For seventy-five years the truth about UFOs has been just about to come out, and never quite arrives. Adam Kirsch, senior editor at The Atlantic, tells me that the real question was never whether aliens are real, but why we so badly need the answer to be yes. In his new book, We Want to Believe, he reads UFO belief as a kind of faith, disclosure as a Messiah forever late, absence of evidence folded in as proof of a cover-up. Underneath sits a harder possibility: that we may be the only minds in the universe, and meaning rests on us alone. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Talk Cocktail Podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. For 75 years, the truth has been just about to come out. Any day now, the files will open. Any day now, someone who knows will finally say it out loud. Once the creatures came to invade us, and the movies of the atomic age taught a nervous country to watch the sky for an enemy that wore the face of one across the ocean. Then the fear turned inward. In the shadow of Watergate, close encounters gave us a working man who only wanted to know what was going on.
SPEAKER_01And a government bent on making him doubt his own eyes. The visitors were innocent and the villain was the cover-up. And then Disclosure Day arrived in theaters, promising the very thing the faithful have awaited all along. The moment that the secret breaks open and the world is finally told the truth. We treat all of this as a question about the sky. Are they real? Are we alone? My guest today, Adam Kirsch, says we've been asking the wrong questions from the start. The real mystery was never up there.
SPEAKER_01It's down here in us, in why a whole culture decided that the defining revelation And he thinks the movies aren't only reflecting that faith, they may in fact be rightful. ...By which the crankish old UFO...
SPEAKER_01And it is my pleasure to... ...to welcome Adam Kirsch to the program to talk about his new work, We Want to Believe, How Aliens Went Mainstream and Why It Matters.
SPEAKER_01Adam, thanks so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Jeff. I'm really glad to be here.
SPEAKER_01Well, it is a delight to have you here. I want to talk, first of all, about why your interest in this subject, in UFOs, and everything that we'll talk about that goes along with it. It's not something that I think people would have attributed to you initially.
SPEAKER_00I think that's true. And your introduction, which I loved, gets at some of the reasons why this subject interested me. I'm not a scientist or a science writer, so I'm not writing about UFOs and aliens really from that point of view. What interests me is, as you mentioned, the sort of resemblance to religious and spiritual longings that I think you can see in the UFO believer in our collective way of thinking about, is there life beyond Earth? Are there other minds? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00It started to look for a while as though there might be more to the UFO than just the sort of made up stories and science fiction that we were used to. There was some reporting that the Pentagon had videos of military pilots encounters with UFOs. There were people who I got interested in that story for the same reason I think
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of people did, which is that I think it would be really amazing to be living in the time when we discovered alien life, that we made contact with extraterrestrial intelligence. And then as I followed the story and learned more, well, what is the facts and what are the science beneath it all? I think that we don't have any evidence that UFOs have been here. There's always better explanations for the things that people claim to be a UFO sighting or an alien encounter. But then in a way that only makes the subject more interesting because it raises the question of why do we want to believe so much?
SPEAKER_00What is it about UFOs that excites our imagination?
SPEAKER_01And that really is a key part of it. There seems to be such a desperate desire among so many people to want the answer to be yes. More than, gee, this is worth exploring. Let's see what the truth is. But there's just such a need for a yes answer.
SPEAKER_00I think that's right. I'll see you next time.
SPEAKER_00Even beyond the sort of scientific research agenda, for those scientists who are engaged in it, often there is a spiritual or moral, some sort of deep longing for the answer to be yes. Carl Sagan, who was a great astronomer, I'll see you next time. Which is what really makes it almost like a religion and the desire for some kind
SPEAKER_00of disclosure to be like a messiah coming. Yes, there's a sort of basic similarity with religion or with stories about miracles that
SPEAKER_00when we talk about UFOs, there are lots of stories of people saying, I saw an alien, I saw a UFO, I've encountered this. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It raises this question of what does it mean to believe in something? Do we believe in things only because we can prove them? Or is belief what we have when we can't prove something? It's sort of in place of proof. And then when we apply that fundamentally religious idea of faith to something like a UFO sighting or an alien encounter, which in theory is not supernatural, right? Those are things that should exist in time and space, should be obeying the laws of physics just like we do ourselves. Right. You get to this sort of impasse where there are people who say,
SPEAKER_00I saw an alien, I saw a UFO, and then are not able to produce that kind of evidence. So in a way, it becomes almost a leap of faith on everyone's part to say, well, I'm going to choose to believe in this, even though there's no convincing concrete evidence.
SPEAKER_01Is there a nexus or perhaps coincidence between the fact that some of the stuff that has been released by the Pentagon now is coming within the context of an administration that is, and a defense department in particular, that leans towards this Christian nationalism and some of those ideas and how that ties in to this belief in UFOs?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's a long story of how religion and belief in extraterrestrials have gotten along with each other historically, meaning starting back in the 17th century when people started to get a more accurate idea of the solar system, the idea So the earth is a planet and there are other planets and then beyond that other parts of the universe. Historically, religious belief argued for the non-existence of extraterrestrials because the biblical account of creation doesn't exist.
SPEAKER_00Talk about them. If you believe that God created Adam and Eve, God created this planet as a home for humanity, that God sent his son to redeem humanity, all of that leads to the idea that we are the center of creation. We are the things that matter most in the universe. And if you imagine that there are other intelligent species somewhere else out there, it raises some challenging questions about the Bible as a truthful record about religious belief. People who were religious spokespeople for religion tended to not believe in extraterrestrials.
SPEAKER_00And for centuries, believing that there was extraterrestrial life was a mark of a scientific, free-thinking mind. So if you look at the kinds of people who believed in that in the 17th, 18th, 19th centuries, they were often... Philosophers like Immanuel Kant. They were scientists like Alfred Russell Wallace. They were freethinkers. That was a sort of a mark of skepticism about religion to say, well, why are we unique? There's no reason to think that we are Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I'll see you next time. There's no reason to believe that humanity is alone in the universe. And then in the 20th century, there's this sort of big surprise that awaits us because once we develop the technology to actually be able to look out into
SPEAKER_00the universe using radio astronomy or even And as far as we know currently nothing alive at all. So if there was any life on Mars, for example, it might have existed a very long time ago or it might exist deep under the surface, but it certainly isn't the kind of life that we would be able to have a conversation with. So that really challenged scientific assumptions.
SPEAKER_00The assumption was there's nothing unique about Earth, so there must be life in lots of places. But as far as we can tell so far, there isn't life any place that we can find except on Earth. And that puts us in a strange position, which is How do we reconcile those two ideas? Which brings us to the current decade or where UFOs have become almost respectable, I mean, in terms of politics and in terms of the way people talk about them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's been a real transformation starting again about 10 years ago, or transformation in the way that the media, the government, mainstream culture talks about UFOs. I think we might be moving towards the end of this period that... The New York Times and the Washington Post published articles saying that the Defense Department had
SPEAKER_00A secret program called the Advanced Aeronautic Threat Identification Program, or maybe Aerospace Threat Identification Program, ATIP. And that this was a sort of small and hidden in the budget Pentagon program whose job was... And that was to collect reports of military encounters with unidentified flying objects. And at the same time, they published these videos which had been circulating on social media before but had never been officially acknowledged by the Defense Department. This is a video that came to be called Pentagon UFO videos.
SPEAKER_00And these were videos taken by military aircraft, infrared cameras on military aircraft. So they're black and white images showing blobs, circles, things moving in ways at speeds, Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The government and the Defense Department had always said, we do not believe in UFOs. We don't take any account of UFO reports. This is not part of our reality. And it had just sort of ignored them. And now it turned out that, in fact, at least in this one small corner of the Defense Department, there was someone paying attention to these things and even had evidence that might be evidence of encounters with UFOs. And that sort of created a lot of excitement, especially among the UFO community, UFO believers who Disclosure is the idea that the government knows more
SPEAKER_00than it's letting on. It has these secrets hidden away and that one day they will have to come out and people who believe in UFOs will be vindicated. It'll turn out that in fact the government, scientists, the military knew all along that there was evidence of UFOs and was just concealing it for their own reasons. And so in 2017, it looked for a moment as though maybe we're about to get disclosure.
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, depending on your point of view, there has not been any real disclosure beyond that. We haven't gotten to the next stage, which would be here is a closure. And I think the sort of logical conclusion is that it hasn't emerged because it doesn't exist. Although there are, of course, still people who say that it hasn't emerged because it's being hidden.
SPEAKER_01The hidden part of it is particularly interesting because the people that are perhaps the most skeptical out there, people that are distrusting of government on every level, are the ones that are also relying on government or believing that it's government that's keeping the secret.
SPEAKER_00Right. It's very similar to other kinds of distrust of government over scientific things. I talk in the book, for example, about vaccine skepticism. If you believe that scientific experts and government experts know the truth and they're hiding it from us about It's in a similar way. You could say they know the truth about UFOs and they're hiding it from us maybe because they think that disclosing the truth would cause panic or maybe because they're trying to gain There are
SPEAKER_00different motives that you could advance for this. But the idea that the government isn't telling us the truth, that there are hidden parts to the story that we are not supposed to know, but that we can figure out by sort of And what it does is it makes what all of this does, it makes the belief immune from its own failure because the absence of any kind of evidence becomes the evidence.
SPEAKER_00That's right. It's impossible to falsify a negative claim. So if you were to say UFOs don't exist and someone says, well, I believe they do exist, prove that they don't exist. It's very hard to prove a negative. All you can say is no one has ever produced any evidence That would be convincing that UFOs have been here, that UFOs or aliens have been on Earth. What there has been and what the government continues to release are blurry, vague, unclear images or some images that seem ridiculous. You know, obviously doctored or fake.
SPEAKER_00But if you think about it in sort of common sense terms, if there were a UFO and it appeared over a populated area, you would think that there would be not just maybe one photograph of it, but thousands or maybe even hundreds of thousands of images of it. Because after all, today almost everyone is walking around carrying a camera in their pocket. If something that extraordinary appeared in the sky or landed on the earth, you'd think that someone would take their phone out of their pocket and take a picture of it. Or that it would show up on radars or that it would show up on a space telescope.
SPEAKER_00And it never does. None of those things ever happen. That's something that's been remarked upon about UFOs from the beginning. Carl Jung, the psychologist, wrote a book about UFO belief in the 1950s in which he said UFOs are not photogenic. There's something about them that prevents people from taking pictures of them. Even people who say, I saw a UFO, then never seem to be able to produce a photograph that they took of the UFO. It's an area where claims are made that can't really be tested in the ordinary ways.
SPEAKER_00And so people have to fall back on other ways of thinking.
SPEAKER_01And because it is so imagination driven, essentially, it's part of why Hollywood has been in love with UFOs since the 50s.
SPEAKER_00Yes, there's been endless appetite for UFO stories. And Steven Spielberg made one of the great or maybe two of the great UFO or alien movies in Close Encounters of the Third Kind and then E.T. Close Encounters is a movie. I think it's a much better movie than Disclosure Day, which is about a lot of the same themes. But it really taps into this sense that The government knows more than it's letting on, that ordinary people have these experiences that they are being told by officials, by scientists and authorities couldn't be real,
SPEAKER_00but by insisting on the authenticity of their own experience, they can overtake. And that basic situation of saying, I believe something that the experts tell me can't be true, is something that a lot of people experience in lots of different ways. Fundamentally, it's what we all experience with religion. If you're a religious believer, you believe things that science says couldn't happen. So if a miracle can happen, you have faith that it happens.
SPEAKER_00In a similar way, UFOs are something that demand and inspire faith, even though, as I said earlier, there isn't anything inherently supernatural about a UFO. A UFO is theoretically an alien piece of technology that obeys the same laws of physics. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00And the majority is supposed to rule. It's not supposed to be a small group of experts tells you what you can and can't think. So if a group of experts says, for example, you should take this vaccine because I know that it's going to be good for you. And there are lots of people who will say, well, I know better than anyone else what's right for my body or for my children, for my family. It becomes a question of authority. Who has the authority to define what's right and what's real?
SPEAKER_01Talk about that need, that essentially that need to believe. I mean, certainly it has deep historical roots, but if we look at it in terms of the modern era and from a generational perspective, it seems to cross generational lines.
SPEAKER_00Well, one thing that I say in the book is that human beings living in the space age, so maybe in the last half century or so, we're in a unique position in the history of humanity because before the 20th century, I'd say that basically everyone in every culture It was sort of a basic belief for just about everyone that there are other kinds of minds.
SPEAKER_00Those could be minds of angels, of spirits, of ghosts, God, or different kinds of gods. There are lots of different names for these other minds, but virtually every belief system, religious, mythological, or even Just common sense ideas about spirits. Most people would have said, for most of human history, no, human beings are not the only minds in existence. And as the scientific revolution sort of changed the way that humans Scientifically minded people thought about the supernatural.
SPEAKER_00Then people started to say, we may no longer believe in spirits or ghosts, but we believe that there are minds on other planets. We believe that there are intelligent creatures like us elsewhere in the physical universe. Why shouldn't there be? That's sort of the basic principle of Copernicanism. That's the idea that Copernicus sort of introduced into the world, which is there's nothing unique or special about Earth. For a long time, humanity thought that Earth was the center of the universe, the And so by that principle, there must be other minds out there. That's sort of just a scientific truism.
SPEAKER_00Now, it's still true that there's nothing unique about Earth from a scientific perspective. And so it's still the logic still holds that there should be other minds. But what's unique about our experience in the last 50 years or so is that for the first time we could actually look for those other minds in a real way. And we haven't found any evidence of them. So that forces us to confront the possibility that we may be the only minds in the universe, or at the very least, we might be the only minds that we can ever make contact with.
SPEAKER_00And also no natural beings that we know how to contact or could ever communicate with, then humanity really is the only mind available in the world. And that's an unprecedented situation. And I think it's something that is very hard for us to live with individually and collectively. It's not what we want to believe about ourselves, about the universe. And aliens are one way of answering that question. It's a way of saying there is something else out there and we can make contact with it.
SPEAKER_01Why don't we want to believe that? Why are we so afraid of this loneliness idea?
SPEAKER_00I think that it puts this huge burden on humanity if what we value about ourselves is that we have minds, we're able to think, we're able to experience reality in a conscious way that animals can't and that certainly, you know, Anything that's not an animal, like a plant or a rock or a star or a comet, anything that we know about that exists, exists physically, but it doesn't exist mentally. And I think that we all have a sense, an instinctive sense, that if there isn't something like a It's being observed, being thought about, being
SPEAKER_00Thank you. We're the only kind of mind out there. So if we're the—
SPEAKER_00Sort of only thing supporting mind, consciousness, meaning in the universe. It leaves meaning in this incredibly fragile and vulnerable position. And that's a hard thing for us to bear, to sustain. We're not up to that challenge, I don't think. And we want to share it. We have this deep need to share it.
SPEAKER_01How much of that is dealt with in some way, in some cases the wrong way, by the fact that the whole UFO belief system fits into a lot of other conspiracy theories that are out there? It sort of taints it in a way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that the desire to believe in UFOs is the desire is so strong that it outstrips the evidence, which is something that you could say about a lot of beliefs that are very important to humanity, that our desire to believe in it goes beyond our ability to prove that it's real. And so if you don't want to give up the belief that humanity has made contact with UFOs, you know, it's so important to believe that you want to sustain that belief at all costs,
SPEAKER_00then the lack of evidence for the belief becomes a problem. And you are led to Maybe it's It's being hidden by the government, scientists, military, defense contractors. But someone out there has it and is hiding it. And that breeds paranoia. It breeds conspiracy theories.
SPEAKER_00Disclosure Day, the movie, is one big conspiracy fantasy where there's an evil corporation that's hiding all this evidence. It's all on a thumb drive. And a whistleblower is trying to get it out into the world before they can stop him. But if you want to sustain the belief in UFOs, you almost have to believe something like that. Or else you have to accept that there's no evidence for it.
SPEAKER_01It really is. I mean, it goes back to Close Encounters, this idea that shifted really from the 50s when we were afraid of the aliens and the aliens somehow represented a threat to civilization. Now we so deeply want to believe that there's something out there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and if you look at the way that how we think about aliens has changed both in terms of like science fiction stories and in terms of actual science and scientific ideas and questions, you see very clearly that the way that we think about extraterrestrials So, you know, in the 1950s and 60s, it was stories that people told about aliens, UFOs were very popular. That's what a lot of the most famous and popular sci-fi stories were about.
SPEAKER_00And there were positive models like Star Trek, for example. Star Trek is a positive model of how humans should live together. Humans should live together in peace and harmony, seeking truth throughout the galaxy. Star Trek was notable for being one of the first And that's an ideal rooted in society.
SPEAKER_00I think we're less likely to imagine aliens that come to destroy us and more likely to hope that we will be able to encounter aliens that could help us in some way, that could solve the problems that we can't solve ourselves, that could sort of lead us to the next stage of civilization. And there's an optimistic case to be made for what an alien encounter might look like. At the same time, There are scientists like Stephen Hawking who warned that if we were actually to encounter aliens,
SPEAKER_00they might be so powerful and have such a different sense of values from ours that they would just crush us underfoot without a second thought. And so we should think twice about whether we want to advertise our existence. Hawking said we shouldn't be sending signals out into the universe that some alien race could use to track us to Earth because that could end very badly for us.
SPEAKER_01The other side of that is also the fact that because it's an element of faith at this point, that really depends on the revelation never arriving.
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, as soon as we get some concrete evidence, it really constrains the way that we can think about what life on other planets might look like. But until we have that evidence, it's very wide open. So we can think about what that life might look Steve McLaughlin, Jr.: We would find giant structures around stars, It's called Dyson Spheres that advanced civilizations would build to harness
SPEAKER_00or capture the entire energy output of a star because we have this idea of things will get bigger and bigger and better and more powerful and there's no Well, 60 years later, we found that there's actually very sharp limits to what we've been able to do in space, and our ability to, say, travel to another planet really hasn't advanced at all in the last 60 years or barely at all. So now we think of progress as taking other forms. Maybe an advanced alien race wouldn't build giant interplanetary structures,
SPEAKER_00but maybe they would be And this is where AI enters the equation today. Yes, absolutely. AI is sort of the most recent incarnation of this. Maybe the next horizon isn't going to be settling on another planet, which seems very difficult.
SPEAKER_00Maybe it's going to be making ourselves obsolete by creating artificial intelligence. Or maybe the two are linked in some way. Maybe AI is the thing that's going to solve the problems that biological humanity can't solve. Adam Kirsch, the book is We Want to Believe, How Aliens Went Mainstream and Why It Matters. Adam, I thank you so much for spending time with us. Thank you, Jeff. It's been a pleasure. Thank you.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...