Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Cocktail

Talk Cocktail artwork

Teaching Students to Navigate Algorithms and Deepfakes

May 21, 202639 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Valerie Ziegler, a high school teacher in San Francisco, and Joel Breakstone, executive director of Stanford’s Digital Inquiry Group, join me on this California Sun podcast to talk about digital literacy in the classroom. Many self-described “screenagers,” they say, can no longer tell real from fake. Together, Ziegler and Breakstone are at the forefront of a movement to prepare young people for a world of influencers, algorithmic manipulation, and artificial intelligence, an effort recently profiled in the New York Times. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the California Sun Podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. There's a war going on for the minds of young people, and it's being fought not on battlefields, but on screens, in the frictionless scroll of TikTok, in the AI-generated clip that looks almost right, in the influencer whose motives nobody thinks the question. The weapons are sophistication and speed, and the casualties are harder to count than bodies. My guest, Valerie Ziegler, Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01How to Question, How to Remain a Citizen in an Environment Specifically Engineered to Make Citizenship Impossible. For over a decade, she's been doing this work alongside the Digital Inquiry Group and its Executive Director, Joel Breakstone,

SPEAKER_02our other guest today. Breakstone is a researcher and educator who spent a decade directing the Stanford History Education Group before spinning it out as an independent nonprofit, and who has made his life's work to put the tools of critical thinking into the

SPEAKER_01hands of every teacher and student in America. What worries them most isn't the deep fakes or the disinformation. It's what comes after. The Shrug A generation that has seen so much that's fake They've stopped trying to find out what's real Kids who can't evaluate a source Can't weigh a claim Can't tell the difference between what someone is selling them And what's actually true That's not just an educational failure It's a generational one. And Valerie Ziegler and Joel Breakstone are among the people

who have decided that

SPEAKER_01this can't be allowed to stand. Valerie's work was recently the subject of a major story in the New York Times. And it is my pleasure to welcome Valerie Ziegler and Joel Breakstone here to the California Sun Podcast. Valerie, Joel, thanks so much for joining us.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for the invite, Jeff. This is exciting.

SPEAKER_01Delight to have you both here. Valerie, I want to start with you. You've been teaching for a while now. What was the inflection point? What was the point at which digital technology and digital information really began to make a fundamental change in the students that you saw come through your classroom and the way you had to deal with it?

SPEAKER_02I think there's actually two major points. The first time I sort of noticed it was when we saw the beginnings of students bringing phones to class. So when I started teaching, There were phones were a thing but they weren't really in our classrooms and we definitely did not have a one to one computer in our classroom so that really changed it when you saw that students were using their phones as a tool in class and so that would probably be about when I don't know 2015 or so and then I would

SPEAKER_02say the second piece where I really saw it was after COVID. When we came back into classroom and students had spent so much time on their devices. Sure, we had online school, but really what that entailed is cameras off and, you know, I'm up here teaching but a lot of kids are on their phones and they were scrolling endlessly. And we had to actually do sort of this breakup with their devices when we came back to the classroom. And the third one I will say is, I know I said two, but three, was really the 2016 election.

There were so many kids that came in with such a variety of takes on what was going

SPEAKER_02on and what had happened, and a lot of confusion and a lot of, I saw this, and a lot of students saying, but that isn't real. And so those were kind of the touch points that really amped up my desire to start teaching this kind of content in the classroom. Joel, talk a little bit about your organization and how it really came to work in this area. We were approached by a foundation that was interested back in 2014 and then into 2015 to develop measures that would give a sense of what

students can actually do

SPEAKER_00when presented. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: We were at the time based at Stanford's Graduate School of Education, and we undertook a national survey to get a sense of how do students make sense of the overwhelming Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: And we asked students from middle school through college all across the country to engage with these tasks and what we found was that we were able

to engage with

SPEAKER_00them. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: It was quite alarming across the board, students struggled at even the most basic tasks when we asked students whether or not a item that they saw on a website was a news story or an advertisement. Jeff Schechtman heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: of that work in November of 2016 shortly after the the presidential election, and there was an enormous amount of interest in this issue not surprisingly fake news was the buzzword of the moment and the question that we got. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: And that was the work that we set out to try to accomplish, to find strengths and strengths. And that was the work that we set out to try to accomplish, to find strengths and strengths. Strategies that students could actually use to discern when

they are scrolling on their phones. And we've had the privilege over the course of that last decade to work with Valerie to develop materials and to test them out to make sure that we're creating

SPEAKER_00resources that actually do improve student savvy in online spaces.

SPEAKER_01Valerie, even before 2015, the period that we were talking about, there was this push that went on to make sure that every student had their own computer, that every student had access to the internet, and that was really seen as something that was a fundamental improvement to education and really kind of what the future was all about. Talk about that period. I mean, I will say that we were a little slower on that one-to-one here in SFUSD.

SPEAKER_02That didn't really happen until COVID. But absolutely, right? I mean, the internet is a source of information. It's so different now when you think about how students research, right? We all went to a library and we looked in books and libraries look really different today. And I'm lucky enough to work with the librarian here at Lincoln to, you know, use all kinds of sources, including AI and the internet. But, you know, I think it was an important step to really get students thinking about the internet

because our early work that Joel and I did was really how do we find information online and students needed to know that and this idea of even what we call lateral reading and so fact checking for those early days to a student a website that had a dot edu yep that's it that's a great source no understanding of you know how you

SPEAKER_02pay for a url or any of that And I think that giving students those skills is fundamental because really when they leave here, they're going to do this on their own. And so that was the thought of how do we help them with that? And if you look at, you know, the the legislation that was passed here in California, AB 873 is about media literacy. And right now, most of that, at least in SFUSD, is only happening with the younger grades. But it's really, you know, helping students understand even little ones. What does it look like when I go online?

SPEAKER_02You know, little kids are online. They're on iReady. They're on all of these different websites. So I think that that's really changed, especially now that we're looking at social media.

SPEAKER_01How did you think about teaching critical thinking before this? How has that idea changed?

SPEAKER_02That's great. And again, I can speak to what Joel and I have been working on for a really long time. When this started at Stanford, we were using the curriculum that is called Reading Like Historian. And we were doing this work on paper with primary sources. And so we were looking at historical documents and doing the same work essentially that we do with online sources. We do what's called sourcing. Who wrote this? Why was it written? When was it written? And in those times, we were looking at, and I still do this when I teach U.S.

SPEAKER_02history, how do we compare two documents from the 1800s and the perspectives of those individuals? And now we're just looking at modern. How do we compare an Instagram post to that content, to a website, to the content we might see on TikTok? So I will say the skills are the same. We're just looking at it in a different lens. And so what I love about this work too is that we can translate that from a U.S.

SPEAKER_02history class to looking at primary sources to, you know, a science class and investigating claims about climate change.

SPEAKER_01How does it impact the education itself? There's only so many hours in a classroom day, only so many hours in a school year with so much energy having to be focused on disinformation and media literacy and understanding what is fake and what is real. To what extent does that take away from teaching the primary source information?

SPEAKER_02I mean, that's the challenge, right? And I'll let Joel talk to some of the conversations we've had, but it is. But that's always going to be the challenge of education, right?

SPEAKER_00Joel? Yeah, I would just say that you've hit the nail on the head. The heart of the problem is that there is not a... Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: The curriculum is already overfilled, and so we have to find ways to integrate these crucial skills into the curriculum that exists, not the curriculum that exists, but the curriculum that exists. How can you teach digital literacy?

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: In a government class that the New York Times article featuring Valerie was talking about how do we begin to have content that is related to the social studies, but also Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: And we can align that with the content that's being taught already in social studies classrooms so that we don't have to add one more thing,

one more responsibility onto the shoulders of already overburdened teachers, but instead find ways to make it part and parcel of the existing curriculum.

SPEAKER_01Essentially, Valerie, it's project-based learning, except that the project is always digital literacy around which everything else is built. It can be project-based learning, but could also just be applying those skills routinely.

SPEAKER_02You know, so as Joel mentioned, I do a lot of this in my government classes and in my econ classes. And so it's starting with those fundamental skills of how do I lateral read? How do I practice sourcing? How do I practice corroboration? And then, you know, every week I do current events in my government classes and econ classes, and I just have them reapply that skill. So what are other sources saying about this topic, regardless of what the topic is? And I will say one other thing related to this is that,

SPEAKER_02again, in California with AB 873, what specifically it's looking at is how do they change the English language arts curriculum to revisit this concept or add in media literacy? So I think that that intent is that it'll come specifically in English classes. But again, I think it's broader than that. If we had these skills, right, then we could apply them against all content areas. But that's tough, right? What does that look like in terms of fitting in in the

curriculum, as Joel said?

SPEAKER_02Since the article came out, I've had, you know, a handful of schools reach out and say, what are we looking at? How do we do this? And, you know, I had a call a couple weeks ago with a private school here in San Francisco that said, we're trying to do our humanities program really wants to do this Focused in the beginning of the year on media literacy and then applying it across all content areas. Slightly easier in a small private school, but I think that that's one way of really thinking about what the future looks like in terms of providing these skills to students and then

applying them in all

SPEAKER_02content areas. Was there a hope at some point early on in this that there would be content

SPEAKER_01moderation, that there would be something that the platforms did that would be a help in this process?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question. I mean, you know, in my class yesterday, we were just talking about the court case that's going on right now, you know, with Meta and the social media trial and comparing that to the tobacco cases and what that looks like. I mean, we'll see what that specific court looks at. But yeah, I think that this is tricky. I think that it's tricky around who becomes the governing body for that content.

Right um there's also on the other side of you know all of the data that's involved as we we look at these websites i mean yeah i i don't know that i have an answer for this i think this is really a broad topic and right now the school district and you know at least in our case here moderates what we can you know what we can look at and we routinely get blocked by websites but then others that are completely open so yeah i think there has to be a lot of thought behind that piece of

SPEAKER_02governance And Joel talk about that as you see it playing out in different ways in different districts and Valerie was talking about how she's dealing with it and how SFUSD is

SPEAKER_01dealing with it. As you look around the country how is this getting dealt with and is there any consistency to it?

SPEAKER_00I don't think there's any consistency. I think that it is an area of intense interest. However, you can look across the country and see that, like California, many other states have adopted media literacy legislation. The question is, what does that actually look like in practice and what materials do educators use? Moreover, as Valerie noted, in many cases, there are various firewalls in place that limit the kind of content that students can access while they are on school networks.

SPEAKER_00And certainly Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: shielding students from real online spaces, and so at the heart of the curriculum materials that we create are links to real online sources, however, we know that in order to make these useful in classrooms that we also need to think

about what are screenshots or recordings of online content so that students can

SPEAKER_00still encounter them when they are in their classrooms.

SPEAKER_01Valerie, how are students coping with this? What do they think about all of this?

SPEAKER_02We talk, Joel and I talk a lot about, and actually Sam Weinberg talks a lot about this, that unfortunately we're getting to an era and a default of everything's fake and this must be AI and there's very little trust. And so that's actually where I have a lot of fear that Students aren't able to navigate true sources and figure out what's real and that there's just this, it can't be real. So that's one piece. And I think that the other piece is that it becomes overwhelming.

SPEAKER_02It becomes overwhelming to navigate, especially news stories, when you take how much content is out there and you could pick any topic and think about that. And then I think the last piece here for a lot of students as well is that, you know, They're spending so much time online. And again, our schools were closed last week. And so one of my prompts yesterday was, what did you do when you weren't in school? And I said, you can't say on your phone because I know that that would be the answer. And so we know how these algorithms work.

SPEAKER_02And so the more and more time on their phone, the more and more sort of things that are coming at them. And I think that becomes overwhelming. A lot of students talk about... When they take a screen break, how much better they feel. And so how do we think about that too?

SPEAKER_01How does this relate to teaching history, for example, as opposed to talking about current events and more contemporary subjects, Valerie? I think Joel can speak to this more in terms of some of the lessons that have been created.

SPEAKER_02But one of the The lessons that dig that I really like specifically looks at the time period after the Civil War. And there's a lot of content on various medias and we also have historical documents. So it's a really beautiful merging of Looking at historical documents, what did they say? And then looking at content creators, and some are historians, some aren't. And so all of a sudden you see this, you know, students going, oh, wow,

this is interesting.

SPEAKER_02Right. And so kind of thinking about We call it a grabber in education, right? I want to get them interested in learning something, and oftentimes that is the way to do it, is to have this overlap as opposed to, oh no, she's going to make me look at another document that's, you know, from the 1800s and language that's really hard to read. So yeah, maybe Joel can also speak to some of the other lessons that are out there that I think do a nice combination of this.

SPEAKER_01But before Joel comments on that, expand that a little bit, Valerie, in terms of what you see, how this plays out in different age groups and different socioeconomic groups in terms of the impact of media on these kids. What I will say for the 12th graders specifically is they're also navigating this

SPEAKER_02I'm about to leave Part of their lives and going into college. And we have a lot of conversations about, you know, how do you do your own work in college, believe it or not, right? How do you make sure that the things that you're writing and doing are yours when it comes to college, but also how do you navigate potentially fake information, right? And so, you know, they've They've had people around them helping them do that.

SPEAKER_02And then once you leave, you're on your own to do that. And then I would also argue for the younger students, in many cases, you know, they just haven't, you know, elementary school isn't a lot of things online, right? Or you're using apps that are very, very sheltered. And all of a sudden, you know, you're doing work independently and you have the entire internet. And sometimes students fall into that trap of really not knowing how to do things on their own. And this is where they might find a website that isn't factual

and hasn't been sourced.

SPEAKER_02So I think a lot of times for students it becomes very overwhelming. It's probably the best answer I have.

SPEAKER_01Joel, talk about it in terms of keeping up with the changes that are taking place, the changes in the amount of information that's out there. And now we're seeing a complete reconstruction of the process as a result of AI. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Without a doubt, it is a rapidly changing environment and it requires frequent updates, far more updating of materials than is required for the history curriculum. And we need to make sure that the I think the kinds of resources that we are creating reflect the lives that students are living. As as Valerie noted, we need to find a bridge between students online lives and what's happening in classrooms. And one part of our approach is what we saw expert online

searchers do in a

SPEAKER_00research project that we did shortly after our initial study, asking young people to evaluate online sources and what we saw was fact checkers from Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman Heffschechman

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman heffschechtman Talk Cocktail Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_00I'll see you next time

SPEAKER_02Can I actually comment on that, Jeff, really quickly?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was going to say, what this also means is a lot more reading, a lot more work for the kids.

SPEAKER_02Well, I would say that, you know, Joel touched on two things that I just wanted to say, that it is hard to keep up. You know, I had no interest in being on TikTok, to be honest. But then I realized that I need to at least see what's out there because that's what students are using, right? And that's where they are. And so it's me trying to figure out how does this work? How am I finding information? And as you can imagine, for a lot of teachers... We have so many things that we're trying to manage all the time, right?

And so the idea that we would add another thing becomes really overwhelming.

SPEAKER_02So I think that's one of the challenges. And then you asked about what it looks like for different socioeconomic backgrounds and different groups. As well, where people get their information changes. If you can look at things coming off of WhatsApp groups. And for a lot of students, they get things off gaming platforms like Discord. I'm not a gamer. So it's just interesting to see that there's so much information Jeff Schechtman heffschechtman Talk Cocktail Podcast

What is the attitude about teachers in general, Valerie, about all of this?

SPEAKER_01Because it does, exactly as you say, create an added burden and really a responsibility to stay up to date, not only on TikTok, but once that goes away, whatever comes after TikTok and whatever comes after that.

SPEAKER_02I mean, truthfully, when the New York Times article came out, I had a lot of people say, oh my gosh, that's really cool. But very few said, ooh, can I get in on this? Because it just becomes overwhelming. That said, there are a lot of English teachers here in SFUSD that are interested in thinking about how we frame this. Again, with the assembly bill coming out, there is supposed to be some movement here, so we'll see. I think for a lot of teachers, it just becomes,

I don't have the bandwidth and the capacity

SPEAKER_02So, yeah, I'm not sure what that looks like. Really, you know, if I were to frame this perfect world, these were skills that everybody would begin at the beginning of the school year and then be infused in little ways in all different classrooms throughout the year over the course of four years. So that by the time that students leave here, they really feel like they are media literate and specifically digital media literate.

SPEAKER_01How much different is it, if at all, do you think, given that you're teaching essentially in the belly of the beast, that in SFUSD, you are in the heart of where all of this technology is taking place? Talk about that. Yeah, I mean, that's one of the challenges is that, again, it's overwhelming.

SPEAKER_02The internet is overwhelming. There's just so many sources out there. But That's actually where a lot of students have two things. They have fear of what the future looks like. A lot of students are really worried about AI and what that means for jobs for them. But on the other side, They're really excited, right? They look at, I had a guest speaker recently that was a former student of mine who's a content creator and all the kids knew her. I didn't even know she was a content creator. When I found out someone's like, oh, do you remember her?

SPEAKER_02I said, she's famous. And so it's interesting, right? So there's, I think that we're in this time period for a lot of students where we're in a period of change. And so there's fear but there's also this excitement of what could be and we are near lots of companies that are doing this work. If I'm honest, I wish we had more collaboration in some ways with these organizations. I took my students to YesSF, which is run by the Chamber of Commerce,

and they listened to a panel of businesses talking about AI and the future of AI

SPEAKER_02and what it looks like. And a lot of them were really interested about that. And a student actually asked the question about, you know, what does it look like to make sure in your I think there's a lot of students are feeling the anxiety of it, but also, you know, the future could be a really powerful place for them. Is there any difference between the way you and other teachers are dealing with this and how administrators in the district are seeing it?

SPEAKER_02Oh, that's an interesting question. I have personally not heard from any administrator about this topic. And as far as I know, at least according to the SFUSC website, anything about media literacy really right now is only in grades K to five. But I know that Joel's work with other school districts, including LA. So maybe he could speak to that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I think that there's certainly a great deal of variation. We've been fortunate to work with Los Angeles Unified for many years, and there is definite interest in finding ways to integrate this content into classrooms, especially social studies classrooms. As Valerie noted, Folks feel overwhelmed by how much there is to do and how to make this part of their classrooms. And that just underscores the need for the rest of us to find

ways to support educators.

SPEAKER_00This can't just fall on their shoulders to find out ways to do this. We can't have mandates without materials. We have to find resources for educators to make it as easy as possible to implement the Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman,

SPEAKER_00Ph.D.: We need to create the resources to make that possible in classrooms and not just you know hope that it will happen after we passed. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: Legislation, we need to also create tools for teachers and then support them in using them well, this is not what we learned in teacher preparation programs. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: Years ago, and so that means that there needs to be professional development to support teachers in using materials that they can. implement readily in their classrooms.

SPEAKER_01And to what extent is this an ongoing program, Joel? And to what extent are teachers and schools being receptive of the things that you're doing?

SPEAKER_00We've had incredibly positive feedback. People are hungry for resources, and there's evidence that it works. Our team has done a series of studies where we have tested out these resources in real classrooms in our most robust Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: To date we worked in an urban school district in the Midwest and saw that after just six hours of instruction, which is less time than the typical American teenager spends online in a single day that we can see

And we've replicated that in other settings and so have other groups not associated

SPEAKER_00with our organization, both in the United States and in broad in Canada and in Sweden. Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: As well as in Italy, so this can work. The key part is finding ways to make it part and parcel of the curriculum so that there are, as Valerie said, Jeff Schechtman heffschechtman Talk Cocktail Podcast heffschechtman Talk Cocktail Podcast

What's a five or 10 minute activity that we can do together to talk about,

SPEAKER_00you know, what is the, what are the sources that you're seeing in your feeds today so that we can continue to build students capacity in making sense Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman, Ph.D.: And pointing out to students where they can find good sources of information as as Valerie highlighted,

there's a real danger in making students believe that they can't trust anything

SPEAKER_00that that plays into the hands of authoritarians. Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_02I think I'm probably on the end of older teachers at this point. But I like to think that I'm sticking with it. I actually have a tech background. When I came to education, this was my second career. So that's always been a passion of mine, is technology and how it impacts the classroom. I will definitely say that when younger teachers are coming into the building, they have new apps, they have new ideas. And so... That part's exciting, but I really think, again,

the fundamentals are the same, right?

SPEAKER_02The same as if you were looking at a primary source, you know, from the Revolutionary War to online media. We're really trying to teach the skills and the skills of understanding where this content information is coming from and whether we can trust that. And that can be really challenging. I'll say that the other thing that becomes a challenge is that because on their phones specifically, and that's really where students are getting most of their content. They are consuming so much content at such a fast rate that

they're really not

SPEAKER_02taking it in, right? They are swiping, they're moving, they're moving, they're moving. If you ever watch a teenager on their phone, it is nonstop. And then when we get to school and we're asking them to slow down and really look at something, that becomes a challenge and how to do that. And I think that, you know, For newer teachers, they've only ever existed in that fast-paced world, too. And so they have sort of this conflict with how do I create an environment where we're all slowing down, myself included. And in fact,

though, they come to this, many of them younger teachers, as digital natives. Does that make it tougher or harder for them to deal with students on these issues?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's an interesting question. You know, this would be a great panel is what it looks like with younger teachers. But I, for my observations, I've had student teachers that are much younger. And they almost as digital natives, they almost default to wanting to not use tech in the classroom, which I think is really interesting. They're looking at sort of How do we do things that are more creative and break kids from their phones? I think, again, in part because they want to take a break.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, I think that's an interesting question. I mean, Joel might work with some newer teachers as well and can speak to that. I know that we are both going to be working with in a couple of weeks with a Stanford education class. So all brand new teachers. So I think, Joel, this would be a really interesting thing to talk about with them.

SPEAKER_00Joel? Yeah, I was just thinking the same thing of that upcoming session with the Stanford Teacher Education Program. I think that there is the opportunity to encounter these questions in different ways, depending on teachers' backgrounds. And that there's opportunity there. I think the key part is to make sure that folks feel empowered to do that work and have opportunities to be in conversation with their colleagues. Jeff Schechtman,

SPEAKER_00Ph.D.: If this is going to be really meaningfully addressed in classrooms, we all need to work together to find ways that work for students, but also work for teachers and that always is more effective when there is collaboration across ages and across subject areas. Valerie was talking about English language arts teachers. We've done work where we have integrated digital literacy Does this add, Valerie, to teacher burnout?

I don't think this is the topic that adds to teacher burnout if I'm honest.

SPEAKER_02You know, it's probably the 36 students in my classroom every hour. But that said, yeah, I mean, you know, this constant addition of tasks, absolutely, it can feel overwhelming. We just have so many things coming at us all the time. You know, there's that That data around how many decisions certain jobs make a day and it's like aircraft controllers, emergency room nurses and teachers. That's true. And one thing I'll add on that related sort of to this topic is I think it becomes challenging to figure out how we teach these

skills when we have

SPEAKER_02the question of phones in schools. There's a lot of talk about banning phones in schools. I'm not going to take a stance on that, but I will say that this is where students get this content. This is where they're finding it's on their phones. And so it's harder to teach these skills if the phones aren't there and you can't get on TikTok or anything in the school and all of that's been banned. So that's going to be a challenge going forward to think about how we do this if our sources are limited.

SPEAKER_02Even in the curriculum from Digg, you know, there's these videos that have been downloaded because in some schools you can't access that. And so that also becomes a challenge.

SPEAKER_01And Valerie, what scares you the most about the future of education given all of this technology we're talking about?

SPEAKER_02Oh, great question. Potentially that teachers are replaced. you know just by online sources and you know students that are often doing online work are very passive they are just Checking the boxes, filling out the thing, writing the essay, probably with Gemini or ChatGPT, turning it in and there's no human connection. And what I find is many of the best days in my classroom are when we are

interacting with each other and I'm learning from them as much as they're learning

SPEAKER_02from me. And I do worry that there could be a world where that doesn't happen. And I think for a lot of students that are already in online programs, that interaction is missing. I also worry that without teaching students these skills that, you know, misinformation is going to lead and that could be really problematic for the future specifically of public education. Valerie Ziegler, Joel Breakstone, I thank you both so much for spending time with us. Thank you. Thank you so much for having us. And you gave me a lot to think about. I really appreciate it.

Thank you for listening and joining us here on the California Sun Podcast.

SPEAKER_01I hope you'll join us next week. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Thomas Frank asked “What’s the Matter With Kansas”? Now he asks What’s the Matter With Creativity?

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Surrogacy Scandal That Exposed a Very Broken System

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Those Powers That Congress Gave the Supreme Court? Congress Can Take Them Away

    Nov 11, 202639 minAudio

    The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. One Win Is Not a Lasting Majority

    Nov 7, 202641 minAudio

    Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Religious Movement That’s Done With Democracy

    Oct 31, 202628 minAudio

    Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...

    Credit the people on this episode