Why I REFUSE to Record Podcasts Without Headphones (And You Should Too)
11 minAudio
Hot take: If you're not wearing headphones while podcasting in 2025, you're doing it wrong. I don't care how good Riverside's echo cancellation is or what magic AI audio cleanup you're using - I will literally refuse to record with guests who won't wear headphones. In this episode, I explain why "fixing it in post" with apps like Descript and Adobe Podcast AI is actually making your audio WORSE, not better. I've been on shows where my studio-quality audio gets destroyed by automated filters that were never needed in the first place. The truth is, these AI audio tools make assumptions about your recording environment and apply blanket fixes that can create weird artifacts, dropped sounds, and unpredictable results. When you wear headphones, you get clean, "unopinionated" audio that gives you or your editor full control over the final sound. 🎙️ What you'll learn: Why automated audio cleanup often makes good audio worse The difference between surgical editing vs. sledgehammer approaches How echo cancellation can hurt when it's not needed My hardware setup for clean audio (without over-processing) The guest who got floored when I cancelled our interview 🎧 Are you team headphones or team "the software will fix it"? Let me know at streamlinedfeedback.com! -- About Streamlined Podcaster: This is the show for solo podcasters who love their podcast but hate how much time it takes. Each week, host Joe Casabona shares the systems, workflows, and podcast automation that let you run a great show without burning out. Joe has been a solo podcaster for 15+ years and helps solopreneurs replace manual tasks with reliable systems so they can take time off worry-free. He knows firsthand what it takes to produce a quality show solo - and he's here to help you do the same. Get Joe's favorite podcasting tools: https://streamlinedpodcaster.com/tools Connect with Joe on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jcasabona/ Have feedback? Send a voice note to the show!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Today, I want to talk to you about headphones. When I first started podcasting all the way back in 2012, headphones were absolutely a requirement, also a requirement, having all of your guests record their audio separately or using an app like Ecamm Call Recorder on Skype, which was not great. It definitely led to low quality shows, which is why I feel at least my show that I launched
in 2016 took off because I was a stickler for quality. Now in 2025, I've been getting more pushback from podcasters and guests about wearing headphones. And I will tell you straight up, I'm not burying the lead here. If a guest is not wearing headphones, I will not record with them. I don't care that Riverside or Squadcast
or whatever has the echo cancellation. I don't care if we're recording on Zoom, which I don't record on Zoom, but that they do the echo cancellation thing. Headphones are still a requirement for me. And I think if you care about quality, which you should, especially now, then headphones should be your requirement. So first of all, why should you care about quality now? We have Riverside, we have Descript, we have apps like Adobe Podcasts
and Descript that can make crappy microphones sound like good studio microphones. But here's the thing. Fixing audio and software is not as good as getting the cleanest audio. possible. And I know this because I've gone on podcasts as a guest where we've recorded with Riverside and you hear how I sound right now. Not to toot
my own horn or anything, but my audio is amazing. I have a great microphone going into a great interface. I have a great recording environment. I always wear headphones. But the end result for some of these podcasts is me sounding worse. And the New Yorker in me, who always assumes malice, figures, oh, well, they just want the guest to sound worse than the host, which is insane. That's too much effort, right? What's
actually happening is they're running it through Descript or whatever magic editing thing they do. the effects that they apply actually make my audio worse, not better, because they're not giving it to an audio engineer. They're just throwing it through some app, right? Or just combining and cleaning up, quote unquote. And so you'll have like dropped sounds or you'll have like this weird artifact that shows up sometimes
because they didn't properly do noise removal. or they did noise removal on noise that wasn't actually there. So why am I telling you all of this? Because when you use something like echo cancellation, and that's the other thing that they could have done, right? They could have been using echo cancellation in Riverside even though I'm wearing headphones. So the echo cancellation was not necessary. The software is then looking for stuff to remove And when it can't find anything,
it does non -deterministic things. Non -deterministic is a programming term for you can't predict what it does. Large language models are non -deterministic. I don't care what the AI quote unquote experts will tell you. You cannot predict how an AI will respond to you. Just go ask Elon Musk and Grok. So when you apply those filters, If they are not necessary, they will make the audio worse.
If they are necessary, they're going to do things to the audio that you may not predict or want. And so when you record your podcast, you should always wear headphones because you don't want the guest's audio creeping into your microphone and vice versa. Right? You want your guests to wear headphones even if you're recording over Riverside or whatever. and it has that echo cancellation because nothing is better than the raw unaffected
analog sound. You can take that and you can fix it in an app like Logic Pro or you can give it to an editor or an audio engineer and they can pull all the right levers, the correct levers to actually fix the thing that you're trying to fix. But if you're just kind of wholesale applying You know, it's like it's like if you decide oh we're going to Paint the entire house gray even if like the Sunroom should be light
blue or we're just going to We're gonna make a bunch of different lunches for all the kids, but we're gonna spray ketchup on all of it Right like great ketchup on hamburgers is fine Ketchup on pizza is an nomination. Don't at me on that So like you're you're You're doing with a sledgehammer what you should do with something more surgical, right? I think that you're using a You're using
a hacksaw when you should be using a surgical knife or whatever So headphones prevent that headphones will ensure that you get the best possible quality from your audio that is not affected by Any software that you don't have a direct hand in fixing. And I'm not saying don't apply fixes, right? I'm recording this in Logic Pro and I do have a compressor, but it's a hardware based compressor, right? And which is like a
noise gate. It's like the opposite of a noise gate. I'm not an audio engineer, so I'm not going to be able to tactfully describe this, but it's basically like. If there is a sound below a certain decibel, it's going to ignore it, essentially. And I am doing that in hardware. I'm not doing it in software where you can get false positives. What I'm doing in software is I'm using audio effects from iZotope. I'll link it in the description.
For breath control and mouth sounds. Because I can't stand mouth sounds. So I don't like listening back to my audio with mouth sounds and so, you know, I have like a de -clicking filter on there. But again, I'm very surgical about how it's applied and it's only applied to my audio. When I have a guest, I don't touch that. I give my editor both and he handles it because he knows what is a light touch and what's too heavy -handed.
The point is in 2025, this is not an editing episode because I, you know, I hate editing. I don't do a lot of editing myself. I do what I have to, but I don't like doing a lot of editing myself. This is about headphones. And so should you as a podcaster use headphones in 2025? Yes. Should your guests? Yes. That is going to ensure
that you get the most clear, unopinionated audio you can possibly get. Because then Riverside or Descript or Zoom or whatever is not applying their filters, which have been applied for a very specific reason. Right? They have made assumptions about how people are using their software. and their filters are going to execute those assumptions.
Whereas if you're not, if you're using headphones and you turn off echo cancellation or whatever audio filters are in Zoom, there are no assumptions. So you can understand the environment the person is recording in. You can hear the issues and you can fix them later. But also headphones ensure that you don't have to fix as much, right? When I recorded in person, this was a problem. Obviously, we had two microphones, but we were too close to each other. And we weren't using student like
headphone monitors. So. I could hear myself on my guest's microphone and vice versa. That's just the name of the game when you're recording in person, I assume. I don't I don't have well, I shouldn't say I assume I don't record in person that often, but we were using kit studios, which was great. But like I didn't understand any of that going in. And so we did just use the combined audio there. But again, we were in person. It was the same environment. We were using the same. We were each using the same microphone. Like
separate microphones, but they were the same. And so, you know, there are the environment's going to matter. And getting the most unopinionated audio is going to ensure that you can get the best edit possible. Alright, that's it for this episode of Streamlined Podcaster. Let me know right over at StreamlinedFeedback .com if you use headphones or have strong opinions about not using headphones. I will tell you, like somebody, there was, this happened one time, a dude got
onto Riverside, was not using, he was using the built -in microphone, he was not wearing headphones, and I said you need headphones, and he said I don't have headphones. And I said, I find that hard to believe, but if that is true, we cannot record because on the form that you filled out to come on this show, you said you were going to record in a quiet place, use the best microphone you can and wear headphones. And he was floored that I said this interview wasn't happening.
But it's that important to me. So let me know. Tell me I'm wrong. Tell me I'm right. Streamlinedfeedback .com. Thanks so much for listening. And until next time, I hope you find some space in your week.
I got to record on the floor of an actual chocolate factory this summer for Start Local, the show I produce with Liam and Eric - and the gear I brought fit in a messenger bag instead of the giant backpack I used to...
Day 30, on International Podcast Day. There was a stumble in the middle, but what's a podcast without a couple of stumbles? I cooked this series up seven days into September, and it made me think hard about my podcast...
Most podcast ad money goes to the biggest shows, and the big companies that bought networks aren't seeing the returns they wanted. So I think podcasting goes the way blogs and YouTube did: go niche and serve a specific...
YouTube is going to keep being a big part of podcasting, and a lot of what Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and the hosts have changed recently is a response to it. The most interesting part for me is discoverability. Other...
Dynamic ads are going to be a bigger part of podcasting, the same way they were for YouTube. I explain what they are, how you can mix programmatic ads with your own recorded spots, and why the technology could also...