You know that feeling when you’re weighing a decision and every option seems loaded? That tense, looping thought of “What if I make the wrong choice?” Today, Caitlin shares a story that cuts straight through that noise and lands on a simple truth: the regret that sticks is often the choice you never made. Caitlin talks about a real crossroads moment, the kind that feels exciting and terrifying at the same time. For one person, it was the leap to teach English abroad and build a life in a new country. For many middle school ELA teachers, the leap looks different but hits the same nerve: trying a new lesson planning approach, saying yes to a leadership opportunity, joining a community, changing a habit, or finally making a decision you’ve been circling all year. It’s about choosing intentionally, trusting your ability to adapt, and protecting your time, energy, and wellbeing so you can be the teacher and person you want to be. If this resonates, subscribe, share it with a teacher friend who needs a push, and leave a quick review so more ELA teachers can find the support they deserve. What are you giving yourself permission to say yes to this week? Here's to another week of living intentionally.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi there, ELA teachers. Caitlin here, CEO and co-founder of EB Academics. I'm so excited you're choosing to tune into the Teaching Middle School ELA podcast. Our mission here is simple: to help middle school ELA teachers take back their time outside of the classroom by providing them with engaging lessons, planning frameworks, and genuine support so that they can become the best version of themselves, both inside and outside of the classroom. And we do this every single day inside the EB Teachers ELA portal.
SPEAKER_00This is a special place we've developed uniquely for ELA teachers to access every single piece of our engaging, fun, and rigorous curriculum so that they have everything they need to batch plan their lessons using our EB Teacher digital planner that's built right into the app. Over the years, we've watched as thousands of teachers from around the world have found success in and out of the classroom after using EB Academics programs. And we're determined to help thousands more. If you're interested in learning more, simply click the link in the podcast description.
SPEAKER_00And in the meantime, we look forward to serving you right here on the podcast every single week. Well, hello, teachers, and welcome back to another Monday Mindset episode. Today I'm actually going to share a story about my younger brother, Keith. Keith is six years younger than I am, so he's 34. And I believe this happened close to right when he graduated from college. And he was at one of those crossroad moments in his life where he was given the opportunity to go teach English abroad in France and kind of move there for that, and also because he fell in love with somebody.
SPEAKER_00And it was kind of a beautiful story. And I remember him going like back and forth between weighing it. Like, is this crazy? Should I not go? Should I go? Just all of the pros and cons of each thing. And I remember when I was his age that I wanted to do something similar. I wanted to go teach English in Italy after I graduated from college. I unfortunately did not make that decision. And, you know, I try not to live my life with regret, but that is something that I wish that I could go back and do.
SPEAKER_00Maybe when I'm 50 and my son's out of college or out of high school and in college, and I can go do that or something like that. That would be fun. But I remember talking to him because he was really like carrying that weight of the energy of like, what if I make the wrong choice? And I just don't know that there's any right or wrong choice necessarily, like when we are at this type of crossroads in our life per se. Um, but I remember telling him at that time, I was like, you will never regret going. You will never regret going.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, you can go if it's not right for you. You can come home, right? You can always come back to California. But if you don't go, if you let the fear of the unknown of going and, you know, falling in love with this person and seeing what happens, I said, if you let that fear hold you back from going, you will spend the rest of your life wondering, what if I had gone? And that wondering of the what if, it is so much worse than the discomfort of the actual decision to go.
SPEAKER_00And so he went and he spent two years living there and had an amazing time and learned so much about himself. And I was talking to him recently about this, because this was, I guess it was 12, 13 years ago or so. And he said to me, He called my brothers call me Sissy, and he goes, Sissy, I think about that conversation all the time. And I don't know if I would have gone without it. And so then that hit me, like as his older sister, right? Because what he was really saying to me wasn't like that I had this like sage advice to give him.
SPEAKER_00It was really like under the heart of it that sometimes all we need is someone to give us permission to say yes to the thing that we already want to do. And I talked about this in one of my Sunday newsletters a couple of weeks ago. If you're an EB Teachers ELA portal member and you're a part of our membership, you got this message. But in that message, I talked about how a lot of the times, you know, we are just looking for that permission. And it's the permission of the thing that we already know we want to do.
SPEAKER_00You know, when someone's at a crossroads with me, I always say, Well, pretend you know the answer, what would it be? And they do. They know the answer in their heart of hearts. They know exactly what they need to do. And sometimes it's just helpful to have that other person in our lives to say, dude, go do it. And so today I want to be that person for you because I think a lot of teachers are standing at a crossroads right now. And it might not be as dramatic as moving to another country, but it might be. And this is your answer to you will never regret going, you will always regret not going, right?
SPEAKER_00But maybe it's something simple. Maybe it's finally trying the EBW approach that you've had access to, that you've been super curious about, or maybe it's raising your hand for a leadership opportunity at your school that feels a little bit scary, or maybe it's joining a community of pickleball players so that you can put yourself out there and make new friends. Maybe it's a much, much bigger decision about your career, about your life, about your school, whatever it is that you've been kind of circling around without landing on.
SPEAKER_00And the thing that I want to offer you is this is that we are almost always more afraid of making the wrong choice than we need to be. Because here's the truth that I've lived over and over and over again. When you say yes and it doesn't work out exactly the way that you'd hoped, you almost always find your way back to better, solid ground, right? You figure it out, you adapt, you learn something that makes you better for the next decision. Life is remarkable at allowing us to experience lessons to help us expand into our next level of ourselves.
SPEAKER_00And so I think about the choices that we don't make or the risks that we don't take, the doors we don't walk through because we are too afraid of what might be on the other side. Those what ifs, that wondering, what if I had just tried? What if I had just done that? It stays with us. And I think September, right, in its own little way, is a crossroads moment because this is the beginning of the year, right? The possibilities are still open. Nothing has been necessarily decided yet. Like you get to choose right now who you are going to be this year, what you're gonna try, what you're gonna commit to, what you're gonna finally stop putting off these ways of being that no longer serve you anymore.
SPEAKER_00So here's what I want you to sit with this week. What is the thing that you've been telling yourself you'll do someday when you're more ready, when things calm down, when the timing is better? And what would it look like to just say yes to it right now? Because someday has a funny way of like never arriving. And the version of you that's on the other side of that yes, they are so worth showing up for. They are so worth saying yes for.
SPEAKER_00And so don't let this be the year that you look back on and you wonder what if. And I want to offer you one more thought before I close out today's episode. And this is a personal share with you. I remember when I was weighing the decision of, you know, my marriage at the time and what to do about it. And we had been married for almost 14 years. I've known my ex-husband for almost two decades, which is crazy. Um, and I just remember sitting with myself and thinking, like, if I wasn't, if if I knew that everyone would be better off on the other side of this, my ex-husband, myself, my son, if I knew without a shadow of a doubt, that the decision to end our marriage would produce an outcome that made everybody happier.
SPEAKER_00That everybody was happy, what would the choice be? And so what that thought did, what that little thought experiment did for me, is it made it super, super clear on what I actually wanted to do and what I actually needed to do in my life without fear running the show. And so that's just something to offer you. Like on the other side of this, if the if on the other side of this decision, whatever crossroads you are at, everyone's happier because you made that choice, what would your decision be?
SPEAKER_00Right? Like it just, and it's not to say it's not hard. Divorce has not been fun. I would not suggest it for anybody if you don't have to go through it. It is immensely stressful and very difficult, and it has been a heck of a two and a half years. And also, I know without a doubt that it was the best decision. My ex-husband is engaged, he has two new stepsons that he gets to have a part of his life, and my son gets brothers, and I love my ex-husband's fiance.
SPEAKER_00There are so many wonderful things that came as a result of that really, really scary decision. And so I just want to offer that to you. You know, what are you gonna regret not doing? And just take the leap because the net will appear. And it's not not gonna be hard, easy, you don't know. It could be the most beautiful decision, whatever it is, that you make in your life. All right, everybody, here's to another week of living intentionally.
In this week's Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast episode, we're exploring how to turn your students' desire to make a difference into a meaningful classroom project! When students read stories about refugees, hunger,...
What if the fastest way to feel less overwhelmed isn’t a new hack, but one honest question you ask yourself before the day runs away from you? In this week's Monday Mindset, Caitlin pulls a surprising lesson from the...
This week, we're sharing a fun solution: a Short Story Escape Room using Walter Dean Myers' The Treasure of Lemon Brown! Pat joins me to walk through how to turn close reading into an exciting challenge using our Into,...
This week's Monday Mindset is all about quiet quitting, teacher burnout, and reclaiming control over how we experience our teaching lives. Teaching middle school ELA can be exhausting, but what happens when frustration...
Another great Teaching Middle School ELA Podcast episode! Veterans Day can feel tricky in middle school ELA: you want to honour service in a real way, but you also need a lesson plan that builds reading skills, not just...