Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation artwork

How Solo Podcasters Can Fix AI-Generated Podcast Pitches

Jul 24, 20259 minAudio

Remember the alien in Men in Black asking for "sugar in water"? That's exactly what AI-generated podcast pitches sound like - almost human, but missing something fundamentally authentic. As someone who receives dozens of guest pitches, I'm seeing a disturbing trend: more people are using ChatGPT to write their outreach, and it's backfiring spectacularly. From generic "hope this email finds you well" openings to completely irrelevant topic suggestions, AI pitches are easier to spot (and delete) than ever. In this episode, I break down why AI pitches fail so badly, share some cringe-worthy real examples I've received, and give you a proven template for crafting pitches that actually get responses. Plus, I'll tell you about the one pitch that was so good it led to an amazing interview. What you'll learn: Why "recently discovered your podcast" is the new spam signal The ChatGPT summary that made me laugh (and cry) My 4-step framework for pitches that actually work Read the full article -- About Streamlined Podcaster: This is the show for solo podcasters who love their podcast but hate how much time it takes. Each week, host Joe Casabona shares the systems, workflows, and podcast automation that let you run a great show without burning out. Joe has been a solo podcaster for 15+ years and helps solopreneurs replace manual tasks with reliable systems so they can take time off worry-free. He knows firsthand what it takes to produce a quality show solo - and he's here to help you do the same. Get Joe's favorite podcasting tools: https://streamlinedpodcaster.com/tools Connect with Joe on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jcasabona/ Have feedback? Send a voice note to the show!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

AI is making podcast pitches worse. A movie scene that has stuck with me for 30 years is from Men in Black. Vincent D 'Onofrio playing an upstate New York farmer named Edgar gets killed by an alien who immediately puts his skin on and wears it like a suit. I guess I should have said spoiler and content alert here. Then, walking into his kitchen, Alien Edgar immediately demands of his

wife, and here's my best Alien Edgar impression. Sugar in water. Sugar in water for those who didn't catch that. Dinafrio perfectly plays this. Moving and talking uncomfortably as if he's actually unfamiliar with how humans move. But it's the request, sugar in water, that always gets me. It's odd because even though most beverages we

consume have sugar or some sort of sugar substitute in them, no one explicitly asks for sugar in water. And while it's an odd request, Edgar's wife obliges and watches in disbelief as he downs the entire glass. It was so close to being believable, but it was missing something innately human. That's how I have felt about podcast pitches

as of late. Now, bad podcast pitches aren't new. I've written about them a lot on my blog and on social media. But in the age of AI, bad pitches have become rampant. worse. More pitches are coming in where the sender says hope this email finds you well or they recently discovered my podcast and it has quickly become one of my favorites.

The last one has very strong sugar and water vibes. In fact, for the question on my form, what episode made you want to reach out? which I've since gotten rid of, but for a long time and I got rid of it in part because it has become useless. Someone straight up sent a chat GPT summary of my episode. How did I know it was a chat GPT summary? Here is the entire answer.

And again, remember the question was, what episode made you want to reach out? In the episode Great Things Require Time, Joe begins with an anecdote about impatient customers waiting in line at the best bagel shop in New York, stating that if all they wanted was a bagel, they could have gone to any grocery store, but the best bagels would be worth the wait. This sense of dedication was admirable that something great will not be reached without patience and hard work. The three most important values to building a successful

digital presence online our professional authenticity, professionalism, authenticity, and consistency. This framework encourages creators to ask themselves and then three questions. So that's not an answer to what episode made you want to reach out. That is the answer to the prompt. Can you summarize the latest episode of this podcast for me? And it ticks all the boxes for a terrible AI answer.

It's a clumsy intro. It's written in third person about the person that they're writing to, me. Unnecessary 10 -point vocabulary word. Factually incorrect. I was actually talking about bagels in Pennsylvania, which as a New Yorker, it was shocking that I was able to find good bagels in Pennsylvania. Sorry, Pennsylvania. And it doesn't even remotely answer the question. Bad, bad, bad. But they don't... They don't have to be bad. Pitches don't have to be bad. Last year

I had my friend Jenny Wright on my other podcast, Streamlines Holopreneur, and her pitch was a breath of fresh air. She focused on the audience, sent the right sort of topics, and showed that she at least looked at the episodes of my podcast before pitching. I am under no delusion that everyone who pitches my show is an avid listener, but part of pitching is understanding the show, who the audience is, and how you as a guest can

help that audience. Jenny and a few folks since then have done that, and they had a great guest page to boot. I knew having her on the show would add a ton of value for my audience. So my advice for pitching podcasts. What can you do if you are pitching? First of all, make it relevant to the show's audience. Don't just make it an email about how amazing you as a person are.

Or if you are a podcast agent, don't just talk about how great your guest is. That is spam filter city. Second, check out the show before pitching. Listen to an episode if you can, but at least scroll through the back catalog and see what kind of topics the show covers. Number three is confirm they actually have guests. You know, I've gotten pitched for my audio notes show, which is super clear. Just me talking into my iPhone about random stuff. Spray and pray is

a bad look. And if I get, if I get a guest pitch for a show that famously doesn't have guests, then even if they pitch my main show, I'm not, I'm going to assume that they're not actually researching my show at all. And finally, you should have a great guest page. Make it easy for the host to understand who you are and why you're qualified to talk about what you're pitching. So creating a good pitch does take more time. This takes way more time than just blindly pitching shows, but this is the sort of thing that will

actually get you good results. Now I will link to an article version of this episode where I have a podcast pitch template. It's usually something like, I came across your show and love its mission to help target audience. Here's how I think I can help add value for your listeners. This is after doing a bunch of research. And then you actually write something that is not just like,

I'm so great. It's like, oh, you help busy, solopreneur parents. I'm a single mom of three and I'm running my own business and I'm managing, right? Like that's a good answer. That's like the exact avatar of somebody I just interviewed on my podcast. And then, you know, I'm happy to answer any questions you have. You can learn more about me here at a page specifically for podcast guesting, right? Notice that this template makes it clear who

the show is for and that you know who the show is for. You're pitching three or a few irrelevant topics and you're sending them to a page that shows your credentials. This will achieve your goal. Show the host that you actually care about their audience. And for the love of all things righteous and good, don't outsource this job to ChatGPT or any generative AI. It's too important

if you're trying to forge genuine relationships that will actually grow your audience and your All right, that's it for this episode of Streamlined Podcaster. I hope you enjoyed it. I'd love to know what you think. Send your feedback over to StreamlinedFeedback .com. That's Streamlined with a D, Feedback .com. And until next time, I hope you find some space in your week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. My Workflow for Recording in the Field

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    I got to record on the floor of an actual chocolate factory this summer for Start Local, the show I produce with Liam and Eric - and the gear I brought fit in a messenger bag instead of the giant backpack I used to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. We Did It: Wrapping Up 30 Days [Day 30 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 30, 20263 minAudio

    Day 30, on International Podcast Day. There was a stumble in the middle, but what's a podcast without a couple of stumbles? I cooked this series up seven days into September, and it made me think hard about my podcast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Small Shows Are the Future [Day 29 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 29, 20263 minAudio

    Most podcast ad money goes to the biggest shows, and the big companies that bought networks aren't seeing the returns they wanted. So I think podcasting goes the way blogs and YouTube did: go niche and serve a specific...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. YouTube Is Podcasting's Discovery Engine [Day 28 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 28, 20263 minAudio

    YouTube is going to keep being a big part of podcasting, and a lot of what Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and the hosts have changed recently is a response to it. The most interesting part for me is discoverability. Other...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Dynamic Ads Are Coming [Day 27 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 27, 20266 minAudio

    Dynamic ads are going to be a bigger part of podcasting, the same way they were for YouTube. I explain what they are, how you can mix programmatic ads with your own recorded spots, and why the technology could also...

    Credit the people on this episode