Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Cocktail

Talk Cocktail artwork

Russia’s Descent Into Madness: Slowly, Then All at Once

Jun 11, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Putin didn’t seize a democracy - he hollowed one out. Twenty-five years inside Russia’s slow spiral, and what it tells us about our own moment. My guest on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Marc Bennetts, arrived in Moscow in January1997, before most of the world had ever heard of Vladimir Putin. He stayed for 25 years. He watched Putin rise, the economy boom and bust, and freedoms quietly disappear. Russia has fallen off the front page. The global conversation has moved on - to China, to trade wars, to the Middle East, to whatever is consuming the news cycle this week. But Russia hasn’t gone anywhere. It’s still there, still fighting a war it started, still governed by a man who controls the world’s largest nuclear arsenal and who, a former Kremlin adviser says, appears to be reacting to pictures in his own head. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00www.microsoft.com

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Who, What, Why podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. Think about what it means to watch someone lose their mind. Not a stranger, someone you know. Someone sitting across the table from you. Someone whose voice you recognize, whose history you share. And you watch it happen, not all at once, but in the slow accumulation of small distortions. Each one almost reasonable on its own. Until one day, the person looking back at you is someone you no longer know.

SPEAKER_01Mark Bennett watched that happen to an entire country. He arrived in Moscow in mid-1990s when Russia was chaotic and loud and intoxicated by something it barely had words for. He stayed for 25 years. He married a Russian woman, he raised a daughter there, he reported from the Arctic to the depths of Siberia, and over those 25 years he watched the thing that had drawn him there. The noise, the possibility, the human wreckage of a society trying to reinvent itself gets

swallowed piece by

SPEAKER_01piece by something darker and more deliberate. It didn't happen overnight, it never does. It happened in the way that propaganda always works. Not by telling people what to think, but by making it harder and harder to think anything else. It happened when his own mother-in-law, a woman he knew and loved, began repeating the things she heard on television and eventually stopped speaking to him altogether. It happened when a Siberian shaman who tried to exercise Putin from the Kremlin

SPEAKER_01ended up in a psychiatric ward. It happened when newscasters looked into cameras and told their audiences that

SPEAKER_00Ukrainian soldiers had crucified a toddler and people believed them. Orwell wrote that to see what is in front of one's nose is a constant struggle.

SPEAKER_01Bennett took on that struggle, and he saw it clearly. That's what made him dangerous to the people in power. And that clarity is what makes his book unsettling in ways that extend well beyond Russia. Three months after Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Bennett was arrested at an anti-war protest in Moscow. The Times of London pulled him out for his own safety. Mark Bennett

SPEAKER_01Mark, thanks so much for joining us.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Thanks for the introduction. It was amazing.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining us. Talk first about what Russia was like when you first got there.

SPEAKER_00I arrived in Russia in January 1997. This was before President Putin came to power. This was actually before anyone had really even heard of Vladimir Putin, unless you were Jeff Schechtman And Russia was in a state of chaos and anarchy, essentially.

SPEAKER_00There was poverty, there was widespread crime. But it was also probably the period when Russians could say and write what they wanted the most in their history. In that sense, they were the freest they'd ever been. It was incredibly chaotic. I would do things like go to parties at nuclear power stations and end up driving around in the middle of the night with drunken truck drivers who tried to teach me how to drive around the perimeter of a nuclear power station's fence,

SPEAKER_00etc., etc. But there was a sense of possibility, a sense of excitement almost as to what could come next. Looking back on it, of course, Russian liberals and opposition figures, most of them, lots of them, see it as a kind of time of when they could express themselves, when they wouldn't be arrested, usually, for saying the wrong thing. But I think the period of excitement was in the years immediately after the breakup, in the two or three years. I think by 1997, it was clear that the security services

SPEAKER_01Or it was clear that there was massive crime, there was corruption. And while the Kremlin wasn't interfering with media to the extent that Putin would

SPEAKER_00later, there was also a kind of great disappointment in democracy or as the Russians have started to call it, shitocracy. And I don't really think it would be fair to say that people were looking to the future of this great sense of hope. I think there was a lot of despair, poverty, and this kind of feeling that maybe they'd been conned. What was what gave Putin such an appeal when he finally came to power? I mean, in the 1990s, the Russians would say everything that our leaders told us

about communism was a

SPEAKER_00lie, but everything they told us about capitalism was true. Such was the kind of decision. Talk about your decision to stay there and to spend more time there. I mean, I initially planned to stay for a year or so, get to another country. I had always been interested in Russia and the Soviet Union

since I was a child.

SPEAKER_00So I initially went there not as an academic or a journalist. I went there to teach English. I mean, it would be fair that I taught English Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01Talk about that good way. What was it about the country that got under your skin that fascinated you?

SPEAKER_00Russia in the 1990s. I mean, I think, firstly, I would like to underline that I never believed in this kind of idea of a mysterious Russian soul or that Russians are somehow unique. I think all people are unique in their own way. And I never believed in kind of Putin's idea that Russians have a unique destiny. And I thought all that was... I was very cynical towards about all that but I mean Russia is the biggest country in the world so I mean I mean even Moscow itself is fascinating but once you get

outside the country you go to Siberia to deepest Siberia where people speak their own language for example in the Yakuts region where people they're not definitely Russians they're Yakuts they speak their own language they have their own culture you go to the Altai in the south of South of Siberia where people still believe in shamanism you go to the

SPEAKER_00far north of Russia where you have um the Arctic Knights and of course it's not just a kind of geographical variety but a large Just people, the people are very different. I mean, in the West there's this idea that it's kind of, that it's just very similar across Russia, that Russians are Russians, but that's not true. I mean, there are lots of different nationalities from the Russians themselves to, again, the Altai people, to the Chechen people, on and on and on.

SPEAKER_00So, and also there was also the appeal in the 1990s, of course, that Kind of history was in a sense being made every day. And I was coming from Britain, which at the time was under Tony Blair. And it was a very bland kind of time. Nothing much was really happening. And so it seemed to me to be kind of far more, I mean, interesting to use one other word just to stay in Russia for a bit. That's what happened. Talk a little bit about the changes that were taking place and Putin coming to power and the way he was able to exploit that sense of the

people that you were

SPEAKER_01talking about earlier.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, whenever, after Putin came to power, whenever I would say to ordinary Russians or talk to them about why I disliked Putin, why I hated Putin, because he was kind of a crook and a liar and a killer, they would say, but we remember what it was here, what it was like here in the 1990s. And for them, this kind of Putin taking control and not being any democracy, it was... It was a fair kind of exchange because in the early 2000s,

oil prices rocketed in Russia.

SPEAKER_00And so Putin was very lucky in that sense. And the living standards of all the Russians soared and became higher than they'd ever been in their history. Russians could take foreign holidays with ease for Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_00They were like, yeah, sure, he's ex-KGB, but we're doing okay. And if the Democrats, as they thought, have come to power again, things might get even worse. So let's just stick with Putin. And he just rode that wave. And then over the years, this enforced his rule through destroying the opposition, often physically. And to what extent did the Russian people have a sense of the

way it was changing?

SPEAKER_01That the appreciation of Putin was economic at first, as you talk about, but then things started to change. It was a little like the frog in boiling water. Talk about that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. The propaganda didn't really go entirely overboard until 2014 when Russia... Annexed Crimea and Putin sent troops into eastern Ukraine. But I think that Russians were willing to abandon what we would think of as a kind of Western-style democracy. because they just had such a bad experience of it in the 1990s and there became

this in around 2011 or in 2011 there were pro-democracy protests over rigged

SPEAKER_00elections and this was Jeff Schecht with the Ukraine situation and they began to arrest opposition leaders again it wasn't the same kind of scale of repression as we saw later they were being jailed for two weeks three weeks things like this but Kremlin propaganda was kind of pushing the idea all this time that Putin is the

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman The argument, which was repeated by a lot of Russians, was there is no other person in the entire country who can rule us. It's only Putin, which obviously had been pushed relentlessly by Russian propaganda. And then this just took on a ludicrous kind of scale when you

have Russian

SPEAKER_00officials such as Vyacheslav Valodin, who is now the Speaker of Parliament, but at the time was a very influential criminal made. He would say things like, if there is Putin, there is Russia. If there is no Russia, there is no Putin. And he obviously felt secure enough in the belief of the Russian people in Putin that he could get away with this and not be laughed out of the room.

SPEAKER_01Beyond the propaganda, was there some kind of mystical hold? You talk about the hold that Putin seemed to have on the population. Was it only the propaganda or was there something else going on? Well, there's always been this reverence in Russia for the man at the top, for the czar.

SPEAKER_00But again, that goes back to the kind of lack of a real democratic tradition or any real experience of genuine democracy. I remember once I was in a taxi in Moscow while Putin's motorcade was going past. On occasion, you would have to wait for up to an hour, maybe a little bit more, whilst his motorcade sped past and everyone was just sitting in their cars waiting. And I said to a taxi driver, it's ridiculous.

Why do you have to wait for like an hour just to go somewhere just because Putin's driving past?

SPEAKER_00And he looked at me and said, but he is one and we are many. which was just the exact reverse of what someone in the West would probably say like there's loads of us someone in England for example would say there's loads of us sitting here why do we have to wait for Putin but he just saw it as completely normal that hundreds of hundreds of cars would have to wait for the president's car because he is one or the one although there's no articles in Russian so he couldn't have said that I mean I don't think there's anything mystical in the sense otherworldly kind of sense over his hold

SPEAKER_00Although Russians do have a very unreported fascination with the occult. I mean, obviously everyone knows about Rasputin, but that continues even to this day. The cottage industry in urban witches and urban wizards is worth billions every year in Russia. But that wasn't really why Putin was able to stay in power for so long.

SPEAKER_01But there was this almost medieval mindset that seemed to take hold.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, throughout history, Russians have had this very kind of, I guess you would call it servile attitude towards the man at the top. There are Russian proverbs from the Tsarist era, such as, when they beat you, say thank you for the lesson. Do the work of seven, but obey only one. On the lawn like this. So yeah, I mean, in that sense, there's something kind of medieval about Russians' belief in Putin.

But I think it's also important to point out that this doesn't concern everyone, that there are vast numbers of Russians who hate Putin and who would like to see

SPEAKER_00Russia as a normal democracy. But at the start of the war in Ukraine, the Kremlin introduced Putin A law essentially making it a crime punishable by up to seven or 15 years in prison to report the truth on what Russia was doing in Ukraine. So the people who would have spoken out, they left the country, hundreds of thousands of them.

SPEAKER_01So, in a sense, Putin has purged Russia now of the very people who would lead any protests if they

SPEAKER_00were to start in the future.

SPEAKER_01And was it the purging? Was it that medieval mentality? How did all of these things, they created a kind of perfect storm for Putin's totalitarian rule to just get stronger over time?

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, he was always authoritarian. And obviously it wasn't a democracy up until 2022 when the full-scale invasion of Ukraine happened. But overnight, literally overnight, Russia transformed into a neo-totalitarian state where any dissent became dangerous, where all opposition media was banned before they tolerated some opposition media up until 2022. But it was literally closed down overnight. Opposition journalists had to flee the country. Opposition activists had to flee the country.

Which the Kremlin portrayed as wartime measures necessary to ensure security.

SPEAKER_00But there was a big difference between Russia until February 23rd. And Russia on February 24, 2022, when the war in Ukraine started and the crackdown began and Russia kind of introduced, Putin introduced kind of political terror that we hadn't seen in the country. Jeff Schecht

SPEAKER_00Why hadn't more of that happened after the Crimea invasion in 2014? Because the Crimea invasion wasn't the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Putin wasn't trying to capture Kiev.

SPEAKER_00His troops weren't involved in gun battles. And to an extent, Steve McLaughlin I mean obviously the annexation of Crimea was illegal but there

was a vast difference in scale of taking one region of Crimea and launching the biggest military conflict in Europe since 1945 and the defeat of Nazi Germany to try and

SPEAKER_00capture All of Ukraine to try and capture Kiev to try and remove President Zelensky So just the scale of the war itself, the scale of the military operation itself was a lot bigger and therefore the scale of the crackdown was a lot bigger Talk about your own experience being arrested at this anti-war protest This was February 28th to 2022 I just got back to Moscow and that date was the anniversary of the murder of

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_00And in the past when such things had happened, the protests, I'd kind of shown my press accreditation and asked why people were being arrested. And sometimes they could manage to get away or whatever. And then this day they weren't in the mood and they just grabbed me as well and threw me in the police truck. And then they drove me to a police station in the north of Moscow where I was separated from the Russians and taken into a room. where there were two guys in plain clothes. When I asked them if they were the FSB, which is the successor agency to the KGB,

SPEAKER_00they went, no, no, no, we're kind of from the foreign ministry. But they wouldn't say who exactly they were. I'm pretty sure that they were the FSB. But it was just surreal. I mean, obviously a little bit worrying because I wasn't sure what they were going to charge me with. And also, I mean, this was... This was probably the worst time to be arrested in Russia as a British journalist since the height of the Cold War. So they just started grilling me, but the questions were just ludicrous. One of the first things they asked me was, well, what do you think of Putin?

SPEAKER_00And I was like, what does it matter to you what I think of Putin? And they were like, well, you have to tell us if you want to get out of here. So I'm thinking, what can I say to them? You know, I mean, I can't tell them the truth that I hate him and that he's destroying Ukraine and he's destroying Russia. That probably wasn't a very good idea, right? Because then he wanted to go home in the next 10 years. But then equally, I wasn't going to say something like, ah, no one understands him in the West. So I sat there for about two or three minutes, literally trying to think of what I could say.

SPEAKER_00And they were like, come on, come on, what do you think of Putin? And eventually I just said, it must be very hard to effectively manage such a large country. And they were like, oh, yeah, it is really hard. And then they asked me some other stupid questions about like, what do you know about Russia? And I've been here for 25 years, quite a lot. And they were like, well, tell us something. And I was like, Moscow is the capital of Russia. And I'll tell us some more. So I just told them, gave them a positive history of Russia since Putin came to power. And they're like, how do you know all that? I was like, I read Wikipedia just before I went out.

They weren't really in the mood for humor, but eventually I was allowed out.

SPEAKER_00And then shortly after that, Russia introduced the law banning what they called fake news on the war in Ukraine. And in their definition, fake news was anything that wasn't published by the Russian Ministry of Defense's website. And they also said it would apply to Western journalists And the Times said I should leave But I'd been there for 25 years My wife is Russian, my child was born in Moscow And initially we decided to stay Until I was told to leave Because they feared I would get arrested And at the time

I thought perhaps it wasn't necessary But as a history show As the next few months showed It actually

SPEAKER_00probably was a good idea

SPEAKER_01And were there other journalists that were arrested around that time?

SPEAKER_00There were Russian journalists being arrested all the time, yeah. But it wasn't until 2023 that Evan Gezhkovich, the Wall Street Journal journalist, was arrested. I knew him in Moscow, but I was already out of the country at the time, but he'd gone back. And yeah, that was a massive shock. And it made me realize that, I guess, the Times was correct to pull me out. Why was Russian propaganda at least for a while so effective that people even like

SPEAKER_01your mother-in-law believed what she was hearing?

SPEAKER_00Well, firstly, because it was relentless and they had complete control of national television, at least. So, I mean, in my mother-in-law's case, for an elderly woman stuck in the provinces with a pitiful pension, television was one of her main means of entertainment. It just literally brainwashed her. I mean, there's no other word for it. But it wasn't just national television. I mean, the message was everywhere. It was in newspapers. It was online. And it became quite common to hear Russians say,

I never watch state television. And then they would repeat the arguments on state television, kind of almost word for word. It was almost as if the propaganda had this kind of trance effect, I think, on many people.

SPEAKER_00And And it kind of built tried to convince them that Russia was in danger that it was surrounded by enemies again this kind of notion that Putin is the only person who can save you but it was just some of the things they would push would Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_00In Scandinavia, there are brothels for animals and the animals have their limbs broken for the enjoyment of zoophiles, but just ridiculous things. It was just relentless, like on and on and on and on and on. And you could see that it was driving people insane. Jeff Schechtman I don't think there's any other word of Kremlin propaganda.

I just grew in her mind into this kind of like demonic figure from the West. I couldn't have like a five minute conversation with her where I started screaming

SPEAKER_00about the evils of the West or Ukrainian Nazis. And so eventually we just stopped talking, unfortunately. www.feyyaz.tv You walk along the streets in Germany and it's awful.

SPEAKER_00You can hear the dogs screaming because they're being raped. Just this kind of nightmarish vision of Europe that had been pushed by Russian state media constantly to people who had never left Russia. There was the obsession that Putin had with Victory Day, the public holiday in honor of the defeat of Nazi Germany by the Soviet Union. I think that also drove a lot of Russians out of their minds as well, because it was just, again, so relentless and almost became,

SPEAKER_00rather than a kind of secular holiday, there was almost something religious about it, this kind of This is kind of glorification of the Soviet Union and which was also linked by the Kremlin to the growing confrontation with the West. So I remember one year, an 11 year old, 12 year old, sorry, Russian girl dressed in Soviet military uniform.

and stood on a bed of nails barefoot on a bed of nails for 75 minutes singing Soviet Red Army songs to honor her grandfathers who had fought in the Second World War I didn't even know how to react to that I mean obviously the Soviet defeat of Nazi Germany and the sacrifices made by the Soviet people to defeat Nazi Germany is

SPEAKER_00something worth Remembering something worth commemorating um but i don't think the correct way to do it is for 12 year old girls to stand barefoot on a bed of nails for 75 minutes and she didn't see the link um so yeah there was there was a lot that was going on and um sometimes it would affect even kind of intelligent people i remember we had a friend who's very well educated studied in america um um spoke a number of languages who in 2020 told me that there

was no one else in in in Russia who could ensure that the country remains sovereign apart from Vladimir Putin this was at the time when the Kremlin was rewriting the constitution to allow him to stay in power for another 16 years so yeah it was frightening and um The power of propaganda was frightening and the people pushing it were doing it

SPEAKER_00deliberately for money, essentially. I don't think, maybe some of them believe it now, but I'm pretty sure at the start they didn't believe it. They just did it throughout their careers and for money. I remember once I was at a protest again against the war in Ukraine and there were maybe 30,000, 40,000 people. This was 2014 after Crimea. That scale of protest wouldn't be possible now. And I saw a journalist from Russian television, Kremlin-controlled television, there was no other.

And she was standing in front of an almost empty road close to the protest.

SPEAKER_00So this wasn't where the protest was taking place. It was close to it. And there were a few people making their way up that road towards the main protest. And they turned the camera and she did her stand-up and she said, As you can see, there are very few people here today, just a few kind of misguided crazes. And that was the message. And then afterwards, I walked up to her and said, but you can see with your own eyes, there were 30,000, 40,000 people over there. Why did you lie? And she just looked at me and said, look, you do your job and all do mine, okay? And walked off, which I thought just summed everything up about Russian propaganda.

SPEAKER_01To what extent do you think that Putin changed in this period of time? I mean, obviously he tightened the screws after the invasion of Ukraine, but was there a sense that he was changing, becoming more authoritarian, becoming more demanding of control? What was going on with him?

SPEAKER_00He's been in power now for 26 years, right? And it's my view that power not only corrupts, but it also drives you out of your mind. He became, I mean, we can't really call him a victim, but state propaganda is taking its message from Putin. I mean, not always literally, he's not calling them every day and saying, okay, today you should report on this, today you should say this, but they know what they have to say. And then Putin watches state television so he's trapped again not

trapped because he created it but he's in this echo chamber where his own thoughts are literally being broadcast on a screen back to him and he during the coronavirus pandemic he was locked up in his residence with his gang of kind of hard-blind former KGB allies and they just spent the entire time ranting about Ukraine as far as we know and filling each other's heads with kind of horror stories about the West and that's almost certainly why he decided eventually to launch his

full-scale

SPEAKER_00invasion. I spoke to a former very influential former Kremlin advisor called Gleb Pawlowski who helped secure Putin in power in the early 2000s and then started to oppose him because he thought that Putin should stand down or shouldn't return to power for a third term. And I asked him, do you recognize Putin now? This is in 2022, a couple of days after the full-scale invasion had begun.

SPEAKER_00And he was like, not at all. He was in the early 2000s. He was a very kind of same-thinking man. But now I don't recognize him at all. He looks to me as if he's reacting to pictures in his own head, which is a kind of image that stayed with me or has stayed with me since the start of the conflict. And this guy who controls the world's largest nuclear arsenal reacting to these images, which are being... Jeff Schecht

that at least 200 well we know that we know the names of at least 220,000 Russians who have been killed in the war 220,000 Russians who have been killed fighting in Ukraine it's looking at excess mortality figures because the Kremlin doesn't give a death toll right so there's no official figure but looking at excess male mortality

SPEAKER_00figures it seems as if it's Jeff Schechtman That NATO would launch an attack on Russia from Ukraine, but Ukraine still now hasn't even been invited to join NATO.

And if NATO was planning to attack Russia from the territory of Ukraine before the

SPEAKER_00war, why hasn't it done it now? I mean, we have the perfect kind of excuse, as it were. I mean, there's a conflict going on, there's a war going on. But until Putin leaves office in whatever way, either he dies or is removed from power, which I can't see happening right now, then he's just going to continue the war in Ukraine and he's just going to continue to transform Russia into something which is not quite yet North Korea,

SPEAKER_00but it's getting there

SPEAKER_01Mark Bennett, his book is The Descent. And thank you for listening and joining us here on the Who, What, Why podcast. I hope you join us next week for another Who, What, Why podcast. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes. You can also support this podcast and all the work we do by going to whowhatwhy.org forward slash donate.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Thomas Frank asked “What’s the Matter With Kansas”? Now he asks What’s the Matter With Creativity?

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Surrogacy Scandal That Exposed a Very Broken System

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Those Powers That Congress Gave the Supreme Court? Congress Can Take Them Away

    Nov 11, 202639 minAudio

    The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. One Win Is Not a Lasting Majority

    Nov 7, 202641 minAudio

    Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Religious Movement That’s Done With Democracy

    Oct 31, 202628 minAudio

    Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...

    Credit the people on this episode