Welcome to Star Wars Generations, where hosts Erin, Alex, and Matthew dive deep into the galaxy far, far away! In this episode, the trio tackles the controversial yet thought-provoking film, The Last Jedi. Buckle up for a thrilling discussion that challenges expectations and explores new perspectives on the Star Wars universe. This movie had so much to discuss that we’ll likely to return to some of the themes we didn’t get to explore in a part II.The hosts kick off by addressing the burning question: Is The Last Jedi a masterpiece or a misfire? (Spoilers, we love it). They explore how the film subverts traditional Star Wars tropes and pushes the boundaries of what fans expect from the franchise. The conversation delves into the movie's portrayal of failure and its impact on character growth, particularly for Luke, Rey, Poe, and Finn.One of the most hotly debated topics is Luke Skywalker's character arc. The hosts ponder: Does Luke's portrayal in The Last Jedi stay true to his legacy? They discuss the significance of Luke's disillusionment with the Jedi Order and how it reflects larger themes within the Star Wars Saga.The episode also tackles the controversial Canto Bight sequence. The hosts examine whether this subplot serves a greater purpose in the narrative or if it's a distracting detour. They debate the effectiveness of the film's commentary on war profiteering and its place within the Star Wars universe.Other topics covered include: The stunning visuals of the Holdo Maneuver and its implications for Star Wars lore Vice Admiral Holdo's leadership style and its reception among fans Rey's journey and the reveal of her parentage The evolving relationship between Rey and Kylo Ren Leia's use of the Force and its execution on screen The film's approach to the nature of the Force and balance As the discussion wraps up, the hosts reflect on how The Last Jedi challenges viewers to reconsider their preconceptions about Star Wars. They emphasize the film's bold choices and its potential impact on the future of the franchise. Whether you love it or hate it, this episode of Star Wars Generations offers a fresh perspective on one of the most divisive entries in the Skywalker saga. Don't miss this engaging exploration of The Last Jedi and its place in Star Wars history!Bonus content on the upcoming Star Wars: Skeleton Crew! We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Before we dive in, here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM Family of Entertainment podcasts.
Speaker 2Well, howdy folks. My name is Lester Ryan Clark, and I'm Keenandias and we're the hosts of The Exorcist Minute, a show where we examine, extrapolate, and excavate the scariest movie of all time.
Speaker 3Each episode covers a single minute of William Friedkin's nineteen seventy three horror masterpiece, The Exorcist.
Speaker 2If you like deep dives, this show is the deepest.
Speaker 3Did you know the film's iconic theme song, Jubular Bells wasn't written specifically for the movie, Or.
Speaker 2That the nineteen seventy three audience members were throwing up and fainting in the theater before they ever got a glimpse of the demon.
Speaker 3What about all the crazy onset mishaps, cast injuries the director of firing real guns?
Speaker 2Ever wonder where weiji boards came from or how they got their name. How about some history on the Catholic Church or the Roman rite of exorcism, or maybe we can tempt you with some juicy demonology. Lourd, did you know that Bazuzu had an ex wife. Find the Exorcist Minute on iTunes or Spotify or wherever you listen to your shows, or at the exorcistminute dot com. Until next time, Folks.
Speaker 3The power of the Exorcist compels.
Speaker 1You ever wonder what bridges the gap between your favorite film genres, subgenres, and movements. CinemaScope is here to explore these connections, taking you on a thrilling odyssey through the ever evolving art of cinema. I'm your host, Andy Nelson, and in each episode, we embark on a deep dive into the forces that sculpt the world of film, from the styles you know in love, like higst films or the French New Wave, to the ones you may not be as familiar with, like Turkish Yeshelcham or Brazilian Nordsterns.
Speaker 1My expert guests and I unravel the complex tapestry of storytelling, style, and innovation that defines the world of film. As we unpact the myriad catalysts of change that shape these diverse styles. Whether you're a student of film, a creative professional, or simply a devoted movie enthusiast, CinemaScope is your gateway to a richer more immersive film experience. Don't just watch movies, understand them, appreciate them, and revel in their artistry with CinemaScope.
Speaker 3Subscribe today.
Speaker 4Hello, and welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. Today we're continuing our trip through the movies and we are talking about the completely non controversial everyone's in the same general opinion about it, the Last Jedi Episode eight, and we've got the normal crew here, myself Matthew, along with co hosts Alex and Aaron. Those of you who may have seen on the Facebook group that we have vi ethical pan of podcasts on Facebook, Aaron and I kind of did a live watch of this together. Don't worry the mouse. We don't want to accept them out the mouse. We did not in any way broadcast
Speaker 4the movie, but we did sort of both hit to play at the same time. We had a great chat about it. People message me about it, so they really enjoyed it, so that was great. You can check out some of our thoughts there as we were watching the movie, but today we're gonna be talking about it. So let me just kind of jump in right from the start and say, what do y'all think of this? Movie.
Speaker 5Love it. I really enjoyed it. It's probably so I watched it last week or the week before when we were originally supposed to record on it, and that was I think only my second time seeing it, and then I watched it for a third turn third time as we were commenting on Facebook. So it's just I feel like now that I've seen it twice within like the last month, I'm starting to like really pick up on little things and enjoy it a little deeper.
Speaker 6That's awesome.
Speaker 4That's awesome.
Speaker 7I've always enjoyed it as well. I think I have a few small grapes with it.
Speaker 6But not enough to take away my enjoyment. Like I think that.
Speaker 7It, you know, has one of the most it makes you like it's the first Star Wars movie that kind of went away from the classic tropes and stereotypes of the films and kind of challenge a lot of them, like head on, and I think the way that Ryan Johnson like interprets the Force and the Jedi, I think really led the way and led the path to a lot of what we're seeing in the modern content being made by Disney. And so I know, I thoughly enjoy it and I'm excited to talk more about it. And yeah, none of my concerns about the movie really are that heavy.
Speaker 4I don't think, yeah, this is a movie I think that really helps us remember, at least me, that Star Wars is so many different things, and Star Wars is movies that can be really entertaining, and Star Wars is this epic conversation that has spread now over almost fifty years about the nature of right and wrong and good and bad and how those things work in our universe. And I feel like Ryan Johnson gets Star Wars in the way that I get it, and that a way
Speaker 4I think a lot of the Star Wars creators get it in a way that almost no one else does. And I kind of in some ways I put this movie on the same level of The Acolyte in that I think this is much much better, to be clear, but I think both it and The Acolyte have an understanding of the Star Wars universe that is very much in line with my own and that I really love because it challenges me and it makes me think about the universal ways that really makes sense. I think in both cases, the Acolyte much more so, but also in
Speaker 4this the execution of how that message is delivered is not always the best, right. I think it doesn't hit prequel level of problems, which again I think has some great Star Wars messaging, but it isn't necessarily always my personal favorite.
Speaker 6Right there, I nod.
Speaker 4I'm setting it up because I've come to enjoy that the prequel is a lot more and I do think this is a much better movie. But I think I but part of the way I bring that up is because there's two things that kept coming to me as I was watching this movie. One is that I think a lot of the reason why people feel unsatisfied by it is that it's set up questions that if they had been paid off in the ninth movie, I think people would think this was one of the best Star Wars movies ever made the way I do. I think the fact that it wasn't kind of makes people think
Speaker 4about these things in different ways. And also just because I, yeah, I just love everything abou how it challenges thinks. So I forgot what was the second point I was gonna make, So let you kind of just keep going on that and then we'll have it as some more specifics.
Speaker 5I agree. I think if there's more continuity that this film would probably have a more popular outlook among like the general Star Wars fans, because it's hard anytime you have a trilogy that's disjointed, it's just hard to like judge it all if the story is not continuous, and it's easy to kind of pick something out as like, well, that doesn't work because it doesn't work, and then you just assume it's a bad piece of art.
Speaker 4One thing I kept thinking about is, you know, if you dig into history, you know that when Empire Strikes Back came out, a lot of people hated it and there's a lot of really negative feeling about how could this guy be his father? You know what does that mean? Imagine if in the next movie and Return of the Jedi, they decided, yeah, that was a bad idea, or just a new director, whatever it was, but for whatever reason or George change his mind. In the third movie, Luke goes to Yoda and Obi Wan and like, yeah, we told you Darth Vader would lie to you. Of course he's not your father, and then the movie just went on. I think we all look at that as like Empire
Speaker 4Strikes Back was horrible and terrible for like setting this up and that yet you know, I watch. What I think is there's this incredible realization from Ray and then also Kylo like getting it at her about it that she doesn't come from this great line of Skywalker's or Kenobi's or anything like that. She just is a person whose parents were kind of terrible people and who yet still has this power. And then in the next movie you're like, oh no, actually she's Palpatine's granddaughter kind of sort of, and I it made me think about that, Like,
Speaker 4I think part of why Empire works so well is because Return of the Jedi pays it off so much. And I think that if Return of the Jedi hadn't done that, we would kind of, I think unfairly view Empire in a very negative light. And I guess that's kind of one of my main defenses of Last Jedi is I think a lot of the things people don't like about it they don't like because they didn't get the payoff they deserved.
Speaker 7I also think it's just I think part of it is what we talked about the fact that like it was Abrams and then Johnson and the back to Abrams.
Speaker 6I think they should just either had Abrams do all three.
Speaker 7And then had Ryan do his own movies or had a different director do each one. So it's not like totally I don't know, cause it feels like to me at least J. J. Abrams had a very specific story in his head of how he wanted this to go.
Speaker 6Ryan saw things differently and kind of.
Speaker 7I mean down it like the simplest thing of like, you know, Ryan Johnson destroys Kyle Wren's mask and then J. J.
Speaker 6Abrams puts it back together in episode nine.
Speaker 7Like it's like there's so many things they just disagreed on, I think, and how they were viewing Star Wars, And I'm not going to sit here and argue as a whole other episode of who was more right in their interpretation. I just think you can't have two different interpretations and expect it to seem like connected. And I think that like people who especially like in the media after after the movie, I think they saw it to such a departure from what they were getting in episode seven that you know, if it had been Ryan directing episode seven and more continuous, I think, like you're right, Matthew.
Speaker 6People would have considered it to be one of the best movies ever.
Speaker 7And like, I think that if it had been more just kind of toned down j j ams doing it again, people would just been like, Eh, it would have been controversy, but it would have been like blown me away either.
Speaker 6Like, I don't know. I think that.
Speaker 7It's just the dysfunctionality of having two directors go back and forth in such a yo yoing storyline and the fact that like Lucasfilm kind of let them do that is what I think does this movie as a service that makes it hard to study within this trilogy as a whole, or the story as a whole, honestly, because it feels to me like the.
Speaker 6Most unique of all nine movies.
Speaker 7When it comes to the way it's interpreting lore and characters and you know, just it's also the longest.
Speaker 6It is two and a half more than two and a half hour.
Speaker 7It is the longest movie of any of the Star Wars movies. So it also goes in depth the most, I think. So, yeah, I don't know, let's get to some specifics though.
Speaker 6Let's let's let's dive into the to the meet and yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah, well, let's starts then with the character of Poe and first just with that opening scene where he's teasing Hawks. I know a lot of people felt like this took them out of it. I absolutely love this scene of him kind of getting at Hawks and finding ways to get under his skin. What do you think of it?
Speaker 6Oh?
Speaker 5I love it. I think it's just so fun because like the you know, opening scroll is so like dramatic, and then like the opening scene and everything, and then Poe's like, sorry, I have a bad connection. Yeah no, I'll hold Yeah, it's fine, and then he makes a yomama joke. It's just I feel like it sets up the movie to honestly be different than any other Star Wars film, right.
Speaker 7I mean, I think it's it's very accurate to like I feel I mean, I've never fought in a war, but I feel like trolling would go on to some degree and these kind of like battles and stuff, and so to me, it felt kind of realistic to like Poe being like the hot head and you know, hot shot that he is, would be trolling Hucks. And I remember watching it was the documentary or what, but like an interview with Ryan Johnson about how like they put that in there and they almost took it out because they were afraid, like you said, right, they would like you know, it would either set the tone or it would like take people out of it.
Speaker 6And he was like, you're ryan to said, like now everybody want to send there.
Speaker 7He fought for it, and then when he Saibody went to the first premiere, he was so anxious for the movie until that joke hit and people laughed, and then he felt really good moving forward because he was like that was reassurance for him that like it was the right choice to leave it in.
Speaker 4Yeah, And I part of why I love it is because I do see this movie through very much the terms of when it was made. And you know, this was made at a time when it felt like concerned. I'm going to put it in a very kind of political standpoint because our wars has always been very political, but you know, there was a real sense of kind of like we're all waiting for someone to come rescue us, and the message of kind of like we have to look at our own failures, we have to learn from our failures, and we also have to stop waiting for someone to come just because we think were right. You
Speaker 4have to figure out a new strategy. Those things really hit me hard and in that vein, Like this movie was made not that long ago and when social media discussions were very much a toxic but thing that was happening just like today. And I commented to Aaron as we were watching it back and forth, the idea of like responding to someone who's just gonna bluster and just going to give you speeches by just as you said, trolling them, making fun of them, you know, And it just reminds me of some of I think the most satisfying social media stuff you'll see when someone is just
Speaker 4going on there like rant about you know, queer people or immigrants or whatever it is, and just mocking them and taking out it's kind of like the modern like you're just so weird, you know, taking out The idea that anyone ever take this seriously is just so perfect, and you can see that. Like the idea that they just let this ship sit there while it's screwing with their computers and like getting ready to do this attack run for twenty minutes for you know, sixty second or whatever without even putting a single tie fighter in the
Speaker 4air is so ludicrous. But of course he gets that unmtch under their skin. That Hucks isn't thinking of launch the tie fighters be ready for this, He's thinking, you know, why is this person listening to my bluster?
Speaker 6I do wish I can't remember. Oh my god, I'm bak at his name.
Speaker 7But with the the the guy on the bridge who was like giving all the orders in that fight, Uh is it?
Speaker 6Do you know what I'm talking about?
Speaker 7What kind of the crimudgeny guy? Oh my god, what is his name? I can like hear his voice and see his face. My point is I wish he had not, you know, died in an opening scene. I thought he would have been a really compelling, fun like villainous character to move forward.
Speaker 6And I was sad that he died. That was just what side note.
Speaker 7But I can't remember his name, so that's fair tragic.
Speaker 6Tragic, I will say.
Speaker 7In the opening sequence, though, I was the only thing that kind of took me out, honestly, more than the joke was how slow the bombers moved. Like I understand it was like for dramatic effect, but like you're gonna launch these And I know that's a part of the reason Poe was like doing his whole bit, But like, I don't know in the world of Star Wars, the bombers are gonna be that slow and you're gonna watch them from that far away, and just I don't know, I just after, I mean, I understand the way that
Speaker 7Star Wars has made, Like after seeing like some of the things they pulled off in the Clone Wars and other parts of Star Wars, like that just felt very like, come on, y'all, it's got to be a better plan than this.
Speaker 4You felt clunky. And I think that's kind of what I meant before about like that, I think sometimes the execution failed. Yeah, I always will carry a little bit of a grudge against those bombers because, as I've mentioned before, I was working at a like game store and we sold you know, things for X Wing the game, and we wanted them to go on sale the day that the movie launched, and so I was opening up the boxes four days and it's set on the box. You know, this is the thing that destroys the what I got spoiled for part of the movie because of And yeah, like I felt like it was meant to be an
Speaker 4homage to like the great you know bomber runs over you know, Germany or Japan or whatever, and like the way those have been highlighted in documentaries like movies like an Ola Gay and stuff like that, and the whole thing about like the way the bombs drop, but like that all depends on gravity, and I guess those ships are close enough to the planet that like the gravity is still affecting them somewhat. But it just felt like this is a very poor design for a spaceship. I like what it's set up, and I love the whole element of you know, Poe was wrong that we're going
Speaker 4to talk about in just a second, but it did seem like the bomber thing was a little silly.
Speaker 5I do have some input about that, because I'm sitting as you guys are talking. I'm sitting here like, okay, how many high speed bombers have we seen in the Clone Wars? In rebels in I like things like that. And then and then I thought to myself, four hundred resists stuts a secret military. They don't have the best stuff. They have anything they can get their hands on. That's my thought process is like, maybe it's highlighting just how.
Speaker 6What would you say, discrecared?
Speaker 5Maybe desperate? Yeah, yeah, the resistance is and that like yeah, it does make you think all these questions. Its like a certain type of homage and like kind of nostalgia to it, right.
Speaker 7I mean, I think that's goes back to the failure of them to like and we talked about in episode seven, but like properly describe like the Resistance connection to the New Republic or like if the Republic suite was completely wiped out, because like that was never clearly established. So like in theory, the Resistance should have good stuff, as we've seen episode eight, they have nothing. And it's just I think it's just that goes back to the disconnect that occur between the movies.
Speaker 4Yeah, I think if we, like the y Wing was established as a bomber and so if they said, like these are literally y Wings from the days of the you know, war against the initial Empire, Like, yeah, I think that would have because I get what you're saying. I think that we could have used another line or two to set it up.
Speaker 6Yep.
Speaker 4But okay, so let's talk about that. What actually happens though, because it does feel like the whole thing is shot as this like heroic last sacrifice. We watch this character who we don't know, but clearly this like necklace thing that she has that's half of something is really important to her. She kicks the controller, it falls, she grabs it, and she sets off the bombs and dies in that moment, and the Dreadnaught is destroyed. I don't know why the shields didn't stop the bombs, but we'll move past that, and then of course we get to the moment where she, you know, Poe comes back feeling so heroic, and Leah
Speaker 4just does that wonderful dress down and the you know, dead heroes there were no leaders, which is one of my favorite lines in the movie. What y'all think of that? Because I think that's where a lot of people already start to get off the bus, because it is very much subverting expectations not only of this movie, but just like everything people had seen. You know, I I think this is still the case, but especially in like the eighties, nineties, two thousands. How many times have we seen a movie about a cop or a soldier or an avenger or whoever.
Speaker 4You know. Nick Fury is saying to the council, I understand your decision. It's a stupid decision.
Speaker 6It's my favorite lines and all of the mart.
Speaker 4Every lethal weapon movie is about the captain saying doing it this way, and our hero is being like, no, no, I'm gonna go I'm gonna do the brave thing. It's always set up as that the Poe character is right and the Layer character is wrong, and so for it to be flipped around here, what do you'll think of that?
Speaker 7I mean, I could be default to lay always being correct, so it didn't surprise me.
Speaker 5Yeah, I was gonna say, I'm on the Laya's side because like, okay, so once the bombers dropped the bombs, the bombs are gonna go off, right, these bombers are slow as hell, They're all gonna blow up, Like this was a suicide mission from the start, or Poe just didn't think ahead five minutes, like it's just not a good plan. And that's exactly what Lea was saying, is like that had the reward did not pay off the losses, Like what did we gain from this?
Speaker 6Not much?
Speaker 5But now we have basically no fleet and a ton of dead people.
Speaker 7I mean, it felt like, based on the way that the movie progressed that like Poe kind of thought was playing together in Lay, I very begrudgingly approved it. Because they felt kind of desperate, and then when she tried to like change it in the middle, he just kind of ignored her because like, I don't think lame with this plan, but like she did clearly approve it in the first place, or it wouldn't have launched. But then like when she gave orders to pull back, Yeah, I don't know. I mean I've always throw all the movies. Lea has always been right, le yeah, very rarely wrong. So I feel like, uh, you know, I don't know,
Speaker 7I never really thought about it as being a reversal of those roles, but I mean you make a good point that usually like yeah, you know, he made the sacrifice. We did it, we did that for for the cause. But they destroyed one NOD of hundreds, and you know it wasn't like, you know, they lost so many lives in already very dwindled resistance.
Speaker 4I always bought the phone and everything up. Anyway, the fact that snoke ship arrives almost immediately afterwards the next time they stop them in hyperspace, and you know, it's just as powerful as a dreadnought, if not more so, with such an effective way of being Like, yeah, this was you blew up one ship at the cost of so much. Yeah, and what do we think about the rest of those arc and and kind of I guess that can wrap the thin conversation into it as well.
Speaker 5I liked that we saw him truly and genuinely learn because, like you guys are saying so often, like the rebellious heroes that you know, like go against the initial plan or disobey there higher ups is like that's the thing to do to get stuff done. And I feel like oftentimes we see a hero like Anakin Skywalker just continue to do that over and over, even though you know it's a toss up if it's going to be a good idea or not. So Yeah, I liked that we
Speaker 5saw Poe actually grow. And this is something you pointed out later in the movie, Matthew, about how when they're in the caves being you know, attacked by all this firepower and there's no way out and Luke goes out to fight. Finn's like, we gotta go, we gotta help him, and Poe says no, like he's here for a reason, He's giving us time to escape, Like how did he get in here? Where did he come from? Where can we go and that's when he said where are the critters?
Speaker 5And you brought up the idea of Matthew of like trust. He didn't trust in Leo when she said don't do that. He didn't trust in Holdo when she said you're in the brig or whatever when she said anything. He never trusted Holdo. And then he finally learned toward the end of the movie, which saved all of their asses because Finn was about to go run out and then they'd all die.
Speaker 6Yep.
Speaker 5So yeah, I liked that we actually see a positive arc in this movie for him.
Speaker 4Yeah, and I wanted to highlight I think we've talked about it in one of our book clubs. If not, we will definitely do at some point. But the book Resistance Rising is about the period in between this movie and the last movie, Rise of Skywalker, And one thing he talks about is that Poe is really like both blaming himself but also a lot of other people are really blaming him for the mistakes that were made. And you know how many of the transports were lost because of this, you know, ridiculous plan they came up with to try and break into the Death Star, try to break into the Dreadnaught, and it's just it always felt
Speaker 4like he kind of got off the hook kind of easily. And I really liked that the book really highlights that, like no, for both most of the Resistance, but also for him himself. He really goes through a period of mourning and of you know, blaming himself and realizing like he made this huge mistake and he has to learn from.
Speaker 5That's that's cool, little additional info. That's what I love so much about like the books and how holistic this fandom is is there's always more little secrets and things you can find and learn.
Speaker 4Yeah, because I do think that kind of taking the rest of Poe's and I think now Finn's story, I do think that the Canto bite scene is I think probably the worst in the movie, you know, And it's just I like the general idea of it, and I like the idea of wanting to kind of talk about war profiteering and the problem that that is, and the idea that like, you know, even the Resistance is spending money that are benefiting the war profiteers and stuff like that. But it just all feels like it's done in such
Speaker 4a ham fisted, heavy handed way, like I've been to Vegas. Not everyone there is evil and terrible, you know, it's the whole thing is not like you know, happy Sunshine and Roses Town. But but the overall idea of Poe and Finn don't trust Holdo and so they feel like they have to come up with this plan and it's hair brained from the beginning, and at leads to some fun adventure scenes, but in the end, all it does is to make it worse. I wish the actual scenes
Speaker 4had been better, But I think someone who says it was just a waste of time completely misses the point. Like to me, it is the most one of the most important parts of the movie. Just in reiterating this idea of like they failed, that's the whole point. It doesn't always work out the way we think it is. The good guys don't always come up with a crazy plan, and that maybe sometimes when a person who has more of a larger picture than you does, especially you know when the gender aspects of it, maybe listening to them is not the worst ady of the world.
Speaker 5May I have an input, so I would like to think about, Yes, they failed in completing their objective, but something Rose said kind of has to me thinking when they right before they're captured or they think they're about to be captured. After they break out of the jail, Finn said, like, well, we tore up this fancy town, you know, hopefully it was all worth it or something like that or like yeah, and Rose said, she goes
Speaker 5over to one of the animals that's been enslaved. She takes off his collar and she says, now it's worth it, Like now this is worth it, right, And I think it's like a subtle and like beautiful way to portray like yeah, even when shit goes wrong, and like even when you actually get a shit somet of people killed, like they're still good that you did. Like the way that they interacted with those stable boys. You know, we see at the end of the movie she gave her resistance rank to one of them. That sparked the hope of rebellion in that whole community. And that's such a
Speaker 5big thing for these movies, and especially for the rebellion the resistance. You know, it's just about hope and like fostering that in the younger generations because they're the ones really have a stake in this. So I kind of liked that we saw these very just subtle interactions of how even though they didn't succeed, they still made a change.
Speaker 7Yeah, can the Candi wedd scenes the part of the movie I personally dislike, like.
Speaker 6The very strongly.
Speaker 7Now it's I really like the concept as well, Like, I love that we got to see like the scene where they describe what you know, it was like, let's see what this guy is selling to. Oh, he's selling to the good guys and the bad guys. It's all just one big war profiteering scheme. I really liked the heart of that. I liked the idea behind it, but it's just like, to me, it felt like that basically they just didn't really know what to do with Finn because throughout the trophy of like you see a Jedi, see now a Jedi, what's gonna happen? What they marketed him so heavily as being like, you know, a Jedi
Speaker 7alongside Ray or some kind of you know, larger presence in the Resistance, and then like in this movie, it's kind of just like relegated to the side quest and in the end, Yeah, sure those small changes are definitely made, but it also results, I mean I know you were talking about how like not all things go as planned, but it results in just half the resistance being wiped out when it was like it was like an ill an ill conceived plan that it just felt like whenever we were there, I feel like he was taking me
Speaker 7out of some of the main storylines.
Speaker 6And I don't know if like maybe we needed to spend.
Speaker 7More time at Cancel Bite, or maybe if we needed to just like execute it better, because like I really did like the concept behind it, but the execution is always just every time I, like I get into those scenes, I kind of roll my eyes. I'm just like this is taking me out of the movie a little bit. And like I mean, like, yeah, they saved sam animals, but they also cause half their comrades to be murdered because they trusted some guy they found in a jail cell to you know, get them onto a capital ship.
Speaker 6It just don't know.
Speaker 7It felt like everyone gets mad at Poe for him being kind of cavalier, but Finn and Rose took a lot of a lot of risk and chances with absolutely no authority to do so and ended up pausing a lot of death same as Poe, and I feel like we get Poe that wrap to that and don't talk about that enough, So again I went to the concept behind it. I just the execution has really always bothered me. That specifically is the one part of this movie that I disliked the most. I really love the rest of it pretty wholeheartedly, but the canto bite bits just really get me, and they mess up the pacing for me
Speaker 7as well.
Speaker 6It's just like, I.
Speaker 7Don't know, I don't know, it's just my my thoughts on cant but.
Speaker 4I think the first time I saw it, I thought it was fun and engaging, and then the more I thought about it, I was like, yeah, I don't really get that, and I think you're right, we do focus more on po Finn and Rose are also at fault there for sure, and you know, I think all of it goes in there and then they're just kind of the larger Like. I think Rose is a great character. I'm really glad they introduced her. I hate all the toxicity she faced and the act the actress Kelly Matron faced Matran I think is howy PROUTSI But also again
Speaker 4I don't know the inside story, but I know John Boyega has has hinted at some of this, and you know, there definitely was some pushback against Ray and Finn being potential romantic partners because she's white and he's black, and there's some other people who didn't want it for other reasons, but certainly that was a big thing. And according Touff, Boyega has said, and I think this is somewhat accurate, it did feel like they were trying very hard to in both the second and third movie pair Finn with another attractive woman to sort of take away the idea
Speaker 4of him and Ray being of having something potential. And there are possibly some very good story reasons for that in terms of like what happens with her and Kylo, though that's not my favorite, but that's another story. But it is like, I think we can't not mention the racism that that's part of all that, and that's just frustrating because like I think, I think, I think Rose is a great character. I think Rose was put in for reasons that are not the best, and which makes it harder.
Speaker 6I agree.
Speaker 4Also, maybe I'm off on a limb here. Finn never like signed up for the Resistance, he was never given an official rank. I think that He's like, you know what, You're on a ship that's about to get destroyed. I'm gonna take one of these escape pods and like, Sayonara because I want to go find my friend. I don't know why Rose is getting so mad at him for that, you know, like and I.
Speaker 6Finn do be.
Speaker 4I say that mostly as a joke, but I think there's also an interesting lesson there of And Aaron and I were talking about this. Rose has this mythologized idea of him of like you're the great hero. You you were part of the people who helped us destroy Star Killer basse or in actuality, like no, he never was going there. He was always going just Ray, And I think that's fine, the same way that like Han probably came back because he was like, yeah, Princess was pretty cute, man. Let me see if I can help well the Death Star and see what can happen. But uh, as well
Speaker 4as the affection for Luke. But yeah, so I just I just there's a lot of things that bothered me about that.
Speaker 7If I may change, unless anyone has something to say about this, I want to change subjects. Briefly, I'm very curious what y'all think about the one.
Speaker 6I think the one one of the Flashblob.
Speaker 7Moments in the movie that bothered a lot of people was if you go back to the beginning when Lea is jettisoned from the ship and then uses the force to pull her partially frozen self back into the ship and they open an airlock to outer space and no one gets sucked out, and it's.
Speaker 6Just a lot going on in that little moment there, And I'm just did that bother y'all?
Speaker 7Did y'all feel okay that she was forced had enough power in the force to do that?
Speaker 6Like it? To me?
Speaker 7It doesn't necessarily bother me per se, but it feels like it was kind of an unnecessary There's other ways you could have like immobilized her for the movie.
Speaker 6If you had to mobilize her, then that going down. I don't know. I'm curing for.
Speaker 5Me, Like I I personally believe that Lea is quite strong in the force. Obviously not like Looke level because she hasn't taken the time to train it, but I kind of have seen it as she uses it either in other ways because she has always used politics and leadership to fight battles, and she can use the force to be a better communicator, or it can just be something she doesn't need to be a badass, and she doesn't like violence are fighting, but in the dire moments
Speaker 5when it needs she needs it, she can use it. That being said, I fucking hated the scene. It looked so awkward having.
Speaker 8Her like Superman her way back to an airlock that should have killed everyone. So yeah, I think it's totally plausible for Leah to have that type of control over the force.
Speaker 5And even if it's like, oh, she gets blown out of the ship and uses the force to come back, just there could have been a better way to do it.
Speaker 6Those are kind of my thoughts on that scene. Matthew.
Speaker 4Yeah, it didn't bother me the way it did for the two of you. At first, I was just like, wait, shouldn't she be dead already? But then I did some reason, I seem to think that like two or three seconds of exposure to like space itself would kill a human being.
Speaker 6It's not.
Speaker 4It's actually like you can last like for ninety seconds a minute at least at over a minute beyond that. Though, I was one of the things that I've always had the idea of that I think a lot of the books have kind of underlined this, especially in the EU, but also in some of the more modern recent books. Is this idea that that, yeah, she has a lot of power in the Force, but she chooses not to engage with it, in part for all the reasons Aaron you were saying, but also because I think she has a realization of like I always think Star Wars has kind of an interesting take on the more power you have,
Speaker 4the more responsibility you have. Whereas here it's not just that it's you have more power, it's that you're now in more danger of being corrupted, and there's more of a need to be kind of like morally pure and good. And there's one thing in one of the EU books where Lea is basically like, look, I couldn't I didn't want to have the Force because I was going to be in the world where I had to cut deals, I had to make compromises, and for a politician to have the force is just way too easy for that to be corrupted because I'm doing things that are like a Jedi, I would see as the dark side all
Speaker 4the time, because that's how you win in politics. And so, yeah, her having the force in that moment, I thought was fine, And I think, honestly, part of why it didn't bother me is that it felt like this movie had fundamentally changed the rules of space combat to a large extent, because this was the second and second situation where I didn't know where the shields of the ship were. Like I said, before they destroyed all the cannons on top of the Dreadnaught. What a ship that big would have sh I have no understanding why the bombs just bounce
Speaker 4off the shields harmlessly. And here again, there hadn't been some big effort to destroy the shields of Home one or whatever that ship was called before that, the second Ratus, I thought Ratus was the admiral of it.
Speaker 5No, they name hold those ship Ratus in memoriam of Admiral Ratus.
Speaker 9Like.
Speaker 7Okay, well, yes, space ravel in space space battle.
Speaker 6With this movie, I think a lot of rules were rewritten.
Speaker 7I think there was just so many rewritten from that, from the shields to ley upon herself back into I mean, we'll talk about it at some point, but the whole maneuver just so many things that were like very new. I think that like Star Wars, fans struggle with newness in a world they like know all the details of them. When you introduce a lot of different mechanics that we haven't seen before, a lot of things all in one movie, it probably is part of the reason people got thrown off either loved it or hated it. People who were like have that open mind towards New Star Wars stuff
Speaker 7were like, yeah, this is sick with opening new world's possibilities of people.
Speaker 6Were like, oh my god, what has happened?
Speaker 7Like every little thing that was changed in different people were probably losing their mind about.
Speaker 6But the way the thing did was silly to me. It just looked silly.
Speaker 7I whether the actual action was silly, I don't think so, but like the way it was done with the little I think for.
Speaker 4Me the other me, we knew Carrie Fisher died before this movie came out, right, all.
Speaker 6Right, Yeah, I think very surely before.
Speaker 4So, so I think for me the other thing was and granted I think I probably got the date somewhat wrong. I knew that Carrie Fisher had died by the time this movie came out, And so when we saw the scene of the you know, the bridge of the ship being destroyed. I thought that was like, oh, that's how they're showing us that Princess Leiah died. And maybe maybe that was a late insert. Maybe it's knew that that carry fisher was probably not gonna live that much longer. I don't know the details, but so I was convinced she was dead, and so when they did this, I think that was she's not but like she's gonna have
Speaker 4to die. So yeah, it didn't bother me, And I think I think there's no problem with doing some new things, Like I think the Admiral Holdo maneuver is just one of the greatest scenes in any Star Wars properties that we've ever had. Oh yeah, And I don't give a damn about whether or not that's makes sense and anything else, but I think, yeah, like having to be so many things like that not seen to line up, it was a little.
Speaker 7Weird when when I when I was in the theater of the premiere and saw the Hotel maneuver, everyone in the whole theater went dead silent, and all you could hear me say, like I didn't mean to say something, but just out loud involuntarily, I just went oh, and like everyone started laughing, was like, oh, I'm still embarrassing, But that's all I could think of in that moment.
Speaker 4And I will say for anyone who has now read some of the High Republic books, that goes into more of the physics of like what happens when things in hyper space are going into hyperspace connect with things that aren't or anything like that. So definitely worked. Wow, let's talk about Luke, I was gonnay. Let's talk about holdough for two more and more second and then yeah, we never that's fine. What do you think of hold as a character?
Speaker 5I love her?
Speaker 6I okay, you go, I'd be quiet for now.
Speaker 7I was just gonna say she bothered me in the beginning, and I liked her by the end.
Speaker 6I think that she was a badass.
Speaker 7She was strong, she had good ideas, but she failed in one fundamental part of leadership, which is kind of like like you don't have to explain yourself as a leader. You're not required to do that. And I think Postion have been listening to her from the beginning. But like to just mention to one of your top you know, people in top people in general in the ship, like here is roughly a plan or like here is like we do have a plan, Like she wouldn't even tell Povid there was a plan, Like I.
Speaker 6Just there was distrust on post I.
Speaker 7But I feel like like Hodo could have done a little more in her people's skill was to make it a little bit like smoother in the ship.
Speaker 6Aaron disagrees.
Speaker 9First of all, he is a captain, not a general, so I know, not even a commander anymore, I said, I said, she didn't have to explain herself, but I feel like the.
Speaker 6Majority is could I understand for the crew, but there was a point speak.
Speaker 5No, you're good, I understand your point. I just feel like also to an extent, she was like punishing Poe, like.
Speaker 9Since you're asking, they had that whole meeting problem.
Speaker 5And yeah, I just feel like, I don't know. It's what Leah said, I feel like encapsulates it that she was more invested or she cared more about protecting the light than seeming like a hero. And so I think maybe in her eyes, it's like I don't want to tell these people of the plan because obviously they're going to disagree with me, but it's literally the only option
Speaker 5I can think of. So I just want to get it going well.
Speaker 7I don't even think she needed to describe the actual plan. But when she when she brought everyone together, you know, and had a meeting, she could have at least said to them, we have a plan that we're gonna be okay. But she like kind of just for no reason, kept being like, just keep going forward. We're gonna tell no one anything, Like it's just even just saying we can't tell you the plan right now, but we have a plan.
Speaker 6It's gonna be okay.
Speaker 7Like leaders are required to offer some level of support for their crew. Yeah, and the people around her, and the fact that it wasn't just po but other captains clearly agreed with him. It felt like there wasn't a plan to the point where they were willing to commit mutiny. Feels like she was failing in that level of being able to be like, don't worry, like there is a plan here, Like we have something that we're gonna be able to do, even if she doesn't want to actually explain the thing because she doesn't have to do as a general or whatever her.
Speaker 6That's all I'm saying.
Speaker 4I think there's a couple of things here, but I really want to kind of go back to when Aaron was saying that and add a piece of context there. Remember, they're being followed in a way that shouldn't happen, and they don't really understand exactly how this is happening, and Rose and Finn come up with an explanation, but they never go back and are like, here's how they're doing it. And I think from Paulo's perspective, I think it's perfectly fine to be like, there's there's a spy somewhere on my crew, or there's some way that information is getting out,
Speaker 4or either way, like sometimes, as the leader, you are supposed to trust your people who will follow you, even if they don't know the plan. And specifically, we had exact evidence that when Poe was given all the information and given a chance to follow his leader as he should have, he directly disobeyed her. She owes him nothing and what she should have expected. And to me, that's that's why I'm I think that book is so necessary.
Speaker 4What he did was such a massive act of insubordination, disobedience, and and he's a trader. He was a direct trader disobeying his direct superior. When she gave him trust that probably he didn't even deserve. And I get why people want to defend him there, But I think that and I'm not saying nowlex this is you by any means. I think she's intentionally positioned, and the fact that she is a woman I think is very important there. And then it's very much about the way that often it's,
Speaker 4you know, the masculine man knows what to do, and the worrying woman is going to be the one to try to hold the mac And I wish we'd gotten a line of expl explanation about how she was at like an important dinner for like some you know, person from another system who they were hoping to win, to explain why she was not in uniform but was in h what looked like a very nice dress without even like an insignia of office or anything like that her rank on it. But I think again, that was intentional. I think she was meant to look fem I think she was meant to look like the exact opposite of
Speaker 4the masculine male. She was meant to look like the exact opposite of the kind of like male authority figure that we expect someone like Poe to listen to, and yes, could she have probably done that better. Yeah, she could have catered more to his ego. And I don't think she should have to because I think he's an idiot. I think you're right, it would have worked more if he had done that. But that's kind of the point. Every one in this movie fails everything.
Speaker 6I don't I agree. I don't think she owed him anything.
Speaker 7That's how I tried to preface from the beginning by saying, like, she doesn't actually have to explain, like in detail or anything. But again, like it wasn't just PO. There was a mutiny of multiple other officers. I think that there was a general distrust of her going on through at least a large portion of her crew.
Speaker 6And I don't know. I mean, I study a lot of history.
Speaker 7I find it really interesting, and I just I personally take issue with the whole idea militaries in general. I understand that it's needed for it to function, but the whole idea of just blind trust and loyalty of your week, like we're just gonna blindly to what we're told. And I understand, I understand objectively, that's the only way wars can be fought.
Speaker 6It's the only way that militaries work. I just I don't know, it makes me.
Speaker 7Uncomfortable to think about just blindly, just especially like if Poe and these other like officers are not familiar with her, don't know much about her, they even like are trying to like get information about her, Like it's not like you fought with this person or like they know Laya. They trust her that, you know whatever, But no one, not even the audience, knows who what's adderal Holdo is, and like we're all expected to just trust her right away. I think I understand the level of distrust, and it feels like that there just could have been a step or two taken to.
Speaker 6Build some of that trust with the people she was now commanding.
Speaker 7But I understand you that's a very good point, Matthew, that I did not consider about the fact that, like she probably considered, there was a spy in their mist and like you know, that would definitely alter the way that she was thinking and trying to figure out what to do. I don't know it just but by the end, again, by the end, I liked her a lot.
Speaker 6I think that like she grew over throughout the movie. But I think in the beginning. She was just not as personable in that moment to her.
Speaker 7Who were her other officers I think would have been helpful to the mission as a whole.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think it's kind of set up for us to not like her and almost like have this like rage towards her at Star like why she being this way? So that we're also surprised, so we have a similar distrust of her that Poe does, and then I think the reveal is more exciting for everybody.
Speaker 6Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 4I think you're exactly right. I think in the same way that Poe is supposed to challenge ask himself why didn't he trust her? You know that we're supposed to ask herselves, why did we have this negative reaction to her? And it's Yeah. I mean I as you said at the beginning, Alex, I think this movie challenges the audience in ways that most Star Wars hasn't, And I think that's I think that's a great thing. And I want to be clear, I think there are very legitimate reasons not to like this movie, But I do think that a lot of the hate that this movie stirs up is people who failed that challenge, people who didn't want
Speaker 4to be challenged and didn't let themselves like be pushed the way the movie is trying to put them.
Speaker 6Yeah, that's fair.
Speaker 4But getting back to a non controversial subject and not something that's stirred up any debate. Let's talk about Luke.
Speaker 5Yeah, debate, Yes.
Speaker 4Saron, for you as someone who you know came in through the prequels and through Ah Soca as a character and stuff like that, and I know you did not have quite the like you didn't grow up with Luke the way like I did and others of my generation did. Sagan, I said, correct, Yeah, what what kind of feelings or expectations did you have about what Luke would be like late in his late in his life that you kind of brought into this movie.
Speaker 5I don't think I had expectations. I feel like I've said this before on the podcast. As a person, I tend to have no or low expectations because I hate to be disappointed. And when you have an idea of something in your head and then it doesn't exactly match up, then you're often disappointed. So I think it also helps that he's not, you know, such a like cornerstone character in my love of the fandom like that obviously helps I didn't. I wasn't sitting at home before the movie
Speaker 5thinking about like, what is Luke gonna be like? And then I think in that first scene with him and Ray and he chucks the lightsaber, I was like, oh shit, it's about to get good, Like we're about to learn a new Luke. To me, that's how that felt, is like, Okay, this is not a calm guy from Return of the Jedi solemnly burning his father and thinking deeply in thought. This is a guy who has been left alone and way too many thoughts by himself, but not enough time
Speaker 5to read all the Jedi texts apparently. So yeah, that's kind of how I approached Luke in this movie. Was just like from that first seeing being like, oh, okay, let's see where this goes.
Speaker 4Yeah, how about you?
Speaker 6Did you?
Speaker 7Guys?
Speaker 6I thought Luke is exactly what I expected him to be, a high key really.
Speaker 7The only part to me that felt dramatic was him throwing the light step over his shoulder.
Speaker 6I was like, Okay, I was a little dramatic, but then I thought, actually he's a skywalker. That makes sense to me. I mean it makes perfect sense.
Speaker 7I mean, based on what we were in episode seven, if you had like I mean, he's lost his entire family and then his you know, Jedi order that he begins gets it destroyed by his own nephew. He feels like he has failed, you know, like yeah, going into like going into exile. Yoda did the exact same thing. Yoda was his master or we wanted in exile. He learned from two Jedis who went into exile when they failed, so like to me makes sense him being like, you know, like, yeah,
Speaker 7the Jedi Order failed, they were they were full of hubris, like having studied because like we know that he went all around the galaxy a lot with Wlando, which is really strange to like find artifacts and learn more about like Jedi and Sith, you know, pass and relics and stuff. Like he had always information and basically determined like we're part of the problem, like we are. Like I think Luke being self aware and a little over dramatic angle going to exile, all of those things makes sense to me for this stage in his life based on what happened, like none of that surprised me in the slightest and
Speaker 7him eventually choosing to help Ray anyway and having to have some sense docked into him by Yoda and then pulling off like the greatest display of force powers we've maybe ever seen.
Speaker 6Y Yeah to me, And I know Matthew grew up with Lukes. I'm very interested to see what they think. But to me, that is Luke Skywalker at a nutshell.
Speaker 4Yeah. I loved it. I thought it made perfect and total sense because I like the story of the dissolution he you know, and I I did not get into EU books uh early the way a lot of other people did, and so and I'll acknowledge like in those books, its kind of built up. The idea of Luke is basically a demigod almost who just has incredible power and always does. I mean, he's the biggest Gary Stu you've ever Gary stew You know, he just is like everything he does is perfect and right and good, and he
Speaker 4has wonderful Once tried to kill him, but he loves you know, he's just so good in the force and oh so yeah. A Mary Sue is a comment that's often used as a kind of like insulting, like oh, she's just too perfect of a female character and like she has no character. She can do anything and everything she wants. And so hold on, Gary Sue.
Speaker 6Is the masculine Versey. So Gary Stu is the male version.
Speaker 5I love that one together by herself.
Speaker 4Oh kay, what did I miss there?
Speaker 7We just said that we pieced together the Gary Stu thing. Yes, after you after you cut off? But yeah, that that makes more sense, Thank.
Speaker 4You for And to be clear, I did not make that up. It was It was by a woman who was pointing out, like all.
Speaker 7This no for sure, I just I don't know if it's like a TV character or something I was missing, But you're not Sea it makes sense, perfect perfect Yeah.
Speaker 4Anyway, So like he just just turned into as perfectly perfect character. And I think a lot of people went in wanting that, and I I'm glad that that character meant a lot for people who really enjoyed those books. I don't think that would be an Indian character on screen. And I think I had always talked about seeing the Jedi through the lens of religion and with all the faults that that has and also all the good things that can have, and so having him specifically name the Jedi as a religion and name what often I think is one of the biggest hubrises and sources of of you know, evil and destruction that a religion can do
Speaker 4when it assumes that it is the it has the monopoly on a way to whatever divinity it is pointing towards, which is exactly what he says, that the Jedi believe they had a monopoly to the force and saw themselves as the force. It was just, Yeah, I love his character. I love the way he comes back. I love the way he's not trying to save Kylo. Though I think that there's an argument you can make that what he was doing was actually really helping to start Kylo on the journey back to being Ben solo, but I think again, the third movie didn't acknowledge that in any way. Yeah. So,
Speaker 4I just like everything about Luke was perfect and very much the kind of thing I wanted.
Speaker 7And I loved seeing his survival skills, like going after the fish, like Ray found him around, and like him going after the fish and still drinking his weird version of blue milk, even though I know it was green milk in this one, but Luke lives and dies by that weird milk and.
Speaker 5From the teeth, Like.
Speaker 7Yeah, exactly, And I I think there was an explanation somewhere in Cannon, but why he was in his Jedi Rose when Ray first arrived.
Speaker 6It was weird to me.
Speaker 7And then he takes him off and is wearing his normal like survival gear. But yeah, I think and I think that like when he finally agreed to teach Ray, it was very much on a trial basis, but then the way he taught, the way watching Luke teach the Force was such a joy, yea, like the little even the briefest sequence where he's like it was also funny he goes reach out and Ray reaches her arm out.
Speaker 6I laughed so hard when I still laugh when I watch that.
Speaker 7Then like when he when she actually reaches out, and like you see like her breathing and the way she's taking in the force.
Speaker 6The way he's explaining the.
Speaker 7Force and not shying away from like the darkness that exists in the world, like.
Speaker 6It just he would be. He's such I feel like he's.
Speaker 7Such a naturally good teacher, and it makes me really feel even more sad for him that his temple was destroyed because I feel like he was probably doing a really good job. But you know, he also gets spooked really easily. I mean, yeah, trauma from kylo Ren obviously theater, but I don't know it just it was so fun to watch him teach Ray and teaching what and have him call out, like when he name dropped the fact that like he's like, yeah, and during the height of the power the Jedi let like Palpatine rise to power under their noses and destroy them like they were a
Speaker 7bunch of idiots.
Speaker 6Like he just he called it straight. He was right about all.
Speaker 7Those things, and he was a little curmudgeony, but I think that was fair for what he'd been through.
Speaker 6Well.
Speaker 4I love his totally underlining all of that, and especially I want to highlight the way he teaches Ray the Force, because the way he teaches it as about being balanced, because this is a subject that came up from the Clone Wars and the prequels, this idea of like what does it mean to bring balance to the force and does that mean to destroy the dark side? And he goes to this wonderful litany of showing that like there's all these dualities of light and dark and of peace and violence and of you know, all these different things,
Speaker 4and that as he describes it, the Force is in the middle of that. The force is whole, The force is the thing that holds them in balance. And I still don't know exactly what the prophecy meant, but clearly I think the idea that like you bring balance to the force by I think out the dark Side entirely is not the case. And I really loved that, And I, on the one hand, wished he'd been more op because I think kind of the it's an interesting corollary then that Ray is able to go into the place of the dark Side and really learn something important and not having it be a bad thing. But of course Luke
Speaker 4can't see that because of what's happened with Kylo, because of what's happened with Vader. And I felt that was like frustrating but also completely accurate to what the characters would be doing.
Speaker 6Mm hmmmm hmm. Yeah.
Speaker 7I never had an issue with Luke adall. The only it is not even a complaint. It was more of like a childhood wish is I'm not upset with the way that Luke didn't actually fight with the White Saber, because I think again that was perfect for his character, But childhood alexetra We wanted to see Luke weel a white saber as a Jedi master.
Speaker 6I've just always wanted to see him actually duel.
Speaker 7Somebody, and we did have you know, we have got to see little glimpses of him with a white saber.
Speaker 6Awike in uh Mandalorian season two men Orion Thank.
Speaker 7You, Yeah, which I think was satisfied that craving because I do like the fact that when he meditates like that is able to project his image across the galaxy and then successfully allows the Resistance to escape and survive without ever actually causing harm or raising a real weapon.
Speaker 6I mean that is the pinnacle to me of.
Speaker 7What a Jedi master should be doing, like non violent, trying to like reason with with Kylo, bringing hope to his sister and to the resistance, all without ever having to like actually hurt anyone or fight anyone. And it it also was just such a flex my god. Yeah, and like watching you know, like I remember like after the movie ended, I like was like, oh my god, I would love my screensaper from my laptop to be
Speaker 7the scene of Luke after he finishes all that hired sitting cross legged watching the sunset for one final time before you phased into the force.
Speaker 6Like that was such I cry.
Speaker 7I still cry watching that, Like I just cry when I rewatched it a couple days ago, because it's so it's so beautiful. It's so like if Ryan Draft did anything right. It was like Luke's goodbye. It hurt to watch him go, but it was just such a peaceful. It's such a like a I don't think Luke wu want to go any other way than like on his own terms, saving other people, doing it in a meaningful way.
Speaker 6It just it was so beautiful. It was so beautifully.
Speaker 7Done, and I made me so happy and sad and I just they were gods with what anyone said. They did Luke so right in this movie, I think, And it made me very happy because Mark Hamill and Luke both deserve that.
Speaker 5Yeah, that was a really great point. But to slightly change the subject or just ask
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...