Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation

Streamlined Podcaster: Save Time Podcasting with Systems and Automation artwork

Is Video a Dumpster Fire for Podcasting?

Sep 11, 202611 minAudio

Eric Nuzum wrote a piece arguing that podcasting's pivot to video is going to end in a charred mess of garbage fire wreckage, and I think he's mostly right - though not for the reason most people assume. This is a reaction to that article and a follow-up to last week's "is video worth it" question: video isn't a magic wand, and adding it to solve your download problem instead of your audience's problem is exactly the rushed, mistargeted move he's warning about. I get into video's three jobs, why 90% of podcast consumption is still audio, and why serving your audience has to come first. Resources & Links "Podcasting's Pivot to Video Will End Up in a Charred Mess of Garbage Fire Wreckage" by Eric Nuzum - audioinsurgent.substack.com Sounds Profitable - where I expect we'll get real data on this after Podcast Movement Nielsen - the 90%-of-consumption-is-still-audio figure Join the newsletter for solo ops and conscientious AI tips: streamlined.fm/join Have feedback? Send a voice note to the show!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Today, I want to do a little reaction piece. A couple of weeks ago, Eric Nuzam? I have never said his last name out loud. Writer of The Audio Insurgent wrote an article called, Podcasting's pivot to video will end up in a charred mess of garbage fire wreckage. Now, last week I covered Is video worth it? I kind of gave you three questions there. Is it going to add a lot to your process?

Is it going to add more to your process than it's worth? And what is the goal of your podcast? You know, if it's if if your goal is more views and it doesn't add a lot to your process, it's probably worth it. If it's newsletter signups and nobody's signing up to your newsletter on the audio version, maybe it's worth the test. If it adds a lot, maybe not. But also, are you going to play the YouTube game? And so I came across this article and I thought it was a really interesting approach. A podcast's, podcasting's

pivot to video. And so he opens up this article by saying, you know, if you are around long enough, you start to know how stories are going to end. And then he, he pivots this towards podcasting's current obsession. with video. So he says, quote, the industry convinces itself that video isn't just an opportunity, but the future, the only future. And suddenly every podcast needs cameras, lighting, a studio, video editors, shorts, clips, and a YouTube strategy. And then he says, OK,

admittedly, this part has already happened. All of this costs a lot of money. He's absolutely true. I'm not going to read the article verbatim, but he he basically talked about how this is transforming the audience, right? Video isn't allowed to steadily find an audience, develop its own creative language. It's transforming everything quickly. Everything is rushing. And then conclusions are jumped to too quickly. The show is blamed. Video didn't work. Budgets get

cut. Teams disappear. Everything, everyone rushes towards the next bright, shiny object. But then he says this. A perfectly real opportunity ends up buried beneath the charred wreckage of an entirely preventable, rushed, and mistargeted pivot to video. And that's the part that I like about this, right? Is we are so reactionary as a people, right? A year ago, if you weren't using AI, you are falling behind. And now I feel at

least more people are listening to the beat of my drum, which is AI is good for certain things. Now you do have what I'm calling AI blue -pilled people who think that AI is is everything in the future. And if you're not using it to do literally all of your work, then you're a fool. Those people are fools, but. We're seeing the same thing in video, right? Oh, Apple Podcasts supports video. You need to have video. Netflix

is calling the Pete Davidson show a podcast, even though it's only on Netflix and only available on video. And I am not one of those people who says video is not really a podcast, right? I think the idea of a podcast is that it is ubiquitous, right? It's you can... your audience can consume it where and when they want. And if that's Netflix, then great. But if I can only get the Pete Davidson

show on Netflix, then it's a Netflix show. It's not a podcast, right? You wouldn't call a House of Cards or something more recent than Bridgerton a podcast. That would be crazy, right? So I think that like there is this rush and I agree with Eric's assessment here that people are rushing, but also there is a perfectly good opportunity, right? So he says a couple of other things in

this article that I just want to highlight. Any time media starts making decisions to solve their problems, instead of the audience problems, things start to go off. This is such an important point, right? Because your content should be in the service of your audience. Nobody is going to watch or listen or read something that sucks. And we know we have such limited time and there

are so many avenues for content now that you need to do something good. And I don't buy into the fact that or to the idea that attention spans are getting shorter. Christopher Nolan just had his biggest grossing movie ever, and it's three hours. And we routinely see this, right? Long movies are killing it at the box office. People aren't saying, oh, it's too long. As long as it's good and compelling content, people will

consume it. So the first thing you need to do is serve your audience. And if your audience is begging for video, then by all means do video, right? But if you are degrading the experience by adding video by making, you know, I made a mistake in last week's episode. I haven't edited it yet. So you'll know before me at this point if I took it out. But like I reference something on the screen and I try really hard not to do that because it makes the listening experience worse. Right. And so this is a really important

thing. Right. I think people see, oh, I don't have a lot of downloads. YouTube has an algorithm. I should add video to solve my problems. But that's that's not going to solve your problems. You still need to make something that serves the audience. So that's number one. And we see, I see this all the time, right? I want to start a podcast and get sponsors and make money. Okay, that's a little bit like the underpants gnomes from from South Park, right? We steal underpants question marks profit. The question marks in this case is who were you serving? And are you

going to get sponsors? Maybe. I'm a sponsorship coach. I should say yes, definitely. But you need to solve an audience's problems before any of that. And video is not going to magically solve your audience's problems. So, the other thing that is mentioned in this article is if video were replacing audio as the preferred podcast experience, we would expect to see established audio audiences migrate to video once it becomes available. And he says this isn't what he is seeing. Talking to producers across a lot of

shows, video results are largely Modest. This is something that I found last week. I know this is anecdotal for me. I haven't done the legwork. I assume as I record, well, as this episode comes out, podcast movement is next week and I suspect we'll get some data from Sounds Profitable about this very thing. So we'll see. But according to Nielsen, 90 % of all podcast consumption is

still audio. Right? So again, serve your audience. And then he breaks down a few things that video podcasting has three jobs. And so again, I like this a lot. I'm going to read this. I'm going to link the article in the show notes because I'm not reading the whole thing. I'm giving you the highlights. I strongly recommend you read this. Video's first job is discovery. Absolutely true. Video's second job is expansion. Everyone assumes that new audience will be just more people who demographically and psychographically resemble

the current audience, and that is rarely true. I'm reading directly from the article now. Video podcast reviewers are different people who come to the show with different needs. Really good and important. There are podcasts where I will switch between listening via audio or video. And I really so Seth Meyers Lonely Island podcast is one of them or the lonely Island Seth Meyers podcast is one of them I will listen basically up into the point where I start where they start watching the short Then I will watch or I'll

stop listening and watch the short because I think that's important context I was doing this with John Boy media podcast for a while because they would show a video They do the thing right? Like if you're only listening, I recommend you go over to the YouTube channel. I don't think that is good podcast content, but they are and have always been a YouTube first media company. Like they they live stream their shows on YouTube a lot of the time. And so that's just part of

their DNA. And then video's third job is monetization. Even though podcasting has priorities, bass ackwards, he says, monetization is still a priority, just not the primary one. So, again, I would agree with this, right? if you can launch a show. And you know, YouTube has just made it harder to monetize. They have increased, doubled, in fact, the number of watch hours and subscribers. So they're making it harder. And that's why I suspect

he made this third, because you need good content that serves an audience. that can get discovered and expanded via video. So maybe this is like the second part of last week's episode where I kind of talked about is podcasting worth it? But is video podcasting worth it? I should say. But this is really important. You need to align with your audience. Video is not some magic wand

that is going to solve your podcasting problems. You can only do that by focusing on your audience. And that means talking to them, solving their problems, not asking AI what their problems are, or just assuming, I want to talk about this. It's going to be a casual show. You should solve problems for most people. I mean, and if you're an entertainment show, you are solving someone's problem, right? It's boredom. It's curiosity. Right. There's there's some problem there that

you're trying to solve, even if you're not a business focused podcast, which is mostly who I help. Right. So if you do want more tips for how to improve your process to build what I'm calling solo ops for conscientious AI usage. Right. So it's doing the tasks and not the craft. Head over to streamlines .fm slash join to join my newsletter. You'll get lots of goodies, but mostly regular tips on. how to build systems, how to focus on your audience, how to do the important work, and take the grunt work off of your plate. But that's it for this episode of

The Streamlined Podcaster. Definitely check out that article. It's over at audioinsurgent .substack .com. I will link it in the show notes as well. And until next time, I hope you find some space in your week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. My Workflow for Recording in the Field

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    I got to record on the floor of an actual chocolate factory this summer for Start Local, the show I produce with Liam and Eric - and the gear I brought fit in a messenger bag instead of the giant backpack I used to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. We Did It: Wrapping Up 30 Days [Day 30 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 30, 20263 minAudio

    Day 30, on International Podcast Day. There was a stumble in the middle, but what's a podcast without a couple of stumbles? I cooked this series up seven days into September, and it made me think hard about my podcast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Small Shows Are the Future [Day 29 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 29, 20263 minAudio

    Most podcast ad money goes to the biggest shows, and the big companies that bought networks aren't seeing the returns they wanted. So I think podcasting goes the way blogs and YouTube did: go niche and serve a specific...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. YouTube Is Podcasting's Discovery Engine [Day 28 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 28, 20263 minAudio

    YouTube is going to keep being a big part of podcasting, and a lot of what Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and the hosts have changed recently is a response to it. The most interesting part for me is discoverability. Other...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Dynamic Ads Are Coming [Day 27 30 Days of Podcast Notes]

    Sep 27, 20266 minAudio

    Dynamic ads are going to be a bigger part of podcasting, the same way they were for YouTube. I explain what they are, how you can mix programmatic ads with your own recorded spots, and why the technology could also...

    Credit the people on this episode