Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions Teacher Exchange began with a question I found myself asking after talking to people who teach evidence-based management: what helps you keep going when teaching and championing EBM can sometimes feel difficult or lonely? I had one possible answer in mind - mentoring. But when I took the idea to Eric Barends, he suggested something characteristically evidence-based: why don't we ask the teachers? What we heard changed my thinking. There wasn't one kind of support that everyone needed. But something that came through strongly was the value of being able to find and talk with other people teaching EBM. That eventually led us to try Teacher Exchange: small, informal online conversations where teachers can share experiences, compare notes and see what they find useful. In this episode, I look back at how the idea evolved, what we're learning from the conversations we've held so far, and how we're trying to make it easier for teachers to find one another. Host: Karen Plum FURTHER INFORMATION: Teacher Exchange: Find out more about Teacher Exchange here. We'll announce future opportunities through the CEBMa newsletter, or simply let me know if you're interested. Other support: If one-to-one mentoring or reflective support would be useful to you, that's available too. A topic you want to discuss? If there's a particular aspect of teaching EBM that you'd value discussing with other teachers, we'd be interested to hear about it. Get in touch: k.plum@cebma.org Other links: Helen Pearson - Beyond Belief: How Evidence Shows What Really Works Podcast episode featuring a discussion with Helen Pearson Contact for more information: Eric Barends, Managing Director of the Center for Evidence-Based Management
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Karen PlumHello and welcome to the podcast. You might have seen something in the CEBMa newsletter or on the website, or maybe you've had an email or more than one email from me about something that we've been trying called teacher exchange. If you haven't heard of them, then they're small, informal, online discussions that bring teachers together, people who simply want to hang out and talk with each other and share experiences. We've held a few now and we're starting to organize some more for later this year.
Karen PlumAnd I've been thinking about how teacher exchange actually came about, because it wasn't something that we sat down and designed as a program. And in fact, when I trace the story back, I realize it started quite a long time before we held the first conversation. So I thought I'd share that story with you. So we're going back to 2021, the year after we were all introduced to COVID, when I started making a podcast for CEBMa to accompany the online evidence-based management training course.
Karen PlumAnd over the years, CEBMa's focus seemed increasingly to turn towards how they could support teachers. And so we created a podcast for teachers, and that's the one that you're listening to, obviously. So this brought me into contact with lots of different teachers, and we had lots of great conversations. But I started to really understand how difficult it can be to champion and to teach evidence-based management. And I remember Eric referring to particular teachers as a lone wolf in their university, somebody that's trying to push forward evidence-based management, perhaps sometimes not, you know, without a lot of support and sometimes with out right resistance.
Karen PlumThat was getting on for about a year ago, I suppose, I was thinking about all of this. And I found myself wondering, how do all of you keep going in the face of how hard this can be? And I guess that led me on to wonder what might help teachers of evidence-based management, perhaps people who are feeling a bit isolated or lacking in colleagues to work with, what might help them? I started to think about things that I've found that have helped other people.
Karen PlumAnd one of the things that came to my mind, because it's a rather a passion of mine, is mentoring. I volunteer as a mentor for organizations in the charity sector here in the UK. And I can see what a difference it makes for leaders to have somebody that they can talk to, to have somewhere safe they can share issues and challenges. And I wondered whether mentoring was something that would help teachers of evidence-based practice.
Karen PlumAs often happens with me, I gave it a lot of thought and I started to form a plan. And looking through some files on my PC from about a year ago, I actually did a lot of thinking and a lot of documenting about how this idea might work and how we might offer it to teachers. I chatted to Eric about it. And because he's evidence-based to his core, he said, Why don't we ask the teachers?
Karen PlumWhat a great question. The man always asks such good questions. So I thought, well, yes, we need to be evidence-based, so of course, let's ask the teachers. So that's what we did. Rather than going and leading the witness, I talked to a number of teachers and asked them, um, what helps them sustain their commitment to teaching evidence-based practice when the environment can be indifferent or resistant to their efforts.
Karen PlumI asked them, Do you need a reflective space? If you need one, where do you find it? And what sort of relationship would be useful in that regard? What would make the support valuable? And interestingly, it wasn't that nobody wanted mentoring, but they wanted something very different. They wanted each other. And I want to say that again because it came across very strongly.
Karen PlumIt wasn't that they needed to be taught how to teach, it wasn't that they wanted somewhere safe to talk to somebody, but they wanted to connect with other people who were going through the same sort of experience that they were. Was I surprised? Uh, well, not really, but it was so different to what I had in mind that it really made me sit up and think about it.
Karen PlumAnd not all of these teachers were um isolated lone wolf pioneers. Some had colleagues in their institution, some had simply been given the topic to teach. They weren't a pioneer at all, but the evidence-based teaching material had become part of a curriculum, and so they were asked, Will you teach this, please? And so very different types of people, some genuinely isolated, um, and said that very clearly, particularly when the wider faculty might look at them and think, well, you know, she's very nice, but wha exactly does she do?
Karen PlumUm, and so you can see how those sorts of people might really value the opportunity to talk with other teachers. So let me be very clear. We are in no doubt that there are lots of different types of teachers, both in terms of what they're looking for and what they deliver, how they deliver it, etc. So when we boiled it all down, we thought, well, if people want to talk to other teachers, other people like them, how can we make it as easy as possible for them to find each other?
Karen PlumAnd so that's where the first pilots started earlier on this year to just allow people to connect with each other. I thought through whether we should have a topic, whether we should have a presentation, should we have an agenda, should we record it, and I rejected all of that. I just wanted to create the conditions where people could talk and just see what happened. I didn't know whether it was going to work.
Karen PlumWhat I was consciously trying to do was not pre-judge and not be looking for a launch pad for a big program or something massive that it would be difficult for CEBMa to manage. Let's just bring people together and let them talk to each other. Now, I know that's not going to work for everybody. Some people would run a mile from such an unstructured engagement. So I just thought, well, let's offer it.
Karen PlumBut one thing that does occur to me is that this echoes the history of the evidence-based movement. If you've come across Helen Pearson's book that was published earlier on this year, Beyond Belief, she makes it very clear that all of the pioneers for the different disciplines of the evidence-based approach - so social policy, policing, medicine, all seemed to begin with relatively isolated people ploughing a furrow, unaware that there were other people doing the same thing in another discipline.
Karen PlumIt certainly showed me that helping people to find each other was something that I really wanted to help them to do. And look, there's no magic to teacher exchange. It's just people talking to each other and thinking with each other. What I've observed from the sessions we've run so far is that people are generous in what they share. Nobody grandstands. People can ask each other questions. How have you done X?
Karen PlumHow do you cope with Y? And all I try to do is to provide the conditions that make it easier for people to have those conversations. In what we've done so far, we've found that the teachers that we have brought together seemed to value the time that they spent with each other. Some said, Wow, I found my tribe and I've connected them with each other. Everybody's got everybody else's email address through their own consent.
Karen PlumAnd so they can talk to each other whenever they want to. Teachers talking together doesn't need me, doesn't need CEBMa. Anybody can reach out to any teacher. But I recognize that sometimes if you don't know where the teachers are or you don't know what they're like, then that might be a bit of an ask. Everybody's busy and it needs to be easy for you to be able to do it. So what we found is that certainly the teachers that we've engaged with so far have found the exchanges valuable.
Karen PlumThe original pilot groups have met again. Actually, with one group, because I messed up the scheduling a little bit. I ended up meeting with a few of them and then a couple more met on their own. Absolutely fine. They had a great chat. You don't need a facilitator, certainly once you get going. But I'm always there to help people to get going if that's what they want. And now I'm moving on to the next phase, if you like, beyond the pilot and those original groups, and inviting more teachers to get together, the ones that couldn't make the original sessions, the ones that would still like to spend a bit of time meeting some other teachers.
Karen PlumWhat's really important is that what happens beyond that conversation is entirely down to the people that took part. If people want to be in touch with each other beyond a session, that's fine. If they don't, also fine. We're not trying to measure success because there are so many different ways in which this initiative can be successful, and many of them I will never see.
Karen PlumI have a thing that I say to people in mentoring, uh, but also when I'm talking with teachers and making the podcast, I talk about sowing seeds. And when we teach and when we mentor, we say things, we plant ideas, and we never know when they may bear fruit. It might be years into the future, it might be tomorrow. We literally don't know. But because we don't know, that's not a reason to not do it.
Karen PlumAs far as I'm concerned, success is - a teacher comes to one conversation, picks up a really great idea from another teacher, never comes to another teacher exchange discussion, that's success to me. And if somebody never manages to attend a session, but feels that yeah, it's it's okay for me to reach out and contact another teacher independently, if they feel emboldened to do that, great, that's success for me.
Karen PlumIf somebody comes to six conversations, enjoys every one, and does nothing specific with any of that, that's also a success for me. But I don't need to know about it. If you enjoy it, great. If it's useful to you, fabulous. If you want to tell me about it, that's great. But I don't need that to keep going. And we don't just keep going with what we have today. We listen to teachers, we ask them, what else might you want?
Karen PlumAnd some things are starting to evolve. Some teachers recently have asked me about convening conversations about specific subjects that they would really like to discuss, perhaps something a bit more in-depth than is appropriate for one of these informal teacher exchange discussions. So we're going to have a look at that. I'm just really wanting to make it easier for people to find each other. And if somebody would like to establish a teacher exchange discussion of their own and simply needs help finding some other teachers, great.
Karen PlumJust ask me or Eric and we'll help you do that. CEBMa doesn't need to be at the heart of this. We want to do what's helpful for teachers. So I asked myself originally how do people keep going when teaching evidence-based management can be hard and lonely? There isn't one answer. But making people more visible to one another is one way to help them to feel that they're not alone. What's important to me is to give people opportunities to talk together and to think together.
Karen PlumI'm cool with the fact that much of what grows won't be visible to me. And I suppose that's what we're really trying to do, make it a little easier for people - kind of ploughing similar furrows - to find each other, to create some opportunities for them to talk and think together, and then let them decide what happens next.
Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions What are we really teaching when we teach evidence-based management? Teachers often hope their students leave with more than knowledge of concepts and frameworks. But...
Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions People working in evidence-based management can sometimes feel like they are swimming against the tide. But they are part of something much larger. In this episode we...
Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions Working with evidence-based management can be uncomfortable. It asks people to sit with uncertainty rather than reach for certainty - something many of us are rewarded...
Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions This episode was recorded live with three evidence-based management experts, Denise Rousseau, Rob Briner and Eric Barends, answering and discussing questions sent in by...
Send us a message with your thoughts or reactions The gap between management research and practice remains stubbornly wide, but a growing movement of dedicated educators is working to change that by embedding...