Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Tudors

Talking Tudors artwork

Episode 360 - The Horenbouts & Anne Boleyn: New Evidence Examined with Natalie Grueninger & Dr Owen Emmerson

Sep 16, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Host Natalie Grueninger and guest Dr Owen Emmerson examine a tiny Tudor portrait miniature held at the Royal Ontario Museum, exploring its possible attribution to Lucas Horenbout and the tantalizing theory that it may be the earliest depiction of Anne Boleyn. They discuss dating, costume and jewel details, related inventories and court accounts from 1527-28, comparisons with a twin miniature at and why ongoing technical research may help confirm or refute the sitter’s identity. JOIN 365 DAYS IN ELIZABETHAN ENGLAND https://www.nataliegrueninger.com/2026/05/17/365-days-in-elizabethan-england/ Learn more about Dr Owen Emmerson: https://drowenemmerson.com/ Learn more about your Natalie Grueninger: https://www.nataliegrueninger.com Support Talking Tudors on Patreon!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome to Talking Tudors, a podcast about the ever-fascinating Tudor dynasty. My name is Natalie Gruniger and I'll be your host and guide on this journey through 16th century England. Are you ready to step through the veil of time into the dazzling and dangerous world of the Tudor court? Without further ado, it's time to talk Tudors. Talking Tutors is an independent and listener-supported podcast that is freely available online.

If you'd like to support the work I do, please consider joining my Talking Tutors Patreon community. Visit patreon.com forward slash Talking Tutors for more information. Once you sign up, you'll have access to exclusive posts, additional live talks, a member-only book club, patron-only giveaways to name just a few of the rewards. Now, on to today's episode. Hello, everyone. Welcome back to another episode of Talking Tutors. Thank you so much for joining us. Today's episode is going to be a little bit different because rather than interviewing

a guest, I'm going to be in conversation with a wonderful guest, my dear friend, Dr. Owen Emerson. Hello, Owen. Hello. It's so lovely to be back with you again, as always. Oh, I'm so excited. I do love our conversations that we have on the podcast and off the podcast as well. And today we are talking about a really exciting subject, and I know one that you are particularly interested in, and it is artwork. It is a miniature. We are going to be talking about a miniature that's held at the Royal Ontario Museum in Canada.

It is technically and officially labelled as a portrait of an unidentified woman by, possibly Lucas Horenbaute or a member of the Horenbaute family and possibly a portrait of Anne Boleyn, Owen, which is extremely exciting. Very exciting. And yet very much want to stress that it's possibly Anne Boleyn. We don't have definitive proof, as is often the case with portraiture. And I actually haven't seen the Ontario version in person yet.

So this is still very much a sort of work in progress. But I am incredibly privileged to have access a present to a twin portrait, which is held in the Baclou collection. It's currently on display at Heber Castle in the capturing a Queen exhibition. So I've been doing a lot of work into both of these miniatures, which is incredibly exciting, and not least with you. It is so exciting. And how lucky to have that there at Hever, Owen. That is absolutely incredible.

And like you, I haven't seen the Ontario Museum version. I'm hoping to at some point, but I haven't yet. But we were given access to some really high-res images. That was thanks to the lovely curator there at the museum. So thank you very much for that. And so we were able to have a really close look at what is an intriguing portrait. I do want to just also stress, you also mentioned, of course, there that we can't say whether this is definitely Anne Boleyn. By the same token, we can't say that it is not Anne Boleyn. And I think in between

those two possibilities is where the exciting conversations can be had. So this is what we're doing in this episode. So just to say that this is suggested to be a miniature by Lucas Horenbaugh. And I'll read you the description that the museum gives, so we're all on the same starting point. It says, an opaque watercolor on vellum laid down on a card set in a tortoiseshell frame, made circa 1525 to 1527. And also just to note, importantly, that it is only 3.7 centimeters wide.

So maybe pause the episode, get your ruler out and have a look. It is tiny, absolutely tiny. and we're going to be discussing some of the details, but of course, this is a tiny object, tiny little treasure. Now, the other thing to say is that we had a conversation with the people at the museum earlier this year and we've been talking about this portrait. We will only, of course, be discussing the things that we brought to the table. The staff at the museum are doing some wonderful research on different aspects of this miniature, but of course, you know, we won't be sharing that research at present.

So just to sort of get that out there. Now, this is so interesting, this miniature, because it's had sort of several possible sitters attributed to it. So at first, I think people thought it was a portrait of Catherine of Aragon. And maybe you can talk to the fact that the Bucleu version of this, the one that's in England, currently at Hiva, actually has a frame that says Catherine of Aragon. I know some people have suggested Jane Seymour and even Mary Boleyn. So what do you think about all of that? Really, really fascinating, isn't it? As with many, many 16th century portraits, particularly those that don't have

a named inscription, they often change identity as our appreciation of these individuals shifts, as new information comes to light. And you're absolutely right, the Bucleu miniature is in, we think, 19th century frame, where it has Catherine of Aragon inscribed on it. Part of its history now, so it remains in that frame. Though, of course, the inscription of the sitter's age on the Ontario version

does preclude it from being Catherine of Aragon. We'll go much more into the detail of that later. Also on the back of the Berkeley miniature is an inscription stating that it's Jane Seen, which is, again, fascinating. I think this potentially is owing to the fact that there has traditionally been this idea that Anne was the French hood wearer and Jane Seymour was the wearer of the English hood. And that obviously isn't the case. We've done lots more research since these

ideas were sort of first put about. And we know that both Jane Seymour, thanks to Elizabeth Norton's brilliant recent research, absolutely wore the French hood. And we sadly know that Anne Boleyn wore the English fashion. So the suggestion of Mary Boleyn is also very, very intriguing. I can absolutely see why. And there's a fourth candidate as well. And that is Elizabeth Blunt or Bessie Blunt. But I'm not sure if that's ever been put forward in an academic argument.

It's very, very popular online. I've never seen anything. Presented academically on that attribution. So, I can't really speak to the specifics as to why that was sort of posited. But yeah, she's had many names. It's really fascinating, isn't it? Oh, I love it. So, there is obviously a tradition that connects, that links this depiction, these miniatures with a Tudor royal woman, or at least a very high status.

Now, normally, When portraits are sort of shared online and people share who they might be, you know, we do always want to find a Tudor queen as a sitter, of course, you know, and I would normally advise caution when sort of attributing this to a royal woman. However, in this case, I think there is some pretty good evidence to suggest that this is either a royal woman or, of course, someone very high up in terms of status. And I say that because of the dating of the miniature and what we know about English miniatures and who's producing them at this time.

So I think what would be really useful as a sort of bit of background information before we look specifically at the miniature is maybe just talking a little bit about what we know about the Horembauts at the Tudor court. You know, this is an artistic family. They are producing incredible artworks. Gerard Horenbout is already very well known by the time he gets to England. And then he's trained several of his children in the same business and they're at the court. But when do they get there and what sort of work are they doing?

Such an important part of this story is when the artists actually arrive in England. And we know that the Horenbout family have worked extensively for Margaret of Austria, who is the regent in the Netherlands. We know that Gerard Horenbout does a vast amount of work for her. And he trains his son, Lucas, and his daughter, Susanna, in this trade. They are limners, so they chiefly are decorating manuscripts.

This is sort of where that word originates. And... It really does appear that Lucas Horenbaut is the originator of the portrait miniature in England. It becomes a huge novelty and it will become a staple of aristocratic artwork throughout the 16th, 17th and onwards. So they are hugely influential. We know that sort of in the mid-1520s,

they arrive and are employed by Catherine of Aragon. So we can see the transfer, really, of the employment of the Horrenbauts from Margaret of Austria, who of course is the twice-sister-in-law of Catherine of Aragon, into the English court. And they are a really significant part of the English Renaissance. You know, we do fixate on Holbein, Just a little aside, these miniatures were attributed to Holbein. They were, you're right, yes.

So it's wonderful that so many scholars have been sort of putting the spotlight onto the Horem bout over the past 30, 40 years. And that isn't really abating. They really are getting the scholarly attention that they deserve. We know that they work for Catherine of Aragon. We know that Susanna is in Catherine of Aragon's household. And we know that Lucas certainly painted both Catherine and also, crucially, Mary, her daughter.

It's one of the earliest surviving, but I think it is the earliest surviving portrait miniature from England, is that gorgeous little portrait of. Mary that is painted for Charles, the Holy Roman Emperor. So this is a really, really significant family. They're sort of at the cutting edge of Renaissance art in England. And they are most likely responsible for the creation of these two exquisite miniatures.

So we know they're working at court for the king and queen. And of course, we know that they work for Anne Boleyn, one of the most beautiful examples of the work that they completed is in a book that you and I know very well, Ecclesiastes. Which is typically held at Annick Castle, but which is also on display at Hever at present. And Gerard Horenbalt illuminated that beautiful book. And it's one of the rare examples where Gerard's initials are actually in one of the miniatures,

so we can be absolutely sure that it was his work. So yes, they not only work for Catherine of Aragon, but also for Anne. It's so intriguing, isn't it? And I just want to just there give a little shout out to the work of Susan James, of course, who's done so much work on the Horenbout family at the Tudor court. If you're interested, you can certainly find out more about the works that she connects, that she thinks are Horenbout from the Horenbout workshop for various Tudor patrons, actually, lots of interesting people. And yes, we've got that gorgeous, that absolutely stunning illumination in Anne's

book, Ecclesiastes, this luxury manuscript made for her during her time as queen. So a little bit later, 1533, probably around, I would imagine around 1534, 35. But oh, and what's really exciting is that we can also link them to her a little bit earlier than that, which is what I love. And I know that, you know, we've looked before at Anne and Henry's relationship, we've looked at Henry VIII's so-called love letters to Anne Boleyn, and there is an intriguing mention in one of those letters.

And he says to Anne that basically he's going to send my picture set in a bracelet. Now, if we can imagine, if this is a bracelet, oh, and this is a pretty small picture of the king, who else but the Horembauts at that time would be capable of that sort of work? It's got to be them. You know, this has to be a likeness created by one of the Horembauts, Lucas, probably. So, yes, that portrait that he sends. And Charlotte Bolland, Dr. Charlotte Bolland, who deserves a great shout out here, posits that one of the

extant miniatures by the Horem Bout may well survive. And it may well excruciatingly be one that was designed to be paired with a portrait of Catherine O'Aragon. So get a real sense there of the sort of seismic shift that is occurring, if that is the case, that, you know, one of those, beautiful little miniatures of the king that had been coupled with one of Catherine of Aragon is now being sent to Anne.

It is intriguing. And I think just also worth mentioning the fact that, of course, we know, Owen, that the Boleyns at this point, we're thinking 1527, 28, are one of the wealthiest families in the country. This is before Anne's rise. You know, they're already incredibly wealthy. They can afford quality sort of artwork being made by the best artists at court. And the other interesting thing that Susan James suggests is that some of the earlier manuscripts made for Anne have also got Horembaut links. So we're now talking about the possibility of someone like George Boleyn.

George Boleyn also commissioning work for his sister, you know, through the Horembaut family. So there are definitely links with Anne and the Horembaut family. She's aware of them. She's there at court, of course. But the dating has always been a bit tricky with the Royal Ontario Museum miniature. We've got an age on there, as you've mentioned. We've got the age of 25, which is, yeah, it's an interesting one because stylistically people,

you know, experts, date these miniatures to around 1527, 2627. It's about the same time that they're doing the miniatures of Catherine of Aragon, of the Princess Mary, of Henry VIII, a few other people at court. So that sort of makes sense, I think. Now, you notice something quite interesting with the clothing, though, when comparing the boucle, the one that's the English version, I suppose, of this miniature, with the one in the Royal Ontario Museum. So do you want to tell us a little bit about that? Yeah, definitely so. And I completely agree broadly with the,

the dating of parts of, of these miniatures. So I. Just to go through sort of what we're looking at here, we have a woman in a, beautiful damask gown. We can actually see the damask patterning on both versions, and it's black. So this is an incredibly coveted color. It's very, very difficult to dye fabric to black in the 16th century. It has to go through a number of different processes, actually dyeing it to different colors to get it there. So this is not a sheep colour to dye silk damask to.

This is a woman of enormous status. This is very, very costly. Black is often now associated with mourning. And while it was worn in the 16th century during mourning, it's absolutely not exclusive to it by any stretch of the imagination. And it is one of the most prestigious colours that you can wear. So that alone tells us this is a woman of standing. We can see that she has decoration across her gown, but also on her hood,

which is in the English fashion. Very importantly, she's wearing cloth of gold on her hood. It seems to be a woven cloth of gold the lapettes are pinned up and the length of the paste that is the sort of bit that comes down like this in the Bucleu miniature. Is bang on really for about 1526 1527 maybe 1528 they end almost touching the shoulders and with the lapettes pinned up that's really about bang on for dating.

Really interestingly there is a significant difference although this is clearly the same woman in the garnishment I would say of the apparel between the miniatures and really importantly if you go on to google images of this painting you can zoom right in, and you will notice that there has been some overpainting at the end of the paste and therefore it's been made slightly shorter. It's just under her chin.

You can actually see where the back has been painted over it and the silhouette of what was a longer paste length has been blacked out. Now, really interestingly, this shortening of the paste is absolutely what happened, by the time we get to around 1534, 1535, even 1533, the pace is decidedly shorter. And really interestingly, it's around this time that the Most Happy Medal is created.

And if you look at the length of the paste, it's around the same length as the shortened version from the Ontario Museum. Now, you'll also notice two other crucial differences. One is that the Ontario version has an extraordinarily elaborate pendant hanging from the chain that the sitter is wearing. And you'll also notice that the seed pearls around the paste of the hood have been,

accompanied with 21 ouches that aren't visible in the bucclue now this is very much a work in progress and it's only a working theory, but what if both of these were created in the late 1520s. And what if the sitter rose in status and therefore it was decided to perhaps update this portrait to give more decoration, more elaboration, more jewellery,

and maybe even to update the fashion so that it fits the current fashion of a shorter paste. I can't prove this. I can prove that there has been an alteration to the painting and this is just my interpretation of why that might have been done. But if that were the case, who is rising in status from around 1527 to the mid-1530s? I think this might. Just might be a clue as to who the sitter is.

Yeah, I think it's an absolutely fascinating theory. And as you've said, it's something you're still obviously working on, but we wanted to share to get the conversation going because I think it's really exciting, really exciting to think about this. Possibly also good to mention that the reason why we don't think this is Jane Seymour, you talked earlier about her association with the English style of headdress. And of course, her this sort of idea that Jane is trying to emulate Catherine of Aragon when she comes, you know, to be opposite to Anne Boleyn.

And of course, again, must shout out the work of Dr. Elizabeth Norton, who's showed that all of that about the hoods, all of that is just not accurate. You know, it's not substantiated. So it's really interesting. And the really exciting thing, Owen, is that I think Elizabeth has cracked Jane Seymour's age. And unfortunately Unfortunately, for Jane, I say this, unfortunately, for Jane, it appears that she was only 24 when she died. And again, I ask you to have a look at the work of Dr. Elizabeth Norton. I did a podcast episode with her, but this is to do with the tapers that are

at her funeral. There are only 24 of them, and there is a tradition to have that to match the age. So the age on these miniatures, on the Ontario miniature, says 25, and unfortunately, it doesn't seem that Jane actually reached that age. And in any way, it wouldn't sort of match in terms of the dating of when stylistically these miniatures were made. So I think we can pretty much rule out that this is Jane Seymour. Catherine of Aragon, of course, is born in 1485. That's not going to work. And we have other miniatures of Catherine of Aragon. So if we're looking, as you say, for somebody who is of extremely high status,

who rises even further in this period, we have Anne Boleyn. I think this is really intriguing, but there are some other little bits in the records, Owen, that I came across when immersed in one of the many accounts I love to look at that might also suggest that this is a portrait of Anne, that this is in fact the earliest depiction of Anne Boleyn, which would be really exciting. Again, nothing that we can prove definitively, but certainly exciting to think about, I think.

And if anyone's joined one of Owen's and my courses that we've done last year, I think we did one where we hinted at this and we talked about it, didn't we? So you probably had a little sneak peek at some of the things I'm going to say, but hopefully you'll enjoy hearing it again. So there are some dual accounts, Owen, that I remember finding and sharing with you. Very interesting dual accounts. Traditionally, these have been dated to 1531 to 1532. They run for roughly 18 months, I think, from memory. Oh, actually,

not that long, to be honest. They're from August until the following May, sorry. And Eric Ives, the wonderful Professor Ives, little got, you know, past him. So thorough, so incredible. He favoured the 1531, 1532 dating for these accounts. And I think that a lot of historians followed his lead and simply sort of went along and it does make sense with some of the, evidence in these accounts but there is another possibility and interestingly it was a possibility that I came across and then realised that Professor Ives

in fact mentions it in his notes, in his footnote. He does say that there's another possibility it could be 1527 to 1528 and. I actually do, I wouldn't think that these date from August 1527 until May 1528, and I'll walk you through exactly why I think that and why I imagine I also thought that was a possibility. The first thing is right at the top of the accounts, actually, second item on these accounts, there's an item delivered to Mistress Anne,

firstly, and we'll come back to that, Mistress Anne at Bewley on the 3rd of August. Now, the reason why we can only have either 1527 to 28 and then 1531 to 32 is because one of the items is the 29th of February. So, that is a leap year. So, it has to either be 1528 or 1532 to fit with the other evidence in this set of accounts. So, we know that the court is at Beaulieu in August 1527 because it's quite

a big deal. everyone's sort of gone there to discuss what the king wants. And what he wants is to marry Anne Boleyn. Now, we're not going to go into sort of all the details, but can you maybe just summarise for us quickly the sort of timing that we put forward in another video that we recorded about Anne and Henry and when this. Got serious, I suppose, this relationship? Yeah, so traditionally, we've had this idea that at Christmas 1526, Anne accepts Henry's hand in marriage, and she does this by sending an estraine,

a New Year's gift, to Henry the Bejeweled Ship, and that that is sort of the beginning of their relationship, officially. However, this has been questioned recently. So, for example, Professor Tracy Adams disputes the idea that Estren is just a New Year's gift, and she also really questions this idea about whether Anne was being offered the position of official mistress. She thinks this is a misunderstanding, a mistranslation, and that it was always

marriage on the cards. And I think I agree with that analysis. Is very, very persuasive. Moreover, as your research has shown, we don't see any record of anyone at court noticing anything until May 1527. That's when Henry and Anne are linked for the first time dancing. And it's not until August 1527 that the first ambassadorial reports state clearly that Henry intends to marry Berlin.

So if Henry and Anne had gotten engaged at Christmas 1526, would they realistically have waited until August 1527 to start manoeuvring? I think this revised narrative is an important inclusion. I think it should be considered very seriously. I think it make sense. What are your thoughts on that? Yeah, absolutely. I do too. And I think it's really important to this particular story that we're looking

at right now because, of course, you know the idea that he chased her for seven years, she refused to become his mistress, forcing him to leave Catherine of Aragon, where this story is very different. It has Henry deciding within a few months that Anne is going to be his queen, whether she liked it or not. That's a whole different discussion. But in Henry's mind, Anne Boleyn is the next queen of England. And so he needs to obviously raise her in status to his people, to his court, because she's going to be their queen. So I think it's interesting just to keep that in mind when we're thinking about

these accounts, because the 3rd of August is, I think, two weeks before Henry requests an annulment of his marriage to Catherine. It doesn't specifically mention Anne, but the details given, we know it is Anne that he's got in mind. He wants to marry her. So we have Beaulieu. Now, what's fabulous about Bewley is that it was also called Newhall previously, and then it was a Berlin property sold to Henry in, I think, around 1516, and Henry enlarges it and beautifies it. And the court, which is quite strange, actually, for the court on progress,

stays for one month at Bewley in August 1527. Now, I have a particular interest in the court's movements, Owen, and have been sort of researching that for many, many, many years. I have never seen the court at Beaulieu again after this time. So there is August 1527. And then the next mention, I think, is really around 1533 when Mary, Princess Mary, or the Lady Mary, is asked to leave because George Boleyn is

given this particular property. So we know they're definitely there in August 1527. They spend a month, they've got a lot of information about that particular state. And there is one more mention of a location in the accounts, and that comes on the 3rd of December, and it's Hampton Court. And if we have a look at the court's itinerary, we know that the court is at Beuley in August, and they're at Hampton Court in December in 1527. If you have a look at 1531, you will find them at Hampton Court in December.

But you won't find them at Beuley in August 1531. So I think we can be quite confident that these accounts, which, by the way, I don't think I've even mentioned, are accounts by Cornelius Hayes, the goldsmith or jeweller, you know, a favoured jeweller of Henry VIII. They're basically his bill for things that he's delivered to the king and other important people like Anne over the period of since August 1527 to May 1528, including a gorgeous emerald ring at Bewley. So, you know, does that sound convincing to you, Owen, that this is pretty much,

and we know that 1528 is a leap year, so that fits in with the 29th of February. There's another important thing, apart from Bewley Hampton, called the leap year, and it's that Anne is referred to as Mistress Anne. Now, if this was 31, 32, would you expect her to be referred to as Mistress Anne? No, I think it's quite clear that she wouldn't have been, and I think we have good evidence of that. I think she would have been styled Lady Anne. From December 1529, she is styled as Lady Rochford, Lady Anne Rochford.

That's how she signs her name and that's how she's referred to in the state papers. And of course, from the 1st of September 1532, she is the Marchioness of Pembroke. And then I think the evidence that you've built, the fact that we know that they aren't at Beaulieu in the latter option, positive by Ives. It's the clincher, really, unless there is any evidence that comes forward that they are coincidentally at the same locations, sort of four years on. I think it's got to be the earlier date. And it also sort of fits with Tracey

Adams' dating of the relationship as well, very, very comfortably, I think. Yes, yes. I think Ives, when he covered both bases, as I mentioned, and sort of says, oh, 1527 is a possibility because he knew they were a beauty there. And in his mind, he thought all these gifts might then be engagement presents. From Henry to Anne, he's trying to build her up. She needs all these incredible jewels, of course. Of course, she's already got her own jewels, but certainly to become queen, she's going to need to be fitted out appropriately.

So we've gone to this extent to sort of date this to 1527 to 28, because of course, this is important when it comes to the miniature. So we've said that the miniature dates from around circa 1527. The Ontario Museum one is the one I'm specifically looking at in this discussion, although they are sort of, you know, cousins or whatnot, the miniatures. And this is a time when we know that Henry has decided Anne will be his queen. He has asked for the dispensation. She is increased in status because he is

favoring her, of course. And so let's look at a few items, Owen, then, that are in these accounts that may, may, I say may because it's not for certain, that may connect to this siddha in this miniature. And the first one we have is a really beautiful item, I have to say. And it comes as a gift to Anne on the 24th of September, 1527. And it says that it's delivered to Mistress Anne on that particular day and it is a Catherine wheel of gold set with 13 diamonds. Must have been stunning.

And just looking at the details, it appears that it was newly made for her because we have a cost for making this particular item. Sometimes they're recycled and we hear that they're just sort of being recycled, but this appears possibly to be a new item made for Anne. But I suppose, Owen, that this might seem strange. Why is Henry, in September 1527, gifting Anne Boleyn a Catherine wheel that is absolutely. Associated with Catherine of Aragon in terms of that's her patron saint. We know there are depictions in, you know, I can think just off the top of my

head, there's a lovely stained glass window at the vine. We have Catherine of Aragon with St. Catherine. There is a wonderful musical manuscript that you and I absolutely love that shows Catherine of Aragon with her patron saint. So this is definitely, you know, you're going to think of Catherine of Aragon when you see Catherine Wheel at this point. But of course, St. Catherine, she's an incredibly popular saint. Let's remember, I realize that this gets a bit controversial as the Reformation proceeds and as religious changes happen.

But at this point, I think she's still someone who women are certainly looking to as a spiritual role model. This particular saint exemplifies beauty and intelligence and piety and innocence, all the things that, of course, Anne is going to want to emphasize. About herself at this point. But do you think it's a little odd that Henry gives her a Catherine wheel at this point? Yeah, I mean, it could be odd or it could be pointed in a way. You know, it could be that she is adopting Catherine.

The iconography of her predecessor. And I don't think that is completely unprecedented. So, for example, if we look at what happens, just one example, to the Queen's Barge, just before Anne's coronation, it is completely stripped of Catherine's iconography and replaced with that of Anne. And also, if we look, for example, at the excruciating exchanges that happen

with regards to Catherine's jewels and even the christening robe that she has in her possession, we can see, I think, time and time again that these items are, not deemed to be Catherine's anymore. They are to be Anne's, and there is enormous sort of, social and emotional battle over them. So, I don't think we're in uncharted waters here at all. No, no. And it happens with Jane Seymour too, doesn't?

She certainly gets a lot of Anne's items. Of course, Anne was deceased by then, and Catherine is very much still Queen of England and alive. But I think the fact that we know that Henry's already requested the dispensation. There is this sort of transfer of power, almost, Owen, that's happening here from Catherine of Aragon to Anne. And this isn't to say that Anne, I have to stress this, we have no evidence that Anne is happy about this, that she's sad about this. We just don't know how Anne felt. I'm just reading what's in the accounts.

And the accounts tell us that Henry has gifted her Catherine Wheel a very substantial, beautiful item. And if we look at the Royal Ontario Museum, Owen, and we look at the decoration around the sitter's gown here at the top, we have definitely noticed, I know that when we got the high-res images of this, there's no doubt they are Catherine wheels. There's quite a lot of them, actually. They're sort of buttons, but they're made as Catherine wheels. So I thought that was quite, because that normally perhaps might put some people off from believing that the sitter is Anne Boleyn.

So what I just want to highlight is that, in fact, Anne also was sort of promoting that closeness with St. Catherine, because St. Catherine is, as I said, a really important saint. So while the jewel, the Catherine Wheel, doesn't feature in the Royal Ontario Museum, we definitely have Catherine Wheels. So we can apply that same sort of thinking that this is Anne taking over, basically, to put it bluntly and simply. And I just also want to note, just because it's interesting,

that Catherine Parr in her inventory, for some of her jewels, she in fact had six buttons of gold made like Catherine wheels. And I wonder, I just wonder, just popped into my head if they were the same Catherine wheels that are in the Horrabout miniature. They really could be. I mean, they are decorative habiliments right around her neckline. We can actually see them in the Bucleu miniature as well. They are absolutely in both. And this might sort of have been a past clue as

to why she was identified as Catherine of Aragon. Of course, we can rule Catherine out because by the 1527 mark at the latest, really, or 1528, Catherine is 40. And this sitter has been identified as in her 25th year. So I don't think it can be Catherine of Aragon. But the inclusion of Catherine Wills absolutely cannot rule Anne out because we know that she has at least one very high-status jewel covered in diamonds

in her possession, because Henry has gifted it to her. It absolutely cannot be a determinant as to why this cannot be Anne. So we've got the Catherine wheels. There's another really interesting item. So once again, delivered the same day, so 27th of September, 1527 to Anne, and it's the setting of a diamond in the brooch with Our Lady of Boulogne. Now, this is a really interesting item. It's absolutely intrigued me since the

second I sort of read about it. It also makes another appearance later. And I think it's the diamond that's set or fixed or enhanced or something later on. But what in December, actually? So what's interesting about this, Owen, is that a jewel can be seen on the sitters just close to her breast area there. And again, I'm just reminding you that this miniature is 3.7 centimetres wide. So it is very, very difficult to get a good sort of look at this. But we have looked at some really high-res images provided by the Ontario Museum,

of this particular jewel. Now, there was a theory in the past, and I'm sorry, I can't remember who said this, that it was Anne's falcon badge. And that was, you know, people were very excited about this because, of course, that would be an interesting find, wouldn't it? Although the falcon, I don't know that Anne's associated with it so early on. But anyway, that's another story. So people thought it was the falcon. because it did look like they were sort of like wings. But we had a very, very close look at this. Other people have suggested that it's possibly a woman sitting in sort of a patch of grass.

It does appear that there's some green. But I'm wondering whether, in fact, it's this brooch that we're looking at in this particular miniature. So Our Lady of Boulogne is, in fact, the Virgin Mary. So she was associated with an interesting legend. I think it's Boulogne-sur-Mer where her shrine was. And Henry VIII, I should know, Henry VIII visited this particular shrine in 1532 when they go over to Calais to see Francis I. A very famous shrine. Go on now, but just as a side note, you can actually go and visit the crypt.

Incredible, huge crypt that was below this particular famous medieval shrine. It was said to be like a miraculous statue. And it apparently appeared one day, this statue, in a boat. With no one rowing the boat or anything. So, you know, hence the miracle, obviously. And it's normally the Virgin, when you look at different depictions, medieval depictions of Our Lady of Boulogne, she is holding the baby Jesus. We can't see any of that detail in this jewel. That is absolutely certain.

However, the jewel isn't clear. So there is a possibility that she may have been holding something, this woman. And the wings, I suggest that normally the depictions have two angels sort of by the side of this, of the Virgin Mary. Could they perhaps be what people had interpreted as the falcon wings in the earlier interpretations? Again, just a suggestion, but I think it's an interesting one to think about. What do you think? Yeah, very much so. And of course, Our Lady of Boulogne has an enormous significance to the Boleyns as well, because they are believed to have originated from Boulogne.

So, you know, her surname is absolutely tied to this saint and... I think it's a really compelling possibility. And, you know, ever since you, you know, posited this as a possibility, I've been going through a lot of 16th century representations of Our Lady. And they aren't always shown in a boat, but they are usually kneeling at the city. So it's a really, really tantalizing possibility.

And one other thing that I think we must bear in mind is that, going back to your point about the size of these matches, I can absolutely see why previous generations thought it was potentially the Berlin Falcon. I think the advent of high-resolution images, and in particular, and a huge shout-out again to the Ontario curators for undertaking some fresh high-resolution. I mean, these are microscopic images that they completed and very,

very generously recently shared with us. It's hard to overstate, you know, how small this miniature is. And to think that this is a tiny little jewel in that tiny miniature, the detailing is incredible for how small it is. And yet there's only so much detail that you can put into something this tiny. So I think this is a really interesting potential. I think it's the most persuasive of the suggestions that have been put forward.

And it absolutely ties in with what we know about the style of jewels that are being created. We can see that Anne is not only having her jewels fashioned in a certain way, a way that perhaps we wouldn't necessarily have anticipated, especially with the Catherine wheels. But also then having them regarnished, updated, it does seem to chime with the earlier theory that I posited, that this Ontario miniature...

May have began in a sort of late 1520s fashion. And as Anne's star is rising, the fashion's been updated, jewels have been added. And very interestingly, you mentioned something else about this list to me some time ago. Do you want to mention that as well? Yes, absolutely. Because I think it's really interesting. There is, yeah. Yeah, so I have honestly wrecked my eyes trying to see more of that little jewel.

But I think that's a possibility. I do think it's a possibility. There is something else that caught my eye about the Ontario Museum miniature compared to some of the other Harenbach miniatures. And that is that the decoration on the sitter's headdress is very particular. We can see, and you can count them for yourself, that there are 21 sort of buttons that you can see decorating her hood. And then when we look back to this inventory, Owen, it just was really interesting that on at least two occasions, I've got two examples here for you,

she is gifted 21 buttons. So we have delivered to Mistress Anne 21 rubies set in roses of crown gold. So to me, they sound like little buttons. They're like gold buttons with rubies. Exactly, with rubies. And on another occasion, again, we have to mistress Anne, 21 rubies and 21 diamonds set upon Rose's heart. So I think they're like little hearts or something. And then it goes on with weight and whatnot. So three times in these jewels within, you know,

from August 1527 to May 1528, Anne is gifted a set of three sets of 21 buttons, ouches, however you want to call them. And when we look at the Ontario Museum, them, the sitter is wearing exactly 21. Now, this could be a coincidence. I did think this myself, but then I went and had a look at the other miniatures that the Hormvarts have created, they certainly do not have 21. There's all sorts of different numbers. Could that be another link to these jewels that Anne's being gifted by Henry.

Early in their sort of relationship when he's trying to deck her out as the next queen? Or just a coincidence? What do you think? I think it's absolutely fascinating. And I think you mentioned also in other inventories, the other queens do have these kind of ouches, but they aren't of that number. So it does seem that there to be a connection between the fact that the Horanbaute miniature has 21 specifically. I do also think it's possible that those ouches have been added later,

because we can see between the Horanbaute, in the Bucleu collection and in the Ontario that there is this addition of a very, very significant pendant that isn't in the Bucleu version. And it is garnished very extensively. And also there are these 21 ouchies or buttons going around the hood. Really interestingly, if we look at the Baclou version, there's just lines of seed pearls.

I think, in fact, there are three strands of seed pearls going right around the paste. We can see those seed pearls in the Ontario version with the buttons or ouches on top of them. And I do wonder if these are also a later addition. It will be really, really fascinating if these are subjected to. Different kinds of analysis in the future, whether we can determine whether that shortening of the hood, the addition of the pendant, and perhaps even the

ouches on the paste were later embellishments. And if they were, then not only can we determine that this is a woman of standing through her costume, through the fact that there are two copies of it. These, you know, these are very expensive things to produce and it is not in isolation. There is a. These might suggest that the woman was of status when they were painted, but has risen in status too.

Yeah, I think it's fascinating to sort of reflect on that. And I did look through very carefully to see if I could find that other stunning pendant, because it is very distinct. It has a particular style that I think we would be able to recognize if described properly in the inventory. Unfortunately, sadly, while she does have some beautiful brooches, nothing that seems to match that particular pendant exactly. Lots of pearls, lots of beautiful things, but nothing that matches that one exactly, which might suggest that it was a gift that came later.

And it was a significant gift from the king, which is why it was added to perhaps a later edition of the miniature. The age, though, is interesting as well, isn't it, Oa? because, you know, there is, of course, the big debate about when Anne Boleyn was born. And I think that previously, if these accounts dated to 31, 32, you know, they wouldn't really match very well. They wouldn't be seen as any sort of evidence for this particular miniature that was said to be produced in around 1527.

However, when we think that this possibly does now, date to 1527, that the accounts are certainly from 1527 and 1528, we might be able to sort of see some more links there, which I think is really interesting. And it really fits with what we know about Anne. I think, you know, if this is a miniature of very late 1527 or perhaps early 1528, then we still have someone that is born around, you know, 1502, which I think works quite well.

Yeah, I think, you know, the style, the age... When she's born, the status that she is, I think she's a real contender. And one other observation I think we should take seriously is the face that we're looking at. And this isn't always a great determinant to a sitter. And we only have to look at the extant portraiture of Catherine of Aragon that does date to her lifetime to know how divergent these images can actually be.

While we can see some synergies between them, there are also massive differences and yet they are of the same woman. But I do just want to draw your attention to the similarities that I think are quite evident between this sitter in these two miniatures and the Windsor sketch of who I think is the link that's held in the Royal Collections Trust. And I think we see almost identical proportions, same colour eyes, same gathering of skin down here, and also a lighter coloured hair than we'd

naturally expect Anne Boleyn to have. I say naturally, it's more a tradition, this idea that Anne had dark or raven black hair. There is no contemporary evidence to support this at all. The earliest reference that we have to Anne having dark black hair comes from Nicholas Sander, a man who did not know Anne, and who was clearly trying to blacken her image. We actually have no contemporary references to Anne's hair colour at all. So the blonde, reddish almost sort of hair that you can see peeking out from

the material, just covering her hair at the top of her hood. Absolutely doesn't rule Anne Boleyn out, I don't think. And if we think of the image in the checkers ring, she has a golden hint to an auburn kind of coloured hair overall. So. If we look at some of the Elizabethan corridor portraits of Anne Boleyn as well, they have decidedly auburned hair. So there's nothing here, I don't think, that rules Anne Boleyn out.

Can we say that it's definitely her? Absolutely not. But it's just as erroneous as to say, this is not Anne Boleyn. I don't think we can prove it is her, but I think she's a very, very strong contender. I have to completely agree. I think, you know, and that's why we haven't focused on her appearance in this, because as you've said, it's very difficult to compare portraits. Yeah, it really is. But I do completely agree with you. I think we're seeing, there's nothing here that says to me this isn't the same woman as in the Windsor sketch. There's nothing that says to me that this isn't the same woman as in the most

happy portrait medal that we know dates from 1534, that we know is Anne Boleyn, that we know it's an image she saw and wanted to be reproduced and put out there. I think they absolutely could be the same woman. There's no doubt about that. But perhaps more convincingly, I think, Owen, it's just who else could it be at this period of time who has the sufficient status, to be among a small group of people being captured in this very new way for England, obviously being done elsewhere.

But for England, this is the sort of Horembaut hallmark at this point. And we have the royal family being paid, you know, being miniatures being produced of them by the Horembaut family. We have a connection between Anne and the Horembauts that predates her queenship. We have possibly even connection that predates them coming to the English court because, of course, of where Anne was educated. We have this incredible... Moment that occurs in 1527 where Henry decides that Anne Boleyn is his next queen.

All of this that happens within a few months where he seeks an annulment from his wife of all these years because he wants to marry Anne. Then she's showered, absolutely showered in the most exquisite jewelry. There is no doubt in my mind that she's also captured by the best artists at court. I have no doubt about that. Whether this is the portrait that came from that, you know, of course, we could debate that. But I do think the evidence is quite good. It's quite strong. Suddenly, I can't rule Anne out.

I don't see any evidence to say that this isn't Anne Boleyn. And then, as you've pointed out, the possibility that this miniature, because it's so valuable, of course, that they've been reproduced or that they've been amended, however you sort of want to look at this, to update her and reflect that increased status from Mistress Anne to, of course, Anne the Queen eventually, which is quite an incredible sort of trajectory that happens over really quite a short period of time. I think, yes, I think Anne is a definite possibility. Yeah, I agree.

I think it's a really, really tantalizing possibility. I'm so excited to be working with you on this project. I know there's more to be found. There always is. And I think it's really important to have an open mind about this. One of the people that I really can't rule out at the moment is Mary Boleyn. But I do need to sort of find a sort of justification, I guess. As to why a portrait of her would be updated in quite the significant way that

I think the Ontario one has. And if I'm right, about that update. And that would need scientific analysis in order to prove it. I don't think it would necessarily be Mary. I think it would make it more likely to be Anne. But time will tell. Time will tell. And we should just also mention that, of course, ongoing research by the Royal Ontario Museum as well, looking into other aspects of this miniature, really exciting looking into the card that it might be pasted on,

the flowers that we see visible, again, very difficult to identify because of the tiny, tiny, tiny size, but they're suddenly working on all of that. So I think it is a, suddenly a work in progress, but Anne Boleyn, for me, remains a very exciting possibility. And interestingly, you say Mary Boleyn, Owen, because I do think that. The Boleyns certainly had the funds to be captured by the horrible bouts. I'd be surprised, actually, to be honest with you, if they weren't. Definitely so. I think that's absolutely a given.

So all exciting. So I hope you've enjoyed our little sort of, you know, we've kind of been just sharing our thoughts with you, really. But I do hope you've enjoyed it because I think it is important to be transparent with your research and to share what you have. And of course, not to rule out possibilities when there's no evidence to say that this can't be Anne Boleyn. I still at this point maintain that there's pretty strong evidence that it is and that it's the earliest depiction of her right at that crucial sort of point where she is moving from Mistress Anne to Lady Anne and all the other fabulous titles.

So, Owen, thank you so much for joining me on this discussion. It's been such a pleasure. A joy as always. And thank you everyone for joining us. And of course, if you're listening to this podcast, you can watch it on YouTube and we might be able to pop up some images there, which might make it a little bit easier for you when you're listening to us going on about these images. But hopefully you've enjoyed it and we'll see you all again very, very soon. Well, that brings us to the end of this episode of Talking Tutors. Thank you so much for joining me. If you've enjoyed the show,

please spread the word on your socials and don't forget to subscribe, rate and review. I also invite you to join the Talking Tudors Patreon community for some fun exclusive content and the Talking Tudors podcast group on Facebook, where you can interact with other Tudor history lovers and hear all the behind-the-scenes news. You'll also find me on Instagram. My handle is TheMostHappy78. It's time now for us to re-enter the modern world. As always, I look forward to Talking Tudors with you again very soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 369 - Did Queen Anne Boleyn Gift a Prayer Book on the Scaffold? Natalie Grueninger & Dr Owen Emmerson Investigate

    Nov 21, 202655 minAudio

    Host Natalie Grueninger and guest Dr Owen Emmerson investigate the widely circulated story that Anne Boleyn gave a prayer or girdle book to a lady (often a Mistress Wyatt) at or near her execution. They trace the legend...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 368 - The Life & Death of Thomas Cavendish: Elizabethan Explorer and Privateer with Dr Iain Gately

    Nov 15, 202652 minAudio

    Dr Iain Gately joins Talking Tudors to tell the dramatic story of Thomas Cavendish, an Elizabethan privateer who sailed around the world, captured the rich Manila galleon Santa Ana, and brought back maps, stories, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 367 - William Paget: King's Secretary & Tudor Survivor with Dr Andrew Johnston

    Nov 7, 202644 minAudio

    Host Natalie Grueninger speaks with Dr Andrew Johnston about the life and career of William Paget, from his humble London origins to his central role as Henry VIII’s secretary. The episode explores Paget’s influence on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 366 - Haunted London with Megan Coles

    Oct 31, 202623 minAudio

    Host Natalie Grueninger interviews historian and author Megan Coles about the spooky side of London: Elizabeth I sightings, headless apparitions at the Tower, Catherine Howard’s ghost at Hampton Court, and Megan’s own...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 365 - Death by Misadventure in Elizabethan England with Dr Jane Bitomsky

    Oct 23, 202629 minAudio

    Host Natalie Grueninger interviews Dr Jane Bitomsky about her debut historical mystery, 'Death by Misadventure', and her PhD research into pregnancy and crime in early modern England. They discuss the real-life coroner...

    Credit the people on this episode