Nathaniel Philbrick, a National Book Award winner and Pulitzer finalist, recasts the Gold Rush as the moment where America learned to embrace greed and live at warp speed. His new book, “The Rush,” and in our recent California Sun conversation, he explores instant wealth, immigration, slavery, and technological upheaval, then follows that same restless impulse from the Gold Rush through railroads and agriculture to Silicon Valley and the artificial intelligence boom. Get full access to Talk Cocktail Podcast at jeffschechtman.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the California Sun Podcast. I'm your host, Jeff Schechtman. Americans have always been very good at turning upheaval into folklore. The revolution becomes powdered wigs and Paul Revere. The frontier becomes cowboys. And the California gold rush becomes a bearded man with a pan standing knee deep in a Sierra stream, hoping that something shiny will change his life. The pictures endure because they're simple. History, of course, rarely is. In January 1848,
SPEAKER_00when James Marshall looked down into a mill race at Sutter's Mill and saw gold, he set in motion something far larger than a migration to California. Hundreds of thousands of people began moving across oceans and continents. Fortunes were made and lost with astonishing speed. New technologies accelerated everything. San Francisco became almost overnight a laboratory for money, ambition, immigration, racial conflict, private power, and political violence. And a country already coming apart over slavery suddenly had an enormous new piece
SPEAKER_00of territory and an enormously valuable one to fight over. The next great fortune... was always just over the horizon. The impulse did not end when the easy goal disappeared. It moved on into railroads, land, oil,
SPEAKER_00finance, and eventually into a stretch of orchard south of San Francisco that became Silicon Valley. Today, as we race once again towards the next technology, the next fortune, and the next transformed world, the gold rush can seem less like a distant episode than an early draft of the country we became. Has spent much of his career returning to episodes in American history that we think we already understand and showing us how much we have missed.
SPEAKER_00He won the National Book Award for In the Heart of the Sea, his Mayflower was a Pulitzer Prize finalist, and his books on the American Revolution have reconsidered many of our founding myths. Now he turns his gaze west. His new book, The Rush, California Gold, The Civil War, and the Making of the Modern World is just out, And it is my pleasure to welcome Nathaniel Philbrick here to the California Sun Podcast. Nathaniel, thanks so much for joining us. Thank you for that introduction.
SPEAKER_01That was just such an eloquent take on what I was trying to put together. I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. You have written a lot about New England, about the Revolution, pilgrims, warships, we could go on. Why California? Why now?
SPEAKER_01Where I've been for 40 years, I became aware that when Nantucket was in the 1840s, whaling was beginning to go downhill. Nantucket had been the whaling capital of the world. Its ships were too large to get through over the sandbar at the mouth of the harbor. Then there was a great fire in 1846 that destroyed the waterfront. And Nantucket was just getting the tar kicked out of it when two years later,
SPEAKER_01they learn of the discovery of gold in California. And so these Nantucketers, who were used to sailing their whale ships around the world in search of blubber that would be turned into oil, decided to load up their whale ships with potential prospectors. They sailed around the Horn in They sailed into the Golden Gate, literally evacuated their whale ships and lit out for the gold fields. In just nine months, Nantucket would lose a quarter of its voting population to the gold fields.
SPEAKER_01And when I learned about this many years I said, man, this is a story I have to return to. But I really felt I needed to know more about this country. So I ended up writing three books about the American Revolution, one about why And, you know, that's where the country began. And I decided, well, hey, it's now time to follow those Nantucketers west and delve into
SPEAKER_01the California gold rush. Because what happened to Nantucket was happening to towns all over the country in 1848 and 1849.
SPEAKER_00Were you surprised as you dug into this the degree to which the gold rush became so much a part of really America's foundational story? Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01You know, I had grown up thinking. You know, limited to California, a fascinating episode where noble prospectors, you know, somehow, you know, found gold and made their fortune. And as I got into the story, I began to realize that the gold rush was much more than that. The discovery of gold in California happened just afterwards.
SPEAKER_01As the treaty with Mexico was being signed after the Mexican-American War, which basically doubled the size of the country, if you add on the new acquisition of Texas and the Oregon Territory, And then to discover that on the farthest reaches of this new territory, there is the potential for immense wealth. This hit at a time when Americans were trying to figure out what their future was. Half the states were The other half were free.
SPEAKER_01Suddenly, the most distant part of the new Western half of the country becomes an instant state, has the population. What to do about it? And so I began to see that the gold rush was much more than gold. It instigated, you could say, lit the long fuse to what would become the Civil War. And so I felt I needed to put the gold rush in that larger context.
SPEAKER_00I want to talk about the Civil War part of it and slavery in a minute. But the other thing that the gold rush ushered in... Yeah. You
SPEAKER_01know, I think Mark Twain is a perfect example. He was a teenager in Hannibal, Missouri in 1848 when Goldman And he would later write, he said, you know, when I was a kid, no one to become rich was never something anyone thought about. And then came the discovery of gold with the lure of heading west, making your fortune in a few years, and then coming back a millionaire.
SPEAKER_01And that changed everything, Twain wrote, and ushered in what he would And so what happened, you know, Thomas Jefferson's pursuit of happiness in the Declaration of Independence became, you know, not something which meant that you hoped to survive. And I think, you know, this is the world in which we live today. And it began with the California Gold Rush.
SPEAKER_00I guess the other part of that is whether that really changed the American ideal, the greed somehow and ambition, I guess ambition and greed, and the potential corruption that went along with it became part of the American ideal or that was there first and this just sort of filled in the blanks? Well, you know, you had America...
SPEAKER_01Moving west, you know, with no compunction about taking Native American land. African slavery was a part of America. And, you know, so you had all of those elements. What the gold rush does is just speed it up to warp speed. And, you know, when there is immense wealth involved, you see things changing quickly. Technology is a big factor in this story.
SPEAKER_01And so it all contributes to this uptick of, you know, greed, lust for power. California just... It also internationalized California in many ways. Talk about that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, we think of California as, you know, primarily the gold rush as an American phenomenon. But what I think a lot of us don't realize is how quickly it became an international thing. And in fact, you know, the new technologies were a part of it. The electric telegraph had recently been invented. Steam engines were creating railroads, but also steamships that were now built. Capable of crossing vast distances.
SPEAKER_01And when you look at the geography of California, and in the beginning, an American who wanted to get there quickly had really only two One was sailing around Cape Horn. The other was going overland from Missouri, 2,000 miles across deserts and over mountains to California. And those both took time, as much as six months. And meanwhile,
SPEAKER_01as news of gold was being touted all over the world, people in Mexico were going Many of them experienced miners rushing across the border. Chileans and Peruvians were making their way up the coast. They were just a fraction of the distance as a New Yorker who was boarding a ship around the coast. That was going to sail around the horn. The Chinese and Australians were much closer than that New Yorker trying to sail to California.
SPEAKER_01And so when the Americans get to California, it's an international situation. There's people from all over the world. Europeans continue to pile in. And, you know, this just creates a problem. You know, this whole cosmopolitan crucible with everyone striving to get gold.
SPEAKER_00It also created an immigration issue, an immigration problem that felt very contemporary when you read it today. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01The Americans here, as they make their way to California, that there are all these Mexicans and there are Native Americans from California in the gold fields. In the early months of that, half the people in the gold fields were Native Americans. And so, but Americans view this as theirs. These others are foreigners. And so, you know, so the question becomes, as California gains the population for statehood,
SPEAKER_01which is a threshold of 60,000, you know, within months, it has that. The question is, who is an American? You know, is it the... You know, all these new arrivals who are just here for the gold. You know, who owns this? And so, you know, it's and it's all, you know, adrenalized at a point to a point where, you know, violence is breaking out in I don't know how far we've progressed from that state where we're still trying to figure out just who is an American.
SPEAKER_00I want to talk about the slavery aspect of this because I think that one of the things that might be most surprising to readers is the degree to which California's position with respect to slavery and its political future was so unsettled during this gold rush period.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, the Californians who arrived in California were by no means abolitionists, but they did not want to share the gold fields with African Americans. And they felt that Southerners who would bring African American slaves to California would have an unfair advantage. And so... From the beginning, it was clear that when California became a state, it would have to be a free state.
SPEAKER_01But that didn't mean that California was going to be a traditional northern state. Because from the beginning, Southerners, many of whom got there before the Northern, who could leave in the winter of 1849, while Northerners who were going to Missouri had to wait till the spring before they departed. Southerners arrived and with the ambition of, okay, if this is going to be a free state, We still want to dominate this state.
SPEAKER_01And so many pro-slavery Southerners arrive in California and begin to dominate it politically. Very quickly, California becomes a state And then there's almost instantly a movement to divide the state in half to create a southern slave portion of California. And making the stakes so high is the fact that there's so much gold coming out of California. How important was the gold economically to the Union victory?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it was in the balance right up until the Civil War. And as Grant, Ulysses S. Grant would say during the Civil War, I don't know how we... You know, could fight this war without the gold from California. You know, this was when gold was literal money. And so these shipments of gold east provided the north with the ability to take out the loans. That enabled it to fight a war against the South.
SPEAKER_01As a Southerner would later say, after the Civil War, you didn't beat us on the battlefield. It was the finances that enabled you to win, and California was absolutely essential to that.
SPEAKER_00One of the things that's so interesting and feels so contemporary as well is the degree to which San Francisco and what we now consider the Bay Area was really unable to cope with the speed at which it was growing, that the institutions and the infrastructure simply wasn't there. And that had some consequences.
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. I mean, because of this, particularly in that first year, as people just pile into the state and before California is a state, there's talk around the campfire and the gold fields about, you know, I think it's It wouldn't be illegal to shoot someone here because there isn't a law against murder in California. And so vigilante justice was a part of the goldfields from the beginning.
SPEAKER_01And what was amazing to me was to realize how, you Five years in, in the streets of supposedly civilized San Francisco, a form of vigilante justice would prevail several times in which a group of businessmen claiming that they were trying to bring law and order to the city, and that question was murky at best, would band together, put together
SPEAKER_01An army of vigilantes and take over the city and begin hanging people that they deemed bad citizens and deporting others out of the state. And so this would happen in 1851 and 1856. And so you have this situation where people are literally taking the law into their own hands, overthrowing duly elected officials.
SPEAKER_01They're putting forward an agenda of their own. And so the rule of law in California is ignored when it gets in the way of many people, whether they be ordinary miners. We'll see you next time.
SPEAKER_00Right. And everybody is a wild agent in a way. Things are changing so quickly.
SPEAKER_01Initially, the gold miners are panning for gold. Within a couple of years, new technologies are entering the gold fields. One of those is hydraulic mining in which these industrial scale fire hoses were used to wash away hillsides to get at the gold. And they were highly efficient, terrible to the The landscape, obviously, but fewer people were required,
SPEAKER_01and so what you had was people were getting the gold faster than ever, but it was corporations doing it rather than the thousands of miners. That's right. Laws are passed limiting hydraulic mining because it's having a devastating effect on farms.
SPEAKER_01The silt that's coming down the rivers is poisoning water and just wreaking havoc. And so, yeah, things are changing so fast that people are having a heck of a time catching up.
SPEAKER_00Talk about it in the context of what we are witnessing today, what we have witnessed in California, particularly in places like Silicon Valley, where the technology, not dissimilar from the gold rush, is moving at such a rapid pace that institutions can't keep up with it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I was struck by, you know, from the beginning, working on this book, that how the tentacles of the story reach in so many directions. And, you know, and particularly when it comes to where we are today with Silicon Valley. I mean, one of the... What happened once the war broke out was the building of the Transcontinental Railroad. And I think many Americans don't realize that the building of that engineering marvel was adopted by the North.
SPEAKER_01... ... ... ... ... It happens at lightning speed. There's two companies, one the Central Pacific in the West battling an Eastern company, and then they're just building it as quickly as possible.
SPEAKER_01What are commonly known as the Big Four, former shopkeepers from Sacramento, including Leland Stanford, would become the 19th century equivalent of billionaires in just a few years through the building of the Transcontinental Railroad. Stanford would purchase a farm that he would name Palo Alto. Stanford, of the big four, was the one who was interested in technological innovation.
SPEAKER_01He would hire a photographer. The two of them would create the technology that would ultimately lead to motion pictures. With the death of his son, Stanford and his wife would found Stanford University, where a of course, which would become a breeding ground for future gold rushes through technology in Silicon Valley. And so, you know, the ethic of the gold rush where you work as fast as you and furiously as you can with little regard to the ultimate consequences,
SPEAKER_01you know, failure is fine as long as you just keep trying over and over again because at some point you're going to get rich quickly. That's what we're living with today, and it began with
SPEAKER_00the gold rush. It's interesting to look at, as you indicate, that the gold rush gave way to the railroads, which gave way to agriculture and oil and finance, and eventually Silicon Valley today, that there's just something in the DNA of the place.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, for me, my interest in history has always been associated with place. I became a historian out of my fascination with where I, my new home on Nantucket. And that led to my books about a whaling in the heart of the sea and then all of the others. And every time I research a book, I have to go to the various places. It's impossible for me to ...to, you know, figure out where it's going unless I can see the terrain.
SPEAKER_01And sure, in many situations, things have changed dramatically. But there's still something about place. And places have a hold on us. And California, I mean, California is this fascinating place. It was named for a fictional island... It was invented in a romance novel by a Spanish novelist in 1510. It was named for a mountainous island where the only metal was gold.
SPEAKER_01Here we are, you know, the discovery of gold, the prophecy of California's name has come true, came true. And I think what began in California is, you know, there's, you can argue about the power of place, but I seem there's an air of inevitability about what has unfolded in California, given how it began.
SPEAKER_00Talk about that sense of inevitability because it does seem to be the case that if something can be built and monetized, it will be in California. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01California has the fourth largest economy in the world. And it's a state like no other. And watching how it transformed, yes, there was gold in the beginning, but then many of the miners, as they see the technologies making it more difficult for individual miners to make their way, go to wheat farming, and wheat becomes the new gold
SPEAKER_01Wheat farming in California is not like farming anywhere else in the country in the 19th century. These are basically agricultural factories. Creating the monoculture we have today in which, you know, huge machines, horse-driven in the beginning were used to, you know, farm wheat in an industrialization. As the railroad opens up once inaccessible and remote portions of California,
SPEAKER_01you have the international character of the gold rush contributing to oil. Wine becoming such a big deal and you have fruit trees and all of this happening. And then, of course, to the South, there are films and making this all happen. And so California is a place. See, there's something special about it.
SPEAKER_00You have the image of a train hurtling forward at pretty high speed. I mean, is that really the image of California? Yeah, I think it's not bad.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's because, and like an out-of-control train, you know, no one is in control of it. But the speed is its essential and danger are its, you know, the essential parts to it. And, you know, it's talking about place. Research trips to California were important to me, not only to archives, but to the places. And one of the places I will never forget is... Up in the top of the Sierra Nevada Mountains at the Donner Pass is
SPEAKER_01a tunnel carved out by some of the 20,000 Chinese workers that were brought to California to work on the Central Pacific Railroad. And a train no longer goes through it, but you can go through it today. And it's awesome. Almost like a horizontal cathedral or a mix between a cathedral and the bat cave in
SPEAKER_01which you get a sense of this immense labor that went into carving this tunnel through the top of the Sierra Nevada mountains and is a kind of monument to, I think, what The gold rush unleashed this incredible application of labor and power all at the behest of speed.
SPEAKER_00If anyone had been able to see the consequences of all this, would anything have changed?
SPEAKER_01You know, I doubt it. No. You know, that's not how Americans at least seem to be wired. I mean, look at California. Look at San Franciscans. They built a city on a property. A fault where earthquakes are just a matter of life and bad things, there's predictions of another really bad thing. But that doesn't prevent San Franciscans from going ahead, pushing ahead.
SPEAKER_01I think, you know, as humans, you know, we're one of the few of only creatures on Earth that know they're going to die. And to continue with life without going insane, we have the ability to lay aside our own annihilation and pursue our lives, you know, with hopefully happiness. And productivity and that kind of thing. And so it's built into us, I think, to, oh sure, that's potentially dangerous.
SPEAKER_01That could kill us. But hey, there's money to be made here. And there's that competitive aspect. There's Well, we got to beat them. And pretty soon you lose sight of where this is headed. And I think that's exactly where
SPEAKER_00we are today. And as you see this so prominently in California, does it change your view in any way of the rest of the country, of the East Coast, of other places you've written about when you see it compared to all of this in California?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's interesting. After writing three books about the American Revolution, which was an incredible experience, exploring the founding of this, you know, where did this country come from? And there's the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, Washington's first administration. How did it all happen? And I got a sense of, you know, it wasn't fated. It was chaotic.
SPEAKER_01It was dependent on a myriad of personalities and And seemingly random historical events that fell into place and created America. But it also became clear to me, working on The Rush, is that something Nothing happened to that vision, that founding in the 18th century. And it was technology. It was this belief in technology.
SPEAKER_01You know, instant wealth. And the gold rush was a fundamental part of this. And when you look around the country, you know, when I go to these research trips on the East Coast or when I was working on a book about the Battle of Little Bighorn in, you know, the Western interior, you know, There's a different feeling there. The regard to history, there's a sense of the past in the present,
SPEAKER_01but I don't get that sense of, you know, A world hurtling into something new. You know, when I was walking around the plains of, you know, Montana and or examining battlefields in the South and mid-Atlantic and New England. But when you come to California, it's different. It's different. The history, it just feels a part of something that's still unfolding and exotic and And more
SPEAKER_00than a little terrifying. Nathaniel Philbrick, his book is The Rush, California Gold, The Civil War, and the Making of the Modern World. I thank you so very much for spending time with us today.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it was great fun to speak with you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00And thank you for listening and joining us here on the California Sun Podcast. I hope you'll join us next week. I'm Jeff Schechtman. If you like this podcast, please feel free to share and help others find it by rating and reviewing it on iTunes and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
We blame American inequality on the usual suspects: tax cuts for the rich, Wall Street greed, the decline of unions. Joining me on this recent WhoWhatWhy podcast, Thomas Frank (What’s the Matter with Kansas) says...
Ava Kofman, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins me on the Califorina Sun Podcast to discuss her five-part podcast, “The Journey,” which investigates the story of a wealthy Southern California couple who used...
The Supreme Court wasn’t always this powerful. Congress once held more control over the judiciary - and could reclaim much of that authority today. With the election over and control of Congress settled, attention now...
Longtime Senate staffer and historian Adam Jentleson thinks that sometimes a big win is the least interesting thing that could happen to his party. His question is what comes after: whether a midterm won on backlash...
Christian nationalists are no longer trying to win democracy, Rep. Jared Huffman argues. They want to replace it with religious rule - and control American life. Something has changed on the American religious right -...