Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Answer Is Transaction Costs

The Answer Is Transaction Costs artwork

Sats in the Game: Stacker News

Nov 17, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail We talk with Stacker News founder Keon Kusha about building a link and discussion forum that uses Bitcoin Lightning micropayments to reward good contributions and reduce spam, bots, and attention waste. We dig into how transaction cost economics and Ostrom-style commons governance show up in trust scores, zaps, downzaps, and territory-level experiments. • Stacker News as Reddit-style forums moderated with money • Commons problems as the root cause of low-quality online discourse • Bitcoin and Lightning Network sats as usable micropayments • Zaps as paid upvotes that feel like real signals • Log-scaled ranking to reduce pay-to-win influence • Private web-of-trust scoring to weight credibility • Downzaps plus Tenderfoot and Wild West viewing modes • Regulatory friction and the move to non-custodial design • Cowboy credits as a ramp for users without Lightning • Territories as paid-to-create communities with residual claimants • Scaling arguments and why money can improve sorting • Minimal deletion policy and self-correcting trust loss TWEJ Letter Book o'da Month Links: Alain Bertaud on Econtalk: Cities without design Alain Bertaud on Econtalk: Fixing sick cities (Transaction Costs!) If you have questions or comments, or want to suggest a future topic, email the show at taitc.email@gmail.com! You can follow Mike Munger on Twitter at @mungowitz

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Michael MungerThis is Mike Munger, the knower of important things from Duke University. Today I'm going to talk to Keon Kusha, founder of the social media site Stacker News. It's as if Reddit were redesigned by a transaction cost economist. One of the coolest things I've seen in a while. More specifically, Stacker News is moderating forums with money. It's a link in discussion forum in the mold of Hacker News or Reddit. He was a former technical lead at Espera, now with IBM.

Michael MungerIt's open source, it's run out of Austin. The core idea, instead of earning free non-transferable upvotes or karma, like on Reddit, users earn and spend Satoshis or SATs, one one hundredth million of a Bitcoin, about 13 cents today, over the Lightning Network. It launched in 2021, raised some seed money, and started as a Bitcoin-only site. Keon and I will talk about what happened then. Since Territories launched in December 2023, it covers everything and it has specific little subdomains.

Michael MungerPolitics, economics, stocks, sports, AI, chess. It's self-expanding and self-monitoring. It's a distributed network with trust, and it has residual claimants built in. This month's economics joke, book it a month, and more. Straight out of Creedmore, this is Tidy C.

Michael MungerMy guest today on the answer is transactions cost is Keon Kusha And I want to say, Kian, welcome to the answer is Transaction Cost. Could you give an introduction about how you came to be interested in the things that interest you and what do you do?

Keyan KoushaYeah. So I'm the founder of Stacker News, which is kind of like Reddit, but we use Bitcoin to incentivize contributions and in some ways impose costs on people who contribute so that they don't overwhelm the network and the community. I got interested in Stacker News, or what brought me to Stacker News is I got interested in commons problems before I started Stacker News. I got really frustrated living with roommates after college. And I wanted to develop solutions for that.

Keyan KoushaAnd I started getting into Eleanor Ostrom's research. And so I had a little bit of background on this. And then I got into Bitcoin, got into the Lightning Network, and had products that I wanted that knew that I knew had suffered from Commons problems. And yeah, that's how Stacker News came about.

Michael MungerAnd the reference to Eleanor Ostrom is interesting. There's a lot of times we tend to think that if people were just moral, if they acted better, that would solve the problem. And I suppose it would in really small groups with repeated interactions. So you can tell some story about that. But for the most part, people are neither good nor bad, but the rules make them so. And so the question is how can we construct an environment where people can maximize their potential? One of the things that you use on Stacker News, and I just want to insert this as a parenthesis, because I some people know a lot about this, and some some people almost know almost nothing.

Michael MungerYou decided to use Bitcoin. So the how do you think of Bitcoin as the uh currency that you use? And is it something that you are going to stick with?

Keyan KoushaI'll definitely well definitely be sticking with it, at least for the foreseeable future. I just think it's awesome money. I I had a I was interested in economics and politics and a lot of this stuff, and and it got me really interested in money because it turns out it's so fundamental to things. And so that that that was that was before Bitcoin. I got into that stuff, and then Bitcoin appeared, and I was like, oh, this actually is consistent with everything. It's also lines up with a lot of my experience building distributed systems, and I get it. It it solves this problem, it solves this problem well.

Keyan KoushaAnd for the I I think for the foreseeable future, it's probably the best, best thing we've got.

Michael MungerAnd you you used a a magic word, distributed, and the what it happens automatically. It doesn't happen, it doesn't need anybody's permission, and it happens very quickly and seamlessly. I think a lot of people who use Bitcoin forget how invisible these transactions are to outsiders. So I I don't own any Bitcoin and I never have. In 2012, my wife and I had a very serious conversation. We had $10,000. We were thinking that we might put all $10,000 in Bitcoin and just see what happened.

Michael MungerAnd so I've never gotten over that because we didn't. And so although I'm pretty confident I would have sold all of it as soon as it went to three or four dollars, that's gonna be my story because otherwise it it is just too sad. The the current value of Bitcoin, I looked this morning, one dollar is about 1,300 satoshis, which means that one penny is about 13 satoshis. We're gonna talk about sats, which is short for satoshis as a unit of currency. That could that could change tomorrow, but right now, at least one penny is about 13 satoshis, uh, meaning that one sat is one thirteenth of a penny.

Michael MungerIt is relatively a small amount of money in the way that we think about currency. So on Stacker, I'm I I go on, I'm going to join Stacker, I'm going to have a subscription and I'm going to participate. What is the experience like?

Keyan KoushaYeah, to start, it's pretty simple. We don't we try to make it familiar. So it's it's free to create your bio, it's free to begin participating and creating comments. And then the hope is if you're earnest, someone notices you who's on the platform and they they give you they zap you a few stats. And a zap is like kind of an upvote, but it it is like a financial award to you. And then hopefully after getting those stats, you want to continue to participate and either zap other people or begin posting, creating more substantive content, and begin participating in the community.

Michael MungerAnd the what's interesting, you said this already, but I want to emphasize because it went by pretty quickly, wouldn't you think in terms of an analogy to Reddit? The reason that you're on here is that you're learning stuff, you're asking stuff, or you're having a conversation about things. And the little sub-communities that can be created are just up to you. And in fact, you could create one, you can join one, you can participate in one of longstanding. And so if I post or if I read a post that I like, then a zap is an upvote.

Michael MungerAnd on Reddit, you can upvote just by clicking the little thumb. In this case, you're asking people to put a small amount of money where their mouth is. And it isn't enough that it it costs them very much, but it it feels like something different. And so it in have you found that that's one of the things that attracts people? Or I realize you wouldn't know about the people who don't join because of that, but is that a controversy?

Keyan KoushaI do, I mean, I do think some people are resistant to spending money where they can get similar things for free elsewhere. And so I've been told that a lot. But for the people who come to Sacramuse and stay there, they are they are enchanted by this idea of someone across the internet valuing their ideas or their content or their contribution. And I think that that that's what that's what keeps them around. And it's also very it's nice to be generous and give back to people who contribute things that you like.

Keyan KoushaAnd there's it's just it's an interesting culture. But yeah, I said I think there are a lot of people who don't who don't want to spend any money at all. And that's it, that's that's okay.

unknownBut yeah.

Michael MungerThere is also something to have it be even a trivial sacrifice. There's a famous scene in Dune where one of the royals uh from another planet, one of the desert people spits at their feet. And of course, you take that as a sign of disrespect. But on Dune, there's so little water that the fact that I'm sacrificing a small amount of water by spitting at your feet, instead of just like upvoting, which is a click, this is a small sacrifice. And sure, it it is trivial, but it's an ancient human sacrifice is an ancient human custom.

Michael MungerAnd so it actually probably ties into some pretty deep brain architecture. So I what I like about it is that it is both modern and ancient because it has that that idea of I'm actually giving you something. Now, a lot of us, particularly young people, are probably used to the idea that just having a lot of likes is a sign that I have gotten something, but it it's not monetized. And so what's great about this is it's a kind of hybrid.

Keyan KoushaYeah, yeah. Yeah, and you don't you don't know. I mean, it's not a sacrifice from anyone to give you those likes. I mean, maybe a little bit of time, maybe a little bit of attention, but you don't know if they're even real people or if they're bots. Um and yeah, and I do think I do I do think it it it's it's a way for me, like I think when I zap people, it's a way for me to show them that I noticed them and value what they did. The only other way, like the only way I can really show someone that I appreciated their conference their content and make a sacrifice for them on Reddit or something is to put a lot of thought and time into something.

Keyan KoushaAnd maybe I don't have a lot of time, but I do have a bit of money that I can, you know, a few ZATs that I can send them.

Michael MungerWell, and you have a there's a I don't want to oversimplify, you have an architecture for making sure that it is difficult to use big zaps just as a means of advertising. So if I instead of one satoshi put a thousand or ten thousand satoshis, you have a uh a way of ranking. The ranking weight is trust times the log 10 of the amount. So 10 sats is one vote, a hundred sets is two, and a thousand sets is three.

Michael MungerSo I can buy influence, but it is at it is at a sharply declining rate. And because the one objection that one might have is well, the if I can spend money to upvote, that's just advertising.

Keyan KoushaYeah, yeah, we call that like rich rank in Bitcoin, where everything is ranked by you know who the wealthiest, what the wealthiest people like. And it's often you know their own content or their friends' content and not necessarily the best content. And I think what we all want in these types of communities is something, and it's it's idealistic, but something more akin to democ democracy and like you know, one person, one vote type of things.

Michael MungerAnd so the it it is possible to have quite a bit of money, but it it much more effective have many people making small zaps than three or four people making even pretty large ones. The log 10 is is pretty sharply declining.

Keyan KoushaYeah, but we still see people, you know, people have other motivations for zapping other than changing ranking, they'll zap people because they want to give them money. And so it's it's a contribution, yeah.

Michael MungerIt's a sacrifice again. So the the the fact that it has multiple purposes in an elegantly simple architecture is a feature, not a bug. That that actually is one of the things that I thought was interesting. You also have the the private trust score that I can earn, I can get more if I am an early adopter. If I if I see something that's interesting and I zap that, and others say, dang, yeah, that is cool. Uh I actually get more of a trust score from that.

Michael MungerHow exactly does that work?

Keyan KoushaYeah. We use we use an algorithm that was developed for BitTorrent networks, which suffer a similar problem where you're dealing with anonymous people on the internet and trying to determine whether you want to give them your resources. And it's called it, I mean, the set of the set of problems or the solution is called web of trust. And it's it's basically like I trust you, you trust someone, and I have a transitive trust relationship with the person that you trust, and you that that forms a web.

Keyan KoushaAnd so we use Markov chains kind of in a Google Peg Drink like way to traverse this graph and determine where where the trust should lie. And that is assigned to people on Stacker News and determines how much weight their SATs have when they're zapping things and also the rewards that they receive. But it's like memory. That's the way I think of trust. It in in human communities, it's kind of like collective memory. And so it's really important because we we don't function well without memory.

Keyan KoushaAnd I see trust as kind of like synapses in the brain, sort of, and it you don't want them everywhere, but you do, they are really important.

Michael MungerWell, and on on the theme of trust, there's also down zaps. So I can pay to say I don't actually like that. And then you have a couple of different forums with the is it Tenderfoot and Wild West. So the there's there's kind of a Western theme because there's also cowboy credit. Can you say something broadly about it? That metaphor is great because Wild West is the one that the that's what many people will use as a to to denigrate. Oh, it's like the Wild West, it had no rules. Well, no, actually, the Wild West had a lot of rules, they were emergent rules.

Michael MungerAnd having read Ostrom, I think a lot of my listeners also uh the the emergent rules that the wild west came up with weren't perfect, but they were pretty darn effective because groups of people that are trying to do something don't benefit from constantly warring and being able to decide nothing. So you have the Wild West and the tenderfoot. How do down zaps work in those two settings?

Keyan KoushaYeah. So in in the Wild West mode, a down zap has no impact at all on what you see and what you experience.

Michael MungerWhat's expressive? I get to say this sucks, but it has no impact on what others see.

Keyan KoushaYeah, well, well, no, actually, it's it if you down like if it's it's if other people are down zapping, that content won't hide for you if you're in Wild West mode. If you're in tenderfoot mode and other people have down zapped it, we you know, people have come together and said this is bad content, you won't see it. And so you're you're letting people spare you from seeing bad content. But wild west mode, you don't want to be spared at all. You want to be exposed to the to the to the frontier as it is.

Michael MungerAnd is there a is there a difference in do some people just stay in tenderfoot or is it something where they start out there and maybe switch? Because I'm interested in how people sort.

Keyan KoushaEveryone, everyone defaults to tender tenderfoot mode. Yeah, and then that makes sense. Yeah, and then over time they might see they might be made aware of content that was down's app and they don't see it, and then they uh they go into Wild West mode.

Michael MungerAnd people have to set up lightning to be able to send and receive Bitcoin, but if they don't do that, they can use cowboy credits because you're non-custodial, you don't want to be in the business of being a giant wallet, or they're just a bunch of other things that would happen. Can can you say something about how you made that decision and how cowboy credits work? It seems genius. This is just great.

Keyan KoushaYeah, well, we started out custodial, so I you know, I wasn't aware of regulations. I didn't think that I, you know, it's kind of naive. It's Bitcoin.

Michael MungerWhy would that why would there be regulations?

Keyan KoushaYeah, well, it's I mean, it's on the internet, it's very small amounts. There's people are sending 10 cents to each other. Why would why would the government care? And then I started talking to other people in the space a few years in, and they're like, oh, dude, you're a money transmitter. If you don't figure this out, you're gonna go to jail to talk to a lawyer, and they're like, Yeah, this is really bad. There's a bunch of platforms that tried to do similar things in the past and they got shut down.

Michael MungerAnd let's let let's be let's let's pause for a second. Not because you did anything wrong, it's just because you failed to get the permission of the state to do it.

Keyan KoushaYep. Yep. That was kind of yeah, they want me to enforce their laws for them. They want me, you know, if I want if I need to be a custodian, I need to get licenses in 50 states, which can take up to two years and several million dollars. And in some states, you you can't get it after several after much longer than that. So that just didn't seem like something I wanted to do. So instead, we we we settled on a technological solution and then a little bit of this graduated ramp with cowboy credits, where we are non-custodial.

Keyan KoushaIt was a huge engineering effort. Probably probably the majority of the time I've spent on the project has been on just trying to satisfy regulations while still creating the experience that I want where I don't have to KYC my users or do anything like that, report them to the government for what they're spending. So we have we instituted cowboy credits for people who don't have access to Lightning. They can use this like custodial money, but that they can't withdraw, but allows them to still transact and put money into the system.

Keyan KoushaThey just can't get these cowboy credits out. And then once they add a lightning wallet that is in their own control, we are able to allow them to transact in SATS without us being money transmitters or having to do AML or anything.

Michael MungerSo the by by analogy, the cowboy credits are script, it's something like gold in World of Warcraft. So the the it it I can move it around, and maybe somebody might offer me money for some, but that's on them. You have nothing to do with that. Yes, this is just script that moves around in the context of the game, or in this case, of the platform. And but there is a it is denominated in SATS, and it is a way of understanding of letting people take advantage of that if they want.

Michael MungerAnd if not, they can just participate on the platform. So I I thought that was that that was an interesting way. Parenthetically, it is an illustration of the barriers and transaction cost that permits and permissions from the regulatory authorities pose. You might well have said, Oh hell, I quit. I'm scared, I can't do this. I'm not going to spend six months just to restore the status quo. All you were doing was restoring the status quo where you were able to transact on this, but you had to make up this whole different architecture and cowboy credits.

Michael MungerGood on you for doing that. But there's an awful lot of things that never happen because of these sorts of restrictions. And it's really hard for us to measure the things that never happened. Think of the innovations or the communities that just don't exist because of these sort of transaction cost friction. So I think that that's one of the things that that Eleanor Ostrom's work illustrates. She tended to select on situations where somebody had solved the problem. But there's a bunch of chaotic settings where we have common good, common uh resource pools and they just dry up, they disappear because people are not able to solve the problem.

Michael MungerSo I I I think you you recognize your place in this grander scheme of things, but that seems to that's part of your aspiration. What would Stacker News look like if it's a success five years from now?

Keyan KoushaWell, my hope would be that it is a less a less toxic Reddit where and where like one of the ideas around our subreddits is that rather than being a moderator, the founders of them are kind of they're setting economic policy. And so we have we have maybe hundreds of little econ little economic experiments going on determining like what is the best way to run one of these communities and manage its resources and what what delivers the best result.

Keyan KoushaSo that's that's what I hope is happening in five years is we have we just have all these economic experiments running on the internet and we discover things that we wouldn't have otherwise.

Michael MungerSo it's interesting the the it the fact that it is decentralized and you have people who are largely, not entirely, but largely responsible for the content reminds me a little bit of Wikipedia, where you have someone, they're not really getting paid. What they care about is this content, and people sort into those contents, and that's probably you you couldn't pay them enough to get the sort of loyalty that comes from just caring about whether we get this right or not. So, how many communities are there about? And how is it decided that someone are there competing communities?

Michael MungerHow do you resolve that?

Keyan KoushaYeah, so there are economic costs to creating a community. Unlike Reddit, we have it costs 50,000 cents. You know, today's price is a little under $50 per month to create a territory. They earn revenue from that territory is people who participate in it. People don't participate in it, they don't earn any revenue at all. So that kind of inhibits a lot of a lot of behavior that you might not want to see. But we have roughly 40 territories, I think, right now. And they come and go. Sometimes they just they don't make money and they leave, and that's exactly what we want is we want to just what you want.

Keyan KoushaYeah. So yeah, I think yeah, I think it works. I think it works pretty well right now.

Michael MungerAnd so the this is both true of. Both posts and communities. The one of the heroes and villains on this podcast is Arthur Cecil Pagu, who talked about the fact that the way to solve externalities was to have a tax. And so if I post on Reddit, I am imposing an attention tax on the other readers who have to decide whether or not that's just stupid. I don't want to read that. So even a small attention tax is uh you might think of it as a Pagovian tax that makes it less likely that I'll just post a bunch of things.

Michael MungerIt's not months, but it's a little bit. It's at the margin. And so the that that kind of Pagovian tax, it does strike me, both for the creation of a territory and for just posting. I'm I have to take into account a little bit the fact that I'm asking attention from other people and I'll think a little bit more about it. So the, but I'm I'm an economist and I care about transaction costs. So of course I think this is nirvana. This is exactly the way that things should work. I think there's a lot of people who don't think that way and who would just like people to read for the pure love of it.

Michael MungerAnd what's great about what you're doing here is they're welcome to Reddit. Go ahead. That's great. So the the question, the reason I asked you about what a success would be, there has been some debate internally about whether y'all can grow. Is this going to scale? So, how big should it be? And if it got too big, might it be difficult? Because there's still there's only a certain amount of attention that I can pay. And so, how how much of this, the the like Wikipedia, dividing into territories means that it might scale because it's modular.

Michael MungerThey're there, I'm not looking at everything on stacker, I'm looking at one or two different territories. So it does seem like there's some hope that it would scale. But if you had millions and millions of people, it might be very difficult to keep track of what's being upvoted and what's being down zapped.

Keyan KoushaYeah, I well, I mean, Reddit seems to solve this problem, and Twitter and these very large problem like platforms solve this problem with one less tool, and I think a really powerful tool, which is money. They're doing this without without money, at least directly. And we have that tool, and so I think we would manage scale. My hope is we would manage scale better and produce a better experience for everyone involved.

Michael MungerI I I hate to keep name-dropping, but the the territories does make me think of Alchene and Demsets and the problem of having a residual claimant, because it's not you, you don't care. You you can have a territory or not, go nuts. But if someone says that we're not covering the costs, including the there are psychic benefits to me to having people participate in this discussion, and there are costs to me to having manage it. And it's just it's up to me. I can have the territory or not. So the the residual claimant is something that is missing, I think, in Reddit, of having someone who has large uh responsibility and autonomy in deciding whether or not they this so the I I realize that I'm just asking you a bunch of questions, the answers to which is yes.

Michael MungerYes, that's right. But the what I what the what I like about it is that you have taken to heart so many of the insights of transactions cost economics and implemented them in something that seems to be working. So, well, good good on you. Thank you. The the trust scores are private, and that protects the integrity of ranking. And it sounds like Goodhart's law, because the the if we all if we if you made the trust scores public, then people would probably be trying to game it so that they could maximize it.

Michael MungerIs secrecy, you think, a permanent feature of that, or it what are the mechanisms if someone is not trusted or if someone acts badly, how can they be removed?

Keyan KoushaYeah. So if someone is not trusted, they're they're zapping their attempt to change the ranking on Stacker News, they have no, they have no impact. They have no ability to do that. That's what happens. And if someone's behaving poorly, they're zapping things that we say don't want to see, or you know, we all kind of decide we don't want to see, then they lose their trust and they go back to zero. So they they can gain it and then lose it. And it's you know, we kind of run this trust algorithm daily and recalculate everyone's sit setting.

Michael MungerAnd so they they don't have to be removed because it's largely self-correcting. Yeah. It is what what if someone posts something that is out uh what are your rules for deciding whether some a post should be deleted?

Keyan KoushaWell, we we would I would only delete something if it were illegal. That is kind of where that's kind of the line the boundary we've drawn. We don't attract a lot of people who post anything like that. We've we've only I've only seen one piece of content like that in five years of the platform.

Michael MungerBecause it it it could be something it could be something diff defamatory or libelous. Do you worry about that?

Keyan KoushaNot really. I mean, we we've seen we've seen things that are defamatory, but that's kind of common in the Bitcoin community to in just any community. Yeah, online. Yes, online. That's actually true at the ladies' tea club. Yes, exactly. Yeah, so I don't worry too much about that. The the hope is that the system in place kind of manages that well and gives it the appropriate visibility. And a lot of these things are you know problems I maybe haven't considered, uh the problems of scale that we haven't experienced yet.

Michael MungerWhat sorts of things are the the things that people read the most? So just give us uh what is it that Stacker News participants are interested in? It it's a pretty self-selected community.

Keyan KoushaYeah, it's I mean, we attract a lot of libertarians and we attract we attract some of our most consistent members are economists, or we have one we have a lawyer that's been very loyal to the platform for a very long time, or a retired lawyer. And I would say we're most popular with economists because I think they get it.

Michael MungerThat there's I don't need to I don't need to convince them that paying for things is good for them, but everyone else and is good for the thing, it it is actually good for the it is not just good for the individual, it it makes the platform better. Well, perhaps unsurprisingly, as a libertarian economist who studied with Douglas North, the I I I would be a fan of this. If someone wanted to join Stacker News, uh I'll I will put up the link, but do you there's any advice that you have about someone how someone could get the most out of it?

Keyan KoushaYeah, I would say just read and and comment thoughtfully. It's you know, a community still small will spot you almost immediately and and welcome you in in a pretty big way. Yeah. So it doesn't, it doesn't take much right now to to get a lot out of it if you put a motochrum of effort in.

Michael MungerWell, I I I have to say for my own part, I I joined and did an AMA and the questions were terrific. And I actually have connected with some of the people that I talked to there offline with with with email. So I I hope that it's not just most of the time when things are new and good, they just seem great, and then there's this process some people have called inshidification, where they it's hard to keep them as good, but some things have, and I I have very high hopes for this.

Michael MungerWell, it is is there any final thing then you would like to say to people about how they should think about Stacker News?

Keyan KoushaI would I would say just I think what one of the things that I'm I've been most surprised with is how how much micropayments resemble just kind of normal economic behavior. And I think I just that was really surprising to me because I think we all have this suspicion that things are different at different scales, and they you know things do change at different scales, but in this case, the overall structure structure resembles normal economics, and I think that is powerful because the economics has been such a force for good, and so I would like to see that applied at at more scales.

Michael MungerWell, the the a number of people have said micropayments don't work, and I think it's more like micropayments in many cases haven't worked so far. This seems to be an instance where they are working. So let me say, Ian, thank you very much for having been a guest on The Answer is Transaction Cost.

Keyan KoushaThank you for having me, Professor Munker.

Michael MungerWhoa, that sound means it's time for the twedge. Every Wednesday night, Superman is useless. He can't do anything. No, no, that's his Bitcoin and stablecoin discussion meetup. You might say it's his kryptonite. That's some quality stuff right there, people. Why does Tom Brady refuse to invest in Bitcoin? Oh, he always prefers deflation. A letter.

Michael MungerI've been an avid listener to the answer is transaction cost for around a year and a half now, and I greatly enjoyed the episode where you apply the theory of transaction cost to issues that don't initially sound like economics. The most recent episode that happened is where you applied transaction cost to the revival of Hebrew. It was especially entertaining as I live in Israel and studied mathematics in Hebrew. Was always curious to see that many terms were translated, such as the words for set and calculus, but others, such as function, matrix, or graph, were effectively transliterated.

Michael MungerI'm sure that the answer is some form of transaction cost even after the era of deliberate promotion of Hebrew in academia. I've also found another example where transaction costs intersect another field, urban planning. There are many great examples of transaction cost in urban planning, especially how cities have changed as cost changed. For example, factories used to be built in the middle of cities because the cost of commute and the proximity to high capacity transportation, such as railroads and ports, outweighed the cost of smog and noise.

Michael MungerNowadays, factories are built outside cities because those costs have flipped. Transportation became cheap, workers can be expected to have access to a car, and smog and noise have become prohibitive to build near residences. Absent parking minimums, a store owner will build parking based on how much access to parking impacts the transaction cost of arriving at their own store. Malls commercial areas are ways of reducing the cost of discoverability, though nowadays the internet has been changing that.

Michael MungerWhat other examples of transactions cost in city are there? And to close, I came up with an economics joke that at least I find hilarious. I'd make a great economist because I understand comparative advantage well enough to know that I should keep working in software engineering. Regards. AL. Well, thanks, AL, and I am interested in the costs of urban planning. There's a couple of terrific econ talks about that with Alain Berthault, and I'll put up links to those because the applications of transaction cost in urban planning certainly are very interesting.

Michael MungerThis month's book is Anthony Cornyn's The Golden Ladder, How Inequality Built Civilization until we made it illegal. It was published in 2026 by Houndstooth Press. Well, thanks, and until next month, thanks for listening to Tidy C.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bookmakers Set Odds To Maximize Profit Not Balance Bets

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail A NOTE OF APOLOGY: I uploaded the raw audio, rather than the podcast. So the first of you who listened heard the raw version, where there was some random stuff at the beginning. Sorry to waste your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Renta Vitalicias: Pension Promises Only Work When Politics Honors Them

    Sep 27, 20261 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We walk through how Chile converts retirement savings into lifelong income and why inflation protection and competition make the design work. Then politics collides with contract law as COVID-era...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. God Speaks Hebrew But Understands Yiddish

    Aug 25, 202628 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We trace how Hebrew goes from a “museum language” to a living vernacular by treating language as a coordination good with huge network effects and real transaction costs. We follow Eliezer Ben-Yehuda’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Main Course was Transaction Costs: Milton's Dinner with Ronald

    Aug 19, 202625 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We tell the story of the Chicago dinner where Ronald Coase walks into a hostile room, and by the end everyone votes with him, led by Milton Friedman changing his mind in real time. Along the way, we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Regime Uncertainty: Political Risk is Transaction Cost!

    Aug 11, 202625 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We walk through the weirdly powerful math that makes a stable $10,000 profit stream worth $50,000 in one world and $1,000,000 in another. Then we apply the same present value logic to politics and show...

    Credit the people on this episode