In Merritt Island, Florida, the investigation into a set of stolen guns led deputies to the home of 50-year-old Gary Kenney. Inside, they found him lying in a pool of his own blood. What initially appeared to be a violent confrontation was only the beginning of a far more complicated story, one involving secret letters, long-held resentment, and questions about who was truly responsible for Gary’s death. Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1January 1st, 2014. A new show is born. Unlike anything else, it will go on to revolutionize true crime storytelling, immersing listeners into the horrors of reality. Its name? Sword and Scale. It's a show that can't be heard just once. Sword and Scale is not intended for all audiences. Let this be your one and only trigger warning. If you're sensitive, turn this off now.
Speaker 2That is, of course, the now late, great Stacey Keech.
Speaker 3Mr.
Speaker 2Keech brought grit, depth, and an unmistakable voice to more than six decades of stage and screen. From Mike Hammer in The Fat City to Shakespeare, his Golden Globe-winning Hemingway, of course, and the narration of American Greed, one of my favorite shows. Stacey's intro trigger warning has been a staple of this program since 2017. The familiar cadence is instantly recognized by any sword and scale fan, repeated hundreds
Speaker 2of times throughout the years. How utterly poetic that he should pass away this week, the week we announced the end of the show. Rest in peace, Stacy. Cheers to one of the best, a true original whose work will keep speaking for him.
Speaker 4I don't think nothing. You think that if I could have done anything... You could have.
Speaker 5You could have.
Speaker 4You could have. Dad, don't go back home, Dad. You're about to get your ass killed, Dad. Yeah, go home.
Speaker 6Go home.
Speaker 5Yeah, get mad.
Speaker 7Don't hit me.
Speaker 8I want you to find yourself in jail.
Speaker 2Welcome to the final season of Sword and Scale, episode 377. A show that reveals that the worst monsters... are real.
Speaker 2On the afternoon of June 16, 2008, a deputy with the Brevard County Sheriff's Office was investigating a burglary on Merritt Island, along Florida's Atlantic coast. Someone had stolen several firearms from an older couple's home. The guns actually belonged to a man named Gary Kenney, but he'd been storing them at his parents' house. Gary's parents reported the missing guns to police, but The investigating deputy still needed to
Speaker 2talk to Gary. Strangely, not long after Gary spoke with his parents, he stopped answering his phone. So, the deputy went to his house, hoping to speak with him in person. What he found when he got there turned a relatively routine investigation into something much more serious.
Speaker 7That's what they were on the way back to do.
Speaker 9A deputy sheriff happened to be at the house because he was investigating the burglary of the firearms from the grandparents' house.
Speaker 10The deputy walks up, looks in the door, the door's standing up, looks down, and there lays Gary.
Speaker 2Gary Brian Kenney was 50 years old. He worked as a welder at Kennedy Space Center and lived in Merritt Island, Florida, with his wife Sharon. They'd been married for roughly 25 years and had three children together. Daryl, Amanda, and Joshua. From the outside, the Kennys looked like a pretty typical middle-class American family. Don't they always? But when investigators looked more closely at Gary's life, it quickly became clear that
Speaker 2things inside the Kenny home were far more unsettling than they first appeared.
Speaker 4I don't know you guys.
Speaker 3You know, I'm sure the people in the neighborhood are probably shocked. Oh my God, they seem like such a nice family, for the most part.
Speaker 8Everybody's got their problems.
Speaker 5You always hear neighbors yelling once in a while.
Speaker 7No big deal.
Speaker 2Like most families, the Kennys had problems. For starters, Gary and Sharon's marriage was strained. According to their daughter, Amanda, the relationship could be volatile. She described her father as someone who could become angry and controlling. and recalled at least one argument where Gary physically grabbed Sharon. But when detectives asked Amanda if her father routinely beat or physically abused her mother, her answer was no.
Speaker 3Was your dad physically abusive to your mom? Did he beat your mom?
Speaker 11He didn't, but there were instances where, like one time we were putting up the Christmas lights and he yanked her across the floor because he got.
Speaker 3Angry, but Did he punch her that he slapped her?
Speaker 11No, he didn't ever hit her, but he would grab her, I guess.
Speaker 3Did she do the same thing to him if she got upset?
Speaker 12No.
Speaker 11Okay.
Speaker 2Amanda's own relationship with her dad wasn't without problems, but for all his faults, she described him as generally a good father.
Speaker 7I'm trying to.
Speaker 8Understand, because you're a very bright girl.
Speaker 3I'm trying to understand. You're saying your dad was pretty much a good dad. You didn't say he was abusive toward you. You know, he tried to give you money for you to, you know, get motivated in certain things he wanted you to get better at.
Speaker 8And parents do.
Speaker 3That, you know, they'll give kids money to all the grass, whatever, just to teach them life.
Speaker 7Lessons, okay?
Speaker 2Investigators also asked Amanda whether her father had ever abused her or touched her inappropriately. At the time, the question might have seemed somewhat out of place, but there was a reason why they were asking. one that would become important later. Amanda's answer, again, was no.
Speaker 3Him and your mom have tussled before, but he wasn't a chronically abusive person that beat her, slapped her, punched her, anything like that. He's never touched you inappropriately, even though your brother made an allegation kind of like that in a letter to us previously. Did he treat your little brother okay? Was he abusive and did he beat him to a pulp?
Speaker 5No. Okay.
Speaker 2Gary's relationship with his oldest son, Daryl, was considerably worse. In 2008, Daryl Kenny was only 22 years old, but he already had a lengthy criminal history and was serving time in prison. According to Amanda, Gary hadn't immediately given up on his son, but as Daryl continued getting into trouble, their relationship gradually deteriorated. Eventually, things reached a point where Gary no longer wanted Daryl coming back to the family home.
Speaker 12My brother had his own reasons for hating my dad because he didn't like the fact that my dad was pushing him away and was telling him that he wasn't allowed back at the house and he didn't like that we were having contact with him.
Speaker 11And he didn't like, he didn't, he didn't like that.
Speaker 12He doesn't, he doesn't really like being told what to do and he doesn't like really listening to authority, especially when it's not something that he likes to hear.
Speaker 2Whatever problems existed between them had reached the point where Gary had essentially cut his oldest son out of his life. But Sharon had not. While Daryl was incarcerated, his mom continued communicating with him. And because Gary didn't want her having contact with their son, Sharon went out of her way to make sure he never knew about it. Typical doting mom excusing all bad behavior for her little baby.
Speaker 8First of all, did you correspond with him at the prison?
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 8Okay, how did you correspond with him?
Speaker 13In letters.
Speaker 7In letters, okay.
Speaker 8And when you wrote the letters, where did you mail them from? From your house, from a post office, from somebody else's house, what?
Speaker 7From the post office.
Speaker 8Okay, and when you received the letters, where did you receive them at?
Speaker 14An extra neighbor's house.
Speaker 8Okay, and what is that address?
Speaker 2Daryl's letters to his mother weren't being sent to the Kenny home. Instead, Sharon had them delivered to a neighbor's house, where she could receive them without Gary knowing.
Speaker 7Why did you feel it necessary to do that?
Speaker 4Because I didn't think Gary would.
Speaker 11Well, I knew Gary wouldn't want me communicating with him because Gary.
Speaker 7Lost his hands at Daryl. See, that right there is the stuff I need to know about.
Speaker 9Gary was controlling to the point that he wouldn't even allow you to get mail.
Speaker 4He wouldn't even talk about him.
Speaker 7I wasn't allowed to talk to Gary about my feelings towards what was.
Speaker 4Going on with Carol.
Speaker 9So you had to sneak around behind Gary's back just to communicate with your own child.
Speaker 7Is that correct?
Speaker 12Yes.
Speaker 8And how did that make you feel, Sharon?
Speaker 4I just wish they could have talked to me more about it.
Speaker 2Sharon told detectives that Gary didn't want her communicating. with their son. So she did it behind his back.
Speaker 13Of course. Of course.
Speaker 2Then, on June 12, 2008, Daryl was released from prison. Three days later was Father's Day. That day, Gary met his parents at a barbecue restaurant. They ate lunch, ran into some people they knew from church, and Gary gave his father a Father's Day gift. There was nothing particularly remarkable about the afternoon. Nothing that would have given Gary's parents any reason to believe they'd remember it for the rest of their lives. The next day, Gary's mother went
Speaker 2into a closet at her home and noticed something strange. Several guns were missing. Gary's guns. He'd been storing them at his parents' house for quite some time. Gary's parents called their son and asked if he'd taken the guns. He told them no and instructed them to call police. When a deputy arrived at Gary's parents' house, he was given the serial numbers for the missing firearms. For the deputy,
Speaker 2the next step was to speak with Gary directly. But now, Gary wasn't answering his phone. Investigators later determined that one of the last people to have seen Gary that day was his daughter, Amanda.
Speaker 4You see your dad going to the house.
Speaker 3He even stops to have a conversation with you, asking you, come back to the house, it's.
Speaker 4Raining for whatever reason.
Speaker 8Okay, dad, whatever.
Speaker 4He goes back, and you leave with your brother.
Speaker 11I understand how that looks.
Speaker 2Unable to reach Gary by phone, a deputy got into his patrol car and drove to Gary's house. What he found there would transform an investigation into missing guns into a homicide case that would ultimately take about a decade to resolve.
Speaker 7That's what they were on the way back to do.
Speaker 9A deputy sheriff happened to be at the house because he was investigating the burglary of the firearms from the grandparents' house.
Speaker 10The deputy walks up, looks in the door, the door's standing on a loose door, and there lays Gary.
Speaker 7Shot to death. He calls for help. Two or three deputies standing out front now. They look up.
Speaker 10Here comes Gary's truck.
Speaker 7Down the road.
Speaker 2Gary Kenney was found lying inside the house in a pool of his own blood. He'd been shot multiple times. There were also several injuries to his wrist and neck. Less than 24 hours earlier, Gary had been eating a Father's Day lunch with his parents. Now he was dead, inside his own home. The deputy had gone there looking for information about some stolen guns, and instead he found a murder. As more deputies started arriving at the scene,
Speaker 2they looked down the road and saw a vehicle coming towards him. It was Gary's truck, and behind the wheel was the man who had just murdered him. you On
Speaker 2June 16, 2008, 50-year-old Gary Kenney was found murdered inside his home on Merritt Island, Florida. Gary had been shot multiple times. He also had several injuries to his wrist and neck. But a gruesome homicide wasn't what initially brought law enforcement there that day. Several firearms belonging to Gary had been reported stolen from his parents' house. Later that day, a deputy went to Gary's home hoping to speak with him about the weapons. Instead, he found Gary lying in
Speaker 2a pool of his own blood. As more deputies started arriving at the scene, the investigation took another unexpected turn. Gary's truck suddenly appeared at the end of the street.
Speaker 7He calls for help. Two or three deputies standing out front now. They look up.
Speaker 10Here comes Gary's truck down.
Speaker 9The road with Daryl behind the wheel and a room-and-riding shotgun.
Speaker 2The man driving the truck was Gary's 22-year-old son. The fuck-up, Daryl Kenney. Sitting beside him was Daryl's friend, a young man named Reuben Nero. Deputies tried to stop the truck, but Daryl took off. Eventually, both men were apprehended. Gary was dead inside his home. His son had just fled the scene in his truck with another man in the passenger seat. Investigators needed to find out what the two
Speaker 2of them knew about the murder and what the hell they were doing there. Daryl and Ruben were taken in for questioning. During his interview with detectives, Daryl didn't waste any time getting to the point. He admitted that he had shot and killed his own father.
Speaker 15Look, everybody that sat on that jury has been through some of the things that you've been through.
Speaker 13Or they've had loved ones that's been through it.
Speaker 14So what, was Cleve not guilty until your trial?
Speaker 13I can't tell you completely.
Speaker 16I just want you to help me understand why you felt it necessary to kill your father. Was it to protect your mother and your sister? Or were you, are you just a go-to killer?
Speaker 2According to Darrell, he killed his father because he believed He was protecting his mother and sister. Gary and Daryl already had a difficult relationship. Gary had essentially cut his oldest son out of his life and told his wife to stop communicating with him. But Daryl claimed there was more to his anger than that. He accused his father of mistreating his family and said he felt he needed to confront him. Ah, the eldest boy... defeats his father
Speaker 2to become a man. That's how really dumb, really poorly adjusted people think, by the way. Maybe listen to your father. He has more experience than you, you dumb, jail-destined piece of fucking garbage. Nah, nah, nah. But why do that when you can just be violent? You know? Daryl had only been out of prison for four days when he decided to go to his father's house and murder him But he didn't go alone. He went with some other
Speaker 2dipshit that the Democrats let out of prison too early.
Speaker 13You met Ruben in prison, right? Mm-hmm. And how did y'all hook up today? Was he already down here with you?
Speaker 7No, I went with him.
Speaker 13A couple of weeks' days in Latham.
Speaker 7And picked him up.
Speaker 13And then y'all went to Ocala, correct?
Speaker 17Mm-hmm.
Speaker 13And then y'all left Ocala and came back here.
Speaker 18Mm-hmm.
Speaker 13What was the purpose of that?
Speaker 19Just to get your dad's truck back to him, or did you have a mind made up that he was going to have to do this today?
Speaker 7I made up my mind that I was going to have to do it if she predicted it.
Speaker 13At this point, I felt like I had.
Speaker 3To do it.
Speaker 220-year-old Ruben Nero had been incarcerated with Daryl and had only recently gotten out of prison. Because fuck law and order, right? Fucking communists. Anyway, according to Daryl, the plan wasn't necessarily to kill his father. He claimed he only wanted to confront Gary about the way he believed his family had been mistreated. But Daryl was armed, and so was Reuben. On the morning of June 16, 2008, the two men
Speaker 2drove to Gary's house. When they arrived, Gary saw them and walked outside.
Speaker 13Y'all go inside the house and your dad's already there?
Speaker 14No, he came out starting this.
Speaker 13Oh, so he's seen y'all drive up?
Speaker 11Mm-hmm.
Speaker 13So what does he say?
Speaker 14He walked out the front door about six feet.
Speaker 13As far as he got. And did you pull the gun on Dan? That's what made him go back in?
Speaker 2Darryl pointed a handgun at his father and forced him back inside. Reuben followed, carrying a 12-gauge shotgun. Gary was now inside his own home with two armed men, one of whom was his estranged son. When Gary moved towards the kitchen, Darryl stopped him.
Speaker 13Where was your dad at in the house?
Speaker 14Not yet.
Speaker 20Sorry, I had to Daryl ordered Gary around, telling him where to go and when he could speak.
Speaker 7Reuben stood nearby, shotgun in hand, like a.
Speaker 13Good little soldier.
Speaker 2Around, telling him where to go and when he could speak. Reuben stood nearby, shotgun in hand, like a good little soldier. Daryl had finally gotten the confrontation he claimed he wanted. His father couldn't leave. He couldn't call police. He had no choice but to listen. But according to Daryl, Gary didn't argue. Instead, he apologized.
Speaker 5Do you want them back in the house?
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 21When the warehouse lit up, when I got by the bushes, he moved and got out.
Speaker 13With his shotgun. Okay.
Speaker 7He called up to me.
Speaker 14By the time I was at the door, he was already right behind.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 14Gary starts walking as if he's going to grab a phone.
Speaker 21So I said, no, it's still not him. He sat down and climbed. He posted up on the other side by the TV, had the shotgun level.
Speaker 13So I ran. I loaded a gun. I loaded a pistol.
Speaker 7So we're going to talk.
Speaker 21I think he said, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I said, no, that's not what I want to hear. I want to hear you talk.
Speaker 2Daryl told investigators that Gary sat in a chair and started to pray. Then at some point, Gary tried to stand back up. Reuben responded with the shotgun.
Speaker 14He said, I'm sorry. I started to pray.
Speaker 7He was down on his knees?
Speaker 5No.
Speaker 21Ruben struck Gary in the head. What happened over the next few seconds would become one of the.
Speaker 3Most important parts of the investigation because, according to Daryl's own account.
Speaker 5His father was not attacking him.
Speaker 8When Daryl.
Speaker 2Pulled the trigger. Gary was simply trying to leave.
Speaker 21He sat right down, got up again. He walked by me. I don't know why he did it. He stopped and looked that out, took a step. By the time I got the safety off, he'd already turned his back and I didn't even see it. I don't know why, but I don't know why I pulled the trigger several times.
Speaker 5What was your dad doing? What was he heading out to do?
Speaker 13That was where he was originally going.
Speaker 21When he stopped, Darrell fired multiple times, shooting his father in.
Speaker 14The back as he tried to leave.
Speaker 2Gary collapsed near the front of the house. Less than 24 hours earlier, he had been eating a Father's Day lunch with his parents. Now inside the home where he'd raised his children, Gary Kenney had been shot to death by his oldest son. But the gunshot wounds weren't the only injuries investigators found on Gary's body. There were also cuts to his wrist and neck. And when detectives compared Daryl's account of those injuries with what Ruben had told them,
Speaker 2the two stories didn't match.
Speaker 3Ruben's saying that you shot him. Ruben's saying that he was standing near the front door. I'm just telling you what he said. He's telling you what he said. Is the TV near the front door?
Speaker 14No, the TV's on the other side of the car.
Speaker 3Well, he's saying that when you shot him, your dad started falling toward him. He threw your dad off and he ran outside and.
Speaker 7Got in the truck.
Speaker 5You got in the truck, said, you know what, I think he's still alive.
Speaker 3You went back in there, and then you came back out and you had a knife.
Speaker 5I'm just telling you what he said, bro.
Speaker 13I've got a question.
Speaker 14If that's the case, I'm going to let.
Speaker 7Him talk to us.
Speaker 2Rubin's version suggested that Daryl's attack on his father didn't end with the shooting. According to him, the violence continued. Only this time, Daryl allegedly used a knife. Darryl disputed that account, but Reuben insisted it was true.
Speaker 15The one thing I can't understand is why we were pushing to do that. No.
Speaker 13Why did you cut his wrist? I did not cut that man's wrist. I did not cut that man's wrist at all. I didn't touch that man's wrist at all. Where did Darryl get the knife from?
Speaker 7Out of his house.
Speaker 13Out of the kitchen? Out of the kitchen.
Speaker 14He was liking some skinny shit.
Speaker 7Then he had some big shit.
Speaker 14He had a butcher knife and a knife. Ruben was adamant that he never touched Gary.
Speaker 7With a knife.
Speaker 16But when detectives asked Daryl about those same injuries, he told them.
Speaker 13A very different story.
Speaker 2He pointed the finger directly at Ruben. Well, you look at that. No honor amongst thieves or murderers yet again.
Speaker 13He asked for a.
Speaker 14Knife and I handed it to him.
Speaker 5Okay, well, you said there's two knives. Why are there two knives?
Speaker 14Because when we went back, he told me I ain't got another one. I said, oh, he's still breathing.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 14I didn't catch him grabbing another knife because he seen me grab the first one.
Speaker 4What did you do with the knife that you grabbed?
Speaker 7I handed it to him with the first number.
Speaker 5And what did he do with that knife? What did you see him do with that knife?
Speaker 7I was still in the kitchen.
Speaker 13I walked back.
Speaker 14He cut his wrist.
Speaker 5You saw him cut.
Speaker 7Your father's wrist?
Speaker 14He also took another one and stabbed him in the neck.
Speaker 2Garrow claimed that Rubin cut Gary's wrist and then stabbed him in the neck. Rubin insisted that never happened. Clearly, someone wasn't telling the truth, and detectives seemed to have a suspicion as to who that might be. If Ruben was responsible for those injuries, then there was only one question.
Speaker 3Why?
Speaker 2He had only recently met Gary. He had no personal relationship with him. He had no history. No reason to hold a grudge. But you know who did? Yeah, the other guy in the room. Daryl, the idiot. The coddled-by-mommy fuck-up.
Speaker 3What beef does Ruben got with your dad to get that personal with him after you already shot him dead? What does he got to gain by this shit? The murder already went down. Your dad was dead, man. Your dad was dead, okay? And we know this, because when you cut a man, he bleeds. When he don't bleed, his heart stopped. Your dad was already dead. So what personal matter does Ruben got with your dad to do
Speaker 3something that personal and cut the man's wrists.
Speaker 4It don't make any sense. I would have just put a cap on his ass.
Speaker 5And he had a shotgun. Why didn't he just blow his fucking head off?
Speaker 14Because the safety was on. He never went back out of the truck to grab him. That's the only reason why. Because he tried to pull the trigger.
Speaker 5Now you're saying that he tried to.
Speaker 7Shoot your dad.
Speaker 2Detectives weren't convinced that Daryl had told them everything that happened inside the house. They were also skeptical of his claim he'd gone there simply hoping to talk to his father. And the skepticism escalated didn't come from nowhere. Investigators had already spoken with Daryl's sister, Amanda. According to her, Daryl had told her a couple of days before the murder that he intended to kill their father. When detectives confronted Daryl with what his sister had told them, he denied ever making that threat. But there was one part of
Speaker 2her story that he didn't deny.
Speaker 7I'll tell you a story.
Speaker 18And she told me that You had told her a little bit ago, a few days ago, that you were going to kill your dad. And that yesterday you talked to her and you told her she needed to stay away from the house.
Speaker 7Between this time and this time.
Speaker 21Darryl claimed he warned Amanda because he knew the confrontation with Gary could turn violent.
Speaker 2But whatever he expected to happen that day, by the time he and Reuben left Gary's house, his father was dead. The two men took Gary's truck and drove to a local mall where they met Amanda and Daryl's mother, Sharon.
Speaker 16So after the shooting, you and Reuben leave and go to the mall and meet your mom and sister and little brother and father-in-law.
Speaker 7You tell your mama what happened. Just want to go back to the hospital a little bit. What'd she say?
Speaker 13Well, I said, don't ask. Don't worry about it. But then y'all left the mall.
Speaker 2Ruben remembered meeting Daryl's family at the mall that day. According to him, Daryl didn't immediately tell Sharon that he had killed Gary. He simply told her that the situation had been handled. When Sharon realized what that meant, Ruben said she started to cry. But Gary's body was still inside the house, and according to Ruben, Sharon told them to go back and clean up. Go clean up what you did. Go clean your room. If only she'd done
Speaker 2that years prior, you know? A little discipline. A little structure, you know? So Daryl and Reuben got back into Gary's truck and headed towards the house. But when they got near it, they saw something they had not expected. Sheriff's deputies were already there. What Daryl and Reuben didn't know... was a lot. But one thing in particular was that the investigation into Gary's stolen guns had led law enforcement
Speaker 2directly to his home. By the time the two men returned, Gary's body had already been discovered. That's when the truck appears at the end of the street.
Speaker 19He was coming back to the house. So we're going to try to move the body then. That's when the police was there. So then y'all try to get away from the police. The police chased you.
Speaker 2Daryl tried to get away. Deputies pursued the truck until he eventually abandoned it and ran. His attempt to escape didn't last long. Within hours of Gary's body being discovered, Daryl and Ruben Nero were both in custody. But detectives still weren't satisfied with Daryl's explanation for why any of this had happened. He continued to portray the murder as a confrontation that spiraled out of control. According to Daryl, he went to the house to talk. He brought a
Speaker 2gun because he believed he might need it. And he fired because in that moment he thought Gary might come after him. Always playing the victim, these fucking clowns. Who takes a gun to a conversation? Detectives, of course, who were no dummies, saw it differently. Daryl knew his father was unlikely to have a gun because he was the person who had stolen Gary's firearms to begin with. He was holding them in his hands. So why would his
Speaker 2father be armed? He also knew that his mother, sister, and younger brother wouldn't be there. He had this all planned.
Speaker 3The thing is, you knew those guns were in your grandparents' house.
Speaker 8You stole them guns from there.
Speaker 3You knew your dad was unarmed. You knew he was unarmed because all the weapons were in your grandparents' house. So you went to a confrontation to the man's castle, because you don't live there no more, to the man's castle when your mom and sister and brother are not there, knowing they're not there, to confront the man armed. You know, let's end this conversation now. But let me tell you a little story, okay? I don't buy your bullshit. You were mad at your dad and you went there Fucking
Speaker 3kill him.
Speaker 14Bottom line.
Speaker 4You knew your mom was not there.
Speaker 3You knew your sister wasn't there. You warned your sister not to be there. You know what kind of man your dad was. You knew it was going to come down to this.
Speaker 2From the detective's perspective, this wasn't a conversation that unexpectedly turned deadly. He believed Daryl had gone to the house intending to kill his father. But even if that were true, neither version explains something fundamental. Daryl had only been out of prison for four days. Gary hadn't spoken to him in years, so why did Daryl suddenly decide that on June 16th, that was the day he needed to go confront his father? Why did any of this have to
Speaker 2happen at all? Why not simply stay away from him and go live your own life?
Speaker 4You know, if you want to talk to your dad... You want to force your dad to talk to him.
Speaker 14Because that's the only way he's going to talk to me. Without playing him.
Speaker 3Why was it such a need to talk to him? Why did it have to happen today? And why did you have to force him to talk to you today? The man ain't talked to you in two years. Why couldn't you let him rest?
Speaker 4Move on. Get yourself a job. Strain yourself up.
Speaker 5I'm just saying.
Speaker 7I'm sorry.
Speaker 4I raised my voice. You just got out.
Speaker 8Got yourself a job.
Speaker 3Gotten your life straight, and maybe in the future you could have had a relationship with your dad.
Speaker 4And you even want to want. I don't know if you want to want. Based on what you're telling us that he did all his life, I don't know why.
Speaker 5You would want a relationship with him.
Speaker 4But let's say you did.
Speaker 7Why not let her?
Speaker 4So you killed a man?
Speaker 3Why didn't you let her ride for a year or two? Maybe if he would have seen that you changed your life around, got a job, and you were trying to do better, maybe he'd open up to you. But see, you would never know that now. But I'm saying, why didn't you make that decision back then? Why say, I'm going to confront my dad if they want? Why didn't you just say, let me leave it at that. Let me just try to make my life straight.
Speaker 14It wasn't my idea.
Speaker 7To move on.
Speaker 2Daryl claimed the murder wasn't his idea. Until that moment, he had described Gary's murder as something driven by his own anger and desire to protect his family. He was the one who picked up Ruben. He was the one who went to Gary's house. He was the one who pulled the trigger and fired the shots that killed his father. Now, Daryl was suggesting there was someone else behind all of this. But during this interview, he never explained exactly what he meant.
Speaker 2Daryl was later charged with first-degree murder. And more than two years later, on October of 2010, he was tried, convicted... and sentenced to life in prison. But the investigation into Gary's death was not over. Weeks after his conviction, Darrell contacted the sheriff's office and sat down with investigators again. This time, he was ready to tell them more about
Speaker 2the person he claimed had been involved in planning his father's murder.
Speaker 7Did you and she ever have conversations?
Speaker 9About you murdering Gary King.
Speaker 14Correct.
Speaker 7Tell me about that conversation, or those conversations. First of all, when and where?
Speaker 6Where, I don't exactly remember, and I don't exactly remember when.
Speaker 14I just know it was within, it was Friday or Saturday.
Speaker 6We had met up, and we had talked about disposing of the body.
Speaker 14We had talked about murdering my dad.
Speaker 2Before Gary was murdered, Daryl had discussed killing his father and disposing of his body with someone else. A woman, believe it or not. The infallible female. But who was she? And what role had she actually played in Gary Kenney's murder?
Speaker 2In June of 2008, homicide investigators with the Brevard County Sheriff's Office in Merritt Island, Florida, were investigating the murder of 50-year-old Gary Kenney. Before Gary was murdered, his son Daryl had been discussing killing him and disposing of his body with someone else. A woman. But wait, women are wonderful creatures. They never do anything wrong. Well, As it happens, there was at least one woman close to Daryl whose
Speaker 2actions that day were difficult to understand. Daryl's sister and Gary's daughter, Amanda.
Speaker 3So then I'm trying to figure out why your brother would want to kill him and you would know that your brother.
Speaker 4Was intending on doing that.
Speaker 5And you even said it out of your own mouth.
Speaker 3I didn't want to believe it was true, but in my heart I felt he was going to do it.
Speaker 4And he even told you to be out of the house on this day.
Speaker 12I said logically I thought he was going to do it, but emotionally I didn't think it was going to happen.
Speaker 3Well, logically I think it's more important than emotionally.
Speaker 12You really don't ever expect that anything like this is ever going to happen.
Speaker 2Amanda had seen her father shortly before he was murdered. Gary stopped and spoke to her before heading home. Amanda knew Daryl had threatened to kill him. She knew her brother had specifically told her not to be there. But still, she said nothing.
Speaker 3And you leave to make sure that nobody's in the house during the time frame that your brother said clear out.
Speaker 7Of the house.
Speaker 11I understand how that looks, but I did never want in my.
Speaker 3And your brother, you see your dad going to the house. He even stops to have a conversation with you. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 4And you knew it was going to happen because you even told him he needed to go see his mom for whatever reason. A part of you was saying, Dad, please get out. You're about to get killed.
Speaker 3And you, let's face it, Amanda, you let him go to his death.
Speaker 11You don't think that every day I think about what I could have done differently.
Speaker 3But my question to you is, did you know you knew about it?
Speaker 4Your brother told you.
Speaker 8I believed.
Speaker 11That you are taking things and you are twisting them.
Speaker 4Out of context?
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2Amanda insisted detectives were twisting her words. She had already explained that while she understood what Daryl had threatened to do, she never truly believed her brother would go through with it. How many times have you heard that before? Now detectives were treating that failure to believe him as something much more sinister.
Speaker 11I would appreciate it if you wouldn't treat me like you're treating.
Speaker 12Me and talk to me like you're talking to me.
Speaker 5I'm talking to you straight up like an adult, like someone should have.
Speaker 3Been talking to you a while ago. You were saying I took it out of context, right? You're saying I was taking things out of context?
Speaker 8You're right here. Black and white.
Speaker 5Okay? Let's go.
Speaker 2The evidence detectives were referring to included boxes of letters. Letters written while Darryl was in prison. But they weren't letters between Darryl and Amanda. They were letters between Darryl and his mother, Sharon Kenny.
Speaker 3I really wish you would go away forever and never come back if you know what I mean.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's better. And she painted your dad out to be a monster. I don't like the way Dad is treating you, and I'm going to do something about it when I get out.
Speaker 3What did Gary do to you that was so wrong if I don't have nothing done about it? I guess I will have to get gangster when I get out.
Speaker 4Don't worry, I will take care of it when I get out.
Speaker 2Suddenly, the warning Daryl had given Amanda wasn't the only conversation that had taken place before Gary was killed. For years, Sharon had secretly communicated with her son while he was incarcerated. Against the wishes of her husband The man who was now dead Gary wanted nothing to do with Daryl He didn't want him at the house He didn't want Sharon communicating with him So Sharon had the letters delivered to a neighbor Like a sneaky little sneak According to investigators
Speaker 2What started as a way for a mother To secretly remain in contact with her Incarcerated fuck-up son Eventually became something else Entirely Check out the lack of accountability on this broad.
Speaker 4No, this was pre-planned, premeditated murder.
Speaker 7You're a smart girl.
Speaker 3You know, you've heard about this stuff. Your brother is going to die one way or the other. And your mom was going to go off and have a happy little life. Get life insurance. Your mom called about life insurance an hour and a half after we talked to her the other night.
Speaker 4Do you find that a little bit unusual?
Speaker 11It's because... That lady came over and told her we had to do it.
Speaker 3Your father is not even in the ground yet, and you're calling about life insurance an hour and a half after being interrogated?
Speaker 11It's not... I understand how... I don't know.
Speaker 4How things look. You don't seem very shocked.
Speaker 3I just told you, and I just showed you stuff, and I've been showing you all day.
Speaker 4How your mom.
Speaker 3I don't... Planned with your brother to kill your father.
Speaker 13Because.
Speaker 11I really think that you don't know any of us. So you don't know how, I don't know, how she really felt or what really, I don't.
Speaker 2Amanda wasn't being accused of writing those letters. She wasn't the person detectives believed had devised the plan to kill Gary. But investigators were convinced she knew far more about what happened among her family members than she was willing to admit.
Speaker 3Your mom knew about Monday and your mom made sure, it's not a coincidence, honey, that your mom was not at the house either and made sure that she was out of the house when your dad was murdered.
Speaker 4And it wasn't even good enough to shoot your dad.
Speaker 3That wasn't even good enough.
Speaker 4That didn't even satisfy.
Speaker 3And I don't even want to tell you what Darryl finished doing to your dad, because it'd be inappropriate.
Speaker 4Your dad was gonna be alligator chum, okay? Your brother and his buddy just never got back in time to do that.
Speaker 3It was just coincidence that a deputy happened to go to your dad's house, because he was investigating the stolen guns, the same gun your brother used to assassinate your dad, when he found.
Speaker 8Your dad dead.
Speaker 3Your mom would have reported him missing like she didn't know what.
Speaker 4Happened to him. I don't know what happened to Gary.
Speaker 3I went to work that morning, took my kids to go take a haircut, and when I got back, he ain't there.
Speaker 4And everyone would have been fooled. Everyone would have been like dummies, especially Gary's family. Oh, my God, how could Gary just disappear? Something happened to him? And the whole time your mom knew about it. That was the plan.
Speaker 11Why'd you take me here?
Speaker 4Because I want to know how.
Speaker 22Much you truly know about what happened to your father. I want to know because I know you knew that your mom was involved in this.
Speaker 2The investigators had a theory. Gary would disappear. His body would be removed from the house and Sharon would eventually report her husband missing. Instead, A deputy investigating Gary's stolen guns unexpectedly arrived at the house and found his body before Daryl and Ruben could return and hide it But Amanda wasn't willing to accept the detective's version of what her mother had done How could she? Women are perfect, after all More importantly, she wasn't willing to accept that
Speaker 2she was somehow responsible for failing to save her father How could she be responsible for anything, really?
Speaker 4She's a woman They have your name on these freaking letters.
Speaker 3Amanda better realize she's in this with us.
Speaker 4What does that mean?
Speaker 11You think that this is something.
Speaker 8You think... Take me.
Speaker 4Tell me how I took that out of context.
Speaker 3Amanda better be in this because she's in it whether she wants to believe it or not, Mom.
Speaker 11I think that it's not bad enough that I'm never going to see you again, but you think that I had something.
Speaker 7To do with it.
Speaker 4Oh, you don't take no responsibility? I didn't do anything. I really didn't. Dad, Daryl's about to kill your ass, Dad. Dad, you better not go home. Daryl's going to smoke you. Daryl stole some guns, and he's coming over here, and he's going to kill you, Dad. You better not go home.
Speaker 7I like it when their voice goes all the way up.
Speaker 3Like three octaves, as they desperately try to squirm their way out of accountability for.
Speaker 4Their own actions.
Speaker 2Or inactions, in this case, I should say. Amanda left the interview room furious, but the investigator's focus was increasingly turning away from Amanda and towards another member of the Kenney family. Sharon. Just over a year after Gary's murder, detectives went to see her son Daryl in jail. By then, their investigation had expanded beyond the two men who had entered Gary's house armed with guns. They wanted to know
Speaker 2what had happened before Darrell had ever showed up at his father's door. Specifically, they wanted to know about his mother.
Speaker 15We both understand and we both know why it is you were charged with this particular crime. The reason that I want to speak to you today, however, is not regarding your involvement. in the investigation against your father, but rather the potential involvement of your mother, who is known as Sharon Kinney.
Speaker 13Is Sharon Kinney.
Speaker 7Indeed your mother?
Speaker 12Yes.
Speaker 15During the course of my investigation, I have uncovered several items of evidence that lead me to believe that.
Speaker 13Your mother, Sharon Kinney, has some direct.
Speaker 7Involvement in the.
Speaker 15planning and potential facilitation of the murder of her husband, your father, Gary. I wanted to speak to you today to determine if you would be willing to provide some information regarding my beliefs. So I'm going to ask you some questions and we'll go from there. Did your mother intend or entice you to potentially do harm to your father once.
Speaker 7You got out of jail?
Speaker 2Daryl told detectives that the idea of harming his father had been planted in his head through the letters Sharon sent him in prison. But at the time, he wasn't prepared to tell them anything. That changed after he was convicted of his father's murder. When Daryl sat down with investigators again, they asked him a much more direct question.
Speaker 7Prior to the murder, you were in state prison.
Speaker 3Correct.
Speaker 7On unrelated charges.
Speaker 14Correct.
Speaker 9And you and your mother corresponded with each other via mail only.
Speaker 3Correct.
Speaker 7We've gone through these letters. Some of them are dated. Some of them are not. So as we go through this.
Speaker 9Interview here, we're going to be categorizing some letters and things of that nature. There are portions of these letters that contain information that incriminates Sharon Kinney. It's the belief of myself and Agent Battagliano that prior to the murder of Gary Kinney, that you and Sharon Kinney conspired or came up with a plan to kill Gary Kinney.
Speaker 13Is that true?
Speaker 14Correct.
Speaker 2According to Darrell, he and his mother had conspired to kill Gary. But If detectives were going to understand how a son could reach the point where he was willing to murder his own father, they first needed to understand what Sharon had been telling him. While Daryl was in prison, Sharon described a home that she said had become unbearable. She portrayed Gary as angry and controlling. Some of these allegations went even further. And if you believe them, You're
Speaker 2putting your faith in someone who gets rid of their problems by getting rid of people. So, there's that.
Speaker 9Some of the letters, some of the things that Sharon would write to you was that Gary was molesting your younger sister, Amanda.
Speaker 13Yes.
Speaker 9Do you have any reason to believe that molestation actually occurred?
Speaker 14As of now, I believe it was all a lie.
Speaker 20I believe she was just using me to get to her own means because she felt that there was no way for her to actually get out of the marriage without being threatened, as she put it.
Speaker 9We've highlighted particular portions of each letter that are germane to the investigation or the plan to carry out the murder and the means to do so, as well as potentially disposing of the body after the murder took place.
Speaker 2The allegation that Gary had sexually abused Amanda was significant. Amanda herself denied that her father ever touched her sexually, though. She did describe Gary as controlling and said there had been incidents when he became physical. But she also described him, get this, as a father who pushed his children to succeed and who, for the most part, had been good to her. Well, which is it? Is he a controlling, abusive asshole, or is he a good father and husband?
Speaker 2It's almost like she can't even make up her mind. By 2010, Daryl said he had also come to believe that his sexual abuse allegation wasn't true. Imagine accusing someone of the worst possible fucking thing you can, abusing his own daughter, with zero evidence or proof, just because you're a little mad that he told you what to do. I mean, holy shit, holy shit. But at the time that he read those letters before 2010, while he was
Speaker 2still sitting in prison, he bought into it fully. At the time, Daryl believed Gary was hurting his mother and his siblings. He believed it 100% because that's what his mother told him. Eventually, Daryl started telling Sharon that he would do something about it. And what did she do? Well, she encouraged it.
Speaker 7This is, once again, a handwritten letter. This is Sharon and Kenny's camera.
Speaker 3Correct.
Speaker 9It reads, what did you mean when you said you were scared of what you could do or will do? I want my problem to go away, but I do not want you to spend any more time here. Were you and her discussing murdering Gary.
Speaker 7At this point?
Speaker 13Correct.
Speaker 8In any of your letters that you wrote her, did you tell her what you were.
Speaker 7Going to do?
Speaker 12Yes, sir.
Speaker 7I mean, how did you say that?
Speaker 23I asked for specific items. I asked for money. I asked for other things such as that. And I told her my words were I'd handle it.
Speaker 2Daryl told investigators that he asked his mother for money and other specific items. His message to her was simple. He wrote that he would solve Sharon's problem. When detectives confronted Sharon about this, they asked her to consider what those letters might have sounded like to a son sitting alone in a prison cell. A son with fewer brain cells than he should have and a mother willing to twist the truth and make up shit to get her way.
Speaker 7Is that your handwriting? This is a photocopy of a letter that you sent Daryl.
Speaker 8Quoting you.
Speaker 9You're writing, if some people go away, you can stay at the house and have a vehicle. Now as I read over some of these things, I want you to try to imagine what a 20, 21, 22 year old boy.
Speaker 13Is thinking.
Speaker 9And all he has to do is sit in a jail cell for 24 hours a day. Think about what mom's going through, his mother. Think about what his little brother and his sister's going through. Because the picture that you paint for Darryl in these letters is enough to make any son want to defend his mother and his siblings.
Speaker 9So either by intent or by inference, You put this in Daryl's mind, and you need to take responsibility for that.
Speaker 2Detectives believed Sharon had spent years creating an image of Gary that would eventually make Daryl want to kill him. Whether that was her intention from the start was another question. Was it malice or stupidity?
Speaker 7Pick one.
Speaker 2But according to investigators, by the time Gary was murdered, Sharon was no longer simply complaining about an unhappy marriage. Nah, she was doing way more.
Speaker 9You caused your son, your child, your flesh and blood to take a gun and shoot his father multiple times because you wanted out. You wanted Gary to go away. You wanted Gary to disappear. You said it in your letters. And your son took you at your word.
Speaker 2Sharon denied that she ever truly wanted Gary murdered. She would later tell detectives that many of the things she wrote were expressions of anger. She was being emotional, you know? She claimed they were thoughts she never expected anyone to act on. The problem was that some of those letters contained more than just angry thoughts. They contain details. Helpful details.
Speaker 9Sometimes I wonder if we should try something or start devising a.
Speaker 7Plan of some sort.
Speaker 4Well, that's not why I said hunt.
Speaker 9Gary runs up to my work on Tuesday and Friday. He rides his motorcycle to work and leaves about 6.15 every morning. He did tell me that he gets up every night and sometimes goes outside to check things out. I was listening to the news and there are so many break-ins and home evasions with guns being used.
Speaker 10Oh, that wasn't what?
Speaker 9No, if you want me to read the entire letter, it pretty much explains why you said that. You know what you were thinking, Sharon. As far as what you're going to do, I would much rather be able to say I don't know anything and that be the truth. Oh, I cannot make a copy of his key, but you can use the one I have. What I really want is for Gary to go away forever. I keep praying I will get a phone call to say that has happened, but not yet.
Speaker 2Gary's work schedule, the time he left in the morning, the nights he rode his motorcycle, the fact that he sometimes stepped outside alone, the key to his vehicle, references to home invasions, ideas for how someone might make him disappear. All those details were in the letters.
Speaker 3Then.
Speaker 2There was the money.
Speaker 9It says all I could think about was either doing him in or doing myself in.
Speaker 7It took all I had not to put something in his potatoes.
Speaker 9But I figured with my luck, he would live through it and I.
Speaker 7Would have to take care of him for the rest.
Speaker 4Of his life.
Speaker 13I do hate him.
Speaker 23She's basically making a statement that she wants him dead and gone. But she's scared that she might mess it up and it will not work.
Speaker 7That's the way you... That's how I'm thinking about it. He says, I am not sure if I.
Speaker 9Will have the $ 500, but I will be real close.
Speaker 7What does she talk about there? What does she mean $ 500?
Speaker 14All right, I.
Speaker 23Asked for $ 500 to buy a firearm and all that.
Speaker 7To kill my father.
Speaker 9So did Sharon know that you wanted the money to buy a gun to kill your father?
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 7And continue.
Speaker 9As far as getting the item you want, I don't want it to come back to bite me.
Speaker 7Later on in life. That's a 30-odd cent. She's talking about the gun again?
Speaker 13Yes.
Speaker 2According to Daryl, the $ 500 he requested was intended to help him obtain a gun to kill his father. That was Daryl's explanation years later. But other passages in Sharon's letters were harder to interpret as anything other than thoughts about Gary's death. At one point, she wrote about resisting the urge to put something in his potatoes. In another, she described a family trip to an alligator farm.
Speaker 7We went to the gator farm in or around Christmas.
Speaker 14Talking about Christmas morning?
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 9I was real tempted to give someone a push. I think that would be a good place to feed the gators.
Speaker 6Referring to killing my father on the gator farm because gators need no evidence.
Speaker 20They digest everything.
Speaker 9And did you or her ever discuss disposing of Gary's body?
Speaker 14Once I got out, yes.
Speaker 7Once you're out of prison all the time?
Speaker 2According to Daryl, disposing of his father's body wasn't merely something he inferred from Sharon's letters. He said the two of them discussed it after he was released. Daryl walked out of prison on June 12, 2008. Four days later, Gary was dead. Sometime during those four days, Daryl said the conversations that had taken place through letters became face-to-face discussions.
Speaker 9So you get out of state prison and you come back here to Merritt Island.
Speaker 14Correct.
Speaker 7And your mom had given you a hotel room.
Speaker 14Correct.
Speaker 9Did you and she ever have conversations? When I say she, you and Sharon, can you ever have conversations about you murdering Gary King?
Speaker 4Correct.
Speaker 7Tell me about that conversation or those conversations. First of all, when and where?
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 6Daryl explained that, in his mind, there was no misunderstanding. He and Sharon discussed murdering Gary. They discussed what would happen to his body afterwards.
Speaker 2Investigators now had Daryl's account. They had the letters. They knew what happened inside Gary's house. They knew Sharon met with Daryl and Ruben at the mall after Gary was dead. Now, they wanted Sharon to explain what all of that meant.
Speaker 7That's where you fucked up.
Speaker 8It went from thoughts to action. You detailed it all out in these letters. Sharon, this is the time for you to tell us why it happened. Okay, this is the time to tell us, right.
Speaker 13Here, right now.
Speaker 7You wanted them dead, didn't you? Not really, no. You wanted them dead, didn't you?
Speaker 17Not really.
Speaker 9Time and time again, Sharon, you said you wanted them dead. You wanted them to disappear. You thought about pushing them over the edge of the gator farm. You thought about poisoning those potatoes. You wished you would have a wreck and die on the way to work. You wished the door would have fell on them and crushed his bones. Ain't that what you wanted? You wanted them dead. You wanted them dead for a reason. What's the reason? You obviously wanted him dead for a reason. You helped plan to get him murdered. You tried to help your son get away with the murder. You told your son to go move the body out of the house. Don't get
Speaker 9it twisted. We got eyewitnesses. There's neighbors and friends of yours that were coming out of the movie theater, seeing you in the mall parking lot, talking to your son and Ruben Nero after Gary was dead.
Speaker 7You can't hide anymore, Sharon. You're not getting away with it.
Speaker 2The detectives were not subtle. They accused Sharon of helping plan Gary's murder and then helping Daryl get away with it. They brought up the potatoes, the alligators, the letters, the meeting at the mall. According to them, the line between thinking about Gary's death and actually helping make it happen had already been crossed. Sharon disagreed.
Speaker 4I didn't really want him dead.
Speaker 7You want me to read the letters again?
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 7You wanted him dead.
Speaker 4I wanted him to go away.
Speaker 7Forever?
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 7You wrote that? Yeah. You want me to read it?
Speaker 11He once told me, Gary once told me that if I ever divorced him, he would disappear forever and I would never see him again.
Speaker 3That's what he told me.
Speaker 7What's that got to do with you and Daryl conspiring to have him killed?
Speaker 4I didn't really want him dead.
Speaker 7Well, you shouldn't have conspired with your son to kill him.
Speaker 9When your son came to you when he got out of prison and laid out his plan for you.
Speaker 4I didn't know what he was doing.
Speaker 13Bullshit.
Speaker 2Sharon said she wanted Gary to go away, not die. Well, then why'd you talk about it so much then with your incarcerated son? She also insisted she didn't know what Daryl was planning when he got out of prison. I'll bet you did, Sharon. Not all of us, sir. as stupid as you or your son. Detectives, of course, didn't believe her. Who would? And they wanted her to explain why she had convinced her son to commit this murder.
Speaker 8That's what we're here for, okay? We're not here to try to figure out how something happened. We know how it happened, all right? We're here to figure out why it happened. Sharon, why did this happen? That's why we're here.
Speaker 13All right?
Speaker 7You want me to keep reading it? To help refresh your memory of why that happened?
Speaker 9Because look, I've got, I've got, this is just one box that we took out of Daryl's hotel room.
Speaker 8And Sharon, we can go through these letters and we can look at them and we can go and present this to whoever.
Speaker 13But you know what?
Speaker 8If it doesn't come from you, what does it mean? I mean, what are people going to think?
Speaker 2The question why had been hanging over this investigation from the start. Why would a 22-year-old man who had been out of prison for only four days recruit another man, steal guns from his own family, and murder his father? Daryl had given detectives his answer. It was his mother. Sharon's answer was a bit more complicated.
Speaker 9That's why you and your son conspired to kill Gary. So you could have an opportunity... To make.
Speaker 7A new life. But if you don't start telling the truth, Sharon, you're not going to have that chance. You wanted it to end.
Speaker 4I just wanted it to end.
Speaker 7You wanted it to end.
Speaker 13I understand.
Speaker 4But I really, I really did. You've got to believe me.
Speaker 7I really did not. You may not have wanted it to happen.
Speaker 4I didn't want it to happen.
Speaker 7You didn't believe that it was going to happen this way. But Sharon.
Speaker 18What you've done is you conspired with your son to kill Gary.
Speaker 7That's what you've done. And we've got to explain it. You've got to help me understand, Sharon.
Speaker 2Sharon admitted she wanted her marriage to end. She admitted writing the letters. She admitted telling Daryl things about Gary. Things that may have stretched the truth a little bit. But she continued to insist that she never truly wanted... what had happened. That distinction mattered. Wanting someone dead isn't murder. Writing horrible things about someone isn't murder. Being angry, miserable, or trapped in a marriage isn't murder. The question was
Speaker 2whether Sharon had crossed the line between wanting Gary gone and actually helping Daryl make it happen. Investigators believed that she had. And they also wondered whether There was another motive.
Speaker 8Sharon, also, why is it that you talked to Gary several months ago and asked him to increase his life insurance policy?
Speaker 4I never asked him that.
Speaker 8You never asked him to do that?
Speaker 4If he did that, I had no idea.
Speaker 8Okay, then why did he tell his friends that you asked him to do that?
Speaker 19I don't know why.
Speaker 4I don't even know what his life insurance policy is.
Speaker 14I never talked to him about that.
Speaker 4I don't know anything about that.
Speaker 2Sharon denied ever asking Gary to increase his life insurance policy. She said she didn't know how much insurance he had and had never discussed.
Speaker 7It with him.
Speaker 2But investigators knew she was a liar and that she had discussed Gary's life insurance with someone else. The timing was difficult to ignore. Gary had been murdered on a Monday evening. Sharon spent much of the night speaking with investigators, and early the following morning, she called Gary's employer.
Speaker 8You called Gary's boss at what, 5.30 that morning?
Speaker 10I think it was like 5.45 because that's when they were due in to tell him Gary wouldn't be there.
Speaker 13Okay.
Speaker 8And what was your conversation with his boss?
Speaker 4My mother-in-law told me to ask him.
Speaker 13No, no, no, no, no.
Speaker 8I asked you what your conversation was with your boss, with his boss.
Speaker 10I told him that Gary wouldn't be in and I told him why. And I did.
Speaker 23Ask about the life insurance, but it was only because my mother-in-law told me to.
Speaker 8Okay, Sharon. what did you ask about the life insurance?
Speaker 4I honestly don't remember.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 8So you were inquiring. Your husband gets murdered around, let's say, between 5 and 6. I can't remember the exact time on Monday. So 24 hours later, after being up all night, you are inquiring about his life insurance policy. That next morning.
Speaker 10That's because his mom told me to ask about it.
Speaker 2Sharon admitted asking Gary's boss about the life insurance. She said she did it because Gary's mother told her to, but come on. Whether investigators believe that explanation or not isn't clear. I'm going to go with no. For them, though, the larger issue remained everything that had happened before Gary's death. The letters, the money, the guns, the conversations with Daryl, and the help they believed Sharon had provided along the way.
Speaker 8You didn't think he would do it? Did you not just sit here and listen to Agent Reyes and explain everything to you? Okay?
Speaker 11I understand everything he said to me.
Speaker 8And you understand that what you did was not right, it was criminal, is what you told us, correct? I understand. You do understand that, all right. You understand that you are the influence to your son's And what you told him to do, he acted upon, and you enabled him to do that, correct?
Speaker 4I guess.
Speaker 8There was no guessing. You either did or you didn't.
Speaker 2Sharon understood that what detectives were describing was criminal. But even then, she stopped short of accepting their characterization of her as the person responsible for what Daryl ultimately did. Daryl had no such hesitation when it came to blaming his mother. Still, there was an important reason to be cautious about taking everything he said at face value. After all, he was a criminal. Back in 2009, while he was awaiting trial for his father's murder, Darrell had made it
Speaker 2clear that he wanted something in return for telling investigators everything he knew about his mother.
Speaker 15Before I ask you any other details regarding your mother's involvement... You've made it clear to me that you would like for me to speak to the state attorney's.
Speaker 24Office, the prosecutor in charge of the case, and the defense attorney that's representing you. And when your defense attorney and the state reaches some type of a potential plea agreement, which is what you're asking for, if that is done and you find it to be to your liking, would you be willing to give further details and potential full disclosure regarding your mother's involvement?
Speaker 10I'll start at day one.
Speaker 2Daryl wanted a deal. He made it clear that full disclosure about his mother's involvement depended on prosecutors and his defense attorney reaching an agreement he found acceptable. There was no sudden expression of remorse for Gary in that conversation. Daryl was bargaining. He had information about Sharon that prosecutors wanted. Whatever he hoped to gain from it, it didn't keep him from spending the rest of his life in prison, though. In 2010, Daryl Kenney was convicted of first-degree murder and
Speaker 2sentenced to life. His accomplice, Ruben Nero, was also convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life. Despite investigators' questions about what Amanda knew before her father's murder, she was never charged. in connection with his death. As for her mother, Sharon, her arrest finally came on March 15th, 2011. Nearly three years after Gary was murdered, investigators sat down with Sharon again.
Speaker 2This time, they weren't there to ask her what happened to Gary. They were there to tell her what had just happened to her.
Speaker 25Today, The grand jury, we provided testimony to the grand jury, and the grand jury came back with what's called a true bill, and they indicted you on first-degree murder. Not on first-degree murder, but armed burglary as well.
Speaker 7Okay? So you are technically charged with first-degree murder.
Speaker 14You have a no-bond status.
Speaker 7What I would like to do is I know you've provided statements in the past.
Speaker 25I want to see if you want to give an opportunity to.
Speaker 2A grand jury indicted Sharon Kenney for first-degree murder and armed burglary. She was held without bond. While investigators offered her another opportunity to talk, she declined. This time she wanted an attorney. Daryl Kenney would spend the rest of his life in prison. So would his accomplice, Ruben Nero. For a time, it appeared possible Sharon could face a similar fate.
Speaker 5But.
Speaker 2And this is the part that, you know, you come for. The case against her became tangled in a legal battle over some of the interrogations. Investigators questioned Sharon on June 16th and June 20th, 2008. Investigators did not read her her Miranda rights before those interrogations. I don't know why they risk it like that sometimes. Maybe they think they're really close to a confession and they don't want to spook the witness or the suspect. But they really should
Speaker 2get better about always reading out Miranda rights. If they're going to talk in any capacity to someone who has information, then they won't get into these stupid little legal loopholes. and let criminals continue to get away with murder. Years later, her attorneys argued that despite detectives telling Sharon she was free to leave several times, the circumstances surrounding those interviews made them custodial interrogations. In 2017, the Florida Supreme Court agreed.
Speaker 2The court ruled that a reasonable person in Sharon's position would have felt constrained and that she should have been given Miranda warnings. As a result, prosecutors could not use statements she made during those interrogations. More than a decade had passed since Gary's murder by the time Sharon's case was finally resolved. In May of 2018, Sharon pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of manslaughter with a firearm. Seven
Speaker 2months later, she was sentenced to 10 years in prison. Daryl Kenney got life. Ruben Nero got life. Sharon, who orchestrated the entire thing, got 10 years. Tell me again how the justice system is fair and how and how unfair it is to women or some shit. Give me a break. Look, she wasn't inside the house when Gary
Speaker 2was killed, but prosecutors believe the murder started long before Daryl and Ruben ever walked through Gary's front door. In their view, and in mine, it started with letters sent to a prison. Letters describing what Gary was supposedly doing to his family. With money, with guns, with schedules, with discussions about how Gary might disappear. And what could be done with his body afterwards. That leaves the most uncomfortable question.
Speaker 2Who bears the greatest responsibility for a murder? The idiot himself? who carries it out, or the person who convinces the idiot it needs to happen? The justice system answered that question with three prison sentences. Whether those sentences accurately reflect each person's responsibility is something you can decide for yourself. Play along and vote accordingly. But there's another problem with trying to reconstruct what happened inside the Kenney family. Nearly
Speaker 2everyone involved eventually got to tell their version. Sharon did. Daryl did. Amanda did. And Ruben did. Guess who didn't?
Speaker 13Yep.
Speaker 2Gary Kenney.
Speaker 5The corpse.
Speaker 2Gary Kenney was 50 years old. He worked as a welder at the Kennedy Space Center. He was a husband, a father of three. People who knew him outside the family described a man who would stop to talk with neighbors and helped others whenever they needed it. Inside his family, the picture was much more complicated. Sharon described a controlling and abusive husband. Amanda acknowledged that her father could become angry and controlling. But Amanda also described Gary as a
Speaker 2good father who wanted his children to succeed. That's a little contradictory, isn't it? Seems like these women just don't like someone telling them what to do. And they don't like it to such a degree they'll make up shit. and paint out their patriarch as a terrible human being when all he wanted was a little fucking structure in his fucked up family of fuck-ups. The last full day of Gary's life was Father's Day. That's pretty Shakespearean. Gary
Speaker 2went to lunch with his parents. Nothing in particular happened. There was no confrontation, no indication that the following day would be any different from the countless others before it. Then on June 16th, Gary's father called him. Some guns were missing Gary told him he hadn't taken them. He told his father to call police. What Gary couldn't have known was that his own son had stolen those guns.
Speaker 2He couldn't have known that Daryl had been discussing his death before leaving prison. He couldn't have known that four days after his son's release, Daryl and another man would confront him at his home. He couldn't have known any of these things. Tell me again how he was controlling Whatever Gary might have said about his family or the accusations made against him, they all died with him. At just 50 years old, he was forced inside his own
Speaker 2home at gunpoint by his own son. And thanks to his wife and his daughter, he never walked back out. One thing I should have clarified in the last episode is that if you ordered merch during that window where
Speaker 2you get free shit, you're going to get it in a separate package. So try and be patient for once. And it may come in days or weeks later. So can you stop the Karen-ing, please? Got enough shit to worry about without these People bitching all the time about everything.
Speaker 17In all seriousness, you will get what I promised you you'll get.
Speaker 2Just give me a minute. It's going to take me a minute. I'm doing a lot of this on my own. So, you know, give me a break.
When David Cole disappeared, the people closest to him seemed to know very little about where he had gone. But as detectives looked deeper into the home he shared with his son and daughter-in-law, Brittany, the stories...
Angela Craig falls seriously ill without warning, leaving doctors puzzled. Soon, investigators start to find troubling evidence connected to her husband, Jim Craig. Their discoveries make friends and family rethink what...
In Clackamas County, Oregon, a night of heavy drinking left behind more questions than answers. As suspicion and jealousy began to take hold, tensions escalated between two former coworkers. Five days later, one of them...
Thirty-three-year-old Jason Schaefer was delivering mail on a quiet afternoon in Longmont, Colorado, when bullets assaulted him. Witnesses saw a figure run from the mailboxes, covered in a hoodie and mask, and at first,...
Jennifer Dulos, an upper-class mom of five, vanished from Connecticut on a spring morning in 2019. Two women, both from privilege, both connected to the same man, would find themselves on opposite sides of what came...