Many of you have been asking me to talk about Christian Nationalism - and I knew exactly who to call! Thank you Xplisset, Julie, Gus Diaz, Iam AMERICA, Diana Lanane, and many others for tuning into my live video with Jemar Tisby, PhD! Join me for my next live video in the app. Parts of this interview were featured in my deep dive YouTube video on the topic. Check it out: Get full access to The Garrison Stack at garrisonhayes.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03I think we're on. Good.
SPEAKER_00Hey, everybody.
SPEAKER_03Hey, you you were talking a little bit early. Earlier, we talked about this kind of political moment that we're in and all of that. But the question that I just asked you that you gave such a beautiful answer to that, you know, just as we were kind of coming on here. is about your awareness of Christian nationalism. What I anticipate is that there are a lot of people who like encounter Christian nationalism before they are able to define Christian nationalism.
SPEAKER_03And so what I'd love for you to do, Jamar, is if you could tell us how you first encountered Christian nationalism. And then I want you to define Christian nationalism. And I think that order really, really, really matters.
SPEAKER_00I believe you are absolutely correct. So I think... we typically encounter white Christian nationalism through the third rail topics that you cannot mess with, abortion being one, right? So a lot of people who call themselves Christians and swear allegiance to the Republican party, if you ask them why, They'll say, I'm pro-life, by which they mean pro-birth,
as we've often heard.
SPEAKER_00And what's been going on, we'll get into the history later, is just for decades they've been discipled to think that the only issue, the main issue, the top issue that Christians need to vote on and ally themselves with is overturning Roe v. Wade and eliminating virtually all abortions. And so that, for broad swaths, especially at the grassroots level,
SPEAKER_00is the litmus test, and it is the only qualification for whether they will vote for a candidate or not. So I encountered it through the abortion issue. But there were also a host of other issues. For instance, when I was in seminary, At Reformed Theological Seminary, which is a very conservative school in Jackson, Mississippi, deep south, that was the first time I ever heard the term government schools or Caesar's schools,
SPEAKER_00like Rome. And the idea behind that is, well, if you're a Christian and you send your kids to public schools, they're just going to get indoctrinated with all of these unchristian, unbiblical, satanic ideas, basically. And so what was the solution? Well, you homeschool. And when you homeschool, you do a particular version of homeschooling. They call it classical Christian homeschooling, where you read all the classics, which all just happen to flow from Western Europe.
SPEAKER_00not Asia, not Africa, not Latin America, no place else but Western Europe contained the classics by and large, right? And there were other issues, of course. There were theological issues around how they view the Bible and interpretations and very sort of literalistic and rigid interpretations. There were other issues around patriarchy and not having women preachers or ordaining women in general. So I encountered it through the issues, through the beliefs, and of course,
primary is this idea that the United States was formed as a Christian nation.
SPEAKER_00And the idea, I saw it when you had a U.S. flag in the pulpit of churches, as if that was an appropriate place. So that's where I first encountered it, and it wasn't until later that I sort of started to wrap my head around what a definition might be.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's interesting that you say this. So I was actually homeschooled. I was a part of, I would not say explicitly Christian nationalist religious community. I wouldn't say it that way. But I would say that there were these ideas that were certainly on ramps into a lot of kind of more conservative American Christianity. And one of them was this notion that the public schools were indoctrinating young people, young Christians to hate God.
SPEAKER_03That was kind of a part of it, that you'd encounter all kinds of debauchery, all kinds of evil if you went to a public school. And so you needed to go to a Christian school, one that aligned with your religious beliefs. And again, I don't think my parents were at all aware of this idea of Christian nationalism. I don't think that was anything that they were thinking about. But they were, I think, discipled in many ways into a kind of Christian conservatism that finds,
SPEAKER_03I think, its origin point in some of these same ideas that we find in Christian nationalism. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You just named the most insidious part of white Christian nationalism, which is that most people don't know they're in it, because to them it's just Christianity. It's all they've ever heard. It's all they've ever known. It's what all the people they respect and love believe. And so it just seems like Christianity, and they haven't necessarily had exposure to or they've been inoculated against different ways of practicing Christianity that look a lot different.
SPEAKER_00And so it's the most insidious part of it, because how can you tell someone they're in danger when they consider that danger normal? not only normal, but right. So when I talk about white Christian nationalism, they think I'm attacking Christianity. No, I'm attacking this thing masquerading as Christianity.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so we are here with Dr. Jim Artisby, author of The Color of Compromise, How to Fight Racism. Oh, my gosh. I have your third book right on my bookshelf.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I got you. I got you. I'm going to get it. Oh, nice. Okay. I'm going to get it.
SPEAKER_03It's the spirit of justice. Here, let me grab it. y'all can go to my bookshop.org you know check out the justice library y'all spirit of justice as you can see i've been i've been in the book man i've been in the book in the book for whatever reason it was slipping my mind um yeah i i love your work of course always at the kind of intersection of faith and justice And history, of course. And I want to talk about that history. But I do think, to your point, it might be helpful to get a working definition of Christian
nationalism here at
SPEAKER_03the top. And then we'll kind of cut through some of these other questions. 100,000%.
SPEAKER_00There are so many definitions out there. So whenever you see somebody online popping off at the Mount saying, well, they never define it. What even is it? Just like, look, just Google is your friend, right? So let me, I'm going to give you two. I'm going to give you one version that's a narrative version, because I think that's more akin to what people are believing. Then I'm going to give you my technical version. And then if you'll Give me the allowance to sort of unpack that. Take your time. Take your time. All right. So the narrative version comes from Philip Gorski and Samuel
Perry and their book,
SPEAKER_00The Flag and the Cross. The Flag and the Cross, short book by data scientists, really helpful. Go out and get it. They describe white Christian nationalism as a deep story, and I love that because what people are doing is they're buying into a narrative, by which I mean they're not seeing this list of white Christian nationalist beliefs and sort of comparing them to other beliefs and going, yep, I subscribe to this, I check off that, I believe this. No, no, no, no. It's a story they're believing. So here's how the deep story of white Christian nationalism
goes, according to Gorski and Perry. America was founded as a Christian nation by white men who were traditional Christians who based the nation's founding documents on Christian principles. The United States is blessed by God, which is why it has been so successful.
SPEAKER_00And the nation has a special role to play in God's plan for humanity. But... These blessings are threatened by cultural degradation from un-American influences, both inside and outside our borders. If you could pin folks down and get them to explain the story of their faith and the nation,
SPEAKER_00it would sound something like that. that this nation was founded as a Christian nation, by which they mean the Declaration is as deep as you go. See, with most folks, in question two and three, you've done it. You've done these person on the street interviews where you probed past the initial talking point and you find their understanding is very shallow. But if you ask them what it means we're founded as a Christian nation, they'll say, that we are endowed by our creator with certain unalienable rights.
SPEAKER_00They'll point to that. And then they'll point to things like one nation under God in the pledge. They'll point to all of these things, which actually came up in the 1950s and in the midst of the Cold War. That's a story worth telling. But then they'll say, you know, Christian principles, these documents were Christian in their essence. And because it was founded as a Christian nation and we had people who adhered to Christianity, that's why America has prospered. And the United States in particular has a special world. So it's a story people believe.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, how does that land in terms of the deep story of white Christian nationalism before I get into a technical definition?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think it makes a lot of sense. And the thing that is surfacing for me, Jamar, is that... not only is America this founded as a Christian nation, that comes with so many theological and cultural presuppositions that inform that. So you can make a statement that I might interpret one way, you might interpret a different way. But when you think about the folks who are founding America and
their intention in
SPEAKER_03founding America, And their habits, which is to say, to enslave and to plunder and to displace. And the fact that they're doing all of this in the name of Jesus. If you really, at the very least under the flag that is associated with Jesus, under this kind of larger co-opted idea of Christianity, if you understand their presuppositions, I think it makes a lot of sense that they could leverage theology and leverage
SPEAKER_03their faith to kind of carry out these awful things. I think today, when people use that, they're also bringing a number of presuppositions to the conversation that often go unnamed. And I know you'll touch on some of those things, but it lands. And I will say that I think, you know, I've been in conversation with folks who I think are aligned with Christian nationalism, but do not like what they call the moniker of Christian nationalism. And I think they call themselves just Christian conservatives. But I think if you read that story to them,
they'd say check, check, check, check, right?
SPEAKER_03And so, okay, that was the narrative definition. Let's get to something a little bit more technical. So this is the Jamar Tisby standard version of white Christian nationalism definition.
SPEAKER_00And I say, white Christian nationalism is an ethnocultural ideology that uses Christian symbolism to create a permission structure for the acquisition of political power and social control. I'll run that back for those listening. White Christian nationalism is an ethno-cultural ideology that uses Christian symbolism to create a permission structure for the acquisition of political power and social control.
SPEAKER_00So that is... Let's unpack that. It's a bit technical. Ethnocultural. This is the white in white Christian nationalism. Let me start with an example. If you go to the U.S. Department of Labor, the official government... social media thread on X. They have all these AI-generated images of blond-haired white men who are supposed
SPEAKER_00to represent the quintessential American working man. And that's on purpose. Because when white Christian nationalists think of true Americans, so-called, it fits that image. They're not thinking of the laborers from Asia who built the railroads. They're not thinking of black people who drained the swamps and picked the cotton. They're not thinking of indigenous people whose land they stole. They're not even thinking primarily of women.
SPEAKER_00They're thinking in these terms. And the idea is to have a society where white men in particular, particularly wealthy white men, are on top and at the center. So it's ethnocultural. And it's an ideology, meaning this is not as much about facts and data as it is about feelings of inclusion and belonging. That's why you cannot argue someone out of white Christian nationalism. You have to invite them into a better story where they feel a
sense of acceptance
SPEAKER_00and belonging, which can be galling because what they're What they're believing and promoting is so dehumanizing, but really, you're not going to argue someone out. You can stack books and articles from floor to ceiling, and it won't make a dent, because for them, it's about a sense of identity, and that's what the ideology teaches. And then it uses Christian symbolism. A lot of people argue, well, is white Christian nationalism Christian? We can address that in a moment, but let me speak to the fact that
SPEAKER_00This is not simply religious nationalism. There's Hindu nationalism, right? There's other kinds of nationalism. This is Christian nationalism because it uses Christian symbolism. Crosses, Bibles, prayers to the Christian God, songs, all of those things. The going to church, they look a lot like Christians in terms of the symbols that they employ. But here's the rub. Why do they do it? It's not to be more like Jesus. It's a permission structure.
In other words, it is a divine imprimatur or blessing on what they're doing.
SPEAKER_00It's the crusader spirit. Like, we're going to go out and conquer the world, and God is blessing us. And that's the purpose. So it's a permission structure for what? The acquisition of political power and social control. So we're seeing the political power right now in real time. You got people like Mike Johnson, Pete Hegseth, you can go on down the list. Even Russ Vogt went to Wheaton College for undergrad. These are folks who identify as Christian, doing profoundly unchristian things.
SPEAKER_00And so, but they're undemocratic things. And so they're acquiring political power. They also want social control. And we can go deeper into that. But essentially, if you want to understand the kind of society that the white Christian nationalists at the top envision, Just look at the Plantation Society. That's essentially what they're trying to reinscribe.
SPEAKER_03Say more on the Plantation Society. I have other questions, but you peeked something here. So when you look at how a plantation was arranged, it was essentially a pyramid.
SPEAKER_00And at the very tippy top was the white, male, wealthy plantation owner. But the entire plantation was conceived of as a type of household, a type of household. And beneath the white wealthy man, plantation owner, was his wife, his white wife, Of course, he had mistresses or people he sexually abused. But his white wife, who was socially acceptable, and his white children.
SPEAKER_00That was the next level. But then, what do you do with the enslaved people? Are they part of the household? Actually, yes. They are children in the household. Some actual biological children, which is messed up. But in terms of a plantation society... They were considered children within the plantation household, but they were considered perpetual children. That's why you can call a grown black man boy in that society.
SPEAKER_00And as perpetual children, they needed perpetual guardianship. So they had to be taught how to work, they had to be provided food and clothing and gainful labor so they could stay out of trouble, they would have to be provided discipline if they ever got out of line, and they would even need to be provided religious instruction from the plantation patriarch. Now how does that relate to 2025? Look who's at the very top of our politics on the right,
SPEAKER_00of organizations on the right. It's almost exclusively white men, almost exclusively white people in general. There are a few women strategically deployed. We can look at Erica Kirk at this point. We can look at Paula White, who also all fit a mold blonde-haired, like the sort of whitest of white women are at the top. We see the conflict here with J.D. Vance's wife, who's brown-skinned and not Christian.
So all of that goes to the plantation society that they're trying to reinscribe. They're kicking out military leaders of color, women in the military, all of those things.
SPEAKER_00Why? So that they can put at the top who they think should be there rightfully, which is white people, particularly wealthy white men. Man, there's so many things in there that I want to touch on, but I know we have to keep going.
SPEAKER_03The thing that stood out to me in your definition is this word symbolism. In your definition, there is almost an acknowledgement that they're using Christianity and the symbols of Christianity to achieve their ethno-religious kind of fantasy. But they really aren't using a specific theology. And maybe I'm misunderstanding that. But when I hear symbolism, what I hear is this acknowledgement that there is a taking of
these kind of these
SPEAKER_03elements that signal something, but don't really get to the root or the heart of what those things were trying to communicate in their original form. And I want to make sure I'm understanding that correctly. I'm not kind of imposing my own beliefs on your definition. Like, what do you mean when you say symbolism?
SPEAKER_00Well, here's the thing. You can't deny that if you were to pick a religion that these folks... most resemble its Christianity. Why? Because of all the symbols that I listed. But I intentionally use the word symbol because the project of white Christian nationalism isn't to look more like Jesus. which is what the core definition of Christian means. It's to be a Christ follower,
and the reason you follow Christ is to be more like Christ.
SPEAKER_00That is not the project of white Christian nationalism. The project of white Christian nationalism is to use religion as a cover, or as I say, permission structure for their real purpose, which is political power and social control. But it's hard for outsiders to notice the difference because of those. Look, they're going to church. There was a there was a narrative early in Trump's first run for president that white Christian nationalism was coming up a little bit in the mainstream.
SPEAKER_00But there were Christians who were saying, well, these are Christians in name only. They don't actually go to church. They don't actually practice the religion. And the actual data show, oh yeah, they were going to church. Oftentimes it rates higher than people who were not considered white Christian nationalists. So that's my only point. And here's the crux of the issue. The reason why people want to sort of parse, are they Christian, not Christian? Number one, it's offensive to people who are truly trying to follow Jesus, right? That's right.
SPEAKER_00We don't like that. But number two, and I think this might be unspoken, but it's an effect of this whole conversation, is to sort of wipe our hands of white Christian nationalists and say, well, since they're not truly Christians, they're not really our problem. right and that's the exact opposite thing because if it's my religion and my jesus then i don't want someone misrepresenting my religion or the jesus that i know from scripture and so the question to me that's more salient is not
is white christian
SPEAKER_00nationalism christian the question for me that's more salient is what responsibility do followers of Christ have to confront white Christian nationalism as an ideology and as something masquerading around as the true religion of Jesus? That's where I think we need to land.
SPEAKER_03We are going to land there. I promise we are going to get to like, what do we do about this, right? But I want to do a little bit more of the history building. When I get a chance to talk to a historian, I am just like, I gotta like extract all of the history I can out of this person. I'll say this, the chat has been going like crazy for you. There's someone who said earlier that their mind was blown when you were kind of defining and giving this kind of texture to Christian nationalism.
SPEAKER_03So there's a lot of appreciation here for what you're doing. I want to look back over a few periods, kind of walk through some kind of key periods throughout American history specifically to get an idea of what Christian nationalism has looked like in these different periods of time. And so I want to start with, I want to start with like, we talked a little bit about the plantation kind of culture. And so I think we've touched on slavery. Let's go immediately following emancipation during the
reconstruction period.
SPEAKER_03What does Christian nationalism, like what is the predominant narrative of Christian nationalism immediately following emancipation?
SPEAKER_00Oh, this is so good. That's a perfect place to start. But I have to go back for a second because I just remembered something. It's important to recognize how do you measure white Christian nationalism? So I'm a senior democracy fellow with the Public Religion Research Institute. Go to prri.org. prri.org. They have reams of data stats on this. They have a scale, and it's a series of questions that you can agree, not just agree or disagree with,
SPEAKER_00is how strongly you agree with them. So here's a sampling of the questions. God has called Christians to exercise dominion over all areas of American society. For those of us who know, that's Seven Mountains Dominionism, Seven Mountains Mandate kind of language. Another question. The U.S. government should declare America a Christian nation. So just like officially make it the thing, right? That's one. Being Christian is an important part of being truly American. So... I mean, that's some heavy coding right there.
So if you're Jewish or Muslim or atheist, sorry, that's not truly American.
SPEAKER_00And it says, if the U.S. moves away from our Christian foundations, we won't have a country anymore, that kind of language, and U.S. laws should be based on Christian values. So those are some of the questions, and then you can scale from one to five agree to disagree. The last thing I'll say before I talk about that period after emancipation is this. It's not a binary. You either are white Christian nationalism or aren't. It's a spectrum. So there's only about 10% of Americans who qualify as what they
call Christian
SPEAKER_00nationalism adherents. These are the extremes. These are the ones who will storm the Capitol on January 6th. They are the true believer. That's about 10%. about 20% qualify as sympathizers. So they would largely agree with all those statements I read, but just not as strongly, you know, maybe three or four out of five, right? And then there's 37% who are skeptics. So now we're crossing over to the other side, people who mostly don't believe this stuff. And then there are 29% who are rejecters,
just outright stiff arm this ideology.
SPEAKER_00You and I would be in that category most likely, right? Here's the thing, only 10% are adherents and 20%, that's only 30% of the population. But what makes them so dangerous is they all vote the same. They vote in lockstep. So that's how we get to where we are politically. So all that said, just background.
SPEAKER_00I will be concise with this portion of the history. What did white Christian nationalism look like in the period after emancipation? It looked like the lost cause. Hmm. inventing the lost cause. So what happens after emancipation is you have a whole bunch of white people in the South, yes, but also all over, who really don't think that black people being free is all that good of an idea.
SPEAKER_00They lost the war But as Bryan Stevenson says, the South won the narrative war. So this myth of white supremacy and black inferiority persists. How does it persist? Well, we know that the period after the Civil War is called Reconstruction. Most people don't know what the period after Reconstruction is called. It's called redemption. And that's after this group of white supremacists, which included all kinds of, like,
SPEAKER_00formal affiliations, it was just a category of people who subscribed to this idea of the Lost Cause called the Redeemers, and I'm so mad because redemption is a Bible word, and it's a good news word, it's Jesus redeeming us from our own rebellion and crafting a new humanity and creating union again with God, But in the hands of white supremacists, redemption meant taking the South back for the white man and more broadly, taking America back for the white man.
SPEAKER_00In fact, in the first presidential election after the Civil War, the Seymour Blair ticket, president and VP candidate, ran on the slogan, this is a white man's country, let white men rule. This is immediately after the nation's most... The bloodiest war this nation has ever seen. And they're saying, you know what? Those three and a half million black people who are now free, that's a mistake.
SPEAKER_00Don't let them... Get in political office. Don't let them vote. This is a white man's country. Let white men rule. So that was the ideology of the redeemers. And of course, they went under the religion of Christianity. They said, this is God's ordained way. So that's what it looked like then. And we can, you know, a lot of ins and outs there. But in terms of a sort of broad movement, we're looking at the redeemers and the lost cause.
SPEAKER_03One of the things I love that's happening in the comments, there's someone who said that they essentially guessed the answer to this question of like, what does Christian nationalism look like in these different eras? So if you're in the comments and you're a history buff and you love history, I want you to kind of put your answer in there as well as I move to the next period. And that next period is Jim Crow. There's so much that happens in between. I mean, you talk about this lost cause, which kind of, is all wrapped up in this kind of redeemer, redemption era. The nadir of race relations is kind of all a part of that time.
SPEAKER_03And so I know we can talk about those things, but I'm gonna skip ahead maybe 80 or so years to Jim Crow. Actually, Jim Crow's a much broader, I'm telling the historian about history. You tell me about history.
SPEAKER_00No, you just tell me where to go. Let me say this one thing about the Jim Crow era. Please. Okay, so 1915. Many folks who are tuning in probably know that was the year the three-hour silent film, Birth of a Nation, was released. And first of all, cinematically, people study this in film school to this day. because it was a first of its kind to use these special effects. It was literally a blockbuster movie with lines around the corner.
It was the first film shown in the White House under President Woodrow Wilson,
SPEAKER_00who himself was the son of a Southern Presbyterian minister. Fun story, they are on a journey of repair and confession. I actually preached at Woodrow Wilson's father's church in Augusta, Georgia. Anyway, that's another story. So 1915, so Birth of a Nation is glorifying the birth of the Ku Klux Klan. And the Redeemers, taking the South back from this rapacious black Union soldier
and northern
SPEAKER_00carpetbaggers, come to disrupt the tranquility of the South, right? That's the story. That sets off basically a national movement. So on Thanksgiving Day, 1915, a man named William J. Simmons, who was a former Methodist circuit writer, so a Christian, he gathers a group of his white friends, and they go to a place called Stone Mountain, Georgia. Wow. Stone Mountain, Georgia, on which it's a historically a very sacred site to indigenous people, but they violated it in a sacrilegious way and put out this
huge bas-relief of
SPEAKER_00these Confederate so-called heroes on there, Lee and some others, right? And then they go up to the top of Stone Mountain, and they do a couple of things. Number one, they burn a cross, which is going to get real famous in the civil rights era, right? Number two, they build an altar. And on that altar, they place three items, a Bible, a flag, and a sword. Wow. So think of that symbolism. The Bible and the flag, America's a Christian nation and a sword,
SPEAKER_00and we will use violence to enforce it, right? And so we see that to this day. One more point on the Jim Crow era. So that same guy, William J. Simmons, who was founder of, this is now the second wave of the Klan. There were three waves of the Klan. One was right after the Civil War. One was during the Civil Rights Movement. but the biggest and most violent one was this era during the Jim Crow period. So William J. Simmons is now Grand Dragon. He does an interview with a newspaper, and it ends up in the New York Times, and I want you to listen to this description from William J.
SPEAKER_00Simmons, the leader of the Klan, and see if it sounds familiar to anything we hear today. He said this, quote, The Ku Klux Klan admits membership to none but native-born, white, Gentile Protestant Americans whose statement of principles was a restoration of the fundamental principles of American democracy as embodied in the Constitution of the United States, an organization whose code of conduct was Protestant Christianity."
SPEAKER_00Any of that ring a bell?
SPEAKER_03No, it all rings a bell.
SPEAKER_00It rings some bells. This is the clan of the Jim Crow era, y'all. He's saying native-born, not immigrants. White, not people of color. Gentile, not Jewish. Protestants, not Catholics. Whose statement of principles was a restoration. there's that language there's the lost cause there's the redeemers but there's also the make america great again it's this idea that we got to go back to this time when things were better and it says the fundamental principles of american democracy in the founding documents like the constitution which
code of conduct was protestant christianity this is a christian nation so that's what it looks like in the jim crow era you're baptizing racial terrorism in the name of christianity
SPEAKER_03Oh my gosh. I think a theme that I'm already picking up on is that it actually doesn't look very different. From time to time. A lot of continuity. There's some continuity here.
SPEAKER_00One difference is the Protestant Catholic thing. Sure. So you'll see there are far-right Catholics. Look up the Catholic integralism movement. That's what people like J.D. Vance represent. And now I think it's something like 16 Supreme Court—I mean, six Supreme Court justices are Catholic, but it's not the sort of— Catholic of Pope Leo, it's the far-right fundamentalist version. So now white Christian nationalism will admit some strands of
Catholicism,
SPEAKER_00but not the ones that look too liberal or woke, right? And there's now, as we speak, an interesting infighting going on about anti-Semitism within white Christian nationalism, because you have the Nick Fuente strain who is just an avowed white supremacist, and that's his brand. And then you have like Ben Shapiro, who's Jewish. And you have a lot of people who are Zionists.
SPEAKER_00And so it's going to be real interesting to see how that plays out. So those are some points of discontinuity, but you're right. A lot of this sounds familiar.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for that bit of clarification and additional context. I want to move on to the civil rights movement, which I'm reading through this book titled For the Bible Told Them So. And it's about how Christians in America pushed against desegregation on the basis of their biblical beliefs, as they said. And there is this huge, especially in the SBC, there's this huge kind of tension around how white American Christians were engaging with segregation
specifically. And the thing that's been really interesting to me is that the organizations,
SPEAKER_03the institutions are often being drawn back into segregation. Like they're kind of trying to take a step forward. The leadership is like, hey, we've got to kind of keep up with the Supreme Court and keep up with the times. And it's the membership. You know, the messengers in the SBC that's like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. We're not doing all that. Can you talk a little bit about Christian, white Christian nationalism in the civil rights era period? When we talk about white Christian nationalism,
civil rights era period, I think the actual... more helpful periodization is to think of the post-World War II era, the post-World War II era. That is truly the birth of what we would call modern white evangelicalism,
SPEAKER_00and I need to say as a caveat, not all white evangelicals are white Christian nationalists, but there's a big overlap. there's a lot of, if that Venn diagram is drawn, it's not one-to-one, but it's pretty significant. Nevertheless, when we're talking about white Christian nationalism in the post-World War II era, it looks a lot like modern white evangelicalism. We referenced before the advent in the 1950s of these phrases like,
SPEAKER_00one nation under God, and even the things like the national prayer breakfast, that originated in the 19... Well, what's going on in the 1950s? You have World War II ending in 1945, and then the United States has emerged as a global superpower. Not only a global superpower, a global democratic superpower, which is important because the other global superpower was their erstwhile ally, Russia. And Russia is communist and Russia is expanding to other
countries and using and
SPEAKER_00implementing communism in other parts of the world. So you get this long, decades long period called the Cold War and nuclear proliferation and all of these things. So this is not just a military conflict. This is also an ideological and religious conflict. So what happens in the United States is you start getting these narratives of the United States is a Christian nation, which is an important distinction versus atheistic, communist Russia.
SPEAKER_00So it's not just coming out of nowhere that this is a Christian nation. In the post-World War II context, it's explicitly as a rebuttal to what they are characterizing as atheistic communism. And then you get the insertion of all of these sort of Christian-y rituals into the civic sphere, which then reinforces this idea, well, the United States has always been a Christian nation. Actually, no, this stuff is brand new. But we have very short memories, and after a while it just seems like, well, this is always the way it's been,
SPEAKER_00and even though it hasn't. And this is blended in with what we now define as white evangelicalism and white Christian nationalism, because you have people like Billy Graham. So there's a historian who sort of tongue-in-cheek said, how do you define an evangelical? It's anyone who likes Billy Graham. And he wasn't far off, honestly. So Billy Graham goes around the world, does all of these massive crusades, preaching conversion to Christianity, but part of his message is an anti-communist,
SPEAKER_00pro-America, pro-democracy message too. And when you look at the allegiances of someone like a Billy Graham, he's cozying up to right wing conservative politicians. Right. And so the only person he actually comes out and endorses for president is Richard Nixon. who crashes and burns and goes down in flames. And after that, Billy Graham never actually explicitly endorses anyone. But you don't have to look very deep to know where his politics lie. And so how that evinces itself in terms of the civil rights
movement is you can go
SPEAKER_00online and Google it. And there's a sign, a protest sign from the 1960s that says communism is race mixing. Communism is race mixing. What does that mean? In the U.S. white evangelical mind, communism wanted to flatten out all differences, because this is the whole, all things in common. Everyone gets everything equal, right? So to white evangelicals, that meant you flatten out all racial differences, too.
SPEAKER_00And so in the Jim Crow and the civil rights era, you had this term amalgamation or mongrelization, right? That was white people saying, well, black men are going to have sex with white women, and they're going to have mongrel children, and the white race is going to be amalgamated into the black race, into all these people, and there won't be a white person anymore. That was the big boogeyman. And so when they said communism is race mixing, that's what they were talking about.
SPEAKER_00If you go the way of communism, or rather, it worked both ways, but if you promoted desegregation, then you were promoting race mixing, which was akin to promoting communism.
SPEAKER_03I want to jump way forward in the timeline. We know that immediately following the civil rights movement, you have this rise of the moral majority, which is its own. You're kind of getting there with Billy Graham and kind of white evangelicalism and kind of moving in that direction. And I want to move to 2000, like 2005, 6, 7, 9, 10. I want to move to this tea party era and talk a little bit about that. But feel free to kind of fill in that,
you know, 20, 30 year gap in between.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, more or less 30 years. Right. I got to feel free to kind of fill that in. But I do want to get us to the Tea Party era because I do think that's that's more or less the time that that we are kind of bearing the, you know, we're reaping the fruit of the seeds sown for in that period around Christian nationalism. So what's important about understanding white Christian nationalism in the 21st
SPEAKER_00century is that it's been an at least 40 to 50 year project. And I'm tracing that back to the rise of the religious right and the moral majority. And so you have figures like Jerry Falwell Jr. who are... kind of becoming aware of the fact that, I mean, after the 50s and 60s and now into the 70s, the social landscape has changed dramatically. You got black people voting, you got the women's rights movement, you got the Chicano movement,
like all of these people who were previously rendered invisible or at least sort of
SPEAKER_00irrelevant. Now, all of a sudden, Mm hmm. You know, we got a we got a Civil Rights Act and a Voting Rights Act and you can't say this, you can't discriminate that way. And what? What? Oh, the poor white man. Right. Yeah. So so so now they're trying to to sort of recalibrate. And one of the things they land on is you can create this fusion between the Republican Party and white evangelicals. And they land on that. We now think it's abortion. The historian Randall Balmer has a theory that it's actually
tied to desegregation
SPEAKER_00and taxes for Bob Jones University and Christian universities. That's another story. But eventually it gets connected to this issue of abortion, which becomes the whole thing. Mind you, even conventions like the Southern Baptist Convention, when Roe v. Wade was first passed in the early 70s, they were like, you know, basically it's up to the woman. They didn't have this hardline stance. That quickly changed, though. So all that to say, they mounted a very strategic and long-term project that
included mass media and
SPEAKER_00mass communication, like mailing lists, that included voter guides being given out in churches, that included... recruiting people like lawyers and judges to fight their causes, like overturning Roe v. Wade, and that's just one example, right? So all of that is a buildup, buildup, buildup. They get their man in the White House in the 80s with Ronald Reagan. He's a very questionable evangelical in terms of his credentials, right?
SPEAKER_00Nowhere near Jimmy Carter, who they came to despise. Despised, right. And then you get Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky, which they take as the most immoral thing to ever happen in the history of man, second only to the crucifixion of Christ, right? But that helps consolidate their people. Then you get, we're still dealing with this, Garrison, you know, you get this black man with this quote-unquote un-American-sounding name.
SPEAKER_00Barack Obama. Barack Obama. Barack Hussein Obama. Barack Hussein Obama. And by the way, was he even born here? I mean, his father's Kenyan, so maybe Trump had a point. That's how he first came on the political scene with the birther conspiracy, right? So they hated... I mean, Obama represented everything white supremacy stands against. An intelligent black man who spoke well, who was a family man, who was everything they said the white man and the white family
were about,
SPEAKER_00but couldn't touch. You know, and this is not talking about his politics. We can go through all that, but just what he represented. And I do think that what we're dealing with in 2025 is in many ways a backlash to a black man ever winning the presidency. And so it's during Obama's first term and the midterms in 2010 that you get the rise of the Tea Party. And that's a modern day manifestation of white Christian nationalism that then morphs into the MAGA movement when Trump comes on the scene as
a candidate in 2016.
SPEAKER_03There's a lot, I keep saying this, I'm gonna try to not say it again. There's so much in there that we could like unpack. I mean, you know, it strikes me that there is this contradiction, constant contradiction here. It almost feels as though, you know, if you are a person who believes in God, it almost feels like there's some irony at play here that these folks are aligning themselves with the people who represent least what they say they believe in. right and they despise the individuals who on the surface
represent the most of what they believe in in thinking specifically about um reagan versus carter or you
SPEAKER_03think about um donald trump versus barack obama like there's this real contradiction thing he happening here that i find uh it would be funny if it wasn't so sad um i want to move to hope a little bit and less hope in the you know give us hope pastor but more in the sense of i want to know like what people can do to work against these forces um
SPEAKER_03You know, you you are a person who, you know, you're a New York Times bestseller and you're constantly talking about this. There is an appetite to learn more about this. And even in our comments section here, you know, there are folks who. identify as believers and they're like, I don't stand for this. This doesn't fit with what I believe. So there's a part of me that thinks that there's something building here, but I'm curious, how do we operationalize that?
If you want to actually work against Christian nationalism, what can you do?
SPEAKER_00So you mentioned my second book, How to Fight Racism. And that is based on a framework that I created called the ARC of Racial Justice. ARC is an acronym that stands for Awareness, Relationships, Commitment. Awareness, Relationships, Commitment. Or as I say to kids, because there's a young reader's version, head, heart, hands. Right? So... This is how I tend to think of the action part or the practical part, because I could give you a bullet point list of a lot of different things, but it'd be really hard to remember it, let alone act on it. So I'm going to give you a framework.
SPEAKER_00So awareness means all the data, facts, information you need to understand about a particular justice issue, in this case, white Christian nationalism. So awareness is a big part of it. I am really frustrated slash baffled that more black Christians are aren't using the vernacular or the language of white Christian nationalism, they may be talking about it or talking around it, but there's an actual body of scholarship under that heading of Christian nationalism, or as I say, white Christian nationalism,
SPEAKER_00that we need to access. And so that means watching documentaries. The one I'll recommend is one I was in called God and Country. God and Country. It's very good.
SPEAKER_03Can I just cut you off and say it's very, very good. It's really well made. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_00I wish I could take credit. I was just a talking head on it, but it is good and informative. Watching those things, reading the books like The Flag and the Cross, or believe it or not, I keep telling people The Color of Compromise doesn't have white Christian nationalism in the name, but it's a book about white Christian nationalism because it's about white Christians behaving badly around race. And then, so that's awareness. So make a plan. Like, what are you actually going to access? Don't just say, oh yeah, it would be nice. Pick out three items. Pick a documentary, a book, and maybe a podcast or an article or something and go off.
SPEAKER_00And then next, relationships. So this looks different for white people and for people of color. So for white people, you're going to, in some cases, have to maintain some type of relationship with the white Christian nationalists among you. Hmm. This is your relative. This is your coworker. These are your church members. Why? Because you're going to have the best chance of grabbing their ear. They're not going to listen to me.
Jailers just look at me and say, he's not one of us, let alone see my work.
SPEAKER_00And so maybe you have an in. Maybe you have an inroad. We honestly need, in the best sense of the word, missionaries to white Christian nationalists. And that's where the relationship aspect comes in. For people of color, relationships come in forming interracial relationships. Solidarity. So I was just on a podcast hosted by Palestinian Christians, and I lived abroad in Israel-Palestine when I was in college,
SPEAKER_00and it was a transformative experience, and I absolutely saw the Black American experience mirrored in the Palestinian experience. And it's relationships of solidarity like that, where black folk get together with Palestinian folk and now especially Latino folk who are being so persecuted by ICE. There's a rise in anti-Asian hate. We people of color are going to have to get together. And that's when things get real serious in terms of disrupting the status quo. Then lastly is commitment.
SPEAKER_00And by commitment, I don't just mean like staying the course. I mean committing to systemic and institutional and policy changes, stuff that affects more than just one relationship at a time. And so we can't do everything, but what's your thing? find that and most of it y'all is going to be local like the federal level it's so big it's so complex and for most of us it's so distant we're going to frustrate ourselves but in your own town you can look at uh boards of
education you can look at city councils you can look at attorneys general races you can look at judge
SPEAKER_00races you can look at uh getting involved in Food banks now faces defunding and not being funded. So look locally and find some sort of issue, and it doesn't even have to be political. It could be in your church or your faith community. One of the things, the last thing I'll shut up, I'm extremely frustrated by both the ignorance and the silence of many church leaders. I'm talking about pastors.
SPEAKER_00You look at their... you know, their Instagram feed or their sermon topics, and it's like we are not free falling into fascism. And I'm just like, how do you preach as if people aren't worried about literally buying groceries and putting food on the table. They're not worried about their healthcare premiums doubling or tripling. They're not worried about them or their neighbors being abducted off the streets in the name of so-called immigration enforcement,
SPEAKER_00right? Like that's not even political, that's just good pastoring. You have to talk about the issues that are affecting your flock. And I see too many pastors who have been so conditioned to think that anything policy related is too political. And by the way, I don't mind being political because there's a difference between being political and being partisan. You can't help from being political because politics has to do with policy and policy has to do with people. So if you're a pastor who cares about people,
you're going to have to get political.
SPEAKER_00That's not the same as getting partisan. So I'm very frustrated by the quietism and the ignorance, the lack of understanding about white Christian nationalism and what we're up against. in terms of the fascism it's bringing in from many church leaders. So when you talk about commitment, what does it look like in your church to embed policies and practices that are pro-democracy, pro-human dignity?
SPEAKER_03There are some incredible comments in here. I wish I could read them all. Joel, Joel A. Bowman Sr., who says he's a friend of yours.
SPEAKER_00I know Joel, fellow Louisvillian.
SPEAKER_03Yes, he says that this pastor is speaking up. And I actually think that's the perfect transition to something else I wanted to talk about. I'll tell you, if you're still watching, First of all, thank you for being here. Hit the share button. That means a lot to me and to Jamar to help kind of get this conversation a little bit further. It means a ton. So thank you for doing that. But I actually think that Mr. Pastor Joel Bowman actually kind of helps transition to something I wanted to talk about here in the last couple of minutes,
SPEAKER_03which is the Black church. I'll tell you. that a thesis so so for those who don't know i make videos online and i i you know youtube is one of the platforms that i make videos on and this will eventually get cut up into a youtube video a deep dive video and one of the thesis statements that i have In this video, first is that I think Christian nationalism is apostasy. I think it is an apostate teaching. It's an apostate way. It is heretical, even, if you will.
SPEAKER_03OK, so that's one of the things that I'm focused on in this video that I'm kind of ideating and making. But the other thing is that I actually think that the black church can be an anecdote. to Christian nationalism. It's not to say that Black people in the Black church can't be an ally to Christian nationalism and come up alongside Christian nationalism. But I do think that there is a part of the Black church tradition
that is inherently antithetical to the things that Christian nationalism is trying to do. And my understanding of that comes from a lot of the history that I've learned.
SPEAKER_03And this is not just saying this because you're right here. It comes from the history I've learned from you and the spirit of justice that is often present in the black church. And I want you to talk a little bit about that history and the way black Christians have worked to fight the forces of white supremacist Christianity in America. The black church is the ecclesiastical rebuttal to white Christian nationalism.
The black church is the ecclesiastical rebuttal to white Christian nationalism.
SPEAKER_00By which I mean the black church is the only U.S. Christian tradition that arose specifically to push back against the myth and the lie of white supremacy within Christian circles. When you look at the history of the black church, we're talking about the post-emancipation period. Well, prior to that, the oldest continuously operating historically black denomination is the African Methodist Episcopal Church.
SPEAKER_00They were actually part of St. George's in Philadelphia, which was a white church. And the reason they left is because after they did this whole big building project, rearranged some seating, they accidentally sat in the whites only section, these longtime members. And they were told to get up while they were praying. They finished the prayer, and according to Richard Allen, who became the first bishop of the AME Church, he said, we left and they were troubled with us no more.
SPEAKER_00So what I'm saying is, where does the black church come from? It's not from some esoteric theological disagreement about the doctrine of the Trinity, or church councils, or something like that. It was simply because black people refused to be treated as second-class citizens in the household of God. It was racism. And so they went and formed the, quote, black church.
So the only reason there is a black church is because of racism in the white church. So that's why I say the black church is the ecclesiastical rebuttal to white
SPEAKER_00Christian nationalism. And as Dwight Radcliffe, who is the chair of the Pennell Center for Black Church Studies out in Pasadena, the way he says it is, the black church at its best. So we know the black church is all kinds of messed up because the black church has people. So don't actually, this is the same as black on black crime, right? Like you point out this great issue with black people that actually every other people group has. So the white church is all kinds of messed up,
SPEAKER_00you know, any kind of church you want to name because it has people. But the black church at its best has something to say. about resisting white Christian nationalism. I'll give you one more example. Charles H. Pierce was an African Methodist minister, black minister, who started the AME Church in Florida in the Reconstruction era right after the Civil War. He was also an outspoken leader, and he was elected several times as a state senator. And Charles Pierce said, a man in this state cannot do his whole duty as a minister.
SPEAKER_00except if he but looks out for the political interests of his people. And you have this long tradition of ministers who were also elected officials because the jobs were so interrelated. If you wanted to look out for your flock, you had to look out for the policies that were affecting them. And you see this now continued with people like Raphael Wardock or Clementa Pinckney, who was tragically murdered, right, in a racial terrorist attack at Emanuel AME.
SPEAKER_00But he was in state government, right? So the Black church absolutely—here's my last thing, my last thing. We keep hopping over the ocean to look at the German Confessing Church of the 1930s and people like Dietrich Bonhoeffer, which is well and good, but in the meantime we completely skip over a domestic version of the Confessing Church, which is called the Black Church.
SPEAKER_00We've been resisting authoritarianism for centuries, and yet You'll hear very few commentators saying, well, let's see how black people resisted. What did they do after the Wilmington coup of 1898, which as we record this is the anniversary of that event? What did they do after their leaders were killed in political assassinations? What did they do to gain the right to vote when not only did they not have the right to vote, they weren't even considered people?
SPEAKER_00They were considered property. You think we might have something to learn from those Christians who maintained hope and organized for activism and resistance? So yeah, the Black Church got something to say.
SPEAKER_03That's a phenomenal place to end it. I want to, of course, end with a couple of book recommendations. We have some very, very smart people watching here with us. The likes are going crazy. People are really, really connecting to what you've been saying here, Dr. Tisby. If you have one, two, three books that you recommend, someone already said, I want to say Mitchell, already said that he's ordered at least one of your books. All right, Mitchell. We love Mitchell for that. Any other books that you'd recommend?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would really recommend a couple of books. Katherine Stewart is an investigative journalist. She wrote the book Money, Lies, and God. If you want to be chilled to the bone, but also deeply informed, Read Money, Lies, and God by Catherine Stewart because she follows the money to all of these institutions and organizations, everything from the Heritage Foundation to the Claremont Institute to all of these ones that we've never heard of.
But she has checked it out and done the Lord's work for us in connecting the dots
SPEAKER_00behind the scenes, right? Another one, which is a classic at this point, is Jesus and John Wayne by Kristen Dumais. And she's able to talk about particularly the 20th century manifestation of white Christian nationalism. And her basic thesis is white evangelical support for Donald Trump isn't a betrayal of their values. It's a fulfillment of their values. And then, of course, all the books that I named, The Flag and the Cross by Gorski and Perry,
SPEAKER_00any of my books, particularly the historical books, The Spirit of Justice, I wrote for these times when we need inspiration to keep going when it looks like we're not winning. And these are true stories. Over 50 different people I profile. And by the way, my last plug, there is a picture book. based on the spirit of justice. This thing is gorgeous, y'all. This is for kids four to seven. Oh, I'm so glad. You'll be using it here before long.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's true. And then there's a young reader's version for kids eight and up. I call it justice for all generations. Beautiful. Lastly is my Substack. That's where I do all of my spiciest takes. There it is. Substack.com.
SPEAKER_03There it is. There's a link probably here or there somewhere where you can click Jamar Tisby's name and, of course, connect it to his sub stack. You can do the same for me. Jamar Tisby, thank you so much for taking the time. I learned a lot and I really, really appreciate it. Of course, again, folks, please, thanks for your patience, for those coming back. I see a couple of the names who were on here earlier. So they came back. They came back. Those are the ones who persevered.
SPEAKER_03They persevered. Of course, drop a like on this thing. Follow us both. You know, all the stuff. Do that. Thank you guys for hanging out. And of course, again, thank you, Jamar, for such a wealth of knowledge and the incredible ability to say it clearly. I appreciate you.
When Gloria Richardson pushed a National Guardsman’s bayonet out of her face, she captured the defiant spark that made her one of the most important figures of the civil rights and Black liberation struggles. Governor...
How did comedy get so… political? Well, we have Dick Gregory to partially thank for that. Garrison and comedian/The Daily Show host Josh Johnson talk about Gregory’s subversive brand of political comedy, his activism...
Do you ever feel powerless in the face of an atrocity? Well, that never stopped George Washington Williams, a Black man who went from being a “barely literate” veteran to a crusader who exposed a genocide in the Congo...
Episode 1 - The Future According to Octavia Butler Sci-Fi author Octavia Butler seemed to have predicted our dystopian present over 30 years ago. But can her understanding of history help us change our future? Garrison...