Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talk Cocktail

Talk Cocktail artwork

Before the Trillions, There Was Once Joy in Silicon Valley

Jul 11, 202640 minAudio

A veteran of three tech eras on how the innocence was lost - and whether AI actually might win it back, through what he calls “enlightened AI.” Recently, on WhoWhatWhy podcast, Matthew Stepka - early internet-café founder, McKinsey alum, nine-year Google veteran who shepherded many of the company’s mission projects including the first self-driving cars, and now an investor in what he calls “enlightened AI” - walks us back through the Valley’s reinventions and asks what each one cost. Before the trillion-dollar IPOs, before the data centers and the doom, before “Silicon Valley” became shorthand for unaccountable power and unimaginable wealth, there was a teenager with an Atari - a gift from his NASA-engineer father - certain he could build any world he could imagine. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_02welcome to the who what why podcast i'm your host jeff schechtman silicon valley has always needed a story not a product not a business model a story something that lets brilliant ambitious fundamentally decent people pour their lives into a profit machine and still feel like they're on the side of the angels information wants to be free we're connecting the world move fast and break things and the most famous of all the one that's curdled so completely it now lands as

SPEAKER_02a kind of punchline don't be evil my guest today was for nine years he was inside google in the era when that motto was still spoken without irony when the company genuinely believed and persuaded much of the world to believe that it could do well by doing good. He ran the mission projects bringing the internet to remote parts of Africa, investing in clean energy, the early work in robotics and self -driving cars. He had a front row seat in other words as one of the most powerful companies

SPEAKER_02hold on to its own conscience but his story starts well before that and it's really a story about the whole arc of this thing we're living through he was writing video games at 17 good enough that a software company tried to hire him straight out of high school back when simply getting online was itself the product he has

SPEAKER_02in other words been present for every reinvention that silicon valley has staged the dot-com frontier the long consolidation when the internet stopped being a frontier and became plumbing and now the moment we're all standing inside of trying to understand And it is that arc That we want to talk about today Because there's a thread running through all of that That is genuinely fascinating Every era of this industry Seems to require A new moral premise A new way of explaining

SPEAKER_02To itself Why its building Is not just lucrative But good The technology changes completely Dial up To search To artificial intelligence But that need That hunger For moral permission Seems to be the one constant which brings us to where my guest sits now he is an investor in artificial intelligence and the animating idea of his work is something he calls enlightened ai technology meant in his words to amplify our humanity a remarkable place to arrive at this particular moment because

SPEAKER_02at a time when so much of the culture has decided that ai might be the great threat of our age he is someone making the opposite case an optimist arriving at something like ai altruism and arriving at it of all what we're looking for is something more interesting the journey what it means

SPEAKER_02that silicon valley keeps needing to tell itself a new story every time it remakes the world what 40 years on the inside teaches you about which of those stories were real and whether the one we're being told right now is something genuinely new or something very old in new clothes it is my pleasure to welcome matthew stepka here to the who what why podcast matthew thanks so much for joining us it's great to be here well it is a delight to have you here i want to go back in your life

SPEAKER_02a little bit you were 17 years old and you were writing video games good enough for silicon valley at the time talk a little bit about what that world was like then what you saw in that world at that time well it's interesting i mean at

SPEAKER_01that time my dad was an aerospace engineer at nasa i wanted to be an artist before that and i still like to dabble but he gave me a computer an atari computer and i just i found my best friend for a while i was totally immersed in that world and the thing about it which gave me the most of anything else was gave me a sense of agency like i could create anything any world i want if i could imagine it i can make it happen and that that stuff for a teenager that felt all powerful that felt so wonderful and it felt so boundless

SPEAKER_01and i love video games i love playing them i love making them even more because you can decide how you want to how you want to go and where it would go and that and that did feel like a real opportunity and i think that's still technology kind of has that kernel

SPEAKER_02in it i hope what did computers mean then what did you see them as besides this this possibility into another world yeah it was interesting i mean

SPEAKER_01to some degree they weren't connected with each other that much uh at all so it really wasn't a way of connecting with other people directly although i was part of these enthusiast clubs and so forth so actually we did we did connect indirectly i started the computer club in my high school and uh ironically that was a great way to kind of you know socialize with people who are also equally as nerdy as i was at the time so there was a bit of that uh sense of belonging in that group and that kind of a club but i think for a large degree it was a thing

SPEAKER_01that you just felt you could you could solve almost any problem you almost felt like there was a chance that we could do anything and you know around that time war games came out and just then we started thinking about how could this all go badly as well i remember that movie was really interesting because 1984 is when i graduated from high school and so it was when i really started realizing wow it's kind of a double-edged sword of something obviously very powerful but also very scary a little

SPEAKER_02while later you co-founded these cyber cafes the cyber java talk a little bit about that this is the early internet cafes

SPEAKER_01yeah this is in the mid 90s uh i was living in los angeles uh at a sailboat and some of my friends from college engineers as well were hanging out with me and we uh we loved going to cafes and we started playing around with the internet a little bit and uh we thought it would be great to mix them together and so my friend he uh he bankrolled it and we all got together we basically started serving coffee and and internet and it was quite fun it was quite an interesting time because like you said people couldn't even find a way to get on they kept hearing

SPEAKER_01about it in the news and it became this thing that everyone wanted to get hold of and get to touch it and feel it and news organizations wanted to report out they couldn't they didn't know where to go they even look at it how do you see the internet as they would come to our cafe just uh at the backdrop to talk about about the internet and it became an interesting thing i ended up teaching a lot of classes there um we had a little classroom on top i would teaching class about how to get online how to start a business uh but we do joke it's the most ridiculous thing we did was start an internet cafe we should have started anything else but an internet cafe in terms

SPEAKER_01of making a lot more money but that

SPEAKER_02i guess we just did what we loved but there was a sense that the product was the access itself that that was what you were selling yeah and

SPEAKER_01then coffee too i'd be enough but we but we and we sold both um and uh it but it was interesting it was also people wanted to know they didn't help there is someone to hold their hand and they were afraid of it they're afraid to break something or do something wrong and uh because technology for a lot of people is very scary and and this was a very friendly environment and we had like the music in the background and kind of a cool environment it kind of demystified it and made it feel a little bit more friendly uh we did some events around uh you know just celebrating

SPEAKER_01you know just connecting between people we even had an early version of uh they call see you see me camera which was these round cameras they let people connect with each other and they were kind of a bad technology black and white really played low res but people started using them this is you know early 90s or mid 90s and they started like talking to each other and when we had a party and all people could come together and talk to each other at the same time it was extremely dorky and weird but it was kind of an early version of what we do now with we don't think twice about zooming or or all that kind

SPEAKER_01of stuff

SPEAKER_02When you look back at that time, and you just touched on it a moment ago in terms of what you were offering people at the cafe, the technology that the internet was all kind of scary at the time. People didn't know what to make of it. They didn't know where it was going. And it had a little frightening quality about it. and so much of what we're dealing with today jumping way forward is also to a lot of people very scary that that one consistent thing seems to still be there and in fact maybe it's gotten worse as technology has advanced

SPEAKER_01without question it's gotten worse i think it's gotten worse in two ways one uh if you don't understand how to use it you feel at a disadvantage and that lack of knowledge that understanding it just it sounds very scary and even people are more tactical there's different levels of being technically astute and and it's hard to know and to know when you know what's going on what's really happening and that that's one kind of theory the other thing is it's got more powerful and more ubiquitous it's this bigger part of our lives now and so the idea of you're kind of giving up so much control to technology especially

SPEAKER_01when you don't understand how it's working seems very scary and then you label it layer on top of that how powerful it is and it's much more powerful than ever has been before just ensure every number is more powerful but just obviously its capabilities are just uh are just mind-boggling now and i think that is you know something which makes it even more i think rightly so people i understand why people are anxious it's you're dealing with a very powerful thing in your room in your life surrounded with you all the time and uh there could be people behind it that are not good uh

SPEAKER_01or itself it could do things unintentionally that you don't mean um all these reasons are reasons to be i think anxious how did you wind up at google um it's funny i kind of tried to avoid it for a while but my thinking was uh i was at mckinsey and i went to a couple startups uh after that and i was i was enjoying what i was doing and i kind of thought oh search must be dead it's like it's so it's still just an old idea and i clearly had and still does have a long path ahead of it apparently so i was completely wrong on that but eventually a friend said you

SPEAKER_01wish he'd come uh just left my last startup that was doing okay but I thought I want to do something different. I'm going to come back to the bay area and he encouraged me to come and that was a big difference and I really did uh I went there at a time where they kind of hit the inflection point becoming a bigger company um they're around 10,000 employees at that time and they were public already as well but and so they were well known but people didn't understand their business model yet they were kind of just there's so much buoyancy people felt very good about google um and you know and they

SPEAKER_01and they really i think as you mentioned earlier in the introduction they actually people really did believe in the the ideas behind it and the founders were very actually involved um and and as well as the ceo

SPEAKER_02was it your sense that the leadership of the company that the founders and other leaders really did believe that or they convinced themselves of that for whatever reason

SPEAKER_01well i can't uh say i can peer too deep into their hearts but uh but i did work with them enough that to say i i mean i definitely believe that they believe it and they um they really wanted to do this uh this this is what they want they wanted to build a company that was um in that benefit for the world and they were willing to you know bet it all over and over again to make that happen they were just uh they're very committed to it i mean i ended up being doing all this work in the company which was extraordinarily mission driven and so it's very easy from my perspective

SPEAKER_01to see how that was true um but the company was always making a lot of money but it could have been made a lot more money had they been more near-term focused or a little bit less uh more cutthroat in some ways but they did intentionally make it kind of a balanced environment in terms of this marketplace they created for advertisers and all that kind of thing and they always had to think about being focused first on the users and protecting that trust and i think they you know they they really felt that and then that feeling would come down to all the engineers that worked there i felt there was

SPEAKER_01a good amount of people buying into that um that idea i mean a good example is idea of church and state between organic search results and the paid search results they were very you know uh very sincere about that and there are a lot of people who would stand up and would make a point if something felt was violating that trust I can't speak about it as much as now today and I think things are a little more complicated now but I do think it definitely was that way at the time I remember there was a project

SPEAKER_02and you'll probably know what it is I can't remember the name of it but there was a government project that Google was asked to do that the employees just revolted against and prevented the company from doing it

SPEAKER_01yeah this is the project maven um this was a government government project to help use ai that the that the tech companies had to help drones at least identify what they're looking at it was not meant to be used for targeting per se um of course that line is pretty blurry um and then as i understand it uh about a few thousand engineers found out about it and they signed a petition to the ceo at the time of sundar and they asked him to cancel the project

SPEAKER_01a lot of this unfolded online in the public eye because eventually it was leaked out and they try to respond in the way that best they could to deal with it. It's an interesting question I think the company culture has always been that you have the right to bring up any issue you want internally but there also is a company culture of secrecy which is you don't air our dirty laundry outside and so that was

SPEAKER_01that last part was obviously violated by the disclosure but i think it became harder and harder to kind of let that be true i mean i i personally believe in whistleblowers having a very important role and i think it's uh sometimes uh people are held to a higher standard and higher calling in terms of what they do not just what uh you know what the company wants them to do for that case so i do think it's harder that's an example of you know what is the nature of uh of what a company should be doing it's

SPEAKER_01an american company it should not be helping the american military and at that time it was definitely becoming more true that the military capabilities were being outstripped by commercial ones and this is true today on the battlefields of Ukraine in a place you're finding out that frankly really cheap technology that's commercially available is starting to beat very expensive technology that the government is building and that is a problem for governments to deal with that's a longer discussion on that one

SPEAKER_02you've been involved in a lot of companies you were at McKinsey as you mentioned you were involved in a lot of startups and certainly you've been around the valley and for a long time and all these companies talk a little bit about the culture of these companies what you have seen that is consistent in their culture and and even in some cases unique in the culture

SPEAKER_01of some companies well I do think McKinsey and Google had one thing in common at least when I was there they were very values driven they're both places that literally everybody in company would know the mission statement and would also bring it up as a an argument for doing something or not doing something and they so they really believed in it and they felt it was both a shield and a sword to get things to keep ourselves consistent with that culture um i know for sure that's not true in both those organizations quite as strongly

SPEAKER_01as it was um people you know may not feel as strongly as they can you know bring up those those ideas and and uh i guess uh object to other decisions because there's a senior management might do um and uh so it can only last for a while i think that kind of especially if the founders are not actually involved to keep it alive i think it's hard to do there's so many other shareholder pressures that will come up i think over time um some of the startups i've worked at definitely has some of that it's very hard to sustain that in a company

SPEAKER_01which is growing very fast and the people are coming away quickly and especially if you know they don't um yeah if they don't really adhere to to those values but you know i think um that i think it gives an advantage in terms of actually attracting the best people and getting them to really sacrifice himself for the work of the company obviously you can incentivize people with stock options and money and so forth but really most people ultimately are much more driven I think by values

SPEAKER_01and omission and I think you know it was authentic for these companies i mean mckinsey may not have it perceived as well more broadly but i believe in the mckinsey vision and its mission which was which was uh to serve as clients and to build a great firm and it was really was focused on that very much so um won't get into what happened where how it might have gone astray but it definitely i think started off that way it was for many years

SPEAKER_02and in the valley among technology companies do you think it's as true today that they are that the people that are working there are

SPEAKER_01a mission driven yeah i i know the individuals a lot of individuals are i would like to say that um and that you know maybe i've been around the block too much where i feel like it is a little bit i get a little cynical uh you know and i hear a lot of startup pitches right and and sometimes people tell me you know what to try and do to save the world and and i'm trying to say well i'm not sure i see how that saves the world or or even how's it that good for the world um and so i do think um you know i'm not sure i believe that people believe it

SPEAKER_01that well they know they're supposed to say it uh so there's a little bit of that the valley has definitely um become a parody of itself sometimes uh because uh people feel like they have to say certain things and be certain way but you know i think authenticity comes through and i think um they're definitely startups i look at and i it's a filter for me is i gotta believe that they do have a mission behind what they're doing um i think the idea you know you want in general uh i believe it i'm not sure who said this so you can research this later

SPEAKER_01but a very famous vc said he's looking for missionaries not mercenaries and i do think ultimately that is uh part of the ballet success the ones that really do well like apple you know steve jobs was clearly a missionary the guy was obsessed with the beauty of fonts and and and the beauty of design um to a point where it could have driven the company out of business but he happened to strike rich and because he did the right thing obsessively and got to something that really mattered to people and would change their lives like the cell phone

SPEAKER_01for example and so forth it's amazing that that kind of thing does drive ultimate a lot of value oftentimes um probably lots of examples of people who failed even though they did all that but so it isn't there's a little bit of luck and timing too but i think the ones we know about the ones we talk about are the ones that are focused

SPEAKER_02that way why do you think that that has been so important to the valley to technology that that these companies be mission driven i mean as you said a moment ago that that some of the pictures you hear some of the people feel like they need to say the right things and and sort of pitch it the right way within the context of a mission and yet we can look at other businesses in other areas whether it's wall street whether it's manufacturing or whatever and you don't see companies with the same mission driven approach they're profit driven they may be excited

SPEAKER_02about what they're doing but it isn't the same need to to craft that vision around what they do

SPEAKER_01yeah it's interesting i remember like the films that came out and the the ideas that came out around wall street in the 80s almost uh celebrated their their lack of morality right they say greed is good right right a fundamental idea and i and i think um it is a bit of ethos um um i think there's a lot of reinforcing mechanism around this um the bay area is a very unique place culturally speaking um i think long term it has

SPEAKER_01a certain wild side to it you know it's a it's where you know we had the barbary coast and all that and then we had of course and probably close the birdie man and all these things everything in between so it has a lot of that going on as well as the hippie movement and all these kind of things it seems to really crystallize the bay area's idea that it's okay to be a rebel to be a little different um but then having a higher purpose somehow gives you a legitimacy around that that you can do all those things and i think yeah

SPEAKER_01for whatever reason i think that does that still is a big part of uh you know the underlying culture of of the area but you know you know i think also you have so many cynical examples you know what happened with theranos and other companies where you know the people do a couple ted talks and they they get really uh well practiced and what they're talking about and everybody's saying well that's great you know and then i was talking to a friend who had who had been to ted with me a long time ago and we were talking

SPEAKER_01about hey whatever happened to x y and z we saw that great ted talk on you know curing cancer or whatever it's about and then we never heard about that again he started realizing there are a lot of you know you know i wouldn't say snake oil salesmen but people who get a little ahead of the skis in terms of you know believing in something and uh there is that notion of um Peter Diamana said this basically something's crazy until it's done or something along those lines which is basically saying people who say hey the idea

SPEAKER_01of having 4,000 satellites up in the air providing broadband to us anywhere on the planet with a pizza box size thing or even smaller that seemed like it was not possible 20 years ago and I think now it's something which is we almost are to take for granted it's so available that kind of thing i do think um so that there's that notion that hey it's crazy until someone does it and you know flight all these things there's big innovations which did require them

SPEAKER_01to take a leap but of course you have to remember that some people did fail fail miserably or terribly or tragically and so it's not always going to uh yield results but in aggregate there will be many celebrated successes that do push humanity forward because of that that willingness to take ultimate risks sometimes the one problem i think is always important to realize is sometimes the ultimate risks are being put on other people right uh and i'm always amazed how that sometimes gets forgot sure it's great to take a risk for yourself

SPEAKER_01but it's one thing but if you do something which is dangerous to other people you should probably think about it is that is society agreeing to

SPEAKER_02that experiment talk a little bit about how you personally got got caught up in all of this when you were at google as part of this mission projects that you were doing

SPEAKER_01yeah so i mean i that that part is hard to explain because i just happen to have a law background as well and a business background and tech background so i became a very good generalist and so when they wanted to take on the founders or the ceo eric schmidt at the time wanted to take on a new project and it happened to be a good person to kind of shepherd it through at least the first phases and incubate it um so that was part of it so i could have a jack of all trades in that sense um but i think you know the mission driven part of these things you know a lot of times they really were um based on you can tie it back to

SPEAKER_01a business purpose uh like the renewable energy investments we did were all actually very good investments they weren't necessarily the best use of capital by google because the best use of capital was this poor back in the search and that was a real problem everything else was just a a bad idea in comparison but we're still making good money on those investments um africa also long-term would be arguably a good investment but it would take uh it takes a long time to get that money back and and even though you look at it from an investment perspective you're gonna have a lot of failures all the way because it's just uh has more inherent risk so that kind

SPEAKER_01of thing so just putting things in that framework i think is a healthy thing and that's my view on maybe do philanthropy or do something for the good you want to think about well how do i use the rigor of of capitalism to make this so as efficient as possible so that it could actually scale and deliver even more value to more people so if i have a good idea that can help people let's make sure i do it for a lot of people and i think that is a good filter and a good approach to take to even doing good

SPEAKER_02and you were involved in robotics and and the earliest days of self-driving cars there at google as well yeah so the last thing i did

SPEAKER_01at google was uh we had purchased a bunch of robotics companies and tried to figure out what to do with them all and uh it was it was one of those things where it just kind of happened and uh definitely Larry Page was very enthusiastic about it and we definitely saw it as a part of the future mostly got folded into Google X and I think robotics is a hard field because it's really specialized robotics make a lot of sense so robots that do one specific thing really well in a relatively semi-controlled environment

SPEAKER_01but trying to do robots around humans and actually normal people and children and pets and home environments really difficult because things are very unpredictable and we probably still have a ways to go uh before that really is something you would feel completely safe about self-driving car is a good example that's extraordinarily difficult problem but there are a lot of people behind every one of those cars even though they're self-driving right there are people actually that have to monitor those cars have to service those cars keep them going so there's really not a um it's an illusion that there's no person involved

SPEAKER_01they're actually a lot of people about and the probably always will be for you know foreseeable

SPEAKER_02future um tell us a little bit about what you're doing now your your fund is the enlightened ai etc

SPEAKER_01yeah i mean this is again for two reasons i think the idea of if you approach ai and as a tool that's can really can actually amplify people's capabilities ennacht ennacht our humanity i mean technology often uh sadly leads to people being more lonely more disconnected not more anxious not necessarily happier and that's that's true that's what i would say you started off by saying you think i'm an you might say i'm an optimist i prefer the term hopeful i think there's lots of reasons to believe that ai can be a very

SPEAKER_01a positive thing for the world and there's lots of reasons to point to that could be true it's not it's not a guaranteed outcome and i don't want to pretend that it is and i think we should be very vigilant about all the steps along the way but how do we make it more more more helpful more more enhancing of our humanity and i think part of it is um what your objectives are so one way of thinking about enlightened ai is saying is your if your design goal is to replace humans and get them out of the picture and then that's what you're going

SPEAKER_01to build and you're probably not going to do that well at it by the way because ai is pretty good it's not usually good enough to do that completely and it's almost always more the question is how much of this can be done by a human that's better done by ai than a human and then what part of it is really better off being done by human and what's the part that humans like doing as well what's the part that gives joy to people in their work gives them a sense of meaning and fulfillment and what parts are the dangerous or boring parts that they would much be happier to hand off to their ai minion friends right like

SPEAKER_01that and so thinking about the capabilities of relative capabilities of humans and ai i think and designing that way you'll get to a better outcome in terms of the humans interacting with it they'll be more supportive of it being rolled out so if you're working with doctors or lawyers or anybody who's going to be using ai they're going to be more supportive they're not going to fight it so it's probably going to be more successful in that sense and then on top of that it'd probably be a better product because you could have the best of both worlds and so i think it's also more sustainable as a business i mean this is a lot harder for someone else to come in

SPEAKER_01dislodge you because you've done a great job making that interface between human and ai really work. So I think those were all those reasons they kind of come together on both sides i mean just fortunately it's both a good thing i think for the world

SPEAKER_02and I'll see you next time. and certainly both those things can be true and the dangers can be true as well i mean whether we talk about the automobile or the earliest days of even commercial aircraft where planes crashed in the early days that wasn't the kind of safety record that we see today that that all of this technology is both good and bad but but you also have to look at it in terms of the potential time horizon not just judge it by where it is at any particular moment today

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I definitely agree, but I was thinking as you went through the intro a bit how yeah time will tell for a lot of these things yeah i think we already know that social media i should say we know so far social media caused a lot of harm and uh it is it probably is more like a drug than we thought about it before and it's not always a good drug in that sense it's not always good for people's psyche for young people especially it preys on people's insecurities and lots of things like that so and that's one example of how unattended consequences um

SPEAKER_01from houseme is deployed and could have been maybe avoided or mitigated better if we kind of thought about that more ahead of time so i i do think um that's where i think it's important to really think about how we deploy technology in our in our day-to-day life especially especially around children and more vulnerable people um who are or people who don't understand what they're doing or what they're using i think that's for all those reasons i think it's good to have a certain amount of caution

SPEAKER_01you'll see this in businesses but businesses are much more cautious about how they use ai than people are they do think about these things about reliability and predictability and so forth and can i actually use this thing is this actually not going to be a long-term better thing and you'll see that the adoption rates are a little bit slower than people can expect it in some cases for

SPEAKER_02that reason cost has certainly been part of that as well

SPEAKER_01oh sure yeah and the thing is the big upfront costs and there's a hope they'll have a big payoff you know it probably will be true i mean i think it will drive a lot of productivity gains and cost reductions but hopefully it also will create new worlds of possibilities um again we don't know that yet so your point about the we'll see uh is true a very satisfying answer for people. People entering the job market, people who are looking at their savings or where to invest your money and what they do. There's so many things that people kind of say you can't tell me just trust it

SPEAKER_01I hope it works out. Or even existential threats for humanity. And there's some of that risk out there as well I guess. So for folks to feel comfortable with that when we have so much uncertainty about the future we can look at analogies about other technologies and what happened you know we can see the internet or almost any of every technology came sure people lost their jobs but then many more people got new jobs that made us not be true again that may not happen this has to happen every time it is it's not a law of nature

SPEAKER_01or something djbj

SPEAKER_02that they better move quickly now because if people continue

SPEAKER_01to be afraid something might stop it maybe i i think uh i don't think anybody was holding back at all you know i don't i don't sense it really there's a lot of talk of holding back like i think you should regulatory model in general i think is a little bit not helpful

SPEAKER_01but one area i think makes sense is that it it talks about the idea different application areas requiring different levels of care and that seems like an obvious idea but it's a good one if you're a self-driving car you should be a lot more careful than a video game you know character that has ai in it right so i think that kind of thing um so i do so for example i think google is being very careful with waymo as a self-driving car and i think that's appropriate um now are they being really aggressive more aggressive

SPEAKER_01on ai in other areas um probably so and definitely more recently when they realized they kind of had to because they're in competition with other people who are doing it anyway so i think that's inevitable yeah i do i think the i think very now there's a lot of competition among them there's no clear winner yet and because of that everybody's extremely aggressively trying to beat each other out anthropic is doing very well in in coding and so that's driving other people to go very strong after coding uh for example uh i think it's i do think anxiety uh is may may get people

SPEAKER_01to motivate to encourage regulation uh or other or potentially even like well people could try boycotting it but then they feel like they're disadvantaging themselves if they don't use it so i think that's the problem the people don't feel much agency here that drives even more of their anxiety

SPEAKER_02do you feel that the valley is a different place in this kind of ai era and and soon

SPEAKER_01to be you know post ai era well we do the leaders in the space frankly some of them are not as inspiring partly because they they don't even try to put things in terms of inspiration in terms of inspiration um i can say some more than others i would say but in general we don't have as much of that sense of mission during language even perhaps there's some of it but not nearly as much um so that maybe that kind of that it creates one sense of brashness um is definitely

SPEAKER_01a little not tasteful um but in in real in real terms um you know you could argue that most of these leaders have been pretty uh ruthless and aggressive and audacious all those things you know everyone from steve jobs you know or even back before to other industries but i think even within the valley that's been true for a while um so i i'm not sure i do think though that there's been um a lot more concentration

SPEAKER_01of wealth that's been created in the last few years it's just unprecedented by any measure and that has created a little bit of a sense of of um a fear that wow a few companies will have so much power and value and i think that's true at the moment that may not be true much longer that i think the value will dissipate over time as people start deploying technology and it also has the technology evolved it will naturally commoditize um as we hit you know some natural limits on

SPEAKER_01the road assuming we hit those limits but yeah if i look at prior like technology um developments you have these s curves right to curve it very quickly you see incredible improvements and capabilities but at some point it starts hitting a shoulder a limit and uh unless they come up with a new technology um you kind of start shouldering out and then it comes becomes more of a cost game i think we haven't gone there yet with ai but i think we will get there uh soon probably post-ipo for a lot of these companies because they want to prove that they can grow grow grow grow before they do that

SPEAKER_01so i do think that's going to be a uh the next phase where people start realizing wait a minute we could just do a pretty good answer that's one tenth of cost money that's good enough and when that starts percolating through and the pricing is adjusted it will change the nature of the value to be much more rational and a little bit less driven by big personalities and a few very powerful companies

SPEAKER_02and finally matthew this whole notion that you're working in of enlightened ai to what extent do you see that catching on and making a real difference

SPEAKER_01Well, I definitely think, you know, the thing that gets people motivated by solving real problems, I think we see close to a real problem and work backwards from that, you have a very different approach to this building technology, which has a general purpose. So I think for a lot of entrepreneurs, that's what draws them in. They want to solve a specific problem that they saw out there, they believe because they saw, and they see these tools of being so amazing that they can do something so quickly and so easily, they can solve those problems. and that i think is creating this cambrian moment of of new startups

SPEAKER_01and ideas being out there it could be very small companies that can very quickly get out there and do things so i do think there's a lot of of of almost individual people just um doing their own doing these uh these mission driven efforts you know but obviously when build a big business too they're actually simultaneously want to be another startup success but they do want to solve a problem and they really believe in that and i think that that is very inspiring i think and i think a lot of people are doing this next generation of founders will be like that um so yeah i see that out there it's um

SPEAKER_01and also the sort of cynicism about the bigger companies and not wanting to be part of the big monoliths and culturally speaking that feels less less attractive

SPEAKER_02than it might have been a decade ago matthew stepka i thank you so much

SPEAKER_01for spending time with us today that's a real pleasure it was great talking to you

SPEAKER_02as well thank you very much thank you and thank you for listening and joining us here on the who what why podcast i hope you join us next week for another who what why podcast i'm jeff schechtman whowhatwhy.org forward slash donate

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Thomas Frank asked “What’s the Matter With Kansas”? Now he asks What’s the Matter With Creativity?

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Surrogacy Scandal That Exposed a Very Broken System

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Those Powers That Congress Gave the Supreme Court? Congress Can Take Them Away

    Nov 11, 202639 minAudio

    The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. One Win Is Not a Lasting Majority

    Nov 7, 202641 minAudio

    Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Religious Movement That’s Done With Democracy

    Oct 31, 202628 minAudio

    Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...

    Credit the people on this episode