Michael Moritz, a former journalist, became one of Silicon Valley’s most successful investors - and a philanthropist who has quietly backed the Booker Prize and San Francisco journalism. Yet he never escaped the terror of his family’s past. On this recent California Sun podcast, the longtime Sequoia Capital leader talks about his new book, “Ausländer,” which traces how his family’s flight from Nazi Germany echoes in the lives of descendants who never lived it. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the California Sun Podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. We think of the past as a place we have left. Time moves in one direction. We tell ourselves that distance is a kind of protection. That enough years, enough miles, enough good fortune stand between us and whatever befell the people who came before. The dead are the dead. And their terrors belong to them. We know better about children. We watch the first five years of life with something close to dread because we've come to understand that what happens to a child
SPEAKER_00before memory has even formed will shape the whole of who that child becomes. The earliest wounds don't heal so much as go underground and surface decades later in a person who cannot say why they flinch. My guest today, Michael Moritz, has written a book that asks what happens when that same law operates not on a child, but on a family. When terror is so complete that it does not stop at the people who live through it, but seeds itself in the ones who come after, and the ones after them,
SPEAKER_00until a grandchild who never saw the country his family fled is carrying a fear he was never taught and cannot name. Moritz calls it inherited despair. It travels, he found, the way the color of an eye travels. It is written in. By any measure the world uses, Michael Moritz won. The boy from Cardiff became a journalist and then one of the most consequential investors of his generation. An early bet on Google, on PayPal, on Yahoo. And steady hands that led Sequoia Capital through the years that built
SPEAKER_00the web we now live inside. He was knighted for it. He has given away much of a vast fortune to students who would otherwise be left behind, to the writers and the prizes he believes in. He arrived, in other words, at exactly the place his grandparents were assured did not exist for people like him. Safe, established, beyond the reach of the thing that took their world. And the argument of his book is that none of it was armor, that the despair he inherited was waiting for him at the top and is waiting now for his sons and that the world he grew up shadowed by,
SPEAKER_00Auslander, foreign, outsider, was never a fact about the past. Michael Moritz joins me today to talk about what history does to people who believe that they have outrun it and the refrain he has carried his whole life and has never once been able to put down, that it happened somewhere. And that it could happen again. Some of our conversations here on the California Sun podcast aren't about just California.
SPEAKER_00So much is about the people who make it what it is. The ones who arrived from somewhere else and built the place the rest of us call home. Michael Moritz is one of them. Classic American dream ascent from a boy in Cardiff to more than 40 years in San Francisco and nearly four decades leading one of California's most significant venture capital firms. Sequoia Capital, one whose imprint touches us all. Knighted in 2013, he is the founder, along with his wife, of the Crankstart Foundation, whose philanthropy now funds the Booker Prize,
SPEAKER_00and underneath it all, a man who still sometimes feels like a stranger in a strange land. It is my pleasure to welcome Michael Moritz here to the California Sun Podcast to talk about his new book, Oslander. Michael, thanks so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_01I'm delighted to be here and found that introduction of yours, Jeff, incredibly sensitive and very moving. Thank you. You are very generous. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you. And thank you for joining us today. Talk about how this story really starts, which is the open drawer that go back to 2019 after your mother's death and the decision to begin to reconstruct your family history.
SPEAKER_01Well, I've never imagined that I would... Writer family history. It took me by surprise, but I think it was triggered by three different things. One of which was that my mother, a few weeks short of her 96th birthday, finally died. She was in good mental health, but the body had given out. And then a few weeks later,
SPEAKER_01a couple of months later, after my sister was clearing out the family house in Wales, my sister sent me, I think, four or five boxes of, you know, U-Haul cardboard boxes that contained papers and documents, a few photograph albums that she had found in the house as she was clearing it out. And then all of this happened at the time that COVID had broken out.
SPEAKER_01And I found, and we all remember this, that certainly people who didn't have children in the house or had some comfortable means and weren't taking care of ailing parents or anything like that, they suddenly had a lot more time on their hands because they weren't commuting, they weren't traveling, and there were more hours in the day. It was those three things. I started digging through these boxes and
SPEAKER_01reading some of the documents. Some of the documents are in German, which I can't read and don't understand written German. And that began this... And talk about, for our listeners, the broad arc of the story, the escape of both your parents from Germany separately and then the story of your grandfather Max.
SPEAKER_01Both my parents were born into Jewish families in Germany in the 1920s. And after Hitler gained power in 1933, both sets of my grandparents understood, wanted to spirit their children to safety.
SPEAKER_01I think both sets, like a lot of other Jews of the time, were hoping that the storm would blow over. But my father arrived as a 14-year-old boy in London in 1937. And had a scholarship. He was a smart guy. And had a scholarship to a school in London.
SPEAKER_01My mother arrived two years later in 1939. She came out on... Something that may or may not be familiar to your listeners, something called the Kindertransport, but for European Jews of a certain vintage is freighted with significance. This so-called children's transport, which occurred by rail, was organized by this extraordinary...
SPEAKER_01A humble and retiring gentleman called Nicholas Winton, who wasn't Jewish but was horrified by what was happening in Europe. And he managed to get about 10,000 children of various ages. Some were very young, some were like my mother in her early teens. He got them to safety in England. So that's how... Both of them got to England. And then you asked about my grandfather, Max.
SPEAKER_01He and his wife eventually were swept up in that horrifying whirlwind and brutality and were exterminated by the Nazis and disappeared, you know, from life and from history. And my maternal grandparents... They got out, believe it or not, they got to England, thinking they were en route to New Zealand, which is where eventually they had managed to get emigration papers to.
SPEAKER_01They got out of Germany 72 hours before World War II broke out.
SPEAKER_00One of the interesting things about your grandfather, Max, is that he thought he was immune in some ways, that he was a judge of some kind, and that he thought he would be okay. That's right.
SPEAKER_01He was raised, he was born in the 1880s. He was raised in a little village in Germany. He was the first child of the family ever to gain higher education. I mean, some of the, you know, most of the universities at that point were closed to Jews. He got a legal training. He then, when World War I broke out, joined the German army.
SPEAKER_01Was one of, I think, 10,000 to 15,000 Jews who served in the German army and fought at You know, the worst battle in the history of humanity, which was Verdun, and somehow survived that bloodbath. And then went back to Munich after the end of the war and became a
SPEAKER_01low-level judge in the Bavarian judiciary. But he was a creature of the state. He had great belief that I think in the state, my assessment of him, obviously I never met him and my father didn't really talk about him, was that here was a conservative man who Who was proud of the fact that he was German, who placed great faith in the state that he was serving,
SPEAKER_01who was eligible for a German pension and Didn't believe that the sort of pogroms that had occurred in Eastern Europe and in Russia during the 19th century could ever occur in a land as cultivated
SPEAKER_01as Germany. And was in denial, I think. But also... I think the state also had its tentacles into him because of the fact that, you know, eventually he was going to be eligible for a pension and all the rest of it. And while he and his wife spirited their sons out of Germany, they left it too late. And there were a couple of letters of his that somehow or other survived pleading
SPEAKER_01to You grew up in Cardiff and Wales. Talk about what that was like. My father was an academic and taught classics for a long time and had found a job at the University of Wales in Cardiff in the early 1950s. He had met my mother previously in Cambridge in England,
SPEAKER_01and they had got married a few years before that, and then moved to Cardiff in the early 1950s, where... They became part of a small Jewish community. There were, I don't know what the population of Wales was back then, maybe two and a half million, something like that. And there are probably about 400 Jewish families in Wales. And so the families in the circle in which they had,
SPEAKER_01you know, they had other friends outside of the circle, but the emotional center of their friendship circle were... Almost all refugees from continental Europe that had connections with the synagogue to which they belonged.
SPEAKER_00What was your interest at the time in understanding that being Jewish was different when you were growing up? I mean, even looking through the phone book for names that were similar.
SPEAKER_01Every child, well, first of all, Britain was a far less multicultural society in the 60s, which was really my sentient age when I was living in Cardiff, than it is today. It was a country that was far more difficult to get around than it is today. I mean, the sort of highways that were built in America in the 50s, they didn't exist in Britain in the 50s and 60s.
SPEAKER_01So it's much more difficult. So Wales was a much more closed community. And I think like every child, every child on the whole, unless they're very unusual, Has this need somehow or other to be like every other child. And though they don't know the word assimilate, that's what they're trying to do. And so I was always very conscious of the fact that I was different from my friends,
SPEAKER_01from my friends at grade school and later at high school. But you made passing reference to Phone directory. And once a year in Cardiff, like in other places, a new phone directory was delivered. And I remember in my early teens, every year, leafing through this phone directory. And the phone directory... Was full of names,
SPEAKER_01pages and pages of last names with people with last names like Jones and Davis and Hughes and Edwards and Lloyd. All of them Welsh last names. And Morris, which is also a Welsh last name, a frequent Welsh, a common Welsh last name. And I'd leave through this telephone directory to the Ems, trying to find our name in the telephone directory,
SPEAKER_01hoping that one year might come where we would be not the only Morris. So to me, the Cardiff and South Wales telephone directory, oddly enough, was a real mark of being different and being Jewish.
SPEAKER_00What sense did your parents have of being different? How did that impact them, particularly your mother, Doris?
SPEAKER_01They, particularly my mother, both my parents were defiantly proud, defiantly and quietly proud of the fact That they were Jewish. And for them, unlike me, the synagogue, I mean, when I was young, it played an important role because I didn't have a choice. But for them throughout their lives, the synagogue, and they were reformed Jews. They weren't conservative or orthodox Jews, played a really important part of their life. But my mother,
SPEAKER_01who had this extraordinary sense of doom being around every corner, One of the aspects, even though she was not afraid of speaking up or speaking her mind or doing those sorts of things, She always wanted to be sure that she didn't get noticed. She never wanted to be the tallest poppy. And I think her fear was being the tallest poppy gets you noticed.
SPEAKER_01Getting you noticed as if you were Jewish would only lead to bad results. And so there was this defiance blended with this desire for anonymity.
SPEAKER_00And this is where you talk about the idea of kind of transmitted dread. Talk about that.
SPEAKER_01I didn't realize any of this at the time, obviously. You know, you're a little kid growing up and... First of all, as I mentioned, you want to be like every other kid, and you're also not aware of the atmosphere in which you grew up. But as I mentioned, my maternal grandparents had managed to get out of... And when my parents and they were together, they always spoke German. And when my grandparents' little circle of friends came around,
SPEAKER_01the conversations were always in German. In German as well. So that there was this great consciousness, obviously, of being different and of being outliers in this country,
SPEAKER_01but more particularly to answer your question. Steve McLaughlin The past for them was always very present, and the echoes of the past were very present. Both the echoes that didn't echo, i.e.
SPEAKER_01the friends and family who'd got annihilated, and then the reminders of what had happened that were present. Always surround them in one way or another. This is a slightly different era, but it also, I think, answers your questions. One of the few things that my father conveyed about this gentleman Max, whom you talked about earlier, my grandfather,
SPEAKER_01who had fought at Verdun, one of the A few things I remember my father telling me about his dad was that he remembered waking up in the night in their small apartment in Munich to the screams of my grandfather, who was having nightmares. About what you'd gone through in World War I. Now, I never remember waking up to screams at all of my parents.
SPEAKER_01But, you know, the experience that they went through and their broader family went through was in every pore of their body. And... I think reflected itself in their great desire for order and their fear of extremism, however it displayed itself and whether it was from the left and the right.
SPEAKER_01More than anything else, they yearned for stability and predictability.
SPEAKER_00As you went through this process, talk a little bit about your own experience, the idea of what you remembered, what you had been told by your parents over the years, and then what you knew to be fact about that period of time, this idea that we all struggle with of memory versus actual fact, reconstructed past. Talk about that process for you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm reading a wonderful book by Nabokov at the moment called Speak Memory that addresses this particular issue. But I think all of this really didn't come into focus for me until I began writing Ausland and then having finished it, reflected on it. And... This investigation of my familial past, the one thing it really... I mean, obviously, I got engrossed with the history story that I was telling. But the one thing it did more than anything else for me, Jeff, was to...
SPEAKER_01It was to help me understand how I became, for better and worse, who I am today. And the imprint, obviously, of my parents and the atmosphere. We all bear this imprint in different ways. Of our formative years and the tussle I think that existed between that my parents fought with about this need to survive, this need to succeed paired with this fear of all the dark things
SPEAKER_01that could possibly pop up from the shadows.
SPEAKER_00And that comes back to this idea we talked about a little while ago of inherited dread, this wound that acts as its own kind of internal engine in so many cases.
SPEAKER_01I think that's right. Look, we were... And I don't want this to come across as self-pitying or anything like that because I've had such a lucky, fortunate life. But there are hundreds of millions, probably billions of people in different parts of the world today who, because of their circumstances, because of their backgrounds and where they've been raised, um, tussled with the same challenge.
SPEAKER_01Um... And obviously, for me, it's highlighted by the millions who got swept up in this in the mid-20th century in Europe. But you go to every continent around the world and there are hundreds of millions of people who are waging the same battle, even if they may not have thought about it as much as I may have.
SPEAKER_00So much of it is also wrapped up, and this brings it a little more contemporaneous, wrapped up in the story of immigrants, the story of immigration. People that come here or come wherever they wind up, but here in In our case, and are driven by whatever that past was, whatever those wounds were, whatever that inherited grief was. And that's a big part of the American story. And it gets left out of so much of this talk about immigration today.
SPEAKER_00You're dead right.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, both of us, you know, living in California, we Probably both subscribe to the enormous benefits that immigrants have brought to the United States. But the mere journey of coming to the U.S., whether you did it through Ellis Island or Whether you're trying to do it today in some fashion is about escaping from one set of circumstances to try and get to
SPEAKER_01a land that offers better opportunities. It's this, first of all, I think, first it's a battle of survival to escape whatever it is, whether it's mild or dire. And then upon landing in America, it's figuring out a path to succeed in America or improve on circumstances.
SPEAKER_01And that's obviously an intense drive in every immigrant. Everybody in America knows today perhaps People from south of the border who they may tend gardens and they may clean houses like some of my family members did when they were able to come to America in the late 1930s.
SPEAKER_01But they have one desire for their kids and that desire is to get them into college or to get them educated, to get them into college, to offer them a better future. It's the same for many people today from Asia and, you know, different parts of Asia. It's the immigrant story in America.
SPEAKER_00And you've talked for years about the way in which immigration was really such a vital part of Silicon Valley. That's right.
SPEAKER_01And it remains a driving force. I think the reason that immigration, you haven't asked this question, but the reason that immigration, look, immigration since the Chinese Exclusion Act, whenever it was at the beginning of the 20th century, end of the 19th century, has been a very heated topic in America. And it always has been, it always will be. I think it's heightened today. When my grandfather was trying to get here, my grandfather Max, he...
SPEAKER_01Even though he was not permitted to enter the U.S., he had to prove that he would not be a burden on the state, that he had means of support or that he had a guardian or somebody else who would take care of his welfare. And I think in that sort of an era, people had an easier time with immigration than they do today, where You know, the common belief is that many, many immigrants will be burdens on the state.
SPEAKER_01And the math doesn't compute where you can't have, you know, 300 million people supporting 100 million people or 50 million or 20, whatever the number is. Who become burdens on the state and aren't taken care for by friends and family. But one of the things I came across when I was writing my book was the anti-immigration sentiment that existed in the 1930s to European Jews.
SPEAKER_01It was enormous. And it was deeply entrenched. And there were some very, very vile things. I think it began obviously with some Americans coming west, but it was also followed by
SPEAKER_01Closely by immigrants from Europe coming to Silicon Valley. And then in the last, probably since 1980 or so, extremely talented people coming from India, China, Europe in particular. And, you know, some from Latin and South America too. And, you know, All of us can rattle off the names of
SPEAKER_01some of these notable people.
SPEAKER_00As you see the attitude towards immigration today and its historical context, in many ways it makes you think that your mother's attitude was vindicated or continues to be vindicated by history.
SPEAKER_01Well, yes,
SPEAKER_00I suppose.
SPEAKER_01But there's The math doesn't work. If the Southern Hemisphere wants to move into the North Hemisphere, it doesn't work, which is why you have the rise of the right-wing anti-immigration parties in Italy and in Germany and France and Spain and the United Kingdom, just as you have here. But if you're a member of a community, That wants to gain access to a better circumstance,
SPEAKER_01then yes, everything seems closed off to you. I mean, in the 1930s, and this is the atmosphere in which my parents grew up, there were two sorts of countries. Or there appeared, if you were Jewish, to be two sorts of countries. Yeah. One were the countries under Nazi occupation, German rule, that wanted to get rid of the Jews, and the rest were the countries who didn't want to receive the Jews.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, that's true for different communities of, you know, different races and religions in different parts of the world today. Yes, it's... I have a friend of mine recently turned 100. He's American, was born in America, grew up in New York state or upstate New York. And he thought, I remember I had a conversation with him a few months ago and he said he thought anti-Semitism was a thing of his youth.
SPEAKER_01You know, what he'd seen as a kid. All the colleges that he wasn't allowed access to because he happened to be Jewish. And here it is 100 years later. He thought this had been banished to the past. And here it is sprung up again. But again, I want to be careful. I don't want to come across as whining or complaining here. I think anti-Semitism is a condition of humanity. I think it's been around for 2,500 years.
SPEAKER_01It's gone through very dark and vicious periods in different centuries. And I don't think anything will change. And why am I not complaining about it? Partly because I sort of proudly identify as being a member of this Jewish community because I think it's part of all of this, part of the need to survive, part of the need to fight has made me who I am.
SPEAKER_00And talk about it as it impacts your children, your sons, and how they see this and what they learn from reading your book, from your story, which they may not have known the entirety of.
SPEAKER_01So Harriet, my wife, and I, both of us are Jewish, but we have a very non-religious household. So both of our sons are aware of the fact that they were Jewish, but neither of them had bar mitzvahs, and we haven't belonged to a synagogue here in San Francisco. And both of them knew my parents as young boys, but I think they still remember them or aspects of it.
SPEAKER_01And I think, you know, and they've heard enough from me about my parents over the years that they understand where they came from. They understand part of their being. And I've said to them repeatedly over the last several years, you know, that I really hope, but I fear that this isn't the case, that I really hope that the Darker aspects of my personality that I think are
SPEAKER_01a result of the way in which I grew up and my various fears haven't rubbed off on them and that I didn't unwittingly transmit some of these emotions to them. But obviously I suspect and fear that I have. Both of them have read the book. They're both in their late 30s. I think the book will be much more meaningful for them 30 years from now.
SPEAKER_00And this idea of inherited dread, how have they processed that?
SPEAKER_01I think they're much more upbeat and optimistic than me, which is great and wonderful. And I think the way a lot of people deal with it as well is to have a really good sense of humor because it's a deflective shield.
SPEAKER_00That's why we have so many Jewish comedians, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think it's a big part of the reason. Absolutely. Absolutely. You laugh your way out of despair.
SPEAKER_00Michael Moritz, his book is Auslander. Michael, I thank you so very much for spending time with us today.
SPEAKER_01You are more than generous to have been patient enough with me. Thank you, Jeff. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00And thank you for listening and joining us here on the California Sun Podcast. I hope you'll join us next week. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...