Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Worth Talking About

Talk Worth Talking About artwork

Shame Redeemed: Learning to Live in Christ's Freedom

Nov 2, 202629 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever felt like you needed to win God’s approval? Do you sometimes think you’ll never be good enough? Shame is something we don’t often like to talk about, but it affects all of us in one way or another. On this episode, Ryan talks with Toni Kim, author of Shame Redeemed: Learning to Live in Christ’s Freedom about topics from the book, including what shame is, how it affects our lives, and how we can find freedom from it in Christ. Toni Kim has been the director of spiritual care for the National Association of Evangelicals since 2021. For 17 years, she served as a minister at Park Street Church in downtown Boston, where she helped found the disabilities ministry Enable Boston. Toni received her B.S. in applied math from Yale University, and a Master in Christian Studies from Regent College, with a double concentration in Biblical languages and interdisciplinary studies. Her thesis was on what the Bible says about shame and how that impacts Asian American evangelism and spiritual formation. In 2021, she completed Harvard Kennedy School of Government's Public Leadership Credential. Toni is a licensed minister with the Conservative Congregational Christian Conference. Toni serves on the board of governors for Regent College and visiting board for Taylor University. Previously, she was on the advisory council for the Fuller Center for Spiritual Formation, the founding board of Joni and Friends Greater Boston and board vice chair of a local Christian community development organization. She and her husband Walter currently reside in Charlottesville, VA, and have two adult children, including a daughter with Down syndrome who lives up to her middle name of Joy. Click here to purchase Shame Redeemed: Learning to Live in Christ's Freedom on Amazon. The Bible app has a special FREE 6-day "Shame Redeemed" devotional plan; click here to check it out. Want to hear more from Toni Kim? Check out this video of her recent speaking engagement at Taylor University chapel.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

00:00:00 Ryan: Hi, I'm Ryan Long. Welcome to WBCL's first episode of Talk Worth Talking About. And today we're talking about an issue that a lot of people don't really like to talk about. Shame. It's something that we all deal with, but something that we really like to avoid, if at all possible. Well, today we're talking with Toni Kim, author of Shame Redeemed, Learning to Live in Christ's Freedom. And man, this book has changed my life. I'm so excited to talk with her. Welcome, Toni Kim. It's great to have you on Talk Worth Talking about. And you know, shame is one of those topics that I think has become popular to talk about lately. But your book, I loved the introduction. Kurt Thompson did not pull any punches. He was like, we can talk till we're blue in the face about this and still not deal with it and still not deal with it with the Lord. And I'd love to start kind of at the beginning with you. How did you get started on this decades long journey with talking and researching shame? 00:01:25 Toni Kim: Yeah. You know, I think coming from an Asian background, I just grew up in the culture of shame. And a lot of it was negative, but some of it was actually, redemptive. And I became a Christian in high school and then got involved with InterVarsity as a college student. And InterVarsity was very intentional about getting Asian Americans together. And as we were talking about the experience of shame, realizing that the Bible was written to a shame based culture. And so part of the journey was realizing that what I had seen as a negative, part of my story. Oh, I you know, there's so much shame in my culture ended up becoming this blessing because it gave us a different window with which to read the scriptures. 00:02:17 Ryan: That was one of the really interesting things I thought that you brought up, is that shame and its associated emotion guilt are not necessarily bad in and of themselves. They can actually be warning signs, much like pain is a warning sign for the body. And I thought that was really interesting to think about. And especially for people that come from cultures that are more comfortable with the concept of shame as something that's part of the culture. You know, I think sometimes American culture can chafe that a little bit. And we have this cultural crisis, which you talk about a little bit in your book. What was that experience like for you? 00:03:02 Toni Kim: I do think that American culture does tend toward in be more individualistic and tend toward guilt. And but then social media has really changed that hasn't it? Because first off, when it first started, there was a lot of shamelessness that was going on, you know, that things that you wouldn't say to a person face to face, you would say, via social media. So there was this kind of shameless behavior. And then with all the kind of cancel culture that's also, that's shame on the negative sense of like, we shame people by canceling them. And so now it doesn't matter what ethnic background you come from, we're all kind of swimming in this shame culture where we feel like we have to be hyper vigilant about what we say or do because something we say or do could go viral and haunt us for a really long time, devastate us. 00:03:55 Ryan: And so what you know, you mentioned, you know, coming from your Asian culture, that kind of drew you to have an interest in this intersection with shame and its relationship with, you know, I don't know if relationship is the right word, but with, you know, how we view it and how we interact with it. Can you talk about how you started to think about that not just in relation to your culture, but also in relation to the Bible and faith? You know, you talked about how the Bible was written to people who come, you know, who were in a shame based culture. Would you can you unpack just even that statement a little bit for people that maybe aren't as familiar with the Bible in its original context? 00:04:43 Toni Kim: Love it. Yeah. I mean, so the beginning of the Bible, when God creates everything and creates, humans, it says that Adam and his wife were naked and they felt no shame. And so there, I mean, they also felt no guilt. But that's not the point of the story. The point of the story is that they felt no shame. And there's something that is really appealing about that to all of us. Again, no matter what cultural background you come from. But so even the beginning of the Bible is framed in terms of here, the kind of visceral problem we have is one of shame and pointing out that, God's original design was that there was no shame, that there was free communion between God and his people, between Adam and Eve. That's the way we were designed to be. But of course, it didn't last very long. So. But I think somehow in our imaginations, we can talk about creation, but then we talk about fall. And then we talk about, we feel like we're destined to live. Expelled from Eden. And in this, like fallen state until Christ comes again. But even in Genesis chapter three, there is good news about our shame because yeah, he deals with our guilt. And there are curses there's punishment. But in Genesis three twenty one, it says that the Lord God made garments of skin and clothed Adam and his wife. And you think about, when, shame makes us want to hide, which is why Adam and Eve, they took their fig leaves. They hid behind the trees. And what we're afraid of is being exposed. And we're afraid that that's what God's going to do to us. But what God does, even in the Garden of Eden was he clothes his children with better garments. You know, fig leaves are not very adequate. And they just made loincloths. He rewarded his loincloths. And God instead gives them the these garments, these robes that were that cost the sacrifice of an animal. So God sacrificed. So in the Garden of Eden, we have the prefigurement of the sacrifice of Jesus. And so God doesn't treat us the way our sins deserve. He is so kind and gracious to us. And so he closed their physical nakedness, but also by giving them the garments. He's claiming them as his children. So even though they rebelled against him and his, you know, the one command that he gave, God still is saying, hey, you know what? I am still your God. You are still my children. And so he even from the beginning of the Bible, God is giving us a picture that he is a, his love is not derailed by human sin. And his provision for us is so much more gracious than we even dare to imagine. 00:07:41 Ryan: And Toni, you use the words guilt and shame. And I think a lot of people use those interchangeably. But you make a really important distinction between those two in your book. Can you briefly touch on that difference? 00:07:56 Toni Kim: Yeah, thanks. I think we do, we interchange sin, guilt and shame because they really are overlapping. And so it's easy to do that. But I think it is helpful to distinguish them. So in general, guilt has more to do with your actions. And then and breaking a law or commandment or a rule. And when you are guilty, then you expect to be punished. And in order to heal or in order to solve the problem of the punishment. So with the punishment of our sin is death. Jesus paid the penalty of, our death. And so then our, the debt has been forgiven. So that is how we think about in terms of guilt. Shame has more to do with identity. And so and it has to do more with the relationships. And so you betray a person, you rebel against God. And so there's a broken relationship. And the restoration from that is, from redemption or this restoration of relationship. And you know, so it's much more, it's very nuanced and complicated. And then you add on the layer of sin as well because we can feel shame for things that are sin, but we can also feel shame for things that are not sinful. So the, you know, the color of our skin or the shape of our body, we feel shame about those things. But if we don't distinguish and say, well, you don't need to repent of that you need to there's a different solution for the different types of shame. 00:09:37 Ryan: One of the things let's move into sort of talking about the why and the how of your book. So again, we're talking about the book shame Redeemed Learning to Live in Christ freedom and. I love the structure of your book because number one, you're very clear up front that this is not a passive book. This is not just let's read about shame. It's let's walk through this together with the, with you the author, with God, and you encourage people to go through it with a friend or a small group, because you talked about the relational component of shame and that you mentioned in your book that shame is healed in relationship and in community. And I found myself being terrified at that thought. Good. But I loved it. And you really have these practical things at the end of each chapter where you have a spiritual exercise and you have, a verse to memorize and so it's very active. Why did you approach writing the book in that way? 00:10:50 Toni Kim: Oh, thanks, Ryan. Yeah. Because I mean, how many of us know all the right answers and yet we're still trapped, right? We're still. Yeah. I know there's no shame. All of us. Right. And that's, you know, God designed us not just as rational beings, but as relational beings. What does it mean that God is love? God, you know, God, father, son, and Holy Spirit. He's existed in relationship. And so being made in God's image. We're relational beings. And so how do things travel from our head to our heart? It travels through relationships. And so reading more books is definitely not going to change anybody. But if a book helps you to have a conversation with God and with other people, that does change us. 00:11:38 Ryan: Amen. Definitely. You know, I it's hard to pick where to go with this because there's so much in this book that is phenomenal. One of the things that I found really interesting is that you talked about not just how shame is relational, but how it often makes us feel like we deserve the disconnect, that we deserve to be separated from others because of what we've done, whether that thing is deserving of punishment and guilt or not. And I think that's a feeling that I think just about anybody can relate to. I mean, I was thinking just even about my child and how sometimes she will say, well, I deserve to, you know, go be in my room by myself. And it's like, no, like, let's solve this together. And can you talk a little bit about, you know, why we feel that way? Why do why does that creep in that we feel like we deserve this? 00:12:53 Toni Kim: Yeah. Isn't it? It's just your heart breaks when your daughter says something like your child says something like that, I'm just like, yeah, I mean, I think that, Satan is alive and active in this world and what he wants to do is to steal and to destroy and to kill and destroy and to convince us that to isolate us, and to convince us that God doesn't love us. And that we are undeserving of his love and everybody else's love. And I think that we as the church have not been aware of the ways of how he does that because there's a difference between condemnation and conviction. And that's one of the things that I think just has to be, we need to help each other to discern the difference. Because yeah, that I deserve to go, be stuck in my room by myself that's living in under condemnation. And it focuses on just, oh, how bad we are and the things that we deserve. And that's not the voice of the good Shepherd or the voice of the Holy Spirit. That because whenever he convicts us or corrects us, there's always this invitation to confession and to restoration, and to receive, the abundant generosity of God's love for us. 00:14:16 Ryan: Toni, you talk about some of the fears that shame brings up. And you talk about fear of exposure, of rejection, of failure and of pain. Can you talk a little bit about why that fear is so compelling? Like, why are we so afraid of these things? 00:14:38 Toni Kim: You know, I think mostly because we love control. I'm ashamed to admit this, but I think that we're all kind of control freaks. 00:14:48 Ryan: I was going to say I thought you were talking about me there, Toni. 00:14:53 Toni Kim: You know, and it's a lot easier to protect yourself, and to not risk these things. And so we're afraid of being rejected. So then let's just, paper over the shame and put on a smile and project an image. Right. So I think, these fears are real because we realize, the control I want to have, is, it's easier than risking the, having my fears met. 00:15:27 Ryan: Well, and you talked about how social media has really brought shame to the forefront. You know, I think about the ways that we try to curate the image that we project on social media and how there's so much fear about like, if I post this thing, what if you know, the wrong person sees it, or, you know, there's even the option on Facebook, like when you list something on marketplace to not show it to your friends because it's like, oh no, that somebody might see that I'm selling, you know, that thing in my house and ask questions, you know? Oh, so it what, you know, again, there's no substitute for reading the book. If you're listening to this, go get the book. It's so worth it. But can you unpack? You know, if somebody just got, you know, two minutes right now to listen? What is a way that we can combat that need for control and those fears that we have that drive us to shame? 00:16:29 Toni Kim: Yeah. I'm sorry. There's no easy way. You have to confront your fears. And you have to, rather than letting Satan isolate you and keep you hidden. It takes the courage of reaching out to a friend. And actually, yeah, asking for help and saying, you know, I'm struggling with this or, I need help on this. So I think there is no other way of dealing with fear than, actually facing it and going through it. But the good news is that when you do, face it, we're often just surprised again, by the grace, graciousness of God and of his people. There are times when we take a risk and then it goes really badly, and we end up, being deeply hurt. Because we are human. Even Christians are human. And so but again, when that happens, when you find someone else to say, gosh, this just happened to me. I took a step and so we it is a process. I wish I could tell you there was an easy solution and that all Christians are going to respond in precisely the way they should. But that's not the case, but God's love is unchangeable and we can just lament to God, God, I took a risk, I thought I trusted you, I was, I thought I was trusting you and it went so badly. And I want to hide. Will you God, help me? So those kind of honest prayers, and those kind of, honest, asking of asking help from others. 00:18:11 Ryan: And you talk in your book about the goodness of God and about how he is a good father. And I loved what you did with talking about redeeming fatherhood Because, you know, I think for some people we hear, oh, you're a good father or we sing the song, you're a good, good father. And there are some people for whom that is a really difficult image and not one that comes with love and care and mercy. Can you talk briefly about the need for redeeming fatherhood in some people's lives? 00:18:53 Toni Kim: Yeah. You know, God is the God of truth, not the God of pretend like. And so he knows how difficult and painful your relationship with your father has been. And so you know, part of what I want people to do is be able to just take that to be able to be honest with that grief and that hurt and to say, God, I don't know why you gave me a father that was abusive or was absent. And so I don't understand. But can you please bring healing to me and convince me that You're different than what my experience with my earthly father has been. And even just having, doing a prayer like that does change your relationship with God because you're, it becomes a more honest relationship. And I as we do that, I do think that, God delights to pour out his love. He delights to convince of the things that are true. And so he's not frustrated with us or like, come on, you should know by now he's like, oh no, let me reassure you one more time. Just kind of the way, you know, with your daughter, you're like, it doesn't matter how many times and she will struggle. You're like, no, let me okay, let me assure you let me remind you and how much I love you. 00:20:21 Ryan: It kind of reminds me of, you know, the saying that you can get ten compliments and one criticism and you'll focus on that criticism. You know, I feel like God does that with us. Like he'll tell us ten times, a hundred times, I love you. I'm having mercy, you know, in the Bible. And we'll fixate on the one thing that says, don't do this. And I'm like, oh, no, I did that. Right. The other thing, so your book has different sections to it that talk about, you know, addressing shame and then kind of dealing with it. But then you end with being vigilant about shame that it's not. Let's work through this. And then we're good for the rest of our lives that we actually have to be vigilant against shame coming back into our lives. Can you talk a little bit about why we need to be vigilant? 00:21:15 Toni Kim: Yeah, I think because Satan is so wily. Again. So it was like the frontal attacks not going to work. I'm going to try attacking him from the side. And so I do think this time, this side of heaven there is an ongoing battle, that we have to continue to wage against. And it's not against flesh and blood. It's against the spiritual forces. And it's also God wants so much more for us than we tend to settle for. And you know, I think, part of the original desire even for me to go into ministry was this window into God's heart of, just how much he longs for his children to know how lavish his love is. And I think sometimes we just, we settle for, you know, relationship that is good enough. Like we would be the woman who has enough faith to touch the hem of Jesus garment. And then it's like, you know, Jesus can keep going on his merry way. I don't need any more than just physical healing. But God stops the procession and he turns around and he wants to give the woman a deeper healing. And I think that you know, we was like, okay, I've dealt with enough shame. That's good enough. I can just coast like this. And God's like, no, I want you to know my love is even deeper than what you've experienced so far. The shame that you've. Yeah. As so as we continue to walk and discover more things about shame, God wants to engage with us so that he can say, hey, there's no part of you that is beyond my love. There's no part of you that's beyond my redemption. And so I think he wants us to continue to know, that it's just his true delight in us. 00:23:11 Ryan: So Toni, as you've, you know, your book just released in, a couple of months ago. What has been the response and what have you heard from people in response to, you know, what you're offering in this book? 00:23:30 Toni Kim: Yeah, it's been really humbling. I've heard a lot of gratitude, a lot of like, wait, are you were you inside my head when you were writing this kind of thing? But I thought. Yeah. And I think there's this sense of, this is the right book for the right time because we are swimming in shame. And so the hope that is already in the Bible, and that just, there's just been a lot of gratitude, which has made me incredibly grateful as well. 00:24:04 Ryan: So what do you hope that someone who reads this book will walk away with? What's your desire for that reader? 00:24:15 Toni Kim: To know again that there is nothing that can separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus. And when it says nothing, he really means nothing. And I you know, I think I mean, you talk about the ongoing battle with shame, like it's definitely a live option for me as well. Like I end every podcast and I'm like, oh, I did this wrong or didn't that wrong. And I could stay there. Or I could say, you know, I just wrote this book on shame. That helps me to say, you know what? I'm not going to dwell in the I'm not going to dwell in that one negative comment and let that be what defines everything that I can, say. Yeah, there are things I could have done better, but I'm not defined by my performance on a podcast. When I'm defined by is the truth that God loves me. And so I want every reader, I want every person to know that it's okay to be in process. And that well, in the process when you keep failing and when you do good things, when you do bad things, God's love is so much. It is so forgiving, so gracious again. So extravagant. And we can swim in that. 00:25:23 Ryan: So to the person who is thinking about picking up this book, but they're like, I don't know if I'm ready to deal with this yet. How would you encourage them to pick it up and go for it? 00:25:37 Toni Kim: Yeah, there's so much good news about shame. There's so much good news about what God has done. And so yeah, it can be intimidating and it can be scary, but there is, there's a lot of like, wow, really, this discovery of, again, God's kindness. 00:25:55 Ryan: Very cool. Are there any last thoughts that you would want to leave with our Talk Worth Talking About audience. 00:26:05 Toni Kim: You know, I think, the crazy thing about Christianity is that we have a God who actually willingly experience shame. I mean, so the fact I mean all of us, by human nature, we want to get, you know, avoid shame. And yet God, who could have done anything, chose to take on human form. And then as a human still to be, mocked, rejected, tortured and killed, crucified as a rebel like he experienced shame. So he understands it, on a very visceral level. And then he has conquered it. And he has given a completely, he has given a way for us to have an abundant life. And so we have an amazing God and he has experienced shame and has transformed what shame means. 00:27:03 Ryan: So I think there is a portion of our audience who. Might struggle and say, this book is not for me because I've done too much like The pile is too big, the mountain is too big. How might you approach that person who says, that's all well and good for everybody else, but I'm past that. This is too big. And maybe it's things that I've done that are too much, or maybe it's things that were done to me and I just can't get through that. 00:27:52 Toni Kim: I would say, sweet listener, my heart breaks for you and God's heart breaks for you as well, because it is not true that what you have done or what you have done, the whether what was done to you. Makes you the one exception for God's grace is so incredibly lavish. Don't let Satan isolate you. Don't let Satan keep you hiding. Because you are not exempt. You are not exempt from God's love. So please, don't. Yeah. Don't hide and yeah, even just read Genesis three one more time. If you don't want to read the book. Start somewhere. Don't let Satan keep you isolated because God in fact does love you. 00:28:43 Ryan: Well, Toni, thank you so much. Not just for being here on Talk Worth Talking About, but for writing such an incredible book. Again, it's shame. Redeemed learning to live in Christ's freedom. It's available at bookstores now. And thank you and God bless you for everything that you're bringing to the body of Christ right now. 00:29:04 Toni Kim: Thank you so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Ryan Long Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Amy Sprunger Producer Feed-stated
  • Bismark Abayie Editor Feed-stated
  • Toni Kim Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Turning Pain Into Purpose

    Nov 16, 202636 minAudio

    Navigating medical complexities involving children, whether it's an acute medical crisis or a long-term illness, is one of those life challenges that puts a unique strain on a family. Vicky Lynn knows firsthand the...

    Credit the people on this episode