Episode 456: Hidden Gems of EB Series: Make the Middle of Your Unit Matter
22 minAudio
This week's Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast episode, The part of an ELA unit that students remember least is often the part we teach most: the long middle where they’re “doing the reading.” We’re not okay with that, because the during-reading phase is where real comprehension, analysis, and confidence get built or lost. So we’re sharing three practical “hidden gems” that make the middle of a text feel active, purposeful, and genuinely engaging for students. First up: emoji annotations. We walk you through a simple icon key that turns annotation into a visual scavenger hunt for character, figurative language, theme or main idea, personal connections, shock moments, opinions, and lingering questions. It works for short stories and novel study, and we also talk through easy swaps like sticky notes or an annotation log when kids can’t write in books. Then we shift into discussion stations, a flexible station rotation that replaces the same old whole-class chapter talk. Four stations, three questions each, clear focus at every stop, plus sentence stems that help students actually respond to each other with evidence. Finally, we share six-word memoir trading cards, a creative but rigorous character activity that doubles as a mid-novel checkpoint and an end-of-book reflection, perfect for tracking character arc changes over time. If you want during reading activities that boost student engagement and strengthen literary analysis, hit play, then subscribe, share with a fellow ELA teacher, and leave a review so more teachers can find the show.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi there, ELA teachers, Caitlin here, CEO of the city. Hello teachers, and welcome back to another episode of the Teacher. You're choosing ELA to teaching Caitlin ELA podcast. I spent a lot of time together. I feel like by providing them with engaging. Planning it. It's so fun. She has such a wealth of knowledge that I appreciate all of the work that you can put into these episodes for listeners and teachers. And today's issue. And we do this really good today inside the EB Teachers.
SPEAKER_00ELA portals. This is a special place we've developed. Of course. This series I hidden jobs. And all about you just going back and like digging everything they need. But you might batch your lesson as an easy teacher. EBITDA. Maybe haven't like fully explored those units. Yeah. So we pulled out some of the things over the years that we've watched as all sons of teachers that you can use with have found anything doing in your classroom. This episode is still going to be supervised.
SPEAKER_00If you're interested in learning more about how you can do this, click the link in the podcast. If you are an EB teacher, and in the meantime, we'll do all of this content, label version, and it's going to make it a whole easier to implement. What we do talk about. So if you think about how EB structures a unit, if you're new here, we follow what we call the into, through, and beyond, which really is like a before, during, or after reading, whichever language you use works. And today we're focused on the through or the during reading part of a unit. And this is really like the heart of units, that stretch where kids are actually in the text, they're working with the text.
SPEAKER_00It's easy, you know, for that middle chunk though of what you're doing to be just like read a chapter and answer some questions, which is actually a side note what's happening in someone else I know, my son in this class right now. Um and it can be kind of boring, right? Um, so today's episode is all about making that middle part actually matter and be engaging for students and not just like read and answer questions, read and answer questions, which is not fun for anybody. And like always, if you're not an E B teacher, like I said, stick around because we're gonna walk you through how to build each one of these them yourself.
SPEAKER_00All right, Pat, what do you got? What excited you about this one?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think the during stage is the most underrated part of a unit. Um, everybody obsesses over the hook at the beginning and the big project at the end, but the during is where kids are really in the thick of the thinking. So if that part's just worksheets and whole class discussions, you lose them right in the middle where it matters. So today we're pulling three resources that are great for that through space. One's going to come from our Harrison Bergeron short story unit. Um, one's from our Stray short story unit, and one is from our our the outsiders novel unit.
SPEAKER_00I love The Outsiders so much. And I wish that when I was in the classroom, I had our EB unit to teach that novel to my students. I feel like I would have done a much better job of teaching that book if I had that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, for sure. They are our local drive-in theater had the outsiders this summer, and I was busy and I couldn't go, but I was like, oh, we could have seen the outsiders drive-in scene at the drive-in. That would have been so cool. Wait, you have a local drive-in theater? We do, the transit drive-in, and it is a gem. We love it so much.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_01My kids are going up with the real experience.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's so cool. I know that that scene in the outsiders is just the best. In the film. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. In the film. And talking about the outsiders, you have a little bit of a plot twist with that last one that you're going to share with us, right? I do. It's a small one. We'll get there. All right. Let's go ahead and dig in. Pat, you are taking the very first one for our listeners. Go ahead. All right.
SPEAKER_01So I love this one because it's so simple and it takes something you probably already want your students to do, which is annotating the text. And it gives kids a reason to actually enjoy it. So this is emoji annotations, and it lives in the during reading folder of the Harrison Bergeron short story unit.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So walk me through it. How can we make an emoji become an annotation?
SPEAKER_01So kids get a key with eight little icons, so eight little pictures of emojis, and each is tied to a specific thing that they're going to look for in the text. So as they're reading, they mark the text with the matching icon. So they draw that little emoji and then they write a quick note above the words or in the margin.
SPEAKER_00I love that. So it's happening like right as they are reading the text. They're putting the emoji next to whatever section it is.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. So let me run through the eight real quick in case you're making this on your own. So there's a stick figure for the main characters. So they draw a little stick figure and they highlight the name. There's a lightning bolt for figurative language. So they know like whether it's a simile or a metaphor or whatever type they're learning. A thumbs up for something that they like and then they write what they like about it, a frowny face for something they don't like and why. A shocked face for the most shocking part of the story, a link icon for a connection to your uh to your own life or friend's life or something else you've read.
SPEAKER_01Um, they can draw a trophy on the sentence or phrase that strongly connects to a theme or the main idea. And then at the very end, there's a you can do a question mark where kids write down at least one question that they're left with. And our key even gives sentence stuck uh sentence starters in case they get stuck. Like I wonder why or what would happen if.
SPEAKER_00I love that. And I think it's so great, especially the characters one. Like the stick figure is so simple. But I remember like as a reader myself, I have a really hard time comprehending things and like keeping it stored in my brain and not having to read the same paragraph five times. And I would always forget which characters were who. And like I'd read a name once and I wouldn't store it in my memory. So to have that highlighted with the stick figure so that my brain just can find that symbol makes it so much easier, I feel like, for students. I love this.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And then going back is so much easier because yeah, when all you're looking at is text, it's so hard to find what you're looking for. But if you know, if you want to find the figurative language, you know I'm just going to look for the lightning bolt and all the findings I wrote.
SPEAKER_00Yep. I love that. So by the time they're done, one text is annotated for characters, figurative language, personal opinion, shock value, personal connection, main idea, lingering questions that they have. That's so easy and helpful, I feel like.
SPEAKER_01Right. And then you can do it all year long too, and the kids know how to do it. Um, and in a longer text, the students can use the emojis multiple times because that's not very much if you're reading a whole book. So they can do multiple lightning bolts. So it's not like it's not locked to Harrison Bergeron or even to short stories. You just need a key with icons that you want students to use and then a copy of the story.
SPEAKER_00I love that. It's so great. So, Pat, what about a novel? Because I know that this is happening in my son's class. They have books, but they're not allowed to write directly in the book. Um, what do you suggest teachers do in that case?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that works just as well. The kids will just use sticky notes with and they'll draw the icon on the sticky note, or they can keep a running annotation log on a separate sheet. Like you could create a chart that they write in the chart and they note the page number or the icon in their comment so you can come back to it and they use the same emojis and the same thinking.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha. I love it. So it turns into like a scavenger hunt throughout the text either way, whether it's a short story or a whole novel. They're always looking for these things that they can put these emoji symbols to.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's the goal. And if you want to further it, you can even have students create a couple of their own emojis. Maybe they've got annotations that don't like completely fit your categories. They could maybe create some new ones too.
SPEAKER_00You could create them as a class, even if you wanted to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you could create a whole cat class chart. That that in itself would be a really fun discussion.
SPEAKER_00Totally. Oh my gosh, I love it. Okay, that's really fun, especially for our students who love to doodle and like draw and are, you know, inclined to do that anyways. Yes, for sure.
unknownThat was me.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so for this next one, I want to talk about talking because discussion is really important during reading and after reading, but it gets so boring when it's always a whole class chapter talk led by the teacher. So this one is called Discussion Stations, and it's from the during reading folder for our stray short story unit. So if you're an EB teacher, you can go find it there. And that's the Cynthia, Cynthia Rylant story about the family that takes in a dog during a snowstorm. It's a very cute story. I love it.
SPEAKER_00I love that story.
SPEAKER_01Um and I love this particular activity because it's a station rotation.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and that's fun. So, okay, here's how it's set up. So you have four different stations, and at each station, you're gonna have three questions. And in the version that's from this particular short story unit for Stray, every station happens to circle around setting or be like focused on setting. So station one for this particular story is just the basics. It's like when and where the story takes place, what words paint the picture of the weather or time of day, and how the author shows what the Lacey's home is like.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so in the stray unit, they're noticing just the setting. Yes, that's exactly right. Um, so then station two connects that setting to the characters, right? How does the snowstorm actually affect what Doris and her family can do? Or what does the house tell you about the family's worries, or how do the characters react to the cold? So you can start to see like setting isn't just setting here, it's so much more than that, and how it impacts everything that students are really reading in this text. Then station three connects setting to the mood, right? What feelings come from the setting?
SPEAKER_00How does the author create those feelings? How does the weather match how Doris feels? And then station four connects setting to seam. So what might the snow or cold symbolize? How does the setting help you understand the message about kindness or family? And why did the author choose winter instead of another season?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so you've got the overarching top, basically overarching topic of setting kind of combined that kind of connects all of the different stations.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's exactly right. So that's just how this particular unit is formatted, though, right? Because obviously setting is hugely important to this particular short story. However, you don't have to structure it that way, right? You don't have to have one overarching topic like setting across all four stations. The way that you I want you guys to think about this and how you can put it into your own classroom is each station is really just its own kind of like self-contained focus with three questions attached to it. So it's four stations, three questions. So you could just as easily make one station about setting, you can make another station about characterization, and then maybe station three is focused on figurative language, and station four is about something else entirely, right?
SPEAKER_00Whatever it is that pertains to your particular story that you are using this activity with. Or like in Stray, you could deep dive one specific literary element and use a different angle at each station.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so you can zoom in or out as much as you want. And the important thing is just that each station has its own focus that ties the questions together.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's exactly right. And since stations aren't sequential, groups can really rotate through in any order that works. And then to keep the talk productive at every single station, there are sentence stems posters that can go along with it. So you would like hang these up around the room, and so you have stems for agreeing or adding on, or like I agree with blank because blank, um, things along those lines to like express opinion, like in my opinion and presenting different angles, right? On the other hand, or whatever. So you kind of get what I'm saying, that you have these different sentence stems to help students start to think about how they want to respond to the questions.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so kids have language ready to go instead of just nodding along then. And I think it's worth calling out with this activity too, that this is like a get up and move activity. We don't want our students to just stay in their seats and be answering these questions, right? Kids are physically walking from station to station in small groups, which is obviously hugely important to middle schoolers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that matters a lot for middle schoolers. So they're not built to they're not built to sit still through a long discussion and a during reading day can already feel like a lot of sitting and processing the text. So just the act of physically moving their spots, it resets their energy and their attention before they dive into the next set of questions. So do the groups rotate together or do the groups change when they rotate?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you can kind of do it either way. It can be refreshing for students to work with different groups and hear different voices, right? Um, but rotating with the same group can also start to like build kind of camaraderie and trust with them. Um, so it's really up to you to decide kind of however you want to structure it with your class. Gotcha.
SPEAKER_01So the real gem here is the organization, then. So there's four stations, three questions each, each one able to stand completely on its own topic, plus you get the built-in benefit of that physical movement.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. And so then you can fill the stations with whatever skills or standards you're targeting, whatever combination you want. And you've got like a really flexible in any order discussion activity for any story, which I feel like is what we're looking for all the time as teachers. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01This this would work with all of your units, and the kids will know how to do it because they've done it before. Yeah. Um I also want to add, because I had really large classes as a teacher, and I know teachers are wondering um like how do we do this with so many kids? You can have multiples of each station. So you don't have eight or nine kids at each station. Um, like you could have two topic stations, and you know, I mean, or you can have each station have two different groups of students, but they're having their own conversation. So don't sleep on this activity just because you have a lot of students.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. And if you do have two station or two, like um, what's the word I'm looking for? Like two places for the same station, that's gonna make it easier for the groups to switch to, right? Because if you want to switch up groups and they go to different stations with different people and it's it works in a variety of different ways. So I think the main thing is like Pat said, is the structure of this, four stations, three questions, but also the fact that students get to get up and move around. Like that is so, so important for our kids. Um, okay, Pat, the last one, I love this one. And this is the plot twist that you mentioned earlier.
SPEAKER_00Tell us about it, please.
SPEAKER_01Yes. So this one's called Six Word Memoir Trading Cards. And it's from our outsiders novel unit. And this is the first full unit I created for EB. So it's one of our classics.
SPEAKER_00I love it. It's a classic.
SPEAKER_01It still holds up. So full disclosure, this one's actually built as an after-reading activity. Uh, if you go in there, the directions literally start with now that you have read The Outsiders.
SPEAKER_00Why are we featured? Why are we putting it in our during reading episode and not in our after-reading episode that's airing next week?
SPEAKER_01Well, because I think it's too good not to steal for the middle of the novel, too. Okay. Um students can pick any three characters from the novel and they write a six-word memoir for each one. And it's just six words that capture that character's perspective on life, like what they value or a lesson that they've learned. Okay, so only six words. I feel like that's tight, like that's tough. Yes. And that's a good thing because it forces kids to distill a whole character arc down to its essence. And the example in the unit is for Randy. His six words are all the fighting isn't worth it.
SPEAKER_01And on the back of the card, they justify it. Randy lost his friend, he disappointed his father, and he ends up sort sort of mending fences with Pony Boy, which is exactly where those six words come from.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha. I love it. That's such a great tag, like it's like a tagline almost. All the fighting isn't worth it. That's so good. Um, so it's front and back. It's like an actual trading card, which I have literally a million sitting next to me from my son's.
SPEAKER_01Does it does his gym teacher give them to him? Because my kids' gym teacher gives away trading cards. No, but that's super fun. His coaches do it, like some of his stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Kids are always, we have so many trading cards now. Um so the yeah, uh, yeah. So basically it looks just like a uh trading card. The front has the character's name, a little portrait or a symbol of the character that the student draws, and the six words, and the back has a justification with evidence from the text. And then there are blank template templates in the resource too. If you're an E B teacher, there's three cards per page, and the kids cut them out, fold them in half, and they color or design uh each one to match the mood of the memoir they wrote.
SPEAKER_00I love this because like my son would love to create a trading card for some of the characters. Like it, I think it's such a neat concept, especially for our more creative students, and it's still highly academic because of that justification part that they have to put on the back of it. Right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it makes it feel like something that's worth keeping because they're putting so much attention into the design. Um, but here's the twist: you don't have to save this for the very end of the book. Um, you can use this exact same format as a check-in part way. So that's why it's also a during reading activity. Um, just pause after a big turning point and have the kids write a six-word memoir for a character based only on what they know so far, and then have the come back and write a new one once they finish the book. So you're doing it twice, and now you've got a during and an after reading activity.
SPEAKER_00I love it. And then they can actually kind of compare how their read maybe on the character has changed. It's like Pat 1.0 versus Pat 2.0.
SPEAKER_01Exactly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So that's what makes the middle of a novel matter. You're not just checking comprehension, you're tracking how a character's arc is shifting through a story. And it doesn't have to be the outsiders. Six-word memoirs work for any character in any novel you're teaching.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love that so much. So that's a nice little twist, right? On our theme today is finding a way to make something matter in the middle of a text, even when it wasn't necessarily built for the middle of the text. Yep, that's the idea.
unknownI love it.
SPEAKER_00All right, so those are the three hidden gems that we wanted to share with you guys today. Emoji annotations, which I love. That is such a great idea. Discussion stations, which just creates a structure for you that you're gonna follow, easily concrete with Chat GPT or whatever AI tool you're using nowadays, but just like change the way that it's phrased so that your students don't just know that it's AI. Like when I read AI, I'm like, oh, well, that's AI. It's like a million miles away. Yes.
SPEAKER_00AI has a very particular um, what's like diction, if you will. Yes, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, it has that voice. It's like the lists of three, so many lists of three. Which we use too. Like it's not, don't think because I wrote a list of three, I used AI, but it uses it everywhere.
SPEAKER_00It just can't stop. Yeah. In everything. And like, even the way it validates the things that I'm it's like, I hear what you're saying, and and I'm like, oh my God, just answer my question, bro. Um so discussion stations provide you with that structure, but also just the important thing to keep in mind with that is that students are getting up and moving around, as opposed to reading a text, sitting in their desk, analyzing the text, boring, like let's get some sort of movement for our kids, especially the ones who need to get up and moving around. And then the super fun one, which is the six-word memoir trading cards.
SPEAKER_00So these are three great ways to make sure that the jeering stage or the through section of your unit is doing just as much work as your hook, and then obviously your final project.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And none of these need you to be teaching Harrison Bergeron, Stray, or The Outsider specifically. An emoji key in whatever story or novel you're on, a four-station discussion setup so you can that you can fill in with any topics, or a stack of trading card templates, and that's really all it takes.
SPEAKER_00I love it. So good. Thanks, Pat, for putting this episode together for us. And we will be back with more hidden gems of EB in upcoming episodes. They're gonna be really, really good. And if you stumbled across something buried in a unit that you think other teachers could use in a new way, we'd love for you to share it in our professional learning community if you are an EB teacher. And I just want to give you a little hint as to what's coming down the pipeline on the podcast this month. So we have another hidden gems for our hidden gems series, and that's all about those beyond lessons.
SPEAKER_00So skipping the unit test and like very specific projects that you can do with your students instead. This one's fabulous. And then this one came. Pat, do you want to talk about where this idea came from for the best EBW resources that our teachers might be missing? Like, I know that you like we see a lot of the same questions in the Facebook group, and you're like, well, we have something for that. Can you talk about where that this idea sparked from for you?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Well, actually, I reached out to our team, especially our team members who are still in the classroom. And I said, basically, we're doing this hidden gems. Like, do you have any ideas? And our team member Melinda, who also teaches in the classroom, said we really need to do an EBW themed uh episode because she's she's in the community all the time and she sees all these questions, and these the teachers have no idea what they have in their hands. Like they have all these really cool things right at their fingertips, just hiding inside of certain folders. So we're gonna take those out of the folders for you and kind of show you around.
SPEAKER_00I love it. It's so fun. I can't wait to record those. And then we're doing something for Halloween, but it's a not so spooky Halloween activity. So even if you can't celebrate Halloween in your classroom, you can still use this activity that we're gonna be sharing towards the end of the month. All right. Thanks guys so much for joining us. Hope you're having a wonderful October. And we will see you next week on the podcast. Thanks so much, Pat, for being here. Thanks for having me.
In this week's Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast episode, we're exploring how to turn your students' desire to make a difference into a meaningful classroom project! When students read stories about refugees, hunger,...
What if the fastest way to feel less overwhelmed isn’t a new hack, but one honest question you ask yourself before the day runs away from you? In this week's Monday Mindset, Caitlin pulls a surprising lesson from the...
This week, we're sharing a fun solution: a Short Story Escape Room using Walter Dean Myers' The Treasure of Lemon Brown! Pat joins me to walk through how to turn close reading into an exciting challenge using our Into,...
This week's Monday Mindset is all about quiet quitting, teacher burnout, and reclaiming control over how we experience our teaching lives. Teaching middle school ELA can be exhausting, but what happens when frustration...
Another great Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast episode! Veterans Day can feel tricky in middle school ELA: you want to honour service in a real way, but you also need a lesson plan that builds reading skills, not just...