Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

Andor • S2 E10-12

May 16, 202548 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Star Wars Generations: Andor Season 2 Finale Reactions - The Dawn of RebellionThe groundbreaking Andor series reaches its powerful conclusion, connecting directly to Rogue One and reshaping how we view the Star Wars universe. In this episode, hosts Matthew and Alex share their immediate reactions to the final episodes of Andor Season 2, examining how the show bridges crucial gaps in the Rebellion's formation while delivering some of television's most compelling character arcs.How Does Andor Enhance the Larger Star Wars Narrative?The hosts explore how Andor doesn't just stand alone but actively enriches the entire Star Wars saga. By connecting seamlessly to Rogue One and A New Hope, the series makes the sacrifices in the original trilogy even more meaningful. The show provides essential context for understanding the Rebellion's origins, showing the personal costs and moral compromises that went into fighting the Empire long before Luke Skywalker entered the picture.What Makes Luthen Such a Complex Character?Luthen embodies the moral complexities at the heart of revolution, raising uncomfortable questions about means and ends. As Matthew notes, the character "troubles me the most, and I think that's the point," drawing comparisons to historical revolutionary figures who employed violent tactics in service of just causes. Luthen's own words resonate throughout the series: "I'm condemned to use the tools of my enemy to defeat them," highlighting the central ethical dilemma facing all resistance movements. The hosts debate whether his methods were justified and how his character forces viewers to question their own moral judgments about real-world resistance movements.How Does the Empire Treat Its Own People?The fate of Imperial officers like Dedra Meero and Partagaz reveals a brutal truth: "You could do everything for the Empire, you could give yourself to it... but in the end, no matter how loyal you are, you're expendable." The hosts discuss how the series brilliantly portrays the Empire's callous treatment of even its most dedicated servants, creating a system where middle-management bullies like Krennic thrive while true believers are discarded when no longer useful.What Legacy Is Left Behind?The final moments of the series spark discussion about how characters' sacrifices ripple through the timeline. As Luthen states in his powerful speech, "I burned my life to make a sunrise that I know I'll never see," foreshadowing the future that Cassian and others will help create but never witness themselves. The hosts debate the controversial ending for Bix's character and whether it serves the narrative or relies too heavily on common tropes.Other Topics Covered: How K2-SO's introduction creates both comedic moments and surprisingly tense action scenes The significance of Easter eggs connecting to other Star Wars properties, including Rebels Whether Kleya and Cassian might be siblings, and why making this connection would undermine the story How actors delivered Emmy-worthy performances across multiple complex roles The perfect execution of Andor as a complete two-season story with clear vision from start to finish Why Orson Krennic's introduction establishes him as the quintessential Imperial middle-manager bully The visual parallels between key scenes in the finale and Rogue One's ending Andor has redefined what Star Wars storytelling can achieve on television, creating a rare series that appeals equally to hardcore fans and newcomers to the galaxy far, far away. By focusing on ordinary people caught in extraordinary circumstances, the show illuminates the personal costs of resistance while never losing sight of why the fight against tyranny matters - even when victory seems impossible and the path forward requires difficult compromises. **************************************************************************This episode is a production of Star Wars Generations, a The Ethical Panda Podcast and part of the TruStory FM Entertainment Podcast Network. Check our our website to find out more about this and our sister podcast Superhero Ethics.We want to hear from you! You can keep up with our latest news, and send us feedback, questions, or comments via social media or email. Email: Matthew@TheEthicalPanda.com Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: TheEthicalPandaPodcasts Twitter: EthicalPanda77 Or you can join jump into the Star Wars Generations and Superhero Ethics channels on the TruStory FM Discord. To learn more about co-host Erin and her incredible cosplay check out her Instagram, LadyTanoCreates. Want to get access to even more content while supporting the podcast? Become a member! For $5 a month, or $55 a year you get access to bonus episodes and bonus content at the end of most episodes. Sign up on the podcast’s main page you can even give membership as a gift! You can also support our podcasts through our sponsors: Purchase a lightsaber from Level Up Sabers run by friend of the podcast Neighborhood Master Alan Use Audible for audiobooks. Sign up for a one year membership or gift one through this link. Purchase any media discussed this week through our sponsored links.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Before we dive in, here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM Family of Entertainment podcasts.

Speaker 2Do you like movies?

Speaker 1Do you like sports?

Speaker 2And we never thought I never played that sport on the screen, but I really enjoyed how the movie made me feel.

Speaker 3Well, then have we got a show for you.

Speaker 4The Adrian Moment is where.

Speaker 3My friend Ocean and I discussed the triangulation of sports, movies and life.

Speaker 2We dive deep into the movies, discussing how they relate to and have affected our lives.

Speaker 3We will talk about why the sport matters to the movie, why you don't have to love the sport to enjoy the movie, and mine a few nuggets of meaning inside.

Speaker 1The story you may not have realized was really there.

Speaker 2After listening to our show, come join us for more conversations about the movie that portray the thrill.

Speaker 5Of victory and the agony of defeat.

Speaker 2Find The Adrian Moment podcast on your Favorit podcast hat and join us while we cover the sports you love and the ones you never think about.

Speaker 3You will never see sports or sport movies the same again. Meet and Zinnia being very polite to someone who is attempting to quid us her wife's saffron.

Speaker 4You know, I'm wildly, madly in love.

Speaker 3With you and their best friend Goldie Glad we didn't miss all the fun. Swords in hand, they defend their city from the worst of humanity. I am Lord Buxton Blue.

Speaker 5What are the Electric hairg Virgil Walcot Vicious Swad.

Speaker 3Follow their adventures on the Swashbuckling Ladies Debate Society audio drama podcast available now at true story dot Fm. Slash Swashbuckling.

Speaker 5Holy Shit, Like, I welcome everyone. This is the Star Wars generation's podcasts. ME and Alex. Aaron's not able to join us right at this moment. I'm sure she'll be back pretty soon for another episode. We're gonna be talking about the show a lot, but let's just kind of do This is just our quick initial reactions Me and Alex. Wow.

Speaker 4Like I sat there for ten minutes in stun silence after it ended.

Speaker 5If anyone had for some reason, if any of you a sort who like want needed to stop it immediately, like I wanted to talk to the people I watched it with, so I hit stop immediately, and someone then told me, Alex, you were the one in my case, go listen to all of the music over the credits. There's no post credit scenes, but trust me, the music is worth it. I won't spoil that one thing yet, but I gotta say we knew the bar for this season was going to be so high, and frankly, one of the things that made the first season of and

Speaker 5Or so good that I think separated it from a lot of the not only Star Wars Disney Plus shows, but the Marvel Disney Plus shows as well. Is it stuck the landing? And I really wasn't sure, especially because episodes eight nine and ten seven eight nine were so good. I was like, where does it go from here? And the fact is the found a way to go even better and even higher, And yeah, I think this is just this is now up there with the wire as I think one of the two or three just flat

Speaker 5out not best science fiction, not best Star Wars, just best television shows I've ever seen.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4I was talking to my friends last night and I said, this is just the best television like I've ever seen, Like just sentence ends there.

Speaker 1I mean it was.

Speaker 4I had taken notes, just a few notes for our podcast today, and one of the things I wrote on here.

Speaker 1Was this show improved Star Wars as a whole.

Speaker 4It elevates everything, It elevates Rogue one, a new hope rebels, it makes the sacrifices it occur in the original trilogy even more meaningful.

Speaker 1I mean it is.

Speaker 4I didn't really like I remember when Rogue one came out, I was like, damn, that's a really special movie, like kind of a shame, it's just a one off. And they found a way to like take that lightning in a bottle they had captured and then like expanded.

Speaker 1I mean, this show was just.

Speaker 4I I yeah, I can't even describe it.

Speaker 5It really was. You know, a lot of people had said that you should finish this show and then go immediately into and Or, and unfortunately, because they're just timing one. Yeah, let me take it again. You know a lot of people had said you should watch and Or and then go immediately into Rogue one, and unfortunately, just due to life circumstances and like, I wasn't able to do that. But I woke up this morning one of the first things I did was turn on Rogue one, and they're right, it just added you know, the whole time I was looking at and Or feeling so off balanced and so

Speaker 5torn and not sure what he should do, and thinking about the fact that like he lost Marva, he lost Luthen, who, as much as he disagreed and disliked Luther at times, meant so much to him. He had lost Bicks, he had lost so much. And yeah, I just and Or hit a lot differently. Rogue one hit a lot differently, then actually went right from Rogue one into the first few minutes of a new Hope, and you write that hit differently. I think this is gonna be one of the things that is both It makes Star Wars so

Speaker 5much better, and I think for us Star Wars fans it is just, you know, the pinnacle of awesome things. But also, frankly, and I've heard from these people already, but I want more folks to find it this way. I think for people who don't like Star Wars or don't like science fiction, or I think it's just not for them, But they enjoy political thrillers, they enjoy action spy thrillers, they just enjoy they hate being in the political and social and cultural situation we are right now and want some catharsis about how it could be better.

Speaker 5This is the show for them. I mean it really just walk that line so perfectly.

Speaker 4Yeah, and like I think that was interesting is the final three episodes specifically, I was actually momentarily I was surprised. Then the final arc of and Or the first of the three episodes, it does not include him for even a second. Yeah, it's all the Luthen and Claya backstory, and we finally it to like understand how like where like what with his background was, where Klaya came from? And it like, I like want to go back and immediately restart indoor now because I want to look at their relationship through that lens of like Claya being raised

Speaker 4kind of as his daughter as as his found individual.

Speaker 1And I was like, oh my god, this makes it.

Speaker 5So much more devastating. Yeah. Well, especially because you know, it's the exception that proves the rule. Because one thing we see about Luthen, I think he's one we're gonna be talking about a lot, both today but also with Aaron and probably with sometimes in future episodes because the character is so morally complicated and so rich. One of the things that we see and we see that he taught Cassian is never get sentimental about the people you work with, because you may have to kill them. He

Speaker 5has that entire rebel group of fifty rebel soldiers who he throws away and leads them right to their death because it's not gonna help him. He the guy who is in the the ISB agent who has been a turncoat working for him this whole time. Young that's his name, he, you know, Young comes to him and says, look, I've burned myself. So because I've learned this incredibly important information, I'm going to tell it to you and I need

Speaker 5you to get me out. And and Loofen says, yeah, I'm gonna get you out, and then kills him, just flat out kills.

Speaker 1Him after he mentions his wife and daughter too.

Speaker 5And which is, as I say, what he taught to Cassian, because it's exactly what Cassian does the tific at the start of Rogue one, and she is the one exception, you know, he not only does he work to make sure that she escapes, he intentionally sets it up so that he will be caught instead of her. Yeah, and uh, And then of course when she goes back for him. Even there, she's not being sentiment. She's going back to yes, prevent him from a life of torture, but also to make sure that the Empire can't get out of him

Speaker 5what it needs to get out of him.

Speaker 4He looks so peaceful when she like disconnected him. Yeah, he looked the first time I'd seen him like it was because he's had this fake smile through at the entire show, through first first, you know, season one and season two, and it felt like when she disconnected him, that was the one and only time we saw a genuine smile across his face, like I'm finally at peace now.

Speaker 5Yeah, So let's kind of start with him because I'm seeing a lot of stuff online about like, oh, he was such a hero, He's so great, We love him so much. What's your kind of final feelings about Luthen.

Speaker 4I think that at his core, he definitely was like a heroic figure.

Speaker 1But like I mean, he employed a lot of like.

Speaker 4He walked the line almost to me between like Sogarera and the mainstream rebellion. Like he did a lot of really like kind of gorilla type things. He scrimped and scrimmed like to just get by in the beginning in order to I kind of build up this the store he had to to you know more uh to you know, get information to and from the rebellion.

Speaker 1But I think that, like at the end of the.

Speaker 4Day, I see him as kind of almost like a necessary evil but has to exist.

Speaker 1Like he kind of did the.

Speaker 4Dirty work that like mon Mathma just didn't want to do or some of these other characters who like were equally my Mathma is equally if not of greater importance, but like she doesn't get to the rebellion, but it's not for Luthen and like and orders can get the training these and like probably a lot of what happened, the Rellium doesn't win unless Luthen does everything he does but doesn't make it all morally correct. But it just opens up that kind of conversation of like how do you win a war against this giant opponent? Like, I mean, he even and in his great speech, I can remember

Speaker 4the exact wording of something along the lines of I'm like forced to fight my enemy like using their their their enemy. Yeah, and he's right, and it was I just I see, I mean, like I don't think he was I think he was fairly cruel sometimes to Cleia. I think he was cruel towards others. He was very paranoid and untrusting, but he also successfully.

Speaker 1Completed what had to be done.

Speaker 5Yeah, I am. I think he is the character who troubles me the most. And I think that's the point, because I you know, I I was reminded recently. I don't want to just assume that this show is about the most modern of current events, but I think that a theme throughout history has been that when people commit acts of violence, especially against civilians or against in ways that we think of as like not you know, just

Speaker 5war or something like that, we are very quick to judge them unless they did it for a side that we think is morally valuable, or especially ones that wins. You know, people remember Nelson Mandela as the great peacemaker, and he was. He was also the one who decided that the ANC needed to turn to violence towards what would be by a lot of definitions terrorism. Innocent people got blown up by the bombs that uh and the attacks that Nelson Mandela helped to put in place, and

Speaker 5that violence helped lead to the situation that led to him being much more peaceful, that helped lead to the end of apartheid. In South Africa. You know, you can look at groups like Hamas, at groups like any kind of group that is fighting for freedom against oppression, you know, and we can get into questions like is there is that oppression? Is that oppression that we understand and agree with? You know that we don't the IRA, you know, there's another one, Like there's so many around the world where I think it's very I'm not saying that I think

Speaker 5all of them are completely justified. I'm not saying that I think Luthan is completely justified. I'm saying I think that for the most part, we sit in ivory towers and pass judgment on this is an okay way for people who are facing horrible situations that we don't to respond and these aren't ways. And Luthen is there to kind of force us to question that, to force us to say, like you know, again, it's not to say that therefore everything is justified. It's to say, like you said, I don't I hate that Luthen killed those people. I

Speaker 5hate that Luthen threw away those rebel soldiers. I hate that, you know, the bombs that he and Clara set up set off when Clara is a kid on Naboo. Those almost definitely killed innocent people, Like they were attacking military targets, but there were people around. They killed innocent people. That was a terrorist bombing by almost any definition. But it moves forward toward the end of the you know, horrible, evil, oppressive empire.

Speaker 1And that was I was just in that Naboo scene.

Speaker 4It was interesting because Claya was like ready to finally like click the button to do it herself, and he like last second pulled it away from her because he, like again, she was the only one. Claya was the only one that Luthin like wanted to protect to the end and like he like knew what had to be done, but like didn't want Claya to get her hands dirty as much as possible.

Speaker 5Well it was weird because he both but he wanted her to make the choice. He wanted to know that she would be willing to push the button, but then he wanted.

Speaker 4To exactly exactly and if I found the exact the exact word is, I'm condemned to use the tools of my enemy to defeat them. And that's I think, like to him, whether it's ego or not, that was his burden. He's like, you can't, which is again very Stargerera thinking of like you can't win a war through only peaceful methods, and like I think that, like I don't know Luthen really want I mean, clearly he pissed off a lot of the people in the in the rebel alliance, but I loved indoor speech basically calling out some of the

Speaker 4rebel leaders and being like, do you know did you know him?

Speaker 1Did you him?

Speaker 4How dare you? How dare you speak ill of this man? He was like he was not perfect. He was actually a lot of bad, probably more bad than good. But if it wasn't for him, none of this happens. And I thought that was really apt description and it was very cool to see and or like stand up to them in that way.

Speaker 5I think the only thing that I found troubling about it, and trust me, there's a lot of other things we're going to talk about Cassian's story so much else. I I didn't like that. For a long time. I have felt that like they were kind of saying like Saw is off on his own and Luthen is still working with them, but a lot of ways Luthen is worse. Like Luthen does things that even Saw, it's like, oh, I couldn't do that. Yeah, And it felt like towards at the end of this, they were kind of heroizing Luthen, especially with that speech from Cassian, while Saw was still

Speaker 5being treated as, Oh, but he's too far, he goes too much. And I've certainly seen that reaction a lot from fans, and I think that is I think I'm charitable. I think what Gilroy was trying to get to is just that the they see it this way because Luthen is still working on the inside where Saw isn't. But among other things, one of the things again I got from watching Rogue one after this was I was thinking about all the ways in which Luthan had kept everyone so compartmentalized and made sure that no one trusted each other, and so Clara felt that like she wouldn't be trusted

Speaker 5and welcomed, and in a lot of ways she wasn't, and like a lot of the council didn't want to trust Cassie and let alone. Luthen. Of course, Saw as paranoid as hell, and I can understand what Saw is, like, I want nothing to do with you people.

Speaker 1I would offer do.

Speaker 5It on my own, and I wish the show had been least a little more understanding towards Saw, but like, that's just a tiny complaint in a much.

Speaker 1Larger No, that's fair.

Speaker 4I mean, like and we only really got like that one Hologram interaction, which actually for those again, I mean, we do a book club, y'all, for our listeners, for our for our subscribers who listened to our book club episode.

Speaker 1We did the Mask of Fear recently, and.

Speaker 4They literally said mask like my mom has said mask of Fear in this show at the exact life. And it was which after her uh Saw via Hologram and bill or Ghana had like a meeting together and they were talking, they kind of finally broke And it was interesting to compare that in my head to the to the book where they first I got together and we're going to try and work together. And I'm curious how the next two installments in that trilogy kind of show the breakdown of that relationship to get to the point that we see that in and.

Speaker 5Or right, because the large part of that book is both and Or. A large part of that book is both bail or Ghana and man Mothma coming to realize they can't just do this as senators. They have to work with someone.

Speaker 1Like salt yep.

Speaker 5So what else do you know?

Speaker 4Yeah, I have I have a few little bull I know we're gonna kind of do it just a broader strokes today.

Speaker 1I have a few more bullet points. Here go forth, dadra.

Speaker 4Oh poor, I would feel bad for like.

Speaker 1I don't, but I actually she got at least what she deserved. Like but it's it's it's to me.

Speaker 4She was such an amazing metaphor for like, uh, you could do everything for the empire.

Speaker 1You can give yourself to it.

Speaker 4You can you can feed the machine like you can feed the tyranny and fascism.

Speaker 1But in the end, no matter how loyal you are.

Speaker 4You're expendable, You're just gonna be thrown to the side. I mean, you think about it. The people who are the biggest hands in this, I mean, Pendergast ends up killing himself, Dandra is sent It looks like to uh Narcino five the same prison that Andro was in. Obviously in rogue one, Cronic is killed by his own weapon. And it's just all these people who thought they had power, thought they had influence, disposable.

Speaker 5Yeah, and like, I didn't think it was supposed to actually be an Arcina five among other things. We were showing that mostly as a men's only prison. Oh and I'm sure that a woman's version, but also like, and they didn't say on program, which I'm kind of glad that it would felt, but.

Speaker 1They wiped the floors. I think the floor was hot.

Speaker 5I think so too. I think what he told me is like, if you go to a lot of American prisons that were built at the same time, they look almost exactly the same. Bearport kind of that. I got the sense it definitely idiot is an Imperial prison. And yeah, much as I'd been hoping for one or two things, either a that she gets promoted and assigned to the Death Star or b that like the final thing we hear is we see her being choked again and her body fall and we just hear the voiceover saying apology accepted.

Speaker 1But no.

Speaker 5This was even better because this was her having to come to turn, her having to realize and live with knowing that exactly that that she put her trust to the Empire, even when Cyril was trying to convince her not to, and it was just you know, someone else came along who was even better at the game than she was, and the meme of and I have no idea where it came from. I don't know if it's direction or just the actor came up with it, because the actor is so good. But that single like Kranick

Speaker 5putting one finger on her forehead while the camera looks right at both of them, was just such a ridiculous but perfect moment that I'm sure is going to become a total memember now.

Speaker 4For the cinematography in these three episodes was unbelievable, but like Krenick walking in behind her and you couldn't see his face, but you just felt his presence like it was kind of scary. Like I mean, like I not that Crinic wasn't kind of menacing in the past, but he was. I always saw him as just this firebrand and like a smaller shadow to Tarken throw on these other bigger leaders. And he threw his weight around in that scene when he was interrogating Dadra and I was like, holy shit, yeah, and then she's like, I'm out of

Speaker 4rebel spy and goes, well you missed your calling then, like he was, he was just cruel and just again it's cast hero and like I just and even when all that was happening, her last act was to like try and help the empire find fine Clia, Yeah, I was just like, wow, dude, loyalty to the end.

Speaker 1I guess girl, but you did jesus.

Speaker 5I mean, this is taking what I think is generally a good concept and putting it in a really weird way. But impact over intentions, you know, like that was the whole Clanic's point was like, whatever you intended, what you did was what the best rebel spy probably couldn't have done, which is also hilarious because he's not realizing how much rebel spies actually had to do with it. But and I think it was a perfect statement about who Krenick is because he is the classic psychological description of a bully. He seeks out situations where he is the most powerful.

Speaker 5When power is taken away from him, he whinds to the people. He doesn't try to take it back. He goes to someone like Vader and goes, wow, Wow, this isn't fair, and he cowers like, you know, a little coward in the corner. When the people with actual power, like Vader or Tarkian exerted towards him, and it's just he is exactly the kind of middle management that an empire, a fascist empire produces, and like we know the emperor wanted people fighting with each other and that this is

Speaker 5exactly what it gets.

Speaker 4Yeah, and it was funny im I went to interaction with Pendergast where Pedergas like save your speech for Palpatine, like save like all your ramblings for like I don't want to want to hear it, and credit like knew the Pedagrass was screwed and was just like a right man good luck, like firsta basically first to the finish then and pedder Gas ending to me was I like, I was a little not bummed it was off screen because it was I was a graphic but like I was like, first I was like, oh, off screen, and then I was like actually seeing like his subordinate, like

Speaker 4just a subtle handbush to stop the storm troopers from going in, and like just knowing what had happened, I was like, Wow, that was kind of an incredible ending for him.

Speaker 5The fact that this show made me feel, for just half a second a moment of sympathy towards both Dedra and pendergasted.

Speaker 1Yep.

Speaker 5Like I sent to my friend who was texting as I watched, like that is incredible writing because they are both evil, terrible people, And I still in both of those moments was like, you know, it's kind of like, I think getting your face eaten by a leopard sounds terrible. And I don't you know, the people who voted for the leopards eating faces party and then get their own faces eaten. Like there's a certain part of like you should have seen this coming, but also I still am like that looks terrible. I'm sorry for you.

Speaker 1You know, but it was successfully written.

Speaker 4Villains, yeah, because if you feel for them in some level, it's obviously it's not the same at all, but like it's just similar to like, you know, it's like the fanos idea of like, you know, you feel like maybe he's slightly right, and like with these characters you feel slight emotional connection to them. There's like a straight evil villains is not as interesting anymore.

Speaker 1To me.

Speaker 5The point of a villain should be to make a part of you think if and I say this especially as someone who with a lot of privilege, maybe it's different for others. But I think from for someone in a comfortable position in the world like I am, I want villains that make me and people like me think, Wow, if I'm not careful, I could become that, you know that I could. I can understand why she makes the first step she does, and I can see how that leads to it, and I can understand how someone who doesn't understand that can make all those same choices. And

Speaker 5that's why, you know, we have to stop. And that's why I hope people can watch this and be like, oh, okay, I need to make different choices because.

Speaker 1Some people have been timeing gonna pop overy to another character K two real funny, so good.

Speaker 4Also a horror movie scene in the hallway. Oh I had read they cut there was more of it. They ended up cutting for time, but like that was.

Speaker 1That was scary. That was actual horror, like holding.

Speaker 4Up his body, just being full of blaster bulls coming down the hallway. Like I did not have K two getting his own hallway scene on my Bingo card, but that was one of the scariest ones I've seen.

Speaker 5And there was a moment where again I was sending this to Paul my my my friend who's been a host of this podcast and been a guest a bunch of times. He's a hardcore poker player. He's taught me a lot professional and there are times where when I play, I am purely irrational, and eight times out of nine he will win. But one times out of nine I will win, and he will just get so upset because the odds say that I should not have done that and it should not have worked for me. You know, we will work when on nine that's the odds work. But still like and I messaged him about that scene where K K two is like, I can't believe you

Speaker 5people are doing these dumb plays in this gambling game they're playing, which I was calling Dominoker because it's kind of like half Domino's half poker. But with Sabakh and I mentioned this and he was like, yeah, I sympathized with K two O in K two ZO in that moment. And but more than anything he brought, you said, he was funny. He brought so much levity, but never in a way that felt like it was breaking the overall tension and pathos and darkness of the show, Like it didn't feel like comic relief. It just felt like, this

Speaker 5is a funny moment among people in a deeply horrifying situation.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean he like wrecked all those people.

Speaker 4Like he started his rampage with imperial offers, are saying are you here?

Speaker 1You're here with us? And he went no, and.

Speaker 4Then just like threw him off of a cliff or of a bridge, and at the end of the rampage he went, I cleared a path.

Speaker 1Yeah, you're welcome.

Speaker 4I just oh, he was still good. And should should we talk about the one of the biggest reviewers in the show, Matthew, You mean.

Speaker 5That while mostly avoiding dumb tropes, the Gilroys did fall into one dumb trope at the very end.

Speaker 1I don't think it was that dumb, but I understand.

Speaker 4I saw very mixed reviews on the internet, and I understand where you're coming from in it.

Speaker 5So here we're talking, I assume about Bix being bis having a baby at the end, and I just like, being a parent is great. I am two months away from it. My wife is pregnant right now. I celebrate people who want to be parents. I celebrate people who decide not to be parents for whatever way and whatever choice they make about their bodies and their pregnancy is et cetera. But to me, the problem with the trope is when it's lazy, and it felt like at this point it is such a trope to say, oh, a

Speaker 5woman survives when her husband doesn't. How do we show that the husband lives on in her life and in her memory. I know, we'll give her a child that he probably never knew about, or if he did, he will still never see. And Star Wars has literally done that already, and they did it beautifully in the the the relationship between in rebels, Yes, thank you that hera has Canaan's child and he lives on with her and becomes a character who come to know and love in

Speaker 5later things, especially in a Soca, and like they were in that relationship and that makes total sense for them, and for Bicks, it just felt like, you know, it's like it's like fridging, you know, and like, you know, the barrier gaze thing that, like it's not a big deal and I'm just kind of going into this rant for game of going to this rant because he brought it up, But like that was one moment that I was like, oh, come on, guys, you could have done better. Like it's just that it's been done so many times and there was literally nothing in the world to let us know what was coming. That's fair.

Speaker 1I mean I totally and I totally see your viewpoint there.

Speaker 4I think for me, it it just it kind of hammered home a few things, like it connected a few things to me.

Speaker 1Like one is that like it made her choice to leave.

Speaker 4We talked about it last week and we went back and forth and like she shouldn't be choosing for somebody else and stuff like that. But like to me, she like basically this reinforced that she chose. She chose, she had to choose the rebellion for him, because he never Andrew would have never, ever, ever, ever like chosen the rebellion if.

Speaker 1He knew he had a kid.

Speaker 4And I think it just adds a little bit to the psychology of like what Biggs was doing there and like why she made the choice she did. But the bigger thing to me that I thought like hit for me was that like she's revealed like holding this baby kind of looking.

Speaker 1At a sunrise.

Speaker 4Also if you look at a side by side of that of that and jin and cassion as the death stars destroying Scauff.

Speaker 1They look identical.

Speaker 4The clouds are design in such a way to kind of look like the same explosion.

Speaker 1Like it's kind of like a side by side.

Speaker 5It was intentional. It was incredible. Everything shot was great.

Speaker 4But my thought was, I think again, thought back to Lutin's speech where he said, I burned my life to make a sunrise that I know I'll never see, and he.

Speaker 1Kind of passed it on the and or and like, yeah, it kind of.

Speaker 4Hit it over the head a little bit, but like quite literally, he was burned alive by the Death Star, did all this with the rebellion for a sunrise for his child he never knew for a sunrise a child who'll never see. So like, I understand that it is. It is a trope that has been overdone in cinema. It was already been done in Star Wars directly with Harry and Kanaan, And like, I think that, like you could have gone through that entire montage and just cut away at the montage had been done.

Speaker 1But it didn't bother me. I just I felt emotional for it.

Speaker 4I mostly just an emotional guy, and so I I was just feeling it, and I was like damn.

Speaker 1That was damn.

Speaker 4I don't know, it just it tugged at my heartstrings in a certain way. But I do understand the critique that you are presenting very much.

Speaker 5Yeah, And I'll just say I think there's absolutely nothing wrong with seeing it the way you did. And I think it was a powerful moment, to be sure, And I think the interpretation that you just put on it makes complete and total sense, right. And it probably again, if I hadn't seen this and also kind of you know, thought about this kind of trope a lot, it probably wouldn't bother meaning as whereas not how much it did. I think for me, it's that what you said there about like that it gives this meaning to you know that Cassian now knows that Cassian doesn't know, but that we know that there's someone who gets to see the

Speaker 5sun rise that Cassian doesn't get to see. And my response is, but there is already. It's Bicks, right, right, And so to say that Bicks has to have a child for that to happen, it feels like it really minimizes her story. That's what makes the woman's story about that she gets to be the person who create you know, helped you know, carries the life of his child instead of Big Skiss to do it. So yeah, that's my only thought there. And honestly, like you know, when people said they teared up about it, I was like, yeah, it's fine. I was already tearing up because of B two because the way I cheered, I literally were like, yes,

Speaker 5B two is there.

Speaker 1He's okay, he's okay.

Speaker 4I know, I know, and uh, I will say too, just regardless of the child or not. The decision that Tony and Gareth had made. Gareth Bale, the director of Brogue One, had made to not have Jin and Cassie and kiss at the end of the Brogue One, which was for some reason a hot button issue at the time. I never got the pressure of the show. We kissed each other, but I know that were.

Speaker 1Like, oh they should have kissed where they died.

Speaker 4But again, this show reinforces that decision that was made ten years ago. Of like, there was one person on Cassim's mind and it was probably Biggs Biss as he was dying.

Speaker 5I don't think that's the case at all.

Speaker 1You think you don't think you're think about Bis at all.

Speaker 5I think he might have been but I think he was in that moment with Jin, and I think people can love multiple people over the course of their lives. Yeah, that's been Like I agree with you that I think there shouldn't have been a kiss. And frankly, while I'm not one of them, I know there's lots and lots of people who do ship Gin and Cassian really hard, and apparently there's a lot of evidence for it in the novelization, but also just watching the movie again, I do think there's a lot of like potential there for it. Sure, I am happy with the interpretation that they're just friendly and colleagues and and you know, you know that they're

Speaker 5linked in this incredibly important moment that like, I like the I think it's important to understand that there can be very deep soul connection relationships that aren't necessarily romantic. Oh absolutely, But I do think that like the fact that Bis lives on and whether or not she has a kid or not, to me doesn't in any way. She left. She did it for him, but she did walk out of his life, and I think for him to accept that, move on and then fall pretty hard for this person. He's having this incredible that.

Speaker 1Sense. No, I see that for sure.

Speaker 4For sure, I was just thinking of along the lines of, like, you know, I don't know. I just thought that again, like the decision to not kiss it just adds another layer to the genius of what I thought.

Speaker 1But you're right, Matthew.

Speaker 5Sorry, I don't mean to shout you down on that one. No, no, no, no, no no.

Speaker 1I'm happy.

Speaker 5This is why I like you to talk about it.

Speaker 1I like having different opinions. Last two things I wanted to mention here, they're both very brief. What do you think about Well.

Speaker 4I guess two things with the Klaya. One, are you a believer in the Klaya and or Sister conspiracy or you absolutely a non believer in that.

Speaker 5I think we've been given literally zero reason to believe it. And I think that stuff that Gilroy said also now further confirms it because he has said that like people wanted to know what happened to the CIS or people wanted and he left a couple of other like dangling strings. And what he said was the whole point was, no, we're not gonna make the universe that small. We're not gonna say like she comes back around. The whole point is that this is why he is clinging to the rebellion so hard, because all of his life has been about him being taken away from people or then being

Speaker 5taken away from him.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 4Yeah, for a brief moment, like at the beginning of the Luthan episode, I thought that like Luthan was like on cashing his planet and that like that was his sister who had escaped.

Speaker 1And then like, obviously it goes on and I'm like, oh, wait, now that doesn't make any sense.

Speaker 4But like for a brief second, I was like, Dan, wait, is this possible? But then I agree that, like I was thinking at the same time, like it would just make the universe small and not everyone has to be related to everyone else and that kind of minimizes the impact of it all. And having that long lost sister is what fuels him so heavily. Yeah, I wanted to see a Quayas spin off, though I would not be mad at like like a one season just like what she like what is she doing during the rebellion or like what's she up to?

Speaker 1Because she's she was the only like.

Speaker 4Like all these characters were introduced, you know, like luthen And and Dedra and and and uh Siri always characters, they were all important whatever.

Speaker 1They all died except for Deadra and Claia.

Speaker 4And I've seen romos of everything from what if Thron employs Dedra in the upcoming you know, his attempts to retake the Empire?

Speaker 1What if Claire gets her own spin off?

Speaker 4I don't know how I feel about all these things, but it's just interested that, like their stories are kind of left open to be continued, if you know, if Disney chooses to do so.

Speaker 5Yeah, I'd love to see more from Claara. I'd love to see more from Val. I definitely thought there was like a possible spark with those two. I think that gets in some problematic issues, especially after the death of Santa. But you know, and that's not like there's nothing wrong. You know, your loved one dies, you move on to someone else, but there's also just like, you know, the one of color dies and now she's that white partner.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 5I'm not saying it's a veto that there's very much more complications there, but yeah, I would love to see more of their stories. I think probably if nothing else, will get them in books. Yeah, and comics, what I mean, both of those actors are incredible, incredible. Frankly, I was thinking about it, like, who would you nominate for an oscar from this show? Because, oh my god, part of it was, like you mentioned how Cassie and wasn't Ian episode the first episode of Tonight episode ten at all? There was a number of episodes in which he is not the main character by any means. He's a he's

Speaker 5a person who's there, but like you know, he rescues mon Mathama, but that's mon Mafama's episode. He goes to Gore, but that is an episode of Cyril and Dedra and the people of Gore. Like, who do you nominate for best actor best actress for this show?

Speaker 4It's really interesting to say that because for most of the season I was like, Tennie O'Reilly, who plays mon Mathma, I'm like, supporting actress like should be like a should be like.

Speaker 1A shoe win.

Speaker 4But then like, now, Likelizabeth Dulau.

Speaker 5That you say it, I think so the woman who plays Ka.

Speaker 1I mean, she has a real case for supporting actress as well.

Speaker 4I don't think I like Luthern's Don't re Worry performance was really powerful, but it like it was it was like smaller moments. I don't think there was enough of a of a breath there compared to Genevieve and Elizabeth to like to do Best Actress. But I mean I could see many of the actors in this show going.

Speaker 1Up for for for Emmys because.

Speaker 4This was I mean, it was just there was not a single bad acting performance in my opinion.

Speaker 5Yeah, you know, all of them were on point. I think I really was blown away by stelling scars Guard. I think if I'm naming an actor, like, they're all actors. But that's the way the categories breakdown. I probably put the guy who plays Serial first, and then Skelling scars Guard second, and the Diego Luna third, but they're all very very close, you know.

Speaker 4I don't I can't remember hold On Seal, just so we have it zero actors.

Speaker 1Sierro's name Kyle Soler, Kyle Solar o ll e e Er. I mean he was spectacular as well.

Speaker 4I just yeah, yeah. The very last thing I've written down here is just a little easter. Egonnised that I really appreciated a little nod towards Rebels, which they did without introducing Harra or Chopper.

Speaker 1The characters which I almost kind of kind of appreciated a little bit.

Speaker 4But as the ICB sweeping Luten's store, they come up across the stone from Lothal with the hands that is in the Rebels episode that opens the world between Worlds, the one that Ezra studies with the help of scene, and I really appreciated that, like they found a way to kind of nod towards Rebels even more without directly like bringing in you know, Harah, Ezra, you know those characters, Because there were times where I wanted to see someone from Phoenix Squadron, or I wanted to see the Emperor

Speaker 4for just a brief minute, and they gave us none of it. They like Tony stuck to his guns and said, we're not doing any cameos.

Speaker 1They did no cameos at all.

Speaker 5Yeah, And like I wish they'd mentioned one or two of those things, Like I think it would have been perfectly fine for them to mention that, like, oh, hey, what what do we do if we can't find a way into Sagerera. Well, this person named Jinnerso has been you know, you know, mentioning Hara or something like that. As the Rebel Squadron, Phoenix Squadron. But you're right, I think I was fined with it. It was a completely complete story on its own. Also just to give one more like crazy easter egg. And I only know this because some people know Arabash the like ba galactic basic language translations.

Speaker 5But the name of the hospital, it was named after the Chancellor of the High Republic in the High Republic books. I think your name is Lena. So so yeah, that was just like such a great pull of like, hey, even High Republic fans.

Speaker 4They really like I mean, they had like so many like kind of just deep cuts that like. And what I love about the show we talked about it before is that you don't have to have watched Star Wars at all. You could have seen no Star Wars, watched the show and had a really emotional response to it, really enjoyed it, really into it, And they were able to weave it in such a way though that there's these little East Rage, these little connections for those fans who do like really love the whole saga.

Speaker 1And are really into it get that extra enrichment.

Speaker 4Which is what I feel like is when Star Wars is at its best, it's not fans service.

Speaker 1That's like over the top, pitting over the head.

Speaker 4It's like, this is for everyone to enjoy, but for those diehard fans, here are little nuggets that like only you're gonna pick up on that will make it a little bit nicer and more fun for you.

Speaker 1But like, are essentially understanding of the whole thing, And I.

Speaker 5Think it's hard to do, and I do think, like, I think it's okay when sometimes you do need to kind of do your homework to understand something. Yeah, that should be for the things that are less like the main flag poles. Because I'll give an example, and we haven't gotten an episode about this, we will soon forgive very brief spoilers for the very start of Tales of the Underworld. But the first like minute or two of Tales of the Underworld is this scene that I experienced this because I watched it with my partner Mary. If you have read the book Dark Disciple hits you like a freight train, yep. And if you haven't read that book, you have literally no idea what's going on.

Speaker 1Yep.

Speaker 5Mary was so confused, she was like, who are these people? Why don't care?

Speaker 1Is that?

Speaker 5As Sage ventriss, I don't get it. Why is she like, And I don't think that's bad. I think for somebody tails the Empire. They were like, look, you book readers, this is for you, and we're kind of saying to how with everyone else? And as a book reader, I was okay with that because it's a small, little, you know, once a year project for something like this, I think you're right they needed to make it much broader and they just did a phenomenal job with that.

Speaker 1Mm hmmmm. I agree. Yeah.

Speaker 4And also Matthew, when I saw that celebration that episode, we could tell who would see it, who had read the book and who didn't, because it was a munch of like huh what and other people were like crying and they're like, oh no, yeah, but yeah, I just think that, like in my closing remark here, I think that we're.

Speaker 1Gonna get We're gonna get.

Speaker 4Too much deeper when we get Aaron back. But I I remember before we like we were did and or primer. Matthew had said that, like, you know, rightfully so, especially if they're like Daredevil and other like flops, that they were a little worried about can this live up to season one? And was also like, I don't know, can this up the season one? And it did it? Somehow? Is it even better than Season one? It actually might be for me, Like I just I didn't think it was possible for.

Speaker 1Them to get even better.

Speaker 4And I think this is what happens when you go into a show with a plan.

Speaker 1They're like from the beginning, it's gonna be two seasons. This is our plan.

Speaker 4We know what we're doing, unlike you know with the sequel trilogy, where they kind of bounced around a little bit with like what their plan was gonna be, and they executed it in such an amazing way, everything from acting cgi storytelling across the board. To me, this is not only the best Star Wars show, but one of the best TV shows I've.

Speaker 1Ever seen in my life.

Speaker 4And I'm really hoping that this level of standard that they have now set the bar is is followed through on in future Star Wars projects, because we now know what they're capable of doing. If this is what they could produce, we should be getting other shows of this high quality in the future.

Speaker 1Hopefully.

Speaker 5Yeah, I think I'm with you. I think this is like, it's weird to me trying to compare Season one in season two because they all it feels like such a full, complete story. But certainly like having watched this now I when it comes to sequels, I am newly hopeful. I have a new hope about second seasons matching up to the first because you're not even laughing at my Star Wars reference. That's annoying, but you know, I, uh, it's okay. It was terrible, but yeah, no, it absolutely cleared the bar.

Speaker 5It was so much better than I fear, like, not even then it feared I was really looking forward to it as hopeful, but it matched those It did not fail to do that. And I do think like I think there's a lot of stuff now that is comparing this to other stuff, and like all of a sudden that everyone loves Tony Gilroy. There's been some like dissatisfaction with Filony growing for a while, but there's a whole bunch of people who are like, you know, screw Filony, it should only be Gilroy. You can make everything again. And like, there's a lot of stuff that I think is come out of Disney plus recently that is not

Speaker 5on the same level of quality of this and shouldn't be. And I don't want and I think I'm okay with that. There's a steak restaurant here in town that when I want to go and spend a huge amount of money and get a really wonderful fine dining experience.

Speaker 1Is an incredible food.

Speaker 5It's very very good. When I want to go have a burger, though, like sometimes I just want a burger and the best burger in the world, exactly what's going to do it for me? And you know, like, yeah, steakhouses are great. Blue Door is great.

Speaker 1Wait what's the steakhouse? Is it Manny's.

Speaker 5I'm not gonna get into that now. Yeah, but like yeah, it's just it's different things, you know, like I don't want the best ice cream in the world to be the best, you know, on the same level it's like a super fancy French to fle Like it's different.

Speaker 1That's that's a fair way of putting it.

Speaker 4And I don't need everything to be like this level, like like this this insane and like sorry, I don't everything to be this like cinematic level of perfection. But just like the writing and the acting, all these things, like the it's just a bar. It's been said. I feel like it's gonna be like again, I've loved all of Star Wars shows, but like you compare with some of the other ones, and like, this is just elevated.

Speaker 1Across the board.

Speaker 5Yeah, no doubt, no doubt.

Speaker 4So I'm just curious to see, Like, I mean, the next show we're getting is going to be the mall a show, but I don't whatever the next live action show is, I'd be very curious to see what kind of follows this one.

Speaker 5I thought Skeleton Crew was wonderful. Candy, I agree, you know, it's not gonna last with me. I thought Rebels and Clone Wars helped make the rest of Star Wars good. Yeah, uh and better, and a lot of them are. It was good, but and I just I love them for that. I think this is one of the most important works of media in the last thirty years, yep, and one of the best that I've ever seen. And you know, for a while I would talk about like unless if you're going to talk to me about the corruption of city government and the police and criminals and all these things,

Speaker 5unless you've watched The Wire, I'm kind of not gonna take you seriously because I think it is so insightful and I think this show is kind of the same thing, like, if you want to be speaking out about fascism and how do we fight it and how do we fall into it, and what's happening in this country and what's happening in this world, watch the show because it's it's about all of that, and there's so much insights and raises, so many questions that I don't know the answer to, but I want, I want, you know. I think it was the the mayor of Rekuvik in Iceland who said

Speaker 5that he would not hire anyone in the city government unless they had worked, unless they had watched the wire, And I kind of want to feel the same thing, like, you know, if you're gonna run for president, if you're gonna be a leader of the Democratic Party, and you understand how to fight fascism and authoritarianism without falling into the stupid traps that so many Democrats have watched the show.

Speaker 1Watch the show.

Speaker 4Watch it's just anyone, anyone, Just tell your friends, just watch the show.

Speaker 1Yeah, and period.

Speaker 4It honestly, Matthew, it's just I'm just happy this exists. And I sent I sent eron and Matthew me and west Night of Anakin saying I want more, and I know I shouldn't because it was perfect as it was, but I just I wish somehow there could be more because it was so good, But I also don't want more. It's like that weird feeling of like I don't want it to be over, but it's so exactly as it's supposed to be.

Speaker 1It's so perfect as it was. I know I need to just be satisfied.

Speaker 5I mean, I put this on the same level as The Wire, which I think is just one of the best works of art you know, ever created. And the fifth season is kind of bad because it did go on too long, and it did have a lot of its funding pulled and it went through some of the stuff, and I'm kind of glad that Gilroy never had to deal with that.

Speaker 1So yep, all right, well, no one, no one. You've reached heure it limit, Alex.

Speaker 5This is great. Members. I promise we're to get back to giving you the bonus content soon. This has just been such a crazy schedule. We're trying to turn these out as fast as we can. But Alex, thank you so much. We'll have aeron and talk more soon. We'll have a lot of other great people we will be talking a lot of an and or for a long time. This is you know, I think we're gonna talk about Star Wars, you know, B B A and A A, you know, before and or and after and or because it's just just changed everything. Alex, thank you so much for listeners or members. Thank you all so much. May the Force be with you.

Speaker 1Uh, stay classy, canari

Speaker 5H.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode