Work with Taylor: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/start-here?utm_source=Youtube&utm_medium=Videolink&utm_campaign=46326 See a $10,000 Sample Plan Here: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/sample-plan?utm_source=Youtube&utm_medium=Videolink&utm_campaign=46250 Taylor's Newsletter: https://demars-financial-group.ck.page/0457622ab4 Can you retire at 58 with $4 million and spend $15,000 per month? In this retirement case study, Taylor breaks down whether a $4 million portfolio can support an early retirement while funding an annual lifestyle of $180,000. Retiring at 58 creates several planning challenges that do not exist with a traditional retirement. You need to account for a potentially longer retirement, healthcare costs before Medicare, market volatility, inflation, taxes, and the risk of withdrawing too much from your portfolio during the early years. Taylor looks beyond the starting portfolio balance to show how retirement income planning, withdrawal strategy, Social Security timing, investment returns, and future spending can affect the long-term outcome. A successful plan is not simply about reaching $4 million. It is about understanding how much you can spend, where that income should come from, and how your strategy may need to adapt over time. If you are asking, “Can I retire with $4 million?” or considering retiring before 60, this example will help you identify the numbers, risks, and tradeoffs worth reviewing before leaving work. 0:00 $4 Million Retirement Plan Overview 1:22 Why an 82% Monte Carlo Score Isn't Enough 2:50 Retirement Spending Changes Over Time 3:35 Three Stretches of Retirement Spending 4:41 Why Retirees Rarely Spend More Later 5:41 Taxes Raise the Real Withdrawal Rate 9:09 Asset Allocation and Sequence-of-Returns Risk 13:26 Building a Retirement Income Buffer 15:20 Backup Levers for a Prolonged Downturn 16:00 Using a Pre-Approved HELOC 16:55 Can Patricia and Kevin Retire at 58? Resources: Website: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/ Phone: (509) 536-9556 Schedule an introduction call with Taylor: https://bit.ly/demarspodcast Check out Taylor's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TaylorMadeRetirement Taylor's Newsletter: https://demars-financial-group.kit.com/827c64fe0e Disclaimer: Since we don't know your specific situation, none of this information should be construed as tax, legal, financial, insurance, financial advice, or other advice and may be outdated or inaccurate. It is your responsibility to verify all information yourself. This content is prepared for entertainment purposes only. If you need advice, please contact a qualified CPA, attorney, insurance agent, financial advisor, or the appropriate professional for the subject you would like help with. Demars Financial Group, LLC or its members cannot be held liable for any use or misuse of this content. Advisory services offered through Demars Financial Group LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor. Demars Financial Group is not affiliated with LPL Financial.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Today's content is pulled from Taylor's YouTube channel. If you want to watch the video version or catch more great content, subscribe by clicking the link in today's show description. Welcome to Taylor Made Retirement, where we explore what it takes to build a retirement that works for your money and your life. With third generation certified financial planner Taylor DeMars.
SPEAKER_00Two retirement plans both start at age 58 with 4 million and spend$200,000 a year. But the one with the better Monte Carlo score is the one I'd be worried about. And it's not just because the 5% withdrawal rate is higher than the familiar 4% rule. Maybe you're ready to retire and your advisor says you can. Maybe you checked bolded, or maybe you just feel like you've saved enough. So what's the hesitation for? Well, for starters, taxes actually push this couple's early withdrawals above 6%. But when I back tested both portfolios starting in 2000, the higher scoring one had less than$800,000 left at 67, leaving them facing a choice.
SPEAKER_00Start canceling the trips they planned or risk running out of money later. I'm Taylor DeMares, certified financial planner who's helped hundreds of people work through these decisions. And I'll show you why the plan with a better score performed worse when spending$200,000 actually works and what you need to put in place before your final paycheck. Let me introduce you to the couple we'll use in today's example. Patricia and Kevin are both 58. Kevin retired a few years ago, and Patricia plans to work until next spring. And between them, they've saved about$4 million. Most of it sits inside of Patricia's 401k and Kevin's IRA.
SPEAKER_00They'd like to be able to spend around$200,000 a year. What worries them isn't whether$4 million is enough money, it's whether spending this much in their 60s means they'll have to start cutting back in their 80s. And here's the short answer: it can work. Their plan by a Monte Carlo score is at 82%. We like to see clients' scores around 80% as a sweet spot before we're comfortable telling them that they can pull the trigger to retire. We don't think of it as a pass or fail score, but more as a temperature gauge, not a verdict. And in the middle of the road median projection, they're estimated to have around$2.8 million and today's dollars at age 95.
SPEAKER_00So you're asking, what else is there to talk about? The fine print on that projection is that it comes with a thousand simulated retirements, each with different market returns built on what we expect their spending, income, and healthcare and more to look like. However, in our family's 50 years of helping retirees and pre-retirees, we have yet to see real life precisely follow a spreadsheet. And you only get to live one of those thousand scenarios. And that 4% rule you've heard of makes that 5% withdrawal rate sound a little aggressive when it comes with the three lines of fine print, which is first, the 4% safe withdrawal rule assumes that you take the same amount out every year.
SPEAKER_00Second, it's figured before taxes are in the mix. And third, it actually assumes that your money is already set up in a certain way before the bad years show up. For Patricia and Kevin's situation, the first line works in their favor, the second one works against them, and the third one depends entirely on what they do before their first withdrawals. Now, if you're close to a decision like this and you'd like a second pair of eyes on your own numbers before you pull the trigger, you could book the call with me in the link description or use the QR code on screen here now. So let's unpack that first line of fine print.
SPEAKER_00That 4% rule assumes you take out the same amount every year, raised for inflation for 30 years. And real retirement doesn't actually spend like that. A study by David Blanchett at Morningstar found that after inflation, retiree spending tends to drift down about 1% every year. So one of the first things we ask any couple is what is their money actually going toward? For Kevin and Patricia, about half of that spending just goes towards their general living expense. And they have housing, healthcare at full price, and vacation before we even factor in taxes.
SPEAKER_00And healthcare is the one that feels like a gut punch for most people. Paying full price in their scenario, premiums and deductibles and out-of-pocket included is assumed to be north of$30,000 a year for the high quality insurance they're wanting. And these numbers aren't going to stay put. I think of this retirement in three stretches, which is the first stretch goes from now at 58 until age 67, and everything comes out of their savings, health insurance is at full price, and the go-go travel trips are their largest ever. And the second stretch starts when Social Security kicks in, assuming at full retirement age for both of them.
SPEAKER_00Together, they'll collect around$6,900 a month, and that picks up a big share of the bills that never goes away. And between Social Security and Medicare, what they pull from savings actually drops by about$100,000 a year compared to those first few years. And in their 70s, travel is going to slow down too. The third stretch is those last few years. And we've built in three years of long-term care for each of them because that's the elf in the room most people like to forget about. So fast forwarding to the first year that they have Social Security, you can see why this$200,000 a year spending isn't a lifetime problem.
SPEAKER_00The hard part is the early stretch and about nine years long. And that$2.8 million that they'd have left in that middle-of-the-road projection, they have two kids today in their early 30s. And by the time that money passes to them, those kids might be in their late 60s, retired themselves. So you might be thinking, fine, they can just spend more later when they know they can. But having firsthand worked with clients in their 60s, 70s, 80s, and even 90s, I've seen how that usually goes. Old habits die hard. And I can't tell you how many times I've shown someone in plain English and in black and white math that they can spend more.
SPEAKER_00And while they say they believe me, most of the time they don't change a thing. It's hard to rewire human psychology. And in fact, research points that same way. A 2025 study by David Blanchett and Michael Finke found that a 65-year-old married couple in their study spent most of the income that shows up like a paycheck, like Social Security, but only around 2% of their savings each year. For Patricia and Kevin's scenario, the lifestyle that they establish early in retirement is unlikely to just become more lavish when they're 80, even if they could. And that's why I'm passionate about helping people spend more early in retirement.
SPEAKER_00And that is if your plan can carry it. And that's the catch. Because this first nine-year stretch for this couple is exactly where the other two lines of fine print hit the hardest, starting with taxes. The second line of fine print with the 4% rule is that it assumes that the certain amount you'll spend is excluding taxes. And the$4 million that this couple has saved isn't all theirs. My wife is tired of hearing me talk back to our TV when we're watching a show like Survivor or The Amazing Race, because whenever anybody is talking about winning the million dollar prize, I'm the one that's trying to look up where that person is from, what state they're from.
SPEAKER_00So I can guess whether it's a little more or a little less than half that they'll actually see hit their bank account after taxes. Because they're not really getting a million dollars. The IRS is getting their share first. And your IRA works the same way. About$2.4 million of Patricia and Kevin's savings is in their$401 and IRA. And part of every dollar in there belongs to the IRS. So say they're past$59.5 and they want$200,000 to land in their checking account for a certain year. If every dollar came out of the$401, they need to take out around$234,000 because that$34,000 is going to federal taxes.
SPEAKER_00If it just came from only their brokerage account, it's much closer to just that$200,000 figure, depending on their gains. Only the growth in there is taxed, not what they originally put in. And a portion of that growth may actually be able to be taxed at 0%. And of course, money from a Roth that's been open for at least five years, none of it gets taxed at all. It's the same$200,000 that will land in the checking account, but very different amounts that come out of the portfolio. Until they reach age 59 and a half, most withdrawals from a 401k or IRA come with a 10% penalty on top of the tax.
SPEAKER_00There are exceptions, like the Rule 55, that could let Patricia tap out of her 401k from the job that she's leaving. But for this plan, their first year of paychecks comes from the brokerage account and some cash. Now I want to show you what happens when I change nothing but the order from which they withdraw from their various accounts. Again, it's going to be the same couple, same spending, and the same market assumptions. And one order is going to actually make them$2.8 million worse off just by changing this withdrawal sequence. So if we refresh the scenario, assuming they draw from their tax-free accounts, then they're taxable, then their tax-deferred accounts, we're seeing that it's going to make them around$2.8 million worse off by their age 95.
SPEAKER_00We change that simply to a pro rata, an equal withdrawal from each of their tax-deferred, tax-free, and taxable accounts. We say that it changes drastically, where their scenario actually has$2.6 million more in tax-adjusted ending assets by their age 95. And these numbers are shown in future dollars. So yes, they're large, but it's undeniable how this makes a seven-figure swing between the different scenarios just by changing the withdrawal strategy alone. And the simple reason for this is the timing. Every dollar from your 401k gets taxed in the year it comes out, while your Roth gets to continue growing tax-free so long as you let the dollars continue and grow as a golden goose.
SPEAKER_00So the order decides how much shows up on your tax return each year and how long your tax-free money gets to grow. The right order is different for every household, and it will change again when things like Medicare and Social Security start. And you might recall the taxes will change one more number. Once you add them into the mix, Patricia and Kevin aren't really pulling just 5% of a withdrawal rate in those first nine years. They're actually pulling around$250,000 a year because their investments are also creating taxable income along the way, which brings us to that annual withdrawal rate of over 6%. Now, if you're wondering which withdrawal order fits your own accounts and how it changes once things like Medicare and Social Security start, that's worth a call with me to unpack your own situation.
SPEAKER_00The links below in the description to get started. And the hard thing about this 6% withdrawal rate is that it lands in exactly the years when a bad market does the most damage. Which brings us to the third line of fine print about the 4% rule, which decides whether this whole plan is going to hold. The research behind the 4% rule tested it against the worst 30-year stretch in market history. And that's why people trust it. But it also assumes something that most people skip right past, which is Bell Bengen, who came up with the rule, used a balanced mix of about 50% stocks and 50% bonds, rebalanced every year.
SPEAKER_00He also found that going too much above 75% stocks actually shortened how long one's money lasted. In other words, the rule survived the bad decades because the bonds were already there when those decades started. So let me walk you through why that matters using one of the toughest starts on record. Someone who had the poor fortune of retiring at the start of 2000 got hit with the dot-com crash, and then 2008, not too long thereafter. And by the halfway point, that retirement was tracking about as badly as retiring in 1929 or 1966.
SPEAKER_00I ran Patricia and Kevin's plan through the actual market returns from 2000 through 2025, and that carries them to age 84. And after that, I use the same long-run returns I'd normally assume. And so I have it shown here in two ways. They have the same savings, the same$200,000 a year of wanted income. And in this first version, they're set up. They have a balanced mix with years of withdrawals already sitting in bonds. In this second scenario, they stay invested the same way they were while they were growing and saving their assets with around 90% of their portfolio in stocks.
SPEAKER_00So let's first compare the two with the ending outcomes. The thousand simulated retirements actually like the more aggressive version better. It's scoring this 89% score of the Monte Carlo simulation against 85% for the balance plan, and it projects a lot more monies left over, about$7.6 million in today's dollars versus around$2 million in today's dollars. And if you stopped here, you'd go all in on the second scenario for the more aggressive and objectively potentially better outcome. Now let's unpack the impact of what happened when we back tested someone actually retiring with this scenario in the year 2000, starting with their$4 million saved.
SPEAKER_00After going through the dot-com bubble burst, fast-forwarding to their age 67, the more aggressive scenario, the one with the better Monte Carlo score, they're actually much worse off with around$800,000 in today's dollars at that age 67 and still trying to live off of$200,000 a year. And unfortunately, fast forwarding not too much longer, by their age 87, they've run out of assets entirely. Contrast that with the couple that has a more conservative asset allocation, the lower Monte Carlo score, the lower projected ending assets, and they fare much better.
SPEAKER_00They'd still get a hit by the dot-com bubble burst and then the double gut punch by 2008. But comparatively, they're at only$1.6 million rather than the$800,000, still withdrawing$200,000 a year. But rather than running out of assets by their age to 87, their assets are projected to last till age 94, right about where we wanted it to anyway, to have their last check bounced to the Undertaker at age 95. These scenarios are identical, other than their starting balance of their bond and stock mix. It's the same couple, their same spending, the same market impact, but wildly different outcomes for making sure that they don't go broke before they croak.
SPEAKER_00And to be honest with you, I feel the software is being far too generous to this aggressive couple. Because it's assuming they wash their$4 million nest egg that they've worked and saved a lifetime for turn into$800,000 and never flinch, meaning they never cut back on discretionary lifestyle spending and they never sold at the bottom of the market. In real life, that's the exact conditions that causes people to go back to work, cancel their trips, or just bail out in the market right before it recovers. I have solar panels in my house, and for an emergency backup, I've been pricing out a battery backup system.
SPEAKER_00Because when the grid goes down, most solar systems without a battery shut off as well. And yes, a generator could get you through, but the whole street is going to know about it. A battery backup will help you keep the lights on and the fridge going. And of course, nobody installs one of those during a power outage. I like to think that your growth money is the solar panels, and the battery backup is what is going to keep the paycheck coming, not if but when the grid eventually goes down. Now, as a disclaimer, right capital software is great, but it can't exactly simulate my exact bucket income methodology.
SPEAKER_00So the plan we're using uses a plain balanced mix, assuming it gets rebalanced every year. Rebalancing will put the mix back on the target, which usually means trimming whatever did well and adding to whatever lagged. That steady mix is what makes the biggest difference. Our buckets income methodology holds the same kind of investments, organized around when clients expect to need the money. So everyone knows exactly which money is going to pay the bills. Again, not if, but when the stocks are down. For our clients, I split the money into three buckets. The pantry is a cash reserve for emergencies.
SPEAKER_00The bond bunker is going to hold up to five years of withdrawal needs, taxes included, and assets that ideally don't care what stocks are going to be doing up or down. For Patricia and Kevin, in this scenario, that's about$1.2 million. And if you're asking why five years of time, because going back to the Great Recession, that's how long it took from the top to the bottom to it to recover all the way back up to where it was before again. This bond bunker allows us to have the confidence to know that everything else in the portfolio can then go inside of a client's growth engine. Because when stocks are down, we can lean on the bond bunker instead of selling stocks at low prices that they will never recover from.
SPEAKER_00But when the stocks we continue to hold do recover, we can rebuild the bunker through regular rebalancing. And then fast-forwarding once Social Security starts, the bond bunker needs get smaller because there's less of a burden on that withdrawal requirement. And I know what you're thinking now that what if five years isn't enough? Because if we go back to the year 2000, fast-forwarding to the end of 2009, the stock market actually even lost money, even with dividends reinvested. And that's why in the test we just watched, there's no guarantee the balanced plan is going to be able to make it all the way to a couple's end of life.
SPEAKER_00So you might ask, what if we're two or three years into a downturn like that, living off the bond bunker, and stocks still aren't showing signs of coming back? That's not the moment to follow the original rules on autopilot. We should have already been talking about what options we have, but at that time we're sitting down with our clients to talk about our backup solutions because we find that there are three levers that can make this bond bunker last longer. The first one sounds obvious, but it's worth saying out loud, trimming the spending that's optional. For Kevin and Patricia, that's mostly things like the travel and the other discretionary spending.
SPEAKER_00The second lever is pulling the ripcord on Social Security. Because instead of waiting to full retirement at age 67, one or both of them could start as early as age 62. And while yes, that check is now smaller for life, it starts paying bills sooner and takes the pressure off the portfolio, again, buying time for the stocks to recover. And the third lever is a last resort, which is a home equity line of credit, a HELOC. Most let you borrow for up to 10 years before you have to start paying it back, which can buy a lot of time for you to write out a downturn. I'd want a client to have that pre-approved before the last paycheck because it's a lot easier to get approved for it while you still have an ongoing income.
SPEAKER_00This brings to mind a couple who came to work with us who are in their mid-50s, thinking that they would need to react and adjust their lifestyle every time the market jumped or dropped. Kind of like the guardrails approach. But once we sized up a reserve of how much they actually anticipated to spend over the next few years, they stopped reacting to the headlines and started following the plan. What I don't do, and what I don't think people want to do in retirement, is cut their spending every time the market dips or jumps, a few percentage points, because I don't think anybody wants to have a plan that requires them to react to things that are outside of their control.
SPEAKER_00Now, these three levers are for a decade like the 2000s, which is a completely different animal. So can Patricia and Kevin retire at 58 and spend$200,000 a year? And yes, it can work, but not because the 5% withdrawal rate passed a test, but because the first nine years are set up before they take the first dollar. Otherwise, you're just kind of holding up your thumb and squinting at a withdrawal rate every year. Because in the good years, like the ones we've been having lately, you're likely to get away with it. But you don't have to remember everything here. Just remember this one thing.
SPEAKER_00Figure out where your next five years' withdrawals would come from if stocks fell by a third next year. It's hard to put it better than Warren Buffett, who said you only find out who's swimming naked when the tide goes out. And if you'd rather know how your retirement plan stands before the tide goes out, that's what a call with me is for. You can use the link in the description or scan the QR code on screen now. And if you're still working and wondering whether you can already stop adding to your savings, watch this video on screen next. It walks through how to find the exact moment you no longer need to save for retirement.
Work with Taylor: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/start-here?utm_source=Youtube&utm_medium=Videolink&utm_campaign=46327 See a $10,000 Sample Plan Here:...
Some financial advice gets repeated so often that people stop questioning whether it actually makes sense. But when it comes to retirement, could following conventional wisdom sometimes do more harm than good? In this...
Work with Taylor: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/start-here?utm_source=Youtube&utm_medium=Videolink&utm_campaign=46320 See a $10,000 Sample Plan Here:...
Some financial decisions look complicated and turn out to be pretty simple. Others look simple and are anything but. Today we're taking a list of common money moves and sorting them into two piles: harder than it looks,...
Work with Taylor: https://www.demarsfinancial.com/start-here?utm_source=Youtube&utm_medium=Videolink&utm_campaign=46313 See a $10,000 Sample Plan Here:...