Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The 365 Commitment

The 365 Commitment artwork

Day 350 - Learning to Triangulate

Sep 24, 20265 minAudio

I remember taking a basic survival course when I was younger. The instructor took us outside to demonstrate a basic surveying technique called triangulation. The concept is simple, so if you are unfamiliar, let me explain. If you know the location of two points and the distance between them, then measure the angles from those points to a third object, you can calculate where that third object must be. If you have ever hiked in the wilderness, you will occasionally come across these brass survey markers. Surveyors used networks of these triangles to map enormous areas without physically measuring every distance. These markers formed the basis for establishing known distances. Later in life, I bought a boat, one of the best and worst decisions I have made in life! However, I decided to take an online "captain" course because taking my boat out into the harbor was extremely intimidating for a newbie like me. That course had a section that was basically the same thing. A sailor might take bearings on two known landmarks, such as a lighthouse and a headland. Where those bearing lines intersect tells the sailor where the ship is. This is often called taking a fix or using cross bearings. This basic principle is that of never trusting one source. So you can triangulate instead. If Source A says one thing, and source B says the same thing and then you find a thir source that also points in that same direction then you can draw some inference as to what reality might be. Where independent lines of evidence converge is your best estimate of reality. The philosophical implication is that you cannot triangulate with only one point of reference. That may be one of the central problems with trying to determine truth from a single news source, expert, ideology, institution, or algorithm. Yet we do this all the time. Just this morning, I saw a news flash that some famous actor was caught cheating on some famous actress. There was even a video showing the actor kissing another woman. The headline was pure clickbait, and no doubt generated a lot of that. I decided to read the comments, and in those comments I saw various stages of triangulation. Many people accepted this one source as absolute truth. Others looked at other sources but found conflicting information. Others questioned the validity and motivations of the original source altogether. If you had the patience to sort through the various comments, you finally determined the reality. This was completely fake. The picture was real, but it didn't show the actor in question. After a few hours, they found the real person; although they looked similar to the actor, they were not the same person. The new fun phrase people like to use today is "AI slop." They will say, "Oh, that is AI slop," or "That looks like AI slop." The danger behind this thinking is that this is not triangulation. This is using your ability to make quick assessments, which your brain is really good at, but it can also be deceived. The test we use to determine if something is AI, called the Turing test, is designed to see if the system can fool another human into thinking that this is coming from another human and not a machine. So, using a quick dismissal like " this is AI slop, is not a good solution. That will work for obviously poorly crafted material, but what about everything else? The answer is that we are going to have to dust off the old textbooks, crack open the surveyor handbook, or nautical charts and learn how to triangulate as our default reaction. Accepting content, viewpoints, news, or other material from external sources at face value is simply no longer an option. We have to follow basic reasoning principles with everything we consume. We should have been doing that in the first place, but now more than ever, this is imperative lest we be led around by the nose.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

This is day three fifty learning to triangulate. I remember taking a basic survival course when I was younger. The instructor took us outside to demonstrate a basic surveying technique called triangulation. The concept is really simple. So if you're unfamiliar, let me explain. If you know the location of two points and the distance between them then measure the angles from those points to find the two a third object. You could then calculate what that what what that third object must be. If you've ever hiked in the wilderness, you will occasionally come across these brass survey markers. Surveys surveyors used networks of these triangle triangles to map enormous areas without physically measuring every distance. These markers formed the basis for establishing known distances. Later in life. I bought a boat one of the best and the worst decisions that I've ever made in life. However, I decided to take an online Captain course because taking my boat out into the Harbour was extremely intimidating for a newbie like me. That core set a section. That was basically the same thing a sailor might take bearings on two known landmarks such as a lighthouse and a headland where those bearing lines intersect tells the Sailor where the ship is. This is often called taking a fix or using a cross bearing This basic principle is that is that I've never the basic principle is this it's never trusting One Source. So you can try angulate instead. If Source a says one thing and Source B says the same thing then you find a third source that also points in that same direction. Then you can draw some inference as to what reality might be. Where independent were independent lines of evidence converge is your best estimate of what is reality? The philosophical implication is that you cannot triangulate with only one point of reference? That may be one of the central problems with trying to determine truth from a single news source expert ideology institution or an algorithm. Yet we do this all the time. Just this morning. I saw a news flash that some famous actor was caught cheating on some famous actress. There was even a video showing the actor kissing another woman. The headline was pure clickbait and no doubt generated a lot of just that. I decided to read the comments and in those comments, I saw various stages of this triangulation. Many people accepted this one source is absolute truth. Others looked at other sources, but found conflicting information. Others questioned the validity and motivations of the original Source altogether. If you had the patience to sort through the various comments, you finally determined the reality. This was completely fake. The picture was real but it did not show the it didn't show the actor in question after a few hours. One of the comments commenting people found the real person. Although they look similar to the actor. They were not the same person. The fun new phrase people like to use today is AI slop they will say oh that is AI slop or that looks like AI slop the danger behind. This thinking is that this is not try angulation. This is using your ability to quickly make assessments which your brain is actually really good at but it can also be deceived. The test we used to determine if something is AI which we've called the Turing test for a long time now is designed to see if a system can full another human into thinking this is coming from another human and not a machine. So using a quick dismissal like this is AI slot is not a good permanent solution. This will work for obviously obviously poor crafted material. But what about everything else? The answer is that we are going to have to dust off the old textbooks crack open the surveyor handbook or nautical charts and learn how to triangulate as our default reaction accepting content viewpoints news or other material from external sources at face value is simply no longer an option. We have to follow basic reasoning principles with everything. We consume we should have been doing the solve all along in the first place. But now more than ever this is imperative. Let's be led around by the nose.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Day 3,239 - Your Minimum is Your Faith

    Nov 20, 20262 minAudio

    I have been thinking lately about the relationship between faith and the amount of effort we are willing to contribute toward something we want to become. We all have ambitions of one kind or another. Perhaps we want to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Day 3,238 - Understanding Action Crisis

    Nov 18, 20265 minAudio

    A fascinating psychological process occurs when a person moves from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. I have been here several times, both in physical challenges and mental ones. I have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Day 3,237 - Jedi Physiological Tricks

    Nov 17, 20264 minAudio

    This morning around 2 a.m., one of my dogs started to make a commotion downstairs. He was whining, barking, carrying on. Of course, I am the one that gets to deal with this sort of thing, so I go downstairs and find my...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Day 3,236 - Separating the Dream from The Decision

    Nov 17, 20263 minAudio

    I have noticed a weird phenomenon about me. I get myself sold on something awesome, or at least the idea of something awesome. In my mind, the dream and ambition of it sound great, and I start thinking of all the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Day 3,235 - Learning to Rest

    Nov 15, 20263 minAudio

    So when you are actually tired. Meaning that you legitimately need a break. Not because you are just feeling down, anxious, depressed, or for some other reason, but when you are just worn out, how do you deal with that?...

    Credit the people on this episode