What in the mundi is the deal with the Salvator Mundi? Is it really a painting by Leonardo da Vinci? This episode explores a painting that was, for a hot second, one of the most famous paintings in the entire world. If not the most famous, then it was definitely the most expensive, selling in 2017 for a still record-setting price of 450 MILLION DOLLARS. Come for some stuff about Leonardo da Vinci and billionaire shenanigans, stay in spite (or perhaps because?) of the pencil mustaches and pink showgirl squirrels. If you enjoy the episode, don’t forget to leave it a rating or a review! If you are really feeling the zing, you can also buy me a coffee at http://buymeacoffee.com/stuffaboutthingspodcast Approximate time stamps: Opening narrative - 00:04:00 Discovery and early restoration efforts - 00:09:35 Leonardo da Vinci - 00:29:50 Provenance - 00:52:50 Restoration and Attribution -- 01:05:55 Exhibition in London - 1:35:00 2013 Sale - 1:48:30 2017 Sale - 2:16:00 Conclusion - 3:00:00 Track features royalty free music and sound effects, including: -Kevin MacLeod, "Brandenburg Concerto No. 4 in G, Movement I (Allegro), BWV 1049," “Comfortable Mystery” -Success Dream (Hooksounds.com) -Rubber Chicken by DogWomble (Pixabay)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Wait, am I recording? You are listening to Stuff About Things, an art history podcast. All right, let's mango.
SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to Stuff About Things, an art history podcast. My name is Lindsay, and I have my PhD in art history, which I use to tell you stuff about things. Usually art history things, but with me one never knows. Another thing that I have is a mouth that is absolutely chalk a block full of metal and plastic, which is on account of my adventure into pretty extensive adult orthodontia.
SPEAKER_00So if my mouth sounds a bit full while I'm talking, it's because it is. It was either sound a little funny while recording or wait six more months to put out an episode, which is too long even for me. And so here we are, doing what we always do, which is our best. Thank you for joining me for episode 47. Episode 47 is, like so many others, a big episode that started as a little episode.
SPEAKER_00In the last episode on the Voynich manuscript, I promised you a full-length episode on a super famous painting. While this episode fits that description, I think, I originally had a different super famous painting in mind. But in the course of researching that painting, I started a little side quest into the painting at the heart of this episode, thinking it would make a good mini-sode topic. That innocent little rabbit hole turned into a six-month research binge.
SPEAKER_00The information just kept going. And now here I am with about three plus hours of content for you. Someday I will actually make a mini sode, but that day is not today. Before we jump into those three plus hours, allow me to take 30 seconds to tell you how you can best support the podcast. Now the best way to do that is to leave a rating andor a review wherever you listen, if that platform allows for it.
SPEAKER_00You might also consider sharing the podcast with someone who you think might enjoy it. Those two things, ratings slash reviews, and word of mouth recommendations, are how most listeners find the show. If you really like the podcast, you can also support me directly by buying me a coffee on Buy Me a Coffee. While I do often use those funds to buy actual coffee, and if I'm being honest, the occasional beer, they are also a massive help in offsetting the cost of making the show, which despite being free for you to listen to, is not free for me to make and post.
SPEAKER_00You can find a link to do that in the notes that accompany the episode. It's also posted on my Instagram as well as somewhere on the podcast website, stuffaboutthingspodcast.com. I am so grateful to everyone who has or will contribute. Thank you so, so much. Now that we got that out of the way, let's get to what we're all here for. The part where I tell you stuff about a supposed lost masterpiece and the absolute madness that it caused.
SPEAKER_00The Salvatore Mundi. Allegedly, maybe, possibly, but almost certainly not entirely, if at all, by Leonardo da Vinci. The painting arrived in a simple black carrying case. The case's handler, a man named Sam, was headed to one of the most exclusive buildings in all of New York City, 15 Central Park West.
SPEAKER_00Sam made his way through the bronze doors, past security and doormen to reach the lobby. It was like walking into an Egyptian temple reimagined for 21st century billionaires. Sam was unfazed. He knew money, and the people who lived in this building had an inconceivable amount of it. It was for that exact reason that Sam was here, holding on to his black carrying case like his life depended on it, and if not his life, then certainly his career.
SPEAKER_00Typically, a professional of Sam's caliber was allowed to go straight up to the apartment in question, but not today. He was instead greeted in the lobby by a man named Bouvier, who escorted him up to the penthouse apartment. When they arrived, several people were waiting, including a man that Sam thought he recognized. After carrying such precious cargo across the city, Sam felt both relief and hesitation as he handed the case over to Bouvier, who retreated with it into an adjoining room.
SPEAKER_00Unsurprisingly, the familiar-looking man followed. Sam watched as the door closed behind them. The man that Sam had recognized was named Dimitri, and he was one of the richest men in the entire world. Dimitri had made his money the old-fashioned way, by identifying an untapped natural resource and bleeding every single cent he could from it. Or technically, rubles.
SPEAKER_00In the 1990s, Dimitri purchased potash mines in the Ural Mountains, and in about 10 years had earned the local nickname the Fertilizer King, an homage to potash's primary use. While hardly glamorous, Dimitri did not care. By the time the mines began to collapse in the mid-2000s, Dimitri was already a billionaire living in Monaco. But what was the fertilizer king to do with all of his untaxed riches, especially if he wanted to hide assets from a soon-to-be ex-wife?
SPEAKER_00Simple. Buy art. Really, really expensive art. That was how Dimitri met Bouvier, an art dealer and business mogul who worked with clients in the highest echelons of society. Dimitri tasked Bouvier with a very important mission: to build him an art collection worthy of a king, fertilizer or otherwise. In 2013, a painting came on the market that caught Dimitri's attention, a small to medium oil painting of Christ as the Salvatore Mundi, or Savior of the world.
SPEAKER_00Despite its fairly run-of-the-mill subject, there was absolutely nothing common about this particular painting. That is, if you believed the experts who had staked their professional reputations on this being an autograph work by one of the greatest artists to ever live, Leonardo da Vinci. It was that painting of the Salvatore Mundi that Bouvier unveiled to Dimitri in the penthouse of 15 Central Park West.
SPEAKER_00The Russian billionaire would later recall feeling a vibration coming from the work, and he instructed Bouvier to do whatever he had to to secure the sale. In just over a decade, the painting had gone from collecting dust and cobwebs in a decaying aristocratic house to having a Russian billionaire pay over$124 million for the pleasure of its company. It was enough to make even the painted Christ blush.
SPEAKER_00While time would not be kind to the pot ash mine mogul-turned art collector, the purchase of this painting did prove an excellent investment. One made so through the irresistible blend of marketing, money, and madness. There was just one small problem. Like the mines from which Dimitri had made his billions, madness has a habit of collapsing when pushed too far. In that respect, the glass orb of the world held by the painted Christ might as well have been a bubble, one that was threatening to burst at any minute.
SPEAKER_00And the clock was ticking. The Salvatore Mundi is a small to medium oil painting that depicts a serene-looking Christ staring out at the viewer. He raises one hand in a blessing, while the other holds a glass or crystal orb. These visual cues are what art historians would call iconography, which is a fancy word for visual shorthand that convey to us, the viewer, that we are looking at a very particular flavor of Christ.
SPEAKER_00I grant you, flavor is probably not the best word, but it gets the point across. This is not Christ as a mortal man, it is not Christ as a teacher, it is not Christ as a sacrificial lamb, or any of the other dozens of ways that Christ was commonly depicted throughout the Renaissance. This very serene version of Christ with his blessing hand and his crystal orb is instead showing Christ as the savior of the world, which in Latin translates to Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00In 2017, this painting of the Salvatore Mundi became one of the most famous artworks in the entire world for about six months, largely on account of a highly successful marketing campaign by the auction house Christie's. As one might expect, this campaign culminated in an auction, at which this painting sold for a staggering sum of$450 million.
SPEAKER_00I will repeat that for the people at the back. $450 million, which made it the most expensive painting ever sold at auction. What is even more bananas somehow is that almost nine years later, at the time of recording in 2026, the Salvatore Mundi retains that title as the most expensive painting ever sold at auction by the absolutely cuckoo bananas margin of$150 million.
SPEAKER_00There's also the fact that after months of a worldwide press tour, the painting basically disappeared. We have a pretty good idea of who owns it, and there are some rumors about where it is, but it has not been seen in public since that 2017 sale. There is one, count it, one reason behind all of this madness. The painting of the Salvatore Mundi has been attributed to the man, the myth, the ninja turtle, Leonardo da Vinci, a man so famous that he's often referred to by his first name alone, which I shall be doing.
SPEAKER_00But while his first name is technically pronounced Leonardo, I have enough things to worry about when it comes to pronunciation. So I'm giving myself a pass on that one. Leonardo, it is. I was originally not intending to do any episode on the Salvatore Mundi. In fact, I had a very different famous painting in mind that I will still probably do an episode on, but I went to the library planning on bleeding the shelves dry of any Leonardo books that they had.
SPEAKER_00And in doing that, I stumbled upon a book by Ben Lewis called The Last Leonardo: The Secret Lives of the World's Most Expensive Painting. And I read the entire book cover to cover in two days. It was an excellent book, and it was hands down the most helpful source and my gateway into this whole wacky story. I also really enjoyed the documentary The Lost Leonardo, which was not nearly as good as Lewis's book, but it was an excellent complement to it.
SPEAKER_00So I'd recommend both of those: The Last Leonardo by Ben Lewis and the documentary The Lost Leonardo. Now, if you were listening closely, you would have heard me say that this painting is attributed to Leonardo. That is very important because that word attributed is doing a lot of heavy lifting, because it means there's no definitive proof that Leonardo actually painted this work.
SPEAKER_00There is, however, enough circumstantial evidence that he could have painted the work, as determined by people who are experts on Leonardo. But oh boy, are the opinions on this matter polarizing? Part of this episode will focus on how that attribution came to happen, including the people who agree with it and the people who don't. But ultimately, the episode in its entirety is not about whether Leonardo da Vinci painted the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00Unless we can get Leonardo on the blower via a Ouija board, that is something that we will probably never actually know. The episode is instead about a series of events and choices and circumstances that created what I can only describe as a moment of madness in the art world. To start, we are going to go back, not 500 years, but rather to the good old days of 2005.
SPEAKER_00Twas in 2005 when an art dealer by the name of Alexander Parrish stumbled upon a bad JPEG of a painting that was for sale through a tiny auction house in New Orleans. It was a frontal half-figure of Jesus Christ as Salvatore Mundi, one painted using oil paints on a walnut panel. The auction house claimed it was a copy after Leonardo da Vinci and placed its anticipated sale between$1,200 and$1,800.
SPEAKER_00Parish was a man who looked through hundreds, if not thousands, of for sale paintings every week. And there was something about this particular bad JPEG that made him pause and look a little closer. He then picked up the phone and called his friend and colleague Robert Simon and asked him to take a look. In addition to their professional work as art dealers, Parrish and Simon had a side hustle as quote-unquote sleeper hunters.
SPEAKER_00They spent a lot of time pouring through auction websites and sales catalogs looking for sleepers, which is to say artworks that are being greatly undervalued by sellers, buyers, or both. It is very easy for that to happen, especially with old paintings that have been passed down through generations or whose history or appearance have been muddled by poor record keeping and the accumulation of interventions that have happened throughout the centuries.
SPEAKER_00Parish and Simon both thought that this painting of Salvatore Mundi could potentially be a sleeper. The two requested a higher quality image from the auction house. After reviewing it, the two decided that it was worth the risk, and they would go halfsies on the purchase. Later, they would claim that they bought the painting for around$10,000, but it later emerged that they had paid significantly less than that.
SPEAKER_00$1,175. Once the check cleared, the painting was packaged up in New Orleans and sent via UPS to New York City, where Parish and Simon were waiting. Seeing the work in person confirmed what Parish and Simon already suspected. There were passages of heavy repainting and clear signs of damage. Rather hilariously, at one point, someone even added a pencil mustache to Jesus, probably to make him look a bit older and presumably more manly.
SPEAKER_00Which, hmm, pencil mustache is an interesting choice. But bad mustaches be damned, there were also portions of the painting that appeared to be original. They indicated that the work was no 17th or 18th century copy intended to look like a Renaissance work, but rather an authentic Renaissance painting that likely dated to the early to mid-1500s. One that Parrish referred to as a quote, extremely good high-quality copy, end quote.
SPEAKER_00Shortly after receiving the painting, Simon and Parish took it to one of the best, most experienced conservators of old masters in the city, Mario Modestini. Part of the reason Mario was so experienced is because he was 98 years old. But in his heyday, he had a very well-respected career as an art conservator and consultant. It is in large part thanks to Mario Modestini that the National Gallery of Art in DC was able to acquire the first and only painting by Leonardo in the Western Hemisphere, the portrait of Ginevere da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00After looking at the painting, Mario was quite pleased. From what he could make out beneath all the gunk and overpaint that had been added to the painting over the years, he said that it had been a very good investment, and was probably the work of a pretty talented painter working probably one generation after Leonardo. Mario also recognized, as they all did, that the painting was in dire need of an experienced conservator, one of whom just happened to be in the room with them.
SPEAKER_00Not Mario, but his much younger wife and very talented conservator in her own right, Diane Modestini. She agreed to take the job, and she would go on to become one of Parrish and Simon's fiercest allies in the business of the Salvatore Mundi. Diane got straight to work. It took her two days to clean away layers of yellowing varnish and thick overpaint, efforts that laid bare just how damaged this painting was, though the extent of that damage is still being debated today.
SPEAKER_00With regards to the Salvatore Mundi, many of those conversations focus on how much original paint still exists. And that can be a confusing concept to those outside the world of conservation, including myself. What is key to know is that paintings like this are created by layering very thin applications of paint one on top of another, which you build and you blend. The top layer of paint is obviously the most vulnerable, while the base layers are more protected.
SPEAKER_00Over time, though, those layers get worn down, something that often happens unevenly. To make matters worse, when a painting is looking, you know, a little worse for wear, it's common for people to want to zhuzh it up with some fresh paint, often to the detriment of the original work. What Modestini found through this first round of conservation was that the painting had suffered considerable losses. There were large areas of paint that had been worn down, including portions of the head and face.
SPEAKER_00The background was also a mess, and you could barely. See the orb that Christ was holding. There were also these massive, mysterious scratches that were running down Christ's face. Something that reminded me a little bit of that scene in Beauty and the Beast, classic movie, and the first movie I ever owned on DVD, where the beast is going all beastie and he sinks his claws into a portrait of his human face and scratches down.
SPEAKER_00In its cleaned state, the Salvatore Mundi looked a lot like that, which is not great. And as if matters couldn't get any worse, the painting was cracked. Uh-huh. Cracked. Something that was caused by a knot in the wood. It's the kind of flaw that no self-respecting painter, especially of Leonardo's caliber, would have selected for a work, because a knot in the panel compromises its structural integrity from day one, as the knot expands and contracts at a different rate than the wood around it, which is something that would definitely cause cracks sooner rather than later.
SPEAKER_00And that is exactly what happened. So the support is cracked, and the paint on that support has been severely damaged to varying degrees across the surface of the painting. A yikes. So then we must ask ourselves: how much of what we're seeing today is actually by the hand of the person who originally made the work, who in this case is allegedly Leonardo. Like everything else with this painting, the answer depends on who you ask.
SPEAKER_00I do consistently see mentions that about 20% of the paint on the surface of the walnut panel was straight up gone. On top of those critical losses, up to 60% of what we can see has been worn down by several layers. That means that only 20 to 30% of what we can see on this painting is paint laid down by the original hand as they intended for people to see it.
SPEAKER_00Though I should say that the people who really truly believe the painting is by Leonardo do claim that those numbers are exaggerated. But they also tend to give exaggerated numbers themselves, with some even claiming that up to 80% of the paint that remains was put there by the master himself. But they're being a little tricky-tricky with that number, because the painting is still severely damaged. That is a simple fact that everyone can agree on. Salvatore Mundi equals very damaged.
SPEAKER_00And if 80% of the paint was indeed put there by Leonardo, not a whole lot of that can be said to be in pristine condition. I'll say it again. Yikes. While the extent of the damage would have been discouraging, Simon Parrish and Modestini all recall that it was at this point when the painting had been stripped of all the gunk people had put on it, including the pencil mustache, R.I.P. to that, that the real quality of it began to shine through.
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately, for us and for them and for everyone involved, the crew did not very carefully document this early part of the process. There are maybe a couple of photographs of the painting in its pre-cleaned state, and then just one in its cleaned state before Modestini then went in with a second round of restoration. Some people point to that as a kind of, haha, they're trying to hide things from us. But the reality is at this point, none of them knew what was in store for them or this painting.
SPEAKER_00As far as they were concerned, they were documenting things just fine. Once Modestini had completely cleaned the painting, but before she started her restoration efforts, the painting was handed off to specialist Monica Griesbach, who was tasked with ensuring the walnut panel itself was stable. It became very clear, very quickly, that it was not. When Griesbach freed the painting from its frame and some other reinforcements, the entire thing fell apart, and Griesbach had to reassemble it like a five-piece puzzle.
SPEAKER_00By the time Diane Modestini got the painting back into her studio, her entire life had been upturned by the death of her husband Mario at the age of 98. It was a profound loss, and Modestini understandably fell into a deep depression. Having the Salvatore Mundi back in her studio gave her something that she had lacked for months. Purpose. She threw herself back into the project, one to which she would dedicate six years of her life in total.
SPEAKER_00Six years. That's a long time. It wasn't necessarily all in one go. Rather, Modestini approached the restoration process, obviously under the supervision of Robert Simon and Alexander Parish. She undertook it in two phases. The first was between 2006 and 2008. And the goal of this preliminary stage was to get the painting in good enough shape that Simon and Parrish could begin showing the Salvatore Mundi to select museums and professionals.
SPEAKER_00The second phase of restoration happened after those experts had looked at the painting, but before it went on public view. It's not entirely clear to me what exactly happened at each of these two stages of restoration. But it seems like the second phase is the more controversial of the two. That said, given how damaged the painting was to begin with, both phases of restoration would have involved a lot of in-painting, the goal of which is to restore a kind of visual wholeness to a very damaged picture.
SPEAKER_00You might be thinking, Lindsay, isn't that an art historical catfish on par with Henry VIII and Anne of Cleves? See Mini Sode 8 for that. No. Well, kind of. I say kind of, because in painting, which is the process of reintroducing paint where there have been losses, is incredibly common. And you would probably be very surprised to know just how many of your favorite works have had pretty significant work done to maintain the wholeness of the image.
SPEAKER_00Maybe not to the extent of the Salvatore Mundi, which we'll talk about, but certainly some. No one wants to look at a damaged painting, especially not a face that is mostly gone or like missing a nose or slashed. Nobody wants that. And so Modestini started to rebuild the image using teeny tiny little paintbrushes and the finest of paints. It was at this point, while up close and personal, with a shadow on the Salvatore Mundi's lip, that she grew increasingly convinced that the painting was none other than a work by Leonardo da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00Pause for dramatic effect, gasps all around, etc., etc., etc. This is where we are going to take a step back into history because there is someone pretty important to this story that you have yet to meet. The man, the myth, the blue bandana wearing, katana wielding, anthropomorphic turtle. Oh, sorry, scratch that. I can't read my own handwriting. Italian Renaissance polymath, Leonardo da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00This section is not going to be a comprehensive overview of the life and work of Leonardo da Vinci. We are going to be hitting the big points with an emphasis on those that are needed to best understand the business of the Salvatore Mundi. If you are an expert on Leonardo, first, what are you doing here? And second, you are almost certainly not going to learn anything that you don't already know. Personally, I enjoy a good refresh every once in a while.
SPEAKER_00But if you would prefer to just get on with the story of the Salvatore Mundi, I will be providing some handy dandy timestamps in the episode description to help you do that. For those of you who are sticking around, let's jump into it. Leonardo da Vinci was born in April of 1452 in a town of Vinci near Florence. Yes, Vinci. His name literally means Leonardo from Vinci. He was the illegitimate son of a not insignificant 24-year-old Florentine man and a 16-year-old girl who was of a much lower class, both of whom would go on to marry different people within their relative social classes by the time their son turned one.
SPEAKER_00We don't know a whole lot about Leonardo's young life, but he was at least partially raised in his grandfather's house in Vinci. He does not seem, however, to have received more than a basic education. He could read and write and do some math, which puts him ahead of most people during his time and also slightly ahead of me, but he certainly didn't have the kind of schooling one might expect based on what he would go on to accomplish throughout his life.
SPEAKER_00His artistic talents must have emerged at some point in his childhood, because by the time he was a teenager, Leonardo had moved to Florence. It was in Florence that Leonardo joined the studio of Andrea Del Verrocchio, who was one of the most esteemed in-demand artists of the age. Not too shabby for a kid from Vinci. Though I will say that Daddy da Vinci was not only a pretty well respected legal notary in Florence, but may have also been personal acquaintances with Verrocchio.
SPEAKER_00That does not mean Leonardo wasn't talented as a teenager. By all accounts, he was extremely talented. But it certainly helps things along. In 1472, after several years of honing his craft as both a painter and a sculptor in Verrocchio's studio, Leonardo joined the Florentine Artists Guild, signaling to us that at the age of just 20, Leonardo was no longer a studio assistant or student, but a master in his own right.
SPEAKER_00Today we only have about 15 to 20 paintings believed to be by Leonardo, and of those, only about 12, give or take, are uncontested or mostly uncontested works by him. The rest, including the Salvatore Mundi, have at least one, if not several, question marks behind them. We also have hundreds, if not thousands, of drawings by Leonardo, in addition to a handful of manuscripts.
SPEAKER_00Apart from a few of his drawings, like that of the Vitruvian Man, hugely famous, Leonardo's greatest hits are primarily his paintings, the majority of which are either religious scenes or portraits. They include The Madonna of the Rocks, of which there are two versions: one at the National Gallery of London, one at the Louvre, The Last Supper in Milan, which is famously in terrible condition as the result of Leonardo's insistence on experimentation, which sometimes, as with this situation, did not go well, and portraits like The Lady with the Ermine, the portrait of Ginevere da Benci, and of course, what is arguably the most famous painting in the entire world, the Mona Lisa.
SPEAKER_00When it comes to Leonardo, our lack of finished paintings and just generally finished works is not necessarily the results of losses over the past 500 plus years, though, of course, that is part of it. A bigger part of it, though, is the simple fact that Leonardo was not very good at finishing things. In fact, he was quite terrible at it, which is rather audacious given how important some of the people and institutions were, that he was hugely pissing off by not delivering what he said he would if he ever delivered anything at all.
SPEAKER_00The reasons why Leonardo often failed to start or complete things are complex, aren't they always? But one of the reasons is the simple fact that he wanted to know all of the stuff about all of the things, and he had the intellectual capacity to do just that. His interests ran the gamut with a strong emphasis on things related to art, engineering, and perhaps most of all, the natural world.
SPEAKER_00But when it came to learning all of the stuff about all of the things, once Leonardo scratched a particular intellectual itch, if you will, he was on to the next thing. That way of operating made him notorious at not finishing projects. None of that was helped by the fact that Leonardo was a perfectionist. And not in the way that we sometimes respond to that stupid question in job interviews.
SPEAKER_00Probably my perfectionism. Uh, no. His perfectionism was at times debilitating. He was easily frustrated when things weren't going exactly as he saw them in his head, resulting in him abandoning a lot of projects midway through, or, alternatively, holding on to paintings way longer than he should have because he was constantly tweaking them, convinced that he could make them better. That is exactly what happened with his most famous work, The Mona Lisa.
SPEAKER_00He worked on that baby on and off for 10 years. And the only reason it was ever quote unquote finished is because he died. But my God, when Leonardo did finish a work, it was something to behold. He was out there doing things that other people had never even thought of. And if they had thought of them, they weren't doing them half as well as he was. One of the main things that defines Leonardo's work is his commitment to capturing the natural world in all of its beauty and complexity, while also being incredibly in tune to the psychology of people, primarily with regards to his portraits, and the narrative power of emotional and spatial relationships between the figures that appear in his other works.
SPEAKER_00On top of all of that, the man can paint the hell out of just about anything and would use these really super, super thin layers of paint that he would build and build and blend and build until you really can't see where one color or contour ends and the other begins. He would do that with a combination of opaque and semi-transparent paints, also referred to as glazes. That means that when you're looking at his paintings, you aren't just seeing the last color that was most recently laid down, but rather a complex interplay of layers.
SPEAKER_00As a result, his paintings have a kind of hazy or smoky quality to them, one that is often referred to in art history as sfumato, derived from the Italian word sfumare, which has a bunch of meanings depending on what you're using it for, but they include to blend, to soften, to dissipate, to fade. He was not the only person doing sfumato. He was not the person to quote unquote invent sfumato, but he is without question the best sfumatoer to ever sfumato.
SPEAKER_00And all of his paintings show some level of that at play. Leonardo was also more than just a technically good painter. He was also a highly creative one and was happy, even eager, to break from convention in the name of making a more interesting and dynamic painting. One thing that he almost never did, or like hardly ever did, was paint figures straight on or in stark profile.
SPEAKER_00He instead liked to angle them, which changed how faces and bodies would catch the light and allow him to better capture more nuanced contrasts of light and dark. There was often even a playful element to how he defied those expectations, like his preference for including distant landscapes that are more like figments of his imagination than identifiable places. Some even look like alien landscapes. Case in point, the landscape in the Mona Lisa.
SPEAKER_00It's crazy. Unlike many artists, Leonardo was actually recognized for having these extraordinary talents during his lifetime, and his skills as both an artist and a thinker were coveted by some of the biggest of the bigwigs of his day. That included serving as the court painter, sculptor, military, and civil engineer, and even the architect for the Duke of Milan, Ludovico Sforza, after which he served as the military architect for the walking syphilitic nightmare that was Cesare Borgia.
SPEAKER_00If you're ever bored and want to be horrified, read about him. After almost a year of moving throughout Italy alongside Cesare Borgia's army, Leonardo then returned to Florence, where he starts to paint absolute bangers like the Mona Lisa. And maybe, just maybe, even the Salvatore Mundi. For reference, that is around 1503-1504. A few years later, he's back in Milan working for the French who invaded the damn place.
SPEAKER_00Rude. Then spends a couple years in Rome working at the Vatican. And finally, hop, skip, and a jump into the future, he gets scooped up by none other than King Francis I of France, who was the key patron of Leonardo in his final years. More on that in a second. As you can hopefully tell, Leonardo was quite a busy man over his four-plus decade-long career. But while singular in many respects, Leonardo was not doing all of this work alone, because in the Renaissance, artmaking was not always a solo endeavor.
SPEAKER_00In fact, it was more often a team sport of sorts. Once he was established as a master painter in Florence, he created a workshop, which involved a series of young men coming to work with him as apprentices and studio assistants, several of whom stayed with him for years and years. Those apprentices are commonly known as the Leonardeschi or the Little Leonardo's. It's a fitting nickname because all of those apprentices learned to paint like him and often imitated his style in their own works.
SPEAKER_00The goal of the workshop situation was to train up these young men as artists in their own right while also getting some skilled labor out of them. Like Leonardo did when he worked in Vorrocchio's workshop, his apprentices would often step in to help him with big commissions, while he would monitor their own paintings and step in to lend a hand as needed. Some, if not a lot, of those works would be copies after works by him, which the workshop could then go out and sell.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes the apprentices would be working from actual paintings that Leonardo had created. Other times they were known to work from cartoons, which are not the cartoons we would think of today, but rather full-scale drawings of what Leonardo envisioned for a final painting. In that respect, he's cutting out the middleman, which is him actually doing the work. A drawing was good enough, it took less time, and it allowed him to do all of the fun, figuring out y stuff without needing to spend weeks upon weeks painting the damn thing.
SPEAKER_00500 years later, though, that method of working puts us, art historians, in 2020. 26 in a little bit of a pickle because there are gaggles of paintings out there that are quote unquote copies of Leonardo da Vinci's works, but we don't often have the painted original. We don't even know if the original ever existed or if apprentices were working from a cartoon. Leonardo had active workshops in both Florence and Milan while he was working in each respective city.
SPEAKER_00The final workshop that he established was in France, something he did on the invitation of King Francis I, who he met through his work with the French in Milan. Leonardo took three paintings with him to France, including the Mona Lisa. He also took along two of his most trusted assistants, who helped him establish a studio at Francis' courts in Amboise. That is where Leonardo spent the final three years of his life, which were filled with all kinds of projects, from planning small cities to staging spectacles for the king and his court.
SPEAKER_00By late 1517, though, Leonardo's health started to decline, something that continued until May 1519, when Leonardo da Vinci died of what might have been a stroke at the age of 67. Leonardo was survived by several assistants who had spent much of their lives working alongside him. Those include Francesco Melzi, who was with Leonardo when he died and played a crucial role in preserving as much as he could of Leonardo's drawings and notebooks.
SPEAKER_00There was also Gian Giacomo Caprotti da Oreno, nicknamed Celai, meaning little devil. Celai had started working in Leonardo's workshop at just 10 years old, and he had remained there for decades. Celai died just five years later at the age of 44. An inventory of his belongings includes a list of twelve paintings, all of which were modeled after works by Leonardo, including Solai's version of the Mona Lisa.
SPEAKER_00Another of those twelve works was a painting described as, quote, Christ as God the Father, end quote. A title that could easily describe the Salvatore Mundi. While the generic title certainly doesn't help much, this entry suggests two things. One, that Leonardo had indeed created a version of Christ as God the Father, potentially the Salvatore Mundi, and that Salai had created a copy.
SPEAKER_00This and other vague titles of works like a half-figure of Christ are the only indications we have to suggest that Leonardo ever painted something like the Salvatore Mundi, given that none of his early biographies mention such a work. We can say, however, with some confidence, that Leonardo did indeed paint or draw an original version of such a work. There are simply too many copies out there for there not to have been an original reference.
SPEAKER_00We also have two drawings that are pretty confidently by Leonardo that show sleeves, yes, sleeves, that correlate closely with multiple copies of the Salvatore Mundi. The natural fall of a flowy sleeve would have been a very tricky part of the painting to get right, hence the drawings. And you know what they always say: where there are sleeves, there is probably the rest of the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00I mean, no one actually says that, but the latter part holds up to a certain extent. It was not until over 130 years after Leonardo's death that evidence emerges that he did in fact paint the Salvatore Mundi. To be clear, not just a half-figure of Christ, not just Christ as God the Father, both of which could potentially describe the Salvatore Mundi, but could also describe a bunch of other stuff. But an actual painting that we know is of the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00That all happened in 1650 when Wencheslash Holler threw himself into the mix. Holler was an artist from Prague who had spent decades living in England, where he worked as an etcher and an engraver. He did a lot of different things, but one of his bread and butter activities was to make etchings of famous works, which was commercially very successful, because us Poors could buy those instead of just yearning after these paintings, we would probably never see, much less afford, because there was just one.
SPEAKER_00In 1650, Holler produced an etching that is clearly a Salvatore Mundi. You can see it with your own eyeballs. Holler signed this work in Latin, which reads, quote, Leonardo da Vinci painted Wences Las Holler, made with aquafortis after the original. End quote. For reference, this mention of aqua fortis is just a reference to materials used for etchings. So he etched it.
SPEAKER_00This was a very common way for etchers to sign their work. They give credit to the person who made the original, then credit themselves with having done the etching. It's the last bit in Holler's signature that has art historians in a kerfuffle. He says that he made this work after the original, suggesting that he personally, with his own two eyeballs, saw a painting of the Salvatore Mundi that he believed was the original by Leonardo da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00Given the timeline of this etching coming a full 130 years after Leonardo died, it's hard to know how serious to take Holler's assertion that he saw the original by Leonardo da Vinci. What we know for sure is that Holler saw a painting of the Salvatore Mundi that he believed was the original by Leonardo, and that he was excited enough about it that he made it into an etching. But we can infer a couple of other things.
SPEAKER_00One of them being that Holler probably saw this painting sometime around 1650. At least that's the most logical explanation given that you wouldn't create an etching after a painting unless the details were pretty clear in your memory. Speaking of details, Holler's etching does look a lot like the Salvatore Mundi that Simon and Parrish bought in 2005. But to my eye, it also looks a lot like some of the other copies of the Salvatore Mundi hanging out in private collections and museums around the world.
SPEAKER_00But for the individuals who believe the Salvatore Mundi purchased by Parish and Simon is the original work by Leonardo, draw very strong parallels between the painting and this etching by Holler. The words, quote unquote, almost identical and similar phrases crop up very often. But the concept of almost identical is relative. As Ben Lewis points out in his book, and as I can see with my own eye, the painting that sold for$450 million and the print by Holler are not identical.
SPEAKER_00Even when you look back at the cleaned version that Modestini was working on in her studio back in 2006, a moment to which this is all leading us back to. The biggest difference that I can see is that Holler's Jesus has a significant beard, one that is far more evident than whatever wispy tufts are going on in the Simon and Parrish Salvatore Mundi. People have ways of explaining this difference away that are entirely hypothetical and speculative.
SPEAKER_00If Holler says he etched a painting after the original, especially if it was an original by Leonardo da Vinci, Holler is not just adding a beard to Jesus because he feels like it. Sure, maybe someone painted a beard onto the Salvatore Mundi, and that beard has been removed in the three centuries thereafter. But lots of things are possible, and that doesn't mean they happened. Case in point, one of the things that really grinds my gears when it comes to the Salvatore Mundi business is how Leonardo scholars have used this etching by Holler to weave all kinds of crazy stories about the journey, quote unquote, another word I can't freaking stand, of the Salvatore Mundi between 1500 and 1650.
SPEAKER_00The entire logic of this is that if Holler made this etching in 1650, it absolutely 100% means that Leonardo painted a painting of the Salvatore Mundi in the early 1500s. And, and, and, and, that painting was absolutely the one purchased by Simon and Parrish in 2005. Excuse me. Huh? I get so frustrated by all of this because it feels like I'm missing something. But the more that I've thought about it over the past six months that I've been uh reading up on this topic, I don't think I am missing anything.
SPEAKER_00I think I'm just approaching it as a skeptic, which in my head is what makes for good research. If you are going in thinking, how can I connect this painting discovered in 2005 with Leonardo da Vinci in 1500, you are going to get a very different narrative than if you're just asking, what does the documentary evidence tell us about this painting that was purchased in 2005? The people doing provenance research for the Simon and Parish Salvatore Mundi took the first route.
SPEAKER_00They mapped out a potential sequence of ownership and events that went from 1500 to 2005. Now, I don't make it a point to criticize people, especially other art historians who are just trying to do their jobs. But in my opinion, Lindsay, hello, that's me. In my opinion, what they came up with is essentially art historical fanfiction, something I am absolutely sure exists and I'm too scared to look. They did this by tracing mentions of what could have been the Salvatore Mundi through various collections, including those of no fewer than three kings.
SPEAKER_00Now it is true that there are often references in inventories and sales catalogs, including royal ones, to various versions of the Salvatore Mundi, or Christ as God the Father, or a half figure of Christ. You can tentatively, emphasis on tentatively, tentatively try to figure out a kind of family tree situation of how those very vaguely described paintings get passed down or sold from person to person.
SPEAKER_00But that is a tricky business because there are usually not formal titles for things, and attributions often change. So something that was previously called the Salvatore Mundi by Sulai might, in the next collection, wind up being called a half figure of Christ from the school of Leonardo. Both might refer to the same physical painting, but before photography was a thing, it was pretty tough to say with certainty which painting each of those references belongs to.
SPEAKER_00As far as I can tell, there seems to have been at least one, if not more, cases of mistaken identity and a lot of idealistic or wishful thinking when it comes to establishing the quote-unquote probable history of ownership of the Salvatore Mundi. I'm not necessarily accusing anyone of acting unethically, but there is a certain level of bias coming into play with the approach this team took that would not pass muster with a lot of art historians I know.
SPEAKER_00And that's just if this were an academic theory that someone was trying to publish an article on or give a conference talk about. But in this situation, those theories are being used by others to sell this painting for hundreds of millions of dollars, which is very unfortunate for art history, but very fortunate for a select few people's pockets. And I am not including any art historians in that mix. I would highly doubt anyone, even the Provenance research team, got much of a cut, if anything, from this whole business.
SPEAKER_00I honestly hope that they did, because they're a huge reason for why the painting ultimately sells for what it does. But no one is usually throwing art historians a bone, which is part of why most of us are poor and or have a day job like me. To be fair to the Provenance research team, they did publish a book in 2019 that I presume goes more into their research and the narrative, etc., etc. That was written by Robert Simon, Martin Kemp, and an art historian by the name of Margaret Dalavale.
SPEAKER_00But unfortunately, I cannot find a copy of that book within 100 miles of where I live. As someone who has largely pooed the Provenance narrative that these folks set forth, I genuinely wish I could have read the book, but gas is expensive. And I don't have 30 bucks to spend on an obscure book about Leonardo da Vinci. Getting down off that particular soapbox, let's go to what we do know about the history of the painting that Simon and Parish bought in 2005.
SPEAKER_00Not hypothetical mentions of it, but what we actually know. Let's work backwards. We know for sure that Robert Simon and Alexander Parrish purchased this painting of the Salvatore Mundi in 2005 from a New Orleans auction house. That auction house, the St. Charles Gallery, was selling items from the estate of Basil Clovis Hendry Sr., a former businessman based in Baton Rouge.
SPEAKER_00Our good personal friend Basil Clovis Hendry Sr. had owned the painting since 1987, when he inherited it from his aunt, Minnie Stanfill Kuntz. Minnie and her husband had purchased the Salvatore Mundi while traveling to London in 1958, when it was labeled as a work by Boltrafio, one of the little Leonardos who worked in Leonardo's workshop. The Kuntzes paid a whopping£45 for the thing.
SPEAKER_00Not too shabby. Before the Kuntzes, the painting had been in the collection of Sir Francis Cook, a man who was so successful in his trade business that he became the third richest man in all of the United Kingdom. He used a good chunk of that money to build an exceptional collection of art that was rivaled only by that of the literal Queen of England. In a catalogue produced of his collection in 1913, the Salvatore Mundi appears under entry 106 as a quote, free copy after Boltrafio.
SPEAKER_00That is to say, it is an unknown artist's interpretation of a work by one of Leonardo's students. Basically, a freewheeling copy of a copy. We know for show that the Salvatore Mundi at the heart of our episode today is the painting referenced in the Cook Collection catalog because very usefully, someone wrote CC 106 on the back of the painting. CC Cook Collection. 106, the catalog entry number.
SPEAKER_00Bada bing, bada boom. It's that kind of physical evidence that is essential to helping us link an object in the present to its location and ownership in the past. The entry in that 1913 catalog is short, but it tells us some interesting things. The first is that the painting was in pretty bad shape already in the early 1900s, having quote unquote suffered from damage caused by overcleanings and heavy repainting.
SPEAKER_00The second useful bit of information from the Cook catalog is that at the time Cook purchased the painting, it was attributed to a different artist, the rather tongue-twistingly named Bernardino Luini, who I believe was more of an associate of Leonardo's rather than a direct pupil or student or apprentice, but still. He certainly painted in Leonardo's style. As for where Cook got the painting from, we know from records he purchased it in 1900 for 120 pounds from Sir John Charles Robinson, who, once upon a time in the late 1800s, was the first superintendent at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, which I thought was delightful.
SPEAKER_00Because I just so happened to love that museum. Robinson was a big Italian art guy. Who can blame him? He was especially into Leonardo. Surprise, surprise. After calling it quits at the Victoria and Albert, Robinson became an art dealer and connoisseur, and he kept awesome notes. But unfortunately for us, those stop in 1898, and none of his existing notes mention the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00Given how well he documented things, the most likely explanation is that Robinson may have purchased the work between 1898, when there starts that gap in the notes, and 1900, when Cook purchased it from him. Interestingly though, if you look at all of the historical sales of art in England around this time, which I am taking from Ben Lewis's book, I did not go, you know, trawling through all of these records, but those records do show that around this time, or at least in the early 1870s, there were two sales involving either a head of Christ or a Salvatore Mundi, both of which were attributed to Noimi, the same painter who was believed to have painted the Salvatore Mundi, our Salvatore Mundi, if you will, when Cook purchased it in 1900.
SPEAKER_00And I do believe that these are two separate paintings. Did Robinson buy one of them and just didn't write it down? We don't know. Maybe there was a third one banging around in the late 1890s. Hard to say. But what I can say is that it is so frustrating to not know where Robinson got this thing from, because from this point forward, well, I suppose backward into the past, the trail of the Salvatore Mundi goes completely cold.
SPEAKER_00So now we have to work with what we got, which is not very much. While we know the Salvatore Mundi is over 500 years old, like that is clear, it is not a modern forgery, it is an old master painting. But the earliest that we can document it to is 1900. And in that 105-year period, between 1900 and Simon and Parrish buying it in 2005, it was never attributed to Leonardo, which is really weird.
SPEAKER_00Because as Ben Lewis points out in his book, Robinson knew his stuff, and the Cook Collection was constantly being visited by art historians. And none of them recognized this work as anything other than a freewheeling copy of a copy. It was right there under their noses, and they failed to recognize anything special about it. It's hard to chalk that up entirely to damage and repainting, because it was damaged and repainted when Simon and Parish bought it.
SPEAKER_00Was everyone before them just too distracted by the pencil mustache? I mean, I've been distracted by a pencil mustache or two in my life, but those definitely didn't belong to masterpieces. I should say that at the time Simon and Parish bought the work in 2005, they didn't necessarily think it was by Leonardo. They might have hoped it was, but it wasn't until Diane Modestini cleaned the painting in 2005 or 2006, I forget what year she started the project on.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't until then that that hope started to crystallize into something more. Did you see what I did there? I got us all the way from Leonardo da Vinci being born in 1452 to the Salvatore Mundi being in Diane Modestini's studio in New York in 2006 when she had a hot date with Christ's upper lip. And it only took me a week to record it. I am so inefficient, but Diane Modestini is not.
SPEAKER_00It was in that studio with these teeny teeny tiny paint brushes that Modestini was trying to inpaint Christ's upper lip. But she was struggling because the transition between light and dark in that section was just too sophisticated. She couldn't replicate it, at least not to the degree of the original. It was in that moment that she finally let herself believe that she was currently communing with paint that Leonardo da Vinci had laid down on a crappy walnut panel almost 500 years before.
SPEAKER_00The longer that Modestini continued to work on the painting, the more convinced she became that it was 100% the work of Leonardo da Vinci. She conveyed that news to her clients, the painting's owners, Simon and Parrish. They were as tickled as can be. They too had believed the painting was special, and now one of the top conservators of old master paintings in New York was confirming that they had absolutely found themselves the sleeping beauty of all sleepers.
SPEAKER_00This is where things start to get a little um, I want to say complicated, that's not the right word. Controversial, kind of. Allow me to explain. Under the supervision of Simon, a part owner of the painting, Modestini began to pursue what she calls an imitative or mimetic approach to conservation. That involves looking at other paintings by Leonardo to inform how she approaches in painting, which is the process of adding new layers of paint where there have been losses.
SPEAKER_00When it comes to the Salvatore Mundi, that was a significant amount of work. For example, when it came to touching up the mouth of the Salvatore Mundi, she looked to the Mona Lisa and other works by Leonardo for guidance. She also looked to other versions of the Salvatore Mundi to inform other aspects of the painting. The logic here was that all of these copies are based either directly or indirectly, they might be copies of copies, but they're all based on a lost original by Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00Modestini thought that she had that lost painting, and if this painting had informed other paintings of the same subject, it made a lot of sense to use them as references. I see the rationale, but I don't necessarily believe the premise. Because it requires you to be darn sure that the painting in your possession is in fact the original. But to be fair, she was pretty confident about that.
SPEAKER_00As you might be able to imagine, this mimetic or imitative approach has been critiqued, often heavily and at times cruelly. The most ardent critics have essentially said that consciously or not, Modestini made this painting look more like a work by Leonardo than it originally did. In his book, The Last Leonardo, Ben Lewis describes it as straddling the line between restoration and invention.
SPEAKER_00Modestini is very much aware of these critiques and these questions about her restoration of the Salvatore Mundi. It would be kind of impossible not to be aware of them because people were basically screaming them in her face. In interviews and on a website that she created entirely dedicated to the Salvatore Mundi, which has been very helpful for the purposes of the pod, Modestini has sworn, up, down, left, and right, that nothing she did to this painting interfered with or imposed anything new on the original.
SPEAKER_00Now I don't totally understand how that's possible, given that there were areas where the painting was severely damaged and she added to it. But I'm not a conservator, so what the hell do I know? Answer not a whole lot. But I do know a couple of conservators and some people who work in that general area of things. None of them had anything bad to say about how Modestini approached the restoration and conservation of the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00They also all concurred that her level of intervention of in-painting was a direct and appropriate response to the amount of loss the painting had experienced over time. Modestini was just doing the job she was hired to do. Despite all of the criticism that she has received, Modestini is still 10 toes down for this painting being a fully original work by Leonardo. She has an entire damn website dedicated to the painting.
SPEAKER_00And she's not without cause. One of her reasons for believing that this is an autograph work is the presence of something called pentimenti, which in Italian literally translates to regrets or slightly more neutrally, second thoughts. In art historical terms, pentimenti refer to visual or physical evidence that a painter has left behind of alterations they made to the painting as they went.
SPEAKER_00These types of things are found by either studying the painting really closely, because you can sometimes actually see it on the surface of the painting, but more often than not by using x-rays and different kinds of light-based technologies. Yet another example of how you can't hide from science, no matter how hard you might try. Modestini was elated to find various pentimenti on the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00For example, whoever painted it had completed the blessing hand but went back in and repainted the fingers to be in a slightly different pose. There are a few other instances of these kinds of changes. If the painting were a copy, the creator would have been working from a model and therefore had fewer things to figure out, and hypothetically would make fewer mistakes that would need resolving.
SPEAKER_00She was convinced that these pentimenti were yet another piece of proof that this painting, the Salvatore Mundi, was in fact a lost Leonardo. Others are not convinced, and have brushed this off and pointed out that there are plenty of paintings out there that are copies of other paintings that have pentimenti. Maybe the first time an artist painted a hand, they didn't like it or thought they could do better, or realized they had deviated too far from the original.
SPEAKER_00Basically, while pentimenti are obviously more common in original works, they aren't shocking to find in copies. Apart from Pentimenti, what are the other reasons people have for thinking that this work is by Leonardo da Vinci? One thing that you never stop hearing about is that there are some beautifully painted passages that outshine the rest of the work, such as the blessing hand. The hair and the lips also get mentioned quite a bit, but the blessing hand is the superstar of this work.
SPEAKER_00I've actually been getting a kick out of just how much people rhapsodize about the grace of the hand, and how whoever painted it clearly had a sophisticated understanding of how flesh sits atop bone. Oh, isn't it just wonderful? While I approach this all with a bit of a reverence, and I do genuinely think it's kind of ridiculous, I can also acknowledge that I have never seen this work in real life, which makes it really hard to comment on how well it's painted.
SPEAKER_00Even if I had seen the work in real life, I can usually tell you if something is poorly painted, but beyond that, to use my favorite German colloquialism, das ist mir wusst, it's all sausage to me. Now I'm not gonna go into this next part too much because it is a bit of a rabbit hole. But the pro-Leonardo crowd also tends to emphasize the rather unusual choice that whoever painted this made to show Christ in all blue.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. All blue. It is rather odd to see Christ in all one color, as he is typically shown in red and blue, a color scheme that symbolizes his dual nature as both man and divine. Now, a rational person might look at Christ in all blue and say, oh, the painter is showing Christ in all blue, the color most often associated with his divinity. And don't that make sense? Because the Salvatore Mundi emphasizes Christ as a savior of the world.
SPEAKER_00Those who believe the painting is by Leonardo da Vinci, however, attach more meaning to this all blue robe. If, if, if the painting is by Leonardo da Vinci, it is safe to assume that it was commissioned by someone important, because our buddy, Leo DeVee, was not the kind of guy who painted for funsies. He painted because someone important asked him to. That has led some people to assume that the rather unusual decision to put Christ in all blue is reflective of the person who commissioned the painting.
SPEAKER_00Who had an affinity for the color blue? The French, that's who. And not just the French, but French royalty. Ergo, therefore, according to this particular logic spiral, the all blue factor of the Salvatore Mundi might suggest that the painting was commissioned by or for King Louis XII, or potentially his son, King Francis I, both of whom were the kings of the French.
SPEAKER_00While I follow what they're saying, it does feel very similar to when I follow the quote-unquote logic of a movie or book like the Da Vinci Code, or probably more accurately, a movie like National Treasure, starring, of course, Nicolas Cage. Now, if this were a movie or a book, I would be totally on board with the blue as a clue thing. But this is not a movie or a book. Sometimes the color blue is just the color blue, and not an indication that Leonardo da Vinci painted a painting for the King of France.
SPEAKER_00I can understand all of those reasons for thinking this painting is by Leonardo. I do question the premise of some of them, but at least someone can say, oh yeah, I think it's by him because look how beautiful this lip is painted. A little weird, but sure. One bit of evidence for those of you who can't see me, which is, I hope, everyone, I'm doing air quotes around the mic there. Bit of evidence that comes up often that I cannot stand is I can just feel it.
SPEAKER_00Other versions of this are things like, oh, it's transcendent. It vibrates, it's like a spiritual experience. My favorite description of this feeling comes from the esteemed art historian Martin Kemp, who will forever be a genuine superstar in my eyes after appearing in Kunk on Earth. If you know, you know. Martin Kemp, who I will reference frequently from here on out, is one of the absolute top scholars on Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00And he talks about how when he looks at the Salvatore Mundi, he feels the zing, by which he means that he has an intuitive response that, among other less woo-woo reasons, leads him to believe the painting is by Leonardo. And this man is an expert on Leonardo. He has dedicated his entire life to studying the man, the myth, the ninja turtle. If Martin Kemp feels the zing, he feels the zing.
SPEAKER_00But I, Lindsay, hello, will not be accepting zing as evidence. Unless, of course, I feel the zing, in which case I am fully willing to be a hypocrite. I will also acknowledge that I do believe in zing. I believe in having an emotional reaction that cannot be put into words. But I will not be accepting it as evidence. I won't do it. There have also been tests done that have shown that the materials and techniques used to create the Salvatore Mundi from the walnut panel and how it was prepared to the types of pigments used to make the painting all align with those that were in active use in Leonardo's studio.
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately for those in the pro-Leonardo camp, all of those materials and techniques were also being practiced by his assistants. It is also so much more likely that an assistant would have been assigned such a gnarly walnut panel, which remember has a huge knot in it, than Leonardo selecting it himself. That would be like a famous race car driver choosing a car with a flat tire. Could it happen? Sure, I guess.
SPEAKER_00But it would also be a pretty stupid choice. Similarly, people's opinions about the technical aspects of the painting also hugely vary. There are lots of very smart, accomplished art historians out there who do not think that the upper lip of the Salvatore Mundi is the greatest upper lip to ever upper lip. Then again, how do you explain the oh my god, it's so incredible passages like the hand people are always frothing at the mouth over.
SPEAKER_00Easy peasy. The painting is by an assistant, but Leonardo stepped in as needed. Much like if the famous race car driver stepped in to parallel park the car with the busted tire. Yes, I realize this metaphor is terrible, and that I know literally nothing about race car driving or parallel parking, but this is how I think these things through in my head. Then there's those who feel what I will call the anti-zing, several of whom talk about the painting as if it's the art historical equivalent of a dead fish.
SPEAKER_00Now, for the record, I also will not be accepting anti-zing as evidence that the painting is not by Leonardo. I am nothing if not equally disdainful of all gut feelings being held up as something like fact. That might be your truth, but it doesn't make it the truth. A little dead fish-based wisdom for you there. There's also the fact that while the materials and techniques used in the painting might align with those we would expect Leonardo and his assistants to be using, there are also quite a few things about the painting that do not align with what we know about how Leonardo approached painting, some of which are explained away more easily than others.
SPEAKER_00For one, we know that Leonardo did not like to show figures straight on or in profile. His figures are typically partially angled, which makes for a more interesting interplay of volume and shadow. Christ in the Salvatore Mundi is about as head-on and frontal as you can get, which for Leonardo was quite unusual. It is not, however, a smoking gun against Leonardo's authorship. Like the choice to go with an all-blue robe, the decision to show Christ head-on might be a situation in which subject took precedence over style, because the very frontal, head-on depiction of Christ often alludes to the Veil of Veronica, which in Christian tradition is a miraculous image of Christ that appeared on a cloth when a woman named Veronica swabbed his face with it in the lead up to his crucifixion.
SPEAKER_00I think I talk a little bit about the Veil of Veronica in the Shroud of Turin episode, though I can't be sure as I have not listened to that episode in quite a few years. It is at the top of my brain, however, because several people, uh, weirdly enough, like I suddenly you'll just get a bunch of emails about one thing that happened seven or eight years ago, which I really appreciate. It's just interesting how it happens. But the most recent flurry of messages that I've gotten has been related to the Shroud of Turn episode, in which I misidentified the separate cana as being the event where Christ multiplied fish, when actually that's the event at which Christ turned water into wine.
SPEAKER_00And if we're being honest, that's a pretty on-brand mistake for me because fish, no thanks. Wine? Yes, please. I was also recently at the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, and the Vale of Veronica is flipping everywhere in the galleries that feature art from like 1100 to 1600. It was everywhere I looked, and it felt a little bit like a haunting. But it demonstrated the kind of iconic nature of the Vale of Veronica and the fact that virtually all viewers would have known what it was if it appeared in a painting.
SPEAKER_00To be crystal orb clear, the Salvatore Mundi is not a depiction of the Veil of Veronica, but one could argue, and people have, that it borrows the iconography, there's that pesky word again, the iconography of the Ve of Veronica and showing Christ very frontally, to make an association with that miraculous image and all of the spiritual and emotional cachet, if you will, that it carries. That's all to say.
SPEAKER_00There might be a reason why whoever painted this, if it was in fact Leonardo, would have set aside his stylistic preference for showing figures at an angle for this more frontal depiction of Christ. There are, however, other aspects of the painting that diverge from what we know about Leonardo's approach to his art that are less easily explained. The chief example of which is the crystal orb that Christ holds in his hand.
SPEAKER_00This crystal orb does not interact with light in the way we would observe in the natural world. The light and how it hits whatever's behind the orb should be more distorted. And that's a red flag against this painting being by Leonardo, because he was an absolute fiend for this kind of stuff. And from everything that we know about him, he would have valued capturing those effects as accurately as possible in a painting. That's not happening here.
SPEAKER_00Some people, like Martin Kemp, have tried to frame this as yet another subject over style explanation, but it does seem like quite the reach. These are things that Leonardo really cared about. And if he's making concessions in other areas of the painting, like the pose of Christ, he's probably not going to make them in other areas of the painting that his patron probably wouldn't have cared about or registered, like light passing through a crystal orb. There are a couple of other instances of things not being accurate, uh, akin to the orb and light, like the anatomy of the fingers somehow, uh, or the way that the tendrils of hair tend to curl.
SPEAKER_00But I admittedly did not delve too deeply into those fingery, tendrilly weeds. They do, however, exist. So you have your pro-Leonardo people, you have your anti-Leonardo people, as in, they're not anti-Leonardo, but they're anti-the Salvatore Mundi being by Leonardo, and then you got the people in the middle, who say that most of the painting is probably not by Leonardo, but rather a workshop production primarily made by an apprentice or an assistant, with some touches by Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00The very frustrating and sometimes uncomfortable truth of this whole thing is that we don't know who painted the Work, and we will probably never have definitive proof. The decision then becomes which side you gravitate towards. Is it a Leonardo until proven not? Or is it a workshop production until proven otherwise? When it comes to research, I personally almost always choose the option that leaves the greater grace for me getting something wrong. Especially if me giving something wrong costs Russian or Saudi billionaires hundreds of millions of dollars.
SPEAKER_00Not because I care about their bank accounts, but because I'm fond of living my life with all my limbs intact. Thank you very much. Then again, I also won't want to be the person who sold a painting for$300,000 when it was actually worth$300 million. Ooh. I mean, to be perfectly honest, I'm just happy to be here judging people in retrospect because all of this sounds very stressful. When it comes to the autograph status of the painting, there are quite a few well-respected art historians who have joined Kemp, Modestini, Simon, Parrish, etc., in believing that the painting is by Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00One of the painting's earliest champions was Luke Syson, a curator specializing in Italian painting who has worked at some of the most prestigious museums in the entire world, including the National Gallery of Arts in London, an institution that has a significant role to play in this story. After Modestini's first restoration of the work, Parrish and Simon started to show the work to select museums and individuals in the field of art history.
SPEAKER_00That included Sison, who traveled from London to New York to see the work. He examined it at a conservation studio at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Fancy. This was not the painting's first visit to the Met. Parrish and Simon had already shown it to a group of Met curators and conservators, and while Simon later claimed that the majority of Met staff who saw the painting agreed it was by Leonardo, there have been people who have disagreed with that particular version of events, something that happens quite commonly throughout this story.
SPEAKER_00Even so, the Met was clearly happy to host the painting and Sisen for his first look at the work. Sison later recalled that the painting, quote unquote, felt extraordinarily right and, quote, seemed to hover somewhere between our realm and something supernatural. End quote. To put it more succinctly, Homie felt the zing.
SPEAKER_00Sison knew his stuff and had been spending an awful lot of time looking at paintings by Leonardo. He just so happened to be preparing a massively hyped Leonardo exhibition at the National Gallery in London. It was going to include some seriously big loans, including several Leonardo paintings from the Louvre, Mona Lisa not included, and works from the personal collection of Queen Elizabeth II.
SPEAKER_00One thing that would guarantee that the exhibition would achieve true blockbuster status would be to include a newly discovered Leonardo painting, especially one that had been authenticated by experts in the field. Sison put out the Bat Call, and he gathered an intimate group of art historians in London to examine the Salvatore Mundi. Ben Lewis actually starts his book with the story of Robert Simon flying to London with the painting as his carry-on item.
SPEAKER_00That is the stuff of my nightmares. In addition to Sison, five other people attended the meeting, all of whom were experts on Leonardo. There was, of course, Martin Kemp, who was joined by Pietro Morani, Maria Terese Fiorio, Carmen Bombach, and David Allen Brown. The meeting and examination happened behind closed doors, if not among friends, then certainly amongst professionals, very few of whom have spilled the beans on what went on and what was said.
SPEAKER_00From what has emerged, it's safe to say that different people had different perspectives on the outcomes of that conversation. Sison later said that all five art historians agreed that the painting was by Leonardo, or rather, quote, pretty much unanimous agreement. Robert Simon took a similar approach, saying there was, quote unquote, unequivocal consensus on the work's authorship.
SPEAKER_00The truth, however, seems more complicated, isn't it always? Three of the five art historians present for that London meeting disagreed with how Sison and Simon characterized their opinions. One even said that she had not been asked to give an opinion and therefore had not. Another claimed that he said something like, Yes, maybe it is by Leonardo, but he refused to give a firmer answer.
SPEAKER_00Of all of those present, Carmen Bombach has given stronger pushback to being looped into this so-called unanimous consensus. She has also made it clear that she did not appreciate the hastiness with which the Salvatore Mundi hype train was moving. She even got a little spicy, woman after my own heart, by suggesting that some of the people involved might be more interested in the fame and renown that could come with discovering a lost masterpiece rather than fully authenticating the painting.
SPEAKER_00A few years after that, she wrote in an article that she suspected the majority of the painting was in fact by Leonardo's pupils, and that the master may have lent his hands to certain passages. That was as close to a quote-unquote authentication that she was willing to get. Not exactly a ringing endorsement. In late 2011, the National Gallery of Art opened the hotly anticipated exhibition Leonardo da Vinci, painter at the Court of Milan.
SPEAKER_00It featured dozens of paintings and drawings by Leonardo, including a lost masterpiece that for the first time ever was being revealed to the public, which was none other than the Salvatore Mundi, obviously. To say that the National Gallery was 10 toes down for this painting being by Leonardo is somewhat of an understatement. Because everything in this exhibition, from the wall label to the handout that people got when they entered to the catalog for sale, paints the Salvatore Mundi as an unquestioned work by Leonardo da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00This was a bold move that surprised a lot of people. Because typically, typically, when authorship of a painting isn't firmly established, a museum or exhibition will acknowledge that fact by putting something like attributed to Leonardo da Vinci. Or even Leonardo da Vinci, parentheses, question mark. But Luke Sison was calling the shots, and he chose not to do that.
SPEAKER_00Instead, the painting was characterized as a full-blown, unquestioned Leonardo. He was, of course, questioned about this decision. And Hibole were his answers interesting. He claimed that in not putting attributed to or signaling in any way that there was doubt about this attribution, that he was simply making a proposal with quote, some degree of scholarly imp, end quote.
SPEAKER_00In other words, Sison knew that the painting's attribution was in question, and he chose not to acknowledge that. I appreciate someone sticking to their scholarly guns, but Sison's decision seems to go beyond that. Acknowledging uncertainty encourages debate, and that was not something he wanted to do. There's also the fact that the vast majority of people going to see this show are not going to question what they're being told by the National Gallery of Art.
SPEAKER_00They are not even aware that they should be suspicious. Because why would the National Gallery of Art be telling me something that might not be true? Ha, museums do that all of the time. It's not always malicious. Like they're not always trying to bamboozle you, but people are going to react to a Leonardo da Vinci differently than they will to something attributed to Leonardo da Vinci. That is not a commentary on how visitors don't get it or are stupid and don't know to ask the right questions.
SPEAKER_00Like, none of that. None of that. But rather that we are socially conditioned and culturally conditioned to react in these different ways. With this exhibition and featuring the Salvatore Mundi in it without any kind of acknowledgement that it might not actually be by Leonardo, Sison was making some choices. To be somewhat charitable to him, you don't do anything in a museum without the board's approval. Especially not the National Gallery of Art in London.
SPEAKER_00You wish. That is not to absolve him of that decision, but rather to say that there are lots of people who are doing an ethically dubious thing here, all in the name of displaying a so-called lost Leonardo. Like anything related to the Salvatore Mundi, the public and art critics alike had very polarizing reactions to seeing the Salvatore Mundi in this exhibition. One of my favorite reviews was by Guardian writer and award-winning art critic Laura Cumming, who described the painting as monstrously hard to admire.
SPEAKER_00She says that Christ looks narcotized, aka high, which is appropriate given that the hand he holds up in a blessing might as well be, quote, fingers holding an invisible joint. Leonardo scholar Frank Zellner, who was very strangely and undoubtedly deliberately not invited to the viewing party a few years earlier, took a somewhat kinder approach in expressing his reservations.
SPEAKER_00He said that the painting has been known to art historians since the start of the 20th century, but that it's remained out of sight before facing and undergoing restoration in the past few years. In other words, people have known about this painting for a long time, and only just recently has there been hype. He also acknowledges that many experts believe the painting is by Leonardo and says it is of a far higher quality than some of the other works that people have attempted to attribute to the master in recent times.
SPEAKER_00But he finishes his article by suggesting that the work is likely a high-quality product of Leonardo's studio, potentially with the involvement of the master, or potentially not. As with someone like Carmen Bombach, Zellner's main issue seems to be how quickly the matter of attribution progressed. The painting had only just been discovered, at least sort of publicly, in 2005.
SPEAKER_00And now, less than 10 years later, it was being exhibited at one of the greatest art museums in the world as a full-blown lost masterpiece by one of the greatest artists to ever live. That is quite the glow-up. Zellner goes on to acknowledge that the world of art history can be quite fickle with regards to things like attribution. In a few years' time, it might seem insane that we ever doubted that the Salvatore Mundi was in fact by Leonardo da Vinci, but that it was just as likely, if not more likely, is the subtext of his uh article, is the potential that we would also be shaking our heads, wondering what the heck we were all thinking.
SPEAKER_00It has now been 15 years since that exhibition, and in many ways, Zellner was right. We are absolutely still shaking our heads, but not necessarily with regards to the attribution of the painting to Leonardo, which is still hotly contested. We are instead shaking our heads at what happened next. In addition to the bold choice to fully say that this is a work by Leonardo da Vinci, the London exhibition featured two other inaccuracies, or at the very least, half truths.
SPEAKER_00The first was printed out in black and white in the exhibition's catalog, on the wall label, and in the exhibition handout. In those kinds of documents, it's common to list where a painting has come from, especially if it is on loan for the exhibition. For this show, all of those documents listed the Salvatore Mundi as being in a private collection. That is, at best, a white lie.
SPEAKER_00By the time the painting was featured in the exhibition, Simon, Parrish, and a third individual co-owned the work. But they were not art collectors, they were art dealers. That brings us to the second half-truth. Nowhere in the exhibition was there any mention that the Salvatore Mundi was up for sale. At one point, Sison even talked to the press and explicitly stated that it wasn't.
SPEAKER_00We now know that that wasn't true. The owners of the Salvatore Mundi were all desperate to sell it, all the more so because it was proving to be quite the money pit into which they were investing exponentially more than they had paid, which I grant you is not that difficult given that they barely paid$1,000 for it. But now they had a Leonardo on their hands, and that is quite a bit more expensive to maintain, much less insure.
SPEAKER_00It is quite controversial to have for sale works featured in museum exhibitions, especially those at public museums, which are funded by taxpayers. This is not a legal thing, it is a moral and ethical thing that comes down to maintaining public trust. Showing a work that is for sale, particularly in an exhibition of this magnitude, creates a conflict of interest for all involved.
SPEAKER_00Not least of all because the exhibition becomes an important marketing tool to drive up the cost of the work. All of that marketing is being paid for by taxpayers, or, you know, at least in part by taxpayers, but it is the private owners who are going to see the return on investment. It is not a great look for a museum to be a part of that. At the same time, I don't want to clutch my pearls too tightly, given that of all of the ethical quibbles that come up during this episode, the National Gallery of Art showing a for sale work is the least of our worries.
SPEAKER_00There's also nothing that stops private collectors from loaning a work, allowing it to soak up the prestige of being in a big exhibition and then turning around and selling it. But at least in that situation, the museum can claim ignorance. In the case of the Salvatore Mundi, though, everyone involved must have known that the work was absolutely for sale and that the National Gallery of Art show would lend it a legitimacy that it might not otherwise have, thereby skyrocketing its monetary value.
SPEAKER_00Ethically speaking, a public institution should not want to be a part of that. Once the exhibition was over, Simon Parrish and their other co-owner, whose name was Warren Adelson, threw themselves into trying to capitalize on the momentum of the exhibition to get rid of the painting for as much money possible. Unfortunately, they had no buyers, which is kind of ridiculous.
SPEAKER_00How could there be no buyers for a newly discovered masterpiece by one of the greatest artists in all of time and space? It doesn't make any sense. That is, if you believe the narrative that they have been spinning, which a lot of people didn't. While there were a few curators who were interested, curators don't hold the purse strings. And none of them could get the museum's board of trustees or the board of directors to crack open the institutional wallet.
SPEAKER_00There were a number of reasons why no person or museum would want to touch this painting with a 10-foot pole, or more accurately, why a museum board of directors would never approve the purchase. The most obvious reason that the painting wasn't selling was the price tag. Simon Parrish and Adelson wanted stupid money for the work. Something like$200 million for it.
SPEAKER_00Very few museums have that kind of money to drop on a painting. Much less a painting that is absolutely not a masterpiece, no matter how many people and companies try to convince us that it is. That has nothing to do with whether or not you believe the work is by Leonardo. Maybe it was a masterpiece once upon a time, but in the year of our Lord and Savior Rick Steves 2013, the Salvatore Mundi was a very damaged painting that had been extensively restored.
SPEAKER_00To add insult to injury, everyone in the world of art history knew that there were questions about the work's provenance and attribution. Whatever way you looked at it, the Salvatore Mundi was not a good investment. As a result, it sat in a storage facility for months on end while Simon, Parrish, and Adelson began to panic. Enter stage right, Dmitry Rybolovlev, and his maybe agent, maybe dealer, definite frenemy, even if he doesn't know it yet, Yves Bouvier.
SPEAKER_00You heard about these two crazy cats at the top of the episode, and I'm excited to tell you more about them because this is the part of the story that I find the most incredible. And it doesn't really even have anything to do with Leonardo da Vinci and everything to do with rich people shenanigans. Dmitry Rybolovlev is your quintessential Russian oligarch, meaning that he is uber wealthy and is not a stranger to having politicians in his pocket.
SPEAKER_00Side note the surname Rybolovlev, or as the Russians I've heard say it, Rybolovlev, sounds and feels on the lips a little bit like gibberish, but it is the man's actual name. Ribolovlev. Oh, Ribolovlev? I'm just kidding. Ribolovlev is a billionaire who made the vast majority of his riches by forging a monopoly on potash mining in Russia in the late 90s and early 2000s.
SPEAKER_00Pot ash is a potassium-based mineral that is incredibly important to manufacturing agricultural fertilizers, which is why Rybolovlev is sometimes referred to as the fertilizer king. It's a fitting, if not slightly silly, title, because at the height of his wealth in the late 2000s, Rybolovlev was among the top 10 richest people in Russia, and within the top 60 richest people in the world.
SPEAKER_00You don't get that rich by being a good man and an ethical business person. You get that rich by being ruthless and careful about it. Something that usually includes paying off politicians and other people who make the rules, which is exactly what Rybolovlev did. He even spent time in a Russian prison in the 90s for allegedly, again, allegedly, ordering the assassination of a business partner, though he was later acquitted of that.
SPEAKER_00Rybolovlev and his mining company have also been accused of negligence, that, again, allegedly, caused mines to collapse and sinkholes to appear in one of the mining towns that he basically owned in the Ural Mountains. An inquest into this city starting to, you know, fall into the ground did absolve Ribolovlev and his company of wrongdoing.
SPEAKER_00But there is a distinct possibility that the inquest was in part funded by one of Ribolovlev's affiliate companies, which is a conflict of interest that makes the National Gallery of Art putting a for-sale painting on display seem like very small potatoes. Long story short, Rybolovlev makes billions of dollars from potash mining, though he probably does so at the expense of thousands of people.
SPEAKER_00Our fertilizer king does what you should do when you make billions of dollars, and he invests that money. But not just in the stock market or his many residences in various European tax havens. He also starts to buy art. That is billionaire 101, because art rarely depreciates in value, which makes it a very stable investment, though all investments do come with at least some risk.
SPEAKER_00Buying art and starting a collection are also ways of establishing oneself in the eyes of others, financially, socially, culturally, and in matters of taste, which is something that money can't always buy. Now it's important to say out loud that seeing art as an investment and making very strategic choices about what you're buying doesn't necessarily mean that you don't appreciate art or that you only see it as basically a fancy stock option.
SPEAKER_00There are lots of people out there who rejoice in their art collections and who buy art first and foremost because they like it. There's also an uncomfortable middle ground of people who don't really care or care secondarily about the art, but who care a lot about owning something that other people want. This is not a new phenomenon. It goes back hundreds, if not thousands, of years.
SPEAKER_00And it's a sentiment that is going to come up a lot in the next portion of the episode. From what little he has said about it, Rebolovlev started collecting art both as an investment, but also because he wanted to and he could. One of the reasons that he is given is actually quite funny yet practical, in that he talks about how the house he and his wife moved into in Monaco in I think the late 90s, early, early 2000s, had previously been owned by someone who was an art collector, and therefore there was already ample lighting fixtures in place specifically designed to display art.
SPEAKER_00What is a billionaire to do? Not use the fancy lighting fixtures? Heck no. They're gonna go out and buy art. Over time, Rybolovlev's rationale for collecting art would evolve. By the later 2000s, he was facing a looming divorce and wanted to hide his assets. This is a classic move. But no matter how many times I have heard of this being a thing, I am not financially savvy enough to understand how buying art factors into it.
SPEAKER_00But that's a bridge I will cross when I'm a billionaire facing an imminent divorce, which gives me at least three to five years to figure it out. When it came to investing in art, whatever his motivations were to do so, Rebelovlev was not messing around. In just over 10 years, he spent approximately$2 billion establishing an art collection that included works by some of the greatest artists of all time, with a clear preference for 19th and 20th century paintings.
SPEAKER_00Ooh, paintings. It's a hard word to say when your tongue can't reach the top of your mouth, which is just perfect for a podcast about a painting. But I digress. Rybolovlev purchased his first major artwork in 2002. By that time, he had essentially left Russia in favor of tax havens like Monaco and Switzerland. In 2002, he purchased the Great Circus by Mark Shigal for about$20 million, something facilitated by his dentist's wife, who was a Swiss socialite who knew a lot about art.
SPEAKER_00Once that sale happened, again, facilitated by his dentist's wife, because why not? The Shigal painting was sent to Geneva, where it was held at the Geneva Freeport. If you were like me and have no idea about any of this stuff, Freeports are massive warehouse-like buildings that act as a tax-free storage facility and customs house for luxury goods.
SPEAKER_00If you are ever bored, Google Freeports, specifically the Geneva Freeport, and prepare to have your mind boggled and your faith in the world just a little bit more eroded. It was at the Geneva Freeport that Ribolovlev first met Yves Bouvier, a Swiss businessman who specialized in the storage and transport of luxury goods, namely art. Over the course of his business, he naturally developed an interest in and an eye for art, which naturally led to him advising people on their art purchases.
SPEAKER_00All the better if they needed someone to ship and store it. Bouvier also benefited from being in direct contact with a lot of very wealthy people with absolutely insane art collections, including items that he was storing for them. With that kind of insider knowledge, he often knew ahead of time what works might be coming up for sale. For someone like Rybolovlev, who wanted to build an epic art collection, Bouvier seemed like the perfect ally.
SPEAKER_00And for someone like Bouvier, Rybolovlev seemed like the perfect mark. According to Ben Lewis's book, after that first meeting in Geneva, the two agreed that Bouvier would help Rybolovlev establish his art collection. The deal was that Bouvier would find and buy the art, then sell it to Ribolovlev with a 2% markup, with the 2% acting as his commission.
SPEAKER_00At least that's how Ribolovlev saw their agreement. Over the course of about a decade, the two worked together to build an epic collection that was the art market equivalent of a now that's what I call music CD. For anyone born after 1995-ish, now that's what I call music CDs were compilations of the greatest hits of the day. And not to brag, but I did own several. Ribolovlev collected works of art by Picasso, Dugas, Gaugan, Klimt, Modogliani, Rothko, Monet, Van Gogh, Renoir.
SPEAKER_00I could go on. Needless to say, if art was an investment, he was buying the hottest stock options of the early 2000s. In the name of diverse interests, he also bought the soccer team AC Monaco, of which he is still the president, though, as far as I know, Bouvier had nothing to do with that. He did, however, have something to do with Ribolovlev buying the Salvatore Mundi in 2013. At this point, Robert Simon, Alexander Parish, and Warren Adelson had owned the painting for roughly eight years.
SPEAKER_00Adelson having come in partway through that. As I've said, they were desperate to sell the work, but were having trouble finding a viable buyer. Much less those that were willing to pay hundreds of millions of dollars for something so highly damaged, even if it might not look that way to the naked eye. Working with Sudbeys, a famous auction house, Simon, Parrish, and Adelson started to cast their nets a bit wider, and they had Sudbeys reach out to private buyers who might be interested.
SPEAKER_00Ribolovlev was among their ranks. He claims that he was intrigued by the painting, and he let his main art man Bouvier know that he was seriously considering buying it. To his credit, a little dig that'll make sense in a few minutes, Bouvier told Ribolovlev that he should absolutely, under no circumstances, buy the Salvatore Mundi, and that if he did, he would be the laughing stock of the art market.
SPEAKER_00When speaking to Ben Lewis, Bouvier explained that he didn't have doubts about the painting's attribution to Leonardo, but he had seen all of the documentation regarding its extensive restoration, and because of that, determined that the painting was not worth the$190 million estimate that Ribolovlev had been quoted. Of course, Bouvier said that he would certainly help Rybolovlev acquire the work, but that unlike all of the other works in his collection, the Salvatore Mundi would be a quote-unquote decorative purchase rather than a secure investment.
SPEAKER_00Ribolovlev was the one who insisted on forging onward, saying, quote, I couldn't get rid of the feeling that there was something special about this Da Vinci. The last Da Vinci. That, my friends, is what led to a private viewing of the painting that Bouvier arranged with Sudby's, not to take place on neutral ground, but rather in the penthouse apartment of 15 Central Park West, which on paper was owned by Rebelovlev's daughter.
SPEAKER_00In fact, he had purchased most of his art collection using trusts established in his daughter's names, which was probably the result of very good but ethically insane financial advising. Again, I don't understand it. It was in that penthouse apartment that Bouvier and Rebelovlev were brought face to face with the quote unquote last Leonardo. Rebolovlev described the encounter to Lewis.
SPEAKER_00Quote, I felt a very special, bright, positive energy. It was a remarkable feeling. I couldn't take my eyes off the Christ. End quote. Now, none of this was being said during the viewing itself, because at no point did Bouvier and Rybolovlev ever speak a common language unless you're including the language of money. If they were together, there was either always someone translating, or in a situation where they were alone, Presumably a lot of silence and presumably miming.
SPEAKER_00Maybe with some caveman-level verbal communication thrown into the mix. After viewing the painting, Ribolovlev decided that he wanted the last Leonardo, so-called, because if the Salvatore Mundi was in fact an authentic Leonardo, this kind of thing would not happen again. Not just in our lifetimes, but potentially ever. Bouvier assured Ribolovlev that he would get him a good deal for the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00And he did. Instead of the original$190 million quote, Ribolovlev ended up paying just$127.5 million. That's like 30% off. It's the billionaire equivalent of a good Michaels coupon. Just like that, the Salvatore Mundi had a new owner, and Simon, Parrish, and Adelson each walked away with about$20 million, some of which they used to pay Diane Modestini for her indispensable restoration services.
SPEAKER_00As to what they actually paid her, Modestini has never specified, though she had said that they were generous. I want to know, if for no other reason that I just happened to be very Snoopy. And thus everyone involved in the story lived happily ever after.
unknownHa ha ha!
SPEAKER_00Just kidding. Like hell they did. This is actually where the story becomes truly unhinged. And that's saying something. Because this whole thing is nuttier than the pink-stuffed showgirl squirrels that I recently bought at TJ Maxx. True story. About six months later, Reba Lovelev was celebrating the holidays like any billionaire would. Hanging out on a beach in St.
SPEAKER_00Bart's. Also hanging out on the same beach was art advisor Extraordinaire Sanford Sandy Heller. When I say extraordinaire, I mean it. Heller's clients include Steve Cohen, the owner of Damian Hearst's infamous shark-based work, The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living. See episode 40 for more on that. Rebolovlev and Heller get to talking, specifically about a painting that Rebolovlev had purchased from Cohen, with Bouvier working as the middleman.
SPEAKER_00Now I don't know how exactly it came up. Maybe billionaires and the people who work with them just talk about money more openly than your average person. But it was over the course of this conversation that Rebolovlev realized there was a$20 million discrepancy between what Cohen had sold the work for and what Rebolovlev had purchased it for. In between those two things was Bouvier, whose standard operating procedure was to buy the work himself and then turn around and immediately sell it to Ribolovlev with a 2% markup.
SPEAKER_00According to Ribolovlev, that was what they had agreed upon when they first started working together. Ribolovlev's reaction to learning about this$20 million discrepancy must have been something to behold, because in his words, his dinner companions, Heller among them, quote, thought I was having a stroke, end quote. He did not immediately pounce on this new information, though he did invite Heller to see his collection and had him give his opinions on what each work was worth.
SPEAKER_00And what Rybolovlev heard was not good. If he almost had a stroke in St. Bart's, you can only imagine how crappy he felt learning that he had paid hundreds of millions of dollars more than his collection was ultimately worth. If Rybolovlev needed any further confirmation of how badly he had been played, in late 2014, he read an article that had been published about six months earlier in the New York Times.
SPEAKER_00That article was by Scott Rayburn. And Rayburn mentions that the Salvatore Mundi sold the year before to a private collector for between$75 and$80 million, constituting a 50% reduction of the original$200 million asking price. But Rybolovlev had paid$127.5 million. The math ain't mathin'.
SPEAKER_00In reaction to this extremely upsetting realization, Rybolovlev does the obvious. He lures Bouvier to Monaco under false pretenses and has him ambushed by a dozen armed men who then take him to prison and interrogate him for three days before being released on 3 million euro bail. For good measure, Rybolovlev also had his dentist's wife, the person who introduced him to Bouvier, arrested as well.
SPEAKER_00That was all just the beginning. In the years to come, Rybolovlev attempts to sue the beans out of Bouvier, his dentist's wife, and many others in multiple jurisdictions from the US to Singapore. He's taken this legal battle worldwide. In these legal battles, as well as in the press, Ribolovlev accuses Bouvier of committing the greatest art fraud in history by buying works for one price and immediately selling them to Ribolovlev for another much higher price.
SPEAKER_00A scheme that, over the course of 10 plus years, would have made Bouvier about$1 billion in fraudulent profits. Ribolovlev also sued Sudbees, who he believed were in cahoots with Bouvier, specifically around the sale of the Salvatore Mundi. Essentially, he claims that Sudbeys knew what was going on and did nothing to stop it. The whole thing quickly becomes known as the Bouvier Affair, which I grant you sounds much sexier than the Ribolovlev affair.
SPEAKER_00That's good branding. Ribolovlev spends the next decade in legal battles with Bouvier, Sudbeys, and various. Other parties, resulting in a veritable crap ton of legal documents that I read with glee, including caches of very juicy emails. The long story short of it all is that in the end, Ribolovlev either lost or had to drop the majority of the cases that he brought against Bouvier and Sudbeys all over the world.
SPEAKER_00Things were much more complex and messy than that all suggests, but that's the gist. However, after reading those aforementioned very juicy emails, I personally believe that Bouvier and Sudbeys were both acting super shady. One woman's opinion. Thankfully for them, shadiness and ethical misdealings are not necessarily illegal.
SPEAKER_00Now you're probably thinking, or maybe not, I don't know. I was certainly thinking, how in the world did Bouvier think that he could get away with this? It's pretty obvious that he knew exactly what he was doing and that it was not in any way, shape, or form ethical. But surprise, surprise, Russian billionaires and Swiss business moguls don't have much interest in ethical dealings.
SPEAKER_00They have an interest in money. And Bouvier was making stacks on stacks on stacks of money by capitalizing on Ribolovlev's naivety when it comes to the business of art. Bouvier had assumed, quite logically, that Ribolovlev would never openly talk about how much he was paying for said art, because one of the main reasons he was buying it, allegedly, was to hide his assets.
SPEAKER_00You can't go around willy-nilly telling people what you paid for a Leonardo and a Renoir and a Modigliani and a Picasso if you're trying to hide your assets. Rest assured that while Ribolovlev's court claims never seemed to go anywhere, Bouvier did get some form of comeuppance in that his business tanked and no one wanted to work with him because he's a rat. There were also former clients of his that were looking into whether he did the same to them.
SPEAKER_00Perhaps worst of all for him was the fact that there were a bunch of splinter lawsuits and investigations related to the so-called Bouvier affair, into things like money laundering, the handling of stolen goods, fraud, etc. And as of 2026, some of those lawsuits are still ongoing. As for Ribolovlev, this whole ordeal was deeply humiliating on many different levels.
SPEAKER_00To his credit, which is not something I offer Russian billionaires very often, he was remarkably open with just how badly he had been manipulated. Oftentimes, people who are taken advantage of in that way don't take action, because taking action requires you to admit that you got scammed. From what little Ribolovlev has said about all of this, it seems like destroying Bouvier's reputation was more important to him than the world knowing he'd been a sucker, which is a level of spite that I very much appreciate.
SPEAKER_00But this all leaves Ribolovlev with a really big problem. He had just built a$2 billion art collection full of paintings that he had overpaid for by millions, if not tens of millions, of dollars. If and when he chose to sell many of them, it was going to result in significant losses, which is exactly what art is supposed to protect you against.
SPEAKER_00In theory, the hardest work in his collection to sell should have been the Salvatore Mundi, the very painting that Bouvier had told him not to buy in the first place, even calling it a decorative purchase. While buying the Salvatore Mundi in the first place, and the entire Bouvier affair left Ribolovlev publicly and personally humiliated, 'twas ultimately he who had the last laugh.
SPEAKER_00Ribolovlev's aim in selling the Salvatore Mundi was to recoup his losses as best as he could. Naturally, he hired an auction house to help him do so, but not Sudby's, which he absolutely hates. He instead hired Christie's, something that would prove to be one of the best investments he had ever made outside of potash mines. Christie's strategy for selling the Salvatore Mundi can be summed up in two words.
SPEAKER_00Epic marketing. The auction house spent millions of dollars on a global marketing campaign that included many exhibitions of the painting around the world, including stops in San Francisco, Tokyo, and London. Ben Lewis estimated that 27,000 people saw the painting during this whirlwind global tour. Christie's also invested in a short promotional film to, you know, promote the painting, and it is four minutes of pure marketing genius.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't even show you the painting itself. Instead, the entire video is shot from the perspective of just below the painting, thus capturing the expressions and reactions of the people seeing it. From babies to elderly women to world-renowned celebrities that include another famous Leonardo, this time DiCaprio. The expressions on these people's faces vary between pensive, wonderment, awe, and of course, straight up tears.
SPEAKER_00It is clear that every one of these people felt the zing. You can still watch that short film on Christie's YouTube channel. It bears the title The Last Da Vinci, Colonel The World is Watching. Ooh. Ahead of the auction, Christie's even printed a separate catalog featuring the Salvatore Mundi. Typically, there is a single catalog put out for each auction, but this painting merited its own publication.
SPEAKER_00And I cannot tell you the rage I felt reading some of these essays. They are alleging all sorts of things, including that the painting had been likely owned by no fewer than three kings. An assertion that I think is wildly unethical, as it paints ridiculously optimistic guesswork as something close to fact. I don't know what's worse. The repeated mentions of the Salvatore Mundi being the male Mona Lisa or the quote that begins the catalog: Beauty will save the world.
SPEAKER_00Those words are from Dostoevsky's 1869 novel The Idiot, which gave me quite the chuckle. I would guess that the people putting this catalog together didn't do a thorough textual analysis of the pages from whence that quote came. They are spoken by someone who is mocking the protagonist, the titular idiot, mocking his belief that beauty will save the world. Now, the entire book is more or less that the idiot is not, in fact, an idiot, but that somehow makes it all the more chilling because it suggests a deep, abiding belief that no matter what the haters say, beauty will save the world.
SPEAKER_00And if your wallet is deep enough, you have the opportunity to own and safeguard that beauty by bidding on this work at auction. Quite the sales pitch. While overzealous and a bit nauseating, a world tour, short film, an incredibly idealistic catalog all seem like logical marketing techniques that a global auction house might employ in order to sell an artwork that is allegedly by one of the greatest people to ever art.
SPEAKER_00What makes absolutely zero logical sense is the decision that Christie's made as to what auction the Salvatore Mundi would be a part of. Typically, auction houses divide things by category or time period or some other rational thematic thing. It usually at least makes sense. Christie's chose to include the Salvatore Mundi in the November 2017 Post-War and Contemporary Art Evening Sale.
SPEAKER_00I'll repeat that. Be post war, aka post nineteen forty five, and contemporary aka now art evening sale. That put the Salvatore Mundi in the mix with works by Andy Warhol, Cy Tuambly, Mark Rothko, Isama Noguchi, Alexander Calder, and other very famous artists who all lived at some point in the 20th century, a full 400 years after their fellow cohort member, Leonardo da Vinci.
SPEAKER_00It was the first time in the auction house's history that an old master painting had been included in such an auction. This decision was the brainchild of Loïc Gouzier, who was in charge of the post-war and contemporary art sector of Christie's. In short, Gusier's primary job, which he was very good at, was to sell artwork for the most money possible, full stop.
SPEAKER_00He saw an opportunity to do just that by including the Salvatore Mundi in this particular auction. His very flimsy rationale for doing this has to do with the work by Andy Warhol that was also up for sale in this auction. That was an homage to Leonardo's Last Supper. Ergo, therefore, it was totally appropriate and not at all sketchy as hell that they were including the Salvatore Mundi in this auction.
SPEAKER_00When asked about this decision, Gouzier said, quote, We felt that offering this painting within the context of our post-war and contemporary evening sale is a testament to the enduring relevance of this picture. End quote. Excuse me, huh? The enduring relevance of the Salvatore Mundi? A painting that emerged into the public barely a decade before this?
SPEAKER_00A painting whose first secure mention is 1900? It is a bizarro claim, and one that I would very much doubt that any art professional actually believes. If we are all being honest, which I believe in most of the time, the real rationale behind this nonsensical but brilliant scheme was the fact that the contemporary art market has been super hot since the mid-1900s.
SPEAKER_00It attracts more billionaires as bidders than any other kind of art. I don't fully understand why this is, and I'm sure it's quite complicated and more nuanced than I'm about to make it seem. But from what I have read, since the mid-1990s, contemporary art pieces have proven one of the most lucrative investments that someone can make. It is lucrative because its value appreciates much faster than most other things, including at times gold.
SPEAKER_00On the flip side, the market for old master paintings, so paintings from before roughly 1800 or so, that market was not doing well at all. It was more or less stagnant, and no one wants to buy into a stagnant market, least of all billionaires, who, whatever other flaws they might have, are usually very good with money stuff. The very hot market for contemporary art may have also been something of a self-fulfilling prophecy, if that's the right term, which I don't think it is, but go with it.
SPEAKER_00What I mean is that if the contemporary art market has been the hottest of the art markets for the past 30 years, anyone who has entered or emerged from the upper echelons of wealth during that time would naturally want to purchase the hottest thing on the market. Doing that was a way to show your status, your buying power, and your taste. The bottom line is that Christie's wanted to make the most money possible on the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00That meant putting it in the auction that was bound to attract the people with the most money, post-war and contemporary art. The grift was real, and it shall be rewarded. As this auction grew closer, the amount of bad press that the Salvator Mundi was receiving skyrocketed, with well-respected art historians and art critics coming out of the woodwork and saying, this is not a work by Leonardo, and even if it is, he was probably only responsible for a fraction of it.
SPEAKER_00And that doesn't really matter because the condition is so piss poor. There were even quote-unquote jokes about how the painting merited its inclusion in this post-war and contemporary auction, because the Salvatore Mundi, as we know it today, is primarily the work of Diane Modestini. For the record, that was other people saying that, not me. It is in this time frame that Modestini really gets thrown under the bus and is heavily critiqued, especially after she doubles down and tries to defend her work.
SPEAKER_00I honestly felt quite bad for her in the documentaries that I watched, despite my understanding of where certain critics are coming from. On the evening of November 15th, 2017, the Christie's Sale House in Rockefeller Center, New York City, was filled to the gills with some of the biggest muckity mucks in the world of art, as well as members of the public who just wanted to watch the show.
SPEAKER_00There were also dozens of people glued to their phones, many of whom were serving as representatives of people who could not attend, often very wealthy people who lived on other sides of the world. The Salvatore Mundi was lot 9b, and the starting bid was$75 million. One of the many things that I have learned over the course of making this episode is that with these very high-profile auctions and lots, auction houses built in safeguards to ensure that these very high-profile lots sell.
SPEAKER_00This is something in the auction world called a minimum guaranteed price. And it's set up in consultation with the current owner of the work to establish the lowest possible price that they would be willing to take to sell it. Christie's then goes out and finds someone who is willing to pay that price, if not go higher, which makes everyone involved absolutely positive that the painting will sell. It became very apparent very quickly that a fail safe was absolutely not needed in the case of the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00The auction proved record setting in more ways than one, including the fact that it lasted for almost 20 minutes, which is at least 10 times longer than your average lot at these kinds of auctions. Within that two-minute average time frame, the bids went from an opening of 75 million to over 180, which at the time was the most anyone had ever paid for a painting at auction.
SPEAKER_00The bidding would go on for another 18 minutes, though with every minute that passed, the bids got less frequent as people started to drop out. When the bid passed 300, the Salvatore Mundi officially became the most expensive painting ever sold, either at auction or in private sale. And even then there were still several bidders until just two remained, both of whom were bidding by phone.
SPEAKER_00Ben Lewis describes this one-on-one bidding war as a clash of temperaments. One bidder was very disciplined and methodical, increasing his or her, maybe get some female representation in here, probably of him though, by$2 million with each new bid. The other person was the opposite, very gut-punchy and willy-nilly, upping his bid by a few million or 10 million or even 18 million dollars at a time.
SPEAKER_00When the gavel finally came down, the winning bid was$400 million. That amount does not include the auction house's commission, which was an additional$50. Not to brag, but even I can do that math without a calculator. In total, the winner was going to shell out$450 million for the Salvatore Mundi. That amount was to be paid out in six monthly installments, five for$58,385,416.67, and one final installment of$58,385,416.65.
SPEAKER_00Two cents less than the others. What a bargain. Speaking of people for whom money is no object, one person who was very closely monitoring this auction was our king of fertilizers, Dmitry Ribolovlev. His daughter Anna attended the sale, and she was texting her dad the entire time. He later recalled that once the bid hit 200 million, he stopped looking at his messages because he was fine with that.
SPEAKER_00The next he looked, probably about 10 minutes later, it was already up to 300 million. Let's just say he started paying attention again. Rybolovlev could rest easy. The painting that Bouvier had said would make him a laughing stock of the art market had not only recouped its cost, but even after paying all the fees, it made him a cool$135 million profit. If I could whistle right now, I would, but I cannot.
SPEAKER_00Following the auction, there was an exclusive after party, one whose guest list encapsulated the luxurious scuzziness of the night. In addition to Christie's elite like Loïc Gouzier and art market titans like our St. Bart's vacationing dude, Sandy Heller, the party was attended by other very high-profile individuals. Lest you think they are too glamorous, many of those same people have a track record of committing, abetting, or benefiting from various art crimes.
SPEAKER_00That's gotta be the most let them eat cake moment of this entire episode. And that's saying something because this episode's tagline could basically be Salvatore Mundi Let Them Eat Cake. As you can probably imagine, the reactions to the news that the Salvatore Mundi had sold for a record price led to some pretty Zingy posts on social media. One of my favorite bits of social commentary came in the form of a spicy back and forth between art historian Thomas Campbell and the Salvatore Mundi's previous owner, Robert Simon.
SPEAKER_00Campbell is a huge deal in the world of art history, and he had only just stepped down as the CEO and director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. This spat all started when, in the aftermath of the 2017 sale, Campbell tweeted, quote,$450 million? I hope the buyer understands conservation issues. End quote. Robert Simon saw this and felt the need to don his white knight costume to defend the honor of his friend and colleague, Diane Modestini.
SPEAKER_00Which, like, good on him, I guess. But he did the thing that you're not supposed to do when clap him back on social media, and he responded with a much longer post. I'm going to read the entire thing because I love a good food, no matter what venue it's taking place in. In that tweet, Simon wrote, quote, Dr. Campbell, this is an incredibly ill-informed and main-spirited comment about one of the most respected painting conservators in the world, one who incidentally spent many years diligently working at your former institution.
SPEAKER_00I personally observed the conservation process on the Salvatore Mundi and can attest to the absolute honesty, modesty, and respect that Diane Modestini brought to her work on the painting, carried out at the highest ethical standards of the profession. Given the prevalence of so many foolish remarks in both serious and social media, I have refrained from responding, but feel compelled to do so now.
SPEAKER_00End quote. Alright, pop off, Queen. Campbell, though, wasn't having any of it. He responded, quote, My comment was a legitimate response to an extraordinary price. Christie's doesn't need your abusive bullying to defend itself. And my comment certainly wasn't an attack on a highly competent conservator. If you don't enjoy my occasional Instagram posts, then don't follow me.
SPEAKER_00End quote. Oh, and after reading that, I realized that this was all actually happening on Instagram, which somehow makes it all the more delicious. Unfortunately, for the purposes of our entertainment, this exchange seems to have fizzled after that. But who is this mysterious buyer to whom Dr. Campbell's original post refers? In the weeks that followed the auction, no one apart from very select staff members at Christie's knew who had purchased the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00It was all very hush-hush, which is quite normal for auctions of this caliber. But in early December, there were a couple of investigative journalists who published stories in the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal about an alleged buyer, a man by the very long name of Prince Badr bin Abdullah bin Mohammed bin Fahran Al-Saud, who was a minor princeling of Saudi Arabia. That didn't make a lot of sense, though, because Prince Badr was such a minor figure in the Saudi royal family.
SPEAKER_00Soon after his very long name dropped in the New York Times, another article emerged that explained that Prince Badr was more likely an intermediary for another person. The information being cited for that was coming from anonymous intelligence sources, aka the FBI, who likely helped Christie's confirm the bidder's legitimacy and ability to pay. Those reports name the actual buyer as Mohammed bin Salman, the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, who was and continues to rule the country on behalf of his father, the king, who has been in poor health for some time.
SPEAKER_00This all makes perfect financial sense because the Saudi royal family are oil tycoons who have a net worth of something like$18 billion. Plenty of money to buy a famous painting. But why this painting? Taken at face value, pun very much intended, the Salvatore Mundi was a rather strange choice for the prince to choose, as it's a figural representation of Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_00Back in the days when I was still serving as a teaching assistant, I supported a course that included an introduction to Islamic art. And one of the first things that students in that course learn is that figural representations are very rare in Islamic art, especially in religious settings. It's not unheard of, but it is very rare. To grossly oversimplify things for the sake of a quick explanation, Muslims believe that God is the ultimate creator and image maker.
SPEAKER_00To compete with that is unwise. The lack of figural representations is also a pretty nifty way of preventing idolatry, the idolization of a thing, especially a thing with a religious figure's face on it. I would argue that this painting is the definition of idolatry, just not necessarily in a religious context. People might not be worshiping it because it's an image of Christ, but they are worshiping it because it's allegedly by one of the gods of art history, shall we say.
SPEAKER_00Knowing that, a very frontal face-forward painting of Christ, who is a prophet in Islam, is not exactly what you would expect a Saudi prince to drop 450 million buckaroos on. The Saudi crown prince didn't seem to give a flying fig about upsetting religious sensibilities, nor did he care that there had been calls for the elite in Saudi Arabia to be less flashy with their wealth.
SPEAKER_00In fact, that was probably one of the things that inspired him to buy the Salvatore Mundi in the first place. What a massive power play it is to sweep in and pay almost half a billion dollars for a painting by someone who the so-called Western world holds up as a rock star of art and culture. It's also a bit of a few to the countries and the cultures who have collected, often through dubious and or illegal means, the arts and culture of his world.
SPEAKER_00One prolific collector who may have even been the almost winner of the bidding was Liu Yinchan, whose name I might be butchering there, but I tried, who is a businessman and mogul based in Shanghai. He was one of the people who really jumped into the contemporary art market while it was hot, and he was known to buy up the best of the best from those markets. When asked about that in 2015, he told the New York Times, quote, the message to the West is clear.
SPEAKER_00We have bought their buildings, we have bought their companies, and now we are going to buy their art. End quote. I would gander that the crown prince of Saudi Arabia probably agrees with that statement. The purchase of the Salvatore Mundi also came at an important moment in the Crown Prince's timeline, as he had just become the de facto ruler of Saudi Arabia in 2017.
SPEAKER_00One of the major goals of his regime is to modernize Saudi Arabia and to project a certain image of himself, his family, and his nation to the world. The image that he wants to project, his PR spin, if you will, is one of progress and modernization and might. When you lift up the rug on that projected image, though, there's a lot of horrific things happening that are either not being talked about, or if they are being talked about, they're being drowned out by the flashy news stories that the people in charge want you to see.
SPEAKER_00It's PR at its finest. And Saudi Arabia is among the best at the PR tactic of look over here, not over there. They often accomplish that through something called washing, which happens all over the world, but is particularly rampant and visible in young Arab nations that are modernizing at warp speed. The most popular kind of washing is of the sports variety.
SPEAKER_00I don't know how many of you listening right now are into sports, but I am very into soccer, and anyone who has been paying attention to the world of soccer slash football will have probably heard the term sports washing. You sometimes also hear about it with regards to the Olympics, for example. Sports washing is the use of sports and sporting events to bring attention and money and prestige to a country through the lens of something good, enjoyable, and that people love.
SPEAKER_00This is all happening while they either ignore or cover up truly despicable things that are not just happening, but probably built the spectacle you are enjoying. The best example of that is undoubtedly the 2022 World Cup in Qatar. If you are aware of that event, but you have no idea what I'm talking about with regards to sports washing, that means it worked. Art washing is also a thing.
SPEAKER_00One of the prime examples of that is the Louvre Abu Dhabi, which is the capital city of the United Arab Emirates, which neighbors Saudi Arabia. The Louvre Abu Dhabi would make a fascinating mini sod, if not a full sod, if people are into that idea. But for the moment, the short version of this story is that in the early 2000s, the United Arab Emirates collaborated with France to conceive of and build their own version of the Louvre, and they were going to build it in the capital city of Abu Dhabi, where it would become a shining beacon of culture and art for the world to behold.
SPEAKER_00It only took about 10 years to build and is a state-of-the-art museum for which absolutely zero expenses were spared, except, of course, for proper pay and treatment of the migrant workers who built it. Allegedly. While it is not a satellite of the Louvre in Paris, the Louvre Abu Dhabi does have an agreement with the French government that allows them to use the Louvre's branding, to have special access to loans and exhibitions from Paris, to have naming rights for things at the Louvre in Paris, and all kinds of other stuff.
SPEAKER_00Rest assured that the United Arab Emirates Department of Culture and Tourism is paying out the wazoo for those privileges. Over a billion dollars for a 30-year contract. To get the Louvre Abu Dhabi up and running, the Louvre in Paris loaned about 300 fairly high-profile works for them to exhibit, in addition to some other things that the museum bought for itself. One of the loaned works is a painting attributed to Leonardo da Vinci, though not the Salvatore Mundi.
SPEAKER_00This painting is instead a portrait of an unknown woman called La Belle Feronier, and the attribution to Leonardo does seem to be pretty strong, though still not universal. Even if it's not one of his best known works, this is still a major get that will get bodies through the door. Despite the incredible resources at its disposal, including a work by Leonardo, there is one thing that the Louvre Abu Dhabi does not have that the Louvre in Paris does.
SPEAKER_00A singular work that defines its collection. It is missing its Mona Lisa. And one thing is for darn sure, you can pry that painting out of the Louvre's cold, dead hands. It is a rare example of a painting that I do believe is priceless in the sense that there is no amount of money you could offer to get the Louvre to give it to you. So what is the Louvre Abu Dhabi to do?
SPEAKER_00Imagine their glee when just two years after opening a painting comes on the market that is not only by Leonardo da Vinci, parentheses, question mark, question mark, question mark, close parentheses, but has been called by some the male Mona Lisa. Ding ding ding ding ding. That's kismet. That's fate. That's destiny. For some glorious months, the Louvre Abu Dhabi believed that at long last it had its answer to the Mona Lisa in the form of the Salvator Mundi, and they were hyped about it as hell.
SPEAKER_00In December of 2017, a day after the news came out that the Salvatore Mundi had been purchased by the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, the Louvre Abu Dhabi tweeted, quote, Da Vinci's Salvatore Mundi is coming to the hashtag Louvre Abu Dhabi, end quote. The Embassy of Saudi Arabia in DC even released a statement backing that up. They claimed that it had been purchased by a Saudi intermediary for the Louvre Abu Dhabi, and the entire thing has the kind of nothing to see here, folks, kind of vibe to it.
SPEAKER_00But these statements, or I suppose a tweet and a statement, caused some confusion because the New York Times article seemed pretty confident that Prince Bader was acting on behalf of the Crown Prince, Mohammed bin Salman. They even had a detailed account of Prince Bader registering as a bidder the day before the auction, sending Christie's staff scrambling to verify his monetary means. In short, the New York Times seemed to know a lot, and that information seems to have been coming from some pretty credible sources.
SPEAKER_00A few days later, after that article came out, the Louvre Abu Dhabi doubled down when it posted a picture of the Salvatore Mundi on its official website and declared that it would be unveiled in Abu Dhabi in late 2018. They called it their quote, gift to the world. Unfortunately, you can't give a gift that is not yours to give. Just two weeks before the Salvatore Mundi was supposed to be exhibited at the Louvre Abu Dhabi, the museum abruptly put the kibosh on its unveiling.
SPEAKER_00They didn't give any reasons for doing so, simply saying that more information would be released in time. As of 2026, we're still waiting. What in the Mundi happened here? To this day, there has never been confirmation about who actually bought the Salvatore Mundi, but we can say with pretty good confidence that it was in fact the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, Mohammed bin Salman.
SPEAKER_00We can also say with pretty good confidence that the Louf Abu Dhabi would not have publicly claimed that they were going to exhibit the work unless there had indeed been plans in place to exhibit the work. This is not a maybe if we put it out in the world it'll actually happen situation. Like there must have been plans for this to happen. As a little sneaky reminder, Abu Dhabi is the capital of the United Arab Emirates, the country that neighbors Saudi Arabia.
SPEAKER_00According to sources, Mohammed bin Salman purchased the Salvatore Mundi with the intent of giving it to his good personal friend, the president of the United Arab Emirates, and the country's new state-of-the-art museum, the Louvre Abu Dhabi. It would have been a very similar gesture to France giving the U.S. the Statue of Liberty. That is, if it had come to fruition, which it did not, and we have no idea why.
SPEAKER_00The simplest explanation is that Mohammed bin Salman decided to keep the painting for himself. It turns out though that he's a bit of a flake. I would say I don't mean any offense, but maybe I do. I call him like I see him. I say that because in 2019, the Louvre, like the real one in Paris, hosted a blockbuster exhibition of Leonardo da Vinci's work in honor of the 500th anniversary of his death. The Salvatore Mundi was supposed to be in attendance for this particular death day party.
SPEAKER_00It was such a sure bet that the owner allowed the painting to travel to the Louvre's conservation lab, where it was studied and tested by the museum's team. That team even prepared a whole freaking publication about the Salvatore Mundi with essays and scientific analysis and all that jazz, which went on sale in the Louvre's gift shop for about two seconds before they pulled it off the shelves. It is now exceptionally rare to find a copy of that in the public.
SPEAKER_00The museum will barely even comment on whether or not it ever existed, which is how you know it's all bad. I don't mean the contents of the book, I mean the situation. Here's the deal. At the very last second, the owner of the Salvatore Mundi pulled it from the show. And when I say very last second, I mean that the curators had prepared a spot for it to go and was holding that spot even after the exhibition opened in the hopes that the Salvatore Mundi would turn up.
SPEAKER_00That all makes it sound a little bit like the Salvatore Mundi just got lost. It was just being held hostage, more or less, while an epic cultural geopolitical standoff was happening behind the scenes. Or so people have reported. Rumor has it that Prince Mohammed bin Salman wanted the painting to be displayed directly next to the Mona Lisa, side by side, like twinsies. The Louvre, oh geez, I got really spitty with that one.
SPEAKER_00Sorry guys. The Louvre and the president of all of France, Macron, who was in charge of those conversations, it seems, were not willing to budge on that display choice, because the Mona Lisa stands alone. Both parties seem to expect the other to blink, and neither of them did. In the aftermath of all of this, there were rumors swirling around that the Louvre had questioned the painting's attribution to Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00I have since seen some scans of this mysterious mini catalog that the Louvre prepared for the Salvatore Mundi. And while they definitely call into question the painting's provenance and its dating, as put forth in the National Gallery exhibit of a handful of years earlier, the director of the Louvre and the scientists in the conservation lab actually endorsed the painting as an authentic Leonardo. Now, on the pages that I have access to, anyway, I didn't think their quote unquote endorsement of it as an authentic Leonardo was as emphatic as some people make it sound.
SPEAKER_00They were not exactly yelling this from The top of the Eiffel Tower. The director even says that the Louvre, quote, privileges the idea of the work as entirely autograph, end quote. That strikes me as a strangely non-committal way of saying the painting is by Leonardo. They're certainly not saying it with their whole chests, which is actually something that I respect and appreciate, because it acknowledges that there's always some margin of error when it comes to these kinds of things.
SPEAKER_00I do trust that the people at the Louvre know their stuff, and I would hope feel confident enough in themselves as an institution to not kowtow to the whims of a Saudi prince. The Louvre is probably one of the few museums in the entire world that has the clout and the power to step on those particular toes. I very much appreciate and respect their complete refusal to hang the so-called male Mona Lisa next to the Mona Lisa.
SPEAKER_00At the same time, though, oh boy, would I have loved to see the absolute carnage and chaos that probably would have come if they had done that. Not just in the world of art history, but geopolitically. Because really none of this was just about a couple of paintings. It's paintings as proxies for world governments. If France had blinked and let all of this just happen, it would have been a total disaster for them.
SPEAKER_00All the more so because Prince Mohammed bin Salman is rumored, if not, I think, almost certainly responsible for ordering the assassination of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, an absolute horror show of a story that came out almost exactly a year before the exhibition in Paris was set to open. I was actually really surprised that the Louvre was still so open to showing the painting at all, given who owns it. That's not the painting's fault, but again, it's never just about the painting.
SPEAKER_00In the end, though, while France might not be smiling like their leading Lady Lisa, they did show that they have at least a little bit of a backbone, which is cool. Now, though, we're left to wonder, where in the moundy is a Salvatore Moundie today? Is it chilling in a freeport in Geneva? Is it hanging out on a Saudi Prince's yacht bobbing up and down in the middle of the ocean? That was a rumor for a while. We don't know. But I do think that in the year of our Lord Brendan Fraser 2026, it is likely that we'll find out where this painting is in just a few short years.
SPEAKER_00Because Prince Muhammad bin Salman is currently spearheading a massive, like I'm talking massive, project in Riyadh, the capital of Saudi Arabia. Known as Saudi Vision 2030, this project includes constructing a cultural campus that will include the Museum of World Cultures and a Royal Institute of Traditional Arts, in addition to a bunch of other stuff. I would bet that the Salvatore Mundi is probably going to be the star of that entire project.
SPEAKER_00I tried to find out a little bit more about all of this, uh, but the English language website is pretty meager and it hasn't been updated since 2025. But from a couple of articles that I've seen, the project seems to be well underway, with some parts of it that are scheduled, apparently, to open in 2027, though it didn't seem like these museums were part of that first phase of opening. Given that the name of the entire project is Saudi Vision 2030, we can probably expect to know more in 2030, which rather terrifyingly will be here before we know it.
SPEAKER_00While the jury is still out on its status as a masterpiece, you can't deny that the Salvatore Mundi clearly has the zing. How else might you describe a painting that 20 years ago was hanging in a stairwell of a shabby Baton Rouge Manor home until one day a man saw a bad JPEG of it in the jungles of the early internet age, took one look at the pencil mustachioed Christ, and saw the potential.
SPEAKER_00That same painting has since passed through many hands, from sleeper hunters and a grief-stricken conservator to a fertilizer king and a Saudi billionaire prince. It's fueled everything from Instagram feuds, art historical debates, accusations of art fraud, and major geopolitical standoffs between some of the most powerful nations in the entire world. To say that the story of the Salvatore Mundi is stranger than fiction seems like an understatement.
SPEAKER_00I, for one, can't wait to see what happens next. And when it does, you best bet that I'll tell you all about it. That is all I have for you today on the Salvatore Moundie. As always, I used a lot of sources to write the episode, but the source that was far and away the most helpful was Ben Lewis's book, The Last Leonardo.
SPEAKER_00It is pretty rare for me to get hooked on a nonfiction book in the kind of I can't stop reading way, but The Last Leonardo really snagged me. There are a few chapters that are a bit heavy on history, but those are skimmable, and the rest of the book is enthralling. The bibliography that Lewis provides at the end of the book was also super helpful in finding other sources, especially newspaper articles.
SPEAKER_00I also very much enjoyed the documentary The Lost Leonardo. Again, not to be confused with The Last Leonardo. That's the book. The Lost Leonardo is the documentary. In that documentary, you can see a bunch of talking heads by the people who are central to this story, including Robert Simon, Diane Modestini, Luke Syson, various critics and our historians, our boy Martin Kemp, and a bunch of other people.
SPEAKER_00It's also shot with them sitting in these dark, dramatic rooms. It's like Martin Scorsese directed it or something, which he did not, to be clear, he did not direct it, but that's the vibe. I also poured over the website salvatormundi revisited.com, which is run by Diane Modestini. That website is a great place to learn a lot more about the cleaning and conservation process that she undertook with the Salvatore Mundi, but also things like other copies of the Salvatore Mundi out in the world.
SPEAKER_00There are some pages of that website that I don't particularly agree with, like the one that sets out the history of the painting, which is essentially a recap of the provenance narrative that was cooked up for uh the painting, but the rest of it is super, super helpful. I will list a variety of other sources that I used to write the episode, along with relevant pictures on the podcast website, stuffaboutthingspodcast.com. It usually takes me a few days to a week to put that together after I post the episode, but it will be there eventually.
SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed this episode of the podcast, please consider leaving it a rating or a review. You can also, of course, buy me a coffee on the platform BuyMeACoffee. The usual thanks go out to hooksounds.com and freemusicarchive.org for the royalty free music featured in the episode. That includes a version of Vox Brandenburg Concerto No. 4 by Kevin McLeod and a song called Success Dream. There's also another song by Kevin McLeod featured in the episode.
SPEAKER_00I'm not quite sure which one yet, as I'm talking, haven't decided, but you can find the credit for that in the episode description, along with all of the timestamps for the episode. For now, I will give you the usual adieu and say that I hope you find the time to look at something beautiful today. A la proxima Michi Pink Showgirl Squirrels. True story.
Ciphers, cosmology, cryptology - oh my! This long-awaited episode delves into the pages and the mystery of what some have called the most mysterious manuscript in the world: the Voynich Manuscript, now in the collection...
Come to learn about the life of Isabella Stewart Gardner and her museum, stay in spite of the purring and the ludicrous number of chimneys. C’est mon plaisir. See images and sources over at StuffAboutThingsPodcast.com....
**busts through wall** SHE’S BACK WITH A HALLOWEEN TREAT! That is, if you’re into 3.5-hour podcast episodes about stolen art. It’s the gift that keeps on giving, mostly because it never ends. This episode covers all 13...
**PART II is still coming! It'll be worth the wait. Should be up by late September-ish** IT’S HAPPENING. That’s right. I’m (finally) doing it. You asked, and I have answered. Put on your cop costumes, stick on that wax...
Anne of Cleves or Anne of Catfish? This minisode pays homage to Anne of Cleves, wifey #4 to King Henry VIII - namely the portrait of her by Hans Holbein the Younger. Was Anne really the most unattractive of Henry’s...