In Episode 589, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about individual illness and collective action and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. How Sweep It Is: The Brewers finish off the Dodgers, and Craig gets a taste of the Classic Dave Roberts managin' 2. For Petey's Sake: Nothing classic about the ALCS, but it is classi Rays/Guardians action (derogatory) 3. The Managerial Merry-Go-Round is in Motion: Joe Espada gets his official walking papers, and Philly tweaks their field staff. 4. Around the Horn: Dombo has found a new star to feud with, and the Orioles will need to find a few more pitchers 5. Got ringz? Five and Dive is listener-supported, you can join our Patreon at patreon.com/fiveanddive. If you want to get in contact with the show, the e-mail address is fiveanddive@baseballprospectus.com. Our theme tune is by Andy Matthews, who you can follow on Bluesky @andymatthewsmusic. You can listen to him on Spotify and Apple Music. It was produced by Barrie Maguire and Tim Ferguson.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Thank you.
Speaker 2Welcome to episode 589 of Five and Dive. I'm your host, Jeffrey Paternostro, joined as usual by Patrick Dubuque and a very ill Craig Goldstein, and not just because he had to watch. Dave Roberts, manageable pen or not manageable pen?
Speaker 1That was a good welcome, Jeffrey. Good and nice.
Speaker 3Yeah, dulcet tones. I would say this. I would say I was about to... I had a number keyed up in my head to say a percentage to disagree with you a bit on what was causing my illness. But the fact that you said it was Dave Roberts managing the bullpen drastically lowered. I thought it was going to be about the Dodgers loss, which I'm very much at peace with.
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 3And we'll get to that. Yeah. But the bullpen management was.
Speaker 2You got a little taste of it.
Speaker 3The bullpen management was stomach churning. that was not my illness but it was stomach churning I for people's edification I've had a fever for three four days I think it's broken at this point I thought it was broken multiple times so we'll see but thank you if you've enjoyed anything on the website thank you to Patrick and to Jenny because it was not it was not for me I was suffering anyway so.
Speaker 2What do we have for banter.
Speaker 1Well, I just got back from teaching a class as we do when we record on Fridays. And so today I taught my favorite single subject when I teach kids, which is the prisoner's dilemma. I put this on the board when they came in. The rules were you must remain silent until voting is complete or you get zero candy. You fill it. Here's a slip. Put your name on it and then check either hug or stab. I have paired you up with somebody else in the class without
Speaker 1your knowing. If you both hug, then you get three pieces of candy. If you both stab, you get one piece of candy. And if you hug and the other person stabs, you get zero and they get ten. Would you like to guess? There were nine students. Would you like to guess how many students?
Speaker 3How did you pair each student up with someone else with nine students?
Speaker 1Well, one I paired with me. I was hoping somebody would be absent, but they showed up late.
Speaker 2It was really interesting.
Speaker 1Uh, no, I, I paired one up with me, uh, namely my own.
Speaker 2Is that fair?
Speaker 3Cause you know, yeah. What did you choose?
Speaker 1Oh yeah.
Speaker 2Okay. That's fair then I guess.
Speaker 3You chose stab.
Speaker 2You gotta teach him a lesson.
Speaker 1Yeah. So how many kids do you think hugged out of, out of nine kids?
Speaker 2Oh man. This is like what? 11 year olds, 12 year olds.
Speaker 3I'll be naive.
Speaker 112 and 13.
Speaker 212 and 13.
Speaker 1Okay. Five.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 1Three. It was one. One kid. One kid. Don't they.
Speaker 3Do the marshmallow test on little kids and they get it? Yeah.
Speaker 1I did the marshmallow test on my kids and one of them passed out of two. We had a 15% success rate on that one. So yeah, I love doing this because it is such a wonderful experience. Did they learn something? Yeah. I think so. We talked about like dominant strategies and why you, why you have every right in the world to want to stab because no matter what the other person does, you do better if you stab than if you don't. And how this is basically the problem with every kind of, you know, like philosophical
Speaker 1collective action problem. Yes. Yeah. I love collective action problems and this is a collective action problem. I didn't actually go into that.
Speaker 3You, you showed up. I wish you had known, I had known you were doing this because my all time favorite, reality TV finale is they do the Prisoner's Dilemma at the end of this show. It was Bachelor Pad, which had three seasons. It was not a good show. I did not understand it for the vast majority. I understood the Prisoner's Dilemma, but I didn't understand the show for the vast majority of it. But the last season, a guy successfully stabs, essentially. He talks the person... into sharing
Speaker 3and then chooses to keep and he won the whole thing. And watching this guy's brain get set on fire, realizing he's pulled this off like on live TV was absolutely electric. It is seven minutes. There used to, I don't know if there, there used to be a clip on YouTube and it's like not there anymore, but it's, it is hands down some of the best TV I've ever seen in my life.
Speaker 2Or you could, or you could just watch, watch a carrot in a box from nine out of 10 cats.
Speaker 1Oh yeah. That's right. I remember the box and that was good. Um, yeah. So good time. Good time. And everybody was shown how, how frail our society is.
Speaker 2And you can probably show the kids carrot in a box.
Speaker 1That'd be a good, uh, probably copious wearing it.
Speaker 3Anyway, I don't think I don't be swearing. Yeah, sure. Whatever.
Speaker 2Okay. Well, I, you're just allowing us talking about the Dodgers getting swept.
Speaker 3So that's all.
Speaker 1That's fine.
Speaker 3Yeah. I, I, uh, This is just a small update. Last week, I forgot to bring this up last time on the pod. I had to attend an event at my child's school.
Speaker 2Yes, you mentioned.
Speaker 3Which you know, it was an open house.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2Okay. Wait, haven't you already done the first day of whatever? And then you do an open house a second time for the same thing.
Speaker 3This is an open house where you get to go for an hour and a half and you're just there.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Was I going to go? Was my wife going to go? Not really, except our son said, I want you to go. And so then you have to go.
Speaker 2It's like during class or something?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2Oh, you just go to school, basically.
Speaker 3You just go to school. So it's at 9.45, which is a normal time, I guess. But it's also like, it's the middle of a work day. Not my work day, I guess. It's the middle of it, but it's a work day. And so like, I go there. They're in... the, the, the class that the counselor teaches, which I don't even know what the, I don't know what that is. Um, that's 45 minutes. Then they go to media. So they're in the library where they get to walk around and pick out library books. That's half an hour. And then they,
Speaker 3we go back to their room, finally the classroom and it's snack time. I was there for like nothing.
Speaker 2You're where your child is six years old, right? Like you're not going to get I could be teaching Shakespeare while you're there.
Speaker 3They do language and math and science and stuff. I thought I might have seen the teacher in action. I like the teacher. I think she's very good, to be clear. But I was interested. If I was going to be interested in anything, it would have been that.
Speaker 1Sure. Right.
Speaker 3But I guess the thing is, like, it's just creating an opportunity for my child to be like, if you're not there, I'm disappointed. that's the entire thing he would never care if I showed up to school or not ever except that they've said here's an opportunity for you to tell your parents you need to be here in the middle of your work.
Speaker 2Day in the animal kingdom that kid will be hunting on its own yeah.
Speaker 3Exactly why am I here.
Speaker 2Go cackle a gazelle or something why are you still here that's my update yeah We had something. We were allowed to go over there for lunch with them last week. And I did that.
Speaker 3It was fine.
Speaker 2I was late because I was getting my finger looked at because I thought I had time to get my finger looked at. But, you know, the American medical system takes longer than you would like it to. And then I got stuck behind a train at a train crossing.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2We have the normal light rail here.
Speaker 3And that's fine.
Speaker 2It goes through whenever. But we also live in between two oil refineries. So they have the oil refinery trains going back and forth several times a day on their tracks. Very slowly.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1They did.
Speaker 2They do not go quickly. Some of them, they just stop for no reason, but it's like between my house, there's a reason.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2But it's like between my house and a lot of things that I need to do because I live in an industrial zone and there's no, like there's a grocery store and a burger King. Um, but anyway, I got there. So I was a little bit late getting to her lunch. So you'd already gotten her lunch, whatever. Um, And I had meant to stop to get something for myself. I didn't have time. But, yeah, we just, like, ate lunch for, like, 15 minutes and she went and played on the playground.
Speaker 1It was fine.
Speaker 2I pushed her on a swing. I spun her on a little spunny thing. And then I went and got lunch at the Burger King. That was the only place I could go.
Speaker 3On the way home. You get those new chicken nuggets?
Speaker 2No, I do. I think I just got them. I actually kind of like the new Whopper okay. Like, it's not– I am not, like, a regular– Like we get McDonald's for her basically when we have to like do stuff. So I have something I can eat at McDonald's, whatever. But if I'm coming home late from like a concert or something or like a baseball game, I will just like, I'm like, it's like a weird, I like, I ate like five and now I'm hungry. So I'll just stop at the Burger King. I'm mostly a rodeo cheeseburger guy, but I don't mind the new opera. The new opera is pretty good. I, I have.
Speaker 3A, I would like to see a baseball team embrace Burger King's new ad campaign, which was previously Buick's ad campaign, which is Domino's. Well, Domino's did like a, we reformulated it, but not like, I guess that's, it wasn't really Buick's either, but like Burger King's is literally like, you told us this was total butt.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So we went back to the drawing board. I think, I think the Reds, I think the Reds have an opportunity to say like, we heard you loud and clear. You think we suck ass.
Speaker 1Yeah. We got a new Cabrian Hayes. Yeah. A new recipe.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Well, the problem with like Buick, Buick hasn't even like.
Speaker 3We've traded for Jared Triolo.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And we've got a new, we've got a new third base recipe.
Speaker 2As someone who's a Gold Glove nominee, Jared Triolo, by the way.
Speaker 3Well, yeah, Brian Hayes, too.
Speaker 2As someone whose elderly father has now owned a lot of Buicks, but none built this century, for the most part. Like, Buick hasn't actually gone back to building, like, gigantic boat-tailed... No.
Speaker 3No, their ad campaign was like, It was like I'm in the Buick and someone would like walk around and not understand what they were looking for.
Speaker 2Even though it was just like an incredibly generic small crossover looking thing.
Speaker 3It looked like every other car now was the new Buick. And like all the old Buicks were exactly what you would picture when you thought of a Buick.
Speaker 2Back when we built something in this country, yes.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3We're like everything else now was Buick's new thing. Well, new. It's probably 10 years old at this point.
Speaker 1But whatever.
Speaker 2Not like everything else. Our first topic. How sweep it is. The Milwaukee Brewers have flipped the 2025 script and swept the Dodgers to punch tickets to their first World Series ever, if I recall correctly. They didn't make it in the strike season, right? I'm not.
Speaker 3I thought they.
Speaker 2I thought on the broadcast they said they made it back Yeah, you're right.
Speaker 3They made it. Well, whatever.
Speaker 2Their first in a very long time.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 21982 or 83.
Speaker 3I think it's 82 because I think on the broadcast they said it was the Orioles and the Orioles haven't been back. The Orioles were the next longest.
Speaker 1Okay. It is 1982. Yeah.
Speaker 3The Orioles were in 82.
Speaker 2Anyway, 2026, we will have the Brewers in the World Series. We'll start with Game 3 briefly. I mean, we don't have to cover these games. Great detail.
Speaker 3Oh, buddy.
Speaker 2But I'm sure Craig's got some thoughts here. Barry, like Robert Gasser pitched very well.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Blake Snow pitched very well.
Speaker 3For a while. For a while.
Speaker 2The Dodgers, you know, they got, what was it? They loaded the bases because it turns out you cannot actually use Abner Uribe every day. Eventually, eventually, eventually there is the cost for that. And that's him walking a bunch of guys.
Speaker 1It's something that happens in every other... It feels like this happens to everybody but the Brewers and Guardians, which is just the guy who doesn't have it. Uribe just didn't have it. The stuff was still there.
Speaker 3This happened to him in the Padres series, too. And I thought they might have trouble using him like that in the Dodgers series, and they obviously didn't until this outing.
Speaker 1Yeah. He just couldn't throw a strike.
Speaker 3Yep.
Speaker 4And.
Speaker 2Well, then he gave up a two-run single, and there was a double on the guy.
Speaker 3Will Smith hit one.
Speaker 2Will Smith hit a double.
Speaker 3It's probably five feet from a Grand Slam.
Speaker 1Yeah, about.
Speaker 2Miguel Rojas, due up next. And rightfully, at that point, Pat Murphy. Well, I should say first, the Dodgers, Dave Roberts brings up Josue DiPaola to bat for Miguel Rojas.
Speaker 3Yeah, this was insane.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2So i'm starting here instead of the blake still.
Speaker 3Stuff no that's fine abner uribe yeah was not pitching.
Speaker 4To the next batter no he was not and if he was you accept that gift yes yeah he had he walked the bases loaded and then threw a pipe shot that will smith who hasn't hit all series almost hit for a grand slam uh double off the wall if if.
Speaker 3I think the only guy he had warming was D.L.
Speaker 1Hall.
Speaker 3I think Chad Patrick had started to warm up during the Will Smith at-bat. Okay. So if you want to bring in a relatively lukewarm Chad Patrick who hasn't pitched the entire playoffs, basically. Or, look, I understand.
Speaker 1I know.
Speaker 3Joe Sheehan calls the Dodgers bench mascots between Enrique Hernandez and Miguel Rojas. Go check out what Miguel Rojas did against lefties. He was legit this year and he did it in the playoffs too. You accept Miguel Rojas versus D.L.
Speaker 1Hall.
Speaker 3Okay? But instead, this was Dave Roberts being in his bag derogatory. He thought he was doing something smart. He pinch hits... as you were saying, Josue de Paula.
Speaker 2To force him to bring in the lefty that he was going to bring in.
Speaker 1That he was going to bring in.
Speaker 3Correct. And then Pinch hits for de Paula.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 3And burns him. He doesn't get to bat to bring.
Speaker 2Up Enrique Hernandez.
Speaker 1Enrique Hernandez.
Speaker 3I mean, how is Enrique Hernandez versus D.L. Hall better than Miguel Rojas versus D.L.
Speaker 1Hall?
Speaker 2Because it's the playoffs and it's playoff for Enrique.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3Okay, but then you could have just done that without burning DePaula.
Speaker 1Sure. You could have.
Speaker 3I mean, that was, I feel like that got, not online at the time, it was the people, a lot of people were asking questions, but like, that was an absolutely insane set of choices.
Speaker 1I wrote the recap on that game, and I did not want to write about that. I still had to stick something in about it, because it was like, well, we can't not say it.
Speaker 3Also, like, Pat Murphy had a phenomenal series.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3This was the biggest mistake I think he made in terms of relievers all playoffs. He stuck because he got stuck with either bringing in Hall to face Smith or sticking with one more batter. And I think he made a mistake.
Speaker 2Hall is good enough to cross over. But, like, none of the bottom of that lineup is all ready.
Speaker 3He put himself in a tough situation, is all I'm saying. He didn't have another righty-ready.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3He stuck with him a little too long.
Speaker 2But you know the next batters are going to be Smith, Rojas, and Edmund. And you want righty. You want a righty for those three guys, even if you're... Right.
Speaker 3So he should have had Patrick. He should have gone double-barreled or whatever. And look, it's easy for me to say in hindsight. It's an understandable mistake. Again, he made very, very few mistakes. And D.L.
Speaker 2Hall has been good as a reliever in the playoffs.
Speaker 3He's been phenomenal. He is part of their A unit. It is him, Uribe, McGill, and Ashby. That is their A unit. And he's... I.
Speaker 2Mean, Ashby is just the S now, I think. He's even beyond the A.
Speaker 3He's just going to fetch every game. Fair enough. But no, I don't think it's a massive mistake. I think it is his biggest mistake.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3Which tells you how the series went. I think that was a... You know, he did a great job this series.
Speaker 2Anyway, Enrique Hernandez and Tommy Edmund strike out, and we were fine.
Speaker 3Edmund.
Speaker 1Somehow struck out two pitches each. It was bad. They were abused.
Speaker 3They were, yeah.
Speaker 2And then Blake Snell comes out for the seventh. And Snell had pitched quite well. And I don't hate this per se, but I think in that spot, you've spent all this money on this bullpen. You've got nine outs to get. You have lefty, obviously they have lefties coming up, but you have, you know, Phillips and Scott available to you. Like, Phillip Scott and Diaz should be there for the final
Speaker 2nine outs in some combination to me.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, look, I don't know that I had a problem with Snell starting this inning.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I think the problem with me saying that is if you're not sure he can get through the inning, you should probably just go with someone else.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2And the problem is if you're giving you, I hate it when managers do that. I'm giving him one batter.
Speaker 3The one.
Speaker 1No, I don't.
Speaker 3Well, I don't know that I, I thought it should be one batter.
Speaker 2But well, it shouldn't have been three.
Speaker 3Look, I mean, Jake Bowers had a great outing. Oh yeah. I mean, I had a great at bat. I, I, you know, I don't know. I don't know that that's on Snell. I mean, the old, the last pitch was a bad location. He threw a lot of pitches. Right.
Speaker 2I had a long rest and he, he had a long set and he threw a lot of pitches in the first of bat too.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And the walk, he threw a decent amount of pitches too. Like he was, He wasn't at.
Speaker 3A massive pitch count when he started.
Speaker 2No, he started the inning around like 85, 86 pitches.
Speaker 3Again, I think it's reasonable. Here's my biggest issue with this and where I end up agreeing with you. I don't know that, like with Murphy, I don't know that's a huge mistake. It ends up being extremely consequential. But I don't know that's a huge mistake to start with Snell there. But Dave Roberts said he was going to manage this game like an elimination game. And I think if you're going to manage this like an elimination game you have to go for the kill. What is stepping on the opponent's throat in that situation?
Speaker 2You've had a day off, obviously, so the pen is fresh. Diaz didn't get used to it. used it's not it's.
Speaker 3Not giving them a third look at blake snell right i mean that is ultimately or i don't know how many better you know yeah it's not giving them another look at blake snell that is that is ultimately if you're managing for the kill or or to to win the game I agree. It's, it's going in a different direction there.
Speaker 2And again, like this is the, the top of the seventh, the Dodgers have three more cracks at it, but like the story of these two games, it's like, yeah, the lineup just, yeah, that wasn't meaningful.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2That's the thing. Like it did in a way that these last few, like even honestly, before they won these two world series, but definitely during the two world series runs, it's felt like.
Speaker 3They could come back.
Speaker 2They come back. They can just get like, it's not, no lead is safe.
Speaker 3They were never out of it. They were never.
Speaker 2And they just felt these last two games. They were out of like, and.
Speaker 3Look, the Brewers, the whole, I mean the whole series.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3The Brewers, as I, as I said, I think Brewers knew how to step on the throat.
Speaker 2And I think I said in the preview, like the Brewers need to get tack on runs against this bullpen. And they did. Now they didn't end up beating them because the Dodgers let's go, but, but they did enough.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Um, Did the Dodgers hit a home run? I guess Otani. So they just hit one home run in this entire series.
Speaker 3That was it.
Speaker 2And that's like that. That's it.
Speaker 3That's the story.
Speaker 2That's not the way they play. They grind you down and then they hit a three-run homer.
Speaker 1Their OBP was higher than their slugging as a team for that series. The OBP was 270. Yeah.
Speaker 2And that game four is more of the same, right? They jumped out to that big lead on the Otani three-run homer. You can kind of see like, okay, maybe the Brewers take their foot off the gas here, rest their pen. But within three innings, they had the lead again.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And they just they got to glass now and they just keep.
Speaker 3Well, I mean, I thought the glass. I look, I said this online. I think. I don't think the first two games were on Dave Roberts at all. I think I think the series largely rests on the bats.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3And that's not that's not really on Roberts to me. I think he made a hash of the last two games. I think the chances they had to win. He blew. Now, they weren't great chances because the offense wasn't very good.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3But, I mean, three straight innings in Game 4, the Dodgers had a runner on third base with less than two outs. Couldn't bring any of them home.
Speaker 2It did feel like he was managing these games. Like, it's still the 2024 Dodgers lineup, right? In a way, like, they can just score seven, eight, nine runs, so.
Speaker 3I don't know. It's not like the... 2025 Dodgers were that good at hitting in, in a lot of their playoffs. I mean, like their, their bats were, they were carried by a rotation that went absolutely nuts. I mean, look, I, I'm of two minds on this series. One is the obvious look, it was a sweep and they, they got, I mean, this was as many people have said, like belt to ask by, by Milwaukee.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3At the same time, the final scores were a one-run game, a three-run game, a four-run game, and a two-run game. And some of those runs were, like you said, tack-ons, kind of almost inconsequential. So if that's what Belt to Ass looks like, where it's not even really the maximum four-run difference, I don't know. On the other hand, if you watch the games, they were outplayed in every.
Speaker 2Phase, in every capacity. And we can talk about this, can sort of blend this into the next topic, like, are the Brewers the prohibitive favorite now to win the World Series?
Speaker 3I mean, you know what I think of the Rays. Yeah, yes, we will get to that in a minute. And, you know, I think less of the Guardians. So, yeah.
Speaker 2But, like, you also, like, look, they've gone 7-1 in the playoffs.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2They've also felt like they've kind of gotten away with some stuff, too, at the same time.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah. I think it's, I think it's, This is what I'm saying about the dominance. And like, again, they outplayed the Dodgers in every phase and it still wasn't. Yeah. It felt more dominant than it was.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Now, and you can say maybe that bodes well.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3But maybe it falls apart faster. I don't think it will. I think I think they are the prohibitive. I mean, I think they're the best team. They were the best team in baseball this year. I think they are going to be the best team regardless of who advances. So, yes, I think they are.
Speaker 2And say what you will about the Dodgers bats. Have you looked at the Rays and Guardians lineup recently?
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, look. Especially the Rays.
Speaker 3Look, the Dodgers bats looked like they did in July and August, where they looked really bad. And they looked like a really flawed team. And then, I mean, Patrick, do you have the runners in scoring position numbers for the Dodgers that series?
Speaker 1I don't.
Speaker 3It's really bad. You cannot win Multiple series like that.
Speaker 2And Rosenthal, I thought I saw noted again, they were struggling against 95 plus fast.
Speaker 3Yeah, but, but they weren't because their actual average was on. So they were hitting like 206 against 95 plus. They were hitting 168 for the series. So it wasn't 95 plus. That was the, that was before game four. It also, they hit like, this is the thing. Like I, and no offense to Chris Towers. I mentioned him because I pay attention to him and I, you know, I read him. And like he said, Dodgers suddenly feel old and creaky. And that's a sentiment I've seen from a bunch of people. They hit eight home runs in the in the Brave series.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Like that was one series ago. They had a really now that wasn't a great hitting series for them, but they hit eight home runs. That was how they won in 2025. Yeah. By not actually hitting that well, but hitting a lot of home runs. They didn't hit any home runs in this series and they struggled in running.
Speaker 2Yeah. So we can go to.
Speaker 3That's how you lose.
Speaker 2We can go to what's next for the Dodgers and what's next for the Dodgers. They're probably going to win 95 plus games in the NL West again next year.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I think that's right.
Speaker 1I think this series just says more about the Brewers being good. Yeah. Like the Brewers are just a great team. They hit seven home runs in four games, you know, against good pitchers. Yep. I don't know what happened to Jake Bowers for a while, but he is... Jake Bowers is such... I think Garrett Mitchell's the weirder one, to be honest. Mitchell is the weirder one.
Speaker 2Mitchell's always having... Mitchell going back to.
Speaker 3I love Garrett Mitchell, but hitting home runs off of lefties is not his jam. No, it's not.
Speaker 2But he's always been like a.
Speaker 1He watched that home run swing. Power speed center fielder. It is. Remember that Hulk Goldsmith swing that I complained about a while back? Yes, I think you said he was calcifying in real time. That bat was like 17 pounds. He just wrenched it through the zone. And he picked the exact right spot because he's a competent hitter. But man, it looked more like he was... I described it as a mobster kneecapping his 100th person and not really having
Speaker 1the heart for it anymore.
Speaker 3I mean, also like David Hamilton, guys. I know we're moving on to what's next for the Dodgers, but like Edwin Diaz pitched three innings. Why? I don't know.
Speaker 2That was the wrong decision.
Speaker 3But what is Dave Roberts? He hadn't appeared in a game that series, had he? Dave Roberts, game three, again, says, I'm going to manage it like an elimination game. And then behind two runs throws Justin Robleski. Yeah. Who shouldn't have even been on the fucking roster. He was so bad in the second half. Why was Justin Robleski getting more innings than Edwin Diaz? Until he decides to throw Edwin Diaz three straight innings. And you say maybe it's not the wrong decision. He gave up a home run.
Speaker 3A no-doubter. David Hamilton pimped it, Jeff.
Speaker 2I mean, I would too if I was David Hamilton and hit a home run in the... an LCS off anyone, frankly, position player pitching.
Speaker 3But my point is he knew.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3He knew he got it.
Speaker 2I mean, the thing about Edwin Diaz is when he gives up home runs, you know their home runs immediately.
Speaker 1Yeah, fair enough.
Speaker 3I'm just saying. You get what I'm saying.
Speaker 2Yes, I get what you're saying.
Speaker 1There's a lot of, like, yeah. Brock Stewart and Chris Bubich and Justin Merleski didn't actually throw that many innings in total. Yeah. But they were sure.
Speaker 2In a lot of moments.
Speaker 1They were memorable.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2Not for the reason you want.
Speaker 1Yeah, these games were too close to have this many different.
Speaker 2I like the Bubic move at the time.
Speaker 1And Edgardo Enriquez, I know, is like not... He's not a B reliever by any means, but man. Yeah, Evan Phillips, seven outs.
Speaker 3You're down on Edgardo Enriquez?
Speaker 1A little bit. Like, he certainly, you know, like, I don't know. He didn't look good in his one game.
Speaker 3Like, it's... I mean, I, I don't know. I think he's generally fine. Look, the problem, the Dodgers bullpen, I don't think is bad, but it's all guys of the same level. Like I don't, there's Evan Phillips and, and Tanner Scott and Edwin Diaz.
Speaker 1Those, those are the, you know, I would include Vessia honestly. Okay. Sure.
Speaker 3Vessia also came in and walked Jake Bowers on four pitches with the bases loaded. So like didn't exactly cover himself in glory. Yeah. Um, and, and it was crucial. It was tied the game. Um, But, like, I don't understand. Then, I can't get it. I mean, Dave Roberts, he then pulls Vessia, who threw nine pitches, with Mitchell coming up to put in Scott in the sixth inning.
Speaker 1Why?
Speaker 3Why? And then he gave up the home run to Mitchell, which, frankly, I wouldn't have foreseen, to be clear. It wasn't that I thought Scott would struggle against Gary Mitchell. It's just a baffling set of decisions to me. I don't know. But, in general, like, none of these guys have been elite. Even Evan Phillips, he's coming off the injury.
Speaker 2I mean, Diaz has been downright bad for.
Speaker 3Most of the year. And many people noted this. Just as the Dodgers planned in the offseason, Edwin Diaz and Kyle Tucker Showing out in the playoffs. And they did. Kyle Tucker was their best hitter.
Speaker 1You know?
Speaker 3And he wasn't even bad. So I'm not going to say damning with faint praise. But there wasn't really anyone close.
Speaker 2So what is next for the Dodgers? Other than Kyle Tucker and Edwin Diaz will definitely be here.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, I mean, Kyle Tucker's opt-out isn't until after next year. So we'll see. They'll be there. I haven't looked at who's potentially out.
Speaker 2I mean, no one really. yeah okay i mean um you know miguel rojas is already retired yeah.
Speaker 3Right he he retired scuba is.
Speaker 2The big scuba yeah free agent.
Speaker 3Uh trinan is hurt he's a free agent evan phillips is a free agent i assume they'll just bring him back as i doubt we'll be back alex vesey is a.
Speaker 2Free agent they might just yeah they can't justify yeah it isn't there anymore like I mean, look, they could, they just can't justify the roster spot for Hernandez at this point. I mean, look, could they use to get a little younger and a little more athletic?
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 2I don't know exactly how they can do that. Look, I think they're going to.
Speaker 3Have to find it. Well, Joey Votto had an idea.
Speaker 1Did you see it?
Speaker 2Yeah, I did see that.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Josue DePaula for Ellie De La Cruz. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, look, it's, it's a, I don't know if it's one for one, but it's a, Pretty good start.
Speaker 3I imagine you'd have to kick stuff in as the doctor.
Speaker 2Yeah. But look, they probably need to find a path for Jose de Paula next year, one way or the other. And that's certainly getting younger. I don't know about more athletic, but he's probably not a worse defensive corner outfielder than Teoscar Hernandez.
Speaker 3So what I would say is I think it's definitely more athletic. I don't think he's necessarily a better defender.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 2You know, Well, the problem is that their two closest position player prospects right now are DePaulo and Sirota. Yeah, they were both in AA this year. Look, Sirota probably needs AAA time. Sirota started the year in high A. He was coming off an E injury. It's just, you know, it's tough when ideally you'd be like, having DePaula take a first baser DH spot, but you have Freeman and
Speaker 2Otani and sort of taking a corner outfield spot, but you might have to play DePaula there. Like they're in, you already have Tucker and Pa has locked in sort of chem play center. I don't think you're going to be the Dodgers, but like there's, they have a fairly set roster right now. And yeah, you can move to Oscar to be in, you know, over paid short side platoon bench base. That's fine. Um, you can try to, they'll trade. They might, they can also trade them.
Speaker 3Like you can get some money at a loss. Yeah.
Speaker 2Eat a little money there. You can probably not want anything too good back and you can make that move. I think easily enough, but yeah, this it's pretty in the infield. Obviously Rojas is retired. That's just getting older months. He's getting older. Freeman's getting older.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2And the, they have some infield prospects, but they're further away. and this is not really a free agent market where, you know, they got to figure out Scooble and we'll, you know, we'll spend the next, you know, we'll spend the four weeks between free agency opening and free agency immediately closing for a few months, probably talking about Derek Scooble a fair bit, but like they, it's like a weird, like, again, I think there'll be really good next year. I think if you ran this series back against the Brewers, they
Speaker 2might win it. Like there's not, I.
Speaker 3Think that if you run it a thousand times, I think that I, this, if this comes off as sour grapes, I apologize. I don't think, I don't mean it to be that way. I don't feel sour towards Milwaukee. I think they outplayed them in every phase. As I said, I think the Dodgers win more than half of them.
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 3I do.
Speaker 2And like, maybe that, maybe they are slightly past, maybe they're slightly past the tipping point for this roster being a, you know, just a methodical, monster in the playoffs but they can still win like it's not impossible to win the world series next year like.
Speaker 3I do wonder i mean how much does a healthy shohei.
Speaker 2Otani oh yeah a huge difference right yeah i think so.
Speaker 3Yeah because even that one home run yeah right like it he was a massive part of their their feeling of inevitability yeah and and You know, they managed in the playoffs in 20 in the World Series in 2024 with him being hurt.
Speaker 1Yeah. Right.
Speaker 3He hurt himself in the middle of the playoffs. But, you know, I think him him at the plate being right is is a and he came up in a lot of important situations and came through in one of them.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3And that's true, and that frankly is more than a bunch of.
Speaker 2Right, and he is one of the younger stars on that roster as it is right now, too.
Speaker 3Yeah, again, I think people bring up the age, but I don't... Yeah, I mean, again, Freeman.
Speaker 2They're all good, but like you do.
Speaker 3As you said, they're going to win 95 plus games and win the NLS. You know, okay. They're older.
Speaker 2I mean, look, it is coming for them eventually because it comes for everybody.
Speaker 1Sure, oh, sure.
Speaker 2But like, I don't think it's a near.
Speaker 3if you want to talk about age 33 and 34 Otani and, and some of these other guys, then sure. Fine.
Speaker 131, 32.
Speaker 3I'm not that worried. Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm not that worried. Also they have to your point, you know, again, they have to Paula, they have.
Speaker 2And they might just sign school to a seven year, $ 400 million contract too.
Speaker 3Like they, they have, but Morales, they have, I'm forgetting that. Don't they have another Quintero?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Um, They're a little further. Kintyre and Morales are a little further away, but yeah.
Speaker 3Right, but they're there.
Speaker 2It's still a really good system. Check out Spoiler Alert for three weeks from now. It's still a really good system. They have pitching coming, too. Like, Zazoueta could be there next year. Yeah, yeah. All right, from the NL to the AL. Our second topic, for PD's sake. The Guardians are up 2-1. Man, the last two games sure have been Guardians-raised baseball.
Speaker 3Here's, I'm going to say something. So I didn't get to watch the one o'clock game. I was asleep because.
Speaker 2I totally like, I missed the first couple of innings. I didn't realize they moved it up to one, but like, this is like one o'clock Thursday afternoon. Guardians raised baseball. It feels right.
Speaker 3It felt right. I, I, the only thing I can say is I got about three, three, four texts about Chandler Simpson.
Speaker 2Oh yeah.
Speaker 3Jeff, Jeffrey B. I was in there and I was not, um, I was not awake for it, but when I woke up and I checked the box score, and I saw PD Halpin had given, given the guardians the lead with a home run. Yes. My, my immediate thought was if Chandler Simpson's hitting, you know, basis clearing triples and PD Halpin is responding with, you know, game, ultimately game winning home runs. Like you just got to move the slider bar up difficulty wise a little bit. Like you're playing
Speaker 3on rookie mode.
Speaker 2That was the hardest ball. The Chandler Simpson hit in the air this year.
Speaker 1Ever. I think. Ever.
Speaker 2I'd have to go back. 102 miles an hour.
Speaker 3How long?
Speaker 1102. 102 at 10 degree launch angle.
Speaker 3I was doing 99 to be rude, but that wasn't that far. No, it wasn't.
Speaker 1Yeah, stand-up triple. On the relay, they threw to third.
Speaker 3Yeah, he's fast.
Speaker 2Yeah, we know he's fast.
Speaker 1So they throw it in afterwards, and they throw it a third, and my initial reaction is, what are you doing? There's no way. Like, you can't see Chandler Simpson, but it's like, there's no way he's not already on the base by now. Where did he hit it? Where had it.
Speaker 2Bounced off the wall? 10-degree launch, technically in the air, by, like, Zach Haslam. Not exactly a fly ball.
Speaker 3I would say.
Speaker 1And those were the only bases that seemed like the Rays got all day.
Speaker 3Yep.
Speaker 1But if you missed the first part of that game, boy, I'm sorry, because there was no second half to that game. Yeah. That inning happened. Petey helped and hit that home run.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And that was it.
Speaker 1It was oops, all pop-ups from there on out. Everyone was talking about the shadows and the balls were just flying into the air. He had lots of fielders covering their eyes the rest of the game.
Speaker 2The beginning of this game, too, it felt like I thought maybe they might threaten the 13th inning.
Speaker 3Scoreless uh listen if we if we get if we uh what we are gonna get no matter what we get milwaukee verse one of these two teams do you think mlb just starts scheduling it at 1 p.m.
Speaker 1Not even not even thinking about the old time feeling yeah there's gonna be no like oh yeah we lose tampa or cleveland we.
Speaker 2Just find this fox sports 2 even exist anymore we're starting it back.
Speaker 3I think they i think they did shut it down i'm not sure but i think they.
Speaker 1Did no it's got to be fox sports 1 because that's the time.
Speaker 3One o'clock It's in the channel title. Yeah, I don't have much.
Speaker 2The Rays won game two. Freddie Peralta pitched well.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, Gavin Williams in game three just looked dominant. They pulled him after five votes. five because he'd given up one base hit or something and it was just like Yeah, I get it. I get your bullpen. Gavin Williams has thrown 70 pitches and has struck out nine batters in five innings.
Speaker 3I presume some of that is like, he's pitching again this series.
Speaker 1Yeah, maybe. Maybe it's just like, well, we're going to have him in the bullpen.
Speaker 2Also, with all the rain in the forecast, they might be able to bring him back to game six instead of game seven if he gets pushed. Obviously, they might just use him for the last four outs of a game in here and then pitch him again. Right, exactly.
Speaker 3Gavin Williams, I should say, like, he does this, right? There was a point earlier this season where he looked like the best pitcher in baseball. I remember Matt Trueblood wrote about the changes he's made. He'd made at the time in May, May or June, I want to say. And like there are, he'll go on like 10 game stretches where he, he is, you might not think it, but he is statistically like the best pitcher in baseball going.
Speaker 1Then he loses it a little bit.
Speaker 3He's not always efficient, blah, blah, blah. But like, this is not, Out of his range. Yeah.
Speaker 1And if it's 10 starts, that'll take him through. Exactly.
Speaker 3Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1It might just be, you know. He looked good.
Speaker 2Guardians up 2-1. Got another game at home. Sean Armstrong is starting for the Rays tonight. Are the Guardians in the driver's seat?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, they're ahead 2-1. Yeah, I mean, I guess.
Speaker 2But also, like, I don't.
Speaker 1I set up the preview for this. And it's like, the Rays are starting Nick Martinez. And the guardians, it doesn't matter who they start. Like they didn't have a starter when I, when I submitted, I'm like, it could be Cantillo. Like, as long as it's not bitey, then they're, they have the advantage just by not having a starter because they have nine innings worth of bullpen. That is just better than Nick Martinez.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Two of them were thrown by Kate Smith.
Speaker 1I'm sorry.
Speaker 2The guardians are starting Sean Armstrong.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Sean Armstrong just on the raise doing opening stuff.
Speaker 1For the raise.
Speaker 2Like recently.
Speaker 3That's why it confused me.
Speaker 1No, I don't think this year. No, he hasn't. All right, whatever.
Speaker 3Um, He's on the Rangers.
Speaker 1Sean Armstrong has actually been on every team.
Speaker 3He hasn't been on the Rays since 20... Yeah, 2023.
Speaker 2But he was definitely.
Speaker 3But, Jeffrey, he's been on four teams since then.
Speaker 2I mean, sure, but I have not paid attention to the teams he has been on since.
Speaker 1No, I would do.
Speaker 2No, he was an opener for the Rays a lot. I'm not pulling that out of whole cloth.
Speaker 1Yeah, he was a Mariner back in 2018. I have no memory of this one.
Speaker 2He was on the Rangers last year. Did not remember that.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was good. Yeah, I know. Even after you said it, even after you said it, Craig, we.
Speaker 2Just like absolutely went out strong.
Speaker 1Yeah. No, I was thinking about this. I honestly, at this point, don't remember if I put it in the preview or not, because it's been a long week. But like you, you look at how vote has used this bullpen. And you think, well, this isn't supposed to, you can't work, right? We watched it with the White Sox. We watched it with the Padres. We watched all these teams overuse their bullpen and then they break and you go, well, what do you expect? The Guardians just might not.
Speaker 2They might not break ever.
Speaker 1Aaron Ashby might not break. That might just be who these teams are.
Speaker 2I very slightly believe that the Rays can score more runs than the Guardians at this point, though. Like, I just, like, you can't get a PD help in a home run every game. No, but Garrett Mitchell disagrees. Well, Garrett Mitchell, again, like, let's be fair to Garrett Mitchell here. He's a good major league hitter.
Speaker 3He has power, but not off lefties.
Speaker 2No, sure.
Speaker 3He's a better player than PD.
Speaker 1Jose Ramirez is now healthy. I'm not trying to antagonize.
Speaker 2Yeah, look, Jose Ramirez is now healthy, like, low in a double.
Speaker 1Chase DeLauder seems to be.
Speaker 2DeLauder's been good, but, like, I don't know.
Speaker 1There are some hitters. The raised offense has just been abysmal. Chandler Simpson has the best. I think it's Johnny DeLuca has the best. No, Chandler Simpson now has the best OPS on the team in the series because of that one triple. We're not counting Cedric Mullins' one pinch hit.
Speaker 3Well, I'm looking at the box score from yesterday. So that should be up to date, right? DeLuca is 6'19. Diaz is 589. Aranda.
Speaker 1For the series. I'm not talking about the whole playoffs. I'm talking about for the series.
Speaker 3Oh, that's the whole playoffs?
Speaker 2That's the whole playoffs, yeah.
Speaker 3Okay, I didn't realize that.
Speaker 1So for the series, Chandler has an 857 OPS because he hit a triple.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 1Richie Palacios had a double, and so he has a 750.
Speaker 3I didn't realize that was a full playoffs. It is.
Speaker 1Like, Aranda has a 09... Aranda's 0 for 10.
Speaker 2Aranda's been bad, yeah.
Speaker 1With a walk. Mesa has been, like... I think Mesa's 1 for 11.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I learned yesterday that Victor Mesa Jr. is eligible for the Rays' 25 and under list this year, and I'm not thrilled about that.
Speaker 1Yeah, not bad.
Speaker 2How can I deal with this?
Speaker 1And that's the other thing about this team right now. One thing about this, their defense has had no influence on these last couple of games because everybody's either striking out or popping out.
Speaker 2There's no balls in play, yeah.
Speaker 1There's no balls in play, and when they are balls in play, they're easily defended balls in play. The Rays have devoted literally a third of their lineup to... converting balls into playing outs, and they're wasting this defensive skill. It's just going to waste. It's rotting. Because they don't need him for anything, and now you've got Taylor Walls hitting, you know, like, basically striking out every time.
Speaker 3You might have to write about Patrick Bailey. He had another hit.
Speaker 1You have told me that too many times.
Speaker 4In my life.
Speaker 2But on the podcast alone, he said it.
Speaker 1Like three times. I have written Patrick Bailey up like four separate times already.
Speaker 3But this time it's about him hitting.
Speaker 1Yeah, I know. It is funny how he's actually hitting now.
Speaker 2Look, I mean, I would rather be up 2-1 in this series than down 2-1. I'm just not remotely convinced in the Guardians.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm definitely not convinced in the Guardians.
Speaker 3Well, why would you be convinced by the Guardians? What about the Guardians is remotely convinced? Well, the fact that their bullpen is just going to do this forever.
Speaker 2Like, until it doesn't, though, is the thing. And once it doesn't, they're... But it might.
Speaker 3It might.
Speaker 1It might. Just go forever.
Speaker 3It might.
Speaker 1Like, how I finished my preview today. If not yesterday, why today? Why wouldn't it keep going for one more time?
Speaker 3This is, again... I think this applies to Milwaukee too, but like you go back to, I go back to the 2021 Braves a lot because like they were not a dominant team by and large. Their bullpen was a huge question mark. And then in the playoffs out of nowhere, this is not applicable to either the guardians or the, or the brewers. Cause they've had good bullpens all year, but like the night crew or whatever they were called showed up and they had four dominant relievers that they just leaned on and And.
Speaker 1Cruised, right?
Speaker 3And the point being, like, if you have a nails bullpen, like, you can just do it. The question is, can you keep doing it over and over and over again?
Speaker 2You're also not going to convince you that Petey Halpin is suddenly Eddie Rosario either.
Speaker 3No, no, for sure. But the point is, you don't need a lot. And I think it applies to the Dodgers. It wasn't their bullpen last year, but it was their starting pitching, right? If you can just get the outs on the one end, you don't need much on the other. And there hasn't been much offense anywhere in this whole playoffs. And so these teams that are– and all of these three teams left are elite at converting balls in play into outs. You know, I thought that was a huge
Speaker 3advantage for Milwaukee in the Dodgers series. And I think both these teams are really good at it, generally speaking. And it was– by the way, it was the difference in the game that the Rays won was Jose Ramirez blew a ball in play. That's why the Rays won that game.
Speaker 1Right? Right.
Speaker 3The very rare instance and it's not the guy you would expect to do it but again like that was that was the difference in that game yeah.
Speaker 1Um and either like the other thing is that nobody's walking like it without any walks like even.
Speaker 2I mean nobody on these scenes like nobody on these scenes was really gonna walk as a thing like even i mean de lauder um ramirez and de lauder ramirez and de lauder walk a little bit like caminero will get his but they've pretty much gone after caminero for the most part because they have their power righties to go after him.
Speaker 1Struck out seven times yeah look.
Speaker 3He's gonna he's gonna go through four in game three.
Speaker 2Yeah he's gonna go through spats like this against good right-handed power stuff like he can be a little boomer bust um yeah i don't know we got at least we got at least two more games probably Three or four more games of this to come.
Speaker 1I hope we have three or four just for the site.
Speaker 3Do you feel like either of these teams are good?
Speaker 2Again, we know your feeling. I think the Rays are fine.
Speaker 3I think the Rays are fine.
Speaker 2I think the Rays are good. Obviously, the McClanahan injury hurts. I think that does put them in a little bit of a rougher spot. Again, they had some of that 20-25 Dodgers where they were built around having, I know how you feel about Nick Martinez. but three good starting pitchers that they could go to.
Speaker 3Let's not compare any rotation with Nick Martinez to the 2025 Dodgers.
Speaker 1I feel more, I honestly felt more comfortable. Like, I understand why they did it, but like, I'm definitely not comfortable with Griffin Jack starting pitcher.
Speaker 2He pitched well.
Speaker 1Yeah. Until he did.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And they'd actually been pretty good about getting him out after like four.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And a lot of these stars, I mean, obviously they were converting him from, I'm just saying there's a difference between three.
Speaker 3Former Cy Young winners plus Tyler Glass.
Speaker 2Now Nick Martinez.
Speaker 3And Nick Martinez.
Speaker 2Fair enough.
Speaker 3I understand the direction you're going. I just think there's a tier difference there.
Speaker 2Well, more to come on the American League Championship Series, unfortunately. But for now, we'll take a break. Come back with the rest of the show.
Speaker 3Welcome back.
Speaker 2Episode 589 of Five and Dive. Our third topic, the managerial merry-go-round is in motion. This is mostly updates on stuff that was already sort of out there, but there's also just not going to be a lot of news during the playoffs because teams don't do stuff or can't announce it when they do. But Joe Espada, officially out in Houston.
Speaker 1He knows what he is. Yeah.
Speaker 2He will not be offered a new contract.
Speaker 3We don't.
Speaker 1We don't.
Speaker 2And pretty much his whole staff, I think, is up for like the pitching coach and one of the other coaches is being retained, but it's, it's obviously still early days, but one of the names making it on the rumor mill for the next Astros manager is our good friend and Patrick's Martine Maldonado.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, you know, you got a little break, you got.
Speaker 2A little break from him for a couple of seasons and now he's, he's back in the agenda.
Speaker 3I mean, has he coached anywhere?
Speaker 2He is a special assistant for the Braves right now.
Speaker 3So no.
Speaker 1It's like we all knew this was coming.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2No, he's exactly he was going to be the team. Like all of this makes sense, right? Like there's nothing.
Speaker 1A real temp to hire situation is I think what we can describe.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1He's been trained.
Speaker 2It's like one of those jobs where you got to leave to get promoted.
Speaker 3Are there any other candidates?
Speaker 2For a little bit.
Speaker 3Let me see.
Speaker 2I did see it. It was it was a great list.
Speaker 1They're all great lists at this point yeah.
Speaker 3I mean like I just I know I said this basically last time.
Speaker 2But like oh yeah so yeah it is a great from the Brad Osmus is another one that obviously yeah.
Speaker 3See now that's a guy with experience but not I don't want to do it like.
Speaker 2That though so here are the is it only catchers It is not only catchers. One of the suggested ones was their bench coach, who has also already been let go. Rodney Linares, who's going to be on all these lists.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 2The Tampa Bay Rays bench coach, Rocco Baldelli, who's going to be on all these lists.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And then if you want some former, there's David Ross, another catcher.
Speaker 3Another catcher.
Speaker 2But then Carlos Beltran and Morgan Ansberg as well.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Jeff Bannister.
Speaker 2I'm seeing Jeff Bannister.
Speaker 3What is the funniest one?
Speaker 2I think it's just Brad Asmus.
Speaker 1Ensberg.
Speaker 2Ensberg is a legitimate minor league coach, though. He's been a minor league coach for a while.
Speaker 3No, he is a coach, but isn't he also notably a kook?
Speaker 2But he's kind of... Isn't he capler-ish? But he's vaguely sabermetric. It's not capler-ish.
Speaker 3Yeah, but it's like sabermetric. he's, he's like a, he's like a, I don't know. I guess it's, it's a strain of capitalism to me. Like he's, he's, he's definitely got like a theory for everything. Like, I feel like he's a, like he's, he's borderline a baseball conspiracy guy, but like for dev, you know what I mean? He's like already one of those, like, old guy like jeff
Speaker 3fry guys except except but not.
Speaker 2Like that yeah do you know what i mean like it's like he's not like.
Speaker 3The old people were always right but is.
Speaker 2It the i don't know was it the rockies or the mariners they had them just make they had just like the players make tacos at instrux or something what yeah that's how you're not gonna play baseball today you're just gonna make tacos or burritos yeah yeah.
Speaker 1Sure it's just asking questions guy but the questions are.
Speaker 2Different some other names from yourself okay Some other names from Brian McTaggart at MLB.com that you'll like. John Gibbons.
Speaker 1Yeah. Gibby. Yeah.
Speaker 3Brandon Hyde.
Speaker 1Yeah. Brandon Hyde's going to be on.
Speaker 3A lot of these lists.
Speaker 2And Danny Lehman, who is also going to be on a lot of these lists. And Albert Pujols.
Speaker 3Danny Lehman is a Dodgers bench coach.
Speaker 2Dodgers bench coach.
Speaker 3Yeah. For people who aren't aware.
Speaker 1Albert Pujols is the funny name.
Speaker 2Pujols is, yeah.
Speaker 1Not that it's necessarily unqualified.
Speaker 3I think Pujols, again, I kind of think Pujols might be good at it. I think he might be good at it.
Speaker 2I don't know if the 2027 Astros is a place to find out. That's part of it.
Speaker 1The name that I'm always going to bring him up, the name I don't see on the slush, Rob Thompson.
Speaker 2Yeah, that is surprising.
Speaker 1Is he still in the Phillies' org?
Speaker 3Did he leave?
Speaker 2I think he actually left, yeah.
Speaker 3Okay. Yeah, I would... If I were.
Speaker 1If I had a team that I didn't want to start over with, Like, I don't know if I'd want him for like a team that's rebuilding, but like, it feels like such a, like for a team that thinks it's going to bounce back next year. Like, it's just like for the Mariners, like a team that's going to expect to contend. Like, it just seems like a real easy, smooth, not as risky, you know, kind of what you're getting.
Speaker 3I think Thompson's a good manager. Yeah.
Speaker 2More news out of Philly.
Speaker 3Speaking of the Phillies, yeah.
Speaker 2They've continued to shake up their coaching staff after bringing in Don Mattingly full-time. Kevin Long is out.
Speaker 3But they had not brought him in full-time the last time we recorded. Did they not?
Speaker 2No. Okay, well, he's there. We joked about it.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah, that's right.
Speaker 2He assigned a two-year deal to manage the Phillies. And bringing in Carlos Mendoza to be his third base coach and infield coach as well.
Speaker 1I like how two-year deals for managers are the one-year deal because you can't sign somebody to a one-year deal. So you just have to, you know, like, we will pay. It's like, here's what your severance pay will be. Yeah. Yes.
Speaker 3I'm just going to go back to what we talked about last pod. Why? What about this experience made me think, yeah, I'll keep drinking more of that card.
Speaker 2Before cycling back to Don Mattingly, they tried to get Chase Utley and Raul Banez.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2So that tells you how enthused, at least some, I would continue.
Speaker 3To just go down my list until someone else. Jimmy Rollins.
Speaker 1Yeah. This feels like.
Speaker 2Freddie Galvis.
Speaker 1This feels like the Dan Wilson hire.
Speaker 3Oh my God. Let's absolutely bring that.
Speaker 2Carlos Ruiz. We can keep going.
Speaker 1That's fine. I just think this is the Dan Wilson hire of this year. I think this is the one that we are talking about.
Speaker 3I think this is worse.
Speaker 2Yeah, this is worse. It's like Dan Wilson. Wilson did not have enough. like we got a lot of Don Mattingly's here compared to Dan Wilson a couple of years ago.
Speaker 3Right. Dan, Dan Wilson, look, Dan Wilson was bad. I'm not trying to, I think, I think hiring Don, like Don Mattingly actively fights with his players.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Oh yeah.
Speaker 2Well, as we'll get to in a minute that, uh, applies to their GM as well right now.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's true. Um, Go ahead.
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 2All right, so we'll go around the horn.
Speaker 1Hold on. The Rockies also.
Speaker 2Why is this on here?
Speaker 1I put it on there.
Speaker 3I know you put it on there. I think it's very funny.
Speaker 1I think it's very funny. The Rockies fired their pitching coach, who clearly was to blame for their pitching.
Speaker 3Yeah, sure.
Speaker 1Like, this is just, like, I, you know.
Speaker 3I fire him for spelling Allen like that.
Speaker 1Yeah, Allen, Allen, Allen. I just, I.
Speaker 2This is like the, this is like being the drummer for Spinal Tap. Like, we don't need to spend a lot of time on it.
Speaker 1It is just weird that, like, It is very much a, what did you think this was going to look like? I don't know if Alan Leitchman's a good pitching coach. I don't think the Rockies know. I don't think the Rockies knew a year ago, and I don't think they know now.
Speaker 2They haven't, like, again, it is, I wrote about this a little bit during the season, because obviously I, while not living at quite the elevation of mile high, am just under a mile high out here, and watch a fair bit of baseball, and the idea of how The Rockies have been doing this for 30 years and have not figured out even really a strategy. They haven't tried anything to try.
Speaker 1To work within the element. Maybe. But I doubt it. I think they would want to be the ones trying something. And I don't think Alan Leitman is the reason why they didn't. So just weird.
Speaker 2Well, now we'll go around the horn. An organization that is definitely trying something, the same thing, calling out their players in the press.
Speaker 3It kind of worked with Bryce Harper.
Speaker 1He had a good year.
Speaker 2Yeah, it was okay. Dave Dombrowski was asked about Trey Turner playing shortstop and basically said, well, we need more from Trey Turner. If he does this again, we'll have to have a conversation about moving him off shortstop. Now I do wonder if he's had that conversation with Trey Turner already, which, or if he's just announced to get a Trey Turner in the press.
Speaker 3Look, Dave Dombrowski has reached a point where Jerry Seinfeld had a bit for, for a long time about older people and just deciding that they don't need to look back anymore when they're backing out of a driveway. Yeah. Or out of a parking spot. They just decided, you know, I'm old and I'm coming back and it's on you to avoid me. I think Dave Dombrowski has reached a point in his career where he's he's not clearing stuff ahead of time with the play. This is, he's old
Speaker 3and he's, he's coming through with a, with a comment.
Speaker 2Do you want to bet that response with the PR department?
Speaker 3No, no, no, I don't.
Speaker 2I don't want to have that many conversations in a day.
Speaker 3Like, no, I don't. I am tired. I don't, I'm not interested. I have a round of golf to get to. And no, I, I'm not clearing that with PR. I don't care what PR has to say. And here I'm throwing.
Speaker 1It in reverse.
Speaker 2Speaking of not caring about what PR has to say, David Rubenstein has talked a little bit about, I guess he's doing press for his book.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2About being an owner.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2And said, apparently it's hard.
Speaker 3Can I read something? I got sent a quote from Rubenstein from Twitter. Mark Normandin. And I'm, I'm assuming it is a direct quote, but I have not seen.
Speaker 2I'm going to see if this is the one I think I was thinking of.
Speaker 3I have not seen the actual quote. So I, I don't know how much, I didn't know if Mark was paraphrasing at all or whatever. A lot of my friends were buying teams and I realized they're making money. They're making more money than I'm making in private equity. He said, I thought I should look at it as a financial thing, but ultimately I bought the Orioles for a philanthropic purpose. Is that the real quote? Is that a real thing he said?
Speaker 2Hey, David, it's a lawyer for the MLBPA. I'm telling you to keep saying that shit.
Speaker 3Holy shit, bro.
Speaker 2Being someone that should have gone through PR.
Speaker 3I've been working on this CBA for five years and he just tweeted it out.
Speaker 2Message discipline, David. Come on.
Speaker 3Oh my God, he admitted it. How many memes can we do? What the fuck, man?
Speaker 1Incredible. Incredible. You know, like the day after the Brewers make the World Series. I'm dying.
Speaker 2I mean, no, but like fans want a salary cap.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So that's we're going to we're going to we're going to pay any attention to the three teams left.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Look, the reality is they shouldn't. A bunch of small series variants proves nothing.
Speaker 2But they were very happy to do it, yeah.
Speaker 3They would have been thrilled to do it if the Dodgers won again. So it is absolutely delicious and we can rake them over the coals. But I want to say, I realize as we rake them over the coals, I realize it's hypocritical, but they were being hypocritical first, so fuck them.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3This is an insane quote.
Speaker 1Yeah, oh yeah.
Speaker 2More money than I can make in private equity.
Speaker 3More money than I can make in private equity, but it's philanthropy.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2And he didn't even have to like, you know, sell the land back to himself and run it to the Orioles or whatever you do when you're.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3We're doing it.
Speaker 2We're doing endless bowls of soft shell crap. As mentioned before, Miguel Rojas has retired.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3He's going to stay in the Dodgers.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm sure.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2They'd already kind of agreed to that when they give him the extra year.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Look, it's not as spectacular a way to go out, but he also made a couple extra million dollars, so whatever.
Speaker 1I mean, he did well.
Speaker 2He was fine this year, yeah. Kate Povich is having elbow surgery, so it's going to get harder for David Rubenstein to be an owner because he's down yet another pitcher.
Speaker 3I think it's a good way to go into the offseason for them, just to understand that this is how every.
Speaker 1He's not your seventh starter.
Speaker 3It wasn't this year. It was two years ago that he was like, I was caught by surprise that Grayson wasn't ready and And whoever wasn't, like, we had a bunch.
Speaker 2Of people who got hurt. The year that Bradish had Tommy John himself.
Speaker 3Bradish got hurt, whatever. And he was just like, we didn't have a plan for that. And I want to be like, you're the guy who's supposed to have a plan for that. It's good for him to get, like, a pre-offseason reminder, or I guess offseason, like, precursor that, like, you are going to need to plan for this.
Speaker 2Just so you know, Mike Trevor Rogers is a free agent. You might want to deal with that, too. Like, he's not going to be back. Like, your contract with him is expired.
Speaker 3Well, he could be back.
Speaker 2He could be back, but I'm just saying, it's like, it shouldn't be a surprise if you don't like, if he doesn't show up next March or you haven't talked to him. And speaking of pitchers, Brandon Woodruff wants to pitch in the World Series.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Good. Okay.
Speaker 3Yeah. Why not? Every pitcher should want to.
Speaker 2Did you see the bit they did with like all the champagne bottles had different.
Speaker 1Extras on it?
Speaker 3Good bet.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, that was a good one.
Speaker 2That was getting a lot of grist in there.
Speaker 1Pat Lestache. Yeah.
Speaker 3No, no, wait. All the champagne bottles had former brewers on it? Former brewers on it.
Speaker 2But like, yeah, like Casey McGahee, though.
Speaker 3So I saw a lot of, there were a lot of people, and I posted, Patrick also saw it, I know.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3But there were a lot of people saying like, this is for John Jaha, this is for whatever. And like, I saw so many, and no one said Bill Hall. And like, Bill Hall is the Milwaukee Brewers. Yes.
Speaker 4Okay?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And then I saw, first of all, it just, God forbid anyone ever play this game. Like I did this and just my mentions were ruined for hours. I don't mind people playing the game. And there were some very good ones. You know, Colin Whitchurch, friend of the program, like said, like I went through all the replies and like no one mentioned Giovanni Gallardo.
Speaker 2Yeah, Yovani Gaillard, to me, is the bad era of Brewers.
Speaker 3Yes, exactly.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3No, that's a great catch. Bill Hall, too.
Speaker 2Yeah, definitely.
Speaker 3I'm getting a lot of people being like, you know, Jeff Jenkins. And look, Jeff Jenkins is a great call. Read the goddamn replies. I don't need 25 Jeff Jenkins. It was good the first time.
Speaker 1You can't say nobody has said this name if people have said this name.
Speaker 3Someone brought up Lyle Overbay. That's good shit.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2You know, it's just rich staff signing up for different blue sky burners to put Jeff Jenkins in your room.
Speaker 3No, but it wasn't only Jeff Jenkins, but it was so many people bringing up the same names. And look, but like, again, like Carlos Gomez wasn't getting brought up enough. Like Carlos Gomez.
Speaker 2I feel like for those, like there's a little too good though. Like, man, that might be the Giovanni Gallardo problem as well.
Speaker 1Well, yeah.
Speaker 2But I don't think it's.
Speaker 3Purely about good. It's about like good during a, uh, An era where they didn't convert, ultimately.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 3But I love that. That's a great pull for Milwaukee. Great job on this.
Speaker 2It's also a good trend. It's also a good.
Speaker 1I'm sorry. I'm going to get this out. Go ahead. Get out. I just loved watching all those names pour out. And I was like chuckling going, yeah, yeah, those guys. Not Larry Hizzle.
Speaker 3Not Jake Andrew.
Speaker 1Not like guys from like the late 70s that I think of.
Speaker 3But you should have. That's what you're here for, Patrick. I don't know those guys.
Speaker 1How has no one said Moose Haas?
Speaker 3Someone did get Gorman Thomas.
Speaker 2Gorman Thomas is like Mr.
Speaker 3Brewer.
Speaker 2But it is a good transition to our game.
Speaker 1So this one is from Colin Richard. Thank you, Colin, because I did not have the energy to make a game last night.
Speaker 3How many did he send us?
Speaker 1He sent us three. God bless. This one is a simple one. It'll be nice and quick. I can play this one as well, and I will this time because I'm feeling gracious. All it is, it's called Got Rings. We're going to name 10 players, and then we're all going to decide together as a group. We're going to workshop, and then we'll come up with our own answers. Has this player won a World Series? Does he have a ring?
Speaker 2Does he have a ring? Okay. I hope Taylor Trammell is on here because I know that's him.
Speaker 1We all know the answer to that one. All right. So the first one is Michael Wacca. oh why not so yeah this is a tough one because like i feel like those early i i don't remember which years the cardinals won championships it's they're just they do.
Speaker 2He was up very quick after he got drafted too that was that was.
Speaker 3The court so i remember this michael walker is firmly implanted in dodgers lore because he went a couple picks after cory seeker and then was in the majors and helped the Cardinals beat the Dodgers in the playoffs.
Speaker 2Yeah, Mets fans did this with Gavin Cicchini, too. That's how I know he's 2012. But did they... I'm trying to remember the last year. So they beat the Rangers.
Speaker 3That was 2011?
Speaker 2I think it was 11, yeah. And I think 13 they lost to the Red Sox, didn't they, in the World Series?
Speaker 3Well, the Red Sox won in 2013, for sure.
Speaker 1I love that we're just playing this as a cooperative game.
Speaker 3That's fine. Just trying to say it was.
Speaker 2Did you not say it was?
Speaker 1No, I was joking. I was expecting you guys to come up with your answers, but I was like, you guys are totally going to banter with each other. I'm going to say no.
Speaker 3I think we've all... I will also say no.
Speaker 1The answer is no. Moving on to number two. This is Stephen Drew.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 1Stephen Drew, boy.
Speaker 3So. When was he drafted?
Speaker 1Steven Drew played for... Well, if he played for every team, it's just a matter of which year.
Speaker 2There's going to be someone random.
Speaker 3That's the vibe I get, too.
Speaker 2I'm going to say yes, because I... I've got Diamondbacks and Nats in my head.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2It was well before the Nats won, and the Diamondbacks didn't win anything while he was there, obviously.
Speaker 1I'm going to say yes, because I feel like.
Speaker 2Oh, man. It's going to be something dumb. I'm saying yes. I don't know who, what team, what year.
Speaker 1Yeah. I'm going to have to look up because I don't think he does.
Speaker 3I'm going to do the same thing.
Speaker 1All right. So we're all saying yes?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1All right. Stephen Drew, the answer is yes. And it was the 2013 Boston Red Sox.
Speaker 3Okay. I was going to say Red Sox. I thought.
Speaker 2I don't remember him being on that team, but whatever.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Makes sense.
Speaker 1Um all right next is Carlos Pena.
Speaker 3Oh lord um.
Speaker 1I'm gonna say no on this.
Speaker 2One I don't think so I just it's like Rays Tigers and Astros and none of them I don't think he had them on while he was there I'm gonna say no.
Speaker 1No Alright, we're doing great so far. The answer is no. 3 for 3 on all of us. Next one is Austin Jackson.
Speaker 3Again, a lot of Tigers.
Speaker 2There's Yankees in there, but the Yankees haven't won.
Speaker 3Since 2009, right?
Speaker 2Yeah, there's going to be an annoying he got picked up in August as a bench outfielder or something or somebody. He bounced around a lot.
Speaker 1I'm going to say no.
Speaker 2He had a brief Mets tenure in there, too. Obviously not when the Mets won it, but I feel like he got picked up a bunch.
Speaker 3He did, and he had some weird month-long hot streaks and stuff. I'm going to say yes.
Speaker 2I'm with Jeff. I'm going to say yes, too.
Speaker 3The answer is no.
Speaker 1He was Cameron Maiden maxing at one point in his career. All right, next one is Francisco Liriano. Man.
Speaker 3I don't think so.
Speaker 2I feel... I'm going to say yes. I will not elaborate further.
Speaker 3Yeah. Jeff's playing the game.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I really... Twins, Pirates.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Those are the first two, right? But he did float around. I feel like he was a reliever for a couple of teams at the end.
Speaker 3Was he? You know what? I'll eat the bowl. I'll say no.
Speaker 1That's fine. I'm going to say yes, but I don't like it, and I don't think I could name what team it is. And the answer is yes. Jeff, do you have.
Speaker 3A guess as to which team?
Speaker 1Was it the Astros?
Speaker 2Yes, it is the Astros.
Speaker 32019 or 2018?
Speaker 12017.
Speaker 22017, yeah. I remember him vaguely being in that Astros bullpen, yeah.
Speaker 3I couldn't, like, just for what.
Speaker 2I couldn't remember specifically the Astros, but I remember he was in a team that won. That World Series didn't happen.
Speaker 3So I don't remember.
Speaker 1Robbie Grossman.
Speaker 3Come on.
Speaker 2Come on.
Speaker 1I'm going to say yes on this one.
Speaker 2I'm going to say yes, too. Again, I couldn't tell you what team.
Speaker 1Possibly more than one. I want to say it's the Rangers in 2023.
Speaker 2I think he might have done more than one. I think you're right. He was one of their late.
Speaker 3Does he only have the one?
Speaker 1He has the one. It's just the 2023 Rangers.
Speaker 2They traded for him and he was not good.
Speaker 3He was on the Astros? I think he was on the Braves?
Speaker 1He was one of the Astros they traded right before. He was on the 2014 Astros. He was on the bad Astros.
Speaker 3Wasn't he on the Braves in the 2020s?
Speaker 1He was on the Braves in 2022. Okay.
Speaker 3I'm close.
Speaker 1Very close. He was one of the guys they got after all the free agents. Okay. That's fine.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 1So it's... I still said yes. That's fine. Alright, next. Nori Aoki.
Speaker 3Oh, man. Was Nori Aoki.
Speaker 2I don't think so. I know he played too much at the end with the Mets, but I feel like he was a brewer the entire time otherwise.
Speaker 3No, was he?
Speaker 1I mean, yeah. I feel like he... For some reason, I'm Connect him to the Royals.
Speaker 3Is he not on the Astros at any point?
Speaker 2Maybe he was on the Royals. I don't think he was on the 2015 Royals.
Speaker 3I think he was on the Royals at some point.
Speaker 1I'm going to say no.
Speaker 2I'm going to say no.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think no also. Okay.
Speaker 1He was on the 2014 Royals that almost made it. Then he was on the 2015 Giants Theater. And then he went to the Mariners. And then he was on the 2017 Astros. But he got traded mid-season.
Speaker 2No, that's a ring.
Speaker 1Did he win a World Series? The game is called Got Rings. yeah it is skull got ring so i guess.
Speaker 3We all had the same answer it doesn't matter but i did say he was on the astros i thought that i just.
Speaker 1Wasn't sure what what year all right three more um store is still uh i have six craig is five jeff has four uh astro ball cabrera good boy um.
Speaker 2Was he now oh it's oh was he on that nats team I think he was on that Nats team. I'm going to say yes.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm going to say yes, too.
Speaker 2All right, fine.
Speaker 3I can't remember. That's fine.
Speaker 1You're going to say yes? Yeah. All right. It's correct. He was on that Nats team. All right. Two more to go. Alex Rios. Oh, man. Alex Rios.
Speaker 2I could not tell you where he went after the Jays.
Speaker 1Oh, White Sox. Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2White Sox, Jays.
Speaker 3Man.
Speaker 1How would you put, why would you put Rios on here?
Speaker 2It feels like a yes. It feels like a yes to me, but also every cell in my body is telling me to say no.
Speaker 1I'm going to say yes, and I don't know why.
Speaker 3I think it's a yes too. I think he was on the White Sox. Was he not on that one?
Speaker 1I'm saying he was on one of those Giants teams.
Speaker 2Was he on the White Sox in 2005? I don't know.
Speaker 3I'm going to say no.
Speaker 2I don't think he was. Maybe he was, but I don't think so.
Speaker 3I'm going to clarify, by the way, Patrick. I have discussed with Colin. He was going for on the roster when they won the World Series.
Speaker 1He named it wrong, but that's fine. The answer is yes. Not the team that I thought it was. He was apparently on the Royals. I can believe that. Who wasn't on the 2015 Royals? He was terrible.
Speaker 2Norie Aoki, yeah.
Speaker 12015 Royals, Alex Rios hit. 255,. 287,. 353. That sounds like Alex Rios.
Speaker 3Dominant.
Speaker 1Was he in the playoffs that year? Did he play in the playoffs? He did. He went two for 15 in the World Series.
Speaker 2Yeah, I have no memory of those at-bats, to be fair.
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 2I've blocked out a lot of them from the end.
Speaker 1Pretty good in the postseason before then. Overall, he was fine, but not good in the World Series. I thought he was a giant. I could have sworn he was one of those mediocre.
Speaker 2That makes sense.
Speaker 1Outfielders. But all right. Last one. And it's a suiting last one. Ty Wiginton.
Speaker 3Oh, my God. Come on.
Speaker 2Is he on the. I think he was. I don't think he was.
Speaker 1I'm going to.
Speaker 2I'm going to.
Speaker 1I'm going to risk it and say no.
Speaker 2I'm going to say yes. I think it was a 2009 Phillies or 2008 Phillies.
Speaker 3I think it was on the.
Speaker 1Yeah. If you want to catch up to me. Yeah. I'm one ahead of you.
Speaker 3All right, then I'll say yes.
Speaker 1The answer is no. He was not. That's okay.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Let's take a look.
Speaker 3I didn't think so. But if I had to say yes, then.
Speaker 2Where was he at? He was on the Phillies. Maybe it was a little at the post.
Speaker 3He was on the.
Speaker 1Let's see. He was on the Phillies in 2012. Okay.
Speaker 2It was post hangover Phillies.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. He was. He was.
Speaker 3Pirates for a while.
Speaker 1He was on the Pirates for only two years, 2004, 2005. Was he on a Rays team that got to the World Series? No, he was a couple years, but he was still a Devil Ray at that point. He was one of the early, I remember this from TAO6, he was one of the first signs that the Devil Rays might be at least trying to think about doing things in a different way. It was kind of an interesting pickup for them. And he was good for them. But then, and he's like, He had a weird career, man. His
Speaker 1batting line is all over the place. He was one of those guys like Craig Wilson who could hit, but he couldn't play any defense, but they played him everywhere.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, weird.
Speaker 2He was the Mets' third baseman before David Wright. They had to trade him to make room.
Speaker 3Shout out to getting to be an all-star on a 1.1 war season.
Speaker 1Yeah, sure did.
Speaker 2All right. Well, thank you, Colin, for the game. Thank you for joining us for another episode of Five and Dive, brought to you by the Baseball Perspectives Podcast Network. You can get in touch with the show at fiveanddiveatbaseballperspectives.com. We are wherever you get your podcasts. Please just search for the Baseball Perspectives Podcast Network. We'll be on that feed. If you're on one of those services, enjoy what we're doing here. We'd appreciate it if you rate and review us. Five stars only, please. And thank you again for joining us.
Speaker 1I'll take instructive criticism. I'm fine.
Speaker 3I'm a mature person. Not in the... Not in the star rating.
Speaker 2Email that.
Speaker 3Email that. We will absolutely take it via email.
Speaker 2And now you've been waiting for the pod to be over. Your time is now.
In Episode 596, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about the weather and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: The first salvo of free agent...
In Episode 595, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about Nick Martinez and feral cats and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Skubal Dooby Doo, where are you?: The latest in the Skubal sweepstakes, with some pun...
In Episode 594, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig once again chat about bagels (and cream cheese) and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. What would it take to be happy? I'll probably start with the money: Qualifying...
In Episode 593, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about beans both Rancho Gordo and coffee and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. It's nice to have options: Lot of players and teams making choices. 2. Go West:...
In Episode 592, Patrick, Jeffrey, and Craig chat about bagel preparation and then discuss five mostly baseball topics. 1. Aaron Ashby's Day Off: The Brewers bats wake up in a big way in Game 3. 2. These go to twelve:...