Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The 365 Commitment

The 365 Commitment artwork

Day 364 - The Evil Word Problem

Oct 8, 20263 minAudio

We all can recall with trepidation the last question on the math test; it was always the dreaded word problem. Most of us just immediately folded. The one brainiac smart girl in class had learned how to convert key phrases back into the required equation and found the word problem to actually be really easy. The one recluse kid in the back corner of the classroom could solve that problem without even writing anything down and, in fact, would refuse to do so because it was boring. So, out of a class of 25, two kids could solve the problem, but only 1 would get an A. Try as she might, and even though she explained the exact scenario using different characters, she could not get anyone in her class to be willing to even attempt the word problem. Most would just punt at the first sight of something that required any ounce of reasoning. Nowadays, math classes are really pushing this concept. This is probably a good thing, although I am not sure about the methodology. Our children bring home a packet of complex word problems, scenarios that the young person has to figure out or fail on the pending test. As usual, the parent finds out about this the night before, and thus we find ourselves trying to explain how the word problem works. We are paying for the years in which we refused to do any word problems; now we are doing them at night with our kids. It is almost as if that smart girl grew up and became an official in the state K-12 administration and fought hard to adopt a 100% word problem curricula to seek revenge on her 28 other classmates in high school algebra. Julie, please forgive me for shooting spit wads into your hair while you were finishing the math test. For the last time, I apologize. You can stop tormenting us now with your continuous production of word problems in your revenge plot. There is a difference between procedural competence and conceptual understanding, and this is what the modern word problem is trying to achieve. Our children have the same reaction we did, which is the immediate recognition that conceptual understanding actually requires us to think and, like it or not, our brains are wired to avoid that level of thinking unless it is required for our immediate survival. Unless, of course, you are the black leather jacket, long-haired boy in the back of the room who was born with a passion to disregard all procedures in life and therefore wholeheartedly embraces high-order thinking. A person can become very good at a procedure while still being unable to explain the underlying idea, adapt it to a new situation, troubleshoot when it breaks, or teach it to someone else. A good test of whether you have actually learned something is whether you can do four things: explain it in your own words, apply it in a different context, recognize when it does not apply, and modify the approach when conditions change. I tried to explain this to my daughter last night; she just rolled her eyes, put her earbuds in, and said, "Dad, can you just give me the answer? The teacher is letting us use notes." Thanks, Julie. You got me to do my word problems. When will the torture end?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

This is day. 364 the evil word problem. We can all recall with trepidation the last question on the math test. It was always the dreaded word problem. Most of us just immediately folded the one Brainiac smart girl in class had always had learned how to convert key phrases back into the required equation and found the word problem to actually be really easy. The one recluse kid in the back corner of the classroom could solve that problem without even writing anything down and in fact would refuse to do so because it was boring. So out of a class of 25 two kids would solve the problem but only one would get an A try as she might and even though she explained the exact scenario using different characters. She could she could not get anyone the teacher could not get anyone in her class to be willing to even attempt the word problem. Most would just punt at the first sight of something that required an ounce of reasoning. Nowadays math classes are really pushing this concept. This is probably a good thing all the way. I am not sure about the methodology our children. Bring home a pack of complex word problems scenarios that the young person has to figure out or fail on the pending tests as usual the parent finds out about this the night before and thus we find ourselves trying to explain how the word problem works. We are paying for the years in which we refuse to do any word problems. Now we are doing them at night with our children. It is almost as if that smart girl grew up and became an official in this state K-12 Administration and fought hard to adopt 100% word problem curricula to seek revenge on her 28 other classmates in high school algebra. Julie please forgive me for shooting spit wads into your hair while you were finished in the math test for the last time. I apologize you can stop tormenting us now with your continuous production of word problems in your revenge plot. There is a difference between procedural competence and conceptual understanding and this is what the modern word problem is trying to achieve our children have the same reaction that we did which is the immediate recognition that conceptual understanding actually requires us to think and like it or not. Our brains are wired to avoid that level of thinking unless it is required for our immediate survival. Unless of course you are you are that black leather jacket long-haired boy in the back of the room who was born with a passion to disregard all procedures in life and therefore wholeheartedly Embraces higher order thinking A person could become a very good at procedure while still being unable to explain the underlying idea adapted to a new situation troubleshoot it when it breaks or teach it to someone else. A good test of whether you have actually learned something is whether you can do four things. First explain it in your own words to apply it in a different context three recognize when it does not apply and finally modify the approach when conditions change. I tried to explain this to my daughter last night. She just rolled her eyes put her earbuds in and said dad. Can you just give me the answer the teachers letting us use notes? Thanks, Julie. You got me to do my word problems. When will this torture end?

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Day 3,239 - Your Minimum is Your Faith

    Nov 20, 20262 minAudio

    I have been thinking lately about the relationship between faith and the amount of effort we are willing to contribute toward something we want to become. We all have ambitions of one kind or another. Perhaps we want to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Day 3,238 - Understanding Action Crisis

    Nov 18, 20265 minAudio

    A fascinating psychological process occurs when a person moves from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. I have been here several times, both in physical challenges and mental ones. I have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Day 3,237 - Jedi Physiological Tricks

    Nov 17, 20264 minAudio

    This morning around 2 a.m., one of my dogs started to make a commotion downstairs. He was whining, barking, carrying on. Of course, I am the one that gets to deal with this sort of thing, so I go downstairs and find my...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Day 3,236 - Separating the Dream from The Decision

    Nov 17, 20263 minAudio

    I have noticed a weird phenomenon about me. I get myself sold on something awesome, or at least the idea of something awesome. In my mind, the dream and ambition of it sound great, and I start thinking of all the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Day 3,235 - Learning to Rest

    Nov 15, 20263 minAudio

    So when you are actually tired. Meaning that you legitimately need a break. Not because you are just feeling down, anxious, depressed, or for some other reason, but when you are just worn out, how do you deal with that?...

    Credit the people on this episode