Send me a message. This week I'm digging into curriculum consultations - specifically the one currently open for Northern Ireland's Technology and Design curriculum, which I helped draft and which closes on 30 September. Before getting into the detail, I wanted to clear up something that keeps coming up in conversations, including one I had only today: what a national curriculum document actually does. In England and Northern Ireland, these documents say what should be taught and why - not how to teach it. The how belongs to teachers, drawing on their professional knowledge of pedagogy and how design and technology capability develops over time. That distinction matters when you're deciding what to say in a consultation response. I also share an insight from the international comparative research project I'm currently leading across fourteen countries: unlike England's three-page document, several other countries' policies go much further, setting out assessment, teaching time, and even pedagogical guidance. It's a reminder that "national curriculum" means very different things in different places. Then I walk through the five questions in the Northern Ireland consultation one by one, explaining what each is really asking and how to use the optional comment boxes to make your response count - whether you teach in Northern Ireland or you're watching from elsewhere to see how a consultation like this works. If you're in Northern Ireland, please do respond before 30 September - and talk it through with your department first. What would you want a new curriculum document to protect, and what would you happily see change? I'd love to hear your answer. Why national curriculum debates feel so personal Consultation on the Northern Ireland Curriculum 2028 Technology and design: Draft curriculum framework for Public Consultation Subscribe on your podcast app, share this with your D&T team, and if it helped, leave a review so more teachers can find it. Support the show If you like the podcast, you can always buy me a coffee to say 'thanks!' Please offer your feedback about the show or ideas for future episodes and topics by connecting with me on Threads @hardy_alison or by emailing me. If you listen to the podcast on Apple Podcasts, please take a moment to rate and/or review the show. If you want to support me by becoming a Patron click here. If you are not able to support me financially, please consider leaving a review on Apple Podcasts or sharing a link to my work on social media. Thank you!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Alison HardyYou're listening to the Talking D&T Podcast. I'm Dr. Alison Hardy, a writer, researcher, and advocate of design and technology education. In each episode, I share views, news, and opinions about D&T. In last week's episode, I hinted at a few things I was going to revisit in future episodes. So here goes. In this week's episode, I'm going to start to chat a little bit about curriculum consultations.
Alison HardyI'm going to mainly focus on the Northern Ireland one, but for those of you listening from other countries and territories, I still think it's worth hanging around. Because I want to start by talking about what in England and Northern Ireland a national curriculum does and does not do, and how the fact that I'm talking to colleagues in other countries and territories about their curriculum, their national curriculum for this subject design and technology, what their documents do.
Alison HardySo I've had a bit of a deeper insight more recently about that. And then I want to talk a little bit about the questions that are asked in the consultation for Northern Ireland to help people who might be listening from Northern Ireland to get to grips with what's been asked and not to feel intimidated. And that might give others and other countries a bit of an insight about how you can get involved and what you can respond to, and also, like I said last week, why it's important to.
Alison HardySo in England and Northern Ireland, because I've been involved in the drafting of both of those, only the Northern Ireland one, as I record this, is currently available in draft form for consultation. The England one we anticipate will come out soon. Um, but there's a lot of pressure on these documents, these policy documents, to solve lots of things. Um and I've had a little bit of a debate today, so that gives a bit of a hint for those people who know what the chat is in LinkedIn about this, about what the what a curriculum document um can do.
Alison HardyBecause some people are confusing a curriculum document as it's written in England and Northern Ireland, and they are two different documents. Please don't think I'm conflating those two territories or jurisdictions. They are a document that details what the purpose is of the subject and what content children should be taught. It doesn't say how it should be taught, it's not a teaching guide for England or for Northern Ireland, it's a document that relays what should be taught and why it is important that children are taught that subject.
Alison HardySo when somebody says, for example, that the curriculum should give an opportunity for doing projects and solving problems for designing and for making, those are actually a teacher's responsibility. That's what they have agency and power over. Now I can hear teachers saying we don't have a lot of power or agency or influence over that.
Alison HardyBut that's where you do have your professional authority. For these two national curricula, they just talk about what should be taught. Okay? In terms of how it should be taught, then teachers need to look in other places and other spaces for the different pedagogical choices they have, you know, whether they do an open design problem, a closed design problem, whether they do it as a design activity only, or a making activity, or an exploration of an impact of technological developments, the teacher has the choice to take those different approaches.
Alison HardyAnd much has been written about those signature pedagogies. And um, Matt McLean and Sarah Finnegan have updated the chapter on um how to teach design and technology in the fifth edition of the Learn to Teach book. That's plug number one for the book, okay? If you're doing a bingo card, um so that's where the challenges become, and also alongside that, a teacher needs to understand how children learn and achieve what the aims of the subject are, and what what that is needed, how how you know how children will gain that learning, hold that learning, use that learning as in their design and technology capability.
Alison HardySo teachers need to have an understanding about how that happens. And so when people say, Oh, I don't need to understand educational theory about learning, I'm like, hang on a minute. You need to be able to understand that there are different perspectives and be able to articulate what what your view is based on those different perspectives because they are voices of authority. Anyway, I've kind of got off a tangent here, blindly. I'm kind of feel like I'm entering into an education lecture.
Alison HardyWhat I'm what I'm trying to say is there's there's the choice about what should be taught, there's and that's in the curriculum documents in England and for Northern Ireland too. There's the choices about how it should be taught, okay, and ways it could be taught that a teacher has within their toolbox, and they select those based on their understanding and knowledge and expertise of how children learn and how their design and technology capability grows over time.
Alison HardyAnd so this is why teaching is complex. So my pushback or my challenge sometimes to people who are saying, um, I want the national curriculum to um give the opportunity to design, make, and evaluate, that's actually a teacher's choice. It's the what are they learning whilst they are design, making and evaluating, and what are they getting better at in terms of how is their D&T capability growing?
Alison HardyOkay. So I'll put a link to that blog post that I wrote. Okay, because it's got more to it than that, but that's all I kind of want to touch on here. But before I move on, I want to acknowledge that in other countries and territories, those policy documents offer so much more. So I'm currently leading uh an international comparative study on how policies in different places define the content, the pedagogy, the assessment, the teaching time, teacher training, and so on.
Alison HardyAnd people have had to fill out this um survey to capture all of the analysis of how it's done in their countries. Now, for England, when I did ours, it's only three pages long. There's no guidance on assessment for um compulsory education for what we would call key stage three, 11 to 14-year-olds, which is the area we're focusing on. There's no guidance on how much teaching time, there's no uh stipulation on how it should be taught in government policy and the national curriculum.
Alison HardyBut in other countries, there is. It's not necessarily stipulation, but there's a clear articulation about it. So that's been a real uh insight for me uh to see how other countries do, and I'm looking forward to learning from other countries about what they talk about. So let's move on from that around what national curriculum documents do in England and then also in Northern Ireland, and how that actually differs from other jurisdictions, territories, and countries.
Alison HardyAnd let's now start to think about the consultation that is happening in Northern Ireland. Now that ends on the 30th of September, although I have seen a date of the 25th of September, but I'm going with the 30th of September. And as I said last week, I think it's really important for teachers to respond because the more voices that respond, if there's a particular issue that comes out and more teachers comment on that, it's more likely to be listened to than if one teacher comments on it.
Alison HardyAnd also, patterns can emerge between primary and post-primary, as it's called in Northern Ireland. Um, in other places it's called secondary, um, elementary. I might have gone that wrong. Please don't, please forgive me other countries if I've got that wrong. But anyway, we get the idea. So the more of you respond, the more insights the departments for education, the government gets it to about how this has landed before it actually gets the point of it being official.
Alison HardyAnd I know in Northern Ireland I've been asked what's my availability in October if I'm needed to go back and look at any of the feedback and respond to it. Okay, so so that's you know, so in Northern Ireland they are gearing themselves up for that. Now I might not be needed. Um but so so that's that's the context. In the consultation in Northern Ireland, you can respond to lots of different things about different subjects, but I'm only going to focus on technology and design, okay?
Alison HardyBecause that's what I was involved with. Um that's my that's my passion, that's my drive. And I'm not here now to say what I think you should write. I'm here to encourage you to respond and what to share what the different questions are and what you might want to comment on. Okay, but without saying what you should comment on, or what you should comment.
Alison HardyThere you go, that's better. So when you open up the document, all I've been able to do is take screenshots. So I'm I'm taking this from my transcribe notes, okay? So it starts off by saying technology and design will be taught from foundation stage to key stage three. At primary level, it is intended that science, technology, and design will ultimately be structured as one subject, but to show clarity of progression to post-primary and encourage focused subject-based feedback, they have been presented as two subject frameworks in this consultation.
Alison HardyOkay, so in other words, this is reflecting that previously in primary, the curriculum was organized, and I'm going to get the language long wrong, but I'm I'm trying my hardest, around areas, and what we might see as technology and design sat within this area called the world around us. And I believe that also included science.
Alison HardyTo bridge that transition in primary teachers' experiences to this movement to this new curriculum, they're now calling it in primary science, technology, and design. In post-primary, it's technology and design, and science is a separate subject, but in the consultation, they're asking you to respond by the subject, even though that's not how it will be taught in primary.
Alison HardyOkay, so that's the introduction. So these questions, when you respond, if you're in primary and you're expecting or you have a view of technology and design, or this subject science, technology, and design, you are likely to have to respond to technology and design and the science part of the consultation separately. You might end up posting the same responses.
Alison HardyOkay, be canny about it. So there are five questions, and I think that's great. It's nice and straightforward. Question one: to what extent does the vision statement clearly capture the purpose, identity, and distinctive contribution of the subject area? In other words, what we've written or what we've proposed, or what has been proposed, because I led a group to do it, but I know that it then goes to a central team and they've um edited sections to have a consistency across all the subjects.
Alison HardyAnyway, there's a vision statement. That's the long and the short of it, okay. What do you think about it? Does it does it does it clearly capture what the subject's about, its distinctive nature? And then there's a selection of from do not know to very effectively. Okay. What I particularly love is there's a space for optional comments. I love it. Okay, too often in these consultations they there isn't a free open space.
Alison HardySo here I would suggest in the optional comments, if you think it's very effective or effective, or just about adequate, say why. Maybe copy and paste bits and say this bit really captures it for me, or this bit doesn't, or I can't get a sense of any mention about, okay. Does it make it clear that it's a distinctive subject area?
Alison HardyOkay. What's differentiating it from art and design, science, home economics? Okay. You might want to do that as a bit of a comparison because that that makes it easier uh for readers to understand kind of where you're coming from. In question two, it says to what extent do the organizing categories for content appropriately reflect the key dimensions of learning within the subject?
Alison HardyNow, the content for technology and design is presented under four dimensions. Okay, now let's be really clear, these are not dimensions that you use to plan and organise a curriculum, in other words, as a teacher, what you will teach and how you will teach it and in what order. But do those organizing categories, those those four dimensions, do they capture the subject?
Alison HardyNow at the end of the vision statement, we talk about how we don't see them as distinct, how we see them as having an overlap, but there are elements of distinctness. But you know, do you agree with the titles of them? Do you um think the there is an implication of about uh priority? We we've tried to write it that it doesn't imply that one dimension is more important than the other, because we don't think there are. That's my personal view, but you might read it differently. This is all about also about the presentation, the wording.
Alison HardyUm you know, is it clear? Does it make sense? Okay. Question Does it is there anything there that's you feel is missing that's not captured in those dimensions? And then question three really moves on to the content. And question three asks, how well does the subject framework cover the most important content? And that's really important. It doesn't cover all the content, it's the most important content, it's what they are entitled to be taught as a baseline, okay, should learn in this subject.
Alison HardyConsider whether the framework includes the knowledge, concept, skills, and disciplinary. That's the particular way of thinking and understanding in technology and design. Does it does it catch all of those in a ways that matters the things that matter the most? Okay. So again, this is where you might want to look at things that you have taught, things that you really believe in, things that you think are missing from what you have been doing, that you think are central.
Alison HardyAre they there? Do they appear in the content? Are they implied? Are you things that are things that are missing? Why, if the things that are missing, you need to go then a stage further, I believe. You don't have to, but it would really help those people who are reading it. Why is it important? What does it add that something else doesn't? And then this is something you might want to think about. If you put that in, what would you take out?
Alison HardyBecause there's there's only so much teaching time. So we've got to be very conscious about not overloading the subject framework, and that's why this language of the most important content is key. And then question four, god, I think this is another good question. Is content I wasn't involved in any writing of these questions, okay? Um, so this is not me blowing my own trumpet here.
Alison HardyIs content appropriately sequenced across the foundation stage, key stage one, key stage two, key stage three? So if you're teaching something in foundation stage, and it or it's no, that's not you're not teaching it. If there's something in the content for foundation stage for technology and design, can you see how or whether that leads into something in key stage one and onto key stage two and key stage three? And also the reverse, if there's something in key stage two, can you follow it backwards to see how that develops and builds from foundation stage?
Alison HardyNow you're really going to have to get your thinking hats on there to kind of see that. But but is it sequenced? You know, we did a lot of work around that, but we might have missed something. And we need to know, because then that will inform an improved version of this, and an improved version will only make it better for all people who are teaching technology and design in Northern Ireland and consequently better for the children that you're teaching.
Alison HardySo, is it appropriately sequenced? Okay, and do you have any other comments regarding this subject framework? Again, I love it. I love an open questions. Have we missed something? You know, that hasn't been considered. Um, assessments, pedagogy are being considered elsewhere, but you might want to put in something. Well, how is this going to be assessed? What's the ways of assessing? What's the ways of teaching this?
Alison HardyUm, I'm hoping to run some events in the next week uh for primary and post-primary teachers in Northern Ireland. But if I don't get to that, as I said before, I'm on a recovery coming back from an operation, I'm still in a boot, I'm still tiring easily. So it's all kind of how I can manage my well-being amongst all this. If I don't, I'm hoping this podcast has given uh colleagues in Northern Ireland something to start with, but I would absolutely encourage you to respond.
Alison HardyBecause if you don't feed back, it's not going to get any better. And come on, we're involved in the world of design. So we want to give feedback, we want to improve. This current version is the current resolution, it's not the finished version, and even when it is published, it's not finished because there's always going to be a critique of it. But this is your opportunity to do it. So please, please, please do that. The more of you that respond, the more, you know, if there's if there's themes, if there's consensus, or even if there's dissonance, do you mean where you don't agree with something, or what you might be the lone voice, you still have to put it in there.
Alison HardyOkay, I really would encourage you. Right. Well, I think um I think I've emphasised my point long enough there, and um I hope that all makes sense. I'll be back when the England National Curriculum Consultation is to do this again. Um hopefully I'll be back before then, because I don't know when that one's going to come out. Um I promised that I would do some episodes around the PAC conference, about authentic learning, about this project that I'm doing. God made it all sorts of things I promised.
Alison HardyUm so I've done this one and I'm now going to get my tea. Thanks for listening. I'm Dr. Alison Hardy, and you've been listening to the Talking D&T Podcast. If you enjoyed the podcast, then do subscribe on whatever platform you use and do consider leaving a review as it does help others find the podcast. I do the podcast because I want to support the D&T community in developing their practice, so please do share the podcast with your D&T community. If you want to respond to something I've talked about or have an idea for a future episode, then either leave me a voice member via Speakpipe or drop me an email.
Alison HardyYou can find details about me, the podcast, and how to connect with me on my website, dralisonhardy.com. Also, if you want to support the podcast financially, you can become a patron. Links to Speakpipe, Patreon, and my website are in the show notes. Thanks for listening.
Send me a message. I’ve been away for a while, and coming back means being honest about why: an Achilles rupture that never healed properly, surgery at the end of July, and six weeks in a boot that has forced me to slow...
Send me a message. I recently attended an event at Nottingham Trent University that wasn't really aimed at me - but it got me thinking in ways I wasn't expecting. Industry designers were talking to final-year product...
Send me a message. A curriculum can look tidy on paper while the teacher behind it is quietly thinking, “Am I getting this right?” We sit with that reality and treat it seriously, because design and technology education...
Send me a message. D&T curriculum leadership often feels like making consequential calls with half a map. When time is squeezed, pupils disengage, policies shift, and senior leaders want clear rationales, it is easy to...
Send me a message. The best support in Design and Technology rarely looks dramatic. It looks like a calm voice re-reading instructions, a bigger print-out placed quietly on a bench, a checklist that turns panic into...