Raj Singh JLL auphonic ===
[00:00:00] [00:00:01] Hi, I'm Edward [00:00:02] Cohen, and this is [00:00:03] Tangent, a [00:00:04] Commercial Observer [00:00:05] podcast, [00:00:06] [00:00:07] [00:00:08] [00:00:09] coming to you [00:00:10] live from CRE [00:00:11] Tech New York at [00:00:12] the Javits Center, [00:00:13] day one [00:00:14] of New York City Real [00:00:15] Estate Week. [00:00:16] [00:00:17] [00:00:18] Global real estate is [00:00:19] worth just under [00:00:20] $400 [00:00:21] trillion [00:00:22] according to [00:00:23] Savills [00:00:24] last year.
That's [00:00:25] more than global [00:00:26] equities, global debt, [00:00:27] all the gold [00:00:28] ever mined [00:00:29] combined. It [00:00:30] is the largest store of [00:00:31] wealth on Earth, [00:00:32] and it is one of the [00:00:33] last industries [00:00:34] on the verge of being [00:00:35] completely reshaped [00:00:36] by AI. [00:00:37] Our guest [00:00:38] today is Raj [00:00:39] Singh, managing [00:00:40] partner at [00:00:41] JLL Spark [00:00:42] Global Ventures, [00:00:43] a corporate venture [00:00:44] arm of JLL.[00:00:45]
Raj, [00:00:46] how is New York City Real [00:00:47] Estate Week treating [00:00:48] you? wonderful, [00:00:49] Edward. Thank you for having [00:00:50] me, and, uh, it's always [00:00:51] fun to be here in the Big [00:00:52] Apple. [00:00:53] Raj, you spent [00:00:54] five years at [00:00:55] JetBlue [00:00:56] Technology Ventures [00:00:57] before [00:00:58] joining JLL Spark [00:00:59] in 2021. [00:01:00] What made you [00:01:01] make the jump [00:01:02] from aviation [00:01:03] to real estate, and [00:01:04] what are the things that [00:01:05] surprised you when you [00:01:06] got here?
Uh, [00:01:07] that is a great [00:01:08] question. The [00:01:09] short answer [00:01:10] is COVID. [00:01:11] So [00:01:12] during COVID, [00:01:13] JetBlue, which is a [00:01:14] great company, [00:01:15] had very hard [00:01:16] times, like all [00:01:17] the other airlines, [00:01:18] so we couldn't really [00:01:19] afford to make [00:01:20] the investments in [00:01:21] startups that we'd like to. [00:01:22] But the [00:01:23] longer answer is [00:01:24] that even though [00:01:25] transportation [00:01:26] is critical [00:01:27] for a [00:01:28] country as big as the [00:01:29] United States, [00:01:30] aviation in particular, [00:01:31] they [00:01:32] don't make much [00:01:33] money.
And so [00:01:34] I was [00:01:35] wondering, all this [00:01:36] value is being created [00:01:37] by the [00:01:38] transportation [00:01:39] industry. Where's the [00:01:40] value being [00:01:41] [00:01:42] captured and [00:01:43] harvested? And one of the [00:01:44] places I thought that [00:01:45] that might be the case [00:01:46] is in real [00:01:47] estate. So [00:01:48] I started thinking [00:01:49] about, okay, [00:01:50] a good example [00:01:51] since we're in New York [00:01:52] is the Second [00:01:53] Avenue subway [00:01:54] extension.
The [00:01:55] apartments are [00:01:56] now worth much [00:01:57] more on that [00:01:58] line than they were before the [00:01:59] line was there. [00:02:00] Value has gone to the [00:02:01] real estate. [00:02:02] Same if you build [00:02:03] a [00:02:04] mall or a [00:02:05] office block [00:02:06] near somewhere that's [00:02:07] booming, you're gonna capture [00:02:08] the value of the fact [00:02:09] that things are [00:02:10] changing. And that got me [00:02:11] interested in [00:02:12] real estate.
And [00:02:13] then you asked [00:02:14] what's surprised [00:02:15] me. [00:02:16] So I thought that [00:02:17] transportation was [00:02:18] the [00:02:19] toughest industry to [00:02:20] put technology [00:02:21] into. [00:02:22] Boy, was I [00:02:23] wrong about that. Boy, [00:02:24] oh, no. Oh, [00:02:25] no. Real [00:02:26] estate, much harder [00:02:27] to get people to [00:02:28] actually [00:02:29] adopt the [00:02:30] technology, in part [00:02:31] because it's not [00:02:32] familiar for them, [00:02:33] uh, and also because [00:02:34] it's been a [00:02:35] hugely successful [00:02:36] industry.
As [00:02:37] you said, 400 [00:02:38] trillion. I've heard numbers [00:02:39] between [00:02:40] 250 and [00:02:41] 500 trillion. [00:02:42] Anyway, a very [00:02:43] big number. Several [00:02:44] trillion. Exactly. [00:02:45] And so they're [00:02:46] like, "Hey, I'm doing [00:02:47] great. Why would I need to [00:02:48] add this [00:02:49] technology?" But slowly [00:02:50] we see a number of [00:02:51] different forces [00:02:52] that are pushing our [00:02:53] industry to adopt [00:02:54] technology.
[00:02:55] One of them is [00:02:56] labor, [00:02:57] so it's much harder to [00:02:58] find labor to do [00:02:59] things that you want to do at [00:03:00] the price that makes [00:03:01] sense for you. I [00:03:02] think another is- [00:03:03] Just the fact that [00:03:04] the industry is [00:03:05] [00:03:06] institutionalizing. It's gone f- [00:03:07] going from [00:03:08] people who are [00:03:09] families that own a bit of real [00:03:10] estate to [00:03:11] huge [00:03:12] institutions that own [00:03:13] tens of [00:03:14] hundreds, maybe even [00:03:15] thousands of [00:03:16] buildings.
You can't do [00:03:17] this without the [00:03:18] technology to be able to manage [00:03:19] that. So I think [00:03:20] the big [00:03:21] trends are pushing us [00:03:22] towards more and more [00:03:23] tech, and we're gonna get [00:03:24] there [00:03:25] Such a unique lens, [00:03:26] I mean, having [00:03:27] had experience in, [00:03:28] in such [00:03:29] critical [00:03:30] infrastructure and, [00:03:31] and critical to our [00:03:32] society, like [00:03:33] transportation and real [00:03:34] estate.
Which [00:03:35] made me think, as you were [00:03:36] saying that, I'm [00:03:37] pretty sure it was [00:03:38] thanks to the [00:03:39] automobile that we [00:03:40] came up with [00:03:41] malls to have [00:03:42] somewhere for [00:03:43] people can- Yeah ... can [00:03:44] drive. Oh, you have [00:03:45] a car now. Okay, that's [00:03:46] great. Where are we [00:03:47] going? Let's [00:03:48] just build some [00:03:49] malls because that way people [00:03:50] can drive [00:03:51] somewhere, [00:03:52] and also create [00:03:53] commerce and bring [00:03:54] jobs.
But, like, these [00:03:55] two industries are [00:03:56] reshaping each other [00:03:57] throughout history. [00:03:58] That's a great [00:03:59] point. I think you're [00:04:00] absolutely right. There's some [00:04:01] really good [00:04:02] stories about [00:04:03] [00:04:04] skyscrapers. Skyscrapers [00:04:05] couldn't happen without [00:04:06] elevators [00:04:07] to make those [00:04:08] buildings work properly. [00:04:09] Right. But then the [00:04:10] skyscrapers started [00:04:11] drawing in [00:04:12] people from the [00:04:13] suburbs, so then you needed [00:04:14] parking in [00:04:15] order to be able to [00:04:16] change and accommodate [00:04:17] those people.
[00:04:18] And you're right, so [00:04:19] these things interplay [00:04:20] with each other. [00:04:21] I think the broader [00:04:22] lens is [00:04:23] where are [00:04:24] we as [00:04:25] humanity going? And [00:04:26] one of the answers [00:04:27] to that is [00:04:28] urbanization. [00:04:29] So more and [00:04:30] more people live in cities. [00:04:31] I think we now [00:04:32] passed the point where [00:04:33] more than [00:04:34] 50% of the world's [00:04:35] population lives in cities, [00:04:36] and some [00:04:37] people may say that's a bad [00:04:38] thing, but for [00:04:39] me, the [00:04:40] city is the [00:04:41] ultimate [00:04:42] innovation [00:04:43] engine, [00:04:44] the thing that [00:04:45] humanity has [00:04:46] created.
Because when you [00:04:47] have the city, you have [00:04:48] all these different [00:04:49] people rubbing together [00:04:50] with new [00:04:51] ideas and different [00:04:52] ideas and one industry [00:04:53] crossing another industry. [00:04:54] This is where we [00:04:55] move humanity [00:04:56] forward. [00:04:57] Much as I love the [00:04:58] countryside, just living in [00:04:59] a small little house in the [00:05:00] countryside, [00:05:01] not so much innovation [00:05:02] is happening there, but the [00:05:03] cities, yes.[00:05:04]
So it's [00:05:05] incumbent on [00:05:06] us in the real estate [00:05:07] industry to [00:05:08] find the technology [00:05:09] to be able to [00:05:10] deliver the [00:05:11] cities that we need to live [00:05:12] in, but also to [00:05:13] innovate and [00:05:14] improve. I [00:05:15] absolutely love that. [00:05:16] Without a doubt, cities [00:05:17] have to be at the top [00:05:18] of human [00:05:19] inventions- Yeah ... right up [00:05:20] there with, uh, [00:05:21] language, [00:05:22] air conditioning, if [00:05:23] you ask me-
[00:05:24] and, uh, Lee- [00:05:25] Lee Kuan Yew in [00:05:26] Singapore as well. [00:05:27] I know we're not here to talk [00:05:28] about aviation, but I, [00:05:29] I have to ask you [00:05:30] just one more question 'cause [00:05:31] I- Sure ... such a [00:05:32] big fan of this [00:05:33] industry. I admire it so [00:05:34] much. I mean, [00:05:35] and, and they figured out some [00:05:36] stuff that, that real [00:05:37] estate still needs to [00:05:38] figure out, or we're [00:05:39] working on it.
I mean, [00:05:40] aviation not [00:05:41] only has reached a, [00:05:42] a near [00:05:43] zero [00:05:44] fatalities, you know, by [00:05:45] making every in- [00:05:46] incident that [00:05:47] happens shared, [00:05:48] an, a, an [00:05:49] industry lesson that people- Mm-hmm ... [00:05:50] can, can learn from [00:05:51] from a safety [00:05:52] standpoint. It's like [00:05:53] you can go to any [00:05:54] country in the world and, like, [00:05:55] y- you [00:05:56] know that the, [00:05:57] the aviation [00:05:58] industry [00:05:59] will be a level [00:06:00] up of whatever other [00:06:01] industry on average [00:06:02] they have there.
[00:06:03] And they've also [00:06:04] figured out [00:06:05] loyalty, like airline [00:06:06] loyalty points is [00:06:07] something that is more [00:06:08] valuable than the, you know, [00:06:09] ish. Eh, [00:06:10] you're shaking your head. I [00:06:11] think- I mean, to [00:06:12] your first point [00:06:13] on safety, yes, the [00:06:14] aviation industry [00:06:15] has done an incredibly [00:06:16] good job [00:06:17] at, uh, [00:06:18] reducing the number of deaths, [00:06:19] and a lot of it [00:06:20] is to do with [00:06:21] checklists and [00:06:22] training, and that's [00:06:23] definitely something that we could [00:06:24] learn from in, in the [00:06:25] real estate industry as [00:06:26] well.
On your other [00:06:27] point about loyalty, I [00:06:28] think the [00:06:29] [00:06:30] airlines have [00:06:31] created Frankenstein's [00:06:32] monster, [00:06:33] and for a while it kinda [00:06:34] did what they [00:06:35] wanted, but now it's a little [00:06:36] bit changing. [00:06:37] Uh, one of the things I used to [00:06:38] say when I was in the [00:06:39] industry is that the [00:06:40] number one, uh, [00:06:41] most profitable [00:06:42] thing that an airline [00:06:43] sells you [00:06:44] is?
[00:06:45] A hotel room [00:06:46] booking. [00:06:47] So [00:06:48] it's a very tough [00:06:49] industry. When I was [00:06:50] there, [00:06:51] the average amount [00:06:52] of profit you would [00:06:53] make from a [00:06:54] airplane, [00:06:55] full [00:06:56] airplane going from [00:06:57] New York to San [00:06:58] Francisco was about [00:06:59] $8 per [00:07:00] passenger. Wow. [00:07:01] Not [00:07:02] exactly- [00:07:03] Crazy. Yeah, not [00:07:04] exactly what you're looking [00:07:05] for. So the [00:07:06] economics keep on [00:07:07] changing.
It's [00:07:08] obviously a very [00:07:09] difficult industry [00:07:10] to remediate when it [00:07:11] comes to [00:07:12] sustainability, [00:07:13] very high carbon [00:07:14] emissions. [00:07:15] And so I think they've done [00:07:16] a lot of things very [00:07:17] well, but they [00:07:18] don't still [00:07:19] really make as much money as [00:07:20] they ought to. [00:07:21] Fascinating. [00:07:22] So [00:07:23] JLL Spark, I mean, [00:07:24] you've invested in [00:07:25] some of the most [00:07:26] successful [00:07:27] companies in the space, [00:07:28] including [00:07:29] the likes of [00:07:30] Elise AI, [00:07:31] DealPath.
I- [00:07:32] in terms of [00:07:33] the [00:07:34] approach that you're taking now [00:07:35] and [00:07:36] what companies are [00:07:37] deemed [00:07:38] venture [00:07:39] backable, and you're not [00:07:40] just a venture capital, you're [00:07:41] a venture capital [00:07:42] within [00:07:43] JLL- Right ... [00:07:44] one of the largest [00:07:45] leaders in [00:07:46] commercial real estate. So [00:07:47] how do you [00:07:48] prioritize in terms [00:07:49] of what [00:07:50] areas to focus [00:07:51] on to invest in, [00:07:52] in terms of your [00:07:53] mandate?
Does this have [00:07:54] to stand on [00:07:55] its own as a [00:07:56] company and investment, [00:07:57] or is it a [00:07:58] requirement that it [00:07:59] plays [00:08:00] into the value [00:08:01] propositions of [00:08:02] JLL's [00:08:03] various services? [00:08:04] How do you think about [00:08:05] that? [00:08:06] Yeah. I think it's [00:08:07] a complicated [00:08:08] discussion. [00:08:09] We have it every day [00:08:10] internally, [00:08:11] but honestly, the [00:08:12] answer is both. [00:08:13] It has to be able to stand [00:08:14] alone as a [00:08:15] company, but it [00:08:16] also has to play into the [00:08:17] value prop of, [00:08:18] of JLL.
The [00:08:19] way that we do it [00:08:20] is that [00:08:21] JLL has its own [00:08:22] strategy, how are we trying to [00:08:23] move business forward. [00:08:24] Each [00:08:25] business line has their own [00:08:26] strategy within that. [00:08:27] And so what we're [00:08:28] looking to do is [00:08:29] say, "Where [00:08:30] can we find [00:08:31] technology that will [00:08:32] augment [00:08:33] the strategy that [00:08:34] JLL already [00:08:35] has, or [00:08:36] will [00:08:37] challenge the strategy [00:08:38] that JLL has?"[00:08:39]
So we're [00:08:40] investing in companies that [00:08:41] are in commercial real [00:08:42] estate because that's what [00:08:43] JLL does. [00:08:44] We are [00:08:45] looking to [00:08:46] support our [00:08:47] leasing advisory [00:08:48] group, our capital [00:08:49] markets group, [00:08:50] our facilities [00:08:51] management group, [00:08:52] property asset management group, [00:08:53] et cetera. And [00:08:54] so we [00:08:55] talk to them on a regular [00:08:56] basis. What's your [00:08:57] strategy?
Has it [00:08:58] changed? Which [00:08:59] areas can [00:09:00] technology help you with? [00:09:01] And JLL's [00:09:02] unique because we [00:09:03] have [00:09:04] a technology team [00:09:05] inside, [00:09:06] so then we [00:09:07] understand, are they [00:09:08] delivering something for you, [00:09:09] or do we need to deliver [00:09:10] something for you? So [00:09:11] the areas where we can [00:09:12] play are, [00:09:13] it's strategic, it's [00:09:14] important, [00:09:15] we don't have a solution [00:09:16] ourselves, let's [00:09:17] go find a [00:09:18] solution.
And then we're [00:09:19] looking for companies that are [00:09:20] gonna be [00:09:21] extremely [00:09:22] profitable on their [00:09:23] own because [00:09:24] if they're [00:09:25] not, then they [00:09:26] won't be around [00:09:27] long to be [00:09:28] strategic for us. So [00:09:29] it has to be a [00:09:30] combination of very [00:09:31] strategic, but [00:09:32] also a really great [00:09:33] idea. [00:09:34] Yeah, I mean, in, in [00:09:35] JLL, even with [00:09:36] it being a, an [00:09:37] incumbent, with it [00:09:38] being a [00:09:39] massive [00:09:40] worldwide [00:09:41] company, you've [00:09:42] still a [00:09:43] forward-thinking company, [00:09:44] very at the [00:09:45] forefront of [00:09:46] technology.
And from the [00:09:47] outside it seems like you've [00:09:48] taken three different [00:09:49] approaches when it comes to [00:09:50] technology. You [00:09:51] build stuff internally. [00:09:52] You also [00:09:53] have acquired [00:09:54] companies. You also hire [00:09:55] services, but you also have [00:09:56] JLL Spark. So [00:09:57] in terms of [00:09:58] deciding what [00:09:59] path [00:10:00] JLL [00:10:01] takes, how do you [00:10:02] support that path [00:10:03] in terms of, [00:10:04] "Oh, actually, [00:10:05] you should buy that [00:10:06] company 'cause we're [00:10:07] clients of them, and we [00:10:08] should have it in-house," [00:10:09] or, [00:10:10] "Actually, yeah, we should [00:10:11] build it now that we [00:10:12] have more [00:10:13] cost-effective tools to [00:10:14] build in-house."
[00:10:15] How do you navigate [00:10:16] that? Is that something that you [00:10:17] take part in? [00:10:18] Yeah, we take [00:10:19] part in that, and [00:10:20] honestly, that's a very [00:10:21] insightful question. [00:10:22] I would say that [00:10:23] there is no [00:10:24] right answer [00:10:25] to that, but there [00:10:26] are shades. [00:10:27] Okay? [00:10:28] So at one [00:10:29] end of, of [00:10:30] certainty is [00:10:31] where we already have a [00:10:32] set of software [00:10:33] products that [00:10:34] we either [00:10:35] created or bought over [00:10:36] time.
Those [00:10:37] are the ones we're gonna [00:10:38] continue investing in, con- [00:10:39] continue to [00:10:40] develop those, [00:10:41] and so that is [00:10:42] very much not a [00:10:43] Spark [00:10:44] perspective. On the [00:10:45] other end of the [00:10:46] spectrum, there [00:10:47] are companies doing [00:10:48] things that are [00:10:49] unique that we are [00:10:50] not doing, that [00:10:51] have a capability [00:10:52] that it would take us [00:10:53] a lot of money and [00:10:54] time to be able to put [00:10:55] together.
That's [00:10:56] Spark. And then [00:10:57] in the middle, there's a [00:10:58] discussion, [00:10:59] okay? "Oh, [00:11:00] this is a really [00:11:01] interesting startup, [00:11:02] but maybe we [00:11:03] could actually build this." [00:11:04] Okay, [00:11:05] interesting. How long would it [00:11:06] take you to build it? How much [00:11:07] money would it take you to [00:11:08] build it? [00:11:09] And the reality of [00:11:10] venture capital is that [00:11:11] it's a [00:11:12] trade-off for us [00:11:13] between money [00:11:14] and control.[00:11:15]
So if [00:11:16] we built something [00:11:17] ourself inside [00:11:18] JLL, we control it [00:11:19] 100%, [00:11:20] okay? But [00:11:21] we have to spend all [00:11:22] the money required [00:11:23] to make that work. [00:11:24] Mm-hmm. And [00:11:25] sometimes those R&D [00:11:26] projects don't work, [00:11:27] so you've now spent a lot of [00:11:28] money, you didn't get [00:11:29] anything for it. [00:11:30] What VC [00:11:31] is like, well, okay, [00:11:32] I'm gonna only [00:11:33] own 10% of the [00:11:34] company, let's say.[00:11:35]
Um, so I [00:11:36] don't have control of that [00:11:37] company, but [00:11:38] the amount of money [00:11:39] that I put in is [00:11:40] also [00:11:41] 10% of the money I [00:11:42] would put in for [00:11:43] R&D. So I've [00:11:44] traded off [00:11:45] control for money, and [00:11:46] the good thing about [00:11:47] having our [00:11:48] combination at [00:11:49] JLL is that we [00:11:50] can decide, do we [00:11:51] wanna control and [00:11:52] own? Do we [00:11:53] wanna be a [00:11:54] partner, only put [00:11:55] in a small amount of money, [00:11:56] but still benefit [00:11:57] from the relationship?[00:11:58]
So depending [00:11:59] on the [00:12:00] circumstance, we'll do one or [00:12:01] the other. [00:12:02] And the good thing [00:12:03] about VC is [00:12:04] that if I have a [00:12:05] dollar, I can put [00:12:06] 10 cents into [00:12:07] 10 different [00:12:08] companies as opposed to the [00:12:09] whole dollar into one [00:12:10] project. And so that [00:12:11] gives me optionality [00:12:12] as well, and that's really [00:12:13] where it works. [00:12:14] [00:12:15] Optionality and, uh, [00:12:16] flexibility ultimately [00:12:17] nowadays for [00:12:18] incumbents [00:12:19] is, is a [00:12:20] true competitive [00:12:21] advantage.
I agree [00:12:22] 100%. [00:12:23] I gotta ask [00:12:24] you, and it's okay if [00:12:25] you don't have an answer, [00:12:26] but, I mean, there was a, [00:12:27] a famous [00:12:28] day in the real estate [00:12:29] calendar this year [00:12:30] for those of us that follow [00:12:31] this very closely. [00:12:32] But [00:12:33] February 11th, [00:12:34] 2026, [00:12:35] when... And [00:12:36] probably every [00:12:37] industry has now gone [00:12:38] through this, where there was an [00:12:39] AI [00:12:40] scare trade [00:12:41] for real estate, [00:12:42] right?
I don't [00:12:43] know if it was [00:12:44] OpenAI or Anthropic [00:12:45] released something that [00:12:46] was for, [00:12:47] allegedly for real [00:12:48] estate. And [00:12:49] all the major [00:12:50] commercial real estate [00:12:51] publicly traded [00:12:52] companies [00:12:53] dropped significantly. [00:12:54] They probably- Yeah ... recovered [00:12:55] within a few days or anything. [00:12:56] What was [00:12:57] it like [00:12:58] inside? Was this [00:12:59] like a code [00:13:00] red moment [00:13:01] where, like, all, all hands [00:13:02] on deck?
[00:13:03] You probably already have [00:13:04] seen this coming, but, like, [00:13:05] just curious what was [00:13:06] going on through that day, [00:13:07] given it was such a [00:13:08] momentous day [00:13:09] where the attention [00:13:10] was on, at the [00:13:11] intersection of real estate and [00:13:12] AI. [00:13:13] I think from my [00:13:14] personal [00:13:15] perspective, I was [00:13:16] kind of a little [00:13:17] shocked. First of [00:13:18] all, I was shocked [00:13:19] that it [00:13:20] took the analysts [00:13:21] so long to [00:13:22] figure out that AI [00:13:23] might be a [00:13:24] problem here, or a [00:13:25] solution.
But [00:13:26] it might have an [00:13:27] impact on our businesses. I'm [00:13:28] like, "Oh, wow. Only [00:13:29] now?" Like- What took you [00:13:30] so long? Yeah, what took you so [00:13:31] long? So that [00:13:32] was the first thing. [00:13:33] And yeah, JLL's [00:13:34] stock, like everybody [00:13:35] else's, went down a [00:13:36] lot. But as [00:13:37] you pointed out, [00:13:38] actually it didn't take [00:13:39] a few days, took a few [00:13:40] months, but it, [00:13:41] they crept back up.[00:13:42]
And JLL's [00:13:43] stock hit a [00:13:44] high, all-time high this [00:13:45] year. It's off [00:13:46] that high now, but [00:13:47] it goes up and [00:13:48] down. And I would say [00:13:49] this, a lot of [00:13:50] the real estate [00:13:51] executives that I talk [00:13:52] to have [00:13:53] a little bit [00:13:54] of worry about [00:13:55] technology in [00:13:56] general. Because in part [00:13:57] it's not where they grew up. [00:13:58] They don't necessarily [00:13:59] understand it, so it's not [00:14:00] clear to them how do they [00:14:01] take advantage of it.[00:14:02]
Now, [00:14:03] those people who have been [00:14:04] relatively sort of, you [00:14:05] know, "I don't wanna dabble in [00:14:06] the technology," [00:14:07] those are the same [00:14:08] people now who are vibe [00:14:09] coding solutions. [00:14:10] [00:14:11] And so we've [00:14:12] gone from like, "Oh, [00:14:13] I'm not sure about [00:14:14] technology" to, "I can [00:14:15] build everything in [00:14:16] Claude." And [00:14:17] so I think [00:14:18] the analysts [00:14:19] overreacted. [00:14:20] I think the [00:14:21] industry is kind [00:14:22] of [00:14:23] overcompensating, and [00:14:24] we will find a [00:14:25] balance.
But [00:14:26] these things do take [00:14:27] time. And [00:14:28] look, I'm not saying you [00:14:29] can't make a lot of [00:14:30] money in the [00:14:31] meanwhile betting on where the [00:14:32] balance might [00:14:33] go, but what I [00:14:34] am saying is that [00:14:35] ultimately I [00:14:36] think that our [00:14:37] industry is [00:14:38] really [00:14:39] well-suited to AI. We [00:14:40] have so many [00:14:41] documents, so much [00:14:42] information, so much [00:14:43] data. It's [00:14:44] really a [00:14:45] great example [00:14:46] of how you could build a [00:14:47] super AI system.[00:14:48]
But [00:14:49] not everything needs to [00:14:50] be AI. [00:14:51] Not every person [00:14:52] should be replaced. [00:14:53] We need to [00:14:54] find the right [00:14:55] solution whereby [00:14:56] we can [00:14:57] empower people [00:14:58] with the [00:14:59] AI doing the [00:15:00] basic work, and [00:15:01] those people are doing [00:15:02] the, the work that [00:15:03] requires an [00:15:04] understanding and the [00:15:05] knowledge of our industry, [00:15:06] because every industry is [00:15:07] different.
So it [00:15:08] was a funny time. [00:15:09] I think we're out of [00:15:10] that now, but yeah, [00:15:11] still we kind of [00:15:12] have some corrections to [00:15:13] come. [00:15:14] Fascinating. And it's a [00:15:15] human trait of that [00:15:16] pendulum swinging [00:15:17] to one extreme- Right ... to the [00:15:18] other. [00:15:19] While that, yeah, it ... [00:15:20] And, and I do have my [00:15:21] theories about [00:15:22] why real [00:15:23] estate and, and [00:15:24] technology sometimes[00:15:25]
I think it has to a lot, [00:15:26] a lot with the [00:15:27] language that we [00:15:28] use. I think [00:15:29] disruption, [00:15:30] which is something we [00:15:31] celebrate in the tech world, [00:15:32] is not something that is [00:15:33] celebrated in real estate [00:15:34] for good measure, [00:15:35] right? Right. Why would you [00:15:36] disrupt a building [00:15:37] with 300 people living [00:15:38] in there or a [00:15:39] 5,000-people office [00:15:40] building?
Like, no one [00:15:41] wants to disrupt [00:15:42] it. But talking [00:15:43] about finding the right [00:15:44] solutions and the right [00:15:45] teams, you speak to a [00:15:46] lot of founders, you [00:15:47] see a lot of im- [00:15:48] solutions out there. [00:15:49] What are some of [00:15:50] the traits or [00:15:51] signals that you [00:15:52] look out for [00:15:53] that some of the most [00:15:54] successful companies [00:15:55] have had? Either [00:15:56] the ones that you've backed or the [00:15:57] ones out there in the [00:15:58] market.
And what does it [00:15:59] take for a founder [00:16:00] and a team to [00:16:01] win, uh, when it [00:16:02] comes to real estate technology [00:16:03] today? [00:16:04] So I think the [00:16:05] first thing that we're [00:16:06] looking for [00:16:07] is [00:16:08] does the [00:16:09] team have a [00:16:10] really strong [00:16:11] vision that [00:16:12] is built on [00:16:13] reality? [00:16:14] So we see [00:16:15] a lot of teams [00:16:16] that come, [00:16:17] they've had an issue in [00:16:18] their lives [00:16:19] around real estate.[00:16:20]
Maybe it's like the [00:16:21] office is a [00:16:22] problem, or [00:16:23] getting to and from the [00:16:24] office, or [00:16:25] distribution [00:16:26] centers don't work the way they [00:16:27] should, and [00:16:28] they try and solve that. [00:16:29] And look, that's [00:16:30] great, but [00:16:31] you need to [00:16:32] know what people did [00:16:33] before, not [00:16:34] make the same mistakes. [00:16:35] So having a [00:16:36] background and [00:16:37] understanding the industry is [00:16:38] really powerful.[00:16:39]
Having a team [00:16:40] that combines [00:16:41] understanding real [00:16:42] estate with understanding [00:16:43] technology, [00:16:44] that's the next thing that we're [00:16:45] looking for. You need to have [00:16:46] a well-rounded [00:16:47] team. If you don't [00:16:48] know all those different [00:16:49] areas, it's not [00:16:50] gonna work as well as it [00:16:51] might. And [00:16:52] then thirdly, you [00:16:53] need to be... [00:16:54] and this is quite [00:16:55] unusual, you need to be [00:16:56] insanely [00:16:57] focused on your [00:16:58] solution, but [00:16:59] also open to [00:17:00] hearing advice.[00:17:01]
So you get [00:17:02] some founders [00:17:03] are very [00:17:04] focused, and then when [00:17:05] the world changes, they [00:17:06] don't see it. They just [00:17:07] focus on the same [00:17:08] solution. Other [00:17:09] people [00:17:10] manage to [00:17:11] hold that focus, but at the [00:17:12] same time [00:17:13] can hear [00:17:14] from the outside the [00:17:15] signal that things are [00:17:16] changing, and [00:17:17] adapt accordingly. [00:17:18] So you need both [00:17:19] focus and [00:17:20] flexibility.
[00:17:21] You need to be [00:17:22] experienced both in [00:17:23] real estate and in [00:17:24] technology, [00:17:25] and those are the [00:17:26] basics that gotta [00:17:27] be there for this to [00:17:28] work. There's [00:17:29] one other [00:17:30] factor which is gonna make [00:17:31] you laugh maybe, [00:17:32] that is really [00:17:33] important when we're thinking [00:17:34] about who we're gonna [00:17:35] invest with. [00:17:36] Do we get on with [00:17:37] them? [00:17:38] You want [00:17:39] somebody to be in your [00:17:40] corner when things are [00:17:41] bad.
You want [00:17:42] somebody who's gonna [00:17:43] understand, and [00:17:44] they want the same. [00:17:45] And so [00:17:46] sometimes you find [00:17:47] founders who are [00:17:48] just not the [00:17:49] right group of [00:17:50] people for you to work [00:17:51] with. And [00:17:52] fine for them, then [00:17:53] maybe they'll find their [00:17:54] people. But that's [00:17:55] really important for us, [00:17:56] is that there are people that [00:17:57] we can sit down [00:17:58] with and work with [00:17:59] and, and [00:18:00] understand each other.
Because [00:18:01] otherwise, when people [00:18:02] don't understand or [00:18:03] like each other, it's just [00:18:04] really hard to, [00:18:05] to stick together when [00:18:06] times are tough. [00:18:07] It gets down to the [00:18:08] human element at [00:18:09] the end of the day. [00:18:10] Every time. Every time. Whe- whether the [00:18:11] human has [00:18:12] the subject [00:18:13] matter [00:18:14] expertise and [00:18:15] covers the industries [00:18:16] that they're- or the, [00:18:17] the sectors within [00:18:18] real estate that they'll be [00:18:19] tackling.
And [00:18:20] what you said, it's such [00:18:21] a, such a [00:18:22] skill because [00:18:23] holding, [00:18:24] holding seemingly [00:18:25] opposing thoughts at the [00:18:26] same time, like having [00:18:27] that vision, like you said, [00:18:28] a clear vision, [00:18:29] but you [00:18:30] also need to take in new [00:18:31] information. [00:18:32] Is that gonna now [00:18:33] make your vision [00:18:34] a little shaky, [00:18:35] or you just adapt it [00:18:36] and have even more [00:18:37] conviction- Right
with the new [00:18:38] information? [00:18:39] Yeah, and getting [00:18:40] along, I mean, that's ... It's a [00:18:41] marriage. [00:18:42] I, [00:18:43] uh, yeah. I'm not sure [00:18:44] my wife would agree with [00:18:45] that. But, uh, it's [00:18:46] certainly a [00:18:47] relationship, [00:18:48] and the best [00:18:49] relationships are very [00:18:50] strong, and that's why [00:18:51] you often see [00:18:52] investors and [00:18:53] founders working [00:18:54] together over multiple [00:18:55] companies, [00:18:56] because they've built that strong [00:18:57] relationship.
[00:18:58] Fascinating. [00:18:59] Let's move on to one of [00:19:00] your portfolio [00:19:01] companies that's been on the [00:19:02] headlines, Elise AI. [00:19:03] I mean, we've had [00:19:04] the likes of [00:19:05] JP Morgan, [00:19:06] Delta, [00:19:07] Amazon, Block- [00:19:08] Mm-hmm ... AI agents from their [00:19:09] platforms just in the [00:19:10] past week. [00:19:11] RealPage just did [00:19:12] the same with Elise [00:19:13] AI and Multifamily [00:19:14] for their latest [00:19:15] AI called [00:19:16] Apollo.
You know, you're [00:19:17] a platform, so you're a [00:19:18] major client of the [00:19:19] companies that you back in [00:19:20] some cases, but you [00:19:21] also back them. [00:19:22] So how do you [00:19:23] think about that [00:19:24] tension right now, and [00:19:25] how do you think, [00:19:26] more importantly, [00:19:27] about how [00:19:28] this doesn't ultimately [00:19:29] affect the clients and the [00:19:30] users of these [00:19:31] solutions? [00:19:32] Yeah, I [00:19:33] think, look, it's always [00:19:34] difficult, right?
And, uh, and we [00:19:35] should all be thinking about the [00:19:36] clients and [00:19:37] making sure that we can [00:19:38] provide them with our [00:19:39] uninterrupted good [00:19:40] service. But [00:19:41] look, every one of these [00:19:42] deals is a [00:19:43] commercial proposition, [00:19:44] right? Everybody wants to be [00:19:45] able to win, [00:19:46] and I've no doubt [00:19:47] that there will be a [00:19:48] solution or [00:19:49] multiple solutions [00:19:50] that will allow [00:19:51] this to go forward.
And [00:19:52] I don't think it's [00:19:53] unexpected. If I look at the [00:19:54] industry, and you made the [00:19:55] point earlier about, [00:19:56] like, AI and what the [00:19:57] signal is in [00:19:58] AI, you know, [00:19:59] we don't [00:20:00] entirely know [00:20:01] yet. I think what we [00:20:02] do know is [00:20:03] that we have an [00:20:04] opportunity to radically [00:20:05] improve the [00:20:06] service we provide to [00:20:07] our clients [00:20:08] at a cost that [00:20:09] would be much more [00:20:10] effective than doing it with [00:20:11] people.
And [00:20:12] so I think it's [00:20:13] in everybody's [00:20:14] interest to find a solution, [00:20:15] and I've no doubt that we [00:20:16] will. [00:20:17] 100%. It's, it's still early [00:20:18] days, and what I [00:20:19] keep thinking about is, I [00:20:20] mean, many of [00:20:21] these companies already [00:20:22] had [00:20:23] armies [00:20:24] of [00:20:25] overseas [00:20:26] workers helping them sort- Yeah ... [00:20:27] through data, right? [00:20:28] Now that an AI [00:20:29] agent is doing it, [00:20:30] we're like, [00:20:31] "Okay, hold on," 'cause [00:20:32] it is different.
Uh, [00:20:33] but yeah, just [00:20:34] funny how the [00:20:35] switch [00:20:36] flipped overnight [00:20:37] immediately from [00:20:38] how we can use this data [00:20:39] and, like, [00:20:40] we weren't even thinking [00:20:41] about it much before. [00:20:42] Yeah. And I think you [00:20:43] make a great point about the [00:20:44] overseas agents [00:20:45] as well. I think [00:20:46] that [00:20:47] outsourcing now [00:20:48] looks like it [00:20:49] was the [00:20:50] dry run for [00:20:51] AI, [00:20:52] right?
So [00:20:53] essentially, if we were able to [00:20:54] build [00:20:55] processes and [00:20:56] exchange data in a way that [00:20:57] will allow a third [00:20:58] party to do that, [00:20:59] we can [00:21:00] probably now take [00:21:01] that work [00:21:02] and get AI to [00:21:03] do it as well. So [00:21:04] it's a big s- [00:21:05] context switch, [00:21:06] and it's not gonna [00:21:07] go t- entirely [00:21:08] smoothly. There will be [00:21:09] issues, and I'm [00:21:10] sure we haven't seen them all.
[00:21:11] But we will also, I [00:21:12] think, [00:21:13] look back in a few [00:21:14] years and say, "Wow, you [00:21:15] know, incredible [00:21:16] that we did all this stuff [00:21:17] by hand [00:21:18] before. You know, it's [00:21:19] just so obvious that we should [00:21:20] be having the machine do [00:21:21] it." Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. [00:21:22] Quick [00:21:23] round. What's [00:21:24] over-hyped [00:21:25] and what is [00:21:26] underrated with [00:21:27] AI in real estate [00:21:28] right now? [00:21:29] I think [00:21:30] agents are [00:21:31] overhyped.
[00:21:32] So a lot of people [00:21:33] tell me that they built an [00:21:34] agent, and I'm like, [00:21:35] "Eh, I'm not sure that's an [00:21:36] agent, actually." [00:21:37] But I think that whole [00:21:38] concept is like everybody's, [00:21:39] like, got an agentic [00:21:40] workflow, [00:21:41] and, um, you know, I don't [00:21:42] think we're quite there yet. Bit [00:21:43] overhyped, [00:21:44] honestly. Yeah. [00:21:45] I think what's [00:21:46] underhyped is [00:21:47] the ability [00:21:48] for AI [00:21:49] to [00:21:50] ingest all the [00:21:51] information that we have without [00:21:52] us having to [00:21:53] pre-format it and [00:21:54] pre-tabulate it, [00:21:55] and then still [00:21:56] deliver value.[00:21:57]
The thing [00:21:58] which disturbs [00:21:59] me about [00:22:00] generative AI is [00:22:01] this hallucination [00:22:02] concept. [00:22:03] So in [00:22:04] another industry, that would just [00:22:05] be called being [00:22:06] wrong, but we say it's [00:22:07] hallucinations. [00:22:08] So that is [00:22:09] something that we need to work [00:22:10] out, and in [00:22:11] particular, in our [00:22:12] industry, what we [00:22:13] are still missing [00:22:14] mostly is [00:22:15] auditability.
[00:22:16] I need to be able to [00:22:17] understand why that [00:22:18] decision was made, [00:22:19] and that is not [00:22:20] just me that needs to do [00:22:21] that. The government [00:22:22] wants to do that. The [00:22:23] tax service wants to do [00:22:24] that as well, and so [00:22:25] we need to be [00:22:26] moving more quickly [00:22:27] towards an answer there. [00:22:28] 100%. Y- [00:22:29] you don't make the rules there. [00:22:30] No. [00:22:31] Where [00:22:32] can Tangent [00:22:33] listeners and [00:22:34] PropTech founders [00:22:35] learn more [00:22:36] about JLL Spark [00:22:37] and connect with you?[00:22:38]
Oh, [00:22:39] well, um, we're pretty [00:22:40] active on LinkedIn. [00:22:41] We have a new [00:22:42] Substack that's out [00:22:43] there, JLL Spark. [00:22:44] Please check that out. [00:22:45] And the [00:22:46] other thing that I think I would [00:22:47] encourage people to [00:22:48] look at is [00:22:49] JLL produces a [00:22:50] lot of research. [00:22:51] We just had a really [00:22:52] interesting piece come out about [00:22:53] data centers, [00:22:54] so I would encourage [00:22:55] people, sign up for that.
[00:22:56] It's really [00:22:57] very good data. [00:22:58] And you can find a [00:22:59] link of that in the [00:23:00] episode show [00:23:01] notes. [00:23:02] Raj [00:23:03] Singh, [00:23:04] managing director [00:23:05] at JLL [00:23:06] Spark, [00:23:07] thank you so much for [00:23:08] coming to Tangent today. [00:23:09] Great pleasure. Thank [00:23:10] you for having me. [00:23:11] [00:23:12] [00:23:13] [00:23:14] [00:23:15] Muchas [00:23:16] gracias. If you learn [00:23:17] something new or [00:23:18] enjoy the [00:23:19] conversation. Text a [00:23:20] friend the link to this [00:23:21] episode right now.
Edward: [00:23:22] [00:23:23] You can [00:23:24] find links, [00:23:25] resources, and ways to [00:23:26] connect with us in the show [00:23:27] notes [00:23:28] [00:23:29] [00:23:30] [00:23:31] [00:23:32]