Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

The Acolyte • Episode 7

Jul 10, 20241 hr 10 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Erin, Alex, & Matthew dive into Episode 7 of Star Wars: The Acolyte! We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM Family of Entertainment podcasts. Okay, now for the lightning round. I'm so good at lightning rounds. That's from Friends, It's my favorite show. Twenty seconds on the Clock starts. Now, who is the captain of the USS Enterprise? Crap? Is it Captain Stubing? No, Morgan Crunch. Next question, which superhero is Tony Stark? Stark? Did Game of Thrones have superheroes? I only

watch two episodes? What planet where Luke and Leah born on Planet Fitness? Oh? Time's up? Sorry? And now a word from our sponsor. Hey, everybody, Nandy kaplan here. Please check out my podcast Make Me a Nerd, where each week an incredible guest tries to baptize this mainstream mom into the world of sci fi, fantasy, and all things nerdy. Available wherever you podcast. That's our show, folks. Wait, mo weeit.

I just thought of it. Padme Amidala gave birth to her twins, Luke and Leah on Paulus Masa. No, that's dumb, is it? Planning? Hollywood? Hell? And welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. Today we are continuing our escapades through the Star Wars show the Accolade, talking about episode seven, I'm joined as always by Alex, who's today representing Saul the Sith and a newly Brunette. Well, here's a questioning and

a post for you, audience members. Aaron is wearing a wig that is jet black hair. To me, brunette is basically brown to black and that whole range. I don't know if there's another word for a per like there's a blonde, there's a redhead. What is a word for a person with black hair besides goth? If you believe Matthew is correct, please comment now. Well, right, but there's nobody listening to our so that's not gonna really be helpful. But we're gonna be a big plus solicity, pushing to get people who know exactly when these are happening stuff like that. But anyway,

she has described as the reformed Indira hater, So sorry, reformed in Dara hater. So glad to have you both here. Eron, I'll start with you, which you think this episode? Oh my gosh, I had a lot of thoughts here. I wrote a whole bunch of them down, lots of quotes. We got some good shit. This is the episode we've been waiting for, guys, so I'm excited to talk about it. Nice Alex, what did you think? It actually made me angry? Like I enjoyed the ol cart, I enjoyed the episode very deeply, but it made

me feel the most angry I felt in the whole show, Like not like a Carfy, not like towards the show for like being bad for any reason, but like angry towards characters like it. I think this episode, more than maybe any piece of Star Wars I've seen in a long time, made me feel hatred towards the Jedi, like act of discussed towards the Jedi. And I discussed it at length, but I thought it was really wonderful and a great way. It felt like to a little bit better connect this story

to some of the storylines and concepts I've seen in pre existing Star Wars. Yeah, it's interesting. I am mostly where you guys are. I think that this gave us a lot of what we're waiting for. And yeah, I think I think I feel oddly uh and Alex, don't take this as critique. This is just where I'm coming from. For me, this feels very similar to Revenge of the Sith. Wow, and that I think that

it. As you guys just said, it gave us a lot of what we wanted in terms of understanding this story. Even more so, I think it gave us a lot of yeah, better ways to understand. Like I'm glad that I don't like I don't think Saul is the one and only bad thing where everyone out points to it, and one hundred years later people say, why are the Jedi so strict about attachments and everyone's like, well, Saul. I think it's actually being done a lot more subtly than that. It's saying like this is the kind of thing that happened, and that Saul

is bad. Like I think Saul's very complicated, nuanced character. Saul did not act right in this situation. A lot of people didn't and most Jedi didn't do that kind of thing, but probably a bunch did. And here's why it's very understandable. The reason I talked to and I will get into all those issues. The reason I compare it to Revenge of the Sith is I feel like so it added a lot to the story. I didn't think the execution of it in this episode was well done. A lot of the

lines felt really cheesy, and some of the some of the scenes, particularly in terms of like how everyone else died and like the mind battle within Dhara, felt like I would have liked something more, and I have some thoughts on him. I'm like, how I thought the way they did this perspective was could have been much better done. But yeah, in terms of like what it gives us for the overall story, I'm very pleased. Totally fair, totally fair. I am curious why, Aaron, why you hate Dara?

She might be one of the only Jedi. I'm not actively furious that. No, I'm a reformed hater because I reformed. I understand. Yeah, I was hating on her before because I thought she was the problem. No episode the problems. He's actually one the only not problematic one there exactly. Well, kal Naka were on the fence about him, because who really knows what he's saying? Fair enough, fair enough, fair enough. Of the English speaking Jedi, she's the only non problematic one, or the least

problem. Before we get into the conversation that Matthew will amazingly lead, what is the name of the of the I'm assuming she's Data Mary, which that choral chorl. I need to write that down. Thank you. I'm gonna be referencing her multiple times today. So yeah, So much of this episode I think is a character study. So why don't we do it by going through character by character and let's start with in Dhara. Yeah, I would just start by saying, I think one of the best comments I saw in this episode is that this is really an episode about motherhood, and let's start that again. One of the best comments I think I saw about this episode

is that there's really a lot of mother energy in this both in terms of I think mother Amaya. Is that how you pronounced her name, the non death Mary, mother to the girls, the leader? Yeah? Yeah, okay, yeah, she I thought was the other voice of wisdom along with Dhara, but as well Friendara. Yeah. I think she was just constantly trying to counsel Soul, but also understanding that she can't she can't just tell him what to do. I yeah, I'll turn it over to Aaron.

Actually, because I think I have I really loved her in this episode. I have some complicated thoughts about what happens afterwards, but Aaron, tell more about why you were no longer hater. Yeah, well, so for Master and Dara, it seemed the first time we saw this episode that she is the one who went out of her way to pursue and say like, hey, we need to like test these kids. We're here because we have a right to do this. And yeah, her wording was still abrasive and definitely

not the best it could have been, but we are shown very clearly Soul is the one who goes out of his way to pursue them, like Soul is the one who brings up the testing and even later and Dara says, that was clever of you to pretend we are going to test them. Never did she plan to take these children away from their coven. Never did she plan to train these children as Jedi. She literally clarifies that she said that as a ploy to be able to talk to the Jedi Council. So this, like quote testing they did of the girls was just a formality. It

was just to cover the plan was to leave afterwards what Indara wanted, and it's just she has a lot of very interesting conversations with Soul this episode, specifically about just his emotions from the very beginning, you know, he's like, well, I'm worried about these twins. You know, we should protect them like something or another they were talking about and and Dara said, don't

confuse Torben's emotions for your own, Like, don't get muddled within these emotions. I do not tell him answers to ease his mind. I teach him to seek the answers himself. And Soul kind of looks at her, she goes, you disagree. That's why I have a paddle on and you don't like it's just it's savvy, but it's facts. Because he's so headstrong, he show so emotional and so convinced that what he thinks is correct and is the truth, rather than inspiring curiosity and others. Like from the very moment,

he's like, these girls are in danger. I have a connection to Osha. I must save her. She must be a Jedi low key white savior complex. Except he's not white, so it's like Jedi savior complex. Yeah. One of the images that really got in my head is, you know, and we know that this happened far too often white folks would go to indigenous populations that they didn't understand. See things that they thought endangered the children and then claim to use that as an excuse to, you know,

basically kidnap the children's that could be adopted by white people. And like, because I don't, I don't think like I think there's some legitimacy to being a little bit worried about what's happening to Osha and May and that they're both kind of being talked into this cult and that Osha maybe isn't really wanting that. But yeah, it's very much white savior to have no to not take so much more time to understand the situation and even figure out if you were welcome, and you know, how how do you empower people within that community to help the situation if you think there's help to be done. It just

it's very white savior as the perfect description. It canda happen real quicker. And that's when I say that, I think that in my opinion, at LEAs from what I perceived in the show, that in Dara was the only one that actually considered that at all. Matthew in that she suggested at first, let me go in alone, and Soul was like, there's too many of them have to go into the team, and she's like, okay, but it's a coven of women with two children. I'm the only women here among us. Let me go in so they're not intimidated by you three men. And of course she is, you know, shot down by the three

loud men, including Soul. But I think that, like, while she did cave, I think in Dara was the only that considered that if she approached on her own, it might be a little less overwhelming, a little less you know, confrontational. I mean, like even if you know witches or not, like for sensitive or not, if like you know, one Jedi, you know woman comes into a covenant women and that's one thing, but having all of them come in together just feel way over the top. And I just really appreciated her like saying that and like being able to be

like, hey, this is the better way to do this. Just frustrated me that she backed down so quickly to Souls yelling yeah. And that's another thing, kind of speaking on the way that she was curious and cautious. Excuse me, that's another thing, just about the way that she was so curious and cautious of kind of their customs and everything. We see this conversation she has with May, where she is like incredibly inquisitive in a very positive

way about their culture. She says, like, is your marking a part of the ascension? May not? She says, do you like it? May not? She goes, it's very beautiful. Ascension must be very important to include a marketing like that. Yeah, And just like May kind of expands upon what ascension means. It means they're going to lead the coven later on and at the end and Dar just says, thank you for explaining that to me, and then conversation ends. There's no well, actually, well this is what I think. Like she's the only one who is genuinely has

genuine noble actions, these noble actions Soul keeps claiming to have. She's the only one who's actually just being curious and kind, right, And I think that all of that stands in such contrast to what you brought up. So I just looked at your name and it said Saul, the sif to what you brought up, Alex of When Saul says you can't go up there, there's fifty of them and only one of you, that very phrase assumes that it's a confrontation it assumes that a conflict is going to happen, and that

you won't be safe if or when it becomes a conflict between one and fifty. I don't really know how four against fifty is going to be better, but you know, Yeah, but even putting that aside, it's such a different attitude towards hers and I. I think it's important to aim that she is still coming from a white savior complex. I think it's an important name that she is still coming from a white savior perspective, and that there's the very idea of her interrogating may like this in a situation that has been created, is I think problematic. But you're right. I think it is so

different and so much more trying of Like, we're in the situation that I did not want. How do I be as respectful to me as I can be, to be respectful for all of them as I can be. Yeah, here's the one thing I want to bring up about in Dara that for me, I think her conduct in what happened here is great. And I don't know what caused the situation, but I'm kind of going on just what we've seen. One of the things that we've seen often in other parts of Star Wars, especially in the Clone Wars, and I think you've seen this

a lot in other settings, is when a master and apprentice, or teacher and student, or Jedi and padawan or whatever it is, particularly when that student is a child is underage, go into a situation and the young apprentice does something wrong and bad things result. The mentor master apprentice, you know, whatever it is, is always quick to say, look, no, it was my fault for putting in that situation. You know. I want to help you learn to not do that again, but I'm going to take

the responsibility, and especially if you're feeling guilt about that, I want to take some of that from you, and I want to help you work through it. It's not perfect by any means, but I did think there was a little bit of Aaron what you brought up of and Daro's kind of fairly hands off approach to Torbin. Like when I looked at Torbin having completely isolated himself for the last how are many years because of his guilt about what happened because and then being very quick to kill himself when May just shows up out

of that guilt, I have to wonder like, why didn't that? To me feels like a failure of his mentor in some regard. And again I have to kind of I guess what actually happened there. And it also goes back to the age old comment of why in the world is a Jedi not higher therapists because they really all need them. But yeah, other than that, I really liked in Dhara in this. I just that just little the little bit of an attitude combined to what we saw in earlier episodes maybe go like, I don't think you helped Torben the way he needed. I think

that's really valid. And I mean I think all of these Jedi, we just see it's like a case study on the opposite of trauma bonding. You know, some people are very bonded by trauma, and other people are just completely repelled from each other. And I think my understanding or impression almost of these Jedi after this happened is that they didn't talk. You know. Yeah, Torbin became a Jedi night, he became a master, he took his vow silence, and you know, maybe they ran into each other, but

it doesn't seem like they had any friendly feelings really, you know, like kol Naka was isolated on this planet exactly. He kind of like fucked off as well, and just like two of the four were like completely gone. Nobody knew where they were, hadn't heard from them either because they disappeared or haven't heard from them because they stopped talking, you know. So yeah, it's just very interesting where I think you're right, she totally failed him. But also I think there's a lot to be said for probably her emotional guilt

and want to just be away from it all, which still makes her a failure as a mentor. You know, as a mentor, you take the responsibility of considering your padawan's emotions. So right, it's a fair point, I I want to say on her real quick. It's just as interesting to me that the Jedi Council directly said they did not want to get involved their like we do not do not we've already interfered too much. Like it made me think that like this group led by and Dara, we basically just went

rogue, is what they did. And it frustrates me that and Dara was unable to Reelin soul let alone. Her padawan, I mean, her Pedalan is one that started the entire rush to the to the sanctuary of the second time. It's just crazy to me because like if the like the Jedi, the actual council seems to like have understood this situation well and said, no, leave them alone, this is not our business. Like what are you doing, like and them from their coven? Yeah, like don't separate,

like don't first, don't steparate. Never in my life did I think I would hear the Jedi council say, don't separate children from their from their mother. That is like their whole things, everything from their parents. But don't separate these twins. Don't take the children. And the one time they make the right call, like this little ragtag team here, like what's this happen? I don't know. Like in Dara, I think just enabled Soul too much and let him get away with too much. I think, yeah, the same way that I'm sorry, I'm bad with her name the Green Jedi.

Who you are thinking, Oh, no, est Vern? The way that Vern has kind of enabled him a little bit in the modern day, I think that maybe that Soul just has this like people form a soft spot for him, it seems like in the order, and so they kind of let him get away with some of his stuff. Similar not exactly same at all, but similar to how like O we want kind of what any can get away with things. And I think that that is what leads to problems like this is because so it was a lot of what his emotions are on wild and then shit, what this happens? Yeah, last thing I'll say,

and then let's move on to Saul. I think this is a really good example of why folks need to trust Disney a little bit more. And I say this including myself a lot of people after episode one, myself included, I think we're fairly frustrated because we had been told Carrie and Moss was going to be a major part of the show and she was dead already and we got more of her an episode three, but especially here, like I now am completely convinced that a she was fantastically cast and that she acted brilliantly

and that she actually deserved to have the attention to her that she did in terms of the publicity and stuff like that. And so yeah, to me, and I think even after episode three, I was thinking we would get this, but I think it was a really good lesson of like, yeah, let's sometimes we are gonna see a lot more of a character than we think we are. And I think it's oh, let's talk about Saul Alex. Do you want to explain your nickname? I really do so. I just want every want to note that in my notes for the episode, I just wrote in all casts the bottom quote, bro, So did not just

what may fall? Brother? What are you doing? This man messed up? I don't. I didn't think it was possible for someone to mess up in almost as bad as a secession of bad decisions, as like Anakin did in episode three. You said similar Revenge of the Sith. But So made every bad decision possible. First off, he like follows you know, I guess again he tries to get in contact with the with Dhara first, but once he doesn't, he just follows these girls and then goes all the way he like I thought he was gonna stop once he like found their hideout.

No no, no, no, no, Christmas had to infiltrate the hideout tail on mountain. But we'll think I was watching someone climb like Mount Doom to go to the rings the way they were paying out of this thing, and then like stalk the children and everything throughout this then leave and then basically like force Indarra to let him storm back in there. And the whole time you can so see clearly see how like emotional unstable he is. And I'm curious why he's so like hell bent on like getting these children tested and like

saving the ship, like like does he have like that bu of a savior complex? Does he genuinely genuinely believe he's doing the right thing here? Has he had a bad experience with witches? I don't know, it's just like all that being said, he made two specific moves that just blow my mind that were so Unjedi like. One, as soon as the main mother in the coven whose name I cannot remember, Soa started whatever she was doing, dissipating into a black cloud, clearly trying to break up a fight. I

think his first instinct is to murder her, is to just stab her when she was being like a fair voice of reason the whole time. That seems insane to me. And then later he's holding up May, holding up Osha, and I get it, like he can't, you know, he had to make an impossible choice kind of when you can make that argument for sure, But to like, like, let may fall save Osha and why about it? To her face, it's freaking crazy. That is psychopathic behavior.

And so I just feel that Soul has not only walked the line, but it feels to me like committed that venture into the territory of the Sith and the dark side, Like that is just murder and deceit and wetting your emotions rule every decision you make. He just really really angered me this episode. I really liked him early in the show, and as the show was progressed, I have liked him less and less and less as an individual. I think I like what you said about him feeling unstable, and I think that's

like the perfect word for him in this episode, because he just is like he's unstable, like you know, like you said, Annasea kind of explodes into her dark mist And I not to defend Soul in any way, but if I were him, I would have seen that as the beginning of an attack versus her trying to break something up, because like, why does this lady turning into fucking mist? That being said, I wouldn't try to stab her immediately, that would not be my first chance. But the moment he does and she turns back to a person and the black drops from her eyes.

He looks so like uncerta And I don't know if it's scared. I don't know, if it's confused. I don't know if it's sorry. It's probably all of them. It's like he knows he fucked up immediately and it's just but at the same time, like you said, he lies about it. He doesn't do anything to make it better. And then when he's fighting Coral and she says like fight me, fight me back, and he won't. He just shakes his head like what is going on? He's so unstable and he's almost like already just so broken and shattered. And it's just the

same way at the start of the episode, he's I have a connection to Osha. Osha needs me. She's in danger. I can feel it. It's like, where are you getting all of these emotions? Like where are you getting this instability? And it's just it was so interesting. I felt like we were going to see him unravel in the episode, but I feel like he already was unraveled and then just continued to PLoP about everywhere. Yeah, I think he is. First of all, it's interesting our various reaction to him. He's quickly becoming one of my favorite characters wild because he is

so I think. I mean, I love villains, and I love like and I think in this case, he is a very relatable villain. I think that's part of the point. I don't think he's yet at the like, yes, Master, you know, I'm gonna chop off Mace Window's hand. But I think he's at the I've just laughed a whole bunch of Tuscans, and I don't know how to feel about that. I think he is definitely on the path towards the dark side, and that the emotions are taking over for him. And I think, first of all, the acting I think is just incredible. He didn't really feel unstable to me, because I

think I did feel like I understood where he is coming from, and that, you know, I think there is a sort of sense of just an instinctive feeling of anytime you see a child in any kind of endangerment, there is an instinctive just I need to protect and there has to be some element of like, I don't fully understand the situation, I need to not rush in before, and he doesn't have that, so I'm not defending him, to be clear, I think he's very wrong in this, but I think I find him. I found it very understandable, and I think that was

a really brilliantly done part of the show. I will say one thing, and I think this show wants us to think this, but I here's where I'm going to disagree. I don't think that he decided consciously screw May I only care about Osha. It felt to me like what the show was saying is you look how much he was straining to hold them both up, that he came to realize he could not save both of them, and that if he tried to save both of them, both would die. And so in

that moment, he chose, and he did choose out of his attachment. You know, But I and I wish the show gave us a little bit more to help us understand that. I'm gonna say more about that differently in a bit, because I think i've I didn't like the overall way this was just a prequel episode on a flashback episode, and I'll say more about that in a bit, But at least from what I saw, the fact that he chooses Osha and not necessarily like which one of them maybe is closer to falling or something, but maybe that was Osha, I don't know. Is

not great, but him recognizing he can't save both of them is to me not the worst thing he did by a long shot. I think that what bothers me is that, like in Anakin's case, the death of his mother, manipulation, manipulation by Palpatine, that there are like kind of reasons we see on screen or even just like suggested on off screen, as to why he is unstable and doing crazy things like killing Tuscans we have been given and

again there's one episode left, and maybe we'll get more. I don't know what kind of more baxtery we get, but there doesn't seem to me to be any reason that Soul should be this erratic, Like just he's so emotional, so quick to like his to dive into his emotions, and I feel like there's no like reason that we're given for him to be this way. Like all the other Jedi that we've seen from this arrow, it's not perfect for any means, but like even again, you know, freaking uh,

oh my god, she was three whole punched. I forgot her name as well Jackie Jackie even she was questioning his how emotional he was and his emotional attachments, like why, like why I think I believe it more if there was some even just a conversation briefly on screen where they're like talking about him losing a padawan or some traumatic thing from his past or something. But like, it just feels like there's no reason for him to be acting this way, and he's just so all over the place with his decision making. Yeah,

shoot, o can I'm gonna jump in by I think we've both been the man have been talking a lot, Aaron, did you have something else you want to jump in with? I did ship? What were you just talking about? Though? And here it is. I the further we get into the show, the more I understand how the creators watched Squid Games and said that's my soul. Yeah, it's all making sense, It's all coming together, you know, Like it's this character is so complex and really like

you do need a master actor to take on something like this, and le Jong is just doing so good and Squid Games is about nothing else but people fall into the dark side and like create the situations where that's really the only way someone can survive. Oh go ahead, Sorry, Oh well, I was gonna kind of change the subject. Is there something you specifically want to talk about. Yeah, I think it's a good time to transfer to a kind of a big thing I wanted to talk about, if that's okay with

you. Ye. So I think I'm hearing what you're saying, Alex and how we are kind of not sure how to see this and we don't know what was going through Saul's head. And this is where I think is my biggest problem with the way this was executed. The first time we saw a flashback, it was specifically from OSHA's perspective. It was what Osha remembers of what happened. We were set up in a way where it seemed like Saul was about to tell May and perhaps even Darth Biceps was going to tell Osha

if he resently has learned more about what happened. And one of the things I think, and I know it's controversial, but that I loved most about the movie Last Jedi is we used the idea of it never told us exactly what happened. It told us three different memories of what happened, because particularly in terms of when people have memories of something and they are shaped and their feelings and emotions towards others are shaped by that to some level, Like what

the idea of, like an objective truth of what happens is very hard to find because the objective truth doesn't have the emotional content. And I think that even if it wasn't that kind of Rasamon style, who really believed Saul was being truthful this time, if Saul had been telling us this story and so we did get a lot of flashbacks, but we also got Saul's narrative that kind of explained why he felt the way he did when he saw Osha, and we got to see May reacting to this. I think that would have been a much more powerful way to tell this story. I understand that you're

saying something that more switched between flashbacks and current day, or you're just saying something that was more specifically clearly from Soul to May. I think, I like, I don't care how you split it up, or if he's doing voiceover or if it's just he's you see him in May at the first five minutes and him and May at the last five minutes. But I think some way of because it felt like this felt like the writers were saying, Okay, now we've told you all these things about the characters, We're gonna stop

all that and just tell you the audience what actually happened. But I have no idea, like, is this supposed to be what Saul is telling May? We just have to watch Saul retell it to May next episode, And as I think we've all been saying, because we don't have Saul narrating it, we don't. We're watching Saul as an outsider instead of what I think everyone has wanted is to hear Saul tell the true story instead of this lie that he's been telling for so long. I'm curious if we do open up next episode with him like what he wants to say to May for all these

years, and maybe it's him coming clean, or maybe it's him admitting why he made the decisions he made that could have happened this episode as well, especially because these episodes haven't been terribly long. If you take out the credits and the preview times, you're looking at like thirty thirty five minute episodes easily could make them forty five to fifty minutes and include this kind of desposition, and I think you're right in that regard, it would be a little more, it'd be easier to digest because I did I while I did enjoy the episode, it did feel very like we're flying around everywhere. I mean,

so much is happening so quickly, and I felt I didn't have time to really sit with it and process things. And if you had cut back to so talking to May, it would have given us a break from the flashback toad jests what we had just watched, and then be ready to take on more. I almost wonder if that wasn't a little bit on purpose though, because this episode, like you said, it moves so fast, but also like this is how quickly the decisions were being made. There wasn't thought going into it, you know, like they walked out of there and Torbin was

like, I want to get the fuck off this planet. You mentioned the virgins. I'm running, you know, like I'm gonna go start some shit, and so I was like, oh, Indara says, you know, stop him. Soul leaves as though that's what he's gonna do, and then they get there and then Soul's like, you're right, let's storm in like that was crazy behavior. Immediately Tortman's like, oh, I think they're locked inside soul is like assault rifles up already, like just like bursts in and it's just, yeah, I think that may have been intentional. You're right.

It was a lot like the episode ended and I was like, the fuck has happened? Like what just happened? I so much just happened and I can't even track. But yeah, I think if this was a longer show, like I think this is a phenomenal story, and I just don't think eight episodes is gonna be enough because I think I do like what you're saying there, and I think if then the next episode, if this was basically like the conceit was that Saul and bic Apps were both telling this to Osha and May, and then the next episode is mostly about their reactions to

it moving forward, and we have two more episodes or three more episodes. Whatever I'm bad at math Power made mart would be I think that I would have loved. So yeah, I am starting to feel like the anxiety of like, what do you mean one episode? Yeah? Yeah, that seems crazy. And also if I may change to CHORL real quick, because you brought up Coral Quarrel was so also like such an aggressor, Like I understand that she was very like she carried these children, and I believe is what I was understanding this and like either did she carry or create them? She

carried them. Okay, That's what I thought. Yeah, So like I understand that there's a protectiveness there in an instinct there, and she'd moves very deeply in her coven. But immediately like telling may she has to like fight these Jedi, go break the door, like like everyone prepare for battle, like you know, like just she also was escalating this fashion that had to be. But she did have two banger lines. One was like she looks basically I can't if it was in dar soul like then in the eye and is like you would have you know, our child joined in an institution and

leave her family. Yeah, because the Jedi order is that it's like it's almost like a factory. Like you bring in these children, you raise them, then you like pump them out his new Jedi and like you're taking away from families in that in that process that you have something to say to that, Aaron, I'm just gonna say not to be a hater, but that was Anna Say's quote, not Corals. Sorry, that was answer. You were correct. You are correct. Is the other quote. Coral said, someday there's noble intentions you all have will destroy every Jediday in the galaxy,

which also hit like a freaking train because we know about happens, because it's like it's just like, so I apologize for his quoting the two of them, but yes, both of them became like back to back heaters. Like it's true the Jedi believing that they're noble in their cause and growing in their humorus is what led to them all being destroyed. And I still can't say her name right and say and say, okay, I want to say Anastasia and Isaiah saying that, like the Jedi orders and institution is also just spot

on because it is it really isn't this It's become like very polarizing, very like I know it's not faceless to us, but I mean, interestingly, we have not seen the Tedi Council at all, so the Council feels faceless. It's like this overarching decision making body and like we know the Council of the modern day and we're very familiar with them, so it feels very weird to me that we haven't even like heard a name of someone on the current council. It just feels very like big business e to me, which I think was intentional and just makes me feel very icky about the Jedi, like

like they have strayed from their like initial creation, their true morals and values like the Jedi of Honestly, in my mind, when it was just Obi Wan, Yoda and Luke, that feels more like a true Jedi like code and honor. And then this whole massive order ever really has folks, it feels so institutional, Like I mean for me as someone who, because this is the area that I've studied, has always seen the Force and the Jedi

somewhat as a religion and a religious institution, there's an awful lot of truth to that, like if you just study world religions, and to be honest, to be very clear, I'm someone who has a very pot I think that religions can be a positive thing and can also be a very negative thing. But that often you know, it starts with a couple of people with an idea and that idea grows, but then over time it becomes institutionalized, and that's where a lot of the problems come from. And so yeah, that idea of and I think that's why I'm really excited to see some of the new movies that are about Ray trying to rebuild the Jedi, because it's

like, how do you fall not fall back into these exact patterns? Eron, I think you had a different direction. You wanted to take us in. I wanted to chat about Torbin. Yeah, we learned a ton about him. I mean, of all, he's kind of a brat, like I don't He's like, we're not doing anything important, we're just studying plans and it's been a whole seven weeks. I want to go home, like, oh my god, stop bitching, get over it, you know. But also it's so interesting like Anna Seya picked that out immediately, Like the

moment they started having that confrontation and they were talking with and Dara, she was in his head before she ever even visibly took over. She was pacing around him, and really like it's the idea of like corrupt, And it's not that she was necessarily trying to get him to do something bad, but she could tell his insecurity. She could feel his unrest, and she was just poking it and trying to like prod him into luring the Jedi away,

because you know, that's what she wants. She wants them to just get out of here, and that's what he wants. So she saw this as we want the same thing. How can I influence you? Right? And so she specifically when she said, you wish to return to Corroussant, your master denies you, I would not keep you from what you want. I would always let you have what you need. M And that was just like such a interesting statement of like the difference between the light and the dark,

and just how polarizing or how maybe like seductive the idea of having what you want and having what you want be a need versus being like what you want doesn't matter the will of the Council, the will of the force, you know, right. It's that feeling of almost like selfishness or greed that is so on Jedi and non Jedi like that she really just like turns on within him. And it's so interesting because that's exactly what then happened, is that

he wanted to get out so oh bad. He made the most rash and reckless and destructive decisions he could have, and soul followed behind him doing exactly the same and worse. So I want to say two things on this. First, in terms of Torbin, I think your description of him is accurate, But I want to say a little bit in his defense, which is for me, as someone grew up all of my life until my mid twenties in New York City, if you had taken which basically is coruscant, you

know, I mean, it's like to so true. No one I knew could drive until the age of twenty five because we were just so used to. Like, the idea of seeing like a full sky terrified me because I'd never seen anything else because they're building all over the place. The idea that you would take me at age sixteen to a wilderness, I would have been just as freaked out. And maybe as Padawan's they're expected to do that. But maybe also like this is another shitty part of the Jedi, like have some how don't want you to get a little more buy in of is this

what they want to do? What kind of missions they get to go on? You know, that's a whole other story. But to Anna sayah, I think part of what the story is making us do is question the binary of light side good, dark side bad. If you want to do Sith or better than Jedi, sorry, Sith are worse than Jedi. I'm one hundred percent there. The Jedi are flawed institution, the Sith are evil.

Like I have no arguments against that. Most of the time the dark side is used for bad things, no argument against that. But in terms of what she did, and let's be honest, she was kind of like mentally tempting him, but then basically like she like mentally took him over and said, paxifically, I won't give him back. She was like, you know, kidnap. You know, she was like holding him mentally hostage her. And what you said about Coral being so aggressive when you are being invaded or threatened with invasion by colonizers, don't I'm not going to stand in moral judgment

of the ways in which you fight back. Really, and yes, I'm very much making that statement about modern day situations, but also about you know, these kinds of situations. Well, I'll stand a little bit of judgment, but I also want to think my judgment matters very much in that Like to me, if you don't like the way someone's fighting back against oppression, don't depress them. And yeah, if you don't like all the stuff that these people are doing to protect themselves, go away and stop making them feel like they got to protect themselves. And I will agree with you that I think Korl with somewhat hot he like. I think it would have been better if Korl had been able to listen more and not just act. But what

I'm gonna say it does is clearly tapping into the dark side of the force. And it's not something I would want people to be like, trained and happy and ready to do. Would I have no moral problem with what she did. That's fair. I you know, I understand that the burden of ruling West Roast really ways in a person before they before they get to this planet. I'm kidding, sorry, but in all reality, I think that I don't know if I understand why Torbin of all of them, went into

that cone of silence for a decade. I understand having trauma from his experience I had, Like hell, man, if I was attacked by a Wookie Jedi master like that, gonna say I would have some trauma, some deep distrust in trauma. But the way that like he you know, says to me like I apologize, like I've been waiting so long to like like forgive me, like I will kill myself for you, Like that feels excessive to me in the role compared to the role he had, Like, yes,

he was rash, he rushed over there. Yes he wanted to like grab the children because he believed in if we if we found the versions, we can go home. I do want to talk about versions of the minute as well, but I don't know to me, like his role in it overall, like he was a child, like in the end of the things he was a paddawan and like, yes he's responsed for his actions. Yes he was old enough to be aware of that. I'm not giving him a free pass by any means, but like Soone and Dara like live their lives and like I guess that like it, being in informative years, I might have

like scarred him more and maybe that's why. But it feels like ten years of silence, almost like a cop out. It's like I'm not gonna actually deal with this. I'm not gonna try and make amends. I'm not gonna try and like be a better person moving forward. I'm just gonna hide in a show for the rest of my life Like that just seems and to be fair, I don't know. Maybe he was reaching out to the forest to try and help people figure something out, but it just felt a little like a cowardly tactic to me instead of like dealing with the problem head on in

some way, or at least like that said, why a Jedi therapist or something like. Again, I get it, but ten years of silence for his role in that feels extra. I think that was a lot of words to say you didn't have an EMO phase when you were a teenager. I did. I did, But like ten years in a bubble of silence, even emo als would have been couldn't handle that. I'm too social. I think I agree with you, except for one major factor that I think also further traumatized him and Aaron. I'm not asking you to cross out the Reformed,

but I do think this is another big strike up against Sindhara that we didn't talk about this whole episode. He is the one she is the one telling him, and Dara is telling Torbin, you have to live up to these ideals. More. You have to stop putting your own needs ahead. You have to do all these things. And then when he screws up and Saul screws up and everything goes bad, she's willing to lie. And she's the one who says we're going to lie to the council. And if you

think about, like how much influen it's a mentor can have over you, and you're sort of feeling like, maybe I did the wrong thing. I need to look to my mentor more. My mentor. I am in the super chaotic place and my mentor is the one solid thing in my life. And then your mentor is like, yeah, actually I'm going to do something that I would never have done before. That's been a fuck with your head in a very serious way. And that's true. Yeah, that's super valid.

I didn't I never I didn't really put that together really, but yeah, it's like, God, that sucks. That sucks ass, because at the end of the day, she lied to protect this random child instead of supporting and protecting her paddle on this whole time. And she liked to protect so one away too. Oh totally, totally. Probably she probably was protecting Torbin a little bit, but yeah, I think so, so would have been much more hurt. Yeah, I mean I think it was a shelter

to all of them because they all fucked up at the end of the day. Right, Yeah, this is like I don't know what kind of operation was going on here, but these four Jedi should not be Jedi the way they were acting. That was just insane behavior on their part. When they walk up and cal Lock is like, yeah, let me just break in, let me just slice these commands, I was like, Bro, you were looking so unblameable until you just decided to break and enter. Literally. Maybe if like they were a little stricter with their who they were going to train and raise and like maybe then like we wouldn't be stealing as many children, maybe there wouldn't be as many bad decisions being made. I don't know,

crazy concept. Yeah, I feel like again this is the problem of the story being too short, because the episode I would love to see and maybe this is the way of telling the story or it's just the follow up is the four of them on the ride back talking to each other about what happened, and I would love to hear Torbin processes feelings and in Dara like because there's just so much we don't know about what happened between those four, and I think the point of it is that those four aren't the heart of

the story. The heart of the story is May and Osha and what happened to them and them coming to learn the truth. But I also just feel like it would have been so much like it's kind of like you tried to give us this little side chapter, but it was so good and it's so relevant to everything else that I just didn't feel like we're not could get enough of it. It's fair, that's valid. I have a feeling that they really didn't talk much, honestly, Like, I think that's why poor Men went into his violence, because nobody did help him process his feelings and emotions

or even process what just happened, like getting face smashed into a wall by a Wookie like which also exactly who's supposed to be your ally, also really sick seeing like a full on Wookie lightsaber battle. That was so fucking cool. Super glad about that, Alex, we may move on to the Virgins. What did you have to say? Hey, God, just I'm so excited to talk about that far for this whole episode that was the part of the exciting episode the most. It's just that, like they're looking for a versions. This prophecy of a versions in the Force has been in the Lower

Star Wars for so long, and to know about higher public Jedi were actively like seeking it out, trying to find like versions is. And then like when they realized that it might send around a person, they all like lost their shit. Maybe that is the reason they all went crazy. They were all like, wait a minute, versions around a person on two people, And obviously, like Soul was shook to his core when he kind of dawned on him that these children were fabricated in a way, like and Dar was suggesting that one consciousness was split into two, Like that could also show that,

like why their twins were like May and Oh Shure so different like ones very aggressive and like leans more towards the dark side a little bit. One's what's softer and leans towards the light side a little bit. But together they make one balanced thing. And maybe the Witches understood balance better than the Jedi do. But it just it was just really interesting because I want to know why how the twins were created and if this method is indeed if we had hypothesized earlier in a different episode of our podcast here, like is that how

the Sith eventually figured it out and how Anakin came to be? Like did this knowledge somehow find its way to through Osha as an adult to uh darth back muscles and that somehow ends up in the general set the line of knowledge. But it's just it's just it's just fascinated because it connected this to Anakin, It connected this to the to the Jedi legends that have existed for a while, and it made me really want to know more about that. And it makes me also upset math that we'ld have more episodes because I want more exploration on that. We're just We're just I just know we're gonna be lovet

hanging on that, Like we're not gonna get any more information on how these twins were created, how they came to be, And I'm just gonna be like, well, what's what's the point then, what's what I bringing up the versions and these synthetically these synthetically created individuals. If we're not going to dive more into it, like just to preserve the uh mystery on Anakin's creation, I don't know man, Yeah, I have a couple of things there, one just as an aside. I think I'm as guilty about this as anyone else. I think it makes sense to talk about how all these Jedi

are acting completely differently than they used to, and I think that that to talk about them being unbalanced and erratic makes a lot of sense. We've been throwing around words like crazy and insane, which are often used as like pejoratives against people with mental health issues quite a lot. So I just want to like kind of maybe say, we see if you can not use those terms quite as much. And again that's to me as much as anyone. But the whole time you were talking, what I was thinking was okay, but what is a virgence in the force. I don't have any idea. They sort of explained it in the prequels, but I don't think anywhere near well

enough. They didn't explain it in this I mean, I don't. I don't want the next five it's to be us discussing what it is. I'm sure you guys can can explain it to me offline, or maybe take thirty seconds to explain it now, but I just to me, that's again failed storytelling is like if I have to remember something from a movie that came out twenty years ago to understand what's happening. It just felt so out of left field that that would be the specific thing that to argument would go because like,

Okay, well you found it. What are you supposed to do with it? You know, because again I don't know what the hell it is. It's a moment of great power in the force, I guess. Yeah. But the versions also was to is a big part of the Star Wars, like the Jedi specifically even searching for like Aaron, you explained, you had your head raised. Oh, I was just going to give you the quotes from this episode so that we like to solidify the context in which they're discussing a virgent tier. It's just, you know, I think it was in Dara said we're looking for a vergence. Torben asked, what's a virgence?

She said, it's a concentration of force energy centered around us specific location. Soul expands upon that and says a virgins could create life like what we see on this planet. It's a power that should be studied protected. Nothing could be more important to the Jedi. This is a Noble mission. Again, I have problems with the second half of his quote there, but I think it's very interesting that hold on. Yes, that is another thing that was sprinkled in from the books. They said this planet is dead because of

a disaster, a great hyper space disaster that happened one hundred years ago, which is say it together a phase one of the High Republic. So I just think I thought it was interesting that like they're kind of tying that together. Maybe that's why they are investigating this planet so specifically because everyone here died, Why is there suddenly life? Like why is the planet so lush? Which they set all this in the episode, but it's thing that I forgot about as the episode went on. So it's just bringing that to the forefront

kind of like it's just they were having curiosity about why there was suddenly an explosion of life on something that was so desolate, right, And I'll acknowledge that isn't much. That is a good description of what a virgence in the force is, and I just must have forgotten it. I think though. It's again because there's so much we're learning so fast, and because it feels like we're not going to spend a lot more time explaining like what the surgeons was, Did these two create it or did they help it happen, you

know, all these various things. To me at that point, it just feels like I'm a guffin. It's like a vergence is important and that's why they're there, and so Torbin knows that if it's there, you can go home like it just which is why I want an explanation. It feels to me like the point of this is to connect it back to the creation of Anakin, to explain to maybe after twenty years, bring it full circle and explain this whole idea of like the medi Koreans are able to create something. How does that make any sense? Maybe Disney's trying to rectify that a little bit, but I mean it interests me a little bit more because like through

every era of the movies, like well, I guess with the exception of the you know, the prequels in a way, but like we're exploring some level of a of a versions Anakin in this in the early area here, the general is searching these for these two twins in the original it's twins in the sequel series, you know, Rey and Kylo are considering like a diad in the forest, like it's always He's like it's the force surrounding one or two individuals and feels like that's always kind of the center focus of these stories.

But maybe Diessey's trying to like draw a line through all of these. I just think they need more deposition to do that, because, like you said, right now, it's just kind of bringing that turn back into the fray and like, yeah, I'm happy I got a better explanation of it, but why and if the if? The why is this is how the Sith learned how to create or how the Sith like how to create life and how Anakin eventually got created. Great, that was satisfying me, but we need to connect those dots at some point. And let's also be clear, the idea that the Sith put in motion the process by which me Skywalker wound

up getting pregnant is by no means supported. We do not have any actual evidence for that. It was. It's in the Legends canon, right, and so I think it could be a theory, But honestly, I am less on board with that theory after this because I think that we could now get more idea of that it's the Virgins and the Force that that maybe this group of which is manipulated somewhat. And and but that if it happened with me, it probably was just like an act of the Force. I don't know, so agay, that was my understand I mean, I could be

incorrect, but my understanding was exactly what you described, was that Shmi like the Force had that version of create Anakin, but it was just that, like it was responding to set efforts to create a being and to maintain balance, the like the Force acting has own a cord to create Anakin as a countermeasure. So it was almost like a would it make more sense to reword it as like the dark Side created Anakin to bounce the Force or this specifically means Sith. No, because I don't think the Sith to me. If

we say the Sith created Anakin, that means the Sith impregnated to me against your will, and that feels really Yeah. Yeah, my understanding was that. And again I think a lot of this probably is expanded universe content. But in that like Plagus and Palpatine are just probably whoever like try to use his power to create life through the Force. Yeah, And then the the Cosmic Force responded to that by creating a versions in Anakin, basically in the light side of the force in theory, to counteract that, like the Sith

have his power. I don't think there's any evidence that Anakin's on the light side. I mean, I've read the darth Plage's book fairly recently, and I I think what the darth Plagi's book says is that they put out this energy of trying to create life and they were successful, and then Anakin was always from that perspective, likely to fall to the dark Side. But I also think that the created him again, not in the like I think that they were. I think the dark Side created him. Okay, in the

book darth plagis. But my whole point was that book is not canon in the Disney canon, and so I think all this discussion go check out our episode where we talked about that book, and we talk about it again. But I think to be clear, all I was ever thinking was that maybe if they were going to bring that storyline, which has the very problematic aspect of SMI getting involuntarily, non consensusally impregnated by the Dark Side, which again is very problematic that's that's an assault, a complete lack of consent. But

I think that like that, maybe we're going to get that being brought in. I now think we're not getting that brought in. That was my point. Like, I think it's in Legends, and I think it's an interesting story in Legends, though very problematic. I don't think we're getting it in here because now we have this Virgin's idea, which is part of that as well, but it takes us in a different direction. But again, we just need three more episodes to explain all this. Right, Well, you're like an hour long finale that might suffice. Yeah, we've gotten about an hour speaking of things going too long or too short, and we're going to

discuss a little bit more some of my ideas of how the story can have been better told and comparing it to Last Jedi, specifically in our bonus member section. Of course, if you haven't become a member, please think about doing so. Five dollars a month, fifty five dollars a year, you get all of the bonus content at the end of the episodes, you get full bonus episodes, and of course you help us keep the lights on. We're right now in the process of revamping some of our audio equipment and that will help the fund that. But Aaron and Alex, I'm sure there's a couple more things you guys want to bring up, being mindful of the fact that we can't hit everything because we're at an hour already, but one or

two more things that you guys wanted to bring up. I just had one thing off to my notes, and it was just I wanted to understand how y'all interpreted this. The witches reached into kaal Naka's mind, right, and then and Dara broke that, and then then they just all passed. They didn't die, right you interpreted that has them passing out and when the fire killed them or do you interpret that as they died when and Dara broke their hold on him. Because that confused me. They I think it was clearly

saying and I didn't like again, I thought this was poor execution because they needed more time to make it more believable. I think they were saying and Dara killed them because remember there were no burn marks, there was nothing looked. They did not look when we saw their dead bodies like they had in any way. And maybe what if they were out called at that point and not actually debt or if they were did what if they inhaled a carbon monoxide or something. I don't know, I did it like to me, it wasn't clear if it like they were dead at that point, and maybe that's just my own confusion. I don't know. I think that's possible. I

think it's a failure of the story that it didn't don't. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's interesting. I didn't really think of it as they could have just passed out, because that's true. Maybe the fire killed them after they all passed out and fell asleep in the middle of a burning temple or whatever, you know, that's very believable. I did interpret it as like their souls leaving their body, like they lost the spiritual and the mental battle and that was all for them, which I then also was like that's kind of dumb, like yeah, like I mean, it almost felt like when

like in Datamur Whul, you kill them, like the the mother who was leading all of just the risen up sisters, they would just died immediately. It just felt very don't know, that's why I thought they just passed out, like they had their connection broken. They passed out and the fire killed them. But if that's actually their death, that makes me have extra issues with the way that was executed. I'll say either way, I think it's somewhat of a cop out because I think what they established was that something that Saw or the Jedi did led to the deaths of all these people, and

then they put it in a way where, you know, I mean, doing anything and everything you can, Like, I don't fault in Dara for trying to stop one of her allies from killing her other two allies, and I yet have no problem with her doing what she did. But it felt like, if you're going to tell us that all of them are dead and the Jedi responsible, I want to see more of that, Like I didn't think they had to have them all die, you know. Yeah. But anyway, Aaron, what are some things you wanted to bring up? Yeah,

just two quick quotes. Well, first of all, okay, maybe three quotes. So Anna Sayah really argued for Osha when she was talking to the other witches. She was really like, you know, she is her own person, like her wants and her desires have to matter. We cannot make this decision without her, and they argue, well, she's the one

who's supposed to lead us in the future. This is our future. And she said, my children are our future. And somebody came back and said, you may be the girl's mother, but you are also our leader. And Assayah looked her dead in the eye and said, right now, I choose mother. Yeah, And that was so powerful of like finally someone in Star Wars standing up for a kid and really being there as a parent and as a supportive figure, rather than trying to exploit the power or the worth

that this child has because of their connection or lack thereof to the force, Like finally somebody is just a mother, you know, and nothing else. It was, It was very powerful, and like you mentioned earlier, Matthew, it kind of the episode was a bit about motherhood because we see Anna Sayah's reaction and her version of motherhood is to defend her daughters but also fiercely advocate for them and support them in every way. And Coral's instinct almost seems

more of reactive fear. And immediately, you know, when that happened, she said to May, the Jedi will not warn you before they attack. She kind of like came at May a couple times and then said, good girl get mad like Coral's i mediate reaction is fight, and I think Anna Sayah's reaction is more of defend. And so that was just it gave me chills, that kind of like interaction there. Yeah, I wanted to make

sure we mentioned that quote at one and then the last thing, when Coral dissipates into Mist and says you should not have from here, Torbin says no, like no, my mind, my mind is fortified. She just goes not you, and Kalnoc is the lightsaber like and he's like and it was like, holy shit, evil Wookie. That was that was well put together.

I really enjoyed that moment. It might have been a little cheesy, but I was like, let's go it got that's so real. That's so real. One more very quick thing, Matthew, I promise that I'm done. I just want to point out that I did a quick search and apparently versienses in the Force are also called nexuses and include things like the cave on Dagaba that Yoda uses tests to test Luke, the Jedi temple, and Corrousont, the wolf spring of Wife that Yoda travels to in the con Wars. Any of this the sit homework of Corbon, any planets or places where the

Force is super wrong and allows like Jedi or Sith to like have a deeper connection to the Force, have force visions go through. Those trials are versionses, and apparently because of that being such a broad term, always places we see these things happening throughout Star Wars, I guess are versions points that I guess, if you think of it that way, kind of a really important to the story as a whole, which then makes sole statement of them being really important and needing to be studied make more sense. Yeah. I just thought that was kind of interesting as I realized that they were including all of

that. And there's apparently dark side, light side and neutral versionses, So I mean, there's It's just interesting and I'm planning on doing a very deep dive later on Wikipedia. I just wish that I didn't have to go to Wikipedia to connect all those dots. Fair, fair, But yeah, I do think it's awesome. Last thing I'll just say about Kal Knaka. Yes, watching him fight with a lightsaber was amazing and I like getting to see at least a little bit of him. But in the bonus episode that only men can check out, and we may make it available for everyone in like

six months, but or you can come a member five hours a month. The we did our last episode on the most recent book in the Higher Republic, Temptation of the Jedi, and in it we have a point of view Wookie character, and so we get here. And we've had that point of view of a Wookie character a lot throughout the books, but here we especially get him. And one thing Danielle and I talked about is that we thought one of the things we were disappointed in an Acolyte is that we hadn't had more of kal Naka as a character instead of just you know, a plot

device. And I think that, like, yes, because they speak shre Wook, like it would not make any sense to them to speak you know, English or human language, because the whole point is just that's not what their vocal cords can do, which is also why we can't speak shere Wrok very well. But like Chewbacco was a completely realized, fully fleshed out character, and I always understood his motivations and his perspectives, and so I kind of feel like they chickened out a bit in not giving us more of you

know, kel Knacker's perspective, and it's just again, the show is doing so many things that maybe it's unfair to ask them to do more things. But it's just disappointing to have a Wookie and feel like he's kind of wasted. That's fair, that's very fair. Like he's kind of just been the Wookie, not like a Jedi Wookie who has character and motivations. You're right, it's kind of just like and he's there tinkering with electronics and growling and looking scary, and then he's dead and then he's possessed. So yeah,

hopefully they can amend that in the future we can see some more fleshed out live action Wookies. That'd be cool. Yeah. Well, on that cheery note again, folks, without hearing your thoughts, send us feedback. We've gotten some already. We're definitely gonna do another feedback episode, probably when the show ends. But also if there's something with relevant, if you've got some thoughts or predictions of episode eight, you know, send them in whatever you want to do. All the information is on the website the Ethicalpana dot com or in the show notes. Also there's information about how to become a member.

You know, it's just really a great thing to do. You get a lot of extra content you support us, and it's only five dollars a month, so we will go into our bonus member content in just a moment for everybody else. Thank you so much. We have spoken. Stay classy, little thall that Tholos another version. It's a good point. Do not alter this little girl's destiny because you have formed an emotional attachment to her. Yeah, I literally was thinking, are they gonna say the A word? And then they did and it made me so happy. So stay trashy. Dagoba

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode