Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Summer's Substack Podcast

Summer's Substack Podcast artwork

Women Rise: The Long Refusal

Aug 31, 20261 hr 26 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Violence is usually most impressive from a distance or imagined rather than experienced. From a distance there can be uniforms and courage. We can create (fictional) righteous fury, decisive gestures, villains who are defeated and emphasize some form of imaginary reward. We might even hide the losses in the closets of history. Very inconveniently, there remain medical appointments, court dates, photographs that somebody has to look at again, houses that feel emptier than the home they used to be, and ordinary objects that acquire meanings they were never created to hold. There are people who survive something and discover that survival is not an ending but another difficult beginning - a new start that they absolutely did not ask for. Violence walks into a room uninvited and stays for generations. For so many reasons, this subject brings my mind to women. Women are not naturally peaceful beings without fury, independent thought, or flaw. History would laugh madly at me for suggesting any such thing. Women have defended empires, enforced racial hierarchies, supported authoritarian governments, protected abusive institutions and participated in political violence. Women have exploited other women. We have failed one another and have sometimes benefited from systems that injured other women who had less power than we did. We must never allow abuse of power to become innocent merely because it is a woman who possesses it. There is no such thing as biological purity- period. Women or otherwise. Certainly, there is not half the human population marching uniformly to rescue humanity from itself. I am not here to tell lies or to distort history. That practice simply will not help us. I am also not interested in hearing some of the long-time patriarchal sentiment. The version of this story in which women supposedly possess some mysterious capacity for endless patience and are therefore uniquely equipped to absorb male violence until men get better control of themselves. Women have had a very long, misinformed, and exhausting education in patience. We have been instructed to forgive quickly, accommodate everyone else very generously, understand the pressures affecting the person hurting us and not our harm. Patriarchal structures over generations have made women responsible to absorb harm to keep the mission of the church, family or workplace intact. I have never understood why the responsibility rested there... one would believe - rationally even - that power be held to account for its’ own actions. Whether individual or systemic - somehow - women have been charged with making oppression “work”. Being submissive and the concept of nonviolence are very different species. These ideas tend to get merged for the convenience of violence and the abuses of power that plague us today - yesterday - and throughout human history. Let me talk about something that I think that it is considerably more useful. Across very different times, geographic, and political regions, women who were excluded from conventional power learned to recognize other kinds of power. Women withdrew labour and disrupted commerce. Continuous circulation of information that challenged norms and eventually changed laws. We occupied public places, protected forests and the Earth. We tried to save our evidence with care. We imagined and then built accessible schools, and we carried so many important messages over generations. We often form groups and coalitions of people to make oppressive suffering visible enough that it can no longer be dismissed as one unfortunate woman’s problem or fault. Sometimes, as history tells us, women succeeded and many times we did not. Some women lived long enough to see laws change and people benefit from their dedication to humanity. Many others died while the system they wrestled for fairness within- was still causing harm. Women have been punished to various consequences for standing up against oppression. The alternative was to remain at risk without any fight at all. I want to say that clearly because discussions of nonviolent resistance can become strangely sanitized and those harmed villainized as being radicalized (rather than being remembered for their effort to ensure rights apply to everyone). I also want to say that history tells us that peaceful protest is not necessarily peaceful to experience. A woman refusing violence has no magical ability to make the person confronting her refuse violence as well. For women, choosing nonviolence has never been a guarantee of safety. If we tell these stories without the injuries, arrests, disappearances and fear, we quietly turn courage into good manners doing the work of oppression and cruelty. The women were not asking oppression and cruelty to stop in their kindest most feminine voices... They were interfering with it. (AUDIO FILE/RECORDING has the complete podcast). References Chenoweth, E. (2019). Women’s participation and the fate of nonviolent campaigns: A report on the Women in Resistance (WiRe) dataset. One Earth Future Foundation. Chenoweth, E. (2020). The future of nonviolent resistance. Journal of Democracy, 31(3), 69-84. Chenoweth, E., & Shay, C. W. (2022). Updating nonviolent campaigns: Introducing NAVCO 2.1. Journal of Peace Research, 59(6), 876-889. Chenoweth, E., & Stephan, M. J. (2011). Why civil resistance works: The strategic logic of nonviolent conflict. Columbia University Press. Jain, S. (1984). Standing up for trees: Women’s role in the Chipko movement. Unasylva, 36(146), 12-20. Library of Congress. (n.d.). 1917: Historical timeline of the National Woman’s Party. Women of Protest: Photographs from the Records of the National Woman’s Party. Madres de Plaza de Mayo Línea Fundadora. (n.d.). Historia. Madres de Plaza de Mayo Línea Fundadora. National Park Service. (2020). And Nothing Less: Episode 3 - Truth is of no color. U.S. Department of the Interior. National Park Service. (2024). Bricklayers Hall. U.S. Department of the Interior. Nobel Prize Outreach. (2011). Leymah Gbowee - Facts. NobelPrize.org. Parks Canada. (2025). Mary Two-Axe Earley (1911-1996): National historic person. Government of Canada. South African History Online. (2011). The 1956 Women’s March, Pretoria, 9 August. Updated July 20, 2026. UN Women. (2025a). Women’s rights in review 30 years after Beijing. United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. UN Women. (2025b). Afghanistan Gender Index 2024. United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. UN Women. (2025c). Nearly eight out of 10 young Afghan women are excluded from education, jobs, and training. United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. UN Women. (2025d). Facts and figures: Women, peace, and security. United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. UN Women. (2025e). Tipping point: The chilling escalation of online violence against women in the public sphere. United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. UN Women, & United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2025). Femicides in 2024: Global estimates of intimate partner/family member femicides. United Nations. Women’s History Archives. (n.d.). Kvennafrí [Women’s Day Off]. National and University Library of Iceland. World Health Organization. (2025). Violence against women prevalence estimates, 2023: Global, regional and national prevalence estimates for intimate partner violence against women and non-partner sexual violence against women. World Health Organization. World Health Organization. (2026, June 18). Violence against women. World Health Organization. Thank you Mandy Ohman, Ellen Newhouse, Laura (NOT Loomer) 📎🐜🐜, Tracy Giddings, MJ Cooke, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. Get full access to Summer's Substack at summerwillan.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome VT Grown. Happy Monday. We're just going to let some people come and join the room before we get started. I hope you're having a good Monday. I don't know about you, but it seemed to me like the weekend just sort of flew right by.

SPEAKER_00Hey Tracy, welcome, happy Monday. If you guys can let me know, if either of you can let me know, if you can hear me, that would be fantastic.

SPEAKER_00The entire summer flew by. I know. Isn't it crazy? It's August 31st. August 31st. Thanks, Tracy. Appreciate it. I don't know how that happened either. I don't know how it's the end of the summer. It's a weird thing I've always had to say because my name is Summer and the end of the summer just sounds so ominous.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, I'm going to just get started for a bit before I get into the actual women rise. Yeah, when I put it that way. Yeah, it's a bit odd to... When you're named after one of the seasons, I mean, you're either in season or you're out of season or if you're at the end of the season, what exactly is that supposed to mean? All right.

SPEAKER_00Welcome everybody. While we are checking sound, I also want to say hello. And I want to thank some of the people who keep helping us build this kind of strange, lovely little corner of the world. At Mediocre Mama, of course, in the Midnight Cafe, where the difficult things can be said without anybody being required to surrender their humanity at the door. Don't miss tonight at 7 p.m. Eastern Time, 12 midnight British Summertime, for the Women's Fear Part 4.

SPEAKER_00We also have Laura Knot Loomer, and I cannot stress enough that the knot remains legally, spiritually, and algorithmically load-bearing. Laura has an almost supernatural ability to locate the absurd scene running through a story and somehow manages to put her finger on it while making us laugh. At Chris Palomino, she brings art as resistance, and she brings color on purpose. Ed Amy Northam is an amazing and creative writer who has a lovely habit

SPEAKER_00of greeting people as though their arrival matters, perhaps because it really does. Ellen Newhouse, a musician, writer, healer, deep thinker. She brings humor and heart and partly responsible for what is about to happen. Check out her new release on September 4th, 2026, a song called White Man's Sin. Mindhaven helps create rooms for thought,

SPEAKER_00reflection, and for human beings who occasionally need somewhere to put their heads down. Neurodivergent Hodgepodge makes room for minds and bodies without insisting everybody fit inside the same little box first. There are so many and many others who join, share, restack, tell somebody else about the room. They bring stories, ask difficult questions, offer another perspective, or they simply sit quietly and make this room less empty.

SPEAKER_00All of these humans are important because none of us is writing this story alone. We are inheriting pages, certainly we are, and some of them are very ugly. Some were written long before we got here. Some people with very large microphones are currently attempting to write whole paragraphs on our behalf, but they do not own the page, and they certainly don't own all of the punctuation. So, If the sound is good and everyone has located the appropriate snacks,

SPEAKER_00are you all ready to proceed? Excellent. Welcome, Jumper, I just saw you came. Welcome, welcome. It's now one o'clock, so I'm going to get started. The Long Refusal.

SPEAKER_00Violence is most impressive from a distance or imagined rather than experienced. From a distance there can be uniforms and courage. We can create fictional but righteous fury, decisive gestures, villains who are defeated and emphasize Some form of imaginary reward. We might even hide the losses in the closets of history. Very inconveniently, there remain medical appointments,

SPEAKER_00court dates, photographs that somebody has to look at again. Houses that feel emptier than the home they used to be. And ordinary objects that acquire meanings they were never created to hold. There are people who survive something and discover that survival is not an ending, but another difficult beginning. A new start that they absolutely did not ask for. Violence walks into a room uninvited and stays for generations.

SPEAKER_00So for many reasons, the subject begins. Brings to my mind, women. Women are not naturally peaceful beings without fury, independent thought or flaw. History would laugh madly at me for suggesting any such thing. Women have defended empires, enforced racial hierarchies, supported authoritarian governments, protected abusive institutions and participated in political violence. Women have exploited other women.

SPEAKER_00We have failed one another and have sometimes benefited from systems that injured other women who had less power than we did. We must never allow abusive power to become innocent merely because it is a woman who possesses it. There is no such thing as biological purity, period, women or otherwise. Certainly there is not half the human population marching uniformly to rescue humanity from itself. I am not here to tell lies or to distort history.

SPEAKER_00That practice will simply not help us." I'm also not interested in hearing some of the long-time patriarchal sentiment. The version of this story in which women supposedly possess some mysterious capacity for endless patience and are therefore uniquely equipped to absorb male violence until men get better control of themselves. Women have had a very long, misinformed, and exhausting education in patience. We have been instructed to forgive quickly,

SPEAKER_00accommodate everyone else very generously, understand the pressures affecting the person hurting us, and not our own harm. Patriarchal structures over generations have made women responsible to absorb harm to keep the mission of the church, family, or workplace intact. I have never understood why the responsibility rested there. One would believe, rationally even, that power be held to account for its own actions, whether individual or systemic.

SPEAKER_00But somehow women have been charged with making oppression work. Being submissive and the concept of nonviolence are a very different species. These ideas tend to get merged for the convenience of violence and the abuses of power that plague us today, yesterday, and throughout human history. Let me talk about something that I think is considerably more useful.

SPEAKER_00Across very different times, geographic and political regions, women who were excluded from conventional power learned to recognize other kinds of power. Women withdrew labor and disrupted commerce, continuous circulation of information that challenged norms and eventually changed laws. We occupied public places, protected forests and the earth. We tried to save our evidence with care. We imagined... And then built accessible schools.

SPEAKER_00We carried so many important messages over many generations. We often form groups and coalitions of people to make oppressive suffering visible enough that it can no longer be dismissed as one unfortunate woman's problem or fault. Sometimes, as history tells us, women succeeded, and many times we have not. Some women lived long enough to see laws change and people benefit from their dedication to humanity.

SPEAKER_00Many others died while the system they wrestled for fairness within was still causing harm. Women have been punished to various consequences for standing up against oppression. The alternative, of course, was to remain at risk without any fight at all. I want to say that clearly because discussions of non-violent resistance can become strangely sanitized and those harmed villainized as being radicalized rather than being remembered for their effort to ensure rights apply to everyone.

SPEAKER_00I also want to say that history tells us that peaceful protest is not necessarily... The women...

SPEAKER_00We're not asking oppression and cruelty to stop in their kindest, most feminine voices. They were interfering with it. The work history tends to misplace, hide, or try to rewrite. Podiums in history tend to be joined at the hip. History likes to remember the famous speeches, the extraordinary or popular leaders, the pic that can be printed in textbooks or posted in Wikipedia. And history loves the specific date we can put neatly on a timeline.

SPEAKER_00It is much less interested in the six months of meetings held in somebody's kitchen that made those events possible. That creates a challenge when we inherit stories about resistance based on incomplete information. We remember the day something happened, but very often miss the infrastructure that made the day possible. Rosa Parks name, for instance, but fewer people may know Joanne Robinson's name.

SPEAKER_00We remember the march, but not who printed and distributed the public notices, among so many other important jobs that made the march possible. Women existed in those spaces repeatedly over time. It was not always noticed because much of women's political history has taken place where formal political history has excluded them, incomplete records of monumental contributions to humanity, human rights, and fairness. All but lost.

SPEAKER_00The American women's suffrage movement offers an early warning about making any of these histories too tidy. Women demanding the vote faced imprisonment and physical abuse. Members of the National Women's Party picketed the White House in 1917 and were arrested. Imprisoned suffragists demanding recognition as political prisoners were placed on solitary confinement. Alice Paul and Rose Winslow went on hunger strike and were force-fed.

SPEAKER_00On November 15th, guards at the Occoquan Workhouse used force against imprisoned suffragists in what became known as the Night of Terror, provoking public outrage when reports of their treatment became known. That's from the Library of Congress. The resistance was non-violent, but what happened to them was not. Even inside the movement demanding equality for women, Equality was unevenly imagined.

SPEAKER_00Black women had to fight racism within suffrage organizations at the same time that they fought disenfranchisement outside them. Ida B. Wells was already an accomplished investigative journalist and anti-lynching activist when she became an important suffrage organizer. The 1913 Women Suffrage Procession in Washington, organizers concerned about alienating white Southern supporters attempted to segregate black marchers. Wells refused to quietly accept the place assigned to her,

SPEAKER_00There is a useful correction in that story for anyone tempted by uncomplicated sisterhood. Women can be oppressed by one hierarchy while protecting another. Wells did not agree that racial dignity could wait until sexism had been addressed. Black women did not get to cue racism and sexism politely and deal with them

SPEAKER_00in separate decades. Women rarely inhabit only one social identity, and a movement calling itself liberation becomes suspect very quickly if someone else's dignity is the admission price. That difficulty has followed women's movements throughout history. It does not make solidarity impossible. It makes honest solidarity more demanding. A few decades later, another black woman would become so famous That the infrastructure surrounding her nearly disappeared from popular memory.

SPEAKER_00Rosa Parks was not simply a tired seamstress who spontaneously reached the end of her patience on a Montgomery bus. Parks was an experienced civil rights activist. The woman's political counsel led by Alabama State University Professor Joanne Robinson had already spent years challenging segregation And the abusive treatment of black passengers on Montgomery's buses. The WPC had met with the mayor, city commissioners, and bus officials long before Park's arrest.

SPEAKER_00Its members were not waiting for history to begin. They were preparing for an opportunity to act. When Parks was arrested on December 1, 1955, Robinson and others worked through the night producing notices calling for black residents to boycott the buses the following Monday. Those notices moved through schools, neighborhoods, churches. The response was extraordinary. Nearly all of Montgomery's black residents stayed off the buses on the first day.

SPEAKER_00And what might have been a one day protest developed into a boycott lasting more than a year. This requires considerably more than indignation. People still had jobs. They still had to get across the city. Cars had to become carpools, drivers were needed, money was needed, shoes wore out, people walked long distances after working all day. The boycott had to survive weather, fatigue, harassment, arrest, financial pressure, and that inevitable moment in any sustained action when the emotional intensity of

SPEAKER_00the beginning is gone, but the problem is still there. That is worth dwelling on because it changes the question resistance asks. Outrage asks whether we object strongly enough. Organizing asks what the system depends on. Montgomery's segregated bus system depended heavily on black passengers continuing to pay fares while accepting humiliation. Once tens of thousands of people understood that their participation was also a form

SPEAKER_00of leverage, their absence became political. 20 years later, women in Iceland demonstrated the same principle with almost startling clarity. On October 24, 1975, Icelandic women withdrew their labor to protest discrimination in paid employment and to make visible the contribution women made to society. Women stepped away from paid jobs and much of the unpaid work that kept households and communities running.

SPEAKER_00The day, drew international attention and became the first of several women's days off, repeated over subsequent decades. The brilliance of the action was that women did not have to produce another complicated explanation of why their work mattered. They stopped doing it, and the explanation simply appeared. Workplaces were disrupted. Households had to adjust. Fathers brought children to work. Care work,

SPEAKER_00so often described as priceless, immediately before somebody explains why there is insufficient money to pay for it, became difficult to ignore once it was absent. There is broader lesson here. Systems often survive without enthusiastic support. They survive because enough of us continue doing the ordinary things the system needs. We fill out the forms, buy the products, accept the language, perform the labor, provide the expertise, attend the event, and occasionally laugh awkwardly at something we know is wrong.

SPEAKER_00Because challenging it would make the room too uncomfortable. The machinery of cruelty includes spectacular acts, obviously. It also depends on ordinary cooperation, and so does resistance. Women in South Africa understood that in a very different and much more dangerous political environment. On August 9, 1956, around 20,000 women marched to the Union buildings in Pretoria to protest apartheid past laws.

SPEAKER_00They came from different racial and cultural communities under a state explicitly organized around racial hierarchy. The Federation of South African Women helped organize the demonstration with leaders including Lillian Ngoi, Helen Joseph, Ramina Musa, and Sophia Williams-Debrun. Women carried petitions and gathered at the administrative center of a government that had every intention of continuing apartheid, whether they approved it or not.

SPEAKER_00It was not a single afternoon of theatrical defiance detached from consequences. Women resisting past laws were arrested and imprisoned. Activists were surveilled, banned, and harassed. The 1956 march belonged to longer struggle in which women resisted the state's attempt to regulate where black people could live, work, and move. Again, the issue was larger than being permitted to speak. The women were contesting the state's claim to decide whose movement,

SPEAKER_00labor, and existence could be controlled for the convenience of somebody else. This distinction between voice and agency matters a lot. Oppressive systems will sometimes allow people to speak because speaking alone does not necessarily alter anything. Begins when speech can affect the conditions in which people actually live. Women in the Himalayan region of India found another form of leverage in

SPEAKER_00the forests around their communities. The CHIPCO movement became internationally associated with images of real women placing their bodies beside trees threatened by commercial logging. The image is memorable, perhaps too memorable, because it can turn complicated local struggles into romantic story about gentle women hugging nature. The reality was much more demanding. Forests were bound to local economies and daily survival.

SPEAKER_00They affected fuel, fodder, soil, water, and the ability of rural communities to continue living where they were. Women experienced these conditions intimately through the work required to maintain households. Their environmental concern was not a decorative love of trees. It arose from the relationship between ecological destruction and human survival. Scholar Shobita Jain warned decades ago against oversimplifying CHIPCO,

SPEAKER_00even while recognizing the significance of women's participation in forestry, community development, and environmental protection. The women's bodies made the consequences visible. There is something important about that because cruelty benefits enormously from distance. A forest is destroyed somewhere else. A garment is produced in someone else's factory. A woman is harmed behind somebody else's door. A child disappears into somebody else's institution.

SPEAKER_00An exploited worker sits several layers below the consumer in a supply chain nobody can see. A person becomes a demographic category, and categories are much easier to sacrifice than our neighbors. Visibility interferes with that comfort. Perhaps no group understands the politics of visibility more painfully than the mothers of Plaza de Mayo. During Argentina's military dictatorship, women whose children had been forcibly disappeared began searching for answers

SPEAKER_00in government offices, police stations, military facilities, churches, and courts. They found one another. They found one another because institutions would not tell them Where their sons and daughters were. On April 30, 1977, they gathered at Plaza de Mayo in Buenos Aires. Their meetings became regular. Their white headscarves became recognizable. Their circular walks around the plaza became one of the defining images of

SPEAKER_00the resistance to the dictatorship. A political transformation here was profound. A disappeared person leaves behind a peculiar form of cruelty. There is no truthful explanation, no grave, no body to bury, sometimes not even an admission that the state has taken anyone. The family is left between hope and terror. While the institution responsible for the disappearance behaves as though the family's inability to prove what happened somehow relieves the institution

SPEAKER_00of all responsibility. The mothers changed the scale of that experience. One woman searching for one missing child could be dismissed as a grieving mother. Women who found one another transformed individual grief into a collective demand for memory, truth, and justice. They were not protected by motherhood. Some mothers themselves were disappeared. Founding figure, I don't want to mispronounce her name, Azucena Villaflor was abducted in December 1977 and murdered.

SPEAKER_00That fact should stop us from ever describing non-violence as a safe alternative. It is an alternative to deliberately using violence as a primary means of political struggle. There is a difference between those two truths. The mother's power came partly from refusing the isolation the dictatorship required. Authoritarian violence does not only injure bodies, it also tries to control reality. People disappear and the government denies it.

SPEAKER_00Families ask questions and are made to feel dangerous for asking them. Terror becomes more effective when everyone experiences it privately. Mothers carried private grief into public space and kept returning. In Canada, oppression has often been easier to sanitize because some of it arrived through paperwork. For generations, the Indian Act imposed sex discrimination on First Nations women. A First Nations woman who married a man without status could lose her own status.

SPEAKER_00While the same consequence did not apply to a First Nations man who married a woman without status, the effects reached into property, community, membership, identity, and a woman's ability to transmit status to her children. Married to Axe Early, a Kenyan Kayaka woman from, I'm going to say this wrong, Kenawaki, Spent more than 20 years challenging that discrimination.

SPEAKER_00Beginning in the 1960s, she wrote letters, organized, testified, spoke publicly, and helped build organizations dedicated to First Nation women's equality. She faced resistance not only from the Canadian state, but sometimes the Indigenous political structures in which male authority had also become invested. Changes to the Indian Act in 1985 restored status to many women who had lost it through discriminatory provisions, and two acts early became the first person to regain her status after

SPEAKER_00the amendments. There is something about her story I think Canadians particularly need to understand. Violence does not always shout. Sometimes it has a filing system. Sometimes it explains that these are simply the rules. Sometimes a human being loses belonging, property, or legal recognition, and nobody in an office raising the form raises their voice. Bureaucracy is extremely good at disguising moral decisions as administrative ones.

SPEAKER_00The language becomes technical enough that we forget a law is doing something to an actual human being. One form of resistance, then, is stubbornly returning the human being to the center of the sentence. Mary kept insisting that the legislation had consequences for women's actual lives. She organized for years. That length of time matters, too. It is tempting to summarize it by saying that she campaigned and

SPEAKER_00the law eventually changed, but the word eventually can conceal an enormous amount of living. The same is true of women who organized for peace during Liberia's Civil War. Beginning in 2002, Lema Kabawi helped mobilize Christian and Muslim women into Women of Liberia Mass Action for Peace. They wore white, prayed, demonstrated, and created coalition across religious divisions, while armed factions devastated the country.

SPEAKER_00When peace negotiations stalled in Ghana in 2003, women increased pressure on the negotiators, refusing to allow talks to dissolve casually while people at home continued suffering. Their campaign became an important force pushing Liberia toward peace. It is easy to tell the story badly. We could say that women possessing some special maternal instinct for peace finally persuaded violent men to behave themselves. That would miss almost everything.

SPEAKER_00The Liberian women organized. They identified leverage. They built relationships across religious boundary that war could easily have deepened. They also understood public symbolism. They sustained pressure. They turned women's social position, so often used to exclude them from formal power, into a source of political legitimacy. They did not simply want peace. They built power around their demand for it. And women are still routinely excluded from the rooms where peace is negotiated.

SPEAKER_00UN Women reported that in formal peace process in 2024, women constituted only about 7% of negotiations and 14% of mediators. 9 out of 10 peace processes has no women negotiators at all. That comes directly from UN Women 2025D. We've become quite comfortable saying that women are essential to peace while continuing to treat their presence at negotiating tables as optional. Humanity can be impressively consistent in its own contradictions.

SPEAKER_00What nonviolent power actually is? There is now a substantial body of scholarship examining civil resistance, and it's useful partly because it removes nonviolence from the realm of moral decoration. Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan studied major violent and nonviolent campaigns between 1900 and 2006 and found that nonviolent campaigns were more than twice

SPEAKER_00as effective as violent campaigns at achieving their stated political objectives. The explanation was not that governments become nicer when protesters behave themselves. Nonviolent movements can attract broader participation because people do not need to be willing or able to engage in armed conflict in order to participate. Workers can strike. Consumers can boycott. Professionals can refuse cooperation. Students can organize. Religious communities can mobilize.

SPEAKER_00Older people, parents, and people with disabilities can participate in ways an arms movement may not permit. Large and socially diverse movements can then disrupt the sources of power upon which governments and other institutions depend. This is a different understanding of power from the one we are usually sold. We tend to imagine power as something a person possesses. The president has power, the police chief has power, the billionaire has power, the general has power, and they do.

SPEAKER_00But their power also depends on other people doing things. Orders must be carried out. Money must move. Workers must move. Information must circulate. Professional expertise has to be supplied. Laws must be administered. Products must be purchased. Institutions require some degree of compliance from enough people to remain institutions. Civil resistance looks at those relationships as And asks where cooperation can be altered.

SPEAKER_00That does not make nonviolence easy. And recent research should prevent us from becoming smug about its effectiveness. Chenoweth has documented a decline in the success rates of major nonviolent campaigns in the 21st century. States have learned to manage protests more effectively. A large crowd can matter enormously.

SPEAKER_00It is not the same thing as a durable movement. And that distinction feels especially important now because digital life gives us the experience of political participation with astonishing ease. We can encounter something horrifying, share it, condemn it, argue with a stranger, receive several hundred affirmations that we are correct, and go to bed feeling as though a substantial civic event has occurred. Sometimes online attention genuinely does produce action, and sometimes we simply The

SPEAKER_00historical women in this essay repeatedly moved in another direction. They converted information into relationships, relationships into organization, and organization into forms of pressure that affected the system that they were challenging. The Women in Resistance data set, which examined 338 major campaigns between 1945 and 2014, also makes women's participation difficult to dismiss as peripheral.

SPEAKER_00Women were present in virtually all of the nonviolent campaigns studied. And higher levels of women's participation were associated with broader nonviolent methods and favorable campaign outcomes, including shifts in loyalty among security forces, according to Chenoweth 2019. We should be careful about what we conclude from that. Women are not a magic ingredient one sprinkles onto a political movement to improve its morality.

SPEAKER_00But their inclusion can widen participation, networks, and social reach. When a movement begins to resemble the society itself rather than one narrow political faction, repression can become more complicated. A police officer sees someone who looks like his aunt. A soldier sees teachers, mothers, nurses, students, and elderly neighbors. A business owner sees customers. A civil servant sees colleagues. It does not make repression impossible.

SPEAKER_00History has answered that question far too brutally and far too often. It may, though, make the social cost of the repression much harder to hide. So now we have to arrive here. There's a danger in writing about historic women and ending safely in the past. We could admire the photographs, marvel at their courage, and be grateful that we are more enlightened now. The evidence does not really permit that ending right now, does it?

SPEAKER_00The World Health Organization reported in June 2026 that approximately 840 million women and girls, about one in three globally, have experienced physical or sexual intimate partner violence, non-partner sexual violence, or both during their lifetimes. Progress has been painfully slow. WHO estimates that the global annual decline in intimate partner violence over the past 20 years has been at only about 0.2%.

SPEAKER_00That matters. In an essay about public oppression, Because we have a habit of dividing violence into political and personal categories as though the two grow in separate soil.

SPEAKER_00They do not. A culture in which women's autonomy is negotiable at home will not magically become egalitarian at a parliament. A culture that teaches entitlement in intimate relationships carries that entitlement into workplaces, religious communities, institutions, and our politics. The forms change. The underlying question whether women possess full authority over their own lives and bodies remains remarkably persistent.

SPEAKER_00There has been extraordinary progress, too, and we should not erase it simply because the present moment is very difficult. Since the 1955 Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, girls' access to education has expanded, maternal mortality has fallen, women's parliamentary representation has increased, and governments have enacted substantial legal reforms protecting women's rights. UN's Women's 30-Year Review identified more than 1,500 legal reforms

SPEAKER_00across 189 countries and territories between 1995 and 2024. Those are gains that matter. We can also see some places where we are losing ground. Millions of women are alive, educated, economically independent, legally protected, politically represented, or able to choose lives their grandmothers could not because people organized and institutions changed. Progress is real.

SPEAKER_00It's just not as permanent as we would like it to be. That's why backlash is too. In the same global review, nearly one quarter of governments reported backlash against women's rights in 2024. Women's rights defenders face threats, funding pressures, and political hostility, while misogynistic narratives have become increasingly embedded in digital media. And political environments. That's according to UN Women 2025.

SPEAKER_00Backlash should not surprise us as much as it does. A right being won does not cause everyone who opposed the right to evaporate. Power reorganizes. The vocabulary changes. Arguments that became socially unacceptable return wearing slightly different clothes. Sometimes they return with a podcast. This does not mean that every disagreement about gender, family, law, or culture is evidence of impending authoritarianism. A democratic society contains disagreement, and it should.

SPEAKER_00People can hold views we dislike without becoming enemies of humanity. If we start describing every political dispute as fascism, oppression, or violence, eventually those words lose their ability to identify the things they were built to describe. Truth requires discrimination and discernment. Some things are disagreements and some are really dangerous. Afghanistan is not experiencing a lively policy debate about women's social roles. Since the Taliban returned to power in August of 2021,

SPEAKER_00women and girls have faced sweeping restrictions on education, employment, movement, and public participation. UN Women's 2024 Afghanistan Gender Index released in 2025 found that 78% of young Afghan women were outside education, employment, or training, almost four times the rate than it is for young men. Bans on secondary and tertiary education have created the prospect that girls' secondary school completion will collapse towards zero.

SPEAKER_00Those facts are difficult to absorb because exclusion issues Let's try to make it a little bit smaller to get some perspective. Imagine being 13 and learning that the classroom simply ends for you. Your brother gets to continue. You do not. Not because you failed an examination or incapable, but just because you're a girl. And still, Afghan women organize, work where they are permitted, support one another, run businesses, provide humanitarian assistance,

SPEAKER_00and continue demanding access to lives the authorities are trying to narrow. I am wary of calling this resilience too quickly. We have developed a bad habit of admiring people for surviving conditions the rest of us have made insufficient effort to change. Sometimes resilience is simply what we call another person's lack of acceptable alternatives. But I am equally unwilling to participate in the erasure the restrictions are designed to produce.

SPEAKER_00Afghan women are still here. Their agency has been constrained. It has not ceased to exist. And that distinction belongs at the center of this essay. Agency is not something authorities give women. Authorities can make exercising it dangerous. They can criminalize it. They can restrict its reach. They can punish us brutally. They cannot create the underlying human claim to agency. The digital world has produced another arena in

SPEAKER_00which women's voices can become both more powerful and more vulnerable. Women can now publish, organize, teach, and build communities across distances previous generations would barely imagine. The same technologies can be used to intimidate them. Through threats, doxing, image-based abuse, sexualized harassment, disinformation, and AI-generated material, UN Women's research on online violence against women in public life has found substantial levels of abuse among journalists,

SPEAKER_00activists, human rights defenders, and other public communicators, with online attacks sometimes connecting directly to offline threats and harm. That comes from UN Women 2025E. This is not merely about hurt feelings on the internet. The goal of harassment does not always need to be persuading a woman that she is wrong. Sometimes the goal is making a speech far too expensive for her to endure. Threaten her family enough and she may stop speaking.

SPEAKER_00Publish her address, manufacture a sexual image, contact her employer, flood her inbox, turn every substantive statement into a discussion about her appearance, stability, sexuality, competence, or likability. If she becomes angry, her anger becomes evidence against her. If she remains calm, perhaps she is too cold. If she leaves public office, somebody will eventually say women lack the temperament for public life. The technology is new.

SPEAKER_00The architecture is, like, ancient. What this asks of us now? There's a difficulty in looking backward at resistance movements from the safety of their aftermath. History compresses time terribly well. A struggle that occupied 20 years can be covered in a few pages and a photograph can capture a march without showing us the months of meetings that came before it. The arguments among organizers, the frightened conversations at kitchen tables,

SPEAKER_00the money somebody had to find, the children who still need to be looked after, the jobs people could not afford to lose, or the mornings when somebody woke up exhausted and went away anyway. I think that compression can leave us badly prepared for periods which we ourselves are required to endure.

SPEAKER_00It can make resistance look much more emotionally satisfying than it usually is while people are actually doing it. Sometimes, of course, it does feel powerful. A room can change. Thousands of voices rise together. A court can rule. A law may fall. Someone who thought she was standing alone turns around and realizes she isn't alone at all. And those moments are incredibly important. But a great deal of the work happens when there is no music underneath it

SPEAKER_00and nobody knows yet how the story ends. The news is bad again. The same lie has been repeated so many times that correcting it feels almost ridiculous. An institution you thought was sturdy bends under pressure you assumed it had been designed to withstand. Something that horrified people six months ago begins slipping into ordinary conversation as though it was always that way.

SPEAKER_00This is the part I worry. We are not prepared for. Endurance sounds beautiful until you have to do it. I don't mean enduring abuse, staying in danger to prove courage, or carrying so much the person herself is eventually destroyed by the work. Women have had quite enough instruction in noble suffering. I mean... Long struggles cannot be sustained entirely as emergencies.

SPEAKER_00People need periods of effort and recovery. They need other people who can take some of the weight when they cannot carry much weight. They need communities capable of surviving the fact that public attention wanders and human beings get tired. And sometimes they need to do the same necessary thing for the 50th time without deciding that the first 49 attempts were meaningless. Women know something about that kind of time. Certainly that way of measuring it.

SPEAKER_00Although I want to be careful about romanticizing why. So much of women's work across history has been repetitive because somebody had to keep doing it. Food is made in the event everybody has the nerve to become hungry again. Children are washed and almost immediately become dirty. Somebody recovers from an illness and somebody else comes down with one. Laundry, astonishingly, has never once accepted that it has already been completed.

SPEAKER_00Care does not often provide the intoxicating satisfaction of being finished. There may be some political intelligence buried in that experience, knowing that returning to necessary work is not evidence that the work has failed. We are going to need some of that wisdom. One of the things oppressive periods do especially well is distort reality. Language begins to move slightly, and then considerably. Away from what is actually happening.

SPEAKER_00Cruelty is recast as strength. Humiliation becomes humor. Accountability is described as persecution. Expertise becomes elitism. A deliberate falsehood is suddenly merely another point of view. Eventually, the people objecting to mistreatment can be portrayed as the source of the conflict because, inconveniently, they keep mentioning the mistreatment. A woman can be told that she has misunderstood what happened while also being blamed

SPEAKER_00for causing whatever supposedly did not happen. If she describes it calmly, she's cold. If she becomes angry, her anger becomes evidence that she is unreasonable. Documentation can make her obsessive. A lack of documentation can make her unreliable. The trap is effective because it forces the person naming reality to spend so much energy defending her right to perceive what is happening that she has left none left for the things she was trying to challenge in

SPEAKER_00the first place. This is one reason I think women need one another so much right now. I do not mean that women naturally agree with one another. We plainly don't. Women can betray one another, compete with one another, behave cowardly and cruelly, get things spectacularly wrong, and occasionally be a complete pain in the ass. Sisterhood does not require us to lie about women in order to defend women. What solidarity can do, however, is create enough human connection that distortion has

SPEAKER_00a harder time isolating people. There is tremendous power in another person being able to say very simply, I saw it too. In oppressive environments, one of the first struggles is often over whether an experience can ever be named. A worker notices discrimination. A journalist sees political interference. A teacher realizes that curriculum is being manipulated. A public servant is asked to implement something that violates the purpose of

SPEAKER_00the institution she serves. Someone hears the language around a group of people becoming gradually more contemptuous and realizes that words, like neighbors and citizens, are being replaced with the language of contamination, invasion, or enemies. Any of those people can start wondering whether she's overreacting because human beings take our bearings partly from one another.

SPEAKER_00When everyone else carries on normally, abnormal things can become strangely difficult to trust ourselves about. That is why we need relationships in which we can compare reality. And I do mean compare it, not merely confirm one another. A friend who agrees with everything I say is not necessarily helping me. Neither is a community that can turn every anxiety into proof of an even larger conspiracy by lunchtime. We need people we trust enough to tell us both, yes,

SPEAKER_00you are seeing this clearly, and when necessary, no Summer, I think that That is actually what happened. A trustworthy community helps us see more accurately. It helps distinguish a serious threat from a rumor, an institutional failure from an imperfect decision, and a political opponent from somebody we have given ourselves permission to stop recognizing as a human being. Truth matters too much to protect it carelessly.

SPEAKER_00Exaggerating what a dangerous person has done, Does not strengthen the case against them.

SPEAKER_00It gives them something legitimate to deny and makes the rest easier to dismiss. If we are asking people to believe women when the truth is difficult, inconvenient, or costly, then we have to remain unusually serious about truth, even when a distortion would be politically convenient. Sorry, my throat was dry. That is not about making women respectable enough to deserve a voice.

SPEAKER_00It is about protecting the credibility of the voice itself. And voice is another thing I think we sometimes understand too narrowly. We picture the microphone. Some women will have that role. They will write books, organize rallies, argue cases, conduct research, run for office, testify before governments, and stand in front of crowds. Thank God for them. But public visibility is not the only evidence of courage, and we should not make it another requirement women have to satisfy.

SPEAKER_00Some cannot safely become public figures. Some work in professions where political activity is restricted. Some are caring for children or parents. Some are disabled or exhausted. Some live in communities where visibility creates real danger. And some simply have absolutely no desire to stand behind a podium, which seems very reasonable to me. Humanity has enough people who enjoy microphones. Agency is larger than just performance.

SPEAKER_00A woman who learns how her local school board makes decisions and shows up when something important is being changed is exercising agency. So is the woman who helps somebody prepare for a difficult meeting, the lawyer who quietly takes a case, the physician who refuses to allow ideology to replace evidence, the librarian protecting legitimate access to information, The manager who will not let harassment become the culture of the workplace or the neighbor who goes with somebody because she should not have to walk into

SPEAKER_00a frightening appointment by themselves. Most of these women will never become symbols of any movement. History is always dependent upon enormous numbers of people whose names history did not bother to keep. There is something freezing No individual woman is responsible for stopping an era. None of us can know everything, respond to everything,

SPEAKER_00speak about everything, or divide ourselves equally among every terrible thing happening on the planet. Constant awareness is not the same as useful citizenship. I think we have developed a strange moral expectation that good people should remain continuously distressed, as though putting your phone down while suffering continues somewhere means you have abandoned the people who are suffering. And it absolutely does not mean that. The human nervous system cannot remain in emergency mode indefinitely.

SPEAKER_00Exhaustion does not make us harder to manipulate. Sorry. Quite often, it does the opposite. We become more vulnerable to simple explanations and satisfying enemies. Despair tells us nothing can be changed, while panic tells us everything has to be changed before bedtime. Neither state is particularly helpful for work that may have to continue for years. So we need to learn how to protect one another from exhaustion without turning away

SPEAKER_00from what is happening. This has to mean something more substantial than recommending self-care to women while leaving every condition exhausting them exactly where it was. Sometimes rest really is a bath and a book, and I'm not opposed to either. But sometimes rest is another woman taking the meeting. It is somebody cooking dinner, recovering a shift, minding the children, answering the email, raising some money, making the phone call or saying, oh, you are done for tonight, we have this.

SPEAKER_00The point is not to discover how much more one remarkable woman can carry. It is to build enough community that she does not have to carry all of it at all. It is an important distinction. It's a political one. It isn't merely personal. Oppressive systems benefit enormously when resistance depends upon a handful of exceptional people. Exceptional people can be exhausted. They can be frightened, discredited, isolated, or removed.

SPEAKER_00Networks are harder to deal with. If one woman knows how everything works, the work becomes fragile. If she teaches ten others and they teach ten others, it becomes communal knowledge. If one journalist holds the only copy of a document, intimidation has enormous power. If evidence has been reasonably, responsibly preserved in several places, it has less. If one woman is always the voice of an organization, attacking her can very well silence that voice.

SPEAKER_00Shared competence makes a community harder to break. So when I talk about women being one another's strength, I mean more than encouragement, although we know we need encouragement and that it matters. But I mean increasing each other's capacity. When we know how something works, we can teach it. When we understand an institutional law, a financial process, research methods, technology, public speaking, or simply how to survive a particular room,

SPEAKER_00we can make that knowledge less mysterious for the women coming behind us. A woman with access can make introductions. A woman with authority can make space. A woman who has finally learned not to apologize before offering her expertise can help another woman lose the apology a little sooner. And perhaps we should become very deliberate about this. Ask another woman what she knows. Ask what she wants to learn. Introduce women to one another when you can see that each carries something the other needs.

SPEAKER_00Give credit to publicity. Correct the record when somebody else's work is being quietly reassigned to the loudest person in the room. If you have a platform, sometimes lend it out. If you have money, understand that financing organizations doing serious work is also a form of important action. If you have expertise, make some of it accessible. If you are in a position to mentor someone, do not turn mentorship into performance about your own importance.

SPEAKER_00Tell her the things somebody should have told you. None of this will trend for long. It may matter, though, for decades. Intergenerational relationships among women belong here too. Oppressive movements depend rather heavily on people forgetting things. Old ideas can be marked as daring new discoveries when the people who remember the consequences have been dismissed as irrelevant. Older women carry memories younger women need.

SPEAKER_00Younger women understand cultural and technological environments many older women did not grow up inside. Neither group is improved by contempt for the other. There is something quite powerful, I think, about a woman who remembers what happened 40 years ago, sitting beside a woman who understands exactly what is happening on a platform invented four years ago, and both of them being willing to admit what they do not know. I do worry about the ease with which we have been taught to treat generations

SPEAKER_00as opposing political species. The young are supposedly naive, spoiled, or unserious. Older women are supposedly obsolete, compromised, or responsible for everything younger people inherited. And none of that helps anyone at all. A 22-year-old woman should not have to rediscover every lesson a 70-year-old woman learned through pain. A 70-year-old woman should not assume the world stopped changing once she understood it. Knowledge can travel in all directions.

SPEAKER_00That becomes especially important because women will be encouraged to turn on one another. We should expect it rather than being surprised every single time it happens. Race, class, religion, nationality, sexuality, age, education, and motherhood have all been used to persuade one group of women that another group is the real danger. Those differences are not imaginary and solidarity becomes meaningless if we pretend they are. And a woman living in poverty can both experience misogyny

SPEAKER_00while having profoundly different protection from its consequences. An Indigenous woman in Canada does not need her history flattened into a universal story of womanhood so that everyone else can feel united. A black woman should not have to choose whether she will address racism in feminist spaces or sexism elsewhere. The challenge is to learn how to remain in relationship without demanding sameness. And that's really hard. It means being able to hear that our version of liberation has left somebody out

SPEAKER_00without immediately constructing a defense of our good intentions. It means learning the difference between being uncomfortable and being unsafe. It means occasionally apologizing like an adult and continuing the work. It also means refusing the increasingly common idea that every badly phrased sentence, ignorance, disagreement, or human mistake reveals somebody's permanent moral essence. A movement that requires moral perfection from its members will eventually become

SPEAKER_00a very righteous group of six people blocking one another online. Cruelty can live with that. Of course it can. The coalition is much more troublesome. The Liberian women knew when Christian and Muslim women organized together. Ida B. Wells knew something about it when she continued engaging a suffrage movement in which racism worked. Was real while refusing to accept racism as the price of belonging.

SPEAKER_00South African women knew it when they crossed racial boundaries a government had constructed its power around. Coalition does not require pretending difference has vanished. It means deciding that some things matter enough to work on together. There is another piece of this I think women sometimes approach uneasily. Power itself. We have been allowed to help much more comfortably than we would have been to wield authority.

SPEAKER_00Helping is wonderful. Sometimes somebody also has to make the decision. Influence is not a character flaw. Money can fund something useful. Institutional authority can protect people. Expertise can settle questions that are actually questions of expertise. A woman, I don't even know why that sentence should ever be required, expertise can settle questions that are actually questions of expertise. Imagine that today. A woman who knows what she's talking about Should be able,

SPEAKER_00every once in a while, to say exactly that without spending the next three sentences reducing herself into a palatable size. Voice without the possibility of effect is not much agency at all. So perhaps one habit we need now is to become more curious about where power actually sits. When something happens, find out who made the decision. Find out whether that person can change it. Learn what law or policy applies and which institution has jurisdiction.

SPEAKER_00Understand what evidence would matter there. Discover whether somebody competent is already working on the issue before creating another organization. Petition or social media campaign from scratch. These questions are not nearly as emotionally satisfying as screaming into the largest digital room available. They have the advantage of occasionally changing something though. That was true for the women whose history brought us here. They did not simply object to injustice. They learned how the systems around them functioned.

SPEAKER_00They understood transit systems, workplaces, courts, legislation, local economies, churches, newspapers, and community networks. They discovered where a system depended upon people continuing to cooperate with it. They kept names and documents because they understood what happens when power controls the record. This gives us a more useful question than, what would I have done? We love asking that about history.

SPEAKER_00I have no idea. Neither do most of us. Substack, Substack, Substack,

SPEAKER_00Do we support organizations doing competent work before they are in crisis? Do we teach children how to distinguish evidence from virality? Do we withdraw attention from people whose business model depends upon making cruelty entertaining? Do we know our neighbors well enough to notice when one of them disappears from ordinary life? Do we have people we can call when reality itself starts feeling very slippery?

SPEAKER_00That is where history becomes very useful, not in imagining ourselves heroically inside somebody else's danger and allowing what they learn to alter how we live in ours. Women also need permission to be afraid. I would like us to stop describing courage as though fear somehow invalidates it.

SPEAKER_00Some had children whose safety mattered infinitely more to them than a future textbook. Some stepped back, some compromised, some lost their nerve and found it again. When we turn women into statues, we make their courage much less useful. Statues do not get tired, but women actually do. Actual women can become impatient, laugh at dreadful moments, argue with people they love, occasionally choose very badly. Need reassurance and wake up on

SPEAKER_00a perfectly important day thinking they simply do not have it in them today. Sometimes another person has to carry hope for us for a while. I don't think that it makes hope weaker. I think it might be the only way human beings have ever managed to keep it for very long at all. Perhaps that is what being one another's strength actually means. It cannot mean that every woman is required to be strong all the time. We have dressed up enough impossible expectations and called them empowerment.

SPEAKER_00Oh God, do I hate that word. Strength can move between people. I may have more today. You may have more tomorrow. There may be a day when I can find the words and another when I cannot. And what matters is that the relationship between us is sturdy enough to hold both truths. That kind of endurance is very different from martyrdom. It might... Also make us resist one of the most dangerous invitations of cruel periods, which is the invitation to become a slightly different version of the cruelty

SPEAKER_00that we actually oppose. Of course, we are going to be angry. Some things deserve anger. Women are being harmed, silenced, threatened, excluded, and deliberately lied about. Rights achieved through generations of work can be weakened. They are being weakened. Institutions can fail us. They are failing us. Public language can become vicious enough that cruelty itself starts being marketed as authenticity. Emotional neutrality would be a bizarre response to any of this,

SPEAKER_00but anger has to serve something larger than anger itself. I know the seduction of contempt. Somebody behaves abominably and it is very easy to feel the humane rules should no longer apply to them. Humiliation begins to feel like accountability. Dehumanization feels excusable because we have directed it toward the correct target. I do not think that road takes us anywhere worth going. If our destination is human dignity, then somewhere along the way our methods have to keep teaching us how

SPEAKER_00to recognize human beings. That does not mean avoiding consequences or giving dangerous people endless opportunities to cause more harm. Some behavior has to be stopped. Some laws should be challenged. Some people should lose positions of authority. Crimes should be investigated and, where the evidence supports it, prosecuted. A woman does not owe continued access to someone who harms her. A society does not owe power to someone who abuses it. Mercy has never required us to pretend consequences are cruelty.

SPEAKER_00What mercy asks, I think, is that we not confuse consequences with dehumanization. That distinction matters because contempt is extraordinarily contagious. It is entertaining even. It produces excellent little clips. It gives people the exhilarating sensation of moral superiority without requiring much from them afterward. Eventually, everybody becomes fluent in the language of disposability while insisting that the real problem is only the category of people they have chosen to dispose of.

SPEAKER_00Women have spent too much of history underneath systems that made our humanity conditional to help construct another one. We can want something better than that. Surely we can imagine it. Men belong to this work too, incidentally, because resisting misogyny cannot become another unpaid responsibility assigned to women alone. Men live inside these cultures. Men raise boys. Men lead workplaces, governments, schools, religious institutions, companies, police services, and families.

SPEAKER_00Men hear what other men say when women are not present and sometimes when they are. There is a significant power in whatever happens next. A man who refuses the joke is doing something. A man who does not reward humiliation as masculinity is doing something good too. A father who teaches his son that strength does not require somebody else's submission is doing something important. A male colleague who notices that a woman's idea has just been reassigned to the

SPEAKER_00Men do not have to hate men in order to support women. In fact, I think we urgently need models of manhood that are expansive enough to give boys somewhere to go besides domination. A humane future requires men who do not experience women's agency as their own diminishment. The women who brought us this far did not leave a guarantee that courage wins. I wish history worked that way. What they left was evidence that Concentrated political,

SPEAKER_00economic, or physical power is not the only power human beings possess. People who look very small when they are separated can become remarkably difficult to dominate when they know one another, preserve the truth, understand the systems governing their lives, share what they know, support people who are carrying risk, and learn when cooperation itself has become part of the machinery doing harm. There is no promise of quick victory in that. And I don't think that we should make one.

SPEAKER_00There may be losses. There will certainly be fatigue. Something we thought secure may turn out to be much more fragile than we had initially imagined. People will disappoint us. Institutions may fail at precisely the moment we need them to uphold. Causes move backward as well as forward. History does not seem especially interested in our preference for a clean narrative arc. These times may require more endurance than we would like. There may be no single election,

SPEAKER_00court judgment, protest, or political moment after which everyone gets to announce that the danger has passed and everyone can go home. That is exactly why we need communities built for something longer than emergency. Courage does not guarantee the outcome. What it can do is preserve the possibility of a different one. And perhaps the most useful thing women can understand in this moment is that none of us has to preserve that possibility alone.

SPEAKER_00When distortion causes one woman to doubt what she saw, another can help her find the ground. When somebody is frightened to speak, other women can make the space around her safer. When one of us becomes exhausted, somebody else can hold the peace of the work. The knowledge of older women does not have to disappear with And the imagination of younger women does not have to wait until someone older grants permission. Women who acquire authority can widen the doorway instead of congratulating themselves for having squeezed through it.

SPEAKER_00When one of us is harmed, perhaps the first thing the rest of us can refuse is the isolation of that harm that so often follows. That is where Monday Mercy belongs for me this week. Not as one more request that women be soft. I think women have supplied quite enough softness to people who mistook it for permission. The mercy I'm interested in is sturdier than that. It protects truth without surrendering compassion and protects people without pretending their suffering is somehow ennobling.

SPEAKER_00It allows us to understand that the work ahead may be measured in years rather than news cycles and then asks a very practical question. What kind of lives and communities Will allow us to remain human for that long. Because there will still be dinners and birthdays during difficult years. And there should be. There will be books and gardens and women falling in love. There will be friends who sit too long over coffee. There will be children learning things.

SPEAKER_00Music played both beautifully and appallingly. And pets demanding immediate assistance during what we were fairly certain was an important historical moment. There will be evenings when the wisest contribution any of us can make to civilization is to shut the phone off and go to sleep. That is not abandoning the work. It is remembering what the work is for. The women of Iceland did not withdraw their labor because they wanted a world in which everybody spent eternity on strike.

SPEAKER_00The Montgomery boycott did not exist because walking everywhere was a superior transportation policy. The mothers of Plaza de Mayo Did not gather because they wanted lives organized forever around disappearance. Liberian women did not build a peace movement because peace activism was the highest imaginable form of human existence. They wanted people to be able to live. And that is the destination. Not the resistance itself but life.

SPEAKER_00A good life if we can build one. An ordinary life in which human beings have enough safety and dignity that most days do not require courage at all. Cruelty would happily occupy our whole interior world if we let it. It would like our attention and our fear and then our hatred and eventually our resemblance. We do not have to give it those things. We can help keep one Another human. Then we can get up again,

SPEAKER_00as rested, as circumstances allow, still connected to reality and to one another, and we can continue. I won't pretend that is easy. It is work and I suspect some of it will need to go on for a very long time. But history has never required women to be invulnerable before they could change anything. They need courage sometimes. They needed knowledge and stubbornness and organization. They needed somebody to keep the documents, somebody to understand the law, somebody to make the food,

SPEAKER_00somebody to find the money, somebody to teach, somebody willing to stand in public, and somebody willing to do the work so ordinary that nobody thought to photograph it. They needed somebody who remembered what happened the last time. They needed somebody younger who could imagine what has never happened before. They needed people who could disagree and And somehow keep enough relationship intact to continue. They needed rest and humor. They needed occasional friends who knew when the most politically responsible thing available was probably a sandwich.

SPEAKER_00And when oppression worked through distortion and isolation, they needed other human beings close enough to help reality remain real. Somebody to say, I saw it too. Somebody else to just say, I know you're afraid, come with me anyway. And occasionally somebody trustworthy enough to say, no, I think we have this one wrong, let's look at it again. That too is solidarity. Perhaps what women have offered history is not a special feminine capacity for peace at all.

SPEAKER_00Perhaps it is something less romantic and considerably more powerful. Women who were denied conventional authority became experts in the places where power hides. We became experts in labor, care, memory, belonging, relationship, information. We became experts in whether ordinary people continue cooperating with something that cannot function without them. They learned that a person can be frightened and still act. That grief can become public memory without becoming vengeance.

SPEAKER_00That care can sustain political work rather than distract from it. That refusing to harm does not require accepting harm. That human dignity means very little if we recognize it only in people behaving well. Most importantly, they kept finding one another. I think we should take that seriously. Not as a slogan about sisterhood. As a method. Find the women doing careful work. Believe women enough to listen and respect them enough to verify.

SPEAKER_00Share knowledge. Increase one another's agency. Protect the person carrying unusual risk. Make authority less mysterious. Learn where decisions are made. Keep records. Build relationships before crisis requires them. Refuse to let political movements turn human beings into disposable categories, including when the category is convenient to us. Let other women carry something when you are tired. Carry something when you can.

SPEAKER_00They ask whether enough of us can remain awake without becoming consumed, courageous without becoming reckless, angry without becoming cruel, and connected enough that fear cannot isolate us one woman at a time. It is difficult and possible. Women have been leaving us evidence of this for a very long time. Our job is not to admire them from a safe distance. Our job is to learn what they knew and then find one another. Really thank you all for your time.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm just going to try to go back through and say hi to everybody. I do apologize if I miss anyone. While I'm going through this, if you guys can just leave comments of whether or not you found this helpful at all. That helps me understand whether or not you enjoyed it and whether or not things like this are good. So thank you for coming, Tracy, Laura, MJ.

SPEAKER_00Sorry, when I'm reading, I can't read. And Ellen, Florian, Bob, Jumper, Lianna, Mr. Irrelevant. Doug, MJ. I

SPEAKER_00think I said Tracy already. Mandy. Honey, Irene, Judy. Martin, Donna. Vito.

SPEAKER_00Adam. Christine. Of course, Jumper. VT, I'm sorry if I missed anybody. I have to kind of scroll backwards through. There's quite a bit of chat today, so if I miss anyone, I apologize. Thank you very much for coming. I hope everybody has a fantastic week.

SPEAKER_00I want to remind you that tonight, Mediocre Mama at 7pm, she's doing part four of her Women's Fear series, which is absolutely amazing. I will post all of the references that I used for this online today so that you can look at where the information is coming from. I like to keep the receipts and some of it is actually quite interesting if you ever wanted to look it up. I look forward to the rest of the week and I hope everyone enjoys their week.

SPEAKER_00And remember that solidarity doesn't have to mean we all agree on everything. It means that we're all here to make sure that the truth stays in the spotlight and to support each other through the actions that are required to outlast the cruelty.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bedtime on the Porch

    Nov 15, 20261 hr 36 minAudio

    Thank you Beth Cruz, sandy bassett, Ann Sczerbowicz, Jumper, Antonio Cruz, and many others for tuning into my live video with Lisa Joy 🏳️‍🌈, julie elder, Amy Northam, CPM, The Bathrobe Guy (Robes) 👘, and Sacred...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Wrigley & Sam: Fiddlesticks in a Fondue Pot

    Nov 13, 202615 minAudio

    Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. Get full access to Summer's Substack at summerwillan.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Bedtime on the Porch

    Nov 9, 20262 hrAudio

    Thank you NeuroDivergent Hodgepodge, Jumper, Christine, Julie Robuck, Carolyn Wilkerson Rouser, and many others for tuning into my live video with Lisa Joy 🏳️‍🌈, julie elder, Amy Northam, CPM, and Sacred Storylines...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Bedtime on the Porch

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

    Thank you sandy bassett, EG, The One Minute Daily Boost, Amy Northam, CPM, Jumper, and many others for tuning into my live video with Lisa Joy 🏳️‍🌈, julie elder, and The Bathrobe Guy (Robes) 👘! Join me for my next...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What Mammon Cannot Count - Part II

    Aug 29, 202655 minAudio

    Thank you Mediocre mamma, Laura (NOT Loomer) 📎🐜🐜, Ann Sczerbowicz, Martin D. Vasquez, Amy Northam, CPM and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. Get full access to...

    Credit the people on this episode