Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

Acolyte Cancelled! Response Episode

Sep 5, 202436 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The hosts of Star Wars Generations address the disappointing cancellation of the Disney+ series, The Acolyte. Join Matthew, Erin, and Alex as they unpack the news, discuss the show's merits, and examine the potential reasons behind Disney's decision.This episode explores: The Cancellation: Was a second season ever truly planned? The hosts break down the timeline of announcements and the lack of clarity surrounding the cancellation. Performance and Perception: Despite passionate fans, The Acolyte may not have met Disney's viewership expectations. The hosts analyze the available data and address the disparity between vocal online negativity and actual fan response. Fandom and Toxicity: The cancellation has exposed a troubling trend of online hate directed at the show, often rooted in prejudiced views. The hosts discuss the impact of toxic fandom and the importance of diverse representation in Star Wars. The Future of Star Wars: What does this cancellation mean for the future of the franchise? The hosts consider the possibility of the story continuing in other mediums, the shift towards a movie-focused strategy, and the potential impact on representation in future Star Wars projects. Discussion Points: The show's unique setting and exploration of the High Republic era. Standout performances, particularly from Manny Jacinto as a compelling dark-side user. The importance of giving new stories and characters time to resonate with audiences. The dangers of catering to the loudest, most negative voices in any fandom. The need for balance between movies and TV shows in the Star Wars universe. Hope for the continuation of these characters and storylines in other forms. Call to Action: Share your thoughts on The Acolyte and its cancellation using the hashtag #SaveTheAcolyte. Support diverse representation in Star Wars and beyond. Continue the conversation with us on social media! We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Here's another show you can enjoy in the true Story FM family of entertainment podcasts.

Speaker 2What's up, Supernatural, superfans. I'm Chrissy Lenz and I'm Nate McWorter, and we're the host of Gang Gang That Dream, a supernatural drinking game podcast.

Speaker 3It's the podcast where we make up drinking game rules for our favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural.

Speaker 1We recap the.

Speaker 2Episode for you and let you know how all the rules played out.

Speaker 3Then we let you know the drinking game rules from the next episode so you can play along.

Speaker 2Plus members get every episode early at ad.

Speaker 3Free with some extra bonus content chit chat at the end of each episode as a member exclusive.

Speaker 2So download Gank That Drink, a supernatural drinking game podcast wherever the finest podcasts are available, and.

Speaker 3Or become a member at true story dot fm.

Speaker 1Ssh Gank that Drink.

Speaker 2And when you're out there in the world saving people and hunting.

Speaker 3Things, you know the family business.

Speaker 2Keep the Gank that Drink motto in mind, be excellent to each other and party.

Speaker 4Yon dudes, Ever, wonder where the devil got his horns?

Speaker 1How about those clove and hoovers for that pitchfork me an angel.

Speaker 5No, he was a snake.

Speaker 1No, he's the Great Red Drag.

Speaker 5No, he's the beast. He's the Prince of this world, Prince of Darkness, believes the Prince of dark Good Morning, Star Lovelies. One of my names is Lester Ryan Clark.

Speaker 1And I sometimes go by Keenan Dias and.

Speaker 5We're the hosts of the brand new podcast The Devil's Details. What comes to mind when I say Lucifer?

Speaker 1How about Satan?

Speaker 5What about just the Devil? How did the big bad of the Western world end up with so many faces? Join us as we dig up, decipher, and deconstruct the Devil's many forms throughout his Take a.

Speaker 1Guided tour with Dante through the Nine Circles of Hell.

Speaker 5Or revisit Satan's angsty bade years in Paradise Loss.

Speaker 1Learn the ins and outs of a Faustian contract.

Speaker 5Easier than a ten ninety nine, but with a hell of a lot more fine brands.

Speaker 1Slither on over to The Devil's Details on True Story FM and join us in the Diabolic discussion.

Speaker 5Love and His is Wah didn't Al Facino play him in a movie?

Speaker 6They sure there wasn't.

Speaker 1Robert didn't there Els one. It was Tin, that was Elizabeth ur he go down to Georgia and something.

Speaker 7Hello, and welcome to the special emergency episode of Star Wars Generations Podcast. For the most part, we are in a state of having episodes ready for you a week or two in advance. We're actually gonna be going on hiatus, probably with this and then The book Club being the last episodes for before September hiatus, which I've explained. But there was major news in Star Wars yesterday which I knew a lot of people are talking about on Twitter, and we wanted to make sure we responded to. So I am here Matthew with my co hosts Aaron McGowan and Alex Corman to talk about the announcement that there

Speaker 7will not be a season two of The Acolyte.

Speaker 6Fuck that, Fuck that, yeah yeah.

Speaker 7So how are we feeling, folks?

Speaker 8So I'll just say I'm disappointed, but I'm not surprised, you know, like, I think that they did set it up such that it could be a standalone and with how much hate it got, even though almost all of it is not really valid critiques, but you know, companies have to listen to the audience. To an extent they don't have to, and they shouldn't have to when a story needs to be told. But I feel like that's what almost always will happen, is that.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8I mean, that's why they stopped doing standalone films because Solo bombed. They were like, never mind, the audience doesn't like that format, fuck it, And so it's unfortunate. But when season one ended, I was on the fence whether we get a season two. I was like, not expect it in any way, and then when they kind of announced it, I was like yeah, and then.

Speaker 9It was canceled. I was like, damn, it got my hopes up.

Speaker 7So let me give a little bit of context for this, a for those folks who may not have any idea what we're talking about, but also just because honestly, I feel like a lot of people who are talking about this online have no idea what they're talking about. And granted, I'm not a Disney executive, I'm not a Star Wars executive, but this is what I understand from what's publicly available. First Off, as Aaron just alluded to, there wasn't always a plan for a season two. So in some ways, I feel like this news is being framed by the media and now by all of us as season two was.

Speaker 7The Acolyte has been canceled. As you said, there was a lot of evidence that they always intended for The Acolyte to be a standalone show. It was shortly marketed as just The Acolyte. Then towards the end when it was getting a lot of very positive fan buzz, a lot of negative fan buzz. We'll talk about that as well, But the Disney executives changed the description of it online to The Acolyte Season one, and so it seemed like they were now discussing the idea of doing The Acolyte season two. They have now announced that they're not going

Speaker 7to do that. The exact reasons for that have not been given what there's a number of likely factors. One thing we do know is that the show was not as successful as some folks at Disney may have hoped. We actually have no idea how successful or non successful it was, because it's a streaming service, and the way Disney records that stuff is by how many new people shine up, how many people are watching it on their services, things like that, And I've heard all sorts of reports

Speaker 7about this was the second lowest or the lowest Disney show that the Nielsen's ratings, which there's some evidence about, but not really because again Nielsen's is mostly about broadcast television and this is streaming. There are a lot of reports and a lot of claims out there about how much this was or wasn't successful, and I'm sure there is some truth to a lot of them, but a lot of them are just straight up made up or being repeated by someone who heard one piece of fact and then now they're going with it, and going with it and going with it. The third thing I think

Speaker 7is why it is so important that we talk about it is there has been I know this is going to come as shock to many of you. There are some elements of the Star Wars fandom that are just a little bit toxic. I know, totally shocked. And once again we have a situation where a number of people, long before the show came out, decided they were going to hate it. And I say that in part because

Speaker 7it was getting review bombed on you know site, the Grotten Tomatoes before the first episode had came out, and lots of people were saying, I'm review bombing this. I've never seen it, I don't want to see it. And some amount of it was just, you know, it's a lot of people of color where the white people in this. Some amount of it was we don't care about this part of Star Wars. Some amount of it was this show looks so woke. And then here's the thing that makes it even more complicated is as I think, you know,

Speaker 7even if you listen to our back episodes, this wasn't a perfect show by any means. I think there are some legitimate critiques, but then some of those critiques get run with by people who again haven't seen the show and just wanted a reason to hate it. And so yeah, some of us saying maybe the plot pacing was not the best becomes this is the worst paced show that anyone has ever seen, and some of the writing best becomes this is the worst written thing that's ever been seen.

Speaker 7And we all know that there's this much hate out there, and you know, I don't don't I think it is possible legitimately think the writing is bad, the directing is bad. It feels hard for me to believe that people actually think the acting was bad, because then the acting was phenomenal. But maybe some people do, and that's legitimate what it became wrapped up in all of this hate, and now that it has been canceled, that part of the community is quite literally dancing on the grave of the show.

Speaker 7And there's a lot of kind of self congratulation about, hey, look we got this canceled. If you woke people, we took away your show, and then a lot of people being genuinely upset because they really love this show, and haters coming in and being like, haha, you don't get your woke nonsense anymore. So I just want to give all that context of why this is a very contentious issue right now and why one we wanted to do this kind of emergency podcast on.

Speaker 6Yeah, I got some thoughts as well. First and foremost, I, you know, I feel like the inherent issue was canceled in this show so quickly, is that our shows is gonna come out. Since then, the Star Wars content, everything has been within the Skywalker saga like or Skywalker Saga adjacent in some way. It's all been in that era and period, and a lot of it is with characters we're familiar with, you know, obviously with the Clone Wars. When that show started on TV, and the newer shows

Speaker 6that Dizzy Is all made have been you know, Obi Wan Boba Fet. You know, Mandalorian has been the most probably like new Is show, like different storyline, but it's still like familiar character imagery with you know, Grogu looking like Yoda and a Mandalorian being were full of Mandalorians and the storyline whatever. This is the first time that we're seeing a live action show or moving anything outside of the saga. You know, we have plenty of books, We have plenty of the Higher Public books, but I think that like, you can't just cancel a show when

Speaker 6the families hasn't been primed enough, because there's plenty of people. I mean, I don't know. I'm a massive Star Wars fan. I'm not great at reading very much in my busy life, so I haven't gotten to read the higher public books. But I was very invested in interest in the story, and I feel like fans would come around to it more if you'd given it time to sit, given us another season, built out the story. I mean, that's how stort has always has been. You build out the story and it gets better as more is added in, Like it's like a soup. I don't know, like you gotta add more ingredients and let it simmer. And it was just like to make that decision so quickly, especially when

Speaker 6they're giving us like what I mean, I'm gonna I don't want to say his name wrong? Is it Mandy Jacinto? Is that how you say it?

Speaker 7Yacinto?

Speaker 6Yep, Mandy Yacinto gave us one of the best performances of like a dark Side person dark Side villain, You Sith user. I mean I would argue probably better that Adam Drivers that we can debate that everybody. It was it was incredible and he was. It made it made us as we as you listened to our back episodes, you know, it made us really think about The dark Side differently. It made us think about like the Sith differently. And then like to wait all of these years to introduce plagas in a lot of action in the last episode,

Speaker 6then to can it like if you were if you weren't sure you're gonna have any additional content coming out in the storyline, why would you waste dropping such an important character at the end, and then go out of your way to like say, yep, that was Darth play against that was him. That's you know, it just feels like so much wasted opportunity. And also the last thing I'll say, the actual story well not perfect, was really interesting and different, and you know what, a story doesn't have to be perfect first get a season two, Like I won't be I won't lie to you if they

Speaker 6making Obi Wan Kenobi season two. The first season was not the greatest story ever told. But people will be all over it because you McGregor's and it's Obi Wan Kenobi. But I feel like and we just can'tcel it why.

Speaker 7I do feel like Obi Wan and Ahsoka were very clearly meant not to be season onees but just to be standalone stories. Like that's definitely a thing.

Speaker 6That we're getting Ahsoka season two anyway. Official, Yeah, it's official, okay, which is like, but I think it's a similar thing that Matthewoka said earlier that like they had planned it as a limited series and then like it was genuinely well and like can you imagine if what they set up all the throng stuff at the end of Ahsoka and then just like dropped it, Like people be pissed because it's a character familiar with because they're not familiar with the characters in this show. They're like, I don't I don't know if the uproar of the fans who want it will be listening to by Dizzy as much,

Speaker 6because they're like, oh, if we cancer the show, nothing lost. There's not enough stories tied in. But it's like, just you gotta give the stories time. How are you ever gonna grow out of the Skywalker saga and that era if you don't just commit, commit a couple of seasons and if it still sucks, cancel it. But like, one season is not enough time. I'm sorry, I'm very upset about this.

Speaker 8Yeah, so I'm having an interesting thought as you guys are talking about how like I think it was kind of intentional that they set this show not quite in the High Republic.

Speaker 9It's like one hundred years after the High Republic.

Speaker 6Sorry, just have.

Speaker 8Thought I had, But like if they were, you know, they're testing out something outside of the Skywalker saga. They're seeing what the fans think and so that if the show does bomb, then they can still make content about the High Republic itself without like all the stigma of This was the first project outside of the Skywalker saga and people hated it, so yeah, I wonder if that was intentional or if they were just trying to get far enough away from anything else and be like, now let's tell a story.

Speaker 7I mean, I definitely think that we're gonna see more of these characters. Like, honestly, my first thought when this news broke was, what do you mean canceled? It was never supposed to have a season two. I bet one of them is going to say in a couple of days, but don't worry, Like, we're gonna keep these actors. We're gonna bring these characters back in other shows. You know, there's gonna be other stories that continue this. It's been enough time now with enough very angry response that I'm starting to doubt that more and more. But I definitely think you're right, Aaron, that, like, I would be amazed

Speaker 7if we don't get books that are follow ups to this, if we don't get more of these characters and eventually like drawing the links between the Stranger and Darth Plagis and Arth Sidius and how all these things tie together, and what role May and Osha play and all of that, and I think it'll be disappointing if it's just books. But I think that, like, I think that's why we have to be loud about why we're't so unhappy about this, because one of the things, Aaron, that really struck me,

Speaker 7and I know this is not how you meant it, but what you said about like the perception that like everyone hated the show. And yeah, one of the things that drives me crazy is when people speak about their opinions as though they're objective fact and the number of people who are out there. Of course it got canceled. No one liked it, no one watched it, no real Star Wars fan liked it, and like the three of us are living proof that that is simply not the case. The fact that our episodes on The Acolyte got between

Speaker 7one hundred and two hundred more listeners than other episodes have gotten and they were you know, repeat listeners, and people writing in and saying they love the show, and all over the internet, all the people who are so upset about this saying they love the show. I think this is a problem, just like across the board. But you know, we live in a world where the Twitter algorithms and the Facebook algorithms and all that care a lot more about hate than they do about love. And someone says, oh, I really like this, you know, a bumber of people will click like, but they're not going

Speaker 7to chime in necessarily. But if someone says, oh I hate this, twenty people are going to come out of the woodwork and be like, yeah, I hated it too, and here's all the reasons why. And I don't know how we solve that problem, but I really do think that it's I mean, I hope it's through podcasts like this and more of us speaking up up and speaking out, because to me, that's one of the biggest fights we have right now, is that I don't think the toxic parts of the fandom are the majority by any means. I just think they're the loudest. And so in the

Speaker 7same way that I think, like majority of people who saw Justice League did not want the Snyder cut, but a small group was very invested and made a huge deal about it and bullied and bullied DC executives until they made it, and guess what, it financially bombed because it was actually not a huge amount of people. And Yeah, I'm really sad seeing Disney give into this kind of nonsense.

Speaker 6Pressure, and I'm looking online and I mean, I don't know how one hundred percent truth this is so big gran of sola. But what I'm seeing here is that, like the show started with like four point eight million viewers on the first day, which is the highest premiere of the entire year. Then it climbed up to eleven point one million viewers in the first week, and then it kind of dropped out of the third episode and dropped out of the top ten and streaming charts. That it returned to the top ten with the finale. However, it was still rated as the lowest amount of washed minutes for Star Wars finale. But that lowest amount of

Speaker 6watch minutes, y'all is three hundred and thirty five million watched minutes for just the finale episode. Like I just yeah, I understand that, like you look at if you're looking just a charts at the bottom line, it may not have been doing as well as other shows. But like I guarantee you look at Netflix and Hulu, and I mean, like a lot of shows I know. I mean I personally liked the Avatar, the West Airbunder live action recreation. There's a lot of issues of that show. And there's a lot of people who are very uhappy on Twitter with that show too. That show is s creamlit for

Speaker 6season two and three immediately. I mean there was never even like a slight hesitation. And it's just like, you know, if you're gonna create a story and you're gonna craft it to be multiple seasons, you know, even if you say, all right, you know what, we're just gonna make one other season, it's worth the investment if you're gonna dive into the story and you're gonna like you're gonna hire these actors who are like getting their life and is there you know, the roles in the Star Wars people becoming attached to them, Like I'm want to be really really upset if i don't get to see these characters and I've action again, Like I you know, really loved

Speaker 6Kimeer and Osha and May and Vernestra, like all of them in live action were so interesting and they left so many interesting stories open at the end, I'm just like, yeah, they might continue them in books, but like it's just not the same once you've already when you've seen it. And we also saw some of the best Lifsaber choreography we've seen in so long. It's just there's so many good things about the show. Why are we one? Why are we? Why are people complaining? And then like, you know, understand, I want to tit of their own opinion, But as Disney executives, people who run this show, how can you

Speaker 6like so quickly just listen to that and not look at the overall like fan base and be like, you know what, maybe we'll give this one more shot, one more shot. I I just it feels like we're just like you said, Matthew, we're caving to the very loud minority. And even if it was fifty fifty, I think stills it that's worth making a season two.

Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, I mean if nothing else, Like I imagine that High Republic book sales have gone through the roof because of this show. Like I've heard from numerous people who have said things like that, like, oh, watching the show, I want to learn more about Vernestro, I want to learn more about all this. I'm now going to start reading the Higher Republic books. Like there's so many knock on effects that these things can have, and I think it's important to talk a little bit more about why this happened, and for me, I think this is one of the things that's most upsetting. I get that there are people who don't want what they call politics in

Speaker 7their shows, and like, for example, I'd say, and Or to me is a very political show. It's about the politics of Star Wars, but it is clearly making it has a point of view and is making comments on the modern police state. And their comments I mostly agree with, and they are comments that challenge me and I want to think about more. I could sort of understand someone saying, look, I don't want that in my star I mean, I think it's always been in their Star Wars and being kind of idiots, but that at least there's some The idea that show had a point of view and an

Speaker 7agenda makes sense to me. I think in something like The Acolyte it bothers me most because the agenda that it had was simply showing that more people than the white and mostly white males who have dominated Star Wars for so long exist, that there are people of color of all different backgrounds, that they can be Jedi and Sith and civilians, that there can be a queer people and a species that uses They then pronouns because we don't,

Speaker 7you know, whatever, for whatever the hell reason. Like, there was nothing pushing this. It was simply acknowledging that these parts of our world, which are really really parts of our world, so whyouldn't they be part of the Star Wars universe? Exist? And yet somehow that becomes woke, that becomes pushing an agenda, and I just find that so outrageous and something we have to fight against so hard because my existence, the existence of so many people, I know some of you all like that. Simply acknowledging our existence in a world like Star Wars isn't an agenda

Speaker 7and never should be thought of that way.

Speaker 9Yeah, Like it's just representation that matters, that's all.

Speaker 6Yeah, something that's found on line I want. I want to bring up to you all. It's really interesting. I did not think about with this being canceled. I'm gonna read to you the current Disney plus Star Wars show history accouite canceled Skeleton Crew, a one season series coming out. Andrew was always meant to be two seasons. It's gonna end up for two seasons. You McGregor hating Christians and have been begging for a season two of Kenobi, but they have no one and Lucas someone said they're gonna

Speaker 6do it book a Boafet, no season two, Donald Lover series now a movie. Mandalorian's spin off of Rangers canceled because of the Gina Carano debacle. Coino Corono, I'm sorry if I said that wrong. Mandalorian. We don't know if it's gonna be a season four, if the movie is gonna end their story. And Ahsoka the only show we know is confirmed with the season two right now, so coming forward, it feels that they're pushing a lap back towards the movies. You know, we have the Daisy Ridley movie, we have the James Mango down to the Jedi movie. But basically Ahsoka season two and the Skeleton Crew and

Speaker 6Indoor season two are the only things we have confirmed on the books one hundred percent happening in a show. It feels like it might be part of a trend of Lucasfilm kind of pumping the brakes on the Star Wars live action series and maybe going back to movies, which is kind of what they feel like they're doing with Marvel as well. And I don't know if they just realize we're oversaturaying the market, if they're just getting skittich, if it's being too expensive, I don't know. But it's just interesting. I don't we think about the fact that, like the live action shows are kind of getting wrapped

Speaker 6up or becoming limited series and nothing really is being hashed out into anything longer. I mean, The Bad Match was four seasons, and that's the way the longest show we've gotten in a while with a four or three three seasons, sure, or yeah for three seasons, and I mean Mando's three seasons, but those are the most and like they've been we've been making Star Wars shows now for the last how many years. Mando came out in what twenty twenty, It like five four or five years almost. I mean, it's just it's eating just before that. It

Speaker 6might have been before that, honestly, but probably pre pandemic.

Speaker 7But there's definitely pre pandemic. I think it was twenty eighteen.

Speaker 6Okay, then it's been six years and we you know, so it's it's just interesting to see that, Like they're like to me, to me, and I don't know, if you're oka, I'm curious to your thoughts on all this, but this the key to making this like an ecosystem of Star Wars that would work well is to have a balance. Maybe you come out with like one to two shows max a year, probably like really just one show a year and then a new movie and like you kind of balance it out. Or maybe you do

Speaker 6like one movie one year and like two shows the next year and then a movie the next year. Like the fact that we're putting out show after show the show with no movies for extended period, and now they're gonna jump back and put out like four movies in a row and really not have much movie in the shows. It feels like we're just whiplashing back and forth and fans are never gonna feel like happy. Like I love the Star Wars movie format I think the most, but the show format works for a lot of things. And like even with just an animated series, like I feel that they have to find a balance here, find balance in the force guys. Otherwise like we're just gonna sit

Speaker 6here with just constant whiplasher. You're not getting the content that anyone want, no one, but no one's gonna be happy well.

Speaker 7Especially because like it feels like they kind of set themselves up to fail and then refuse to listen to the feedback because you know, I do think that one of the most legitimate critiques of The Acolyte, one that we definitely all had, myself, especially, is that the pacing felt pretty off in many ways. And I think that one of the complaints that was made about a number of the Marvel shows is that the short kind of season of eight episod thirty minute episodes and all just

Speaker 7being basically one story and not episodic in the slightest is a format that really isn't working for the kind of stories that Marvel wanted to tell. And I think we're starting to get the same problem in Star Wars, and this was the one that probably had that the most, and I do think that, And so my hope is that they're going to take some time and be like, let's reevaluate and come back out of the gate saying, yeah, we're gonna do less shows, but it's going to be, you know, twelve episodes. I remember like Bad Batch was sixteen episode shows and it had fairly distinct arcs, and

Speaker 7or it was I think twelve episodes but in three episode arcs, and you know, I think this like this is like a little longer than a movie, but not so it's like it's longer than it feels like too long for a movie, but not long enough to actually get into the kind of storytelling and you know, more like different chapter kind of idea that often a TV show can get into. So yeah, I hope that things, you know, change, I hope they listen. I think one thing we have to acknowledge, though, is that Bob Iver

Speaker 7the new head of Disney. I don't think he's the new head of Disney. Maybe he's new or he's just gone in a new direction. He said recently that he thinks, and he was talking more about the Disney movies, like the Princess movies, but I think he means this from Marvel and Star Wars as well, that he thinks that they've become too agenda focused and too message focused and need to get back to just good storytelling, which I mean, it feels like such a betrayal of what all of those things are a because it just feels like you're listening to the anti woke mob and it feels like

Speaker 7you know, you're you're thinking that representation is an agenda, but also like, you know, the best of these things always had a message Captain America too, so you know, Civil War, like the Hulk movies always had fairly distinct messages. I honestly don't think these movies have more of a message. These TV shows have more of a message. It's just that the message is pissing off more of the anti woke crowd and so yeah, and screaming about it, and so it feels like that. So I and I just say that as like, this is what the head of Disney is saying. So it may well be that we're

Speaker 7gonna get a lot more white guys in our stories again, and a lot more like safe shows, which I think would be real step backward.

Speaker 6Oh, I'm sure they'll end up throwing together like a season two Kenoby or something just to kind of like placate the fan base for a little bit, or like something in that vein.

Speaker 7Yeah, I think to me, if they make a season I already didn't really I didn't love Kenoby. I didn't think there's any need for it. I have great respect for you and Hayden, and I hope to see them do lots of great things together. I really don't want to see a Canoby season two, and if that had come out before all of this, I'd be like, Okay, fine. Honestly, if they green light it now, it's going to feel like they're doing it because it's a much safer show and it's two white guys, and it probably just won't watch it.

Speaker 6Like, yeah, I would feel that way, But unfortunately I am such a blind obsessor of you McGregor's, you know, Matthew, so I would. I would take any um Regors show. I don't care if it's Canover season two or what the hell it is. I don't I just want more of him, But I would rather that be pushed down the pipeline a little bit more and us get more. Like But the fact like Accolyte and Skeleton Crew exciting me because there shows that like I know nothing about. I watched the show Skeleton Crew, I still have no clue. All I got was space scoony vibes, and that's what the only vibe I can get. I no idea what's

Speaker 6gonna happen. That's exciting for me. Like it's also exciting to get a show like and Or where I can kind of like try and like predict things and try and get into it in that way. But I also like the stuff where I don't know what's happening. That's the exciting part of new content. Yeah, you have thoughts, Aaron on all this.

Speaker 9I mean, it's just an unfortunate situation. It's just the way that I feel like the.

Speaker 8World in media is is the negative voices are louder, and companies tend to react to whoever's screaming the worst things, and it's a bummer if we do see representation taken away. I like to have enough faith and hope in just you know, humanity that that won't happen. You know, I hope there's other people at Disney, if not the head executive or whoever that is, if there's not other people that are really pushing for representation.

Speaker 9But yeah, I mean, I'm bummed about the show. It sucks.

Speaker 8But I want to say something nice to end on a good note, and I don't know what I'll say this.

Speaker 7I think some of the folks who I have the most sympathy for are the folks who gave this show a real chance, who were happy to see diversity and all that, and just didn't like it because I think you're kind of getting screwed now, because you know, it's hard to stand next to people who are awful when you have some opinion. And I want to really acknowledge that. I do not think it makes you racist or sexist or anti woke to not like this show. I think it is completely legitimate. Rihash, who was one of the

Speaker 7most you know, in favor of all this kind of stuff. People I know simply didn't like this show. I think that is totally legitimate, and I want to make that clear. And I think that's fine, and I think it's just it's one reason why I think we need to just all start, like just stop giving any attention to these haters, like just ban them, shut them out of the conversations so that US fans can have conversations with the people who care about it. And yeah, because I think I think we can talk about that the show was not the best by any means, but just the fact that it's there's so much hate and it's taken over the

Speaker 7conversation and that Disney's listening to it, I just think is awful.

Speaker 6Yeah, And like like you said, Matthew, there's a place you know, when we say, like I know what you mean, Like when you say, like ban these haters, what you know, what you know, what you mean? And obviously what I think we all mean is that like we want to create a space where like we can have these conversations like if you have an actual like critique of the show, conversation, let's talk about it. I am so happy because I always have my own critiques to talk about it and through like what we think is wrong with it? What we think does you know is doing well with it? Like there is just I don't know if I've ever

Speaker 6seen a show where there's absolutely nothing good about it, like at all, Like every show has something you can talk about, and like in the Star Wars you know, universe, I think it's especially true. And those haters who are just like blanket, what you said, like just review bombing blanket. This is awful, This is trash, bad, everything bad, Like did you watch every episode? Did you follow the story? Like do you know, do you like anything except for the original trilogy? And I've been hating on every Star Wars content since then, Like just that is the part

Speaker 6of the like the fan base that like I don't even want to even necessarily call a fan base, because like, if you're just constantly shitting on every piece of content that gets made, are you actually a fan or are you just like living in nineteen eighty and are mad that nothing has been as good to you since a tray of the Jedi, Like, yeah, it to me.

Speaker 7I mean, the thing that I think is just the worst part of humanity coming out in so called fans is folks who are literally dancing on the grave, like they'll claim no one likes it, and then when people go on line or like, hey, this makes me really sad because I love this show, and they say, oh, you're just stupid. Then you're not a real fan, you know, or haha, I'm glad you're so sad because we're winning Star Wars and just like yeah, you know, how the hell are you like that? So I do have a positive note, I'll say, which is that it does seem quite likely. Now, I mean notock on wood. You know,

Speaker 7a lot of work still the go, but there's a decent chance that we're going to get a vice president who is a confirmed Star Wars fanboy in all the best ways. I would like to think that he'll convince Kamala to I'd like to think he'll convince Kamala to release a executive order that he asked to make a season two. I don't think that's gonna happen. That would probably be an abuse of power. But yeah, I think having someone who's just like, hey, like, think about just

Speaker 7how joyful a person he is and his positive attitude about everything. I think like him talking a little bit about why he loves Star Wars and hey, like, isn't Star Wars great?

Speaker 2Like?

Speaker 7I think that can help bring out some of the positivity and the fandom. I think I've been seeing a real movement to just kind of like ignore the haters and just really focus on like, yeah, let's just talk to each other about why we love this. I think this is a real step back for that. But I think Walls is gonna be a really positive thing for Star Wars. And so that's that's where my hope is coming from. Yeah, and fandoms are built on hope. Princess Leah said that there's rebellions podcasts, and yeah, all right with that, thanks everybody. This is a quick emergency meeting,

Speaker 7no promos, no nothing. Alex and I. If you're watching on video, Alex and I aregs stick around and do our special book talk edition for the members only that I'll come out there as a separate episode. Aaron has to go and become a fantastic, fantabulous, wonderful, amazing cosplayer. And if you're going to Comic com Tecon Teev Khan, thank you. Information would be in the show notes. If you're in Northern Minnesota, you want to go to Northern Minnesota, trust me to see Aaron doing cosplay is worth driving cross country.

Speaker 7Totally go and see it. If you can go this weekend, go If not, We'll totally have links to things on the show notes in a couple of weeks.

Speaker 6And Aaron judge the Cosplay concess right.

Speaker 9Yes, yes, I'll be judging the cosplay contest.

Speaker 8I'm also going to be on a panel about cosplay, getting questions asked, and I'll have a booth and I'm selling prints, so long shot. I doubt anyone will hear this and come to the con. But if you do, buy one, get one free prints. If you happen to be a fan, just come up.

Speaker 9And tell me. Otherwise here everyone else, haha, you missed out.

Speaker 7Here's my question. Uh, and I think you are going to be a judge with the highest levels of integrity. But am I right that that if there's a pretty good Ahsoka or Mystique or Twilight cosplay, they might get a little extra love.

Speaker 9I don't know.

Speaker 8See, Okay, it's like hypothetically, yes, but I've never done something like this before, and I do want to try and be really unbiased.

Speaker 9And I'm gonna try and really focus.

Speaker 1On the.

Speaker 9Like the handiwork and how well something is made, you know, because.

Speaker 8Like if you do the body paint really good, but your armor looks shitty, You're not gonna. I'm sorry love Ahsoka, but I prefer this Zelda over here, who handmade.

Speaker 9Yeah, I'm just saying this is prediction.

Speaker 6I haven't done it yet.

Speaker 9I'll tell you guys later.

Speaker 7I mean, the ethics of judging are something we can definitely talk about. Well, all right, thank you all so much. Aaron's gonna take off to all of you, your great audience. Please keep the positivity alive. We have spoken.

Speaker 6Steak Glassy.

Speaker 9Now this is pod Racing.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode