Paris Marx is joined by Will Tavlin to discuss how the Netflix model transformed film into the Typical Netflix Movie and how the company uses claims about data to deceive the public. Will Tavlin is a New York-based writer who has written for n+1, Bookforum, and the Columbia Journalism Review. Tech Won’t Save Us offers a critical perspective on tech, its worldview, and wider society with the goal of inspiring people to demand better tech and a better world. Support the show on Patreon. The podcast is made in partnership with The Nation. Production is by Eric Wickham. Also mentioned in this episode: Will wrote about Netflix and the Typical Netflix Movie for n+1. Support the show Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01The decision to make crap and garbage is one that they would say that you know the data tells us that we have to do that, but ultimately they're the ones who are choosing to invest in that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_00We're able to have a little bit of a break over the end of December, early January. I hope you enjoyed the two premium episodes that we made public for you to discuss AI and data centers and you know the power that these cloud companies are able to accumulate as we become more dependent on these cloud services and on these very energy and resource-intensive AI services that they're all trying to push on us. So I think that they, you know, were conversations that made an important contribution to this conversation that we're trying to have. So yeah, I hope you were able to check them out over the break.
SPEAKER_00But we have a bit of a different conversation today. Will Tavlin, who has been on the show in the past, is a writer based in New York City and who has written for N Plus One, the Columbia Journalism Review and Book Forum. He has a great new piece on the way that Netflix is changing, you know, the type of cinema and television that we consume, how that is a product of the streaming model that it really pioneered and that so many other Hollywood and tech companies have adopted as a result. But how that does have consequences for what is made when it is supposed to be something that is just on in the background while you're using your phone rather than something that you're really expected to engage with and try to take something out of.
SPEAKER_00So I was really happy to have Will back on the show. I feel like to a certain degree, I was like having to remember exactly how to do an interview after three or four weeks of not recording anything new. But I think we had a really fascinating conversation about these topics getting into the history of Netflix and the lies and deceptions that are in its origin story and what it has told to the public. And then also how, of course, you know, the types of things that we often watch on these platforms are becoming degraded as there's this incentive on the one hand to cut costs, but also to make sure that there's always something new being added to the platform that, you know, that is not going to cause controversy and that might kind of grab somebody's attention and at least have them watching for a while so that Netflix or any of these other platforms can say that, you know, they have all these great viewership numbers as they, you know, have these autoplay features that just keep playing new things over and over again, regardless of whether you're actually watching them.
SPEAKER_00I would just say before we get into the episode, I have some big plans for 2025. You know, a lot of great guests lined up and who I'm hoping to have on the show, but also hopefully some more exciting things throughout the year that I'll be able to announce and tell you about as things move forward. So I would just say, you know, 2025 is probably going to be a terrible year for a whole lot of reasons, especially when we look at the tech industry and how these tech billionaires are leveraging and wielding their power against so many of us.
SPEAKER_00But tech won't save us will be here to guide you through that, to make sure that you continue to have a critical perspective on everything that the tech industry is doing so that you can understand, you know, what all of this means for your life and for our wider society, and hopefully what opportunities exist to push back on these things and, you know, hopefully steer us in a bit of a better direction than the one that these very powerful individuals are trying to uh push us toward. So with that said, if you do enjoy this conversation with Will, make sure to leave a five-star view on your podcast platform of choice.
SPEAKER_00You can share the show on social media or with any friends or colleagues who you think would learn from it. And if you do want to support the work that goes into making the show every single week, so I can keep having these critical conversations and we can do everything else that Tech Won't Save Us does. You can join supporters like Steph in Dallas, Bria in Durham, North Carolina, Jess from Austin, Texas, and Nin from Copenhagen by going to patreon.com slash TechWon't Save Us, where you can become a supporter as well. Thanks so much and enjoy this week's conversation. Will, welcome back to Tech Won't Save Us.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me back on. I'm very pleased to be here.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. We were overdue for another conversation about streaming and Hollywood and all these things. And then, of course, you released a fantastic new essay in M plus one. So I said, ah, here's the opportunity to dig into all this again. So I think, you know, a lot of people have been probably watching a lot of movies. Maybe they went to the cinema, maybe they were just like watching Netflix or Amazon Prime video or something like that over the holidays. And you know, we have the Golden Globes just happened and we're entering this season where there's going to be a lot of talk about awards and what the biggest movies of 2024 were and all this sort of thing.
SPEAKER_00So I think it's a good opportunity to kind of dig into all this, right?
SPEAKER_01Definitely. It's always a good time to talk about Netflix.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is true. You know, I wanted to start with Netflix because in the piece that you wrote, you talk about the origin story, right? Where Netflix came from. And Reed Hastings, you know, I guess one of the co-founders he was of the company, told this specific story about how Netflix came to be and how he came up with this idea that is probably not totally accurate. So can you give us some insight into what went on there?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so what happened was Reed Hastings co-founded Netflix with a guy named Mark Randolph in the late 90s. What happened was they were at a company that Reed Hastings started that was purchased for a lot of money, hundreds of millions of dollars, something around 700 million dollars. They were basically commuting to work every day together. They were carpooling, and they were sort of thinking about a new business idea, what to do next, and they wanted to do something specifically over the internet, because they had seen what Amazon was basically doing with books.
SPEAKER_01And Reed Hastings asked this question: well, why can't we do the same thing with movies? The way that he tells it is that he had rented a VHS tape around this time from Blockbuster of the movie Apollo 13, and he basically forgot about it. When he eventually did find the tape like under some papers in his dining room, he returned it and he was shocked to learn that he owed$40 in late fees. And he described this process of feeling embarrassed and humiliation and also like anger at having to pay so much money.
SPEAKER_01And Reed Hastings was not alone in this sense. There's a lot today, I think, of kind of blockbuster nostalgia, which I think is misplaced because what people are actually nostalgic for is the normal video store, the neighborhood video store, not necessarily the franchise video store. And the franchise video store, epitomized in Blockbuster, was notoriously despised by most of its customers. The late fees were ridiculous. They could fetch as much lost tape from Blockbusters could cost as much as like$200 back then.
SPEAKER_01There were all these class action lawsuits near the company's peak, around, I think, the year 2000. Blockbuster collected something like$800 million in a single year in late fees. It was unbelievable. And it wasn't just that. I cite in the essay from this journalist Gina Keating, who wrote a history of Netflix. Often another common blockbuster experience was like walking in and seeing like 50 copies of a movie you never want to see, and then nothing else.
SPEAKER_01Basically, the selection was really bad. But you did get your free popcorn, right? So totally. And internally, the company executives at Blockbuster referred to their business model as quote, managed dissatisfaction. So the way that Reed Hastings tells this is basically like they saw this business model that wasn't working, and basically this new DVD technology had emerged around this time. This is around 1997. And they did this test where they took a disk and put it through the mail, USPS, and it came back fine, and they were like, great, we have a business model.
SPEAKER_01Now, the business model that Netflix became famous for was like basically in opposition to the blockbuster model of late fees, which was this idea of like no late fees and doing a subscription model instead. And basically how it worked was you would pay a monthly fee for Netflix, and you would be able to rent up to three DVDs at a time, and you could keep them as long as you want. The catch was that if you wanted a new DVD, a fourth DVD, a fifth DVD, you would have to um send one of the three that you had rented.
SPEAKER_01So you can only have three out at a time, but no late fees. And Reed Hastings, again, the the way it was presented was very much like I had this terrible experience with Blockbuster, and then I came up with this idea for this business model of no late fees, which became immensely popular. What actually happened was that the Apollo 13 story was made up. Mark Randolph has given interviews about this over the years. It was a lie, and actually Blockbuster sometime in the mid-2000s basically looked through their database when they were, you know, coming under attack from Netflix and found that there was never evidence of such a transaction and told Reed Hastings at once at one point to stop telling the story in public.
SPEAKER_01What actually happened is like when Netflix was first founded by Reed Hastings and Mark Randolph, the unlimited subscription model only came like a couple years later, I think around 1999. Initially, they were selling and renting DVDs out to customers a la carte, basically, the way you would from Blockbuster, but just over the internet. And how they came up with the unlimited model, though, is really interesting because it says a lot about the company and also where the company would head in the future.
SPEAKER_01How it happened was they weren't really growing as fast as Hastings would have liked them to grow. And they also had this kind of logistical problem, which was because they had no brick and mortar stores, they had basically the centralized warehouse where they kept all of their DVDs. It was like hundreds of thousands of DVDs. And this was great, in a sense, for Netflix's customers because their selection was great. That was one of the reasons why it was so much better from Blockbusters, because you'd you'd find like crazy stuff on there, like Mario Bava movies, like all sorts of just like weird things that a brick and mortar store like Blockbuster, which would be incentivized to carry, you know, like 30 copies of Steven Spielberg's AI, that they would just never have.
SPEAKER_01But they had this warehouse of all these DVDs, and Mark Randolph gave this interview where he was talking about how him and Hastings were basically riffing one day about how it was really inefficient because there were all these DVDs that they had that were not in circulation, essentially. And this is where the idea for no late fees came about was that Mark Randolph was like, well, what if we just rent these DVDs and then people can keep them as long as they want and we'll have this subscription model?
SPEAKER_01And the idea is that by doing so, they would increase the amount of time that people would actually hold on to their DVDs, and then there would be fewer shipping costs essentially, and there would be fewer DVDs for them to manage and store because people would just naturally kind of like hold on to things for a longer amount of time. And in fact, in the years following this decision, Netflix started tracking heavy users of the service and they labeled them internally as quote pigs and basically throttled their deliveries.
SPEAKER_01And this was like if you were renting DVDs out at just kind of like a normal pace, essentially.
SPEAKER_00I enjoyed that little like anecdote in there about how it identified these people who were using it a lot. But I did think it was really interesting how you know they kind of like turned the customers into these like mini warehouses where all these DVDs could be stored, you know, to kind of change up the model, but also, I guess, in their eyes, make it more efficient. And I guess I'm wondering then through the piece, you kind of chart how Netflix progressed from targeting the video store initially and and Blockbuster to then once it had kind of achieved that and started to launch its streaming service to taking on television and now more recently to going after the film industry.
SPEAKER_00And so I wonder, you know, why it's important to understand that trajectory and what it tells us about Netflix as a company and how it has changed over time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a great question. What you said about turning customers into like mini warehouses is really accurate because I found one of the most interesting things about this is the way that this Netflix business model like preceded all of these other tech companies that would come in like 10 years later, like Airbnb and Uber, which got people to basically leverage their assets in order to create a more like streamlined and efficient business model.
SPEAKER_01Netflix was doing this like a decade before all of those people, having people like leverage their homes basically into mini Netflix warehouses. And the difference between Netflix and Blockbuster is really this. And what I say in the piece is that like Blockbuster punished customers for being forgetful in their business model, and Netflix basically rewarded them for being mindless. This distinction in Netflix's business model set the stage for really what they would become in the future, essentially.
SPEAKER_00That makes a lot of sense. And I do think it's interesting to understand those distinctions between the two models, right? And then how that helps to inform, you know, the direction that Netflix takes as it launches the streaming service uh, you know, in I believe it's 2007, and then you know, really kind of takes off down the path that we have seen it progressing through over the past almost two decades since the launch of the streaming service. So as I was saying, you know, there was this progression from like the video store to television to the film industry. What does that tell us about Netflix as a company and why is it important to understand?
SPEAKER_01Well, they targeted specifically businesses that people hated. And I think there's a tendency to kind of ascribe a kind of master plan, like an evil genius type thing, to some of these companies, especially tech companies sometimes. But Netflix really found its extremely dominant business model in stages and did so by experimenting with launching into different types of entertainment and basically crushing it.
SPEAKER_01And the sort of natural next business for them to get into was television and specifically cable television. And once again, cable television was a business that was widely despised by most people. Cable providers are notoriously some of like the most despised types of businesses in the United States. Uh they have these vast monopolies, they basically charge an arm and a leg for a service that is often subpar.
SPEAKER_01And actually, something that is true that Reed Hastings has said over the years publicly, and also people I spoke to who heard this from him firsthand, is that streaming was always one of Reed Hastings's ambitions. He's talked about this publicly, is that like Netflix in his eyes, like DVDs was always just like a pit stop on the road to streaming, and that streaming was a business that they knew they wanted to get into in the late 90s, but basically like the infrastructure wasn't good enough, internet speeds weren't fast enough, the technology wasn't there to be able to do it.
SPEAKER_01And so a lot of the years from like 2000 to 2007 was them sort of biding their time and also successfully destroying Blockbuster. But by 2007, they were able to launch their first streaming service, which was called Watch Now, and it was really primitive. It was like only a thousand titles were on it. And you can only use it, I think, on Internet Explorer, on PCs.
SPEAKER_00Everyone's favorite web browser.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Uh you had to like pay for like a certain number of hours to stream in advance. But in fact, streaming made perfect sense for the company because Netflix had always the sort of premise of even when they were a DVD service of the company was like hoarding customer data to basically improve recommendation algorithms for users so that you know to find things in their vast catalog of titles better, essentially.
SPEAKER_01And the streaming platform allowed them eventually to ascertain data in real time, these kind of like minute decisions that users would make about like stopping, when they started, when they stopped, once Netflix went to like iPhones and tablets and whatnot, you know, they can tell how they were viewing all sorts of data, you know, having this kind of like bird's eye view of the user.
SPEAKER_00I I think that's a really important point that I just want to put a pin in, right? Because I feel like when we talk about Netflix, you know, we talk about it as the streaming service and before that as the DVD rental business, but we don't often talk about that through line where it's always about collecting this data on the users in developing these recommendation systems that, yes, exist in the DVD business, but then come to be very consequential and important to the streaming business as it takes off, and you know, the amount of data that is collected just becomes so much vaster as a result.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally. And it's really important to note just how much of like Netflix is fundamentally just like a tech company. I mean, the analogy that I often think about is the way like Uber, for instance, I think in certain court bot battles it's had with like the state of California, one thing you could say about Uber is that it's a transportation company. And one thing that they argue often in these court battles to avoid certain kinds of regulations is oh, we're not a transportation company, we're like a tech company, we're a data company or whatever. Netflix is kind of and has always been essentially the opposite, which is like a fundamentally they are a tech company that poses as a Hollywood studio.
SPEAKER_01The data is really important for them, and as they grew and moved into making original content, the data became especially important. And specifically, like their first big show that they produced originally was House of Cards, which they paid a huge amount of money for, and there was this line often that they said at the time, which was like, oh, basically data, then our ability to ascertain data, you know, is the reason why this show exists.
SPEAKER_01We saw that people love Kevin Spacey, and so we wanted to a project with Kevin Spacey, and people love David Fincher, so we want to do a project with David Fincher. And of course, it also helped with the release of that show as well, because Netflix executives and engineers observed how people often watched television on their platform in these large batches, which was known as binge watching. And Ted Serandos at the time decided basically to like indulge that and released all I forget how many episodes were in the first season of House of Cards, but it was somewhere around 10, I think, release all of them at once as opposed to doing like the normal appointment-style television viewing.
SPEAKER_01He was like, we're giving users what they want, essentially. And that show was a success. It got a lot of attention. And, you know, they were stating to investors at the time, like, this is the future of entertainment, our ability to basically be more flexible with things like, you know, the length of a season of television, the fact that they didn't have to abide by all these rules that have been established by broadcast networks, that this would let them get all these subscribers in the future. People would be hungry for this new kind of innovative Netflix content.
SPEAKER_01Their algorithms were extremely powerful and could, you know, ascertain certain trends and then make great shows out of that, which of course ended up being BS. And one of the things that I think a lot of people forget about in these instances is like, especially when they cite the data, is like there's always somebody, a human being at the end of this interpreting the data. It's not just the data becomes the show and this kind of like one-to-one thing. A lot of the things that Netflix said about itself at this time uh were disingenuous and and didn't really turn out to be true.
SPEAKER_01And in fact, its approach to television was really less about changing the content itself and way more about changing the underlying structure about how television got made.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I I think that's a key point, right? And as you're talking about with House of Cards, when Netflix makes that step into original content, I guess. And of course, it I don't believe it was the first show, but it was the big one. It was its big like introduction where it really started pushing these narratives about how it was funding original content and what Netflix was going to be, and how the streaming model was going to be so superior to traditional television in particular in that time. And I think the film stuff comes a bit later. But Netflix starts to sell this narrative that it is like the place where filmmakers and and artists are going to have so much more freedom, and it's this like superior model to what existed before.
SPEAKER_00And only on streaming are you going to be able to see these, you know, much more original stories and these stories that have these perspectives that you won't see on like broadcast or cable or whatever. And it seems like for a few years, that is really like the dominant way that a lot of people talk about Netflix and streaming, where you have these like originals like House of Cards, and later, you know, Netflix really gets into like buying independent films and other streamers do as well. And it kind of all plays into this narrative.
SPEAKER_00And then by the end of the 2010s, we're seeing all of that really go away because the commercial incentive to sell this story seems to have evaporated. So can you talk to us a bit more about what Netflix was doing there and what the ultimate outcome of falling for all that was?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. And this would be a good place to maybe talk about how Netflix got into movies. It started making television first, but then quickly stepped into movies and specifically acquiring independent films. They also funded some like more big projects. Like they signed this very splashy deal with Adam Sandler, but really their focus around 2015 was acquiring independent films from top festivals and funding small projects, basically, which was met with a lot of excitement from indie filmmakers specifically.
SPEAKER_01The reason being is because the American independent film business, while it had this basically, I write about this in the piece, this commercial boom basically in the 90s, which was funded a lot through this explosion of distribution channels that emerged, and specifically home video, and also this rising generation of indie autors, people like Allison Anders and Gus Van Zant and Quentin Tarantino, who had this, you know, provided these kinds of very fresh perspectives in the film industry.
SPEAKER_01The emergence of home video really led to this commercial boom and also the spread and demand for American films in countries all across the world. And I talked to some producers from this time about how, you know, one was able back then to basically like fund an indie film basically by selling territorial rights, foreign and also ancillary rights in these different countries. And there were all these ways to, there were basically more commercial possibilities to make a film.
SPEAKER_01Because, you know, I talked to Ted Hope, for instance, who um was a producer in the 90s and then eventually worked at Amazon later on. And he was telling me about how, you know, back then you could have five distributors, you know, clamoring for a film in a foreign territory. And he gave this quote about how if you picture five different outlets and a hundred different territories, you have like all the 500 different ways to find success and 500 bytes at the Apple, essentially.
SPEAKER_01And as I said, this was good for indie film in the sense that you could sell territorial rights before you made the movie, you could fund the movie. It took a lot of risk out of the equation. And basically what happened in the 2000s, though, is that the largest Hollywood studios basically stamped out this commercial boom as they shifted more to like IP projects, these larger blockbusters, think of like Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter and Pirates of the Caribbean, and these things that, you know, if you booked them on thousands of screens and it was successful, you could make like a billion dollars at the box office essentially.
SPEAKER_01This model of sort of IP-driven blockbusters was preferred by studios who saw it as less of a risk than indie films made by auteurs, even if they were commercially successful.
SPEAKER_00And I guess we see like a lot of the consequences of that in some senses today as well, where it feels like we can't get away from those types of films like at all.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, totally entrenched themselves as just like the dominant movie in Hollywood. And it's a process that even intensified after 2008 as executives essentially found a kind of new cash cow in the superhero movie, essentially. So by the time that Netflix and also Amazon, the other streamer that's a big player in the film business around this time in 2015, like came into the American independent film industry, people were really excited. I mean, filmmakers were excited, journalists were excited because they saw these tech companies as you know, these potential saviors of indie film.
SPEAKER_01Netflix and the other streamers didn't necessarily believe in like the idea of like territorial rights and foreign rights. They were global platforms, essentially, that wanted the global rights to the distribution of films that they acquired, which wasn't true in all cases and became more common as the years wore on, essentially, acquiring global distribution rights. But that was essentially their goal because they wanted to keep all viewing confined to their exhibition platforms.
SPEAKER_01Like there was essentially no business sense to Netflix to selling the films abroad because they owned an exhibition platform, which other studios did not. People watched on Netflix.com and wanted to keep all that viewing confined to Netflix.com.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think I think some of the only times I've seen like exceptions to that is when they have like uh co-productions or they're like getting the rights to something that was made in a specific territory. And so like, you know, if they buy something that say CBC made in Canada, then CBC probably has it in Canada, but globally, like outside of Canada, it's on Netflix platforms.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And early on, that wasn't true in all cases, but it was definitely that became truer as Netflix and Amazon acquired more films and as their sub subscriber bases exploded, basically, and they became these huge global players. So when they went to festivals, the idea was like eventually what it became was like we're gonna acquire this for this lump sum and basically guarantee that the financier makes a profit, will cover the budget of the film plus a premium, essentially.
SPEAKER_01And that number has varied, but at its peak, I think was somewhere around like 30% of the production budget. So this model was really welcomed by a lot of people, filmmakers, especially, because Netflix, first of all, was spending tons of money. They were just splashing huge amounts of cash at all of these festivals, hoovering stuff up. And they were buying things for their platform, ensuring that the companies that funded these films made a profit, making sure that filmmakers got paid, and then putting them on their platforms, which were global, and basically telling filmmakers like your indie film is going to be seen by like our huge audience.
SPEAKER_01And there was also this role of journalists as well, who I quote from in the essay about this idea that like Netflix with its huge subscriber base, and uh it it's it's sort of this like Chris Anderson long tail theory of audience and viewership and business, which is like with these platforms that have all these viewers and the internet, like you can make something for 10,000 people instead of like a million people, and it will still be successful, essentially. It can still be like profitable in some ways, which is not necessarily true on the Netflix platform, but true in other kinds of business models, essentially.
SPEAKER_01And all these journalists were excited that, like, oh, well, these indie films that traditionally have like smaller audiences, they will be able to like find, you know, Netflix will be able to use its algorithms to like push this niche film to this particular niche, which they've found through their algorithm, you know, and and then all these people will watch it and it'll be great, and filmmakers will get their audiences and they're getting paid. It was this sort of like uh naive utopian idea of what the future of indie film was going to be, which it did not end up like that at all.
SPEAKER_00I guess it's like by the end of the 2010s, like that optimism kind of starts to dissipate, right? Like it's only a few years, is it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, only a few years. And that optimism dissipates for a number of reasons. One of which is that the idea that Netflix's global viewership is going to mean global audiences just turns out to be completely bunk. And also the power of Netflix's algorithms, uh, being able to deliver these things to people also just turns out to be not what people expect it to be. And the reason that is, is because essentially Netflix doesn't market these movies at all. Netflix acquired some great movies in this period.
SPEAKER_01Like two of the pieces I name in the piece are Bong Jun Ho's Okja. They also acquired Alice Rohrvacher's Happy as Lazarus, which it's insane that this movie is on Netflix. They acquired it, I think, only for US distribution, I think, but it's insane that this movie is available on Netflix. It's also basically trapped on Netflix. Because all viewing is confined to the Netflix platform, there's really no way for films, once they go on there, to circulate in the way that movies have circulated for all of their history, which is in like these ancillary forms, whether it's like rep theaters or home video or on airplanes.
SPEAKER_01Netflix doesn't really allow for any of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because there's very few Netflix movies that get shown, you know, in the cinema. I I know now there's like increasingly they might show something for a few weeks, but there's a lot of cinemas that still won't show Netflix films because you know of its business decisions and because it has kind of not wanted to deal with cinemas for for so long. And then of course it also very rarely releases physical copies of what goes onto the platform. So it's like if you're not subscribing to Netflix, you can't access this unless I guess you pirate it or something.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, exactly. And then the other big reason, of course, was the lack of marketing because Netflix had this belief that, oh, well, the platform is doing all the marketing, it's delivering things to us. But uh I got this good quote from Ted Hope in the piece where he was talking about how one of the great inefficiencies back in the old days of distributing a movie was whether your movie was crap or good, you still had to tell people about it because you had to get people to buy tickets to come to the theater.
SPEAKER_01And marketing has always been kind of the lifeblood, part of the lifeblood of cinema, which is like advertising essentially, publicity runs, getting, you know, just think of like actors and directors on like late-night shows, right? Like college screening tours, that used to be more of a thing, radio spots, press junkets, you know, all of this was part of the calculus of, especially an indie film, you know, taking a low-budget picture movie and turning it into a hit and something that can be exploited in the future, you know, and put into rep theaters and continue to make money and really like make it part of, you know, what some people will say like the zeitgeist and cementing it in the minds of the public.
SPEAKER_01And none of that happened on Netflix. Basically, you know, when a movie went onto Netflix, they basically dumped it on the platform and maybe perhaps pushed it to people. And this is something that like I had to watch a lot of movies while researching this piece, a lot of movies that Netflix acquired in this period, and so many of them. It's like the thing that I compare it to is like the trove of lost silent movies from the 1910s and 20s that we don't have today because uh Hollywood hadn't standardized film preservation at that time.
SPEAKER_01Netflix's archive of films from this period is like that. It's like, you know, these movies that I write about, like, you know, this movie that Bree Larson directed with Samuel L. Jackson and Hamish Link later called Unicorn Store or like Fun Mom Dinner, or like or Polka King with Jack Black, these movies have effectively just like disappeared. Unlike the lost trove of silent movies, you know, what's weird about the situation is that these movies actually still exist and can be watched on Netflix's website, and for the most part, you know, nobody watches them.
SPEAKER_01And I think this was something that Netflix executives, if they learned anything from this period, it was this idea that actually, like whether or not people are watching these movies doesn't necessarily like impact one's success as a streaming platform. Uh because Netflix's subscribers, you know, shot up basically between the years of 2015 and 2020, around 2019, around the time that they really abandoned indie film altogether, although it some people would say it was earlier than that.
SPEAKER_01Like if there's anything that these executives learned, it was like to have this successful streaming business, you didn't even need people to be watching the films at all.
SPEAKER_00But like, how does that make any sense? So you have a company like Netflix, right, that is buying all these independent films, is you know, paying a ton of money for some like big kind of blockbuster like movies to put on its platform. And then so many of them, okay, they might, for the first little while that they're out, get a little bit of a push, but some of them don't even get that. And they just kind of disappear into this library of movies that a lot of people don't really go searching through, right? They look at the tiles that are on the home screen, maybe they'll go into like one of the subcategories or something and and take a look at some of the stuff there.
SPEAKER_00But in general, what you are watching, what you are seeing is what Netflix puts in front of you, not like actually going to do a deep search of this, you know, deeper archive and deeper library. So, how does it make any like business sense for them to be spending so much money buying these things and then they just drop them on the platform, hardly anyone watches it, and it disappears, and that's it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I think they realized it made little sense for them in terms of like what they were trying to be. And what I mean by that is like as they got more and more subscribers, they increasingly went after this kind of like lowest common denominator filmmaking in a number of ways.
SPEAKER_00In that case, would you say that all of this money that they spent on independent films and getting people like Martin Scorsese to make these like really expensive films that just allow him to do whatever he wants? Is this then just like kind of marketing money? Like in the sense that you know they're spending all this money to acquire this project so that all of these journalists and you know the media will kind of cover the streaming services in a certain way and say, look, they're spending all this money to let these au tours do their thing and blah, blah, blah. Meanwhile, like the real direction that Netflix is heading in is what you're about to talk about, which is like, you know, this really kind of very kind of basic data-driven stuff that's like kind of you know, basically like content slot to throw onto the platform.
SPEAKER_01An important part of like their dip into indie film was always like funding these established big name autors like Alfonso Quaron and Jane Campion and Martin Scorsese, and basically giving them like blank checks to do whatever they wanted. And that was always a means of legitimacy, basically, and nothing more. I mean, that was always a way to convince top Hollywood talent and their business representatives that you know the company was essentially the opposite of what it is, which is like to telegraph that they are like this grand star-making enterprise that has like the interests of cinema writ large and wants to fund great art with like great commercial appeal, which is never what they were really doing at all.
SPEAKER_01And this is kind of you can see this in the fact that like when these movies are released, the biggest autors on Netflix are able to get some kind of semblance of like a marketing campaign and some kind of semblance of a theatrical release, usually a couple, two to three weeks exclusive in a select number of theaters, some of which Netflix owns or operates, like the Paris here in New York, and then basically dumping them onto the streaming platform where they languish essentially.
SPEAKER_01Some of those movies, it's important to note, have you know found a way out of the Netflix's platform in the sense that like if you're Martin Scorsese you're like powerful enough to negotiate for like a criterion collection, physical media release and whatnot. But for the most part, you know, these movies don't circulate. And Netflix doesn't have the interest of cinema at all. What it has the interest of is making, you know, essentially content, which is what it really transitions to doing in full force kind of around 2019, 2020.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And and so, you know, as opposed to those like independent films and those auteur films, in the piece you talk about a style that you term the typical Netflix movie, you know, that increasingly, as you say, around 2019 becomes much more prominent and much more common. How would you define what those are? And why does a company like Netflix really start to shift to making that kind of a film to fill its platform with?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's not just Netflix, it's it's the other streamers as well, which by this point includes all the major Hollywood studios who have basically launched their own streaming platforms in an attempt to catch up with Netflix. And I was thinking a lot about this thing that, once again, that Ted Hope told me about how he was basically brought onto Amazon around 2015, I think, to sort of like acquire sort of like these excellent filmmakers in Hollywood. And what happens is that it goes to this idea that like what these streaming platforms are are customer acquisition companies and not actually Hollywood studios.
SPEAKER_01They make money from acquiring customers who become monthly subscribers. And for Netflix and the streamers, as their subscriber bases grow, they increasingly want to basically make stuff or acquire stuff that is kind of the bottom of the barrel, lowest common denominator, mass audience crap, basically, that they can instead of pleasing, like you know, the niche long tail 10,000 people or whatever, they increasingly want stuff that will be watched by 20 million people instead of like 200 people or 2,000 people.
SPEAKER_01You can really see this in the movies that they start making. The typical Netflix movie is I write about like a bunch of different qualities of it. One of the things that about it is the title of it, just to start with, which is like always this like really dumb sort of SEO title that says exactly what it is, like a murder mystery, literally called like murder mystery, for instance.
SPEAKER_00What about the one that seemed to dominate the holidays, Hot Frosty?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, yeah, hot frosty. I haven't seen that one yet, actually.
SPEAKER_00I don't plan to watch it either.
SPEAKER_01Or like, you know, there's this other one that I talked about, which was like a romantic comedy about a wine executive called A Perfect Pairing. There's this sense of like the movie is made so that when you come across the tile or whatever and watch the 30-second trailer, that you can recognize aspects of it and sort of ascertain what it's about immediately. There's a certain look to these films as well. I mean, they look like crap, but they have a lot of drone shots in them.
SPEAKER_01That's the thing about them. They're kind of cut in this insane way. They're very frenetic. Another thing that I noticed in watching all these Netflix movies is just even like the title credits, you know, the sort of things that you would see appear, the titles at the start of the movie, you know, when it says the name of the movie and who's in it, they look just completely like thrown together in Adobe After Effects using like these templates.
SPEAKER_00Would you say that it's like the update of the Hallmark movie for like the streaming era?
SPEAKER_01There's definitely an analog in the Hallmark movie. And of course, Netflix increasingly in the last couple of years now invests a lot of money into making their version of like the Hallmark Christmas movie. It's this kind of movie, I call it anti-cinema, that like anybody who has had a Netflix account and come across this stuff kind of knows it instantly by sight. There's all this weird dialogue as well. Like I quote in the piece from one of these Adam Sandler movies, he's talking to a friend of his and he says, want to catch a beer.
SPEAKER_01Like as if, like, want to go to a bar and get a beer, but he says, want to catch a beer. There's this kind of like automated sense that the movies are kind of on autopilot, a kind of screensaver quality to them. They manage to both look very expensive and cheap at the same time. They're very saturated, but also bland. They have a very small dynamic range. They're very dark, but they'll have these colors, like reds will be like, you know, lipstick red.
SPEAKER_01They'll also be very green as well. And a lot of this comes about. From Netflix's sort of insane requirements around their technical requirements, that they require things to be shot with these ultra powerful digital cameras, oftentimes at really high resolution. Although resolution is not necessarily the reason why these things look bad, but they'll be compressed for televisions and laptops, which has a lot to do with the reason why both like colors are saturated, but then there's also this very small dynamic range.
SPEAKER_01They look very low contrast. They look like garbage, essentially. This is what not only Netflix, but all of the streamers begin producing, and it's seen to be a lot more efficient than the older model of like acquiring movies from independence, which also, you know, were risky and at times got them into trouble. Like I mentioned the movie Cutties, for instance, which was an acquisition from France and which sparked this baseless right-wing panic, essentially, that Netflix was sexualizing children.
SPEAKER_01Also, making these movies from scratch allowed Netflix to ensure that they would keep global distribution rights in perpetuity, which was also extremely important for them. And so that they could, you know, lock down this growing number of movies to the platform and not share rights with anyone, essentially.
SPEAKER_00Is the goal then, I guess, like on the one hand, to reduce the cost of having new content, whether it's acquiring or creating or whatnot, but also to make sure that there is like this constant pipeline of new things that are low cost that are being added to the platform. So instead of like, you know, something big that's coming every month, it's like every week there's this new like crappy movie or TV show or something like that. That at least is like, look, there's something new to watch because our goal is not to give you good cinema or to get you to go to a theater every now and then and buy a ticket, but to keep your Netflix subscription or your Amazon subscription or whatever like active, so you're paying every month.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, that's exactly right. Like cadence, keeping a regular cadence of content is like crucial to the customer acquisition business. Even if those movies aren't good at all, because what's important is basically keeping a customer interested just enough to keep subscribing. Although it is important to note that Netflix is still spending in this period tons of money on like some select projects, but what instead of like$200 million or whatever for the Irishman, it becomes like$200 million for some Ryan Reynolds pseudo-blockbuster, essentially, uh, which makes no sense on the Netflix platform and which is basically this giant burning pile of money that nobody cares about or remembers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's fascinating. And, you know, we talked about earlier how data is so important to Netflix and the next Netflix model and has been since before the streaming platform. I'm sure Netflix would talk about that its content decisions are being informed by its data and stuff like that. Do you have anything to suggest whether or not that's like actually the case? Like whether these shitty movies that it's making to keep people subscribed are actually shaped by the data on the platform, or if that's kind of like an overblown sort of thing that it wants you to believe, but is not actually totally true?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, Netflix has always said that, you know, data informs its decision making, but an important thing to always remember is that there's like a human at the end of that who is making decisions ultimately about how to interpret that data. There was actually an article that came out in 2022 by Elaine Lowe, who used to write for Business Insider, where she interviewed a bunch of Netflix executives who were basically talking about how data informed their decision making, but only up to a point. And this is in the television realm, but like Netflix gave, you know, this nine-figure huge production deal to Shonda Rhimes, I forget the year now.
SPEAKER_01It was, I think, around 2018. And one of the things that she's reporting in the piece is how when it's Shonda, she can kind of make whatever she wants and Netflix will be fine with it. When it's anyone else, Netflix will come in and note the thing to death or cancel the show altogether. Which is just to say that, like, I think Netflix's data, the way it uses data, has always been ideological, and they would pretend otherwise, and they would say, well, people want this crappy Lindsay Lohan Christmas movie that looks like garbage.
SPEAKER_01Ten Sarando says this in interviews. He's like, well, people watch it, you know. 60 million people watched it, you know, within the few first week. And, you know, perhaps we'll talk soon shortly about how those numbers are basically bogus. But, you know, that's ultimately like ideological. And it's like, well, people want good movies also. People want movies made by good directors. The Irishman was, in my opinion, like the best movie that Netflix has produced. A lot of people watched it. The decision to make crap and garbage is one that they would say that you know, the data tells us that we have to do that, but ultimately they're the ones who are choosing to invest in that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's fair. And and you kind of like preempted my next question, which is, of course, about the viewership data, right? We hear a lot about how you know a different Netflix show or movie has had a ton of views if you know Netflix wants us to think it's something that is like really consequential or that we should go watch. And it started to like sort of share some data, but but not really. You know, it's still very limited what they provide in these like six-monthly reports. So, how would you describe what Netflix is actually doing there and what the views metric actually means?
SPEAKER_01Netflix has always withheld data basically from the public. And for a while, this was a flex for them. Withholding that data was very good when it came to dealing with talent, directors, producers, actors, in basically allowing them to pay everybody less if you don't know how much your show or movie is actually being watched. It gives you less leverage in negotiations when you're trying to ask for more pay. They so-called opened the black box in various ways.
SPEAKER_01Throughout the 2010s, in lieu of data, they often relied on basically making like ridiculous statements to the press with basically no pushback whatsoever. The instance that always comes to my mind is this New York magazine profile of Netflix back around 2017 where Ted Serandos was going on about how this crap movie had just come out, uh, The Kissing Booth, with uh Jacob Alordy and Joey King. And Netflix was really touting the popularity of this, and he wouldn't give any numbers to the journalist who was writing the article.
SPEAKER_01But instead of the real numbers, he cited the data from something called the Star O meter, which is basically a user-derived metric to measure the popularity of celebrities on imdb.com. And he's going on about how, like, oh, Jacob Alordi, you know, the other week he was number 25,000 on the Star O meter. And this week he's like number one. An important thing here is also that like the story of a lot of tech companies is that like the media or traditional media played a huge role in kind of co-signing Netflix's self-described success over the years by basically not really questioning these kinds of statements in any kind of serious or meaningful way.
SPEAKER_01But going to like 2020, I around that time, Netflix started doing this thing of releasing the number of quote-unquote views of certain stuff. And, you know, they started releasing all these numbers about how like, you know, this movie that you've never heard of is like the number one watched movie in like all of South America. And this other movie is like the number two of all time. You know, every week it seemed like Netflix movies were kind of like breaking these new arbitrary records that came from Netflix itself.
SPEAKER_01And a lot of those records were based on this stat of views that Netflix had come up with, which was basically a view was if anyone watched more than two minutes or at least two minutes of a particular movie, essentially, uh, because in Netflix's eyes, this was long enough to show that two minutes was long enough to show that the choice was intentional. They use this word intentional, which is funny because the Netflix platform, Netflix.com, the entire viewing experience is designed to be completely unintentional.
SPEAKER_01An essential part of it, of course, is the autoplay feature, which like launches users into the next movie or show like seconds after something ends. Sometimes before something officially ends, I've gotten that before. And it's anyone who's had a Netflix account knows it's very possible. In fact, it's common to kind of let the platform essentially just run and you can be watching something for a few minutes that you never chose and that you have no interest in continuing to watch.
SPEAKER_01They were actually kind of lampooned for this by a lot of people, and they ended up switching up their viewership metrics over the next couple of years. And more recently, listeners might remember, I think it was late 2023, I believe, they announced there was this big hubbub about like Netflix announcing it was going in a full transparency mode. They were opening the black box of data. Ted Cerandos did this press conference with or this call with journalists where he was describing the way that like basically Netflix would start releasing these Excel spreadsheets every six months that show the total number of views from the previous six months for every single title, both television and movies, that appears on Netflix.
SPEAKER_01This was more BS, though. There's basically two things that appear in these spreadsheets, which anyone can download online on their website, one of which is it'll say views, and the other thing it will say is viewing hours. And viewing hours is actually this kind of crucial statistic that Netflix now organizes everything around. And basically how they come up with the number of views for a movie is they first tally the number of viewing hours for that movie.
SPEAKER_01So, like, you know, if the kissing booth you'll see on these spreadsheets, it might have they measure it in number of hundreds of thousands, and there's a lot of rounding involved as well, which makes it even less accurate. Basically, what the company is doing is measuring every single second that Netflix's customers spend watching the kissing booth. Like if you click on it and you watch it for like a couple of seconds, or you play it at 1.5 speed, like Netflix is measuring all of that and lumping it and rolling it into this total viewing hours essentially.
SPEAKER_01And then what they do is they basically divide the viewing hours by the runtime. So if it's 100 million viewing hours and the movie is 90 minutes long, that's 1.5 hours. 100 million viewing hours divided by 1.5 is around 66 million and you know 666,000 views essentially. So it's a situation where you can have, if two people watched 45 minutes of The Kissing Booth, for instance, and then close their laptops, which anyone who has watched a Netflix movie knows how easy it is to not finish a Netflix movie, that would equal, in Netflix's eyes, one full view.
SPEAKER_0190 people who watch one minute of a movie also equal one full view. It's this completely opaque way of understanding viewership, and it's also a kind of devaluing of what a movie is, essentially, from something that was once traditionally consumed in full in the theater, you know, and really paid attention to this kind of tranch of pixels that Netflix can kind of sweep into piles and put one over here and one over there to kind of give the illusion that this thing is more popular than it actually is.
SPEAKER_00So I I guess that gets us to like, you know, the biggest question of your piece then, right? You know, if we examine what the effect of the Netflix model has been and how Netflix is changing the type of film and television that we watch to serve its bottom line and its incentives and what have you, then what is the you know wider consequence of all these changes on film as a medium as you begin to have the typical Netflix movie and as you know you have this deceptive views metric and all these sorts of things?
SPEAKER_00Like what does that do to film as a whole and how we understand it?
SPEAKER_01This was a big part of the reason why I wanted to write the piece because Netflix has been written about, I mean, it's been covered so much over the years, and especially in the last couple of years, in the aftermath of the overlapping strikes with the Writers' Guild of America and the Screen Actors Guild, there are a lot of media outlets started writing about like more of the late, like how Netflix basically devalued kind of the labor side of things and how everybody started getting paid less, which we haven't really spoken about, but it's obviously a big part of it.
SPEAKER_01And that's been well reported on at this point. And reading a lot of these accounts, I felt kind of maybe frustrated, or not frustrated, but like something I felt that was never really quite captured in these accounts of how Netflix changed the industry, is how one of the main goals and effects of Netflix was to essentially devalue the cinema specifically and to make movies more like television and more like something that just kind of exists in the background, which has historically, you know, been the great dividing line between the cinema and television, is that like movies happen in the theater in a place where you're really like forced to pay attention to them.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, people walk out of movies. I saw a complete unknown the other night and I watched somebody walk out like 45 minutes in, which was an interesting time to walk out, but they were the only ones who walked out, right? Like most people who buy a ticket to a movie stay in the movie and watch the whole thing. And Netflix is when people, especially people in the business, talk about the way that you know tech company, these tech companies, these streamers, Amazon and Netflix have devalued the industry.
SPEAKER_01One of the things that they're also talking about is the way that movies have been transformed, movies which, you know, this business that has historically been like the center of the world's attention and was really based on this idea of like grabbing one's attention have now been relegated to this thing that basically exists in the background and in fact is designed to exist in the background. One of the things that people have kind of like latched on to in the essay is this quote that I got from these a bunch of screenwriters who I talked to who've worked for Netflix, who all said this common note essentially from one of the things that people have really latched on to in the piece is this quote that I got from some screenwriters I talked to who work have worked for Netflix, where you know they describe the most common note from Netflix executives is this thing of like, have characters announce what they're doing so that people who have it on in the background can still follow along.
SPEAKER_01And this is actually something that's is not necessarily like novel. Like I first learned about this actually in an interview that the actress and director Justine Bateman, who's very anti-AI, gave to the Hollywood reporter like a year ago.
SPEAKER_00And also pro-Trump, surprisingly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, she has a very complicated politics, you might say. In this interview, she described this phenomenon of like executives increasingly searching out what they called, quote, second screen content, which is probably how people, especially who work in Hollywood, are more they're more familiar with this term. The idea of the second screen being like, okay, so you have like your on audiences are like on their phone, they're scrolling, and then they have something on in the background and they're on television just so that they have it to basically exist in the background.
SPEAKER_01What's really interesting about the way that term is now being used is that second screen is a term that's been around and uh around Hollywood for a little while. And it really came to prominence in like the early 2010s with television executives, but it meant something different back then. And what it how it was often used was to describe this phenomenon with the rise of things like Twitter and Facebook, but really specifically Twitter, and this the phenomenon of like people like live tweeting television shows as they were watching them.
SPEAKER_01And when they used this term second screen, what it meant was like, oh, the second screen was like social media essentially. And it was used to describe the way that social media could help these television shows and help with the publicity and marketing. So that like when there was an episode of Mad Men on, if people were using the second screen, you know, there'd be this relationship between the two screens where like the second screen was helping the primary screen in the business sense.
SPEAKER_01What has happened with the development of streaming platforms and what Netflix really pioneered over the last 10 plus years or so is a kind of reversal of these screens. So that now, in the kind of minds of executives today, the second screen is actually the television show or the movie. And the phone is considered to be, or whatever the laptop or the tablet is considered to be the primary screen. And that is like really the shift that Netflix augered with respect to movies was transforming this thing into a kind of background noise, into a second screen.
SPEAKER_00I find that really fascinating because I feel like it, you know, reflects why I feel like I find myself more drawn to the cinema even more than I used to be, because if I watch something at home, I'll often find myself drawn to like pick up my phone or something like that, even if I want to, you know, concentrate on what's happening. But if I'm in the cinema, if you know, you're just in this space where like the expectation is at least supposed to be, I feel like it's changing more and more, that you don't have your phone out in this kind of collective space where you're experiencing this piece of film.
SPEAKER_00And I feel like I don't 100% remember what viewing movies was like at home before the advent of smartphones, but I feel like even then, like you could still zone into something in a way that you really don't now, because there's all these devices and there, all these like you know, things trying to grab your time, where it makes the cinema experience so much more valuable because it is this like opportunity to give yourself to just like ignore everything else and consume this piece of art for an hour and a half, two hours or so.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, this is really the reason why you know you hear the word content used by all of these studio executives is because in this business model that they're pursuing, where like movies basically become content and this kind of background noise, you know, they see it as financially advantageous for them to pursue this because there's only 200,000 cinema screens around the world, and there's something like 20 billion internet-connected devices, which I'm sure can't all connect to streaming platforms, but you know, billions, right?
SPEAKER_01So from their perspective, and also from the perspective of like Wall Street investors, a platform that contains content essentially is seen as more valuable than a film that plays in theaters because of just the sheer number of eyeballs that you know they think that these things can attract, essentially.
SPEAKER_00I feel like we're seeing this growing kind of public turn against social media and other aspects of you know what this kind of digital revolution or whatever you want to call it has brought to us. And I wonder if in 2025 that really starts to extend even more to the streaming platforms as well, as people see the growing like consequences of this, the prices going up, you know, the kind of crap that exists there and how you're missing out on. Increasingly, you're missing out on like, you know, good television and good movies. You know, there are some exceptions to that, obviously, but a lot of stuff that's being made for these things are really kind of you know not great.
SPEAKER_00And I wonder if that starts to shift. Uh Will, it's always fascinating to talk to you about all this stuff, to dig into it. Really good to talk to you again. Thanks for coming back on the show.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me on. I hope the listeners enjoyed it.
SPEAKER_00Will Taplin is a writer based in New York City whose most recent essay on Netflix was published by M Plus One. Tech Won's Save Us is made in partnership with the Nation magazine and is hosted by me, Power Smarks. Production is by Eric Wickham. Tech Won's Save Us relies in the support of listeners like you to keep providing critical perspectives on the tech industry. You can Join hundreds of other supporters by going to patreon.com slash techwon'save us and making a pledge of your own. Thanks for listening, and make sure to come back next week.
Jensen Huang’s affairs may be making headlines, but it’s his crimes that are threatening to burst the AI bubble. Ed Zitron joins Paris Marx to discuss Huang’s explosive exit from Nvidia, including his role in the tech...
Elon Musk is wants Starlink to become a wireless provider, powering mobile phones in the United States and beyond. But that would grant him even more control over our communications. Paris Marx is solo this week to...
Lula has made history as the first candidate to win a presidential election despite losing the first round of voting, all while Meta seemed to be putting its thumb on the scale for his far-right competition. LaĂs...
No one is comfortable with police surveillance in the US, which is why there’s a bipartisan backlash to Flock cameras. Jason Koebler joins Paris Marx to discuss the rise of Flock, how their cameras are being pitched by...
Hyperscale data centers are not an inevitable infrastructure, but a product of capitalist financialization pushing us further from a livable future. Ingrid Burrington interviews Paris Marx about his new book Hyperscale,...