In today's episode of Talk Heathen, Richard Gilliver, Doctor Ben, and Jamie The Blind Limey tackle faith, morality, and whether believing scientists counts as religion! yh on TikTok explores whether faith is evolutionarily adaptive and argues objective morality requires God. The hosts challenge whether community cohesion actually depends on religion or just on shared psychology. Does religion create community or does community create religion? If morality comes from God, why do believers disagree so much about what's moral? Georgi in Bulgaria attempts to explain how belief systems shape reality and claims that without historical divisions we wouldn't have concepts like crime. The hosts struggle to follow the logic. If beliefs create reality, why can't we all just believe ourselves into utopia? What does division have to do with defining crime? traffic cone on TikTok argues that trusting the Earth is round without doing experiments yourself is faith, just like religious faith. The hosts distinguish between accessible evidence and absence of evidence. If you can verify a claim anytime you want, is that really the same as believing without evidence? What happens when you actually test the claim? Thank you for joining us this week! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/talk-heathen--3195702/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Feels reliable, even when it isn't. This is the core of why people feel like it's leading them to truth, even without any objective confirmation of that. It reminds me of the quote by philosopher Karl Popper who said, I wished to distinguish between science and pseudoscience, knowing very well that science often errs and that pseudoscience may happen to stumble on the truth. Faith can often feel like it's leading you to the truth because it appears to be being fulfilled, like spontaneous healing after severe illness, especially when
Speaker 1medicine has appeared to fail. Events like this can be convincing to those who believe, those who aren't willing, like Papa, to take that next step and unravel the appearance from the facts. If you have any example of fulfilled faith you'd like us to explore, or if you want to talk to us about any other aspect of what or why you believe, give us a call because the show is starting now. Hello, welcome everyone. Today is October 11th, 2026,
Speaker 1and we want to welcome you to Talk Heathen. I'm your host, Richard Gilliver, and joining me today is Dr. Ben, my very, very, very old friend, Dr. Ben. How are you?
Speaker 2I'm here.
Speaker 3I finally have a weekend off for the first time in six weeks. Been working 90 hour weeks and it's been a lot, but I'm here this week. I'm here next week. And it's going to be a great time. Super excited, especially excited to be back.
Speaker 2Here hosting with Richard Gilliver.
Speaker 3So I hope we get some good calls today because we're ready. We're ready for some philosophy, ready for some medical myths if you want to bring those.
Speaker 2If you think prayer can provide healing, come talk to us.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I mean, getting either one of us on the show these days, because we're both so busy, but getting us on together is like gold dust. So if you do want to go talk to us too specifically, now is the time to do it. Talk Heathen is a live calling show and we have open lines. So get your calls in at 512-991-9242 or from your computer at aca.show slash call. And we are tri-streaming today. So a big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and
Speaker 1YouTube mobile. And if you are watching this on TikTok tonight and you'd like to talk to us, then request to join and we'll bring you up on stage. Please, please make sure that you are over 18 years of age before doing so. And of course, at Talk Heathen, I can't speak, we are open to all of your questions about religion, secular humanism, atheistic morality, cosmology, philosophy, science, history, life, the universe and everything. And Talk Heathen is a production of the Atheist Community of Austin, a 501c3 non-profit organisation
Speaker 1dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism and the separation of religion and government. But before we go any further, I want to send a big thank you to the crew who put this show together every week. I want to see them on the screen. You want to see them on the screen. They are on the screen. Hello, crew, and thank you for doing everything you do. You are all amazing, as always. And me and Ben couldn't do what we do without you, because it's hard enough, as you've already noticed with my bad speaking today. just to
Speaker 1sit here and talk never mind doing stuff in the background as well so thank all of them and if you want to be like one of those attractive crew members two of them were attractive Not Greg.
Speaker 4Not the beardy one.
Speaker 1No. You can all be a guest on one of our shows or eventually even become a host. We're always looking for people interested in being part of our productions. So email volunteer at atheist-community.org to get involved. And today we are talking about... faith uh and uh we have a call being screened at the moment but let's let's dive into today's topic bend a little bit before that
Speaker 1call's ready.
Speaker 3Yeah before we start getting some nasty messages from greg after after insulting.
Speaker 1Him wouldn't be the first time it wouldn't be the first time so faith faith is a is a thing uh it's uh I suppose it's present in kind of both our fields of study, isn't it? You get people in hospitals who are religious and want to apply faith to their healing. How does that look on a day-to-day basis when you're on the hospital wards and things?
Speaker 3Yeah, it happens pretty frequently where people just want Jesus to take the wheel, if you will, or just whatever God wants to happen is what's going to happen. And you get into some interesting theology even within that statement because, yes, if you are a person of faith and you believe that God's plan is going to happen, you have to then think about, okay, there have been so many different avenues for people people to have either been treated for
Speaker 3something or not been treated for something. So does God usually have a favorite of medicine versus not medicine? It seems like he could go either way, like it could be a coin flip. And why is it that God's plan seems to be in favor of treating people's illnesses when they're rich, but God's plan involves not treating their illnesses if they're not rich. Why are the outcomes so different?
Speaker 3Why does God favor one of these groups over another, especially when we're looking at the Bible, which says that multiple times that the rich are not going to be the ones to inherit the kingdom of heaven. Like it's the poor people that are going to be more blessed. So, but then why are we saying the rich people get the most blessed? Is it really faith that's playing into this or are there more factors as well? And of course, I think you and I would both fit on the
Speaker 3side of, there are these other factors that are actually determining the, what your outcome is going to be. And it's not how much you pray. It's not how religious you are. It's not whether or not God is blessing you. It's just a multitude of other factors that are playing into whether or not you survive whatever illness.
Speaker 1Yeah, well, we do have a call being screened, but we've got some on TikTok ready to come up. So if we want to get those up....
Speaker 2I'm not able to put them.
Speaker 3At least I don't see the– oh, I think they're already brought up. YH, you are live on the show.
Speaker 6What do you say, partner?
Speaker 7How are you?
Speaker 1Very well. How are you?
Speaker 6Doing fine. Doing fine. Say, have you ever come across those studies? I looked it up a while ago. It was some. gov websites.
Speaker 7What's the one– The religious or the faithful, it doesn't seem to matter which one, they seem to live longer. They make more money. They have more children. Oh, they do better in combat, weirdly enough.
Speaker 2Is this one study that you're citing?
Speaker 3Is there one study that looked into all these different variables at the same time?
Speaker 6No, I don't think so. I don't think so. But when I tried, which one was the. gov website?
Speaker 7I think I found it by Googling the benefits of faith or religion in peer-reviewed studies. But yeah, I mean, what about the idea that it's really an evolutionarily adaptive thing, that the only reason it would exist is if nature preferred it since it seems to be so ubiquitous?
Speaker 3I think we're dealing here with a survivorship bias in that sense, because if You know, if we're going to say that, well, all these people who have been faithful have survived over millennia and it proved to be advantageous, who's to say that, like, so we have these people who have survived. Many of them happen to be believing in some kind of supernatural entity. Is that the factor that allowed them to survive or did they just happen
Speaker 3to survive from something else? And then this is just an incidental finding associated, or is there some combination of these things? And I think you'd have to really control some of these variables here in order to, is this a causation or a correlation? And so one thing that may have been advantageous for humanity is having a group of people that are going to protect you, that are going to look after the children, look after each other.
Speaker 3having numbers is something that could predispose you to survive better. And we do see in history, and this is all speculation on my side, I don't have a study to back this up, but if you have people of a particular culture, of a particular religious group oftentimes, they all stick together in numbers, they all defend each other, and therefore they may be more likely to survive.
Speaker 2So um right there.
Speaker 3May be other variables here that are making it seem like faith is the factor uh keeping people alive but but really it may be something else.
Speaker 7Well i mean as far as i've been able to figure it i mean whatever the thing might be it could be a a failed dead-end loop but Under materialism, whatever you're looking at, the only reason it exists is because it's successful. Like 99 point whatever percent of all the species that have ever existed are extinct. Nature seems to be pretty damned picky. So it seemed to me that if you're seeing this phenomenon take place, like I say, it's got to be good for something. Like you think of what, like the placebo effect and all of that
Speaker 7and how people that had medicine before and maybe the people that you dance over them with a rattle and sing them a song.
Speaker 6Hey, I don't know how it works, but it works.
Speaker 3I think with this too, we have to be careful as well of, okay, yeah, a lot of these factors that developed, a lot of traits that developed over time were good enough to to just barely be good enough. We don't necessarily know how much better, like how optimal are these things, or are these things just barely good enough to survive? We just know that these traits have stuck around, and there's some reason why those traits were favored, and we can study that through the scientific method. But
Speaker 3just because a trait has persisted or that a species has persisted doesn't mean that they're optimal in any way. It doesn't mean that that particular trait is helpful for even other multitude of things. It just means that there was something happened that that trait was good enough to not be eradicated.
Speaker 7Yeah, there's a guy named Jonathan Haidt. That's a good point you make. There's a guy named Jonathan Haidt. If you haven't heard of him before, you might be pretty interested. He's an atheist. But he's a sociologist. I think he's sort of on the left wing side of things if he had to be on something. But he talks a lot about religion. And for him, religion has a pretty broad definition. He thinks that people make religions like birds make nests. And that even in modern secular humanism, we're
Speaker 7making what you could call a religion. For him, it's something that you pick that's sacred. And then the community circles around that. That glues them together in a large enough number beyond the Dunbar number it's called in anthropology.
Speaker 6It's like 150.
Speaker 7And then after that, the little tribes split off and they fight each other, except if you've got whatever, Islam, Christianity, whatever it is. then you can make this a bigger alliance with people and go out and accomplish things and get more territory and build ziggurats and temples and whatever the heck.
Speaker 3So why, so why if, if the factor here, and I want Richard to be able to jump in here too, but if the factor here is the community, if that is the sticking point that is allowing people to survive and, uh, be able to function or that people are just going to do these things and, uh, do them for the sake of community, essentially, that in no way has to rely on a supernatural entity. So you can label anything
Speaker 3a religion if you want, but really what you're just talking about is community. And that person who you're citing really is just talking about things that bring people together, which would be more of a community. And I wouldn't necessarily put the label of religion on it. Religion has a very specific definition.
Speaker 2A lot of the times.
Speaker 3And I think if we kind of take religion and apply that word to something that we all just find meaningful, I think we're entering into just a different conversation and that no longer makes the supernatural point of this significant. So do you want to focus on communities of people or do you want to focus on religion as being a belief system?
Speaker 6That's a fair point.
Speaker 7I don't think I'm making his point very clearly, but you might understand a bit better coming from him. But what always gets me when it comes to this, I don't know anything about any of this stuff, but I'm fascinated by it. So I just try to listen to people that are smarter than me and try to understand what the hell they're talking about.
Speaker 6I listened to these guys the other day. See what you think of this?
Speaker 7Your point about, well, what use is it in all of this? I think it's probably morality because I listen to these guys. One was an atheist. One was a theologian. They were both PhDs or experts or whatever. Talked for like four hours, and in the end of it, they both agreed that to have objective morality, you need God because God sets the rules of the stage.
Speaker 6Nothing outside of him. Okay, so fine. You can all agree.
Speaker 2Do we need objective morality, though?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 7I think you do because that's the game. You're trying to play a game. You're trying to play chess or checkers or soccer or football.
Speaker 3But does religion even have objective morality?
Speaker 6I think, no, but yes.
Speaker 7No, not really, but according to him, yes.
Speaker 6Ask the Amish.
Speaker 7I'm jealous of these people. I'm not talking them down. Think of whoever, the Mujahideen, ISIL, the Amish, Orthodox Jews, Orthodox Christians on Mount Athos. you ask those guys about god and morality and all that stuff you're not going to say ah well i don't know it could be this could be that no they'll say i know i know for sure like 100 i have no doubt in my mind it's just like this they know and that's and as far as those things go that's the closest thing you're probably going to get to an objective morality
Speaker 7and if everybody's doing it together which is super hard to get them to do they're going to be unified in a way that Yeah, Mohammed takes over the Middle East. Christianity takes over the world. Yeah, yeah, they're always fighting back and forth in between one another because that's the nature of humanity. But to the extent that you can get them to agree, ah, now you've got a team.
Speaker 1You know. YH, let me jump in a bit because you've already given me enough to talk about on my own for about a week. So I don't want to get too bogged down into stuff. Let me try and address a couple of things because I actually agree with you on a few of the things you've said with caveats. So I don't know what studies you're referring to. There are a series of studies. I have read the studies, but not for probably about three or four years, called the Blue Zone Studies, which investigate why people in certain
Speaker 1regions live longer. I don't know whether these are what you're referring to or not. They don't say anything about people being better fighters, from what I recall. So maybe you're thinking of something else. The Blue Zone studies do indeed find that people who live in areas with higher religiosity live longer they don't conclude that the religion has anything to do with them living longer uh the the kind of the discussion is more along the sidelines of the fact that they have tends to have healthier diets
Speaker 1they tend to be in regions with healthier diets uh and and better medical care and things like that and you know so we've got to be careful when we're looking at stuff like this uh And the Blue Zone studies were highlighted to me by a theist who was making the claim that religious people live longer. And he'd given me these studies to look at. People can read studies if they don't know how to correctly read studies and take what they want from them. So we've got to be very careful when we're doing this, when we're
Speaker 1reading studies. uh anyway uh but there are these things go up and they're called for blue zone studies go and look we'll go and look them up if these aren't the things you're talking about and they give a whole array of factors which these people who live in these what are called blue zones these areas where.
Speaker 7People tend to have longer life and all of that no no i didn't know there was a religious aspect to that i thought they were narrowing down to like lifestyle and food.
Speaker 1They are then. This is what I'm saying. They do say that in these studies that people tend to have higher religiosity, but they don't put the extra length of life down to the higher religiosity. It's just a factor that they investigated as part of these studies. The next thing I wanted to come on to was, what did you talk about after that? There's so much stuff I wanted to get into. The guys who did this debate
Speaker 1and came to the fact about morality, I'd love to know who this atheist guy was who he was talking about, because you can be atheist and believe in objective morality. A lot of atheist philosophers think there is objective morality. You don't have to believe in God. Interestingly, And I don't know what background you're from, but specifically from the Christian aspect, not only don't I think that through God's
Speaker 1actions and instructions in the Bible, the objective morality is shown in the Bible, I don't think it's even necessary for the theological character of the Christian God it's the theological characteristic of the christian god is more in line with subjective morality and this is one of these things that always puzzles me when theists kind of go down this road of well objective morality is true god presents up because he doesn't if you have a look at
Speaker 1his actions if you have a look at his instructions everything's subjective it comes down to opinion it comes down to the opinion of a mind, which means that it is subjective. And it's not that there's nowhere in God's actions or instructions in the Bible.
Speaker 4Which state?
Speaker 1Look, here is this outside stake we're putting in the ground. This is objectively true. This is objectively moral. And this is objectively what you must do. Because at every point where it appears that might be the case in the Bible, either God instructs somebody to do something which is in opposition to that or his own actions are in opposition to that. So I think it's a subtle point that's often missed by people. And you can examine this, and
Speaker 1I have examined this, because as people who watch the show regularly know, I am an incredibly boring tit. I have examined this over and over, and it just seems to come out and get the same result every time. Subjective morality seems to be consistent with the theological character of the biblical God.
Speaker 6Don't start bullying at all. You're doing fine.
Speaker 1So, and you said, remind me of the other thing you said before the objective, before the morality thing, because I think there was something else. Oh, that's it. That's how I have remembered. The thing about, you know, how faith and stuff has had an evolutionary thing, an evolutionary focus. I tend to kind of agree that religiosity is, or belief in the supernatural or belief in stuff is an
Speaker 1evolutionary trait which has been helpful for human beings. And people, again, jump on that as though to say, look, this means that religion is true.
Speaker 4No, it doesn't.
Speaker 1What it means is that we as human beings throughout our history have made use of this. It has had utility for humankind's kind of prospering throughout the years. And I also don't think that the, I will shut up in a minute. Sorry, I told you you're giving me a lot to talk about. I also don't think that it's, I think the guy you were talking about with the kind of definition of religion, I agree with Ben that he's spreading that far too thin. You know, when the
Speaker 1very first, the very first part of the degree I did in religious studies was, was talking about the definition of religion. And we examined it, you know, what does it mean? What does religion mean? Can it apply to people at football matches who take on this?
Speaker 7He gets around it by saying that you don't need a god to have religion.
Speaker 6You could have like Confucianism or Taoism.
Speaker 1I agree. I agree with that. But I don't think, I think you can spread that too thin. and apply it even without a god. Confucianism, Taoism, Buddhism, these are all religions which are cited. I've got a background in Buddhism. These are all religions which are cited as, look, these have no gods, which is not technically true, but these have no gods, and so they are not religions, but they do have other religious aspects to them. Taoism and
Speaker 1Buddhism certainly have supernatural elements to them. They have elements of ritual to them. They have elements of authority to them. They have elements of what you might call a clergy to them. They have all these elements which we recognize as religious elements. And you don't get that in things like secular humanism. That's not there. What you've got there is communities which are different things.
Speaker 6You know what I mean?
Speaker 1And you can have communities that are religious, but you can also have non-religious communities. And I think just to say that someone has a shared goal, someone is in community together, therefore it is religious, I think that's spreading the thing too thin. It might just be me. It just seems too thin for me to accept that.
Speaker 7No, it's a perfectly reasonable feeling to have, and I agree with you more than I don't.
Speaker 6But I'm convinced. I just can't articulate it properly.
Speaker 7I saw a Jewish lady, and she broke it all down like this is the– I don't know. She compared it to Christianity, like this is sort of a neo-Christianity. She was comparing it to politics, and it was dead on. I can't remember what she said, but it was– and that's something that really brought me over to thinking about it because I was watching all these political debates or something during 2016, and I was watching the behavior of people, and I thought, Mike, I mean, what is that?
Speaker 6What are they even doing? It devolved.
Speaker 1That's psychology.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1That is psychology. That's not religion.
Speaker 6It was amazing.
Speaker 7Like it devolved to the point where like a left wing person and a right wing person started barking at each.
Speaker 6Other like dogs.
Speaker 7Like, you know, like they were like yelling gibberish at each other. And I'm like, what is that like? And another thought I keep having is like what would be the modern equivalent of blasphemy? Could you– so in anthropology, they talk about this thing called the taboo code. Yeah, taboo code I think it's called. But there's something that's universal in all human civilizations, which is a taboo. And it's like a line you don't cross. It's beyond the pale. And basically what it represents is what glues the group together.
Speaker 6And so if.
Speaker 7You were in the Crusades and you could convince Saladin or Prince Baldwin and all of his men that either Jesus or Muhammad was a bunch of shit, you know, it just doesn't exist.
Speaker 6It's not real.
Speaker 7Their armies would dissolve immediately. Like they'd lose all their morale. That's what's gluing these guys together. And so the argument is that what's going on with those political people? is that when you're poking someone's deeply held belief like that, you're not just poking, I don't know, gun rights or something like that or whatever it is. No, you're poking the thing that's gluing their group together. And if they were to go against that, they would be heretics. They would be blasphemers. They'd lose their job. They'd lose their marriage, maybe.
Speaker 7They would lose their friend group, at least their support group, at least their community. So that's basically his argument.
Speaker 1But isn't that just reframing? the fact of community, the fact of how psychology works in communities, isn't that... I'm being very careful because I'm writing about communities in psychology at the moment, so I don't want to kind of get into trouble from my university for publicly talking about what I'm actually writing about, which is a real issue. So I'm being very, very careful here. But isn't it possible...
Speaker 1that what's happening here is a reframing from using normal psychological phenomena, which is present in groups, and just reframing that to a religious standpoint and saying, look, religion, that's religion. When in actual fact, it applies to all groups, whether religious or non-religious, and you're looking at it simply, or the lady who you're talking about is looking at it purely from a religious lens, and making the incorrect conclusion
Speaker 1that that means all groups who do this are religious, when in actual fact, religious groups do this as well as other non-religious groups.
Speaker 7No, it's a completely fair point. I think you'd have to listen to the professor talk about it, Haidt, Jonathan Haidt. Anyway, it sounded reasonable enough to me. And then the angle of evolutionary adaptation is, That seemed like a pretty good one because if you're just a materialist, everything has to be down to that. There's no reason for anything to be around except if it's good for survival. And, yeah, I just– I don't know what to make of any of that, especially on top of morality being subjective because a group has to agree on a rule set.
Speaker 6They have to– you at least have to.
Speaker 7Act like morality is objective because if you get too far into the weeds, hey, everything just goes.
Speaker 3To– you know. I don't think, no, you don't even have to act like it's objective. You just have to agree as a society on what the priorities are. And I think even within the, I think secular humanism is a great example of this because there is no objective morality that we're referring to, but there are kind of general principles that we all agree upon for the most part in the secular humanist spaces. pretty much agreeing that
Speaker 3human rights are kind of at the forefront of things and trying to reduce suffering.
Speaker 2And a.
Speaker 3Lot of other things we can kind of disagree on, and there's a lot of gray areas. So I think if you can agree enough with the people around you to not start killing each other and not start, you know, hurting people, that's really good. kind of what you need um i don't think you have to pretend that morality is objective or just assume that it is in order to get cohesion in your society you just have to agree generally with the people around.
Speaker 7You yeah but that would presume that that i mean we have an assumption in secular humanism which comes from the enlightenment which comes from christianity that um what there's the spark of the divine in everyone basically the golden rule.
Speaker 3I want to i wanted know like what you think comes from Christianity specifically.
Speaker 7Again again there's another guy i'm fascinated with it i really won't be able to articulate well but he's a he's a historian his name's tom holland he's not spider-man he's a he's an old british guy with glasses and gray hair from the uk and um but he wrote a book called dominandi i think it was called and his whole argument is that all the atheists, secular humanist guys and all of that, they're actually Christians from a moral perspective because it's might makes right. Think of Frederick Netsche, master slave morality and all of this. Before Christianity, you've
Speaker 7got might makes right. We're the Romans. We're going to crucify you. And that's our job to do that because you're weaker than us. And this is the natural order of things. The Christians invert the hierarchy because they're the lower caste and they feel bad about being such underlings. And they say, hey, you know what's really nice around here? Not like honor and glory, pity. And meek will inherit the earth and all that stuff. So Genghis Khan and the Vikings and whoever, the Persians and the Aztecs, they would agree much more with the Romans. And so he thinks, ah, well,
Speaker 7there's this new morality that's happened here. And the strength that pushed the Christian Roman Empire through to conquer the world and in the British Empire. This is really sort of a pagan energy or whatever you call. And then the ultimate conclusion, he agrees with Nietzsche here, is this sort of secular humanist equality for all, egalite, equality, fraternite. Everyone's equal because they have the spark of the divine within them. And that's how come you look after the
Speaker 7minority and so on and so on and so on. But I don't know if that answers your question.
Speaker 3So I feel like there's a lot of generalization that specific things like that come from Christianity. I get that a lot of your examples are pulling from Western philosophy and kind of Western cultures. I think, would you not agree there are atheists that come from Eastern backgrounds that may not believe in a God and may accept a lot of the principles of secular humanism, but probably wouldn't
Speaker 3have had a Christian background?
Speaker 6Could you rephrase that?
Speaker 3Like you're essentially saying that secular humanism, like that philosophy, like gets the morality from Christianity. Do you think there are ways to be secular and wanting the best for all people and to reduce suffering? Do you think that is inherently a Christian idea? Or do you think somebody could come to that conclusion from a different background that's not Western?
Speaker 8Western.
Speaker 6That's a very good question. I don't know. I don't know.
Speaker 7But I do know that I mean, I think I think I really do agree with someone like Carl Jung, who would say that you can't really get out of it. Like if all of the Middle East were to become secular humanists tomorrow, all of India were to become secular humanists tomorrow. whatever they were up to, whatever rules they had in their society, would still smell like Islam. It would still smell like Hinduism. Because you've got a whole group of people whose very root and ground of being has been steeped in whatever you call, a philosophy, a religion, something.
Speaker 3So you have those influences, but that kind of would suggest then that this sense of morality that is secular... would not be exclusive to people coming from Christianity. So this could not be adapted from Christianity alone then.
Speaker 1Sorry, I just want to jump in on this point as well, because I think this is an important point to make. When religions traverse, when Islam traverses, when Christianity traverses, what you get is a change in its kind of moral structure and its moral codes. and those tend to adapt to the culture that it goes in. So I think if we got rid of, let's say, let's just
Speaker 1make up a completely Islamic state, which is only Islamic, if we got rid of the Islam from that state, I don't think it would take long for it to adopt kind of outside influences and its morality change along with them. You only have to look at places like Iran, which were completely secular until relatively recent, until the caliphate took over, and then it became hardcore Muslim. And even
Speaker 1now there are rebellions in that country. trying to rebel against that really hardline Islamic thing because they are aware they have other moral systems that they are aware of and they don't agree with the mainline one. I don't think it would take long at all. I don't think... I don't think a culture would cling on to this Islamic system forever in a day after that Islamic system had completely been eradicated. I just think we adapt. That's what we do as human beings, as human cultures. I'm
Speaker 1sorry for jumping in on your kind of point, Ben, but I think it was relevant.
Speaker 2Waj, do you have any thoughts?
Speaker 7No, I thought that was a brilliant point. Yeah, I mean, it could be true. It could be true. It could be true. I'm trying to remember what you asked me. I tried to answer it. And there was a specific question you said, now, do you think it could be?
Speaker 3Well, yeah, just like the idea that, and this is a common argument brought, especially by Christians is that the morality of secular humanists or, or the morality of people in general comes from Christianity and But I'm pushing back on that because I think a lot of times people will arrive at very similar codes of ethics and similar
Speaker 3philosophies relating to morality, even if they come from very different places.
Speaker 2And so I think maybe.
Speaker 3There's some of this, there's a chicken or the egg situation of Did the religion input this into the society or did the people already have those ideas and input that into their religion? And I think that's something we have to think about as well.
Speaker 6It's a hell of a thing.
Speaker 7I saw a debate in between a guy named Bernard Levy, and he was arguing for liberalism. And the guy debating him was a famous Russian philosopher who is now a pariah because of his support for Russia and fighting Ukraine. His name is Alexander Dugin, and he's a traditionalist. He's christian but a really weird one like i think he was like uh what do you call that red brown alliance thing where you're a bolshevik international socialist and he was like a occultist just anyway he speaks 12 languages and he's a smarty pants and so is that bernard
Speaker 7levy guy so i listened to their debate and dugan was against liberalism and his critique to this guy was pretty interesting he thought that um He thought that secular humanism and liberalism was basically neocolonialism and.
Speaker 6Colonization.
Speaker 7We think we know better than the Islamists who separate the men and the women. We think we know better than the African Christians who want to outlaw gay marriage or whatnot. I mean, want to force our point of view on them.
Speaker 6We're racists.
Speaker 7We're horrible, evil people for doing that. So basically the argument would be something like this is a neo-religion, whether you want it to be or not.
Speaker 6Secular humanism is.
Speaker 7Civilizing the savages of the world for the good of their immortal souls to bring them to the light of equality, equality, fraternity, everyone's equal.
Speaker 1Who is this we that this person was talking about? Because it sounds immediately off the cuff. That sounds like he's just making a straw man argument. He's making a lot of assumptions in what he's saying. I mean, he's not here to defend himself. It's very hard to have conversations like this when we're talking about other people. I've not seen the debate. I'm just going on kind of your brief synopsis of it. That sounds very much like
Speaker 1he's strawmanning people. And I think we've got to be very, very careful when we look to assessing things like this because it's not as clear. It's not as black and white. It's all very well good in a debate when you want to try and win points. It's not as black and white as that in reality. is, you know, especially from the Christian point of view, maybe you want to
Speaker 1be careful. You might be firing some, you know, own shots there. You might be shooting yourself in the foot on that one a little bit. You know, I mean, I think we've got to be careful when we're assessing stuff like this. And, you know, whenever I watch a debate like that, I don't watch many debates because I find them tedious, if I'm honest. I'm not into all this point story and stuff. i want to find out about what's true and what's likely true uh i'm not interested in people who start with the position and kind
Speaker 1of want to fight for that position or all guns blazing but on the very rare occasion i do watch debates What I try and do is I try and go through and I try and, you know, pick out what is your argument? What is the argument you're making, the point you're defending or advancing? And why are you making the statement you're making? Is it simply to support that point or is it because it is true? And very often in debates, you will find that on both
Speaker 1sides of whether it's humanism, atheism, theism, you will find on all sides of the argument, people tend to let the kind of truth of things slide a little bit to advance the point a little bit more. And I think you've got to be very, very careful about that, watching that on debates. And it's good practice if you do watch debates to do that, just to kind of look at it and think, what is this person really trying to say under the surface level of what the
Speaker 1words they are using?
Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, that's very well said. I mean, to me, I don't know anything about anything. All I'm figuring is these guys think about this all their lives.
Speaker 6They must know something more than me.
Speaker 7If I listen to them long enough, maybe I can understand some of what they're trying to say. But like the most nihilistic position you could take would be like Neche or something like Neche. That's why it acts like that is because it's just a will to power. The morality is nothing but a tool that the weak used to bludgeon the strong over the head with. And that's how come they do that. That's how come they're all hypocrites because it never mattered to begin with what was true because there is no truth except for just your will to power or whatever. And that's how come, that's how come it's just a really sophisticated war. It's just
Speaker 7a really sophisticated power game. But still in the end, like to try to get to some ultimate a reliable path to truth? I mean, that's one of the best questions I've ever heard in my life, and I can't stop thinking about it. I mean, have you ever heard of a perennialist or a traditionalist?
Speaker 6Have you ever heard of these guys?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 6What do you think of them?
Speaker 3Ben?
Speaker 2I'll let you jump in, Richard.
Speaker 1What do I think of them in what respect?
Speaker 7Well, you know, their big claim is the reasons why the religions, what's the ultimate truth?
Speaker 6Is there an ultimate truth? Is there an objective truth?
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1Ah, why?
Speaker 7Oh, because all the religions rhyme and they rhyme enough so that they're all referencing some golden age or Satya Yuga or some ancient time before everything got corrupted that everyone's sort of pointing back to in a.
Speaker 6Right, I've got you, I've got you. It doesn't work quite well.
Speaker 1There's a great paper. It's not about this at all. It's about DMT.
Speaker 7And.
Speaker 1But it. It's a good paper because it's bad. It was conducted by John Hopkins University. I can't remember the name of the paper off the top of my head. But what it does, it tries to kind of take this idea that, you know, all religions ultimately believe in the same thing, the same ultimate truth. There's a really interesting part of that paper where it quite literally says that This is
Speaker 1our methodology. What we're doing is we are taking all of the things that match from all these different religions that we can put together and say, look, they all believe in the same ultimate truth. Here's the key point of it. What it also says is all of the cultural aspects of those religions that don't match with that, we are disregarding. And that's really, really interesting. that you
Speaker 1have to– you can't just– that is cherry-picking at its very apex to say what you do, what you get. If when you look at different religions, there are similarities. There are similarities in a lot of these different religions. There are also a lot of differences. And if you're going to say that, well, look, they all believe the same thing because– This matches and this matches and this matches while simultaneously disregarding the stuff that doesn't work for you.
Speaker 1That's just bad science, I'm afraid. That's really, really bad science.
Speaker 6Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's a hell of a thing. It's a hell of a thing.
Speaker 7Because if we're right, that the function, like Carl Jung, he had some idea about a patient. Like if you can't figure out why a guy is doing something, ask what it's doing. What is this going to produce if it's taken to its conclusion? And maybe that will give you some answers. I think that's a generative thought to have about religions. If you ever get tired of thinking about the metaphysics of it, what the hell are they up for?
Speaker 6What are they doing? What are they good for? What's their utility?
Speaker 7And I think we're right in that it does function as a glue that holds people together.
Speaker 1I'm writing a book currently. I'll not advertise the book because, first of all, it's not written, and second of all, we're a non-profit. So I'll not go any further than saying I'm writing a book. It's about religious history in the area in which I live. The first chapter of that book is about anthropology. Now, I'm not an anthropologist. I've consulted people who are and I've consulted archaeologists in writing this chapter to make sure I'm along the right tracks.
Speaker 1What is really, really interesting in this book that I learned while writing this is that the first kind of aspects of what you might call ritual, which then go on to become religion, you know, hundreds and thousands of years down the line, the first aspects of ritual are The first species we'd see them in aren't ours, the Neanderthals. And this is, as I say, I'm being very careful here because it's, as I was cautioned by one of
Speaker 1the archaeologists I was talking to, you know, we can't say anything for absolute certain, and I want to put that caveat out there. But what we do see is what looks to us like ritual, like early forms of ritual. Ritual didn't begin with us. It began with Neanderthals. And we the way we've kind of adapted ritual and it works for us in a way was because as we were, we have different brains to Neanderthals. We have different ways
Speaker 1of thinking to the Neanderthals. And as our species grew and expanded, and I'm talking only from the aspect of Britain here because this is all I've studied, so I can't speak about outside Britain. As our brains grew and expanded, what happened is we could cover more ground. And language, as the neocortex in our species grew, language developed and strong social bonds developed. And all these things combined... were
Speaker 1what allowed our species to flourish and expand. And it allowed us to spread out further. It allowed us to get better resources. And these things all grew up together. And at the same time, we were asking questions about the world. We had elements of ritual in what we were doing. It is no surprise to me from the anthropological aspect that we have developed religion and that in some cases it has utility. That's not surprising to me
Speaker 1at all. When you look back and you see how it developed and you see how our brains developed and our psychology developed and how we interact as a species develop, that is not to say that religion is anything other in these early stages of religion, because now obviously it's expanded and we have lots of different religions and people use it for lots of different reasons. It's not a surprise to me that it had utility while we were going through that expansive phase.
Speaker 6Sure, sure, sure.
Speaker 7I mean, you ever think of North Korea in this context, or the Christian critique of communist states, and that they make, it's a Christian heresy, according to them, they've made a They've made a religion out of the state. And it really does seem to be in people's DNA to pick a leader and to deify him, the dear leader or the pope or the king who was put there by God or whatnot. It really makes you scratch your head. Can you really get rid of a thing like that with whatever, something modern like democracy or secular humanism or
Speaker 7something like that? Or does it just keep going under a different form? And isn't the goal really the same in the end? which is basically to get everybody on the same page, playing the same game and agreeing to the same rules. And can you do it without God? Like I saw Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris on stage. I know you don't like debates, but it was another debate with him.
Speaker 1And it was I don't like Jordan Peterson or Sam Harris either so you've hit the jackpot with.
Speaker 7That one well me neither me neither that makes two of us but um but they got to a point and uh Peterson said something and and Harris stopped this is now hold on a second excuse me let me get this straight straight are you trying to say that people are so stupid that they need God?
Speaker 6And Peterson, in so many words, went, yep. And basically his argument.
Speaker 7Was that at any given point in time, you're going to have in a population people who are so stupid that that they really do need fairy tales. I mean, this is a derogatory way, a pejorative way to put it. But I think it has truth in it. I mean, he references what the army and how they had to recruit people. They were desperate for people, but they had to reject so many, a huge number of people, just because they were too dumb to be taught how to dig a ditch. And it reminds me of a guy
Speaker 7who you might be familiar with, Bob Ross.
Speaker 6Bob Ross, I think is his name. Extreme World. He's a documentarian. from the UK. He's a bald guy. He's got a podcast and a bunch of shows. He's been around for a long time.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was like, we're talking about Bob Ross, the painter.
Speaker 6Ross Kemp, Ross Kemp, Ross Kemp. I always mess his name up.
Speaker 1It's an accent.
Speaker 9Not the white guy with the afro. They're not the other guy. So he went to South Africa. I'll never forget this episode. He's talking with these dudes. There's like five or six guys. He's talking to them at night.
Speaker 7And these guys' hobby is to drag women off against their will and to have their way with them. And it's just tragic. It's horrible to listen to. But so he started asking them questions, questions we would all ask. Things like, I mean, don't you feel any sense of guilt about this?
Speaker 6Basically, where's your conscience? Don't you feel bad?
Speaker 7And he must ask that question 10 different times in 10 different ways. And I'll tell you, those men were not being obtuse or defensive or... or arrogant, or haughty, or anything. They literally couldn't understand what he was saying. They thought he was saying, well, aren't you worried that you would have been caught? They kept saying things like, oh, well, we covered her mouth, and things like that. Oh, you know, nobody saw us. Let me jump in and say a couple of things. I want to give Ben a chance to... Yeah, yeah, but just to put a bow on that, I think
Speaker 7that goes right along with what Peterson was saying to Harris.
Speaker 6I think those men need.
Speaker 7the boogeyman in the sky to say, you're going to hell forever for doing this. They need something more than just morality, the love of humanity that, oh, we're all the same and we should treat each other the way we would want to be treated.
Speaker 2Well, I don't think they need... Richard, I'll let you speak and then I'll jump in.
Speaker 1Sorry, I don't think they need that. And that was one of the points I was going to make. I don't think that they need that. And I think what you're confusing is the idea that we need and it's not a surprise that peterson's confusing this because i think the man just walks around confused constantly but i think i think what's been confused here is this idea that we need this as opposed to the fact that this is the way that our brains work now our brains are great pattern recognition machines and that is also the
Speaker 1flaw that's where most of the kind of the logical fallacies come from is just the way our brains are made up and the way we interpret the world. It's not that we need this, it's that we are like this. And I think the goal, if we're talking about any kind of goal, is to not overcome it, because I don't think we can overcome the way our brains work, but to recognize it in ourselves and try not to fall prey to it. And that's why we have logic.
Speaker 1That's why we are aware of logical fallacies. They are safeguards to stop us falling into this kind of pattern recognition, mistake-making brain that we have. So I don't think it's inevitable that we have to live in our societies, have to live like this. I think it's inevitable that our brains are this way, but we can overcome that. And I think if we're talking about any goal at all, that's the goal we should be talking about. And just
Speaker 1quickly before Ben jumps in, on this point, on the point where you were just talking about, there's a great book called The Ten Types of Human. I can't remember the guy's name who wrote it. He's a human rights lawyer. And he looks at the psychology of people in different places around the world. And often people who were doing acts, horrendous acts like the one you were talking about, people who were engaging in modern day slavery. And he puts a really good kind of spin on it and aspect
Speaker 1on it. He started writing the book after witnessing in a, I don't know whether it was like a youth prison, a child was killed by the prison guards and he wanted to understand the psychology behind why people behave that way. So he went on a massive multi-year journey in writing this book. It's really useful for understanding the psychology of stuff like this, but I am going to show up now. I'm going to let Ben jump in and let you respond to Ben.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3I think just on that, with the specific example of, With the specific example you brought up.
Speaker 6Could you tell me what that guy's name was so I can write it down? The guy was writing a book.
Speaker 1I can't remember the guy's name, unfortunately. I know the book is called Ten Types of Human, but I'm not sure what the guy's name is.
Speaker 6Gotcha, thanks.
Speaker 3But just on your example from South Africa, there's a few things that I see here as being an issue.
Speaker 4For one, that.
Speaker 3People who, I think there's a few different issues specifically with the psychology of that group of people that would be taking advantage of another group of people that they see as less than in a way. I think part of this is it could be that they're from a society or a culture or a belief system that allows them to take advantage of other people like that. And actually you see that a lot through Christianity. You see
Speaker 3that a lot through Islam. You see that where men especially believe that they are entitled to having women for whatever purpose they want. And so that's a case where if we're trying to stop that particular behavior in society, Religion may not always be the right way to stop that because we have plenty of religions, probably overwhelmingly so, have religions that enforce that kind of behavior or allow that kind of behavior. So I think, really, the religion
Speaker 3wouldn't be needed to prevent that type of behavior. What we need is just social consequences. And I think if we have enough people, and this is essentially what we get, like those people, if they had said, well, we weren't going to get caught, we did all these things so that we wouldn't get caught, right? That shows that they are aware of social consequences, at least. We don't need to threaten them with hell. We don't need to threaten them with whatever punishment God is going to give them.
Speaker 3We can say, hey, you are going to be punished in some way through society, whether that be people aren't going to work with you, you're not going to get a job, you're not going to be able to advance in society, whatever that may be, we can use secular means to kind of cause a similar change of behavior And when that doesn't work, right, we have people who legitimately do not process motivation like that. There are people
Speaker 3who legitimately do not understand social consequences. And that kind of falls into the bucket then of an antisocial personality disorder. And there are ways to kind of help course correct those people as well. There are different forms of motivation in those cases. And a lot of that also actually comes down to social consequences of, okay, even if I don't feel guilt about this action, even if I don't feel the ability to put myself in someone else's shoes
Speaker 3and understand from their perspective, I can understand that, oh, if I do this thing that is seen as bad in the society, I will face consequences or like there's some kind of logical pathway that they can take instead of to get to that point. And so I don't think we need to even bring in the idea of a deity.
Speaker 2We just need.
Speaker 3Social consequences to kind of get those behaviors sorted out.
Speaker 1Right, right.
Speaker 7I think the argument is that I don't know if it's for the dummies so much as it's for everybody somehow.
Speaker 6I don't know how it goes together.
Speaker 7But I think the general argument that people would make on that side is that It's to set up an objective morality, or at least a facsimile of an objective morality, or a rule set. Because without the big guy in the sky, it's just up to everybody's interpretation.
Speaker 6Something like that.
Speaker 1It's up to everybody's interpretation with him. And that's kind of the problem. But I think, look, I think I love the way you're trying to investigate all... these different things. What I would kind of say to you is narrow down your focus and at the same time go beyond the surface level of stuff. Instead of watching Jordan Peterson in a debate... go and look at... Try and get
Speaker 1some papers. I know there's kind of free ways to circumnavigate the paywalls and stuff. And get yourself looking at some papers, anthropology papers, and read what the latest science is saying. Because Jordan Peterson is not an expert in anthropology. You know what I mean? Go and look at what the people who study it are actually saying on the subject. And I think... you've got the right kind of attitude and the right inclination to really get a lot out
Speaker 1of this when you're doing it. You keep saying, you know, I'm just, I don't really know anything about anything, but you know, go and learn because you've got the capacity to do so. And I think you've, you've, you've got a lot of things to say, which is really good as well. But go and have a look at the people who are actually doing the work rather than watching, essentially, watching the stuff on TV. Go and look at the actual work that's being done. And I think you'll get
Speaker 1much more out of that with this kind of insatiable appetite for kind of knowledge you have, which is a great thing.
Speaker 6Well, thank you. Yeah, that's kind of you to say.
Speaker 7I don't want to spoil your book, but as far as you can tell from the anthropological research you've been looking at, I mean, what are the implications as far as you can tell? I mean, insofar as the things we've spoken of and then the title of your episode, Faith Being a Reliable Path to Truth.
Speaker 1Well, my book's not really about faith. You know, it's literally about the history of religion. in a certain area. But I was in the process of writing a paper on faith. I pulled out because the guy who was writing it turned out to be a bit of a dick. So I didn't want to write it with him anymore. I'll just be honest. But yeah, I think it's an interesting subject. But I think we've got to look at,
Speaker 1first and foremost, what does faith, if we're talking about faith, look at what does it mean to different people, because there are multiple different religions who all have concepts of faith that are all very, very different. So I think the starting point on asking a question about faith is to say, what does faith mean to different people across time and across space? Because even in Christianity, as with most things in Christianity, Faith has changed meaning over time
Speaker 1and over geographical location. So look at what people mean by faith. Look at what the Bible says about faith and how it's interpreted now compared to how it was interpreted back in the day. And kind of start your studies there. That's what I do, as well as knocking my microphone. So I apologize if you got a loud bang then. That would be my starting point if you really want to ask questions about faith.
Speaker 6Well, no, not at all. I didn't hear anything. I think that would be my last question to you, fellas.
Speaker 7Well, if it's all hogwash to begin with, and we have all of our explaining left to do when it comes to– religions are and all that. And then the materialist point of view would be, ah, well, it's just some kind of adaptation.
Speaker 6And there is no truth.
Speaker 7Qua truth, there's no ultimate truth. If you had to point at one, Sometimes I wonder if this is the right way to look at it. If you had to point to some ultimate truth, it would only be survival. That all the creatures that live on the earth, from microbial to flora or fauna or what have you, have basically two rules. Well, first is try not to die. And the second is reproduce. And so then if the faith is aiding in the reproduction of whatever people group
Speaker 7we're looking at, aren't they doing it right?
Speaker 6Isn't that the real truth for them? You know, whatever. There's a big glut in the birth rate in Europe or America.
Speaker 7Guess who's having the babies? It's the religious. Maybe this is actually a good thing.
Speaker 3I think we've hit on a lot of good things. We may need to have another conversation in the future because we've got some other people that want to chat with us as well. But please, I'll be back next week if you want to keep chatting. And there's other shows on today too if you want to call into those as well.
Speaker 6Okay, all the best. Appreciate the conversation.
Speaker 2Yeah, thanks for talking.
Speaker 3All right, I see we have another one on TikTok, and we also have one in the call-in queue.
Speaker 2Do you have a preference, Richard?
Speaker 1Let's... Ooh, I don't know what the one on TikTok wants to talk about. Let's take Georgie in the call-in queue because he's taking the time to call. I don't want to leave him hanging too long. If the guy on TikTok can just wait, and we'll get to him as soon as we can. Georgie, welcome to the show.
Speaker 6Hello.
Speaker 1Hello. Hello. How are you?
Speaker 5I'm doing great.
Speaker 1What did you want to talk about?
Speaker 5Well, I want to explain to you how faith or any kind of a belief or a belief system is actually dictating, it's affecting our reality.
Speaker 1And what do you mean by reality in this respect?
Speaker 4Our day-to-day life. Right, okay.
Speaker 1So you mean our subjective experience?
Speaker 5Yes, you can say that.
Speaker 1Yeah, I can get on board with that. Do you want to kind of expand on that and tell us a little bit more about what it means to you in your day-to-day experience?
Speaker 5Well, I want first to say something about the past. Like in the past, we had tribes and countries with kings and queens, and people divided each other on the basis of all sorts of stuff. And for example, if nobody stole anything in the past, we wouldn't now have laws against that.
Speaker 6Okay.
Speaker 1So what has this got to do with faith?
Speaker 5For example, if nobody stole anything in the past, we wouldn't even have the words like steal, robber.
Speaker 3So all that means is that there has been a problem in the past and we've tried to come up with solutions to that problem. which, I mean, I kind of would agree that there have been things that people didn't know about, and so they made up a religion to explain those things.
Speaker 2Would you agree with that?
Speaker 5Yes, but everything is a minute religion.
Speaker 4Every word is like a spell.
Speaker 3That is just an incoherent statement. What do you mean by religion?
Speaker 5What I'm saying is if we didn't divide ourselves in tribes and stuff like that, We wouldn't even talk about crime today. We would just live together.
Speaker 3I don't think that those two things are necessarily related. I don't think that dividing ourselves up would have really any impact on what we determine to be criminal behavior or not.
Speaker 2I think even if we were one big.
Speaker 3Cohesive, happy society, we'd still have people within that society that would commit acts against each other that we would probably end up calling crime. So you're saying a bunch of things and trying to make them related, and I don't think they are as linked as you think they are. Can you kind of give us some arguments of why these things are linked? It seems like you're making some claims, but not really stringing things together for why they are that way.
Speaker 4I am not a religious person. I said that.
Speaker 5At the beginning. So what I'm saying is, give me a second to remember. So everything is on the basis of the individual's point of view, focus, and belief system. And in the past, if we didn't work with each other, we wouldn't even talk about it, you know?
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, it seems a bit of a moot point, really. It's kind of like saying, you know what, if we didn't have the colour yellow, we wouldn't have the colour yellow yet.
Speaker 4I agree.
Speaker 1So I'm struggling to kind of connect this to the subject of faith, which the call screener said you wanted to talk about.
Speaker 5Well, faith, belief, are the same thing.
Speaker 1So belief that something occurs is belief that something occurs?
Speaker 5Like imagine a parallel reality of Earth where we didn't war with each other. We would be like the Teletubbies now.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 4I think.
Speaker 1We have got someone on TikTok waiting to call us. I think we've kind of gone to where we can go with this one. I appreciate your call, Georgie. Maybe next time call with something that's a bit more substantive. Can we bring the TikTok caller up, please?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2Oh, did I get booted from the TikTok? Hello.
Speaker 1Hello. How are you? Thank you for joining us. What is it you'd like to talk about?
Speaker 6Well, see, faith is not a reliable path to truth.
Speaker 8And I feel like reliable is a accurate word i'd say it's a fundamental part of it like if we any perspective we hold whether it's a philosophy or religion we have to rely on our pattern recognition something we know is wrong often and we have to trust it regardless we have to acknowledge there's a missing link to knowing and still put what's the word faith in that that it's a fundamental aspect of.
Speaker 6How we know things like uh The world is round. Most people know that, right?
Speaker 8How many people do you think have done the experiment to prove to themselves that the earth is round? There's an important difference. A lot of people only believe. Some people know, but we use the word faith because they're putting confident trust. They think they know it. They're not saying, oh, I believe the earth is round. They're saying, I know the earth is round. That's faith.
Speaker 1How many people, how many people, if they choose to do so, can go and do the work themselves to find out that the earth is round?
Speaker 6Everybody. You can do it in your backyard with shadows, but people generally don't do that.
Speaker 1How many people who... If somebody told me that God existed, and I'm not picking on a particular God, I'm just using a generic God. If somebody told me that God existed and all I need to do is have faith... to believe in him, to know that that was true, how much of that work could I do myself? What work could I do to go and convince myself with evidence that God existed outside of just having faith?
Speaker 6Well, you couldn't. That's why they call it faith.
Speaker 8And that's why I'm arguing that in most cases, people who think the earth is round, it is faith. Because while they could do something to make it knowing, they could go do this experiment.
Speaker 6They don't, right?
Speaker 8They're in the same position as those people saying God is real because they don't have that evidence, but they're choosing to believe what they're told on the grounds that they find humans trustworthy.
Speaker 3There's a difference here in these examples, because I would say that faith is believing in something without evidence to back it up. With your example of the earth being round, we can get that evidence. So even if you don't have the direct eyewitness evidence of going up into the atmosphere and seeing the curvature of the earth that way, we have other ways, like you mentioned, that we could demonstrate that. We have mathematical proofs. You have real-world examples
Speaker 3using nautical navigation, et cetera, to give you those proofs.
Speaker 2So we have evidence.
Speaker 3So I would say that believing something because there's evidence, that would make this no longer faith. I think there is, with regard to the God claim, there is no evidence that God is real.
Speaker 2So that would be faith. Because there's an absence of evidence.
Speaker 1Hold on.
Speaker 8You're right that there is evidence that the earth is round. But there was a point where we didn't have that. That evidence has always existed whether or not we as individuals see it. What I'm pointing out is if we don't see that evidence, it's the same as the evidence not existing to us. It is the same circumstances that creates the grounds for what we call faith.
Speaker 6What's the difference?
Speaker 3Right, but before there was evidence, right, before there was evidence that the Earth was round, they believed that the Earth was flat, and that would be.
Speaker 2A faith claim. People would probably have faith that.
Speaker 3The Earth is flat because they did not have any evidence to back that up, right? But since they got the evidence and kind of disproved that idea that the Earth is flat, like, right, they jumped to the Earth is round because of evidence that that guided them in that direction.
Speaker 2So I think saying that.
Speaker 3Oh, well, before we had this evidence, this would be faith. Okay, sure, but we're not in that place. We have the evidence, and that's why we're making this claim.
Speaker 8That's what I'm getting at. Like, most people don't have the evidence.
Speaker 6The evidence is accessible, but that's not the same thing as having it.
Speaker 1But we have a body of work that we have regarding science and regarding, you know, the scientific method.
Speaker 8Is that different than like a theological person refusing to go look at science when they choose to prefer that the earth is or that God is real? We have evidence, but the person is choosing not to look at it. And that is creating their perception of the world.
Speaker 1The person's not choosing not to look. Sorry, I'm a little confused. The person's choosing not to look at which evidence.
Speaker 6OK, I'm pointing out. I'm sorry. Let me reword those.
Speaker 8I'm pointing out if the information and the evidence is accessible to us, that is not enough to turn faith into knowing something.
Speaker 6We have to see the evidence.
Speaker 8We have to actually be able to articulate that to say that we know it. Otherwise, we are putting faith in other people's claims. We are trusting other people's words. It requires more than excess.
Speaker 3It's not just words, though, Traffic Cone. Evidence comes in multiple forms.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3And if you can give even if you can give a a mathematical proof, if you can give like when we're teaching something to somebody else.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Like there are ways to.
Speaker 3Know things um even if you're not the one directly conducting the experiment like you can go through and um i mean you can replicate an experiment which kind of would be saying that you're able to do it yourself but you can sift through you can sift through the experiments that have been done you can read the papers you can analyze the data that they got.
Speaker 1You don't even know and you don't even have to go that far because we've we have things like GPS systems, satellite systems, which all demonstrate in our everyday lives.
Speaker 8In these systems, the definition of faith is putting confidence in a person, thing, system.
Speaker 1No, no, no.
Speaker 2That is not faith. I'll post it in the comments.
Speaker 6I have the definition copy-pasted.
Speaker 3If you mean confidence, if you mean confidence, then say confidence.
Speaker 8Faith is complete trust, confidence, or strong belief in a person, idea, or system, especially without.
Speaker 6Let me put the other half on there.
Speaker 8Physical or empirical proof. See, the accessibility... So.
Speaker 1You've just debunked your own arguments because we've literally just been speaking about, when it comes to the Earth being round, satellite systems, sat-nav systems that work because the Earth is round. That's how they work.
Speaker 8I'm not saying that these systems don't work. I'm not saying you can't prove that these systems work. I'm pointing out people don't care to, and they generally just trust what they're told.
Speaker 3But that is, we do have evidence though, right?
Speaker 2We have evidence.
Speaker 3So whether or not people choose to look at that evidence doesn't mean that there's an absence of evidence for those claims.
Speaker 6Okay, let me put it like this. Do you have evidence of.
Speaker 8The star system working, how it does right now.
Speaker 6Do you have that on you? Do you know that?
Speaker 2We could find it pretty easily.
Speaker 6You could find it pretty easily, exactly.
Speaker 8But you don't have it. There's a pretty big difference there. That's what I'm pointing out. The difference between knowing and believing is exactly that. The difference between faith and trust is exactly that.
Speaker 3And what- No, traffic, that in the definition you gave us of faith, in the definition you gave us, it was that there is empirical evidence for something that you're going to trust or have confidence in. And the difference is whether you have evidence or you don't, right? And so- You've already, like Richard said, you're contradicting that because now you're trying to use the word faith to describe something that you have evidence for.
Speaker 8No, that's not the reasoning. You don't need to use the word faith within the definition of faith. I'm pointing out the fundamental difference between knowing and believing and the fact that empirical evidence is something that you have to be able to comprehend. It is something you have to be able to articulate. If it is accessible, but you cannot do that, then you do not have it.
Speaker 7No.
Speaker 6Period.
Speaker 1We see the empirical evidence as, No, you're saying.
Speaker 8We have it and I can go to someone to get it. That's not saying the same thing.
Speaker 1No, I'm saying we see it working every single day in our lives.
Speaker 6And the forefathers could say the same thing.
Speaker 1Oh, but the snow goes around.
Speaker 6Yeah, we see it every day. just that doesn't mean that that's how that works.
Speaker 1That's not empirical evidence so there's a difference but yeah there is a difference yes that's the point we're trying to put across here there is a difference between empirical evidence that we see in our lives every single day that demonstrate that these things work and just simply saying, oh, look, that looks, that's the way, like, that's the way it is.
Speaker 6How do we recognize the empirical evidence?
Speaker 1Because we go to school and we learn this from a very, very early age.
Speaker 6That's exactly what I'm getting at.
Speaker 8The shadows are empirical evidence the earth is round, but unless you are taught and understand why that is, you cannot use it as such. I cannot give you a raw evidence of entropy if you do not understand what entropy is.
Speaker 1We are taught that. I was taught that. Maybe you were taught that at school. I don't want to speak on your behalf. I was taught that at school. Maybe I just went to a very good school.
Speaker 10I don't know.
Speaker 1I didn't feel I did. I got kicked out twice.
Speaker 6Can you explain how it works?
Speaker 3I was taught how to do a lot of mathematical proofs related to physics in my physics class.
Speaker 8Because you're saying there's math, right? But you're not telling me the math. That's what I'm pointing out. You're saying there's evidence out there.
Speaker 2I'm not a physicist.
Speaker 3I don't have the math off the top of my head to give you a mathematical proof.
Speaker 2Of the earth being around.
Speaker 6You don't know how it works.
Speaker 8You believe that's how it works because there's very strong evidence in everyone around.
Speaker 3Traffic cone, do you believe that we can know anything at all?
Speaker 6To a degree, yes.
Speaker 8I think just knowing the limitations of our mind is evidence that we have the capacity to understand.
Speaker 1How do you know the limitations of your mind if you've not been taught how to use it?
Speaker 8That's literally what I just said. I said no to that question to a degree because we can recognize limitations to our mind.
Speaker 6You just repeated what I said.
Speaker 2How?
Speaker 1I'm asking you how you can know the limitations of your mind.
Speaker 6Well, we understand the limitations of our eyeballs.
Speaker 8We know that we don't see the actual shapes of things.
Speaker 3Now you're saying that we know this. Did you learn that from somebody else or did you come to that yourself? Can you tell me the proof of that right now?
Speaker 6Yeah, I have faith in the science that I was taught.
Speaker 8So I will arguably claim that the science I was told is true because I have faith in it because there's probably more.
Speaker 6Evidence to back what I'm saying than there is the opposite.
Speaker 3And I would argue that that is not faith. That is confidence in something that you were taught. And especially if you can say probably, if you can assign a probability to that, then you probably have confidence and it's not necessarily faith. So it sounds like you have some evidence that you're leaning on to give you that viewpoint.
Speaker 1Go back to the.
Speaker 6Definition, guys. Oh, my God.
Speaker 8Faith is complete trust, confidence, or strong belief in a person.
Speaker 6Idea, or system. That is the same as math. The idea is science.
Speaker 1Without evidence. You forgot that little bit off the end again. Look, traffic cone.
Speaker 6No, exactly. That's what I'm saying. You have to have the evidence.
Speaker 1You're saying that if the evidence.
Speaker 6Exists, that's enough. That's not how it works. You have to be able to bring the evidence to the table. You can't just say there's evidence out there.
Speaker 8That's like me saying God is real, and we haven't found the evidence out there, but we will, and that's evidence.
Speaker 6That's not how it works. We have to discover it first.
Speaker 2Traffic cone.
Speaker 3From our side, we did not say we will have evidence for any of the things we brought up. We do have evidence for the things that we're talking about. I just can't pull it off the top of my head.
Speaker 1Traffic cone. We're getting to the end of the show. We're going to have to let you go, unfortunately. Traffic cone. Traffic cone. Traffic cone. Traffic cone. We are going to have to let you go, unfortunately. We're five minutes from the end of the show. So I would implore you to call back earlier and have this conversation.
Speaker 8Uh next week or but i i do appreciate the conversation and i apologize for any emotion behind my stance.
Speaker 1It's look it happens don't worry about it uh we are going to drop you out traffic on thank you for the call please do call back when we've got more time uh unfortunately we are getting to the end of the show we've just nipped you in at the end I'm just going to... There's loads of announcements to do. I'm going to forego one because we're close to the end of the show. I want to bring Jamie in really quickly. And while Jamie's coming up, I'm just going to read out the top five patrons. Dinglebury Jackson. Oops. All singularity. Kaleve Helvete. Casey Kickendall. And then number five,
Speaker 1just a period character. And our honourable mention this week is Carol Lynn. We do thank everybody who follows us on Patreon and gives to us on Patreon. If you want to have your name read on the air, please consider supporting us at aca.show forward slash Patreon. t-h jimmy the blind lineman you were getting a little bit animated there tell us all your thoughts on that uh i.
Speaker 10Mean yeah maybe it's a little bit harsh with some of the hand motions i was making i was talking to uh traffic cone in the chat before he came up to keep him engaged seems like a like a nice enough guy but i i would argue to him that the logical the logical extreme of demanding that you must have done the experiment yourself to have any to not to be able to call it faith. The logical extreme of that, the reductio ad absurdum, is hard solipsism, which we don't have an answer for.
Speaker 4How do you trust your own eyes? How do you trust your own perception?
Speaker 10And he's probably not seen the kinds of calls we have to take and the fact that people of faith, people who have faith in God, the Hebrews 11 kind of faith, are constantly making the equivocation fallacy of trust in science is the same as faith in God. I think he was making the same fallacy. But again, hopefully he calls back in. I'm going to be on next week.
Speaker 4Kick in early.
Speaker 10I'll be more than happy to talk to you directly, Chief, because he was asking me for my opinion in the chat.
Speaker 4As for Georgie, he's always incoherent.
Speaker 10And I thought the conversation with YH was fascinating, but I didn't exactly know what he actually wanted out of the conversation other than just to chat.
Speaker 4It was a bit hard. Anyway, fantastic show, guys. You've done a fantastic job. If you want to take us there.
Speaker 1Yeah, Ben, any final thoughts?
Speaker 3Not really. I mean, it was great that we had some good audience participation today and some good conversations.
Speaker 2So keep bringing it.
Speaker 3If any of the callers want to call into the next show, I'm super excited. One of my good friends is going to be I guess a couple of my good friends are going to be over on Truth Wanted next. So if you want to go call in there and have some more fun, they are available for those conversations as well.
Speaker 1Yeah. we do appreciate all the callers, whether, whether we agree on everything or not. Uh, this is a community. It's a community for people who don't believe and people who do believe people often forget that little bit. Uh, sometimes, uh, you know, if you don't, if you do believe you are a believer in God or the supernatural or anything, you are welcome here. Just, you're welcome to come and have these conversations with us off air as well. You're welcome to come down to the free thought library. If you're in the local area and you know, people are
Speaker 1here and we are here as a community and we appreciate everybody being here if you don't believe especially this is your community we know people have had some hard times in religion in the religious communities they grow up with and we are here for you if you do believe you we don't hate you we're just not convinced we'll see you next time We want the truth. So
Speaker 1watch Truth Wanted live Sundays at 2.45 p.m. Central and call into the show at 512-991-9242 or connect to the show online at aca.show slash call.
In today's episode of Talk Heathen, Jamie The Blind Limey and Sofia Spina, later joined by Kelley Laughlin, weigh secular humanist morality against divine command theory, from biblical slavery to slippery slopes! Litaf...
In today's episode of Talk Heathen, ObjectivelyDan and Jamie The Blind Limey dig into the golden rule's pre-Christian roots, a push for a platinum rule, first causes, and spirits who forgot they built the universe!...
In today's episode of Talk Heathen, Doctor Ben and first-time co-host Steve Ghikadis, with Jamie The Blind Limey lurking in a shark costume, ask whether secular humanism offers a better moral foundation than religion!...
In today's episode of Talk Heathen, Scott Dickie, ObjectivelyDan, and Jamie The Blind Limey tackle the thorny question of objective versus subjective morality, divine command theory, and whether free will is just a...
In today's episode of Talk Heathen, Jamie The Blind Limey, Scott Dickie, and The Beard of Empathy tackle soulmates, conditional love, and whether eternal torture can ever be loving. Isaiah in Canada questions if the...