As part of our September hiatus, enjoy this rebroadcast of one of our favorite episodes!What are the 3 best duels in Star Wars? Best acting performances? Paul and I challenge each other to come up with top lists on the fly in one of the more fun, and more ridiculous, episodes we've had in a while. Stick around to the end to hear how this episode created a second! We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Here's another show you can enjoy in the true story FM family of entertainment podcasts.
Speaker 2What's up, Supernatural superfans. I'm Chrissy Lenz and I'm Nate McWorter, and we're the host of Gang Gang Dream, a supernatural drinking game podcast.
Speaker 3It's the podcast where we make up drinking game rules for our favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural.
Speaker 2We recap the episode for you and let you know how all the rules played out.
Speaker 3Then we let you know the drinking game rules from the next episode so you can play along.
Speaker 2Plus members get every episode early and ad free.
Speaker 3With some extra bonus content chit chat at the end of each episode as a member exclusive.
Speaker 2So download Gank That Drink, a supernatural drinking game podcast wherever the finest podcasts are available.
Speaker 3And or become a member at true story dot fm.
Speaker 4Gosh, Gank that Drink.
Speaker 2And when you're out there in the world saving people and hunting.
Speaker 3Things, you know the family business.
Speaker 2Keep the Gank that Drink motto in mind, be excellent to each other and party yon.
Speaker 5Dudes, Ever, wonder where the devil got his horns?
Speaker 1How about those clove and hoos for that pitchfork isn't he an angel?
Speaker 5No, he was a snake.
Speaker 1Noh, he's the great Red Drag.
Speaker 5No, he's the beast.
Speaker 1He's the Prince of this.
Speaker 5World, Prince of Darkness, believes the Prince of dark Good Morning, Star Lovelies. One of my names is Lester Ryan Clark.
Speaker 1And I sometimes go by Keenan Dias and.
Speaker 5We're the hosts of the brand new podcast The Devil's Details. What comes to mind when I say Lucifer?
Speaker 1How about Satan?
Speaker 5What about just the Devil? How did the big bad of the Western world end up with so many faces? Join us as we dig up, decipher, and deconstruct the Devil's many forms throughout.
Speaker 1His Take a guided tour with Dante through the Nine Circles of Hell.
Speaker 5Or revisit Satan's angsty bade in Paradise Loss.
Speaker 1Learn the ins and outs of a Faustian contract.
Speaker 5Easier than a ten ninety nine, but with a hell of a lot more fine brands.
Speaker 1Slither on over to The Devil's Details on True Story FM and join us in the Diabolic discussion.
Speaker 5Love and His is Wah didn't Al Fachino play him in a movie?
Speaker 1They're sure there wasn't Robert didn't there else one that was Elizabeth fur He go down to Georgia and some.
Speaker 6Hello, everyone, Welcome to this rebroadcast episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. I've been talking a lot on TikTok Someone and hear in other places about how we can get past all the toxic, hating stuff that we have in the Star Wars community right now. And I think one of the best positive things we can focus on is lists what do we love in Star Wars? As much as making lists, myself and Paul Hoppey on an episode a couple of years ago, put together a bunch of our top three lists. We talked about different things that we love and it just led to a whole bunch of different great conversations. And so while we're on
Speaker 6this hiatus, I'm going to share this episode with you all now. Hope you enjoy it. As always, you can become a member with all the information. As the show notes, it's only five dollars a month, fifty five dollars a year. Also, even though these are rebroadcast episodes, we would love to hear your feedback. We'll do feedback episode about all this kind of stuff as we get back into regular episodes in October, so please enjoy, and we have spoken. Welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Universe podcasts. We love lists in podcast land and so today, so today myself and Paul Hoppy, we'll be asking each other questions
Speaker 6of what are your top three or bottom three or whatever it is about Star Wars. Now. In the past, we've done this where we both gave each other lists and we knew what the questions were gonna be and we had time to write them out. This time it can be off the cuff. I don't know what Paul's gonna ask me, Paul didn't know what I'm gonna ask them. So we're just gonna play it by ear and see how it goes. And I promise you this was a well thought out, well planned episode that had nothing to do with the fact that Sarah had to cancel at the last minute and so we couldn't do the Rebels episode we were planning. Nope, this was our plan all along.
Speaker 6All that more, after a commercial break, we have no control over Welcome back to matthe your host. I'm joined as fairly usually by the podcast guest a Jure Paul hoppey, Paul, how are we doing today?
Speaker 4We are doing pretty well. We're indoors where it is seventy something degrees, whereas outdoors it is one hundred and teen something degrees.
Speaker 6Okay, so yeah, I would invite you to the Great Frozen North, but that would involve you dealing with people, so it's probably.
Speaker 4Not traveling distance and seeing folks.
Speaker 6And once we get a tele quarters set up, we'll make that happen.
Speaker 4The Jedi needs not these things.
Speaker 6So let's dive into this and let me just kind of ask you as a start. And it maybe that we're about to tear it apart the whole premise of the episode, but what is your general feeling on like coming up with lists of like, you know, top five this or top three this or top fourteen things about the Clone Wars you never knew Number seven and is sure to make you mad.
Speaker 4Yeah, so you know the last thing. Obvious clickbait titles are you know, obvious clickbait and you know, unpleasant. I think you know my biggest pet peeve is such and such that you don't know. I'm like, just just stop, just stop. In terms of lists, I enjoy lists, I think lists are fun. I think if you phrase a list you know, ten of the greatest cool. You know, if you title your list the ten greatest, no, you're wrong,
Speaker 4because there's just that's not a thing, you know. It's like whether it's subjective or something, that's like you're using some theoretically objective measure. It's just like I think being like, these are three of my favorite rank right as opposed to these are my three favorite. It's like, you don't you don't have to rank everything. It's like, just give me, give me a list of things that you really enjoy, really don't enjoy, think are really good in this way cool, you know, just like you don't have to be so
Speaker 4superlative of it.
Speaker 6And that's kind of like why I like this idea of doing it, because I think you're right that some preparation can help. And I think we both did this. But I certainly prepared my top three for each of the questions I'm gonna ask you. But I also think that, yeah, like if I sit and take hours and hours to figure out my top ten favorite or something, I'm still probably gonna be like I'm just at some point gonna stop. I'm never gonna actually know my true top ten, because it's gonna change so much moment to moment. But this way it's like, Okay, what's the first three that really strongly come to mind for you, you know, or something
Speaker 6like that, which, yeah, is a little less objective more just like because more than anything, it's just a fun way to talk about these things. So with that, let me ask you my first question. And this is kind of like it's going back to one of our favorite themes, certainly my favorite, I think one that you've expressed a lot of interest as well in both the podcasts we do together. Who are your three Who are your top No, here's the way to ask it, who is your second, third, and fourth favorite villains? Because I know the number one is Darth Vader and you know what would tell me two, three, four?
Speaker 6But who are your top three villains not named Darth Vader in Star Wars?
Speaker 4Yeah, it's tough because, like I think about Star Wars and I think it has like, are arguably the greatest villain of all time? Certainly one of them, certainly you know, one of the most iconic with I think the most iconic voice of any character.
Speaker 6I mean, I wouldn't put hucks quite that high, but yeah, he's close.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, exactly, I know what you mean. But I think unless you said hunt, yeah, it's it's weird. I I can't think of like a clear number two, you know. I could think of ones that I like. I enjoy mof Gideon right from the Mandalorian, and I think most of that is just Giancarlo Esposito, yeah, you know, because he's just so good, and I think a lot of
Speaker 4that's the performance more than like the characters' motivations. I'm like, eh on the characters motivations. Okay, okay, I have a clear number two. It's it's Throng, right, yeah. Like in terms of villains in Star Wars who are clearly villains, I think he, after Vader, is the one who kind of has the most the best blend of you know, comprehensible motivation and complexity and like presence. To me, a
Speaker 4great villain. For me to really love a villain, they usually need some level of presence where they can just especially on screen villains, right like where when they're on screen there is this this like weight they like, you know, they fill up the rooms so and throng. I really only know from the Rebels to v Show. I know there's all the novels and everything, but I haven't read those, but I do see what people see in Throng, you know.
Speaker 6Yeah, Like, I think it's really interesting that you name him because Thron is also on my list. But I think a lot of fans would say, I so would disagree with this, but a lot of fans would say that, like of the various different versions we got, like on screen, Thron is great, but he's even better in the books. So I think it's awesome that just from the just from the on screen you still put him that high, because I do as well.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, like it just it comes through, you know, you know, I mean I'm thinking back and the the earlier, you know, if we think through like so like the Emperor is like not my favorite villain, you know, the Emperor to me just is there as a plot device in a way that makes every is like so just binarily evil, right, that.
Speaker 7Most mustache twly of mustache trullers, right, and that he he lets everybody else be oriented around him in some way, right, and lets the rest of the story just function really well.
Speaker 4So I think he functions really well as a villain, but isn't like particularly interesting or compelling.
Speaker 6And that's one of the funny things, because I was thinking I would never put Emperor the Emperor on this list, but going by the books and to some extent that's somebody said the Clone Wars TV show, but mostly just going by the books, I would probably put Sheef Palpatine on this list, and certainly like Senator Palpatine like and Darth Sidius like. The way his character has been fleshed out in the books makes him so much more interesting because you get backstory, you get all the things that they would never give him in the seventies and eighties, like you get backstory, you get motivation, you get all
Speaker 6the little ways that his plans were working or were not working. But yeah, I just I thought about putting him on the list, was like, but still the main way we know him is the Emperor, and the Emperor is just he's good in the first three movies, as like you said, the thing everyone Lady rents himself and then he comes back and gets pumped, and that's just I hated the whole resurrection.
Speaker 4Thing, so oh yeah, I don't I didn't mind it, but it didn't really do a lot for me, you know, I like, I certainly wouldn't put Kylo Ren on my list of like top villains, you know, I you know, we talked about Doku, and I feel like Doku the understanding I have of Douku from what what you and and Jonah were telling me, I think is a very interesting character in terms of the character that I saw on screen, I wouldn't wouldn't put in there. I would say, actually, Mal,
Speaker 4I think is one of the villains with the most I mean most interesting character lines because you can't really call it an arc.
Speaker 6You know, it's a bag.
Speaker 4It's very much like it's like I mean, Mal is kind of it's sort of the more you change, the more you stay the same, you know, and so you know, and then also he's just got some like great duels, you know, like how much does that factor into you know a you know, I I one of my questions, might you know come into this, but like how much how much of how much you know? What a how you rank a villain is like the moments they're involved in and that they cause. Right, yeah, and then so
Speaker 4what what have I got? I've got thrown, I've got Mal and.
Speaker 6I'm off Gideon unless you want to come out with something better.
Speaker 4Yeah, No, I think I wouldn't use Gideon. I mean, I think that performance is one of my favorite you know, it's a top tier performance. But I might even go with like Agent Callous in Rebels, you know. I mean, I think Rebels does really well with having villains antagonists who do feel compelling, you know, Like I wouldn't put Hondo on this list because I don't think Hondo's like a straight up villain.
Speaker 6Yeah to me, I mean I he's a lovable scamp. He he's an antagonist at times.
Speaker 4At times, but yeah, he's very much not a villain. Yeah. And so you know Callous, I feel a little conflicted, but like I'll throw him, I'll throw them on there.
Speaker 6I think is I would say to people who are listening along with us for our coverage of Rebels and have not watched ahead of this podcast spoiled major spoiler warnings, so maybe skip ahead like sixty seconds. But yeah, I came very close to putting Callous on the list. But what I love about him is he has such a good redemption arc.
Speaker 4And so I wasn't gonna mention that I was kind of just like implying it, but yeah, exactly.
Speaker 6Yeah, exactly right, and spoiler section, Yeah, No, I think it's a good list. And one thing I think is interesting, and this is true about my list as well, is that my list neither one of our lists truly draw We obviously were taking Vader from the original three movies and Graham off Tarkin was a very close second for me in those three movies. But other than that, I'm going to think one of the things about both the prequels and the sequels is they don't really have any truly great villain characters. Kylo Wrenz somewhat, yes, but again
Speaker 6he's also more of a like antagonist who's played as a villain. But you know from the very beginning that clearly he's gonna have some kind of redemption or something is gonna happen.
Speaker 4You certainly suspect it might be true. I mean nobody knew. Yeah, nobody knew because nobody knew because it wasn't written, because there was no plan for that quote unquote trilogy. But like, yeah, it definitely felt that way as much as like, that's very similar to Vader's arc, right, except you've seen it before so you see it coming, Yeah.
Speaker 6Exactly, So I had as my top three. Uh Fron was one of them. Definitely h the second. This might be recency biased because I just watched Rogue one again two nights ago director Cretic, and in part it's because I do think he's very menacing in a way. But what I love about him is he's not a vader or a Tarkan. He's a middle management bureaucrat, like so much of his story, like, I love the kind of big picture stuff, and I think with that movie and
Speaker 6bad Batch also explores this. But it's like when you have an empire and an empire where if you mess up, you're gonna get killed, like employee loyalty to each other is zero, and like meet like bureaucratic infighting is gonna be all over the place. And that's exactly what that movie is about, you know, in terms of like the battle between Tarkin and Credic, and so I just it's not even as much his character as just what he represents and what he shows. But I just the idea of this guy who, like I don't know if he
Speaker 6believes in the empire. I don't know if he cares about the emperor, but he wants to have his control of you know, he built this thing, and he wants to get credit for this thing, and he gets mad when Tarkin and he'll he'll do what he needs to to get credit for that thing. And yeah, I just thought that was pretty cool.
Speaker 4Yeah. I think, you know, in order to have an evil emperor, and in order to have an evil empire, you need a lot more than an evil emperor, right, you need a lot of people to go along with it, whether they're true believers or whether they're just trying to they're out for themselves, right, Yeah, but they need to be willing to say, yeah, okay, I'll do this horrible, unspeakable thing in order to like, you know, have a nicer speeder or whatever.
Speaker 6And to be clear, like he's an awful human being. He watches the destruction of Jedda and says, that's so beautiful, you know, but yeah, it's it's.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, No, he's not a good guy.
Speaker 6I think most of the most of the time we get villains who are true believers, and so it's just nice to see the bureaucrat. And then my last villain is a sage ventress. Oh, not even while she's with Dooku, but just her arc afterwards, where she often still is a villain, and particularly the books make this clear. She she sometimes teams up with our people, she sometimes doesn't, and sometimes she's just doing her own thing, like and they give her this room to be in this middle space where she wants to kill Douku. She wants to
Speaker 6do other things that, like we would say, are overall good, but she doesn't want to help the Jet. She doesn't want to become a Jedi, definitely. She doesn't want to give up her dark Side powers. She so respects part to the dark Side. In the book, she comes to more of a redemption. But I just the way they keep her in this kind of middle ground of antagonist who is dark side, who is not Sith, and who's very morally gray is just one of my favorite kind of characters.
Speaker 4Yeah, I I almost she's almost in that category of I wouldn't necessarily classify her as a villain, even though she clearly is a dark Side Force user who begins as a clear antagonist. I feel like she becomes interesting once she's no longer Doku's apprentice, you know, up until then, it's like, you know, she looks cool, she's got two right red lightsabers. Yeah, that's fun, you know, but like once once he betrays her, then I think she has
Speaker 4such a character arc that feels to me, you know, the forth side of scum and villainy almost you know, just the kind of like outcasts, like you know, willing to do not really great things, but like not for like evil, you know, just like she's just doing I mean, like.
Speaker 6I don't mean this in a in a gender way, but like I like non binary characters. I like characters. Look at the binary of Jedi, Sith, good, evil, Like, let's play with that a little bit. Mm hmm. So what's your first question?
Speaker 4So I've got a list of like eight potential questions. Okay, one of them was favorite villains, so I'll delete that. I figured I would come up with at least enough that if all of yours were on my list, then I'd still have enough extras.
Speaker 6Quick editorial comment. I said to Paul that we should probably come up with five questions, because I want to make sure we have enough to fill the time. Paul suggestion, perhaps we only do three. We've now we agreed on three, so we have six total. We've only done one of six and we're twenty minutes in, so yeah, we'll get too as many as we can.
Speaker 4I don't think we're actually twenty minutes in because we like blabbed a little before we actually started the pod. But yes, that's true. Yeah, yeah, no, I'm not planning to go through all these I'm looking at them thinking, okay, well, here's one that it plays with like villains a little bit, and it will reference many of the same characters. What are three of your favorite duels?
Speaker 6I was thinking this is gonna be three of your favorite lightsaber battles or something like that. Yeah, gets Maul's in a lot of them. Okay, And for me it's it's always this hard moment of I enjoy the fight. I enjoy the like, you know, sort of visual effect of the fights. But as I said before, I'm not fight scenes aren't the primary thing that motivates me, so that matters to me. But what generally matters much more to me is the emotional stakes I feel in. And
Speaker 6here I think I'll kind of square that circle. I do think that the way the fighting is done, if it's done well, should probably reflect that you know and so like, honestly, the first one that comes to mind, even though we just did a podcast episode about how it's not really a duel it lasts three seconds is Obi Wan and Mall because it just is to me and it's a great TikTok that I'll post along with this episode where they really break down, like how Knobe goes through these different stances and like the mind game the two of them play, and that most of the
Speaker 6fight happens before they start fighting, because the fight is like four slashes and then we're done. But there's just so much emotional weight to that fight. There's so much history of these two characters and it feels like such this perfect coda that like I remembered it as such this epic fight that I was shocked what I saw that it was only like five seconds long, because in my head it had so much power and I sot think it does.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's that's definitely on my list too, So I'll just respond to that briefly. I think it's very much a duel in the you know, the way that a gun duel can be a dual, like one person shoots, the other person shoots, it's over or maybe just the first person shoots the other person's dead, like you know, that's basically what happens here, right, Mall shoots Kenobi, Perry's Kenobi kills Mall boom done, you know. And but the dual part of it is like the part that happens beforehand, right,
Speaker 4it's the drama, it's the setup, and I feel like there's there's so much of that. And yeah, I mean we talked about it a bunch on the last pot. Go listen to that pod if you haven't, if you had, you know, all those thoughts are, you know, still fresh.
Speaker 6So I don't want all three to be mall. So I'll say like tied for second and third because they're just so both so well now I'm just going to say.
Speaker 4This, pick one, but you can mention them both.
Speaker 6Here's the thing, the the two God, there's just so many good fights duel of the fates at the end of Phantom Menace. A I think part why it's it stands out is that I do think the rest of Phantom, the rest of Phantom Menace was very much not a movie for me, and that that's fine. I've really enjoyed listening to why people take such great meaning and power from it. I just didn't love it that it stands out so much more, but also especially as I've learned so much more about Qui Gon and this whole idea
Speaker 6of like really just giving thought to Obi Wan was just the wrong person to train Anakin, and like he admitted that all the way back in uh Empire strikes back. But the the idea that like, if Qui Gon had been able to raise Anakin, the whole galaxy would have worked out very so differently, and and that to an extent, that is the duel of the fates, and that on some level, when Maul kills Qui Gon, the fight's over, there's still an interesting fight still, and Oiwan gets to
Speaker 6kill Mall well he thinks he kills Paull but bisecting, which doesn't mean killing oddly enough. But yeah, I think that's that fight to me is just really impactful. And I'll say, though, here's my I hate previews as much as I love that battle. If the first time I saw a dual sided Lightsaber was in a theater, I think my love for Phantom Menace would be so much higher, like just that one thing, because there is so much
Speaker 6beauty and just amazingness and like, oh my god, what the hell are we going to do when Mal reveals that second blade and just to have not seen that before and to watch these two people trying to figure out how to fight, Like, I mean, Ray Park was just amazing, Like he was a sunt coordinator, the sword fight teacher, and they're like that he was supposed to teach Mal and they're like why does he just be mall? So Yeah, the vision, beauty of it, the music of it, and just the meaning of it. I think that's that's that's my number two.
Speaker 4Nice. Yeah, that that's one that was close for me, but it isn't in you know, it's it's somewhere in the top ten for me. You know, I feel you on the you know, the fate aspect of it, right, And that's something that I had never really given that much thought before, but I think is a really good point personally, Like the music is amazing, yeah, and it it carries a lot of things, you know throughout Star Wars, the music and so there it really elevates that to
Speaker 4another level. That was also the first like really acrobatic lightsaber battle. I think that you had, right, like through the original three movies, like you know, they kind of gradually ramped up from you know, really not super impressive to like, okay, you know did the sidekick? Okay, yeah, that's pretty good form, all right. You know where that those battles were much more about the the the emotion, I think, whereas here there was you know, there was emotion, right, but there was also this like real the choreography was
Speaker 4another level. Yeah, and yeah, that's that's.
Speaker 6What I think. It's really true. And you know this is when like we go from lightsaber equals Claymore to lights equal equals rape Year and that's just a lot more fun of a fight to watch.
Speaker 4Yeah, or or equals postaff Like I did not see till the theater, and it was quite I sat through the rest of the movie, which I was like, eh, I was like, all right, all right, this is this is why I'm in this theater. Yeah, this is this is a moment.
Speaker 6You know that that's impressive that you were avoiding previews all the way back then that well, because yeah, I definitely saw it on like I saw it on a different TV show, Tvah.
Speaker 4I didn't watch TV. Yeah, so that helped.
Speaker 6That's smart. That's smart well, even though I know it does not look great. Honorable mention to me for the obi Wan versus Vader fight in the first movie in a New Hope. Honorable mention to me for Ah Soca versus Mall at the end of Clone Wars. I think it probably shouldn't be in my top three because again, mostly I've just talked about it so much on talk about something else. Honorall mention for the when Asca and obi Wan fight together against dark Side people, because it's
Speaker 6just like they're kind of like bantering and they're both making fun of how like they can't imagine they're doing this, and like the.
Speaker 4Good in Clone Wars.
Speaker 6Yeah, in Clone Wars. Yeah, but the one I'm gonna come with from my top three. And again here this is a motion over acrobaticness, but is return of the Jedi Vader and Luke because there's just the real duel. There is Vader trying to pull Luke to the dark side and Luke trying to pull Vader to the light side, and the lightsabers are just a prop in that larger duel. And to me, that whole duel and that whole scene is the heart and soul of everything I love about
Speaker 6Star Wars is the idea that like, yes, like you can't, Vader can needle who can can get under his skin, and Luke can lose it for a minute when Lea is threatened, but can still pull back enough to find the compassion in Invader and to pull him back to the other side. And it's also just like it's fun to watch a fight where one person's trying not to fight, you know that. It just creates a different kind of dynamic. And I think they shot it really well.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's my number one that I'm not going to count as number one because I want to talk about other ones besides that, and unpair of Strikes Back, which are my number one and two because to me, you know, Star Wars ultimately comes down to the like the Luke Vader thing, yeah, Anakin, the three of them and sort of how they interact to me is like the heart of the original Star Wars, which is the Star Wars I lived with until the Phantom Menace basically, right, So.
Speaker 6I will quick interject, I was going to ask you what are your top three Star Wars movies, and then realized it would just be the original trilogy, I'm ninety percent sure.
Speaker 4So Rogue one I think is ahead of Star Wars A New hope, that's fair, but like those who are close. And I was gonna if that was a question, I was gonna go with the trilogy as one unit and then so yeah, but no, that's a good that's a good A good guess it's pretty close. It's you know, it's like that's one two and like tied for third basically. Yeah, so yeah, yeah, the like the lighting and the music, I think that's the not the first time you have vocals, right,
Speaker 4because when the Emperor shows up, you have some human voices in the music, right, But that's the first time you do in like a big in like a fight scene, which then I think they did again and du all the fates, right, But like the lighting, the music, like the production to sound it like it all comes together so well to really underscore, underscore the emotions of the fight, right, which are the key to the fight. And and it's cut up across so like it's broken up rhythmically by
Speaker 4the other two battles that are going on right, right, and it's really interwoven with those so well. And the fact that Luke doesn't want to really fight, right, that's not really what he's there to do. It does change the dynamic, and you know that he does get so emotional that he screams something that's either no never or not her and you can't really tell. And I guess it's subtitled, but like it's yeah, that that is just like to me, that's that. I think that's my favorite Star Wars moment because that's like or second you know,
Speaker 4but that whole time in that movie, yeah, you know, and then Empire strikes back to me also is this you know, that's their first duel and they do want to fight, but like Vader doesn't really want to fight. Then yeats to capture him. I thought of that, right, He's not trying to kill Luke, He's trying to bring him to the dark side. And in the second one, Luke's trying to bring him back from the dark side, you know. And I you know, I like that Luke loses that first one and then he wins the second one in like the same way, you know, cutting off
Speaker 4the lightsaber hand, And I think those two duels just really also the lighting and just the way they're shot is so perfect. In those two movies, and to me, it's like, without those I would just like Star Wars, you know. I think it's like that's that's what elevates those movies to like movies that I really love. But those two don't count because they're they're like the vader, you know, of the Villain's question.
Speaker 6Let me just say two quick things about them and then get you to your actually answer, Yeah, go ahead. One is I think also one thing you said about how that lightsaber battle is intercut with the two other battles that are happening, one on the surface of end or one the space battle, and all three battles are interesting, and all three bats and the rhythm of the battles matches each other. To me, the most damning thing about like the way for if Phantom Menace had done that,
Speaker 6I think I would have had a much better opinion of the movie. Again, it's the fact that it's cutting between this utterly ridiculous spar starship battle where a kid is just floating around and no one knows how to shoot against him, and this ridiculous battle of gungans versus droids that are both so boring and so badly cut that it's just so different.
Speaker 4Yeah, and a fourth thing too, it's got like Amidala and then like all sneaking around and stuff. It's like cutting back and forth. Yea four things because each movie, like A New Hope was like one thing, and then Empire was two things, and Jedi was three things, and then A Phantom Menace was four things. And I think finally they got to Attack of the Clones, they're like, all right, let's not cut between five things.
Speaker 6Yeah, that's that's much better. The other thing I was gonna say to also about that Jedi fight scene is like, again, this is the stuff that I notice more than like the martial arts stuff. There's particular shots that are just that that tell so much, and to me, the defining one, there's a couple like this, but the defining one is when Luke finally like takes the bait and attacks and he swings at the Emperor, looks like invader blocks him, and it's just this perfectly again exactly if there's like
Speaker 6in my head there're two lightsabers crossed with the Emperor laughing in the background, and it's like that moment tells you everything about the Emperor's motivation for that entire movie, like he wants these two to fight because I honestly believe in that moment he doesn't care who wins, like he cares, right, But it turns out like he wants that he doesn't know which with these two his best.
Speaker 4And he wants whoever is stronger, and that's the one who's gonna win. Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure.
Speaker 6Again goes to the bureaucrat that like, get your bureau has to fight against each other and the best will arrives. He's bureaucrats.
Speaker 4But you know one thing about that scene, That shot is so great, except I feel like Luke is swinging from the wrong.
Speaker 6Side that made him be true.
Speaker 4He feels like he's swinging away from the Emperor, and I'm like, I don't understand if he was when at the Emperor. He should have been coming this way, but he's coming the other way. That always has bothered me because I'm like, this is so good, but it's also like I think it's wrong. I think it's shot wrong.
Speaker 6It's funny. I just a couple hours ago recorded some episodes with the Marvel Movie Minute Folks, a great podcast. I love it, and I was teasing I went pretty deep into like having fun with those guys, and I was teasing them about how they really look for the minutia in movies. It's stuff that I used to not notice but now I do, and so like, don't point that out to me.
Speaker 4I don't want to think about my people.
Speaker 6Yeah, they really are. They really are, all right, So what are your actual top three?
Speaker 4Okay, my top three that aren't disqualified from being too awesome and seminal and just like you know, at the root of like you know, my initial love for Star Wars are Oh so you already mentioned mal versus Kenobi, which is just we've said everything that needs to be said about that. It's not about the Yeah, that's it period. Mal versus Soka. I'm gonna take that one because I know that was choreographed and shot with two actual people.
Speaker 4It is ray Park and I think it's Lauren and Mary Kim. I might be messing up her name, but I think that's her name. Who is an outstanding stunt woman? Who she was she was doing ah Soka right right? And then the funny thing is she is the stunt double for the the Governor. I think she's called in Uh in the Mandalorian in the episode of Jedi Who when she's fighting against Ahsoka, which I thought was I'm pretty sure this is true. I'm pretty sure. So anyway,
Speaker 4I thought that was that fight is so interesting because it's like this really great, well done duel and like, you know, like it doesn't really matter because you know, what's going on is the like at the same time, is the whole you know, Anakin's fall thing, right, and so it's like it matters, but it also feels like, you know, getting to see this epic duel between these two characters who know, like they know they're the side characters, you know, which you don't always get, but they know that,
Speaker 4like the fate of the galaxy is at stake, and they're just here out on a scaffolding, like you know, dueling.
Speaker 6I have to say, in particular, I'm trying to not have as many tangents because we're going so long, but this one, I'm gonna have all the tangents that we know us. I love that, particularly as you mentioned that that Ray Park is a part of that, because Ray Park is an amazing martial artist and fight coordinator and all that kind of stuff. I don't think there's anything about his like acting, especially his line line delivery in a Phantom Menace that's really that noteworthy. And I think because of that part, because of the characters, gets much better writing at this point, when most people think of
Speaker 6the actor who plays Darth Maul, they could think of Sam whitwer who's the voice actor who I think plays him phenomenally the Clone Wars, and on some of them it's are like a little sad, like, wait, no, Ray Park originated this character and now Sam Whitwerer has just taken it so much further. So to have ray Park be back and involved with such a critical moment for this character, I just I just love that. To me, like I think they got it in part because it's very good, but it also to me, it's just a really nice way of honoring like these two people who together really gave life to this character.
Speaker 4So well yeah, yeah, exactly, the circle is now complete and all that.
Speaker 6Yeah exactly.
Speaker 4Yeah, Yeah, I think that's great because like what ray Park brought to the character was the physicality, right, and so having that in having him bring that to that episode, which is you know, that four arc episode of of Clone Wars is just I don't know. It's tied for like top in my you know, Star Wars things basically got it?
Speaker 6Oh so is that your three?
Speaker 4No? I just listed one?
Speaker 6Okay, oh two.
Speaker 4I listened to Oh yeah, yeah, so mal versus Soka, mal verus Kenobi, right, and then I already had two Vader versus. So like, clearly my villains are fairly weighted towards, you know, with with their duels. And I specifically said duels, not lightsaber battles, because my third one, well it involves a lightsaber is dn Jar in the Mandalorian versus maf Gideon with the spear the best gar spear versus the Dark Saber, which like that that kick thing, the thing
Speaker 4he does with the like he kicks the spear and it comes up. And I just think it's really well done in an episode that also is tied for like my favorite Star Wars things ever and and yeah, and I mean Dark Saber looks awesome and I think it's the first time we really see it right in action, in live action in terms of actually in a fight. Right. Yeah, So yeah, that that one just that's like both for like where it sits within that whole episode and that show.
Speaker 4And then also just like just the choreography, you know, like it's just really really thoughtfully creatively done. You know. It's like because I feel like you see things and you see things and so often it's like, yeah, well I've seen that move before. I've said, oh, what's that. You know, like for like someone to do something physical and some action thing and like really surprise me, like it takes something, and then they did it.
Speaker 6There I'm gonna add one more hounorable mention just because and then we get to your left your next question, but because you said duel, like I still was thinking this is lightsaber battable. Yeah, you said duel. The fact that Cad Baine has actual literal duels like both in the Book of Boba Fat and in the Clone Wars TV show, And like if you told me that someone wrote a black Cat cowboy and put him in Star Wars, I would think you're nuts. But Cat they do it so with Cat Bain, So anyway, yeah.
Speaker 4And I mean they have they have that a lot in Mandalorian as well, right, And I think some people are like, oh, but they just did this. It's like yeah, but you know it's still good. It's you know, as long as you have the right characters and you shoot it right, it can you know, it can be good?
Speaker 6Definitely. All right, So what's your next question?
Speaker 4Okay, my next question this is kind of overlapping. I guess I'm gonna go with what are three of your favorite live action moments? Because we did our favorite animated moments? Right mm hmm. I thought that was the thing we did, so like in the live action everything like what are three? And I didn't actually come up with these for myself? So go ahead.
Speaker 6So I'm gonna be controversially here to start out. I think my favorite moment in all of Star Wars is you know, projection Luke against Kylo Ren is just such an incredible moment of to me, let me, I think it's visually gorgeous, like the whole idea of like the sand and like the fact that like you have to pay attention enough to notice that like Luke isn't causing that red, he isn't moving the sand. Who everybody else is?
Speaker 6The dialogue in it is is both like like I don't think I've ever laughed quite as much as when Luke brushes the dust off of his shoulder after like all the things get fired at him and just the whole like everything you just said is wrong. Yeah, so that that that's gonna be my number one.
Speaker 4So I'm actually going to respond to that that out of all the things that I absolutely loathe about the last Jedi, that's not one of them. Okay, that is definitely taken on its own. I think is a great scene. I've certainly laughed harder, but but yeah, it's the the sort of moment when like every the dust is clearing and then just like still standing there. He's like, yeah, no, what is that all you got? Yeah? I think that's fantastic.
Speaker 6I think that's one number two. I've talked about this to death, so I won't say too much of it, but it's just if I cannot save Anakin, I will have venge him. Vengeance is not the Jedi way. I am no Jedi. I mean I get goosebumps just saying those lines again. It's from the Twilight of the Apprentice, the episodes from Rebels when Ahsoka is fighting with Anakin slash Vader.
Speaker 4The famous live action show. Oh okay, sorry, I thought you were gonna I thought you were referencing Kenobi. Now actually no, so I've got.
Speaker 6A similar question, but in a different way. But well, yeah, live action, okay, live action, live action. Hondo has never been in a live action You.
Speaker 4Can't use Honda. We already did animation, right. That was great, Go listen to that episode. We had a lot of fun.
Speaker 6The moment when we talked about that. Like, I think the if we hadn't just done duels, I think the the Luke Vader fight scene would have been one of them. I think when we this is silly, but it has been attacked, so I have to defend it.
Speaker 4Ye ye oh yeah yeah.
Speaker 6And it's not just because it's a silly song and I like silly songs, and I hate the idea of Luca's cutting it, but like you know, one of the fundamental ideas of those movies, at least the original trilogy, was supposed to be like the way that machinery is replacing man, and that man can fight back against machinery and or the sentient life can fight back about machinery. And like some people think the Eoks are silly, I love the idea of these indigenous folks who don't have any technology, but only they have their technology and using that to defeat this incredible technological menace. And so the
Speaker 6way that song was done, and like the whole like I can visualize it entirely in my head. You know, the way that they dance with each other and one of them I think it's wicked dance. No, it's the it's the medicine man type person who dances with Han and like the drum set of Imperial helmets, which I admit as an eight year old, I was like, are their heads still in there? That's so badass. I don't mean thinks that's probably not the case, but.
Speaker 4Maybe I mean the Ewoks eat people. That's that's right. Like people are like, oh, they're so cute and fluffy, it's so cheesy, Like they eat people.
Speaker 6They eat people. That's very true. So I think that would be the second moment. Third would be it's fun. I mean, all of Rogue one is so good.
Speaker 4Oh, I know what it is.
Speaker 6It's also going to be from Last Jedi. It's also going to be very controversial. The Honda maneuver. I just think the the where she takes her ship to light speed to crash into the Imperial Star Destroyer to or the New Order First Order Star Destroyer to stop that from happening. It's just I don't care about the physics. I don't care about like why didn't they use it before you can head? Kennon answers to all those questions, just the pure filmmaking of it, of having all the sound just stop and just that incredible visual moment, as
Speaker 6well as like this person who's had everything about her leadership has been questioned up to this point, and it's just such her willing to sacrifice herself like this to like she knows general organa Leah would want to sacrifice self, but she won't, and so she does it instead. It's to me just want to like in terms of like just single moment, one of the most perfect in Star Wars. No comment, that's fair, that's fair.
Speaker 4I'll just just I'll just leave that. Yeah. So those are your three two from Last Jedi, yeah, and one from Wait and one from a Return of the Jedi.
Speaker 6Yeah. Okay, okay, there's I mean, as I'm thinking about it more, there's definitely some other like hot Hot Han knocking Vadership out it like Hans you.
Speaker 4Know, oh yeah, coming out of nowhere.
Speaker 6Yeah, Hans moment in New Hope is definitely up there. And actually I'll throw one more in the because it is it's double edged because it's such a perfect moment of romance that the whole rest of the series is constantly trying to get back to and failing. But I love you, I know. Oh yeah, it's just such a defining, beautiful moment.
Speaker 4Yeah. I had one category that was going to be favorite lines. Yeah, and I don't know whether that would be there, but it certainly it certainly could be, you know. Yeah, for me, coming up with three moments is like hard. Like I'll also say, like the entire end of Return of the Jedi, Like I'm just not going to pick anything from that because I could easily just have my top three be like, you know, I mean, there was the Lightsaber battle, and then even after that, there's like Luke being like because I'm a father, you know, I'm a father like my Jedi before me, that is that
Speaker 4is not the line. That is definitely not the line, you know, And then Vader turned I mean, Vader turning to the Emperor to me is like that's the pivotal moment, you know, the fate of the galaxy right there.
Speaker 6But like and he says nothing. When he does it.
Speaker 4He says nothing, Yeah, I have another thing that might that might come up again. And then the whole yub nub thing as well, and and like Luke with like the lighting, uh, the you know, the Vader armor on again. It's so like that whole thing. I'll just set that aside. And like also the parts of Empire Strikes Back that I've already mentioned, Like, I'll set that aside as well. And I guess I'll have one sort of cheat, which is the last episode of Mandalorian season you know, season two,
Speaker 4episode eight.
Speaker 6I don't think it's a cheat. I think the whole thing is phenomenal.
Speaker 4I mean, I think the entire episode is fantastic. But like the moments that really stand out to me aside from anything I've already mentioned, you know, And I mean there's all the like jetpack, park Core and all that stuff, you know, but like the you know, you know, beat beat beat, and they're like, oh, this is how many life forms? None? You know, Like that's like so chilling when it's like, oh, it's the Dark Troopers. And then like and you know, I mean then Luke showing up spoilers,
Speaker 4I guess I often try to like not mention that, but because it's like it was just so amazing, like watching that right when it came out and having no idea that that was definitely what was gonna happen, you know, and Bokatan being like the Jedi, you know, like like there's so much weight there from like to me, it brings this feeling of like really how much sort of the galaxy went through, Like just Bokatan saying that line because of having seen her way back in Clone Wars and knowing, you know, knowing that she knew Jedi, but
Speaker 4then that there was there were these decades where she didn't you know, and then the Empires fall in and now she's here and like then her reaction there it's just it. It's you know, and Katie Sakoff does a great job and mc nawen does a great job, which is none and like that whole end there for me is just like that's outside of like the original trilogy, which I'm just gonna disqualify. I'm just gonna say, I'm not gonna mention that, you know, is just it's it's the most of like what Star Wars can be to me.
Speaker 6Yeah, I think I think that makes to all sense. It's it's just and and to me, it's the perfect marriage because it is both incredibly emotional powerful moment. Like I had a friend who actually got the Luke revealed reveal spoiled for them, and like, I think that might be the single moment in all of Star Wars that I would be most upset if it had been spoiled for me. Like, yeah, I don't remember a time when I didn't know Vader was Luke's father, so I can't
Speaker 6really count that, but like, but yeah, I think all of that is just and it's yeah, and it's it's both the emotional meaning of it, but also just the cinematography of it, the lighting, the the slow reveal, and the fact that you only really know it's Luke because of his glove, which is this weird thing of like his connection to his father. It was just like, yeah, there was so much thought and love put in every shot of that scene.
Speaker 4Absolutely yeah, And like just like the whole episode, like so so much of that episode is just so well executed, you know, and could only be executed that way by people who have so much investment in the whole death you know. OOV or whatever, like the whole world.
Speaker 6I'm gonna throw we other quick cheat that it made me think of, which is because again this is like a two second moment, but the end of the first episode of Mandalorian when you don't really know who this care. I think it's maybe the end of the second episode. No, it's the end of the first episode. You don't really know whose character is. The robot wants to kill the baby. Yeah, Amanda hasn't said much about it, and all you hear you see him draw his gun, you hear the gun go off, and for us half second you don't know what happened. Yeah, and then you see the robot fall,
Speaker 6and I was just like, that is just that's just brilliant filmmaking, like in terms of like shooting and effect. It was just that moment. That moment sets up everything about Mando's characters.
Speaker 4So well, absolutely for sure, and the whole show right, like the arc of the show exactly. Yeah, And I guess for a second one I'm gonna go with the moment from Rogue one that I think maybe you were gonna mention, I'm not sure which where Donnie Yen's character, I don't remember the character's name, they say like three times. I think it starts with the c where he's just walking towards the button and he's just like, I'm one
Speaker 4with the force, the forces with me. I'm one with the forest, the forces with me, you know, and then he goes and presses the button and gets shot and you know everything, you know, it works right, but like, yeah, I just I just really I don't know, because that was a whole movie that like wasn't about the Force, you know, it was about the rebellion and outside of like any connection with any Jedi, and and so they're kind of having that character, they're like doing that. It just it just really to me, it kind of brings
Speaker 4it together a little bit more in a way, you know. And it's like you don't really know whether he's using the Force or not. You know, like maybe he is, maybe he's not. It doesn't really matter, you know. It's like, I mean, it's funny because it's kind of like I guess it's like his faith in the Force and his conviction and whatever, which which isn't really something that I'd say I can relate to in a you know, kind of you know, real world thing. But I just think it plays really really powerfully there.
Speaker 6Yeah. I think that moment sets up a true understanding of how non Jedi like the way they mythologize the Jedi and the Force much better than almost anything in Clone Wars, does you know? Yeah, it really just drives that home.
Speaker 4And then also sets up there's something very similar in I believe the penultimate episode of Clone Wars, so where Rex is saying something like that or Ahsocus, either Rex or Ahsoka or they're both saying it's something you know they're both.
Speaker 6Yeah, I remember what you're talking about. I can't place it.
Speaker 4Yeah, And I guess I won't pick a third one because I basically picked all of the end of Return of the Jedi.
Speaker 6You know, I did think it's funny that you I suggested we do five, you said, let's do three. So we have to make some decisions, and we've both been cheating like crazy. But that's fine. This is all arbitrary. We can do that.
Speaker 4Yeah, and that's what I said. I mean, I even said in the message. I was like, look, we're going to talk about more than what we call our top three, right, We're gonna say these are three of our favorite and then here's some other, you know, ones that didn't quite make it today. Maybe on another day they would Yep, okay, I have one more, but why don't you? I mean, I have five more, but oh.
Speaker 6You say you're one more quickly and then I'll try to restraint.
Speaker 4Yeah, this one is little okay. This one's kind of like a throwaway almost outside of like the racism and anything else like really problematic from like the Phantom Menace or anywhere else outside of that. What are to you the three biggest really cringe moments in any Star Wars anything.
Speaker 6These are the good one, And people who've been listening to me talk about Star Wars for these episodes can probably guess a couple of das. Number one for me is uh doku uh. It's specifically at the moment when Dooku gets off the ship and you see that he has been working with Palpatine this whole time because I on this. He gives Kenobe this beautiful speech where it's clear he believes that that he's doing this for the
Speaker 6right reasons, and part of the thing is we know that he's right and Kenobi's wrong. He says, look, there's a sith behind all these maneuvers and you don't know that, and Kenobi's like, no, we can't know that, and like that would set up Dooku as such this utterly brilliant villain. You've heard me talk about this all the time. I'm not gonna say but more about it. But yeah, so to me, that is that's absolutely cringe worthy. There's so much about Last Rise of Skywalker's cringe worthy to me that I feel like picking anyone moment I'm gonna I'm
Speaker 6gonna put the way we were like that whole movie Oliver Turnity Jedi is good. All that that's gonna be bad, not all of it, as we're discussing about it, but like, so, what are my other two? I think you responded to that first one? Will I think of other two?
Speaker 4No, I just said word like, I agree, you know, I'm with you on that one. I'll suggest one for you from the same movie, Okay, go for I mean, yeah, there's might in Yoda, and I would think that. I don't know if that's what you would That's not necessarily what I mean by cringe moments, But because you went with the Douku one, I feel like that from things you've said.
Speaker 6Okay, yeah, Yoda to me is because that's not like I'm going to focus on cringe in the story, you know, Okay, yes, Yoda, because you have also said, like, besides like the racism and some sexism. To me, that's just pure ableism in that scene. Sure, I feel like I have to give an honorable mention to I hate sand.
Speaker 4And just yeah that's number three.
Speaker 6But I would say even perhaps like to me because that's a terrible line. But to me, the more cringe worthy moment and here, actually I'll say this one is I can't sleep, I can't think. I forgel the exact wording, but at some point it basically comes to you, I am tormented by the kiss you should never have given me. I am in agony, and I just like Anak is a boy like forgiving I'll bleep this out. Anakin is an f boy. Like it's just all of like the
Speaker 6the incredibly manipulative gas lighty like you should be with me because I am hurting because you reject me, and so it's your fault. He's not an F boy, He's an insel. In that moment, like it just feels like I I would say, I cannot understand why people romanticize Anakin and Padme as this great romantic couple, but then people romanticize the Joker and Harley, and I think there's actually a lot of similarity there. I think there's I
Speaker 6think there are some of the same toxic elements, and it's also shown in the Clone Wars when you know, Anakin catches Padme with Clovis. But yeah, I think that would be My second one is just that whole speech of I am so hurt by the fact that you're rejecting me, that you should be with me.
Speaker 4Yeah. I I mean, I guess all the Jedi are literally involuntarily celibate, right, Yeah, but yeah, I don't know, I have some that kind of delves into a whole thing that I kind of don't really want to get into. Okay, but yeah, I mean you could just say every line in in Attack of the Clones and I'd be like, yeah, yeah, it's just very cringey dialogue.
Speaker 6It's the It's part of why I love you. I know, it looks so much better. H Third moment, give me your list. I'm having give your list. I'm having trouble coming right.
Speaker 4My list is number one, No Number two, No number three, I hate sand Okay, so five words. So I guess Vader says no multiple times now in Return of the Jedi, not my Return of the Jedi. But that just ruins the best. Like that's actually I believe my number one moment in all of Star Wars is Vader turning and chucking the Emperor down the chute, you know, because that is the turning point, that is what the entire original
Speaker 4trilogy was building towards. It's the climax, and Lucas was just like, how about I ruined it for Yeah, you know, it's like yub Nub getting stripped away in this just even tighter, more efficient form. Yeah.
Speaker 6And it's funny because like, Han shot first is probably the moment that's the most talked about in terms of stupid things Lucas added or took away. Yeah, but I feel like maybe it was because by the release of that movie, we were just so used to these terrible things that we didn't focus on it more. But yeah, to me, that one, Han not shooting first is a dumb moment and it hurts his character development. But yeah, I think that moment is far more important.
Speaker 4Right, Yeah, just the weight of the moment.
Speaker 6Yeah, so yeah that I was thinking, like to me that you don't exist, But yeah, if I have a third cringe ear the moment, it's just all of the things from that movie, all of the things that Lucas later inserts.
Speaker 4Right, all the changes that aren't just like, you know, a little bit of CGI that makes cloud City look like it as well knows. Yeah, Okay, that's fine, you can do that.
Speaker 6That's what Luke reconnecting with Biggs. I think it's probably my only where I'm like, yeah, that actually adds a little to the movie.
Speaker 4Right, Yeah, that's just that's just director's cut, you know. That's like, that's okay, you can put something back in that you cut for time, you know. I'm always fine with that. Yeah, And but I just I still don't understand why Disney doesn't have multiple versions available on d Plus. You know, like you could just do that. It's just a streaming service. You could do that.
Speaker 6There is apparently on the internet. I'll see if I can find where it is and put a postal link in the screen screen shots. But someone's put in the show notes. Someone has put I think on YouTube, like the original version that was shown in theaters in the nineteen seventies really, and so like this is not only like not with the Lucas editions, but like you before the remastered so like the tie fighters are jerking around on the screen, and like the explosions look pretty bad, and yeah, I want to see if I can find that at some point interesting.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, I'm curious.
Speaker 6So okay.
Speaker 4So so then the second no is just like when Vader becomes Vader and you know, he's in the suit for the first time and he's like, no, I'm like, you managed to take you know, the greatest like voice actor of live action anyway, you know, and like just just clowning on him, like what the you know, and you know in the same movie, you've got that backswing. You know, that whole scene doesn't work for me. But it's not like there's a single moment that's like super cringe.
Speaker 4It just doesn't quite work for me, you know, Whereas the no is just this like, you know, feces ice cream on the top of a cake of feces. I don't know, yeah anyway, Yeah, and then then I hate Sand. I mean, there's not that much to say about it. I hate Sand. I don't like it, but I'm not gonna like try and romance someone with it. I mean, I guess it's understandable he doesn't know how. But the idea was this was supposed to be romantic, right, I think that was the aim. And I'm like, oh goodness.
Speaker 6And I think my third will be from that movie. It's Padme dying of Side of Sadness.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, that's yeah.
Speaker 6Padme is probably the single Dooku gets more development, but in terms of like a character who I think was criminally underdeveloped and underused in live action and then gets completely rewritten. So much more added to her character in both the Clone Wars and in the books. Is padmea Amidala. She's much better in the Clone Wars. I think she's much more chemistry with Anakin in those in those TV shows, but in the E. K. Johnson books about Padme, Queen's Shadow of Queen's Peril, Queen's Hope. I think the third one is it just gives a character so much more depth,
Speaker 6And so the idea that like a it makes no sense because Leah apparently remembers Padme. She remembers her birth mother right right, yes, so like which I don't care if he's the force like you saw for three seconds and yeah, it's just like the pet he puts out the books, like the padme Amidala you saw in the Clone Wars. Would that woman just give up on life because her love turned to the dark side?
Speaker 4Right, yeah, no not that yeah not no, no way, no way. So yeah, it's yeah, it's it's it's that's very bad. That to me has this kind of like misogynistic like undercurrent you know that I think exists in you know, the prequel trilogy significantly more than in the original trilogy, which is interesting, yeah, you know because it was like twenty years later and it's like somehow like gone backwards because like Princess Leigh in the original one. Okay, there's you can have plenty of complaints. I don't remember
Speaker 4a second female character besides Buru, who like there isn't barely did anything right besides getting fridged.
Speaker 6Like there are three women characters in all of those first three Star Wars movies.
Speaker 4Yeah, like that's you know man mathma oh yeah yeah, yeah, who you know. But that's the thing, like, yes, there's a dearth of female characters, right, But it's like, okay, you've got Amperu who's like kind of you know, relegated to irrelevancy, but like Princess Leah is like badass, you know, and Moon Mathma is in charge of like the rebellion. You know, like that's those are bold choices in nineteen seventy seven, in nineteen eighty three, you know, so very much. So at least, like, you know, that's better than Amidala
Speaker 4in in you know, the third uh, you know that in Revenge of the Sith. Anyway, I think in the second movie, she actually had a little bit more agency in a few spots that was kind of nice.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean, like her dragging Anakin to go rescue.
Speaker 4Yeah, like, yeah, that's a moment.
Speaker 6You know, if it wasn't like, if it wasn't for the fact that she's supposed to fall in love with Anakin for no reason that I can possibly understand. Yeah, especially while Daddy Warren Kenobi is right there as the invent we often point out. All right, so somehow I think you got to do two questions in a row. I thought we were okay coming to the end.
Speaker 4Well, I did three questions in a row.
Speaker 6Okay, I only asked one of Okay. So it's more so going in a different direction. Who are the three best actors in Star Wars?
Speaker 4Oh? So, to clarify, do you mean the three best actors or the three actors who do the best acting within the Star Wars.
Speaker 6Three best acting performances within Star Wars?
Speaker 4Okay? So I'm gonna take this as meaning live action, okay. And if you want to list any voice actors, that's cool. I haven't really listened to the series in English, so I don't really share the same voice actors you do. You're like, Sam Whitweer. I'm like, yeah, sure, Like you know, i'd have to look up whose voices I've been hearing, because you know, I've listened to mal in Spanish and German and Cantonese, you know. So I'll take it in terms of live action. Geez, I don't know. That's hard.
Speaker 4It's really hard. I mean, I'll say first of all that I think Mark Hamill's performance is dramatically underrated and made like sort of played like in a certain way. Like it's not like I think it's underappreciated, you know, But I think his best acting is like as the Joker, you know, And and so you know, I don't think
Speaker 4that i'd necessarily, you know, put him up in the in the top three. Like it's hard with like Vader, because like James Earl Jones's voice is amazing, but like it's that's Vader's a composite, composite, you know, the way Mal is in the animated series, right, Yeah, And so like I don't know if I'd go with James Earl Jones either, especially because like also it was it David Prowse or it was Sean What's what's his name? It's
Speaker 4a third person, right, who plays physical Anakin, who I think gives a great performance. But in this like little he's in one scene, you know, so I think Christopher Lee, I'm gonna throw up there because I think he doesn't have that much to work with, and he's in one of my least favorite Star Wars movies. But like when he's on screen, I can watch, you know, like he
Speaker 4he just he has just so much presence, and you know, maybe part of its bias because like we just covered Dooku, you know, I.
Speaker 6But he's definitely would be one of my on my honorable Mentions list. I think, yeah, he's the fact that we care so much about this kind of nothing character. I think it's a thousand percent because of Christopher Lee.
Speaker 4Yeah for sure, for sure. I mean I think Harrison Ford like just like does the swashbuckler like he I think he brings something to Han solo that not a lot of actors would, you know. I mean, I think he's one of He's like a generational swashbuckling actor, you know who it's It's not like a ton of emotional depth. There is emotional depth there, but you know, especially like when they're stuck in the asteroid belt, you know that whole thing. The fact that he improved the line, I know.
Speaker 6You know, yeah, I mean that he also improved the He didn't improv, but he was when I came up with one, I just shoot the guy with the sword and raiders the Lost Ar Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah, because like he was sick apparently that day, and it's like, what if we don't do this sort of duel that I don't want to do and I just shoot him. They're like, oh, yeah, that's good, you know. And Mike, if you want that to be a writing credit instead of acting credit, I don't know, you know. I mean I think carry Fisher's fantastic in the series. I'm trying to think it like in more recent things. I mean, I think Tomorrow Morrison is great in Book of Boba Fat Yeah, and in in Mandalorian, Like I
Speaker 4think it's it's hard. It's like like Pedro Pascal, like he doesn't get to use his face, you know, and yet like to you know, that's like that's like doing the James Earl Jones job of like actually having your voice communicate so much, but then also using body language because that's like his body as well, you know. So I mean I could easily put like Vader through like the composite of all of the people involved in Vader and and like Mando as like two of the top ones.
Speaker 4Like I don't know, it's it's that's a question that I feel like I'd really need to give some more thought to to really, you know, Like I think Diego Luno was fantastic and Rogue one, but like I feel like a lot of people were fantastic in Rogue One. I don't I don't remember the actress's name who played.
Speaker 6Yeah, I want to see Dady Ridley, but she's ray. I think it's also very good, but yeah, Like, I mean, I think one of the great things about Rogue one is it's truly ensemble movie. So yeah, picked absolutely any one of the individual actors is really hard.
Speaker 4Yeah, and I think it just has like performances over across the border. One of the things that really carry that movie to like a higher level just about all the performances. Felicity Jones, that's it, that's it. Yeah, plays generous.
Speaker 6Yeah, so you named all three other ones on my list. I say it's kind of funny because there are a couple of people from the animated shows who who are very close You've never heard de Bradley Baker, who does the voices of all the clones. Yeah, and it's just amazing what he does with his voice. But I realized, but like my number one though, is a no matter what end. Probably number four are both voice actors, they're just from live action, because yeah, I had no problem
Speaker 6putting James low Jones as just the like just amazing. And the other honorable mention for me is Frank Oz as Yoda.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, I was thinking about that too, But yeah.
Speaker 6The ability to convey that kind of playfulness and wisdom and like to call out Luke while it's just so good. But the other two on my list are Carrie Fisher, who I think you said pretty much everything that's say. The only thing to add is, I think all of the Big Three from the original movies, I think all of their actors do a good job of conveying who they are now in the sequels. But to me, there's something about Princess Leiah becoming General Organa that Carrie Fisher does that is just so powerful and I just love I just think her. So she's number two on my list,
Speaker 6and then my third is Petro Pascal for all the reasons you said, like the ability that I never miss I never had a moment where I'm like, I wish I could see his face to know what he was thinking right now, And it's his body language, his voice, his I mean even that, like he's so withdrawn, like he doesn't show much emotion. So the ability to like have that it's just acting gold, I think, mm.
Speaker 4Hmm, yeah, absolutely, I'm I'm I'm with you on all of those. Yeah. In terms of the sequel trilogy, Carrie Fisher's performance is by far my favorite out of I mean, I I like what they did with Leah, you know right, Yeah, and and and I think she gives a great performance. And obviously it's tragic that you know, she died when she did.
Speaker 6Yeah, which I think would have made unfortunately, that last movie so much better. Yeah, with hers to Lanet, I would have to. Okay, So let me ask my last one, and this one might it might be the less of a challenge to me and more of a challenge. It's I thought this would be a really hard one for you, but maybe it's only gonna be hard for me. What are your three favorite things about Rise of Skywalker?
Speaker 4Oh? Yeah, no, let's see. I mean number one has to be that you hate it so much that I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding.
Speaker 6I love Last Jedi and you did not, And so I know you got some Shouden freude when I was like this movie ruins Star Wars and she's like, yeah, what's that feeling, friend.
Speaker 4I will say like, yeah, like the fact that she's Ray Palpatine, you know, until she decides to be Ray Skywalker, like felt very vindicating. When I was like, look, you don't know like that Kylo Wren was either telling the truth or even knew what he was talking about you know, like, do I like that choice for her character? Not sure, not really so much. Let's see, I mean three things
Speaker 4that I liked the most about it. I mean, okay, I just thought it was overall like a fairly fun movie and like the end. Oh okay. Number one. Number one is when Ray takes the one lightsaber and holds it up over her back and then Ben reaches over his shoulder and draws that lightsaber out of thin air. That is amazing. That is an awesome moment. It's if I loved the sequel trilogy, that would be one of
Speaker 4my top moments. You know, the fact that it resides in that movie undercuts it some right. The fact that we have no connection to these Knights of Wren who he's now going against to are like his boys, like that really makes that moment not as huge. But that one simple maneuver that's awesome Like that, I'm sorry, that was just awesome.
Speaker 6Yeah, I'll give you that. I think I was gonna say earlier that the the Ray and Kylo w Ren fighting together after they kill Snoke in Last Jedi was another one of my favorite We're like, I feel like the rest of the context of what happens afterwards ruins it. But yeah I did love Yeah, yeah, hey that that Rea Quinge worthy moment for me about Last Jedi.
Speaker 4But go on, sure, okay, fair, what do you rather?
Speaker 6Two?
Speaker 4I really like that. I'm gonna look up someone's name very briefly, go for it. Yeah, Okay, she is who I thought she was. I really like that. Finn finds another former Stormtrooper, you know, who's portrayed by Naomi Aki, who is in the third season of Master of None that if you still haven't watched, you still I think I should watch it. I mean, it's it's very different
Speaker 4from like everything else that I enjoyed, but I just thought it was I thought her performance and that was exceptional. But in this like I think her performance it's fine, it's good, you know, but like the character sort of like that whole thing them showing up there and like finding these other people who left this storm you know, I like that as a concept that there are other people who defected, you know from the first order, you know, the fact that that's like they're like, oh, maybe maybe let's get you know, put John Boyega with like a
Speaker 4black woman, so that like the racist people aren't like, oh no, he's gissing a white woman you.
Speaker 6Didn't like, you didn't like the Asian. Yeah, I was gonna say that's that. That moment, to me is very bittersweet because it's a brilliant plot point.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 6Yeah, and I would love it if it wasn't being done to erase all the possible plot oilines. It's like, he's not gonna be a Jedi, he's not gonna be with Ray, but but we'll give him a Stormtrooper buddy, Like, yeah, it's too bad. Could you write it outside of that context? It is a great moment.
Speaker 4Yeah, oh okay. And then I was gonna say my third one. This won't be my third one. But I do think that it is overtly subtextual, if you'll permit me, that oxymoron that Ray that Finn is for sensitive and that's what he wants to tell Ray. I think there is no other sensible interpretation. I think if you think anything else, you're out of your mind. And like that's okay. I don't want to stigmatize, like you know, mental illness
Speaker 4or be but like I need to use the phrase here, like I think you're out your damn mind. Because like, clearly, very very clearly, that's what he is trying to tell her. Bittersweet, Why didn't he just tell her? Why didn't you make it textual? Why don't you just put it in the movie. But I do think that's obviously there, and I think that's better than it not being there at all. Yeah, but that's not gonna be my number three. My number three is gonna be Ray healing the giant creature that they are going to kill or is going to kill
Speaker 4them or whatever. And she's like, wait, it's injured. Let me see if I can heal it. Oh, I can. Cool. It's like, should force healing have been a thing all the time? Probably, But I guess she's like super powerful, and like at this point I'm on board with that, you know, And I think, Yeah, Like I like the idea of her helping one of these creatures instead of just like killing it. I thought that was nice.
Speaker 6I think that was a great moment. I do also love that the Finn moment you brought up and the I've can say something positive about what was the second of the second the thing you were gonna not mention.
Speaker 4Well, there were two Finn moments. There's there's Finn talking.
Speaker 6To the stormtrooper Jenna.
Speaker 4Yeah, the former Stormtrooper Jana, and then Finn trying to be like, oh, yeah, by the way, I want to be a Jedi too, because like I can kind of feel this sports thing and like can we do this?
Speaker 6Yeah, So just on the Finn thing with with trying to tell her that the Force yet that has now been confirmed a couple of places like the Lego Star Wars movies where you're not canon, but like they've made it so clear and including making some jokes or Obi Wan's like, no, of course you're a Jedi. That's why you can talk to me as a Force ghost.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 6And I believe also the someone involved in the movie has also confirmed that. And it's bittersweet for me though again though, because I do think they are trying to create that. They're they're trying for a lot of the movie to make you think he wants to profess his love to her, and I think that by the end, I think you're right, it's pretty clear it's not that. But I think that they wanted to make that intentionally murky for a lot of the movie, which I really didn't like being out of me in all of those moments. And I'll say kind of like, you know, I've recently been able like for me, Revenge of Skywalker, Rise of
Speaker 6Skywalker and Attack of the Clones are like these polar opposites on the two different polls in which you can view the movies, where I think like Attack of the Clones adds quite a lot to the overall Star Wars story, but it hurts the actual movie making. It's god awful. I think if I watch either Rise of Skywalker or Solo as standalone space adventure movies, they're perfectly enjoyable. I would agree with that. I think the acting, the dialogue, there's no cringe with the moments. To me, it's just
Speaker 6nothing to do with Star Wars. But but what i'd say about the and again that's my opinion. I'm not for a moment saying anything else is wrong. You get to enjoy it. And I hearing other people talk about why they love those movies has really helped me say that cool, it's awesome. You get to see that. The three things I'll say though that I liked about Rise of Skywalker Again, I love Ray as a character. I love the way she's developed, and I think the way they show her flirting with a dark side rise of Skywalker and to some extent tapping into it, like she
Speaker 6uses she uses lightning, you know, like which is very considered to be dark Side, and she uses it in a moment of anger and like, yes, she's upset because she thinks she killed killed Chewi, but which kind of funny to me because like she still did probably kill some rebel prisoners, just maybe not the one she cared about, but like, like to me, she.
Speaker 4I definitely kill some people. Yeah, you know that.
Speaker 6I've often said on this podcast that I I think the Jedi rules were pretty dumb, especially by the time of the prequels, and I really like the like good side Force users who are like, you know, maybe may be pushing this at at or the atsd off the cliffs so we don't get shot with mind control is an okay thing to do, and so like Keenan knows that Ezra does that, and yeah, I love Ray getting to experience that, and then it makes it so much more powerful when she turns away from it. My second would be Lando showing up with the big fleet like
Speaker 6and here again it's like, yeah, that's the moment where if I don't think about it, I love it because it is it like, yeah, although I don't know what we're gonna do, we we can't fight them, and Orlando's saying, there's more of us. Yeah, it's that came out after Uh I'm pretty sure today that came out after endgame, right, it did, but.
Speaker 4It was certainly shot before endgame came out.
Speaker 6Okay, that that because it is so similar to the on your Left scene that it's either like they're brilliant for both doing it or it's a copy, which would be annoying. But yeah, so that that's a second moment. It's again bittersweet to me because I think it completely undercuts the point of Last Jedi and also just doesn't make any sense that all these people would come and get there so quickly and but fair.
Speaker 4Enough, and they have they have the ghosts in it, Yeah, the ghost ship you know from Yeah, Yeah, it's like in there somewhere there's like a bunch of recognizable ships apparently.
Speaker 6Well, and I would say that is my third favorite moment then, because like pacifically, because it is live action acknowledging the animated shows. Is when in that moment when Ray thinks she is like done, and the voices of all these Jedi throughout time that we've met all speak to her, and it includes the voice the animated uh. In mind that it includes the voice of Ahsoka, who has never appeared in live action. And to me that
Speaker 6was like that that and I guess, yeah, the ghost goes together as like Star Wars acknowledging the animation in live action. You know, it's kind of like the first time we saw like the the Marvel Netflix shows, or like the Agent of Shield acknowledged on the big screen. The MCU was a big deal. To me, this felt very similar.
Speaker 4I don't even know that that's the thing that happened.
Speaker 6So okay, yeah, saw the Agents of Shield. Stuff has crossed over. But and then the last I Will says as Gnora Will mention Hucks being the Scott the spy and being very quickly like found out and shot because I was like, yeah, again the bureaucracy stuff, like yeah, he's just gonna protect his own skin. He doesn't care who wins. But I did have a moment of like, if you give me an Admiral huck a General Hucks redemption story, I'm out. I'm walking it and so over him to have like, yeah, you're the spy, you're helping us. Nope,
Speaker 6you're dead. That was just like, Okay, that that's good writing there. I'm happy with that.
Speaker 4Yeah. I mean I'm not with you so much on the like oh good, you're dead. But like I liked that. It was that he was just like he was just messing with Kylo Renni. He's like, I'm sick of this man, boy, you know what I mean Like this, Like he's like it's like I'm just sick of you know, this guy. So like screw him, Like I'm gonna I'm just gonna give this information away just to mess with him, because like I just don't like him.
Speaker 6Yeah, exactly exactly. So, so I have a couple of the questions we're gonna ask. My thought is we've been talking about wanting to have a stinger at the end of episodes. I think what I'm gonna start doing and switch off only do one question of time is at the end of our Star Wars episodes during and or, let's ask one of these questions back and forth. Because I think it's a fun thing to do. It's a fun way to kind of think about some it'll.
Speaker 4Be a nice twenty minute stinger.
Speaker 6Yeah. Look, we got through six questions in under an hour and a half, so I'm incredibly impressed by that.
Speaker 4Okay, fifteen minute stinger. You know, wait, you asked three questions. I feel like you only asked two.
Speaker 6No. I asked favorite villainers, best actors, and figure things about the rise of Skywalker.
Speaker 4That's right, okay, fair, fair fair. I feel like I want to tell you what my other ones were, but should I not?
Speaker 6Uh? Yeah, no, I told it. I think it'd be fun to kind of keep going as we go through. Okay, okay, fair fair fair unless unless you want to have the Unless you don't want to surprise and have us always know that no one will get a chance to prepare.
Speaker 4I think if we wanted to be a stinger, we should know an.
Speaker 6Well one of us should know, but should put Oh yeah okay, so yeah, yeah, go ahead and tell me tell me the questions you didn't ask, and to tell you the questions I didn't ask.
Speaker 4Okay, I was gonna I was gonna ask like favorite three Jedi Okay, favorite three scoundrels, Okay, favorite three droids.
Speaker 6Oh, he's the good ones?
Speaker 4Right, and then favorite lines. Oh that was it? Yeah, Okay.
Speaker 6The other ones I was gonna ask is three favorite episodes or arcs of Star Wars TVs. But like you divided live action and uh animated, I just had not to ask it tonight because it's so similar that basically gonna do like, okay, three favorite moments from the TV shows versus Okay, so have you a fun one discussed?
Speaker 4Uh?
Speaker 6Then max one is gonna be kind of similar to your your three favorite like scoundrels, your three favorite neutral characters, okay, yeah, and and then yeah, I was gonna ask your three favorite movies, which I think is like, okay, so if if we did that half right, so hold on a second, that's gonna be our stinger. Thank you so much all for listening. We we're gonna answer one last question after the ads. But uh, you're a great audience. Thank you so much for being a part of this. The Ethical Jedi is where we can find all the podcasts I do. It's where you can.
Speaker 4Find all the ways it.
Speaker 6God, but I have been with the exception of a one hour break for lunch, I have now been podcasting for the last last four and a half hours. So anyway, the Ethical Panda, you'll find all the podcasts I do a lot of which pause on. You'll find all the ways to content us. I want to hear your answers to these lists. I'm probably actually gonna put them out on Twitter as well, on the Star Wars on the The Ethical Panda Twitter account, So sign up for that. Mostly though, folks start getting hyped for and or we
Speaker 6definitely are. We're gonna be doing episode of episode coverage. We've been live streaming some of our recordings on Paul's twitch stream. We're gonna act like this is my wanting to like officially announce it. We're gonna be doing it pretty much every Wednesday night at seven thirty pm Central Time, eight thirty pm Eastern, six thirty pm Mountain. Look, I'm acknowledging you, though, I still think you should kick rocks because you've got rocks and five thirty pm Pacific time, and that'll be on Paul's twitch stream, which is just
Speaker 6twitch dot tv slash zen Madman. And the last thing I want to mention is because they just don't have enough ways to talk to you all, I have started a discord channel. It's just called discord server. It's just called the Ethical Panda. This is a great way to come hang out with other people, have more of these discussions, get to know us, and also talk about random stuff.
Speaker 4And there will be a link to that, right, and invite to that in the in the discord in the show notes, because I think, I think you can't just like find a discord channel, right, you need an invite somewhere.
Speaker 6I know you actually can and then ask for an invite, but if you make it likely findable. But yeah, we'll definitely cool with some moderation because I do want to Ma. Sure, we don't get like you know, but I think if you're here, a troll like you would have lost this podcast a long time ago. So all right, Paul, any last words from you about what you're up to these days.
Speaker 4I'm Zen Madman. I spend a lot of hours doing a lot of things, and I have a headache right now. I'll talk about it some other time. Sounds good, But you can find me on Twitter and Twitch as Zen Madman and YouTube.
Speaker 6And yeah, all right, so thank you so much, folks. This is a false goodbye. There's an after coming. Thank you so much for your great audience. And as fans be good to each other. All right, So the original trilogy is number one? What are number two and three of your favorite Star Treks Star Wars movies?
Speaker 4Number two is definitely Rogue one, and I think number three is solo interesting. Okay, Like I wanted to say that to troll you, but then I realized it might be true. It's probably The Force Awakens. The Force Awakens is probably like my fifth favorite Star Wars movie.
Speaker 6That's what I think. It often gets talked down about. Like I think people don't recognize just how good it is.
Speaker 4It's a very well made movie that when it came out was what I think a lot of people needed to see in terms of like, oh, a Star Wars movie that's well made doesn't have terrible dialogue. You know. It's like it's technically well made. You know. The performances are really good. I enjoy all the characters taken on their own. I don't like a few of the developments, but overall, I think it's a mostly good movie. Yeah, you know, and I think a lot of the complaints about it I understand, but I don't think that nullifies, you know, what's good about it. I think it's just
Speaker 4you know, yeah, you could have had a few lines that explain maybe why Ray is able to fly like a millennium falcon type thing. You know, you didn't, Okay, you know, like there's a lot of power creep, but that's just kind of what happens with these things. Like you know what, I think they've got a few new characters who have who are have very good portrayals, you know, and they have really good chemistry with one another. I think that's one of the things that's the biggest thing to me that really makes that movie work is the chemistry between them all.
Speaker 6When we're talking about best accre, I was like, Okay, well maybe I should put you know, Oscar Isaac or no, but maybe I should put John Boyet like all of that, and frankly, honestly who I probably should have had. I don't like a lot of the things they do with his character. But Adam Driver is just phenomenal as kylo Ren like, especially once you realize yea, what they're doing with him, Like I think he's he's very a very good actor.
Speaker 4He definitely gives a very good performance for sure. And like Solo, I'll say though, like there are parts of it that I really like, and I think as like, if you're not thinking about it as a Star Wars movie, I think it's good, you know, and I mean not like the best movie, but just like, you know, at least fine, and yeah, it's just there's oh, it's got the Droid's Rights droid in it, right, Yeah, that's a fun part. I really like that. Although then she gets non consensually put into the Millennium Falcon for the rest
Speaker 4of existence, so like, I don't know, that's like sweet but questionable. Yeah, you know what I mean, It's like it's like hmmm, I don't know, hmmm.
Speaker 6Where It's like you could have you could have had her ask for that as like her dying moment.
Speaker 4You know, right, yeah, exactly, Yeah, if you did that, it would have been a better movie. But yeah, no, I mean I just definitely rank that above the prequel trilogy or the last two, you know, I mean, yeah.
Speaker 6Yeah, I think I think that's very fair. I think, like, so I love a heist movie, and Solo is a heist, right, and exactly just so much of it doesn't fit with my understanding of how things in the Star Wars universe work, right, and and like you know, so I definitely I can't put that one out there. But I think I also agree fandom Menace to me, not Phantom Menace. The Force Awakens. I think it was exactly the movie we needed. I think I'd rank it a little lower because I feel like it doesn't really have for me, it doesn't have very good rewatch value. It's just like I feel like
Speaker 6it was the movie I needed. Then now it's a little bit too much a New Hope all over again. I disagree about the power stuff with Ray. I do think rays. I think Ray knowing what she knows and Luke and Anakin knowing what they know all are a piece. But I know we disagree on that.
Speaker 4Yeah, I think they're like super different and there's a big conversation there, but they are similar. I will definitely grant.
Speaker 6That, And I will say you are one of the only people on this planet who will have that conversation with because and this is a larger topic, but I think I think you the acknowledge this as well, but maybe not much as I think it is like an awful A lot of the people who have that critique. I think it's motivated in large part because on some subconscious levels, they're a lot more willing to accept that from a male character than from a female, or they're just much more likely, much more critical of a woman character. I know you well enough to know that I don't. I know that's not where you're going with this, and
Speaker 6we have that conversation. We will.
Speaker 4Yeah, I'm upset on her behalf that she doesn't get to have as much of an arc as I feel like she deserves as a character. Honestly, Yeah, I think.
Speaker 6It's a fair way to put it, and that part I definitely agree with, Like, I think she is a great character. I don't want her to get more and not kiss the genocidal manag but that you know, that's fine for me. The top three movies are I put a New Hope specifically which and I will say this is one hundred percent Nostyllagia value. It's one hundred percent. That's the movie that made me love all of this. It's just it will always be my favorite. Rogue. One I agree with you is also just a MA I'm so excited for and Or. And I thought about not
Speaker 6putting this on because you might think I was trolling you, but it honestly, is just one of my favorites, the last Jedi. It is just it is. We don't. We disagree on it, and that's totally fine, and and I'm glad. I'm glad that we've now in terms of the end again, Like, I think your reasons for disliking it are are very valid and very different from an awful lot of the hate it gets. And there's some discussions you had there about why people that, you know, the way people think of people who dislike things and stuff like that. But to me, it's just it hits so much what I want out of Star Wars.
Speaker 4So yeah, and like, honestly, that makes the movie itself bother me a lot less than it would, you know, like the fact that I know that it's this very meaningful movie for for you know, people I care about like that. What better thing can a movie do than like hold meaning to people, you know, right in important ways, And so I'm happy that it does that. I do want to actually, can.
Speaker 6You comment on that? Yeah, I really appreciate that, and I want to say I would feel the same, But I'm so glad you don't truly love and find Rise of Skywalker the movie experience, because I don't know if I could do this. I don't know if I could be a bigger person as you are. Anyway, this is supposed to be a stinger, but as you said, the stinger's gonna last for whatever. So get your last thing and then I promise we'll let you guys go back to your next pot.
Speaker 4Yeah. I mean, I was watching a movie and somebody I was with did say, I don't know if I can be friends with people who like this movie, because sometimes, like you know, if like somebody's like, oh yeah, I read mind comp and I think it's pretty good, Like you know what I mean, Like there are things a person could like and you could be like, I find that a little susy. That seems pretty suss, you know what I mean. But yeah, what I like, I kind of want to have a long conversation at some point about.
Speaker 6Due to the magic of two people who just are absolutely, totally, one hundred percent in love with the sounds of their own two voices, Paul's request to discuss that at some point became a discussion for the next fifty minutes, and we decided that instead of giving you a fifty minute stinger, we would instead just take that and turn it into the Superhero Ethics episode about discussing fandoms where there's toxicity and hard opinions, but legitimate opinions as well. We would
Speaker 6just take that entire discussion and turn it into a Superhero ethics episode. So enjoy. I hope you enjoyed our stinger. Please know that the stinger went much longer and it will be a Superhero episode Superhero Ethics episode coming out soon. Meanwhile, thank you all so much for listening to this and as fans, be good to each other.
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...