Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

Skeleton Crew Wrap-Up and Listener Feedback

Jan 30, 202540 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Join Erin and Matthew as they dive into the first season of Star Wars: Skeleton Crew! They discuss key moments, themes, and respond to your feedback, wrapping up with their final thoughts. Don't miss it! **************************************************************************This episode is a production of Star Wars Generations, a The Ethical Panda Podcast and part of the TruStory FM Entertainment Podcast Network. Check our our website to find out more about this and our sister podcast Superhero Ethics.We want to hear from you! You can keep up with our latest news, and send us feedback, questions, or comments via social media or email. Email: Matthew@TheEthicalPanda.com Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: TheEthicalPandaPodcasts Twitter: EthicalPanda77 Or you can join jump into the Star Wars Generations and Superhero Ethics channels on the TruStory FM Discord. To learn more about co-host Erin and her incredible cosplay check out her Instagram, LadyTanoCreates. Want to get access to even more content while supporting the podcast? Become a member! For $5 a month, or $55 a year you get access to bonus episodes and bonus content at the end of most episodes. Sign up on the podcast’s main page you can even give membership as a gift! You can also support our podcasts through our sponsors: Purchase a lightsaber from Level Up Sabers run by friend of the podcast Neighborhood Master Alan Use Audible for audiobooks. Sign up for a one year membership or gift one through this link. Purchase any media discussed this week through our sponsored links.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Before we dive in, here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story Fmfamily of Entertainment podcast.

Speaker 2Meet and Zinnia. You are being very poet to someone who is attempted to quinos her wife's saffren.

Speaker 3You know I'm wildly, madly in love.

Speaker 2With you and their best friend, Goldie Glad we didn't miss all the fun. Swords in hand, they defend their city from the worst of humanity.

Speaker 4I am Lord Buxton Blue, What are You Electric Hair? Virgil Walcot Vicious Suad.

Speaker 2Follow their adventures on the Swashbuckling Ladies Debate Society audio drama podcast, available now at true story dot fm. Slash Swashbuckling, What's Up? Most Excellent Friends?

Speaker 5It's Christy and Nathan from the Most Excellent Eighties Movies podcast.

Speaker 1It's a podcast where a filmmaker and a comedian and.

Speaker 5Their most excellent guests adventure their way through the eighties movies we think we love or might have missed with our grown up eyes to see how they hold up. Join us for delightful discussion eralligin recaps, ratings, and deep cut recommendations.

Speaker 1Plus members get some extra fun shit chat with the hosts after the show.

Speaker 5Download the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast today at true Story dot fm.

Speaker 1Or find it wherever the finest podcast are stored.

Speaker 5And do you remember to keep the Most Excellent Eighties Movies podcast.

Speaker 6Motto in mind?

Speaker 1Be excellent to each other and cardion dude d'es.

Speaker 4Hello and welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. I'm Matthew, your host. I'm joined by Aaron, one of my co hosts, and we're really excited today We're gonna be wrapping up Skeleton Crew. We're gonna be talking about kind of our thoughts on the whole series. We're gonna be going into a lot of your listener feedback. This is probably not the last time we'll talk about Skeleton Crew, but this is gonna be kind of our like wrap up episode of that sort of thing. Wanting also to let you know though that Alex Sadley cannot join us, but he will be with us of course for following weeks. He just we had to schedule some things around some of my medical stuff this week. I

Speaker 4do also want to take a moment, though, to say kind of a more general comment about this podcast and the world we're in.

Speaker 6Right now.

Speaker 4I'm recording this today on January twenty first, Tuesday, a day after here in the United States, we celebrated Martin Luther King and also a day after the inauguration of our new President Trump. And one of the many things that happened on that day was a lot of executive orders were issued. That's scared the heck out of a lot of people, myself included, because now, according to the federal government, my gender doesn't exist, and the gender identities of a whole lot of my friends no longer exist, and the safety of a lot of immigrant folks I know and folks like that.

Speaker 6Are really in danger.

Speaker 4And there are folks out there who may disagree with me politically on those things, and that's totally fine.

Speaker 6But I have to tell you that when I was really.

Speaker 4Scared listening to all of this, what I do was I turned on Star Wars because Star Wars has for me, always been one of the places I go to when I'm afraid, particularly when it seems like everyone's against me. And there are moments like when you know Lea realizes that no one else is coming to help, or when you know it feels like Luke is all alone, that that moments of feeling like the whole country, the whole world, like the you know everyone is out to get you. You know, you go on social media and it seems

Speaker 4like there's just so much hate directed towards trans folks and immigrants and women making and people making reproductive choices and any.

Speaker 6Of the rest of it.

Speaker 4And I know sometimes, you know, some folks will even try and make Star Wars into against those things, and I just for me, Star Wars is always the most woke piece of media I've ever found and will continue to be, And that's always gonna be the perspective of me on this podcast that I'm here for the wokeness. I love the wokeness of Star Wars. I love that Star Wars has a message against Empire, a message of that a small band of rebels, even if everyone thinks they're wrong, even if everyone thinks that jin should just give up, that that there's too many out there, that's

Speaker 4a feeling a lot of us can have too. And if Star Wars, in this podcast and anything like that can be a small ray of hope, a small ray of escapism, to help remember that you know, there are other good things out there. But then also a means of remembering, like none of us can strap into an X wing, but there's lots of other ways we can help to make this world a better place and help to keep this country from becoming a worst place in the world, the worst place. Then I hope that that's that that that happens, and that that for me is very much a part of what this podcast is all about.

Speaker 3Yeah, I second that. I mean today I had therapy Loves Therapy shouts out, and my therapist asked how I was feeling after the inauguration, and I said, all I can think about is that jin Urso quote where Sagarera asks her you can really stand as see the imperial flag rain across the galaxy, And she just said it's not a problem if you don't look up, because that's yeah, that's like the shitty thing is like what can you

Speaker 3do when politics and government isn't going the way you wanted? Like, sorry, guys, I'm getting emotional, but this election actually kind of forced my hand to make a reproductive medical decision that I wasn't planning to make this year, but I wanted to be able to do what I need to do for myself when I had the choice.

Speaker 6Yeah, and so I'm.

Speaker 3Really grateful that Minnesota is a state where I could get that done without needing the you know, approval of a man in my life. And that's not the rights that many women have across this country, and that that's fucked up. It just is, you know, it's not cool to have the government make you feel like you have to behave as sir in way because your rights are going to be taken away. So I understand that not everyone listening to disagrees with us, and that's okay. You know, you can have different points of view if you don't,

Speaker 3especially like I mean, both Matthew and I are part of the LGBTQIA community and that is a very big topic with this election specifically, and so that feels harder and bigger for us than it probably does for a lot of people who are cisgendered and straight. And that's okay if you don't see it our way. But I still like using our platform to say, you know, even when shit's hard, Star Wars gets it right.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, I mean some of the best representation I've seen of by people of asexual people of people all over gender maps is happening right now in Star Wars books, you know, and it's just I just want to say that for those of you out there, her feeling, you know, and and also how much of how much of Bad Batch was about immigrants being you know, helping helping refugees, helping people find safe places they could go in warring danger and all the kind of issues that we see in our own world. We're not gonna try this into a politics podcast, but Star Wars has been political ever

Speaker 4since George Lucas based the rebels in part on the Vietcong and the Empire on America, and so we're just going to keep that up. And you know, I just want to let people know that I do know a lot of other podcasts are gonna be a lot of other media is trying to be like, well, given the changing tides in this country, let's let's change with them. We're not going to This is who we are, this is what Star Wars always has been. Star Wars is woke. We are woke, and and we love that. So with that, let's now talk about overall Skeleton Crew, which is kind

Speaker 4of funny. Big Skeleton Crew is fantastic and great, and I think a lot of us loved it in part because it was one of the least like, you know, raising big issues kind of shows. And that's okay, Aaron. Overall, what do you think about Skeleton Crew?

Speaker 3I loved it. It was so lovely. I talk about my parents all the time on this podcast, and I'm going to continue, okay, But a big thing about this show was that it brought back what Star Wars was to me when I was younger, which was that we could fully enjoy it together. Because I have pretty differing views from my parents, my dad specifically, and watching shows like and Or and shows like The Acolyte are it's tougher. You know, we don't agree on things. He's upset about

Speaker 3things that maybe I'm excited to see in the media, and so it makes it tougher to have just like a pure familial enjoyment experience. And I love that Skeleton Crew gave us that back again and we were able to just have this lighthearted, kind of fun show that had important themes and important things. I mean, we got an episode that really dives into like disabilities, and that's fucking awesome. We don't see that a lot in media, and it did it in such a beautiful and subtle way that if you don't have a disability, maybe you

Speaker 3wouldn't catch it. And I kind of think that's beautiful is that it speaks to the people it needs to and it's not in the face of people who don't understand it.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 3So yeah, I really liked this show overall for just the I feel like the joy it brought. What were your thoughts overall?

Speaker 4Yeah, I think so, And I think kind of building what you were just saying, like, I love and Or, and I thought Acolyte did a lot of things really well. And I'm really glad that Star Wars made both of those shows, and both of those shows are very heavy, and both of those shows very clearly are dealing with a lot of real world issues, and I want my Star Wars to include that. But I also wanted to include Skeleton Crew, you know, And I think that, like I see a lot of stuff online about like, oh, it should all be like Skeleton Crew or no, Skeleton Crew is bad.

Speaker 6It should all be like and Or.

Speaker 4I want there to be all of it, because you're right, it's not that this show said we're not going to touch on any issues. There's an sent to which I think there's no such thing, like all media is making commentary, even if it's always doing is upholding a status quo, that's still a commentary, and that's staking out a position. But the fact that there was just so much joy in the show and so much whimsy and so much like the stakes were high, but you always kind of knew they weren't that high. There was always just a sense of like things are going to be okay that

Speaker 4you don't have in a lot of Star Wars shows and that I don't always want in a lot of Star Wars shows, But in this it just felt so perfect, and it more than anything, it made me feel like I am glad that we can have a Star Wars universe at this point that's big enough that it can compass all these different kinds of media and all these different tones, because I think we need all of it. And I think I wound up loving Skeleton Crew. I didn't know if I did, but even before I wound up loving it, I definitely had a moment of like,

Speaker 4even if this isn't for me, I'm really glad it's for other people. As it turned out, it was for me as well. But I think that's the other most important thing is just we can be at a point now where Star Wars can have something for everybody and not everything is for all of us.

Speaker 6That's okay too.

Speaker 3Yeah. I like what you said about kind of like the stakes of the show, because never once in the show did I think a main character was going to die, Like there was no question on whether or not those kids were going to make it through the show, because just from the setup of the show, you knew that just isn't where this was going. There was no way that was going to be part of the storyline. Like, these children are dealing with a lot of other hard topics, they don't need to also deal with death, you know. And so I really loved the stark difference, especially like

Speaker 3compared to the Accolade. I loved that show. I really enjoyed it. But holy shit, the gut punch of losing every single main character except for three yeah, was diabolical. Absolutely, And I loved the difference in the show where when Kb's crashes and Ferns screams and Jod says, it wasn't supposed to go like this. I didn't want to hurt anybody deep down. I knew she was okay. Yeah, I knew that her and thirty three did some crazy Anakin

Speaker 3Skywalker crash landing. You know.

Speaker 4For me, honestly, the scariest moment that where I thought like, oh wow, this this would be really intense, where it felt like it would kind of break the steaks, but but I could believe it could happen. This is one that Alex and I talked about that I wonder if you saw the same way when Wim is holding the lightsaber and Jod is trying to use the force to pull it out of his hand, I thought that, like Wim was going to activate the lightsaber and wind up like stabbing John without meaning to you, And like I was like, oh, oh, so you're saying that the stakes

Speaker 4are this kid won't like die, but at.

Speaker 6Ten years old, he's gonna murder someone and that's gonna be on his Oh my god, Like, yeah, that's that. Well, that's gonna screw that kid up real bad.

Speaker 4But halfway they didn't do that, which I was very relieved about. But yeah, other than that, like the show, I think did this perfect walking of a line in that it was kind of like a roller coaster where like it makes you feel afraid, but in the back of your mind you always know that you're safe enough that you don't completely freak out. In the back of my mind, I always knew that the kids weren't going to die, but I also believed that the kids didn't know that that the like, I felt like I could

Speaker 4see the moment when the kids went from that childhood's sense of and vulnerability to actually realizing, wait a minute, were way over our heads. We could actually die. This could be terrible. And I just really credit the writing and the acting of all the kid actors because it pulled that off.

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah, we had some really impressive performances.

Speaker 6It was.

Speaker 3There was never a moment in this show where I felt like bad acting or like a misportrayal of the character pulled me out of it.

Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah, I think it's very true. It's very true.

Speaker 4Let's talk about John because that was one we were talking about all season long about was he going to turn into a good guy all along? Was he did he have this secret nefarious plan? Was he a Jedi?

Speaker 6Was he not?

Speaker 4They kind of just picked a They kind of didn't go to any of those extremes. They just let him be a villain, but without him being like Mohaha evil, but also not giving him redemption. And they said that he was like loosely connected to the Jedi and that's how he learned about the Force. But he wasn't a Padawan, he wasn't Order sixty six. He was just a guy. What do you think of what they do with this character?

Speaker 3It was I think I liked it in the end. It was interesting because going into the last episode, I had kind of these expectations or hopes of what we would learn about Johd, and I feel like that was not fulfilled. But when the episode ended, I didn't feel like I was missing something.

Speaker 6Yeah, I think.

Speaker 3I was expecting them to flesh it out more, but I'm also just really happy with where it ended. Of like, like you said, he's kind of just a guy, and he's got really understandable and really human things driving him, and some you know, prejudices against these kids who haven't had a hard life like he did, and how it comes out sideways where and now you're threatening to carve up their parents, but you claim you never wanted to hurt anybody, and that just got away from you. And I think Yeah, he was a really human character. And

Speaker 3I really liked having the one guy, you know that everyone's been championing, championing jew Law as like the main character, like the big guy in the show. And I feel like we all, or I at least going into the show, had this concept or thought that like, oh, yeah, he's gonna come in and save the kids. And I like that it started that way and it divulged into an actual, like really human character and a really understandable character. And

Speaker 3I liked that we didn't see any grand death or him being arrested or anything. It's just like, well, he failed, and now the good guys are coming, so that sucks.

Speaker 4Yeah, you know, I think it's so true, and I think there's a real tendency, especially in Star Wars, because this is kind of where we started. I think, I think that's so true. And I think for me, Star Wars has always been about the idea of moral grayness and that there is possibility of redemption and all of this kind of stuff, and I think that's really true. But I think and I think this is somewhat true, especially the earliest Star Wars stuff, the original trilogy that I love, but that it's easy to kind of see the world as truly evil, unredeemable people or heroic people

Speaker 4who have made mistakes, but they can be redeemed and they're they're good.

Speaker 6And then everyone is kind of one or the other.

Speaker 4And I was seeing some stuff about like either a you know, kind of being a position of like either A Jod should have been a villain, which meant that he wouldn't have any remorse whatsoever, or that B Jod wasn't a villain, and so he should have gotten.

Speaker 6A redemption arc and the reality he is. Lots of people are not that simple.

Speaker 4Then, as you said, Jod wasn't a cookie cutter, he wasn't a cardboard then, as you said, Jod wasn't a cardboard cutout. He was just a guy who had a lot of motivations for what he did and had a lot of reasons why he was willing to sort of be cruel and be terrible and and he was very jaded and cynical and willing to kind of screw over other people and was willing to murder people Like Brutus was not posing any danger, there was no self defense.

Speaker 6He just straight up murked Judas brutus.

Speaker 4I'm sorry, But at the same time, he genuinely didn't want to harm the kids, and he wanted to scare the hell out of them, and but he generally believed that he wasn't gonna hurt the kids, and probably, as he said, kind of let himself believe like, which maybe wasn't very accurate because because he wasn't just you know, mohaha power. He was trying to be a bad guy, but also had some some lines he didn't want to cross. And I think that honestly, most villains, most people probably fall somewhere into those categories. And I really like that

Speaker 4betrayal from him.

Speaker 3Yeah, so, what else.

Speaker 6About the show did you want to talk about?

Speaker 4We've guys got some listener feedback will jump into, but any other kind of points that you wanted to bring up, or kind of overall things you love it or didn't love.

Speaker 3Let me check my notes. I will say I kind of liked how in this show we got like the mention, I mean, like in the first episode, or maybe it was the second episode where the girls are pretending to be like something official, you know, and they say, what's the name of your crush?

Speaker 7In Neil's Like, like, I loved that we got the accuracy of like people their age having crushes but it not being a big part of the show.

Speaker 3And like obviously, you know, like Neil kind of have crush on that girl Hanah because she's a badass and because she saw him for who he is and she saw his strength for what it is, and that like physical strength and defiancy isn't the only ways to be strong, right, And I love that we have kind of this tension between like Fern and Whim of like, oh do they are they just little kids fighting with each other because they think different things? Is there maybe a little crushing happening? Is there not? But it doesn't matter, Like it wasn't a big part of the show. And I like that

Speaker 3because I feel like oftentimes an aspect of storytelling is like the romance of it, you know, and it's Chris is kind of thrown in there. And that's something that I love that Star Wars doesn't always do. I mean, with my favorite character Ish Soka. They you know, they had Lux Sponterey in the Clone Wars, but overall they never really paired her with anyone And I love that and I really like how this show also just kind of had it like held space for that concept, but it didn't harp on it or any like that.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think sometimes there's shows as they're like I think sometimes so the reaction to not wanting to be too romance focused is to be like aggressively aggressively platonic and like no acknowledgment of that when the reality is Yeah, and I think these kids are meant to be like prepubescent or like on the cusp of puberty. It's not that I think that they're like, you know, raging hormones or anything, but they are at the age when like starting when like some of them may start to have crushes on each other and others don't, and others don't know what they're feeling and won't be like, oh I

Speaker 4had a crush until like twenty years later. And I appreciate that the way they played it, like, yeah, we could see that energy happening, but it wasn't a big deal, you know, it just it just existed and it didn't take over the show and it didn't become like I never had a will they won't they moment. I never had a like our Fern and Whim gonna kiss or like let their hands touch and a little like ohe is and that's so cute.

Speaker 6They're gonna grow up and start dating later kind of a way.

Speaker 4It was just, yeah, yeah, these are just the complex feelings that that kids can have among each other.

Speaker 3Yeah, I feel like, I don't know, there's a lot in this show that I loved. I liked the kind of different parenting setups that we had.

Speaker 6Also.

Speaker 3I mean, we've got our single father Wendell with his microwaveable homemade meals, ye, which when I watched it with my parents and he goes homemade, my mom went ugh, and I was like, I'm glad you get it too, Like I'm glad say that.

Speaker 2Yeah exactly.

Speaker 3And you know the dynamics between how it's different between Wim and Wendell versus Fern and Farah and they're both single parents, but yeah, need of them really listen to their kids, but it comes out in different ways. And I really loved that at the end of the show they did really listen.

Speaker 6They did, and yet it was still in very different ways. You know that.

Speaker 4For For Wendel, it was can he be a little more adventurous? Can he be willing to try something, whereas for Fern's mom, it was, you know, can can she? Can she go against the authority? Can she you know, not be the good little soldier but actually listen and break the rules.

Speaker 6And it was really beautiful as well as.

Speaker 4It seemed like all of those parents were bonding and were connecting with each other. But again, and not to be like super anti romance. Like I love romance and stuff, but especially in stuff that is more kid aimed. Sometimes it feels like they just throw in romances but with no build up whatsoever. And like there was a part of me going into it that was like, all right, are Whim's dad and Fern's mom gonna have like romantic you know, gazes at each other or something.

Speaker 3Okay, Well there was none of that.

Speaker 4Just these are all parents who are not They're all just united by, you know, the worry about their kids and the worry about their world and how they balance those out.

Speaker 3I will say I was always very curious where the fuck Neil's dad was, because my boy was like never around. He was there in the hologram, but he like never really had a speaking moment. So I was like, okay, but also what they had like four other kids, so somebody got to watch the babies.

Speaker 6Someone's got a babysit, Yeah exactly.

Speaker 4Yeah, all right, we'll talk about some feedback we got, and the first one we were getting some on our discord, which I always encourage people to check out our discords more. I mean, in the process of kind of redoing our social media presence and trying to have a much more active presence. At first, I was like, oh gosh, we have to do this without TikTok. Now, of course TikTok is maybe back, who the hell knows, but we're gon we're gonna put out a lot more information about how to find us on social media and of course how to send us feedback. This is all gonna come from our discord, which there is a link to in the show notes, but you can find us in discord, email, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok,

Speaker 4Blue Sky is going to get started pretty soon.

Speaker 6All sorts of ways to find us, but this comes to us. Most of these.

Speaker 4Two of these comments are from once the show was over, but one of them came I think after episode three, and I'm very apologetic to Corrascano, who's been one of the most loyal fans of the show, always commenting on our discord and I love you for that, dude, Thank you so much for connu to be a great fan. And he wrote in I think again this was after like episode three or four. I had a couple of thoughts. I wanted to get your takes on at Aton. What if at Aton is actually an empire controlled world where the governor, minister, chancellor is someone who isn't ruthless for a change. What if it's a place where the Empire has,

Speaker 4as Matthew says, made the trains run on time, Empire went in resources and the administrator has an unusual approach. Instead of taking the resources, the empire gives the people purpose incomes, so the natives give the resources away. Naturally, you'd have to shield the people from what the Empire is doing in every other area of the galaxy. So all of the restrictions in lack of pushback from the characters are explained.

Speaker 6Thoughts.

Speaker 3I like that concept of like, yeah, maybe it's the government that we all view as the big bad, but in this situation, yeah, it's working out okay. Like you said, the trains are running on time. You know, people go to work, they go home, they eat their meals, they're happy, they raise their kids. I think that would have been a very interesting way to see it go. The one thing is the timeline of this show I don't think would have made sense, but that early in the show, I don't think we knew how long at Aden had

Speaker 3been missing for, so that would be very interesting. And then it would be like, well, is that an imperial like remnant or a splinter? Is that someone who kind of said I'm going to take my power and build it my own way, like a throng type almost, you know, using the power for means to an end.

Speaker 6Yeah, yeah, I mean when.

Speaker 4First couple episodes before we really learned everything, I definitely thought this was kind of what was happening, and not necessarily even that it was like the empire or whatever, but that you know, you know, a world where there's extreme poverty, an extreme income disparity, or just there's an empire and like all the people who oppress the empire are being you know, horribly abused. Yeah, the people who take care of the empire are treated quite well, and you know, in some ways I was kind of thinking of it almost as like, you know, district one in

Speaker 4the Hunger Games kind of thing, or the capital in the Hunger Games, and where it's not even the capital, but you know like it because if we understand that in this world there's like the immense poverty, but then there's places like Can't Bite, there's gonna be a suburbs. You know, there's going to be a suburban world, and a lot of those kind of goonies type movies that I really loved. One of the themes sometimes was kids in the suburbs realizing that not all kids have the privileges that they do, you know, that not everyone gets

Speaker 4to grow up on a safe street where the most difficult thing is are you going to take the test that will get you into you know, one elite college or another. And that's kind of where I thought we were going, was that this was going to be about, Yeah, this is a really happy little community and whoever it is helps keep it safe. But the question is what's the cost to others to keep this community what it is? And we didn't get that story, and I was very happy with a story we got, but I do think like at some point I would love to see like

Speaker 4going back to under the Empire, like, what was life like from more of those planets where things were mostly running pretty well and the people were pretty happy, and they may have thought about like, oh, we don't want these, you know, agitators rocking the boats as people who were comfortable under empire will generally say about the folks who are not so happy.

Speaker 3It would be interesting to see something like that.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think it's been explored in some of the book books, So you get to put in to be Alex here for a moment. Kriscano also writes, Alex, I have a theory on why the ship was so ready to go. So this is because I think Alex was talking about finding it weird.

Speaker 3Yeah, he criticized the ship.

Speaker 4Yeah, And Carscano says, I'm a flight paramedic on a helicopter and I can tell you that a we trust our mechanics one hundred percent with keeping our aircraft ready to go in a moment's notice, and to that end, we always full the tanks when we get back to base after a mission so they're ready for the next mission. If SM thirty three and the previous captain were expected to have to book it off at at the snap of a finger, they may have made sure to advance the ship was ready to go.

Speaker 3Hmmm, that's a good point. First of all, really cool job. Thank you for sharing that with us. That's cool. But yeah, that's a great point that I always love insight for people who actually live in that aspect of the real world, because yeah, I don't know shit about planes. Like my sister's a pilot, she flies for some country, but I don't know that stuff. But yeah, that's a great point. Just how they probably did have that ship kind of prepped and ready, and based on the captain's logs that we saw later in the show, I think that's one

Speaker 3hundred percent true. Is he had the plan to like go in and come back out right and just something something went wrong, which I also liked that we never fleshed out what went wrong. Yeah, other than like the idea of mutiny.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think you're right, because sometimes it's fun just to keep mysteries alive and not really know all the details. But you know, I also say, like, I'm the kind of person who if I check my cruising rate if my gas thing is on, but I know that I can get about ten more miles out of my car and my home is seven miles away. I used to be the kind of person who'd be like, all right, well, I'll just get home and tomorrow, you know, filling out the tank.

Speaker 6It's gonna be tomorrow Matthew's problem. And then tomorrow.

Speaker 4Matthew is a procrastinator and says, I will get in my car when I'm exactly ten minutes to go to go ten minutes and then realize, oh, no, I have to put my gas in my car.

Speaker 6Yep, what the hell was yesterday, Mathe?

Speaker 4You're doing so yes, this idea not only do you have a cool job, you have a good perspective. Because this idea of keep keep the thing fueled up for the emergency in the future, maybe a lesson I could learn so good on that.

Speaker 3Honestly, that's the lesson I've had to learn too, especially when it's but cold here in Minnesota this past week and a half. Like I'm talking negative fifteen, Like it's not roadshield, Yeah, it's not. It's not good. And every day my car starts as a miracle. And yesterday I was low on gas and I was like, I think that's going to be tomorrow Aaron's problem. If I stopped myself. I said it's going to be colder in the morning, so then I did it yesterday.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 4I haven't gone out for a couple of days, in part because I know I have to feel out my car and I don't.

Speaker 6Want to do this weather.

Speaker 3So it's so cold.

Speaker 6Yeah, when door dash can come, bring someone to feel my car, let me know.

Speaker 4And also he thanked us each for a couple of things that it apparently made him laugh out loud. From Alex, it was, oh my god, Max Reebo is Neil's dad.

Speaker 6I am sad to.

Speaker 4Say we've officially gotten word on what race, what species Neil is and it's not the same species as Max Rebo, so that theory dies a hard death, but they are both perhaps the elephant genus somehow.

Speaker 6For me it was for me it was shot trunk wedding, which thank.

Speaker 4You I am, I am, And apparently Eliza aka Aaron aka Today the real good guys, he quite enjoyed your phrase the historical documents and immediately picked up that that was a Galaxy Quest reference, which I appreciate it as well.

Speaker 6So well done, well done.

Speaker 3Do you want to know something crazy?

Speaker 6You had no idea that if that's a Galaxy Quest reference.

Speaker 3I have no idea what Galaxy Quest is.

Speaker 4Okay, well we're happening. Sorry. Galaxy Quest is both it is specific the Star Trek, but it could apply to a lot of this one of the best both parodies but also love letters to fandom.

Speaker 3Oh okay, so is it like Spaceballs, but like actually a love letter and not just like making fun of.

Speaker 6Yeah, yeah, it's it's about very short version.

Speaker 4It's about the crew of a TV show like Star Trek who get pulled into a real life version of it. And part of the idea is that they meet these aliens who don't understand the concept of fiction, and so they got all these broadcasts of the Star Trek show and referred to them as historical documents.

Speaker 3Yes, that's awesome. Well just take that out. No, I knew exactly what I was doing.

Speaker 6Exactly exactly. All right.

Speaker 4We have two last comments. Then we're gonna have our member section. Of course, you become a member fromly five dollars a month fifty five dollars a year. We have our bonus section for members coming up the end of the month. We're gonna be continuing our book club this month. We're gonna be talking about just the books in general and why we find the Star books adds so much to the Cannon and to our enjoyment of it all, including some of the books from earlier Canons as well EU as well as Disney Cannon. But all the informations in our show notes. But for now, let's get back to the two. More comments from Andy Nelson, who's one of the UH podcastmos who runs all of this. He writes,

Speaker 4I finished watching it last night, and I have to say it was a ton of fun, great group of kids, and Jude Law was perfect as the pirate.

Speaker 6I wasn't thrilled that the supervisor.

Speaker 4Ended up being a big computer, but in the scope of things, I think it was a bit of an easy way out because it would be harder to like Jod had it been a person that he'd actually killed. And we've never really seen essentially droids controlling everything before, so it seemed a bit of an anomaly. And like you, Matthew, I wish there's a bit more at the end. I get it, it's the kid's story and we end with a successful end of a big adventure, but a scope of things I could have used a little something more. That being said, I was still satisfied with what we got. So this was a common Alex and I had brought up that we kind of wanted a little bit more in an epilogue of like seeing where everyone is. You know,

Speaker 4a week or two or a couple of months after this, did you have any that same feeling?

Speaker 3I mean no, like yes and no. Like part of me wants it, but I also did not expect it in the show. Yeah, Like I didn't think that they would do an epilogue. I kind of thought they would just kind of tie it off and leave it as they did. So I wasn't disappointed or felt like something was lacking when we didn't get more. But I always do love a little follow up, So I mean, part of me is still hoping that they do like a comic book of like the setup of at Aton or something like that. I will agree about the droid stuff.

Speaker 3I mean that's something my dad said too. He's like, really, it's just a droid, and then when he stabbed it with the lightsaber, he's like, no fucking way, it's that easy to kill, Like, no way, Like that's bol But one thing I loved was that Sarah knew it was a droid, like everyone knows it's a droid, because in my head I kind of was thinking, well, if they're being controlled droid, then like it's got to be this kind of Wizard of Oz level veil of secrecy. You know, you think it's somebody but it's not. But no, Pharah

Speaker 3was like, yeah, for sure, it's a droid, Like duh, he knows best. And that was just interesting to see how far into the system she kind of was, whether it's good or bad. You know, she just truly didn't see a single problem, you know. Yeah, I was just so excited for Frin to go meet this giant droid.

Speaker 4Right, Yeah, It's just what you always knew. And it's funny because and I'll admit my feelings on this were exacerbated by the fact that, like I literally paused the watch of that last episode so that I could be on the phone with my healthcare company trying to sort something out, and I got stuck in one of those phone trees where it feels like, oh, nothing you say is actually being listened to and you can't actually get to talk to someone. And so the whole time the parents were trying to explain things to the droids, and the droids were just like the security droids were just not listening and to repeating the same information and acting

Speaker 4like they were so helpful. I was like, I get your frustration right now. This is this is very real. So last comment Riki Riki the co host over on Superhero Ethics but has also been on a lot of great Star Wars content. He writes a satisfying conclusion to a good show. The VFX looked not great, but especially for a lot of the hover the v the VFX the special effects looked not great, but especially for a lot of the hoverbike scenes, which is weird because nighttime

Speaker 4scenes have traditionally been used to hide VFX, but in this case, the suburban globe perhaps showed too much. Like Aaron, I had a theory that Renod, like Aaron, I had a theory that Renod would be the supervisor, but even in episode seven that started to look less likely, and the whole automated control started to seem like where we were going. I have questions why didn't anyone of the Empire know about this planet? But it's fine for this to not be explained right now. They've left a door wide open for a good season two with John unaccounted for, also hoping that the Pirate vein survives, and he just

Speaker 4becomes this returning, recurring joke where every crew he joins gets wrecked.

Speaker 3Every crew Jod joins, every.

Speaker 6Crew Vein joins. Oh I guess yeah, I think I think was Jod. Right, who's Vain? Let me let me look that up.

Speaker 4Oh yeah, okay, so Vain just remind people was the nickto, the guy with kind of like a leathery looking face and horns who was on the.

Speaker 6I think he's the same same species as.

Speaker 4Handu a naka showing a lot of people who worked for him, and he was kind of the second command once once Jod took over.

Speaker 3Yes, yeah, I think that would not a nikto, but that would be a great joke. Yes, yeah, I will say. I'm a little bit bummed that blurb died because I was looking forward to that glow weed farm good. I wanted to know what that meant.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, I think that there was a lot of fun little guys like that, you know, like most of that pirate crew survived, so I think.

Speaker 3Yeah, get Kona, she was a battye mm hmm.

Speaker 6She was fun.

Speaker 3I appreciated the kind of Pacific islander theme that she had. Mm hmm yep, yeah, I think it would be fun to see this crew.

Speaker 6Mm hmm.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, I think it'd be fun to see this crew. I think it'd be fun to see more of the Pirate Code. Certainly SME thirty three is one that I want to see come back a lot. So yeah, I think overall a great show that just left us a lot of good things to talk about.

Speaker 3Yeah, I definitely want a Pirate's comic. I want to know about Tac rennerd please, yeah, please, Like I appreciate that it was mysterious, but also now the show's over, spill a beines, let's be here. I want to know.

Speaker 4Well, we already know that one of the books we're getting next year is gonna is gonna pick up some more.

Speaker 6Of the Acolyte story.

Speaker 4So okay, So I think that the idea of that things that are introduced in TV and either where we're not gonna get into all the reasons why I act like I canceled and maybe we'll get saved. But whatever it is for shows where there it leaves a lot more questions than it answers than I think the books and comic books and things like that are gonna be a really good place to see the next board. Yeah well all right, well, thank you so much Aaron for being a part of this. Thank you much for our listeners for writing in with your thoughts and feedback. Please

Speaker 4remember to keep doing that. We love feedback. We're gonna spend in the next couple of months going over a lot of fun things as we get ready for and or kicking off in May. Uh and if you're a member of course, stick around. We're doing our next story in the story archive from a certain point of view.

Speaker 6For everybody else, thank you so much. We have.

Speaker 3I promise I'll watch Galaxy quests. Stay glassy at Atten

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode