Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Test Corrections with Josh Andrew

Test Corrections with Josh Andrew artwork

When to Refuse a Promotion | Test Corrections with Roosevelt Montás

Oct 6, 202658 minAudio

We tend to treat professional advancement as an obvious good. It brings more responsibility, more influence, and more prestige. But what if success pulls us away from the work that gives our lives meaning? Roosevelt Montás, author or Rescuing Socrates, joins Test Corrections to discuss ideas worth saving: the teaching life, citizenship, liberal education, our attention, reading Great Books, and our own sense of purpose.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Test Corrections, a production of Liberty Classical Schools, a show devoted to returning to the questions that we face as teachers, school leaders, parents, or professionals that we miss or just overlook on the first assessment. So we go back and we correct our answers. I'm your host, Josh Andrew. In college, a professor and mentor once told me, save your soul. Don't be a leader. The instruction was followed by a catalog of stories about great men and women who were approached with promotions and essentially fled from the hills.

SPEAKER_01It was hard to take advice like this seriously at 21 when the point of getting a college education was oriented, at least partially, toward securing the most lucrative job possible. And if that came with more authority, then so be it. A move from vice president to senior vice president seems like a no-brainer. So does going from captain to major, manager to director, or accountant to CFO. But what about teacher to principal? Like most professions, when you have success at a school, when you get things done, someone comes along and asks you if you want to do something different.

SPEAKER_01But I've wondered if there's something unique and almost sacred about the teaching life that should prompt us to ask a different set of questions about whether promotion is an inherent and unquestionable good. Today, my guest is Dr. Roosevelt Montatz. Roosevelt is a professor at Bard College in New York and leads their Center for Liberal Education and Civic Life. Before this, he led the Great Brooks Program at Columbia University for a decade and directed their Freedom and Citizenship program.

SPEAKER_01In 2021, Roosevelt published a book called Rescuing Socrates, which is one of the most stirring and personal defenses I've encountered of the enduring value of an education that prepares a person to be free. Roosevelt has this special talent for identifying the questions that lurk just beneath the surface of our daily reality, but which demand our complete attention. We sat down to discuss the qualities of a great teacher, the costs of professional growth, and the connection between citizenship and a liberal education.

SPEAKER_01Welcome, Roosevelt. Thanks for joining us here this afternoon. Thank you, Josh. It's really a pleasure to talk to you. So early in the book that you've written about rescuing Socrates, you have this really striking metaphor about teachers as found fathers and found mothers. It strikes me as a very personal metaphor, and I wonder if you would unpack that.

SPEAKER_00Sure. As with much else in that book, it's very personal. And part of the reason why that book is personal is because my life has unfolded in such a way as to provide a quite stark illustration of what a liberal education can do. A very stark illustration of how someone who may lack the traditional advantages that usually people who get liberal education have can benefit and be transformed by and empowered by a liberal education.

SPEAKER_00I came to the to the US when I was 12, not speaking English to uh with a single parent. My mom was here. Also didn't speak English at a minimum wage job. So I had a lot of things sort of stacked against me as far as uh social success, financial, uh cultural, political integration into greater American society. Um and uh a liberal education, um, which I sort of stumbled into, a liberal education based on the study of great books, uh, based on discussion, based on reflection on fundamental human questions, both sort of existential and spiritual, but also social and political.

SPEAKER_00This kind of education really opened my world. Um and so so sort of my life story illustrates quite starkly what a liberal education can do for anyone, and which it does for even students who come with the most sort of advantaged, privileged backgrounds, uh, have this experience with liberal education. Um and part of that experience is is about relationships with people, um, and prominently relationship with teachers.

SPEAKER_00Liberal education is something that happens from person to person. Um, it is this distinctive human tradition uh of cultivation and transmission. It is not, you know, it's not like instruction so much as transmission. I say that that it happens by contagion. Um so so the role of the teacher um as a kind of guide, as a kind of uh encourager, and as a kind of uh sometimes a challenger, somebody who challenges you uh and who inspires you but also calls you to a higher plane of thinking and of being.

SPEAKER_00Um the teacher is fundamental to the process of liberal education. Um and that and that um relationship between the student and the teacher has a sort of pastoral parental component. Um, you, as a teacher in a liberal education context, look out for the souls, for the whole development of the person uh from a position of greater uh uh age, greater uh authority, greater uh perspective and information, greater experience.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but you do it with that uh a kind of care and a kind of investment that is akin to uh to the one that a parent brings to a relationship. In my case, um, you know, I left my my other parent, my father, when I left the Dominican Republic. So uh I came here to just have one parent. Uh one parent who, as I said, had you know was restretched and very um ill-equipped to help me navigate American society and certainly higher education.

SPEAKER_00My mother didn't even finish high school. Um, so teachers were really um uh crucial, really critical to my development. And at every stage in my life, I have had the fortune of finding teachers who uh established and cultivated that kind of relationship. That relationship where, yes, they were my intellectual mentors and sort of educators, uh, but there was also something more fundamental about their investment in me and about the bond that we formed. So uh these teachers were also found parents for me.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess I'm I'm curious in in the other side of that relationship, the notion that the student has some power. The student is the one who does the finding, right? Even in your book, the notion of rescuing Socrates, it is the reader who rescues the teacher. And I I wonder about that dynamic. And in what way are we reliant upon our students to become the thing that we ought to be, right? If teachers function primarily as as pastors, as guides, we are not that until we've been found.

SPEAKER_01And I wonder what your experience is with being found.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh that's a that's a beautiful way of putting it and of thinking about it. Um there's a there's a sort of a precept in the Buddhist tradition, maybe it's broader than than than Buddhist. I I'm not I'm no scholar of Eastern religion, but um that when the it goes something like when the student is ready, the teacher will appear. Um that is the the student's disposition and inner orientation somehow invokes, somehow materializes the teacher.

SPEAKER_00Um you can look at the sort of the obverse of that or the reverse of that, which is that um you can't teach an unwilling student. Uh this kind of teaching cannot be done except in response to a readiness, in response to an openness. Uh now part of the magic of the teacher is that sometimes the teacher catalyzes that opening. Sometimes the teacher, in being the way that they are, um, is able to um create that space and to evoke that that that readiness from the student.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but it's absolutely um a um a relationship that that requires and depends on a particular orientation uh from the student. Um and what this sort of ancient precept upholds is that when the student uh is ready in that way, uh the teacher, the resources to meet that need will materialize, will come come in into them.

SPEAKER_01I wonder sometimes if if one of the reasons uh liberal education as a tradition can be sort of fragile, especially as it appears at the university, is because of this mutual dependence, right? It it we would prefer that it just relied on one intelligent person to stand in front of a group and say intelligent things. But instead, there is there's a dependence. There is a requirement that the student be there and present and ready and that the teacher do the same.

SPEAKER_01Uh I'm just curious if if how how you think about that notion of uh that dependence being part of the fragility of the project.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Um it is a it is a profoundly essentially human project, uh a project of relationship building, um, and of an and as I've said, of human-to-human cultivation that cuts against the main thrust and current of the university. Um, you know, the university as it has come to be, the contemporary 21st century university, has its roots in in the 19th century.

SPEAKER_00There's a big transformation in the university in the 19th century, driven sort of the engine of that transformation in Germany and the emergence there of a research university, a university whose purpose was the investigation, reproduction, dissemination of new knowledge. It was sort of set up to be at the cutting edge of human knowledge. And of course, that's been extraordinarily powerful. It has transformed our society, our culture, our uh our world many times over and continues to.

SPEAKER_00Um, but when you focus on knowledge and discovering new knowledge and transmitting new knowledge, you're not focused on people. Um, that is, there is a different mission of the university that was sort of the standard, what the university was about before that that that transformation into a research university that had to do with not so much with being at the cutting edge of new knowledge, but with transmitting a repository, transmitting a tradition, transmitting an accumulated human culture, which included a lot of knowledge.

SPEAKER_00Um, but it's it's it's its focus was on the development of people. It's it's it's return one to use contemporary language, its return on investment was a particular kind of person. Whereas today's university, the return on investment is a in an investment is a kind of knowledge, a kind of breakthrough, a kind of usefulness, a kind of uh economically productive form of knowledge. Um so that's the dominant paradigm in the university today.

SPEAKER_00That's why the universities are organized around disciplines, that's why the faculty are hired and promoted and rewarded based on specialized research. Um, and in all of that, the basic thing, the basic traditional mission of the university, which is to equip people to live certain kinds of lives, uh, that has taken a backseat. Um and it is a, you know, anybody who is truly committed to the project of liberal education finds this tension and finds themselves often marginalized in the university, often sort of ill at ease, often feeling um uh uh sort of like a sideshow in the university.

SPEAKER_00Um so that the centrality of relationship that liberal education depends on is not the university is not built to host that. It's not the primary mission of the university anymore. So um so it's so so we find ourselves swimming against the current when we uh when we promote and practice liberal education in the university.

SPEAKER_01Do you find that academics sort of recoil at the notion of only being transmitters of knowledge? I think that most people probably want to be originators of knowledge. We want to believe that we are so brilliant that every insight starts with us. But there is a kind of essential humility about being a conduit. Yeah, that's right.

SPEAKER_00Um, and uh as you say, the culture of the university, you know, the the PhD, for example, which has become the standard um credential for being a professor, for higher for being a uh a teacher in higher education, PhD as a degree is a is a research degree, and the sort of its traditional definition is that you are granted a PhD for making an original contribution to knowledge. Uh, this is what you do, this is how you get a PhD, this is what having a PhD means.

SPEAKER_00Although in practice, the question how many PhDs actually have made contributions to knowledge. Um, but um I think part of part of what's involved in in that is that is the very definition of knowledge. Um, and there is a sort of I don't know, platonic definition of knowledge uh that that is sort of scientific, is concrete, is uh reproducible, is sort of eternal, uh, it is objective, uh, and it is cumulative.

SPEAKER_00You understand, you you build on it, you understand things better, etc. There's another kind of knowledge that that that that is something like wisdom. It's something like a practical, it's something like uh an understanding and a capacity, a skillfulness of living and being. Um now I can I can't remember who, but somebody described these two types of knowledge as as the one, the kind that Plato shared with the gods versus the kind that Ulysses shared with the foxes.

SPEAKER_00Um that is there is a there is another kind of very human, very situational, very um uh practical in this and in the sense of concerning how to live well. Um that's a very different kind of thing, and uh and that transmission of an accumulated cultural wisdom is central to that, it's central to living well. Living well um has been the task of civilization.

SPEAKER_00Um, so there is uh an extraordinary wealth of, you might say, knowledge that is encoded, that is captured in the trajectory of civilization concerning this question of how to live well. Um, that is actually resistant. You can't, you know, you can't like do a PhD in how to live well and like codify how to do it. And then you know, all you have to do is just read my dissertation and you'll be able to live well. Can't do that. It's not the kind of knowledge that is codifiable and that and that can be uh that that can be reduced to the precise, almost mathematical terms in which to which knowledge of the Platonic kind is reducible too.

SPEAKER_01So is there a different kind of criteria then for evaluating what sort of person is qualified to do liberal education? Um, framework, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Um again, not not that this is much uh applied or much embraced in universities, because as I you know, as I said, it's it's not it's not the thrust. There are places, and you know, I'm I travel all over the country visiting universities, visiting programs, visiting classrooms, visiting places in in which liberal education is happening. Um so uh when I say the university, I speak sort of the of the the the the uh the the the leading elements or the dominant uh culture of the university.

SPEAKER_00Um but in this task of being a teacher, being a liberal education teacher, you you cannot separate your own manner of living, your own manner of navigating the basic fundamental problems that come with being human. You cannot divorce that from uh from the task of teaching. Uh you cannot divorce who you are from how you teach.

SPEAKER_00Um it is uh so it's a it's an entirely different sort of of skill, uh of disposition, of of capacity. It is it is highly um it is highly specialized. That is being a teacher, being able to uh facilitate, to guide, to encourage, to um cultivate um young people, requires uh uh a lot of a lot of um intention, a lot of often experience, reflection, practice, um commitment.

SPEAKER_00So it is not um it is not something that one does sort of uh off the cuff or that one does just because you were born with that gift because you're charismatic. Uh it's not it it is actually quite a refined and um uh learned and cultivated capacity itself.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we we say often at our school that the teacher and the teacher's life is the first text that students read. Yeah. Right. Before before the Iliad is open, before Brothers Karamansov is open, before Pride and Prejudice, whatever it is. The students will first read you and they'll ask a question about your credibility, your authenticity, and then they'll determine whether or not the text is worth reading. That's just the way it happens. That especially especially with high school students, right? Who are after a different kind of thing than a university student, perhaps.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00I think that's absolutely right. And and your credibility and your authority does not come from your scholarship or from from the um erudition of your of your intellectual training. Um that that's not where it comes from. It it comes from a a more grounded personal fundamental um thing that you convey. Um you know, one one simple way of putting it is that the liberal education teacher conveys care for the student as a person.

SPEAKER_00And that care is secondary to the care that they have for the discipline and subject they're teaching. Right? It is the Yeah, yeah. Uh but the thing, you know, the thing that you care about most is not Homer in that liberal education classroom. Um, the thing that you care about more is not most is not Homer. The thing that you care about about most is what reading Homer and talking about Homer with the students does to them. Um now talking about the liberal arts classroom, which usually the the the in the American system, it usually happens in the first two years of college.

SPEAKER_02Sure.

SPEAKER_00And the second two years are more focused on a on a disciplinary specialization that prepares you for a job, for graduate school, for a professional pursuit. Um, so this kind of education, it's usually focused in the lower, the lower college. So it's different, for example, if I'm teaching the Iliad to first-year students who are not majors in majoring in classics or in literature. They're just the general student body. Some of them are pre med, some of them are going to be entrepreneurs, some of them are going to computer science, some of them are going to law, some might go into literature, some might go into psychology, just the general student body, and I'm teaching the Iliad to them, right?

SPEAKER_00It is in that context that what I care. About is what reading the Iliad is going to do for each of these students as people. Now, if I am teaching the Iliad in a graduate seminar where I am training classes who are going to pursue careers around translating Homer or producing scholarship, then it's a different task. It's a really fundamentally different task. And there it's really my scholarly erudition that I am reproducing and transmitting. That is a disciplinary, i.e.

SPEAKER_00non-liberal pursuit. Liberal education and discipline specific. Liberal education and specialized knowledge are opposite terms, which is why, counterintuitively, a liberal arts major is an oxymoron. A liberal arts specialization is an oxymoron, although we treat the liberal arts in the university like we treat the other fields. You can study physics or you can study Italian literature. And we um we treat the liberal arts as knowledge-based research disciplines.

SPEAKER_00And it's fundamentally, it's one of those fundamental mismatches where the mission of the university has caused liberal education to sort of be denatured to fit into this disciplinary research bureaucratic organization of the university.

SPEAKER_01What's required of the student in this dynamic? There's so much hand-wringing about college freshmen and whether or not they can read books and pay attention. My general experience with students is that I'm utterly inspired by them over and over and over and overcome by their joy and enthusiasm for the project. So nonetheless, what is the kind of skill that you're looking for? Is there one that's missing? What do you hope for students to bring into a liberal education classroom to be able to do this project well?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, I think that your experience speaks to this thing where the classroom is a dynamic. Um that is there are two elements coming in together and and sort of mutually reinforcing and feeding and constituting each other. Um or mutually neutralizing each other. Um but it's it's it's a relationship, and that's what a relationship is, right? A relationship is a is a is a thing that is shaped by at least two elements, and neither functions or drives the thing on its own.

SPEAKER_00They're mutually constitutive. Um so you know what you experience, what you describe experiencing with your students, that joy, that curiosity, that energy, that love, um that's not independent and separate from the thing that you bring in. They that is constituted in part by something that you bring in. You probably, I mean, I experience this as a teacher where sometimes I'm teaching, say I'm teaching first-year students. I taught at Columbia for more than 20 years, just finishing my first year teaching at Bart, teaching, say teaching first-year students.

SPEAKER_00And we can be reading a text, you know, I don't know, Montaigne or Shakespeare or Plato or Baldwin, whatever. Um, and I have this magical, exhilarating, profound, sort of eye-opening and and deeply provocative, satisfying class. You know, that sometimes that happens. And then I go and I talk to my colleague who's teaching the same text in the same class and says, you know, my students um uh just didn't do the reading, they don't seem to care about this.

SPEAKER_00I am so fed up with uh with this. You know, and and it's like, okay, something happens in the dynamic of my classroom that's different than the dynamic of that classroom that produces, and you know, and it's when I when I describe what happens in my classroom, it's not just that I'm such a great teacher, it's not just it's not that my students are such great students. Um, then the same happens in the other classroom. Although people often tend to say, well, it's the students, right?

SPEAKER_00The students are deficient in some way. Um I should add a caveat because of this example that I gave, which is that I also have classes sometimes that flop, right? This class that I described that happens. It happens with some regularity, but also I get classes where just the thing does not gel. Yeah, uh, where in fact students did not do the reading, but where in fact, you know, I'm coming down with something, or I uh, you know, my child and I just had some very unsettling interaction before we said goodbye, and I walk in there and I'm just not, you know, the the wires are not connecting.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, so you know, I just want to that caveat that can happen and does happen. It's part of the process and part of how how you recover from that and how you behave in those circumstances are part of the big package. Um, but this thing about it being a um it being a dynamic and that it's always seemed to me that as a teacher, 90% or greater, 95% maybe of what makes me effective is being able to evoke interest in the subject from the student.

SPEAKER_00That is, if I can get the student interested in what we're talking about, in what we're reading, in what is happening in the classroom, 95% of my job is done. Um then then then this this this this this magic happens, this this this this dynamic takes over. Um and and it's almost like self-executing. But that initial thing, that's that's that's my big job. My big job as a as a teacher is to organize the syllabus, organize the classroom dynamic, organize the the questions and the provocations and the exercises that I bring to light that spark in the student, um, to somehow crack the puzzle of how is Homer relevant and meaningful to me?

SPEAKER_00An 18-year-old living in 2026, you know, with with cell phones and TikTok and you know, the complexities of the contemporary life. How is Homer of any relevance and meaning to this person? If I can crack that, if I can bridge that, uh then the job is done largely. Then then we just then we just play the music. Um so that's that's the job of the that's the job of the teacher, which is another reason why you can't you can't fake it.

SPEAKER_00If you actually if homework is actually not meaningful to you, if homework does not illuminate your human experience, if if some if if homework is not valuable to you, you can't make it so for the students. You can't facilitate that happening for the student if it hasn't happened for you. It's one of one of one of those requirements of the liberal art teacher that you know their mind has to be on fire uh about what they do. And if your mind is not on fire about that, then you have no business teaching that in a liberal education context.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It is such a a delicate dance to find what your role is in igniting that fire. I remember I had a student in my first year who used to sleep through every single one of my classrooms in Detroit without fail. He would come in, his head would hit the desk, and he would just fall into a deep slumber for the duration of my class. And I just I read massively about how to reach him. I remember the last book that we read, his freshman year, was uh was The Odyssey.

SPEAKER_01And the first couple books of the Odyssey, of course, are the Telemachi and tell the story of Telemachus navigating home while Odysseus is gone.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And this student came to me a couple of weeks before uh before we started reading Homer's Odyssey and he said, Mr. Andrew, I want to tell you why I've been sleeping through all of your classes. I was like, oh, great. This this should be rich. I'll I'll find out how terrible of an educator I am. And and he shared that uh at the time he was homeless and that school was the first warm place that he could find in in a given day. And so he would come into my classroom, which was first hour, and he would fall asleep because he felt safe.

SPEAKER_01And so we're reading the telemeka, or reading the Odyssey, reading the telemachi. And I remember him raising his hand for the first time for the entire school year. I called on him and he said, Mr. Andrew, I know what it means to be Telemachus. What are you talking about? I know what it means to feel responsible for my mother and to desire guidance from my father and to have no idea where to turn. I really hope Telemachus gives me good advice. And it was like, this is it. This is the thing.

SPEAKER_01This is uh this is liberal education. And I had no idea how we created the conditions to achieve that moment, except by just reading essentially a book aloud. But that speaks exactly to what you're describing, right? A child through time and space reaching out and saying, This is instructive, not in a technical way, but on the most important pressing question of how to live a good life.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Wow, that that that story illustrates so many, so many things. Um like for that student who lives in particular life, a particular circumstance, a particular human reality, what that child needed in that classroom was a safe split safe space from which in which they can disconnect and sleep. So there is a way in which a liberal education in that moment at that time, in that circumstance, meant taking a nap.

SPEAKER_01Sure.

SPEAKER_00You could not get the other thing when the body and the mind needs psychological rest and physical rest, right? Um the conditions, however, are thereby prepared for the other thing to happen, which eventually does happen. Um it rate, you know, because we teach in in systems, in bureaucracy, in in credentialing machines, right? We have to give the student a grade. We have to say the student now can pass to the next grade.

SPEAKER_00Um you can see how counterproductive or counter the spirit of a liberal education that machinery is. Um, because how do you assess a student like that? Right? How do you assess, yeah, that, you know, did they do that, did they pass, did they learn, did they um well, it sounds, you know, just just from the anecdote that you said, it sounds like that student got what the student needed, and that it and and maybe got something that was deeper and more transformative and more valuable than what some of the other students got, who uh were not in those circumstances and who did not have this strange, unexpected, yet illuminating connection with a mind from 3000 years ago.

SPEAKER_00Um, so you know, grades are um inimical to the project of liberal learning. We have to deal with them, we have to do them, we have to uh function within that system. Uh, but we have to we have to do it with uh with the awareness of of what a handicap they can be. Uh it's as if you know we have to tell students, I'm gonna give you a grade, but we must engage in this activity as if grades don't matter.

SPEAKER_00Um and that's that that's itself a difficult, a difficult uh balance to to strike.

SPEAKER_01You obviously have this deep love and and rich imagination for what it means to be a teacher, to be charged with the responsibility of forming the souls, the minds of the students that are in front of you. I'm curious how your sense of of the job evolved, the point at which you had administrative responsibility, right? You you run a center now, you you ran a center at at Columbia. Uh what did it mean to transition from teaching for a couple hours a day or whatever the job entailed to having a different kind of responsibility?

SPEAKER_01Was there discomfort in that? Did you resist it? Just narrate that for me.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Um my first job out of grad school, my first two jobs out of grad schools were for full-time teaching, but they were both short-term appointments. One was a one-year visiting professor, full-time teaching, another one was a three-year postdoc full-time teaching. And at the end of that third year in the postdoc, um, I had the opportunity to administer and be the administrative head of the Center for the Core Curriculum, the Core Curriculum at Columbia, which was a huge honor and a huge um challenge and something clearly that I wanted to do that that was sort of the most meaningful type of education, the most meaningful type of um of work.

SPEAKER_00But I remember the first, my first day um in the office. So, you know, the Center for the Core Curriculum is an intellectual enterprise, obviously a pedagogical enterprise, a cultural enterprise, but it's also like an office. Um, and the I had a staff, and the office opened at nine and it closed at five. And I had to be in the office and I had to manage my staff, and I had to, and and I remember the first day uh in the sum in the middle of the summer, having kind of a panic attack at the end of the day.

SPEAKER_00Um, as I as I realized how much administrative um you know uh organization and burden this job carried, and that, and that this was this is uh this is my the center of what I was going to be doing was going to had to do with scheduling, with registration, with programming, with hiring faculty, with interviewing faculty, with um meeting with problematic situations, with plagiarism, um, and the interstaff sort of politics and relationships and the managing the higher administration.

SPEAKER_00Um when I took on the job, my predecessor in that job did not teach, um, had had come from the faculty, but um put aside teaching. I insisted that I would need to continue to teach in order to do that job. So it was sort of carved out, built into the job for me. Um, and but essentially I taught on top of my administrative responsibility. I didn't have to teach, I didn't get paid extra to teach, uh, but I could teach.

SPEAKER_00And I did. I taught, I had that job for 10 years, and I taught every semester of those 10 years. Um, because the thing that made the administrative job meaningful was this thing. And if I lost connection with that, I could not do the administrative job. And the administrative job was actually critical. The thing that happened in the classroom could not happen without this administrative apparatus.

SPEAKER_00Um, and the reason why I ended up at this job is because I was always meddling, I was always like volunteering to be in committees. I always cared about that stuff. Yeah. I cared about what the right class size was and what the shape of the classroom was and what the budget was and what the curriculum was. I was always being drawn into these conversations about the structure and shape of the vehicle that delivers the liberal education. Um, and as my reward, I I I got I got that job that could have consumed my entire uh my entire energy. Um another thing that I did while I did that job is that I used it as a platform to promote liberal education wherever.

SPEAKER_00So as I did that job, I I did some writing, but I did a lot of speaking. I would visit campuses, I would go to conferences, uh I would invite people to come to Colombia. I uh became a kind of missionary for the idea of the core. And again, that was something that I took on uh because it it answered to my deepest interest and commitment to the job. Um I stepped down from that after 10 years, as I said, and spent, I don't know, seven years or so again, teaching full-time.

SPEAKER_00And then last year, I had this uh opportunity to start a center whose mission would be to promote liberal education of the type. The sort of the stuff that I was doing on my own while I was director of the core, and and subsequence to that, sort of going around visiting campuses, organizing meetings, writing, promoting a center that whose mission would be that. Um, and again, I had the opportunity to simply run that center. Um, but again, I decided that I could only run that center meaningfully if I was also teaching.

SPEAKER_00Um, so now this this uh position, this new center, um it's it's uh whereas in before it felt like teaching was something that I had to do on top of the job. Uh this time teaching is very much part of the way I organize the job. Um and teaching not only undergraduates, but doing an analogous thing as what I do with undergraduates with faculty. Uh, that is bringing faculty from all over the country into classrooms where we have conversations around text that are sort of the graduate equivalent, the professional development equivalent of what I do with uh with undergraduates.

SPEAKER_00Um I participate in those conversations. I'm not the teacher in the same way that I am with undergraduates. I am even less the transmitter of information with that group. But it's a very similar um convening and orchestrating and sort of uh uh facilitating a certain kind of conversation and development and reflection on liberal education. Um but again, just to go to come back around, um, I've made deliberate choices to remain connected and invested in the life of students and in the fundamental task and the fundamental mission of liberal education.

SPEAKER_00Um because you can you can you can get drawn in into the mechanics of it and lose sight of the whole point of uh why we're doing this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, this is something that has unsettled me for some time about maybe K-12 education in particular. Um I'm part of this movement of classical schools that is growing at at great speed. And as a consequence, people are desperate for school leaders. And so the moment that you show any kind of skill or acumen in the classroom, someone comes and says, Do you want to manage a large budget and run a school? How are these two things related? How are these two projects in any way similar? And uh in most professional contexts, when come someone comes and offers you a promotion, you take it.

SPEAKER_01You say yes. You don't you don't say no to such a thing. But I've wondered if if schools, if teachers, if leaders ought to be applying a different kind of framework to teachers when when they're evaluating this. Uh so I I'm also curious if you've ever said no to a promotion. Has there ever been an opportunity where it's like, yeah, yeah, that would take me too far from from the core thing, from the essential no, many times.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, one of the reasons why I stayed as director of the core curriculum for 10 years is because there was no other job that I was interested in in the higher administration. Um, and and people, you know, after after a while, people began to think that that was kind of weird. Like, why don't you want to be dean? Why don't you want to be vice president? Why don't you want to be provost? Why don't you want to be um, you know, be why don't you want your boss's job?

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, and I just did not. Um and um, you know, I I've been recruited for deanships and precedent university college presidencies. Um, and I I have not I have not pursued them. I have not pursued those those opportunities because they are not um they seem to take me away from the thing that I care about. The thing that I care about is liberal education. If I become a college president, I will be in a position to advance liberal education in a significant way, in a way that I'm not now.

SPEAKER_00But I would also have to care about sports and about fundraising and about residential life and about you know sexual harassment policies and to computer policy. I mean, uh it's just an entirely different portfolio. Yeah. And somebody has to do that. And I feel a lot of gratitude for the people who take on those jobs, and who, especially when they do it, which is rarer and rarer, but there are many who do it with this with the same kind of commitments to liberal education that I share.

SPEAKER_00My hat is off to them. That's not my calling. Um, at least now. Uh, it may be that in the future I am called to do something like that. Just like you know, I I I made this transition from being full-time in the classroom to not being part-time in the classroom and and and running this operation where I do have to worry about budget and I do have to worry about fundraising, and I do have to worry about staff at a smaller scale than like a president, dean, or provost would. Um, but I that felt like the right thing to do at this stage.

SPEAKER_00And it may be that in a future um there is a different calling that I feel, or a different, or a different instrument through which to pursue what I feel is my calling. Um and that, you know, I I realize that I use this, I'm using a word that is associated primarily with with religious uh religious calling, but I do think that um the teacher, the liberal education teacher, that is a teacher of people, not the teacher of subjects, the liberal education teacher um is is is a calling.

SPEAKER_00Um, it is a uh vocation, it is a thing that that that in which your life's purpose feels to be fulfilled. Um and um you know I think I think that the teachers that are transformative, that's the way they're ready to teaching. And it's not you know, it's not like a unicorn. There are a lot of people in classrooms who are there because of because they feel called to do that.

SPEAKER_00And you know better than I the ways in which our educational system often takes those people and beats down that calling and and and forces them in some way to uh denature that and and end up doing something that is quite far from the thing that drew them into the profession.

SPEAKER_01So when you're not writing about liberal education, from what I can tell, you're writing about citizenship. Uh you've done a lot of work on our in the last year about great founding documents, the declaration, the constitution. I don't know that everyone would see a connection between those two worlds, right? There's something intuitive about asking questions about what your life means, what it's for, uh, and and liberal education offers, maybe not answers, but but the best versions of those questions with great people.

SPEAKER_01And then you bring up this topic of citizenship. And I I wonder what the two things have to do with each other. Of course, even the center that you're running is about liberal education and civic life. How do you how do you connect these things? And for people that see them as entirely opposite, right? I know a lot of people that love liberal education and want nothing to do with with politics, with civic life. Yeah. What are we missing?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh, that's a great question. And I and I and I've thought a lot about the relationship between these two things. Um a couple of things to say. Um, one is that liberal education is by definition not pursued for the sake of of an external outcome. That is, it is not pursued for a predetermined outcome, it is not pursued for professional skill development, it is not uh pursued for um a given job, uh, even though it prepares you for many kinds of jobs, it's useful for many kinds of jobs, but that's not why you do it.

SPEAKER_00It is not even pursued for the sake of good citizenship. When you're pursuing it for the sake of something other than its intrinsic value, you're not doing liberal education anymore. Um, just like a liberal education will in fact develop higher order cognitive capacities and personal capacities and expressive capacities and empathetic capacities and imaginative capacities that will make you a better professional in almost any field. You'll be a better computer programmer, you'll be a better doctor, you'll be a better lawyer.

SPEAKER_00You precisely that betterment happens because you're not pursuing that. You're not pursuing the goal of being a better lawyer. You're just pursuing uh uh an activity that is valuable in its own sake. Citizenship, same thing happens. You are going to become a better citizen. You will develop precisely the skills and capacities and dispositions that are required for the complex task of civic participation, for the complex task of self-governance.

SPEAKER_00But you don't do it for that sake. Um if you look at the reverse of that, a free society, a democratic society, a self-governing society requires a population that is capable of performing all the tasks that are necessary for self-governance, reflection, debate, um, participation, commitments to the common good, capacity to understand things from a different point of view, capacity to understand data, capacity to understand uh values.

SPEAKER_00Um you cannot have a democracy without universal liberal education, even though liberal education is not pursued for the sake of democracy. Um liberal education is about the free life, it's an education for freedom, it's an education to maximize freedom. Freedom, of course, is a tricky thing. Like in your own personal life, when you're free, um how do you manage that freedom in a way that is actually um uh productive, conducive to flourishing, conducive to a good life, conducive to a meaningful, happy life.

SPEAKER_00It's tricky. Many people take their freedom and they drive themselves to misery, they drive themselves to failure, they drive themselves to the grave by using that freedom. So managing that freedom requires a kind of human cultivation, an understanding, a discipline, a commitment to values, an overarching vision of the good life that serves as an organizing uh philosophy of your life.

SPEAKER_00So liberal education is for that. Liberal education is to equip you to live a flourishing life of freedom. It has liberal education has a collective dimension to it, too, which is that we as human beings are the kind of beings that fulfill themselves, that flourish in the context of relationships and in the context of communities. Aristotle said this a long time ago. You know, man is by nature a political animal.

SPEAKER_00We are the type of beings whose fulfillment, whose flourishing, whose full life involves cooperative endeavors in community, communities of care, of affection, of mutual responsibility, of mutuality. Um, that's just the way we are. We are social political beings. So, in order for us to exercise our freedom and to flourish as human beings, we need to be embedded in communities.

SPEAKER_00Um we need to be embedded in communities that are themselves free and self-governing. So, liberal education, which is focused on sort of this cultivation of the individual, happens and must happen in a social context, in a social context in which freedom, um uh self-governance, um the consensual cooperative pursuit of the common good, um is is the rule of the day. Um so, yes, liberal education and civic life are inextricably intertwined.

SPEAKER_00And I think, you know, I I began by saying you can't see that relationship as one of instrumentality or goal. That liberal education is the instrument by which you achieve a good society, that liberal education is instrumental, goal-oriented. It's that's not the relationship. Uh, but there is a sort of mutually constitutive um relationship between a self-governing community, self-governing civic life, and a self-governing individual.

SPEAKER_00And liberal education is what what what you need to accomplish both.

SPEAKER_01Well, Roosevelt, I sorry, that was a very long-winded. No, it's so interesting. Yeah, and and such an essential question. I uh I I have a a final question that that I like to ask folks, which perhaps emerges apropos of nothing, but I'm I'm interested in your response nonetheless. Uh what have you changed your mind about in the last in the last 20 years as you think about your work at Columbia? You are now at Bard, you've worked as a teacher, you've you've run centers, you've made this work accessible to all kinds of students across New York and across our country, right?

SPEAKER_01Your life is animated by liberal education and also a sense of civic responsibility. I'm curious in all of this, if if there's something that you look back on and think, you know, I got that wrong 10 years ago. I was sort of misguided about this. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00There are many things. Um but one of the adventures of, or like the great adventure of a life of inquiry, of self-reflection, is that you experience a kind of evolutionary growth, evolutionary um displacement or movement, where then you know you can get to a point where you realize that you've actually changed your mind about something very fundamental.

SPEAKER_00You have drifted into a position that's quite different, maybe the opposite of where you started. One one of one of those big trajectories in my life has been I don't know, one way to put it is sort of self-determination. That is, I have a much um a much reduced sense of my own power to shape my world the world around me.

SPEAKER_01Interesting.

SPEAKER_00That is, I feel much more that the world happens to me than that I shape the world that happens to me. And I, you know, I think I held the view that it was in my power to shape a lot more about the world around me and about myself than I now think. You know, I feel more and more that I am an engaged observer and less uh uh an agent, a driver.

SPEAKER_00I am I I find myself much more in the passenger seat of my life than in the driver's seat of my life. Now that I just always thought of myself as being in the driver's seat. And now I just realize that a lot of that was a kind of misperception or delusion that I'm actually much more in the passenger seat. Um, and you know, that's not to say that I don't exercise agency, that I don't make choices, that I don't actually an agent and and and therefore accountable and responsible for my life.

SPEAKER_00That's all still true. And yet I've just become aware that there is a lot of that happens through forces and mechanisms that I sort of come to me. That I, you know, it's it's something a practical example of this is you know, imagine when you take a walk, I don't know, from from your office to your car or something. Imagine like a five or 10-minute walk. During that five or 10-minute walk, your mind thinks about all kinds of things, maybe, maybe 30 or 40 or 50 different things.

SPEAKER_00And you're not directing that. That is, those thoughts come to you, those thoughts arise in you. Um, and then they may be triggered by a car that hunks or a bird that flies, or you look down, you see something on the floor. God knows what. But you are it's like the you're watching a film that's playing, but you are not play, you're not the one who is orchestrating those thoughts. Um a lot of a lot more of my life feels that way than it used to.

SPEAKER_00Um, and again, it's not it's not uh it's not a thing that denies agency. Yeah, but it's um but it puts it in a different compartment, puts it in a different place than um than than I conceived it to be in my uh in the younger version of myself.

SPEAKER_01Well, there are many more conversations, I think, to be had on that subject. Many many questions, yeah. But we are incredibly grateful for your time today, Roosevelt. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Josh, it's such a pleasure to talk to you. Thank you for your for your really incisive and and uh and and sensitive questions. Yeah. Thanks, Roosevelt.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Good Teaching Be Taught? | Test Corrections with Doug Lemov

    Nov 17, 202659 minAudio

    For nearly three decades, Doug Lemov has devoted his professional life to describing in excruciating detail what good teachers do. He can tell you where they stand, where they look, how they give directions, and how...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is Trusting First a Leadership Strategy? | Test Corrections with Bruce Deel

    Nov 3, 202657 minAudio

    Bruce Deel developed Atlanta’s City of Refuge around the principle of trusting first. When a person in crisis arrives at his door and requests help, he says, “yes,” and asks questions later. He does not require folks to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Do We Need a New SAT? Test Corrections with Jeremy Tate

    Oct 20, 202646 minAudio

    There's no shortage of critiques of our standardized college entrance exams, and yet every school year, millions of students sign up to take the SAT and ACT. These assessments have defined academic achievement in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Leading when you're Young | Test Corrections with Matt Westmoreland

    Sep 22, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    What does it mean to lead in the city where you were raised? Matt Westmoreland grew up in Atlanta, attended Atlanta Public Schools, and returned home after college to teach. By 26, he was serving on the Atlanta Board of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Are Work and Family at Odds? Test Corrections with Glen Jackson

    Sep 8, 202644 minAudio

    Can you build a life and an institution together without one consuming the other? Glen Jackson, co-founder of Jackson Spaulding, joins this episode to reflect on building a company over three decades, the power of a...

    Credit the people on this episode