speaker 2Welcome to episode 588 of Five and Dive. It is Tuesday, October 13th. I'm your host, Craig Goldstein, joined as usual by Patrick Dubuque and Jeffrey Paternostro. Our recording schedule has gotten weird. The playoffs are not conducive to recording in a way that sets everything up. Like if a game goes, if a series goes to its maximum length, Right, sure. It's not helpful for twice a week, but I guess
Speaker 2if you're recording more often, maybe it's not so much of a problem. But we are coming to you two games into the NLCS, one game into the ALCS. We did not do an ALCS preview because at the time when we last recorded, we didn't know who it was. Anyway, before we get to that, which we will, do you have any banter?
Speaker 1Do you guys remember Deck? Yeah, we remember Deck. We'll start with Deck.
Speaker 3No, it's not Deck. No, it's not Deck. I feel nostalgic for Deck. The passage of time has worn down the edges of Deck to a pleasant sheen. You know, when I was working on the Deck, it was sunny out. I could listen to things on a speaker that I could put anywhere I want. I could move in any direction.
Speaker 2Left, right, up.
Speaker 3All of those directions were available to me when I worked on Deck. And now we've moved on to the sequel to Deck, which is Crawl Space. Crawl Space makes Deck look like paradise on Earth. We have a leak under our house. And I had to find out why there was a leak under the Crawl Space. And then in going down there, I had to find out what the Crawl Space actually looked like. In the five years since the last time I went down to the crawlspace. And the answer is not good. So I have been
Speaker 3cleaning bits of insulation and also every piece of detritus that my previous owner of my house ever left down there while he was just working on things.
Speaker 2Can you just do like a controlled burn in the crawlspace?
Speaker 3It's hard to burn like just random pieces of copper. And like he just like left fittings down there.
Speaker 2Extra wire.
Speaker 3Uh screw screws you know the uh the caps yeah if you had one more you just toss it i'm just thinking.
Speaker 1Of the uh i'm thinking of the simpsons episode with the swear jar when homer steps on the rusty nail and it's like fiddle dd that will require a tetanus shot and so i imagine like because you know those if you've got a leaking those nails are rusted i assume there's also like water down.
Speaker 3There yeah and dirty yeah yeah there's.
Speaker 1Are you up to date on your tetanus shots No.
Speaker 3As a matter of fact, I'm not.
Speaker 1You might want to consider that.
Speaker 3I might. Actually, I might be. I have no idea. I don't remember having a tetanus shot in my life, and I'm pretty sure that none of my doctors would have let that fly for this many years. I'm sure I just got one and I didn't mentally file it away. Anyway, it's miserable, and I hate it. It's going to cost me untold dollars, which we're still trying to figure out. We're trying to establish.
Speaker 2I think you need to If you're going to reveal this, Patrick, I think you need to reveal the thing about the concrete.
Speaker 3The fact that, you know, I'm getting.
Speaker 2So, all right.
Speaker 3I do think there should be a form of time cop where you can go back in time to try and punish people who owned your house before you. You should be able to go back and just, like, you know, just lock them in actual stocks.
Speaker 2Hit them on the nose with a rolled up newspaper. Yeah.
Speaker 3So... We have a second bathroom and he basically, the previous owner, did the plumbing himself. And he embedded the pipes to the second bathroom in concrete. He covered the whole thing up. So now that there's a leak.
Speaker 2It's leaking out. That way nothing can get out.
Speaker 3Nothing can get out except the water.
Speaker 2No, no, no, no.
Speaker 3And now they can't get in to fix the pipe. It is, like, honestly, like, here's one for the lit majors out there. This one, this is like a weird combination of Death of a Salesman, where I feel like everything around me is decaying as I'm decaying, as everything is falling apart. And also, As I Lay Dying, because we're literally encasing something in concrete that caused it to break and ruin the life.
Speaker 1Patrick is just going to watch this movie probably like seven years from now. But he's going to be sitting watching a history of concrete just frowning the entire time.
Speaker 2That's more of a book that he'd read than a movie he'd watch.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Anyway.
Speaker 1Our previous owners, we're on a slab because it's Utah and we're close enough to the lake you can't really put a basement in because the ground is like, you heard of liquefaction? That's something that will keep me up at night sometimes. I have. Actually, this is a fairly new build, so generally it's been fine. At some point, we'll have to replace the roof, but I had to replace the garbage disposal. But our previous house in Connecticut, the previous owner was a bit of a DIY guy,
Speaker 1but also the upstairs bathroom wasn't that great-ish. That would tend to leak through the ceiling at times. But I do it. I'm all on board with Patrick's idea of a quantum leap, but just for pulling permits.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. You just go back in time and pull permits.
Speaker 2The DIY guys are not getting permits.
Speaker 1That's why, but you, you leap into their body and you make them pull permits.
Speaker 2That's like, so yeah, just, just you dial. I thought you meant you just pull their permit.
Speaker 3You leave it in their body. You call city hall and say, Hey, I've got a question about something I need to work on. And then you leap out before they have a chance to answer.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yep. That's, that's how you do it.
Speaker 1Yeah. All right.
Speaker 2On that note, let's, uh, Move on to the program. Our first segment, Gavin and AC. I get this reference.
Speaker 3I'm aware.
Speaker 2I've not seen the show.
Speaker 1No, no one's seen the show. It was on for like.
Speaker 2It didn't just end.
Speaker 1Gavin and.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 1What was I?
Speaker 2I don't know. This is the game.
Speaker 1James. Yeah, you're right. It's a James Corden show. I was. I was like thinking of a different. I was thinking of the Fox show with Thomas Hayden Church.
Speaker 3Yeah, Thomas Hayden Church. And who?
Speaker 2That is also called.
Speaker 3Gavin and Stacey.
Speaker 1Debra Messing or someone that looks like Debra Messing. I'm not.
Speaker 2That one I don't know. This is a BBC. I know about Gavin and Stacey because I watched.
Speaker 1Once you mentioned the BBC one, I remembered it. But wasn't there also a.
Speaker 2I watched Graham Norton.
Speaker 3Wait, no, what is... That one was Ned and Stacey.
Speaker 1Ned and Stacey. Okay, that's what it was. Well, I accidentally did the right slash wrong reference.
Speaker 2Anyway. This one works better.
Speaker 1Obviously, I've heard of the show because it was in my head when I did this.
Speaker 2We're at Gavin and Stacey, which means we're going back in time to. Saturday? Was it Saturday?
Speaker 1Yes. And look, we should.
Speaker 2Game five.
Speaker 1Give Gavin Williams his flowers.
Speaker 2No, absolutely. ALDS, game five. Gavin Williams, much was made, mostly on my behalf, about his usage. He was just fine. He was better than fine. He was fantastic.
Speaker 1He did gas in the sixth inning, which might have happened anyway, but he did.
Speaker 2Again, I mean, he was... What was his first game? Five innings and 11 strikeouts? Something like that.
Speaker 1Something like that.
Speaker 2He strikes out a lot of White Sox. The White Sox strikers like to strike out. But credit to Williams. He looked phenomenal.
Speaker 1He was throwing 100 on the top rail and good luck.
Speaker 2Yes, the top inside corner above the hands to Munataka Murakami. He looked fantastic. He was throwing a hellacious curveball that he was getting Miguel Vargas on. He looked fantastic. Yeah. He did not seem any worse for wear from his, what was it, four outs? Three outs from game four. I don't know what else to say. I mean, it
Speaker 2was a tough game. Look, this game... I feel for White Sox fans.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2In the sense that you're up 2-0.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Then you get spanked. Going home up 2-0. You get spanked in your two home games. You go back. And this was a tight game.
Speaker 1Burke pitched pretty well.
Speaker 2Burke pitched very well. The only damage in the whole game was a ball that no one should swing at. No one should make contact with. No one should make good contact with. And Jose Ramirez did all of that and hit it for a home run. That was the damage.
Speaker 3Yeah. You know.
Speaker 1Yeah, look, that was kind of the.
Speaker 3Story.
Speaker 1Like, they, the Cleveland pitching figured out enough, right, on how to get these guys to swing and miss.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Like, and they still got their walks. Like, Miguel Vargas walked a ton.
Speaker 2Right, yeah.
Speaker 1Like, they got guys on base, and look, they had, obviously, when Williams gassed in the six, like, they had the bases loaded for Murakami and they brought in something like Sabrowski. It's a good pitcher, a good left on left, but like that.
Speaker 2And he just, well, they got the, they tagged Sobrowski in previous games, but not this one. I mean, Sobrowski will, will strike you out half, about half the time. And the, he walks about 15% of guys.
Speaker 1And look, he just, I'm sure they just told him, I'm sure they told him you're throwing your fastball. in the zone on the inner half to Murakami. And if he catches up with it, whatever, you're not walking.
Speaker 2I'm like, yeah, again, 15% walk rate. I don't know that he has that much.
Speaker 1Oh, sure.
Speaker 3It was an interesting call with the base.
Speaker 1I don't think he was really trying. He wasn't really trying to tease him either. He was just, yeah, he went, he went after him.
Speaker 2I mean, this time he, this time he had it to do. I think there are many in the multiverse of Eric Zabrowski versus Murakami appearances. My guess is there are some, a fair bit, Where Cebrowski just doesn't have the command. Or the control, I guess, if we're going to be that fine about it. But, like, yeah. I think... I mean, this was a....
Speaker 1I guess this was a good series within the confines of it was the White Sox versus the Guardians.
Speaker 2It was very.
Speaker 1It was very AL Central. It was intriguing. The games weren't like.
Speaker 2Well, the 9-5... Three and nine to five.
Speaker 1I mean, some of those was like tack on late. Like they were reasonably close early for the. Yeah. But basically what happened is what we kind of thought would happen to be in the series. The White Sox pitching just.
Speaker 2They didn't have the horses.
Speaker 1They didn't have the horses. They needed, they needed Grant Taylor to be perfect.
Speaker 3And he wasn't.
Speaker 1He wasn't. They needed Hagan Smith to not walk three guys an outing. And he didn't like.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1And it was fine when he pitched outside of the throwing error.
Speaker 3It's becoming a common theme in this postseason.
Speaker 2I think I mentioned this last time, but I had been texting with Nick Schaefer, and he said you guys called, because I think, Jeff, you brought it up, but what if one of their starting relievers or whatever goes two-thirds of an inning? Or whatever. And Anthony Kaye went two-thirds of an inning. No, I think they won that game.
Speaker 1I think Hagan Smith did, too. They pulled him because he walked three guys.
Speaker 2You're right. I think he didn't finish in any. But, like, you know, the thing is it adds up when you only have these guys and you use all your guys every game.
Speaker 1And eventually you have to expose the middle of your pen. Like the non-Newcomb-Taylor. Yeah.
Speaker 2And again, like, heading into the tail end of the regular season, Newcomb looked amazing. Yeah.
Speaker 1And he pitched okay in the playoffs.
Speaker 2He did. There's a lot of trouble with these guys throwing a first base.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2We'll get to that. But we'll get to some more of that. But, like, a lot of these guys just, I mean, Newcomb had two errors throwing a first base, right? So, in a series, I think. So, yeah. I mean, he did look pretty good. They got a little more rest built in and that kind of stuff. But, like, it's a lot of innings for a lot of these guys.
Speaker 3Yep.
Speaker 1And look, the other story of this game is like, Cade Smith came back again and just shut the door.
Speaker 2It's a cyborg.
Speaker 1He's a cyborg. It's just like, yeah, it's ridiculous. Like, he's just, I don't know why we'll get to game one. I don't know why he pitched in game one.
Speaker 2I don't know why he pitched.
Speaker 1Oh, and yeah.
Speaker 3Because it was a two-run lead and he started warming up. It's the same thing that happened the last time, except they didn't tack on the edge.
Speaker 1You can let him rest. Like, he's pitched a lot.
Speaker 3Yeah, let the potato rest. And you don't die if you do an up and down. Yeah. Right? It's not good. It doesn't kill you.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well, yeah, sure. But that's right.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2But they're insisting that he doesn't up and down anyway. I guess this was just an up, but whatever.
Speaker 3It's just, yeah.
Speaker 2So what's next for the White Sox?
Speaker 1Man, that's a good, like, I have this, there's a lot of stuff you can take away from this season that's positive, right?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1Like the, the Miguel Vargas.
Speaker 2Overwhelmingly.
Speaker 1I mean, come on. Yeah, yeah. But I'm like, The Miguel Vargas breakout, like, look, this might be the best season of his career. I would suspect it probably is, but I think there's been like real changes here.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1That are sustainable.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 1You know, you had Maedroth improved a lot, especially on power. Antonacci came up and was a good regular. He's not great defensively, especially in love. Like they have to figure it out.
Speaker 2You know, what you're what you're trying to say is you could foresee a lot of regression.
Speaker 1Like i think we're gonna be sitting here in five months and doing the doing for the 2027 white socks what we did for the 2026 blue jays there are a lot of step back candidates here i mean yeah they don't have much to give.
Speaker 3Back no and and like ultimately we'll come down to can they develop two more pitchers right like.
Speaker 1I mean yeah i mean i guess the lineup like Murakami was not good when he came back from the injury. Colson Montgomery was not good in the second half. Now, some of that, both of those are hidden by Montgomery's full season line isn't great, but it's better than he was in the second half. And Murakami had an 800 OPS. It's Tristan Peters going to do this again. Like, what's the catching? Like, look, maybe they'll get a full season of Kyle Teal. And I think Kyle Teal is fine. A good enough regular compared to what they were running
Speaker 1out for most of the season, right?
Speaker 2He's a solid starter.
Speaker 1He's a solid starter, yeah.
Speaker 2But, like, even now, they were hitting Kyle Teal fourth, right?
Speaker 1I'm not fully convinced on Braden Montgomery, and also Braden Montgomery hasn't been that good.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1But, yeah, it's the pitching, right?
Speaker 3It is the pitching. Like, they're just going to have to, like, they had Shane Smith, and then they lost Shane Smith. Right. They have Sean Burke. They need both Shane Smith and Sean Burke and Davis Martin and, you know, like, Yeah, the team will probably get converted, right? They should.
Speaker 1They should, yeah. Of all the teams that made the playoffs this year, this is the easiest team it is to see winning 72 games next year. I'm not saying they will, and I'm not saying none of these other teams can't. I think it's the easiest team to see that happening.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, they are going to have, by the way, you just talked about the team, they're going to have Luis Castillo.
Speaker 3He's there. They're going to have Andrew Benintendi for one more year, too, yeah.
Speaker 1And look, they can just platoon Benintendi, and Montgomery is actually better against righties this year than lefties.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, I think in a lot of situations like this, the real trick is, can you do it again? Because a lot of these guys came on a lot faster than... you would have expected, you know, Antonacci had like the AFL breakout and then people noticed him in the WBC and then he came up and he was pretty good. He's a good, he's a good player. And I honestly think he'll just be a pretty good player. I don't think he's a star, but I think he's
Speaker 2a solid average to above, you know, slightly above average regular. That's a really useful player. But like the problem is you, you need more, right? You need more of that. And like, I agree with you guys on the pitching. And at the same time, like, Do any of us feel good about their lineup?
Speaker 3Good?
Speaker 1Good, no.
Speaker 2Could it be good? Absolutely. I have no problem saying that. But I don't know that I feel good. You've got to do it again.
Speaker 1These guys don't hit for average.
Speaker 2Again, the strikeouts. 21 strikeouts in Game 5?
Speaker 1They walk and they hit homers. And look, especially in that ballpark, that will work to an extent. But it's It ends up being thin margins because any step back in power results, if these guys are hitting 26 homers instead of 36 homers, they don't really have other ways to score runs.
Speaker 3They can't chase. This is a team that needs discipline for how this works.
Speaker 1They have guys with good approaches, but I do think there's a difference between you know, 162 game season where you're seeing a lot of four starters and middle relievers. And when you're seeing Gavin Williams and Parker Messick and, you know, Kate Smith and like the guys, like they're going to get theirs.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1Like that's just the reality of it. And like a lot of these guys, I haven't, I could look at it, but a lot of these guys don't chase, but they're also passive in zone.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1And that again, against, worst pitching over the long haul is a viable strategy in a five game series against the guardians rotation and bullpen. Like it can get exposed.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, look, they're going to have money to spend.
Speaker 1Yes. They all, I mean, they always have money to spend. Sure.
Speaker 2Uh, there are 20 per per cops. There are 20, 27 CBT payroll right now. Doesn't factor in any arm to be clear. uh is 89 million 89.6 it's a lot of money to spend if they.
Speaker 1Want they want to spend it right like and they're still.
Speaker 2There aren't a lot of guys to spend it on there aren't a.
Speaker 1Lot of guys no um like i guess one of the you know one of the questions they're gonna have to look at i think especially this offseason is you know what do you do with munitaka murakami in that contract yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's tough. I don't know if that was a season where you're like, yeah, sign me up for five years of this. Right.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3Yeah. It also feels bad to let them go in one year. Neither outcome feels good.
Speaker 2Well, he's there for a second year.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Was it a three-year deal? No. No, I'm saying they've got one more year.
Speaker 2Oh, in one year. Okay, I got you.
Speaker 1I misunderstood.
Speaker 2But... Yeah, I mean.
Speaker 1If they're struggling at next year's deadline, he will obviously be I mean, if he does something similar to this, be an attractive trade base at the deadline.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I.
Speaker 3Don't know.
Speaker 2It's a tough spot to be in. A lot of clubs kind of face this when they arrive early, right? And I think they did. But they also, by making the playoffs, it puts more pressure on Right.
Speaker 1This is like, what if the Orioles made the playoffs a year before they won 100 games, right? Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, but the different, like, it's... Well, but their trajectory at the time seemed a lot more stable. Like, it was easier, again, at the time, to say, like, oh, Gunnar, Adly, like, these are foundational pieces. I don't... If you want to say... Miguel Vargas is a foundational piece.
Speaker 1I always want to say that, Craig.
Speaker 2Yes, but I'll go there with you. I think that's fine. But he's also not like... Gunner was an MVP candidate.
Speaker 1I think this might be Vargas' bestie. It was a 5-1.
Speaker 2There's a tier of difference there.
Speaker 1There's a tier of difference. I don't know if they ever crossed over on lists. I don't think they did. Vargas was the 29th best prospect in baseball and Gunner was one.
Speaker 3Right. Right.
Speaker 2And and again, with the Orioles, you had a bunch of first round and first overall picks that I don't like. And like those guys are all already here and also with a lot more question marks again in the moment.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2I'm not saying it's obviously it's not worked out for the Orioles, but like right in the moment, you know, Colson.
Speaker 1Yeah, Colton had 197 this year.
Speaker 2Yeah, right. They're more flawed, which doesn't mean they don't have their qualities. They do. But Hagan Smith, would anyone, including fervent White Sox fans, like to hazard a confident guess at what Hagan Smith's 2027 looks like?
Speaker 1No, yeah, I mean.
Speaker 2I don't, for good or ill.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I just have no confidence in it and not in him, in my, in what any, anything I would throw out there, I would have very little confidence in. So I, it's a weird spot. And again, I think we're going to keep seeing this going, going into a, a, what's going to be a very abbreviated off season.
Speaker 1I mean, you can like, it's funny. Cause you look even on the pitching side, right? Like they got a good season out of Schaumburg. They got a, Do you know what Eric Fetty's ERA was this year, Craig?
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 13.83 for 140.
Speaker 2Okay, I was going to say 3.75. Yeah, that's pretty good.
Speaker 1You know, so you can see, like, if you stretch out Grant Taylor and you got Taylor and Burke and, like, you know, you get one of Schultz or Smith there. I don't know if they can, but you can see.
Speaker 2Fetty's a free agent.
Speaker 1Yeah, they might bring him back. They might not.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 1They're going to have to get creative, I think, on the pitching side, right? Like, this is honestly a team that should open the accounts for like Adrian more home, right. Someone like that.
Speaker 2More of that. Yeah.
Speaker 1Maybe they just signed Michael King actually. Like maybe they should.
Speaker 2Well, that's, I was thinking Michael King, but that also feels like Michael King signs and gets hurt. And then you're back in the same goddamn situation. But like, I get what you're saying about more home, but like, is more grant Taylor, the solution, because we don't know if grant Taylor can start.
Speaker 1We don't know if we don't know, but like, There's also like there's no like they need to go out and get a starter and there's no starters.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1So you're going to have to be.
Speaker 2They should go get Tarek's call.
Speaker 1Yeah, sure.
Speaker 2But if you want to do pitching chaos, do it with the guy who allowed pitching chaos to work.
Speaker 1Right. And again, there's this. You know, they just don't. spend the money, right? Like they don't give long-term contracts. They don't give big, like they just don't.
Speaker 2No, but okay. So if you, if you want it, if you want a potential frontline starter, and I'm not saying a number one, but a potential frontline starter, who's not going to cost you years, maybe Sonny Gray.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2Phenomenal season.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2He throws in today's game.
Speaker 1It's home run suppression, too, which applies in Fenway. It applies in this park. That's just, I feel like that one goes back. I know what you're saying.
Speaker 2He's 37.
Speaker 3Right, yeah.
Speaker 2So if you want to cheap out, if you don't want to go, you know, six figures.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2No, nine figures. Jesus. Nine figures.
Speaker 1I mean, Jerry Reinsdorf doesn't want to go six figures.
Speaker 2Does not want to go six figures. He is, unfortunately... Bound by the CBA to go six figures.
Speaker 3It's an entry level job.
Speaker 2If you don't want to go nine figures.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2You know, Sonny Gray is.
Speaker 1Someone like.
Speaker 2That's a good fit to me. It is.
Speaker 1And it's like. It's better than I think they'll do a none and off anyway.
Speaker 3So. Sure.
Speaker 1Which is like the story of the White Sox under. Well, not even better than I think they'll do in most cases. That'll be an improvement. The one they found under Jerry Reinsdorf for the last 20 years.
Speaker 3Yeah. We'll trade for Luis Severino.
Speaker 2They already have Luis Castillo. Please. All right. I feel like we've done game five in the White Sox. Let's go to our second segment, Something Brewing. I thought this was going to be a Dodger Blues end line, but why not go for the positive? The Brewers are up 2-0 in the NLCS. They've looked like the convincingly better team. Game one was tight.
Speaker 1Game two was fairly tight as well for a while.
Speaker 2Game two was hideous, but close for most of it.
Speaker 1Game one was how I expected a lot of this series to go. Game two was... No one expected game two to go. Teams forgetting how to play baseball, basically.
Speaker 2Again, Logan Henderson had some issues throwing to first. Pitchers, when you feel the ball, just go into the windup. Better to have issues throwing a first than throwing a home, which he did generally pretty well.
Speaker 1Didn't he throw a wild pitch in there too to score a run?
Speaker 3I don't think so.
Speaker 2There was a wild pitch. There was a bat. It was not a good pitch. It was also not a good block from Contreras to move Mookie Betts from second to third in the first inning.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2And he then scored.
Speaker 1And then he scored. Okay, that's what it was.
Speaker 2You know, this one's generating a lot of discourse heat. This series, I think. A lot of it's ironic. Here's what I'm going to say. This is a very personal issue for me, and I don't mean this in terms of the series. I don't have a problem with the Dodgers losing to Milwaukee. Milwaukee's a very good team. I laid out last pod why I thought the Dodgers were the better team, but they're losing. It happens, and they're losing to a good team who I think has outplayed them.
Speaker 1And look, they did it with, not that they pitched great, but their two best pitchers can... Trade blows.
Speaker 2Can trade blows. Absolutely. Yamamoto, yeah. And the lineup worked. Yamamoto, he didn't have control of his splitter, and it's hard for him to put guys away. We saw this the first three months of the season when he arrived, right, before he really found his splitter and was able to miss bats with it. He could not put these guys away, and credit to them.
Speaker 1Bad timing. You wouldn't like to have it in this start versus the other 30 he made this year, but that's where he was. That's happened in a short series.
Speaker 2It does. And again, I think Milwaukee had a good approach against him, and they fouled a lot of balls off. I mean, the Jake Bowers plate appearance was absolutely phenomenal. That was great theater. It was just a great job by Bowers. And look, I had said this about Terang, and I didn't like the approach that yabamoto had even with he he didn't seem to adapt to not having the splitter we didn't see a lot more curveballs we
Speaker 2did in the jake bowers plate appearance but like uh bryce turing hit a double first inning they tied it right back up after getting that gift um from from the wild pitch and when the dodgers took the lead bryce turing hit a double he, everything was away. The game plan was obviously away, but he was spoiling away. He was, and Yamamoto was missing away when Turing wasn't spoiling. And I thought you've got to throw, he throws a cutter, throw a cutter up and in on the hands. You
Speaker 2can be a ball, but throw it up and in on the hands, but he didn't, he went away, away, away. And, and Turing sliced it down the line, which was a great bit of hitting. He kind of did the same thing with, with Contreras. And Contreras hit a, you know, pulled it. It wasn't a great contact, but he pulled it and got the bat on the ball because he wasn't, Yamamoto wasn't adapting to what wasn't in his arsenal in the moment. And that's something he generally misses. in that curveball. He's been liberal with it before. He didn't do it yesterday.
Speaker 2And the Brewers were able to take advantage, again, to their credit. But what I was going to say was, in terms of the discourse on this for me, and this is, again, me personally, I'm online too much. We've all been here for part of this too much. And I mean this in both directions. The level of just general antagonism is absolutely draining to me in terms of people saying, it's people who I generally agree with, right?
Speaker 2Immediately putting this in terms of how this is going to look in the labor context of If the Brewers knock off the Dodgers, if they do, whatever.
Speaker 1The owners and the commissioner do not care. This will change literally nothing. They've already said it will change. They want a lockout, they're getting a lockout.
Speaker 2They don't want a salary cap. They don't care about the narrative. I don't think they're going to try that hard personally, but they are going to try it.
Speaker 1I'm not even going to call them hypocrites because they're just going to do it no matter what and pretend like it.
Speaker 3I think a lot of it is people wanting to believe that how they feel will matter.
Speaker 1Right yes sure or that like i.
Speaker 3Do think that if if it's brewers guardians it is going to change people's public perception yeah sure.
Speaker 1I don't think that's going to have much yeah i mean like you've got three small market teams with good priming you can debate how much tampa and milwaukee actually likes climbing relatively small markets but like that they do everything right and The Rays just swept the Yankees, right?
Speaker 2But at the same time, it's that discourse. It's the labor discourse. It's the small ball versus non-small ball discourse. Again, you go back to game two. The Dodgers scored on a wild– it was a walk. It was a pitch. Mookie got strike three overturned on a challenge. So then walked the next pitch. Took second on a wild pitch. Or sorry. Had a productive out to second, took third on a wild pitch, scored on a sacrifice. The Dodgers
Speaker 2got two runs on Logan Henderson throwing errors and a third run on a sacrifice fly that was the result of Logan Henderson's throwing error. Yeah.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2That is about as small ball as you can get.
Speaker 1Well, people don't.
Speaker 2Milwaukee has hit both home runs in this series. Yeah. There's two homers and Milwaukee is at both of them. But people want to talk about how Milwaukee is in the middle of the analytics. I saw a John Boy video that they hate both extremes. They don't like the old school ballplayers and they don't like the extreme analytics. And it's just about having a good team. Well, guess what? Milwaukee has, I'm not saying Milwaukee ignores scouts or anything. They don't, but Milwaukee has a good team because they're partially partially because they're, they're extremely into analytics.
Speaker 1They're extremely model heavy. Their model values things slightly differently than other teams. Sure. But like the other thing is, look, I've, I've written and filed two lists so far. It is the Brewers and the Dodgers. If you look to the top of both those systems, The Brewers, if anything, have more extreme, like, modern analytics, pull and lift hitters than the Dodgers do.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And the Dodgers have a lot. The Dodgers like them.
Speaker 1And if Jesus Mane doesn't end up one, it's because he's not lifting the ball enough for us nationally. Like, this is an absolute joke to me. People don't bother to actually look into how the Brewers work because they don't pay attention outside of playoffs.
Speaker 2No, look, and I said this last night. Milwaukee does the small things. They do. I said it last year when they swept the Dodgers in the season series.
Speaker 1That's more coaching and instruction than anything.
Speaker 3Else, though.
Speaker 2Yeah, they do. They steal bases and get those guys to come around. They've done it multiple times. They did. Look, the difference, I mentioned the home run, but the difference in game one was they sacrificed in front of Luis Lara and he hit a single. And the Dodgers had a very similar situation where there was Otani walked, Teo Hernandez made an out that was not a productive out and not a sacrifice. And then Max Muncy hit a single. And if Shohei Otani was on second base, either via steal or a productive out, he would have tied the game.
Speaker 2And Milwaukee did that and the Dodgers didn't. And that ended up being the difference. But what I also said yesterday, and this was based on yesterday's game, And I think it'll get lost in all the– there's a lot of stuff that happened yesterday. So it's fair that it gets lost. But Sal Freilich made an incredible catch on a Freddie Freeman ball that would have gone for extra bases. And I think the only Dodgers extra base hit right now is a Kyle Tucker double that let off an inning yesterday. And it would have gone for extra bases, and it would have potentially been a big inning. Now, the Dodgers ended up scoring that inning because of a Henderson error,
Speaker 2but it could have been a lot of runs.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1I think both those guys probably would have scored if he dives and misses that because it was first and second, right? Yeah.
Speaker 2And when he hit the double, that's right. I think, right. So again, you end up in a situation where Milwaukee's defense and look, Cooper Pratt made an error. I think they called it a hit at the time. I don't know if they overturned it. Cooper Pratt made an error. Henderson made a bunch of, there were a lot of mistakes defensively, but they are also still very good defensively. And because they are very good defensively, When you score, even with their mistakes, you score less than you would otherwise. The Dodgers in that, I think it was the third inning. It might have been a different one.
Speaker 3I apologize.
Speaker 2But the Freddie Freeman, that inning could have put up three, four runs. And they put up one, I think, in that inning.
Speaker 1People want the Brewers to be this good. Old school fundamental team knocking off the big, bad, rich.
Speaker 2They're actively talking about the Rays and Brewers as small ball teams.
Speaker 1You don't know anything about how these front offices work. I cannot spell this out more clearly for you. You have not bothered to look into this at all. You're just making up stuff that.
Speaker 3Sounds good in your head.
Speaker 1Sounds good in your head, right? But again, my problem is... The brewers have a robust analytical department run by the same guy that ran analytics at BP for years. Like, come on, guys.
Speaker 2And to me, look, people can have their thoughts all they want. I don't really care. The issue to me is, again, what I find very draining in this moment is the reflexive antagonism. Yeah. Of going to score your points.
Speaker 1It's very much who are we versus. It's Matt going, who are we versus? Everything that happens on a baseball field, right? Jared's made this point a lot. It's like the baseball media, social, whatever, will be a lot better if people can sometimes just say shit happens.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Shit happens. And like the actual story of the series is the Dodgers aren't hitting. That's the long and the short of it.
Speaker 2And again, credit to Milwaukee's pitching and especially the bullpen.
Speaker 1Aaron Ashby. Here's Aaron Ashby again.
Speaker 2Aaron Ashby, Abner, Uribe every day. And look, Uribe looked gassed at the end of the Padres series, and he has not had an issue at all in this series. McGill has looked good.
Speaker 1This series goes deep. You never know, right?
Speaker 2But you've got to bank the wins now. A runner.
Speaker 3Right. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, look, I think, again, it's weird to say this because of all the errors, but Milwaukee's defense has showed out. Yeah.
Speaker 1No, especially in game one. They made a lot of like. They turned three double plays in the first five innings.
Speaker 2And look. Some of that was people need to understand how how slow. Enrique Hernandez.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2That was both an incredible turn from both Pratt and Terang, and I think a lot of runners beat that out. And it's a run, if they do.
Speaker 1And the reason Cooper Pratt is playing shortstop every day and got a huge extension, as I'm sure... Because he can play short. Yes, he can play short. The Brewers defensive model, I'm sure, values him in a certain amount of runs that made them give him that money. He's probably going to post a 690 OPS every year, right?
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 1Like that's how that works as a hitter.
Speaker 3He might.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I need like, he showed more power as a prep too. Like, it's not like Bryce Terang is more of a pull and lift guy now. Right. Like Contreras, the power hitter, Churio.
Speaker 2Well, he had Oppo on an inner third fastball for his home run.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1Like they have, they have guys that can do this. Like, again, it is just building a good team, but it's building a good team with this. Like the players they acquire, It's extremely model-based. I don't know what to tell you.
Speaker 2As you said, shit happens. Look, the Dodgers have four-pitch walked Garrett Mitchell left-on-left twice. You could not predict that.
Speaker 1Garrett Mitchell is not good.
Speaker 2Garrett Mitchell is the one who they sacrificed over ahead of Lara. I think.
Speaker 1They're starting Robert Gasser and somebody else in these next two games against Snell and Glass now. The story can flip quickly.
Speaker 2We'll see.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, look, as a Dodgers fan, I don't feel confident.
Speaker 3No, you should.
Speaker 1But I'm just saying that like. Yeah.
Speaker 2There's also. You know, Shohei Otani has drawn a lot of attention, despite, I think, as Jeff said, this this is a lot. Look, yesterday they had three hits. They scored four runs, fine, but they had three hits.
Speaker 1They need to hit homers, and they're not hitting homers.
Speaker 2They can't, they can't. Well, look, they've had, and I said heading into this series, I don't think they're going to struggle like they did with runners in scoring position. Well, they've struggled to get runners in scoring position, and they haven't hit when they've been there. Right? They've scored their runs on, they scored their run in game one on sacrifice flies.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And they scored their runs on sacrifice flies and errors. You can't put up a lot of runs by trading outs for runs. Now, you can trade outs for runs at certain points and it's the right move. I'm not saying that. But it's really hard to score a lot of runs trading outs for runs. And that's been their offense right now. That's been their run-scoring offense right now.
Speaker 3And....
Speaker 2Look, I said this online multiple times. I don't know if I said it on the podcast, but it does not make any sense to me that you acknowledge Shohei Otani is not whole. And the acknowledgement of that in terms of action, they've acknowledged it in words for over a month now at this point. But in action is we're going to take him from either hitting first or second to hitting fourth. okay this guy look he i will say this after he came back from the il he looked like he could let it rip without hurting
Speaker 2himself which he could not do before he is letting it rip and contacting nothing he is behind on 94 that is a guy that if you have to put him in the lineup you cannot hit him fourth i don't they don't have to put him in the lineup they are and the argument would be like if you're gonna hit him seventh or eighth why are you hitting him right and that's a fair point but but This is how Dave Roberts operates.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2He did this with Mookie Betts last year. Mookie Betts could not hit for an extended stretch last year, and his answer was, I'll hit him fourth. Yeah.
Speaker 1And Katie Wu and Ken Rosenthal, piece of the athletic last night, that's like, all right, maybe we'll... They're considering at least giving him a few, like a blow at some point.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's too late.
Speaker 2The game isn't going to fix it. He had a 15-day IL stint. It didn't fix it.
Speaker 1And like, look, this is... it's going to be hoseway to Paula. And that's a big ask of hoseway to Paula, but he looks like he can take better bats right now than show.
Speaker 2He can at least walk. He knows not to swing.
Speaker 3He's not swinging.
Speaker 2Yeah. He just, his, his one swing, not as one swing, but I might only be, his only swing was a pop out. Yeah. Um, to end the game.
Speaker 3Yeah. No, he, he had great, he had a great, it was a game one where he pinch hit, uh, didn't take the bat off his shoulder. Walk to first was pinch run four.
Speaker 2He did take the bat off his shoulder because he almost swung. Yeah, he just swung at something. The second pitch. He like check swing something and then did a very aggressive head shake. Again, I love... He's a great watch.
Speaker 3But he... I.
Speaker 1This is the John Singleton Patrick wants, right? Exactly.
Speaker 3Exactly.
Speaker 2Yeah, kind of. I mean, I went on the Effectively Wild live stream of game one and they had reference. I wasn't on for them, but they referenced like the don't take the bat, the don't swing. Like you just you go up there and you don't swing. And he's walked. He's had three plate appearances. He's popped out and walked twice. And and he knows. But the thing is. We can talk about Otani's. Physical health, he's not 100%. I think he's, again, he's behind on middling, velocity, et cetera, et cetera. But
Speaker 2his approach has just been awful. Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, his approach is generally not... His approach is also generally not good, but he's so freakish athletically, he can foul that stuff. He'll take bad swings, but then the next time when he gets something in the zone, he'll crush it, right? Or he'll foul something off that looks like a slider or a foot out. He's not doing that right now.
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 2No, and look, I feel like a lot of this is being framed as Dodgers failures, and there are Dodgers failures. They're being caused by Milwaukee, right? Aaron Ashby abused him. Aaron Ashby, his stuff is so freaking nasty. And yeah, I mean, we'll see. I would be surprised if they give him arrest. I think it would be the right move.
Speaker 1I mean, it... I mean, again, DePaul is a lefty, too, so you're putting yourself in the same spot. But, like, wrestling him against Gasser probably isn't the worst idea in the world, right?
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2Well, yeah, I mean, you can put a righty into that spot, I think.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2You can play Miguel Rojo. You can DH Teo.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2And get right-handed Tommy Edmond into left field or something like that.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2Well, he's supposed to be better as a righty. Yeah. Right, you can... Do that if you wanted to. But I'd be surprised.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2The last thing on our, Jeff spoke to it a little bit, but the last thing on our rundown here is can the Dodgers come back? And I'd say, again, I know how this sounds coming from me and my particular biases, but yeah, I mean, right. It's going to be Blake Snell and Tyler Glass now against Robert Gasser and we don't know. Look, can they come back?
Speaker 3Sure. This is the hardest thing.
Speaker 2They have to hit. This is the same thing as before.
Speaker 1And the Brewers have already heavily used their pen in games one and two. They get the day off, obviously.
Speaker 2They're going to heavily use their pen every single game of every single series, and it's going to be fine.
Speaker 1Until it's not, or if it's not, right? If it, if.
Speaker 2We'll see. They're going to try and outrun some stuff.
Speaker 3The hardest thing for any fan in the postseason to do at this point in the year is to is to look three games in the past. Like you look at the Yankees that won, that just, just destroy the Red Sox. And then immediately just got completely destroyed by the Rays. Like they hit for two days. They stopped hitting for three days. That was, you know, two series, forever in baseball. Yeah. The Dodgers can like every starter the Dodgers have can go out there and pitch one run ball for six innings. And they have guys who can,
Speaker 3they have a lineup that can hit three home runs. You, they of course can win any game because that could happen on any game.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3It's not even, it's not even a freak occurrence. It's not, you know, we're, we're not asking for Taylor walls to hit home run, right? We're not asking for Patrick. We're not asking for Taylor ward to take a swing. We're not, we're not expecting Patrick Bailey to do whatever the hell he's been doing. Um, it's, it, you know, it's perfectly reasonable. Uh, I don't, I, I wouldn't give them the odds at this point. Sure. Dakota still thinks they have pretty solid shot as we've.
Speaker 2Seen, but, They are not favored, we should say. They're no longer favored.
Speaker 3Down to nothing. They're finally no longer favored.
Speaker 2But yeah, I think that's right. Look, we went into this series and my two comments on how the Dodgers win and how Milwaukee wins. For the Dodgers, it was the bats need to show up. And they have not shown up. And they have not shown up. And credit to Milwaukee. Now look, the other part of it is, you know, I was texting with my dad a little bit during both these games or whatever. But like, but even yesterday he said like, oh, especially it was, I think it was right after the Freeman Rob, uh, from, from Freilich. And he said something about like, they're, they're
Speaker 2taking good swings. Like they're getting, they're just not getting the results. And I said like, you know, there's no time for moral victories.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And like, you can say, Oh, like they've talked about Will Smith is hitting it hard, but it's right at people. It's getting better. Will Smith has one hit this entire post season. It's not good enough. And there's not time. This is not the, the regular season things where you say like, you can take that moral victory and, And eventually it's going to come. But this is not the time for eventually, right? Like you can, as you're saying about the pen, Jeff, with Milwaukee, is you can outrun eventually. Yeah. The White Sox tried, right? They couldn't do it, but
Speaker 2they tried. And they had a decent shot.
Speaker 3And the Guardians are trying, too, to a certain degree.
Speaker 2The Guardians are also, yeah. I mean, I think, and we'll go to that. But I just think... The bats need to show up. And the other thing I said was the bottom of Milwaukee's lineup needs to pass the baton, basically. And they've gotten on base. They've been a problem. They've caused a lot of stress for the Dodgers, even if they haven't come around to score. They've caused a lot of stress. Sorry, what did you say, Patrick?
Speaker 3You can't stop David Hamilton.
Speaker 2David Hamilton was on base all four times. One was a fielder's choice. And his speed is a problem. And that's a big deal. Now, it also is, you know, it's not all the bottom of the lineup, right? Bryce Terang hit a solo home run and Wilson Contreras has come through with a home run and a solo home run and a base hit from the top of the lineup. But I do think the stress matters. Do we want to take a break or do we want to go
Speaker 2to our third set?
Speaker 3Let's take a break.
Speaker 2All right. We'll come back with the rest of the show. We'll be right back. Welcome back to episode 588 of Five and Dive. We're on our third segment. We're going
Speaker 2to go over to ALCS. We're on Fraud Watch.
Speaker 1Indistinguishable from every other Raze segment we've done this year. Yes.
Speaker 3The Raze finally lost a postseason game.
Speaker 2The Raze are losing. The Raze are losing to the Guardians despite taking an early lead. I said this to Jeff before the show as we were talking about this because Jeff was poking me during the game yesterday. But Here's the problem, is that I can't win for losing, right? Because if the Rays lose this series and I get to claim them as the frauds they've been all along, it will be against the backdrop of Cleveland beating them.
Speaker 2And if you asked me, if I'm going to be honest, if you asked me at any point, at any point during this entire season, whether I thought the Rays or Guardians were better, I would tell you the Rays every single time. Fraudulence be damned. So I can't win in this one. It is what it is.
Speaker 1Man, this was... this sure was a raised guardians game.
Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, it wasn't bad. So I'm going to actually, my, my son, Felix wanted me to bring him up on the podcast. He actually asked me to refer to him in order to do so. I have to explain that I watched this entire game and I saw, I should say, I saw this entire game and I watched little pieces of this game because Felix had this, he, he has this thing. He, he's not a sports fan. He does not care about sports. He hates sports, in fact, because all his friends at school want to play sports and
Speaker 3he doesn't. And so he gets mad when they all go off to play sports during recess. When I have something on the TV, then he will try his hardest to get every single ounce of my attention away from that television. He doesn't realize he's doing it. But he was literally just blocking my face with cushions and stuff.
Speaker 1I think he realized he was doing that, I would feel like.
Speaker 3Well, no, he wanted to do it, but I don't think he knew why.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3And I'm like, yeah, I mean, you know, it's Rey's guardians and he is my son. Sorry, buddy, I can't spend time with you right now.
Speaker 2You dedicated a lot of your time to the Rockies once. I don't think this is necessarily worse. The cat's in the cradle and the guardians are playing the Rays. So I had it on, but it was like, between him and the game itself, it was so hard to focus on this game.
Speaker 3And it was fine. It wasn't so perfectly boring that I felt like, oh, no, I'm getting it. Things were happening, and I wasn't quite processing them, but they weren't actually important enough to process. No one thing was like, oh, we gotta stop and watch the big play. It was just kind of like, waves of I don't know. It's weird. It's hard to explain.
Speaker 2Yeah, I would point out here, just on a box score level, the Guardians had 14 hits.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And again, I do want to just.
Speaker 3And I feel like they reached second, like, third, like, five times.
Speaker 2Yeah, well, there's a lot of singles right now. I think... Especially with Rasmussen. I do want to reach back also to the Dodgers series, because I do... I want to give Milwaukee... Again, I feel like we're talking about Dodger failures a lot, but, like, Milwaukee had, what, 12 hits last game. We're talking about the Dodgers. Milwaukee showed up, right? Cleveland's offense showed up in this one. It was Nathaniel Lowe had two hits. It was Jose Ramirez. Look, Jose Ramirez has turned it on. He's found whatever has been missing a lot of this season. Three hits from him,
Speaker 2three hits from De Lauder, a big hit from Adele, two RBIs, two hits from Nathaniel Lowe. If concluding with the Guardians offense being, you know, heavily impacted by Nathaniel Lowe isn't convincing. Well, as Jeffrey said before, shit happens. Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, and it's still better, right? He says after the trade deadline, like they needed two guys like Nathaniel Lowe and Joe Adele. And like DeLauder, we've said all year when he's been healthy and he's been mostly healthy, has just given them a different look in the lineup. Cause he can hit singles. He can hit doubles. He walks, he hits home. Like he's a good, he's just a good hitter.
Speaker 2Yep. But a lot of it is set up by Jose Ramirez actually being Jose Ramirez, right? Like when guards ball has worked and to be clear, nobody knows what guards ball is, especially the people, the announcers talking about guards ball. I couldn't, I was losing it during the, during game five of the ALDS on, on their discussion at Ron Darling. No offense, Jeffrey, obviously the man does not know what guards ball.
Speaker 3No, no one does. guards ball isn't a thing you can define.
Speaker 1Guards ball is also anything you want it to be much like we got shot with the brewers right.
Speaker 2Yeah much like a balk we don't know what we didn't even talk about that stuff in game one in the milwaukee series but but the like alex vessia is probably balking no.
Speaker 1Ball i mean every left-handed pickoff move is a.
Speaker 2Balk yeah right they're all stepping not towards the base they're stepping more towards home um but miserowski got called for a buck that fray i i don't know i don't know what they were seeing who knows Uh, and, and the same applies to guards ball. Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, Seltzer Bach. Yeah. Seltzer Bach to Angel Arnaud Martinez over in the ninth.
Speaker 2Oh, did he see?
Speaker 3I didn't even.
Speaker 2Oh, Jesus.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3I'm sure it's a point of emphasis. A strangely time.
Speaker 2Into the playoffs. Don't let it, don't let a bulk happen. I did see someone posted. I don't know. No verification on this. I don't know if it's, it's real or not, but there was like a quote from a 11 year umpire that was like, I never called a bulk because I don't know. I didn't know what a bulk was. Yeah.
Speaker 3All right, so I will say, so the Guardians scored seven runs and had 14 hits. They were good. There was one point in the game for one-plate appearances where anybody was standing on third base. It's just, like, it was solo home runs, and it was doubling people from first. Like, it was just kind of, like, it's that.
Speaker 2Two doubles and two homers, yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's that kind of weird postseason thing I've been thinking about a lot, where it's just, like, there isn't any tension because everything just happens in the moment, right? Mm-hmm. Um, and it's usually, they're all solo home runs. It's all, it's all that's why.
Speaker 2It's in the trop too. Like, can you have tension in the trop? It feels weird. By the way, I'm not trying to take just pot shots. I feel the same way about the, the Rangers warehouse. Like it just doesn't feel like a place for tension.
Speaker 1I don't know why I haven't noticed this before. It just hasn't bothered me. But like the way the ball, like just looks like it kicks up dirt every time it lands in the trop outfield.
Speaker 2Oh, it's the fake dirt.
Speaker 1It's the fake dirt. Something about it just drives me nuts aesthetically.
Speaker 3Little pebbles, little rubber pebbles.
Speaker 1Why is it so wet?
Speaker 3It feels carcinogenic.
Speaker 2And to drive on the shit happens point, and I'm sorry to twist the knife for any White Sox fans still listening, but Eric Sabrowski gave up a home run to Cedric Mullins.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Again, he dispatched Murakami, and it's nasty stuff, except also he either walks guys or gives up home runs a lot. And Cedric Mullins, left on left. Like, what? Shit happens, man. That shit doesn't usually happen. There's a lot of lefties who don't hit lefties coming up.
Speaker 3P.D.
Speaker 1Halpin, again, in Game 5. In Game 5, did it.
Speaker 2Cedric Mullins here, the Garrett Mitchell walks. These are guys who do not produce left on left, and Small sample, you know? Variance swamps everything to go back to Sheehan, you know?
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know what else to say about this. We did not do our preview. I don't know if we want to do a quick version of how these teams win.
Speaker 1Well, the Guardians will win if Chase Dillard or Joe Adele and Nathaniel Lowe keep hitting, basically.
Speaker 3Sure, yeah.
Speaker 2Jeff, do you want to say what your prediction for the Rays was going to be?
Speaker 1Rays in four, yeah.
Speaker 3The Guardians will win if they can win the Rasmussen starts.
Speaker 1Yeah, fair enough.
Speaker 2Yeah, sure.
Speaker 3I mean, we had, like, Dakota had Cleveland favored for this series, which we were like.
Speaker 2I was shocked by.
Speaker 3I was shocked by that, too. I think it's part of it is that, like, we'll have to talk about this, I think, in the offseason, but we need some sort of, like, dial we can move about how many, how many F and downs, how many times, like every time a reliever comes in, we just twist the dial a little bit. Cause it feels like Cleveland can't keep doing this.
Speaker 2And, and they're going to try and outrun it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Right. But, but the rays don't have to, because they've, they've basically.
Speaker 1Had two rounds of rest next year. How many, however many innings in the playoffs you project for Kate Smith and Aaron Ashby, just double it.
Speaker 2Double it.
Speaker 3There you go. Just, yeah. Put a finger on the scale.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Um, Yeah, now, this was the Rays' best chance.
Speaker 1Yeah, they have Messick and Williams going.
Speaker 2Now you get Messick and Williams. Yeah, they're pretty well positioned. But look, I mean, I don't, I think the Rays are the better team up and down, generally. But like, I don't do, yeah, you're going to get Gavin Williams versus Nick Williams, Nick Martinez. Martinez, excuse me. That's, you're going to favor Cleveland, right?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2But I don't know, like the, again, not that I love this lineup, but like the race, the race can put five, five runs up if they, you know, that can have, they can, they can wait out these guys. I mean, like the Williams has starts where he's not sharp or where he's really inefficient. And then if you can get into more Sabrowski and look, I'm not going to say Kate Smith, the man's a cyborg, but like you can get into some of these other guys. And if you can get into them multiple times, you know, Yeah, you want to get to Cantillo. You might have a shot.
Speaker 1You want to get to Cantillo, yeah. Like, Hunter Gattis has been pretty good, but Hunter Gattis has also.
Speaker 2Hunter Gattis didn't have a great year.
Speaker 1He didn't have a great year, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, like. We'll see.
Speaker 3You just can't get beat by Patrick Bailey. If you get beat by Patrick Bailey, you deserve to lose.
Speaker 2Which is also how I felt about, like, the Yankees. You can't get beat by Ryan valade yeah but you did yep and you're gonna lose if you do so i yeah i don't know we can move on we'll go to our fourth segment the gang tries to find a new manager boy uh alex cora seemingly has turned down the phillies a second time.
Speaker 3If Where Dyer's a master negotiator, one of the two.
Speaker 2I think that's fine. Yeah. If I'm a Phillies fan, I frankly am not that upset about that. I might be upset about the next bit of business.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Which is that they appear to be going back to Don Mattingly.
Speaker 1They know it's the offseason now. You don't have to choose between these two managers.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Like you did in June.
Speaker 2How do you go towards the end of the... First of all, do we remember how Don Mattingly started? It was like by fighting Bryce Harper through the press.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Like he, I don't, what about the way things went under?
Speaker 1I know that Harper also like gave a quote where he's like, what about the.
Speaker 2Way things ended this season makes you think this is our guy. Aside from the fact that his son is the GM.
Speaker 1Harper also like direct, more or less directly got asked about Mattingly coming back. They said, I don't comment on field staff, like staff decisions like that.
Speaker 2Like, Which is probably a fair answer.
Speaker 3Sure. It's a fair answer that all the time happens to be fairly funny. Yeah. We don't know how managers work, but it sure seems like from everything we can see that there has to be better options. We can tell the things he does do. that other people would do better. And you have to assume that the stuff that we can't.
Speaker 2See every reliever in the bullpen, just called the therapist, both the physical therapist and, and just the regular.
Speaker 3Therapist looking at Googling. Are there combos? Can I have talked to somebody while I'm doing stretches? Um, like I, I don't know. I, to me, I don't, I, this is when you, you get a guy who's the next good manager. This is when you're like, you have a roster that is pretty much already in place, right? And like, you're not going to have to deal with a lot of young players, like find somebody who's got energy, who
Speaker 3might rekindle something in some of these veterans. But if not, like Scott service is out there, you know, like, I.
Speaker 1Mean, Dusty Wathan, who's on their staff already has been considered the manager of the future there at various.
Speaker 2Times, but apparently it's not a long future.
Speaker 3I just, like, even among the retreads, there are several that I would think of first, right?
Speaker 1I mean, I would literally take David Ross over, like.
Speaker 3Yeah, David Ross, Bob Melvin, like, there's guys.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I'm sure you could lure one. Bob Melvin feels like a perfectly solid fit for the 2027 Phillies.
Speaker 2Can you bring Bruce Bochy out of retirement again?
Speaker 3Yeah. You will not remember that Bob Melvin ever managed that club.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3But that's probably for the best because you're going to remember that Don Mattingly did. Yeah.
Speaker 2It seems staggering that they would immediately go back to Mattingly.
Speaker 1The other thing that sort of came out that was sort of alluded to is that Mattingly isn't sure about coming back without roster changes.
Speaker 2Play the hand they're dealing you. I guess they're giving you power hand.
Speaker 1Yeah, might as well.
Speaker 2I really can't. They can't. They can't do that.
Speaker 1The funny part about this was, I think, put it out to me in one of my group chats, is that he's, like, Mattingly is kind of saying, I will only take this job back if my son doesn't fuck up the offseason.
Speaker 3I don't even know how much he could mess it up at this point. There's so little they can do. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So, I'm just going to... Sorry, Mike Axe at CBS went through manager candidates. Yeah. For the Phillies. There's, there's obviously the incumbent is Mattingly current incumbent. Uh, as you mentioned, David Ross thrown out there, uh, Rocco Baldelli. Yeah.
Speaker 1Like I haven't even, yeah.
Speaker 2Uh, Rodney, uh, Linares from the, from the Rays office has, has been a long time mentioned, but never, uh, George Lombard senior.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Also in that group. And then he throws out Carlos Beltran, which would be quite a move at this point, I think. And Albert Pujols.
Speaker 1Yeah, Pujols is just going to be around all these jobs now, I think.
Speaker 2I actually, I think Pujols might not be like a bad move. Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, look, on some level, he can't be tactically worse than Don Mattingly.
Speaker 2I know he does. I mean, he does like Winter League. I have no idea.
Speaker 1Like, that's like, yeah.
Speaker 2But but also like if you just want to go from a from a will he get respect from the guys? Right. A veteran clubhouse. Yeah, absolutely. Yep.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2Like and I think he seems to really want it as a manager. Now, I don't know if that's a great idea. Like, I do think a lot of these guys should actually cut their teeth and and manage a little bit. And I know he has in the Winter League side.
Speaker 1It's a different world.
Speaker 2He's on the WBC.
Speaker 3That's true.
Speaker 2But I do think you should do a minor league season. I think that would honestly help. And I don't think it's because you need to be humbled. You just need to do it for a full season. Yep. And I think that would help a lot. But major league teams don't seem to believe that anymore. And I don't know. That's not the worst name I've seen. I feel like they could do worse and specifically don that.
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 2The Mariners are also looking for a manager.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2A name we didn't bring up for the Phillies, although it might not be a bad name to consider. Joe Espada, current manager of the Astros, although it sounded like they asked him.
Speaker 1Extremely current.
Speaker 2Well, yeah, but they asked him if he wanted to leave, it sounded like, or whatever.
Speaker 1I mean, he's also, his contract runs through like. Another three weeks.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And look, the Mariners are interested in Joe Espada. They are going to interview him because Houston has granted them permission to do so. So he seems to be available.
Speaker 3So, yeah. He seems to be available. One team very much does not want him. Another team really does. There is no way for us to know which of them is right or why either of them is motivated in the way they are.
Speaker 1I think.
Speaker 2I think Espada has done a solid job from what we can see.
Speaker 3I don't really understand why Houston wants to get rid of him. It is Houston. You can look at this and go, it is the Mariners, but it's also Houston.
Speaker 2Again, the Astros reluctantly won this division. They're not a good team, and that's fine, but He did more with that team than I would have expected. I guess that's one way to say it.
Speaker 3If one of the Hallmark Zone managers is keeping something afloat, the Astros were kept afloat. Right.
Speaker 2Exactly. Exactly.
Speaker 3And the Mariners may need to.
Speaker 2Be kept afloat. They need some flotation devices.
Speaker 3They need that exact skill set.
Speaker 2They need some flotation devices. I guess that'll take us to our game.
Speaker 3All right. So we're going to go into the booth for this one. I'm going to preface this and say, first of all, set your expectations low. I made this game three minutes before we started recording. And I don't know how I would do. I would probably fail this game miserably. This feels like the game you guys will do better at than I will. But all you have to do, in the light of the you will remember Don Mattingly, is I'm just going to name 10 managers who are managing in 2020 during the COVID season.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3And you just have 10 teams, and you have to tell me who managed those teams. Okay. All right? So who wants to go first?
Speaker 2Can you repeat that?
Speaker 3I'm going to name 10 teams.
Speaker 2For the listeners.
Speaker 3Yeah, because I said it so eloquently. I'm going to name 10 teams from the 2020 season. You tell me who managed those teams.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3That's it. If you get three, you did fine.
Speaker 2All right, Jeffrey, you go first.
Speaker 3All right. Jeffrey, who managed the Houston Astros in 2020? Okay.
Speaker 1Dusty Baker.
Speaker 3The Cincinnati Reds.
Speaker 1Oh, the... The pitching coach. I don't remember his name now.
Speaker 3Oh, God.
Speaker 1That's not something I keep track of, clearly. How does this help the Cincinnati Reds? How does this help me with this game? Pass.
Speaker 3The Colorado Rockies.
Speaker 1I knew the Rockies were going to come up.
Speaker 3Of course.
Speaker 1Rockies in 2020. I think they've had the same... I should just... Clint Hurdle. Sure, why not?
Speaker 3The Philadelphia Phillies. Oh, boy.
Speaker 1When did Girardi get... Joe Girardi.
Speaker 3The Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim.
Speaker 1Joe Madden, I think.
Speaker 3Kansas City Royals? Oh, boy.
Speaker 1Did they get rid of... They got rid of Yost. Is it Mike Matheny? I think it was Mike Matheny.
Speaker 3The Miami Marlins.
Speaker 1Don Mattingly.
Speaker 3The Chicago White Sox.
Speaker 1Oh, so... Did La Russa come in in 2021? Or was he there... No, they only made that. It was La Russa. Tony La Russa.
Speaker 3The Boston Red Sox?
Speaker 1Again, it's because Cora got suspended. Jesus. It's not coming to me. Why is it not? It's a pitching coach again. I'm in trouble with pitching coaches. Shit.
Speaker 3Yeah, pass. And finally, the San Diego Padres.
Speaker 1Oh, good Lord. Oh, the San Diego Padres in 2020. That's how it would have been before. Is that actually literally Bob Melvin? I'm going with Bob Melvin.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1He's not looking.
Speaker 3No, he's not looking.
Speaker 1Not looking at all. Craig, look at your screen.
Speaker 3No, he's chatting. All right, welcome, Craig, to the show.
Speaker 2All right. Just staring out a window. All right.
Speaker 3I'm not going to tell you how many Jeff got. Mostly just because I think that will make you more anxious.
Speaker 2So we got a lot.
Speaker 3Let's go ahead. Maybe. Maybe it didn't. But now you're going to think about it. I'm going to start with the Houston Astros. This was 2020.
Speaker 12020.
Speaker 2I believe it was Dusty Baker.
Speaker 3Cincinnati Reds.
Speaker 2Oh, come on. Brian Price? Yes.
Speaker 3The Colorado Rockies. Oh, Jesus Christ.
Speaker 2The Colorado Rockies have always been and will always be managed by Clint Hurdle. Boy. Was it Walt Weiss? I'm going to say Walt Weiss.
Speaker 3Philadelphia Phillies?
Speaker 4I knew you were going to do that. I knew you were going to say the Phillies.
Speaker 2Oh, I don't remember. Was it Girardi seven years ago? How long did Girardi last? I don't remember who was before Girardi. So I'm going to say Girardi because I don't remember who was before Girardi.
Speaker 3The Los Angeles Anaheims of Angels.
Speaker 2Do they have managers?
Speaker 4They just don't let them run wild.
Speaker 2The Los... The Los.
Speaker 4Let's see.
Speaker 2In 2020. Okay. Suzuki. I don't know if I could tell you who the manager directly preceding Kurt Suzuki was.
Speaker 3I think I can. But it's not the right answer. Because they don't last seven years.
Speaker 2I just do not think about the Angels.
Speaker 3Was it?
Speaker 2Well, no. It probably couldn't have been. But I don't remember. I'm just going to go with Mike Socha.
Speaker 3Okay. Kansas City Royals.
Speaker 2And again, this is just Ned Yost.
Speaker 4I don't think it was Ned Yost at this point.
Speaker 2Who came after Yost?
Speaker 1Who was it between Quattro?
Speaker 3He was....
Speaker 2Is he the manager now? I don't know who manages the Royals right now.
Speaker 1It is Quattro.
Speaker 3It is Quattro.
Speaker 2Who came after... Who came after Yost?
Speaker 1I just remembered one of them. God damn it.
Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 4Who came after Yost?
Speaker 2Oh, it was.
Speaker 4It's like a retread.
Speaker 2I don't remember. So I'm just going to say Yost.
Speaker 3Okay. The Miami Marlins.
Speaker 2You know, Patrick.
Speaker 3I think.
Speaker 2Oh, you know what? I think it was Skip Schumacher.
Speaker 3Okay. The Chicago White Sox.
Speaker 2Okay, this is killing me because.
Speaker 42021 was La Russa. But was that his first year? Or was he there right before? And it was Renteria. I.
Speaker 2I'm going to say La Russa.
Speaker 3Okay. The Boston Red Sox.
Speaker 2The Boston Red Sox.
Speaker 32020.
Speaker 4Can I bring back Cora?
Speaker 2When did Cora? Cora got suspended later. So I'm going to say Alex Cora.
Speaker 3Okay. And the San Diego Padres.
Speaker 4When was the Jace Tingler.
Speaker 3Era?
Speaker 1God.
Speaker 2Jeff, did you get this one?
Speaker 1I had a guess that I felt more confident about before you said Jace Tingler. Then I had to think about when the Jace Tingler era was.
Speaker 2It's upsetting. I can name a lot of Padre's manager. So there's Schilt, but that's too recent. Before him was Tingler, but I don't know if that was 2020. I think before him was Nick Green, wasn't it?
Speaker 1You mean Andy Green?
Speaker 3No, no, no.
Speaker 2Hold on. Hold on, Patrick.
Speaker 3I'm just looking up when Andy Green did it.
Speaker 2Andy Green. That's right. I'm going to say Chase Tingler. It's a funny name.
Speaker 3Okay, well, you're correct. Congratulations to Jeff. You win five to three. I think both of you outscored what I would have done if I had thought about it for five seconds.
Speaker 2I don't remember.
Speaker 3There's a lot of guys on this list who have not managed since, which is very interesting. There was like a real tide that changed around 2021, 2022. To go down the list, Dusty Baker was, in fact. That was your warm-up question. The Cincinnati Reds, Brian Price got fired in 2018, I think. Okay. After like Yeah, he was fired early in 2018 after four years.
Speaker 2At the helm. I was trying to think of Brian Price and couldn't come up with it. These guys need to get ejected so I can remember them.
Speaker 3The manager was, in fact, David Bell, who got four and a half years.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah, I never would have remembered that.
Speaker 2Very Brian Price. He's very Brian Price to me.
Speaker 3I do think it's very funny that you guys did not get the Rockies manager, who I'm pretty sure was one of the longest tenured managers ever. Not at that point, but certainly later. It was Bud Black.
Speaker 1I was trying to decide between Clint Hurdle and Bud Black, and I picked Clint Hurdle.
Speaker 2When was Walt Weiss there?
Speaker 1Weiss was like early 2010s, I think. Yeah, it was early on.
Speaker 3Weiss was manager of the Rockies from 2013 to 2016. Then it was Hurdle, then it was Black. Alright, next is the Philadelphia Phillies. Both got Girardi. He was correct. The Angels, it is Joe Maddon.
Speaker 2Oh, yeah, sure. I should have remembered that.
Speaker 3It feels like he managed 30 years ago, but he actually managed from 2020 to 2022.
Speaker 2No, that's on me.
Speaker 3I should have remembered that. And then it was Ron Washington, and then... Right. Right, Suzuki. Kansas City Royals, Jeff got this one's correct, it is Mike Matheny.
Speaker 2I knew it was a retread. I couldn't come up with a name.
Speaker 3He was the Yost Bridge.
Speaker 2I knew it was a retread, but I just could not come up with a name.
Speaker 3The Miami Marlins were, in fact, Don Mattingly.
Speaker 2Oh, okay. Schumacher was right after him, right?
Speaker 3Schumacher is a perfectly fine guess.
Speaker 1I only remember because that was the COVID year and he had a bunch of blowups with Jazz and Rojas and they.
Speaker 2Still won the playoffs.
Speaker 3The White Sox, this was the year that famously Rick Renteria had been taken the most of the way and then got bumped for La Russa right when they were on the cusp of what turned out.
Speaker 2To be a very tiny cusp.
Speaker 3You said Renteria and then you went with La Russa.
Speaker 2But it was Renteria.
Speaker 3It was Renteria.
Speaker 2Okay, that's fine. I wasn't sure. I just picked one.
Speaker 3For the Red Sox, you are correct, Jeff. This is the year that Alex Cora was not allowed to manage. And so Ron Reneke, the Brewers manager, did one year and they had a bad year. And then he was not asked back. And then finally for the Padres, it was in fact the Jace Tingler era. Oh, yes.
Speaker 1So after when was Melvin then?
Speaker 3Let's see. Melvin, I want to say was after, before, after, yeah. So the Padres get around.
Speaker 1No, they do.
Speaker 3So the Padres history. So after Bud Black left to go to Colorado, Andy Green for four seasons, Jay Stingler for two, Bob Melvin for two, Schilt for two, and now Stammen will probably also be there for two. That's a little cynical on my part, but I'm happy with my odds there. All right. So congratulations, Jeff. Congratulations. to all of us for having survived.
Speaker 2Yeah. Thank you to all our listeners for joining us on another episode of Five and Dive, brought to you by the Baseball Perspectives Podcast Network. You can get in touch with the show at fiveanddiveatbaseballperspectives.com. We are wherever you get your podcasts. Search for Baseball Perspectives Podcast Network and we'll be in that feed. We are also on Patreon if you want an ad-free experience or to join the Discord. If you are on any of those services and want to drop us a five-star review, we'd greatly appreciate it. Thank you again. And if you've been waiting for the pod to be over, your time is now.
In Episode 596, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about the weather and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: The first salvo of free agent...
In Episode 595, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about Nick Martinez and feral cats and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Skubal Dooby Doo, where are you?: The latest in the Skubal sweepstakes, with some pun...
In Episode 594, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig once again chat about bagels (and cream cheese) and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: Qualifying...
In Episode 593, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about beans both Rancho Gordo and coffee and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. It's nice to have options: Lot of players and teams making choices. 2. Go West:...
In Episode 592, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about bagel preparation and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Aaron Ashby's Day Off: The Brewers bats wake up in a big way in Game 3. 2. These go to twelve:...