The digital world is being rebuilt around AI, and for the first time in a generation the concrete of that world is still wet. Lainey Feingold thinks that's the opportunity! Technology can now read any text aloud, describe any image, caption any voice in real time - the most powerful equalizer disabled people have ever had, if it's designed in rather than bolted on. Feingold, a disability rights lawyer who won talking ATMs and accessible banking without ever filing a lawsuit, has gathered thirty-nine authors from ten countries into Digital Accessibility Ethics. Their case: build for the person at the edge and everyone gets a better product. Who do we decide to build for? Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the program. I'm Jeff Schechtman. But almost none of it is cruelty either. The walls didn't go up out of malice. They went up out of expediency. The cheaper path, the simpler build, the default that shipped on deadline.
SPEAKER_00Exclusion is mostly what happens when no one in the room had a reason to think of the person who wasn't. The quiet machinery of leaving people out runs on nothing more sinister than convenience. For three decades, the remedy has mostly arrived as a threat. Comply or get sued. And lately the threats have become an industry of their own. A wave of drive-by lawsuits that treats access less as a moral question than as a shakedown and leaves the people it claims to defend exactly where they started.
SPEAKER_00But compliance is a flaw, and a flaw was never the point. The point was belonging. And here's the secret, hiding inside of all of it. This was never really about them. The curb cut was carved for the wheelchair. And now it carries the stroller, the suitcase, the delivery cart. The caption was written for the deaf. And now the whole bar reads it over the noise. Build a world that works for the people at the edge, and you have quietly built a better world for everyone in the middle. Inclusion isn't charity bolted onto good design.
SPEAKER_00It is good design, and it pays its way out into a hundred corners no one was even aiming at. Which is what makes this particular moment so electric. Because the entire digital world is being poured again from scratch around artificial intelligence. And a thing that gets built only once every few generations is right now, wet concrete. We almost never get to start over. But we're getting to start over. Down one path, access is written into the first line of code and the technology
SPEAKER_00that could read any text aloud, describe any image, caption any voice in real time, and become the greatest equalizer disabled people. The same hands are on the same wet concrete. The only question is whether this time we do it on purpose. My guest has spent her career proving you can. Lainey Feingold built her reputation not by suing the banks and giant corporations,
SPEAKER_00but by sitting down across the table and getting them to choose. Talking ATMs, accessible sites, inclusion arrived at by agreement instead of verdict. She is living proof that the right thing and the smart thing It's editor is my guest today, Lainey Feingold. It is my pleasure.
SPEAKER_00To welcome her here to the program. Lainey, thanks so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_01Oh, Jeff, thank you so much for having me and for that introduction, which just captures everything we're going for.
SPEAKER_00Well, I want to talk about this idea first of discrimination being in some cases purposeful, but in so many cases simply neglect and just efficiency or just trying to get things done. Talk about what you see in that regard in a general sense first, and then we'll narrow it down to this whole digital area that you talk about.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that is a great question. Disability discrimination is It can be very intentional and it can also be, as you mentioned at the top, people just not thinking about the people who are going to use the products and services. There's over a billion people with disabilities across the globe and we know how to design and make them so they work for people who can't see,
SPEAKER_01people who can't hold a mouse, people who And
SPEAKER_00in those cases where we don't, is it lack of understanding or lack of caring? I mean, in terms of the results, it doesn't matter. But talk about what you see in terms of the people you talk to with respect to these issues.
SPEAKER_01Well, there's lots of different motivations why things come out they do. I do think it is lack of caring. It is lack of understanding. But it's also lack of education. I am consistently disappointed when I talk to random strangers, as I do, who tell me they're in tech. And I say, well, what do you know about making things work for disabled people? And nine times out of ten, people are very interested.
SPEAKER_01They want to know. But too many of them don't. Too many students get out of college without ever hearing about Digital accessibility and making tech work for disabled people. Kids are learning to code, you know, or use AI to code in elementary school. Accessibility is just left out. Assumptions are made about who's using technology, and those assumptions don't include disabled people.
SPEAKER_00And is this a problem that is larger in the tech world or is it a larger problem in business and really in enterprise in general that there is this lack of understanding or lack of acknowledgement?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, we have to be careful in making assumptions in this conversation, for example, because there are companies, large companies, I think I say in the introduction that there's Pockets of accessibility culture all over the world. It's just that there's not enough of them. And too often people are motivated, especially in this current tech environment, let's do things fast. Let's, you know, break things and fix them later.
SPEAKER_01Let's do things cheaper. And people aren't stopping to say, okay, what is the impact of this type of process that So yeah, it's a whole combination of things. It's capitalism and how money is spent. It's lack of education. It's pressure to do things faster, to be the first one out of the box.
SPEAKER_01It's an assumption that AI can fix everything so we don't have to worry about it. Many factors contribute too.
SPEAKER_00Certainly there are people with disabilities within the tech world, within the tech community. What have they been able to infuse into that environment that has been helpful or have they been listened to?
SPEAKER_01What I'd say about that, I think it's widely acknowledged when you have disabled people in the room, the outcome of the decisions in that room are going to be more inclusive. The employment rate for people with disabilities is still dismal. But again, there are pockets where accessible technology is enabling people to work. We have a good chapter in the book about how hiring portals,
SPEAKER_01just the very way you get hired, it's all digital now. And that digital, whether it's how you submit your application, who Or what scans your resume? Who or what is doing your interview and evaluating it? All of those things can either encourage inclusion or can exclude.
SPEAKER_00What has been, as you've seen it and the people that write some of the stories in the book, what has been the greatest resistance point in terms of making these changes within the tech world? Is it an issue of money? Is it issue of not knowing? What has been the greatest really pressure point that fights back against this?
SPEAKER_01I think there's a perception that it's a lot more expensive to make things inclusive for people with disabilities than And actually, there's a lot of research done on this that when you do it right from the beginning, it doesn't really add that much of a cost. It's just like you say, when no one is in the room talking about its importance, then it tends to get left out. People either don't know, they don't want to spend the money,
SPEAKER_01they don't want to put the time into it, they don't want to put the resources into it. It's seen as an other. It doesn't affect us all. But like you said at the top, when things are inclusive for disabled people, they're more inclusive for everyone, including people without disabilities.
SPEAKER_00How has ADA played into this whole world in terms of accessibility in the tech world?
SPEAKER_01The ADA, the Americans with Disabilities Act, was enacted in this country in 1990. Ever since as early as 1996, the United States Department of Justice said that the ADA applies to technologies. Now, of course, we have a totally different Department of Justice here now that should not even still be called the Department of Justice. But the ADA is still strong.
SPEAKER_01And the ADA has really two components that impact digital accessibility. And one is, it's a non-discrimination law. You can't leave people out. And this book proposes the digital accessibility ethics framework. It's a first time that there is a lens that we're offering to say, let's look at these issues through Ethics and the values of ethics, and one of those values is inclusion.
SPEAKER_01Another of those values is avoiding the risks and harms of exclusion, and that's what the ADA is all about. The other part of the ADA, besides non-discrimination, that makes it relevant in the digital age, even though the law is 30-plus years old now, is that it says, We need to effectively communicate with each other. And we are all communicating digitally now.
SPEAKER_01If you design a website that hasn't been designed so people can use it, if they can't hold a mouse, if they can't see a screen, if they can't hear a video, then you are not effectively communicating. So that's why the ADA is... The ADA is relevant. I've used the ADA in my work since 1995. As you mentioned at the top, I started doing collaborations with the blind community, bringing blind people and bankers together in a room to build the relationship so
SPEAKER_01that bankers could see, you know what? If we have an ATM that does not talk, a blind person has to share their PIN, has to disclose their private finances. Can't even get $20 of their own money out of a machine because nobody built this machine to be accessible. So the ADA underlie was underneath all the negotiations I did. But as you mentioned, we haven't had to do a lawsuit
SPEAKER_01because we've used this process called structured negotiation.
SPEAKER_00And how much progress have you seen over the past 10 years or so in the tech world in these areas?
SPEAKER_01Well, one thing to note is that the Digital Accessibility Ethics book is a global book. And as you mentioned, we have authors from 10 different countries. And I wrote a couple chapters as well as being an editor. I was one of three editors. The other two, Chancey Fleet and Regine Gilbert, and I are the editors of this book. I wrote a chapter on the global legal landscape and interviewed legal experts. Advocates for accessibility in a few countries, including India.
SPEAKER_01So when we talk about improvements, different countries at different paces, Indian Supreme Court has done a lot of good things because of advocates, because of the blind lawyers that I interviewed and other organizations in India to advance accessibility in that country. In Africa, we have a chapter on the digital accessibility landscape in Africa looking at what's happening on the continent written by two people in Kenya.
SPEAKER_01Kenya has adopted the first accessibility standards for the African continent, and now they're trying to expand it across all of Africa. So the pace has been different. I'm an optimist. I think I need to be an optimist to be in this for so long, especially in these very challenging times. So there have definitely been improvements. It's just the pace of progress isn't fast enough given what's at stake here.
SPEAKER_00Why do you think that there's been so much more progress in certain regards in other countries as opposed to the U.S. where so much of this technology is being developed?
SPEAKER_01Well, I didn't mean to say there hasn't been progress in the U.S. I meant to say that in all countries, you have to evaluate the progress sort of differently. And we have had the ADA for a long time. We have laws. We do have the lawsuits, as you mentioned. The Right to file a lawsuit in the United States can be abused, and I do write about that in the book as an ethical issue. There's a chapter on access to justice and what that means
SPEAKER_01when disabled people are excluded from that as justice systems move online. But there are also ethical lawsuits, and I speak around the world, and whenever I talk to advocates, I They're like, we don't even have lawyers in our country who understand accessibility and can advance it. You know, we want lawyers. We want to be able to file lawsuits. We don't necessarily want to import the entire U.S.
SPEAKER_01legal system that is so adversarial and can lend itself to abuse. But the law has contributed to progress. Also, The large tech companies, you know, a shout out to Microsoft, to Apple, have really integrated accessibility into the products. I'm not saying any one company is perfect. I'm not saying all the products are perfect.
SPEAKER_01But one of the things about the digital accessibility ethics framework, it calls on all of us to stop. We call it the power of the pause. You know, stop and ask a question. What assumptions am I making about who will use this technology? How have I ensured that this Word document that I'm going to send out or this social media post that I'm going to send out, how have I ensured that that works for everyone?
SPEAKER_01And you answer that question and you get to another question. And like you said, There's a million decisions being made, and we are at a particularly important one as AI continues to be marketed everywhere. Some of the big companies take your iPhone. There's so much accessibility built right into the iPhone. Most people don't know anything about it. In the settings, I invite all your listeners to go to accessibility and try all those things.
SPEAKER_01My 93-year-old dad who died this year, he worked up until the very end. He was always on the phone. He had a lot of trouble hearing. I said, Dad, I can put captions on your phone so you can see what the people are saying. Oh my God, he thought I was the smartest person in the world, but I wasn't. I just knew that built into the iPhones and also to the Android devices is a live captioning feature you just have to toggle on.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, same with the Microsoft and the emails, you can check them. There's an accessibility checker, just like a spell checker. If we can think about the ethics framework, And that there are values that I believe all people care about. Keeping information private, having secure systems, inclusion, fairness. If we just ask ourselves for everything we do in tech, whether we're a one-person operation or a global corporation,
SPEAKER_01who's being left out by this decision we're making? And let's make another decision. So inclusion is the norm instead of exclusion.
SPEAKER_00Have lawsuits had any value in motivating companies in some cases to do the right thing?
SPEAKER_01Yes. I'm going to say yes to that. Unfortunately, the lawsuits can also result in a very narrow understanding of what the right thing is. If all we have is Out of a lawsuit is a checklist. And the people who need the services and the products to be a consumer, be a creator, be a customer, be a professor, be a student,
SPEAKER_01if they're not part of the equation, then whatever comes out of a lawsuit is likely to be lost six months after the lawsuit's over. But what we try to do in the digital accessibility ethics book And about half the chapters are written by disabled people, is to tell some stories that this stuff really matters. Like we have one author from the Bahamas who's a double amputee and she, you know, is in the Bahamas, which is the center of hurricane activity and the whole globe.
SPEAKER_01And she writes about what does it mean when you haven't stopped to ask yourself, is the information about how to stay safe when possible? The hurricane is coming. Where to go for safety? If that is not designed with everybody in mind, people are going to die. So the risks of not doing accessibility go far beyond the legal risks. What's happening in the United States is that the focus is so much on the legal risks that we're missing the people side of the story.
SPEAKER_01And that is crucial to ethically handling accessibility.
SPEAKER_00In terms of addressing some of these accessibility issues, what is the nexus, as you see it, between needs in the real world, in the physical world, and in the digital world? Is progress moving in both areas simultaneously? Is one having a positive or a negative effect on the other? What is the nexus between the two, Ray?
SPEAKER_01Well, one thing is, is that the physical world and the digital world aren't necessarily two completely separate things. And we have a chapter in the book on smart cities about things like kiosks, traffic signals. I've worked on making sure traffic signals give out information to pedestrians so they know when to cross the street. If they can't see a walk, don't walk sign.
SPEAKER_01So there's a lot in the physical space. We have a smart cities chapter, as I said. We have a digital amenities chapter where you're in the physical space. You need to buy a ticket. You go to the ticket machine. The physical space sort of idea of that is if you're in a wheelchair, can you reach the buttons to buy the ticket, to enter your credit card so you don't have to share anything personal? And for blind people... Do these machines talk? So I think one of the things,
SPEAKER_01like you mentioned, the curb cut, we use a term called the curb cut effect, which is what's good for originally, what originally began as something for disability accommodation, like wheelchairs, now is good for everyone. In the digital world, as you said, we use often the caption, the caption example. Captions originally, of course, started for deaf people. They're helpful for all of us. There's a wonderful chapter in the book on cognitive accessibility,
SPEAKER_01which I personally learned so much from because how many of us Disabled or not disabled go to some sort of digital environment and can't figure out what to do next. Bombard it with information. What about how easy it is to sign up for something and how hard and complicated it is to cancel your subscription? So all of these things, disability as an innovator, disability as a way to embrace all of humanity,
SPEAKER_01I think people are more used to understanding, oh, we have to have a ramp into the building. You know, we know what an accessible toilet stall looks like because we've been in bathrooms, regardless. With digital, the knowledge still isn't as widespread as it needs to be. We have a really good chapter in the Digital Accessibility Ethics book on teaching accessibility, how to teach it.
SPEAKER_01What subject you are studying at any level of education, how can you make your digital resources more available, and how can you have an environment where professors with disabilities are able to flourish in their jobs? I find, I'll say I've been at it for a long time, as you mentioned, whenever I talk to people about the work I do, People are interested.
SPEAKER_01People want to know more. And people don't think it's fair that disabled people are left out. And that's why with this book, we're trying to say, yeah, it's not just about the law. You know, it's not just about a business advantage, which it is. It's about fairness. It's about privacy. It's about equitable decision making. It's about things that I think most people believe in. They just haven't connected the dots. So we're hoping this book can help do that.
SPEAKER_00What is happening as you see it now in the world of AI and the way that it is taking or not taking any of this into appropriate consideration?
SPEAKER_01That's a good question as you framed it, taking or not taking. Both things are happening. Our book has a foundational chapter on AI written by Yuta Trevrenes, who's a Canadian design professor and I would say probably the most Well-known and impactful person talking about the risks of harm as well as the benefits
SPEAKER_01to disabled people in the use of AI. And so there's a lot of ideas in the book about making sure that not only are AI tools accessible so people at work can use whatever tools there are, but what are we asking the AI to do? And When we ask AI to make decisions for us, you know, tell us who should get this job. Who should we favor when we interview? Should this person get health care coverage?
SPEAKER_01Should this person get into school? AI is doing all those things. And when you are an outlier, as people with disabilities are in a statistical sense, then disabled people are going to be hurt. We have a really great chapter on how employers use AI tools at work for all sorts of things. You know, there's people who work on computers and the AI is measuring how many keystrokes and did they take a break? A lot of those things are disability related.
SPEAKER_01So on the other hand, AI has made some great offerings in terms of, you know, its capacity to Help summarize large documents, to describe the visual world for people who are blind, still with the need for human intervention. And the thing about the digital accessibility ethics framework, as one of the editors and authors, it's like, wow, technology is changing so fast.
SPEAKER_01Can we write a book that's going to be useful six months after it's published? Yeah. That weighed on my shoulders from the very minute I had the sort of idea of this book, which was about six years ago. And I truly believe that the framework, which is values-driven, and suggests, okay, these are our values, and from that comes the actions we're going to take and the questions we're going to ask. Those are going to be the actions, the questions, the values for the technology tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01One of them is transparency. Very important when you're talking about AI, are you disclosing as an employer, as a university, as a healthcare system, are you disclosing what you're using AI for? Because the law is very clear in the United States and other places that people with disabilities have a right to accommodations when accessing Services and products. And if you don't even know that AI is being used to make decisions,
SPEAKER_01say you have a disability, say you have diabetes and you need to test your blood sugar more often, or you have something where you need to eat more often, you leave your desk, but the computer thinks because it's AI that you're screwing off instead of tending to an important healthcare need. So the transparency value of And the actions we have to take and the questions we have to ask when we're using AI, those are going to be around whatever the next generation of AI is.
SPEAKER_00What about in the area of education and technology? Because certainly we're seeing more and more technology incorporated into education. And we're seeing more and more pressure against a lot of accommodation within the education world right now with respect to disabilities.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, education is a huge topic. I mean, one thing I want to tell your listeners and you that in the conclusion of this book, we say we have written 32 chapters that we are proud of and we can envision. 32 more and 32 after that, written about different topics, written by people with disabilities, different disabilities, written from different countries. So, you know, we could have a whole book, 32 chapters on digital accessibility ethics in the education setting.
SPEAKER_01One of the chapters in the book is written by an author named Josh Mealy, who is a, he's a MacArthur genius, but he's, he's received a MacArthur genius award. He's an inventor, he's a blind physicist, and he writes about hackathons, which are a very common thing both in education and in Where people come together and they're going to solve a problem. And often those problems are, oh, let's solve a problem for a disabled person.
SPEAKER_01And he writes about how can we do that ethically, which should be required reading for anyone in education. How do you include disabled people? How do you make sure that disabled people are participating in every aspect of the educational program, the hackathon or the capstone project? Not just as students, but as professors, as invited experts, all those sorts of things.
SPEAKER_01So yes, I mean, everything is digital now more and more so. And wherever there is digital, It is our hope that this book will say, let's make the right decisions. You know, let's make decisions that incorporate the values where we're asking the right questions, where we're taking the right answers, where we're taking the right actions. And many of those questions are going to lead to, I don't know. Like how many disabled people were involved in the design of this product?
SPEAKER_01Someone down the pipeline is going to say, I don't know. It's not a wrong answer. That's a right answer that leads to the next question. How can we do better next time? How can we make sure we have disabled people in our teams? That kind of thing.
SPEAKER_00From a policy perspective, does the ADA need to be updated as a piece of legislation for the digital age?
SPEAKER_01I'm going to say no to that, in part because we have a very strong civil rights law in the ADA. Yes, of course, it could be stronger. But in this political environment, I would be opposed to opening up any law that provides any rights because the risk of it weakening is greater than the benefit of it strengthening.
SPEAKER_00I guess the other part of it is in a more normal political environment, should it be addressed?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's okay. There has been a push to open the ADA or mend the ADA to... Require notification before lawsuits can be filed about digital accessibility or other types of accessibility. And that impetus to make that change is driven by lawyers who I believe don't act ethically in using the ADA. Well, I don't think we should open it regardless of the reason.
SPEAKER_01There's never going to be a time where there's not a threat of it being weakened. And the law is strong. I mean, the courts starting in about 2017 in the U.S. have recognized that the ADA covers websites, that the ADA covers mobile apps, covers kiosks. I mean, I could in an ideal world write some legislation that would be More mandatory for digital accessibility that would, especially on the employment side,
SPEAKER_01make it more robust when it comes to requiring accessible tools at work. But I'm going to still say no to opening up the law. I will say this, that there are... There are laws – there's legislation pending that would not open up the ADA, but a new law that could provide more recognition of the digital age.
SPEAKER_01I'm in favor of that. I've written about it right now. I'm forgetting that. I'm forgetting the name. But there's a law that's been introduced the last couple of years that would more directly make developers – Responsible for putting out accessible websites. Would more directly go to other entities, the people who are creating the platforms that may not otherwise be covered by the ADA. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_01We could have stronger laws. And some of them, there's a law we have on Communication and Video Accessibility Act. They have a law pending in Congress legislation. I mean... Personally, I don't see any positive legislation happening for the next period of time, but I value the advocates who are pushing it even in this time. So yes, I don't favor opening the ADA, but yes, there are ways that we could have laws that recognize digital is everywhere,
SPEAKER_01and if digital is everywhere, accessibility has to be everywhere.
SPEAKER_00And finally, is there an activist community, disability community in Silicon Valley that is addressing these issues or working for some of these issues?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yes. There are thousands of people who have an accessibility certification from something called the International Association of Accessibility Professionals. And there are people in every... I'll take that back. There are people... In lots of the Silicon Valley companies, I mentioned Apple, Salesforce has a strong accessibility team inside Microsoft. I usually hate to mention companies because I'll hang up the,
SPEAKER_01you know, we'll be off this call and I'll remember, oh my God, I forgot to talk about this. Workday has an accessibility team. There are accessibility teams. We have digital accessibility conferences. We have lots of books on digital accessibility. And we have the advocates outside, disabled people who are constantly demanding that a product be made accessible. I'm always, when I talk to corporations, I say, look at your call logs. Look at the people who are writing into you.
SPEAKER_01And if they're saying, you know, in the And you're chapped to your chatbot or wherever. I can't find this. Or I'm not able to do this. Or I can't do this myself. And I have to ask for help. Those are all accessibility issues. Not everybody's going to call up and say, we have a, you know, you missed an accessibility standard. We haven't mentioned this, but there is an accessibility standard.
SPEAKER_01The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines that has been in force since the late 1990s, it was supposed to be incorporated into parts of the ADA this year. The administration has bumped it for a year, but they're out there. Advocates are always advocating for more inclusion of it. So yes, accessibility is now an industry. It is also a community.
SPEAKER_01It's a community of activists. It's a community of disabled people and allies. And we're not going away. The idea of this book is here's another tool. Here's an ethics framework that you can use. Even if you're a one-person person using tech, if you post a picture on social media, describe the picture. So someone who can't see is going to know what your post is about. If you're a global company,
SPEAKER_01you know, all these values, everything you touch has ethical implications. So, you know, let's get it done.
SPEAKER_00Lainey Feingold's book is Digital Accessibility Ethics, Disability Inclusion, and All Things Tech. Lainey, I thank you so much for spending time with us.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...