Lose a pickup basketball game and you shrug it off. Lose a tennis match, Matthew Futterman learned, and it feels like you got beaten up. As the US Open gets under way this week, Futterman, veteran sports journalist for The Athletic and author of The Cruelest Game, goes inside the sport’s real battleground - the head - where even the greatest lose nearly half the points they play, and the hardest thing any champion does is learn when to leave. Then there’s the money. At the top, fifty to a hundred million a year rides on winning, and every sponsor becomes one more voice in your head. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Talk Cocktail Podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. We think tennis is a contest between two people, one on each side of the net, trading a ball until one of them cracks and the other lifts a trophy. And still no athlete in sport is more alone. A distance runner is alone too, but the runner has only the clock, an honest, indifferent adversary that never gets inside your head.
SPEAKER_01The real opponent arrives when the match turns. It's the voice that says you're tired, that you're finished, that you're about to lose in front of everyone. No one put that voice there. You did. And there is no teammate to hand it to. No coach who can play the point for you. No clock to run out and end the suffering. There is only you and the thing in your own head and the terrible privacy of
SPEAKER_01that fight taking place in the least private room imaginable. And then comes the cruelest part of all. Suppose you win that fight over and over again for 20 plus years. Suppose you become one of the greatest who ever lived. There is still one code no champion has ever really cracked. Nobody knows how to leave. Maybe that's because the hardest opponent isn't across the net. It's the version of yourself that still believes one more tournament, one more season, one more miracle is still waiting.
SPEAKER_01The Pressure. The isolation, the impossible calculation of when enough is enough. These belong to anyone who has ever tried to be great at a single unforgiving thing.
SPEAKER_01Tennis just makes it visible on a lit court with the whole world watching. So why does this sport more than almost any other go after the mind before it ever gets to the body? What are the codes that let the very best survive themselves when everything is on the line? And what can the rest of us, chasing our own versions of greatness, learn from the people who play the cruelest game of all? For three years, my guest Matthew Futterman immersed himself inside the world of professional tennis. From practice courts to training academies,
SPEAKER_01from the tunnels beneath Arthur Ashe Stadium to the hometown these players came from, talking with Djokovic and Federer and Osaka and Goff, Alcarez. And the next generation trying to replace the legends, all in search of the hidden codes that separate champions from everybody else. Matthew Futterman is an award-winning sports journalist with The Athletic, after years at the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal, and the author of the new book, The Cruelest Game, Chasing Greatness in Professional Tennis. Matthew Futterman, welcome to the program.
SPEAKER_00Oh, thanks so much for having me. That's quite a beautiful introduction. Yeah. Very impressive. Wish I had written some of those words myself.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you so much for joining us. Appreciate it. You know, there are so many books that have been written. I mean, Phil's whole sections in bookstores and libraries about sports performance and the success of athletes. Somehow all of it seems different with respect to what it takes to survive and succeed in tennis. Talk about that in a general sense first.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I think what originally drew me to this subject and the experience I had when I first started as a full-time tennis writer in 2020, which was after 20 years of being a sports writer, 25 years of being a journalist, was... It suddenly felt different than every other sport I'd covered, and I'd covered all of them. I'd covered the NFL and Major League Baseball and college sports and the NBA.
SPEAKER_00And the Olympics, I've been to, you know, eight or nine Olympics at this point, World Cup, you know, everything there was. And I'd gotten to know a lot of really great athletes pretty well. And I had been a, you know, a junior tennis player, a youth tennis player, and then played a couple of years, a few years of college tennis, and, you know, experienced some level of torture in the game. But it suddenly hit me, especially as I became a full-time journalist,
SPEAKER_00that this was the only sport where consistently you had players who were at the peak of their powers and in their athletic primes walking away from the game. Every few years. And, you know, we like to think about Bjorn Borg as being this one-off. But really, I think he was the canary in the coal mine in terms of the way it's gone. And like all these great players that have come after him. Finish up pretty early.
SPEAKER_00Even McEnroe was, you know, was pretty much done by the time he was about 30. Becker was basically done by his late 20s. Steffi Graf, Pete Sampras, you know, in their early 30s. Kim Kleisters walks away just recently. Ask Barty in world number one in 2022. She quits at 25. I mean, this is not normal behavior. And so that has led me to, that led me to the question of what, Some of us like to call the Passover question.
SPEAKER_00Why is this sport different from all other sports? And what I came to as I talked to all these players and coaches and people who had been in and around the sport for so many years is Was that this sport was set up in such a way that it could deliver incredible ethereal beauty and ecstasy, but also a kind of cruelty that I felt like in terms of the existence of
SPEAKER_00a tennis player that I just didn't see with athletes in other sports.
SPEAKER_01And so much of that cruelty goes to this fact that there is the psychological component, that the mental game is in many cases even tougher than the physical game.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, Alan Fox, who's really the father of... He actually has a PhD in psychology and was a terrific tennis player and a Wimbledon quarterfinalist in the 1960s and then went to graduate school and eventually did a little investment banking, but sort of found his way into bringing psychology to professional tennis. He was really one of the first people. He said to me,
SPEAKER_00He said to me very early on when I was sort of researching this question, he said, look, you can go to a park and you can play pickup basketball for a couple hours and, you know, win or lose. You've pretty much had a good time, even if you do end up losing. He's like, you go to the park and you play a tennis match and you lose. It kind of feels like you got beat up. And, you know, as soon as he said that, all I could think of was, you know, I'm someone who's gotten beat up a lot in his life.
SPEAKER_00On tennis courts. And, you know, it was kind of one of those light bulb moments of, well, why? And I asked him, like, well, why do you think that's true? And, you know, he started with talking about the scoring system. And, you know, you can win the first set and win 24 out of 25 points. But, you know, really, your lead is just 1-0. And the other player can catch up pretty quickly. Whereas, you know, if you're up 24-1 in pretty much any other sport, you've got to Comfortable lead that you can mostly coast to the finish line.
SPEAKER_00You know, there are points that are worth half a match. And then you get into... The way a tennis player is raised these days, which is that you're talking about kids who are doing nothing else, but mostly doing nothing else but this sport, certainly in all of their non-academic hours, from the time they're six or eight years old. And that really is a tremendous amount of players these days. And they go away to academies and they go to school online rather than going
SPEAKER_00to Regular school and being socialized. You think about all the young women and girls who turn pro when they're 14 and 15. From that age on, they're hanging out with mostly older men, which is a weird way to evolve during some very formative years. It's a very tough existence from a very early time. There's a tremendous amount of pressure. It's an expensive sport, so families have Often invested every penny in your success
SPEAKER_00or more likely your failure to become the best player in the world and win tens of millions of dollars doing this thing. And that is not a burden that even the best players carry lately.
SPEAKER_01And going back to Alan Fox, talk about the psychological part, the reason you feel beat up after going to the park and losing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think this is the mistake that people have in that they- There are a lot of people who write about tennis as if it's a kind of ballet. And it is beautiful to watch. These athletes are in full flight. They have the flexibility of gymnasts. They have the lungs of marathoners. I don't know if there's a faster runner out there, either in a short distance or she says she'd be a great half miler than Coco Gauff.
SPEAKER_00They have these incredible athletic talents, but at the same time, this is a combat sport. You can't touch, you know, you can't touch the other person, although, you know, if you hit a ball at the other person and it hits them while they're standing on the court, you get the point. So that tells you something about a reward for aggression. But, you know, what you're really trying to do is you're trying to mercilessly smother the opponent and, um, I think it's not a coincidence that Irina Sabalenka,
SPEAKER_00the current world number one, the main sort of mindset person and her fitness trainer, Jason Stacey, his background is not in tennis. His background is in jujitsu. And what he has really worked hard with her on is getting control of her breath. And he talks about it. And compares it to compares playing a tennis match to some of the grappling he did in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, where you'd be upside down in a headlock.
SPEAKER_00And the first thing you have to do at that moment is you have to figure out how to breathe normally, because if you can breathe normally, you can think. And anyone has played tennis. Has had those moments when the points are going very quickly and you're losing and you're getting out of control and it's hot and the other guy's just better than you and you feel like you're in a headlock. And the first thing you really have to do is take a deep breath, bring yourself back to some sense of equilibrium and start making good decisions.
SPEAKER_01And that line between thinking and overthinking is also part of it because it is very easy to cross over that line and that has consequences as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, especially, I mean, the thing that every athlete and certainly every tennis player is chasing is that flow state when you're not thinking and you're just reacting and playing instinctively. What's fascinating to me about tennis is you can talk to some of the greatest players who have ever played, someone like Mats Villander or, I mean, he hasn't won Grand Slam titles, but just recently Grigor Dimitrov has talked about this because he suffered a terrible injury when he was in the flow state against Yannick Sinner at Wengelden
SPEAKER_00and he was beating him. He was up two sets to love. Um, Against just about the best player in the world and tore his pectoral muscle. But even the best tennis player even experiences those great moments maybe about a half dozen times in their career. So you're always chasing that moment, but they're kind of impossible to get to. You will get there sometimes, but you're always going to have to think to some extent.
SPEAKER_00And the question is, what are you thinking about? I think the most important thing and what I learned most from Novak Djokovic is how much he tries to think about right now, this moment, not think about the last point, not think about what's coming up next. But if he's sitting on the side of the court waiting during a changeover, He's thinking about what it feels like to chew a banana and get that fiber
SPEAKER_00and potassium into his body. He's feeling that cold ice towel on the back of his neck. And then when he gets up, To play the next point, he's thinking hard about how am I bouncing the ball? How am I going to make this toss? So it's in some ways very methodical, but it becomes a kind of rhythm and a kind of meditation. And that's sort of where you want to get to. And how do you do it, especially in the pressure moments? Well, it takes practice. And It takes a long time. And some people have natural gifts to do it better than others.
SPEAKER_01And talk about, Djokovic talks to you in the book about those voices in his head and how to keep those voices out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's the thing that amazed me is, you know, these people are so good at what they do. They've had so much success in their life. And in some ways, this is kind of heartwarming to hear if, you know, you're a mere mortal in not just sports or But just in any other endeavor because I think a lot of us experience a lot of doubt every day, every hour at times. You know, can you do this thing? Can we get through it? And I asked Novak, like, what is it like to be inside your head in these, like, in these crucial moments?
SPEAKER_00And he said, he's like, it's a complete roller coaster. He's like, you have every human emotion from great confidence to terrible self-doubt. And... Of course, I'm sitting there listening to this and thinking, you've won 24 Grand Slam titles at the time. I think he had won 23. You've won more than anybody else. Why do you have any reason to doubt anything in your life? And yet he does, because that's the nature of the sport. Even the greatest player loses nearly half the points that he plays.
SPEAKER_00I think Roger Federer won about 52% of his points. I think the greatest season in terms of a point differential is Andy Murray winning about 55%, 56% of his points. But think of how much losing goes along with that. And so you really have to be able to do something, play a point, play it as best you can, and then move on to the next one very, very quickly.
SPEAKER_01Is there any comparison to hitters in baseball in that regard? I mean, given that, you know, if you're a huge success, you're only going to be successful 30% of the time.
SPEAKER_00That's what I'm, you know, constantly reminded of when I'm in tennis. It's like, you know, that I have seen some of this before. You know, I think Tiger Woods had the best win rate in terms of golfers, and he was only successful, I think, about one out of three times when he would play tournaments. So... Sports are incredibly humbling, but I think what's so fascinating about tennis is even with all that humility, the glory of it, the winning of it, feels so good.
SPEAKER_00And when it happens, all that these players want is to feel it again. Yeah. I think that's what makes it, you know, it's not I think, I really, I know this because he told me this. That's one of the things that makes it so hard for someone like Novak Djokovic to walk away gracefully, to just sort of put it aside because, you know, what has made these players great? They're, you know, in some ways, you know, their greatest superpower is a level of self-delusion that told them
SPEAKER_00that they could go into this incredibly difficult sport A global sport where only about the best 80 people in the world break even and make a decent living, only about much fewer than that become wildly wealthy and successful. You have to be incredibly confident and have the ability to convince yourself of something very difficult. That's what got you where you were.
SPEAKER_00It's still there. And so you still think, even in your late 30s, if I can just hit one of those purple patches for two weeks and then play the greatest match of my life on a Sunday, on any given Sunday, I can do this again. And that's what makes it so hard for even the best players to walk away.
SPEAKER_01One wonders whether the sport, and you talk about tennis as kind of an x-ray of the psyche, but whether the sport reveals character or creates a set of neuroses that builds its own character.
SPEAKER_00I think both of those things are true. But I do think in a very real way that there's just nowhere to hide on a tennis court. And... I've just seen it over and over again and time and time again that this sport, unlike anything else, because of the nature of the performance, because it's not a golfer walking the course with a caddy. It's not a boxer who's got a corner man that he talks to every three minutes.
SPEAKER_00You are out there just alone and You can't help but be revealed out there. Moments of pressure sort of reveal character and show or certainly reveal parts of character.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's what tennis does to a greater degree than just about any other sport.
SPEAKER_01And do you see all this repeating generation after generation? Has there been a change in character or in the nature of the cruelty of the game as generations have evolved? Or has this been pretty consistent? You know, I think it's pretty
SPEAKER_00consistent. I think it's evolved and it's gotten just... To a greater degree. It's been exacerbated. Players didn't really experience, I mean, you know, the game has always been hard. But the stakes were a lot lower in the 1960s when tennis, big time tennis was mostly an amateur affair. You know, and people didn't really, it wasn't really followed in great numbers.
SPEAKER_00But that all changed in the late 60s when the sport was professionalized and in the 70s where You know, what was at the time a significant amount of money came into it and TV came into it. And so what you had, as I mentioned Bjorn Borg earlier, you know, he wasn't just a famous tennis player. He was kind of like a Beatle and he couldn't leave his hotel room. And, you know, it was a much different life than it had been 10 years earlier. And that has only grown over the years as the media exposure has grown now.
SPEAKER_00And especially in recent years with the advent of social media and players, you know, finishing matches and grabbing their phones to see what the instant response was from people who have been watching the match. As bad as unhealthy a dynamic as I think you can get, but that's the world we're living in right now.
SPEAKER_01And is there a gender difference? We know the money's the same, but is there a different lens that you look at this at through
SPEAKER_00gender difference? The money is only the same at the biggest tournaments. The economics of being a female tennis player week to week on the tours is far different from being a male tennis player. They still have ways to go to get to pay equity at what are called the 250s and 500s, which are the third level and fourth level of tournaments on the main tour. In terms of the gender difference,
SPEAKER_00Girls and eventually women, they are able to break through at a much earlier age. They evolve much more quickly. It used to be commonplace to have 16 and 17-year-olds. You're starting to see, and then it went through a period where there weren't very many of them. And I think there was, at one point last year, or the year before it, There was only, I think, one player under 18 in the top 100.
SPEAKER_00That has changed a lot in the last year or so. Things go in cycles and good players come up. So I think that is the big challenge that girls sometimes are thrust into the spotlight at a much younger age, and that can be Yeah, that can bring a lot of difficulties.
SPEAKER_01What's the price that you think they pay
SPEAKER_00for that? I think it can be a very high price, but I think of it not only just in terms of pressure, but I especially think of it now as the equation has changed in terms of college sports and That there really is an ability for players to spend maybe a year or two in college the way Emma Navarro did and sort of hone their skills,
SPEAKER_00grow up a little bit, things like that, which I think really has shown in the last few years to have great value, especially because the best players are earning salaries in the age of Where college athletes can get paid now. So there's a price to it in terms of, you know, it's not really fair that you become so successful athletically at a moment
SPEAKER_00where your mind is still forming and you're thrust into the spotlight and expected to be witty and charming. You know, and you're judged along the standards of fully formed adults. I'm certainly really glad that, you know, I wasn't sitting in front of microphones when I was 18 years old. So I think that's really, really hard. And I mentioned college before. I think there can be a real social value to sort of growing up and seeing the world, seeing a little bit of a different world that way,
SPEAKER_00you know, especially if Especially if you spent much of your childhood like in tennis academies or going to lessons and doing online school and, you know, you hear women talk about the ones who have gone to college, women talk about, you know, like the great fun and the great value they had and, you know, living in the dorms and playing for a team and the camaraderie and the friends they made. And I think it's made them. You know, more fully formed and well-adjusted human beings. But, you know, some players are great and the money is just simply too good.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, Mira Andreva, you know, she's a French Open champion now and 18, 19 years old and still a teenager. And, yeah, she turned 19. And, you know. There's nothing you can do about it. She's going to have to grow up in the spotlight.
SPEAKER_01I wonder if, getting back to the psychological part of the game, is it different for these young women in particular that are 16, 17 years old? And do they deal with the psychological part of the game, the in-your-head part, the part that Djokovic talks to you about? Do they deal with it differently because they're so young?
SPEAKER_00I do think... I do think everybody is ready to deal with different things at different ages and in different ways. And I think one of the big messages that players have to receive or would get a great benefit from receiving is that if you're not quite ready to deal with all this at 19 or 20, like, That's okay.
SPEAKER_00You know, you can still have a long career. I think about, I think about a conversation I had with Coco Goff, who, you know, came on the scene at 15 years old and has pretty much always been famous, you know, and I asked her a couple of years ago, how much of herself, how much of her fully formed tennis self was she at this point? And she said, well, I'm 21. So I think I'm like 65, 70%. He said, cause, cause I look at the, you know, cause I look at the statistics and I see that most women They win their big titles
SPEAKER_00after they're about 24 years old. That's when they really sort of hit their groove. And so I got a few years to go. And I thought that was a really sort of intelligent and analytical way of looking at it and giving herself some grace and giving herself a few years to evolve in ways that sometimes the rest of the world doesn't want to allow her to Why are we seeing more variety of winners and losers the women's side these days?
SPEAKER_00You know, I would say, you know, two main reasons. One is they play best of three sets and compared with best of five. So there's more opportunity for upsets in a shorter time frame. You know, it's, I can think of several matches where if they had, if they had, where one player was coming on in the third set and, and, If they had had the opportunity to play another two sets,
SPEAKER_00the cream might have risen to the top. So that's the main reason. The other is the sport is just a lot less serve dominated on the women's side. Yannick Sinner is so good at so many other facets of the game. He also has just this incredible serve right now. And so you're just going to get very few chances to win. To attack him and break his serve in that sense. Whereas in the women's game, like you don't see, you see some great serves. Certainly Serena had outrageously good serve and she showed it,
SPEAKER_00you know, coming back, playing her first match in four years, that she could still crack some aces when the pressure was on, which is incredible at 44 years old. I hope she keeps doing it for a while because she's a great story. But, you know, even... Even she could be beaten because it's a little slower than 140 miles an hour and it can be attacked.
SPEAKER_01Talk a little bit about generations. You know, your former newspaper, The New York Times, runs articles, it seems, you know, every couple of days about what's going on with millennials, with Gen Xers, and so many other areas. Talk about this new, young breed of players, particularly on the male side, that have come up so successfully. And is there any difference in this younger generation and the way they're approaching the game?
SPEAKER_00First strike. Yeah, they're all, I mean... I think a whole generation of players up until Alcaraz was learning the game to try and play a version of what Federer, Djokovic, Nadal, and Murray were playing. You know, only in their later years did they start really playing much more first-track tennis, much more aggressive tennis, rather than sort of taking several shots to get into the point.
SPEAKER_00And I think if you ask players today, especially the ones like Felix Auger-Aliassime, who's 25 years old, who grew up in Canada and had his, you know, the models for him were Federer, Djokovic, and Nadal. And he, you know, so he was, came on to a sport and Casper Rude's another one is a little bit older. They came into a sport where they thought they were going to have this time to get into points.
SPEAKER_00And I think what, what Alcaraz and Sinner and now Hodar, Rafael Hodar and others have, are showing is that they, that it's just played at a much sort of faster level in some sense. And that any short ball, any ball, That isn't, you know, deep and hard is going to get attacked and that that's the way, you know, this era of hitting 12 shots in order to set up the winner on the 13th. That's not going to happen too much anymore. It'll happen on the occasional point,
SPEAKER_00but with regularity, it is people looking for that first opportunity to go on, go on the attack.
SPEAKER_01And talk about that with regard to fans and how fans see that.
SPEAKER_00You know, I think it's, I mean, I think it's, I think it's exciting. I think it's dynamic. I hope it results in shorter matches because, you know, these epic tennis matches that go five and six hours, you know, it's anywhere between four and six hours. I don't know about you, but I don't really want to do anything for five hours. Right. I would never go see a five hour movie or it seems crazy to me that this is the way it is. So, In terms of how fans experience it, I hope they experience it in terms of the pace of the game
SPEAKER_00picking up and moving more quickly and being a little less methodical.
SPEAKER_01And finally, talk about the cruelty of the sport as it relates to, particularly at the highest level, how much money is at stake now? You've mentioned that a couple of times. I mean, the stakes are pretty high.
SPEAKER_00Um, look, that upper tier, that upper tier center, Alcaraz, uh, you know, those are, those are players that are going to take in 50 to 100 million dollars a year if they can, if he can reach that sort of superstar level. There is a deep, there is a steep drop off very quickly. So much of their money from endorsements and advertising and, you know, those things are all riding on their success. Um, so, That is a big deal from a financial perspective, obviously.
SPEAKER_00But it's also a challenge for a younger player, and even a mid-career player who suddenly starts to have a good deal of success. I think of Francis Tiafoe, who had that breakout U.S. Open a few years back. And he kind of became more famous than he was good. And I know that sounds a little glib because he's really great. But all of a sudden he had endorsements from Cadillac and Lululemon.
SPEAKER_00And it's a certain kind of player who can carry that burden. Because now you're not only sort of playing for yourself, but you got all these sponsors who've invested money in you. And in your success. And that's not always the easiest thing. We look at it from the outside and think, oh, yeah, look at all that. Look at all those contracts and ads they've got coming in. But then you walk onto the court and you have a couple of bad weeks and losing a few first rounds. And all of a sudden, the imposter syndrome starts to seep in.
SPEAKER_00And people are snickering at you in the locker room and saying like, Yeah, you're pulling in all these ads and I just kicked your ass on the court. So who are you anyway? That's a challenge. So there are financial stakes, but also mental stakes. And the financial is just more things to get inside their head. More things to get inside their head. And yeah, and I think the last thing you want when you're in the middle of a big time match is to have anything inside your head other than How do I hit this yellow ball coming
SPEAKER_00at me as effectively as possible?
SPEAKER_01Matthew Futterman, the book is The Cruelest Game Chasing Greatness in Professional Tennis. Matthew, I thank you so much for spending time with us. Thanks so much for having me.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...