Join hosts Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan as they dive deep into the first three episodes of Star Wars: The Bad Batch, season three. They analyze key plot points, discuss character arcs and development, explore major themes, and speculate on what's to come in the rest of the season. Whether you're a diehard Star Wars fan or just enjoy compelling storytelling, this episode offers insight that will leave you eagerly anticipating the next episodes.Key Questions Discussed: How did Omega and Crosshair end up imprisoned and what is their dynamic like now? What do the experiments at Hemlock's lab imply about Palpatine’s motivations regarding cloning technology? How does the horror vibe of the vine planet tie into larger themes of scientific amorality in the show? What does Emery's perspective reveal about the complex power dynamics under oppression? Does Omega’s compassion for Crosshair and Emery reveal a character flaw or moral strength? Other Topics Covered: Speculation about Omega’s origins and Force sensitivity Analysis of villains like Dr. Hemlock and their detachment from consequences The emotional significance of the Bad Batch being split up Importance of clone identity and found family in the show How the squad’s coordinated escape plan connects them despite past conflict Clone aging and the introduction of young clone characters We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, and welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. My name is Matthew Fox. I'm one of your hosts. I'm joined today by Aaron McGowan, another one of my co hosts here on Star Wars Generations, and today we are talking about the Bad Batch Season three episodes one through three. We did another recording of this a few days ago, but we had some audio problems and we decided we rebably want to give you a top notch episode, so we're coming back to you today. And well, many of you are going to listen to this on a podcast, and so we'll probably never notice this not only a recording video that's going to go off on various
channels the next few days. We are live streaming this, so if you are finding it on the live stream, that's awesome. We didn't really let anyone know. We kind of want to let this just kind of test out to see who gets notified and who wants to jump in. But if you do see it, if you do want to jump in, please let us know and please ask questions as we go, because we'd love to have you part. So with that, let's just kind of kick off the conversation erin the bad Batch talk to us about season one and season two, like what this show had meant to you, and how are you feeling going into this these first episodes? That is a big question. But the bad Batch to
me, season one was the revival of Clone Wars. Like as much as Rebels is kind of a rival of Clone Wars, it's not like I see Clone Wars and Rebels as very different shows, but the bad Batch felt like the Clone Wars and it's probably because of the similar animation style, Like I'm sure they did that very intentionally speaking of the animation is just stunning all three seasons so far, but season one it kind of just tells a story of this squad of extra special Clones after Order sixty six and how their inhibitor chips
didn't work. So season one they end up escaping the Empire and kind of being on the run for a little bit. They also escape with this young girl clone named Omega. Anyway, so season one was just a really great like introductory. It got us introduced to all the characters, gave us some deep dives on a few of them, like Hunter and Omega. We had a lot of fun like chase, scenes, battles, and it kind of overall was just about like family and like the building of the bond that is their squad. So then season two we get a look into Crosshair in the
Empire, because so far season one he was just trying to hunt down the rest of the Batch. Now we're seeing what it's like to be in the Empire. And so we have some really great episodes of really great characters from that. We get to see Commander Cody again, we get to see Howser again, and we get to see Captain may Day Commander may Day on the title. But yeah, we got some really great clones and to see how the Empire is affecting them. We got the arc with Rio Chucci about like
clones that are defecting from the Empire and what's kind of happening to them. And of course we just got some lovely stuff with the Batch. And then it ended with a gut punch that was TeX's death. Yeah, yeah, and here we are the beginning of season three. I think you're very right, and I love the way you phrased it, especially in terms of like how this and Rebels line up to that line, how this and Rebels line up to the Clone Wars, because I think part of what I love about
the show so much is it kind of takes on the best aspects of both. I think you're right that it is more of a sequel to the Clone Wars than Rebels ever was the animation style, the focus on the Clone character is much more, the use of the Force is almost completely non existent, although the Force as a plot aspect is becoming a major thing. But in the Clone Wars as much, you know, it is about the people fighting the Clone Wars, and often the Clones are the Shock Troops and the Foot
Soldiers, but there's a lot of Jedi and a lot of lightsabers and a lot of force using. So in many ways this feels very similar. But also like Rebels is all about found family, Rebels is all about a small group of people trying to make a difference, whereas the Clone Wars basically it's about a whole galaxy spanning war and every story we're jumping around to different characters all throughout the galaxy, and so I kind of feel like this is taking a lot of the best parts of what made Rebels so good and no saying
let's do that, but in a much more Clone focused story. Yeah, definitely, I would agree, because it's like, like you're saying, the Clone Wars was just everywhere, it's different people, different family groups, different friend groups, different species everything, and then Rebels was very centered on the one Found family. And then I feel like bad Batch is exploring the idea of Found family within like almost like a biological family. Yeah, because it's like they are all obviously brothers and they treat each other as such, but
after Order sixty six things kind of change, and so it's like and they have that conflict through all of these seasons about well, I don't want to kill REGs, like I don't want to kill clones working for the Empire, Like those are still our brothers even though they're not. They don't agree with us, and they're trying to kill us. Like it's just this interesting like divergence. Yeah, because it's the brotherhood we were introduced to in the Clone Wars and just like the bad Batch is tearing it apart and like diving into
Clones, which is everything I've ever wanted. I love clones. All I want to talk about is clones. Yeah. Yeah, and we're getting their stories told in such interesting ways, especially because if the Clone Wars, I mean, it's much more militaristic than anything else Star Wars to put out because it's part it is about the military and the soldiers in it and all the sort of interesting and difficult questions and challenges that they face. This now is about what happens when we're trying to decommission soldiers, when soldiers are being pushed out, and when in this case, you know you signed up to work
for one government. Well, in the Clones, they never signed up. They were just basically slave soldiers, but they were loyal to a particular kind of government. And now that's gone, and now you know, it's all about the empires that are republic None of them want to support that, and one of them has had changing loyalties and that's what we're exploring now. Yeah, So with all that in mind, what do you think of these first three episodes? Uh, it was like, well, it was a lot of mixed emotions. So I've been incredibly busy and overstressed lately, so being
able to sit down and watch a new episode of The Bad Batch was just like, ugh, like a breath of fresh air was so exciting. And then we actually get into the episodes, and the first episode confined No Fresh Air to breathe yea kind of depressing. It's just showing where Omega and Crosshair are at in Tantis, which is the Laboratory research station. Yeah, and Crossing is like a prisoner. She's you know, like a quote quote lab assistant. She's also a prisoner, but they're just having her do things because
Naalisse wants her there and so was a very the episode was set up really interesting, like we had the start of the day happened like four maybe five times, where it's the same start to every day and we see a little bit of Omega's day and it's the same thing. She goes to bed and it starts the exact same way every single day. And that type of storytelling is just so interesting because it like it accentuates the gravity of time passing,
right. It's not just like, oh, we're gonna tell you it's been a long time, which they do also tell you in later episodes of the premiere, but like they're not gonna say, oh, oh, Mega, you've been here for this many days, but like just seeing how into the routine and like almost submissive she was in the first day that we see her, and then seeing that day after day after day, and we just know it's like, by the time we first see her, she's been here for a while. By the time we get towards where she starts to crack, she's been here a long time. And so, yeah, I really really
liked the way that episode was set up, and it gave us, you know, a check in on Emory and a lessay and doctor Hemlock, and it gave us the little bit of character building with Batcher, which is the round so cute that she named it Batcher. She just like needs a little something of her brothers to hold on to, and it's not like, yeah, we see also she makes like a little doll out of Hay or whatever here, but she doesn't name the doll that because, as we see later in the episode, Emery and the Clone commandos are just to take it away,
like she's not allowed to have personal items. But the idea that this is a lurk a hound, it's my job to feed them. Nobody hears me say this name. Nobody knows like the name of the dogs other than me. Nobody cares to name the dogs. And it's like a private and special and relatively constant thing that she can turn to. And I just thought that was really sweet. Yeah, I mean, I think going back to what you said about the kind of montage at the start, one of the things I think is so powerful about it is it shows how much this is
designed to drive the fight out of you because it's so monotonous, it's so mundane. I mean, think about the worst kind of like you know, punch in, punch out, do the exact same thing to make a widget or to serve someone or whatever that you do at a job, and this is that, you know, times a thousand, and it really says I think a lot about her character that even in that situation, two different parts of her character can keep coming through. One is her just general like love and compassion and curiosity about the world around her and the creatures around her,
and that's Batcher and that some of the others, and the other is and this is kind of like the love but also just goes so much more about family that she continues to have that love for all of her brothers because in the prison with her is Crosshair. Crosshair is the member of the original Bad Batch group who for various reasons that have been discussed at length. I'm sure we'll get into more as these episodes go on. Did follow Order sixty six at a time that the rest of this particular squad, for like, because
the chips are malfunctioning, but also because of who they were, they didn't, and so he believed they should have been following orders. That there's a chance the bad batch had to kill a paddle on Jedi and they didn't, but he thinks they should have, and that he thinks that when the higher up said bring in Omega, that they should have done that. And Crosshair has directly tried to kidnap Omega and basically bring her in to jail in prison and being a laborat and she has even now, she has so much compassion
for him, and she goes to him and wants to help cheer him up and wants to make his day better and wants to help him escape. And he at least is past that point of wanting to like work for the Empire, but he's just fundamentally broken. He keeps saying to her, like, you should don't waste your time on a hopeless lost causes like me, I have a quote here from that moment, please go for it, you know. So it was so good. So Crosshair said, don't risk anything for me. I belong in here, and Omega said, none of us belong
in here. Yeah, which is just a portrayal of the exact thing you were saying. Yeah, No, that says it so perfectly. And by the end, she has given him some hope and together they're trying to escape. And I imagine that the reunion with the rest of the bad Batch is going to be very tense at times, and that, you know, I can't predict it exactly, but I would guess that she's probably the one who is some of the best reasons to be fearful this guy, to not trust him. But she's going to be kind of the peacemaker and she's gonna be
one saying like, hey, remember you're all brothers, because she's Omega and she's exactly what they all need. It is it is. We did learn something else about her in these episodes, something that we've wondered for a long time. Erin you want to explain what we learned, Oh, I was thinking of something completely different. I think, are you talking about the m count. Yeah, we learned that she has a high m count, which presumably is Medichlorians. They seem afraid to say that name, as though just
saying m count will somehow fool us. But I think it is now canonical that she is for sensitive. It doesn't mean she's a Jedi, means she has like real strong force powers. So I think we've seen the very basic latent force powers in her character already, but it has now been confirmed that's why she can do the crazy things she can do. She is for sensitive and that that's obviously something that matters. Yeah, definitely, real quick. When you asked if there was something we've been wondering about that I wanted to
share, I thought you meant the ponytail, because I've been wondering if she has a ponytail, and she does, and it's so cute. As to the m count, they did fool me for like ten to fifteen minutes with the mcount thing because I just wasn't paying attention to it. I was kind of ignoring it, and then I was like, wait a minute, they're talking about Medichlorian's right now. But yeah, like you said, I think it means nothing about her being a Jedi. It doesn't mean that she's going to start using force powers or wielding a lightsaber, but it does explain how
she can pick things up so quickly basically, And how do you think she came about? Like so Na Leisa created her? Is that we agree on that, right? Why do you think did that? Let me back up a bit and talk about this holiday of m Count. And first I want to say that Alex Korman, who's our third third host, we had to switch things around to re record, he couldn't be here. He was really
excited about this m count stuff and I'm very sad he's not here. I think he makes a very good case for why. From some perspectives, this is really great storytelling and a story he really wants to know more about. He's been on record and some of our other stuff getting ready for Generations, started getting ready for the Bad Batch. How interested he is in how it was that all the cloning thing happened to eventually create you know, possibly Snoke and definitely Palpatine by rise of Skywalker. And I am so glad that he
is excited for that, and I'm really looking forward to hearing him talk about that more. Yeah, definitely we actually we had a really great conversation. Are you okay just getting into Sidious right now a little bit? Yeah? Sure, okay, because we did get the good Oh yeah, I was just gonna say, he's excited to see the Mediclorian count stuff because he loves Darcidius thinks he was the perfect villain for all three trilogies. I'm not sure one hundred percent agree with that, but I love Alex for who he is.
But he was just saying how he's always pondered and wondered on that and thought about Palpatine so deeply as a characters, especially because he read Darth plagis right, Yesagius, And he just had this fascination about who Sidious was and like his personality traits and like what drove him really and so like this is really satisfying that itch in Alex's brain and probably a lot of people's brain. And now Alex put it in perspective. For me, I'm also kind of
wondering about it, like, yeah, why did Sidius pursue making clones and Alex. Alex's idea was that he is so afraid of death. Yeah, and I think one idea that came up as part of that conversation. Is that it makes sense in part because and this granted we get a lot from that book Darth Plagus, but also from some other sources, both in the original, extended and now the Disney canon, is that up till now, for the last thousand years since Darth Bain, every Sith has wanted to live
as much as they could. But it's also felt like they were part of the grand plan, and that you know, Bain didn't think what happened in his lifetime, most of them didn't think what happened in their lifetimes. That everybody was always like, I'm going to move the ball as far down the field as I can in my time, and then someone else will keep going. By the time we get to city, it's over. He has finalized the plan, they've taken over, the Sith have won, and it kind of feels like he wants to therefore just put a stop on history at that point. And so, yeah, him wanting to live forever, I think
is phenomenal. And I feel like I was just gonna say, because like in his mind, his master plan, the little puppeteers he's been puppeting for the entire first two trilogies, like or sorry, the entire prequel trilogy, until he forms the empire, like it's all come to fruition, and now he just he viewed that as the perfect world, the perfect empire that would have like peace and happiness in the galaxy, and he's like, this is perfect and it needs to be maintained. Therefore, I need to live forever
because there's no way this infrastructure could work without me. And it's just like a very interesting mindset, exactly. And I promise all these is eventually getting back to your question of why was Omega created the way she was? What I was gonna say about it is I think those questions of why does Citius want to do this and how do others feel about the cloning process is great and I'm excited to see that explored. I really want to know, for example, does Darth Vader know about this project, because on the one hand,
I think it'd be very hard to keep it secret from him. On the other I think Sidias has a very good reason I want to keep it secret from him, in part because this might be about cloning Anakin's replacement one day. If he thinks he needs to do that, or he's concerned that Anakin might want to clone Palpatine's replacement. You know, I mean, there's' just so much all the the sith backstatting, loyalty fights that have always been a part of their history. That's a really complicated issue. The issue why does Palatine want to do this? And how do the other commanders feel about that? All of that is really fat The how the w I put it
this way, the why and the generalized how of the cloning process is fascinating to me. What I think Alex has made clear he's really excited about and a lot of fans have too, and I think there's nothing wrong with it, but it's definitely not. What I care about is the scientific how, the like, you know what, how did all this happen? And it's part of why I I really don't like all the m count stuff and Minnachlonian stuff because for me, and again this may also be you know, the different ways we experienced Star Wars, the Force has always been first and foremost
a myth, a mythological spiritual kind of a thing, not spiritual kind of like a modern day religion, but just like that, there is something a truth that you understand but could never like roll dice about or like put into exact terms. You know that I have fifty four force points and this other person has fifty one horse points. Like I've played all the Star Wars video games and role playing games, but I always think, to some extent that's a little off because that's just not how I understood the Force worked. So for me, the more that we make the Force a scientific thing that can
be cloned and that is all about you know, m counts and these other things, that's not the story I care about. Yeah, so, and again I am not saying therefore it makes it a bad story or story they shouldn't have made. And I think that's a good example, I hope for it's okay to recognize that some parts of Star Wars aren't as much for you as they are for others. But all that being said, here's here's an answer to the original question. Because of that, I really don't want Omega
to have been intentionally created that intentionally, somehow they did some What I would love much more is that probably everyone went into this cloning process thinking, well, yeah, you know, the Force is something that is part of the natural order that the clones are kind of a break against and so, yeah, they're not really for sensitive, and it suddenly along came this clone who, through whatever kind of adjustments they made to her, becomes for sensitive.
And then the idea that like the Force just kind of acted on its own, because as Yoda would always say, you know, the Force is unpredictable. You cannot expect exactly what the Force is going to do. That's something that Yoda talked about, Qui gon Jin talked about the Sith have always talked about. And so the idea that these scientists are struggling to replicate what the Force did on its own in Omega. I love the idea that it was a successful science experiment and now they're trying to do more. They want to
study it so they can do more examples. That it could be a great story, and I'm start going to keep watch because I love everything else in the Bad Batch, but that I'm really hoping it's not that. Yeah, I feel like I have a couple different ways of viewing and thinking about this question, because, like so a big part of my influence and understanding of Kamon Owens comes from the Republic Commando book series, and in that series, the lead scientist her name is Cosi. She basically was the one behind most
of the cloning things. And then when the Empire comes, you know, orly sixty six, the Empire is there, a lot of the characters in the books defect and go elsewhere, and then they go and they kidnap Cosi so that she can find a way to reverse or slow their aging, like they're accelerated aging. Like they kidnap her and say you fix this for us, or we're gonna kill you, right, which, like I mean sounds
like maybe harsh, but like when you're in the book series, it's like those dark moral questions come up. So it's like a very interesting part of it. But to me, like Cosi, they portrayed her as this crazy scientist, like a mad scientist who just fucked with genes for fun and did random shit and just like had pleasure in creating experiments even if they went bad and she had to like kill them, like she didn't really care. She was just curious as to what would happen. And so with that idea of
Kimino and scientists, in my mind, I'm thinking about Nalissa, and I'm like Yeah, she's clearly like one of the top scientists. She was maybe a little mad with power or just like seeing what she could do, and maybe she did accidentally create Omega. Like I don't see it as she was like I'm going to clone a for sensitive person. Here you go. I see it as she was like, I'm gonna make a girl clone and see what else I can do. And then she comes out with an encount and Nalisa doesn't even realize that at first, maybe or maybe she does. But
that's the way I kind of see it because I almost I kind of liked the idea that like Nalasa intentionally created her, like to be her. So then the idea that, like something else in the changing of the genome ended up with some for sensitivity because that's how the force works. It just shows up randomly. Y. That's how I kind of head canon it. That fits into it makes the science still respect the anonymity of the force almost,
Yeah, And that's why they're not able to make clones so easily. That's why they can't figure it out without her, because it wasn't done on purpose. Yeah's no, I can really see that being fun and I think a lot of it will come down to a question that has never really been answered that I think a lot of people are very curious about for reasons both related and not as related to the story, which is how was a girl clone created? Because a lot of it comes down to what you understand cloning to
be and how exact two different genomes have to be in order to both be a clone. Because as a lot of folks, especially in the circles I hang out in, have talked about, I think there's one theory that if truly every clone is just about biologically the exact same as the other, the only real difference would be maybe that some of them have their aging sped up or some don't, or some of them have the in hibbit chip some don't. Then Omega was probably assigned mail and which would make Omega trans and I
think that would be even phenomenal interpretation of her character if she is if she is a girl, because that's what the character felt like they were and identifies as and realize that they were. But the theories pushing that are kind of based on applying our own world's understanding to genetics and cloning to this entirely fantastical space world. Ye so, and I will say if we had no other
examples of trans clones anywhere in this world, I would want to push for that even further. But in the Queen's shadow Books and am always talking about, a character is introduced called Sister, who is a clone who was part of the Rags, brought up as male and came to realize that she was a woman and transitioned. So having that character means that I'm not as invested in the Omega must have been excuse that Omega must have the exact same genetics.
I think it's the double Y chromosome. Forgive my science teacher, who will probably be mad at me. If Shary hears this, it'd be amazing if you were listening to it, you know. So I think it's that, like a chromosome has to be added to make a creature male in our universe. But again, who the hell knows in this year, So maybe they just didn't do that in Omega's case. Maybe she did. She does have two Y chromosomes, or who the heck knows, maybe X crimosomes. I don't know, it's X y well aren't most No, I was just thinking for males, that's x y not double y, right, yeah,
okay, yeah, I think women are are double why men are x y and then some men are xx y and that can cause issues and stuff. I don't know, I'm e toeally wrong here. The point of all this being though, I am. I think, especially if we're going to get into questions of how was Omega created, I think the question of was her gender changed intentionally or basically is her gender genetically changed? I'm be very careful
here because in the main universe, and probably even for most Star Wars writers, genetic markers equals gender. In our own world, I think more and more people come to understand that's not true. But I'm going to go with that. That understanding of it that if they intentionally wanted to make a female clone, versus if they made a clone that then the character decided that they were female. Yeah, that then was female exactly. I don't think that matters unless we're suddenly caring about the exact way that Omega was created. But
if, as you say it, some changes were made and maybe it was accidental that she became for sensitive, then yeah, then I think that'd be an interesting thing to explore. Yeah, it's so interesting how head Cannons interact. Right, It's like you can have so many different ideas and then seeing if they fit together, and then you sit there and you're like wait, but also, none of this is confirmed. This is just what I think. Yeah, exactly, exactly, yeah, and it's amazing. How I hope I've gotten better at this. I think Paul yelling at me in the many years of our podcast certainly helped. But there have been times where I
watched something and then I interpret it a certain way, and then if I haven't seen it in a while, I will probably remember it closer to the way I interpreted it than the way it actually is. And I think people do this all the time. That's why fact checking is so important, and going back to the original it's so important. Absolutely. I also just want to say to the last thing on that head Cannon's are real and hend Cannon's are great, you know, And like, I love what Mark Hamillo said where he said that he doesn't have a specific opinion on Luke Skywalker's sexuality,
but if it's important for someone that Luke Luke Skywalker be gay, then Luke is gay. And in the same way, I think, no matter what they tell us if it is important to you that Omega is trans which I think is completely valid, then keep no matter whatever the hell we get told in the next ten episodes or whatever it is. Yeah, thirteen episodes. I love that, and I love the like affirmation and support from an actor to be like, yeah, like, these are characters that are not me. These are characters created for you guys. Let them be what you need. Yeah, so that's super cool. I didn't know that. Let's talk
about our boys, our boys going to adventure. Uh, Hunter and Bunker like the brains and the bron and the Hambo and the sad dad. Yeah, two boys with very cute butts and not a lot of brain cells between them. Would we think? Very rough? Okay, so one thing I didn't know, but I'm gonna mention at the top before I forget. I saw a post about this. When we first see Hunter and Record on the
ship, you know, oh, well, we're introduced by that to them because they're returning the severed horn to that one crime lord guy to get information about where Hemlock's lab might be. So they're on the ship and Hunter's like looking through the info or whatever, and in the foreground unfocused. You see text goggles that are shattered m which, as Alex horribly pointed out in our group chat, means that they recovered his body, which hurts. It feels
good because they needed that, and I appreciate that it kind of puts to bed the idea that, oh, maybe Tech's not dead, like as we've talked about, oh did they recover his body? I mean I come from the comic book world where anything could be possible. What if, like he fell into the deep pit. What if they only found goggles and are like maybe they fell off, and He's like they think they fell off. He's still dead down there, but maybe they're like, oh, well, the
Scavenger's got to his body for you know, I mean, if you're right, because I don't want all that speculation, but yeah, like for me, it takes away the gravity and the emotional effect of last season. If he's just alive, even if that's like revealed later on and there's a good explanation, I would prefer that grief to be real and to be constant because I like to suffer. But no, so we see those glasses, which sucks, and then they go to this planet where Hemlock's Labs supposedly is,
and they see this lab that's been destroyed by orbital bombardment, Like, so, whatever happened there, the Umpire scrapped it, took all their people out, and then just blew it to shit, basically, just blew it up. And so Hunter and Record go and they sat down. They're kind of wandering, and then they are held up by two young clones who are probably like in normal people age probably between like eleven and fifteen, maybe sixteen.
So then for clones, they're like five six years old something like that, maybe seven, And I think it's clear that there's two of them at first. And then they take the boys back to meet this other guy who's clearly kind of like the leader of them. He appears a little bit older than the other two, and you know, during Record like what happened, and they were like, yeah, don't know what wrong, but the empire took all their scientists, left all the clones, and just blew it up. And we only got out because we had decided to escape that day. And
they said that they ended up there because they were told they were being transferred to like the front lines or something like that, and then they were just brought to a lab to be experiments, which is fucking horrifying anyways, and so they kind of talk through things, and Hunter or they say that they had seen a control panel that was still intact somewhere in the ruins. Because you know, the boys have been around. I've meant to go write their names down and I forgot, but they say that they had seen that,
and then they kind of hypothesized with Hunter and Record that there could be information about where Hemlock went afterwards, where he might have taken Omega somewhere on that control panel. And so then Hunter and Record decide to go there. Uh, and the boys are kind of like two of them are like, you'll never survive, Like that's so dumb, Like you guys are never gonna find your way out there. And there's also these like I wish I'd written down what they were called specifically, but a type of like sentient vine that had arose from an Empire experiment that like I think they were electric and then if
you like cut off some of it, it like sprouts into a second little one that like comes and chases you. So a very interesting concept. And so basically they're trying to like avoid these vines and not disturb them as best they can. So they take Gonky with them because they need a power source, right, which, as we talked about in our lost audio files, is the first time a Gonk droid has ever actually been crucial and helpful. Yeah, and like gonks were already getting I think they used a Gonk once
or twice in earlier Bad Batch episodes, but this I think was definitely the most like Gonk Gonk was you know, required for this mission, not just helpful. Yes, well, Gonky's been around, yeah, but yeah, there's just been boot chilling. He usually gonks across the ship as they fly crazy. Yeah. Yeah, it was so good. It was such a nice moment. And I gotta say, like, I think the the horror vibes, it really gave that in a strong way. I am and this is probably Paul's influence to me in a large extent, but entirely I am
getting to the point where I'm kind of done with our heroes going to the planet where a large perhaps scary to humans, but like not being aggressive, just living doing its own thing on its own planet. Life form exists and because our heroes disturb it, it starts fighting back, and then our heroes have to kill it. I've had enough of that. I can be done with that, please. But other than that, I thought it was an incredible episode and it really did. The horror of it was great, the
sort of not really fully understanding what this life form was, which I think in many way, God, I hant even thought about this. Now, why is it that they can't figure out scientifically what this life form is and how to best deal with it because Tech isn't there, Like that's just another gut punch, Like I don't even know that's coincidence, and I'm headcanning if that was intended. But it's just, you know, all these ways, like seeing just the two of them on their own felt so weird, but
you realize, like, yeah, Echo is off doing his own thing with Rex and all the awesome stuff they're doing. Tech is dead and Crossfire is imprisoned and it's just these two boys left. And I really loved that, and it really I don't like splitting the party, so I do hope we all get back together fairly soon. But I thought for these three episodes, going back and forth between the two groups really really worked. Yeah, and I really liked it. Yeah, I agree, And I feel like it's
something that was done very intentionally and the melancholy mood of it came off very well. How the first episode we only saw Omega in a little bit of Crosshair. The second episode was only Hunter and Record. They mentioned Rex and Echo, but they were never actually heard over any sort of audio. We never saw them. And then the next episode we go back and it's just Crosshair and Omega again, and it's just this void and divide that like feels
so unnatural and foreign within a squad and like being that through the first two seasons, like this has been you know, the squad that is a family, the squad that sticks together, and now they are so far apart that they can't even get in contact with each other. Yeah. Yeah, Like it was such a perfect mood to like put us in coming out of season two, because like if they had been like okay, like here's the drama and the start of it, but like it's still kind of like happy fun,
I'd be like, now when I'm watching them back to back, it's gonna be whiplash going from season two to this. But it just like it works. It's eerie like that these episodes that are very eerie, and it works very well, and especially with the appearance of the Emperor at the or in the third episode, just really like that's the mood of like what's going on here? Like how this is gonna go? I mean, we'll probably
get some like what do you call them standalone episodes? What are they called? Filler episodes? We might get a few filler episodes, But I I that's where I'm gonna push back. I think that some standalone episodes are filler episodes, but that there's an attitude by many people that all standalone episodes are by definition filler episodes, which I think is very not the case. No, I don't. I don't mean filler episode like that. I just mean like separate little adventures where like maybe something important happens emotionally, but like no
progress is gained towards the bigger goal. But thank you for the clarification, because it is thought of in a bunch of different ways. Side quests is a great way to see it, and often it is I was trying to think of it does progress the main plot, but in a they go to someone who they've been told can give them the next piece of the puzzle, but that person says, okay, but you've got to go do this quest. You got to go pick this berry off this tree for me. So they spend the whole episode on the side quest, finish the side quest, and then the person at the end says, great, well, now I
can tell you you got to go talk to this person, and then that person does a thing. Yeah. Yeah. I think I think those are looked down upon a lot, and I think sometimes, like particularly in the days of network television, you know, twenty three episodes every season. There definitely were some episodes that just felt like this show would have been just as good one episode lighter, but they had to fill this many episodes for the season. But standalones are not that, and most I think of a bad batch standalones were not that. Another thing I wanted to touch on, and
you gotta hinto that, but I want to go deeper on this. I am, as many people know, really fascinated by villains and by villain motivations, and you were talking about the sort of scientist aspect of these characters who it's not that they're sadistic and they want to hurt people. It's that or they have these like malicious like I want to take over the world goals. It's that they are utterly fascinated by the science and utterly untroubled by the consequences,
either of those they experiment on or what other people use this science on. And to me, it's the difference between being amoral and being immoral. What immoral is like, you know, having bad morals like wanting you know, working in the service of greed or your own your own advancement or revenge or things like that, which, by the way, all of which can actually be more moral than we think. But I'm painting in broad strokes. But amoral is really when you just don't have moral compunction as part of it.
And the character I've Been trappeda from Shira is one of my absolute favorite examples of this. I think a lot of great villains are more like this, and I think it's really interesting the way they've given us those characters in this. You know, I think the Cheminoans have always had some aspect of that. Otherwise I see at least one of them is developing in some real compassion for Omega. But for example, Hemlock, there's a scene where the pilots of a shuttle crash in an area that is known to be very dangerous
in terms of like wild animals that live there, and by the time they radio in, we can already hear that the monsters are attacking them and that they're engraved danger. And the Hemlock is asked, should I send out a patrol to get them, and Hemlock says, if they crashed outside the barrier, it's already too late for them, and he literally turns off the speaker so that they don't have to hear them screaming. And for a lot of characters, I think, especially like Palpatine or early versions of Vader, that
might have been Oh, those stupid fools, they crash their ship. They deserve to be torn apart, you know, wahaah, enjoy their suffering maliciously. Yeah, it's malicious, yes exactly. I don't think Hemlock, you know, wanted those two to die. I think he probably thinks it is unfortunate that they died, not out of compassion for them, but just those are two trained pilots, those are valuable imperial resources. But I think he's also just hyper realistic of they are probably dead already. Any attempt to rescue
them would put more of my soldiers' lives at stake, and I'm not interested in protecting imadual soldiers, and I don't want to get into a witch is worse because I think, like some of the scientists are kind of in a morally great place. Hemlock is straight up evil, but it's evil of amorality, of utterly not caring about the consequences instead of wanting them. Yeah, it's like the amoral versus the ema is kind of the difference between if you remember from the Clone Wars, doctor Nuveau Vindi who created the Blue Shadow virus,
like his goal was to kill people. He wanted to watch the universe or the galaxy just explode in disease, like that was exciting and fun to him. But like you're saying, Hemlock like he doesn't necessarily want to cause pain, but he is willing to do anything to reach the scientific goals he has. And he's a very cost effective person and he really cuts his losses and like you said, he's not going to go expend more resources to probably not even help these two people who just kind of fucked up on their way
down, you know, right, And it's not malicious, it's just calculated and he probably never thought about it. Again, Yeah, he's not bothered. He's he is not going to have bad dreams at night about the people who had to die. Correct. Yeah. So I just think that's some great storytelling from them. Yeah, and I did write down. The actor who plays Hemlock is Jimmy Simpson. Okay, I mean a comedian, but
also I've seen him in a couple of just like really spooky scary roles, and it's just one of those voices that I recognized and I was like, where have I heard that? And it just like it all came together, like he just does such a great job with the just cold, calculated, like what would you call it, Almost like a detached eagle. Yeah. And I think the result of it winds up being quite terrifying and quite chilling, I think is the right word. Because if someone wants to kill me
out of hate and out of this like strong emotion, I feel there's a chance I can appeal to their emotions. I can make an emotional appeal of like wait a minute, like you should have compassion for me, or like I can wash your car really good, you know whatever it is, Like, I can appeal to that emotional thing, but if you have just calmly and logically decided that I'm a resource that is better disposed of, there's no compassion, there's no there's no like vindictiveness. It's not a hate of me
that I need to there is no anger for me to calm down. And so I think in that ray, like it, the person who hates you and wants to do anything they can to kill you is terrifying too. This is just terrifying in a very very different way, but a very because it's not the norm, I think it's all the more effective. Yes, absolutely, Like it's it comes down to, like, yeah, like you said, you can play for people's emotions, but you can't convince someone of your usefulness when they've already decided you're worthless, right like, And that applies in
real life, yeah, unfortunately, very much. So, I mean, just look at the responses when you know, innocent people are killed, especially through like racism or as we saw most recently, mostly transphobia with necks getting beaten up and losing their life being killed and you know by transphobia and just all these kind of things like racism, whatever. Yeah, it's hard when someone doesn't see you as human, unless worthy as human compassion, it's harder to then appeal to their emotions. And yeah it Star Wars making a great
point for sure. And just the last thing for me on that is where was it? Where was the thought ahead, callousness? The oh, just one last thing on that. I think part of why that scene with the two fallen pilots was so powerful is often we see a version of that screen told for a very different reason that scene, because often we see that scene as a way of our hero has to make the hard choice, and you
know that the hero hates it, but you know the hero has to do this because if they try to save the two people, then two hundred might die or two thousand or two million, And so we see the pain on the hero's face and we see how hard it is for them, and we see them being haunted by the voices of those who died later, and it's just the exact opposite. Hemlock doesn't have a thought in the world as he shuts off that speaker, and that just makes it like it's just such a great villain moment. Yeah, yeah, They've done a great job of creating
this villain from like the mystery surrounding him last season and it was like just whispers and now it's just like this concentrated two episodes that delves into exactly how he works without actually telling us much at the same time. For sure, definitely that was well done. Well, there's so much more we could cover. Oh what were you gonna say? I was just gonna say, do you have any thoughts on Emory? Emory is the other Clone who, Yes,
that's the female clone with the brown hair and the weird goggles glasses. I really am enjoying her story and I want to see more of it. And I think they're exploring a very interesting dynamic, which is, you know, a thing that happens under oppression A lot of the person who is well treated and thus winds up having more loyalty towards the people who are oppressing them because I think, well, I'm not being as oppressed as everyone else,
versus the person who's like, no, this is all wrong, and you know it breaks my heart. Obviously I want her to help Omega, but I also understand why she didn't. I think she thinks, like I have it good, you know. And I think there are a number of other struggles that have happened for freedom in our own country and around the world. I think civil rights and anti slavery is one of the best examples where there were terms that were given to those who are more or like on the side of the masters, even though they were still slaves or oppressed or whatever it
is. But in terms I'm gonna use here, but I think folks can probably guess what I'm talking about, where, you know, it's that tension, and I think it is very easy to just say, oh, well, you have it good, so you're selling me out. And I think we're supposed to be pretty mad at her for selling out Omega, But I also I think we're gonna get some more from her perspective that kind of shows us like she is just as caught in this, and she is probably on some level like a It may be that she's just as like science focused and
so she doesn't kind of notice like she's a slave because she gets to be in the laboratory, or it might be that she some part of her is just as aware that she could be easily killed at a moment's notice. But she's trying to ignore that because they're being so nice to her. What about you, what's your take? Yeah, I mean I'm interested to see where they go with her story. And I thought, as you were talking about your thoughts, is she gives us a really good POV to view Hemlock's Lab
from here on out now that Omega and Crossing are gone. It gives us a character to central or center around, because you can't really center around the villain too much. Not a let's say, is honestly not that interesting and deep. Yeah, well, I mean she contained smultitudes, but she doesn't seem like the right choice for a kind of central character either, So I think that will be really interesting. That being said, right now, currently I have no good or positive thoughts or comments about Emery. I don't like her, and that's just me being a salty bitch because she did Omega dirty
twice and I just I don't like it. I think it's totally fair, and I think I think the story could be told in a way where Emory never changes sides and gets a very satisfying death or defeat when when we might take her out. I think for the most that's where the bad batch has not been anywhere near as predictable as a lot of shows are sometimes it is, you know, there are definitely some tropes it has, and it does feel to me like I will be somewhat amazed if Emory doesn't wind up helping
Omega in the end, like she doesn't make a hero turn where she turns on Hemlock and maybe she's the one to kill Hemlock or she just sacrifices herself to help Omega escape against hemlock wishes. You know, I kind of feel like we're being set up for that, which is why I'm sort of having maybe I'm having like sympathy in advance for her. But I think you're right, they're an a good job, I meaning, like, yeah, from Omega's Well, here's the thing. It's also that Omega is so much the moral heart of this show. Yeah, Omega nice. Yeah, And I think that also makes it harder for me to like, I kind of want
a shake Omega and be like, girl, this person's not helping you. Stop trying to save all these lost, wounded puppies. And by the way, when you start dating, you can't fix them, like cause it if anyone's gonna grow up to try and fix them. It's Omega, and I say this, like, forget the gender part. I say this, I can fix them. For a long long time. The first time I was in an emotionally healthy relationship, I told my best friend at the time that I was kind of bored and he said, that's because you're used to drama.
Was a very telling statement. But anyway back to this, Yeah, so I I don't know what to feel and think, which is why I think the writing is so good, because I feel like part of me thinks Omega's going too far and the Omega should be just like, no, you're terrible, I hate you. Part of me thinks that the fact that Omega still cares for her means that I should still care for her. Part of me thinks the writers are going to do something good with it. I just don't know what. Yeah, I'm sure it'll do something great, you know, like it's a felony production. It'll be amazing. I'm sure I'll have
more thoughts about her character a few more episodes in, but right now, I'm still mad about last season and I'm just mad. That's one thing I do want to talk about quick that I loved so much? Is planned seventy two? Yeah? Talk about that? Yeah? And I found a clipping of the screenshots from that scene where Crosshair asks Omega did they teach you planed seventy two? And she goes mm hm. Tech had me memorize all of
the plans, and cross Hair goes, of course he did. Yeah, And it's just like right, more pain, Like I don't even know if cross Hair knows Tech is dead. Well, I suppose Omega would have told him, Yeah, But the part of me that wishes we had gotten to see that moment, and part of me that's really glad we didn't, yeah, because it would have probably just been an emotional gut punch or the way that you know, masochistic watchers like the two of us would still have enjoyed
but shouldn't tell. But I also wouldn't I would. I am very curious to know, like what role does TeX's death play, Like clearly he had his turn against the empire completely before he knew that, which I think is good. Yeah. I wonder if some version of the script did have Omega telling him, and I think maybe it would have just been too dark. I don't know, but I do think that him, just like her honoring Tech by saying it's he who did this, and and Crosshair saying of course
he did. It really felt like the two of them bonding over their shared love for their for their their their their their brother. Absolutely and kind of I think with the idea of like wishing we could have seen that moment, it's kind of like we all wish we could see the moment when like, did you say the one I want to see? You go ahead? You go ahead, but you're anthan ice. Uh oh, like seeing the moment when Ahsoka found out that Darth Vader came back to the Light, which we
kind of had the idea explored maybe a little bit in the Ahsoka show. But it's like, does she have that exact impression from that or does she just think that Anakin can appear in multiple ways? We don't know. But it's the idea of wanting to see something like that. But it's a much more interesting plot device if you don't just put it out there, because now we get the amazing uncomfortable conflict of when they do meet up with the rest of the batch. Nobody knows how cross Hair responds to text death. Nobody
knows what he thinks about it, how he feels about it, and if you know, they meet up in Omega's like, oh, like, we were both so heartbroken about this, blah blah blah. Like they kind of maybe we'll trust him a little sooner, But it's like the idea of you are so foreign to us. We don't trust you, we don't like you, you've been hunting us, you suck. And also like, we don't know if you've had an emotional no reaction to text death, therefore completely fuck you. And I think it'll give us more interesting conversations around text death rather than just giving us a huge emotional thing right at the start. As painfully
great as that would have been, I like it how they have skirted around it in a way that we can keep exploring it throughout the season. So I'll say, I think you have me somewhat convinced on this one. I think the idea is that we don't know. Then it is important to me that Omega doesn't tell him that some prison guard came and been like, well, we clipped one of your brothers last night, you know, or something like that. I will say, though, in response to your example,
I don't think we need to see everything on screen, and sometimes there's stuff that I wanted to see on screen that I don't. If Star Wars comes to an end, and eventually if Feloney passes away, and I have not seen Ahsoka and Luke responding to you know, Ahsoka and Luke geting to talk about their father, about his father, and Leah involved well somehow, and Ahsoka learning that he came back, and Luke getting to hear about what his father was like before and what his mother was like, and both of them
hearing that I will either buy every paper in the Felony estate and like search for like the napkin where he wrote the idea on, or I will just learn necromancy and dig up Filoni's grave and some in his spirit and be like you're going, I am not gonna let your soul rest until you tell me what happened. No, tell me, tell Dave, tell me what it is. Dave so yes. But as I put aside my maniacal bit of
fandom aside, this has been a great conversation. We've gone on for about an hour. I don't want to make these too long. I'm sure you've got a long list of things. Was there any one one or two last things? You want to bring up? Two tiny things? Back to Plan seventy two. I just loved the way it worked together, Like they have never Omega and Crossair have never been on the same team. They have never worked together in even the slightest way. And even until the very moment that
she comes to him and is like, we're gonna leave now, he doesn't want to be involved, he doesn't want to work together. And then it's like they're in this slide for death. You know. Do you know this plan? Yes? I do, and it goes perfectly. She hops up in that ship, she gets the pilot out of there, or knocks a pilot out, stums a pilot, I believe, and you know, mentions motions to cross Hair, and then she comes down in this elevator lift. The door is open. He's like laying cover fire, and then he steps backwards. She gets on her knees and lays cover fire for him, and
just the visual perfection of that plan in motion. That they have never worked together, but the fact that the idea that this core squad, this core family that they both started from or come from, is so strong that you don't need to have that actual reliance on each other. You just need to know the plan. And I really loved that because I think that also kind of ties back to the themes of the first two seasons, is like, yeah, this is the family, We are close, and I think that
something like that will bring them closer together despite what happened obviously with crosshair. So yeah, I just there's a lot about that scene that I really really loved. No. I cheered up during that scene for the same reason, and like it's a kick ass, you know, fight scene. But one of the things that made the first season so powerful is that when they start out, Omega sees them as brothers. They see her as a kid who they need to take care of. And the first time they come across like
none of them are parents, they're like, you know, soldiers of fortune, they're the eighteen. The eighteen doesn't have a you know, ten year old girl that they adopt, and the first time they find someone who they know is a good parent, they're like, you should take this kid dead. But by the end of that season, they see her as their sister, you know, just as much a part of their family as anybody else. So yeah, yeah, so that was one. What's the other tiny thing? Oh no, just like when she's escaping, I don't remember. There was one door that she opened and she was like waiting for a step behind her, and a little mouse droid came and she just like herb stomped
that bitch. She was just like, oh my god, I just would you write, haha, fuck that mouse droid. Ah My heart broke because like that's poor little Like I know they're all snitches, but like it's just one snitches. It was just made that way, you know, it's just it's doing its best. I just thought it was funny. Sorry, yeah, no, no, c good. I just thought it was funny that Omega, who has so much love and compassion and caring for the whole world, in this dire moment of action, was like, fuck this mouse droid.
She's like, I cannot be found out. I don't care if I hurt your feelings. Get out. And I just thought that was really funny. It's like, oh, Mega's in go mode. She's ready to go. It was awesome. It was awesome. Well, thank you so much, Aaron. As always, fans, We're gonna be back, We're gonna be doing every episode of Star Wars Generation. We're gonna be doing every episode of Star Wars The Bad Batch going forward. This was three and one, so there's no bonus content, but we will be continuing our bonus content starting next week, where we're gonna continue to go over stories from the Star Wars
from a certain point of view. Right now, we're doing a new Hope and you can get that bonus content. We're also doing bonus episodes. We have a book club that's releasing a new book every month. This month we released a book that rumor says might be relevant to this particular storyline, so check that out if you're interested. We're actually gonna have a snippet of that at the end of this as a like, Hey, if you want to join the book club, this is the kind of things you get, and all that comes for only five dollars a month or fifty five dollars a year. You get bonus content the en episode, well the end of most episodes,
you get extra content and also add free content. So if you sit here in the ads, that's not a great way to do it. Meanwhile, though, Erin is not only a fantastic podcast host, but a wonderful creator in her own world. So if I was just as a crazy collection of words, google the words Lady Tano Creates, what would I find. You'd find a lot of SOSFA cosplay stuff, You'd find some Lightsaber content. You would find an original Twela character as well as an original zombie Twela character,
and you'd find updates on my upcoming projects, which are which are Poison ivy fifty two, Mystique the classic comic book version, and then Shinhati from the Ahsofa Show. That being said, disclaimer, these past few months have been hard for me school workwise, so I haven't been as active, But when I get back to it, I will continue posting and you can always contact me on those about things you want to talk about in these episodes. Are questions you have about the podcast, you can always hit me up on Lady Tano Creates or we're at s w Generation Podcast I believe on Instagram,
m h yeah, all in me. You can also just if you search for Star Wars Generations or if you search for the Ethical Panda, you'll find all the ways to find us. They're also all in the show notes and all on the little graphics card that I will show at the end of this episode. We're gonna get better at having like graphics cards and having all the information on here. We're still just learning how this goes. But please do check out the live feed. Please check out. We're gonna be putting posts, a little tiktoks and videos and stuff like that up. Check Out all the awesome things that Aaron is doing. Check out all the great things Alex
is doing. Most of all, thank you as much for being fans. Yip yip. Emotion and sentiment have no place within these walls. Stay classy, Chorussant
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...