Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Shift with Craig

Talking Shift with Craig artwork

Katie Shive: Solving the Brand Identity Crisis

Jun 9, 202648 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Talking Shift, Craig sits down with brand strategist Katie Shive to unpack the massive brand identity crisis hitting the mortgage and financial sectors. They break down why consumers are craving raw authenticity over polished corporate graphics, how to build a rock solid personal brand foundation, and the exact strategy needed to leverage AI without losing your humanity. Talking Shift Insights Information is no longer a competitive advantage; consumers can access data instantly, meaning your credentials are just table stakes. AI doesn’t capture raw human emotion, making small imperfections a trust signal in a world of deepfakes. Stop trying to market to everyone; narrowing down your ideal client persona forces you to solve the specific midnight anxieties that keep your clients awake. Vulnerable storytelling moves the needle faster than any sales pitch because people connect with people, not product. AI will not replace you if you protect the relationship; let technology automate the transaction while you double down on real-life connections. Today's Guest Katie Shive: A premier brand strategist and AI integration expert tailored for the modern mortgage and real estate landscape. Known affectionately as the "brand therapist," Katie helps her clients extract their unique origin stories to build a high-converting personal brand identity. Connect with Katie on her socials and Katie Shive. LinkedIn Instagram Craig Davis, Host: A leader’s leader, executive coach, and speaker with 20 years in the mortgage business, Craig is a Stage 3 cancer survivor with a mission to help busy leaders get unstuck, reduce stress, and Make Shift Happen in life and business. 👉Coach Craig Davis 👉Craig’s LinkedIn 👉Craig’s Instagram Check out Talking Shift on all your favorite platforms. 🎙️ The Talking Shift Podcast 👉 Apple | Spotify | YouTube If you enjoy this podcast, please support it by liking, subscribing, and sharing with someone who needs to hear it.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01But where we are shifting right now with in a in a society that you can outsource your voice, your pictures, your video, your copy, we are quickly being trained to trust nothing out the gate. And now you have to earn my trust because I'm starting at no trust because I'm assuming you used AI to do everything. So now I'm looking for a breadcrumb that makes me think, oh, there was a real human behind this post.

SPEAKER_02So when shift happened, it's our choice. Either we let shift happen or we make gift happen.

SPEAKER_03Hey, what's up, everyone? Welcome to the Talk and Shift podcast with my very good, dear friend, my rad collab partner, my AI fight clubber, my good friend Katie Scheid, the brand expert of the business. Katie, welcome to Talk and Shift.

SPEAKER_01Thanks. I'm excited to be on the show. We we talk a lot of shift outside of Talking Shift. So it feels really fun to be officially talking shift on record.

SPEAKER_03Well, I kind of figured at some point we should just turn the camera on because we have so many good, like, and these are like, you know, it's funny. I mean, even just before we, you know, we press play right here, we're sitting there talking about what's happening in this business. You know, I mean, we we serve the mortgage business, but really serving the greater business, and and I often say, like, our world is is under shift right now. We're going through shift, society's going through shift. I mean, it, you know, obviously the social media noise, but the social media noise has has expanded text now because of the AI, you know, war on on our eyeballs and attention and and you know, and you mark that against again the headlines and politics and you know, the mortgage business.

SPEAKER_03I'm looking at rates this morning or the 10 years at like 466. And so, you know, there's just so much going on, but yet in all of that noise, and this is I think where, you know, why I'm so excited about this conversation, because there's so much noise, and as off as you often hear me say, so we have to be the signal, the signal through the noise. And so for everybody listening, whether you are an executive, you're in leadership, you're an originator, you're in real estate, you're not even in the mortgage business, you're doing what you do.

SPEAKER_03There's a brand identity crisis out there. Like, and and I was just giving a webinar the other day, and it's like, you know, three years ago, we were taught, and always intuitively lead with value. Lead with value. And now my argument is no, don't lead with value. Why? Because it's not memorable, it's noisy, and it's it's one of the crowd. We instead we have to lead with the problem we solve. And that problem we solve is the value.

SPEAKER_03And so I'm seeing now in a very fast amount of time that this brand identity crisis of like, what are we doing? Like, what do you do? How do you serve your client? How do you make that connection? And why should they care? And, you know, Katie, you are someone that cuts through that noise and you you know, helping, you know, your clients, you know, through your brand book builder and so much more, really, really, you know, isolate in and find that brand identity and solve that noise and be the signal.

SPEAKER_03And so, you know, Katie, what are you seeing as like a common thread when you're starting to work with clients and people are coming to you? What, you know, what is that crisis point?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I mean a lot of people initially will hear of me of like, oh, you need to call Katie. She helps, you know, build AI tools. So going back to, you know, right now, AI is largely the shiny object. It's the predominant conversation in in most rooms and in a lot of different capacities. And so everybody in business that has a pulse that is trying to grow their, grow their reach is needing to figure out this AI. And so people will come to me and be like, okay, well, I just need, I need to learn how to use AI.

SPEAKER_01And I always say, like, hey, what are we, what are we trying to accomplish before we just answer the question, let's use Chat GPT better. What is the greater goal that you have? It's not just to be the next Sam Altman and lead in building AI tools, but what is your goal? And so when I kind of unpack that, most of what I find is that people, like you're saying, they don't know how to create a signal. They don't know how to build trust with their audience. Um, and for a long time, I would argue that as marketers, we've always said, well, you just need to post more.

SPEAKER_01You just need to create more content. You just need to get in front of more eyeballs. And there, it's not that that statement is entirely wrong, but I feel like it's it's half baked. Like, yes, you need to get in front of more eyeballs, but you need to get in front of the right eyeballs with the right story. Because you could have a strategy that makes you maybe go viral, but that doesn't mean that it's going to actually convert to better conversations and eventual sales. It could just mean that you have lots of eyeballs from the wrong, you know, from the wrong audience.

SPEAKER_01So I always look at what is your brand foundation, right? If I were to scroll any of your Instagram, you know, pages, LinkedIn, email, any of your digital accounts, really quickly would I be able to get a sense of who you are, what you do, how you help, the value that you're talking about, right? The problems that you solve. More often than not, I can't answer that question or I can't answer it quickly. An example, recently, I was doing an audit for a mortgage team.

SPEAKER_01I was on a call with them. And so I was prepping for the call and I was looking at one of their top producers to use as an example. And I go to the individual's page on Instagram, and I had to scroll like 10 swipes before I got to one post that this individual ran, you know, a race, like a 5K or something. And I was like, okay, of the hundred pages of the hundred posts that I just scrolled past, it took me a hundred to get to one 5K. Everything else was your corporate branded stuff, which teaches me nothing about who you actually are.

SPEAKER_01So I'd say that's really where I start is hey, before we try to develop any AI systems or actually build a content strategy, we actually need to start really back at the basics, like understanding who are you? Why should I give you my business? Why should I give you my attention? And let's start with your story.

SPEAKER_03Well, and it's so important. And, you know, and so much what I'm focused on right now, too, is well. And again, it doesn't matter if you're an executive, you're a CEO, you're a branch manager, regional, you know, or an originator. There's been a an onslaught of people that are like, I'm not gonna say they're stuck, some are stuck, but like, what am I doing? And so I've been diving right back into okay, what's our vision, mission, and values? Because before we can even start creating our brand and how are we going to connect it to the market?

SPEAKER_03And to your point, like I want to tell people, you know, people connect with people, not product. And our consumer, who is an AI-empowered consumer now, I think they are caring less and less about the logo on your door. And yet we're not really sure how else to connect. And people, and to your point, people care about the 5K race you ran. They don't care about the DSCR loan that you have or that product that you have. They don't even know what it means anyway. Right.

SPEAKER_03And so really getting down to the cord of okay, what do you believe in? What do you care about? What problems do you solve? Who are you solving them for? Why does that matter? Is that what gives you abundant energy as if you're plugged into the wall versus if you're plugged into a battery that's going to be depleting? Well, and that's why I jump right into okay, vision, mission, and values. And I actually I care less about your vision. I care the most about your mission, which means your purpose. What is your purpose? And when we get clear and connected with that, that's what gives us abundant energy.

SPEAKER_03That's what it gives us, I think, abundance, especially in our personal brand and being able to connect that into the market.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you're, you're super, you're you're 100% right. People, I mean, I know this is a a very worn-out phrase of people do business they like, know, and trust. But at the end of the day, you know, information is no longer an advantage. Like that, that is not your value proposition. You cannot lead on I'm the most well-versed on X, Y, or Z.

SPEAKER_03I know all my products.

SPEAKER_01It's it's important. I do want to know, like, yes, when I'm looking at your content, I need to be able to answer that this person knows what they're talking about. Yes, I want confidence. And yes, I want to know that you're a competent like person and you can do exactly what you say you're gonna do. So I need to know that you're good. But more than that, I also want to know who are you as a person? Because there's like we think about the financial services sector at least, like whatever aspect that is, like, it is really vulnerable and scary and overwhelming.

SPEAKER_01Actually, this is a great example. My parents, they're older age, and I literally spent over an hour on the phone with them this morning. They're in the process of trying to figure out if they want to buy a different house and what their kind of not end-of-life strategy, but this would be like their last move that they would do. I'm just listening to both my parents and the overwhelm that's just kind of coming up through the words and the phrases that they're saying. And I'm like, yeah, they're the type of person they would care less about the programs and the products. At the end of the day, my mom's like, I just need to talk to a human.

SPEAKER_01I don't want to talk to a call center. Like, I just, I, I need that trust. Um, and that's that's the power of what your content, what your personal brand can convey when you do it. But here's the thing most of us have not even stopped to even ask the question of ourself, right? What is your mission or what fires you up? Like, let's be honest, we're not in an industry that is just super easy and void of stress, right?

SPEAKER_01I joke that we're all missing a screw to stay in the mortgage industry, especially if you have any kind of tenure. Glutton for punishment. We're all a glutton for punishment, right? And so, like, why do you stay in here? And yes, the money can be really good, and that that is an element of it, but that certainly cannot be your driver. So, why do you keep showing up? I mean, some of the simple questions I even get out are like, what do you believe about homeownership? And if it's just that I want to empower everybody to become a homeowner, like that is the most cliche statement.

SPEAKER_01Like, what is deeper than that? An example that I love, you and I have a mutual friend. Shout out to Kelly Carr if she's listening. But she sent an email out. And I Kelly and I have worked on some stuff with content. You know, everybody nowadays it seems like a lot of people have a newsletter. A lot of people have uh, you know, an email roster that you send, right? And you should. It's a really, it's a really good tool to deplatform. But, anyways, she sends out, I think it's a monthly email, and I get a ton of emails, right? Like we're all competing for noise and what we actually read.

SPEAKER_01So your subject line is really critical. So there was something about her subject line that I was like, uh, it's Kelly. I love Kelly. I'll open her email and check. And I started to read, and this was one of the best emails that I've read in a really long time because she opens with a story. And so she starts by sharing, hey, I was preparing for an upcoming like BI group meeting where I had to share why, like my why, why I'm in in this industry. And she goes, the first thing that came to mind is the tier, you know, the elevator pitch that I've been saying for the last 15 years.

SPEAKER_01I love helping people become homeowners, blah, blah, blah. But it's the most flat, devoid of any semblance of like, oh, that's really compelling. Anyways, here's where the email got really good because she said, you know, it dawned on me. I thought of a story leading back to my dad. And she shares this story how her dad passed away when she was 14. And she had he had left her some funds in a trust that she was able to access. She closed on her very first condo three days after she turned 18.

SPEAKER_01That condo, instead of staying in the dorms, that was her housing all through college. And then she shares the really sad part is that right when she graduated college, she learned that her dad's wife had embezzled her trust fund and she lost all of her inheritance. And her one liner at the end is she said, but I still had my condo on Capitol Hill. And then she starts to say, 20 years later, however long she's been in the journey, she starts to talk about, and I realized that that single purchase helped me, blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_01And it was the it was the one thing that I had left for my dad all of these years later. And all of a sudden, I'm reading this email. I'm like spoon feeding, like line for line.

SPEAKER_03I'm listening. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01My kids are in the car. Like my husband is like getting ready to drive out the driveway. And I was like, everybody can wait. I'm finishing this email. Because now I was drawn in by a story that had a very clear conviction behind her why. There was not a shred of call me if you want me to pre-approval. There was not a shred of sales. It was just like, you know, and I'm texting her, she goes, It was my most vulnerable email I've ever sent. And I said, this is what will move the needle.

SPEAKER_01Now, here's the cool part. It wasn't just an email. She sent that email out, and a client who she had been talking with for a period of time leading up to that read the email, called her, and booked a consultation that day.

SPEAKER_03Oh my God. Like, okay, so first of all, big shout out to Kelly Carr, good friend of both of ours. She's up in the Seattle market. Anyone who's listening up in the Seattle market, please call Kelly. But even you just you telling me that story, I'm pulled in, I'm listening, I'm like, oh my God, that like I can picture it. And it's so genuine. Are you telling me that anyone who starts hearing that story from Kelly doesn't know what she believes in? That story right there immediately creates empathy. It creates trust. It creates, you actually care about what I care about.

SPEAKER_03You care about not just the transaction, but now I understand about what homeownership actually means to you.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03And that is a personal brand.

SPEAKER_01Yes. And why, okay, so you're not just closed slinging loans because that's what's putting, you know, food on the table. And there's nothing wrong with that, by the way. But all of a sudden, she found a way to unpack the layers behind her story. And she even said in her email, this was the first time that I was able to connect the dots in my own story and have like it just all lined up.

SPEAKER_03And that's amazing. And she's a veteran loan officer and has been a very high origin, you know, a high volume originator, you know, and a great originator. But I think that, you know, underneath this too, again, going back to our, you know, our point about signal versus noise, the shift in society, now AI, this feeling of like, okay, what am I doing? Why does it matter? There's something about like this full circle, like the more advanced we get with AI, what I'm also seeing is, but we're coming back to the basics.

SPEAKER_01It's like an anti, it's almost like an ant, and I don't want to say anti-AI, but to your point, it really is like, hey, we have gotten so far in perfecting and almost um glamorizing our content, right? We used to say your Instagram thread needs to have beautiful cover thumbnails, and every third one needs to be this. And in four period, that worked, right? That was kind of the algorithm, and that's, you know, that was a few years ago.

SPEAKER_01But where we are shifting right now, with in a in a society that you can outsource your voice, your pictures, your video, your copy, we are quickly being trained to trust nothing out the gate. And now you have to earn my trust because I'm starting at no trust because I'm assuming you use AI to do everything. So now I'm looking for a breadcrumb that makes me think, oh, there was a real human behind this post.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, case in point, I will not every time, but I will intentionally put a typo in my comments or my content, not be like I'm a grammar nerd. So it's like nails on a chalkboard for me to leave a typo in there. But I occasionally will do it as a signal because AI can't, like it doesn't write, it doesn't write typos, right? And so it's like for me personally, yes, I approve every single piece of content that I put out there. And I work through, I do use AI, but I work through every piece of my content.

SPEAKER_01But it's like you're saying, we're going back to the basics where we got so far off kilter for overproducing our videos and overproducing our content that, you know, I see this movement now. People are like craving IRL, right? We're in real life. So people are going the opposite way of like, hey, I want to de-platform and I'd actually like meet with you in real life.

SPEAKER_03Well, that's exactly it. I mean, and that's what's, and think about how fast this is happening. Because right, I mean, we have to have more polish, more lighting, more microphone, more, you know, editing. And then remember, like, just like two years ago, like all the reels had little emojis popping up and all the edits and the cut through, and that's what you're supposed to do. And like, we got to keep up with that and do that. And I'm like, I don't want to do that anymore. And I used to just do a bunch of like, I'm just gonna walk and talk, right? And and I like doing that. But that's exactly this full circle that has happened so quickly that people just want authenticity.

SPEAKER_03People care about what you care about, and they want that human, you know, whether it be a typo, an um, a, you know, whatever the case is. Now, you still have to have a good sound. I'm not gonna, you know, discredit all of that, but the point is just be human. That's it. And, you know, even some of the great, you know, I was on a website recently and um, you know, as a marketing website, and I was watching the promo video of it, and right in the middle of the promo video was a blooper, and he couldn't pronounce a word, and so but they kept it in there.

SPEAKER_03And when I talked to him later, I said, dude, that was the best promo video that I had seen. That blooper actually is what pulled me in and connected me.

SPEAKER_01Yes, and it breaks the pattern disrupt.

SPEAKER_03And that's the signal.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And good.

SPEAKER_01Because we're craving, I think. Here's the thing with really good produced content, there is this pressure, you know, and everybody, especially in our industry, we're all following each other, which may be good or bad, but we're seeing not everybody's stuff. And there is this like almost like this competition of like, I've got to keep up with the Joneses in terms of my content. And so it's created this pressure of like, well, my content has to be a certain caliber. Again, I'm not saying don't have us your own standard for excellence. I'm not saying throw out just spaghetti against the wall and see what sticks.

SPEAKER_01You still need to find what your level of professionalism and excellence looks for you, but do it in a way that feels natural to you and doesn't feel forced and produced, right? So there's there's some tactics that I would have with, you know, one of the things that always helps is who is your ideal client persona, right?

SPEAKER_03We'll refer to I'm doing those frameworks right now. Yes.

SPEAKER_01We yeah, we say it's like, what's your ICP? Okay. And I mean, when we when we just simplify this, I like to ask my clients, I say, when you're creating content and you're whether it's video, written, whatever it is, who do you imagine is sitting here doing this, looking at their phone, moving their thumb, and scrolling. You like if you try to create content for everybody, it's gonna speak to nobody because you can't be all things to all people. So as much as you can narrow in niche and you're gonna have multiple ICPs, right?

SPEAKER_01You're gonna have, and I would argue that you can have ideal client personas and you can also have ideal audience personas, right? There's gonna be people that are gonna consume your content that might not convert, but maybe they know somebody that knows somebody that, you know, whatever. But as much as you can get into that piece, so an example or an activity that I do with clients is when we're trying to get to that, I'll ask them, okay, as a loan officer, for example, you probably work with first-time home buyers. Great. Most of us do.

SPEAKER_01All right. But rather than just saying a first-time home buyer, because that could be the 22-year-old that just graduated college and is wanting to house hack and has very low risk, up to the 40-something year old that's got a baby on the way, they're married, they are living paycheck to paycheck, their level of risk is very different and lived experience. So let's imagine who would your who is the ideal first-time home buyer that you love working with? Like if every first-time home buyer could come to you like this. Now describe them to me, right?

SPEAKER_01Try to put a real face or a name to it. Now let's talk through okay, what were some of the fears? Like when they came to you, what kept them up? Like what, what got them off the fence? Was it really rate or was it really this? You know, so trying to break down some of that. So as much as you can try to understand who. Who is going to be looking at your content? Now, when you start thinking about, okay, I need to send an email or I need to create some content. Great. Write that content or speak to that persona.

SPEAKER_01And the more specific you can get, the better it's going to be.

SPEAKER_03Well, it's so funny. I mean, that's exactly like when I'm talking about. So I'm doing these, you know, these 60 to 90 day sprints right now, all about how do you break into any conversation, how do you become remembered? And then how do you get referrals as a part of that? And the three-part framework, I mentioned the first part, which is we need to first figure out what your purpose is, right? Because that's what's going to connect you. The second part is exactly what you just said. It's your ideal client persona framework. And as we go through that, and you know, because it's it's not often that, you know, I'll be on stage or something like that. I'll say, okay, everybody, who's your ideal client?

SPEAKER_03And some will say, anyone who needs a mortgage. And I'll say, oh, okay. So a first-time home buyer versus a savvy real estate investor that has 20 properties, same person?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, not at all.

SPEAKER_03That savvy real estate investor, you may not want. That person might crush you. Whereas somebody else might say, Yes, I want every bit of that because I'm the complicated loans guy. I'm the guy who masters, you know, wealth and real estate. Like I want, in fact, I don't want the first-time home buyers. Great. So now we're identifying. And then there's a framework that we go through again, identifying what's their problems. And I heard you say, you know, what keeps you up at night. That's exactly it. What is that 2 a.m. to 5 a.m.? Solve that right there. My whole purpose in my whole purpose in life is so you sleep at night.

SPEAKER_03If you're up worried about your mortgage, your payment, building wealth throughout real estate, what have you, I'm not doing my job. My purpose is that you sleep at night, so you don't ever have to worry about that.

SPEAKER_01Well, and I think for a long time we've believed the idea that everybody's rate sensitive. I've got to be rate competitive. And I'm like, rate is the smallest fraction to the whole part of this process. If you were to pull, you know, 10 people that came into your office, how many of them truly, all other things stripped away, were actually rate sensitive?

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_01And that that is a piece. And it's it's often it's multiple things. It's not usually just one. But at the end of the day, what is that 2 a.m. thing? Is it like, oh, do I go with five and an eighth or five? No, it's probably like, hey, is is this gonna work? Am I gonna have enough margin? Am I am I gonna be house poor? Or, you know, there's so many different things that can be kind of driving those fears. And again, there's probably many variables of that. You know, there's exercises to work through.

SPEAKER_01Okay, let's kind of do some some work to figure out what could some of those things be. Now we figure out, okay, we have our ideal client persona. We've identified some of the things that really are making them fearful. Now let's look at your story and how does your story potentially connect with their fears? How is what you do and what you're really good at, how does that speak to those fears and their needs? Great. Now let's bridge that by telling the story.

SPEAKER_01So going back to Kelly as an example, she's also a mom of young adults. So you better believe that story doesn't just connect with the first-time home buyer that might be stressing, like, should I buy my home? But I bet you it connects with all of her past clients that have bought a home before that are like, I have a grandchild who is in that position. I have a past client who has young adults that are just getting ready to go off to college. There's so many different personas now that can connect in with that one story.

SPEAKER_03Well, and again, people connect with people, not product. People care about what you care about. And so now we're creating brand identity. Now we're creating brand connection, has nothing to do with the logo behind you, it's everything to do with who you are, and that's what we're gonna connect. Okay, so let's let's shift gears a little bit because I mean, we've talked about AI, you know, it's come up in this conversation, and you know, obviously that is a big conversation. Now, you know, we could joke around and say, yeah, AI is just a fad. It's gonna go away just like the internet. Well, you know, joking around, you know, aside, of course, we have to lean into it.

SPEAKER_03And to whatever degree that means, I mean, not everybody has to become an AI, you know, expert or an AI, you know, CEO and start, you know, vibe coding and building. And you and I certainly have been, you know, going down those paths and whatnot. But as the because we have an AI-powered consumer, and as a mutual friend of ours, also Eric Post, who's the CEO and founder of Hoosie, H-U-Z-E-I. You know, says, the most important thing for us and our value is we also have to keep our humanity out in front of AI.

SPEAKER_03And what I add on top of that, it's our humanity and our humility, which I think is so much of what we're talking about. Our humility has to come through as well. And if we can put our human keep our humanity and our humility out in front or on top of AI, then that prevents AI coming on top of us, which is what it is, absolutely is trying to do. It is absolutely trying to replace all of us because transactionally it can. Yes, it can, but it doesn't mean that's what our consumer wants, and it certainly isn't what we want.

SPEAKER_03So, how do we leverage, how do we amplify with AI? So, what are you discovering? You know, certainly because you are you're very, very involved in using AI as a tool, as an amplification, you know, vehicle, if you will. Where, you know, for someone who's listening to this right now, and what I find too is a lot of people, I mean, yes, everyone's using AI to some degree, you know, whether it be just starting with a search function, or I've made it as far as I have a custom GPT, or now all of a sudden I'm starting to like clod code and build something, you know.

SPEAKER_03I mean, everyone has a varying degree. But I think there's also a lot of people that, and I was talking to a guy over the weekend about this, he's like, I just don't want to learn something new. And I get it. And I feel like there's also people like, I don't even know where to begin to even ask the questions for how AI can help me solve or do something more, you know. But so what what's in your discovering as you're working with clients and kind of the spectrum of usage? What what are you discovering? How are you helping? You know, what's what are some of your ahas with with AI?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I mean the AI overwhelm is right so real.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, the the threat is real.

SPEAKER_01It's honestly, there is not a day that goes by that I don't hear in some fashion of feedback of I'm overwhelmed, I don't know where to start. I literally had a current client text me last week because I mean, a lot of the work that I do is kind of in sprints. So, you know, I have like the initial work with helping them build out their brand book, and I can talk about that in a second. But then it's like, okay, well, what happens after that? Right. And so this individual literally texted me and was like, I feel so overwhelmed right now because I'm trying to stay in my pipeline.

SPEAKER_01I'm trying to stay on top of my team and my loans and this, that, and the other. And now I have to learn AI, exactly what you just said. They said, Can I, will you be my AI emotional support friend, comma, for a fee, of course. Right. And I was like, but in some variants, I feel like we all can somewhat identify with that. Like, I don't have all the time in the world to be going and learning the best prompts or how to use this. And it is a very new tool to know how to leverage. So, you know, going back to, I think you asked, you know, how am I guiding people through this process?

SPEAKER_01The way that I have approached it very early on is I've remained curious. Now, when I first learned about, you know, I first heard about AI, my husband told me about it. My husband is in technology and he has always been an early adopter. And so this was almost three years ago now, where he was like, Oh, have you heard of Chat GPT? And I was like, What is that? Like, this is before it was even common.

SPEAKER_03I just think we all have our moment when like we heard about Chat GPT for the first time, which is crazy. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I was like, so he was like, look at what this can do. And so he gave me an example, and I was like, I mean, I just like my brain was unlocked. I was like, I feel like I'm in an altered dimension. I don't even know how to fathom this. So, you know, from very early on, I saw the potential. And so for me, I have remained very curious. What is AI? What does that mean for my role? How could it help me? How can I learn it? So I have just integrated into my life and my business because I want to just to learn.

SPEAKER_01But second to that, you know, I joke that I was AI before AI was AI. What I mean by that is how I started in the mortgage industry and doing what I'm doing now is I knew nothing about mortgage. I knew how to market. I had worked for other industries, but I'd never been in the mortgage industry specifically. And I got a I got a job with a team, a couple of top producers, and I knew nothing about the mortgage space. But I instantly had to ghost write all of their content as if I was them and I had no context for the industry.

SPEAKER_01So I was consuming every podcast, every book, every blog that I could. And really what was the differentiator for me is I sat between their offices and I said, Hey, every time you have a conversation where you can leave the door open, will you? And so what I did is I spent three years eavesdropping on their conversations. How do they talk to a nervous buyer? How do they overcome a rate objection? How do they pitch a builder? How do they talk with a loan or a realtor? Right. So I was learning how what their scripting is, their value proposition, what have you.

SPEAKER_01And I got to the point where I could ghostwrite all of their content, even their thank you cards. Like I just wrote as them. And so you fast forward and you think about like that is one of the roles that AI does for us today, is the whole point is that your AI gets to know who you are and it can help you think and it can help write your content as if it is you. And so that's where I started with AI. And so that's really the role that I play now, helping service providers, loan officers, coaches, really anybody in the mortgage and real estate space define some of those foundational questions of your brand, your brand.

SPEAKER_01Who are you? What do you do? Who do you serve? What makes you different? And then we build together, I help them build a brand book, which basically puts to words some of those descriptions. And now you can use that tool in your AI platforms to help it serves as a single source of truth, just for me.

SPEAKER_03And we'll put the link in the show notes. But I mean, everybody, you need to check out what Katie has built with her brand book. And, you know, and I went through the process with you, Katie, early on, you know, as you're, you know, developing this. And, you know, what's so powerful, and you know, one of the most amazing things that AI can do among many, obviously, is being, and again, we'll use the word again, is being able to cut through the noise. You can just brain dump into whatever AI platform you're doing, ask it to synthesize what you just said. I mean, ask it to give you back what you're looking for. And it really has an uncanny ability of to take that entire brain dump and put it into a very concise sentence or bullet point.

SPEAKER_03You're like, oh, that's it. How come I couldn't think of it?

SPEAKER_01Couldn't I say that? Right. Yep.

SPEAKER_03No, it'll go off in some different directions, right? And that that's where it gets hard because in one hand it's simplifying. And as it's simplifying in its one hand, it's complicating in the other hand. And I think that's what your brand book has done very well at is you've pre-engineered a lot of, you know, these prompts and this and these other factors to help train your AI and build out your AI team, if you will, so that you always have this access point to go to it. And now it's not just brand as a singular strategy, it's brand as a dynamic strategy to the market that we're constantly evolving, you know, from there.

SPEAKER_03And so it's such a foundational item, you know.

SPEAKER_01And the brand book, I mean, just as you said, it's not meant to be a set it and forget it tool, right? I mean, who the business that you have today probably looks very different than the business business that you had even 18 months ago, just because the market that we're in is different. Maybe your book of business has changed. Maybe you've moved to a different company or a different location. So if you think about it in that way, you as a person and you as a brand are going to grow and evolve.

SPEAKER_03As you should.

SPEAKER_01As you should. That is like a healthy signal. And so you want your brand foundations to change. Some of the things that probably aren't going to change are things like your origin story. How did you get into this business? Some of your backstory, I say every brand story has a good backstory. But again, it's a it's a foundational tool that starts there where most people are going to, you know, just chat GPT, Claude, maybe Gemini, and they're trying to write content.

SPEAKER_01And they're like, why does this not sound like me?

SPEAKER_03And I think that's what has turned a lot of people. It turned me away too. Because that was sort of the initial, like, okay, the the the first blush with AI for a lot of people is like, oh my gosh, it can create a whole month of content for me. Let's do that. This is amazing. And then you start looking at it, you're like, I don't sound like that. And I sure as hell never say the word fluff. You know, and I don't use M-dashes like this, right? That's kind of always my, I don't have the straight talk, right? So you also start digging into it, like, I hate it. I don't want it to do it. I don't want to do that anymore. Right. And so that's the sort of full circle.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because it's like, yeah, I would never, I would never talk like that in real life. So then they kind of swing the other direction of like, well, AI sucks. And it's like, well, no, you need to be trained. If you think of AI like a tool or an extension of your team, there's also a layer that comes with having to train it, right? If you hired somebody, a real human to do all of your copywriting for your social media, or you hired a marketing person or whatever that looks like, there is going to be an onboarding, a let's get to know each other as the sorts.

SPEAKER_01And so that's where the brand book helps accelerate that. It serves as a single source of truth. So whether you're working with uh, you know, an outside agency of real humans, or you're working with your AI team, you're kind of you're all on the same page contextually.

SPEAKER_03And you're organized.

SPEAKER_01What?

SPEAKER_03And you're organized.

SPEAKER_01And you're organized. And then you can update that document. So say you're like, oh, my company just came out with a new product and I'm really good at this, and I really want to pursue being a divorce specialist or going after new construction or adding in another vertical. Great. Now you already have your brand book. So all you need to do is add in another ICP, another ideal client persona. Let's go after this. And that's where AI can get really helpful. It's not just for writing content. Like that's that's one really helpful use case of so many.

SPEAKER_01You know, you can have it look at being like a business coach. And I would never say that it should replace human coaches because that's obscene. But for little one-off things like, okay, hey, I'm feeling stuck in this area, knowing everything you know about my content strategy or my marketing strategy or my sales, whatever it is, what are three ways that I might be able to leverage this? So you can start asking questions and organize some of your thoughts, but it still doesn't replace you, the human in the loop.

SPEAKER_01And it still doesn't replace your actual team. We still need coaches. We still need all of that.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_03And I mean, I have a client who's a CEO of a company, and that's exactly what we've been doing. I said, look, this is use Chat GPT to brain dump because we're we're solving some very complicated things. We're solving some, we're solving for some very complicated relationships as well. You need such an immense amount of outlet to get everything out and to be able to find all these nooks and crannies and to be able to. The other thing is AI is non-judgment. It's, I mean, it's not human, even though it can sound like human, but there's a no-judgment zone.

SPEAKER_03There's an ability to completely brain dump. And I have to say, then he would forward me all of ChatGPT's responses, then I would give him some additional kind of coaching on ask ChatGPT, talk like this, make sure you're uncovering this, for example. But I'm telling you, and and talking about, you know, the the you know what was going on. ChatGPT's analysis of the situation was so good. And I was learning from it as well because I was getting these insights for what from the brain dump. And it really, really helped us solve this really big complicated problem faster with insight.

SPEAKER_03And, you know, for example, like as a coach, I'm not trying to give them the answers. What I'm coaching them on is to make sure that we're asking the right questions so we go through, so we can know that we're going through the right amount of decision process that will lead us to the answers. And that is what AI, you know, in this primitive form, is so good at. And quite often we jump right to a conclusion, we jump right to an answer because that's what we think we're supposed to do, and we're trying to get to that, but we might miss some very, very important branches on this tree, you know.

SPEAKER_03And so it was a really good example of an experience. And this is, and I say in its primitive form because this is still in very much a an ask, right? A search engine, an ask. And AI is moving from asking to now doing, building, yeah, you know, and so there's this evolution, there's this velocity, you know, and you know, this kind of next frontier.

SPEAKER_01It's so fast, it's changing so fast. You know, as somebody that is in it full time all the time, it's still incredibly overwhelming. Like I know you and I are very much, I would say, very forward adopters of this.

SPEAKER_03Trying to be.

SPEAKER_01And it still feels like you're being waterboarded every day. And, you know, there's there's new apps, there's new tools, there's new all of these things. And, you know, I had a moment a couple weekends ago where I really struggled because I was like, hey, when I first jumped headfirst into this, like I was one of a few, at least in our industry, that were like starting to really get loud about this. And I'm like, and now everybody's an AI expert and AI consultant, everybody's got an app, and at least that's kind of how it feels. And so then I had this moment of internal conflict of like, okay, well, how am I different from anybody else and my messaging and my value offer?

SPEAKER_01And, you know, I just went back to hey, at the end of the day, we will always need brand foundations. We always need to get really clear. I hate using the word clarity because it's so overused now. But at the end of the day, we always need to be clear on our value proposition. That's why I think what you do is so important because you're helping people understand what is your mission, what is your vision. Those are core foundational things that you should be able to answer, you need to answer.

SPEAKER_01Then you bring in AI after the fact. And how can that as a tool help leverage what you're doing instead of replacing all of those things?

SPEAKER_03And I'm going through the exact same. You and I are in a similar path, right? And I feel the same way that that overwhelm, or as I'm building something and I'm trying to build something very big and very powerful, you know, profit and like you know what you and I've talked about, and some of you guys in the audience are, you know, are familiar. But the velocity of AI widgetry hitting the market. And I'm and I was just at the gathering, you know, in Austin, the housing wire event, and there's so much AI product. And I'm asking myself, what of these are going to be here next year?

SPEAKER_03And by the time we even get something rolled out, is it too late to get to advance past that?

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_03And, you know, and this next frontier of AI, you know, with open claw that hits the world and this what I call an AI agency, again, going from asking AI to do something and it was is responsive, to then now creating an AI org chart of AI employees that are managing each other to then go out and do things on your behalf under, and I'll say that again, under management, and then you can just text and speak to it. That is, I mean, this is this is wild.

SPEAKER_03And that's just one big vertical. Then you have the the build vertical within AI, which is again what I'm doing through Claude Code, what you're doing, and now so many other people are doing. So then again, you sit back and say, okay, wait a second, because I'm going through this. Exactly what you just said. Like I'm excited about what I'm building, but not to lose sight of what I do.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And there's there's a difference there. And what I do, right? Helping people find purpose, lead with purpose, and really amplify their brand, themselves, living in their genius zone, so they can lead more effectively and be connected into their business and their success in their life. You know, I mean, I often say my joy per my joy, purpose, and passion is helping you succeed on purpose, but in your design, not just my design, and being able to extract that. So that's not AI, that's human. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Right. But then we can use it to amplify.

SPEAKER_01And that's not gonna change. That's the beautiful part, is it's not gonna change because at the end of the day, people are always gonna want to buy and sell homes and people are always gonna want to do business with people. Is AI massively disrupting what normal has looked like and will look like? Absolutely. And are some roles gonna be absolved or kind of changed? They already are and they will for sure. But at the end of the day, if your goal is to be like you're saying, how can I be human?

SPEAKER_01How can I be a real person? How can I continue to be so clear on the problems that I solve and be so resolute in finding the people that have that problem and being so convinced that you're really good at what you do? and you can help them from a place of service, you'll be fine. I mean, it's it's it's Rocky trying to sort this all out, but again, I think Yeah. You just you have to be really clear on on your why and your conviction and let that that lead you.

SPEAKER_03AI will not replace you if you don't let it. AI wants to replace the transaction. So you have to then protect the relationship.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And but isn't that in a way I feel like AI has maybe amplified some of the problems or the core things that we've needed to already be good at. We have always been in the relationship business. No matter what facet of sales that you're in, that should always remain the core is that I'm in the people business. Good marketing, whether AI is involved or not, should always be answering the question what problem do I solve? Why am I different and why am I better and who do I help?

SPEAKER_01The all of your core efforts should already be working toward answering those questions. AI has just made it loud and has amplified it. And I think the people that can get really clear at answering some of those questions are going to stand out.

SPEAKER_03Katie, the last question I want to ask you if there is one word, or it could be a couple words, but if there's one word that you want everyone to from this conversation to remember, what is it?

SPEAKER_01Remember. I would say curiosity. If you can remain curious, let your curiosity carry you. So some of us are curious in a lot of different directions, but going back to what you care about and what your convictions are, if you let your curiosity carry you into those directions, you will find yourself in opportunities you might not have otherwise if you had just tried to keep yourself in a traditional box. And I think your curiosity will allow you to explore, experiment, and you know try different things that your other competitors might not.

SPEAKER_03And curiosity is one of the greatest characteristics of leadership.

SPEAKER_01So I would say unless you're a cat, then we all know what happens to the cat.

SPEAKER_03That's probably more mischievous than curiosity. Well I appreciate I appreciate you coming on talking some shit. I mean this again is just such a good centering grounding conversation getting our brand identity you know as that signal versus the absolute noise behind us. But here's the great thing that's your competitive edge because it is so noisy there's so many logos behind us. There's so much corporate marketing that's getting in the way it's actually if you're listening to this that is your competitive edge. So be the signal the be brand identity that you are we just have to surface it and extract it and then let's get it to market.

SPEAKER_01So yep.

SPEAKER_03Awesome. Katie, where can people find you?

SPEAKER_01KatieShife.com and I'm most active on LinkedIn and Instagram just by my name KatieShife. I'm pretty easy to find and love the real conversations. I answer all my DMs I write all my content. So if you reach out it's yours truly behind the response.

SPEAKER_03It's the real human. Well I appreciate you coming on guys check out Katie for sure. You're gonna love the content she's producing. You're just gonna love Katie. She's a rad human being she's a fellow member of the Good Human Club as we like to say and uh and definitely check out her brand book the service she provides the brand book the personal coaching that comes with that it will change your business and it might change your life I mean it's it's that good and it's again I'm gonna say it again. I've been called a business therapist myself and I never realized that before I got into this I was like oh there is that vertical right there.

SPEAKER_00There is that vertical right there.

SPEAKER_03All right Katie Apicy coming on everybody thanks for joining us for another episode of Talk and shift see you again soon. Hey thanks for joining me today on Talking Shift I hope you enjoyed it and I'm looking forward to seeing you on our next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Preventing Burnout with Dr. Sharon Grossman

    Nov 17, 202654 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your best people aren't always leaving for more money; they're leaving because they don't feel valued. Dr. Sharon Grossman shares the daily habits that make people want to stay and prevent burnout. I...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. From Tragedy to Triumph: How Rob Beckner became a $100 million producer despite all the odds

    Nov 4, 202653 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail A severed spine ended his successful construction career overnight. Here is how Rob Beckner rebuilt his mind, redefined rock bottom, and rose to become a $100 million producer in the mortgage business....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 3D Printed Homes with Robert Spiegel

    Sep 7, 202651 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail How do we solve for housing affordability and obtainability in America? And as natural disasters continue to destroy homes and communities, how do we build housing that is not only more affordable, but...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Alan Mack: Building the Luxury Niche

    Aug 24, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Mortgage industry veteran Alan Mack spent years as a top producer for the big banks. But when corporate red tape began stripping away his personal brand and limiting how he could serve clients, he made...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Escaping The Identity Trap with Angelica Ventrice

    Aug 10, 202644 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Former top pharmaceutical sales rep and fitness entrepreneur turned Executive and Leadership Coach and TEDx Speaker, Angelica Ventrice joins Craig to Talk Shift about how so many of us, especially high...

    Credit the people on this episode