Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Surprising Ethics

Surprising Ethics artwork

Feeling the pinch: A philosophy of breathing space, w. Dr Adam Piovarchy

Nov 1, 202648 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Too many things, not enough time. The pressure can feel relentless. In response, should we maximise productivity and hope to feel better? Maybe not. Maybe we need breathing room: to avoid burnout, weather storms, and reduce the risks that being alive brings. But how can we strike the right trade-off between using our energy, time and money and preserving them? For this we might need new tools. Enter Dr Adam Piovarchy, whose brand new research (co-authored with Zvi Mowshowitz and Scott Siskind) brings us a new perspective on these life decisions. Adam is today’s guest and accessibly explains his new idea of “slack” and how it might apply to your life. We discuss the importance of saying no, the dangers of a maximising mindset, debates pitting baby boomers against millennials/gen Z on who has it easier, competition for jobs and life chances, habits, and even how to retire well. Give your feedback! https://tinyurl.com/feedbackformSurprisingEthics Podcast website for contact details and more: surprisingethics.buzzsprout.com Instagram: @surprising_ethics_podcast tinyurl.com/surprisingethics

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Too many things, not enough time. The pressure in life can feel relentless. And many people respond to that by seeking to maximize productivity. And so we're told to optimize, to strategize, to maximize, and all will be well. But is maximizing productivity a sensible goal? Is maximizing anything, even life experiences or how ethical we are, ever really a good idea? We might think a maximizing mindset is often a recipe for risk, burnout, and life chaos.

SPEAKER_00So what if we had the conceptual tools with which to resist maximizing and instead have a more balanced set of values? What if we had access to a new idea that enabled us to plan breathing room, to avoid burnout, and to reduce unnecessary risk in life? Just such a new concept is being discussed. But what is it and how can it help with our lives?

SPEAKER_00I'm Will, an academic in moral and political philosophy at King's College London, and thanks to the Centre for Research and Ethics based in Montreal and to the Leverhume Trust for supporting this podcast. Today we discuss how to think about planning our time, our lives, and the values we want to pursue with the limited energy we have. As always, we begin with the status quo on our topic before looking at a surprising alternative. So a popular approach to the topic of how to use our time, money, and energy that I think could fairly be called the status quo is that we should maximize.

SPEAKER_00More is better. More is always better, whether it's work, output, income, or valuable life experience. And so we should set about trying to maximize the good things we have in life. As always, I bring you a few clips to illustrate this. And in videos online called things like, here's my take on maximizing productivity, we get stuff with this kind of vibe.

SPEAKER_03And by the way, you can't manage time, you can only manage your energy. And the way to get the most out of your time is to have lots of energy. And the way that you have lots of energy is by taking care of your health. And the way that you take care of your health is by making it a priority and planning and scheduling your life around eating nutritional food, exercising on a regular basis, because that in itself is going to give you a lot more energy, which when used correctly will give the illusion of more time when in fact you're just more productive because you're more focused and you have a much higher potential for output.

SPEAKER_00If you want to increase your productivity by up to 400%, here's another online commentator, this time from an online web development community.

SPEAKER_01This gives you more chances to accomplish things. Since if you say, okay, my New Year's resolution is to get in shape, you could just make that a quarterly goal. And now in the span of three months, you can focus on getting in shape. And now for the next three months after that, you can focus on something entirely different. This is a great way to be able to scale what you're doing and focus on different things in different periods.

SPEAKER_00And we find this maximizing vibe pushed even further by the likes of Andrew Huberman, where the advice extends to such delights as radical fasting patterns.

SPEAKER_04So I don't eat anything until about 11 a.m. or 12 noon. I'm not absolutely religious about it. There are days when I'll have a few Brazil nuts or a spoonful or three of almond butter, for instance. But most days I'm not doing that. I'm just not eating anything. I'm drinking some caffeine. Caffeine source for me is yerba mate, guayusa tea. Those are my preferred sources. I tend to avoid coffee these days. Occasionally I'll have a cup.

SPEAKER_00Today we look at a surprising idea that counters this maximizing trend and that focuses on breathing room, headroom, spare capacity. A new concept has just been introduced in a top academic venue, a journal called Ethics, and I'm very lucky to be joined by one of its authors, Dr. Adam Peavaki. He's a research fellow at the University of Notre Dame, Australia. He's based at the University's Institute for Ethics and Society and works in moral psychology among other fields.

SPEAKER_00And he's written this article along with co-authors Svee Moshewitz and Scott Siskind. I'll let Adam introduce the idea, which is labelled Slack, but just to say it's not the same as abundance, freedom or wealth. You could be rich and have no slack, or be of much more modest means and have much more slack. So while of course we should recognise from the outset that having this thing called slack can sometimes be a privilege, it's not the same as being rich or well resourced.

SPEAKER_00Our conversation is less a direct manual for living and more exploration of new tools and ideas that can shape how we live. And our conversation covers themes like time management and the importance of saying no, maximising mindsets versus settling for enough, debates between boomers and zoomers, competition, life trade-offs, and even pensions. And just before I bring you the speaker, I just wanted to say that I really want more listeners to be actively involved in the podcast.

SPEAKER_00There's many ways to get involved. There's a survey in the episode notes that you could uh fill in to let me know what you think about this podcast. You can also email me, just head to the show notes and click the Surprising Ethics Buzz Sprout link. And it's really brilliant to hear from listeners and really helps me to keep up with the motivation. So please do tell me how this podcast has impacted you, even if in only a small way. And also send me suggestions for uh episode ideas, whether that's a specific text or question or a general theme, and I very much hope to hear from you.

SPEAKER_00So please do get in touch. So here is Adam Piavaki. So yeah, thanks Adam so much for being here. First question would be that your your new research brings us this very exciting new idea of Slack. Can you kind of briefly give us a bit of a teaser trailer of Slack and perhaps give us some examples that kind of concern everyday life?

SPEAKER_02So yes, uh, but I'm gonna start with a bit of a preamble about um concepts and kind of new ideas. Uh so uh sometimes in philosophy and sciences, you will sort of announce that you've made a new discovery. Um maybe you've discovered like a new planet or a new element, right? Um, sometimes you've got a new answer to an old question, right? So, like, what is justice? Everyone knows what justice is, and but maybe you've got a new answer. And sometimes you've just kind of got this new concept which lets you think about things in a slightly sort of new way that's kind of useful, even if you haven't kind of discovered anything brand new.

SPEAKER_02I think Slack kind of falls into this third category. Um, Slack is something I think that everybody has in their lives, they might not notice it or they might think about it in slightly different terms, but it's the kind of thing that once you start paying attention to it, you sort of notice that yes, this is something worth thinking about. So the way I think of Slack, it might be easier for me to kind of just gesture at a bunch of examples. So one obvious example is just of um money, right?

SPEAKER_02If my kind of car suddenly needs repairs, um having money enables me to pay a mechanic to fix it. So my ability to get to work will be constrained by my lack of money and my lack of functioning car. Um another one is like space. So if you have a big house with a big property, you can fit lots of cars and have pets that can run around. If you live in a small apartment in a city, you can't have those things. So the lack of spare space means that kind of what you can take care of and own is constrained. Uh another one is time. So this is where I think the term slack kind of originally comes from in um in project management.

SPEAKER_02So that's the time a task can be delayed without causing a delay to other tasks. Because sometimes you have to have things kind of done in a certain order, and if one thing is not done, well then you can't do anything kind of after that, right? So you have a bit of slack, you have a bit of wiggle room, um, you can have a bit of delay, it doesn't upset other things. And then another one is maybe uh what we might think of as social bonds. So, you know, your friends and family can provide Slack by being this kind of safety net, right? If your pipe bursts in your apartment and then you kind of need to move out while the repairs are getting done, well, if you've got family, you can kind of go live with them, that's very handy.

SPEAKER_02If you don't have a family and you don't have enough money to kind of go somewhere else, well then you might end up homeless. So um, you know, your lack of social bonds will then constrain your ability to be to be housed. So the key thing here is kind of, yeah, this idea of the absence of constraints that are binding. The idea, the core idea is about kind of sometimes you can be under a constraint but not have that affecting you, meaningly affecting your behavior. There's this famous quote from Anatoly France that the law in its majestic equality forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread.

SPEAKER_02And so I think the core idea there is look, even if the rich are in some sense constrained from sleeping under bridges, that doesn't meaningfully affect their behavior. It's not like they sort of go, oh no, I can't sleep under bridges, I'll have to go sleep in my big house. Like, um, whereas the law does sort of constrain the poor um in a very meaningful way. So that's kind of the the core idea of Slack, that um you can have more or less Slack in your life. You can be your the constraints you are under can add up and interact in interesting ways, and some of them can bind you very tightly, and some of them um whereas in other cases they might not.

SPEAKER_02So it's not just a total like the number of constraints, it's not just kind of what options are foreclosed. In total, it's about how they interact.

SPEAKER_00Great. So like in in informal terms, like it's similar to the idea of headroom or like spare resources, but it's not quite the same as that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so sometimes people talk about like spare capacity. Um headroom, maybe that's uh that's sort of something nearby in the ballpark. Um, I think a useful uh another useful analogy is thinking about bottlenecks. Um so here's something interesting I learned. In road design, um, roads tend to be most efficient when they're operating at about 70% capacity. And so you might think, hang on, there's all this extra space, we can fit more cars in there. But when you do that, um you suddenly get kind of traffic jams. Um, there's these bottlenecks that sort of people have to work around and things get kind of much less efficient.

SPEAKER_02So the idea is there's a similar kind of thing happening in your life in terms of how you function and how you kind of go about the world, where you need a certain amount of kind of spare capacity in which to um make decisions and do things and have things interacting. And if that falls below a certain threshold, you can suddenly be very constrained and you have to reorganize everything to kind of work around that bottleneck.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00And maybe this is like jumping the gun, but I think one thing listeners will find really valuable uh from today's discussion is kind of having a new word, having a new concept that allows us to be more conscious of different kinds of slack in life and also gives us a kind of firmer grasp of trade-offs that I think maybe we don't even know we're making, right? Because we're not we're not conceptualizing them. Um so I'm sure there'll be kind of advice pepper throughout the episode as we kind of unpack things and get to the more get to the nuances. But to get us started, do you have any kind of initial nuggets of advice about how people can apply ideas of Slack in their own lives?

SPEAKER_02I think you're right that once you've got a label for something, it becomes a lot easier to notice that thing. Um and so that is part of what I think the value of the paper is that I sort of hope people will sort of hear that and go, ah, I know exactly what that is, and then it helps them make sense of um their lives. This a good example of this is Schadenfreud. Um, right? English doesn't sort of have a word that corresponds to that, but when you introduce that term, they, you know, uh pleasure rather's pain. Everyone goes, ah, I know exactly what that is, and sort of um then it's easier for them to notice it as they're going about their day.

SPEAKER_02You know, there's gonna be cases where people might be um, you know, they're free to do things, but they're nevertheless quite constrained because maybe they've taken on too many responsibilities that they have to kind of uh um keep up.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So like I guess it also relates to this like kind of advice to say no to more things. And when you when you when you do say no to things, um, and this is kind of uh unhelpful for me because I'm relying on the podcast and people saying yes to doing episodes, but but when people do say no, often they feel feel like they need some kind of urgent or obvious reason, like I can't do this because I've got a child to look after or I've got a plane to catch, whatever. But I think also maybe in planning, like having spare time that's unaccounted for, unspoken for is I think essential to having avoiding feelings of like desperation and a lack of control that sets in.

SPEAKER_00One interesting observation you make in the paper is about moral integrity and about how having slack is essential for having integrity. Often you can be in a situation where you can't turn down a job or you can't turn down maybe what your boss wants you to do because you have not enough slack to like say no and and like hold your moral ground.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think these are some really good observations. Um it is it is sort of a bit rude or um to say no, um I can't do that, or I don't want to do that because you know I just want to keep to spare capacity just in case, or just because that you know, spare capacity seems good to me. Like that's sort of not recognized as a good, legitimate answer for most people in most circumstances today. But um nevertheless, I think it is something that we kind of have to do. And sometimes I think people implicitly might know this, they might sort of make an excuse or sort of it isn't the real reason why they sort of don't want to do something.

SPEAKER_02But nevertheless, it's sort of saying that you know, sometimes you want to keep some time or your kind of mental uh capacity or your resources, you know, in the back pocket just in case. Um just in case what? Well, I I think you know, I think that's the wrong question. I think if you're sort of asking someone, justify what you need to keep a case for, or you know, run the probabilities or like what likely outcomes. Um if you do that too often, I think you're just gonna end up kind of spending your slack on things. It's sort of good to just have a buffer as a kind of a a as a um matter of of prudence.

SPEAKER_02Um but it yeah, but it's again, it's I think it's hard to do that if you aren't thinking in these terms and you don't sort of recognise the the value of slack. And then conversely, it's um important to not make too many demands on other people's time. But sometimes you do just have to sort of say no, sort of I'm I'm at my limits or I I'm I'm busy doing other things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think one thing I loved about the paper was this idea of emotional slack. Um and I I don't think I'd thought of slack or spare capacity as applying to emotions or emotional bandwidth. Um yeah, could you unpack that a little bit?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean it's it seems to me like some people just have more capacity for kind of dealing with either more stressful situations or a greater number of kind of stressful things kind of at once. Um, you know, there's just you know no one has infinite kind of patience or capacity to deal with stressful things. Um or to kind of, you know, if you do, if you just keep going on and on, you head we know that you know people head towards burnout. Um this is a common you know thing of study for professions like kind of doctors.

SPEAKER_02And so even if but even if you're not in like a high stress position, you can end up kind of very, I guess, stressed or having to deal with more things than than you're capable of in your kind of everyday life. And so if you take some steps to kind of at least, I don't know, like you know, decompress or have some time off or like do other things or catch up with friends, right? A lot of these prescriptions are common for um the movements that people make to kind of start taking better care of your mental health, right?

SPEAKER_02Um, which I think is something we are sort of increasingly getting better at. Um, but maybe um it can still be a little bit vague about sort of how you do that or kind of what's the best approach. And so yeah, if you think of look, my amount of my emotional capacity, my ability to kind of take on a bunch of things, that is a that is literally a capacity. It's like I have this amount um and I need to keep some kind of buffer, otherwise if I go too close to my limit, then something's gonna kind of tip me over, and now I'm gonna um have to reorganize things to kind of deal with that, then that obviously that's not going to be good.

SPEAKER_00So we we want or need Slack to kind of yeah, make remain somewhat in control of lives and to kind of reduce the risks that we face. But then you identify uh in your article threats to Slack because Slack is something that can be gained, lost, spent, bought. Um and yeah, and and the being aware that those dynamics can help us like kind of protect ourselves from other people's demands on our on our resources, but also our own decision making. So can you kind of talk about these these threats to Slack?

SPEAKER_02So, yeah, the core idea that um threat Slack is often under threat is uh I think really articulated well by one of my co-authors. So there's a few reasons why it's perhaps under threat. So one is just if we don't have the label to talk about it, then it's sort of hard to notice that it's there. And so you might kind of end up spending it because the things you can spend it on um are sort of very noticeable and tangible, and you get them now, particularly in the case of money. Whereas the benefits of keeping the Slack are kind of a bit more diffuse and vague, um, and uh as I said, like adjust-in-case. Um, so it's a bit sort of harder to notice.

SPEAKER_02Um another kind of threat is occurs when you have some kind of goal that seems to have like a lack of upper bound. Um so sometimes you have a goal like I want to run a marathon, you know, that's very tangible, has a distinct set point. But a goal like I want to be the best or I want to earn the most money or earn more money or um, you know, get more famous, right? There's just kind of no upper limit to kind of how famous you can kind of be. Um and you know, the various people have various reasons for having those goals. But if you have a goal like that, then you're always going to be faced with this decision between um using your spare capacity to pursue that goal, like get further along, or saying, no, I'm gonna go do something else.

SPEAKER_02And then you feel like, well, now I'm I'm falling short of that goal, right? I'm not as committed to to you know, um, this goal as I thought I was. And you know, you hear talk from like Olympians and things about how they're pursuing this kind of this greatness goal just is all consuming in their life and can lead to um you know sort of bad outcomes either if they fall short or even if they do succeed, but then when they kind of finish, then they've got sort of um nothing else, they haven't built their life uh anything else around their lives um to give them some kind of stable foundation.

SPEAKER_02Um another one though is with moral goals. Um so um many some readers here will be familiar with utilitarianism, the idea that you kind of we should do the greatest good for the greatest number, um, we should kind of maximize happiness. And there's this famous objection that look, if you really try to do the most good um that you can do to every action, well then your entire life becomes consumed by this, right? Every time you buy a cup of coffee, instead of donating that money to charity, you're doing the wrong thing. Um and so the the objection goes, if you really live your life this way, you're quickly going to get kind of burnt out and um you're gonna be very grumpy.

SPEAKER_02And one, this is just maybe not how humans should live, but two, it's very plausible that actually you'll not do the most good as well. So the thought is regardless of kind of how convincing you think utilitarianism is, if you have this kind of goal to like be as moral as I can, um if you don't make some effort to put like a kind of a line in the sand of like I'm not gonna go above this, well, you're quickly gonna be consumed by it because you're just always gonna be faced with this choice of, yeah, but I could do more, yeah, but I could do more.

SPEAKER_02Um and yeah, it just sort of seems like that's sort of not the way that sort of most people want to live their lives.

SPEAKER_00So does that kind of speak in favor of this idea of satisfacing, kind of like trying to be satisfied with a certain threshold level of like improvements or or outcome rather than saying, I want to be more and more famous, more and more wealthy, I want to build this business and expand my entrepreneurial whatever endeavor more and more and more. Saying like I want my business to grow by 15% in the next two years, rather than kind of this general vague optimizing strategy of being healthier and healthier and healthier, more and more and more rich, and it kind of just eats up all of your all of your spare capacity.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so yeah, I think that's right. That's uh a sort of satisfacing mindset, is one where you kind of say, here's like the threshold, and I want to get above that threshold, but once I'm there, I can stop and then go do other things, think about other things. I've sort of stopped pursuing this goal. And so if if you can pull that off, yes, I think that is in many domains, that is a much healthier, beneficial way of doing it, and that would be a way of i of kind of maintaining a certain level of Slack.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then w one more thing on on the the uh threats to Slack is in the workplace. So you uh this remind me reminds me of David Graeber's uh Book bullshit jobs. So like where when if you have Slack at work, your boss will see you as being lazy or in need of more work or uh something isn't right, right? If you have spare capacity, like what what's going on? Like we're paying you to do nothing. Um so this slack isn't really allowed in in most workplaces.

SPEAKER_00Is that is that right?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it seems like I mean, it's not like impossible that you could get a job that has some slack or that gives you a f a fair amount of downtime. But in general, yeah, if you are doing um if you have a job and you sort of finish too quickly, um, well, you're gonna get given more work to do, right? Um and so there's this weird thing in many jobs where you it's this thing where you don't wanna spend all of your slack getting the job done as quickly as you can because then more work is going to get given to you. Um, but you you also don't want to like take too long doing the job because then you you're kind of, you know, there's this opportunity options on the table that you could be taking to do other things.

SPEAKER_02And so um the I guess the the market-based kind of structure incentivizes you to eliminate Slack as many places as possible. And you know, that can be good in some cases because it provides efficiency, which you know don't generate lots of benefits for um, you know, consumers and and whatever. Um, but it does sort of mean that there's always going to be this pressure to kind of eliminate Slack to kind of get rid of it, to get as much get as much efficiency as kind of as as we can. And at least I think one of the one of the benefits of having this on table is that you can kind of notice, well, there are at least these trade-offs that are being made.

SPEAKER_02Um you know, it's yes, efficiency is good. That you know, that is a reason to kind of pursue that, but something is kind of lost in in pursuing that.

SPEAKER_00Hi, it's Will editing the episode just to say if at all you're able to hit the subscribe button, that would be so helpful in helping to get the podcast out to more people and encourage philosophy into people's lives. But you could also consider sharing the episode with a friend. Apologies to interrupt, and here is the conversation again. Yeah, so let's talk about uh competition then. Uh you have this wonderful line in the paper, competition incinerates slack.

SPEAKER_00It seemed to me this is kind of a sad trade tension because you have this really valuable resource that kind of promotes things like safety and exploration and rest and freedom and moral integrity, and then it's being threatened by something that's absolutely basic to modern market economies and like most societies, which is competition. Maybe you can unpack a little bit more like this dynamic and maybe what we can do to respond to it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so uh this is uh something I have my co-author Scott's written quite a bit about, and I think he's identified something important. So um, particularly for yes, zero-sum competitions in particular, um, it seems like if you have any slack and you're in a zero-sum competition, um, in general, the person who's gonna win that competition is gonna be the person who spent all their slack competing. Um you know, not sort of necessarily, it's not like an ironclad kind of rule of of the universe, but in a lot of circumstances, this is how things are going to go. And so, you know, part of the things that Scott warns about is sort of saying, watch out for these kinds of traps where it looks like, you know, hey, I'll just have to like work really hard and and try my best, and like, hey, something good will happen at the end.

SPEAKER_02If you don't notice that, like, no, it's a zero-sum competition, and taking those steps will, if if if other people are gonna have to take the steps as well, you can kind of end up having to rush it up, rush it up, um, spending all your resources and your spare energy um before you can kind of get to to where you want to go.

SPEAKER_00Um zero sum being like where if I win, you lose, and if you win, I lose. And there's no way we can both win. Yeah. There's one maybe there's one there's one spot in the artist's gallery where one artist is selected to exhibit their works, what your example, right? And this could it can't be both of us.

SPEAKER_02Yes. And so in some senses, you can kind of think of competition and slack as kind of like the inverse of each other, right? If you've got no competition, you've got like tons of slack, you're not under any constraints, but if you've got heaps of competition, then you've got kind of um lots of constraints kind of kind of binding you all at once. And then the interesting question then is well, what's kind of the optimal balance of these things? So um economists you know love to talk about the benefits of competition. And I'm I'm totally on board with that sort of in general. Uh competition's great between businesses because it you know reduces prices and incentivizes the uh businesses to kind of deliver better products that people want.

SPEAKER_02But there are some circumstances where it seems like too much competition kind can be bad, not just for the the business that kind of goes out of business, but for consumers as well. Uh so just as an illustrative example, uh, there's this one paper that argues that during the COVID-19 lockdowns, there was this basically this large shock that all these businesses had to kind of deal with all at once, right? You had uh lockdowns, so people stopped spending. And some businesses had lots of slack, particularly mostly the big ones, they had resources that they could kind of spend to keep them afloat during that temporary shock.

SPEAKER_02And other businesses did not. And so those small ones went uh out of business, and then the bigger businesses were able to kind of take over that market share. And that's bad for consumers, right? Because now you've got uh you know greater market concentration. And so now, in theory, you should have new businesses kind of entering in um once the shock has passed. But of course, you know, that's quite very idealized. But the point there is that part of the reason these smaller businesses had to close is because they had not previously accumulated uh enough slack to kind of weather that shock.

SPEAKER_02There was too much competition for them to kind of accumulate uh profits to kind of um keep there as a buffer. And so it the interesting observation is again, this is just an illustration, but um, too much competition in conjunction with this shock then produced um like less competition overall because once the small ones had been taken out, you then had um fewer companies that sort of didn't have as much competitive pressure with each other, right? Um this is uh why it's interesting to think about kind of slack and competition as these kind of two forces that are pushing against each other and how different balances of those forces can generate kind of different outcomes in in various circumstances.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So in practical terms, at the individual level, it's like if you're a student or an academic or an artist or an entrepreneur, whenever you have spare time, your incentive is to spend that spare time on improving your your essays, your articles, your product, your art, and never to kind of rest, right? And it's just kind of a quite a draining pattern. And I guess we wonder why we feel often overwhelmed or or out of control. But I think there are these, yeah, these these interesting market forces that have benefits, but also just pushing us too much to be and there's what one response maybe is to put like sharp limits in and say, like, I will spend my spare time improving my article, improving my product, but not at the weekend, right?

SPEAKER_00Like um, and like I think it's I yeah, I certainly found that quite helpful helpful, like somewhere in my in my student days, just being like, you know what, I have to have a weekend, like uh otherwise you just you're just constantly incentivized to do more.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's funny. Um it's one of the things that we sort of tell um children when they're broad-eyed bushytail, is like you can do anything kind of if you if you work hard, right? Um, and that makes it sound like it's just a matter of, oh, you just have to put in X amount of you know effort or or days, and then you kind of get this reward. Um, but then I think that's kind of the wrong message. It's not like if you work hard enough, it's if you're willing to sacrifice enough of other things to get it. Um I think this is the thing that people for don't often don't notice when they do certain things like maybe starting a business um or going into academia is that they don't realize how intense the competition is and thus how much you have to sacrifice to kind of focus kind of single-mindedly on this thing.

SPEAKER_02Um so you would know you're an academic, um, it's very, very uh hard to get academic jobs because there are so so many grad students for so so few jobs. And so they often go to people who are able or willing to um put all of their resources into um you know just getting enough publications or whatever it is that kind of help the CD. And I mean people tell you when you start grad school, oh, it's very hard to get a job, it will probably not happen. But I don't think they kind of articulate or necessarily where it's not just like, oh, it's unlikely or you have to be smart, or it's about like, no, um it's that if you really want to go for this and give it the best um chance of success, that like you might have to sacrifice a lot of other things that you hadn't sort of intended to um when you thought it would be a good idea.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. So like maybe the more honest advice wouldn't be if only you work hard, you'll succeed. It's like if only you work hard and harder than everyone else is willing to work hard, who've also heard the advice to work hard. So it's like, well, you know, can we really be in control of our own success when actually it's like it's so comparative and positional? It's like brutally like you might have worked really hard, but it's not you haven't worked as hard as this person because they've they sacrificed even more. Um so yeah, I think that's maybe why, yeah, I tend not to like that kind of if only you work hard advice, um, it's sort of it's it's not quite true, perhaps.

SPEAKER_02Um and it it's still obviously a very noisy, chancy, at the even at the end of that, it's still not guaranteed this, you know, the dice can just roll a certain way. Um but one of like just so something that's also like relevant here is then when you have people who are in these kinds of competitions um and sort of realizing, oh no, like this is maybe more than I signed up for, it's very reasonable for them to want um certain kind of breathers, right? They sort of want they'll say things like, um, you know, it's it's we don't sort of earn enough money as grad students, for example, you know, if you give me more money, then I will have more time to go and write my articles.

SPEAKER_02And like maybe we should do that, but the fact of the zero-sum competition means well, if everybody gets that money, they're all just gonna spend the extra time writing those articles. And so the it's just going to kind of raise the bar that you then have to have to cross, and so it won't actually make things easier for you. And now, maybe you should still give people money, maybe that's like a fairer competition to have. But I think people often don't realize that like the fact of the competition means that giving people more slack is not going to make everybody collectively better off overall. It's because that slack is just going to get eaten up in a slightly different way.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Yeah, so maybe uh we can talk now about kind of current trends in society. So I just wondered how this idea of Slack relates to kind of current preoccupations or debates in society. Is there any like useful connection between those those two things?

SPEAKER_02I think one interesting debate that often's had is between uh sometimes it gets described as between boomers and zoomers. There's this pretty little debate about whether like did the older generation have things better than kind of we do today. And um, both groups like likes to kind of pick the statistics to kind of favor their their narrative. So, you know, um people my age and younger will sort of say, hey, the older generations, they could afford the houses were much cheaper and you had to work less to afford one, and university was was free for some people, and so you guys had it easier and you kind of got all this wealth and pulled the rug up behind you.

SPEAKER_02Whereas so the old people older than me will sort of say things like, No, like you guys have so much information and so many resources, and you can more freedom to pick what jobs you want, and um obviously quality of life is better, and you know, products are better, and you know, you've got a higher life expectancy, right? So who's who's kind of right? Um obviously it depends. I think what's what I've read from some economists is that even though individual workers are working less today than sort of let's say 50 years ago when you had like a single breadwinner, because a very common kind of health-old structure has gone from sort of male breadwinner with sort of wife at home doing the housework too often now, two workers individually they're doing less paid employment work, but you've now but the total for the household has increased, right?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um so it's a thing where you you want both both people are working and so they earn more money, and that seems good. It seems like that should give you more slack, more breathing room. Well, now it's a kind of it's a lot more work that's kind of outbalancing the the decrease in the household work and sort of child rearing that needed to be done. So it seems like the upshot is just that you can have people both be working less as individuals and yet still have less time overall. Um, and because you know, today, because it's much more common to have uh dual income households, well, that's raised kind of the flaw of um how much you need to be earning to have like a nice house, right?

SPEAKER_02So it's true that you can have people both earning more and needing to spend more because it as more people do it, you've got more competition, and thus that's eating into what would have been Slack kind of previously. So I think there's kind of a germ of truth to kind of both these perspectives, um, which makes it a bit distorting to sort of simplify it down to just like well, one side had it had a better or or not.

SPEAKER_00So I know I wanted to move to some of the negatives of Slack. So you it seems like this good thing, like Slack is this is good is this good thing that kind of protects us uh mentally, emotionally, morally, financially, whatever. But then you say that there are these sort of hidden dangers about people or companies or politicians having too much slack. So could you walk us through how merely having a sort of a good thing could actually be such a negative force?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, the facetious answer is that, well, slack's good when the good guys have it and bad when the bad guys have it. Um but that's not very informative. So yeah, I mean, obviously, if tyrant in power has a lot of slack to kind of do as he wishes, uh, that's bad. We should stop that. We should um put in constraints, maybe term limits or separation of powers. But so that's like the obvious one. And where I think Slack can be interesting because it's bad is that it can um it can hide certain kinds of problems if you've got kind of this buffer to weather certain crises that can prevent you from being incentivized to solve certain problems, right?

SPEAKER_02So if you're a politician, you might think, I just need to get to the next election. I don't need to actually fix the problem that are making the voters angry, right? I can put a band-aid solution and then that'll make them happy and then I'll get elected again, right? You know, we we talked about this before that competition is in many cases very good because it incentivizes you to, you know, make reforms and and um look for kind of new solutions. You know, um if you're if you've got kind of a buffer from the uh consequences of your actions, well, that also prevents learning, right? You don't get kind of feedback on um what needs to change.

SPEAKER_02It can also kind of foster dependency as you just sort of just don't develop the skills that you need to flourish in a kind of in a in a different situation where there's perhaps um less support for you. You might also be tempted to put in kind of less effort um and adopt kind of lower standards. So, you know, if you're a a student and you just sort of know that look, if I don't do put the effort in my assignment, but I can just sort of apply, you know, sort of easily say I, you know, um I was ill over the weekend, you sort of don't need to provide like a doctor's certificate or anything, right?

SPEAKER_02You've now got this buffer that prevents you from getting like a failing grade or being kicked out of the course, and that's incentivized you to kind of not put in the effort to, you know, learn the material and develop those skills, for instance.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I was thinking like is there like a formal slack in terms of like bodily resources or like health, where it might be better if having smoked three cigarettes, you have some life-threatening illness. That would sound awful, but actually it's because you have a buffer. You can smoke, nothing happens. You can smoke more, you enjoy it, nothing happens. You smoke more, you have a chat with your friends outside the pub, have a great time, feel more relaxed, nothing happens. And so, because of this buffer, you keep smoking, and then there's some sort of click where you suddenly have a problem. But if it were the case of cigarettes were like so unbelievably unbearable for your lungs that you your body wasn't giving you the slack to inhale those things, and then if you knew that after three whole cigarettes like that, you'd be done, you'd be like, Okay, let's have one cigarette and call it a day, like let's not go to three because we know what's gonna happen.

SPEAKER_00So, I guess, yeah, this this sort of like flexibility can be a bad thing, I guess.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that sort of by having this kind of buffer, you sort of go, Oh, well, I know I'm safe, so I'm gonna take these risks, and then it might be a slippery slope, or you sort of start to develop habits, but you don't think of you don't think in terms of like, is this like a habit that I want to develop? You just think of it, I just need to have strength of will and I'll just decide to stop. And um, maybe that's like a slightly distorted view of kind of human psychology. Yeah, I think that's that's absolutely right.

SPEAKER_00And then I took it to be the case, maybe this is wrong. The one kind of thread in the paper is you know, we haven't been able to think about slack enough, and we need to think about it more, and we need to kind of guard our slack more and kind of have more slack. But is it possible that many people are kind of slack obsessed without realizing it? I I kind of count myself perhaps among these people. So that is, you know, you always want to hold on to spare money, you always want to hold on to spare time or goodwill that's extended to you by others for a day that can never come.

SPEAKER_00So one interesting thing I heard recently on a uh podcast is about like um retirees and pensioners who are just not spending like they they they spend they spend so much of their time and energy in earlier life, like saving money for retirement. And then when they're retired, they don't spend the money and they they die with it, right? So they kind of they they're underspend or they actually keep increasing their wealth as their kind of window of life becomes shorter and shorter, they're still increasing their wealth to like new heights, and they never get to enjoy that money. And it even if it's not about you know luxury goods being great, they could donate it to charities, they could kind of you know that they could have these experiences of trying to have an impact on the world through giving it to other people or giving it to charity or whatever, and they they don't, they just kind of die with this accumulated wealth, and there kind of seems to be something quite sad there, and yeah, you mentioned habits, it seems like you built up this habit in early life that then doesn't serve you like in later life.

SPEAKER_00So is there a significant chunk of the population who actually needs to like think about Slack as a as a kind of way of spending more of it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's interesting. Um so I think maybe there's two um pathologies here. So one is accumulating too much slack, like you know, it's it's mostly like it it mostly seems to have instrumental value, right? It seems like if you're just there's a certain point where you know having more wealth just in case seems irrational because you've just already you've already got enough wealth that you can kind of handle anything that comes your way, right? So if you're kind of adding more bills onto the pile, then that that sort of seems pointless, at least from your kind of um own well-being.

SPEAKER_02You're sort of, you know, the point of having the money is to kind of spend it or to protect you to or protect you from certain things. So that's that's definitely kind of one, I guess, pathology, one way we can go wrong. That we're um, I guess too cautious or too risk-averse. Another one though, which I took you to be kind of picking up on at the start, was cases where people are using the need for Slack as an excuse to not do other things. Um so maybe this thing is a case where um maybe, I don't know, someone shirks their responsibilities but sort of says, oh, I'm I'm sort of taking a mental health day, right?

SPEAKER_02Um and like, you know, absolutely people should take mental health days, but also some people might, you know, use that as a justification when actually they didn't need it. They might kind of come to think that I need, you know, my spec capacity my spec capacity is so very, very low when actually it's sort of much higher than they are making it out to be. And so it might be that you kind of get in this feedback loop where people are telling themselves, oh, I have to be kind of really cautious, I sort of don't have much slack, and then kind of it's yourself kind of making the habit of thinking in that kind of way. Um so sometimes psychologists talk about something called like a locus of control, where people who sort of see themselves as masters of their own destiny and being able to kind of make decisions and determine how their life is gonna go, uh tend to have better outcomes in part because that belief makes them go and make better decisions and and you know get the things that they want.

SPEAKER_02And so I can see this, I can see this risk coming about where if we tell people, hey, you need to keep on to your Slack, you need to that at least in some cases, some people might sort of invoke that as a justification for doing kind of crappy things and not helping out when actually actually they could have. There is at least kind of costs to both kind of attitudes, I guess.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Um so yeah, um maybe like to end I can imagine a listener thinking this is this is useful, and I think Slack's a really valuable resource that can't be boiled down to like money or time, it comes in all these different forms, and it's really good to have Slack. But there's just so much that I could be doing that I can't, I just I can't afford to to have Slack for several reasons. One is like the kind of thought you get from like Oliver Berkman, the kind of anti-time management guy, and who says like the amount of books you could be reading is is infinite, the amount of podcasts you could be listening to is infinite, the amount of places that restaurants you could eat in is for all intents and purposes in the like world infinite.

SPEAKER_00And so there's so much stuff you could be doing, which is a problem, it seems. And also, like morally speaking, like Felina philosophers often identify like more and more and more duties that we didn't think we have, so like you know. Duties maybe not to not to buy animal products or duties to give more money to charity. These things can feel like they require time or or or money or willpower. And then you've got like looking after kids, which seems uh I'm not a parent, but seems to be like almost a never-ending task because yeah, children understandably have like one one need after another.

SPEAKER_00And then you've got work and your career and making sure there's like bills that are being paid, and then you've got exercise, and then you've got the fact that you're eating all these processed foods that aren't good for you. And so, like, it people might just think like this is so much I could be doing in any given realm. A kind of philosopher or a doctor or um sports expert will tell me that I should be doing all these other things, and so like I guess that drives up the opportunity costs of having Slack. So, yeah, what what would you say to that kind of thought of being like I have to like live on the edge because there's so much to do and I can't really afford Slack?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think you've put your finger on something important, which is that you know, in today's world where we've been given a lot more information and we're a lot more aware of all our options, right? All the things you could be doing, all the people you could be meeting, all the um careers you could be having, all the places you could be going. We're now a lot more aware of kind of the opportunity costs of keeping our slack, of kind of not doing any one of those things. And so um it can feel like there's a lot more pressure to not just kind of do a bunch of these things, but like do the best one of them, right?

SPEAKER_02The answer to you know how you should approach this, I think, is yes, to kind of look at um what do most people in your situation who are competing or saying this like, you know, how are they ending up? Not just on obviously like the people on Instagram who kind of get to curate it and make it look all very nice, but sort of our average Joe. Certainly there's a widespread perception that people today have a lot more mental health issues and are a lot less satisfied, even though in in kind of terms of their material circumstances they are they are much better off. Um plausibly social media ha has has a lot to do with this.

SPEAKER_02Um so I guess I would say, look, it's certainly true that yes, um, you shouldn't have too much slack, you should spend it on some things sort of wisely. Um but certainly this mentality of I have to optimize everything, I have to kind of squeeze every efficiency out that I can, um does lead to certain pathologies that do seem to be manifesting in many people. And so perhaps it's um you know not prudent to do that. Maybe you should try to have a bit more of a satisfying mindset where um you just sort of aim for good enough on each of these things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and also like maybe if you have you do kind of hop on a plane to Tokyo because you heard about this incredible um restaurant, and then if you try and pack too much in, you actually probably maybe can't even enjoy the experiences that you're having in the first place because there's sort of this constant pressure on you in terms of like not enough time. Um so yeah, but maybe like the satisfacing mentality is actually really good because you can kind of focus on quality of like, yeah, I don't have much time to go meet new people in any given week, but I'll I'll do it like once every two weeks, and then it'll be like something that I can really try to enjoy, or not try to enjoy, but I think that's also a pathology, like trying to enjoy something, but but have that like mental bandwidth to kind of actually focus on it.

SPEAKER_00That's all we have for today. Thank you so much for listening until the very bitter end. See you on the first of next month for more. Do check out the back catalogue of episodes, and see you soon for more surprising ethics.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The philosophy of breakups: are breakups good? w. Dr Justin Clardy and Idil Çakmur

    Oct 1, 202651 minAudio

    Are breakups actually *good*? Do they unlock striving, freedom, and authenticity? Or is anchoring and commitment the ideal path? Is the trend towards non-committal, undefined 'situationships' bad or good, and why? And...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Sex, dating, and discrimination. w. Dr Simone Degn and Dr Søren Midtgaard

    Jul 1, 202641 minAudio

    Being straight: a fair sexual preference or discrimination? What about not wanting to date people of certain races? Or screening dates based on height? What counts as discrimination in dating, and what is simply...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Activism for good causes: often morally wrong? w. Tobias Leenaert

    Jun 1, 202644 minAudio

    Are activists who fight for a good cause with a bad strategy on the hook morally? The episode begins with a striking thought experiment which suggests the answer may be ‘yes’. The episode also asks: Are hard-line...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Counts as a War of Self-Defence? Iran & Beyond w. Prof David Rodin

    May 1, 202657 minAudio

    What actually counts as self-defence when waging war? The 21st century has seen a pivot towards ‘preventive wars’: wars fought in anticipation of a possible future attack. The war in Iran is the latest example. What can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is the manosphere making men incapable of love? w. Patrick van Straaten

    Apr 1, 202653 minAudio

    Research shows it’s love - not money or social status - that can soothe the suffering many men are feeling today. But is the manosphere taking this balm away from men? It encourages men to see women as stereotypes and...

    Credit the people on this episode