Give this country a tragedy and it will have the heroes and villains sorted before the ambulance has pulled away. Americans no longer need to know what happened to know whose fault it is. The one reflex a divided country still shares is the certainty that arrives before the facts do.In May 2023, Jordan Neely, homeless and in the grip of mental illness, died in a chokehold on a Manhattan subway, held down by a former Marine named Daniel Penny. Almost before the facts were known, the argument was settled. My guest on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Anand Giridharadas, put it this way, they got their group number and went to stand in the right line. Giridharadas, a former New York Times correspondent and author of Man in the Mirror: Hope, Struggle, and Belonging in an American City, treats that subway car as a biopsy: a small incision that reveals the condition of the whole body. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Who, What, Why podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. Somewhere along the way, we lost the ability to look at something and not already know what it means. A thing happens, something terrible and genuinely confusing. And before the facts are in, before we even know the names, we know whose fault it is, what it proves, and which side we're supposed to be on. The meaning arrives ahead of the event. ... ... ... ... ...
SPEAKER_00Held down by a young former Marine named Daniel Penny. Within hours, long before anyone understood much of anything, the two of them had been slotted into their assigned places. Neely was a discarded life, or he was the menace every rider fears. Penny was a vigilante, or he was the one man willing to act when no one else would. Nobody needed more information. Everybody already had the answer. My guest today spent three years refusing to do that, and what he found is that the subway car was And having learned
SPEAKER_00The strange thing is where all those separate stories end up in the same place. Across a country that agrees on almost nothing, more and more of us have arrived at one shared conviction. That when something goes truly wrong, no one is coming to help. My guest, Anand Gahardes,
SPEAKER_00spent three years inside this story, and the result is his new book, Man in the Mirror, Hope, Struggle, and Belonging in an American. Anand is the author of the previous works, Winners Take All, The Persuaders, and True American. And he has written a story where what takes place inside a small subway car in New York City represents the state of America in 2026. Anand Gahardes, thanks so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_01Jeff, thank you so much for having me. I got to say, I think that was the single best framing and introduction of the book I have heard yet. And I have been hearing a lot over the last few weeks, but that was singular. So thank you for that deep understanding of what I tried to do.
SPEAKER_00Well, I appreciate that. And I want to start with this idea that shortly after this incident happened, that it took almost no time for everybody to dig in on all sides, that the reflexive response to the individual narratives was almost immediate. Talk about that first.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this was a story that was reduced to clickbait before anybody had a chance to think. And I would suggest that it's not the only story that before or since that we have done that to. I think we're in the middle of doing that to the Cornell rape story. I think we did that with the Lindsay Clancy trial not long ago. This is sort of what we do, this social media brain that sort of gets its claws on these stories and
SPEAKER_01then reduces them and then serves them up to us in this form where We don't really need to do what you and I are, I think, doing right now, which is thinking aloud, listening to each other, processing, maybe even being altered by what we hear. But instead, people just kind of get into their group number like they do at the airport. You know, I'm group number three. I guess I got to go stand over there. So the story of this moment on an uptown F train in Manhattan where a black person
SPEAKER_01An unhoused, mentally ill man named Jordan Neely was acting erratically on the subway, was put into a chokehold by Daniel Penny, a 24-year-old former Marine, white, originally from the suburbs of Long Island, came to New York City seeking more. This incident, when which Jordan Neely died, became reduced instantly to... These kind of group numbers almost, right? You either have to feel as though Jordan Neely is a victim of every marginalization
SPEAKER_01and systemic injustice of American life, or you have to think he is a career criminal who someone finally had the courage to put down. You either think Daniel Penny was Batman in kind of entropic, anarchic Gotham, or he is a vigilante in Donald Trump's, you know, white supremacist America. And people in those cases, when cases are reduced like this, everyone knows their role.
SPEAKER_01Just like the group numbers when you fly, you know where you're supposed to stand. And so what we are then expected to do by this culture is to go stand in our lane and yell as loudly as we can. It's all meant to be outbound transmission. There's no inbound transmission possible when we're doing that kind of yelling. And so a story like this comes along and it generates a huge amount of news and noise and no one learns a thing.
SPEAKER_01And in this case, the reason I chose to spend three years on it is because I was convinced that that reduction and that tribal sorting actually erased a lot of what we needed to face as a country. It was very easy. I think what was harder to face but more important to face are questions like what are the systems in this country that are meant
SPEAKER_01to hold people like Jordan Neely, people who are homeless, people who are experiencing mental illness, people who don't have support, people who are traumatized. And what does it look like to have systems that would actually hold folks like that or hold all of us when we are in difficult straits? What does it look like to have a culture in which so many people feel that the system is not working, the system is rigged, the system doesn't hear or see them, and therefore so many people feel a permission structure to take matters
SPEAKER_01into their own hands? What does it look like to live in a society in which You know, that the racial and other kind of tribal hostilities of our time have been ratcheted up and ratcheted up. An anonymous trust, which was, I think, a hallmark of American life in earlier decades, has really changed. I wanted both to be in this story because I think both of those stories are at the heart of this era we've been living in.
SPEAKER_00The other system that's worth looking at in this context is what this sorting replaced. What was there before that allowed us a greater level of deliberation as a society that we could determine views about this and that we could in instances hold two thoughts in our mind at the same time? It's a great question.
SPEAKER_01I mean, Well, I mean, I just listened to you and I are sitting here doing this right now. Like, it's not that it's gone. It's here still. It's available. Right. Books are still available. Public radio is still available. You know, long form interviews of all kinds are still available. But. A new thing obviously has pushed into the discourse, which is social media platforms generally owned and operated by extremely wealthy and powerful people who have an interest,
SPEAKER_01I think, in us not deeply deliberating so much as in loudly yelling in forms that generate engagement. I am thoroughly enjoying this conversation with you. But I'm aware that the kind of conversation you and I are having is less likely to provoke engagement in in the sense of reactions and comments and replies than
SPEAKER_01if I was to use this time we have together to say Donald Trump is an idiot. Donald Trump is an idiot. Donald Trump is an idiot. Right. Immediately. If we were watching it in real time, there would be hearts popping up at the exact moment that I said those phrases, even if I was saying them self-consciously, critically. And so what has happened is the space to my wife, Priya Parker, is a conflict resolution facilitator, and she has this phrase that I love. It's called letting the arrow pierce.
SPEAKER_01When you're criticized, when you just hear an idea that's challenging to you, just let the arrow pierce. It doesn't mean you have to agree with it, but just that little bit of space, almost like in meditation, the whole goal of meditation, as I have vaguely understood it and tried to do it at times, is not to become some, you're not trying to become the Dalai Lama, you're trying to create a very brief pause
SPEAKER_00between the action and the reaction.
SPEAKER_01A really brief pause is the difference between a very healed person and a very reactive, not healed person. And so similarly, when you hear information that is contrary to your model of the world, when you hear a racial testimony from someone in a different group than you about what the world is like for them, When you hear a reason someone voted for Donald Trump or a reason someone voted for the DSA or whatever it is that makes you uncomfortable,
SPEAKER_01do you grant that little, let's call it a kind of civic meditative pause where you say, huh, that's interesting. I'm hearing a bunch of young people say that they want to be socialists now. That makes me uncomfortable because I don't think socialism works. Or I grew up in the Cold War and, you know, I thought it was kind of a dangerous thing and that leads to a lot of bad things that I don't want in my country. But hold on. If lots of young people in New York City and San Francisco and elsewhere seem
SPEAKER_01to be gravitating to this thing called democratic socialism, am I going to let the arrow pierce for a second, which is to say, just be a little curious? Why is that happening? What might I not see? One of the most important questions you can ask in a democracy is, what can I not see? Where are my blind spots? And becoming curious about what you can't see. This may sound preachy, but it is basic civics. Because the whole idea of a democracy is we have all these different experiences of the world.
SPEAKER_01And then we sort of have to pool our information when we vote. And we have to arrive at some kind of choice about the future. Do we want to lock up all the homeless people we're seeing in public space or do we want to have better treatment facilities, right? You can't choose those kind of choices without us listening to each other, without us pooling and trading experiences and saying, huh, you know, I never thought That that person on the street actually might be a victim
SPEAKER_01of all these traumas and that it actually might be more productive to reduce and heal the effects of those traumas rather than incarcerate them. Huh, let me just sit with that for a second. In the kind of America we have allowed ourselves to become, there is no letting the arrow pierce. There's no sitting with anything. There's no civic meditative pause. And I wrote this book Not just because I wanted to get out of that for myself, but I did. I had fallen prey to this as much as anybody else.
SPEAKER_01I wanted to write a different kind of book in which I grappled with ways of looking at the world that I found challenging. But I also wanted to do that for you. This book is, among other things, an attempt to stretch the reader, to grant a little bit more grace to the views of people that May make you uncomfortable or may simply be unlike you.
SPEAKER_00The other part of that, in addition to granting the grace, is that it also requires, perhaps, complexity and the willingness to take on, even in those brief moments, the complexity of a situation, the complexity of people. And that seems to be anathema to so many today.
SPEAKER_01It is. And it's I learned this thing when I was reporting my book, The Persuaders, which four years ago is about activists and organizers generally on the left who are trying to think about how do you change minds in this age of polarization and division and kind of everybody knowing what they think about everything in advance. And one of the things that I learned from these organizers I followed was that, and this is a very powerful basic framework,
SPEAKER_01That we all, every single one of us, knows that we are complicated on the inside. Everybody listening to this has a wonderful, colorful, kaleidoscopic sense of their own complexity. We all know that we love our mother so much, and yet this thing and that thing and this thing about her makes us crazy. We all know That we're so grateful we became parents.
SPEAKER_01But gosh, it is so hard on some days. And on some days, maybe we even questioned that decision. We all know that we love candidates from this party. But gosh, we may have huge private doubts about, are they actually getting anything done? Are they actually offering a meaningful difference? You can go down the list. You know your own complexity. The issue is that we don't think other people far away from us on issues or ideology.
SPEAKER_01We don't think they are as complicated. We think they are monoliths. So if you're a progressive, you know your own internal struggles. You know things you have doubt about. But you think everybody in MAGA is a, you know, Well, it's not true. They are as complicated as you are. They have as much roiling thoughts and doubts as you do. And Steve Deline,
SPEAKER_01a brilliant organizer who worked very hard on gay marriage and did a lot of door-to-door interviews. Pioneered a lot of the door-to-door canvassing work that helped win gay marriage years ago. He said to me, the thing I have most come to learn in this work is that most people are 60-40 on most things. Which is to say, forget a 50-50 country. Most people within themselves are 60-40 on most things. Think about something as hot-buttoned as he worked on gay marriage.
SPEAKER_01What he found... Is that when you knock on the door of someone who's super hostile to gay marriage back in the day, what you might perceive, and as a gay person as he was, he would be very reasonable to perceive that that person's 100% against him. But he learned that that person was 60% against him. And what was the 40%? The 40% was all the other intuitions that were in that person. That might favor gay marriage.
SPEAKER_01Not necessarily about gay marriage, it's about life. So for example, a person whose church teaching tells them gay marriage is wrong.
SPEAKER_00That's animating the 60%.
SPEAKER_01But does that same person have a sense that the government shouldn't tell people what to do? Yeah, they might. That's the 40%. Does that same person have a sense that love is crazy and wild and inexplicable and no one can really get in the way of it? Yeah, they might have that view. That's in the 40%. And so what Steve Deline taught me was to win that fight, you don't have to crush that person. You have to help their 40% grow to over 50%.
SPEAKER_01And when you say it like that, well, that's not that hard. You have to make certain things more salient to them and certain other things less salient to them. I say all that to say when you... You're not only being a bad citizen, you are reducing drastically your ability to win the fights you are in. You're reducing drastically your ability to defend democracy. Democracy depends on a faith that other people are as torn up as you are.
SPEAKER_01And therefore a faith that the right set of words, the right persuasive laborers,
SPEAKER_00How much of that has to do with individual trust? And how much does that lack of trust have to do with distrust first of institutions? It's almost a chicken or the egg question because it is the lack of trust in institutions that arguably, and particularly as it's part of the story that you tell here, that the lack of trust in institutions has given rise to greater distrust in individuals.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to answer that by way of a story from my childhood that is really striking to me. My parents came to this country from India in the 1970s. And India, I would say then and even now, is an extremely low trust society in both senses of your question. It is low trust in systems, in the government, in the authority, in processes that are supposed to work. And it is, I would say, very low trust,
SPEAKER_01you know, what's I think scholars call anonymous trust, which is high trust among people you know, but very low trust in the commons of people you don't know, right? Which is why people arrange marriages among people they only know and things like that. My parents came to this country and my dad was so, they were living in Shaker Heights, Ohio. And I think one of the things that just knocked my dad's socks off Was the anonymous trust in this country? Was the sense that you were honest in your taxes?
SPEAKER_01Even if you thought the odds of getting caught for skimming a little bit were low. That you, you know, that you'd have all these things where you could just, in theory, you could take something and no one would take it. Or people would leave money and even if there was no one there. You know, you couldn't have this in so many countries. I remember when he, sometimes in a restaurant I was growing up, they would forget to put an item on the check. And my dad would call them back to say, you got to add this item to the check. And I remember thinking as a kid, why would you voluntarily ask to pay more money?
SPEAKER_01And my dad would say, I'm so thankful to be in an honest country where everyone just, there's this trust, right? And I think that was a hallmark of this country. And people have written about, scholars have written about this notion of anonymous trust as a powerful... Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Systems are working, that the IRS is broadly reliable, if annoying, that generally speaking, the policies do the things they're supposed to do. And I think the era we have lived through, I think from the time my parents came here to now, there's been a real erosion of that anonymous trust, both at the level of the system and interpersonally. I wrote a piece a couple of years ago about All these killings where people would drive into a driveway by accident at night
SPEAKER_01and someone would just start shooting. Or people would walk down, cross a property line or trespass, people would just start shooting. This notion that strangers are danger, this notion that everyone is a suspect, it is all part and parcel in America in which this basic anonymous trust in other people and in the ability of the system to function has declined. And I will say, I am someone who does not blame individuals for this as much as viewing our failure
SPEAKER_01to make people feel... Seen and heard and helped by policy. This is just a downstream consequence of that. When so many people feel unseen, unserved, unhelped, uncared for by power for so long, you start to trust nothing and no one. And that may be the death of democracy as much as a tank in the street. I
SPEAKER_01think sometimes when we focus on this question of the health of democracy, we fixate on the wrong thing. You know, I think in some ways democracy dies if it dies not only with a bang but with a whimper, as that old poem says. And the whimper is simply most people getting used to the idea that they're not going to be helped.
SPEAKER_00In a way, the system fails and then we turn on each other as a result.
SPEAKER_01And that is what happened in so many ways in this subway car. I spent all this time trying to figure out what happened in that subway car in New York. And one thing that really struck me, first of all, is that there was a common sentiment in that car that In spite of all the differences, which was this sense of abandonment that, you know, Jordan Neely felt abandoned all his life and had reason to feel that way,
SPEAKER_01abandoned by systems, abandoned by those who should have cared for him. Daniel Penny professed to feel abandoned by law enforcement. You know, his lawyers talked about There should have been cops there. There should have been mental health and other systems to keep Jordan Neely away from being in that state, in that place. The passengers in that car felt abandoned in their own way and sort of expressed that in 911 calls that we could later hear.
SPEAKER_01When you look just at that subway car, which I have tried to investigate as a microcosm of this country, that sense of abandonment is everywhere. And I would ask those listening to this who may live in a very different world, it seems like, than that subway car or those systems, do you not feel... That same basic thing. I think this sense of abandonment is the defining political emotion of our age. It is what people who vote for Donald Trump feel.
SPEAKER_01It's what people who voted for Zoran Mamdani feel. It's what people who voted for the Democrats, who are going to be voting for the Democrats, I think, in the next few weeks. It's the feeling that is animating that wave right now. It is the sense of being unheard, unseen, unfelt, uncared for, disrespected even, ignored, that is so powerful, that is fueling this authoritarian age. And one of the things I wanted to do in this book is to use one case.
SPEAKER_01Sort of like when you go to the doctor and there may be something wrong with you and they take a little biopsy of a small part of your body and they cut it out and they look at it. And they're able to tell you remarkable things about your whole body. About systems that may be several feet away from the incision. They're able to tell you things that are going on on all kinds of levels. They're able to tell you things about what may have happened to your dad and what may happen to your kids based on that little incision. I made such an incision.
SPEAKER_01In writing this book. And I wanted to tell a story of that emotion of abandonment in America. What happens when so many people feel unheard and unseen? When Jordan Neely felt and was so unheld by such a giant apparatus intended to help folks like him, in which so many people fear disorder in this era, whether it is real or imagined, but feel it and react to it and vote accordingly. And in which the sense of taking matters into your own hands has become
SPEAKER_01a final thread of our common culture. We don't seem to have that much in common anymore. But that notion of... Let's take matters into our own hands. That has become a kind of common glue. It was present in this case where the right wing glommed on to Daniel Penny as a hero who stepped into the void. But right as this case was wrapping up, the CEO of United Healthcare, Brian Thompson, was assassinated in midtown Manhattan, not far away. A lot of the Courthouse guards and reporters who worked on
SPEAKER_01the Penny case ended up working on the Mangione, Luigi Mangione case not long afterwards. The cases kind of became connected that way. And in the Mangione case, a similar if opposite fandom developed on the far left, valorizing Luigi Mangione for stepping into a void and taking matters into his own hands. When the Penny case was resolved and Daniel Penny was finally acquitted, Jordan Neely's defenders, including an activist named Hawk Newsome,
SPEAKER_01stepped up to the cameras and said, if they're going to have vigilantes, we need our own black vigilantes. We need our own schools. We need our own health care system. So we have to ask ourselves. And one of the aspects of the mirror I'm trying to hold up in this book is, is that where we want to go? Do we want to? And I'm not shaming any of the individual people who are drawn to this idea of taking matters into their own hands. There are so many regular people out there who would never do that themselves, but who sort of are loosely supportive of that notion.
SPEAKER_01And what is more important than shaming people for being loosely supportive of that notion is to ask why they feel that way. In what condition have so many millions of people been left? In what In what kind of experience of democracy have they been steeped that it seems to them the best way to get a good future for you and your family is to take matters into your own hands?
SPEAKER_00There's also the sense beyond the feeling of abandonment that you're talking about of the larger systemic failure. It wasn't as if Jordan Neely was unseen. He was very much, as you write about, on the radar of institutions. And yet even with that, even being part of regular PowerPoints about him, even with that, nothing could be done.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think that is one of the great things about reporting. And I think this is like the most reported kind of street level reporting I have ever done in my career or certainly since I was in my 20s as a foreign correspondent in India and didn't have family, didn't have kids, could ride trains in the middle of the night to interview migrants and that kind of thing. I've really gone back to that kind of shoe leather reporting with this book. And one of the things I found was that contrary to this feeling that
SPEAKER_01so many people do have, this kind of casual sense of, you know, when they see homeless folks in trouble or folks in psychiatric distress in public space or in public transit, people often have a casual sense of, oh, no one's doing anything. The government's not doing anything. There's this kind of basic metaphor that you hear all the time, you know, people slip through the cracks. Jordan Neely slipped through the cracks. And I think one of the things I found in the reporting by being on the ground as much as I was, by spending time in the bowels of these systems,
SPEAKER_01watching these systems work, is that it's not true that no one is doing anything. There is a multi-billion dollar complex trying to help folks like Jordan Neely. And it often is very, you know, staffed by incredibly compassionate, kind people who Who do heroic work trying to build rapport with people in crisis, trying to coax them into shelter, trying to coax them onto medication, coax them into care.
SPEAKER_01The issue is not no one doing anything. The issue, you know, Jordan Neely was, as one public official I spoke to for the book said to me, Jordan Neely was discussed pretty much every week in a PowerPoint presentation by name in the mayor's office in New York. Okay, that is not slipping through the cracks. That is not, you know, I used to be a reporter for the New York Times in Mumbai. There's about 10 million people who live in a home in Mumbai and 10 million people who don't have a home. I can assure you there's no PowerPoint presentations in Mumbai about the other 10 million.
SPEAKER_01I can assure you no one in the government knows any of their names. Right? We are lucky to live in a country, I'm lucky to live in a city where... Jordan Neely was on a list called the Top 50 list of the most precarious, vulnerable New Yorkers who they watch for. And in that PowerPoint presentation once a week or however often it was, people would say, which agency saw him last? Which outreach worker saw him last? What did his weight look like? How was he speaking? What was his affect like? Had he decompensated since last time?
SPEAKER_01So we have to sit with the fact that Jordan Neely still ended up dead on that subway floor. Despite that level of surveillance, care, watchfulness, resources. And what it suggests, Jeff, is a much more challenging, thorny problem than the easy problem of we're not spending money. No one cares. No one's doing anything. What it actually suggests is that this crisis of folks without a home and
SPEAKER_01with mental issues is... is a complex system. Each of these lives is a complex system that is often quite resistant to the blunt tools of these systems and to the fragmented tools of these systems. So you have an issue where cops have physical coercive power. If someone is acting erratically, cops can do something about it.
SPEAKER_01But they're often not physically present where these things are going on. They're not trained mental health practitioners. They don't want to be doing this work. They're not great at it. It's not their thing. Then you've got clinicians and outreach workers and other social workers who are incredibly kind. They know these folks. They have relationships they built over years, but they don't have any coercive power. They're not even allowed to touch people in many cases. So. When they get in a situation and someone really needs care, unless it is an imminent life or death situation,
SPEAKER_01they often don't have the authority or feel they don't have the authority to go anything further than a suggestion. You have hospitals. This is one of the things that I think most struck me in my reporting. Hospitals really, I think, came out as in some ways villains in this story. Certainly in New York, Hospitals that take in folks like Jordan Neely in active distress and, you know, who need real care. Jordan Neely's own family says he should have been held longer. He should have been held even if against his will.
SPEAKER_01He should have been, you know, really helped. And these hospitals basically because someone like Jordan Neely may not have the, you know, obviously doesn't have the health insurance that you might have or I might have. Not a blue chip insurance guy right there. They kick him out. They kick him out after a day once they claim he's stabilized. They would sometimes write in these records, these ER records, you know, we sent him home with instructions to work on his coping skills or identify his social triggers.
SPEAKER_01I mean, this is someone living with full-blown florid schizophrenia, living on the street. And the ER's advice is to work on your social coping skills? So... If you think about it, what I'm describing is a vast complex of people and systems and money. But we talk about erratic people. Well, this is an erratic system. This is an erratic authority. It is often over-present where a lighter touch would do.
SPEAKER_01It is under-present. Where a more concerted touch would do. It is sometimes too interested in physical coercion where a kind of more relational approach would be better. Sometimes it invests too heavily in a relational approach where you actually need some level of coercion. One of the reasons I wrote the book is a lot of what I have just described to you is argued over Behind closed doors,
SPEAKER_01in hospitals, and in the shelter system, and in city governments. These are kind of treated as technocratic questions. And I became convinced as I did this reporting that these are questions that the American people need to debate themselves. You need to know the difficult moral decision over when someone in public space crosses the line from My body, my choice, physical autonomy, they have a right to be there as long as they're not endangering others.
SPEAKER_01When do they cross that line into, no, we have a collective obligation in the name of their dignity and our order to sweep them up and force them into care. Do we as a society want to build the back end of care that that would require? Do we want to bring back a level of institutionalization that was very problematic? In the 50s, 60s, 70s. These are not questions that I think technocrats should be debating behind your back
SPEAKER_01and behind closed doors. These are questions about, frankly, members of our own families. These are questions about health and wellness and what happens to any of us when we fall. And I wanted these questions to be grappled with by the public, not behind the public's back.
SPEAKER_00And finally, with respect to these questions as they relate to somebody like Jordan Neely, but also coming back to where we started this in terms of the state of America today, in three years of reporting this, where, if anywhere, did you find reason for hope?
SPEAKER_01I actually found, and it may not sound like it from the conversation, and that's one of the challenges of this book of actually trying to show people how much brightness... I found, I think actually, although it's a dark subject, it's a bright book because what you're finding on page after page are so many the people I portray who are trying to actually pull us closer to our common humanity, who are thinking about in an age of dehumanization, how do you go the other way?
SPEAKER_01How do you pull us closer to the sense of what it means to be a human being? And this was a story about an alleged act of dehumanization on the subway floor. The Manhattan DA's office, when they prosecuted Penny, alleged that he held Jordan Neely for as long as he did in that chokehold, ultimately resulting in Neely's death, because he dehumanized him. He didn't register him as a fully, fully alive human being like himself, fully fledged human being like himself.
SPEAKER_01And... I decided that I wanted to tell this story by, first of all, me as the author humanizing everyone, which I did. And I've been criticized. People who feel themselves to be sympathetic to Daniel Penny do not like that I humanized Jordan Neely. People who find themselves to be sympathetic to Jordan Neely do not like that I tried to empathize with Daniel Penny. I tried to engage people.
SPEAKER_01In deep reporting to understand what these two men's lives were like. And I found along the way a lot of people who give me hope, the outreach workers who keep doggedly working to save one life at a time. My character, Moses Harper, who was Jordan Neely's close friend and mentor in the Michael Jackson dance community, who goes to schools in the Bronx and elsewhere and educates young people, often gang affiliated young people, young people who are already in high school in the carceral system. And she tries to teach them to save the next Jordan Neely before it gets that way.
SPEAKER_01I wrote about activists who insist on the dignity of homeless people when almost no one else in our society cares. I wrote about public officials who are thinking really hard about this question of the line between dignity and autonomy and how we respect people's freedom to Be where they want to be and who they want to be and make the choices they want to make. And at the same time, make sometimes difficult choices about knowing better for people.
SPEAKER_01I think above all, there's one institution that I read about in the book that is an incredibly hopeful example, which is the institution called Fountain House, which is a mental health clubhouse and folks can look it up. Fountain House is a gorgeous physical space in New York. It's a townhouse in the west side of Manhattan. That for several decades has been engaged in a profound experiment founded by people who themselves were mentally ill and were institutionalized in New York. And as they came out of being institutionalized, they realized they actually wanted to stay in touch with their fellow patients
SPEAKER_01because that is what had helped them heal on the inside. So when they got out, they started what eventually became Fountain House. And it's this mental health clubhouse. People don't sleep there. It's a daytime place where folks with mental illness can go. And it's got, you know, a newspaper that it produces and the members produce a newspaper. It's got a literary magazine. It's got a wellness center. It's got a thrift shop. If you have a job interview, you can go get some clothes for the interview. It's got a wellness center. It's got food. It's got a cafe.
SPEAKER_01And part of what Fountain House, the theory, Which if you're listening to this may sound totally obvious to you and intuitive to you or totally hokey depending on how you look at the world. Fountain House's theory is that if we live in an America in which we think when we think mental illness, we think pills, we think therapy, obviously we think institutionalization, we think hospitals. Fountain House is built in the idea that there's a neglected remedy, which is community.
SPEAKER_01Which is being needed by other people, which is being noticed when you're not there at the 10 a.m. meeting of the Fountain House Times. And so much of the American response to everything, including mental illness, is individualistic. You're sick, take this pill. Well, Fountain House is built on an understanding that is not hard to explain in many other parts of this world, which is that the remedy for things is often community. Community is the therapy.
SPEAKER_01As folks will often say about Fountain House. And I think that, you know, if you're listening to this, you may not have those issues of mental illness in your life. But ask yourself, in those moments of your life when you have had the kind of people around you who noticed when you weren't there in the morning, the kind of people who asked after you, how did it affect your well-being? And so Fountain House, to me, points to It's not a cure-all. Nothing here is a cure-all.
SPEAKER_01But I think it points towards something that is maybe missing from a lot of our discussions about how we not only help We need more of each other and we need more structured ways to find each other. And to go back to the beginning of this conversation, we need ways of being together that are not mediated by social media platforms, that want...
SPEAKER_01Anand Girahardis, his book is Man in the Mirror, Hope, Struggle, and Belonging in an American City. Anand, I thank you so much for spending time
SPEAKER_00with us. Thank you so much for having me. Thank you. And thank you for listening and joining us here on the Who, What, Why podcast. I hope you join us next week for another Who, What, Why podcast. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes. You can also support this podcast and all the work we do by going
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...