Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The 365 Commitment

The 365 Commitment artwork

Day 354 - Evidence of Work is Not Evidence of Learning

Sep 28, 20264 minAudio

We all instinctively know this is not right, yet we tolerate it. Anyone who has recently made it through K-12 or has been a parent of these young people knows what I mean. School has increasingly substituted evidence of work for evidence of learning. A completed worksheet, a submitted Google Classroom assignment, a passing quiz, satisfactory completion of an online module. These all fall firmly into the evidence-of-work category. All of these things were intended to support learning, not replace it. They have become proxies for learning, and now we have a problem. Artificial Intelligence is brutally effective at exposing bad proxies. So schools are now banning devices, banning AI use, and spending billions on district-controlled devices and methods to restrict cellular traffic. Doing everything they can to prevent what they are referring to as the mechanism that is harming education. A student can now produce the worksheet, the five-paragraph essay, the chapter summary, the vocabulary definitions, the discussion-board response, and perhaps even the presentation without much underlying knowledge. Schools understandably see this as a crisis. Countless dollars spent on software, online curricula, and evidence-based modalities are now at risk. This begs the question. What exactly is under threat of being lost? If the educational activity was primarily “read this, answer these questions, submit it by Friday,” AI has not destroyed teaching. It has destroyed the mechanism schools were using to verify compliance. That is uncomfortable because it forces education back toward the expensive, difficult thing: actual teaching. What is being exposed here is a fallacy. For decades, we have often treated the production of academic artifacts as the same as the development of a mind. They are not the same thing. Three things that I was not eager to do in school were to read, write, and solve math problems represented in paragraph form, what kids call word problems. An essay is important because writing forces a person to organize their thoughts. Math problems help you build intuition for problem solving, and reading builds sustained attention and fosters comprehension. It is absolutely correct to fear that if a student performs these artifacts while skipping the cognitive work, then yes, something important is being lost. However, the answer cannot be "We need better ways to make sure students complete the worksheets themselves.” Which is almost a direct quote that I heard from a school administration official recently. AI proliferation is almost universal, at least in the halls of U.S. high schools, so it will get increasingly difficult to confuse completion with competence. The question is not whether the student completed the activity. The question is, did the student do the cognitive work the exercise was intended to create? Perhaps the real educational opportunity AI presents is that it makes busy work nearly impossible to defend. If a machine can complete an assignment perfectly while learning absolutely nothing, we should at least ask whether completion of that assignment was ever particularly good evidence that a human being had learned anything in the first place. We all already know this. AI did not create the crisis in education. It revealed that much of education had already been automated before AI arrived. We now need to make the thinking visible. Measure thinking, not completion. We can no longer focus on assessing the artifact. We will have to focus on our ability to explain, defend, apply, question, revise, and extend what we have produced, whether AI helped create it or not.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

This is day. 354 evidence of work is not evidence of learning. We all instinctively know this is not right yet. We tolerate it. Anyone who has recently made it through K through 12 or has been apparent of these young people knows what I mean school has increasingly substituted as evidence of work for evidence of learning. A completed worksheet a submitted Google Classroom assignment a passing quiz satisfactory completion of an online module these all fall firmly into the evidence of work category. All these things were intended to support learning not replace it. They've become proxies for Learning and now that we and now we have a very big problem. Artificial intelligence is brutally effective at exposing bad proxies. So schools are now Banning devices Banning AI use and spending billions of District control spending billions on District controlled devices and methods to restrict cellular traffic. Doing everything they can to prevent what they are referring to as the mechanism that is harming education. A student can now produce the worksheet the five paragraph essay the chapter summary the vocabulary definitions the discussion board response and perhaps even the presentation without much underlying knowledge schools. Understandably. See this as a crisis. Countless dollars spent on software online curricula and evidence-based modalities are now at risk. This begs the question what exactly is under the threat of being lost? If the educational activity was primarily read this answer these questions submitted by Friday. AI has not destroyed teaching it is destroyed the mechanism schools were using to verify compliance. That is uncomfortable because it forces education back towards the expensive difficult thing actual teaching. What is being exposed here is a fallacy. For decades we have often treated the production of academic artifacts as the same the same as the development of the mind. They are not the same thing. Three things that I was eaten not eager to do in school was to read write and solve math problems represented a paragraph form. What kids call word problems today. An essay is important because riding forces a person to organize their thoughts. Math problems help you build intuition for problem solving and reading builds sustained attention and fosters comprehension. It is absolutely cracked a fear that if a student performs these artifacts while skipping the cognitive work then yes, something important is being lost. However, they answer cannot be we need better ways to make sure students complete the worksheets themselves. Which is almost a direct quote that I heard recently from a school administration official. AI proliferation is almost Universal at least in the halls of us high schools. So we'll get increasingly difficult to confuse completion with competence. The question is not whether the student completed the activity. The question is did the student do the cognitive work. The exercise was intended to create. Perhaps the real Educational Opportunity AI presents is that it makes busy work nearly impossible to defend. If a machine can complete an assignment perfectly while learning absolutely nothing we should at least ask whether completion of that assignment was ever particularly good evidence that a human being had learned anything in the first place. We already know this AI did not create the crisis and education it revealed that much of education has been automated before AI even arrived. We now need to make the thinking visible measure thinking not completion. We can no longer focus on assessing the artifact. We will have to focus on our ability to explain defend apply question revise and extend what we have produced whether AI helped created or not.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Day 3,239 - Your Minimum is Your Faith

    Nov 20, 20262 minAudio

    I have been thinking lately about the relationship between faith and the amount of effort we are willing to contribute toward something we want to become. We all have ambitions of one kind or another. Perhaps we want to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Day 3,238 - Understanding Action Crisis

    Nov 18, 20265 minAudio

    A fascinating psychological process occurs when a person moves from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. I have been here several times, both in physical challenges and mental ones. I have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Day 3,237 - Jedi Physiological Tricks

    Nov 17, 20264 minAudio

    This morning around 2 a.m., one of my dogs started to make a commotion downstairs. He was whining, barking, carrying on. Of course, I am the one that gets to deal with this sort of thing, so I go downstairs and find my...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Day 3,236 - Separating the Dream from The Decision

    Nov 17, 20263 minAudio

    I have noticed a weird phenomenon about me. I get myself sold on something awesome, or at least the idea of something awesome. In my mind, the dream and ambition of it sound great, and I start thinking of all the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Day 3,235 - Learning to Rest

    Nov 15, 20263 minAudio

    So when you are actually tired. Meaning that you legitimately need a break. Not because you are just feeling down, anxious, depressed, or for some other reason, but when you are just worn out, how do you deal with that?...

    Credit the people on this episode