Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

The Wire, the Jedi, and the Danger of Institutions

Aug 15, 20241 hr 11 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Host Matthew Fox and guests Paul Hoppe and Pete Wright dive deep into the unexpected parallels between HBO's The Wire and the latest Star Wars series, The Acolyte. We explore institutions, morality, and the blurred lines between light and dark.Are the Jedi more like police officers? Over zealous social workers? The hosts unpack this provocative question, examining how both The Wire and The Acolyte portray the complexities of institutional power and individual agency. They discuss how characters in both shows grapple with loyalty to their organizations versus their personal moral compasses.How do The Wire and The Acolyte challenge our perceptions of good and evil? The conversation delves into the nuanced portrayal of characters in both series, highlighting how they subvert traditional hero-villain dichotomies. The hosts explore how these shows force viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about authority, justice, and the nature of power.What can Star Wars learn from The Wire about storytelling and world-building? Matthew, Paul, and Pete praise both series for their richly developed characters and intricate plots that illuminate larger societal issues. They discuss how The Acolyte brings a fresh, grounded perspective to the Star Wars universe by incorporating elements reminiscent of crime dramas.Other topics covered include:• The role of family and legacy in shaping characters' paths in both series • How institutions can corrupt even well-intentioned individuals • The challenge of reforming deeply entrenched systems • The importance of nuanced, realistic characters in conveying complex themes • The balance between cynicism and hope in storytellingAs the episode concludes, the hosts reflect on the power of these narratives to make us question our assumptions about morality and institutions. Whether you're a die-hard Star Wars fan, a devotee of prestige TV, or simply someone who loves thought-provoking discussions, this episode of Star Wars Generations offers a fascinating new perspective on two beloved franchises. Don't miss this deep dive into the dark alleys of Baltimore and the shadowy corners of a galaxy far, far away! We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM family of entertainment podcasts. Never wonder what bridges the gap between your favorite film genres, subgenres, and movements. CinemaScope is here to explore these connections, taking you on a thrilling odyssey through the ever evolving art of cinema. I'm your host, Andy Nelson, and in each episode, we embark on a deep dive into the forces that sculpt the world of film, from the styles you know in love, like higst films are the French New Wave, to the ones you may not be as familiar with, like Turkish Yeshlcham or Brazilian Nordsterns. My expert guests and I unravel

Speaker 1the complex tapestry of storytelling, style, and innovation that defines the world of film. As we unpact the myriad catalysts of change that shape these diverse styles. Whether you're a student of film, a creative professional, or simply a devoted movie enthusiast, CinemaScope is your gateway to a richer, more immersive film experience. Don't just watch movies, understand them, appreciate them, and revel in their artistry. With CinemaScope subscribe today.

Speaker 2Hello, welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast today, as we are joined by returning guest former host, still all around enthusiasts of most things Star Wars, with the occasional exception, mister Paul. Happy Paul.

Speaker 3Today, We're doing well. I managed to come through the deluge and be, you know, be here and relatively dry. So I'm looking forward to talking about one show that I love and one show that I'm interested to hear.

Speaker 2What happened sounds good? Sounds good. Also, Paul, I need you to be on your best behavior because we have my boss on the line.

Speaker 3I see, I see, I didn't know.

Speaker 2Also joined by mister Pete Right. Pete is one of the founders of the Next Real family of podcasts, of which this is a member, and so it's just great to have Pete on because Pete is someone who's been talking about Star Wars with me from time to time and also as a big fan of the other show we're talking about, the Wire. Pete, you want to say.

Speaker 4Hello, Well, hello, I really hope I am not the prince of diminishing returns with I appreciate that.

Speaker 2Let me start by getting a little bit of a rundown on what we're talking about today, because chances are that, unlike Pete and myself, I'm guessing most of my audience has not seen all of either HBO's The Wire, a gritty TV like true level crime story about Baltimore in the early two thousands, or The Acolyte, the most recent Star Wars show. But as I was watching one of them, I kept thinking. As I was watching The Acolyte, I kept thinking about The Wire and kept thinking about how

Speaker 2the two of them actually seem to have some very similar perspectives about the idea that we often focus on individuals, but really we need to look at institutions and how those institutions affect the people within them. Basically, if the Wire is kind of raising questions of acab, is the Accolyte raising questions of age app that's kind of the idea we're thinking about today. Are the Jedi police, how do they compare to police departments? And what is just

Speaker 2the degree to which the Wire looks at institutions and how does that apply? Now? Pete and myself have seen both, Paul has only seen The Wire, But we're gonna kind of walk him through a little bit what happens on the Acolyte and talk about how all this fits together. Let me start though, because I'm imagining a lot of you haven't seen The Wire. Paul. We're not gonna give a plot summary of The Wire. It's five seasons, it's the main character is the city of Baltimore itself. It's a phenomenal show. It's a very depressing show. It's got some of the most amazing characters you're bring us on television.

Speaker 2But Paul, what do you think about You and I often talked about sort of the difference between stories of individuals and stories and institutions. What do you think The Wire has to say about that?

Speaker 3I think you can read it different ways if you choose, But the main thing I would say is that The Wire is first and foremost a great show, like a brilliant show. Like when I watched and Or, I was like, is this show as good as The Wire? Because that's basically like to me, that's the high water mark of television. I think The Wire is great because of its individual characters. Yes, And I think everything it has to say about institutions hits so hard because every one of those characters. Feels

Speaker 3like a real person in a real city dealing with what it means to be part of one institution or another, whether it's a legal institution like the police, or political institutions or schools or unions, or a not so legal institution like you know, a gang, or some hierarchy in the drug trade, and you know it. Each season examines how the drug trade affects a different portion of the city,

Speaker 3really right, And they get away with killing off so many characters, so many interesting, relatable, sympathetic characters, and some not so sympathetic characters, perhaps by just introducing an entire new cast every season to whoever survived the previous season. Basically you know and it at the end of the third season, no big spoilers, but one of my favorite characters got whacked and I was like, I'm not watching anymore. And the season four is maybe my favorite season, yeah,

Speaker 3because they managed to just come with a whole new angle and pile that on top of everything they already had. And really, at the end of the day, most of these characters are entrenched in one institution or another, and I don't view that as a good thing. I don't think most of these institutions are really doing good things, and I think it it doesn't allow the individuals involved

Speaker 3to really be individuals in terms of you know, there's there are these various agencies essentially, and basically what they do is they largely strip people of agency.

Speaker 2I think that's so true. I think one of the things that the Wire really showed me is that when you get these institutions, some of them just have purely you know, make money, entrepreneurial, do bad things, whatever it is motivations. But a lot of them, the schools, the unions, even to some extent the police and the cops, start out from a place of we have this benign motivation, and quickly I feel like one of the main parts

Speaker 2of the story is that the institution becomes like the goals of the institution become what not just we have to do this good thing. But in order to do this good thing, the institution has to be strong, it has to be safe, so we have to protect the institution. So it gets to the point where it's the institution itself that you're working on. So that in the seasons about the police, we see a lot of focus on the stats and the interest isn't in how do you actually reduce crime? The interest is how do you reduce

Speaker 2the statistics of crime that are being reported so that the police look better. And with the schools, it's about not how do we give the kids the best education, but how do we produce the best numbers in the testing so that we continue to get funding. And for the teachers at least theres some sense of because if we continue to get funding, we continue to do the good things. But like in all these institutions, I think there's a sense of like we're so wrapped up in the protection of the institution itself that we're actually losing sight of a mission. He is that kind of what

Speaker 2you get out of it?

Speaker 4Well, yeah, I mean it's it's it's interesting to me to look at at this again after so long, So it's been so long since I've digested the entire the entire thing. It really is the systems that are on indictment here in these shows, right, it's this, it is is it possible? So the show asks, to my eye, to properly serve and maintain a the complexity of human institutions that we have allowed to grow potentially beyond the

Speaker 4service to us as human beings, as human individuals, and every one of the seasons, I think the largely the last season of the show is I think, I think probably seen as the least favorite. I don't know, I mean, I'm not I don't want to speak truth to power here, but I feel like the media season is largely seen as the one that kind of starts lampooning itself. But at the same time, it is the extent to which the show goes taking our beloved drunk Jimmy MacNulty and making him a purveyor of fake news, right like this

Speaker 4is the story of embedding the media with a story that does not exist. And to what extent does an officer of the law go to achieve the personal ends of doing good in the world at the expense of the organization that set him up to do it in the first place. It asks the same questions I think you could say of Brazil of the administrative state? Is it possible for the administrative state to truly and authentically

Speaker 4serve the goodwill of the humanity that created it? And that Ora boros that we see in the narrative of The Wire absolutely gets to the challenges of human created organisms they are. Are they too complex for their own good?

Speaker 2Yeah? I love the focus on Jimmy McNulty because, let me quickly tell his kind of overall story. He's the person who fundamentally refuses to play the games. He doesn't want to play with the stats. He wants to deal with the real issues. So, for example, when the bodies of twelve twelve women who are clearly being trafficked to do sex work are found dead, the various parts of the Baltimore police organizations, whether it's the Marine unit or

Speaker 2the city or the county, are all just trying to dump the bodies on someone else in terms of screw up their stats, whereas McNulty actually wants to solve the crime. And then a situation you described, and basically it is his frustration with the system and his inability to deal with the system in a very kind of he's clearly coming from the best way, but also has a sense of like if he doesn't do it, no one else can do it, so to hell with everyone else. He drinks himself into a stupor and blows up his life multiple multiple times. And then by that fifth season, there's

Speaker 2been massive budget cuts to the police because in part because of some great political machinations by little Finger. I'm sorry, in this he's playing a city council member who becomes a mayor and then goes on to even higher office, but is basically the character of little Finger without the accent and the focus on sounds of stark. But the point being that by that fifth season, as you said, we're kind of pointing out how the news refuses to pay attention to the actual crime that's happening. He invents

Speaker 2a situation of a serial killer, and so the media gives him so much attention about the serial killer that the mayor starts directing funds towards the serial killer, which he then redirects to be used towards fighting the actual crime that he sees, and of course it all blows up in his face, and it's you know, I agree that that's the weakest season, in part because I think the writers of the show were themselves journalists, so they don't have that level of they're not separated from it. And I think there was a little too close to home as well as being a shortened season. Yeah, but

Speaker 2it is still it really helps this driver on this point of no matter who you are when you're part of one of these institutions, you're almost always gonna get eaten alive by it.

Speaker 4Well, they also put a hat on a hat, right, because not only do we have the story of Jimmy McNulty dealing with his choices to invent the news, but we also have the Stephen Glass character, the reporter who actually invents quotes and stuff, like he's just a straight up fabulous And that is that to your point? I mean, that is David Simon running out of runway to get all the digs into the paper that he worked for during this season, like this felt like a vendetta season, and I think that's another reason that it kind of feels like it comes off the rails, and yet I

Speaker 4still liked it. Don't come out of this all.

Speaker 3I mean, I know, I think it's the weakest season, but that doesn't mean it's bad, right, I mean it's still better than the best season of a lot of shows. Yeah, and it's a lot of shows. Also, just how many great seasons can you make, you know, in any given show, I think I think shows.

Speaker 4The answer the answer is four four then and then also this one right.

Speaker 2Right, Well, so with that established, Let's talk about the Acolyte because Star Wars is obviously a very different world than the one we talk about here, and let me kind of give a little bit of a summary of the Accolyte for Paul. I assume most of the people who listen to Star Wars generations have seen in the Accollte right now or not have skipped this because I don't want to get spoiled, But if you're just along for the ride, I would definitely say go watch The Accolyte because I think, well, we talked about this in length before, but I'll just reiterate. I think it was

Speaker 2a terrible week by week show. I think it's a fantastic bin show with some weird timing issues, but the main idea of the story is that I think the Jedi have become the jet. It's showing the Jedi as an institution because in the show, I think the two major there's individuals who have problems, and then there's institutional problem. The individual problem, which I think you see absolutely in the Wire, but also we see all around us, is

Speaker 2that when you tell people that their job is to go out and help people, it's very hard for them to see people and decide they don't need help, and we wind up getting this kind of white savior complex story, a Jedi savior complex story, because it's mostly about a character is not white. But I think you see how it applies. Who goes to a planet, who sees these four sensitive children being raised and trained in a way that he doesn't understand and decides they have to be saved,

Speaker 2and then interferes in a way that tries to save them without fully understanding what's going on. Terrible things happen because of this attempt to save them, and he starts lying in order to sort of protect himself and protect the pegle he's trying to save, at which point he involves the like the rest of his unit. Basically, if you think it was like a police squad, a Jedi squad that's on this mission, who then decide that for the good of the Jedi, they have to lie about what happened. Because we're getting to the situation where the Senate,

Speaker 2the Galactic Senate, is starting to provide oversight into the Jedi or wanting to grow an other site to the Jedi, and everyone's very concerned that if they do that, they're not really gonna understand the Jedi, and they're going to make it harder for the Jedi to do their mission, and so therefore they have to lie. They have to cover all this up, you know, maintain the Lightsaber Wall of silence, if you want to go that direction, in order to, as they see it, like to protect their ability to do good in the world. As someone who saw both, is that a connection that kind of makes

Speaker 2sense to you?

Speaker 4Yeah, you know, the sort of cultural implications of the narrative are really interesting. I as I started thinking about this conversation, it feels almost this initial investigation into the mothers and the children on this planet, it feels like the police going into the towers in the wire right. It feels like we're authority, and that authority has been conferred on us by us, and we're going to come

Speaker 4into this culture that we obviously don't understand, and we're going to exert our authority upon you. And the fact that conflict comes out of that is one of the really interesting gifts of the season. Even more so, like the show is set up under the pretense that the Jedi Order and the Galactic Republic have been prospering for centuries without incident. But the fact that this happens at such an isolated incident with for Jedi on a remote

Speaker 4planet indicates that, you know what, it probably happens even more so, and that I think is a huge gift to Star Wars lore. The fact that we are building a sort of a precedent of mistrust makes it vastly more interesting to know that these people are you know, for lack of a better word, human right, it humanizes the Jedi, whatever species they are. It humanizes them in

Speaker 4a way that we can relate to because they are all flawed. They're all flawed at some level. And this is the conflict between institutions when flawed individuals are forced to exert authority on behalf of complex institutions. And that's the wire, that's the whole thing.

Speaker 3I just want to add that we're all wearing blue.

Speaker 4Clearly we know our saber colors.

Speaker 2So you two are in better shape. I am not if in blue line, yes, well, I don't know.

Speaker 4I'm ranting on this. Does this rant resonate with either of you guys?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 3I mean I didn't see the acolyte, but I get as I feel like I probably would enjoy hearing about it more than watching. Maybe at the moment I won't get into that too much, but sometimes like I start watching a show and I'm just like, I'm not going to enjoy this right now, and I feel like there's some chance that I will later, and so I'm kind of like, Okay, maybe i'll watch it later when I might enjoy it more. But the I mean, the Jedi, I think have always like in the original trilogy, it's

Speaker 3just this sort of mysterious backstory, right and it feels like it should have been like hundreds of years ago that they existed, but somehow it's like nineteen or twenty or something like that, which that's you know, it is what it is. But in the then the prequel trilogy, we see that there's kind of all this stuff going on in terms of it as an institution that doesn't feel great. I think the Clone Wars does a better job of than or at least a job of expounding

Speaker 3on that and making it really clear some of the stuff with the Soca, especially in terms of that, you know, the Jedi are this institution that is fabled and powerful but also mistrusted by many of the you know, the people on the ground kind of were the people literally underground on Coruscant, and or maybe it's not ground because there's no rock. It's like metal, they're under metal. I don't know what it is, but it's And so I

Speaker 3think that's a definitely a more interesting story, you know, and seeing that one hundred years before everything fell apart, they're already was some mistrust to begin with, and you know, perhaps for a good reason. I mean it seems for a good reason, like we knew that the Jedi were just like taking children from everywhere across the galaxy, and I think you had to like give it a little thought to then realize, oh, that's probably not good.

Speaker 4I mean, I know they have matching robes, right, but you.

Speaker 2Know, it's probably not great. And one thing that this show really focuses on is that so the character that the character who sort of leads this charge, who is the most like I think you made a great comparison there, but the cops going into the towers. For me, though, the scene it really illustrated was sort of when the social welfare system of childcare tries to deal with Bodie I'm sorry, tries to deal with one of the middle schoolers who like has getten kicked out of his foster home,

Speaker 2and you can tell that there's a sense of like, they honestly want to do what's right for this kid, but they have no idea what that is. They put him in a situation where he gets beaten up for being a snitch because they just don't get it. And a lot of that, to me always harkened back to, you know, I think we want to see the people who like break up families, whether it's like you know today in the like foster care system, with like black families and families of color whatever, all the way back to eighteenth nineteenth century, you know, social workers taking kids

Speaker 2from Native families and others and all of all non white backgrounds and some white, especially Native families, putting them in white homes thinking they're like, oh, this is gonna make them better because you know these strange families or their strange rituals. That's exactly the energy I get from Sun. And yet it is so clear that he has so much love for Osha, the person who's he in his mind is rescuing. And what really came to me though, and this is where it relates to what Paul was saying,

Speaker 2just now, he tries to say that he can understand what it's like for Osha to have lost her family at age eight because he he lost his parents, like he has no memory of his family, right, And I think that it really put me in mind of the Obi Wan Anakin thing where both son and uh, that's the right name.

Speaker 4Right, it's soul. I love, I love what you're doing with it. But but the name is master Soul.

Speaker 2Right, so I'm thinking it's a synonym. Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah, in orbit, let's say.

Speaker 2The person who we find out is the Sith user. His name is is a reference to Moon, which is also kind of amazing, but yeah, that's soul. What he's trying to do with his inability to understand OSHA's pain losing her family, to me, relates a lot to Obi Wan's inability because obi Wan was also like doesn't have memory of his birth family and can't really relate to Anakin's missing his mother and stuff like that.

Speaker 4There is there's an interesting I mean, how am I allowed to say some things about back lie? Are we really steering away from spoilers or we just say like spoilers, Okay, this is what the things that I think is really interesting when you look at a parallel like like really the dark Side in itself, and I think that's what they're setting up here in the Acolyte by looking so far in the past of the Jedi sort of you know arc is that the dark Side itself is evidence that things are not going great in the High Republic,

Speaker 4and they aren't really great for force wielders in general, and we have to put our you know, put a foot down on it. But what's interesting about our Sith force wielder is that, sure he's doing some bad things, but the argument of why he's doing some bad things is not because I want to take over the universe. It's I want to be free and be trusted to wield my power the way I want to wield it. And the first thing that someone does with that kind

Speaker 4of a viewpoint, when told you can't do the thing you just said you want to do, is do the wrong thing, like react with some sort of authority, you know, with some sort of exhibition of power. And that's exactly what we get in season five of The Wire Right, we finally get to this point of look, we know we have built a system of rules together, we humans have built the police force, and we built the laws and everything, and we built a system that's supposed to take care of you people, and now we're telling you

Speaker 4we can't. We can't take care of you. We can't give you the tools you need to do your job, and you're not allowed to do the things that are going to get your job done. That's the same story as as you know Chimir's story in Acolyte and leading to sort of why he's an outcast as you know, as our friend and the Wire starting to plant dead bodies like that's that's him trying to figure out, I can't do this thing that I want to do in

Speaker 4a human system that we built, and now you're telling me I can't do my job. Yeah, that I think is a is a fascinating parallel.

Speaker 2Yeah. I think that's really true. And I think it's one of the things I like most about the Accolyte, particularly given where so much of the rest of Star Wars comes from, is that whereas the Sith that we've seen in terms of like you know, the Emperor, especially if it's you know, other characters who we've seen, they're fascists, they want to rule their authoritarians, right, Darth Biceps, as many of us on the Internet has been selling our person who who notably doesn't say he's a sith. He says, that's what you would call me. He's basically like the

Speaker 2most extreme libertarian you've ever met, exactly right, Alan, And as he basically says in that great speech, if you guys know that I exist, you'll hunt me the rest of my life. So I have to kill every single one of you to make sure that you don't know I exist, so you'll do So it's a very kind of like it's get off my lawn with like atomic you know, to defense one, and it's it makes a very different change because he's I don't think he even has the sort of like altruistic motives of a Jimmy McNulty,

Speaker 2but he does seem to, like generally like when he meets both with May and with Osha, genuinely sympathizes that, like the Jedi treated you badly the way they treated me badly, and I want you to be able to have the same level of treatom with your fourth powers as I.

Speaker 4Do, right, he presents. That's one of the most interesting thing is he presents when he's not, you know, actively killing people. He presents from a position of kindness, right, And that's I mean, that's the sensitive moments that we have with him and the young women are fascinating to me because he actually makes a case. That's one of the things that this show does is make the case for the sith And that's a treat. It's a treat

Speaker 4to be to be tested like that, the same way we're tested in the wire in saying, what would I do in level if I were Pres in the school system? What would I do if I were faced with this, with this very real constraint in the classroom, how would I choose to solve my immediate classroom problems? Would I do some things that maybe are not necessarily Okay.

Speaker 3I'm trying to figure out where to start. I so yeah, I mean it's like I was gonna say something about MacNulty, but then like Pres has such a strong story right where I think I have to Yeah, go.

Speaker 2Ahead, let me make a thirty second summary. Pres starts out as a police officer. Yeah, it's a complete fuck up. He's not very good at being a police officer. He's there in part because his father in law is very able place in the police. But it turns out he's very good with numbers, so when they stop having him be like on the streets and let him be like the numbers guy, he's good at cracking codes. He helps figure out like the beeper codes that the criminals are using, Like you're really good like the scenes, like you know the tech put Yeah, exactly. He gets put back out

Speaker 2onto the street during a hard situation and winds up shooting someone else who happens to be a black cop, and the police kind of both recognize that he's really screwed up, but again do a like we have to They're both like, we have to, like avenge our rone, we have to protect our own. So he's not brought up in charges, but he's kicked out of the police and he finds himself as a teacher in a school. Starts out incroubly idealistically, realizes how bad that is, and eventually becomes fairly like an effective teacher and a good teacher,

Speaker 2in part because he is much more hard nosed and much more willing to like play around the rules and deal with the kids how they have to be dealt with.

Speaker 3Yeah, basically trying to figure out how he can do what he understands the mission to be within the institution that seems to have largely or completely lost sight of what its purported mission is, right, right, And I think that's kind of true with him as a cop as well. And I think him as a cop is a perfect parallel to the Jedi, because it's basically, like, you know, they're basically saying, Okay, you're a cop, so you're supposed to have a gun and go out and do cop things, and you can do this other kind of detective work,

Speaker 3but because you're a cop, you have a gun and a badge and you go do cop things. And he's terrible at doing gun and badge cop things, but he's actually great at doing I'm in the office detective work, right, research, trying to crack code, stuff like that. And it's like the system, the institution didn't have room to recognize sort of the talents of one of its members and to say, Okay, this guy shouldn't get his gun back. He should never be on the street as a cop with a gun, right,

Speaker 3I mean, you know, and I think a lot of us are maybe like, well, maybe there shouldn't really be cops on the street with guns. But that's a separate thing, right. But here it's like, if you're gonna have cops on the street with guns, he shouldn't be one of them. But that doesn't mean he can't do something else that's vital to the mission. But the system has gotten such an idea of like, oh, well, Jedi have lightsabers, so here's your lightsaber. Go do Jedi things. Whereas like you know, and I mean I know some of them are like librarians in the you know, in the temple or whatever, but like that inability to kind of recognize what an

Speaker 3individual's temperament is, what an individual's strengths are, and finding a role for that person that's that matches their strengths where you can get value out of them. While they are also like basically expressing who they are with their work. They're like doing what they're good at and what they find interesting and you're like no, no, no, but you have to go do this other thing that then they happen to be terrible at and you know ends catastrophically.

Speaker 2Right, And that's actually kind of a perfect thing because I don't even thought of this, but soul, the character we talk about who I think has the in many ways. I think by the end of the show, he has fallen into the dark side. And a part of what the show's really about is that that's not a like again, there's not like a thin line or a thick line. It's a very gradual thing. And it happened like because Saul never becomes a fascist or a libertarian. He's always coming from a very altruistic place, but coming from that by the end, he's willing to like, you know, kill innocent people, or kill at least people who are defenseless

Speaker 2in order to do what he thinks is needed. And we see him at various points though, being a phenomenal teacher of young people, of young of Yenglings, and we see him being incredibly compassionate and able to help people, help Jedi who are kind of losing their way a bit. And and yeah, as they think about it, if they just kept him in the Jedi temple teaching, instead of giving him a lightsaber, instead of giving him this hero complex and sending him out into the world to encounter people like this, Uh, but it's it's kind of awesome

Speaker 2because they're not Dath Mari Doath and Mary, But they're witches. It's another group of witches that is raising these twin girls, and he sees them like in this kind of ceremony that's about honoring their dark side, their force powers, and they're not they're not sif they're not like super evil, but they're definitely willing to play with some of the dark sides of the Force that the Jedi find anathema, and that's what kind of sends him into a panic. And Yeah, I think he's very much a pres in that regard of if they just let him be a teacher, maybe things have worked out a lot better.

Speaker 4Yeah, we're not. We're not like you know I I I raise my kids not to be afraid of words, right, we don't. There was there was no moratorium on you know, profanity in the house, and as a result, my kids learned a lot of words, probably younger than they needed to, and they have a healthy respect for language. It's kind of the same thing that we see on this on this plane, We're gonna teach the kids the powers that they have inside of them. We're going to teach them to use the things they aren't only imbued with good

Speaker 4and evil. Once you do something with them right, and you can't learn what to do with them unless you know what they are. And that runs headlong into the institution of the Jedi at this period in history. And you can see if Matthew what's her name in charge of the Jedi with the blue oh Vanara, you can see her wrestling every sequence with what comes next? Should

Speaker 4I go out into the field, should I come back and wear a bigger robe like what she's constantly wrestling with what she is going to do next to maintain the gentle tension between infrastructure and the agents in the field, the Jedi in the field, and that is a hard line to walk for her.

Speaker 2Venestra, So I got that wrong, Yeah, I think she very much. To me is the Cedric Daniels figure. Seda Daniels is uh. He's the kind of the leader of the main police unit that we follow, and he is willing to break the rules sometimes but also has a healthy respect for like what the mission is, but also fundamentally believes in the goodness of the cops and the idea that you have to protect the cops first so

Speaker 2that the cops can do the mission without being willing to see the fundamental rot that that is there, so that when Presbluski the when we're talking about before he even has the shooting, we talked about how a couple of the cops go into the towers is Harry, they don't understand and they try to exert their authority and it goes nowhere, and there's this teenage kid who's giving them a whole bunch of lip and Presbluski hits him with the butt of his gun and guy was losing an eye, And Seda Daniels the first like he is

Speaker 2clearly very angry at them, both because they screwed up, but also because I think he feels genuine sympathy for this kid, and I think he, as a black cop, has a lot of frustration with white cops who there's a lot of racism and how they treated this. But the first thing he says is Pres Buluski is get your story straight, Like he still has that we have to protect the institution, and you're part of the institution, even though I think you're a fucking idiot. Yeah, And that's Venestra is the one who doesn't go on the missions but winds up kind of here. I'm gonna shift

Speaker 2actual movies for a second. If you think about the ending of The Depoted, forgive me the Departed. I'm gonna spoil the end. It's a fantastic movie. Skip ahead if he haven't seen it yet, but it's like twenty years old, so I feel okay seeing it. You know, part of both that actually, even LA confidential in both institutions, like at the end, the actual story of what happened is ridiculous and complicated and fucked up, so some of the people wind up like lying to sort of say, oh,

Speaker 2it was all this one person's fault. Order to have a story that keeps everything okay. Actually, a like confidential is probably the better comparison of what happens in The Acolyte. Yeah, because that's exactly what Master does. Vannestra figures out what happened. She knows that it was Saul who screwed up, but that a whole bunch of other Jedi took part in it, and instead she kind of just blames it all on Saul, so that it like when she she gives her speech to a few of the senators and actually the Chancellor of the Republic about how this was all Saul and

Speaker 2as she's saying. What I was hearing was, you know, like we're used to with cops that they'll defend their own, but sometimes there's someone like a Derek Chauvin. He was the person who was involved in the killing of the main person involved in the killing of George Floyd, who want the cops will just be like, oh, okay, we're gonna cut that person loose because they were a bad cop. We're not like that. And when Vanestra says this is a rogue Jedi, a Jedi who like isn't like us, I very much heard the cops saying, Derek Chauvin that that's not the institution, that's the bad apple.

Speaker 4He's not us, right, it was that was a way to excize the poison and save her role as part of the infrastructure.

Speaker 3Right, And I think sort of the same happens to make Nulty right at the end of the wire. Yeah, he's kind of the bad apple that everybody forgets when they're using that metaphor that like it spoils the whole bunch. I think is yeah, rest about the whole one bad apple. So saying oh that was just one bad apple, we're good.

Speaker 4Yeah, say the other app right.

Speaker 2Exactly right. They're like, we're not spoiled, we're good, we're good about in time, don't turn us into Clider. And just to add even more context to it, I think the act like works completely on its own as its own show. Frankly, I've heard from a lot of people who aren't Star Wars fans who just see it as a really interesting, like sci fi you know, show about all these kind of complicated issues we're talking about. But if you've read the Higher Republic books, I think it it's even more context because this is all taking place at the end of the Hyder Republic period. The Hydropulic

Speaker 2books are happening over a long period long time, much earlier in this about sixty to eighty years before the events of the Acolyte. Because Vernestro is from a species I think it's named, I'm not sure what it is, though she's entirely green as you pointed out, and her species ages much has a much longer lifespan. She's part of a series of events in the High Republic. We're basically because of failings of the Senate and of human

Speaker 2government and of the government of non force believer force users. The whole Republic comes close to being destroyed and taken over by these horrible forces, and it's a Jedi who have to save them. And it really is a sort of like like, I can very much understand that Binestra could go through that and come to the belief that no one will ever understand the Jedi. Everyone will always doubt us, but we are the only ones who can save us, you know, that real kind of chip on her shoulder of it has to be us and if

Speaker 2they don't, if they don't trust us, well that's not our fault. We just have to do it anyway. M hm.

Speaker 4Yeah, it's it's interesting to be I did not know that about her and her lifespan and that she comes from this era that actually it fills in a hole for me that I think I've always believed. My head canon was that, you know, we're we need to go all the way back to when the Jedi were just like six people who realize they can move stuff with their minds and kind of convince each other to order pizza when they didn't want to or something like that, like when they were a gang, you know, and they

Speaker 4were like, hey, we could use our gangly powers for good. Or we could use them for evil and they start recruiting. That's what That's what I kind of want to see, like who was the first Jedi Jedi?

Speaker 1Day?

Speaker 4And and let's go, let's go back to the beginning here. We already we have an impressive infrastructure that is so effortlessly tested, uh and already so inoculated by that whole vibe of we have to protect our own. We are not above we are the high Republic, and yet we are not above protecting our own at the cost of one right that it's it's it's still gross.

Speaker 2Right, you know well, And I do think that that's where I made the joke of at Acab versus a jab. I do think that here's where the metaphor breaks down somewhat, because you know, for anyone who really knows the history with policing in this country, there's always been the idea that they're there to serve and protect and all that. And I do think a lot of individual police officers do have that motivation in their hearts, at least at the start, and maybe some actually get through it to the end and hold on hold on to that idea too.

Speaker 2I think, though a lot less but it did start out as an organization to catch runaway slaves, like there's always been some massive problems baked into the institution. I think it's entirely possible the Jedi started from a much more altruistic place like union, like a lot of unions did, though a lot of unions started out very corrupt, right uh, you know, And same with the school system, same with any of it.

Speaker 4Reference the Wire season two, Yeah.

Speaker 2Exactly the whys and and what what what? I think the Jedi don't have at this point, but I'm sure they eventually wind up having. And Plocun I think is a good example of this is the cop. Well, Plokun is the most extreme example. But the cops in the Wire do have people who are no longer at all interested in their overall mission. They're interested in protecting their own position or rising up in the ranks, you know,

Speaker 2or in one situation, getting someone who they think has dishonored them because they get a stained glass window in a church. Like really, in the entire season is driven by one man's ego, because the dock workers Union gets a stained glass window in one church instead of the Policeman's Union. It's it's that petty and I kind of feel like we don't have that with a Jedi yet, but we can totally see it going in that direction.

Speaker 4But we also have the same question that we're asking of the Jedi and the police, like is it okay to give somebody a job and ask them to be a savior of all that is good and a protector of those in need that is also a capitalist unit of measure? Right, Like, they are not superheroes and neither are Jedi.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4That's the thing that that I think this show endeavors to pull apart is these people are not superheroes. They make mistakes, and when they do, how does how does the the what are the antibodies? Systemic antibodies that take care of that? The police are? They are fallible and wonderful, and the show pulls apart the frustration that exists for individuals of good intent to try to exist in an

Speaker 4organization and discover that it's impossible to exist with sustainable good intent because of what we've done.

Speaker 3Yeah, Like I would argue that that McNulty isn't necessarily motivated by altruism, Like he's got a thing he wants to do, which is like you know, like he likes solving crimes, Like he wants to solve murders. That's what he wants to do. And like maybe that's because why he became a cop, and being a cop gave him it, you know, a way to do that or maybe who knows why, But like each person really does have their Yeah, the people who did become cops in the wire chose

Speaker 3to one way or another right, whether it was you know, to protect and serve, or whether it was like, oh, that has a pretty good pension after I put in my twenty or thirty years.

Speaker 4Or whatever, or my dad and his dad and his dad before him were all a cops.

Speaker 3Right, exactly exactly. The Jedi I think are different in that they are superheroes. I would argue, like literally, like they have superpowers within this world. But it's like everybody with a superpower being this is kind of a little like Marvel Civil War kind of stuff, but like basically being told by the government or by some organization which is a kind of a non governmental body. However, the Jedi work compared to you know, the rest of the

Speaker 3Republic basically, oh, you have to sign up with us, family and then do this thing that is more like policing fair enough or you have to never use your powers and then like they become super villains, right, and so like there's no agency in becoming a Jedi, right. One is basically made at one's born with their forced

Speaker 3sensitivity and then they're essentially turned into a Jedi by the institution. And that seems extra problematic, you know, compared to like, couldn't there just be some people who have force powers and they just like use them to build things faster? You know, like is that not an absurd thing?

Speaker 2Like yeah, And there's actually a great scene in The Acolyte where what I like at the show is very rarely saying we, as a narrator can tell you here's the way the Force really works. It's a lot of different people giving their perspective, and they're all unreliable narrators. But at one point when the darkseyde User, I'm not positive as a Sieth And that's a whole other conversation for another time. But he's talking with Osha, the person who was trying to be a Jedi who saw who

Speaker 2Saw rescued but now is thinking about joining him, and you know, he talks about how he left the Jedi, and she says, well, but don't you lose your powers if you don't train them with the Jedi. And he says, that's what the Jedi want you to think, you know that specifically that he's kind of pointing out, like, yeah, the Jedi claimed and here's tying it in. Remember Luke Skywalker saying the Jedi claimed they had a monopoly on the Force. And what he's kind of saying is, actually, you can be a Force user if you leave the Jedi, but no one ever does because they convince you that's

Speaker 2not true. And do we actually know that's very that it is possible for everyone, or that he's kind of special. We don't, but at least raised the question in a way I love.

Speaker 4Well, it's it's funny going down this road because it's you know, relative to the universe that these properties exist. Force powers are the authority that are given to these people and for their organization, and what authority is given to the police, right that, given the protection of the laws of the land, weapons they get, guns they get.

Speaker 2They have the monopoly on legal violence.

Speaker 4They have them. Great, that's a great way to put it. If you take away the word legal then what we have is a much more capitalist clash between the guys who also have authority in their culture. Right, They've created their own the drug culture, and we get a great view of that, and we get a great view of how these guys do their work. And it's full of violence, but it's also full of a lot of payroll, and and their power is in their guns and who has the bigger guns? And so you know, to what extent

Speaker 4do these do? Do we are we left to question the value in exerting authority over others by way of these artificial tools, is I think a principal question for the Wire in particular.

Speaker 2Yeah, Paul, what's kind of your take on the way it looks institutions in terms of way it looks at like the gangs led by people like Stringer Bell and then Marlo Stanfield and others like that.

Speaker 3Yeah, I mean those are institutions too, right, They're just not institutions on paper in the same way, but you know.

Speaker 2They almost become that. But then Stringer stops him from taking minutes of a criminal.

Speaker 3Right, Yes, yes, that's true.

Speaker 4Do you ever think like Stringers, like man, I wish we could take minutes?

Speaker 2Yes, god meeting of drug dealers run according to Roberts rules of order. Yeah, and this guy don't take minutes and he's like, no.

Speaker 3Yeah, wait till we go fully legit and then you could take minutes. But like you know, di'angelo, he's running a tower or something, right, and then he messes up and by which I mean he murders someone and gets seen doing it, and then you know, they they fixed the situation. So he gets off. He doesn't he doesn't go to jail for that. But oh wait, or does he No, right, he doesn't go to prison. He doesn't get convicted.

Speaker 2But he was on bail in jail for like nine months. Yeah, he's found not guilt, waiting trial.

Speaker 3Right, right, and then he gets demoted. You know, he gets demoted because he did a bad job of protecting the institution, because he did public violence in a way that brought the heat basically, right, It's like they don't really care if you shoot someone and it does it and somebody's just dead. They care that now the police care, right, and they particularly care. The more the police care, the more they care. And you know, and they also have

Speaker 3like there's the end of season one when webey basically takes the rap for just every murdy. He's like, oh, yeah, I did that one too, I did that one. No, that one was little man. But he's dead, you know, like and he's protecting the institution, and they're basically selling him out as like one bad apple almost, I mean not literally, because parties view their institution as a legitimate institution. But they're basically basically saying, no, he's responsible for all the bad things you're gonna you know, give us a

Speaker 3hassle about. But that's actually a you know, he's getting a nice severance package kind of thing, because like he's getting life anyway. But and so he gets someone to you know, be able to feed his fish and everything.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3But but that you know, that's even when kind of being sold out by the institution, he's still protecting the institution because there's still like value for him to be gained, you know, to get there. The same way you know, the cops might somebody might be fire, but they like they still might end up with a pension, right, they still might get some kind of severance. Maybe sometimes they don't obviously in rare cases.

Speaker 2But yeah, it just well, and one thing I think that I'm really struck by with with those two stories of Webay and D'Angelo is that in both cases, participation in these criminal organizations is baked into their families. Like DiAngelo gets caught and doing a mission for Barksdale and he's ready to turn over to the police in part because he kind of hates what he's been having to do and he like seeing just the damage that the work he's doing is causing and people getting killed. He's

Speaker 2ready to get out. And it's his own mother who goes to him and convinces him to take the heat, to take the years, and eventually he winds up being killed in prison, and the mother is like, no, you have to do this, in part because she's used to this very cultural lifestyle that she knows will be taken away. In Webay's case, his own son is still living with Webay's act we as actually current partner, I think wife or at least you know, his girl. Around the way is the phrase that's used in this all the time,

Speaker 2and the mother is saying to the son like, you got to go out and bang on those corners. We need to have a better family lifestyle, and Webay actually helps to break it. Because he winds up like working with this great and some other people that like, help we bake it out of that kind of a situation. But overall, yeah, it's it's a very similar kind of thing. And like one thing that I think to me, one of my favorite connections between the two is that, you know, you've got Cedric Daniels and others having to work with Presboluski,

Speaker 2who they eventually find a use for, but at first it's like, ah, he's the bosses whatever, we got to deal with him. And then you've got people like Proposition Joe who have to deal with this idiot guy because it's his cousin's you know, I think it's his wife's cousin or something like that. Or you know, it's like there are a couple people in the criminal organization who have these same family connections, and there are a couple of moments where the cops and the criminals are dealing with each other and realizing they're having the exact same frustrations in their various institutions. And sometimes the moments are very poignant, sometimes they're hilariously funny, but they're really kind

Speaker 2of show like the same institutional thing happens in both places.

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean it's it's a Godfather story too, right, Like it's this it's the same thing like family, crime, family and police family. I like the LA confidential reference, Like all of these are we we all, we're all in it together. We all have the same problems, the untouchables. Right, there's another great story of of you know, crime has made us a family and an organization and an institution, and quote unquote legitimate institutions are just going to have to find their way to navigate that, just as we

Speaker 4have to navigate them.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4I love that I put myself in the we position of organized crime. I may regret that.

Speaker 2I thought I'm not supposed to tell you, but the kickbacks have to pay, right.

Speaker 3So DiAngelo is basically like a young kid who's like forced to be a Jedi, and it just it doesn't work out very well because like he wasn't really meant to be a Jedi, Like doesn't really, I mean, you know Jedi and I've never.

Speaker 2Made the connection, but you're right, like all the kids who we see who are growing up in this world, where as they understand it, you know, hitting the corners and then rising up the criminalizations is their only option. Yeah. Yeah, it's very much like the the Young Wings becoming Padawans.

Speaker 4He's really in speaking directly to the acolyte. He is May and Osha. Right, They both, for different reasons, were disregarded by the Jedi establishment. One fleshed out, one never got it and got alt training.

Speaker 2But I'm trying to remember the name of we based kid. It's nay More, I think, or name on something like that.

Speaker 4Oh, that's good, it's not.

Speaker 2I think it's name on name on.

Speaker 4Yeah, that's right, that's right. Yeah.

Speaker 3I want to just like comment on how hilarious it is that there's a Star Wars character named Osha given their complete lack of work workplace safety.

Speaker 2That that comment was made on a number of occasions.

Speaker 3And literally the first time she shows up, she's in a very unsafe work situation.

Speaker 2Right, yes, yeah, the first few minutes of it, did I did? Yeah?

Speaker 4Yeah, that's so good.

Speaker 2That is wonderful. What you've got a little while on this are any of the last comments for Pete for you, any of the last things you want to bring up, sort of like the succession about how putting these two shows in conversation for each other what they bring.

Speaker 4Up, Well, it's I I guess it's it's an interesting putting it in the parlance of The Wire. The Acolyte is an interesting I don't know what would what would the commercial say, an unflinching look at at urban life in the High Republic, And and I think they I think they've done something really unique with that show to to ground the Star Wars universe in a much more modern human reality that makes it more approachable, more relatable

Speaker 4than some of the other properties, just by you know, giving us some of these elements of you know, that we've learned about through our exploration of the Wire and these these sort of crime families. I think it's it's really fascinating, and you know, illustrating the struggle between individuals and institutions is table stakes, you know, for for these kinds of properties.

Speaker 2Like one of the things I think that really highlighted for me. I have often talked about my frustration that Obi Wan isn't willing to deliver the killing blow to take out Anakin once and for all, and he's now with a new Obi Wan show. Has had two opportunities to do this and didn't do it either time and the way this show. I don't think we'd ever heard it named before in such a specific way that it is a Jedi tenant that you do not kill and unarmed. If you know someone who is unarmed that you you just don't do that. And hearing that play, hearing that explained,

Speaker 2and seeing Saul wrestle with that, I think also gives me a better Like I still think Obi Wan's wrong, but at least now I better understand he's like he's kind of the one good cop in the broken institution. Again, there're no know one is broken, as there are a lot of good cops in the Jedi. There's a lot of good cops in the Jedi and it, you know, and there are some decent people who are cops. But also, like I made the joke, I don't think a jab applies the way a cap does what I definitely think that like this this show helped me to much better

Speaker 2understand Obi Wan in those moments, even if I disagree with him.

Speaker 4It's interesting. I'm sorry, Paul, go ahead, Oh.

Speaker 3Just I was just gonna say that if he's been given a hard and fast rule, like it's it's harder to do something that violin it's a hard and fast role that you've been since childhood.

Speaker 2Yeah, it makes you kind of wish the Star Wars had Arkham. Like Arkham doesn't hold people for long, but at least Batman doesn't like, you know, knock the Joker down, prevent his plan and then just walk away. Can effort to put Joker in a situation where it's like you're not going to screw anything else up. There's like at least this, Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 4So I think this is I think this is really just as we wrap up, really interesting that the sort of institutional influence in the Wire, it's there. The institutions are, particularly in the later seasons season two, the Union's schools, educational boards, the media self serving, resistant to change, betraying the individual. The acolyte. Institutions are flawed and fallible, like the Jedi Order is totally susceptible to institutional rigidity, right, and moral failure, failure that the David Simon is like

Speaker 4on the record as saying, I'm going all in on talking about the moral compromise that individuals have to make in complex institutions. And these are harsh realities and that's gonna be it. It's going to be a noted cynical approach to the argument of whether large scale institutional reform is even possible. And I'm curious your take on the idea of cynicism in The Acolyte. Like, at the end of The Acolyte, do you get the sense that Leslie

Speaker 4Headland is presenting a cynical view of the world of the Acolyte or because for me, as soon as the show pivots to be more explorational of the dark side, there's kind of less cynicism in the show. I'm curious your take on that.

Speaker 2I don't think it is anywhere near a cynical as the Wire. What I think it's saying that the starting place of Star Wars of there is clear good and evil in the universe, and there's a light side and a dark side, and there's good guys in bad SyES. And yes, it is possible for a good guy to become a bad guy if they've give into negative emotions. As long as they don't get they're going to stay a good guy. That that world is far that there's

Speaker 2there can be far more nuance in the world. I think the nuance can often be seen as cynicism. And I actually push back a little bit, and I think that there is I think the Wire isn't cynical necessarily, It's very realistic. But I think it's constantly trying to say that there is hope, that are good people trying to do their best in these institutions, but that yeah, we unless we look at the institutions themselves, nothing's ever going to change. But yeah, there is a hell of a cynicism in that. I think, though with the Acolyte

Speaker 2it's not I don't think it's anywhere close to that. I think it's just more the idea of you have to look at these things as much more complex and that there can be forgetting. This is probably the most direct spoiler going to give, but I think it's a vital point to it the show. One of the climactic scenes of the show is Osha Force choking a helpless, weaponless soul to death, and we're kind of rooting her on when it happens, and we know this her turning

Speaker 2in the dark side. We literally see like the one of those beautiful shots I've ever seen. We see like right down the barrel of her lightsaber and see the crystal turn red and then see her blade turn red because it's been corrupted by this act she's done. And it's not like, oh, yes, in a perfect world, I want you to do that, But that kind of like anti hero. I don't believe in the death penalty, but when I watch someone brutally kill a terrible, terrible person on screen, I'm kind of going to root for it.

Speaker 4See how they get there.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, that's kind of how I felt when this person who had her life destroyed by this man who thought he was helping but was basically an eighteenth century social worker. I was kind of rooting for her, and then I had to asked myself, what the fuck is wrong with me? I just rooted for someone to use the force choke.

Speaker 4Yeah, as you tried.

Speaker 2But I think that's I think that's what makes the show so good is it really makes us challenge ourselves in terms of this, like is good and evil this clear and simple and possible?

Speaker 4That I see less cynicism in that natural turn, because it felt like a natural turn, and the end of the wire does not offer me that much hope. Right, everything falls apart and we are back to status quo. I think the name of the show the Wire. I think they actually get usable evidence from a wire, like once in season three. I think there's a big celebration, like the wire generally fails. Everybody's always listening to each other. So like even the entire conceit of five years of

Speaker 4this show is met with cynicism in there in aptitude on all parties.

Speaker 2That's fair, Paul.

Speaker 3Slot, Yeah, I I only sort of see the Why is that cynical? I mean I feel like I generally consider myself a cynical optimist, by which I mean I think everything's super messed up. It's very likely to remain so, but it doesn't have to, right, Like, there are possibilities, and so I don't think hope and cynicism are necessarily antithetical,

Speaker 3you know, Like I think you can kind of survey what's going on and not think it's great, but not necessarily despair, right. And I think a lot of the characters in The Why. No. I think a small number of the characters in The Wire kind of have that viewpoint, and a larger number have the kind of you know, I've I've given up and I'm just now fulfilling my purpose within my institution in order mostly just to maintain

Speaker 3my own status quo. Right, there's just a few characters who have legitimate ambition, you know, little Finger or or mayor Karketti or whatever from LA. Right, Yeah, I think his name is supposed to be like that anyway. But it's it's definitely like a lot of people are just kind of going along. They're just like it's I feel like it's about inertia almost as much as anything, you know,

Speaker 3and and I mean with with Baltimore, it's about there's inertia and then there's there's decay, you know, because the city has has it used to be a big shipping port. It's not anymore. Right, things have changed, but the city hasn't necessarily changed along with them in a way that that benefits its residents. There's an LA Confidential quote that I think kind of perfectly captures this sort of like resignation and sort of just going along kind of inertia.

Speaker 3And it comes from Jack Vincenz, the Kevin Spacey character, when Edmond Esley asks him, that's the guy Peer's character. He asks him, you know, why did you become a cop and he just says, I don't remember. Yeah, And it's just it just hits because it's like, here's a guy who's all, you know, he's this like fancy cop who's like a consultant on a TV show, and he finally kind of gets this, like I'm going to try and solve this one case, mostly so that he gets

Speaker 3kind of reinstated in his previous you know, so he gets to run a tower again instead of just you know, being in the in the pit. But but it's just like he's he's lost sight of whatever it was that motivated him in the first place, right, which is the opposite of Edmond Exley, who's you know, he's got Rollo Tomassi. He's got this backstory that's super clear. He knows exactly why he became a cop quote unquote what he thinks is right. And he would you would never shoot an

Speaker 3unarmed person in the back just because he knew they were guilty and they would get away with it. And you know, spoilers, maybe he does.

Speaker 2Yeah, so it.

Speaker 3Actually sounds like a fairly and and and maybe we root for him to do so you.

Speaker 2Know, yeah, well that's fantastic. And pat was any of the last things you wanted to add in terms of this conversation or kind of where you take your thoughts. I will say, as bonus content, we're gonna ask Paul if this is me the acolyte sounds with something he does or doesn't want to see. I have a guess on it. But we're gonna do all that in the bonus content, which by the way, you can get if you become a member. It's for only five dollars a month or fifty five dollars a year. You get access to the bone content that's at the end of all of our episodes. You get access to bonus member episodes.

Speaker 2We just did one on the book Darth Plagis, which is actually quite relevant to this TV show. And most importantly though, I think you just helped keep the lights on. We are trying to as go the cynical fundraising roots of some of the police and unions and other things like that in the wire. We just want to get it from all fans and other kind of support like that. So just five dollars a month, it helps us to we're currently upgrading all of our audio equipment. It helps keep Pete off my back begging me to, you know, do more of these things. Just helps us to literally keep the lights on and It's a great way to

Speaker 2show your support. We also love your feedback. We'd love to hear your thoughts on this. Does this connection make any sense to you? Are we completely off our rockers and sho go back to just talking about Star Wars? Let us know what you think. All the ways to contact us are in the show notes, as is how to become a member for again, only five dollars a year. With that, Paul though, any last thoughts from you?

Speaker 3Yeah, if we get enough members, can can we get like a stained glass window for.

Speaker 4Yeah, the glass podcast window?

Speaker 2Absolutely yes, let's do it right now. Us and the totally awesome eighties podcasts are gonna have a rivalry with one of us gets to put the staining glass window on the True Story FM next Real podcast website. Yeah.

Speaker 3My last thought is basically just that I think a show like The Wire works so well because while it has these huge overarching ideas that it really wants to communicate and explore, it does that through characters who feel like real people and just instantly they just feel like a person in just a moment. And the you know, the the one Star Wars thing that really did reach

Speaker 3that level for me was and or where every character just like they're on screen for a few minutes and they just feel like a person somehow. And it's what I.

Speaker 2Would call.

Speaker 3Seemingly effortless writing, which I know is not actually so effortless, you know. And so I think when a show is trying to say really big things, I think the most effective way to communicate those big things is to really get the small things right and to really have the people feel like people. And when they do, then those other things can come through in a way that doesn't feel forced. It doesn't feel like the purpose of this character is to do this thing. And I think too

Speaker 3many screenplays tend to treat their characters the way the institutions in The Wire and perhaps the Acolyte treat their members.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think that's a fantastical point. I've always said that one of my favorite characters, if not my favorite character on The Wire, is one whose name, the actor's name, is never in the credits because he's never a main character. It's Prop Joe. He's this kind of like side character of a different dealer, but who just has such a He's so like all. I think one thing that makes The Wire so great is is never dealing with stereotypes, because it introduces you to thirty different cops, and thirty different drug dealers, and thirty different teachers and thirty different journalists, all of who have their own different individual take on things and their own idiosyncrasies and own quirks. And I

Speaker 2think that is one of the strengths of the Wire as well. Is sorry, I think it's one of the strengths of the Acolyte as well. Is that we get five Jedi who are involved in what happens, each of whom, with one very notable exception, they still haven't figured out how to make a Wookie and live action being a character other than Chewbacca. But the other four each has a very different motivation for how they become part of this plot, and I fully believe each of them, and each of them feels to me like a fully realized character.

Speaker 1Nice.

Speaker 2Yeah, all right, well that thank you all so much. As I said, members, stick around if you want to become a member. These discussions can be particularly fun. It's twenty five dollars a month. All information is in the show notes. But for everyone else, thank you all so much for listening. Please share this with your friends. Please send us feedback. We have spoken

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode