How To Respond To A Porn Relapse: Feedback, Not Failure
19 minAudio
When sexual relapse happens, how should we respond? Instead of spiraling into shame or self-contempt, discover why reframing relapse as feedback rather than failure is the key to lasting growth. You'll learn how to build a practical "relapse plan," why repentance is about coming home rather than punishing yourself, and how safe community and God's grace disrupt the addiction cycle. Whether you’re a teen navigating your own recovery, a parent, or a leader walking alongside someone who struggles, this episode offers a roadmap toward healing, self-compassion, and authentic progress. What we cover in this episode: Feedback vs. Failure: Why shifting from self-interrogation to curiosity reveals what your body and mind actually need. The Mountain Hiking Analogy: Why relapsing doesn't "teleport" you back to the start line or erase the momentum you've gained. Redefining Repentance: Moving away from the "penalty box" mindset and stepping into repentance as returning to a loving Father. Creating a Relapse Plan: Practical steps for responding after a fall - who to tell, how to avoid isolation, and how to practice self-kindness. Responding to Vulnerability: How parents and mentors can celebrate a teen's honesty instead of reacting with anger or immediate lockdown measures. Disrupting Self-Sabotage: Understanding how grace breaks the loop of self-contempt that often fuels repeated acting out. Resource mentioned in this episode: Kind to Myself by Tenth Avenue North (song) Click here to send us a voicemail. We will reply! Are you looking for licensed professional counselor who specializes in working with teens? Email Blake Brinkman at redefinestudentrecovery@gmail.com Watch the video of this episode at youtube.com/@StartYounger Buy the book Outgrow Porn at outgrowporn.com or Amazon.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Start Younger, the podcast about outgrowing porn, understanding our sexuality, and building healthy recovery practices.
SPEAKER_00Porn is reaching boys sooner than ever, which means helping and healing has to start sooner, too. Let's start younger.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Start Younger. I'm here with Doug Carpenter, Blake Brinkman. Thank you for listening. Today's topic is one that is very close to my heart. We're talking about how to respond to relapse. I've never relapsed in my life. I don't think relapse is a part of my story at all.
SPEAKER_02You're the first I've ever heard of.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Just kidding. Give you a gold star. You know, sometimes when we don't feel safe to disclose a relapse, we can just pretend like we've never had one.
SPEAKER_02It it also there's such a feeling of our worth being tied to how sexually pure, quote unquote, we are, how long it's been since we last watched porn or masturbate or acted out sexually. So there's such an incentive almost in that paradigm to pretend I didn't relapse or to bury it underneath or to hide it. When in actuality, we want to build the opposite. We want to use our relapses as opportunities to learn from.
SPEAKER_02A question I always ask our teens is what is God maybe trying to teach you through this? Not that he caused the relapse, but he is in this process of sanctification with us.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's helpful to view relapse as feedback, not failure. Yes. Is it a failure? Yes, at some level. But when you look at it that way, it can keep you stuck in shame and in the cycle of sexually acting out. Whereas when you look at it as feedback, it becomes our greatest teacher.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Relapse provides you really important information about yourself. When you relapse, we use this word all the time, approach this with yourself with curiosity, not an interrogation. You know, don't interrogate yourself or jump into a shame spiral, or I'm back to square one, I'll never change, I did it again. God hates me. My parents would be so disappointed in me. That's a shame spiral cycle. And you don't want to fall into that. Let's figure out what I can learn from this.
SPEAKER_00I also love the phrase progression, not perfection. We are growing, we're developing, we're trying to move forward in health and in sexual health. We're progressing. You know, it's funny when I teach college and I teach other therapists about being therapists, when we talk about addiction, I use this. You want progress, not perfection. You want the relapses to get further apart and shorter when they happen. And that's progress. Progress is not ultimate perfection.
SPEAKER_00None of us reach perfection.
SPEAKER_02And I wanted to say, too, on this idea of tone is everything, especially with you, the teen out there, of how you even talk to yourself. A lot of times we're asking the right question, but the tone is completely off. Of I can ask, why were you watching that? What's going on? And you can hear just the shame, the anger, the hatred going on. Whereas I can actually ask those questions with a gentleness, a kindness, a curiosity of, hey, I wonder what was going on.
SPEAKER_02Why was I watching that? I bet there's a really good reason underneath, connected to my desires and feelings.
SPEAKER_01When I was a teen, I had over a year without porn before I relapsed into a season of acting out more frequently than I had in a long time. And it caused me to question everything. I wondered: have I really healed? Have I just been fooling myself? Is this freedom thing even real? Is it even possible? I had to realize that although I had grown a lot, although I had gotten free in significant ways, my circumstances changed.
SPEAKER_01And especially when you're going through adolescence and entering adulthood, you can get weeks and months without porn when you have a supportive system around you and when your needs are getting met. But when you go into a completely different environment, that might be part of the reason why all of a sudden it got so much more difficult. And it doesn't mean there's something wrong with you. It doesn't mean that all the momentum you gained was for nothing. It means you're up against challenges you've never had to face before.
SPEAKER_01So relapse does not invalidate whatever healing and growth you have already gained. It reveals the limits and it shows you maybe where you need to go next.
SPEAKER_00It needs to be a roadmap of where I need to grow more.
SPEAKER_02I love that. I I like to use the hiking analogy of where we're going on a long hike up a mountain, and so many teens view that whenever I relapse, I teleport back to the trailhead start. And I I've lost all my progress, all my success, all my growth goes out the window. And that's just not how it works at all. I may have taken a tumble, I may have twisted an ankle, and yet I'm still on the path, and I get the choice to keep walking forward.
SPEAKER_02My counselor always used to put it to take my next right step. What does that look like? And often in relapse, all that looks like is what can I learn from this? What can I get curious about underneath this? I wonder what led me to this in this moment.
SPEAKER_01And in addition to relapse being an opportunity to learn, it's also an opportunity to be loved. It's an opportunity to be completely open and find out that my deepest, darkest secrets don't disqualify me from love and acceptance. A lot of times we hide behind our performance. We think that an impressive amount of time without porn is part of what makes us acceptable.
SPEAKER_01And one of the benefits of relapse is that it can shatter those illusions, it can destroy self-righteousness, it can take away pride. That's actually a good thing when it leads us to realize that I am loved no matter what.
SPEAKER_02So good. I I always say one of my biggest turning points is in my journey was when I really started to learn that even right after I relapsed, God still loved me and his face and smile still shined upon me. For so long, I felt the sense of God must hate me and just throw his love out the window whenever I act out. And I had to have people in community re-teach me what was actually true about God and how he felt about me even in relapse.
SPEAKER_00Right, because we read in the Bible about how sin separates you from God. But he also said, Come to me, cast your burden upon me. So we can use that as an opportunity to approach God versus building distance and rejection and running from God.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. A lot of times Christians will talk about repentance as the most important thing after sin or after a relapse. I really love Jay Stringer's definition of repentance. I think he got it from Dan Allender. Basically, the idea is this repentance is returning to the feast that the Father is throwing in your favor. It's coming home. It's not beating yourself up. It's not trying harder.
SPEAKER_01It's not making a promise to never do something again. It's coming home. And that's beautiful.
SPEAKER_02And that's so different from the penalty box approach we often try and apply if I sit here and punish myself long enough, if I clean myself up, clean my act up, then God will love me again and He'll let me play again. He'll let me out of here. It's what Drew's saying here of the feast is already awaiting us.
SPEAKER_00I think we're taught in a lot of Christian circles that repentance is making an about face and turning away from the problem and kind of promising to never do it again. So then when you relapse, you immediately feel like a failure. Like, well, I must not have been repentant. I must not have felt bad last time because I fell back into this.
SPEAKER_02Yes, this is so good. And I I love this point. There's so much energy around turn away from any temptation, turn away from sin, run the other direction. And don't get me wrong, there's some wisdom to that in moments. However, it can often build this resistance to digging in with curiosity, with kindness, with good mentors and community around you of what was going on in me underneath it all, in these desires that are good, that are God given, to be loved, to be affirmed, to be accepted.
SPEAKER_02What was feeling depleted that led me to these things?
SPEAKER_01And also not just turning away from what's bad, but turning toward what's good, reconnecting with God, with others, with ourselves.
SPEAKER_00I think another good thing is we hear so much in you know the psychology world about having a relapse prevention plan. I think you also need to have a relapse plan. What is my plan? If I do relapse, what should I do? Who should I reach out to? Who should I tell? Who should I let support me? What kind of things do I need to do to be curious and to figure out maybe why or what I was feeling and what I was thinking? And how did those things contribute to my relapse?
SPEAKER_00But have a relapse plan that won't isolate you, that won't put you in a shame spiral, won't send you into the depths of despair.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes we don't share our temptations or our relapses because we don't want to be a burden to others or we don't want to bring them down. If someone, especially a young person, tells you about a relapse, that is an incredible opportunity. What a gift, what an honor, what a sacred space for you to be trusted to receive that.
SPEAKER_00Because let's face it, relapse is embarrassing. You feel embarrassed, you feel shame, you feel like, wow, why do I not have more control over myself in this? You know, so if if a teen or somebody admits that, praise them for that, encourage them for that. Encourage them that they can come to you.
SPEAKER_02And I love that starting with all of those things before we get into action steps. There can be a temptation of when a teen shares this of like, okay, let's lock down the phone, let's go to bed at eight, let's, you know, turn all of this off. And those times will come. But let's start with celebration. Celebrating, encouraging the honesty, the courage, the beauty in this vulnerability and authenticity that was offered by a team that I'd be willing to bet felt immensely scared to share this.
SPEAKER_02And yet they had the courage to do so. We need to start there and not rush past it.
SPEAKER_00Look at how many adult men don't share and don't share with one another that I'm struggling or I'm having an urge or I've relapsed and it's embarrassing or difficult to share that with another friend. You know, and that's even more difficult, I think, for a teen.
SPEAKER_01When I was a teen early on in recovery, I found that sharing my relapses actually became a huge blessing to the other guys in my group because it gave them a sense of safety and permission to share their own. And it brought us together. We started praying together more. We started checking in with each other more, and they became some of my best friends.
SPEAKER_02I love that. Something that comes up a lot from my teens that I want to hear y'all's thoughts on is this idea of well, if I do accept this grace and this love even in my relapse, I'm just gonna take advantage of it. I'm just gonna run wild and uh I'm not gonna be able to control myself. So I have to beat myself down and punish myself. I can't accept grace.
SPEAKER_00I would first say, what does accepting grace look like for you? What do you think that means? And does beating yourself up make the grace better? No, actually it doesn't. God's grace is there for all of us.
SPEAKER_01Blake, how do you respond to those guys?
SPEAKER_02And it's one of those invitations, I think, to look into the deeper story underneath of what narrative has taught you that you are bound to return to these things no matter what. That I think in my story, that was how I felt of I'm just someone who watches porn all the time. I that's a part of my identity. And yet the more we accept this grace, this love from God and those around us, we start to see how untrue it is.
SPEAKER_02When there is, there is a desire to turn away, to turn towards what's good, to operate within our bodies in a holy and freeing way, honoring our arousal in godly ways. And I'll just say for every teen I've worked with that gets caught in this, the more they turn to grace, I've not seen them fall off the wagon into oblivion.
SPEAKER_01I think that grace disrupts a key piece of porn addiction, which is self-contempt and punishment. Yes. We often talk about relapse as self-soothing, which is certainly part of the picture when we're feeling pain, uncomfortable emotions, we're going through difficult suffering and changes in life, it's natural to want to self-soothe.
SPEAKER_01And that's just one side of the coin. When life is hard, yes, we self-soothe. But also, when life feels too good, we self-sabotage. Sometimes shame is actually more comfortable than self-acceptance. Sometimes self-condemnation just feels normal, and so that's part of what the relapse is doing is it's reinforcing some of the negative beliefs about ourselves.
SPEAKER_01So self-sabotage, self-hatred is actually part of what porn is providing. Yes. It's almost like this is what I deserve. And maybe if there are some really wonderful things going on in my life, I might go back to porn because that helps me feel more normal. I want to recommend a song for you all to listen to. It's called Kind to Myself. Kind to Myself by 10th Avenue North.
SPEAKER_01This is the perfect song to listen to when you relapse or when a friend relapses and you want to share something with them. The song says, What does the voice in your head sound like when you fail for the thousandth time? Is it cruel or is it kind? I gotta be kind to myself because I can't change any way else. If the kindness of my savior is how he changes me, I can be kind to myself. When we receive grace, kindness, compassion, we start to believe maybe I am worthy of good things, maybe I don't deserve bad things, and maybe I can allow myself to receive what's good instead of settling for poor.
SPEAKER_00And I also want to normalize that even in the face of grace, you are going to face this again because you're human. Relapse, urges, triggers are all going to come around again. The Bible teaches us we're flesh and spirit and we war with this flesh. So it is normal to have this come back around again and have to face it and figure out what to do with it. So we don't become non-human just because we're granted grace.
SPEAKER_00We're granted grace in spite of our humanness. And I think we all have to accept that human side of us and that grace much more abounds because of it. So good.
SPEAKER_02It makes me think of to the the idea Drew's talked about here a little bit before of befriending our bodies. Other friends will call it honoring our arousal. We can almost kind of demonize any form of sexual feeling in us as, oh no, this is temptation. This is where I go to act out. And some of this is biologically designed into us. And so what does it look like to honor that well in God's creation and without sin?
SPEAKER_02You know, that's a really healthy journey to walk. That is good for learning and development.
SPEAKER_01God created all this from the very beginning. And just like learning to ride a bike, learning a new language, learning a musical instrument, or learning a sport. Learning to outgrow porn will have lots of mistakes along the way. It doesn't mean you're doing recovery wrong. It means you really can outgrow porn at any age.
How is it possible to understand sexual fantasies in a way that leads to healing? Many people assume every sexual thought or feeling is a reflection what they truly want at their core. In this episode, Drew Boa breaks...
When and how should you start talking to your kids about sex? Rather than having one overwhelming, 100-minute "talk," the key is normalizing sex education through thousands of unhurried, everyday micro-conversations....
When a young person is hesitant, resistant, or completely uninterested in outgrowing porn, parental responses often lead to power struggles. This conversation flips that script. Rather than viewing resistance as...
Teens aren't sexually struggling due to a lack of willpower or moral character. The four-part model of the brain (Bottom, Top, Left, and Right) explains why: the heavily developed "bottom brain" (survival and safety)...
Why do uncomfortable emotions like fear, anxiety, anger, or deep loneliness so easily morph into sudden sexual urges? Let's deconstruct the toxic myth that "men don't have feelings" and reveal the link between...