Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Cocktail

Talk Cocktail artwork

A Timeline of Western Decline

Sep 17, 202658 minAudio

Everyone wants to name the moment it all went wrong. Most people name 2016, and one man, and an election they’re sure the next election can undo. My guest on a recentWhoWhatWhy podcast, Bianka Banova, says they’re off by decades. The disorder people feel now - the cost of living that won’t fall, the wars that won’t stop, the ground shifting underfoot - isn’t the beginning of anything. It’s the moment the water got hot enough to feel. She argues the world came apart slowly, one comfortable choice at a time, beginning with decisions made decades ago. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_01Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Who, What, Why podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. There is a comfort in believing that everything went wrong recently, that the disorder in our politics, the fraying of our alliances, the sense that the ground has shifted under every old certainty, all of it arrived with one man and will leave when he does. It lets us treat the moment as an interruption rather than a destination. It lets us imagine that normal is only an election away. But my guest today, Bianca Bonova,

SPEAKER_00says that comfort is a story we tell ourselves so we won't have to look at the choices underneath it. The world we're mourning, she argues, did not end recently, and it did not end by accident. It came apart slowly over the better part of a century, one comfortable decision at a time. There was an order once, and it was a bargain. American power kept the sea lanes open, goods moved, and prosperity followed on a scale the world had never seen. But the peace that made all of it possible rested on something nobody much wanted to pay for.

SPEAKER_00And so year by year, we stopped paying for it. We enjoyed the calm and let the walls that held it up go quietly unattended. We found it easier to trade with us. And when those rivals told us in plain language what they meant to build and who they meant to break, we decided we had better things to believe. In a recent piece in her Substack, Waronomics, entitled The Timeline of Western Decline, Benova traces the unraveling step-by-step from the post-war order of 1945 to

SPEAKER_00the wreckage of 2026. She marks the real turn not at Trump and not even at Crimea. But in 2008, the year Russia rolled into Georgia and paid no price for it. The year Washington rescued the banks and taught every rival capital that the American establishment could be bought. What follows from there is the slow bleed of the two pillars everything rests on. The dollar and the military. Each one eroded less by an enemy than by our own long preference for the easy path.

SPEAKER_00Every step, she insists, was a choice. And almost none of them looked like catastrophe on the day they were made. This is the unsettling heart of what she wants us to see. Decline rarely announces itself. It comes instead as a long sequence of reasonable accommodations. And the bill for all of them is only now sitting on the table. ... ... ... ... ... ...

SPEAKER_00She knows from the inside what captured institutions look like, what extractive politics smell like, and what it costs a people to finally decide they have had enough. It is my pleasure to welcome Bianca Bonova back to the Who, What, Why Podcast. Bianca, thanks so much for joining us.

SPEAKER_01Thank you very much for having me back, Jeff.

SPEAKER_00Well, it is a delight to have you here. Thank you so much. I want to start with this general idea that this sense that people have, this feeling that things are not normal anymore, that the world has fundamentally changed, is a much larger frame than most people give it in that it is not just about Donald Trump and what changed in 2016. Talk about that in a general sense first.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that the reason why people have this general sense right now is because for the first time since that process started, they actually really started feeling the pain of what that accumulation of choices have led to. And we're seeing that with our economies, our economy. Rising standards of our rising cost of living, inflation, proliferation of wars, breakdown of supply chains,

SPEAKER_01bottlenecks when it comes to industry and production and output. Constant layoffs across not just like the software industry that we're seeing now with AI, but all of the other industries across the board. So people are for the first time really seeing that there is a permanence to this crisis. Because back in 2008, when it happened, yes, when it happened, it was a shock. But Because of the choices that were made to bail out the banks and to bail out

SPEAKER_01the insurance companies that were insuring those loans, it kind of went away quickly enough. So people thought, okay, no, this is a recession and we're going to recover. But that recovery never truly came. It just continued to erode further and further and And now we live in a world where people are just looking around and they're like, I can't afford what I used to be able to afford 10 years ago. You know, every time I turn on the news, there is, you know, new wars happening all across the globe,

SPEAKER_01you know, attacks and basic instability and volatility all around. And at the same time, there's this discontent where, you know, on the one hand side, people can feel it in their daily lives that, you know, it's not only that their lives are not as stable and as prosperous as they used to be 10, 20 or 30 years ago, but also there is lack of hope that this is going to change in the next election cycle or next year or even in the next 10 years for a lot

SPEAKER_01of people. And this is where that general feeling that things are falling apart is coming to people, and rightfully so, because they have been falling apart for quite some time. And yeah, this is one of the reasons why this article was basically conceived, because I wanted to help people connect the dots and for them to realize that we have been the frog that has been slowly boiled on a low heat.

SPEAKER_01And this didn't just happen just because Trump was elected or just because the Ukraine war happened or something like that. This has been a long time in the making and it Their current standards of living and their current lives are experiencing that sort of volatility because certain choices, certain political choices were made for far too long and nobody really bothered to seek accountability.

SPEAKER_00And let's talk a little about those choices because you argue that really in order to understand the full picture, we need to go back to 1945 and some of the choices made then.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that after the Second World War and soon after that, the Cold War started, but basically there was a good... There was a good deal that was struck for the Western world. And that deal was the United States is going to be the new global superpower. They're going to be the new Pact Romana. The United States military and the United States Navy is going to be protecting the trade routes, the sea lanes, the choke points.

SPEAKER_01And trade is just going to be moving freely and openly. And this is where globalization started. And after the end of the Cold War, 1991, it exploded even further when, you know, like the Soviet Union collapsed and when China and Russia and all the former Soviet republics and satellite states were Also introduced into that world order. So that was a very good deal for a very long time. And it was a very good deal for everyone involved because a lot

SPEAKER_01of other states didn't have to invest so heavily in their military. They could just literally pay the United States to do that for them. So basically the deal was you're going to invest in your military and you're going to be the new Pax Romana or, you know, the Pax Americana and you're going to protect globally. And you're going to protect supply chains and the trade routes. And we're just going to continue producing. And, you know, your ports are going to be clogged with products that were produced from all over

SPEAKER_01the world and were shipped just in time for use. Very reasonable price. That worked well for the people that were manufacturing those products and those goods, whether they were based in Unfortunately, it was based on the premise that

SPEAKER_01Once we start trading, and this is a lot of the German school of thought here, the idea was once we integrate our economies and once we intertwine our trade, wars are just going to organically cease to exist and what used to be our former adversaries in the face of The Sino-Soviet axis of Russia and China, they're just going to come to the table, play by the international rules, engage in fair trade,

SPEAKER_01and they will realize that it's much better for them to just peacefully trade amongst each other and with the rest of the world so they can become more wealthy and become more prosperous.

SPEAKER_00Talk a little bit about the Cold War, the impact that that had, and what was perceived to be what was going to happen going forward after the West, quote unquote, won the Cold War.

SPEAKER_01Well, after the end of the Cold War, especially in Russia and in Eastern Europe, the A lot of us went through what is now called shock therapy because the Soviet system was just so inefficient and dysfunctional. I think that most people in the West are just, when you tell them stories of, you know, queuing for bread for an hour on time or not even having access to plastic, like for example, we skipped the plastic revolution.

SPEAKER_01So if you wanted to go And take, for example, yogurt or sour milk, like you had to bring your own glass jars and then they fill them up at the supermarket and then you go back home and so on and so forth. So just something as little as plastic, it was not part of the Soviet system. So when the Soviet system collapsed, it was incredibly... It was incredibly humiliating because when you spend 50 years saying that this is

SPEAKER_01the superior system, and I have a bunch of books here back home with the Soviet books that are on biology and chemistry and so on and so forth, and that propaganda of the superiority of the Soviet system, of the superiority of socialism and communism, it was ingrained in every single facet of society. You would go... I'll give you an example. I was reading a biochem book, and they were explaining the molecule of morphine,

SPEAKER_01and there was a footnote that said, oh, FYI, excessive use of morphine leads to addiction, but this is something that doesn't happen in the superior Soviet system. It is a disease that is much more common in the rotten capitalist system. And I'm quoting, they basically say, rotten capitalist system. They spent 50 years propagandizing that. And at some point, it came to a point where the communist elite in Russia and

SPEAKER_01in Eastern Europe realized that an American woman, like an American single mother on food stamps, has higher purchasing power than they do. And there was a, I don't remember which book What was it? Just in an average supermarket in Texas. And apparently Gorbachev turned to one of his aides and he said the Cold War is over.

SPEAKER_01So that realization that the Western system of free market capitalism won, it was incredibly... And this is where I've talked very often about the difference between the Eastern mindset and the Western mindset. The West had its empires, whether it's Portuguese, Dutch, the British, the French, they lost their empires.

SPEAKER_01Yes, it was a very humiliating defeat, but, you know, like they looked there once for a while and then they moved forward and said, OK, now we're going to building prosperity because that is the best way to have a peaceful society, to provide prosperity for as many people as possible, not just for the aristocracy, not just for the upper class, but for people. As many people as possible, like the middle class, working class, so on and so forth. And that's the project that they have been engaged with for several decades.

SPEAKER_01The Eastern world does not operate on that software. It's all about imperial pride and the fact that they lost the Cold War really wounded their ego and really wounded their pride because they see themselves as empires. And I'm talking both about China. And when they started reforming and they started reforming very differently, the path that both sides took was, you know, quite different, yet similar in some cases, but quite different.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. In both Russia and China, especially in Russia,

SPEAKER_01like the raw materials industry, whether it's oil, gas, rare earths, so on and so forth, they were usurped either by the state, in the case of China, that was the trillionaire. Chinese Communist Party or by oligarchs. And the idea was not to create like a thriving industry for the sake of creating factories and making, you know, life better for citizens, but it was to weaponize that against the West when the time comes. And that boils down to the Eastern world inability to face that accumulating,

SPEAKER_01like post-Cold War, accumulating defeat. What they essentially did for the past 30, 35 years, they've weaponized every tool that they have at their disposal, and now they've launched a second Cold War. And that's exactly what we're looking through right now, a second Cold War.

SPEAKER_00And talk about the impact of Russia's invasion of Georgia and that being a key moment, as you argue.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so Russia always does this, like they always test gradually until, you know, what they can get away with. In the early 90s, they tested that with Chechnya and with Grozny. They basically just, you know, leveled Grozny to the ground. But at the time, because it was the 90s, it was very chaotic and nobody in the West really understood what Chechnya was and what was happening over there. They kind of assumed it was just like an internal conflict between Moscow and one

SPEAKER_01of its federal republics. So nobody paid attention to that. And that kind of got swept under the rug. And it was kind of ironic because the president of Chechnya at the time, he said that Russia will go for Crimea one day and they will go for the rest of Ukraine. And he said that in 1995. So that was a... He was a very serious prophet at the time. Anyway, after that, they got away with that and they decided,

SPEAKER_01okay, now we're going to try with something else. And that was Georgia because Georgia and Ukraine were kind of always, you know, It wasn't so much about NATO expansion, but it was something that was talked about that maybe whether it's the European Union, whether it's NATO, we should eventually incorporate them into the larger alliance. There wasn't that much popular support about that at the time,

SPEAKER_01but it was something that was definitely discussed in certain circles. So the Russians decided in 2008 to launch the war in Georgia. It lasted, it was a very short-lived war, like I think it was about two weeks or something. And they annexed 20% of the territory there. And of course, you know, what? They conducted some cleansing of the local population. They moved Russian citizens to live there, which is basically their playbook.

SPEAKER_01They've done that over and over for the last several centuries. The problem is nobody did anything. It was treated as some sort of regional quarrel or a conflict or something like that. Nobody from Washington, nobody from Brussels. Absolutely nothing happened there. And that was the moment where Russia realized, okay, if I can get away with Chechnya and if I can get away with Georgia, then I can get away with more.

SPEAKER_01Unfortunately for us, that coincided with the... With the financial crisis of 2008, and nobody wanted to, nobody cared about what was happening in Georgia at the time. And as we started bailing out banks, Moscow realized, and Beijing as well, they realized that You know, the political elite of the West, it is going to side with the financial institutions and with the banking system and

SPEAKER_01with the too big to fail, you know, insurance companies or, you know, private And if that political elite is for sale, you don't actually have to go and buy the political elite, whether it's in Washington or London. You just have to make good relations with the Bank of London and Wall Street. And they're going to be doing the bidding for you because they're going to be paying their You know,

SPEAKER_01they're going to be financing the political campaigns of politicians and lobbyists and so on and so forth. So those two events were the moment where Russia and China realized that the West is not as powerful as it used to be during the first Cold War. And now is their time to... And, you know, continue executing their plans. And, you know, a few years later, Crimea happened. One year after Crimea, you know, Beijing started

SPEAKER_01doing embargo on rare earths. So our capacity to produce missiles and fighter jets and, you know, like defense equipment was significantly reduced because of bottlenecks, because, you know, a single F-35 requires half a ton of rare earth minerals that we don't own the supply chains for those. We don't own the refining, the processing, the mines, nothing. All of that, 80 to 90 percent of that is in China. So, yeah, it was 2008. It was like kind of a domino effect.

SPEAKER_01The 2008 financial crisis in Georgia, and that was the green light. The West is not going to do anything about it, so we can proceed with our plans. And they did.

SPEAKER_00Talk a little bit about decisions that the U.S., that the West could have made at those points that might have changed the outcomes. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01In the Western world, especially in the Anglosphere, I have noticed that in particular, it operates on the basis of... Now, in continental Europe, precedents do happen, but they are treated as precedents. You don't actually go back and say, well, because this happened, we're going to change the system, and that system is going to continue based on that precedent.

SPEAKER_01Once international law is, the whole purpose of international law is to not break it. And once you break it, there should be some sort of cost for you. Just like, you know, in any society, if you break the law, you're going to get like either a fine or go to jail, depending on the severity of which law and, you know, how you broke it. Same applies for international law. And if there's no consequences for you for breaking international law,

SPEAKER_01then international law has no merit. And this is when you go to societies where, just to scale it back for your listeners, when you go to societies where you see a lot of corruption and you see a lot of crime and you're wondering why is that happening, it's exactly because of that. Institutions that were supposed to keep the order and that was supposed to enforce those laws in that order, they no longer function. And people don't see, when they don't see enforcement, they're not going to follow the rules.

SPEAKER_01And it's the same with geopolitics. If Russia can attack Georgia and invade and annex 20% of its territory without any repercussions, because people should remember that This happened in 2008. In 2014, Russia was hosting the Winter Olympics. So nothing happened in terms of any serious repercussions for breaking international law and invading a sovereign nation and annexing 20% of its territory. No sanctions, no repercussions, nothing.

SPEAKER_01I think that was the moment where the Western world needed to realize that if they let that one slide, The Russians and the Chinese are just going to come, coming back for more and more. And they're not going to be satisfied with, especially Russia, it's not going to be satisfied with just 20% of Georgia, as we saw, because six years later they attacked Crimea and, you know, the West committed the same mistake. They said, well, you know, maybe we'll let that one slide. Maybe, you know, if they take Crimea, it's going to be fine.

SPEAKER_01It wasn't fine because... Then they launched the war in Eastern Ukraine in Donbass, and that continued for eight years. And then in 2022, they launched the full-scale invasion. And now we have the largest war on European soil since the Second World War. So the mistakes that the Western world did is basically not sticking to the principles that they have To the values and principles that they have professed all throughout the Cold War and the post-Cold War period.

SPEAKER_01One, two, not taking decisive actions of punishing people that break international law. And that also applies for China because China has broken every single rule of the World Trade Organization of which they're part of. And having no cost for doing that. And basically just projecting their wishful thinking onto Russia and China. And this is something that,

SPEAKER_01and I've said that in the article, like one of my biggest quarrels with the Western world is that people don't seem, especially the political, including the intellectual class, they do not seem to believe that When their own adversaries are telling them what they're going to do to them right to their face. So if you go back to the thing was 1992 or three when there was a conversation between Yeltsin and And President Clinton.

SPEAKER_01And it's in the archives. Like, you know, it can be, you know, there was a stenographer there and everything that was said between these two was recorded. Yeltsin was very open and, you know, he basically just said to Clinton, yes, we want to take back the rest of Europe. You know, you can... You can go back to your Western Hemisphere and, you know, provide security and, you know, protect their supply chains. And, you know, Russia is half European, so we're going to be...

SPEAKER_01This is our own backyard. So, you know, eventually we're going to agree on this. It's not going to be now, but down the line, this is our plan. He basically said to Clinton, we have a plan to rebuild the Soviet Union in some shape or form. Clinton didn't believe him. The same with China. Like, they are not hiding. And if people start reading... Russian media and Russian analysts, the same as the Chinese ones, they're not—neither the politicians nor the intellectual elites in these countries,

SPEAKER_01they're not hiding their plans. They're having them in plain sight. But nobody's paying attention because I feel like this is the— The biggest mistake of the West is projecting their views and their values and their ideas onto others and thinking that, oh, just because we won't do it, because who on earth would want to start a war when wars are, you know, wealth... Talk a little bit about the impact of the U.S. military failures in Iraq and Afghanistan and the role that played.

SPEAKER_01Unfortunately, and, you know, we can debate the reasons or the need for those military interventions, you know, for a very long time. And, you know, there's the official version of why it happened. And then there's another version, depending on how people are analyzing these events and these wars. I usually analyze them from You know, geopolitical trade and supply chain perspective. Other people are analyzing it from other places, other perspectives. But anyway,

SPEAKER_01because these wars were not well run and well executed in a way that they didn't produce the outcomes that the politicians and the military establishment promised that they are going to deliver. And they had to move the goalpost over the next 20 years. The legitimacy of the American military started eroding.

SPEAKER_01And as I said in the article, there is difference between And criticizing the way that these wars were run. And there is a difference between basically saying that the American military is not a legitimate force and painting it as some sort of warmonger. And that narrative was, it kind of spread its tentacles slowly.

SPEAKER_01So, yeah. Unfortunately, that social credit, that social capital that the American military had,

SPEAKER_01it was wasted on these Middle Eastern wars, especially in the war in Afghanistan, because that one... It took 20 years, and basically, like, the running, it's rather unfortunate, but the running joke is, you know, spending 20 years and however many trillion dollars of replacing the Taliban with the Taliban, because ultimately that was the outcome of that war. So that was a very long time of bad propaganda against the American military.

SPEAKER_01Yes, of course, as any propaganda, there was a level of truth when it comes to how these wars were conceived and how they were led and managed, but ultimately basically destroyed the credibility of the American military. And the unfortunate aspect of prolonged People totally forgot that the reason why they had such a long period of peace and prosperity was because that vast machine created.

SPEAKER_01The American U.S. military and the American Navy was making sure that the trade routes were open, that all the choke points through which our trade goes is well protected and your cargo can go from point A to point B. And we can have this just-in-time supply chain management work perfectly where we don't have to spend money on warehouses and we don't have to stockpile on warehouses. And I think that's what I'm saying.

SPEAKER_01Of the American military and American military supremacy. And they don't realize that, and this is not their fault, actually. This is the fault of the fourth state. Our journalists and analysts and academics that did, unfortunately, a very poor job at Educating people on the basis of how globalization works. And globalization works not because everybody is willing to do it. Globalization works because there's one superpower that is an enforcer of these laws.

SPEAKER_01In the same way that the Romans were enforcing the laws and making sure that all the trade routes of the Mediterranean were open. And traders and merchants can pass through without getting... Attack by, you know, robbers and thieves and pirates and so on and so forth. It's the same. It is absolutely the same situation, Roman Empire 2.0, but at the global scale. And yeah, unfortunately, the wars in the Middle East,

SPEAKER_01they kind of gradually destroyed the credibility of the American military. And as we can see, both in the United States and abroad, people They don't want to hear about increasing budgets of the military. They don't think that the military should have big budgets. They don't think that foreign entanglements are a good idea. But they also don't understand that without those foreign bases and without those foreign entanglements, you're leaving the arteries of our nation.

SPEAKER_01...Of our global system vulnerable to Iran, to Russia, to China. And, you know, at some point you're not going to be able to order the goods that you want to order. And, you know, somebody needs to do that job. And unfortunately, the United States is coming to a point where they either don't want to or they're not capable of doing that job anymore.

SPEAKER_00Talk about the failure of globalization, the idea that the de-escalation of the world could happen if people could trade with each other and if there was this economic currency that could travel throughout the world.

SPEAKER_01Well, I was actually talking about this recently. So the more I listen to people discuss the current realities of our situation, the more I realize that many people do not really understand the difference between consumer supply chains and industrial supply chains. The Western world excels at the former. We're absolutely exceptional when it comes to consumer supply chains. You can go to Amazon or any other alternative. You can order anything from, you know...

SPEAKER_01Supplements to technology to phones, whatever. But we have allowed much of our industrial base beneath those products to erode for the past several decades. I personally, and I don't think that many people will be that heartbroken if their shoes or T-shirts are not produced locally. But the unfortunate reality is that in many critical sectors, starting from energy,

SPEAKER_01Moving through defense, semiconductors, telecommunications, advanced manufacturing, and including agriculture, we no longer, in the West, we no longer control the complete supply chain infrastructure that is required to produce agriculture. And that vulnerability is not just limited to raw materials like oil and gas and rare earth and stuff like that. It actually extends to refining, processing, specialized components. So a product in the West may carry an American or European logo, but, you know, the...

SPEAKER_01It still remains fundamentally dependent on China or other third country inputs at several crucial stages. And this is the distinction that a lot of people fail to miss. There's a difference between having access to a finished product and having the capability to, the industrial capacity to produce that product independently from China or Russia

SPEAKER_01or even India and the global south. And this is the problem where I think that globalization started breaking down because consumer abundance created the illusion of industrial strength. And when a certain crisis, whether it's the Suez Canal crisis in the past, the current crisis with the Hormuz choke point, the war in Ukraine... You know,

SPEAKER_01like trade relations or geopolitical tensions or, you know, like trade wars happening like they're happening right now with tariffs. When these things happen, they disrupt an otherwise operational system, which is globalization. Unfortunately, globalization relies on the idea that everything will happen perfectly. So for me, For you to have this iPhone, for example, everything needs to go perfectly. All the components and all the raw materials and all the manufacturing and all

SPEAKER_01the assembling, it has to go perfectly for you to be able to click order and for you to be able to get it. Unfortunately, it has started to break down and it has been breaking down for the past 10 years because China has been leveraging their chokehold on article companies. And again, just a reminder, a single F-35 contains half a ton of rare earth minerals.

SPEAKER_01Our laptops, all of our complex technologies, they all use those materials. And we have hollowed out our industrial base and given it all up. And I'll give you another example with the current crisis with the Patriot missiles. In reality, the United States no longer has the industrial capacity to produce missiles

SPEAKER_01at scale. We currently need that production at scale because we are at war. And that war requires a lot of missiles and a lot of shells and a lot of ammunitions and a lot of drones. And all of these things, they don't grow on trees. They require raw materials. And I'll see you next time.

SPEAKER_01They're feeling it in other ways and they'll continue to feel it in the next 10, 15 to 20 years until we solve this. And we have to solve this because it's about our own survival.

SPEAKER_00Talk a little bit about the solving it part because the instinct today seems to bring up the drawbridge and just move in on ourselves.

SPEAKER_01The solving is the West has to finally come to terms with the fact that they are a member of a club I call the real 1%, which I actually call them the exceptionals. The reality of our world is that corruption and ideology and nepotism are the de facto operational software for 99% of the world.

SPEAKER_01And that has been the case. It was patronage. It was family before the law. It was strongmen above it. This is the oldest political issue. Technology that humanity has. Until very, very, very recently,

SPEAKER_01literally a handful of countries decided to Experiment with something very radical called constitutional democracies, trying to build reputable and functional institutions, creating high-trust societies to establish processes, governing a nation with an overall consensus between the government and its citizens, having equality of citizens before the law. It's crucial for people to realize that all of this is very, very new.

SPEAKER_01And if you do the rough math out of 8 billion people alive today, those that are living in genuinely high-trust, functional, constitutional democracies are a very modest minority. And unfortunately... People in the West have to understand two things. First of all, you have to stop projecting your values, your views and your successes to the rest of the world because we see that 99% of the world is not operating as a constitutional democracy

SPEAKER_01with free market capitalist system, you know, with meritocratic institutions and so on and so forth. However flawed, because I'm sure that there are going to be a lot of people saying that, oh, you know, It's not that peachy. Well, it's not that peachy, but in comparison to what? If you're comparing yourself to the rest of the world, you have to understand that it is actually quite peachy. And also people in the West have to understand that this exception and being... A true exceptionalist, like the American societies,

SPEAKER_01like most of Western, most of European societies are, this is not a permanent future of the Western order. It is a practice. It's kind of like a muscle. You need to continue training that muscle consistently. Otherwise, he's going to atrophy. So moving forward, people have to realize that We've tried with Russia and China and, you know, with other people to go with the appeasement,

SPEAKER_01to go with, you know, let's trade, we're going to close our eyes for certain human rights. We've been trying that for decades. This is the result that we're seeing. And the result that we're seeing now is the complete breakdown of supply chains and wars proliferating.

SPEAKER_01So I think that it's time if we're going to be fixing this problem. ...To realize that moving forward, we should not make the same mistakes. And if we're going to be the winners of the Second Cold War as well, first of all, we have to keep the alliance strong and have to realize that despite our differences... Between, you know, like the United States, Canada, America, our Pacific allies, our East Asian allies, like South Korea and Japan, we're all in this together.

SPEAKER_01However flawed our societies are, we're all trying to be, we're all doing our best to become part of the 1% of the exceptional societies with constitutional democracies and, you know, free market capitalists, so on and so forth. And the only way to move forward is from now on, we have to realize that we cannot depend, especially for crucial things like defense and all of the other critical industries

SPEAKER_01that I mentioned earlier in our conversations. We cannot depend on adversarial powers like China, no matter how, you know, Good they seemed at the time. We have to understand that these are authoritarian states, and they're going to remain authoritarian because liberal democracy is never going to work in China, and it's never going Russia is a whole different story. But you cannot let people that have such an opposing values and worldviews from your own

SPEAKER_01To have such a crucial input on your survival, because if they decide to close down the choke points, like the one in Iran and Taiwan and, you know, like the Red Sea lanes and so on and so forth, and if they decide to close the tab on rare earths and all the raw materials and everything, we are, and excuse my French, we are screwed. So that strategy of trade through appeasement and peace through weakness,

SPEAKER_01it's not going to work. So we have to show some teeth and we have to do the incredibly hard work of rebuilding our own supply chains and rebuilding our industrial capability within the Western alliance, which means that we have to drop The illusion that we can have these service-based economies where everybody is going to be working in an office and they're going to be making six figures or whatever people on Instagram and social media are trying to,

SPEAKER_01whatever illusion they're trying to sell, this is not going to work. We need to become industrial powerhouses like we used to be back before all of that happened. So I hope I answered your question.

SPEAKER_00Indeed. What do you make of the argument that we hear more and more of that it's free market capitalism here that's part of the problem?

SPEAKER_01Well, it is actually part of the problem. And I'm saying that as a free market capitalist myself, that is, you know, like I am a Hayekian at heart, like Friedrich Hayek for me is the ultimate economist. I think that your listeners should definitely go and listen to a few interviews with Gina Raimondo. She used to be the Secretary of Commerce under the Biden administration. She talked about industrial policy and she made that argument as a free market capitalist as well. She was like, look, you have to understand that there are certain crucial industries that are part

SPEAKER_01of national security. And I'll actually put... And agriculture as well under the national security umbrella, not just energy and defense and semiconductors and telecommunications and so on and so forth. And those industries are not always profitable. And they're not always profitable at the scale that we're used to seeing profit from, say, the service-based economy and from, you know, tech startups and, you know...

SPEAKER_01Financial fintech companies and so on and so forth. China is operating on a loss when it comes to, say, rare earth processing and refining. They're not making tons of money from selling those, despite the fact that those are crucial components and crucial materials, but they have to sell them on the cheap side to make sure that They had to settle for so long on the cheap to make sure that nobody else in the world was competitive.

SPEAKER_01Nobody else in Europe or anywhere else was able to compete with Chinese rare earths. So what they would do is just, okay, no, we just close down the mines and close down the refineries because we can just buy them from China. And this is where the invisible hand of the market, it can't solve that problem because for them it's a math problem. And the math problem is I want higher returns, I want better margins, and the best way to do that is to go and outsource.

SPEAKER_01And it's fine to outsource, don't get me wrong, like I love globalization, everybody does. But when you start outsourcing your defense and when, you know, your telecommunications, your crucial industries that are part of your national security, well, then you have a problem. And unfortunately, we live in a situation where I feel like It's only the military and national security establishment that realizes that risk.

SPEAKER_01And everybody else, whether it's the political class, whether it's the business class, people in finance or a wide range of businesses, they don't realize that risk. Because for them, they would rather cooperate with China and cooperate with Russia, even if it means that... A whole bunch of people in Taiwan and Eastern Europe need to be enslaved under those nations.

SPEAKER_01That is a better deal for them. This is what they would prefer. This is where free market capitalism actually fails because for them it's a math problem. For us, it's a matter of national security. It's also a matter of survival because Yes, it is cheaper to buy raw materials from Russia and China, but the geopolitical price that we pay is

SPEAKER_00so much higher. That, of course, as you talk about it in the end of the piece, requires the West making some very hard choices. And part of your point is we can make them now or later, but we're going to have to make them.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I mean, I think that if you look back, there was... Once you start examining the world from that prism and from that perspective, there were multiple times in the past 20 years where we could have made those choices and it was going to be less painful for us. But because they were made by a political class that can't think strategically, they're just sweeping things under the rug and hoping that the next guy is going to deal with that mess.

SPEAKER_01It comes a point where those choices become very, very painful. Just to scale it down, say, for example, you're someone that's not taking good care of yourself in terms of physical activity, good nutrition, good sleep. When you're in your 20s, you can get away with it. When you're in your 30s, yeah, you can kind of get away with it. But moving from 40s up, like, if you don't do something, it's just going to get worse and worse and worse.

SPEAKER_01So, yeah, like, the more we postpone the difficult decisions, the worse it's going to get. And I fear that there's a lot of populists on the rise right now, both in the United States and both in Europe, that are promising things to people that are just impossible. And people are going to fall for it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Talk about that. What are the promises that you hear that are so dangerous as you see it?

SPEAKER_01They would come and say, oh, well, you know, like we're going to fix the cost of living crisis. How are you going to fix the cost of living crisis? Or we're going to lower inflation. I mean, your supply chains are breaking down, my guy. There are multiple wars going on. Like, Seriously, this is how you're going. They're promising people. So basically populists are making two promises. The first promise is the product that they're basically selling to their electorate is a time machine.

SPEAKER_01They're telling people... We're going to stop time and present right now because it's too crazy. And we're going to turn back the clock to some time, like whether it's going to be the 90s where, you know, the labor market was better or the 50s and the 60s where a still worker could raise like three and a half children and a stay at home wife on a single salary. Whatever their idea of a golden age is, this is what they promise people that they're going to revert back to, which is absolutely possible, first of all.

SPEAKER_01And the second, they're basically promising things that are physically impossible to deliver. You can't fix the cost of living crisis because... You have spent the last 50 years hollowing out your industrial base and creating a service-based economy and printing money and subsidizing all sorts of ridiculous ventures. You know, you can't just like stop that and, you know, go back to a time where the economy worked better.

SPEAKER_01And unfortunately, because there are people like people that are now in their 30s and their 40s, they do remember times when things were happening. A lot of people are going to fall for that because nobody's going to come and say the hard truth. And the hard truth is that, you know, for the past 50 years, we have made some absolutely terrible political choices. And those political choices have led to that point.

SPEAKER_01And this is basically what I'm trying to do with mononomics. I'm basically trying to connect the dots between decision A and outcome B. And sometimes a decision A happened 30 years ago or 40 years ago. And the outcome of that decision, we're feeling it right now.

SPEAKER_00Finally, talk a little bit about whether or not you have any optimism about any of this. Do you think that we're capable at this point of making those hard choices?

SPEAKER_01Oh, I think we're very capable of making those hard choices. And I'm actually optimistic about it, but I'm just not optimistic the way that people usually are, which is in the short term. I do believe that in 20 years' time, I will be living in a much better, Thank you.

SPEAKER_01It requires more pain. Unfortunately, especially for people that have lived in peace and prosperity, and God bless them for that. This is the absolute best way to live your life in peace and prosperity. They need more pain. And when they get to that point, they're going to change tune. And this is something that happened in Ukraine. I mean, not so much the peace and prosperity part, but... You know, I was just talking with a friend recently that up until the morning of the invasion,

SPEAKER_01most people didn't believe this was going to happen. They just believed that, you know, this was not real. So and then when it happened and then continued to happen, people changed very much. And, you know, oftentimes there's this study that circulates where they ask people from various countries in the West whether they're going to fight for their country and most people say no. I don't think that's true. I think that if it comes down to it, you know, because those studies were done in Ukraine as well prior to the full-scale invasion

SPEAKER_01in 2022. Yes, most people say that, no, I'm not going to fight for this country. And at the end of the day, look what happens. They are fighting and they're winning.

SPEAKER_00Bianca Bonova, her Substack is Waronomics. I thank you so very much for spending time with us.

SPEAKER_01Thank you very much for having me. It's always a pleasure.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. And thank you for listening and joining us here on the Who, What, Why podcast. I hope you join us next week for another Who, What, Why podcast. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes. You can also support this podcast and all the work we do by going to whowhatwhy.org forward slash donate.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Thomas Frank asked “What’s the Matter With Kansas”? Now he asks What’s the Matter With Creativity?

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Surrogacy Scandal That Exposed a Very Broken System

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Those Powers That Congress Gave the Supreme Court? Congress Can Take Them Away

    Nov 11, 202639 minAudio

    The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. One Win Is Not a Lasting Majority

    Nov 7, 202641 minAudio

    Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Religious Movement That’s Done With Democracy

    Oct 31, 202628 minAudio

    Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...

    Credit the people on this episode