Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Cocktail

Talk Cocktail artwork

How Civilizations Lose the Signal

May 27, 202646 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In my latest WhoWhatWhy podcast, you’ll see that there’s a moment in the conversation when something clicks. When the thread connecting baby names to the fall of the Roman Empire to Bitcoin to Jeffrey Epstein to the basket of deplorables to the last reserve currency suddenly becomes visible. And once you see it, you can’t look away. That thread is the signal. Not communication. Not language. Something older and more fundamental than either: the mechanism by which civilization itself coordinates billions of people who will never meet, across timescales no single human life can fully comprehend. Simon Pearce writes the Liminal Lens Substack and is president of Emotif, a strategic consultancy that helps organizations thrive in an eara of rapid change and disruption - He has spent years mapping how that mechanism works, how it fails, and what it looks like when a civilization is deep into the failure. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to this special Who What Why podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. There's a game we're all playing, and most of us don't know the rules. It starts earlier, earlier than we think. Before we know what we want, we're already watching to see what other people want. We imitate, we signal, we compete, and over time those signals harden into something that feels like personal preference, like conviction, like identity. But it isn't, not really. It's the accumulated residue of a social process so old and so pervasive

SPEAKER_00Simon Pierce has been staring at it hard. He's been building essay by essay across a series that now spans four deeply interconnected pieces, a unified theory of how civilizations organize themselves, how they compete, and how they come apart. And the thread running through all of it is the signal, not the message, not the meaning, the signal, the compressed, legible, imitable marker that tells the world who you are and what

you're worth and whether

SPEAKER_00you're inside or outside the circle that matters. What he's found is both elegant and unsettling. Signals work until they don't. They coordinate behavior across millions of people who will never meet They make hierarchy legible and therefore actionable As signals become cheaper to imitate, they inflate As they inflate, they detach from the reality they were meant to represent And when that detachment grows large enough When signals stop pointing outward at the

world And start

SPEAKER_00pointing only at each other The system doesn't just mislead And here's what's at stake. We're living through a moment when almost everything that was supposed to hold things together, institutions, credentials, political discourse, shared truth, seems to be failing at once. And most of the explanations on offer are either too narrow or too tribal to be useful. They explain a piece of it, a symptom, a personality, a party.

SPEAKER_00Simon Pearce has built something different, a framework that shows these aren't separate failures. Steve McLaughlin

This is a description of right here, right now, on this morning, on this conversation.

SPEAKER_00Simon Pearce writes the Liminal Lens Substack. He is president of Emotive, a strategic consulting company that helps organizations thrive in an era of rapid change and disruption. He's been doing some of the most original civilizational thinking being published anywhere. building a unified theory that connects evolutionary biology to

medieval feudalism,

SPEAKER_00to modern platform economics, to reserve currency cycles without ever losing the thread. And today, we're going to get into all of it. It is my pleasure to welcome Simon Pierce here to the Who, What, Why podcast. Simon, thanks so much for joining us.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, Jeff. Great to be here.

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you so much for joining us today. Appreciate it. I want to begin by talking a little bit about this idea of signals and what you mean by them specifically, because I think that's a good foundation to begin with to talk about this. Sure.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, I think when we think about signals, I think it's very easy for us as people to file that in our minds under communication, right? And language. And I think what I mean by signals is actually something much broader than that. I think of it as a civilization scale mechanism for... And you could argue that it's even bigger than that because

signals appear in nature.

SPEAKER_01You could say that hormones within the human body are You could say that the red striping on a poisonous frog in the Amazon is a signal. And in fact, that last example is quite a good one because once that signal occurs, Jeff Schechtman

I think signal erosion is a natural ecological phenomenon that we see in the plant

SPEAKER_01kingdom, we see it in the animal kingdom, and we see it in human civilization. What does that tell us in terms of our own individual agency and the degree to which we're able to effectuate that agency when in fact so much of this is because

SPEAKER_00of those signals, because of that influence?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a tough question. I mean, it's very hard when you ask that question not to go all the way into the deep end of the swimming pool. And by that, I mean, you know, free will versus determinism or my favorite kind of sub flavor of that, which is turtles all the way down. Right. This can become a very sort of recursive problem.

SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman You might say we have no agency, that we're just a bundle of constraints, internal, external.

SPEAKER_01And the fact that we feel like we have agency is just epiphenomenal. It's just a trick of fate. I don't quite believe that, but I don't think there's really any way to prove that one way or the other. I think what we can say without going all the way into the deep end of philosophical speculation is that we're often much more I don't know if it's popular culture,

SPEAKER_01but certainly in culture recently, there's this whole concept of the hyper object, right? As we approach these These major thresholds in human history and human society, that could be AI, Ray Kurzweil's idea of the AI singularity, Ray Dalio's idea of the coming fiscal cliff. Peter Turchin's idea of the end of... I won't say the end,

but I guess he calls it end times, but it's a period of disintegration.

SPEAKER_01All of these things feel... Massive and I think from an individual standpoint it's hard to have much agency against these hyperobjects or in relation to these hyperobjects but the way I think about it is not in terms of cause and effect but Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01So to a certain extent, it is a kind of natural Yeah, so the way I think about what we might call performative behaviors is

SPEAKER_01I rather think of them as local optimizations. So I think a node in a system or a set of nodes, if you think of the human being as a bunch of biological nodes in a broader civilizational system that has some sense of itself and is trying to maintain So when you see these kind of performative things, what you're normally seeing from a system standpoint is a form of local optimization, right? Like I'm going to perform behavior X in this context to get outcome Y. So, you know,

I try not to view performativeness as through a moral lens although it's easy to go there because it can be really annoying but it's kind of a human system that's figured out how to optimize for an extremely specific set of local conditions and

SPEAKER_01isn't connecting to the broader system and so when there's a performative relationship between two human beings where one is performing something for the other It probably means that the complexity of the links and the ties between those two human beings are somewhat simplified and thin and not that complex, right? It's the difference between a loving relationship and a relationship that's sort of built on let's go out and let's buy each other things.

SPEAKER_00I guess it's also an issue of what the reward system is, what the recognition is and what the reward system is.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there's no one reward system and they exist on different temporal framings and the reward systems are not stable throughout human history. And so this is Ray Dalio's point about the rise and fall of reserve currencies. Reserve currencies through the last three cycles have lasted about 150 years each, which is enough human generations that the person at the end of the reserve currency doesn't remember what it was like at the beginning.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's actually not a coincidence, right? That's kind of part of it. And so by the time you get to the fourth, fifth, sixth generation of human being in that reserve currency scheme, they think of that reserve currency as a sort of permanent object. It's part of the permanent landscape. I think it can be incredibly jarring to realize that it is contingent that it is itself a signaling system within a broader human civilizational

signaling system and that these signaling systems are subject to imitation in fact I think currency inflation is really just if you really break it down it's highly analogous to Any form of valuable signal that becomes so valuable that it gets imitated, right? And so during the Roman Empire, you know, the first denarius that was minted was 95% silver.

SPEAKER_01The last denarius that was minted was 3% silver. You could never quite say at what point the denarius became worthless, but it was an ongoing process of signal dilution The signal stopped referring back to the thing that it was supposed to refer back to in the first place. And this happens with the poisoned frog or the not poisoned frog that has the red stripe. That's exactly the same thing as the denarii's.

SPEAKER_00Right, it becomes incredibly self-referential, and then with each generation, it's the opposite of digital, really, because each generation decays from the previous generation. The copies, each copy that comes along, each degree of self-referential nature becomes weaker or different than what came before. It's not like digital copies.

SPEAKER_01No, it's copies of copies of copies of copies. That's right. Yeah, I think that's right. You know, I also think that highly complex civilizations, every human being is going to optimize first and foremost for their local conditions, right? Their immediate family, their immediate career. What I think happens in what Ray Dalio would call late in the long-term debt cycle is that these clusters of local optimization are are hyper-optimized for local conditions but are completely

disconnected from other

SPEAKER_01pockets of local optimization, right? And so, again, the fragmentation that we're seeing, I don't view it primarily as a moral thing in the sense that The human beings who are going through these bizarre fragmentations right now across the world, especially in the West, but frankly everywhere, including China. Those human beings are not, I want to phrase this carefully, they're not inherently, I think, less moral than previous generations.

SPEAKER_01They're extremely locally optimized for their own social milieu. Certainly the fragmentation of media has helped this and that they're actually incapable of understanding the other groups and I think perhaps what makes me a little bit unusual is I talk to lots of these I talk to lots of these groups I talk to people who might be considered part of the quote unquote

business elite I talk

SPEAKER_01to people who Most definitely not in the business elite, but might be considered part of the media elite, depending on where you sit. I talk to university professors. I talk to ordinary people. So I think one of the things that I did by accident was I didn't locally optimize my life I mean, I did and I didn't.

SPEAKER_01I've kind of bounced between a lot of different worlds, I think because I'm just extremely curious about the differences between those worlds. And so when I take a step back and look at current conditions, what I see is a bunch of like internally coherent philosophies within these local bubbles that make complete sense when you're inside them, but are not capable of having an information exchange dialogue. So then we're back to signals again. Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01Jeff Schecht And I think that's overwhelming for a human being to realize you've caused that much death and suffering because these two groups are optimizing for local

SPEAKER_01conditions and are failing to interpret what's going on Jeff Schechtman Could just do a better job of understanding each other, right? And so, you know, why does that happen?

SPEAKER_01Well, over the period of a long cycle, let's say four, six generations, these subcultures actively select for insiders who don't understand the outside and who are focused on the inside. They actually create more self-referential nodes within the cluster. And that's the problem in a nutshell.

SPEAKER_00And why in a world that is theoretically smaller, when things like social media exist, when better communications exist, do we still suffer from these same problems? In theory, the shrinking of communication should help solve some of that, but in fact it makes it worse.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, to me it's not a paradox. This is where Turchin's book The Great Holocene Transformation is helpful because what he's mapped over thousands of years of human history and he has this great chart that has two Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01And on the other axis, you have the scale of the civilization. And what's very clear is there's sort of a path to a larger scale civilization that requires more complex signaling and coordination systems. And if you don't achieve the next level of civilizational communication system, you're not going to achieve the next level of scale. Now, in the modern world, we've never had more people alive on the planet,

SPEAKER_01and our industries have never been more complex. The differences between technical knowledge spheres has never been more complex. I mean, we live in an exponentially more complex world, and we've managed, I think at this point in our history, to locally optimize some key areas. The aerospace industry is fantastically Almost mind-bogglingly well-optimized locally within the confines of that industry

to the point where we can get on a plane anywhere in the world with no worries,

SPEAKER_01knowing that it's extremely safe. Nothing is perfect, but the airline industry achieved Six Sigma decades and decades ago, which is absurd. To the layperson will say, Six Sigma is an extremely high level of quality control. across all systems. I mean, if you're building an airliner, everything's trackable back to the original rivet that you've put thousands of these rivets in these planes. And airline rivets have all these reporting requirements.

SPEAKER_01What we lack is a stabilizational compute layer And part of that's human cognition. I'm not just saying computers. I mean, civilizational compute layer that enables us to globally... You have to listen more carefully to what I'm saying if that's what you're thinking right now because that's not what I'm saying. The globalist architecture was built on something that could scale

SPEAKER_01Jeff Schechtman Superstate in dramatic fashion and said, this isn't working for our people. And that process, the Brexit process is far from done.

I think one of the things as human beings that can be frustrating is these things

SPEAKER_01that I'm talking about take decades, if not hundreds of years to play out. So not all of this plays out in any one human lifetime. So you can't have to be enormously patient. Yeah. It's frustrating because you want to see how the movie ends. But we're not even halfway through the Brexit process. And that's just one country that crashed out of the European super state that was supposed to be the model for global governance, right? You know, these institutions that we tried to scale, and they have not succeeded in scaling.

SPEAKER_01And when you and I last spoke, it was before the Iran war. And we were joking, because we weren't even able to publish it in time. We spent some time I'm talking about how war was one of the symptoms of this kind of breakdown of overarching global government systems. You were going to see that in war. And before we even got the episode out, a major war started. So we're back doing it this way now.

SPEAKER_00Talk about why it was unable to scale, in your view.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's not going to surprise you to hear me say that there are lots of reasons why it failed to scale. But one of the biggest reasons in my opinion was it lost touch with ground truth within the societies that were being brought together and amalgamated into a global society and a global government system. So why did that happen? Well, it happened because within each of these societies the United States,

SPEAKER_01Europe, China a tremendous amount of stratification was going on at the same time what Peter Turchin calls the wealth pump which is a repeating cycle in history And this is what Thomas Piketty would call R is greater than G, right? So you're growing your economy. You have all these productive businesses. It's great. And you need to reward those productive businesses for being productive and innovating.

SPEAKER_01And you do all of that. But what you find is over time that the thing that made you successful carries within it the seeds of its own destruction because the most successful companies and individuals and groups and families Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01I'm talking like 80 90% of the population in wealthy countries, and that does not include the population of less wealthy countries, are saying, you're telling me this is great, but I'm not Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_01Jeff Schechtman And maybe victim is too strong, but what she showed me in that statement,

she's failed to understand the structural demographic drivers that were creating

SPEAKER_01the discontent. And that to me is inexcusable as a leader. Jeff Schechtman You know, we've got 30,000, 40,000 people killed and injured every month in Ukraine right now,

SPEAKER_01which is a great tragedy. We don't know what's going to happen in the Strait of Hormuz, but I think it's clear that there's a significant oil products shortage. Deficit now that is going to lead to hunger and starvation in some parts of the world. So the inability of large and small nation states to coordinate effectively at the global scale is a tragedy. If that makes me a globalist, then so be it. Hopefully people will see that I'm not a globalist in the sense

of wanting to scale

SPEAKER_01institutions that won't scale. Now, maybe there's some version of those institutions that could scale, But that's all very theoretical for me. It's like, okay, but you're proposing scaling this thing now to do this job. And some of them just ran out of gas. I mean, some of it's just cyclical. I mean, we had some institutions that scaled quite well, but the assumptions that drove their scaling just went away, right? So some of it is, oh, we tried to take something and it wouldn't scale. Some of it is we took something, it scaled,

SPEAKER_01but it left a bunch of people behind and we can't keep scaling it. We've got to reform it. I'm going to go back to money because I think that people misunderstand what money is because Especially the Bitcoin guys, actually. First of all, we live in a process universe. I believe this to be a good model for describing the universe

that we live in. That what we think of as objects are stable patterns within a broader process of

SPEAKER_01instability or entropy generation. You can read A.N. Whitehead on this I think is good. I particularly like from a physics standpoint Stephen Wolfram's view on this.

SPEAKER_00So the whole thing is a process.

SPEAKER_01So you can't really store value and think of money as an object, right? Like money is a civilizational, especially reserve currencies like US dollar. It's a civilizational nervous system that coordinates many of the other nervous systems to keep the organism alive. Like if you think of civilization as an organism or the world biosphere as an organism and constantly signaling to each other in order to keep the energy moving in order to move down the

entropy gradient,

SPEAKER_01which is the one certainty, you know, the first and second laws of thermodynamics, basically. So the one thing we cannot escape, at least we haven't figured out Jeff Schechtman jeffschechtman

But you ultimately want signals to be meaningful and the only way to make them

SPEAKER_01meaningful in the long run is for them to be quote unquote expensive. That is almost, this is where I do overlap with the Bitcoin guys a bit, this kind of proof of work concept, right? So peacock feathers are expensive because they make the male, first of all, they're biologically expensive to produce but they make the male peacock enormously vulnerable to predators. So it's quite an expensive flex. That's not like a fake signal. But human society seems to find ways to take these expensive

signals and kind of

SPEAKER_01make them cheap. I think this is why reserve currencies that accumulate puddles of wealth in very few sets of hands get displaced by new reserve currencies because once the wealth has puddled and it's It becomes a stagnant pool. Its signal value goes away because the signal value of money is dynamism and energy and getting things done, creating new things,

SPEAKER_01exploring, expanding. But because of what Piketty has shown in his work, it's going to puddle. I mean, it's puddling now, right? And so it becomes kind of like a stagnant pond. And I don't think the people sitting on top of the stagnant ponds fully understand. Jeff Schechtman

SPEAKER_00That after a while, the saturation, again coming back to the peacock, the saturation makes the signaling cheap.

SPEAKER_01Cheap, and therefore, you know, I kind of think of financial inflation like type 2 diabetes for a civilization, right? Because I'm not a medical expert, but my very rough understanding of how type 2 diabetes works is you're getting all these kind of hormonal signals, insulin signals, And the body stops responding It's gotten so many signals It learns to ignore them It says they don't mean anything anymore And so this can happen

With reserve

SPEAKER_00currencies as well

SPEAKER_01Now, it's too much of a digression for today. I think of crypto as the last hurrah of the ancien regime. I don't think it solved this problem at all. What I think it is, it's a bunch of people who realize this is happening, and they're looking for a personal lifeboat off-ramp without changing anything else. In fact, the puddling that I described, that stagnant pond, So much worse with cryptocurrency than it is with the US dollar. I mean, it's orders of magnitude worse.

SPEAKER_01And there's data to kind of back that up. So I kind of compare the crypto guys to the Marxists. They've like correctly diagnosed the problem and totally failed to understand the solution, which is kind of like how I feel when I talk to Marxists. I'm like, great diagnosis. I'm not going to give you the keys to the car. All of which leads to this, the next status level that you talk about of really rule breaking. Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, this is now is sort of going back into the cultural side of this thing from the macro side. So, yeah, this this this is more specifically about virtue signaling, which we haven't touched on. Right.

SPEAKER_00So money is a form of signal. Right.

SPEAKER_01But within these kind of subcultures or subgroups, virtue is a form of signal that can get you things. It can get you hired in certain jobs. It means that if you signal certain virtues, then you're not threatening to the structure that you're in. So then you're trusted with responsible jobs in corporate or government jobs. This is... Something I wrote about recently that actually we're very close

in that regard today in the professional managerial class to what George Orwell described in 1984

SPEAKER_01with one absolutely critical thing that Orwell got wrong. Orwell's character of Winston Smith was a so-called outer party member, which roughly translates to the professional managerial class today, as opposed to the ownership class, which would be the inner party. Okay, all good there. But he's horribly impoverished in 1984. I mean, he barely gets enough to eat. He's sick all the time. And this is not how it plays out in our world.

The modern equivalent of Winston Smith is extraordinarily well compensated.

SPEAKER_01But in most cases, just like Winston Smith is required to follow the doctrine, is required at times to perform double think. The concept of the thought police in the UK in particular recently has gone from being abstract to being not just within corporate life but has now gone full civilizational so I forget how many ordinary people have been arrested for tweeting in the UK now I left the UK 26

SPEAKER_01years ago and when I left it wasn't like that you could go You know, the joke was you could go and say anything you wanted on Speaker's Corner. And it was all part of the fun and games of our society. You could say anything you want. People have been arrested for tweets that only five people saw. And I guess the sick person was the thought police. Jeff Schechtman

I think is nuts so Virtue Signaling is itself a set of signals that Rob Henderson talks about with his upcoming book Luxury Beliefs so the interesting thing about Virtue Signaling is it's there's a line from my favorite movie that none of your

SPEAKER_01readers will know there's an English cult movie called With Nell and I And these two out of work actors, one of whom is very posh, they go to the rich uncle of the posh one to get the keys to his cottage because they decide they need a holiday. And it's a whole nightmare. It's hilarious. And the guy comes out with the keys for Jeff Schecht

And it's low cost, but it's low cost to the virtue signaler in some ways.

SPEAKER_01Certainly financially, it's low cost. It's just a statement. But it's very exclusionary. Like what Henderson says is like a working class person could get away with espousing these beliefs because that immediately would cause suffering in the community if these policy ideas were acted upon. Now this is where I part ways with Henderson though because I think there is a cost it's cognitive right so again back to George Orwell Winston Smith he got that the part the cognitive load he got right it's it's it's it's quite and you talk to people who've spent 30 years in corporate life who have not had

the the skill or the luck or the good fortune or the combination of those things to kind of rise up

SPEAKER_01to I'm talking to someone who's really stuck in middle management you see how ground down some of these people part of the double thing here is they're not allowed to admit it in public but you can see it on their faces and in private people will admit this to you but it's part of their membership they don't want to drop down Out of the PMC because once you drop out of the top 10%, you're in the immiserated classes.

SPEAKER_01Right now in America, the productivity growth that we've experienced since 1970, nearly all of that's gone to the top. 10%. Almost none of it's gone to anyone else. Now, some things got cheaper through capitalism like TVs and stuff, but houses didn't get cheaper. Education didn't get cheaper. Healthcare didn't get cheaper. So, okay, yeah, you can get a cheap flat screen TV and you have all the benefits of the internet. And that's true and that's valuable. I'm not discounting that, but I think it's a more complicated game.

So, you know, virtue signaling, luxury beliefs, that's a very interesting and complex area. I don't know that I fully, even now that I fully understand how it works, but at the top

SPEAKER_01And now I'm going to finally answer your question. So what's interesting is opting out of luxury beliefs at the top end also mirrors George Orwell's 1984 when he finally meets with O'Brien and O'Brien turns off his telly screen. And Smith says, and I think Julia is there as well, Smith and Julia meet with O'Brien and they say, wait, you can turn off your telly screen. And O'Brien says all inner party members can turn off their telly screen. So and to those who haven't read the book it's the telescreen that monitors you so it has a camera on it so you're never you're never alone you're

always monitored and so you know I think obviously Epstein is an extreme case of this and there are other dynamics at play around predatory human nature and things like that but you know all the people who went to the island they're kind of the inner party members

SPEAKER_01who can turn off their telescreen they espouse virtue in public and vice in private and in fact I think you look at Harvey Weinstein I'm now about to get in real trouble but it's fine but you look at Weinstein And you compare him to other people in Hollywood And you're like, he was an extremely coercive And let's face it, kind of unattractive He was unattractive,

wealthy and powerful So he used these very extreme forms of coercion to get what he wants There are equally morally bankrupt people in Hollywood today Who are

SPEAKER_01good-looking people You can think about who some of these people are. I'm going to avoid getting in trouble by naming them. Some of these people engage in extremely exploitative relationships in private. And then some of these people may have recently participated in the mother of all virtue signaling movies, which is you can figure out what this movie is for yourself. It's...

I heard it described as Antifa the movie and it won bunches of Oscars for its virtue signaling because it was so virtuous but some of the actors in that engage in turning off their tele screen in private so they portray these extreme in this case leftist visions of virtue although I don't think this is exclusive to the left

SPEAKER_01in public and then in private they adopt a Jeff Schechtman

Is the line so clear between him and people who are blessed with better facial features?

SPEAKER_01I don't know.

SPEAKER_00We see it in Silicon Valley as well.

SPEAKER_01It's not just Hollywood.

SPEAKER_00Yes. In fact, arguably we're seeing more of it in Silicon Valley these days.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. It's a conundrum for sure. But as Ray Dalio has pointed out, you know, our society is approaching the fiscal cliff, which to me is an end game of the current signaling regime. I can't tell you when we're going to get there. Might start next week. Might take 15 years. I have no idea. But the current meta signaling regime that we are in is not in

its early stages. I'm not going to get into prognostication here because my favorite historical fact is how the Western Roman Empire kept going for 300 years after Nero so it's like big complex and we have a lot going for us this is the thing I'm not a doom and

SPEAKER_01gloomer because underneath all of this We have a lot going for us. There's genuine innovation happening in this system. And some of these pockets and these subcultures, they're not all bad. Some of them are profoundly generative and productive. And they're going to benefit all of humanity. But when we find these pockets or subcultures that are not, I think we're reaching the point where society can't afford those pockets anymore. And it's going to have to remove some of the impunity.

SPEAKER_01And you see this... Jeff Schechtman

The job of a civilizational signal is to coordinate billions of human beings who

SPEAKER_01will never meet each other into a better outcome for everyone, on average, without falling into John Stuart Mill kind of utilitarianism. I don't want to fall down these rabbit holes of socialism versus capitalism because I think actually they're one of the great signaling misfires of our age is this obsession with these two systems and Turchin helped me get there because you know when I look at his work throughout history and I'm like all his failure modes repeat across all these different types of civilization with

different governance

SPEAKER_01systems and the same failure modes keep showing up I'm like well it's So it can't be, well, this one's good and this one's bad because it keeps happening.

SPEAKER_00Turtles all the way down.

SPEAKER_01Turtles all the way down.

SPEAKER_00Simon Pierce, we will continue this conversation someday. I thank you so very much for all of this.

SPEAKER_01Appreciate it. Thank you for having me. Thank you. It was great. And thank you for listening and joining us here on the Who, What, Why podcast.

SPEAKER_00I hope you join us next week for another Who, What, Why podcast. I'm Jeff Schechtman. You can also support this podcast and all the work we do by going to whowhatwhy.org forward slash donate

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Thomas Frank asked “What’s the Matter With Kansas”? Now he asks What’s the Matter With Creativity?

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Surrogacy Scandal That Exposed a Very Broken System

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Those Powers That Congress Gave the Supreme Court? Congress Can Take Them Away

    Nov 11, 202639 minAudio

    The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. One Win Is Not a Lasting Majority

    Nov 7, 202641 minAudio

    Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Religious Movement That’s Done With Democracy

    Oct 31, 202628 minAudio

    Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...

    Credit the people on this episode