Climate researcher and SOLARCYCLE co-founder Pablo Dias discusses why collective action is better than individual guilt in addressing environmental challenges. From China's renewable energy surge to the dangers of "doomism," Dias argues technology and markets are already delivering progress - but only if we move beyond lifestyle policing. The future isn't written, but are we reading the present correctly? Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the program. I'm Jeff Schechtman. There's a genre of conversation about climate that's become so predictable, it's almost scripted. Alarm, urgency, sacrifice. The planet's burning, time's running out, and if you're not panicking, you're not paying attention. But then there's the other conversation, quieter, less theatrical, but possibly more important. The one that asks, what if human beings are actually pretty good at solving problems when the incentives align? My guest, Pablo Diaz.
SPEAKER_00lives in both worlds. He's a climate researcher, an environmental engineer, a professor who's taught sustainability at four universities. He's also the co-founder of SolarCycle, a company trying to solve the problem most people don't know exists, what to do with dead solar panels. And he's just written a book entitled Climate Changed, a book that tries to cut through the noise and explain what actually matters. His book arrives at an inconvenient moment for the narrative.
SPEAKER_00In 2025, renewable energy surpassed coal globally for the first time. Not in Scandinavia, not in California, but in China and India. Countries building clean energy at scale not because they're being told to, but because wind and solar got cheap enough to make economic sense. Diaz argues against what he calls doomism. The idea that the problem is so big we might as well give up. But there's still another trap. A public that's heard the alarm so many times they've learned
to tune out.
SPEAKER_00Survey after survey shows climate change ranks low on voter concerns. People aren't going to stop driving. They're not giving up meat. And every time someone tries to tell them they should, So what's the actual story here? Is it that we're failing to act or that we're acting in ways that don't fit the script? The technology is solving problems faster than regulation ever could. That the conversation has become so captured by absolutism and lifestyle policing
that it's lost the very people it needs to persuade Diaz says that the future isn't written yet but maybe the more interesting question is whether we're even reading the present correctly It is my pleasure to welcome Pablo Diaz here to talk about
SPEAKER_00climate change Pablo, thanks so much for joining us Hi Jeff, thank you for having me. I'm excited. Well, it is a delight to have you here. One of the first things that you talk about in your book is kind of how we got here. And to really understand the environmental problems we face and what has transpired, it's important to go back even to the Industrial Revolution and see how concerns first materialized about environmental issues. Talk about that first.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's important, you know, for us to take a few steps back and really look at the big picture and like how things are evolving, right? So we start at the, we open up talking about like how the humans always had an impact on the environment, right? But it was at the The 18th century when we had the revolution, the industrial revolution in the Great Britain that we started seeing a 50-fold impact in what we used to be able to do before, right? We just took the rails, if you will, of nature and were able to bend nature to our will which is
unprecedented in
SPEAKER_01history before. And then a century later is where this spreads out and we start seeing the first signs of damage in there. And only on the 20th century we sound alarm bells and start doing small steps towards what we needed. 21st century has arrived and this is the time for us to take meaningful action. So taking a lot of this broad perspective on history helps us understand how things have flowed and why this is something that we're worried about now but weren't necessarily worried about a few centuries ago.
SPEAKER_00When we talk about the 20th century, it does seem like something changed around the time of the late 1960s, the early 1970s, the beginning of Earth Day, which happened in 1970, that the consciousness about it, the awareness changed.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I totally agree with that. And in my opinion, their big role there is the collective rights groups organizing and being able to not only push this as a agenda that needs to be discussed and thought about, But also a lot of data from scientists that do the work every day, putting one brick after the other to be able to back up claims. So it's collecting data that can point to, like, these are facts, these are not, you know, opinions. And then collective groups, environmental groups,
SPEAKER_01and even policy, you know, that then follows those steps of those data points.
SPEAKER_00One of the things that happened during that period is really, it seems like, a shifting of focus where there were a whole bunch of environmental issues and things that were of concern to people, and little by little the focus got narrower and narrower around the subject of climate change. Yeah, I think that's a great point you made, Jeff, because we did have examples, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, you know, the acid rain and those kinds of pollutants and the ozone layer that were, you know, one of many subjects within the environmental discussion. And they were tackled with policy and with, you know, basically human beings getting together. And they show a history of collective action that has big effects on solving the issues. And then the climate change situation became the centerpiece for,
I think, a few reasons.
SPEAKER_01One is, there's a big pushback from people that have a lot of interest on keeping the status quo right, as we know, the energy matrix of the world. Jeff Schechtman how can we keep the status quo and not have to change this one thing around climate change so I think that's the one piece of the environment
movement that gets conflated between vested interests and environmental impact and if you look back
SPEAKER_01One of the things that was done on purpose, right, as the IPCC, the International Governmental Panel on Climate Change is created, and as the states start to get together to speak about this and discuss this, is they deliberately change the name from global warming to climate change in an attempt to soften the language used for this problem specifically. Did we lose sight of other environmental issues, important environmental issues, by doing that?
SPEAKER_00I think we did, Jeff.
SPEAKER_01This is my personal opinion. But if I look back at the reason why I started writing the book and the questions that I got from Jeff Schechtman jeffschechtman Talk Cocktail Podcast We've had, you know, the Clean Air Act in the US and we've had a lot of good stories,
SPEAKER_01success stories in other countries. China's probably the poster child right now, given how fast they were able to move away from air pollution. Air pollution is one thing that is somewhat diagonal to climate change because in regions in which you have more rainfall due to the changes in climate, due to the warming of the average temperature of the globe, you're actually going to have less air pollution. So in a way, the more climate change, the better for those regions. Obviously, other regions, you're going to have less rainfall and therefore air pollution is going to be
SPEAKER_01worse. But they are independent things. They have effects to each other, but they're independent. We can completely solve climate change, completely solve the warming of the globe, and we might still have air pollution problems. We might still have eutrophication problems, which is basically when we overfeed our water systems by giving too many nutrients that are basically dispersed from our agriculture.
SPEAKER_00One of the things we've seen, you mentioned China a moment ago and what they've accomplished in terms of air pollution, but we've also seen it here in the US. Los Angeles is kind of the poster child in that regard, a city that in the 70s was choking as bad as China was for many years and managed to clean that up. Absolutely. And I think it's extremely important for us to look at these success cases, right?
SPEAKER_01Because these success cases are basically... Jeff Schechtman Jeff Schechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman Hechtman
SPEAKER_01is one of those things we can show like, hey, look at how it was, look at how we tackle this scientifically and with data and look at what the result is. We can do the same with basically all the current problems we have. And honestly, we're doing a lot already. And I think that's often missed in the public discourse because this idea of the problem is too big and therefore there's nothing we can do about it is actually counterproductive to solving the problems. It's actually a tactic, may I say, employed by those that don't want Jeff Schechtman
SPEAKER_00Jeff Schechtman
Collective action is something that happens slowly and builds momentum and then
SPEAKER_01there's a tipping point, if you will. And so there's not that instantaneous feedback of like, what I'm doing is I can see the result right now. And often as human beings that we are, we want to see results right away. So I think that there's a bit of the psychology around that idea of there's a delayed gratification, if you will, of putting the effort now to be able to see the results later.
SPEAKER_00You know,
SPEAKER_01This is, it's not real, it's not there. And then the second one is, you know, it's real, but don't worry about it, it's not that big of a deal. Even if it's there, it's not going to do anything. Those two things kind of fell after, you know, decades of data piling up against those arguments. And now there's new tactics. And the new tactics are basically deflection and doomism, right? And deflection is basically saying, you know, It's not the collected things that are going to change. What really needs to change are our individual habits, right? So the issue is not that we have this whole system set up to
produce and release
SPEAKER_01fossil fuels and CO2 into the environment, but rather it is because you are choosing to drive your car to work and you're using gasoline because you made that choice. You're polluting the planet. It's not because, you know, we have all these different systems in place for us, the way we produce electricity, but it's rather because you chose to eat meat on a Monday when you should be eating, you know, a vegetarian diet. And that's the tactic of deflection. And dumism is the one that we talked about already, which is basically, you know, yeah, this is all true,
SPEAKER_01but it's so hard, it's so big that, you know, individuals can't do anything about it, so you're better off not thinking about this or just ignoring it. One of the things that we see over and over again is the way in which some success
SPEAKER_00breeds more success that when people see that results are possible, it has a positive effect.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yes. I think that's true in many, many different facets of this issue that we're talking about. I think one example of this is that of climate litigation, which is something that I honestly learned about as I was writing the book. Climate litigation basically is when people, citizens get together to sue the government by saying, you are not doing enough to protect us as citizens from all this damage that we're doing to the environment. And once a few of those cases were successful in different countries, That, you know, prompted other countries and other groups to take action.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, it's a good example of what you're saying. You know, you see people didn't know this was possible until the first case was won. And then, you know, all of a sudden you start getting other examples of that happening in the globe.
SPEAKER_00Talk a little bit about technology, the importance of technology and the way it is often looked at as not part of a collective action sometimes, but as a single panacea.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's a great question, a great topic. One of the key books, actually the book, Bill Gates' book, How to Avoid a Climate Disaster, came out as I was, you know, halfway through my book. And when his book came out, I was like, I read it and I thought this was really good. And I might not even write mine anymore because I think this is, you know, hitting the same things that I wanted to hit. Until, you know, I finished it and like, oh no, he's over-relying on technology. He's Jeff Schecht
But it is extremely dangerous for us to rely on a solution that does not exist yet.
SPEAKER_01And I'm speaking as a technologist myself, as somebody who's been for decades doing research and developing technology and currently is, The leader of a technology company. So I do think it is extremely important for us to invest in technology, but it's also extremely important for us to not over rely on technology. And there are some dangerous ideas out there that can't really be tested in a lab before we do Jeff Schechtman jeffschechtman
SPEAKER_01Jeff Schechtman jeffschechtman You know, all the way to material production of green steel. Jeff Schechtman
SPEAKER_01I think both things need to go hand in hand. Talk about the way they need it.
SPEAKER_00You can't do lifestyle policing unless you give people some hope, give people a sense that if they do their part, technology will do its part, and it is this collective effort ultimately that will lead to success, but it can't be one without the other.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I absolutely agree. Let's talk about two examples to be extremely practical and pragmatic about the answering your question one is you know let's say we want people to drive less and to either use more public transport or to use bikes more unless there are policies in place and there's an infrastructure that allows people to do so it's going to be basically you know uphill battle because and I've lived in many different places and I lived in places in which you know it's extremely safe to
ride a bike and it's extremely convenient to ride a bike and I used to ride to work every day and it was
SPEAKER_01you know a Best part of my day. And I also lived in countries and in cities in which you basically don't have an infrastructure for bike. It's extremely dangerous. You don't want to drive at night because there's a risk of being, you know, assaulted or mugged or something like that. And so that's a great example of, you know, you want individuals to do the right things, but you need to put the conditions in the environment so that more people choose that, not just the people that are extremely, you know, engaged and worried, but also the people that, you know, might be on the fence or might not be thinking about that subject. And they just use a bike or they use public transportation
because it's more
SPEAKER_01convenient to do so. So I think that's one example of how these things go hand in hand. Another good example is, I just mentioned green cement and green steel, which are basically ways to produce these extremely important materials that we need to be able to, you know, support a world with 11 billion people, which is where we're heading according to the United Nations. And we need to, you know, provide housing, we need to provide infrastructure for them to live comfortably. But producing cement and producing steel are extremely energy consumption, but there's a lot of energy consumption associated with it,
SPEAKER_01but there's also the emission of CO2 inherent to the process. And so One way to do this is you just say, let the technology develop itself and we're just going to expect companies to pay a premium to be able to purchase that kind of material. Another way to do it is governments say, if you produce this material, we're going to buy it for this amount and we're going to be able to buy this minimum quantity of it. Because governments are a big buyer. It's not an individual buying for a house for their own
personal property.
SPEAKER_01This is major infrastructure. And that gives a very powerful signal to the market and to innovators that, okay, it's worth my time investing this technology and accelerating the development of this technology because there's a carrot at the end that is basically guaranteed by my government. So that's another example, Jeff, of policy going hand in hand with individual action, individual collections.
SPEAKER_00Why do you think that voter concern about climate issues is so low?
SPEAKER_01That is a question that I'm not an expert to answer, so I'll give you my personal opinion and I'll try to relate that back to the book. I think it's important to call that out as a scientist. The political debate recently has been extremely polarized and it is something that You know we're in a very tough political position not just in the US right globally you know I'm Brazilian Brazil the situation is pretty similar to the US as far as the polarization on the politics and for whatever reason
climate change in the
SPEAKER_01environment is a topic that was It's now considered that of a certain political camp. And the polarization basically means that people that are not aligned with that camp are not aligned with environmental issues in general, which is a shame because obviously the environment is an issue for all of us and it doesn't really matter which side of the aisle you stand. It's something that needs to be tackled collectively. But to bring it back to one of the things that we talk about in the book, there's this human propensity,
SPEAKER_01psychologically speaking, to Not want to have, you know, to want to have the gratification instantaneously and not to want to delay that gratification. And climate change kind of falls into perfect limbo of everything that we don't want to think about. It's, you know, it's a gradual thing. It is a tough subject to be able to address with human beings in general.
And as you point out in the book, some of the doomism that surrounds it is not helpful.
SPEAKER_00No, absolutely not. Yeah. Talk about that.
SPEAKER_01I think, you know, it's... So the book basically breaks down the solutions, right? The book is split in three parts. We've talked about the beginning. It's like, you know, how this environmental movement came to be. What are the big broad stroke history facts that are important for us to understand? Then we talk about the problems and we deep dive into... Jeff Schechtman
Don't worry about doing anything because it's not going to change anything.
SPEAKER_01You're not powerful enough. Your voice doesn't matter that much. What you do is not going to make a dent. And the book basically says that if you just focus on the little steps, that is basically playing into this doomism because you're going to be trying your best at doing everything you can individually, saving as much water as you possibly can, saving as much energy, Riding your bike, never using your car, never eating anything that has a bigger footprint.
SPEAKER_01And those things are good, but they're not going to solve the problem. Basically, if we all stop driving our cars today, if we all stop flying, if we all became vegetarians, we still have a problem to be solved. Because the individual actions, they matter, but they're not enough to solve the problem. And that plays right into doomism, because if you stay in this loop forever, you're basically going to be stressing yourself out, you're going to be living with guilt because you're never doing enough, and you're going to be living probably a life that's going to be unsustainable for you. And really what we need are the big steps,
which are those of collective action.
SPEAKER_01That is, you know, first, understanding the problems, learning more about it, to joining movements that are already in play and already have momentum, supporting them with your time, effort or money, depending on your life situation, creating these movements yourselves, voting for policies that are or for politicians that are pushing policies that are favorable. And then obviously teaching others and educating others about, you know, the things that we're discussing here today, Jeff. And so if you just stay in the little steps, you're going to play into this doomism narrative.
SPEAKER_01The first part is the learning part. And the learning part is really understanding we're actually doing pretty well. Like we're not as we're marching towards our objective. There's a lot of good things happening in the world. We need to be And we're going to execute on them.
One of the things about doomism also is that it leads to a sense of dismissiveness
SPEAKER_00eventually, which is totally counterproductive. Absolutely, yeah. And that plays once again with this idea of you're responsible for doing all the
SPEAKER_01actions that are required. And even if you do everything right, you're not going to be enough. And, you know, that leads to apathy. Like I, you know, I've been there. That's, you know, one of the seeds of this book is me trying to do my best. And at some point I got confronted with teaching the subject. And when you need to teach it, you need to, you know, hopefully study a lot and back it up with data. And as I dug into the data, it's like, wait, this doesn't really match like the lifestyle that I've been proposing to myself. Or you know the solutions and the final results that I'm
aspiring to and that was really transformative for me and that's why this book came to be it's so that I can show the data to other people and I can show this different view of not only the issues but the solutions to other people so that they can live sustainably and they can aspire to a future that we are all living sustainably and you don't have to sacrifice your life for that it's actually much more achievable than a lot of
SPEAKER_01people think
SPEAKER_00And talk about your efforts with SolarCycle and what you're doing.
SPEAKER_01Sure, absolutely. So one of the key things that we need to tackle climate change is to achieve net zero, which is this idea that we are going to produce some CO2 with some processes because we're not going to be able to make everything neutral, but the things that we do produce, the CO2 that we do produce, we can capture. And to achieve net zero, one of the key things that are required is the energy transition, going from a fossil fuel economy that produces electricity through fossil fuels, i.e.
thermal plants and plants based on coal, oil, gas, to that economy that uses renewable energy.
SPEAKER_01And the pulsar charge for renewable energy is basically wind and solar. Unfortunately, all good things need to come to an end, and that's also true for solar panels. And solar panels, they last between, call it 15 and 25 years. And when they do come to an end, there's two options. They can go to a landfill and basically, you know, stay there basically forever. There's no plan B after a landfill. Or we can recycle them and we can flip those resources back into play. And SolarCycle does the latter, but it does the latter with the objective of really creating the circular economy
SPEAKER_01that we aspire to do, which means we're not needing to extract additional resources from Mother Earth. We're just using the resources to be already extracted and doing so in a way that enables the energy transition to occur. Solar panels are unique in the sense that they have been getting better and better over time. So we're getting more and more power with less material or less mass, if you will. And so what we can do through the efforts of SolarCycle and so many others is take these materials from solar panels to create a new wave of solar panels that we need
SPEAKER_01to be able to achieve the energy transition. And talk about the fact that so much of what we have heard lately about things that
SPEAKER_00are recycled turn out to be not very constructive, that a lot of things that we think are recycled really, really aren't or are to a very small percentage.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's a great question, Jeff, and it touched on something that is very relevant in this whole discussion. If you look at recycling, depending on the material you're talking about, it's going to be either amazing or not that good. And basically to make it really simple, if you look at plastics or polymers, you can only recycle so much. There's a limit to it. You degrade it over time. And so it's the idea you just talked about.
SPEAKER_01It's not as good as some people. I think it's not a panacea in any sense. On the other hand, if you look at metals, metals are basically infinitely recyclable. When you take a metal, aluminum, gold, silver, pick your metal. And you extract it from an end of life product and you put it back into a new product, it performs exactly the same way. The only loss that you have is the loss that you're going to have in any process because it's not perfect to recover 100% of a given material. So you can use them infinitely, right? As long as you're keeping them outside of landfill,
SPEAKER_01you can use them infinitely back into the supply chain, back into any industry that you want. I know this is not the area you're in but talk about it as it relates to batteries for example
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think the situation with batteries is similar too. We've seen tremendous progress in how efficient they are and being able to power more with metal-glass material. We've seen tremendous progress in the cost of batteries over time. And there's been tremendous progress on recycling too. So the story is quite similar there because the most valuable things in batteries are the metals. And we can talk here about lithium, we can talk about cobalt, nickel, which are things that are recyclable, infinitely recyclable as far as properties go.
And it's also something that there's a big industry that was already in place when solar cycles started to be able to take these batteries and try to make new
SPEAKER_01batteries with it. So I think And again, this is just another example of what we talked about, Jeff. There's a lot of progress happening. There's a lot of good things. We're moving in the right direction. On the broad spectrum of things, we're moving in the right direction. Sometimes we're not moving fast enough, but we're moving in the right direction.
SPEAKER_00Pablo Diaz, his book is Climate Changed. Pablo, I thank you so much for spending time with us. This was a great talk. Thanks, Jeff, for having me. Thank you.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...