In this open-forum session, ICIMS administrators work through a practical reporting problem: how to alert an onboarding team when an accepted candidate's start date changes, using a dedicated revised start date field, dashboard and scheduled reports, or an API listener. The group also discusses connector failures caused by edge cases such as multiple state tax forms, documenting integration quirks, catching bad data entry like placeholder salaries and hourly rates on exempt offers, and whether hidden list values can be searched. The second half covers digital adoption tools such as WalkMe and their maintenance burden, a first-hand comparison of ICIMS form flexibility with Eightfold, and a detailed look at building Power BI dashboards with AI-generated SQL in Snowflake, including how to validate code and data by cross-checking with other models and manual pulls. Attendees also share early access news on a unified ICIMS reporting tool intended to address siloed reporting, plus recent performance and onboarding portal branding issues. In this episode: - Notifying onboarding of start date changes: add a revised start date field and report on blank versus not blank rather than relying on updated date - Using an API listening for field changes as a more advanced option, and keeping the original start date field updated for the ADP integration - Connector failures from edge cases such as two state tax forms with different marital statuses, and documenting connector quirks - Catching hiring manager data entry errors with dashboards, reports and an offer exception report for wrong pay types and values - Using a job profile field driven by FLSA status to set pay frequency in offer letters - Whether hidden list values that were previously selected can be searched, and possible user permission export on the roadmap - Evaluating WalkMe and similar overlay tools: maintenance with process changes, multiple login groups and UI changes - Comparing ICIMS iForms flexibility with Eightfold feedback forms and the trade-off between customization and SaaS simplicity - Building Power BI dashboards with Snowflake AI-generated SQL and validating results by reading code, manual pulls and cross-checking with other models - Early access to a unified ICIMS reporting tool intended to address siloed reporting, plus recent performance and onboarding portal branding issues Chapters: 00:00:00 Informal Opening and Gratitude Check-In 00:02:03 Reporting on Revised Offer Start Dates 00:06:17 Connector Challenges, Testing and Data Entry Quality 00:12:43 In-App Guidance Tools for ICIMS Training 00:18:37 Searching for Hidden List Values 00:24:39 Moving from ICIMS to Another ATS: Form Flexibility 00:28:58 Offer Pay Type Errors and Template Fixes 00:31:27 Community Resources, Events and Vendor Spotlight 00:35:01 AI-Assisted Reporting, Dashboards and Code Validation 00:50:03 Early Access to Unified Reporting and Open Issues https://systemadmininsights.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Alex MarcusAll right, let's go ahead and get started. Welcome to System Admin Insights, everybody. Happy Halloween to those of you who celebrate. We'd like to get started with a little bit of gratitude at the beginning of the call. Please drop one thing in chat that you are grateful for. I am grateful for utility gloves, because my cat is… really doesn't like to have her claws trimmed, and they are razor sharp. Like, she just puts her paw on my hand and it hurts.
Alex MarcusSo, I had to get some, like, heavy-duty utility gloves and tackle her, and now… now we have a system. Let's see, Don says, trick-or-treating, alright, Greg says, extra hour of sleep this Sunday. I thought we were done with this! I thought… I thought we canceled daylight savings time, what happened? It didn't pass?
GuestDidn't pass.
Alex MarcusOh, really? Yeah.
GuestNope. It didn't…
Alex MarcusI didn't know that. Oh, I agree.
Gueston anything.
Alex MarcusI guess not, alright.
GuestI'm glad it didn't pass, because they were trying to make the daylight savings time the one that's on the permanent, instead of just getting rid of the whole concept, so…
Alex MarcusYeah, okay. Alright, so it goes. Alright, so, let's see what we have in our discussion forum today. Alright. There we go, here comes Angela. Alright. Okay, see, is Tonya here, not yet. Alyssa… not yet. Alright, that's it. So, it's open forum today. Who has a question? What's going on?
GuestI like the hat.
Alex MarcusThank you very much. What's budget, budget, budget Halloween costume. So, what's on folks' minds today?
GuestI'll ask a question.
Alex MarcusPlease do.
GuestWe have… Issue where, when candidates have accepted their offer, but they would need to change the start date after the fact. We're capturing that right now, just simply in email correspondence. We have the offer module, but we don't use it fully, so when the offers are sent out, they actually get sent out outside of ICIMS to DocuSign. Because we need additional signatures and that sort of a thing. So, when the candidate accepts, we've got the offer date, or sorry, the start date.
GuestIn the Offer Details tab. But then if they change it, we're going to change it on the offer details tab. I need a way to let my onboarding team know that there's been a change, and that the email getting kind of lost here and there is not working well, so I'm hoping there's a way within the system To figure out a report or a notification that lets them know there's been a change to a start date for an upcoming hire. So there's two ways you could potentially do this. They're both kind of based on the same concept. So, you would build a report, and the report is, based upon the profile updated date.
GuestThat's kind of… It's gonna be kind of hard to see, if you're using the same field for start date, the original start date field, I would recommend that you have a new start date field or a start date change field, also to kind of back yourself up on this, and just update both of them. But… you could do it based off of if additional start date… if revised start date is blank, don't show. Or if revised start date is not blank, show. You could also do it based off of updated date, But if updated date… if they update anything else, updated date is gonna change. Okay. So, the revised start date one is really the more reliable of the two, and then you can build the dashboard report upon it.
GuestAnd then you could also build a scheduled report where revised start date is filled in. Hmm, yeah. Yeah, so those are… but it's also based on the report, so start… step one would be the report, and… The really super crazy way is to have an API listening for the field to change. Oh, okay. We're not quite set up with that yet, but that might be on the horizon, so that's a good thing to think about. We could incorporate if we do get there. So creating another field with the revised start date.
GuestAnd… I need to change both of them, because the field that's… we're collecting it in right now is what's pushing to ADP in the integration. Yeah, you would… You would need to change the existing start date field to the revised start date, but having the second field, meaning you just have to fill it in twice, but having the second field Blank versus not blank. is a very obvious way for you to report on that. The only place where that gets kind of tricky is if it happens more than once.
GuestHmm. So, you… the updated… I would have your logic be where the updated date is, like, secondary. Primarily is revised start date blank. Or is updated date on after the higher… like, what is the updated date, the most recent updated date on the field? But I wouldn't have updated date be your first filter. Okay. Makes sense, yeah. Thanks, Vivian. Welcome.
Alex MarcusThanks for the question, Michelle.
AnnouncementIf you work with HR Technology, I'd like to invite you to join System Admin Insights. It's a free community where the people who actually work with these systems come together to share what they've learned, solve problems, and help each other get better at their jobs. We also offer professional learning and certification for people who want to deepen their expertise and advance their careers. You can find us at systemadmininsights.com.
Alex MarcusAngela, what's going on in your world?
GuestOh, not much. Halloween is actually my anniversary with my company.
Alex MarcusATCC anniversary.
GuestYep, 4 years, so that always makes it memorable. But not too much, I'm still working through. Thank you, connector challenges, and all of that good stuff, you know, just… API fun, all of that automation works lovely until there's a snag, and then it's… it's a lot more difficult to… To manage through, so…
Alex MarcusYeah, automation fatigue.
GuestA little bit.
Alex MarcusI think I was talking about prompt fatigue the other day, right? When you're trying to do something with AI, and then you realize that you could have done it more quickly, just manually. Same thing with automation. It gets to a point where you're like, boy, the amount of time I've invested into this. Yeah, yeah, is it actually worth it? Is there… is there a light at the end of the tunnel?
GuestSo we weren't able to solve this, you know, this particular connector issue. We just keep running into connector issues with, with state tax forms. Okay. You know, and I think, you know, our connector is still fairly new, so we're working through a few kinks, and most of the time it works beautifully. But when we have the anomalies, you know, in this case, we onboarded someone in one state, and then they moved their office location, so they're relocating to another state. So they've got two state tax forms.
GuestThey'd have different marital status on both, and the connector can't figure out which one to use, and so the whole thing fails, and… you know, it's probably not even worth fixing, because it'll probably never, ever happen again, but… you know, figuring out if it's worth trying to do things differently, or just plan for anomalies and have to onboard manually, so… As long as it gets, like, 90% of your use cases, and then you just have the one or two edge cases, that's usually… That's who we are. That's who we are. That's… it's probably as good as it gets, it's just… You know, you want it to be flawless, so…
Alex MarcusHas anybody else done a project like this? Any tips?
GuestI mean, I just, especially dealing with a new connector, it's more about… And if it's new even to ICIMS, it's more about documenting the quirks, That sounds like it's, obvious, but it's the kind of thing, because especially if you're going through all the testing, and, you know, you're working on a lot of… you're working on different projects, like, 6 months later, you'll look back and be like, oh, that's why we did A, B, and C, and just save you the time, or if someone's like, why… why didn't we just go with just doing this instead? And you're like, well, we… could've, but this scenario, or there's this one quirk between this or this that we can't do this. That… that has saved me a few times, and then just, like.
Guestwith the testing, I like to, I discovered you know, I was trying to explain to a team, actually, earlier today, we had… didn't have enough time to do pilot testing, and so they wanted to go live with something, so we did. And then they started catching all these other weird quirks. It wasn't ICIMS, it wasn't the other vendor, it was just, you know, it just is. And I told them, I was like, you know. We're kind of… this is what happens, you put it in the wild, all the testing.
Guestnever substitutes for that, and you just catch these things, you're like, I would never have expected someone to do A, B, and C in that way. Like, you're like, wow. And you just have to document that, and just… and sometimes you go back into the other vendor and be like, hey, is this something that you could build out… build around for the future? And sometimes they'll be like, yeah, it works for them. Other times, it's just something you just have to be like, we have to work around it. It's a fun… it's the exciting part about connectors. I like the white… the white knuckle ride, when you're catching them, you're like, whoa, you know. But… It's… it'll eventually make its way. You make it to the other end, you're like, okay, cool.
GuestCool. Part of the piece for us, even more challenging than the connector sometimes, is training the organization around the way things work, because previously in ICIMS, they're inputting data there, but it just lives in ICIMS. It's not our source of truth, and it's not impacting payroll, or finance, or HRIS, or Building through all these other systems, and… Now we're getting to the point where we actually have all of these connected, and so, you know, we still have hiring managers who… who guess instead of maybe asking a question, or, you know, and so, for us, it's been, like, building dashboards and reports that will help us catches… Those training errors, where maybe it's a new hiring manager that doesn't know the org structure enough to really put in the right variables, and, you know, kind of validating that stuff on the TA intake, and… Building processes around.
GuestHow to make sure that we catch those instances, because they don't understand the importance of the data that they're putting in. My favorite is when someone is, like, just enters a value, because they realize, if I enter this value that's required, it'll allow it to proceed. Even though that value makes no sense. So I've had my favorite was someone will put in $1, and I'm like. Why didn't you just ask? It wasn't that they were guessing, they just didn't have the time to ask, so they put a dollar in for, like, a salary. And of course, that translates in the system. You're like, why are we paying this person an annual salary for a dollar? Of course, auditing catches it down the line, and we all catch it, but when you go back and you kind of try to Dissect, well, why did you… why did someone do that to begin with? But just so they could get around it and proceed.
GuestBecause they didn't have the time. I had inherited an ATS once that had 10 listed as a gender. And I don't know how it happened, but in that system, there were about 20 people after that that also had 10 as their gender. So, you know, weird things like that can happen. I don't know how other people ended up selecting it, but we got rid of that fun thing, but… 10. Always entertaining.
Alex MarcusWow. Chasing… chasing the Erfolg's Er Leibnis, is that what it is, Vivian?
GuestOh, God, I don't remember how to pronounce.
Alex MarcusI don't know the German term for that satisfaction.
GuestYeah.
Alex MarcusOnce you've chased down all the edge cases, and everything is… is 99.9%.
GuestThe opposite of schadenfreude. That one I can pronounce.
Alex MarcusYeah. I have a question for the group. I was talking to a customer today, and they are rolling ICIMS out in a few months. And they said, when it came to training, they're like, oh, well, we just signed with WalkMe. And WalkMe, if you're not familiar with it, is a sort of tooltip type of thing, where it plants things in your dashboard, and… I'm just curious what folks experience with… I'm skeptical, if you can't tell from my tone of voice, but, like, does it actually work? Their landing page says, like, you know, anonymous customer quote, our AI rollout initiative was 10 times better because of… really? I don't know.
Guestto walk me.
Alex MarcusI pers… I personally, I see stuff like that, I dismiss it as quickly as I can, you know? But who's worked with a Walk Me or a tool like that?
GuestI had them… I actually did a series of demos with them a couple years back. At the time, they were positioning themselves for Workday. Right, there's another, there's another competitor, I think it's… I don't know if they're still around, it's in the Walk Day sphere, Phenom, that's another one. Phenom does the same concept, you know, they can do kind of a layover. an overlay, and you can either do kind of a quick tip, or it says, you know, can you walk me through, plus the phrase, walk me, walk me through how to do something, right? And it… At the time, they weren't doing ICIMS, they were touting that they could do Workday and a few other vendors. I think they were just thinking about going into ICIMS.
GuestYou know, it's one of those things where my question to them is, what's the maintenance gonna look like to keep that up? Because what if your processes change?
Alex MarcusSure.
GuestAnd the other thing is… You know, it's… I get the, inherent convenience you would get out of it versus just doing… using some other, either video or something like Scribe to show that, so you don't have to exit the application. But it's… it's, to me, it's like, it works for, I think, for really complicated step-by-step cases where people are not gonna do something a lot. If it's something that they're gonna use a lot, it needs to be something that's not gonna get in the way. So it's there.
GuestBut if some… you know, and if someone's an experienced user is not gonna need to click on it, great. But if it keeps coming over to you and saying, hey, do you need help with this? Do you want… it could bother users really quick. We didn't go with them because they were kind of expensive, and I just… there was, like, I think I… In me, there was also this kind of gut instinct after several demos, I just thought they were over-promising. I hope I'm wrong, they would definitely, they definitely have experience working with, like, HRS systems like Workday, because they, they definitely have, have excellent, but with some smaller, nicher ATSs and stuff, I wasn't yet convinced.
Alex MarcusI mean, when I'm learning new software, I always have… two Chrome tabs, and split screen. Alright, split tabs, rather. So, split tabs, I've got AI on one side, I've got the product on the other side, and I just ask it what to do, and I do screenshots and dump the screenshots into AI. I… I don't know if… like, that's… that's what I would want. like, how do I do such and such on this screen? If it could read the screen even better, right? But I would imagine a tool like that, where it is an AI interface that is in one screen, and you just ask it what to do, and it tells you.
Alex MarcusI don't know if Walk Me does anything like that. I guess, because then there's no maintenance, right? Because it's keeping up to date with what's actually there.
GuestYeah, that's the… the main issue was always when I asked STEM and Phenom, and it was always, well, you could do this, you could go with the flows, and again, if it's something that you don't… doesn't change very often, then I can totally see the case. If it's, you know, Workday, for example, their home interface has changed. surprising… a surprising amount of times in just the past couple years. And if you're dealing with, like, an enterprise where, like. just your dashboard. I'll give you an example. If you're working with, let's say, ICIMS, and you've got more than 10 login groups, and each has their own custom dashboard, if you're not careful in how exactly you do the overlay and the walkthrough, you might not have to account for that. So, there are ways around that. You could work with Phenom and walk, walk me to actually just focus on certain parts so you can minimize that, but you're still gonna have some type of maintenance you need to do, especially with, like, like, I wouldn't do it if… if you're a new ICIMS client, you don't have to worry about the big… too many UI changes, but let's say you're doing… you did this as an… with a legacy UI, and you move out to a new UI, that's a nightmare. You're gonna have to do everything from scratch again.
Alex MarcusYeah. Vivian, you said they had to walk me at ICIMS for a while?
GuestLittle history about WalkMe. ICIMS, all the, like, people that have been laid off or left ICIMS in the last, two and a half, three and a half years, went to WalkMe. My former manager is Half of my former team is over there, so a lot of your ICIMS history, folks, and some of the better implementation team is over at WalkMe. So, I'm familiar with them. from that perspective, that I'm still in contact with a lot of those colleagues, and I've seen a demo of it, and it seems like a pretty cool tool. We can do a vendor spotlight on it, if you think that would be something anybody here would be interested in.
GuestI know lots of good folks.
Alex MarcusYeah, let's look into it, yeah. Yeah, I'm curious to see how it's evolved, because I haven't seen it in a few years. Okay. Well, thanks, everybody. Who has a question today? Let's see… Julie Sheffer-Chase. How are you doing with ICIMS today?
GuestI'm doing okay. Nothing new.
Alex MarcusNothing new? Okay. Got it. Greg, what about you? What are you working on today?
GuestI actually did have a question. So, this one is… I've been running into situations where certain connectors are running… are running into issues, and when I looked into it, it's because, the connector and, we had maybe a value that was hidden. And then, of course, we forgot to, hide. the value, that value from the object. So, people were actually clicking on hidden.
GuestOr it was hidden after the fact. It's weird how it's acting. But my question is. Is there a way to search for hidden? to search for something that is hidden. So basically, for example, let's say that you've got, like, a list. Right? In a list box, and it, you know, you've got a whole, you know, items 1 through 10. And then, for whatever reason, one of the items, you had to hide. But maybe someone already had previously selected it. So it's gonna come up as, if I look at it after the fact, as hidden. What I'm trying to do is find out if there's something that is considered Passing that is listed as being full.
GuestIt's being shown to the user as being hidden, so that either we could either search on it and create a validation rule on that, or just be able to hunt down something and see what we can do about it. Haven't found anything specifically about finding Zion. Hidden. That's a per-user type of view. Right. So, I don't know that you can actually sort… search on that. That's, That said, though, weren't we talking just briefly a little bit ago, and maybe I'm just imagining this conversation, about them creating new tools on how to, export user permissions?
GuestGreg, weren't you the one that mentioned that that was something that was in one of the roadmaps? I think… I remember… no, yeah, it was a few weeks ago. yeah, I think someone else mentioned that that was something they were talking… they had talked with their, their manager… their account manager about, and there was a way to export. I know on… My end, there's a way we can do kind of like, you know, the… they had custom done something for us for, like, doing search locks. And we can actually log out that, we can actually do that, and we can actually export, through user management, of course, you know, what login group everyone belongs to.
GuestBut yeah, I do remember someone saying in one of the previous calls that there was something on the roadmap for exporting. So, like, if you, you know, if you needed to do something for documentation, whatever, you could actually do just that. Yeah, because I've had, like, a… because we've been… they've been talking about doing it for years, and years and years. So, if that's the case, if that is coming, then that would be the only way I could think of that you'd be able to do that. Okay. Yeah, cause… But, yeah. Alright, that was worth a try. Yeah, I didn't think it… that was a long shot, so that was… let me just ask.
Guestgoing through everybody's log… logging in as a user, and going through every single dashboard panel and every single view, I can't think. Yeah. One way that you would do that. Alright, thanks.
Alex MarcusAny other ideas on that? Alright, good luck with that, Greg.
GuestYeah, thanks.
Alex MarcusCordell, how you doing today? What's on your mind with ICIMS?
GuestYo, yo, yo, yo, Friday! No, no, I have, non-ISom stuff to discuss today.
Alex MarcusAlright, let's hear it.
GuestYeah, so realizing that you don't watch the news all that much, heads up for Sunday, you might have a little traffic problem throughout the boroughs. There's a marathon that's going on over there. Congratulations to, Angela. October 8th was a vacation day for me, and nothing better to do than watch the ICIMS, next. session that they had, and Angela was one of the featured… Presenters over there, so…
Alex MarcusAlright.
GuestNice, nice. to have a brush with fame over there. And then… recently in the news, now it may not be directly to Terry, so this is the Kevin Bacon game, that he's close enough to Cheesecake Factory. Cheesecake Factory's been in the news quite a bit, with a little bit of bantering between an ex-president and a current president, and for those who have been watching the news, I'm sure you know what I mean, but Terry, congratulations, I want to know how your marketing team does it.
GuestHave you seen the meme? The… the marketing guy, the cheesecake marketing guy's… Face on the day after. There's a meme running around, and it's this poor guy going. We have, over the last few years, have really changed. How our marketing is handled. Used to it was word of mouth only, and now we're… Using influencers and social media and, you know, our marketing department.
GuestI'm gonna say is not in… They've taken on a younger mentality on how to market the business, and they are having a… they're having a field day with this, and, you know, quite honestly, it's been a… it's been… been quite a big jump in, in our sales as well. People going and not wondering what to check out. People who've never been to Cheesecake Factory want to see what a Saddam Hussein's Cheesecake Factory looked like. So, it's been, it'll be good, it'll be good for our fourth quarter, investor report.
Alex MarcusWhat are we talking about? I have no idea what he's talking about.
GuestLook up, President Obama takes a dig. And Cheesecake Factory, and you'll see what we're talking about.
Alex MarcusOkay.
GuestYeah.
Alex MarcusWow.
GuestYeah, but ICIMS-wise, we're… we're, we're still… we're, like… one foot in ICIMS, one foot in, in 8-fold, and eventually we'll be moving over to 8-fold. there's… not a lot of stuff going on, although I guess I'm, fall release is coming out, we're in Wave 2 for that, so… I'll have to pay some attention to ICIMS. What's been the most surprising thing for you as you're going through the process of migrating from one system to the other?
GuestWell, so we haven't done the full migration yet. 8Fold has a… one of their modules is just called Talent Acquisition, but then they have another module which has, like, is a limited, a light version of talent acquisition, the ICIMS product, doesn't have everything in there, like, doesn't have offers in there, and some other stuff. And then they have this talent tracker module, which is their more full-scale, I guess, as full-scale as it's going to be for right now, ATS.
GuestAnd we're looking at implementing that Probably in mid… or starting to implement it, like, or finish it by the end of 2027. So, I haven't gotten into all of the ATS comparisons. What I dislike about the 8-fold, and some of it's kind of neat, is the… I… we have a lot of… Flexibility with iForms and… ICIMS. We… it has… like, zero flexibility in Eightfold. Basically, it is, here are your 10 different choices of what types of, items you can present on a form.
GuestYou can have a yes-no, you can have a text box, you can have a thumbs up, thumbs down, whatever it is, then you can write a question, and… you're just very limited. You can't pull in variables from one part of the system and pre-populate your form, and I think probably that's the… The worst thing about… Their feedback forms. Hmm. But, we're starting to use it a little more, and it is kind of… A little more user-friendly for the person who receives a feedback request, a thumbs up, thumbs down. It's… it's presented very nicely.
GuestAnd… We're doing minor modifications to be able to see our candidates in the different stages or statuses. Out of the box, it's… they're all lumped into one Grouping, and you can do a checkbox to just show different… statuses, so if I don't want to see everybody, I just want to see… I have filters, basically. I just want to see people who are in my screening stage. You have to do a check mark there, so we ask them to modify the view of applicants on a position, so that we could just click on a button and not have to go through filters. So… And where it's… It's a difference between, like, having the ability to do customizations and not having the abilities to do customization, so I'm a little bit stuck in that world, where it's nice with ICIMS, you know, there's pros and cons to each, there's more… Support, like, when you have to… maintain the product that has customizations. There's more stuff to maintain.
GuestBut there's less flexibility if you're in a, like, a SaaS product, but… Doesn't allow you to do a lot of that stuff. So that's all.
Alex MarcusIt's always a trade-off.
GuestYeah.
Alex MarcusYeah.
GuestAlright, did you find out the Cheesecake Factory, Alex?
Alex MarcusNot yet, I started to, I got over… I saw, like, a wall of memes in my brain, just couldn't handle it. more… more… more stuff than I can compute, but I'll look at it later.
GuestYeah.
Alex MarcusOh, thanks for the update, Cordell. Amanda! How you doing, Amanda? What's going on for you?
GuestOh, I'm actually struggling with a similar situation with the whole, FLSA versus hourly versus salary situation that was being discussed earlier, unless I misunderstood that topic, in which case I'm way off the page, and I need to just call it a day. So… A lot of… we've gotten a lot of upticks in our people, our users, entering in hourly rates for an exempt offer, and vice versa, and then that, you know, trickles down to. you know, improper pay, and people not getting their paychecks the right way once they get hired, and that sort of fun stuff. So, trying to work in some auditing and some… flags and that sort of thing. That's my… that's my career Friday.
Alex MarcusRight, that sounds like fun.
GuestWe have that exception report that Kaitlyn builds. She's not on the call today, but there's a, like, an offer exception report that she's mentioned, and I actually think if you search the SAI, board, it was originally one of your ideas, that we use pretty frequently, that could help you in this situation. It's just basically, like. $100,000 an hour, you know, like, in flags. That's wrong! So, yeah.
Guestcan't fix them not putting the information in correctly without CFL and all kinds of fun, which… Maintenance. Is it worth the, lift, is a call, but… You could also make the fields not required, and make them… fill them in in templates, and then hide, like, basically make them read-only, but that's the only other answer. Oh, that's assuming that we have any sort of consistency in our process. Come on, now! Which most people don't, you know? Yeah, it's a fun, fun, project to try to fix. I actually was trying to figure out how to not have to rework all of our offer templates and everything to incorporate some read-only fields based on So, okay, let me back up. What I did, I created a new field on the job profile that would, automatically pull in either hourly or annually based on the FLSA status.
GuestAnd then I used that new job field to be the pay frequency in the offer letters. well, in the new offer letters, and I'm trying to figure out how to incorporate that without redoing all of my offers, but it's probably gonna just take redoing all of the offer templates, but… Yep, that's what I'm doing today. Happy Halloween.
Alex MarcusSo, I've been… I… I was… we have a UKG call now, and Angela was on it, and one of the things that came up on the UKG call. was… UKG has a… what do they call it? BI something, Angela, where they keep all… customers can share reports that they put together?
GuestIt's a Cognos or Power… it's, Something like that. I know what you're talking about, I just don't know what it's called.
Alex MarcusOkay, yeah. BI library or something like that. I don't remember exactly what it was called, but it made me think that we should have something like that in SAI. And somebody else, I think it was Pamela, asked if there were some reporting things that folks could share. So I… put a post here, ICIMS reporting greatest hits, I pinned it on the side, and… I linked to the Notion page that we have, which is our own collection of reports we like to share with folks, with, let's see, is that gonna work? Yep, with screen grabs and everything. So if you want to share anything that you're particularly proud of.
Alex MarcusThis could become a nice resource for folks to see how other customers have set things up. Another call-out is, so as I mentioned, we have… Other vendor community events, we have one for Workday coming up, this will be our first one, November 5th. We've got another UKG one coming November 12th. And I think we've got an ADP one starting in December, so if you use ICIMS with one of those systems, please join us. Tell a colleague who might be interested.
Alex MarcusAnd we also have, we had our first Before You Sign call this week, or last week, and it was a very interesting conversation. We talked to a couple of folks who were looking at, switching vendors, and we talked through some of those dynamics. And we also have AI Study Club, which is an opportunity for all… talk about AI for wherever you happen to be in your AI journey. It's not, geared toward beginners or super advanced. We're really trying to make it accessible to everybody.
GuestThere's one more vendor spotlight that's not on that calendar just yet. On November 17th, we're doing a vendor spotlight with Faster, which is going to be one of the, ICIMS… sponsored preferred vendors for CRM. So they're actually actively in the process of working with ICIMS to build, their integration with ICIMS and their preferred vendor status. I don't actually 100% know what that means, but they will definitely explain it further, because they're very proud of it. But yeah, so we have a vendor spotlight on November 17th with Faster, and they're gonna be focusing their conversation on, internal mobility, and how their tool can help you with internal mobility.
GuestSo, more to come on.
Alex Marcus1117, Vivian? Great, thank you.
AnnouncementIf your organization uses an enterprise ATS and needs help getting more out of it, that's what we do at IRD. We help companies implement, optimize, and manage their recruiting technology from system administration to reporting and analytics. Our consultants work directly in these systems every day so we understand the practical challenges that come with keeping them running well. Learn more at integralrecruiting.com.”
Alex MarcusAlright, who else has a question today? Ben, welcome. Ben, what's going on for you? Any ICIMS questions? Ben, you're muted if you're there. Alright. Just listening is fine. Cheryl, what's going on in your world?
GuestLots of reporting still. I don't think I've touched ICIMS, like, the actual ATS or the platform in a very long time, and really done too much in there. It's just been a lot of reporting and building out Power BI dashboards and stuff, so… fun times! I kind of miss it.
Alex MarcusInteresting. So what is… what are you spending most of your time on now?
GuestStarting to get into intern conversions, using AI to… code for me a lot more. It's been so much faster, as I know you know. So, I've been able to do, like, intern conversions, I've been able to put a current, active. openings for a specific group. They wanted a dashboard so that they could see the health of all of their requisitions, meaning stages that they're in, candidates. Offers declined, things like that.
GuestIncluding, you know, how long the job's been open. So I put something like that together. I'm currently also working on, more intern reporting, since that is kind of, We just hired a whole bunch, so it's one of those… that program is starting to close out, so they're starting to think about, like. how to make their program better, and if they're getting the ROI that they want, and, you know, things like that. So it's been… it's been interesting, but good. I mean, like, I've been working on that for… Gosh, probably the whole time I've worked here.
Alex MarcusSo you're building custom dashboards with AI, or you're doing…
GuestSo I'm doing a couple things. I'm building… Power BI dashboards, and in order to build those BI dashboards, I am using AI to code to get me the data that I need. So, for an example, instead of pulling in all of our tables, it's just like, okay, I only need these fields, these tables, calculate this so I don't have to calculate it in Power BI. So when I go into Power BI, it's a lot less work, because the code is doing all of it.
Alex MarcusWell, and you don't have to wait for a BI resource.
GuestExactly.
Alex MarcusYeah, okay.
GuestSo fast, and so much better.
Alex MarcusThat is… that is really cool. And I know so many… so many folks in TA and HR are, like, at the back of the line for BI resources. If now, somebody who has your level of business process, workflow insight can actually build themselves, that's super cool. Yeah.
GuestOh, and trust me, I mean, I got hired for that, like, because I could do a lot of that, but at the same time, like, my coding skills were very elementary, so it was taking me a long time to code things, but now with Snowflake's AI, oh my gosh, you guys, love it. I mean, I still have to double-check everything and validate everything, but… that… that dashboard that I made, that health dashboard. The time they asked for it to the time I had it up and running and go live was about 2 months.
Alex MarcusWow.
GuestSo, to me, that…
Alex MarcusFantastic.
GuestVersus, you know, typically it probably would have taken me, like, 6 months to a year.
Alex MarcusYeah. Well, I actually… I had, Claude start timestamping things when using Claude code, because every time we'd… I would ask… I wanted to know how long it would take to do something, and every time it estimated it, the estimate was wildly off. And so I had to timestamp everything, and I asked it to analyze the chat history and compare its estimates to how long it actually took to do things. It was off by a factor of 7. Claude said something would take 7 hours, it actually took one. Which was interesting just for… working with Claude, but I think also it kind of points to, generally speaking, how much faster things can go. And you said 2 months as opposed to 6? That sounds… it's 3 times faster, it sounds about right, and as you continue to develop these skills, I think it'll… it will get faster and faster for you, too.
Alex MarcusSo what about auditing the results? So I've started… Vivian's finally got me into Reddit. I was allergic to it for a long time, but I found that the only place where my posts don't get flagged as spam, even though I wrote them myself, I write, like, AI, I guess, are, like, Claude and Vibecoding forums and whatnot. And so I'm posting some of my stuff that I'm working on in progress over there. And, you know, I usually… it's usually, like, 80% neutral to positive, and then 20% people just roasting me, and… telling me that I'm a complete amateur who knows… has no idea what he's doing. So I'm trying to grow a thick skin and learn, but, you know, the critics are all like, yeah, well, we'll see how this actually goes, and you don't know how to audit your results and whatnot, and… You know, I… for the record, I do audit my results, exhaustively, right? But what I'm trying to… to speak to is, like, how do you know, since this is… this is… You know, bleeding edge.
Alex Marcusfrontier sort of work that you're doing as a sysadmin, right, who was not trained as a BI expert, there are certainly going to be critics who are like, what does Cheryl think she's doing? Right? Whether they say it or not, right? So, like, how… I feel like the bar is even higher for folks in our professional demographic to demonstrate the rigor of what we're doing. So how are you… there's a long explanation. How are you approaching that? How are you demonstrating your ability to audit through the stuff that you're creating, and your… and how are you demonstrating… because, of course, I'm sure you're doing a fantastic job, but how do you communicate that rigor in a way that other folks will find credible?
GuestRight, so, unfortunately, I don't really have a good answer for you, because if you recall, I am actually the Talent Acquisition Data Analyst. So, with that title. comes expectations of knowing that I do this, and that I know how to do this. So when I build a lot of these things, the other expectation is that when I, for example, like, when I first started this job, was I need to… know SQL, or I need to understand SQL. So, as an example, our HR analysts want access to our TA data.
GuestAnd my question was, well, how are they going to access it? Are they going to access the tables directly? Are they going to be using it like AI? Because even in my own instance of using AI, and saying, hey, I'm connected to this table, and I name the specific tables, and I name exactly the keys, and I name everything that I need. if I don't name those things, it starts assuming. So it's like, oh, okay, well this… it starts going, great, you want last access date or something, and they assume that that name of the field exists, and it's like, no, that doesn't exist. Like, I… I called it that, but that's not really what the name is, and so it's one of those… even in, like, my own time using AI, if I'm not specific about how I want the code written, or how I want things to do, or how I want it to look, I have issues with the AI, so how do I validate it? I read the code.
GuestBecause I can read the code, and I know and I understand the code. So a lot of times, I will read the code to make sure it's doing exactly what I think it's doing. And then to validate my data, it's probably exactly what you do, right? Like, I'll go pull all the data, I'll pull the data out of ICIMS, I'll pull it out of the data lake, and I'll just, you know, manually do it in Excel or something, and go, okay, I should see this result. Am I getting that result in my Power BI? Am I getting that result in my data? So… I mean, most likely, your validation is probably like that, like myself, but… for myself, it's just more… I already have that one step up of, people are gonna believe me a lot more, because this is my job, and, you know, it's… it's… my title, or, you know, it was my title, but it's my title, so… Got it. It's a little bit different, right?
Alex MarcusYeah.
GuestBut even, like, when I talk about the HR analysts wanting to see… use the data and see the data, you know, the biggest thing I keep pushing back on is, okay, we need to curate the tables so that it's easy for them to use, it's easy for them to understand, it's easy for AI to access and read, because right now, the way our tables are… are out there is when you guys think about For example, if you think about a job, and it has a location, and that location may have, let's just say, a business unit that connects to another location profile, that connects to, you know, some data points within that profile.
GuestWe all know in ICIMS how it connects. In a database, like, it pretty much kind of connects like that. But someone outside of TA will have no clue that that's how it's connected, and that's where I get really protective of my data, and even right now, I'm struggling because I have to respond to HR analysts want access to my data, and do I want to give it to them? And I'm like, not right now, because I need to clean up my data. I need to make it accessible to them so it makes sense to them, so it's easy for them to just go. I need this data, and it all exists in one table, and they can find it.
GuestSo… That's kind of where I'm at in the process with AI and validation. But validation, honestly, like, in my head, I'm with you. It just… Most of us know to go pull the data, to maybe manually, you know, calculate this data, and then compare it to what our dashboard is showing.
Alex MarcusDamn.
GuestAnd understand… for me, it's more, I have to understand the SQL behind it, I have to understand what my dashboard is actually doing, so that If I need to fix it or explain it, I can. So, if you haven't done the… the lovely, I will ask So, Snowflake is Coco, so I will ask Coco, can you explain this section of code to me? Like, what is this exactly doing? I'm assuming it's doing this, like, what is it doing, right? Like, I go through that with… to understand exactly what it's doing, if it's adding something I've never seen before.
GuestHave you ever tried… I've done this, where if I'm kind of suspicious that it's… because even if you ask it to double-check, you know, someone gets confident, oh, I double-checked, it works. You know, have you ever tried taking that code, and then going to something like another model, and be like, hey, so I'm trying to do A, B, and C, give us a go. Yep, 100%, 100%. put it in and says, what say you? Are you catching anything? And I might even give it some anonymized, real data to, like, that's been an anonymized, of course, so they say, hey, can you… can you test the code on this? What do you get? And I like to see what it comes up. I get some interesting results. Sometimes it gets a little sassy, I mean, it reproduces, but I've noticed that sometimes it will catch, even suggest, some improvements, which I may or may not take. I mean, I agree with, but… I don't know, what's been your experience with that?
GuestOh, yeah, no, definitely. So, funny enough, I… my boss told me to name my co-pilot. It's okay. Copilot now has a name called Scout. Don't ask, I don't know. So, I only say this because this will make more sense. So, I take code from Coco, which is Snowflake, and I put it into Scout, which has Claude, and it has Claude, Opus. We don't have… I don't have Claude code, so I just have Claude Opus, so I do that.
GuestAnd I'll say, tell me what this code is doing, and if it makes sense, like, the response it gives me, or exactly what you said, I'll grab some data, I'll pull some data out of ICIMS, put it together maybe into an Excel spreadsheet, and say, hey, here's some data, this is the code that, you know, Coco wrote. does it… is it doing what I want it to do? Like, tell me what it's doing. Play devil's advocate. What is it not doing? What are the bad things about this code that I just wrote? I do that a lot to clean it up, because sometimes like, when AI will… build something, and I'm like, okay, why did you build it that way? That's gonna take forever to run. And it will even be like, oh, you're right, okay, let me rebuild it this way, and it's like.
GuestThen I go to Claude, and I say, is rebuilding it this way any better or worse? Like, how is this for Power BI? You know, smooth, like, it running and things like that, and… yes, back and forth sometimes, it's dumb, but it does help, because especially if you don't know… you don't understand the code, or you don't know what it's doing, or you don't know if that's the best route. Like, I don't know the best route for SQL programming, I can just read it. That's about it. So yes, I do that a lot, and I will intentionally even go into, like, incognito modes and ask again, and then go into another incognito mode and ask again, and just, like, ask it a couple times using different models, because with Copilot.
GuestI don't know if you guys have this, but, like, we have just Copilot, and then we can also use, like, ChatGPT, and we can also use Claude. So, like, I'll ask different things, and I'll just do it in incognito mode, so that it… and I'll tell it, like, do not look at any other, you know, any other chats. Focus on this one. And honestly, I get different answers all the time, but for the most part, if I'm asking it, like, is this good code, or does this code make sense? Is it there a better way to do this? most of the answers are the same, and so then I can go, okay, I feel better about this. But if it's… if it tells me flat out, like, oh, this is horrible code, because it has done that, it's funny, I agree with you, it is funny. And if I told Coco that, Coco would get very defensive about it.
GuestBecause I have done that. Like, Copilot didn't like your code. What about doing it this way? And he'll tell me, like, Copilot doesn't know what it's talking about.
Alex MarcusYeah. It's, this, this is, this is great.
GuestI love it!
Alex MarcusThis is really great AI literacy.
GuestRight?
Alex MarcusA lot of folks, I think that's… that's… as you… as you… as you develop in your AI skills, you start to realize that having… managing the context of the conversation is very important, whether that's going in incognito. Whether that is using multiple LLMs, I do that. I also… so it's… at a certain point, you start to feel like a human clipboard, passing conversations between LLMs, and so one of the things that I'm doing is I created a bridge via Slack. So, while Claude codes, it sends a message to Slack, ChatGPT picks it up, Slack, evaluates the code, passes it back through Slack over to Claude.
Alex MarcusNice. So, yeah, that's one way to kind of take… get me out of that human clipboard mode, so I can go take a walk or whatever, come back in an hour, and there's 47 messages where they've gone back and forth and eventually come up with the right solution.
GuestI wish I had that.
Alex MarcusYeah, yeah, yeah, that was… that was a fun one. Yeah, initially I had a bridge happening through, like, a message board on GitHub, but Slack was a lot… a lot easier. Yeah. Cool, thank you for sharing.
Guestdivert this, but I know we only have a few more minutes left. Out of curiosity of those on this call, is anybody else signed up for this early access to the new unified reporting tool? No. I am. Can you share about that, a little bit more about that? That sounds interesting. I just know that they… so a long time ago, I was told that if you have the CRM, and you know that there's that ad hoc reporting tool in there. that ICIMS, the ATS side, was eventually going to get a reporting tool similar to that, and it's a lot more robust and configurable and things like that, so it's just, like, a lot better reporting tool.
GuestI have no idea if that's what that is. I just know that I had said a long time ago, like, hey, yeah, I want to sign up for, you know, if you guys do any testing or you need feedback, I want to be part of that, and so I got… an email in regards to their unified reporting tool, so I was just wondering if anybody else is going through that, just to bounce some topics off of…
Alex MarcusCarrie, did you say you… something there?
GuestYeah, I went ahead and signed up for it as well, and my under… you know, one of my For 10 years, one of my biggest complaints to ICIMS has been siloed reporting. The lack of ability to do recruiting workflow with onboarding, and You know, and so that's what this is supposed to… Solve for is, in addition to a lot of enhancements, it's supposed to solve for the, siloed reporting issues.
GuestThis isn't just… So this isn't just limited to the CRM product, this is supposed to eventually… cut across all the modules and all the apps. Wow, that would… that is a… that would be… that would be a game changer. Including CRM, as far as I'm aware, also, yeah. Wow.
Alex MarcusWow, that's great. So this is a prototype, it's not active, or what's the status?
GuestYeah, it's just the early access to a prototype tool, I believe, in that we're supposed to give feedback. So, Terry, I may reach out to you and poke at you and see what you get, what kind of thoughts you get. Yeah, I'm looking forward to it, because, like I said, it's been the biggest pain for me in the siloed reporting. There we go. I agree.
Alex MarcusOh, that's great. Yeah, keep us posted. I'm really excited to see that.
GuestWill do.
Alex MarcusYeah. ICIMS… ICIMS reporting, it's… it's a learning curve. Let's see, Amanda said, is this the same as reports through… the… My sense is that this is something different.
GuestNo, if you… do you have CRM? We do, yeah. If you go to, the Reports tab in CRM, or CXM, I guess, You know how, if you want to build out reports. Not just look at their canned reports, I… I think that is Looker, don't get me wrong, I think that is part of Looker or something. It's like a BI tool. It… that's what I was told a long time ago, that eventually the ATS was going to move to, but it be unified, so… I'm… I have no idea what this looks like, so maybe wait until, you know, me or Terry finally get access to it to see it before I should, you know, put anything in writing, and so anybody listening to this call.
GuestPlease don't quote me on that. But no, that's what I was told a long time ago, was that The reporting was gonna go towards that more so, where you just are able to have more options and things like that, more control.
Alex MarcusThat's great. Yeah, thank you so much for sharing that. I'm excited to see what that looks like. Yeah.
GuestMe too.
Alex MarcusLast question, any of the ICIMS migration goblins biting anyone right now? We talked a lot about that last week. I reached out to Kyle, and she connected a few customers who had, mentioned it on this call. To… to a senior manager over there to discuss. Anybody else seem mysterious? Things popping up.
GuestMinus what I posted, nothing new on our end.
Alex MarcusOkay.
GuestYeah, I mean, it seems like, the… Whatever the infrastructure thing… issue that was happening about a month ago. they kind of quietly sorted out. I mean, they didn't come back and tell me exactly what it was. it may not even been them, it may have been something downstream with one of their other vendors, but seemed like a lot of it has cleared up. Not seeing the slowness or performance issues we were getting with filtering or reporting. At least, you know, knock on wood, it's not for now.
GuestSo, one issue that I am dealing with, initially, our onboarding portal, you know, where you have your branding company branding on the header and footer, that got wonky, like, it was not reading, so I thought it might be our job site. I opened the ticket, it got fixed. And it got same thing back again last week. So now I know for sure it's not us, it's somewhere ICIMS, so I don't know if anyone has experienced that.
Alex MarcusIt's, anybody seen that? Okay, I'll make a note and pass that on, Ben, thank you.
GuestYep.
Alex MarcusRight. All right, well, that's all the time we have for today. Hope you have a great weekend that is restful and restorative. If you have Halloween plans, kids with Halloween plans, hope you guys have fun, stay safe, and we'll see you here next week, same time, same place. Take care, everybody.
Administrators prepare for the ICIMS fall release, reviewing which changes are on by default: carousel enhancements that preserve bulk selections, the DocuSign auto-send update for offers, AI and AEDT consent defaults,...
This AI Study Club session opens with a question from a Reddit post: is pressure to use AI for everything wearing down HR professionals' critical thinking? Participants describe how AI has instead broadened their...
UKG admins share practical tips: using HTML in Event Studio to add links and images to new hire emails, building burst reports as email-style notifications, finding shared report code in BI Exchange, and using AI to...
SAI’s open forum covers practical ICIMS fixes from peer admins: flagging start date changes for onboarding teams, catching hourly vs. salary mismatches in offers, documenting connector quirks, and weighing in-app...
ICIMS admins and TA leaders swap takeaways from HR Tech, then dig into real-world fixes: tagging candidate source on event links, upgrading from CRM to CXM, getting faster answers from support cases, and running hiring...