Star Wars: The Acolyte is finally here, and Alex and Matthew dive into episodes 1-2!Note: Due to the fast turn around on these episodes, we will not always have bonus content. This episode does not have any. We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Friends are long. Wait is over, the Acolyte is here, and we on Star Wars Generation's podcast are here to talk to you about it with myself and Alex Korman Alex general Kenobi. How are we thinking about this new show? You know, I would say that I was actually talking to a friend the other day, but this is the most blind I ever gone into a Star Wars anything. Like I'm usually I usually like eat up all of the you know, the non spoiler reviews and trailers, and I went in here having just seen the initial trailer, and I was like really pleasantly surprised.
I mean I felt gripped through both episodes they were over. I was like, wait, there's no way that like thirty minutes passed that quickly. Yeah. I think that, like, you know, the suspense is definitely there. There's like we were promised to kind of a mysterious Sith tale, and that's definitely present. I think that so far. I mean, is it a mandola a mana? How do you pronounce it? You know, Amandola? I think it's Amandola. The name, yes, Amanda Stenbury. I think it's been fantastic, especially playing like two characters. I've really I just
yeah, I've thoroughly, thoroughly enjoyed it. I think it's a breath of fresh air. It's new, it's different. I don't feel like I'm watching a remake or like, you know, anyone's pandering to any fan service. Like it just felt really new and that was really fun for me. Yeah, I feel very much the same. Welcome to team. Don't get too into spoilers and trailers land. And it's funny because I have read a lot about I've read all the Higher Republic books, which I know this is coming
at the end of that time, and so there were a couple of references that I definitely caught that will go over in a later podcast. But even so, I felt like I had so little idea of what was going to happen, and I loved that. And there were a couple of things that surprised me. Big spoilers. By the way, if you don't want to be spoiled for the show, this is definitely a time to check out spoilers coming in three two one. I did not expect them to make a big deal of Carrie and Moss and then kill her off. That was a minute
crazy to me, because like I had to see your thought, because like, that's all the thing, Like they show her in the trailers so heavily, and they've talked her up, and then she's dead. Five minutes into the show. I was like, are you are you joking? I wondered if we're going to see more of her but flashbacks? Yeah, like flashback or something. It would be really bold though to have done that, And at first I was angry, but then I just got so caught up in the rest of the story and agreed. I think Steinberg is doing an amazing
job. I haven't seen her in much. The only thing I've ever seen her in was she was Rue in The Hunger Games, which was fantastic. But I realized that, yeah, that's her, that's her. That's the other big casting you might recognize is did you recognize the guy who's playing the the person who sells poison to Maya? He looks familiar, but I couldn't put a finger on him. That's Jason from the Good Place. See I don't watch The Good Place, but okay, he still looks familiar to me.
I should have seen him online, but I mean, it's him. And then of course Filipino surfer, uh like himbo boy, like beautiful and thoughtful and caring as dumb as a box of rocks, and like this his part is so different, and I just yeah, I'm I'm in so far that Yeah, shars about the mysteries go ahead. I was just gonna say that, just what we're talking about the actors. I just wanted one more
shout out to uh Lee jon Jay who plays Master Soul from Squid Games. I think he is doing absolutely fantastic as well. I mean, like there is no you know, I know there have been completes in past Star Wars projects about like acting. I thought every bit of acting was very strong, very convincing, and very fun. Agreed, agreed, even like the young wing kimember her name, but the padawan who's running around with them is really fun. Jackie Jackie Jeck Jackie Jackie yep Jackie and Shirtless Yard, who was
quite a good deal of thirst Ord Horde that I am happy to be a member of, and I imagine Aaron is going to become a member of, but we'll have to discuss with her when she next comes on. Yeah, it's just and I what I appreciate is that already it feels like I know, I know who these characters are, I know what's going on, and they feel so rich, Like you know, Yord kind of walks right in and uses some mind control to like read someone's mind in a way that I
think like a lot of people are like, no, wait, that's not what the Jedi I supposed to do. And and I think your reaction is supposed to be like yeah, exactly, Like these are not perfect cookie cutter Jedi. These are real people with real struggles about their emotions, and I'm just with a here for it. Yeah. I mean they even made a point to like, you know, the Jekie pointed out Triessor Soul. She was like, uh, that kind of attachment or that kind of nostalgia is not like recommended. And like the other Jedi Master who was only a screen
briefly, the the one who's all green. She like even said the Master Soul like, you know, I don't know, wis you were still so attached to your patal, Like it's like attachment might be frowned upon, but it's like not seeing it's completely taboo, Like it's like understood and like recognized and and and I also think it was very cool that like it feels like the story will run through both the you know, the character of May and Osha, and so you're kind of seeing the Jedi and this and the you know, the sith accoltever you want to call them at this point, but
seeing the Jedi order at its height, like the Jedi Temple was all over the galaxy. There's different types of Jedi. I mean, like this Wookie Jedi, like like in the Jedi we know, like you're supposed to like go back to the Temple unless you're on a mission. Like it's like very like horstant based, and like this this Wookie is just like fucked off to some random like Wooded world and that one master's been meditating for ten years. Like yeah, like it's just it's super cool. It's like you said, it feels very rich and like I don't feel like it was. I think
it was a breath of fresh air because it's these characters we don't know what I immediately felt like I do know them, and I feel comfortable with them, and I like am engaged with them. But I think it's very hard to do. Like off the bat, I don't think I felt completely that way with a character since like maybe Dinn in Mando like feeling like connected pretty early on, like that was just it's really well done. Yeah, I think that's very true. I'm thinking about Master Torbin because he's the one who is in that kind of like meditative force field for ten years. And I'm
so curious about that because I think that a lot of times when we think about Jedi withholding their emotions, it's often these very external ones. You know, it's love, it's attachment, it's desire, its possession and jealousy, and then the things that can lead to if people harm the you know, the folks that you care about, rage and anger and revenge and all these things. We haven't heard about. Guilt, we haven't heard about like self
doubt, and we only got that little picture of it, but clearly that was a part of what was happening with Torben, and the fact that all she had to do was show up and offer him this poison and say, like, you know, this is what you should do, and he did it without hesitation. We got any hesitation, And we've seen Jedi sacrifice themselves for others, like that's the very first Jedi death we ever see with Obi wan, but I can't ever remember a Jedi just sort of I mean basically
unliving themselves literally that's what they do, yep. And and it's interesting because he, you know, he he says that you know, him was the exact quol I was she had written down, but you know, says something along the lines of, you know, like we tried our best. We thought what we were doing is right. I think that is what he said, like we really believe what we were doing is right. But like he like wanted he's been waiting for her, and like he was like, I'm gonna make this right. I apologize to you, like which is no hesitation, And like I'm curious if he believed that this was Osha and there's some
weird past there, or like if he feels like he genuinely like he realizes that it's May and genuinely did something wrong the day of that fire that took the family. Like I'm also very curious, like, like how much did the Jedi have to do with that, because she's hunting down these four specific Jedi who were on that planet when that happened. But the story goes it May set the fire, so like was May framed like with something else going on under you know, under wraps. Something feels fishy. Here, something
doesn't feel like it fits. And I'm very curious why, like, you know, she's hunting these people down. And was Master say his name again, Matthew, I'm sorry, Torn Torven? Thank you? Was Master Torven in that in that meditative state? T O r b as boy Ben okay, thank you, thank thank you? Was Master Torbin in that state? Because he felt immense guilt, like was it or was he you know, did he think he really had achieved some level of like peace, you know,
because you know that those two, you know, May was talking with the apothecarist who I don't think we got to figure got a name from him, m hm, and they're like, yeah, you know, the pieces all fit. Just think they have peace. And so I'm very curious that about as well. Sorry, I have many questions about the show, but it's just so well, especially because you're right, the story we've been told is that May set the fire. I think not necessarily that they'll do it the same way as like a direct reference to a last Jedi, but I
think we will get that kind of Raschaman's style. We will probably see that event through the eyes of different people, and that part of the idea is that different people remember it in different ways, and that the actual truth is probably somewhere in between. And that one thing that Aaron and I have talked about, I think you're at least one of these podcasts and not positive. But we know this is coming at the end of the High Republic, and so I don't think anyone needs to know the High Republic books to understand the show. But there's sutly some things the Higher Republic books have established that I think are helpful, one of which is there there's an incident in Phase two
where some really you know, awful information has learned about the Jedi that Yoda and another master at the time is about two hundred years before the events of the show, three hundred years before you know, Anakin and Luke and all them. They decide to hide, like Yoda, specific deside not to enter this into the Jedi records at the Temple, not to tell anyone about it. And so I think the possibility that the official story of what happened may
be kind of a cover up of something that Torben, you know, that maybe like Torbin had done something truly awful and the rest had helped cover it up, or you know, they'd all been part of something or you know, whatever it might be. Feels to me like it's gonna be really important part of the story. I fully agree with that, and like, you know, I'm curious if it's a cover up or if it's more like I'm curious like if the maybe the Sith leader was formerly a Jedi you could have.
I don't, like, I've had so many different like people tell me theories today and I don't really know if I haven't landed on anything myself. I just feel like I want more, I want to know more, and again I haven't felt like, you know, I will say that well, you know, with Ahska, I was waiting for specific moments. I was waiting for Hayden Christmas and Anakin to show up. I was waiting for that, you know, for the Obi Wan, I was waiting for the duel with Darth Vader. Like it felt like the last few shows outside of and Or Andrew was very unique. You know, I've been waiting for like X
thing to happen, and this show feels very open ended, like I literally have no clue what's going to happen next. I know she's going after two Jedi, two more Jedi, but that's it, and I think that's it's exciting to me. We're gonna have a lot more on that. In just one second. We're starting the conversation. But we want to hear from you. Send your thoughts, questions, or anything else you want to hear. Siscuss to feedback at the Ethical panda dot com, or you can find us on Twitter, Instagram, or TikTok under the Ethical Panda. You can even
chat with us on Discord or Facebook. Find those link in the show notes or on our website, the ethical pana dot com. And if you like this content, when I become a member, your early access to add free episodes for all podcasts and the Ethical pan of Family, along with bonus content at the end of most episodes, plus member only episodes, and it's just five dollars a month or fifty five dollars for a full year. Sign up the Ethical pana dot com or through the link in the show notes and now back to our episode, Welcome back. Everyone. Also apologized to anybody who was watching this on stream. You'll notice that you could see Alex's wonderful,
smiling face, but not my own. That's because I am traveling. I've been traveling a bunch the last couple weeks. My laptop doesn't really have the ability to do camera as part of this, but once I'm back in my studio, we will have all of our faces as part of this discussion. So I wanted to pick up on what you're saying about theory there because I very much agree. Ian. Are you a big MCU fan? I am, well, I am. I've fallen off a little bit of the show is very recently that I've watched most if ninety five percent of the concept was
pleased back when Wanda Vision was coming out. Did you get caught up in the Mephisto of it all? A little bit? A little bit the podcast community that I was a part of, and I was very involved with, people got really obsessed with this question of is Mephisto going to be a part of the show, and just every week there was theories and more theories and what did this mean and what did that mean? And as a result, I feel like a lot of us didn't enjoy the show as much as we could have. And I kind of intentionally pulled away from it and watched a
lot of people I know, like, I think I enjoyed a lot more than a lot of other people I know who by the end talked about how disappointed they were because they felt like all these theories had been set up and none of them were paid off. And I had to kind of, you know, be like, you guys kind of did most of this yourself, and I I think you're right. I very much want to know who is the SIF, in part because I want to know to what extent are we honoring the story from Darth Plagis and that book which is extended universe, so it's not officially cannon, but certainly a lot of stuff from those books haven't brought into the canon, or are we going in a totally new direction.
Other than that, there isn't a big moment I'm waiting for, and I think I'm gonna try as hard as I can not to get into theories. I think I really want to just be able to enjoy the show as it is and just take each week as it is without being like, oh, well, maybe this meant that. And so I'm going to kind of wait to see if this thing I think is gonna happen happens, Yeah, and I totally you know, I agree with that, and like I you know, like I said, I kind of think of theories, but I couldn't even come up with anything because it's not like in past you know. You know, I was, especially with Star Wars, and notorious for trying to
come up with theories on things like with the SOSCA. I had theories after every episode. When episode seven came out in theaters, I wrote down like three double space pages or single space pages on my laptop and what I thought was going to happen in the rest of the trilogy, Like I because I just I knew the characters, I knew the story, I knew like the vibe of that era, so I could make educated guesses and theories. But like these are currently like I mean, as someone who hasn't read the Higher
Republic books, you know, I don't know any of these characters at all, and like I don't at this point, I don't even know how the Jedi order functions. I mean, you know, we had we saw a young Wing literally say, I see fires spreading everywhere, and I think that if imagine for a minute, if young Anakin Skywalker said that in front of Mace wind Doo, like I mean, MITx Wood, it would have immanely crucified this poor child because you know, he's talking Sith talk, but this child says it and immediately matters. Saul is just like, yes, the
force is that it can grow like that, like very like accepting. I actually kind of like I can see how the j how these Jedi became the later Jedi, but I like the current Jedi more so far, Like though we don't make mass decisions, we have a constructive conversation like, but we also like allow people to be themselves. Yet their attitude seems to be like I was thinking about the thing you mentioned before about how attachments are still very much like frowned upon but not like one cut off. It feels to me
like this is an era of alcoholism is bad, but like yeah, if you have one or two drinks, okay, but don't let it get out of control, versus the total abstinence of the you know, the U of the Clone wars time and the thing about fire. First of all, I don't know if you felt this, but I thought it was a really well done misdirect because At first I thought it was a flashback that that was actually Young may or Young Kosha, until they established clearly that it wasn't. But
even so, one of the things that the higher public books have done is I feel like, really and this is something actually that Danielle in The Star Wars will probably on at some point they talked about a lot on her Tiktoks. It feels like it's really recaptured the mysticism of the force and the idea that it is something that exists and everyone knows about it, but you know, it's a thing that by definition we don't have language for, and so we try to come up with metaphorical language for it. But everyone's metaphor is going to be different, and there's a great There are two Jedi who feel
very pulled towards each other, and they understand the Force in different ways, and it's still one of them sees it kind of like as an ocean, and the other understands it as a song. And they talk a lot of the time about how when they clash it's because they can't really understand each other's metaphors, but when they really work well together, it's because of how those two different metaphors fit together, and so the idea that someone does see it as fire fits that, you know, in a way that doesn't necessarily have to be like, oh my God, that means you think we're all going to burn to death, that means you're influenced by the seth or something like
that. It feels a lot more like like the best way I can kind of describe it, I think, from my point of view at least, is that these Jedi that we're seeing in the Accolte trust in the mystery of the Force and the Force presents itself in mysterious ways. While the current Jedi, as in like the Jedi of the Skywalker Saga, really believe more or less in the Force and more in the Jedi's interpretation of the Force and their
own orders believed. It feels much less like, it feels much more disconnected. It's almost acthlete, you know. It's interesting to me, it feels like Qui Gon is like almost a unique bridge because he feels a lot more like he would have fit in really well with the Jedi of old and did not. He was an outcast and kind of a quirky one, considered among the Council in the current era. So you know, it's very fun to me to see that, like he really feels like, you know, the death of Qui Gon, it feels actually more symbolical to me because it's like the death of this former you know, beliefs of the Jedi, and you
know that the stronghold of the current beliefs that we see going through the clod Wars and that era of the Republic, and I think it goes all the way into last Jedi where when Luke says, you know, he says one of the things that the Jedi did was that they're arrogance of thinking they were like the only that they had like mastery of the force. And I try not to use the idea of religion to understand the Jedi too often, but I think it's a power metaphor that helps, and that that's a thing that I think that can often happen in like sociology sociology of religion that we talk
about a lot of like is the job of the religion to help point towards the divine whatever that is that is something else? Or how much does it become like, no, we want people to see the divine in us, you know, and that only through us and things like that. And then I think that's kind of what Luke is calling out. And I think in some ways like Luke would want to look back to this time more in terms of what he thinks of the Jedi could be because a lot a lot of critiques, I think, and and that. But I also like that it's it does seem like, you know, maybe maybe Soul's attachment to his Paddlewan
is a little bit too much. You know, maybe we are that that the the events we're seeing now could well be the reason that by the time of Mace and all that, people are just saying just just don't have any attachments. It's just it just gets too muddy and messy. And think about what happened to Soul and Saul and all those people back then, and you know, and it's also something I just want to touch on quickly, is that it's interesting to me that May and Osha are twins because they're both for sensitive beings, and you know, both experienced the same trauma and both believed that the other was dead. But you see how both of them went completely
different directions about the influences that they in front of themselves with and how they reacted to it, you know, shows how the Force can react so differently, even in siblings. And it was also, I think very cool to see a Jedi who walked away from the order was still immediately like she wasn't shamed. She was like, it was my choice. The Jedi like, all right, that's fine. You went and became a mechanic and did your own thing, and you know, immediately accepted to like be helpful back on
a mission, and like there was no hesitation versus like the Jedi working with Ah Soca was like they had the running up the flagpole. The council had to debate it, like Mace was all sassy about it, calling her a citizen. Like it was just very such a different time. Yeah, and it's so cool to see that a big big you know, and I recognize that, like, you know, the clearly the general world still sees the jedis being oppressive and pompous and too much, and I'm sure we'll see more of that, but they seem a lot more likable to me than the Jedi
that we're familiar with. Mm hm. I will say also, and here's a little bit spoilers for the most recent books of the Higher Public, so skip ahead a minute if you don't want to hear that. I am a little curious abo how this fits in the timeline, because this is one hundred years after those latest books, and the situation is very, very different as of the last High Republic book we got, and there's another one to come out pretty soon. But at the point, at the point that that book
ends, like the Galaxies is split down the middle between these two warring factions, one of which really has the Jedi on the run and it's kind of kicking Jedi ass. And so I admit that when like it opened with the words of like we've had centuries of peace, I kind of did some math and was like, that doesn't fit. But I mean, okay, maybe something is un Maybe in the books that I'm reading, something will be unknone so that everyone forgets about it. I don't know, but uh, I'm not bothered by that. I'm just kind of curious. But even so, I'm saying, like, this period is still very different than the Higher Republic
books we've seen in terms of the way the Jedi are functioning and things like that. Yeah, what else caught your tension about this these episodes. That's a good question, you know, I think that you know from my for my first impressions, you know it well, First of all, some of the visuals. It was interesting because I thought that, like some of the visuals were fantastic, and some of them looked bad, Like the ship crash looked awful, like bad CGI. I'm sorry, but like the I noticed that, like you know, some of the I think they did some combination
like CGI practical effects on some things, and they looked fantastic. I mean, like the practical effects for Pip the droid, for the the Trade Federation folks, like all that looked like really crisp and fresh and cool and like again it's cool to see, like for me, like it's such a nerdy little thing, but like just seeing how the Trade Federation was operating still kind of under the table sweezy a hard years earlier. Like just the times of Nontle Nugget doesn't have anything to do with the story, not characters were familiar
with it. We're not obviously not seeing newt gun ray, but we're seeing a familiar species, a familiar organization, and it's fun to see them. One hundred years ago. It was fun to see like the temple gold plated and like shiny, and I don't know, it just kind of had this cool little zip to it all. I just two quick things on that, one more humorous, one serious, the first being I did think it was fun that once again we see people working under incredibly unsafe working conditions in this world, which happens all the time. And this time her person's name was
literally OSHA. Yeah. OSHA is the American organization that is supposed to handle workplace safety. And we've often said that like the Death Star needed OSHA to come in and insist on like railings on the walkways and stuff like that. But more seriously, you know, the Neomodians, and this is something that Riki and I my other co host, have talked about a good deal. The Neomodians were incredibly racist, very like Japanese Asian, but especially Japanese kind of stereotype and the language they used and here they sounded like they had an
alien accent that sounded similar, but it was not the kind of like super exaggerated. And again, I am white. I want to hear what Asian creators personally Japanese creators and Japanese American creators, but also any Asian creators have to say about it, and if they feel differently, then I would certainly defer to that. But from what I've seen online so far, because I did see one or two others supporting the same idea, it felt like they really kind of adjusted and decided to tone that down a lot in a way that I really liked. I agree, I've had the same exact thought as I was watching. It felt far less problematic to me. And again,
I mean, I'm also you know, I'm Middle Eastern American, like I differ as well, but I do did feel like it was much more tastefully done than has been in the past and still got very much the point across, and could have been done this way originally and been just as good. Yeah, probably better. Honestly, Yeah, I think it's true. This doesn't mean I need to see more Gungans and then not have quite the same I'm just gonna I'm kind of done with them in general. But yeah,
and then the last thing I kind of just wanted to bring up quickly is I don't have theories, but you know, the brief moment we saw this sith Master whatever whatever he is, whoever he is, you know, it was it gave off very like, you know, here's a guy in a mask, very Kylo Wren Darth Vader esque, you know, vibes like but it's obviously pre all these guys. I don't know, you know, I don't know why, you know, the mask is just to highest identity with the deal with It's interesting to me because like he has a red lightsaber,
so clearly he has been trained, you know, it's for our registmers might not know, like, in order to attain a red light saber, it's not just like finding a red kyber crystal. You have to pour your hate and anger into the crystal through the force to basically like turn it to the dark side. Kyber crystals are naturally like a tune to the light side. And so he really has been trained to some level, has to have some knowledge or access to sit holocron sis, text sis, tempo something. So I'm very curious to see where that goes. But he was very menacing and
like the voice was just so just cold, and but what really something was what he said in that like the acolyte kills without a weapon, He's very like harping on this, Like it's very not the Sith we know it. Siths we know are very aggressive, like do murder with weapons, murder in any way possible, like achieved or go no matter what. But this guy has very specific ideals. But I think it's very interesting. Yeah, yeah, I'm really curious about that. And this is kind of related. I really liked the fact that so far May doesn't have a lightsaber m hm,
and that it's clearly something that like she has to work towards and this whole thing of like you have to learn how to kill with different weapons, and so she has to kill with a knife, And what I thought was a really kind of badass way of playing specifically upon the Jedi's empathy and the desire to, you know, try to rescue others at times the expense of themselves, and the way she took advantage of that was so brilliant. And then to kill someone else literally without a weapon. Yeah, it really makes me feel like there's a real reverence for this idea of she's not just Darth May
right now, you know, this is a real like we're starting on these different ideas and she's not even maybe a full sith. Yet she is in training and she has to prove herself. And the idea that like because we think of like you need a red lightsaber to kill a Jedi with a green lightsaber, and the idea that you have to kill numerous Jedi to prove that you're ready for a red lightsaber like that. Yeah, you didn't call her a padawan. He calls her like an acolyte, like a follower basically, like I feel like it's me like an acolte would be like a step below a padawan. Like he's like, you have to prove yourself. And and
like you said, I I mean like after she kills the Jedi master what's your name, uh, Jedi master in Zara, she like goes to kill the bartender and like probably you know, retriactly, you know, from a standpoint, should have to prevent her like identity from being revealed, but like seize the child and chooses to let him live. But that's very not like I mean we just saw in Tailors of the Empire, like absolutely merciless killing
by the inquisitors. Like it's not the typical dark side we know where you just kill to cover your ass, killed just to kill like it was like there was a moment of compassion, which makes me feel like May is not fully gone. We saw a lot of fear in her every time she said like attack me with all your might or whatever, like there was fear in her voice, very good fear and so like to me like this sith master, whoever he is, is playing on that fear, playing on her past anger and trauma. And I'm very curious to see, like what Ocean's role is is she's able to bring her sister back, like if they kept in
front of each other or confront this dark side user. Like there's so many questions I have and I don't I don't need answers right the second, but I'm excited to learn them. I'll just say one other thing about that, and it can be kind of a wrap up then a last wrap up. Stuff you want to have. We're gonna try and keep this up as a kind of short I love that from the very beginning they made very clear that these are twins, that these are two distinctly different beings. Because at first, with a little moment of her kind of talking to May in her head,
you know, Mary, my partner, we were watching together and we both kind of wonder like, is this going to be a d id like disassociative identity sort of had the same thought, same thought, which is the it's the much more accurate term for what used to be called like, you know, multiple personality disorder or something like that. Yep. And frankly, I am not an expert in that by any means, but I certainly know enough about it to know that Hollywood often gets it very, very wrong, and that often it's used as kind of an excuse for this is why a person is like, oh they're so bad, and it's just I just didn't want that, and so I was really good, No, these are two
different people, and that's that's really awesome. I had the exact same well, Matt that ire on the fully on the same pagey'll you all really take this episode in. But I, I like had the exact same thought of like like it to me, I was like, wow, is she gonna is just like you know, like you know they even they really they did that on purpose, like you know, like they made her crewmates say like where were you last night? And like she doesn't say where she was, and like it makes you think, like is she undercover. Is she lying to herself? Is she does she have the so of identity sort of like
did her trauma of the past make her break? And like even like when she crashed, like she sees her sister and I'm like, is this a moment where like she disappears into this other you know, into her sister's persona or with this dark side persona. But I agree, like I think it's actually more interesting to have you know, these twins who went different directions, right, and it's I don't know, it's it's also cool because you get to see this one actress perform two very different characters, and she's performing them
both very well, like very well, like like you know, I I am like really impressed by her acting so far, and I'm excited to see like how she continues with that. Yeah, I feel very much the same way. And it's like I haven't even thought of this till now, but I think about how you're not supposed to have attachments, and part of that is you're supposed to cut off all connection since you're then you're both taken to this temple at the same time, Like, how is that not an attachment
or do they separate twins and try to raise them separately like that. That's a whole other area of questions And now I really want to see them as floor. So yeah, yeah, and I real quick, I just want to say the last The last thing here is just I we have only we saw that. Actually, Aaron and I talked about this if you always in the last week's episode in that Old Republic video game like cinematic trailers, which is not I don't know if it's actual consider can or not. I don't think it necessarily is. But we see, like like the Jedi separating siblings
who both have for sensitivity, and like how they would and like bringing commentary in, like how they would take one and not the other, and how that can affect the psyche of both, the distrust it can exist there. And it's really interesting because I've always wanted an exploration of that because I've always thought to myself that thing is like, you know, I don't Matthew, do you have any siblings? Yeah, you're like if you're if you know, what can you imagine like if you two were like children together growing up and then suddenly a Jedi master comes they trained you both and they take your
sister away from you, and they say you're not worthy, your sister is not only are you told you're not good enough, but then you're you know, you're you're built in sibling and best friend or you know your sister is taken from you now and like your sister probably is then taken away and it's like, well, I miss you know, I miss my sibling, I miss my person, and it's it's just crazy to think, like how Jedi have destroyed families like that and like just thought it was the will of the force when they could have taken both or they could have left them both alone.
Like yeah, it's I'm very excited to see that explored and the the the you know, obviously like May was you know, May was presumed dead. But the implication I've at least understood it is that Osha was already a paddle on or being at least touted to enter the Order at this point, but maybe not. Maybe so just like the fire happened and so just took her in because he saw something in that moment. But it is it is very interesting to me. Yeah, I think it's all true. It's interesting
to me. What is interesting to you all? Listeners, We want to know what you think. Let us know. We'd love to hear your thoughts, your theories. We're not gonna go too deep on them, but someone hear them. If you've got them. What do you like? When do you not like? Send it all to us? Sent us feedback. The ethicopana dot com has all the information. Show notes is all the information. Please let us not you think. Please keep listening. Please share this with your friends, and most importantly, we have some superhero Ethics is an ethical pan of podcast part of the True Story FM network. If you enjoyed the show, please share it and leave a rating or review on your podcast app if possible. The best way to support us is by becoming a member.
Find info and social links in the show notes. Thanks for listening.
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...