Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation artwork

My "Brown M&Ms Test" for Filtering Bad Podcast Pitches

Jul 24, 202512 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Remember Van Halen's famous "no brown M&Ms" rider clause? It wasn't because they were divas - it was a genius test to make sure venues actually read their contract. I've borrowed this concept to create my own screening system for podcast guest pitches. With 4-8 pitches hitting my inbox daily (and most being AI-generated garbage), I needed a better way to separate serious guests from spray-and-pray agencies. In this episode, I share the exact screening question I use that instantly reveals whether someone actually researched my show or just copy-pasted a ChatGPT template. I'll also share some real examples of terrible pitches I've received (spoiler: one agency sent me the SAME pitch twice for different shows), plus the simple criteria that save me hours each week in pitch evaluation. What you'll learn: Why Van Halen's M&Ms clause was brilliant (and life-saving) My specific screening question that AI can't fake Real examples of hilariously bad AI-generated pitches The exact criteria I give to agencies to stop wasting my time How this system helped me find amazing guests like Jackie Schiff and Elizabeth Howell Read the full article What's your "Brown M&Ms test"? Share it at streamlinedfeedback.com -- About Streamlined Podcaster: This is the show for solo podcasters who love their podcast but hate how much time it takes. Each week, host Joe Casabona shares the systems, workflows, and podcast automation that let you run a great show without burning out. Joe has been a solo podcaster for 15+ years and helps solopreneurs replace manual tasks with reliable systems so they can take time off worry-free. He knows firsthand what it takes to produce a quality show solo - and he's here to help you do the same. Get Joe's favorite podcasting tools: https://streamlinedpodcaster.com/tools Connect with Joe on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jcasabona/ Have feedback? Send a voice note to the show!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Perhaps you've heard this story from the 1980s. It's about Van Halen. While on tour, the rock band Van Halen included an interesting line item in their rider. Now, if you don't know, a rider is basically a contract for a stage performance and it includes everything from where the band wants to stay, accommodations and things like that. to how they want the stage set up and designed

to what they want in their green room or dressing room. And so this was a line item for something they wanted in their dressing room. M &M's warning, absolutely no brown ones. And this was in all caps. So again, M &M's warning, absolutely no brown ones. It's not that they hated brown M &Ms. After all, all M &Ms taste the same, right?

The color of the M &M doesn't affect the flavor. Or that they were divas. They weren't divas. As David Lee Roth explained in his autobiography, Crazy from the Heat, they had a lot of important safety clauses in the rider as well. Van Halen's show was one of the first highly technical shows in the industry and a lot could go wrong. The M &M's clause made sure a venue read the entire

writer. So here is an excerpt from David Lee Roth's book, and I'm just going to read it verbatim. So when I would walk backstage, if I saw a brown M &M in that bowl, well, line check the entire production. Guaranteed you're going to arrive at a technical error. They didn't read the contract. Guaranteed you'd run into a problem. Sometimes it would threaten to just destroy the whole show.

Something like literally life -threatening. This is a pretty great test. After all, like they had pyrotechnics and rope work and the flyer thing that I forget the name of and harnesses and stuff. And if a venue couldn't even do something as secure M &Ms minus the brown ones, what gave them confidence that they did the pyrotechnics the right way? So anyway, I think this is a really

great test and I've decided to implement it for my podcast guest pitches. As you know from a previous episode or any of the million times I've written about it, podcast pitches are getting worse. AI is making them so much worse. Shockingly, despite my best efforts, this hasn't gotten through to the biggest offenders, guest pitching agencies. In the intervening time since I wrote my article

about AI making podcast guest pitches work, again, this was like June 2024, And now when I'm recording this in July 2025, they have seemed to degrade even more following this all too common format. Hey, Joe, I loved your recent episode about and then completely AI generated summary. It reminded me of client name who something that may or may not be related to episode. So if you can't tell what the fill in the blanks were, I'll link the

article. And then just more AI slop. And I've attached their one sheet. When can we get them on the show? Looking forward to hearing from you. And if you're wondering if this is just like an overgeneralization of the pitches I'm getting, here is a real... I'll read it verbatim. I will... I'll censor the client information because it's not their fault. I mean, I guess it's their fault they've hired a crappy agency, but they... Probably don't know this. This is

a real one I've gotten twice from the same person. Hi Joe, I just listened to your episode Automate to Build Relationships and couldn't agree more with your message about using automation thoughtfully. Your point about not automating away humanity really resonated with me, especially when you emphasized that relationship building isn't a numbers game. I'm reaching out because I have a guest who I believe would be perfect for your show. especially given your recent discussion about the right way to approach automation. Known

as the is the founder of and has made it his mission to help entrepreneurs automate with purpose, not just for the sake of automation. I'm going to tell you again, I got this pitch twice, two different times because I have two different shows. and I'm sharing it because it's so blatantly obvious that they didn't listen to the episode which was, by the way, less than three minutes

long. That's right, it was a voice note. Now, I've offered a ton of advice on how to improve guest pitches, but what if you're the podcaster that's getting pitched? How can you separate the wheat from the chaff? I personally have a forum that goes to Notion where I can quickly evaluate guests. Naturally, you can join my mailing list over at Casabona .org slash join to get a copy of that automation. But I also have a

specific question I'm looking for, and I should I should jump ahead here, not jump ahead. I should I should backtrack maybe and say that I do read every guest pitch. I read every one of those crappy emails. Because I have gotten good guests from them. My friend Jackie Schiff. And my friend Elizabeth Howell. And my friend Brittany Lynn. Brittany Lynn. That makes it sound like I forgot her name. But my friend Brittany Lynn. They were

not my friends at first. They just had really good pitches. And then we formed actual good relationships. Where they understood like who I was looking for in a guest, right? And so I do get good pitches and I've had amazing guests from those pitches. So I do read every one, which makes my Brown M &M test even more important. So how I am checking this, I have one specific question I'm looking for an answer to. And there's

something you should know I get a lot of I get like four to eight pitches per day on average because there's actually two places where I'm accepting guest pitches on my application form over at streamline .fm slash apply. And on pod match from my friend Alex and Alex and Filippo. And like I said it's important to me that I read every pitch because for all the bad ones I've gotten I've gotten some fantastic guests coming through cold pitching. My brown M &M's clause.

It used to be what episode made you want to reach out? Obviously AI has ruined that question. So now it's a practical experience question. Guests must propose a specific time -saving process system or automation when pitching. This makes it really easy for me to scan through a pitch to know if they took the time to read the directions. and learn about the show. If they don't include

a specific time -saving process system or automation, it's a really easy rejection. So, and like I said, it's much better than my previous screener of what episode made you want to reach out. I also say I'm not interested in founder stories, but that still requires parsing the pitch to see if they are pitching their story or if they're just really including biographical information. So once I apply this quick test, if they are pitching a specific time saving process, the

evaluation becomes much easier. And I'll let you in on a secret here. If the pitch is good, even if they don't strictly give me this, right? If they try or they say, hey, I don't really have a specific one, but you know, here's what I'm thinking about. It shows me that the real reason for this is it shows me they've read the instructions. If Van Halen saw Brown M &M's in

their green room, they knew their next step was to do a full walkthrough of the tech again to make sure there were no issues. If a guest fails my test, I just reject them. But if they pass, it's time for the actual work. So that's when I start researching them and I've tried deep research through chat GPT. It's fine. I don't fully trust it though, so I need to go actually check things. One prompt I do have in guest research,

I can do a whole episode on this actually, but I do say like be skeptical, verify that they can speak to the topic they're speaking or they're pitching. And that's been pretty good. I'll include one more addendum here. And that is that when I do get you know, sometimes I will get Pitches via email where people are asking me What how

do you like to get pitches and so I will say this I'm currently looking for case studies, solopreneurs who've saved time by implementing a process, system, or automation. The criteria are clear and inflexible. The guest must be a solopreneur, no employees, only contractors. The guest must have built a system that saves them time, and they must be able to speak intelligently

about it. They must also be able to talk about how the system has had a positive impact on their business. I am not interested in founder stories or general tips in some area of expertise. Bonus points if they are a parent. If the above criteria is met, you can fill out the form here. That's usually enough to get the pitching agencies off my back. I respond once and now they know exactly

how they'd be wasting their time. So now my question for you is what's your Brown M &Ms? That guest pitch screening process saves me hours each week and reduces the friction in evaluating cold pitches. As you think about your podcast process or really any screening process, I encourage you to think about what your Brown M &M's test is. And if you already have it, let me know. Head over to

streamlinedfeedback .com and tell me about it. I'd love to hear it. I'll read a few on the show if I get a bunch. But that's it for this episode of The Streamlined Podcaster. I hope you enjoyed it. And until next time, I hope you find some space in your week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. My Workflow for Recording in the Field

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    I got to record on the floor of an actual chocolate factory this summer for Start Local, the show I produce with Liam and Eric - and the gear I brought fit in a messenger bag instead of the giant backpack I used to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. We Did It: Wrapping Up 30 Days [Day 30 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 30, 20263 minAudio

    Day 30, on International Podcast Day. There was a stumble in the middle, but what's a podcast without a couple of stumbles? I cooked this series up seven days into September, and it made me think hard about my podcast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Small Shows Are the Future [Day 29 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 29, 20263 minAudio

    Most podcast ad money goes to the biggest shows, and the big companies that bought networks aren't seeing the returns they wanted. So I think podcasting goes the way blogs and YouTube did: go niche and serve a specific...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. YouTube Is Podcasting's Discovery Engine [Day 28 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 28, 20263 minAudio

    YouTube is going to keep being a big part of podcasting, and a lot of what Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and the hosts have changed recently is a response to it. The most interesting part for me is discoverability. Other...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Dynamic Ads Are Coming [Day 27 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 27, 20266 minAudio

    Dynamic ads are going to be a bigger part of podcasting, the same way they were for YouTube. I explain what they are, how you can mix programmatic ads with your own recorded spots, and why the technology could also...

    Credit the people on this episode